{
  "model_key": "claude_fable_5",
  "display_name": "Claude Fable 5",
  "provider": "anthropic",
  "evaluation_model_ids": [],
  "thinking_effort": "max",
  "configuration_note": "Claude Fable 5 answered the 50 tasks in three rollouts through OpenRouter's chat completions route (anthropic/claude-fable-5) at maximum reasoning effort. Requests set max_tokens to 128,000, the model's output limit. Each request was one user message holding only the question text and its figure: no title, headings or system prompt. Answers cut off at the output limit were re-run; every attempt is counted in tokens and cost. Answers were graded by GPT-6 Luna at maximum reasoning effort. Cost uses OpenRouter's list price for Claude Fable 5 on 2026-11-10 ($10.00 input, $1.00 cached input, $50.00 output per 1M tokens).",
  "mode": "direct_qa",
  "summary": {
    "rollout_count": 3,
    "answer_count": 150,
    "scores": {
      "overall": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "response_count": 150,
          "correct_count": 126,
          "incorrect_count": 24,
          "partial_credit_count": 21,
          "zero_count": 3,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.62,
          "score_percent": 90.5,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 3,
            "1": 9,
            "2": 6,
            "3": 6,
            "4": 126
          }
        },
        "active": {
          "response_count": 150,
          "correct_count": 126,
          "incorrect_count": 24,
          "partial_credit_count": 21,
          "zero_count": 3,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.62,
          "score_percent": 90.5,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 3,
            "1": 9,
            "2": 6,
            "3": 6,
            "4": 126
          }
        }
      },
      "part1": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "response_count": 90,
          "correct_count": 88,
          "incorrect_count": 2,
          "partial_credit_count": 2,
          "zero_count": 0,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.9555555555555557,
          "score_percent": 98.88888888888889,
          "score_distribution": {
            "1": 1,
            "3": 1,
            "4": 88
          }
        },
        "active": {
          "response_count": 90,
          "correct_count": 88,
          "incorrect_count": 2,
          "partial_credit_count": 2,
          "zero_count": 0,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.9555555555555557,
          "score_percent": 98.88888888888889,
          "score_distribution": {
            "1": 1,
            "3": 1,
            "4": 88
          }
        }
      },
      "part2": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "response_count": 60,
          "correct_count": 38,
          "incorrect_count": 22,
          "partial_credit_count": 19,
          "zero_count": 3,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.1166666666666667,
          "score_percent": 77.91666666666667,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 3,
            "1": 8,
            "2": 6,
            "3": 5,
            "4": 38
          }
        },
        "active": {
          "response_count": 60,
          "correct_count": 38,
          "incorrect_count": 22,
          "partial_credit_count": 19,
          "zero_count": 3,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.1166666666666667,
          "score_percent": 77.91666666666667,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 3,
            "1": 8,
            "2": 6,
            "3": 5,
            "4": 38
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "by_rollout": {
      "1": {
        "response_count": 50,
        "correct_count": 42,
        "incorrect_count": 8,
        "partial_credit_count": 7,
        "zero_count": 1,
        "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.6,
        "score_percent": 90.0,
        "score_distribution": {
          "0": 1,
          "1": 3,
          "2": 3,
          "3": 1,
          "4": 42
        }
      },
      "2": {
        "response_count": 50,
        "correct_count": 43,
        "incorrect_count": 7,
        "partial_credit_count": 6,
        "zero_count": 1,
        "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.64,
        "score_percent": 91.0,
        "score_distribution": {
          "0": 1,
          "1": 3,
          "2": 2,
          "3": 1,
          "4": 43
        }
      },
      "3": {
        "response_count": 50,
        "correct_count": 41,
        "incorrect_count": 9,
        "partial_credit_count": 8,
        "zero_count": 1,
        "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.62,
        "score_percent": 90.5,
        "score_distribution": {
          "0": 1,
          "1": 3,
          "2": 1,
          "3": 4,
          "4": 41
        }
      }
    },
    "tokens": {
      "response_count": 150,
      "usage_record_count": 150,
      "complete_usage_count": 150,
      "missing_usage_count": 0,
      "missing_cached_input_count": 0,
      "complete": true,
      "totals": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 293550,
        "output_tokens": 1527826,
        "total_tokens": 1821376
      },
      "known_totals": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 293550,
        "output_tokens": 1527826,
        "total_tokens": 1821376
      }
    },
    "by_rollout_part": {
      "part1": {
        "1": {
          "response_count": 30,
          "correct_count": 29,
          "incorrect_count": 1,
          "partial_credit_count": 1,
          "zero_count": 0,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.9,
          "score_percent": 97.5,
          "score_distribution": {
            "1": 1,
            "4": 29
          }
        },
        "2": {
          "response_count": 30,
          "correct_count": 30,
          "incorrect_count": 0,
          "partial_credit_count": 0,
          "zero_count": 0,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 4.0,
          "score_percent": 100.0,
          "score_distribution": {
            "4": 30
          }
        },
        "3": {
          "response_count": 30,
          "correct_count": 29,
          "incorrect_count": 1,
          "partial_credit_count": 1,
          "zero_count": 0,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.966666666666667,
          "score_percent": 99.16666666666667,
          "score_distribution": {
            "3": 1,
            "4": 29
          }
        }
      },
      "part2": {
        "1": {
          "response_count": 20,
          "correct_count": 13,
          "incorrect_count": 7,
          "partial_credit_count": 6,
          "zero_count": 1,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.15,
          "score_percent": 78.75,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 1,
            "1": 2,
            "2": 3,
            "3": 1,
            "4": 13
          }
        },
        "2": {
          "response_count": 20,
          "correct_count": 13,
          "incorrect_count": 7,
          "partial_credit_count": 6,
          "zero_count": 1,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.1,
          "score_percent": 77.5,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 1,
            "1": 3,
            "2": 2,
            "3": 1,
            "4": 13
          }
        },
        "3": {
          "response_count": 20,
          "correct_count": 12,
          "incorrect_count": 8,
          "partial_credit_count": 7,
          "zero_count": 1,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.1,
          "score_percent": 77.5,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 1,
            "1": 3,
            "2": 1,
            "3": 3,
            "4": 12
          }
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "answers": [
    {
      "question_id": "part1-001-double-length-and-width-mosfet-its-intrinsic",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "If we double the length and width of a MOSFET, what happens to its intrinsic gain?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer: The intrinsic gain **doubles**.\n\n### Why\n\nIntrinsic gain is $A_v = g_m r_o$. Let's look at each factor (assuming the bias current $I_D$ is held constant):\n\n**Transconductance — unchanged:**\n\n$$g_m = \\sqrt{2\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}I_D}$$\n\nDoubling both $W$ and $L$ leaves the ratio $W/L$ unchanged, so $g_m$ stays the same.\n\n**Output resistance — doubles:**\n\n$$r_o = \\frac{1}{\\lambda I_D}, \\quad \\text{where } \\lambda \\propto \\frac{1}{L}$$\n\nChannel-length modulation is a *fractional* effect ($\\Delta L/L$), so a longer channel is proportionally less affected by it. Doubling $L$ halves $\\lambda$, which doubles $r_o$.\n\n**Result:**\n\n$$A_v = g_m r_o \\propto \\sqrt{\\frac{W}{L}} \\cdot L = \\sqrt{WL}$$\n\nDoubling both dimensions: $\\sqrt{(2W)(2L)} = 2\\sqrt{WL}$ → **gain increases by 2×**.\n\n(Equivalently: $A_v = \\dfrac{2}{\\lambda V_{OV}} \\propto \\dfrac{L}{V_{OV}}$, and since $W/L$ and $I_D$ are fixed, $V_{OV}$ is unchanged while $L$ doubles.)\n\n### The trade-off\n\nThis gain doesn't come free. Gate area quadruples, so $C_{gs} \\approx \\tfrac{2}{3}WLC_{ox}$ goes up 4×, while $g_m$ is unchanged:\n\n$$f_T = \\frac{g_m}{2\\pi C_{gs}} \\rightarrow \\text{drops by } 4\\times$$\n\nThis is the classic analog design trade: **longer devices give more gain, better matching, and lower 1/f noise, but slower speed**. It's exactly why high-gain amplifier stages use non-minimum-length transistors, while RF/high-speed paths stick to minimum L.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6bfa08e73209e34677df875955adcd9f9f7d30b3fef53173d8e46c3f22569353"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that intrinsic gain doubles: W/L and gm remain unchanged, while doubling L approximately halves channel-length modulation and doubles ro. The fixed-current assumption is consistent with the stated scaling; the extra speed discussion does not undermine the answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b623efa74b67c0787641e221f1d6de9d7318205927fbcd9490d3ed132b5450df",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 34,
        "output_tokens": 3066,
        "total_tokens": 3100,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2336,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 34,
        "output_tokens": 3066,
        "total_tokens": 3100,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2336,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-001-double-length-and-width-mosfet-its-intrinsic",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "If we double the length and width of a MOSFET, what happens to its intrinsic gain?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**The intrinsic gain doubles.**\n\nHere's why. Intrinsic gain is:\n\n$$A_v = g_m \\cdot r_o$$\n\n**Transconductance stays the same.** Since both W and L double, the ratio W/L is unchanged:\n\n$$g_m = \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}I_D} \\quad \\text{(fixed } I_D\\text{)} \\qquad \\text{or} \\qquad g_m = \\mu C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}V_{OV} \\quad \\text{(fixed } V_{OV}\\text{)}$$\n\nEither way, g_m doesn't change (and note I_D itself is unchanged at fixed bias, since it also depends only on W/L).\n\n**Output resistance doubles.** Channel-length modulation weakens with longer channels: λ ∝ 1/L, or equivalently the Early voltage scales as V_A ≈ V_A′·L. So:\n\n$$r_o = \\frac{1}{\\lambda I_D} = \\frac{V_A}{I_D} \\propto L$$\n\nDoubling L doubles r_o.\n\n**Result:**\n\n$$A_v = g_m r_o = \\frac{2I_D}{V_{OV}}\\cdot\\frac{V_A' L}{I_D} = \\frac{2V_A' L}{V_{OV}} \\;\\rightarrow\\; 2\\times$$\n\nNotice that W drops out entirely — the gain improvement comes purely from the longer channel. The width increase just compensates to keep the current/overdrive the same.\n\n**The price you pay:** gate capacitance C_gg ∝ W·L quadruples while g_m is unchanged, so the transit frequency f_T ≈ g_m/(2πC_gg) drops by 4×. This is the classic analog design tradeoff: longer channels buy you gain at the cost of speed.\n\n(This uses the first-order square-law model; in real short-channel devices λ doesn't scale exactly as 1/L, but the qualitative trend — longer L gives higher intrinsic gain — holds, and it also holds in weak inversion.)",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "41fac5169033a5edbefdc70a19529288724f147cb82d5c9b598f1ba02d69f50e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that intrinsic gain approximately doubles: with W/L and overdrive fixed, gm and drain current stay approximately unchanged while the longer channel doubles ro. The stated bias-condition caveat is appropriate; the extra speed tradeoff does not affect the answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b623efa74b67c0787641e221f1d6de9d7318205927fbcd9490d3ed132b5450df",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 34,
        "output_tokens": 2641,
        "total_tokens": 2675,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1937,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 34,
        "output_tokens": 2641,
        "total_tokens": 2675,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1937,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-001-double-length-and-width-mosfet-its-intrinsic",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "If we double the length and width of a MOSFET, what happens to its intrinsic gain?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Intrinsic gain doubles\n\nThe intrinsic gain is A_v = g_m · r_o. Let's look at each factor (assuming the drain current I_D is held constant):\n\n**Transconductance — unchanged:**\n\n$$g_m = \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox} \\frac{W}{L} I_D}$$\n\nDoubling both W and L leaves the W/L ratio the same, so g_m (and the overdrive voltage V_ov) are unchanged.\n\n**Output resistance — doubles:**\n\n$$r_o = \\frac{1}{\\lambda I_D}, \\quad \\text{where } \\lambda \\propto \\frac{1}{L}$$\n\nChannel-length modulation becomes weaker with longer channels (equivalently, the Early voltage V_A ∝ L). Doubling L halves λ, so r_o doubles.\n\n**Result:**\n\n$$A_v = g_m r_o = \\frac{2V_A}{V_{ov}} \\implies A_v \\text{ doubles}$$\n\n## The catch\n\nYou pay for this gain with speed. The gate capacitance C_gs ∝ W·L **quadruples**, while g_m stays the same, so:\n\n$$f_T = \\frac{g_m}{2\\pi C_{gs}} \\propto \\frac{\\mu V_{ov}}{L^2} \\implies f_T \\text{ drops by } 4\\times$$\n\nThis is the classic gain–bandwidth tradeoff, and it's why analog designers use longer-than-minimum channel lengths in gain stages (op-amp input pairs, current mirrors) but minimum length where speed matters.\n\n*Caveat: this is the square-law/first-order result. In short-channel processes the λ ∝ 1/L relationship is only approximate, but the qualitative conclusion—longer L gives higher intrinsic gain at the cost of speed—still holds.*",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "cce8bcbc465e9d4d5e374f32bc3c26ccf7cb020645a44b56966f3e805ef17cf1"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that doubling both dimensions leaves W/L, gm, and (under the stated bias assumption) drain current approximately unchanged, while the longer channel roughly doubles ro and intrinsic gain. The added speed discussion is secondary and consistent with the stated first-order assumptions.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b623efa74b67c0787641e221f1d6de9d7318205927fbcd9490d3ed132b5450df",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 34,
        "output_tokens": 2240,
        "total_tokens": 2274,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1627,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 34,
        "output_tokens": 2240,
        "total_tokens": 2274,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1627,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-002-student-says-transconductance-mosfet-goes-up-as",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "Student A says the transconductance of a MOSFET goes up as the overdrive voltage increases. Student B says it goes down. Who is correct?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Both can be correct — it depends on what's held constant\n\nThis is a classic trap. Transconductance can be written three equivalent ways (square-law, saturation):\n\n$$g_m = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}V_{OV} = \\frac{2I_D}{V_{OV}} = \\sqrt{2\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}I_D}$$\n\nwhere $V_{OV} = V_{GS} - V_{TH}$. The first formula says $g_m \\propto V_{OV}$; the second says $g_m \\propto 1/V_{OV}$. Both are valid — they just correspond to different constraints.\n\n**Student A is correct if W/L is fixed.**\nIf you take a given transistor and simply raise $V_{GS}$, then:\n\n$$g_m = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}V_{OV} \\quad \\Rightarrow \\quad g_m \\uparrow \\text{ as } V_{OV} \\uparrow$$\n\nNote that the drain current also rises (as $V_{OV}^2$), so you're paying for the extra $g_m$ with more current.\n\n**Student B is correct if I_D is fixed.**\nIn real analog design, you usually have a fixed current budget (the transistor is biased by a current source). Then:\n\n$$g_m = \\frac{2I_D}{V_{OV}} \\quad \\Rightarrow \\quad g_m \\downarrow \\text{ as } V_{OV} \\uparrow$$\n\nTo keep $I_D$ constant while increasing $V_{OV}$, you must shrink $W/L$, and the net effect is lower transconductance.\n\n## The resolution\n\n$I_D$, $V_{OV}$, and $W/L$ are not independent — they're linked by $I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}V_{OV}^2$. You can only choose two freely. Saying \"increase $V_{OV}$\" is ambiguous until you specify what else changes.\n\n## Practical takeaway\n\nThe second viewpoint leads to the key design metric, **transconductance efficiency**:\n\n$$\\frac{g_m}{I_D} = \\frac{2}{V_{OV}}$$\n\nFor a given current, a *small* overdrive gives you the most $g_m$ per amp (which is why low-power designs bias near weak inversion). Large overdrive, on the other hand, buys you better linearity and speed. That trade-off is exactly the tension hidden in the two students' arguments.\n\n(Bonus: in short-channel devices with velocity saturation, $I_D \\propto V_{OV}$, so $g_m$ becomes nearly independent of $V_{OV}$ — and both students would be wrong.)",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f6d3436ef37bb52cb9550a4ee4b538ee48863aac8bf14d87c36cfc0f571700b3"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies Student A as right for a fixed transistor size, explains that current rises with overdrive, and notes Student B's fixed-current condition. The central answer matches the golden solution; extra design commentary does not change it.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "e805626814432e31b3628b4bf4073fa0c2304a7c8ea8bad4f0422be86c312f74",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 52,
        "output_tokens": 2395,
        "total_tokens": 2447,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1488,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 52,
        "output_tokens": 2395,
        "total_tokens": 2447,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1488,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-002-student-says-transconductance-mosfet-goes-up-as",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "Student A says the transconductance of a MOSFET goes up as the overdrive voltage increases. Student B says it goes down. Who is correct?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**Both can be correct — it depends on what's held constant.** This is a classic trap, because transconductance can be written three equivalent ways using the square-law model:\n\nStarting from the saturation current:\n\n$$I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}V_{OV}^2$$\n\nDifferentiating with respect to $V_{GS}$ gives:\n\n$$g_m = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}V_{OV} = \\frac{2I_D}{V_{OV}} = \\sqrt{2\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}I_D}$$\n\nAll three expressions are the same quantity, but they tell different stories:\n\n**Student A's scenario — fixed device size (W/L constant):**\nIf you simply raise $V_{GS}$ on a given transistor, $V_{OV}$ increases and $I_D$ rises with it (as $V_{OV}^2$). Then $g_m = \\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)V_{OV}$ increases linearly with overdrive. ✓ Student A is right.\n\n**Student B's scenario — fixed bias current ($I_D$ constant):**\nIf the current is set by a current source and you adjust W/L to change the operating point, then $g_m = 2I_D/V_{OV}$, and increasing the overdrive *decreases* transconductance. ✓ Student B is right.\n\n**The resolution:** $g_m$ depends on two of the three quantities {$I_D$, $W/L$, $V_{OV}$}, and they're linked by the square law — you can't vary $V_{OV}$ \"by itself.\" Each student is implicitly holding a different variable fixed.\n\n**Practical takeaway:** In analog design, power budgets usually fix $I_D$, so Student B's view dominates in practice. The transconductance efficiency $g_m/I_D = 2/V_{OV}$ improves at low overdrive, which is why designers bias toward weak/moderate inversion when power efficiency matters — trading off speed and matching to get there.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "1c040c477dd0b9cd7a04a5d606a591096bdb585aa609324ce2583889c3109c33"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies Student A as right for a fixed device size, since increasing overdrive raises drain current and gm. It also correctly explains Student B’s fixed-current case; the additional practical-design commentary does not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "e805626814432e31b3628b4bf4073fa0c2304a7c8ea8bad4f0422be86c312f74",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 52,
        "output_tokens": 2130,
        "total_tokens": 2182,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1438,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 52,
        "output_tokens": 2130,
        "total_tokens": 2182,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1438,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-002-student-says-transconductance-mosfet-goes-up-as",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "Student A says the transconductance of a MOSFET goes up as the overdrive voltage increases. Student B says it goes down. Who is correct?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**Both students can be correct — it depends on what is held constant.** This is actually a classic trap in MOSFET analysis, and the resolution lies in the fact that transconductance can be written in three equivalent ways (using the square-law saturation model):\n\n$$g_m = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}V_{OV} = \\frac{2I_D}{V_{OV}} = \\sqrt{2\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}I_D}$$\n\nwhere the overdrive voltage is $V_{OV} = V_{GS} - V_{TH}$.\n\n**Student A's case: fixed device, increasing V_GS**\n\nIf you take a given transistor (fixed W/L) and simply raise the gate voltage, then:\n\n$$g_m = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}V_{OV}$$\n\nHere g_m increases *linearly* with V_OV. Note that the drain current is also increasing (as V_OV²) in this scenario. **Student A is right.**\n\n**Student B's case: fixed drain current**\n\nIn practical analog design, the bias current is usually fixed by the power budget. If I_D is held constant and you increase V_OV (which requires shrinking W/L), then:\n\n$$g_m = \\frac{2I_D}{V_{OV}}$$\n\nNow g_m *decreases* as V_OV increases. **Student B is right.**\n\n**The practical takeaway**\n\nCircuit designers usually think in Student B's terms. The ratio\n\n$$\\frac{g_m}{I_D} = \\frac{2}{V_{OV}}$$\n\nis called the *transconductance efficiency*: it tells you how much gain you get per unit of bias current. A small V_OV gives high efficiency, which is why low-power analog circuits are biased at low overdrive (often near weak/moderate inversion). The trade-off is that small V_OV requires a large W/L, which adds capacitance and can hurt speed and linearity.\n\n**One refinement:** in short-channel devices, velocity saturation makes I_D roughly linear (not quadratic) in V_OV, so g_m eventually saturates at high overdrive rather than continuing to rise — weakening Student A's trend even in the fixed-device case.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0616398e676a4e8522a58eaf6750a45703bcecd32318adc6a4e4ef498fcd7b81"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies Student A as right for a fixed device: increasing overdrive also increases drain current, so gm rises linearly in the square-law model. The fixed-current case for Student B is accurately distinguished; the additional design and short-channel comments do not undermine the answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "e805626814432e31b3628b4bf4073fa0c2304a7c8ea8bad4f0422be86c312f74",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 52,
        "output_tokens": 2066,
        "total_tokens": 2118,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1332,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 52,
        "output_tokens": 2066,
        "total_tokens": 2118,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1332,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-003-small-signal-model-pmos-device-identical-nmos",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Is the small-signal model of a PMOS device identical to that of an NMOS device?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**Yes — the small-signal model of a PMOS is identical to that of an NMOS**, both in topology and in the polarities of all the elements ($g_m v_{gs}$, $g_{mb}v_{bs}$, $r_o$, and the capacitances). No current sources need to be flipped and no signs need to be negated.\n\n**Why the signs work out**\n\nIn the large-signal sense, everything in a PMOS is reversed: current flows from source to drain, and $V_{GS}$, $V_{DS}$, $V_{TH}$ are all negative. But the small-signal model captures *derivatives* about the bias point, and the two sign inversions cancel:\n\n- For a PMOS in saturation, $|I_D| = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(|V_{GS}| - |V_{TH}|)^2$.\n- If $v_{GS}$ rises by $\\Delta v$ (i.e., becomes *less negative*), then $|V_{GS}|$ *falls*, so the source→drain current *decreases* by $g_m \\Delta v$.\n- A decrease in source→drain current is equivalent to an incremental current $g_m \\Delta v$ flowing **drain→source** — exactly what the NMOS dependent source $g_m v_{gs}$ produces for positive $v_{gs}$.\n\nThe same double-negation occurs for channel-length modulation (giving a positive $r_o$ between drain and source) and for the body effect (giving $g_{mb}v_{bs}$ with the same polarity). Formally:\n\n$$g_m = \\frac{\\partial i_D}{\\partial v_{GS}} > 0, \\qquad \\frac{1}{r_o} = \\frac{\\partial i_D}{\\partial v_{DS}} > 0$$\n\nfor both device types, with $i_D$ defined consistently (into the drain).\n\n**Practical consequence:** when drawing the small-signal equivalent of, say, a PMOS common-source stage, you substitute the *same* model you'd use for an NMOS, and the analysis proceeds identically (gain $= -g_m(r_o \\| R_D)$, etc.).\n\n**Caveats — what *does* differ:**\n\n- **Parameter values**: $\\mu_p$ is typically 2–4× smaller than $\\mu_n$, so for equal dimensions and bias current, a PMOS has lower $g_m$ and higher overdrive. $\\lambda$, $\\gamma$, and junction capacitances also differ.\n- **Bulk connection**: in an n-well process, each PMOS sits in its own well, so the source can be tied to the bulk, eliminating body effect ($g_{mb}$ drops out). NMOS devices share the substrate and don't have this option.\n\nSo: same model, different numbers.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "43bad2d27150a1fb266d6422ba3620cac10388883933b8df5405ba9a5517dfd4"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "The answer correctly says the PMOS model is the same in form as the NMOS model. Its source-referenced variables and drain-current convention support the stated signs; the other caveats do not change the core answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "ad8a01fc96398ca5ab0993a444ff64ba0cfcb88738d2a52872ea47f671e0635e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 33,
        "output_tokens": 5619,
        "total_tokens": 5652,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4699,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 33,
        "output_tokens": 5619,
        "total_tokens": 5652,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4699,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-003-small-signal-model-pmos-device-identical-nmos",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Is the small-signal model of a PMOS device identical to that of an NMOS device?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**Yes — the small-signal models are identical.** Same topology, same orientation of every element, and all parameters (g_m, g_mb, r_o) come out positive for both device types. This is a classic result emphasized in analog texts like Razavi's.\n\n**Why the signs work out**\n\nThe small-signal model describes *increments* around a bias point. If you keep consistent conventions for both devices (i_D defined flowing into the drain, v_GS = v_G − v_S), the PMOS large-signal behavior is just the NMOS behavior with every voltage and current negated:\n\n> I_D,PMOS(V_GS, V_DS, V_BS) = −I_D,NMOS(−V_GS, −V_DS, −V_BS)\n\nWhen you differentiate to get small-signal parameters, the two minus signs cancel. Concretely, for a PMOS in saturation:\n\n> I_D = −½ μ_p C_ox (W/L)(V_GS − V_TH)²  \n> g_m = ∂I_D/∂V_GS = −μ_p C_ox (W/L)(V_GS − V_TH) > 0\n\nsince V_GS − V_TH < 0 for a conducting PMOS. The same argument gives positive r_o and g_mb. So the standard model — g_m·v_gs and g_mb·v_bs sources pointing from drain to source, r_o across drain–source, plus C_gs, C_gd, C_sb, C_db, C_gb — applies unchanged.\n\n**Common pitfall:** flipping the dependent source or writing g_m·v_sg for PMOS. This is unnecessary — small-signal quantities are deviations and can be positive or negative regardless of the DC bias polarity.\n\n**What *does* differ: the parameter values**\n\n- μ_p ≈ μ_n/2 to μ_n/4, so for equal dimensions and current, PMOS has lower g_m and f_T (hence PMOS devices are often sized 2–3× wider).\n- λ, γ, and |V_TH| generally differ between the two types.\n- In a standard n-well process, a PMOS can have its body tied to its own source, making v_bs = 0 and eliminating the g_mb source — a practical asymmetry, not a model difference.\n\nSo: identical model structure; only the numbers change.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ee533fed7c423df025db33ccfc10f993086bc9932126abb92ef4dc80358d8604"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that the PMOS small-signal model has the same form as the NMOS model, using consistent source-referenced variables and signed drain current. Its added sign explanation is consistent with that convention; differences in parameter values do not change the model structure.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "ad8a01fc96398ca5ab0993a444ff64ba0cfcb88738d2a52872ea47f671e0635e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 33,
        "output_tokens": 5347,
        "total_tokens": 5380,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4600,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 33,
        "output_tokens": 5347,
        "total_tokens": 5380,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4600,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-003-small-signal-model-pmos-device-identical-nmos",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Is the small-signal model of a PMOS device identical to that of an NMOS device?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**Yes — the small-signal model of a PMOS is identical to that of an NMOS**, in both topology and the polarity of all the dependent sources. Only the numerical parameter values differ. There is no need to flip the direction of the g_m generator for a PMOS, which is a common misconception.\n\n**Why the signs work out**\n\nSmall-signal parameters are derivatives of the large-signal characteristics at the bias point. For a PMOS, both the voltages *and* the current reverse polarity, so the sign flips cancel. With I_D defined as current flowing *into* the drain:\n\n- NMOS: I_D = ½μₙC_ox(W/L)(V_GS − V_THn)², so g_m = ∂I_D/∂V_GS = μₙC_ox(W/L)(V_GS − V_THn) > 0\n- PMOS: I_D = −½μₚC_ox(W/L)(V_GS − V_THp)², so g_m = ∂I_D/∂V_GS = −μₚC_ox(W/L)(V_GS − V_THp) = μₚC_ox(W/L)|V_GS − V_THp| > 0\n\nBoth derivatives are positive, so the same model (current source g_m·v_gs from drain to source, with the same orientation) applies.\n\n**Intuition:** if v_GS rises slightly, the NMOS conducts *more* current into its drain, while the PMOS conducts *less* current out of its drain — which is the same thing as the drain current (into the drain) increasing. Both devices respond to Δv_gs with a positive ΔI_D.\n\nThe same cancellation happens for r_o (∂I_D/∂V_DS > 0 for both) and for the body-effect source g_mb·v_bs, and the capacitance network (C_GS, C_GD, C_DB, C_SB, C_GB) has the same structure.\n\n**What does differ**\n\n- **Parameter values:** μₚ is typically 2–4× smaller than μₙ, so for the same dimensions and |I_D| a PMOS has lower g_m. λ, γ, V_TH magnitudes, and junction capacitances (p⁺/n-well vs. n⁺/p-substrate) also differ.\n- **Circuit-level flexibility:** in a standard n-well process, each PMOS can have its bulk tied to its source (eliminating body effect), whereas all NMOS devices share the grounded substrate. But this affects how you *use* the model, not the model itself.\n\nSo in small-signal analysis, you can treat both device types with the exact same equivalent circuit — just plug in the appropriate parameter values evaluated at the bias point.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "83acf31bd91d9aa108d397a15e4154bbe7dbdd6b69b1f1572ad2b01c6098bd30"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that the PMOS small-signal model is the same in form as the NMOS model, satisfying the golden solution’s full-credit rule. Its sign discussion uses source-referenced variables, for which the model can have the same structure.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "ad8a01fc96398ca5ab0993a444ff64ba0cfcb88738d2a52872ea47f671e0635e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 33,
        "output_tokens": 4433,
        "total_tokens": 4466,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3571,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 33,
        "output_tokens": 4433,
        "total_tokens": 4466,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3571,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-01.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Analysis\n\n**Key observation:** M₁ is *diode-connected* — its gate and drain are tied together. Since the source is grounded:\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_{DS} = V_X$$\n\n**Operating region check:** The saturation condition is $V_{DS} \\geq V_{GS} - V_{TH}$. Here this becomes:\n\n$$V_X \\geq V_X - V_{TH} \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad V_{TH} \\geq 0 \\;\\checkmark$$\n\nThis is *always* satisfied, so whenever M₁ conducts, it is **in saturation** (it can never enter the triode region).\n\n# I–V Relationship\n\n**For $V_X < V_{TH}$:** device is off:\n$$I_X = 0$$\n\n**For $V_X \\geq V_{TH}$:** device is saturated:\n$$I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_X - V_{TH})^2$$\n\n(with channel-length modulation, multiply by $(1+\\lambda V_X)$).\n\n# Sketch\n\n```\n I_X\n  |                                    *\n  |                                   *\n  |                                  *          ← parabolic\n  |                                *             (square law)\n  |                              *\n  |                           *\n  |                        *\n  |                   *\n  |______________ **_________________________ V_X\n  0           V_TH\n      (I_X = 0)\n```\n\n**Features of the curve:**\n- $I_X = 0$ until $V_X$ reaches $V_{TH}$\n- The curve departs from zero with **zero slope** at $V_X = V_{TH}$\n- It then rises **quadratically** (parabola)\n- The slope at any point equals the transconductance:\n$$\\frac{dI_X}{dV_X} = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_X - V_{TH}) = g_m$$\n\nThe diode-connected MOSFET behaves like a two-terminal \"diode,\" but with a **square-law** characteristic rather than the exponential characteristic of a pn junction.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "03338cd3e1f0ec5a4b181951fc27d4001b7a5c6b7a3768926d221aa8f37d8980"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the diode-connected NMOS, shows it is in saturation when conducting, and gives the zero-below-threshold, quadratic-above-threshold I–V curve. The channel-length-modulation note is optional and does not affect the answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "769af5ac610bb7825c7abce92bf56d510d018662cbce83d47eef1dee2597750d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1304,
        "output_tokens": 1880,
        "total_tokens": 3184,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1191,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1304,
        "output_tokens": 1880,
        "total_tokens": 3184,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1191,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-01.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting Up the Problem\n\nThe gate of $M_1$ is tied to its drain (a **diode-connected** transistor), and both are driven by $V_X$. Therefore:\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_{DS} = V_X$$\n\n**Which region of operation?** Check the saturation condition:\n\n$$V_{DS} \\geq V_{GS} - V_{TH} \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad V_X \\geq V_X - V_{TH} \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad V_{TH}\\ge 0 \\;\\checkmark$$\n\nThis is *always* satisfied, so a diode-connected MOSFET **never enters the triode region** — it is either off or in saturation.\n\n## The Two Regions\n\n**1) $V_X < V_{TH}$:** The device is off:\n$$I_X = 0$$\n\n**2) $V_X \\geq V_{TH}$:** The device is saturated:\n$$\\boxed{I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\,\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left(V_X - V_{TH}\\right)^2}$$\n\n(Including channel-length modulation, multiply by $(1+\\lambda V_X)$, which bends the curve up slightly.)\n\n## Sketch\n\n```\n I_X\n  |                                    .\n  |                                   .\n  |                                  .\n  |                                .\n  |                              .\n  |                           .          I_X = ½ μnCox(W/L)(Vx–VTH)²\n  |                        .\n  |                    .\n  |                .\n  |           . \n  |______.-·________________________________  V_X\n  0     V_TH\n  \n  (I_X = 0 until V_X = V_TH, then rises parabolically)\n```\n\n## Key Observations\n\n- The characteristic looks like a \"square-law diode\": zero current below the threshold, quadratic growth above it.\n- The slope at any operating point is \n$$\\frac{dI_X}{dV_X} = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_X - V_{TH}) = g_m,$$ \nso the diode-connected device behaves as a small-signal resistance of $1/g_m$.\n- For $V_X < 0$, the grounded terminal acts as the drain and the terminal at $V_X$ as the source; then $V_{GS}=0 < V_{TH}$, so the device remains off and $I_X = 0$ there too.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c04e01b1e0e4c872d1a7a6496c110c9a904e2508b66fd58a2baac5166117836f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the diode-connected NMOS as off up to threshold and in saturation with a quadratic current rise above threshold. The negative-VX simplification is outside the question’s main point and does not affect the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "769af5ac610bb7825c7abce92bf56d510d018662cbce83d47eef1dee2597750d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1304,
        "output_tokens": 2161,
        "total_tokens": 3465,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1372,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1304,
        "output_tokens": 2161,
        "total_tokens": 3465,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1372,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-01.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting Up the Problem\n\nThe gate and drain of M₁ are tied together (a **diode‑connected** transistor), so:\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_{DS} = V_X, \\qquad I_X = I_D$$\n\n**Key observation:** Since $V_{DS} = V_{GS}$, we always have\n\n$$V_{DS} > V_{GS} - V_{TH}$$\n\nso whenever M₁ conducts, it is **guaranteed to operate in saturation**. The triode region is never entered.\n\n## The I–V Relationship\n\n**Region 1: $V_X < V_{TH}$** — M₁ is off:\n\n$$I_X = 0$$\n\n**Region 2: $V_X \\geq V_{TH}$** — M₁ is on and in saturation:\n\n$$\\boxed{I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left(V_X - V_{TH}\\right)^2}$$\n\n(or multiplied by $(1+\\lambda V_X)$ if channel-length modulation is included).\n\n## Sketch\n\n```\n I_X\n  │                                    ·\n  │                                  ·\n  │                                ·\n  │                              ·           ½ μnCox(W/L)(V_X − V_TH)²\n  │                            ·\n  │                          ·\n  │                        ·\n  │                      ·\n  │                   ·\n  │                ·\n  │            ·\n  │        ··\n  ────────────┼─────────────────────────────  V_X\n  0          V_TH\n     (device off)      (saturation)\n```\n\n## Comments\n\n- The curve is a **parabola shifted right by $V_{TH}$**, starting with zero slope at $V_X = V_{TH}$ and steepening as $V_X$ increases.\n- The slope at any point equals the transconductance: $dI_X/dV_X = g_m = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_X - V_{TH})$.\n- This square-law behavior is why a diode-connected MOSFET acts like a two-terminal nonlinear \"diode\" — it begins conducting near $V_{TH}$ and presents a small-signal resistance of $1/g_m$ once on.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d50d38a2b82126b710825a41b2446c0717092a072f3f9a0489e65c0635635f0a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the diode-connected NMOS, off below threshold and in saturation with a quadratic current rise above threshold. The optional channel-length-modulation note does not detract.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "769af5ac610bb7825c7abce92bf56d510d018662cbce83d47eef1dee2597750d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1304,
        "output_tokens": 2220,
        "total_tokens": 3524,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1498,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1304,
        "output_tokens": 2220,
        "total_tokens": 3524,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1498,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-02.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Analysis\n\n**Setup:** The source of M₁ is grounded, the gate is at V_X, and the drain is held at 1 V. Therefore:\n- V_GS = V_X  \n- V_DS = 1 V (fixed)  \n- I_X = I_D\n\n# Operating Regions\n\n**1. Cutoff: V_X < V_TH**\n\n$$I_X = 0$$\n\n**2. Saturation: V_TH < V_X < V_TH + 1\\text{ V}$** \n\n(since V_DS = 1 V > V_GS − V_TH here)\n\n$$I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_X - V_{TH})^2 \\quad \\Rightarrow \\quad \\textbf{parabolic rise}$$\n\n**3. Triode: V_X > V_TH + 1 V** \n\n(now V_GS − V_TH > V_DS = 1 V)\n\n$$I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\Big[2(V_X - V_{TH})(1\\,\\text{V}) - (1\\,\\text{V})^2\\Big]= \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\Big(V_X - V_{TH} - 0.5\\,\\text{V}\\Big)$$\n\n⇒ **straight line** with constant slope $\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(1\\,\\text{V})$\n\n# Sketch\n\n```\n I_X\n  |                                      /\n  |                           triode   /\n  |                          (linear) /\n  |                                  /\n  |                               _/\n  |                           _.·´ ← smooth transition\n  |              saturation .·      (value AND slope continuous)\n  |              (parabola)·\n  |                      ·\n  |                    ·\n  |   (off)         .·\n  |_____________..·´___________|____________→ V_X\n  0           V_TH          V_TH + 1V\n```\n\n**Key features:**\n- I_X = 0 until V_X reaches V_TH\n- Quadratic growth while M₁ is saturated\n- At V_X = V_TH + 1 V, the device enters the triode region; the curve becomes a **straight line**\n- The transition is smooth: at V_X = V_TH + 1 V both expressions give $I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(1\\,\\text{V})^2$ and the same slope $\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(1\\,\\text{V})$",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6d7cb9b068bd1bb5eab1e3a9c8b8328c1e56161ad3e0e536539547ecb43f59bb"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies cutoff, the quadratic saturation region through V_TH + 1 V, and the roughly linear triode-region rise beyond it, with consistent equations and transition behavior.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "da000995f2032c3caf224acfa4963413c96cebf89a3cc792e76c3a444d327ffc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1459,
        "output_tokens": 2286,
        "total_tokens": 3745,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1440,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1459,
        "output_tokens": 2286,
        "total_tokens": 3745,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1440,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-02.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Analysis\n\n**Setup:** M₁ has its source grounded, gate at V_X, and drain fixed at 1 V. Therefore:\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_X, \\qquad V_{DS} = 1\\text{ V (constant)}, \\qquad I_X = I_D$$\n\nAs V_X increases, the transistor passes through three regions:\n\n## Region 1: Cutoff (V_X < V_TH)\n\n$$I_X = 0$$\n\n## Region 2: Saturation (V_TH < V_X < V_TH + 1 V)\n\nHere V_DS = 1 V > V_GS − V_TH = V_X − V_TH, so:\n\n$$I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_X - V_{TH})^2 \\quad \\Rightarrow \\quad \\textbf{parabolic rise}$$\n\n## Region 3: Triode (V_X > V_TH + 1 V)\n\nOnce V_X − V_TH exceeds V_DS = 1 V, M₁ enters the triode region with **fixed** V_DS:\n\n$$I_X = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left[(V_X - V_{TH})(1\\text{ V}) - \\frac{1}{2}(1\\text{ V})^2\\right] \\quad \\Rightarrow \\quad \\textbf{straight line}$$\n\nwith constant slope $\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\cdot(1\\text{ V})$.\n\n# Sketch\n\n```\n I_X\n  │                                    ／\n  │                                  ／   ← linear (triode)\n  │                                ／      slope = μnCox(W/L)·(1V)\n  │                              ／\n  │                           ⟋\n  ½μnCox(W/L)(1V)² ─ ─ ─ ─ ⟋\n  │                      ⟋ │\n  │                   ⟋    │  ← parabola (saturation)\n  │                ⟋       │\n  │           ⟋            │\n  │______⟋_________________│____________________  V_X\n  0      V_TH           V_TH + 1V\n   (off)\n```\n\n**Key features:**\n- I_X = 0 until V_X = V_TH\n- Quadratic growth for V_TH < V_X < V_TH + 1 V\n- Linear growth beyond V_X = V_TH + 1 V\n- The transition at V_X = V_TH + 1 V is **smooth** — both the current value $\\left(\\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(1\\,\\text{V})^2\\right)$ and the slope $\\left(\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\cdot 1\\,\\text{V}\\right)$ match on both sides.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "dc12532ed9020a17b5f4869e348d1f91cd9e601f4291ce45376f2a6ff9272019"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies cutoff, quadratic saturation current up to V_TH + 1 V, and the roughly linear triode-region rise beyond it. The equations and transition continuity are also correct.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "da000995f2032c3caf224acfa4963413c96cebf89a3cc792e76c3a444d327ffc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1459,
        "output_tokens": 2147,
        "total_tokens": 3606,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1225,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1459,
        "output_tokens": 2147,
        "total_tokens": 3606,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1225,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-02.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Circuit Analysis\n\n**Setup:** M₁ has its source grounded, its gate at V_X, and its drain held at 1 V. Thus:\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_X, \\qquad V_{DS} = 1\\ \\text{V (fixed)}, \\qquad I_X = I_D$$\n\nSince V_DS is *fixed* at 1 V while V_GS increases, the transistor passes through **three regions**:\n\n**Region 1 — Off** ($V_X < V_{TH}$):\n$$I_X = 0$$\n\n**Region 2 — Saturation** ($V_{TH} < V_X < V_{TH} + 1\\,\\text{V}$, since $V_{DS} = 1 > V_X - V_{TH}$):\n$$I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\,\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\,(V_X - V_{TH})^2 \\quad \\Rightarrow \\ \\textbf{parabolic}$$\n\n**Region 3 — Triode** ($V_X > V_{TH} + 1\\,\\text{V}$, since now $V_{DS} = 1 < V_X - V_{TH}$):\n$$I_X = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left[(V_X - V_{TH})(1\\,\\text{V}) - \\frac{(1\\,\\text{V})^2}{2}\\right] \\quad \\Rightarrow \\ \\textbf{linear}$$\n\nwith constant slope $\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\cdot(1\\,\\text{V})$.\n\n## Sketch\n\n```\n I_X\n  |                                        /\n  |                                      /   ← triode: straight line,\n  |                                    /        slope = μnCox(W/L)·(1V)\n  |                                  /\n  |                                /\n  |                             _/•  ← I_X = ½ μnCox(W/L)(1V)²\n  |                          _-¯\n  |                       _-¯    ← saturation: parabola\n  |                    _-¯          ½μnCox(W/L)(Vx−VTH)²\n  |                 _-¯\n  |______________--¯\n  +----------+--------------+------------------→ V_X\n  0         V_TH        V_TH + 1V\n```\n\n## Key features\n\n- **I_X = 0** until V_X reaches V_TH.\n- **Quadratic growth** from V_TH to V_TH + 1 V (saturation).\n- **Linear growth** beyond V_X = V_TH + 1 V (triode), since V_DS is pinned at 1 V.\n- The curve and its **slope are both continuous** at V_X = V_TH + 1 V: both expressions give $I_X = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}(1\\,\\text{V})^2$ and slope $\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}(1\\,\\text{V})$ there — a smooth parabola-to-line transition.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "881987f95016298e4fa3868c82584ea566aa7da993e6e7d047c9d78dea9bc91a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies cutoff below threshold, quadratic saturation current up to VTH + 1 V, and roughly linear triode current beyond that, with the correct boundary and equations.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "da000995f2032c3caf224acfa4963413c96cebf89a3cc792e76c3a444d327ffc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1459,
        "output_tokens": 2129,
        "total_tokens": 3588,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1140,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1459,
        "output_tokens": 2129,
        "total_tokens": 3588,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1140,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-006-device-act-as-current-source",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "Can the device shown in the figure act as a current source?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-006-device-act-as-current-source/figure-03.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**No.** Even though the transistor operates in saturation, this connection behaves like a *diode*, not a current source.\n\n**What the circuit is**\n\nThe arrow (source) is at the top node, so $M_1$ is a PMOS whose gate and drain are both grounded — i.e., gate and drain are shorted together. This is a **diode-connected device**, with its source at the node carrying $I_X$ (call its voltage $V_X$).\n\n**Why it's always in saturation**\n\nSince $V_G = V_D$, we have $|V_{DS}| = |V_{GS}| > |V_{GS}| - |V_{THP}|$, so whenever the device conducts, it is in saturation.\n\n**Why it still fails as a current source**\n\nThe gate–source voltage is *not fixed* — it is set by the terminal voltage itself:\n\n$$V_{GS} = 0 - V_X = -V_X$$\n\nSo the current is a strong (square-law) function of the voltage across the device:\n\n$$I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\,\\mu_p C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left(V_X - |V_{THP}|\\right)^2, \\qquad V_X > |V_{THP}|$$\n\n(and $I_X \\approx 0$ for $V_X < |V_{THP}|$).\n\nAn ideal current source must deliver a current **independent of the voltage across it** (high output impedance). Here the $I_X$–$V_X$ characteristic is a parabola, like a diode. In small-signal terms, the impedance looking into this node is only\n\n$$R \\approx \\frac{1}{g_m}\\,\\Big\\|\\, r_O \\approx \\frac{1}{g_m}\\quad (\\text{low}),$$\n\nwhich is the opposite of what a current source requires.\n\n**What would work instead:** a MOSFET biased with a *constant* $V_{GS}$ (e.g., gate tied to a fixed bias voltage, source grounded) and kept in saturation — then $I_D \\approx \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}(V_{GS}-V_{TH})^2$ is nearly independent of $V_{DS}$, and the device approximates a current source with output resistance $r_O$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "92d5bf40ce459dffcf3e3e6c37c6b784854d3e1cc986da856add3950a5a95732"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as a PMOS with its source at the IX node and gate and drain grounded, and explains that the diode connection has low small-signal resistance (about 1/gm), so it cannot act as a current source.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "20b0fcb71c5ac038622c26f3ac86aaf2af15f4064029312681192c8362271780",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 576,
        "output_tokens": 6151,
        "total_tokens": 6727,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5421,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 576,
        "output_tokens": 6151,
        "total_tokens": 6727,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5421,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-006-device-act-as-current-source",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "Can the device shown in the figure act as a current source?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-006-device-act-as-current-source/figure-03.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**No.** This is a diode‑connected PMOS device, and although it always operates in saturation, its current depends strongly on the voltage across it — the defining failure for a current source.\n\n**Analysis:**\n\nThe arrow (pointing into the device) marks the top terminal as the **source** of a PMOS transistor, with the gate and drain both grounded. So:\n\n- $V_{SG} = V_X$ and $V_{SD} = V_X$\n\nSince the gate and drain are at the same potential ($V_{GD} = 0$), the saturation condition is automatically satisfied:\n\n$$V_{SD} = V_{SG} > V_{SG} - |V_{THP}|$$\n\nSo whenever the device conducts ($V_X > |V_{THP}|$), it is in saturation, and:\n\n$$I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left(V_X - |V_{THP}|\\right)^2$$\n\n**Why this disqualifies it as a current source:**\n\nThe voltage across the two-terminal device *is* $V_{SG}$ itself. The current therefore varies quadratically with the terminal voltage rather than remaining constant. The incremental resistance is\n\n$$\\frac{\\partial V_X}{\\partial I_X} = \\frac{1}{g_m}\\,,$$\n\nwhich is *low* — exactly the opposite of a current source, which requires very high output resistance. (And if $V_X < |V_{THP}|$, the device turns off entirely.)\n\nIn other words, this connection behaves as a **two-terminal nonlinear resistor (a \"MOS diode\")**, not a current source.\n\nFor a MOSFET to act as a current source, $V_{GS}$ must be held fixed by the bias and the current taken from the **drain**, where the device presents a high output impedance ($r_o$).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "25badfbe133cd7e855a2bf7f888c42277ea8be0f42cb6003cfa559273d0e5aff"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as a diode-connected PMOS, reads its terminals and voltages correctly, and explains that its low incremental resistance (about 1/gm) and voltage-dependent current prevent it from acting as a current source.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "20b0fcb71c5ac038622c26f3ac86aaf2af15f4064029312681192c8362271780",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 576,
        "output_tokens": 7830,
        "total_tokens": 8406,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7234,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 576,
        "output_tokens": 7830,
        "total_tokens": 8406,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7234,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-006-device-act-as-current-source",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "Can the device shown in the figure act as a current source?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-006-device-act-as-current-source/figure-03.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Identifying the Circuit\n\nThe device is a **PMOS transistor** with:\n- **Source** at the top (node X, where $I_X$ flows in)\n- **Gate** tied to ground\n- **Drain** tied to ground\n\nSince the gate and drain are at the same potential, this is a **diode-connected** transistor.\n\n## Checking the Operating Region\n\nWith $V_G = V_D = 0$ and $V_S = V_X$:\n\n$$V_{SG} = V_X, \\qquad V_{SD} = V_X$$\n\nThe saturation condition $V_{SD} \\ge V_{SG} - |V_{THP}|$ becomes $V_X \\ge V_X - |V_{THP}|$, which is **always true**. So the device is in saturation whenever it conducts ($V_X > |V_{THP}|$).\n\n## Does It Behave as a Current Source?\n\n**No.** Even though the device is saturated, its current depends *strongly* on the voltage at its terminal:\n\n$$I_X = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left(V_X - |V_{THP}|\\right)^2$$\n\nA current source must deliver a current that is (nearly) **independent of the voltage across it** — i.e., it must present a very high incremental resistance. Here, because the gate–source voltage *is* the terminal voltage, any change in $V_X$ changes $I_X$ directly. The small-signal resistance seen looking into node X is only:\n\n$$R_X = \\frac{1}{g_m} \\parallel r_O \\approx \\frac{1}{g_m}$$\n\nwhich is quite **low**.\n\n## Conclusion\n\nThe circuit behaves as a **two-terminal nonlinear resistor (a \"MOS diode\")**, not a current source:\n\n- $I_X = 0$ for $V_X < |V_{THP}|$\n- $I_X \\propto (V_X - |V_{THP}|)^2$ beyond that\n\nA MOSFET acts as a current source only when its **gate–source voltage is held fixed** and the current is drawn from the **drain** while the device remains in saturation — conditions this diode-connected configuration does not satisfy.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d5fe1a052ca1490876a32e43830ff4244b119a2ea2155e8a8b9e5d7667261320"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the PMOS and its connections, and explains that the diode-connected device presents low incremental resistance (about 1/gm), so it cannot act as a current source.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "20b0fcb71c5ac038622c26f3ac86aaf2af15f4064029312681192c8362271780",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 576,
        "output_tokens": 5478,
        "total_tokens": 6054,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4768,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 576,
        "output_tokens": 5478,
        "total_tokens": 6054,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4768,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration/figure-04.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\n**M₁ is a PMOS transistor** (source on top, toward $V_{DD}$). The input drives the **gate**, the output is taken at the **drain**, and a resistor $R_S$ sits in the source lead. This is therefore a **PMOS common-source (CS) amplifier with source degeneration**:\n\n- $R_S$: degeneration resistor (source → $V_{DD}$)\n- $R_D$: drain/load resistor (drain → ground)\n\nSince $V_{DD}$ is an AC ground, this is simply the familiar NMOS degenerated CS stage \"flipped upside down\" — all results carry over directly.\n\n# 1. DC (Bias) Analysis\n\nA single current $I_D$ flows: $V_{DD} \\rightarrow R_S \\rightarrow$ M₁ $\\rightarrow R_D \\rightarrow$ ground.\n\n**KVL through the input loop:**\n$$V_{SG} = V_{DD} - I_D R_S - V_{in}$$\n\n**Saturation-region current:**\n$$I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}\\left(V_{SG} - |V_{THP}|\\right)^2, \\qquad V_{out} = I_D R_D$$\n\n**Saturation condition** ($V_{SD} \\ge V_{SG} - |V_{THP}|$) reduces to:\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} \\le V_{in} + |V_{THP}|}$$\n\nNote the negative feedback in bias: if $I_D$ tries to rise, the drop across $R_S$ grows, $V_{SG}$ shrinks, pulling $I_D$ back → **bias point is stabilized** against $V_{TH}$ and $\\mu_p C_{ox}$ variations.\n\n# 2. Small-Signal Gain (λ = 0)\n\nThe PMOS small-signal model is identical to the NMOS model. With gate current zero, the same $i_d$ flows through $R_S$ and $R_D$:\n\n$$i_d = g_m(v_{in} - v_s), \\qquad v_s = i_d R_S, \\qquad v_{out} = -i_d R_D$$\n\nSolving:\n$$i_d = \\frac{v_{in}}{\\dfrac{1}{g_m} + R_S} \\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad \\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = -\\frac{R_D}{\\dfrac{1}{g_m} + R_S} = -\\frac{g_m R_D}{1 + g_m R_S}}$$\n\n**Sign check (intuition):** $v_{in}\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_{SG}\\downarrow \\Rightarrow I_D\\downarrow \\Rightarrow V_{out} = I_D R_D \\downarrow$. The stage **inverts**, just like an NMOS CS stage.\n\n# 3. Including Channel-Length Modulation (λ ≠ 0)\n\nSince $r_O$ connects drain to source (not to AC ground), it cannot simply be placed in parallel with $R_D$. Full analysis gives:\n\n$$A_v = -\\frac{g_m r_O R_D}{\\,R_D + r_O + R_S\\left(1 + g_m r_O\\right)}$$\n\nEquivalently, $A_v = -G_m R_{out}$ with $G_m = \\dfrac{g_m r_O}{r_O + R_S + g_m r_O R_S}$.\n\n*(If the n-well/bulk is tied to $V_{DD}$ rather than the source, replace $g_m R_S$ by $(g_m + g_{mb})R_S$ in the denominator to account for body effect.)*\n\n# 4. Port Impedances\n\n| Quantity | Value |\n|---|---|\n| Input resistance | $R_{in} = \\infty$ (gate, low frequency) |\n| Resistance looking into drain | $r_O(1 + g_m R_S) + R_S$ (boosted by degeneration) |\n| Output resistance | $R_{out} = R_D \\,\\|\\, \\left[r_O(1+g_m R_S) + R_S\\right] \\approx R_D$ |\n\n# 5. Key Design Observations\n\n- **Gain–linearity tradeoff:** $R_S$ reduces the gain from $-g_m R_D$ to $-R_D/(1/g_m + R_S)$, but linearizes the stage and desensitizes it to device parameters.\n- **If $g_m R_S \\gg 1$:** $A_v \\approx -\\dfrac{R_D}{R_S}$ — the gain is set by a *resistor ratio*, nearly independent of process and temperature.\n- The effective transconductance is degraded to $G_m = \\dfrac{g_m}{1+g_m R_S}$, which is the classic result of local series feedback.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bb9efe73199012f104595756e991acfd523affe732bb251e7494e6ec774a33ea"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the PMOS common-source stage with source degeneration and gives the required inverting gain, -gmRD/(1 + gmRS).",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "cd8fcec5f92210366117d02bce0f4174b55a012666155b3dfc965be2c669f3a3",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1560,
        "output_tokens": 10125,
        "total_tokens": 11685,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8502,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1560,
        "output_tokens": 10125,
        "total_tokens": 11685,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8502,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration/figure-04.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThe transistor **M₁ is a PMOS device** (source arrow pointing *into* the gate, source at the top):\n\n- **Source** → tied to $V_{DD}$ through $R_S$ (source degeneration resistor)\n- **Gate** → driven by $V_{in}$\n- **Drain** → output node $V_{out}$, loaded by $R_D$ to ground\n\nSince the input is at the gate and the output is at the drain, this is a **PMOS common-source (CS) amplifier with source degeneration**. It is the exact mirror of the familiar NMOS degenerated CS stage.\n\n# Large-Signal (Bias) Analysis\n\nOne current $I_D$ flows from $V_{DD}$ through $R_S$, M₁, and $R_D$:\n\n$$V_S = V_{DD} - I_D R_S, \\qquad V_{SG} = V_{DD} - I_D R_S - V_{in}$$\n\nAssuming saturation (and $\\lambda = 0$):\n\n$$I_D = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\big(V_{DD} - I_D R_S - V_{in} - |V_{THP}|\\big)^2, \\qquad V_{out} = I_D R_D$$\n\n**Saturation check (PMOS):** $V_{SD} \\ge V_{SG} - |V_{THP}| \\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_{out} \\le V_{in} + |V_{THP}|$\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis ($\\lambda = 0$)\n\nGround $V_{DD}$ for AC. With $v_s$ the source-node voltage:\n\n**KCL at the source node:**\n$$\\frac{v_s}{R_S} = g_m(v_{in} - v_s) \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; v_s = \\frac{g_m R_S}{1 + g_m R_S}\\,v_{in}$$\n\n**KCL at the drain node:**\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{R_D} + g_m(v_{in} - v_s) = 0$$\n\nSubstituting $v_s$:\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = -\\frac{g_m R_D}{1 + g_m R_S} = -\\frac{R_D}{\\dfrac{1}{g_m} + R_S}}$$\n\n**By inspection:** gain = −(resistance at drain)/(total resistance in source path) — the degeneration adds $R_S$ in series with the \"intrinsic\" $1/g_m$.\n\n**Sign check:** raising $V_{in}$ reduces $V_{SG}$, reducing $I_D$, so $V_{out} = I_D R_D$ falls → inverting amplifier. ✓\n\n# Port Impedances\n\n$$R_{in} = \\infty \\ \\text{(gate)}, \\qquad R_{out} = R_D \\,\\|\\, \\big[r_o(1 + g_m R_S) + R_S\\big] \\;\\xrightarrow{\\;r_o\\to\\infty\\;}\\; R_D$$\n\n# Nonidealities (if needed)\n\n- **Channel-length modulation** ($r_o$ finite):\n$$A_v = -\\frac{g_m r_o R_D}{R_D + r_o + R_S(1 + g_m r_o)}$$\n- **Body effect** (n-well at $V_{DD}$, so $v_{bs} = -v_s$): replace $g_m R_S$ in the denominator with $(g_m + g_{mb})R_S$:\n$$A_v = -\\frac{g_m R_D}{1 + (g_m + g_{mb})R_S}$$\n\n# Design Insight\n\n$R_S$ introduces **series (degeneration) feedback**:\n\n- The effective transconductance drops to $G_m = \\dfrac{g_m}{1 + g_m R_S}$, so gain is traded for **linearity and bias stability** (less sensitivity to $V_{TH}$, $\\mu_p C_{ox}$, temperature).\n- If $g_m R_S \\gg 1$, the gain approaches $A_v \\approx -R_D/R_S$ — set by a **resistor ratio**, nearly independent of transistor parameters.\n\nThe result is identical in form to the NMOS degenerated CS stage, since NMOS and PMOS share the same small-signal model.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d4844b19bdc4d746e49a917ef14bbc67a52525800a967118d33eba69440d52f9"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M₁ as a PMOS common-source stage with source degeneration and gives the inverting gain −gmRD/(1 + gmRS). Its additional analysis is consistent with the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "cd8fcec5f92210366117d02bce0f4174b55a012666155b3dfc965be2c669f3a3",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1560,
        "output_tokens": 7192,
        "total_tokens": 8752,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5742,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1560,
        "output_tokens": 7192,
        "total_tokens": 8752,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5742,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration/figure-04.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **PMOS common-source (CS) amplifier with source degeneration**:\n\n- **M₁** is a PMOS device (arrow pointing *into* the channel at the top terminal), so its **source is at the top** (toward V_DD) and its **drain is at the bottom**.\n- **R_S** degenerates the source (connects source to V_DD).\n- **R_D** is the load (connects drain to ground), and **V_out is taken at the drain**.\n- Input drives the gate → *common-source configuration* (not a follower, since the output is at the drain).\n\nThe topology is simply the PMOS mirror-image of the familiar degenerated NMOS CS stage.\n\n# DC (Bias) Analysis\n\nWith the source at $V_S = V_{DD} - I_D R_S$:\n\n$$V_{SG} = V_{DD} - I_D R_S - V_{in}$$\n\nAssuming saturation:\n\n$$I_D = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left(V_{DD} - I_D R_S - V_{in} - |V_{THP}|\\right)^2$$\n\n(a quadratic in $I_D$), and the output level is:\n\n$$V_{out,DC} = I_D R_D$$\n\n**Saturation check:** PMOS requires $V_{SD} \\ge V_{SG} - |V_{THP}|$, which reduces to:\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} \\le V_{in} + |V_{THP}|}$$\n\nQualitatively: M₁ turns on when $V_{in} < V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|$; lowering $V_{in}$ further increases $I_D$ and raises $V_{out}$, eventually pushing M₁ into triode.\n\n# Small-Signal Gain\n\nTreat $V_{DD}$ as AC ground; the small-signal drain current $i = g_m v_{gs}$ flows through both $R_S$ and $R_D$:\n\n$$v_s = iR_S, \\qquad v_{out} = -iR_D, \\qquad i = g_m(v_{in} - iR_S)$$\n\nSolving (with $\\lambda = 0$, bulk tied to source):\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = -\\frac{g_m R_D}{1 + g_m R_S} = -\\frac{R_D}{\\dfrac{1}{g_m} + R_S}}$$\n\n**Inverting gain**, identical in form to the NMOS degenerated CS stage. Refinements:\n\n- **With channel-length modulation ($r_o$):**\n$$A_v = -\\frac{g_m r_o R_D}{r_o + R_D + R_S + g_m r_o R_S}$$\n- **With body effect** (if bulk ties to $V_{DD}$ instead of the source):\n$$A_v = -\\frac{g_m R_D}{1 + (g_m + g_{mb})R_S}$$\n\n# Input/Output Impedances\n\n| Quantity | Result |\n|---|---|\n| $R_{in}$ | $\\infty$ (gate, at low frequency) |\n| $R_{out}$ | $R_D \\,\\|\\, \\big[r_o(1 + g_m R_S) + R_S\\big] \\approx R_D$ |\n| Effective $G_m$ | $\\dfrac{g_m}{1 + g_m R_S}$ |\n\nNote that looking into the drain, degeneration *boosts* the transistor's output resistance by the factor $(1 + g_m R_S)$.\n\n# Design Insights\n\n- **Trade-off:** $R_S$ reduces the gain magnitude from $g_m R_D$ to $g_m R_D/(1+g_m R_S)$, but in exchange it **linearizes** the amplifier and **stabilizes the bias point** against variations in $V_{THP}$, $\\mu_p C_{ox}$, and temperature (negative feedback).\n- **Strong degeneration limit:** if $g_m R_S \\gg 1$,\n$$A_v \\approx -\\frac{R_D}{R_S}$$\ni.e., the gain is set by a *resistor ratio* — nearly independent of transistor parameters.\n- **Headroom:** the signal swing at the drain is limited by $V_{out} \\le V_{in} + |V_{THP}|$ (saturation) and by the drops $I_D R_S + V_{SD}$ fitting within $V_{DD}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "2f0719cac90c650a2888db476fb1f697e4632fe3a8eb67eb6a63cc6248848a3f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the PMOS common-source stage with source degeneration and gives the inverting gain −gm RD/(1 + gm RS). The added body-effect and output-resistance refinements are consistent with the topology.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "cd8fcec5f92210366117d02bce0f4174b55a012666155b3dfc965be2c669f3a3",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1560,
        "output_tokens": 7464,
        "total_tokens": 9024,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5984,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1560,
        "output_tokens": 7464,
        "total_tokens": 9024,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5984,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-008-source-follower",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-008-source-follower/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Analysis: Source Follower (Common-Drain Amplifier)\n\n## 1. Topology Identification\n\nThe NMOS transistor **M₁** has:\n- **Gate** → input (V_in)\n- **Drain** → tied directly to V_DD (AC ground)\n- **Source** → output node (V_out), loaded by resistor R_S to ground\n\nSince the drain is common to both input and output loops, this is a **common-drain stage**, better known as a **source follower**.\n\n## 2. Large-Signal (DC) Behavior\n\n- **V_in < V_TH:** M₁ is off → I_D = 0 → **V_out = 0**\n- **V_in > V_TH:** M₁ conducts, and current through R_S raises V_out:\n\n$$I_D = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_{in} - V_{out} - V_{TH})^2 = \\frac{V_{out}}{R_S}$$\n\n- **Operating region:** Saturation requires V_DS ≥ V_GS − V_TH, i.e., V_DD − V_out ≥ V_in − V_out − V_TH. Since the drain sits at V_DD, M₁ **remains in saturation for all V_in ≤ V_DD + V_TH** — it essentially never enters the triode region.\n\nThe output \"follows\" the input with a level shift: **V_out ≈ V_in − V_GS**.\n\n## 3. Small-Signal Gain\n\nApplying KCL at the source node (including r_o and body effect, where v_bs = −v_out):\n\n$$g_m(v_{in} - v_{out}) - g_{mb}v_{out} - \\frac{v_{out}}{r_o} = \\frac{v_{out}}{R_S}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_m R_{eq}}{1 + g_m R_{eq}}, \\quad R_{eq} = R_S \\,\\|\\, r_o \\,\\|\\, \\frac{1}{g_{mb}}}$$\n\nSimplified (neglecting r_o and body effect):\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_m R_S}{1 + g_m R_S} < 1$$\n\nThe gain is **always less than unity**, approaching 1 when g_m R_S ≫ 1.\n\n## 4. Port Impedances\n\n| Parameter | Value |\n|-----------|-------|\n| Input resistance | ≈ ∞ (gate, at low frequency) |\n| Output resistance | $R_{out} = \\dfrac{1}{g_m} \\,\\|\\, \\dfrac{1}{g_{mb}} \\,\\|\\, r_o \\,\\|\\, R_S \\approx \\dfrac{1}{g_m}$ (low) |\n\n## 5. Key Non-Idealities\n\n- **Body effect:** Since the source voltage varies while the bulk is grounded, V_SB = V_out, making V_TH signal-dependent:\n$$V_{TH} = V_{TH0} + \\gamma\\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi_F + V_{out}} - \\sqrt{2\\phi_F}\\right)$$\nThis introduces **nonlinearity** and reduces gain by the factor involving g_mb.\n- **Level shift:** Output is displaced from input by V_GS, consuming voltage headroom.\n- **Asymmetric drive:** M₁ sources current well, but sinking is limited by R_S.\n\n## 6. Applications\n\n✅ **Voltage buffer** — high input impedance, low output impedance, used to drive low-resistance or capacitive loads  \n✅ **DC level shifter** — shifts signals down by V_GS  \n✅ **Output stage** in amplifiers where impedance transformation (not voltage gain) is needed\n\n**Summary:** This source follower provides a near-unity voltage gain (A_v ≲ 1), infinite input impedance, and low output impedance (~1/g_m), at the cost of a V_GS level shift and nonlinearity from the body effect.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "fd1373c9213b3e64f3ba3edefadf5c83d4c0b40167c19c194c5752f78de45664"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source follower and gives the required positive, less-than-unity gain expression. Its body-effect and output-resistance refinements are consistent with the circuit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8f23ff232475a4bec79b12629414fe11fc7b9c6e9609b2ebcfc0e4ed2a0839d7",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1264,
        "output_tokens": 3806,
        "total_tokens": 5070,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2470,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1264,
        "output_tokens": 3806,
        "total_tokens": 5070,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2470,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-008-source-follower",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-008-source-follower/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification: Source Follower (Common-Drain Stage)\n\n**Topology:** The input is applied to the **gate**, the output is sensed at the **source**, and the drain is tied directly to $V_{DD}$ (an AC ground). This is the classic **source follower**, biased by source resistor $R_S$.\n\n---\n\n## 1. Large-Signal (DC) Behavior\n\n**Cutoff:** For $V_{in} < V_{TH}$, $M_1$ is off, no current flows, and $V_{out} = 0$.\n\n**Conduction:** For $V_{in} > V_{TH}$, current flows through $R_S$:\n\n$$V_{out} = I_D R_S = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left(V_{in} - V_{out} - V_{TH}\\right)^2 R_S$$\n\nThe output \"follows\" the input with a level shift:\n\n$$V_{out} = V_{in} - V_{GS}$$\n\n**Saturation check:** Since the drain sits at $V_{DD}$, we have $V_{DS} = V_{DD} - V_{out} > V_{GS} - V_{TH}$ whenever $V_{in} \\leq V_{DD} + V_{TH}$ — so $M_1$ remains in **saturation** for essentially all practical inputs. ✓\n\n---\n\n## 2. Small-Signal Voltage Gain\n\nAt the output node, the transistor current must flow through $R_S$. With $v_{gs} = v_{in} - v_{out}$ and $v_{bs} = -v_{out}$ (body grounded):\n\n$$g_m(v_{in} - v_{out}) - g_{mb}v_{out} - \\frac{v_{out}}{r_o} = \\frac{v_{out}}{R_S}$$\n\nSolving:\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_m \\left(R_S \\,\\|\\, r_o \\,\\|\\, \\tfrac{1}{g_{mb}}\\right)}{1 + g_m \\left(R_S \\,\\|\\, r_o \\,\\|\\, \\tfrac{1}{g_{mb}}\\right)}}$$\n\n**Simplified cases:**\n\n| Assumption | Gain |\n|---|---|\n| Neglect $r_o$, $g_{mb}$ | $A_v = \\dfrac{g_m R_S}{1 + g_m R_S}$ |\n| $g_m R_S \\gg 1$, with body effect | $A_v \\approx \\dfrac{g_m}{g_m + g_{mb}} < 1$ |\n\nThe gain is **positive** (non-inverting) and **always less than unity**, approaching 1 as $g_m R_S \\to \\infty$. Body effect fundamentally limits the gain even for very large $R_S$.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Input and Output Impedances\n\n$$R_{in} = \\infty \\quad \\text{(gate, at low frequency)}$$\n\n$$R_{out} = \\frac{1}{g_m} \\,\\Big\\|\\, \\frac{1}{g_{mb}} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_o \\,\\Big\\|\\, R_S \\;\\approx\\; \\frac{1}{g_m} \\quad \\text{(low)}$$\n\n---\n\n## 4. Key Properties & Applications\n\n- **Voltage buffer:** High input impedance, low output impedance → drives low-resistance or capacitive loads without loading the previous stage.\n- **DC level shifter:** Shifts the signal down by $V_{GS}$.\n- **Drawbacks:**\n  - *Nonlinearity:* $V_{GS}$ (and $V_{TH}$ via body effect) varies with $V_{out}$, so the gain is signal-dependent.\n  - Gain < 1, with body effect causing additional attenuation.\n  - Limited output swing: $V_{out}$ cannot exceed $V_{DD} - V_{GS}$ and headroom is consumed by the level shift.\n\nIn practice, $R_S$ is often replaced by a **current source** to stabilize $I_D$, making $V_{GS}$ roughly constant and improving linearity.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d7f426b66214d71d04371f386328c42e4782396b3272a9746d29c646db77a03b"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source follower and gives its positive, less-than-unity gain gmRS/(1 + gmRS) under the stated simplifications. The body-effect and output-resistance refinements are supplementary.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8f23ff232475a4bec79b12629414fe11fc7b9c6e9609b2ebcfc0e4ed2a0839d7",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1264,
        "output_tokens": 3463,
        "total_tokens": 4727,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2081,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1264,
        "output_tokens": 3463,
        "total_tokens": 4727,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2081,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-008-source-follower",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-008-source-follower/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification: Source Follower (Common-Drain Stage)\n\nThe NMOS transistor $M_1$ has:\n- **Gate** → input $V_{in}$\n- **Drain** → tied to $V_{DD}$ (AC ground)\n- **Source** → output node $V_{out}$, loaded by resistor $R_S$ to ground\n\nSince the input is applied to the gate and the output is sensed at the source, this is a **common-drain amplifier**, commonly called a **source follower**.\n\n---\n\n## 1. Large-Signal (DC) Behavior\n\n**Cutoff:** For $V_{in} < V_{TH}$, $M_1$ is off, no current flows, and $V_{out} = 0$.\n\n**Conduction:** For $V_{in} > V_{TH}$, current flows through $R_S$. Assuming saturation:\n\n$$I_D = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left(V_{in} - V_{out} - V_{TH}\\right)^2 = \\frac{V_{out}}{R_S}$$\n\nSolving this quadratic gives $V_{out}$ as a function of $V_{in}$. The output \"follows\" the input, offset downward by $V_{GS}$:\n\n$$V_{out} = V_{in} - V_{GS}$$\n\n**Region of operation:** Since the drain sits at $V_{DD}$, saturation requires $V_{DD} \\geq V_{in} - V_{TH}$. For any realistic input ($V_{in} \\leq V_{DD}$), **$M_1$ never enters the triode region** — a key advantage of this topology.\n\n**Nonlinearity note:** As $V_{out}$ rises, $V_{SB}$ rises, so $V_{TH}$ increases via the **body effect**. Also, $V_{GS}$ varies with $I_D$. Both effects make the follower somewhat nonlinear.\n\n---\n\n## 2. Small-Signal Gain\n\nWriting KCL at the source node (including $g_m$, body transconductance $g_{mb}$, and output resistance $r_o$):\n\n$$g_m(v_{in} - v_{out}) - g_{mb}\\,v_{out} = v_{out}\\left(\\frac{1}{R_S} + \\frac{1}{r_o}\\right)$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_m}{g_m + g_{mb} + \\dfrac{1}{R_S} + \\dfrac{1}{r_o}} = \\frac{g_m R'}{1 + g_m R'}}$$\n\nwhere $R' = R_S \\,\\|\\, r_o \\,\\|\\, \\dfrac{1}{g_{mb}}$.\n\n**Simplified cases:**\n\n| Assumption | Gain |\n|---|---|\n| Ideal ($r_o \\to \\infty$, no body effect) | $A_v = \\dfrac{g_m R_S}{1 + g_m R_S}$ |\n| $g_m R_S \\gg 1$ | $A_v \\to 1$ |\n| With body effect, $R_S, r_o \\to \\infty$ | $A_v = \\dfrac{g_m}{g_m + g_{mb}} = \\dfrac{1}{1+\\eta} < 1$ |\n\nThe gain is **positive (non-inverting)** and **always less than unity**. The body effect alone typically limits it to ~0.8.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Input and Output Impedance\n\n- **Input impedance:** $R_{in} \\to \\infty$ at low frequency (gate draws no current).\n- **Output impedance** (looking into the source):\n\n$$R_{out} = \\frac{1}{g_m} \\,\\Big\\|\\, \\frac{1}{g_{mb}} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_o \\,\\Big\\|\\, R_S \\;\\approx\\; \\frac{1}{g_m + g_{mb}}$$\n\nThis **low output impedance** is the circuit's main virtue.\n\n---\n\n## 4. Summary of Properties & Applications\n\n**Strengths:**\n- High input impedance, low output impedance → ideal **voltage buffer**\n- Can act as a **DC level shifter** (output = input − $V_{GS}$)\n- Transistor stays in saturation over a wide input range\n\n**Weaknesses:**\n- Gain < 1, degraded further by body effect\n- Nonlinearity because $V_{TH}$ (via $V_{SB}$) and $V_{GS}$ depend on the output level\n- The drain current, and hence $g_m$, depends on $V_{out}/R_S$, varying the gain with signal level\n- Consumes voltage headroom ($V_{GS}$ drop)\n\n**Typical use:** placed after a high-gain stage (e.g., common-source amplifier) to drive low-impedance or capacitive loads without loading down the gain stage.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "69141c79aa2a1fb8c8d9a5d0bfb613203f21f50c10e7c7481d50e0dc98cc764c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source follower and gives the positive, less-than-unity gain gm·RS/(1 + gm·RS), matching the full-credit rule. The additional output-resistance and body-effect discussion is supplementary.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8f23ff232475a4bec79b12629414fe11fc7b9c6e9609b2ebcfc0e4ed2a0839d7",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1264,
        "output_tokens": 4436,
        "total_tokens": 5700,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2823,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1264,
        "output_tokens": 4436,
        "total_tokens": 5700,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2823,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-009-common-gate-source-input",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-009-common-gate-source-input/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\n**M₁ is a PMOS device** (the source arrow points *into* the transistor), connected as:\n\n- **Source** ← V_in (bottom terminal)\n- **Gate** ← V_DD\n- **Drain** → V_out, with **R_D** from the drain up to V_DD\n\nTopologically this *looks* like a **common-gate stage** (input at source, gate at a fixed potential, output at drain). But let's check whether it actually works.\n\n# Can M₁ Ever Turn On?\n\nA PMOS conducts only when its source–gate voltage exceeds the threshold:\n\n$$V_{SG} \\geq |V_{THP}| \\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad V_{in} - V_{DD} \\geq |V_{THP}| \\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad V_{in} \\geq V_{DD} + |V_{THP}|$$\n\nFor any input in the normal range $0 \\le V_{in} \\le V_{DD}$:\n\n$$V_{SG} = V_{in} - V_{DD} \\le 0 < |V_{THP}|$$\n\nEven if we test the *other* terminal as the source: with no current, R_D pulls that node to V_DD, giving V_SG = V_DD − V_DD = 0. **Either way, M₁ is in cutoff for the entire input range.**\n\n# Transfer Characteristic\n\nSince $I_D = 0$, there is no drop across R_D:\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} = V_{DD} \\quad \\text{for all } 0 \\le V_{in} \\le V_{DD}}$$\n\n```\nVout\nVDD |————————————————————   ← flat line (M1 always off)\n    |\n    |__________________ Vin\n    0               VDD\n```\n\nSmall-signal gain: $A_v = dV_{out}/dV_{in} = 0$. **The circuit cannot amplify.**\n\n# Why the Design Fails\n\nThe gate is tied to the **wrong rail**. A PMOS needs its gate *low* relative to its source. With the gate at the most positive supply, conduction would require $V_{in} > V_{DD} + |V_{THP}|$ — i.e., driving the input **above the supply**. (Even then, V_out = V_DD + I_D·R_D would exceed V_DD, and once V_in surpasses V_DD by ~0.6 V, the source–n-well junction forward-biases. Not a practical mode.)\n\n# How to Make It Work\n\n**Option 1 — Use an NMOS** with identical connections. Then it becomes a proper common-gate amplifier:\n- Conducts for $V_{in} \\le V_{DD} - V_{THN}$, with $I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}(V_{DD} - V_{in} - V_{THN})^2$ in saturation\n- $V_{out} = V_{DD} - I_D R_D$\n- Gain: $A_v = +g_m R_D$ (non-inverting; $(g_m + g_{mb})R_D$ with body effect)\n- $R_{in} \\approx 1/g_m$ (low), $R_{out} = R_D$\n\n**Option 2 — Keep the PMOS but rebias it**: tie the gate to ground (or a low V_b) and return the load resistor to ground. Then M₁ conducts for $V_{in} \\ge V_b + |V_{THP}|$ and provides the same CG gain $+g_m R_D$.\n\n**Key takeaway:** This is a classic \"trap\" topology — the connections mimic a common-gate stage, but the PMOS gate biased at V_DD guarantees cutoff, pinning V_out at V_DD with zero gain.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "74ec9cb70202de000560e097cd92ad7872b2fbcf004e345eaedb6a8a9c6ef010"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly recognizes the source-input common-gate connection and gives the appropriate gain and input-resistance relations for a hypothetical NMOS. But it misidentifies the depicted device and concludes the actual circuit is cut off with zero gain, contradicting the intended common-gate analysis.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "1b3a848197667846074404db3b3d8871ff2129384f8d686f3624e0319ea90d69",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1233,
        "output_tokens": 24308,
        "total_tokens": 25541,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 23082,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1233,
        "output_tokens": 24308,
        "total_tokens": 25541,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 23082,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-009-common-gate-source-input",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-009-common-gate-source-input/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Common‑Gate (CG) Amplifier Analysis\n\n## 1. Topology Identification\n\n| Terminal of M₁ | Connection | Role |\n|---|---|---|\n| Gate | Tied to $V_{DD}$ | **AC ground** (fixed bias) |\n| Source | Driven by $V_{in}$ | **Input** |\n| Drain | $V_{out}$, through $R_D$ to $V_{DD}$ | **Output** |\n\nSince the signal enters the **source** and exits the **drain** while the gate is held at a constant potential, this is an NMOS **common-gate stage**, with the bias established by the input's DC level itself (no separate bias network needed).\n\n## 2. DC (Large-Signal) Operation\n\nWith $V_G = V_{DD}$:\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_{DD} - V_{in}$$\n\n**Cutoff:** $V_{in} \\ge V_{DD} - V_{TH} \\;\\Rightarrow\\; I_D = 0,\\; V_{out} = V_{DD}$\n\n**Saturation:** as $V_{in}$ drops below $V_{DD}-V_{TH}$:\n\n$$I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}\\left(V_{DD} - V_{in} - V_{TH}\\right)^2, \\qquad V_{out} = V_{DD} - I_D R_D$$\n\n**Saturation condition:** $V_{DS} \\ge V_{GS}-V_{TH}$ gives\n\n$$V_{out} - V_{in} \\ge (V_{DD}-V_{in}) - V_{TH} \\;\\;\\Longrightarrow\\;\\; \\boxed{V_{out} \\ge V_{DD}-V_{TH} \\iff I_D R_D \\le V_{TH}}$$\n\n**Key design constraint:** the drop across $R_D$ may not exceed one threshold voltage, or M₁ enters the triode region. This caps the achievable gain:\n\n$$A_v = g_m R_D = \\frac{2 I_D R_D}{V_{DD}-V_{in}-V_{TH}} \\le \\frac{2V_{TH}}{V_{OV}}$$\n\n## 3. Small-Signal Analysis (λ = 0)\n\nWith the gate at AC ground: $v_{gs} = -v_{in}$. KCL at the drain:\n\n$$\\frac{-v_{out}}{R_D} = g_m v_{gs} = -g_m v_{in} \\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad \\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = +g_m R_D}$$\n\nThe gain is **positive (non-inverting)** — raising $V_{in}$ reduces $V_{GS}$, reduces $I_D$, and $V_{out}$ rises.\n\n**Input resistance** (looking into the source):\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{1}{g_m} \\quad \\text{(low — characteristic of CG)}$$\n\n**Output resistance:**\n$$R_{out} = R_D$$\n\n## 4. Non-Idealities\n\n| Quantity | Ideal | With body effect | With $r_O$ |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| $A_v$ | $g_m R_D$ | $(g_m + g_{mb})R_D$ | $(g_m+g_{mb}+\\frac{1}{r_O})(R_D \\,\\|\\, r_O)$ |\n| $R_{in}$ | $1/g_m$ | $1/(g_m+g_{mb})$ | $\\dfrac{R_D + r_O}{1+(g_m+g_{mb})r_O}$ |\n| $R_{out}$ | $R_D$ | $R_D$ | $R_D \\,\\|\\, r_O$ |\n\nNote: body effect actually **increases** the CG gain (one of the few topologies where it helps). If the source driving $V_{in}$ has resistance $R_S$, the gain degrades to:\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_m R_D}{1 + g_m R_S}$$\n\n## 5. Practical Observations\n\n- **Low input impedance** ($\\approx 1/g_m$): suited for impedance matching (e.g., 50 Ω RF systems) or sensing *current* inputs — not ideal for high-impedance voltage sources.\n- **No Miller effect:** the gate is grounded, so $C_{GD}$ is not Miller-multiplied → excellent high-frequency behavior (why CG stages appear in cascodes).\n- **Bias caveat:** the input source must carry the full DC drain current $I_D$, and its DC level directly sets the operating point ($V_{GS} = V_{DD} - V_{in}$).\n- Same gain magnitude as a common-source stage ($g_m R_D$), but **non-inverting**.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "664bff8ca134909975390da5decaae4c1e219b973c29b116584bacb04fe8f807"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-driven common-gate topology and gives the essential results: approximately 1/gm input resistance and positive gain of gmRD. The additional analyses are consistent with the stated assumptions.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "1b3a848197667846074404db3b3d8871ff2129384f8d686f3624e0319ea90d69",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1233,
        "output_tokens": 11920,
        "total_tokens": 13153,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10309,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1233,
        "output_tokens": 11920,
        "total_tokens": 13153,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10309,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-009-common-gate-source-input",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-009-common-gate-source-input/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is an NMOS **common-gate (CG) amplifier**:\n\n| Terminal | Connection |\n|----------|-----------|\n| Gate | Tied to $V_{DD}$ (AC ground / bias) |\n| Source (arrow) | Driven by $V_{in}$ |\n| Drain | Output node, loaded by $R_D$ to $V_{DD}$ |\n\nThe input enters the *source* and the output is taken at the *drain*, with the gate held at a fixed potential — the defining signature of a CG stage.\n\n# Qualitative Operation\n\nSince $V_{GS} = V_{DD} - V_{in}$:\n\n$$V_{in}\\uparrow \\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_{GS}\\downarrow \\;\\Rightarrow\\; I_D\\downarrow \\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_{out} = V_{DD} - I_D R_D \\uparrow$$\n\nThe stage is **noninverting**, unlike a common-source amplifier.\n\n# Large-Signal / Bias Analysis\n\n- **Cutoff:** for $V_{in} \\ge V_{DD} - V_{TH}$, $M_1$ is off and $V_{out} = V_{DD}$.\n- **Saturation:** as $V_{in}$ drops below $V_{DD}-V_{TH}$:\n\n$$I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}\\left(V_{DD} - V_{in} - V_{TH}\\right)^2, \\qquad V_{out} = V_{DD} - I_D R_D$$\n\n- **Saturation condition:** need $V_{DS} \\ge V_{GS} - V_{TH}$, i.e. $V_D \\ge V_G - V_{TH} = V_{DD} - V_{TH}$. Therefore:\n\n$$\\boxed{I_D R_D \\le V_{TH}}$$\n\nA key consequence of tying the gate to $V_{DD}$: the drop across $R_D$ cannot exceed one threshold voltage, which directly limits the achievable gain ($g_m R_D$).\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis\n\nWith $V_{DD}$ as AC ground, the gate is grounded and $v_{gs} = -v_{in}$. KCL at the drain (including $r_O$):\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{R_D} + \\frac{v_{out}-v_{in}}{r_O} - g_m v_{in} = 0$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\left(g_m + \\tfrac{1}{r_O}\\right)(R_D \\,\\|\\, r_O) \\;\\approx\\; +g_m R_D}$$\n\n(With body effect, $g_m \\rightarrow g_m + g_{mb}$.) The magnitude equals that of a CS stage, but with **positive sign**.\n\n**Port impedances:**\n\n$$R_{in} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_m + g_{mb}} \\quad (\\text{low}), \\qquad R_{out} \\approx R_D \\,\\|\\, r_O \\approx R_D$$\n\n# Key Properties & Practical Notes\n\n- **Low input impedance** ($\\approx 1/g_m$): a drawback for voltage amplification from high-impedance sources, but useful as a **current buffer**, in **cascodes**, or for matching low-impedance (e.g., 50 Ω) sources.\n- **Excellent high-frequency behavior:** $C_{GD}$ connects the output to an AC-ground gate, so there is **no Miller multiplication** — a major advantage over the CS stage.\n- **Biasing caveat:** the DC level of $V_{in}$ sets $V_{GS}$ and hence $I_D$, and the signal source must sink the entire bias current. In practice, the bias current is established with a current source/resistor at the source node and the signal is capacitively coupled.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "e5affabd441a4e6eb2fa5912244cf8674fd268b4b292861a77aaac2a08d70b10"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-driven common-gate topology and gives the non-inverting gain, including the ro expression, and low input resistance. The additional discussion is largely consistent; its gain-headroom claim is a minor qualification, not a flaw in the essential analysis.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "1b3a848197667846074404db3b3d8871ff2129384f8d686f3624e0319ea90d69",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1233,
        "output_tokens": 27065,
        "total_tokens": 28298,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 25772,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1233,
        "output_tokens": 27065,
        "total_tokens": 28298,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 25772,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Analysis: A Flawed Common-Gate Stage\n\nThis circuit (a classic example from Razavi's *Fundamentals of Microelectronics*) is an **attempt at a common-gate (CG) amplifier** — but it contains a fatal error. Let's see why.\n\n## Topology Recognition\n\n- **Gate** of NMOS $M_1$ is tied to a DC bias $V_b$ → AC ground (consistent with a CG stage)\n- **Drain** connects through $R_D$ to $V_{DD}$, and $V_{out}$ is taken there\n- **Input** $V_{in}$ is coupled through $C_1$ to the **source**... but the source is *also tied directly to ground*.\n\n## DC Bias — Actually Fine\n\nSince $C_1$ blocks DC, the bias point is set only by $V_b$:\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_b, \\qquad I_D = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_b - V_{TH})^2$$\n\n$$V_{out,DC} = V_{DD} - I_D R_D$$\n\nThe transistor is properly biased in saturation as long as $V_{DD} - I_D R_D \\ge V_b - V_{TH}$. **The problem is not the bias.**\n\n## Small-Signal Analysis — The Fatal Flaw\n\nThe source node is hard-wired to ground, i.e., it is a **zero-impedance node**:\n\n- The signal arriving through $C_1$ sees an AC short to ground. The entire $v_{in}$ drops across $C_1$, and the source node voltage remains **exactly 0 V** at all times.\n- With $v_g = 0$ (AC) and $v_s = 0$:\n\n$$v_{gs} = 0 \\;\\Rightarrow\\; i_d = g_m v_{gs} = 0 \\;\\Rightarrow\\; \\boxed{v_{out} = 0,\\quad A_v = 0}$$\n\nThe input source merely pumps a useless reactive current $i = C_1\\, dV_{in}/dt$ straight into ground. The transistor just sits there as a DC current source loaded by $R_D$.\n\n**Key principle violated:** a signal can only be injected into a node with *nonzero impedance*. Grounding the source shorts out the input.\n\n## The Fix\n\nReplace the direct ground connection with a **source resistor $R_S$** (or better, a current source):\n\n- **Bias:** $I_D$ now satisfies $V_b - I_D R_S = V_{GS}$ (solved with the square law)\n- **Signal path:** $C_1$ (a short at signal frequencies) couples $v_{in}$ to the source, which now presents an impedance $\\;\\frac{1}{g_m}\\parallel R_S$\n\nThe circuit then works as a proper CG amplifier:\n\n$$A_v = +g_m R_D \\quad (\\text{non-inverting}), \\qquad R_{in} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_m}\\parallel R_S, \\qquad R_{out} \\approx R_D$$\n\nwith $C_1$ chosen so that $\\frac{1}{\\omega C_1} \\ll \\frac{1}{g_m}\\parallel R_S$ at the frequencies of interest.\n\n**Bottom line:** as drawn, the circuit is biased correctly but provides **zero gain** because the grounded source shorts the input signal to ground.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "db5e7c5df5f89c9a9e653e48a694efb1034c088a20fe6660dbe6d39fb28b3bfa"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly notices that the source is hard-shorted to ground, so the input cannot produce a small-signal source voltage and the ideal gain is zero, as required for full credit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "4fa501e147a166a71d6aa33565bbe693318d65c0c8c788e7a5087eb13c71d3ea",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1904,
        "output_tokens": 6797,
        "total_tokens": 8701,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5671,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1904,
        "output_tokens": 6797,
        "total_tokens": 8701,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5671,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Analysis: A Flawed Common-Gate Stage\n\n## Topology Identification\n\nThis circuit is *intended* to be a **common-gate (CG) amplifier**:\n- Input $V_{in}$ coupled through capacitor $C_1$ into the **source** of $M_1$\n- Gate held at a DC bias $V_b$ (AC ground)\n- Output taken at the **drain**, with load resistor $R_D$ to $V_{DD}$\n\nHowever, there is a critical flaw: **the source of $M_1$ is tied directly to ground.**\n\n## DC (Bias) Analysis\n\nThe bias point itself is fine. With the source grounded:\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_b \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad I_D = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_b - V_{TH})^2$$\n\n$$V_{out,DC} = V_{DD} - I_D R_D$$\n\n$M_1$ operates in saturation provided $V_{DD} - I_D R_D \\ge V_b - V_{TH}$. The capacitor $C_1$ correctly blocks DC, so $V_{in}$ does not disturb the bias.\n\n## Small-Signal Analysis — The Problem\n\nIn the AC equivalent circuit:\n\n- The source node is connected to ground by a **wire (zero impedance)** → $v_s = 0$ always\n- The gate is at AC ground ($V_b$ is a fixed DC voltage) → $v_g = 0$\n\nTherefore:\n\n$$v_{gs} = v_g - v_s = 0 \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad i_d = g_m v_{gs} = 0 \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad v_{out} = 0$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = 0}$$\n\n**Intuition:** The input signal is simply **shorted to ground**. The entire swing of $v_{in}$ is dropped across $C_1$ (the signal current $i = v_{in}\\cdot sC_1$ flows harmlessly into ground), and the source node never moves. No signal reaches the transistor, so nothing appears at the output.\n\n## How to Fix It\n\nThe coupling capacitor must drive a node with **finite, nonzero impedance**. Replace the direct ground connection with:\n\n1. **A current source $I_1$** (best option): sets $I_D$ independently and presents high impedance, giving the standard CG results:\n$$A_v = g_m R_D \\;(\\text{noninverting}), \\qquad R_{in} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_m}, \\qquad R_{out} \\approx R_D$$\n\n2. **A source resistor $R_S$**: bias becomes $V_b = V_{GS} + I_D R_S$, and the gain is approximately:\n$$A_v \\approx \\frac{R_D}{\\frac{1}{g_m}} \\cdot \\frac{R_S}{R_S + \\frac{1}{g_m}} \\cdot \\frac{1}{1} = g_m R_D \\cdot \\frac{R_S \\| \\frac{1}{g_m}}{...}$$\n(i.e., slightly reduced because $R_S$ shunts part of the input signal away from $1/g_m$).\n\n## Key Takeaway\n\nCapacitive coupling only works if the node being driven can \"move.\" Here, the direct ground wire makes the source a stiff AC ground — the bias is correct, but **the signal path is destroyed**, yielding zero gain.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "71ae55717d911cd8da83f73c7133b5216e0fbef1e011055481dca947d2aa5388"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly notices that the source is hard-shorted to ground, so the input cannot create a source signal and the ideal small-signal gain is zero. The extra fix suggestions do not alter the essential conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "4fa501e147a166a71d6aa33565bbe693318d65c0c8c788e7a5087eb13c71d3ea",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1904,
        "output_tokens": 4769,
        "total_tokens": 6673,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3601,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1904,
        "output_tokens": 4769,
        "total_tokens": 6673,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3601,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is an **attempted common-gate (CG) amplifier**: the gate of $M_1$ is held at a DC bias $V_b$ (an AC ground), the input is coupled through $C_1$ into the source, and the output is taken at the drain across $R_D$. This is the classic \"flawed CG biasing\" example (from Razavi's *Fundamentals of Microelectronics*).\n\n# DC (Bias) Analysis\n\nSince $C_1$ blocks DC and the source is tied to ground, the bias point is well-defined:\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_b \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L}(V_b - V_{TH})^2$$\n\n$$V_{out,DC} = V_{DD} - I_D R_D$$\n\nwith saturation guaranteed if $V_{DD} - I_D R_D \\ge V_b - V_{TH}$. So far, so good — the transistor conducts and can sit in saturation.\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis — The Fatal Flaw\n\n**The source node is wired directly to ground, so it is an AC ground.** Consequently:\n\n- The signal path $v_{in} \\rightarrow C_1$ terminates on a short circuit. The source voltage cannot move: $v_s = 0$.\n- With $v_g = 0$ (fixed bias) and $v_s = 0$:\n\n$$v_{gs} = 0 \\;\\Rightarrow\\; i_d = g_m v_{gs} = 0 \\;\\Rightarrow\\; v_{out} = -g_m v_{gs} R_D = 0$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = 0}$$\n\nThe input source merely pushes a useless current $i_{in} = j\\omega C_1 v_{in}$ straight into ground; the transistor never \"sees\" the signal. The input impedance is just $1/(j\\omega C_1)$ — the amplifier is invisible to $V_{in}$.\n\n**The underlying conflict:** the ground wire was added to provide a DC path for $I_D$ (without it, $C_1$ blocks the bias current and $M_1$ carries zero current). But a direct short satisfies the DC requirement while destroying the AC operation.\n\n# The Fix\n\nReplace the short with an element that is a DC path but *not* an AC short — a resistor $R_S$ (or better, a current source) from source to ground:\n\n**Bias:** $\\quad V_b = V_{GS} + I_D R_S$ (degeneration also stabilizes $I_D$ against variations in $V_b$, $V_{TH}$).\n\n**Small-signal (with $C_1$ a short at signal frequencies, $\\lambda = 0$):**\n\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{1}{g_m}\\,\\Big\\|\\,R_S, \\qquad R_{out} = R_D$$\n\n$$A_v = +\\,g_m R_D \\quad \\text{(noninverting, for an ideal source)}$$\n\nor more generally, with source resistance $R_{sig}$:\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{R_{in}}{R_{in}+R_{sig}}\\cdot g_m R_D$$\n\nwith a high-pass corner set by the coupling network: $f_L = \\dfrac{1}{2\\pi C_1 (R_{sig} + R_{in})}$.\n\n# Summary\n\n| Property | As drawn | After fix ($R_S$ added) |\n|---|---|---|\n| DC bias | OK: $I_D$ set by $V_b$ | OK, and stabilized |\n| Voltage gain | **0** (input shorted to ground) | $\\approx g_m R_D$ |\n| Input impedance | $1/j\\omega C_1$ only | $\\tfrac{1}{g_m}\\|R_S$ (low — typical of CG) |\n\n**Bottom line:** the circuit biases correctly but provides zero gain, because grounding the source turns the signal injection point into an AC ground.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "fcb1bc990b25792c25d61bed7f5c80d309bc4164efde2c5ca8d9110a4b74a6a1"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies that the source is hard-shorted to ground, so the input cannot produce a source signal and the ideal gain is zero. The golden solution explicitly grants full credit for this conclusion; the additional redesign discussion is not essential.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "4fa501e147a166a71d6aa33565bbe693318d65c0c8c788e7a5087eb13c71d3ea",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1904,
        "output_tokens": 12313,
        "total_tokens": 14217,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10974,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1904,
        "output_tokens": 12313,
        "total_tokens": 14217,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10974,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-011-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-011-many-poles-have/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Answer: **Two poles**\n\n### Reasoning\n\nAt first glance the circuit contains **four** capacitors, but not all of them contribute independent dynamics:\n\n**1. $C_{SB}$ plays no role.**\nThe source of $M_1$ is tied directly to ground, so $C_{SB}$ has *both* terminals at AC ground. It can never charge or discharge and therefore does not affect the transfer function.\n\n**2. The remaining three capacitors form a loop.**\n- $C_{GS}$: gate → ground\n- $C_{GD}$: gate → drain\n- $C_{DB}$: drain → ground\n\nThese three capacitors form a closed loop (ground → gate → drain → ground). In a capacitor loop, once the voltages across *two* capacitors are known, the third is automatically fixed (KVL). Hence only **two independent state variables** (initial conditions) exist.\n\nEquivalently: the circuit has only **two nodes** whose voltages can vary — the gate node (X) and the output node — and each contributes one pole.\n\n### Confirmation from the transfer function\n\nWriting KCL at the gate and drain nodes gives:\n\n$$\n\\frac{V_{out}}{V_{in}}(s) = \\frac{(C_{GD}\\,s - g_m)R_D}{R_S R_D \\,\\xi\\, s^2 + \\Big[R_S(1+g_m R_D)C_{GD} + R_S C_{GS} + R_D(C_{GD}+C_{DB})\\Big]s + 1}\n$$\n\nwhere $\\xi = C_{GS}C_{GD} + C_{GS}C_{DB} + C_{GD}C_{DB}$.\n\nThe denominator is **second-order in $s$**, confirming the circuit has exactly **two poles** (and one zero at $s = +g_m/C_{GD}$).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0794d33e72448d97626b932f952e6bd3ad9dd8635e75ba5adf4f8c6ada8fb309"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies that CSB is shorted out and that CGS, CGD, and CDB form a loop with only two independent capacitor voltages; the second-order denominator confirms two poles.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d6e2d72c604ae3c83e7b25306ecb7ec85736574c7dd1a3f26a206b697a6dabfe",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2126,
        "output_tokens": 1835,
        "total_tokens": 3961,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1230,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2126,
        "output_tokens": 1835,
        "total_tokens": 3961,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1230,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-011-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-011-many-poles-have/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Answer: **Two poles**\n\n## Reasoning\n\nThe number of poles equals the number of **independent** capacitor voltages (energy-storage states) in the circuit, not simply the number of capacitors.\n\n**Step 1 — Eliminate C_SB:**\nThe source of $M_1$ is tied to ground, and the bulk is also grounded. Therefore $C_{SB}$ has *both* terminals grounded — it carries no signal and contributes nothing to the dynamics.\n\n**Step 2 — Check the remaining capacitors:**\nThree capacitors remain:\n- $C_{GS}$: gate → ground\n- $C_{GD}$: gate → drain  \n- $C_{DB}$: drain → ground\n\nThese three capacitors form a **closed loop**:\n\n$$\\text{gate} \\xrightarrow{C_{GS}} \\text{ground} \\xrightarrow{C_{DB}} \\text{drain} \\xrightarrow{C_{GD}} \\text{gate}$$\n\nBy KVL around this loop:\n\n$$V_{C_{GS}} = V_{C_{GD}} + V_{C_{DB}}$$\n\nso one capacitor voltage is fully determined by the other two — only **two independent states** exist.\n\n**Step 3 — Count poles:**\nEquivalently, the circuit has only two signal nodes (the gate node and the drain/output node), each with capacitance to ground and finite resistance:\n\n| Node | Pole |\n|------|------|\n| Gate (input node) | $\\omega_{p1} \\approx \\dfrac{1}{R_S\\left[C_{GS}+(1+g_m R_D)C_{GD}\\right]}$ (Miller) |\n| Drain (output node) | $\\omega_{p2} \\approx \\dfrac{1}{R_D\\left(C_{DB}+C_{GD}\\right)}$ |\n\n$$\\boxed{\\text{The circuit has } \\mathbf{2} \\text{ poles}}$$",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "752200edcbeb5b3db15153362b6f08aba75ed7d2a8c2e7d967c84ef8a0aba002"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes there are two poles and justifies the count by noting that C_SB is grounded at both ends and the remaining three capacitor voltages are constrained by their loop. The approximate pole formulas are not needed for the conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d6e2d72c604ae3c83e7b25306ecb7ec85736574c7dd1a3f26a206b697a6dabfe",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2126,
        "output_tokens": 1483,
        "total_tokens": 3609,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 838,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2126,
        "output_tokens": 1483,
        "total_tokens": 3609,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 838,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-011-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-011-many-poles-have/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Counting the Poles\n\n**Answer: 2 poles**\n\n## Reasoning\n\nThe number of poles equals the number of *independent* capacitor voltages (independent energy-storage elements) in the circuit.\n\n**Step 1: Eliminate C_SB**\n\nThe source of $M_1$ is tied directly to ground, so **both terminals of $C_{SB}$ are grounded**. This capacitor is shorted out and plays no role in the dynamics.\n\n**Step 2: Check the remaining capacitors**\n\nThe three remaining capacitors are:\n- $C_{GS}$: gate → ground  \n- $C_{GD}$: gate → drain  \n- $C_{DB}$: drain → ground  \n\nThese three capacitors **form a loop** (gate → drain → ground → gate). In a capacitor loop, one capacitor's voltage is fixed by the other two:\n\n$$V_{C_{GD}} = V_{C_{GS}} - V_{C_{DB}}$$\n\nso only **two** capacitor voltages are independent.\n\n**Step 3: Equivalent node argument**\n\nEquivalently, there are only two circuit nodes whose voltages are state variables — the **gate node** and the **drain (output) node** — and each contributes one pole.\n\n## Result\n\nThe transfer function has a second-order denominator:\n\n$$\\frac{V_{out}}{V_{in}} = \\frac{(sC_{GD} - g_m)R_D}{s^2 R_S R_D \\xi + s\\big[R_S(1+g_mR_D)C_{GD} + R_S C_{GS} + R_D(C_{GD}+C_{DB})\\big] + 1}$$\n\nwhere $\\xi = C_{GS}C_{GD} + C_{GS}C_{DB} + C_{GD}C_{DB}$ — confirming **two poles**, even though the circuit contains four capacitors.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "4d6d6d780127fa4baa2523f7c4af1301d58a12cb5daedfba9428a0b492096932"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies two poles and justifies the count by noting that C_SB is grounded at both terminals and the remaining three capacitor voltages are constrained by a loop. The second-order denominator is consistent with the result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d6e2d72c604ae3c83e7b25306ecb7ec85736574c7dd1a3f26a206b697a6dabfe",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2126,
        "output_tokens": 1793,
        "total_tokens": 3919,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1181,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2126,
        "output_tokens": 1793,
        "total_tokens": 3919,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1181,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **common-gate (CG) amplifier with negative feedback** — a classic example of **voltage–voltage (series–shunt) feedback** (e.g., Razavi, *Fundamentals of Microelectronics*, Ch. 12).\n\n**Topology:**\n- **Forward amplifier:** M₁ with load R_D, input applied at the **source** (V_in), output at the **drain** (V_out) → common-gate stage.\n- **Feedback network:** R₁–R₂ divider **senses V_out** (parallel/voltage sensing) and **returns** a fraction to the gate:\n\n$$V_F = \\frac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}\\,V_{out} \\equiv K\\,V_{out}, \\qquad K = \\frac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}$$\n\n- **Subtraction:** occurs across the gate–source terminals, since $v_{GS} = V_F - V_{in}$ (series mixing).\n\n**Negative feedback check:** V_out ↑ → V_F ↑ → V_GS ↑ → I_D ↑ → larger drop across R_D → V_out ↓. ✓\n\n# Closed-Loop Gain (small-signal, λ = 0, no body effect)\n\nThe drain current is $i_D = g_m v_{GS} = g_m (V_F - V_{in})$, and $V_{out} = -i_D R_D$ (neglecting the loading of R₁+R₂):\n\n$$V_{out} = g_m R_D (V_{in} - K V_{out})$$\n\n$$\\boxed{\\frac{V_{out}}{V_{in}} = \\frac{g_m R_D}{1 + \\dfrac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}\\, g_m R_D}}$$\n\n**Including the loading** of the divider on the output node (replace $R_D \\to R_D \\parallel (R_1+R_2)$):\n\n$$\\frac{V_{out}}{V_{in}} = \\frac{g_m\\left[R_D \\| (R_1+R_2)\\right]}{1 + K\\, g_m\\left[R_D \\| (R_1+R_2)\\right]} = \\frac{A}{1+KA}$$\n\nwhere the open-loop gain is $A = g_m [R_D \\| (R_1+R_2)]$ and the loop gain is $KA$.\n\n**Deep-feedback limit** ($KA \\gg 1$):\n\n$$\\frac{V_{out}}{V_{in}} \\approx \\frac{1}{K} = 1 + \\frac{R_1}{R_2}$$\n\ni.e., the gain is set by a resistor ratio, independent of $g_m$ — desensitized to transistor variations.\n\n# Terminal Impedances\n\nSeries–shunt feedback **raises input impedance** and **lowers output impedance** by $(1+KA)$:\n\n| Quantity | Open loop (CG stage) | Closed loop |\n|---|---|---|\n| Input resistance (at source) | $\\dfrac{1}{g_m}$ | $\\dfrac{1}{g_m}\\,(1+KA)$ |\n| Output resistance | $R_D \\| (R_1+R_2)$ | $\\dfrac{R_D \\| (R_1+R_2)}{1+KA}$ |\n\nBoth are ideal trends for a **voltage amplifier** (high Z_in, low Z_out).\n\n# Sanity Checks\n\n- $R_2 = 0$ (K = 0): gate grounded → plain CG stage, gain $= g_m(R_D\\|R_1)$. ✓\n- $R_1 = 0$ (K = 1): gain $\\to \\frac{g_m R}{1+g_m R} \\approx 1$, a unity-gain follower. ✓\n- The gate draws no current, so the divider is unloaded; its only loading effect is $R_1+R_2$ appearing at the drain.\n\n# Assumptions\n\n- Channel-length modulation ($r_o = \\infty$) and body effect neglected.\n- V_in treated as an ideal voltage source (it also carries the bias current of M₁).\n- The divider additionally self-biases the gate from the DC output level.\n\n**Summary:** A non-inverting voltage amplifier with closed-loop gain $\\approx 1 + R_1/R_2$, stabilized by negative feedback, with boosted input impedance and reduced output impedance.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "8812a2a400f3e8f65f12fb707e9d8e198eeaefcadb0aaebb4b40de1114e8bbca"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source input, output-divider feedback to the gate, and negative feedback; its loaded closed-loop gain is also correct. The golden solution explicitly grants full credit for these essentials, and the extra impedance discussion is not required.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c4eb57e96a0e70ff6aa718bcfd4e80be89f93bd2bf97d638ee206a2ecd64f575",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1772,
        "output_tokens": 7886,
        "total_tokens": 9658,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6447,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1772,
        "output_tokens": 7886,
        "total_tokens": 9658,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6447,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Analysis: Common-Gate Stage with Voltage Feedback\n\n## 1. Topology Recognition\n\n- **M₁** receives the input $V_{in}$ at its **source** and delivers the output at its **drain** → it operates as a **common-gate (CG) amplifier** with load $R_D$.\n- **R₁–R₂** form a voltage divider that **senses $V_{out}$** and **returns the fraction**\n\n$$V_F = \\frac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}\\,V_{out} \\equiv K\\,V_{out}, \\qquad K=\\frac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}$$\n\nto the **gate**. Since the controlling voltage is $v_{GS} = V_F - V_{in}$, the feedback signal is *subtracted* from the input across the gate–source port.\n\nThis is **voltage–voltage (series–shunt) feedback**: voltage sensed in shunt at the output, voltage returned in series at the input.\n\n**Polarity check (negative feedback):** $V_{out}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_F\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_{GS}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow I_D\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow$ drop across $R_D\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_{out}\\!\\downarrow$. ✔ Negative feedback (it also stabilizes the DC bias point).\n\n## 2. Closed-Loop Gain (direct KCL, with $\\lambda = 0$, no body effect)\n\nKCL at the output node (small-signal, $V_{DD}\\to$ AC ground):\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{R_D} + \\frac{v_{out}}{R_1+R_2} + g_m\\underbrace{\\left(\\frac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}v_{out} - v_{in}\\right)}_{v_{GS}} = 0$$\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;\\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_m R_D (R_1+R_2)}{R_1+R_2+R_D(1+g_m R_2)}\\;}$$\n\n**Limiting case:** for large loop gain ($g_m R_D R_2 \\gg R_1+R_2+R_D$):\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} \\to \\frac{1}{K} = 1+\\frac{R_1}{R_2}$$\n\ni.e., a **non-inverting amplifier** whose gain is set by the resistor ratio — insensitive to $g_m$ and $R_D$.\n\n## 3. Feedback-Theory View\n\n| Quantity | Expression |\n|---|---|\n| Open-loop gain (incl. divider loading) | $A_0 = g_m\\big(R_D \\,\\|\\, (R_1+R_2)\\big)$ |\n| Feedback factor | $K = \\dfrac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}$ |\n| Loop gain | $T = K A_0 = \\dfrac{g_m R_D R_2}{R_D+R_1+R_2}$ |\n| Closed-loop gain | $A_v = \\dfrac{A_0}{1+T}$ (identical to the boxed result) |\n\n## 4. Port Impedances\n\n**Input resistance** (series feedback at input → *increased*):\n\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{1}{g_m}(1+T) = \\frac{1}{g_m} + \\frac{R_D R_2}{R_D+R_1+R_2}$$\n\n(vs. just $1/g_m$ for a plain CG stage).\n\n**Output resistance** (shunt sensing at output → *decreased*):\n\n$$R_{out} = \\frac{R_D \\,\\|\\,(R_1+R_2)}{1+T} = \\frac{R_D(R_1+R_2)}{R_1+R_2+R_D(1+g_m R_2)}$$\n\n## 5. DC Bias Note\n\nWith zero gate current, $V_F = \\frac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}V_{out}$ and \n\n$$V_{out} = V_{DD} - R_D\\!\\left(I_D + \\frac{V_{out}}{R_1+R_2}\\right),\\qquad V_{GS}=V_F - V_{IN} > V_{TH}$$\n\nThe feedback loop self-biases M₁: any drift in $I_D$ is counteracted through $V_F$.\n\n## 6. Summary of Feedback Benefits (and assumptions)\n\n- Gain desensitized to device parameters: $\\frac{dA_v}{A_v} = \\frac{1}{1+T}\\frac{dA_0}{A_0}$; ideally $A_v \\approx 1 + R_1/R_2$.\n- Higher $R_{in}$ (good for a voltage-sensing input), lower $R_{out}$ (good voltage output), and bandwidth extended by $(1+T)$ if the output pole dominates.\n- Assumptions used: $\\lambda = 0$ (no $r_O$), body effect neglected, zero gate current. Including $r_O$ and $g_{mb}$ modifies $A_0$ and the impedances but not the structure of the results.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0124feee4837a2ce50905bfe98b18ce6d516876d8a945e2d8e117b76aa5884c5"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source input, output-divider feedback to the gate, and negative feedback. Its closed-loop gain is algebraically equivalent to the golden result; the additional analysis is consistent with the stated assumptions.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c4eb57e96a0e70ff6aa718bcfd4e80be89f93bd2bf97d638ee206a2ecd64f575",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1772,
        "output_tokens": 10306,
        "total_tokens": 12078,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8589,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1772,
        "output_tokens": 10306,
        "total_tokens": 12078,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8589,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a classic **negative-feedback amplifier**: a common-gate stage (M₁, R_D) wrapped with a resistive voltage divider (R₁, R₂) that feeds a fraction of the output back to the gate.\n\n**The four feedback elements:**\n\n| Function | Element |\n|---|---|\n| Forward amplifier | M₁ + R_D (input at source, output at drain → common-gate) |\n| Output sensing | R₁ + R₂ placed *in parallel* with V_out (voltage sensing) |\n| Feedback network | Divider: V_F = V_out · R₂/(R₁+R₂) |\n| Subtraction | M₁'s gate–source port: V_GS = V_F − V_in |\n\n**Topology:** voltage–voltage (series–shunt) feedback — senses output *voltage*, returns a *voltage* in series with the input.\n\n**Negative-feedback check:** V_out ↑ → V_F ↑ → V_GS ↑ → I_D ↑ → drop across R_D ↑ → V_out ↓. The loop opposes the change. ✓\n\n# Closed-Loop Gain (λ = 0, body effect neglected)\n\nSince the gate draws no current, the divider is unloaded:\n\n$$v_F = \\frac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}\\,v_{out}$$\n\nKCL at the drain node (V_DD is AC ground), with i_D = g_m(v_F − v_in):\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{R_D} + \\frac{v_{out}}{R_1+R_2} + g_m\\left(v_F - v_{in}\\right) = 0$$\n\nSubstituting v_F and solving:\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;\\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_m R_D (R_1+R_2)}{R_D + R_1 + R_2 + g_m R_2 R_D}\\;}$$\n\nThe gain is **positive (non-inverting)** — as expected for a common-gate forward path.\n\n# Feedback Interpretation\n\n- **Loaded open-loop gain:** $A_0 = g_m\\left[R_D \\,\\|\\, (R_1+R_2)\\right]$\n- **Feedback factor:** $K = \\dfrac{R_2}{R_1+R_2}$\n- **Loop gain:** $T = K A_0 = \\dfrac{g_m R_2 R_D}{R_D+R_1+R_2}$\n- **Closed-loop gain:** $A_v = \\dfrac{A_0}{1+KA_0}$ (identical to the boxed result)\n\nFor large loop gain (g_m R_D large):\n\n$$A_v \\rightarrow \\frac{1}{K} = 1 + \\frac{R_1}{R_2}$$\n\n— exactly the MOS analog of an op-amp **non-inverting amplifier**: the gain is set by the resistor ratio, independent of g_m.\n\n# Port Impedances\n\n**Input resistance** (series mixing raises it): open-loop common-gate gives 1/g_m, boosted by feedback:\n\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{1+T}{g_m} = \\frac{R_D+R_1+R_2+g_m R_2 R_D}{g_m\\,(R_D+R_1+R_2)}$$\n\n**Output resistance** (shunt sensing lowers it):\n\n$$R_{out} = R_D \\,\\Big\\|\\, (R_1+R_2) \\,\\Big\\|\\, \\frac{1}{K g_m} = \\frac{R_D(R_1+R_2)}{R_D+R_1+R_2+g_m R_2 R_D}$$\n\nNice interpretation: through the divider, M₁ looks like a *diode-connected* device with effective transconductance K·g_m, presenting 1/(K g_m) at the output.\n\n# Additional Remarks\n\n- **Including r_O and body effect** (body grounded, so v_BS = −v_in):\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_m + g_{mb} + 1/r_O}{\\dfrac{1}{R_D} + \\dfrac{1}{R_1+R_2} + \\dfrac{1}{r_O} + \\dfrac{g_m R_2}{R_1+R_2}}$$\nBody effect actually *helps* the forward gain here (a common-gate property); only g_m appears in the feedback term since V_F drives only the gate.\n\n- **Biasing:** The gate bias is self-derived from the output (V_F = K·V_out). Saturation requires V_DS ≥ V_GS − V_TH ⟺ V_out ≥ K·V_out − V_TH, which is automatically satisfied for V_out > 0 since K < 1.\n\n- **Feedback benefits:** gain desensitized to g_m variation by (1+T), bandwidth extended by (1+T), input impedance raised, output impedance lowered — all signatures of series–shunt negative feedback.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "515531d38bb2d60742a1ccde65f20439eeb25b2ef162248b07c4b62e646cef2e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source input, output-to-gate resistive-divider feedback, and negative-feedback action. Its closed-loop gain is algebraically equivalent to the correct expression and has the right non-inverting high-loop-gain limit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c4eb57e96a0e70ff6aa718bcfd4e80be89f93bd2bf97d638ee206a2ecd64f575",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1772,
        "output_tokens": 20147,
        "total_tokens": 21919,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 18518,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1772,
        "output_tokens": 20147,
        "total_tokens": 21919,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 18518,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification: Source Follower with Current-Source Load\n\nThis is an **NMOS source follower (common-drain amplifier)** where:\n- **M₁** is the input device: gate = input, drain tied to V_DD (AC ground), output taken at the **source**\n- **M₂** is a **current source** (constant gate bias V_b, source grounded), replacing a resistive load\n\n---\n\n## Large-Signal (DC) Operation\n\nM₂ sets a constant bias current (when saturated):\n\n$$I_{D} = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_b - V_{TH2})^2$$\n\nSince M₁ must carry this same constant current, its gate–source voltage is fixed, and the output simply \"follows\" the input with a DC level shift:\n\n$$V_{out} = V_{in} - V_{GS1} = V_{in} - \\left(V_{TH1} + \\sqrt{\\frac{2I_D}{\\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)_1}}\\right)$$\n\n**Operating limits:**\n- M₂ saturated: $V_{out} \\ge V_b - V_{TH2}$\n- M₁ saturated: $V_{in} \\le V_{DD} + V_{TH1}$ (nearly always satisfied)\n- The main residual nonlinearity comes from **body effect**: $V_{TH1}$ varies with $V_{SB1} = V_{out}$\n\n---\n\n## Small-Signal Gain\n\nKCL at the output node (body of M₁ tied to ground, so $v_{bs1} = -v_{out}$):\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in} - v_{out}) - g_{mb1}v_{out} - \\frac{v_{out}}{r_{O1}} - \\frac{v_{out}}{r_{O2}} = 0$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1} + g_{mb1} + \\dfrac{1}{r_{O1}} + \\dfrac{1}{r_{O2}}} \\approx \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}} = \\frac{1}{1+\\eta}}$$\n\nThe gain is **positive but less than unity** (typically 0.7–0.9), limited primarily by the body effect ($\\eta = g_{mb}/g_m \\approx 0.2$–$0.3$).\n\n---\n\n## Impedances\n\n| Port | Resistance |\n|------|------------|\n| Input | $R_{in} \\to \\infty$ (gate, at low frequency) |\n| Output | $R_{out} = \\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}} \\,\\Big\\|\\, \\dfrac{1}{g_{mb1}} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{O1} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{O2} \\approx \\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}$ — **low** |\n\n---\n\n## Key Takeaways\n\n✅ **Advantages**\n- Acts as a **voltage buffer / level shifter**: high input impedance, low output impedance\n- The current source (vs. a resistor) keeps $I_D$ and hence $V_{GS1}$ nearly constant → gain closer to 1 and better linearity\n\n⚠️ **Drawbacks**\n- Gain < 1 and nonlinearity due to **body effect** on M₁ (unless M₁'s body can be tied to its source)\n- Consumes voltage headroom ($V_{out}$ shifted down by $V_{GS1}$)\n- Nonzero output resistance of M₂ ($r_{O2}$) slightly degrades gain",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "3a9d4a8a44e06fe724070fc4078afec5321fef5c0f2a3598d352dbc517baaa8f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as a source follower with M2 as its current-source load and gives a positive gain below unity, with appropriate body-effect and output-resistance refinements.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9c0eaf5035e4eafe98a151f1035fd6512be41f7b78831b9e6cd3dd9618a8eb67",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1295,
        "output_tokens": 3685,
        "total_tokens": 4980,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2454,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1295,
        "output_tokens": 3685,
        "total_tokens": 4980,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2454,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is an **NMOS source follower (common-drain amplifier) with a current-source load**:\n\n- **M₁** — input device: gate = $V_{in}$, drain = $V_{DD}$ (AC ground), **output taken at the source** → common-drain configuration.\n- **M₂** — biased by the fixed voltage $V_b$, acts as a **current source** (current sink) that sets the bias current $I_{D}$.\n\n---\n\n## 1. Large-Signal (DC) Analysis\n\nM₂ sets the bias current (assuming saturation):\n\n$$I_{D} = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_b - V_{TH2})^2$$\n\nSince $I_{D1} = I_{D2} = I_D$ is constant, $V_{GS1}$ is (nearly) constant, so:\n\n$$V_{out} = V_{in} - V_{GS1} = V_{in} - V_{TH1} - \\sqrt{\\frac{2I_D}{\\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)_1}}$$\n\n**The output \"follows\" the input with a roughly constant level shift of $V_{GS1}$.** \n\n*Caveat:* if the body of M₁ is tied to ground, $V_{TH1}$ depends on $V_{SB1} = V_{out}$ (body effect), introducing some nonlinearity.\n\n**Conditions for proper operation:**\n| Condition | Requirement |\n|---|---|\n| M₁ on | $V_{in} > V_{out} + V_{TH1}$ |\n| M₁ saturated | $V_{in} \\le V_{DD} + V_{TH1}$ (essentially always true) |\n| M₂ saturated | $V_{out} \\ge V_b - V_{TH2}$ (sets the **minimum output swing**) |\n\nMaximum output ≈ $V_{DD} - V_{GS1}$ (for $V_{in} = V_{DD}$).\n\n---\n\n## 2. Small-Signal Gain\n\nWith the drain of M₁ at AC ground, KCL at the output node (body of M₁ grounded, so $v_{bs1} = -v_{out}$):\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in} - v_{out}) - g_{mb1}v_{out} - \\frac{v_{out}}{r_{O1}} = \\frac{v_{out}}{r_{O2}}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_{m1}\\left(r_{O1}\\,\\|\\,r_{O2}\\,\\|\\,\\tfrac{1}{g_{mb1}}\\right)}{1 + g_{m1}\\left(r_{O1}\\,\\|\\,r_{O2}\\,\\|\\,\\tfrac{1}{g_{mb1}}\\right)} = \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+\\tfrac{1}{r_{O1}}+\\tfrac{1}{r_{O2}}}}$$\n\n**Limiting cases:**\n- Neglecting $\\lambda$: $A_v = \\dfrac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}} = \\dfrac{1}{1+\\eta} \\approx 0.7\\text{–}0.85$\n- Also neglecting body effect: $A_v \\to 1$\n\nThe gain is **positive but always less than unity** — the body effect is the dominant limitation.\n\n---\n\n## 3. Input / Output Impedance\n\n$$R_{in} \\approx \\infty \\quad \\text{(MOS gate, at low frequency)}$$\n\n$$R_{out} = \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\,\\frac{1}{g_{mb1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\,r_{O1}\\,\\Big\\|\\,r_{O2} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}} \\quad \\text{(low)}$$\n\n---\n\n## 4. Key Takeaways\n\n- **Function:** voltage **buffer / level shifter** — high input impedance, low output impedance, $A_v \\lesssim 1$. Often used to drive low-impedance or capacitive loads after a high-gain stage.\n- **Why a current-source load (M₂) instead of a resistor?** With constant $I_D$, $V_{GS1}$ stays nearly fixed, so the gain is higher and more linear, and performance doesn't depend on $V_{out}$ through the load current.\n- **Drawbacks:** gain < 1, body-effect nonlinearity (unless M₁'s body ties to its source), DC level shift of $V_{GS1}$, and limited downward swing ($V_{out,min} = V_b - V_{TH2}$, the overdrive of M₂).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f05c170d6064a75db5e1f3abc26cc9fdafc799b599254dc25c23dd22df47925b"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as a source follower and M2 as its current-source load, and gives a positive gain below unity with appropriate body-effect and output-resistance refinements. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9c0eaf5035e4eafe98a151f1035fd6512be41f7b78831b9e6cd3dd9618a8eb67",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1295,
        "output_tokens": 4977,
        "total_tokens": 6272,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3376,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1295,
        "output_tokens": 4977,
        "total_tokens": 6272,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3376,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification: Source Follower (Common-Drain Stage)\n\nThis is an NMOS **source follower** with a **current-source load**:\n\n- **M₁**: input device — gate driven by $V_{in}$, drain tied to $V_{DD}$ (AC ground), output taken at the **source**.\n- **M₂**: biased by constant voltage $V_b$, acts as a **current sink**, setting the bias current $I_{D}$.\n\n---\n\n## 1. Operating Conditions\n\n**M₂** (in saturation, neglecting λ):\n$$I_{D} = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_b - V_{TH2})^2, \\quad \\text{requires } V_{out} \\ge V_b - V_{TH2}$$\n\n**M₁** is in saturation as long as it conducts, since $V_{D1} = V_{DD}$:\n$$V_{DD} - V_{out} \\ge V_{GS1} - V_{TH1} \\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_{in} \\le V_{DD} + V_{TH1} \\;\\;(\\text{always true})$$\n\n---\n\n## 2. Large-Signal Behavior\n\nSince $I_{D1} = I_{D2} = $ constant, the overdrive of M₁ is fixed:\n\n$$V_{out} = V_{in} - V_{GS1} = V_{in} - V_{TH1} - \\sqrt{\\frac{2I_D}{\\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)_1}}$$\n\nThe output **follows the input with a roughly constant DC level shift** of $V_{GS1}$. The constant bias current (vs. a resistive load) keeps $V_{GS1}$ nearly constant, improving linearity — the residual nonlinearity comes from $V_{TH1}$ varying with $V_{out}$ (**body effect**, if bulk is grounded).\n\n---\n\n## 3. Small-Signal Gain\n\nKCL at the output node (with $v_{gs1} = v_{in} - v_{out}$, $v_{bs1} = -v_{out}$):\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in}-v_{out}) - g_{mb1}v_{out} - \\frac{v_{out}}{r_{o1}} = \\frac{v_{out}}{r_{o2}}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1} + g_{mb1} + \\dfrac{1}{r_{o1}} + \\dfrac{1}{r_{o2}}} = \\frac{r_{o1}\\,\\|\\,r_{o2}\\,\\|\\,\\frac{1}{g_{mb1}}}{\\frac{1}{g_{m1}} + \\left(r_{o1}\\,\\|\\,r_{o2}\\,\\|\\,\\frac{1}{g_{mb1}}\\right)}}$$\n\nNeglecting channel-length modulation:\n$$A_v \\approx \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}} = \\frac{1}{1+\\eta} < 1$$\n\nTypically $A_v \\approx 0.8$; it equals ≈1 only if the body effect is eliminated (source tied to bulk).\n\n---\n\n## 4. Port Impedances\n\n| Quantity | Value |\n|---|---|\n| Input resistance | $R_{in} \\approx \\infty$ (MOS gate) |\n| Output resistance | $R_{out} = \\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\,\\dfrac{1}{g_{mb1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\,r_{o1}\\,\\Big\\|\\,r_{o2} \\approx \\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}$ |\n\n---\n\n## 5. Summary of Properties\n\n✅ **Voltage buffer**: high input impedance, low output impedance — good for driving low-impedance loads  \n✅ **Level shifter**: shifts DC level down by $V_{GS1}$  \n✅ Current-source load gives better linearity than a resistor load  \n\n⚠️ Gain is always **less than unity** (degraded by body effect)  \n⚠️ Nonlinearity from body effect ($V_{TH1}$ depends on $V_{out}$)  \n⚠️ Consumes voltage headroom; minimum $V_{out} = V_b - V_{TH2}$ to keep M₂ saturated",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c574ebf402facaeaa85a7684fc26a81d1c44c4aef65f82df3f7f6302c1dc389a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M₁ as a source follower with M₂ as its current-source load, takes the output at M₁’s source, and gives a positive sub-unity gain with the appropriate body-effect and finite-output-resistance terms.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9c0eaf5035e4eafe98a151f1035fd6512be41f7b78831b9e6cd3dd9618a8eb67",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1295,
        "output_tokens": 3935,
        "total_tokens": 5230,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2444,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1295,
        "output_tokens": 3935,
        "total_tokens": 5230,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2444,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-014-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-014-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# CMOS Inverter Analysis\n\n## Circuit Identification\n\nThe circuit is a **static CMOS inverter**, consisting of:\n\n- **M₁ (NMOS):** source grounded, gate driven by $V_{in}$, drain at $V_{out}$\n- **M₂ (PMOS):** source tied to $V_{DD}$, gate driven by $V_{in}$, drain at $V_{out}$\n\nThe two gates are tied together (input node), and the two drains are tied together (output node). The devices operate **complementarily**: when one turns on, the other turns off.\n\n## Digital (Large-Signal) Operation\n\n| $V_{in}$ | M₁ (NMOS) | M₂ (PMOS) | $V_{out}$ |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| $0$ | OFF ($V_{GS1}=0$) | ON ($|V_{GS2}|=V_{DD}$) | $V_{DD}$ (logic 1) |\n| $V_{DD}$ | ON | OFF | $0$ (logic 0) |\n\nHence the logic function is **inversion**: $V_{out} = \\overline{V_{in}}$, with **rail-to-rail output swing** and (ideally) **zero static power**, since one transistor is always off in steady state.\n\n## Voltage Transfer Characteristic (VTC)\n\nAs $V_{in}$ sweeps from 0 to $V_{DD}$, the circuit passes through five regions:\n\n| Region | Condition | M₁ | M₂ | Output |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 | $V_{in} < V_{THN}$ | Cutoff | Triode | $V_{out} = V_{DD}$ |\n| 2 | $V_{in}$ slightly $> V_{THN}$ | Saturation | Triode | Falling from $V_{DD}$ |\n| 3 | $V_{in} \\approx V_M$ | Saturation | Saturation | Steep transition (high gain) |\n| 4 | $V_{in}$ larger | Triode | Saturation | Approaching 0 |\n| 5 | $V_{in} > V_{DD}-|V_{THP}|$ | Triode | Cutoff | $V_{out} = 0$ |\n\n**Switching threshold** $V_M$ (where $V_{in} = V_{out}$), found by equating saturation currents:\n\n$$\\frac{1}{2}k_n(V_M - V_{THN})^2 = \\frac{1}{2}k_p(V_{DD} - V_M - |V_{THP}|)^2$$\n\n$$V_M = \\frac{V_{THN} + \\sqrt{k_p/k_n}\\,\\big(V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|\\big)}{1 + \\sqrt{k_p/k_n}}$$\n\nFor a symmetric VTC ($V_M = V_{DD}/2$), one needs $k_n = k_p$, i.e., $(W/L)_p \\approx (\\mu_n/\\mu_p)(W/L)_n \\approx 2\\text{–}3 \\times (W/L)_n$.\n\n## Analog Operation (Amplifier)\n\nIf biased near $V_M$, **both transistors are saturated** and each acts as a common-source stage driving the same output. The small-signal model gives:\n\n$$A_v = -(g_{m1} + g_{m2})\\,(r_{o1} \\,\\|\\, r_{o2})$$\n\n- Transconductances **add** (push–pull action), effectively doubling $g_m$ for a given bias current — good power efficiency.\n- The gain is high (on the order of the devices' intrinsic gain), which is why this topology is used as a crude amplifier, crystal-oscillator gain stage, and the heart of ring oscillators.\n- Drawback: the bias point depends strongly on $V_{DD}$ and process, so supply rejection is poor.\n\n## Power Dissipation\n\n- **Static:** ≈ 0 (only subthreshold/gate leakage).\n- **Dynamic:** $P = f \\, C_L \\, V_{DD}^2$ from charging/discharging the load.\n- **Short-circuit:** For $V_{THN} < V_{in} < V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|$ during transitions, both devices conduct simultaneously; the supply current **peaks near $V_{in} = V_M$**.\n\n## Key Properties Summary\n\n- Output swings fully from $0$ to $V_{DD}$ → **maximum noise margins**\n- \"Ratioless\" logic — correct levels regardless of transistor sizing\n- Very high input impedance (MOS gate), low output impedance in both logic states\n- Forms the fundamental building block of CMOS digital logic",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ab3fdab66b5b4e680880809c64c1c0216d477d85ddcc3950e4886f063a12879f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the CMOS inverter with an NMOS pull-down and PMOS pull-up and describes its inverting operation. The supplemental VTC and small-signal analysis are broadly consistent with the circuit; minor assumptions do not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "840046eac3d7c03b675f1189f0c155481e30a0dabe801adc9eba216a9a4a04f4",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 4158,
        "total_tokens": 4482,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2601,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 4158,
        "total_tokens": 4482,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2601,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-014-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-014-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification: CMOS Inverter\n\nThis is the standard **CMOS inverter** — the fundamental building block of digital logic (also usable as a high-gain analog amplifier).\n\n**Topology:**\n- **M₂ (PMOS):** Source tied to $V_{DD}$, acts as the *pull-up* device\n- **M₁ (NMOS):** Source tied to ground, acts as the *pull-down* device\n- Gates are tied together → input $V_{in}$\n- Drains are tied together → output $V_{out}$\n\n---\n\n## Static (Logic) Operation\n\n| Input | M₁ (NMOS) | M₂ (PMOS) | Output |\n|-------|-----------|-----------|--------|\n| $V_{in} = 0$ | OFF ($V_{GS1}=0$) | ON ($V_{GS2}=-V_{DD}$) | $V_{out} = V_{DD}$ (logic 1) |\n| $V_{in} = V_{DD}$ | ON ($V_{GS1}=V_{DD}$) | OFF ($V_{GS2}=0$) | $V_{out} = 0$ (logic 0) |\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} = \\overline{V_{in}}}$$\n\nKey consequence: **in either steady state, one transistor is off**, so no DC path exists from $V_{DD}$ to ground → *(nearly) zero static power dissipation*. Current flows only during switching.\n\n---\n\n## Voltage Transfer Characteristic (Regions of Operation)\n\nAs $V_{in}$ sweeps from 0 to $V_{DD}$:\n\n| Region | Condition | M₁ | M₂ | $V_{out}$ |\n|--------|-----------|----|----|-----------|\n| A | $V_{in} < V_{THN}$ | Cutoff | Triode | $V_{DD}$ |\n| B | $V_{THN} < V_{in} < V_M$ | Saturation | Triode | Falling slowly |\n| C | $V_{in} \\approx V_M$ | Saturation | Saturation | **Steep transition** |\n| D | $V_M < V_{in} < V_{DD}-|V_{THP}|$ | Triode | Saturation | Approaching 0 |\n| E | $V_{in} > V_{DD}-|V_{THP}|$ | Triode | Cutoff | $0$ |\n\nThe supply current peaks at the trip point (region C) and is zero at both extremes.\n\n**Switching threshold** $V_M$ (where $V_{in} = V_{out}$), found by equating saturation currents:\n\n$$V_M = \\frac{V_{DD} - |V_{THP}| + \\sqrt{\\dfrac{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}}\\; V_{THN}}{1 + \\sqrt{\\dfrac{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}}}$$\n\nChoosing $(W/L)_2 \\approx (\\mu_n/\\mu_p)(W/L)_1$ (i.e., wider PMOS) gives $V_M = V_{DD}/2$ and symmetric rise/fall behavior.\n\n---\n\n## Small-Signal Behavior (Region C — Amplifier Mode)\n\nIf biased near $V_M$, both devices are saturated and act as **parallel common-source stages** driving the same output:\n\n$$A_v = -(g_{m1} + g_{m2})\\,(r_{o1} \\,\\|\\, r_{o2})$$\n\nThe transconductances **add**, giving roughly twice the gain of a simple CS stage for the same bias current — which is why this topology is also used as an analog gain stage.\n\n---\n\n## Key Properties Summary\n\n- **Rail-to-rail output:** $V_{OH} = V_{DD}$, $V_{OL} = 0$ (full logic swing, no threshold loss)\n- **Large noise margins**, maximized when the inverter is symmetric\n- **Infinite input resistance** (MOS gates)\n- **Power dissipation is purely dynamic:** $P \\approx f\\,C_L\\,V_{DD}^2$ plus brief short-circuit (crowbar) current during transitions\n- **Regenerative, sharp VTC** → excellent for logic; high gain near $V_M$ → usable as an amplifier",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "597940f9194961600dc79f66d32f91e28908a967a2f520c089509fc376ddf43a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the CMOS inverter, with an NMOS pull-down and PMOS pull-up, and describes its operation accurately. The supplemental analysis does not contradict the inverter’s essential operation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "840046eac3d7c03b675f1189f0c155481e30a0dabe801adc9eba216a9a4a04f4",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 3452,
        "total_tokens": 3776,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2008,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 3452,
        "total_tokens": 3776,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2008,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-014-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-014-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# CMOS Inverter Analysis\n\n## Circuit Identification\n\nThis is the classic **CMOS inverter** (NOT gate), the fundamental building block of digital CMOS logic:\n\n- **M₂ (PMOS)**: Source connected to $V_{DD}$, acts as the **pull-up** device\n- **M₁ (NMOS)**: Source connected to ground, acts as the **pull-down** device\n- **Gates tied together** → input $V_{in}$\n- **Drains tied together** → output $V_{out}$\n\nThe two transistors operate in a complementary fashion: when one conducts, the other is off.\n\n---\n\n## Static (DC) Operation\n\n**Case 1: $V_{in} = 0$ (logic LOW)**\n- M₁: $V_{GS1} = 0 < V_{THN}$ → **OFF**\n- M₂: $V_{GS2} = -V_{DD}$, so $|V_{GS2}| > |V_{THP}|$ → **ON** (deep triode)\n- Output pulled to rail: $V_{out} = V_{DD}$ (logic HIGH) ✓ No static current flows.\n\n**Case 2: $V_{in} = V_{DD}$ (logic HIGH)**\n- M₁: $V_{GS1} = V_{DD} > V_{THN}$ → **ON** (deep triode)\n- M₂: $V_{GS2} = 0$ → **OFF**\n- Output pulled to ground: $V_{out} = 0$ (logic LOW) ✓ No static current flows.\n\n**Result:** The circuit inverts the logic level with **rail-to-rail output swing** and (ideally) **zero static power dissipation**.\n\n---\n\n## Voltage Transfer Characteristic (VTC)\n\nAs $V_{in}$ sweeps from 0 to $V_{DD}$, the circuit passes through five regions:\n\n| Region | $V_{in}$ range | M₁ (NMOS) | M₂ (PMOS) | $V_{out}$ |\n|--------|---------------|-----------|-----------|-----------|\n| A | $V_{in} < V_{THN}$ | Off | Triode | $V_{DD}$ |\n| B | slightly above $V_{THN}$ | Saturation | Triode | falling |\n| C | near $V_M$ | Saturation | Saturation | steep transition |\n| D | approaching $V_{DD}-|V_{THP}|$ | Triode | Saturation | near 0 |\n| E | $V_{in} > V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|$ | Triode | Off | $0$ |\n\n**Switching threshold $V_M$** (where $V_{in} = V_{out}$), found by equating saturation currents:\n\n$$\\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_M - V_{THN})^2 = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_{DD} - V_M - |V_{THP}|)^2$$\n\n$$V_M = \\frac{V_{THN} + \\sqrt{\\dfrac{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}}\\,\\big(V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|\\big)}{1 + \\sqrt{\\dfrac{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}}}$$\n\nFor a symmetric VTC ($V_M = V_{DD}/2$), one requires $\\mu_n (W/L)_1 = \\mu_p (W/L)_2$, i.e., $W_P/W_N \\approx 2\\text{–}3$ since $\\mu_n > \\mu_p$.\n\n---\n\n## Small-Signal Behavior (Region C — Amplifier Mode)\n\nWhen both devices are saturated, the circuit is actually a **high-gain amplifier**: both transistors act as common-source stages driven by the same input, so their transconductances **add** and their output resistances appear **in parallel**:\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = -(g_{m1} + g_{m2})\\,(r_{o1} \\,\\|\\, r_{o2})}$$\n\nThis large gain (steep VTC slope) is what gives the inverter its sharp, regenerative switching and good noise margins. It's also why a CMOS inverter can be biased at $V_M$ and used as a linear amplifier (e.g., in crystal oscillators).\n\n---\n\n## Power Dissipation\n\n1. **Static power:** ~0 (one transistor is always off in either logic state; only leakage flows)\n2. **Dynamic power** (charging/discharging load capacitance $C_L$):\n$$P_{dyn} = f \\, C_L \\, V_{DD}^2$$\n3. **Short-circuit (crowbar) power:** during transitions, when $V_{THN} < V_{in} < V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|$, both transistors conduct simultaneously, allowing a brief current spike from $V_{DD}$ to ground.\n\n---\n\n## Summary of Key Properties\n\n- ✅ Full rail-to-rail swing: $V_{OH} = V_{DD}$, $V_{OL} = 0$\n- ✅ Essentially zero static power\n- ✅ High input impedance (purely capacitive gate)\n- ✅ Low output impedance in both logic states (strong drive)\n- ✅ High gain in transition → excellent noise margins\n- ⚠️ Speed limited by $R_{on}C_L$ time constants: $t_{pHL} \\approx 0.69 R_N C_L$, $t_{pLH} \\approx 0.69 R_P C_L$",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "16242232405c605ca86d6b9aea735f84fb7d49dc609064f040a643a50f838d95"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the CMOS inverter and its NMOS pull-down/PMOS pull-up operation. The extra analysis is largely consistent; its optional terminology does not contradict the inverter’s operation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "840046eac3d7c03b675f1189f0c155481e30a0dabe801adc9eba216a9a4a04f4",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 3368,
        "total_tokens": 3692,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1476,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 3368,
        "total_tokens": 3692,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1476,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\n**First key observation:** both transistors are drawn with the *same* symbol — the source arrows on both M₁ and M₂ point outward at the bottom terminal. **Both devices are NMOS.** This is *not* the familiar CMOS inverter, even though it looks like one at first glance.\n\nWith both gates tied to $V_{in}$ and the output taken at the middle node:\n\n| Device | Terminals | Configuration |\n|---|---|---|\n| M₁ | D = $V_{DD}$, G = $V_{in}$, S = $V_{out}$ | **Common drain (source follower)** → non-inverting |\n| M₂ | D = $V_{out}$, G = $V_{in}$, S = GND | **Common source** → inverting |\n\nSince no DC load is shown, the same current flows through both: $I_{D1} = I_{D2}$.\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis (general)\n\nWith $v_{gs1} = v_{in} - v_{out}$ and $v_{gs2} = v_{in}$, KCL at the output node gives:\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in}-v_{out}) - g_{mb1}v_{out} - g_{o1}v_{out} - g_{m2}v_{in} - g_{o2}v_{out} = 0$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{g_{m1}-g_{m2}}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}, \\qquad R_{out} = \\frac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{o1} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{o2} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}}$$\n\n**Interpretation:** the follower tries to pull $V_{out}$ *up* with the input (+gain), while the common-source device pulls it *down* (−gain). The transconductances **subtract**. Contrast this with a true CMOS inverter, where the NMOS and PMOS currents reinforce and $A_v = -(g_{mN}+g_{mP})(r_{oN}\\|r_{oP})$ — there the $g_m$'s **add**.\n\n# Region-of-Operation Check (the catch)\n\nCan both devices be saturated? M₂ saturated requires $V_{out} > V_{in} - V_{TH}$; M₁ conducting requires $V_{in} - V_{out} > V_{TH}$, i.e. $V_{out} < V_{in} - V_{TH}$. **These contradict** (body effect on M₁ makes it worse). Therefore:\n\n> Whenever current flows, **M₁ is saturated and M₂ is in triode** — M₂ acts as an input-controlled resistor loading a source follower.\n\n# Large-Signal Transfer Characteristic\n\nEquating $I_{D1} = I_{D2}$ with $k_i = \\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)_i$, $a = V_{in}-V_{TH}$, $m = k_2/k_1$ (ignoring body effect, λ):\n\n$$\\tfrac{1}{2}k_1(a - V_{out})^2 = k_2\\left(aV_{out} - \\tfrac{1}{2}V_{out}^2\\right)$$\n\nSolving the quadratic (physical root):\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} = \\left(1-\\sqrt{\\frac{m}{1+m}}\\right)(V_{in}-V_{TH}) \\equiv \\beta\\,(V_{in}-V_{TH}), \\quad V_{in}>V_{TH}}$$\n\n**The square-law nonlinearities cancel exactly** — the output is a *linear*, level-shifted, attenuated replica of the input, with gain set purely by the geometry ratio:\n\n| $m = (W/L)_2/(W/L)_1$ | 1/4 | 1 | 4 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| $\\beta$ | 0.55 | **0.29** | 0.11 |\n\n- $m \\to 0$ (weak M₂): $\\beta \\to 1$ — pure source follower\n- $m \\to \\infty$: $\\beta \\to 0$ — heavy attenuation (never inverts)\n\n*Sanity check (m = 1):* at the operating point $g_{m1} = 0.707\\,k_1a$, $g_{m2,tri} = k_2V_{out} = 0.293\\,k_1a$, $g_{ds2,tri} = 0.707\\,k_1a$, giving $A_v = (0.707-0.293)/(0.707+0.707) = 0.293 = \\beta$ ✓\n\nThe supply current is $I_D = \\frac{m}{2(1+m)}k_1(V_{in}-V_{TH})^2$ — **static power is drawn whenever $V_{in} > V_{TH}$** (ratioed, class-A behavior).\n\n# Summary of Properties\n\n- **Function:** non-inverting **attenuator + level shifter**, $V_{out} = \\beta(V_{in}-V_{TH})$, with gain programmable by W/L ratio and ideally independent of bias level (body effect and channel-length modulation add mild nonlinearity and reduce β).\n- **Output impedance:** low, ≈ $1/g_{m1}$ — drives capacitive loads well; both pull-up (M₁) and pull-down (M₂) are active.\n- **Input impedance:** purely capacitive; $C_{gs1}$ and $C_{gd2}$ are partially bootstrapped by the factor $(1-\\beta)$ since the gain is positive and < 1.\n- **VTC:** dead zone for $V_{in} < V_{TH}$ (both devices off), then a straight line of slope β; maximum output ≈ $\\beta(V_{DD}-V_{TH})$.\n- **Not a logic gate:** non-inverting, can't reach the rails, burns static current.\n\n**Pedagogical takeaways:** (1) check the symbols — same-type devices stacked this way give *competing* paths, not a complementary inverter; (2) the gain follows by inspection, $A_v = (g_{m1}-g_{m2})R_{node}$; (3) always verify operating regions — here the gate-tied connection *forces* M₂ into triode, and that triode behavior is precisely what makes the transfer characteristic linear.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "99db5e5862d849f5e8483b50bb6d0068c45834986278b560d52f86effe6c6522"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Identifies both devices as NMOS, recognizes the upper source-follower and lower pull-down actions, and correctly concludes this is not a normal CMOS inverter, satisfying the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b598ce9b14c47387d9b8d874c626add0f845d3b4bc6f5ad44a431e7ddf11ad3d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 31175,
        "total_tokens": 31499,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 29069,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 31175,
        "total_tokens": 31499,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 29069,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nAt first glance this looks like a CMOS inverter, but **both devices are NMOS** (both source arrows point outward). The connections are:\n\n- **M1:** gate → V_in, drain → V_DD, source → V_out ⇒ **common-drain (source follower)**\n- **M2:** gate → V_in, drain → V_out, source → GND ⇒ **common-source device**, which also serves as the follower's bias-current sink\n\nSo the input drives the output through **two parallel paths**: a non-inverting follower path (M1) and an inverting common-source path (M2), summed at the output node.\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis (both devices assumed saturated)\n\nKCL at the output node (M1's body at ground → body effect g_mb1; V_DD is AC ground):\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in}-v_{out}) - g_{mb1}v_{out} - \\frac{v_{out}}{r_{o1}} = g_{m2}v_{in} + \\frac{v_{out}}{r_{o2}}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v=\\frac{g_{m1}-g_{m2}}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+r_{o1}^{-1}+r_{o2}^{-1}}}$$\n\n**Interpretation:** the numerator shows the follower path (+g_m1) and CS path (−g_m2) *fighting each other*; the denominator is just the total conductance at the output node.\n\nNeglecting channel-length modulation and body effect, and noting both devices carry the same bias current (so g_m ∝ √(W/L)):\n\n$$A_v \\approx 1-\\frac{g_{m2}}{g_{m1}} = 1-\\sqrt{\\frac{(W/L)_2}{(W/L)_1}}$$\n\n- A sub-unity, geometry-defined gain — zero if the devices are matched.\n\n**Port impedances:**\n- R_in ≈ ∞ (gate input)\n- R_out = 1/(g_m1+g_mb1) ∥ r_o1 ∥ r_o2 ≈ 1/g_m1 → low, follower-like (hence a broadband output node)\n\n# Large-Signal Reality Check\n\nBecause the gates are tied together at DC, current balance forces:\n\n$$V_{out} < V_{in} - V_{TH} \\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad V_{DS2} < V_{GS2}-V_{TH}$$\n\nso **M2 actually sits in the triode region** (a gate-controlled resistor), while M1 stays saturated (V_DS1 = V_DD − V_out is large). Solving with M1 saturated / M2 in triode (equal V_TH, γ = λ = 0), with r = (W/L)₂/(W/L)₁:\n\n$$V_{out} = \\left(V_{in}-V_{TH}\\right)\\left[1-\\sqrt{\\frac{r}{1+r}}\\right]$$\n\nProperties of this transfer characteristic:\n\n| Condition | Behavior |\n|---|---|\n| V_in < V_TH | Both devices off; output floats (high-Z) |\n| V_in > V_TH | **Linear** in (V_in − V_TH), slope between 0 and 1 |\n| Identical devices (r = 1) | Slope = 1 − 1/√2 ≈ **0.29** |\n| M2 very weak (r → 0) | Slope → 1 (pure source follower) |\n| M2 very strong (r → ∞) | Slope → 1/(2r) → 0 |\n\n(The incremental gain in this regime equals the slope exactly — the circuit is inherently linear to first order.)\n\n# Conclusions\n\n1. **It is not an inverter** — there is no complementary PMOS; M1's source (not drain) is at the output.\n2. The circuit is a **level-shifting attenuator/buffer**: positive gain < 1, set accurately by a geometry ratio, with low output impedance (≈ 1/g_m1) and essentially infinite DC input impedance.\n3. As a voltage *amplifier* it is poor, because the follower and common-source paths largely cancel (g_m1 − g_m2 in the numerator).\n4. To realize the saturated-M2 small-signal result (e.g., to get a negative gain with g_m2 > g_m1), M2's gate would need a **separate DC bias** (AC-coupled input); the direct DC connection shown forces M2 into triode.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "36444bd3669896516c989496ed7f1b95809c6d3498f83f26ffa6acbfa20c8c90"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Identifies both devices as NMOS, recognizes the upper source follower and lower pull-down, and correctly concludes this is not a normal CMOS inverter. These satisfy the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b598ce9b14c47387d9b8d874c626add0f845d3b4bc6f5ad44a431e7ddf11ad3d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 18669,
        "total_tokens": 18993,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 17205,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 18669,
        "total_tokens": 18993,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 17205,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nBoth devices are **NMOS** (source arrows point outward). This is *not* a CMOS inverter — that would require M1 to be a PMOS with its source at $V_{DD}$. Instead:\n\n- **M1**: gate at $V_{in}$, drain at $V_{DD}$, source at $V_{out}$ → a **source follower** (common-drain), non-inverting path.\n- **M2**: gate at $V_{in}$, drain at $V_{out}$, source at ground → a **common-source** device, inverting path.\n\nThe same input drives two paths of opposite polarity into the same output node, and M2 also acts as M1's bias/load element.\n\n# Operating Regions (key observation)\n\nWith no DC load, $I_{D1} = I_{D2}$.\n\n- **M1 is always saturated**: $V_{D1} = V_{DD} \\ge V_{in} - V_{TH}$ for any realistic input.\n- **M2 must be in triode.** Proof: if M2 were saturated, $V_{out} \\ge V_{in} - V_{TH}$, which forces M1's overdrive $V_{in} - V_{out} - V_{TH} \\le 0$, i.e., M1 off — contradicting current balance. Hence whenever the circuit conducts ($V_{in} > V_{TH}$):\n\n$$V_{out} < V_{in}-V_{TH} \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad \\text{M2 in triode (a gate-controlled resistor)}$$\n\nFor $V_{in} < V_{TH}$, **both devices are off** and the output floats (high-impedance, dynamic node).\n\n# Large-Signal Transfer Characteristic\n\nWith $\\beta_i = \\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)_i$, $x = V_{in}-V_{TH}$, $y = V_{out}$ (neglecting body effect and $\\lambda$):\n\n$$\\frac{\\beta_1}{2}(x-y)^2 = \\beta_2\\left(xy - \\frac{y^2}{2}\\right)$$\n\nSolving the quadratic (physical root $y < x$), with $r = \\beta_2/\\beta_1$:\n\n$$\\boxed{\\,V_{out} = \\left(1-\\sqrt{\\tfrac{\\beta_2}{\\beta_1+\\beta_2}}\\right)(V_{in}-V_{TH})\\,}$$\n\n**The transfer is exactly linear in the overdrive** — the square-law nonlinearities cancel ratiometrically. For identical devices ($\\beta_1=\\beta_2$):\n\n$$V_{out} = \\left(1-\\tfrac{1}{\\sqrt 2}\\right)(V_{in}-V_{TH}) \\approx 0.293\\,(V_{in}-V_{TH})$$\n\nThe gain is set purely by the **W/L ratio** and always lies between 0 and 1 ($\\to 1$ for $\\beta_1 \\gg \\beta_2$).\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis\n\nKCL at the output ($V_{DD}$ = AC ground):\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in}-v_{out}) - g_{mb1}v_{out} - g_{ds1}v_{out} = g_{m2}v_{in} + g_{ds2}v_{out}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{\\,A_v = \\frac{g_{m1}-g_{m2}}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\,}$$\n\nInterpretation: the follower contributes $+g_{m1}R_{node}$, the common-source path $-g_{m2}R_{node}$; they **partially cancel**. Because M2 sits in triode, $g_{m2} = \\beta_2 V_{out}$ is small while $g_{ds2} = \\beta_2(x-y)$ is large — so the gain is always **positive but sub-unity**, consistent with the DC slope (0.293 for equal devices; body effect via $g_{mb1}$ reduces it further).\n\n**Impedances:**\n- $R_{in} \\approx \\infty$ (capacitive only; $C_{gs1}$ and $C_{gd2}$ are partially bootstrapped by the factor $1-A_v$).\n- $R_{out} = \\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}$ — **low**, buffer-like → wide bandwidth with capacitive loads; good supply rejection (only $g_{ds1}$ couples $V_{DD}$ to the output).\n\n# Dynamic / Practical Remarks\n\n- **Adaptive bias:** $I_D \\propto (V_{in}-V_{TH})^2$ — the stage burns little current at low inputs; rising edges get a boost from both M1 (increased $V_{GS1}$) sourcing and M2 sinking harder.\n- **Asymmetric transients:** on a falling input, M1 cuts off and the load is discharged only by M2 (which momentarily saturates, acting as a current source) with a *reduced* $V_{GS}$ → slower pull-down.\n- **Memory effect:** for $V_{in}<V_{TH}$ the output is floating — the operating point is only defined for $V_{in}>V_{TH}$.\n- **Accuracy limits:** body effect ($V_{TH1}$ rises with $V_{out}$), channel-length modulation, and mobility degradation perturb the ideal ratiometric linearity.\n\n# Summary\n\nThe circuit is a **source follower loaded by an input-driven triode device**: a non-inverting, level-shifting **linear attenuator/buffer** with gain $1-\\sqrt{\\beta_2/(\\beta_1+\\beta_2)}$ (≈ 0.29 for matched devices), near-infinite input impedance, and low output impedance — superficially inverter-like, but functionally very different from a CMOS inverter.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "322b4dbd76de890b6a636eebd12380a388278aab22bf0da19227da256799a716"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies both devices as NMOS, describes M1 as a source follower and M2 as a pull-down, and concludes this is not a normal CMOS inverter, meeting the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b598ce9b14c47387d9b8d874c626add0f845d3b4bc6f5ad44a431e7ddf11ad3d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 22493,
        "total_tokens": 22817,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 20528,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 324,
        "output_tokens": 22493,
        "total_tokens": 22817,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 20528,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **common-source (CS) amplifier with a diode-connected PMOS load**:\n\n- **M₁** (NMOS): common-source input device — gate driven by $V_{in}$, source grounded, drain at $V_{out}$.\n- **M₂** (PMOS): **diode-connected** load — its gate is tied to its drain, so $V_{GS2} = V_{DS2}$. Source and (n-well) body at $V_{DD}$, so **M₂ has no body effect**.\n\nSince $|V_{DS2}| = |V_{GS2}| > |V_{GS2}| - |V_{THP}|$, M₂ is **always in saturation** whenever it conducts.\n\n---\n\n# Large-Signal (Transfer) Characteristic\n\n**Region 1: $V_{in} < V_{THN}$** — M₁ is off, no current flows. For M₂ to carry zero current, $|V_{GS2}| \\le |V_{THP}|$, so the output sits at:\n\n$$V_{out} = V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|$$\n\n(it only creeps toward $V_{DD}$ via subthreshold conduction).\n\n**Region 2: M₁ saturated** — Equating drain currents $I_{D1} = |I_{D2}|$:\n\n$$\\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_{in}-V_{THN})^2 = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{THP}|)^2$$\n\nSolving:\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} = V_{DD} - |V_{THP}| - \\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}}\\,(V_{in} - V_{THN})}$$\n\nThe characteristic is a **straight line** → inherently linear amplification.\n\n**Region 3:** When $V_{out} < V_{in} - V_{THN}$, M₁ enters triode and the gain collapses.\n\n---\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis\n\nA diode-connected MOSFET presents an impedance of $\\dfrac{1}{g_m} \\parallel r_o \\approx \\dfrac{1}{g_m}$. Thus:\n\n$$A_v = -g_{m1}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{m2}} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{o1} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{o2}\\right) \\approx -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nSince both devices carry the same bias current, using $g_m = \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}(W/L)I_D}$:\n\n$$A_v \\approx -\\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}} = -\\frac{V_{OV2}}{V_{OV1}}$$\n\n**Output resistance:** $\\quad R_{out} = \\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}} \\parallel r_{o2} \\parallel r_{o1} \\approx \\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}}$ (low)\n\n---\n\n# Key Properties & Trade-offs\n\n**Advantages**\n- Gain depends only on a **ratio of geometries and mobilities** — insensitive to bias current, supply, and temperature (to first order).\n- Very **linear** transfer characteristic while both devices are saturated.\n- Low $R_{out}$ ($\\approx 1/g_{m2}$) → high bandwidth at the output node.\n- PMOS diode load avoids body effect (unlike an NMOS diode-connected load).\n\n**Disadvantages**\n- **Low gain**: achieving $|A_v| = 10$ requires $\\mu_n(W/L)_1 \\approx 100\\,\\mu_p(W/L)_2$ — a severe area/sizing penalty.\n- Gain–swing conflict: since $|A_v| = V_{OV2}/V_{OV1}$, high gain forces a **large overdrive on M₂**, which eats into the output swing.\n- **Limited swing**: output range is roughly\n\n$$V_{in} - V_{THN} \\;\\le\\; V_{out} \\;\\le\\; V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|$$\n\n**Summary:** a simple, well-defined, linear low-gain stage — commonly used where predictable gain matters more than large gain or wide swing.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "31a8740fa5b70fd5d5ee2614c83a792582c4146ef27b5393a35839aa48fa6d51"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-source NMOS stage with a diode-connected PMOS load and gives the correct inverting gain, including a consistent channel-length-modulation form. The additional analysis does not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "890a218dd592ccc44d29c47d073a2630294c84b195016d665cdb5f09108c1fc5",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 792,
        "output_tokens": 4120,
        "total_tokens": 4912,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2614,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 792,
        "output_tokens": 4120,
        "total_tokens": 4912,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2614,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Common-Source Stage with Diode-Connected PMOS Load\n\n## Circuit Identification\n\n- **M₁** (NMOS): source grounded, gate driven by $V_{in}$, drain at the output → **common-source amplifier** (input device).\n- **M₂** (PMOS): source at $V_{DD}$, gate tied to its own drain → **diode-connected load**.\n\nSince $V_{GS2} = V_{DS2}$, M₂ always satisfies $|V_{DS2}| \\geq |V_{GS2}| - |V_{TH2}|$, so **M₂ is in saturation whenever it conducts**. It behaves as a two-terminal element with small-signal resistance:\n\n$$R_{M2} = \\frac{1}{g_{m2}} \\parallel r_{o2} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}$$\n\n(No body effect for M₂ since its source and n-well body are both at $V_{DD}$.)\n\n## Large-Signal Behavior\n\n**Region 1: $V_{in} < V_{TH1}$** — M₁ is off, no current flows, and $V_{out}$ rises to approximately:\n$$V_{out} = V_{DD} - |V_{TH2}|$$\n(M₂ cuts off when $|V_{GS2}|$ falls below $|V_{TH2}|$; subthreshold conduction eventually pulls the output slightly higher.)\n\n**Region 2: Both in saturation** — Equating drain currents $I_{D1} = |I_{D2}|$:\n\n$$\\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_{in} - V_{TH1})^2 = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_{DD} - V_{out} - |V_{TH2}|)^2$$\n\nSolving:\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} = V_{DD} - |V_{TH2}| - \\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}}\\,(V_{in} - V_{TH1})}$$\n\nThe transfer characteristic is **linear** in this region — a key property of the diode-connected load.\n\n**Region 3:** For large $V_{in}$, when $V_{out} < V_{in} - V_{TH1}$, M₁ enters the triode region and the gain collapses.\n\n## Small-Signal Gain\n\n$$A_v = -g_{m1}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{m2}} \\parallel r_{o1} \\parallel r_{o2}\\right) \\approx -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nExpressing the transconductances (equal bias currents):\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v \\approx -\\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}} = -\\frac{V_{OV2}}{V_{OV1}}}$$\n\n## Key Properties and Trade-offs\n\n| Property | Implication |\n|---|---|\n| **Gain set by geometry ratio** | Insensitive to process, temperature, and bias current variations → well-controlled, linear gain |\n| **Gain–swing trade-off** | High gain requires $(W/L)_1 \\gg (W/L)_2$, which forces a large $V_{OV2}$, consuming headroom. E.g., $\\|A_v\\| = 10$ with $\\mu_n \\approx 2\\mu_p$ needs $(W/L)_1/(W/L)_2 = 50$ and gives $V_{OV2} = 10\\,V_{OV1}$ |\n| **Output swing** | $V_{in} - V_{TH1} \\leq V_{out} \\leq V_{DD} - |V_{TH2}|$ |\n| **Low output impedance** ($\\approx 1/g_{m2}$) | Output pole $\\omega_p \\approx g_{m2}/C_{out}$ is pushed to high frequency → good bandwidth, but low gain |\n\n## Summary\n\nThis is the classic **CS amplifier with diode-connected PMOS load**: a low-gain but highly linear and process-tolerant stage, whose gain $\\approx -\\sqrt{\\mu_n(W/L)_1 / \\mu_p(W/L)_2}$ depends only on device dimension ratios rather than absolute parameters — at the cost of limited gain magnitude and reduced output voltage headroom.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "02b97776fac205158f46480d6a9ec3468d5ac2a26f251215fb36fc17bfb0f6e7"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-source NMOS stage with a diode-connected PMOS load and gives the inverting gain including both devices’ output resistances, as well as the usual −gm1/gm2 approximation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "890a218dd592ccc44d29c47d073a2630294c84b195016d665cdb5f09108c1fc5",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 792,
        "output_tokens": 3481,
        "total_tokens": 4273,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1976,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 792,
        "output_tokens": 3481,
        "total_tokens": 4273,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1976,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **common-source (CS) amplifier with a diode-connected PMOS load**:\n\n- **M₁ (NMOS):** input device — gate driven by $V_{in}$, source grounded → common-source configuration\n- **M₂ (PMOS):** diode-connected load — gate tied to drain, source at $V_{DD}$. Since $V_{GS2} = V_{DS2}$, M₂ **always operates in saturation** when conducting.\n\nBoth transistors carry the same bias current $I_D$.\n\n---\n\n# Large-Signal Analysis (Transfer Characteristic)\n\n**Region 1 — $V_{in} < V_{TH1}$:** M₁ is off, no current flows. The output rises toward the supply but stops at:\n$$V_{out} \\approx V_{DD} - |V_{TH2}|$$\n(The output *cannot* reach $V_{DD}$ because M₂ turns off once $V_{SG2} < |V_{TH2}|$.)\n\n**Region 2 — Both in saturation:** Equating drain currents (neglecting $\\lambda$):\n$$\\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_{in}-V_{TH1})^2 = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{TH2}|)^2$$\n\nSolving:\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} = V_{DD} - |V_{TH2}| - \\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}}\\,(V_{in}-V_{TH1})}$$\n\nThis is a **linear** input–output relationship — a key feature of this topology.\n\n**Region 3 — Large $V_{in}$:** When $V_{out} < V_{in} - V_{TH1}$, M₁ enters the triode region and the gain collapses.\n\n---\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis\n\nThe diode-connected M₂ presents a resistance of $1/g_{m2}$ looking into its source–gate–drain node (no body effect, since the PMOS body ties to its source at $V_{DD}$):\n\n$$A_v = -g_{m1}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{m2}} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{o1} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{o2}\\right) \\approx -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nSince both devices carry the same current, using $g_m = \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}(W/L)I_D}$:\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v \\approx -\\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_n (W/L)_1}{\\mu_p (W/L)_2}} = -\\frac{V_{ov2}}{V_{ov1}}}$$\n\n**Output resistance:** $R_{out} \\approx 1/g_{m2}$ (low).\n\n---\n\n# Key Properties and Trade-offs\n\n| Property | Implication |\n|---|---|\n| **Gain set by geometry/mobility ratio only** | Insensitive to bias current, supply, and temperature → well-controlled, highly **linear** gain |\n| **Gain–swing trade-off** | $\\|A_v\\| = V_{ov2}/V_{ov1}$: high gain demands a large overdrive on M₂, eating into output swing |\n| **Area cost of gain** | e.g., $\\|A_v\\|=10$ with $\\mu_n \\approx 2\\mu_p$ requires $(W/L)_1 \\approx 50(W/L)_2$ — impractically large ratios |\n| **Limited swing** | $V_{out,max} = V_{DD} - \\|V_{TH2}\\|$; $\\;V_{out,min} = V_{in} - V_{TH1}$ (edge of triode) |\n| **Low $R_{out} \\approx 1/g_{m2}$** | Fast output node / wide bandwidth, but inherently modest gain |\n\n**Bottom line:** This stage trades raw gain for a **precise, linear, process-tolerant gain** of $-\\sqrt{\\mu_n(W/L)_1 / \\mu_p(W/L)_2}$, making it useful where moderate, well-defined amplification is needed rather than maximum gain (which would instead call for a current-source load).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "433f87ba6590b3a966f85cd60bb74868595877c65beba6fa9e44920c172eaa93"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-source NMOS stage with a diode-connected PMOS load and gives the inverting gain including both devices’ output resistances, consistent with the full-credit rule. The extra large-signal discussion does not change the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "890a218dd592ccc44d29c47d073a2630294c84b195016d665cdb5f09108c1fc5",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 792,
        "output_tokens": 4209,
        "total_tokens": 5001,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2745,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 792,
        "output_tokens": 4209,
        "total_tokens": 5001,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2745,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nBoth devices are **PMOS transistors** (source arrows point into the gate), but they play very different roles:\n\n| Device | Terminals | Function |\n|--------|-----------|----------|\n| **M₂** | Source → V_DD, Gate → V_in, Drain → V_out | **Common-source input device** (source is at AC ground) |\n| **M₁** | Source → V_out, Gate & Drain → GND | **Diode-connected load** (V_G = V_D = 0) |\n\nSo this is a **PMOS common-source amplifier with a diode-connected PMOS load** — simply a CS stage \"flipped upside down.\"\n\n# Operating Conditions\n\n- **M₂ conducts** when $V_{SG2} = V_{DD} - V_{in} > |V_{THP}|$, i.e., $V_{in} < V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|$\n- **M₁ is always saturated** while conducting (diode connection forces $V_{SD1} = V_{SG1} = V_{out}$)\n- **M₂ stays saturated** if $V_{SD2} \\ge V_{SG2} - |V_{THP}|$, i.e., $V_{out} \\le V_{in} + |V_{THP}|$\n\n# Large-Signal Behavior\n\nEquating the (equal) drain currents of M₁ and M₂:\n\n$$\\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_{DD} - V_{in} - |V_{TH2}|)^2 = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_{out} - |V_{TH1}|)^2$$\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} = |V_{TH1}| + \\sqrt{\\frac{(W/L)_2}{(W/L)_1}}\\,\\big(V_{DD} - V_{in} - |V_{TH2}|\\big)}$$\n\nNote the **linear** input–output characteristic (square-law nonlinearities cancel) — a key benefit of diode-connected loads. The swing is bounded roughly by $|V_{TH1}| < V_{out} < V_{in} + |V_{TH2}|$.\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis\n\nThe diode-connected M₁ presents an impedance $\\approx \\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}} \\parallel r_{O1}$ (use $\\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}$ if its n-well is not tied to its source). Therefore:\n\n$$A_v = -g_{m2}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{m1}} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{O1} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{O2}\\right) \\approx -\\frac{g_{m2}}{g_{m1}}$$\n\nSince both transistors carry the same current and are the same type ($\\mu_p C_{ox}$ cancels):\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v \\approx -\\sqrt{\\frac{(W/L)_2}{(W/L)_1}}}$$\n\n**Port impedances:**\n- $R_{in} = \\infty$ (gate input)\n- $R_{out} = \\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}} \\parallel r_{O1} \\parallel r_{O2} \\approx \\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}}$ (low)\n\n# Key Properties & Trade-offs\n\n✅ **Well-defined, stable gain** — set purely by a geometric ratio, insensitive to process, temperature, and bias (mobility cancels because both devices are PMOS).\n\n✅ **Good linearity** — the transfer characteristic is linear as long as both devices are saturated.\n\n⚠️ **Low gain** — e.g., $|A_v| = 4$ requires $(W/L)_2/(W/L)_1 = 16$.\n\n⚠️ **Headroom cost** — since $|A_v| = \\frac{V_{OV1}}{V_{OV2}}$, higher gain demands a large overdrive on M₁, and the output cannot fall below $\\approx |V_{TH1}|$, limiting swing.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "14acb09d045ffa2d9974a5cdb7de404a59950c70fa58ac9d19170f952c2b62c5"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies both devices as PMOS, M2 as the common-source input device, and M1 as a diode-connected PMOS load with gate and drain grounded. It gives the required gm/gm gain, approximately −gm2/gm1; the extra analysis is consistent with the stated assumptions.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b9bd40d93897263d8f8ec48e8a570180ddbbc0962f905b31861c1d4b96315bc9",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1848,
        "output_tokens": 9220,
        "total_tokens": 11068,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7843,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1848,
        "output_tokens": 9220,
        "total_tokens": 11068,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7843,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nBoth transistors are **PMOS** devices:\n\n| Device | Source | Gate | Drain | Role |\n|--------|--------|------|-------|------|\n| $M_2$ | $V_{DD}$ | $V_{in}$ | $V_{out}$ | **Common-source** amplifying device (input at gate, source at AC ground) |\n| $M_1$ | $V_{out}$ | GND | GND | **Diode-connected load** (gate and drain both at 0 V, so $V_G = V_D$) |\n\nThis is a **PMOS common-source stage with a diode-connected load**.\n\n# Bias / Large-Signal Behavior\n\nThe same drain current $I_D$ flows from $V_{DD}$ through $M_2$ and $M_1$ to ground.\n\n- $M_2$ conducts if $V_{SG2} = V_{DD} - V_{in} > |V_{THP}|$, and is saturated as long as $V_{out} \\le V_{in} + |V_{THP}|$.\n- $M_1$ is diode-connected ($V_{SD1} = V_{SG1} = V_{out}$), so it is **always saturated** when on; it requires $V_{out} > |V_{THP}|$.\n\nEquating the two saturation currents (with $\\lambda \\approx 0$):\n\n$$\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_{DD} - V_{in} - |V_{TH2}|)^2 = \\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_{out} - |V_{TH1}|)^2$$\n\n$$\\Rightarrow\\quad V_{out} = |V_{TH1}| + \\sqrt{\\frac{(W/L)_2}{(W/L)_1}}\\,\\big(V_{DD} - V_{in} - |V_{TH2}|\\big)$$\n\nThe transfer characteristic is **linear** (constant slope) as long as both devices stay saturated — a hallmark of diode-connected loads.\n\n# Small-Signal Gain\n\n$M_2$ injects a current $g_{m2} v_{in}$ into the output node. Looking into the source of diode-connected $M_1$, the impedance is $\\frac{1}{g_{m1} + g_{mb1}} \\parallel r_{O1}$ (body effect appears if $M_1$'s n-well is tied to $V_{DD}$, since its source moves with $V_{out}$). KCL at the output node gives:\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = -g_{m2}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{m1}} \\,\\Big\\|\\, \\frac{1}{g_{mb1}} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{O1} \\,\\Big\\|\\, r_{O2}\\right)}$$\n\nNeglecting channel-length modulation and body effect ($\\lambda = \\gamma = 0$):\n\n$$A_v \\approx -\\frac{g_{m2}}{g_{m1}} = -\\sqrt{\\frac{(W/L)_2}{(W/L)_1}}$$\n\nsince both devices are PMOS carrying the same current, so $\\mu_p C_{ox}$ and $I_D$ cancel. (With body effect: $A_v = -\\frac{g_{m2}}{g_{m1}}\\cdot\\frac{1}{1+\\eta}$, where $\\eta = g_{mb1}/g_{m1}$.)\n\n# Port Impedances\n\n- **Input resistance:** $R_{in} = \\infty$ (MOS gate)\n- **Output resistance:** $R_{out} = \\frac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}} \\parallel r_{O1} \\parallel r_{O2} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}$ (low)\n\n# Key Properties and Trade-offs\n\n- **Inverting amplifier** with gain set purely by a **geometry ratio** → insensitive to process, temperature, and bias current; excellent linearity.\n- **Modest gain:** achieving $|A_v| = 10$ requires $(W/L)_2 = 100\\,(W/L)_1$ — expensive in area.\n- **Limited swing:** the diode-connected load prevents $V_{out}$ from dropping below $\\approx |V_{TH1}|$; the top of the swing is bounded by keeping $M_2$ saturated ($V_{out} \\le V_{in} + |V_{THP}|$).\n- Low $R_{out}$ gives good bandwidth into capacitive loads, but inherently caps the achievable gain.\n- Tying $M_1$'s n-well to its own source (possible for PMOS) eliminates $g_{mb1}$ and restores $A_v = -g_{m2}/g_{m1}$ exactly.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "48182fe75ab29d85b25eb2bd98d159f79ebf7218cc08fdf27bd5d60e8aa34b02"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies both PMOS devices, M2 as the common-source input device, M1 as a diode-connected PMOS load with gate and drain grounded, and gives the gm/gm gain −gm2/gm1. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b9bd40d93897263d8f8ec48e8a570180ddbbc0962f905b31861c1d4b96315bc9",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1848,
        "output_tokens": 19801,
        "total_tokens": 21649,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 18234,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1848,
        "output_tokens": 19801,
        "total_tokens": 21649,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 18234,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **PMOS common‑source amplifier with a diode‑connected PMOS load** (both devices are PMOS, as indicated by the source arrows pointing toward the gates):\n\n| Device | Terminals | Role |\n|---|---|---|\n| **M₂** | Source → $V_{DD}$, Gate → $V_{in}$, Drain → $V_{out}$ | Input (common-source) transconductor |\n| **M₁** | Source → $V_{out}$, Gate → GND, Drain → GND | Diode-connected load ($V_G = V_D$) |\n\nBias current flows from $V_{DD}$ through M₂ into the output node, then through M₁ to ground.\n\n# Large-Signal (DC) Behavior\n\nM₁ is diode-connected, so it is always saturated when conducting. Equating drain currents (saturation, $\\lambda \\approx 0$):\n\n$$\\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_2\\big(V_{DD}-V_{in}-|V_{THP}|\\big)^2 = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_1\\big(V_{out}-|V_{THP}|\\big)^2$$\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{out} = |V_{THP}| + \\sqrt{\\frac{(W/L)_2}{(W/L)_1}}\\,\\big(V_{DD}-V_{in}-|V_{THP}|\\big)}$$\n\nThe transfer characteristic is **linear** in the active region — a hallmark of a diode-connected load of the *same* device type.\n\n**Operating region limits:**\n- M₂ on: $V_{in} < V_{DD} - |V_{THP}|$\n- M₂ saturated: $V_{out} \\le V_{in} + |V_{THP}|$ (upper swing limit)\n- M₁ conducting: $V_{out} \\ge |V_{THP}|$ (lower swing limit)\n\n# Small-Signal Gain\n\nThe diode-connected M₁ presents an impedance of $\\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\,\\|\\,r_{O1}$ at the output. The CS stage gives:\n\n$$A_v = -g_{m2}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\;\\Big\\|\\;r_{O1}\\;\\Big\\|\\;r_{O2}\\right)$$\n\nNeglecting channel-length modulation ($r_O \\to \\infty$):\n\n$$A_v \\approx -\\frac{g_{m2}}{g_{m1}} = -\\sqrt{\\frac{(W/L)_2}{(W/L)_1}} = -\\frac{|V_{ov1}|}{|V_{ov2}|}$$\n\n*(If M₁'s body is tied to $V_{DD}$ rather than its source, include body effect: replace $g_{m1}$ with $g_{m1}+g_{mb1}$.)*\n\n**Sign check:** $V_{in}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow |V_{GS2}|\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow I_D\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow V_{out}\\!\\downarrow$ → **inverting**, consistent with the slope of the DC equation.\n\n# Port Impedances\n\n$$R_{in} = \\infty \\qquad\\quad R_{out} = \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\,r_{O1}\\,\\Big\\|\\,r_{O2} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}$$\n\n# Key Takeaways\n\n- **Ratiometric gain:** Since both devices are PMOS carrying the same current, $\\mu_p C_{ox}$ and $I_D$ cancel — the gain depends **only on the geometry ratio**, making it insensitive to process, supply, and temperature variations.\n- **Good linearity** across the valid input range (linear $V_{out}$–$V_{in}$ relation).\n- **Trade-offs:** modest gain (large gain requires a very large $(W/L)_2/(W/L)_1$ ratio) and reduced output swing, since each swing limit sacrifices roughly one $|V_{THP}|$ or overdrive.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "59d95bb85cbec3b3c81ba782e6ea71f1819a82b65e10a21d302a89f450650556"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies both PMOS devices, M2 as the common-source input device, and M1 as the diode-connected load to ground, with the expected gm/gm gain. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule; the additional claims use ideal-model assumptions and do not overturn the essential analysis.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b9bd40d93897263d8f8ec48e8a570180ddbbc0962f905b31861c1d4b96315bc9",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1848,
        "output_tokens": 9235,
        "total_tokens": 11083,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7819,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1848,
        "output_tokens": 9235,
        "total_tokens": 11083,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7819,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-018-find-rout",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "Find Rout in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-018-find-rout/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# PMOS Cascode Current Source — Output Resistance\n\n**Setup:** This is a PMOS cascode: M₂ (source at V_DD, gate at V_b2) acts as a current source, and M₁ (gate at V_b1) is the cascode device. We look into the **drain of M₁**.\n\n## Step 1: Resistance at node X\n\nFor small-signal analysis, V_DD, V_b1, and V_b2 are all AC grounds. Looking up into the drain of M₂ (whose gate and source are at AC ground), we simply see:\n\n$$R_X = r_{O2}$$\n\n## Step 2: M₁ degenerated by r_O2\n\nM₁ is now a transistor with source degeneration $r_{O2}$. Apply a test voltage $v_x$ at the output, inject current $i_x$:\n\n- The current flows through M₂, so the source of M₁ sits at $v_X = i_x r_{O2}$\n- With gate and bulk at AC ground: $v_{GS1} = v_{BS1} = -i_x r_{O2}$\n\nKCL at the output node:\n\n$$i_x = g_{m1}v_{GS1} + g_{mb1}v_{BS1} + \\frac{v_x - v_X}{r_{O1}}$$\n\n$$i_x = -(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})\\,i_x r_{O2} + \\frac{v_x - i_x r_{O2}}{r_{O1}}$$\n\n## Result\n\n$$\\boxed{R_{out} = \\big[1 + (g_{m1}+g_{mb1})\\,r_{O1}\\big]\\,r_{O2} + r_{O1}}$$\n\nSince typically $(g_m + g_{mb})r_O \\gg 1$:\n\n$$R_{out} \\approx (g_{m1}+g_{mb1})\\,r_{O1}\\,r_{O2} \\approx g_{m1} r_{O1} r_{O2}$$\n\n**Interpretation:** Cascoding \"boosts\" the output resistance of M₂ by the intrinsic gain of M₁ (roughly $g_{m1}r_{O1}$), making this a much better current source than a single transistor.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "1cef40169b0a76138d3e551ea1b7a318a4aef7f4122229bce7190871d37fb73d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the PMOS topology and M1 as the cascode device, and gives the full output-resistance expression and its standard approximation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0e58951a444fd5eb5a81c93c3c94eef4ae9b6f921b6512a0c0fecf7f946efcb1",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2825,
        "output_tokens": 2374,
        "total_tokens": 5199,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1659,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2825,
        "output_tokens": 2374,
        "total_tokens": 5199,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1659,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-018-find-rout",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "Find Rout in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-018-find-rout/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting Up\n\nThis is a **PMOS cascode current source**: M₂ (source at V_DD) acts as the current source, and M₁ is the cascode device. We look into the drain of M₁.\n\nFor small-signal analysis, V_DD, V_b1, and V_b2 are all AC grounds.\n\n**Step 1 — Resistance at node X:**\nM₂ has its gate and source at AC ground, so looking into its drain we simply see:\n\n$$R_X = r_{O2}$$\n\n**Step 2 — M₁ with source degeneration:**\nM₁ is a common-gate device whose source is degenerated by $r_{O2}$. Apply a test voltage $V_x$ (current $I_x$) at the drain of M₁. Since $I_x$ flows through $r_{O2}$:\n\n$$v_X = I_x r_{O2} \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad v_{GS1} = -I_x r_{O2}, \\quad v_{BS1} = -I_x r_{O2}$$\n\nKCL at the drain of M₁:\n\n$$I_x = \\underbrace{(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})(-I_x r_{O2})}_{\\text{dependent sources}} \\cdot(-1)\\cdot(-1) + \\frac{V_x - I_x r_{O2}}{r_{O1}}$$\n\nSolving:\n\n$$V_x = I_x\\left[r_{O1} + r_{O2} + (g_{m1}+g_{mb1})\\,r_{O1} r_{O2}\\right]$$\n\n## Result\n\n$$\\boxed{R_{out} = r_{O1} + r_{O2} + (g_{m1}+g_{mb1})\\,r_{O1}\\,r_{O2}\\;\\approx\\; g_{m1}\\,r_{O1}\\,r_{O2}}$$\n\n**Interpretation:** The cascode device M₁ \"boosts\" the output resistance of the simple current source ($r_{O2}$) by a factor of approximately its intrinsic gain, $(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})r_{O1}$ — this is why cascoding is used to build high-quality current sources.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c20cf826d2d610a266fa8a71cb521aad89710d9490889e9d0a04d11e5b336c9d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the PMOS topology and M1 as the cascode device, and gives the full output-resistance expression and valid approximation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0e58951a444fd5eb5a81c93c3c94eef4ae9b6f921b6512a0c0fecf7f946efcb1",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2825,
        "output_tokens": 1879,
        "total_tokens": 4704,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1170,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2825,
        "output_tokens": 1879,
        "total_tokens": 4704,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1170,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-018-find-rout",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "Find Rout in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-018-find-rout/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# PMOS Cascode Current Source — Output Resistance\n\n## Circuit Identification\n\n- **M₂** (source at $V_{DD}$, gate at $V_{b2}$): acts as a current source, presenting resistance $r_{O2}$ at node $X$.\n- **M₁** (source at $X$, gate at $V_{b1}$): acts as the **cascode device**, degenerated by $r_{O2}$.\n\nThis is simply a transistor ($M_1$) with a source-degeneration resistance $R_S = r_{O2}$.\n\n## Small-Signal Derivation\n\nApply a test voltage $v_X$ at the output and measure $i_X$. Since $V_{b1}$, $V_{b2}$, and $V_{DD}$ are AC grounds, $M_2$ reduces to the resistor $r_{O2}$.\n\nThe test current flows through $M_1$ into node $X$, so:\n\n$$v_{\\text{node }X} = i_X r_{O2} \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad v_{GS1} = v_{BS1} = -i_X r_{O2}$$\n\nKCL at the drain of $M_1$:\n\n$$i_X = g_{m1}v_{GS1} + g_{mb1}v_{BS1} + \\frac{v_X - i_X r_{O2}}{r_{O1}}$$\n\n$$i_X = -(g_{m1} + g_{mb1})\\,i_X r_{O2} + \\frac{v_X - i_X r_{O2}}{r_{O1}}$$\n\nSolving for $v_X/i_X$:\n\n$$\\boxed{R_{out} = r_{O1} + r_{O2} + (g_{m1} + g_{mb1})\\,r_{O1}\\,r_{O2}}$$\n\n## Approximation\n\nSince $(g_m + g_{mb})r_O \\gg 1$ typically:\n\n$$R_{out} \\approx (g_{m1} + g_{mb1})\\,r_{O1}\\,r_{O2}$$\n\n**Key insight:** The cascode transistor $M_1$ \"boosts\" the output resistance of the simple current source $M_2$ by a factor of approximately its own intrinsic gain, $(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})r_{O1}$. Note that $g_{mb1}$ appears because the source of $M_1$ (node $X$) is not tied to its body ($V_{DD}$).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0a66f72f19f9b42568965de0661eb77938b4b9f09f0ea965cf19f7995cd1ec3e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Identifies M1 as the cascode device and gives the correct full output-resistance expression; the approximation is consistent with the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0e58951a444fd5eb5a81c93c3c94eef4ae9b6f921b6512a0c0fecf7f946efcb1",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2825,
        "output_tokens": 2277,
        "total_tokens": 5102,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1482,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2825,
        "output_tokens": 2277,
        "total_tokens": 5102,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1482,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "How do we ensure that M2 is in saturation in the figure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Condition for M2's saturation\n\nM2 is a PMOS device with its source at $V_{DD}$ and gate at $V_{b2}$. It operates in saturation as long as:\n\n$$|V_{DS2}| \\geq |V_{GS2}| - |V_{TH2}| \\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad V_X \\leq V_{b2} + |V_{TH2}|$$\n\nThat is, its drain (node $X$) must not rise above $V_{b2} + |V_{TH2}|$.\n\n## How the circuit guarantees it\n\nThe key observation is that **M1 sets the voltage at node X**. Since M1 carries the bias current, it requires a fixed source-gate voltage, so:\n\n$$V_X = V_{b1} + |V_{GS1}|$$\n\nSubstituting this into the saturation condition for M2:\n\n$$V_{b1} + |V_{GS1}| \\leq V_{b2} + |V_{TH2}|$$\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{b1} \\leq V_{b2} + |V_{TH2}| - |V_{GS1}|}$$\n\nSo M2 is kept in saturation simply by **choosing the bias voltage $V_{b1}$ low enough** relative to $V_{b2}$.\n\n## Why this is robust\n\nBecause $V_{b1}$ is a fixed bias, $V_X$ is \"pinned\" at $V_{b1} + |V_{GS1}|$ and does **not** depend on the output voltage. The cascode transistor M1 shields M2 from output swings, so once the inequality above is satisfied, M2 stays in saturation regardless of what happens at the output. (M1 itself remains saturated as long as $V_{out} \\leq V_{b1} + |V_{TH1}|$, which defines the output compliance of this cascode current source.)",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f243b07539445379185e48bc5217ef14116f6c3cb88b9bd5e9c10a2a3b52f5f9"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly gives M2’s PMOS saturation condition, uses M1’s relation V_X = V_b1 + |V_GS1|, and derives the resulting bound on V_b1. The additional compliance discussion is consistent with the topology.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "519fe1851b4fd9a0e83d2b184c82583260701cb7382ec5e7c6bdd728b4cc9a0f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2789,
        "output_tokens": 2619,
        "total_tokens": 5408,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2023,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2789,
        "output_tokens": 2619,
        "total_tokens": 5408,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2023,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "How do we ensure that M2 is in saturation in the figure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Ensuring M₂ Operates in Saturation\n\n**Key observation:** The voltage at node *X* is *fixed* by M₁ and the bias current, not by the output. Since M₁ carries a fixed current and has a fixed gate voltage, its source voltage is \"pinned\" at:\n\n$$V_X = V_{b1} + |V_{GS1}| = V_{b1} + |V_{TH1}| + |V_{ov1}|$$\n\n**Saturation condition for M₂ (PMOS):** M₂ requires\n\n$$|V_{DS2}| \\geq |V_{GS2}| - |V_{TH2}|$$\n\nWith the source of M₂ at $V_{DD}$, this translates to a condition on its drain voltage ($V_X$):\n\n$$V_{DD} - V_X \\;\\geq\\; (V_{DD} - V_{b2}) - |V_{TH2}| \\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad \\boxed{V_X \\leq V_{b2} + |V_{TH2}|}$$\n\n**Combining the two:** Substituting the value of $V_X$ set by M₁:\n\n$$V_{b1} + |V_{GS1}| \\;\\leq\\; V_{b2} + |V_{TH2}|$$\n\nSo M₂ is guaranteed to be in saturation by **proper choice of the bias voltages** $V_{b1}$ and $V_{b2}$ — specifically, $V_{b1}$ must be low enough (for a given $V_{b2}$) that node *X* does not rise above $V_{b2} + |V_{TH2}|$.\n\n**Why this works regardless of the output:** M₁ acts as a cascode device that *shields* node *X* from the output node. Variations at the output (where $R_{out}$ is measured) appear across M₁'s drain-source, while $V_X$ — and therefore $V_{DS2}$ — remains essentially constant. Once the inequality above is satisfied, M₂ stays saturated independent of output voltage swings, preserving the high output resistance:\n\n$$R_{out} \\approx g_{m1} r_{O1} r_{O2}$$",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "2bd90b68fe5464f04f0ffbda2845d251ad63157cb0ae1fc2e045006fee37bc67"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies both devices as PMOS, gives M2’s saturation condition, relates VX to Vb1, and combines them into the required bias-voltage inequality.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "519fe1851b4fd9a0e83d2b184c82583260701cb7382ec5e7c6bdd728b4cc9a0f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2789,
        "output_tokens": 3018,
        "total_tokens": 5807,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2317,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2789,
        "output_tokens": 3018,
        "total_tokens": 5807,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2317,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "How do we ensure that M2 is in saturation in the figure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting Up the Condition\n\nIn this PMOS cascode current source, **M2** has its source at $V_{DD}$, gate at $V_{b2}$, and drain at node $X$. For a PMOS device, saturation requires:\n\n$$V_{SD2} \\geq V_{SG2} - |V_{TH2}|$$\n\nRewriting in terms of node voltages ($V_{SD2} = V_{DD} - V_X$ and $V_{SG2} = V_{DD} - V_{b2}$):\n\n$$V_X \\leq V_{b2} + |V_{TH2}|$$\n\ni.e., the drain of M2 may not rise above its gate by more than one threshold.\n\n## Why the Bias Voltages Guarantee This\n\nThe key observation is that **node X is pinned by M1**, not by the output. Since M1 carries the bias current $I_D$, its source-gate voltage is fixed at:\n\n$$V_{SG1} = |V_{TH1}| + |V_{OV1}|, \\qquad |V_{OV1}| = \\sqrt{\\frac{2I_D}{\\mu_p C_{ox}(W/L)_1}}$$\n\nand therefore:\n\n$$V_X = V_{b1} + V_{SG1}$$\n\nSubstituting into the saturation condition gives the design requirement:\n\n$$\\boxed{V_{b1} + V_{SG1} \\leq V_{b2} + |V_{TH2}|}$$\n\nor equivalently (if $|V_{TH1}| \\approx |V_{TH2}|$):\n\n$$V_{b2} \\ge V_{b1} + |V_{OV1}|$$\n\n## The Important Takeaway\n\nThis condition involves **only** $V_{b1}$, $V_{b2}$, and device parameters — it does *not* depend on the output voltage. The cascode device M1 \"shields\" node $X$ from swings at the output, so once $V_{b1}$ and $V_{b2}$ are chosen properly, M2 remains in saturation regardless of what happens at the output terminal. (The output voltage only affects whether *M1* stays saturated, requiring $V_{out} \\leq V_{b1} + |V_{TH1}|$.)",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5cec275734445622b8a6e09b31e8f1ff1c522951edc141556dd281bb5ec2b04e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies both devices as PMOS, gives M2’s saturation condition, and relates VX to Vb1 to derive the required bias condition. The answer captures the essential mechanism and matches the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "519fe1851b4fd9a0e83d2b184c82583260701cb7382ec5e7c6bdd728b4cc9a0f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2789,
        "output_tokens": 4668,
        "total_tokens": 7457,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3948,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2789,
        "output_tokens": 4668,
        "total_tokens": 7457,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3948,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Cascode Amplifier Analysis\n\n## 1. Circuit Identification\n\nThis is an **NMOS telescopic cascode amplifier**:\n\n| Element | Function |\n|---|---|\n| $M_1$ | Common-source input device (transconductor), converts $v_{in}$ to drain current |\n| $M_2$ | Common-gate \"cascode\" device, gate at AC ground ($V_{b1}$), passes $M_1$'s current to the output |\n| $I_1$ | Current-source load (sets bias current, ideally infinite output impedance) |\n| Node $X$ | Internal low-swing node between the two transistors |\n\n## 2. DC Bias Conditions\n\nBoth transistors carry $I_D = I_1$. For proper operation, both must stay in **saturation**:\n\n- **M₁ saturated:** $V_X \\geq V_{GS1} - V_{TH1}$, which requires\n$$V_{b1} \\geq V_{GS2} + (V_{GS1} - V_{TH1})$$\n- **M₂ saturated:** $v_{out} \\geq V_{b1} - V_{TH2}$\n\nWith $V_{b1}$ chosen at its minimum value, the lowest allowable output voltage is:\n$$v_{out,min} = V_{OV1} + V_{OV2} \\quad (\\text{two overdrive voltages})$$\n\nThis is the main **cost of cascoding**: reduced output swing compared to a simple common-source stage (which only needs one $V_{OV}$).\n\n## 3. Small-Signal Gain\n\n**Transconductance** (output AC-grounded): the resistance looking into $M_2$'s source ($\\approx 1/(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})$) is much smaller than $r_{o1}$, so nearly all of $M_1$'s current enters $M_2$:\n$$G_m \\approx g_{m1}$$\n\n**Output resistance** (looking into $M_2$'s drain): $M_2$ \"boosts\" $r_{o1}$ by its intrinsic gain:\n$$R_{out} = r_{o1} + r_{o2} + (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{o1} r_{o2} \\approx (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{o1} r_{o2}$$\n\n**Voltage gain** (with ideal $I_1$, i.e., infinite load resistance — exact result):\n$$\\boxed{A_v = -g_{m1} r_{o1}\\big[1 + (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{o2}\\big] \\approx -g_{m1}(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{o1} r_{o2}}$$\n\nThe gain is on the order of $(g_m r_o)^2$ — roughly the **square** of a simple common-source stage's gain. If $I_1$ has finite resistance $R_1$, then $A_v = -g_{m1}\\,(R_1 \\parallel R_{out})$, and $R_1$ typically dominates unless the load is also cascoded.\n\n## 4. Frequency-Response Benefit (Miller Effect)\n\nWith a *moderate* load resistance, node $X$ is low-impedance ($\\approx 1/g_{m2}$), so the gain from gate to drain of $M_1$ is only about $-g_{m1}/g_{m2} \\approx -1$. This **suppresses the Miller multiplication of $C_{GD1}$**, improving bandwidth.\n\n⚠️ **Caveat:** with an *ideal* current-source load, the impedance looking into $M_2$'s source rises to $\\approx R_L/[(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}]$, so the gain to node $X$ becomes $\\approx -g_{m1}r_{o1}$ (large), and the Miller benefit is partially lost. The pole at node $X$ is high-frequency only when the output load impedance is not extremely large.\n\n## 5. Summary of Properties\n\n**Advantages:**\n- Very high voltage gain due to boosted $R_{out}$\n- Better reverse isolation (output-to-input feedthrough through $C_{GD}$ is blocked by $M_2$)\n- Potentially wider bandwidth (reduced Miller effect)\n- $M_2$ shields $M_1$ from output voltage variations → better linearity, reduced channel-length modulation effects on $I_D$\n\n**Disadvantages:**\n- Reduced output swing: headroom of $V_{OV1}+V_{OV2}$ consumed at the bottom (plus the current source's compliance at the top)\n- Requires an extra bias voltage $V_{b1}$\n- To actually realize the gain $\\sim(g_m r_o)^2$, the load $I_1$ must itself be a cascoded current source\n\n**Input resistance:** essentially infinite (MOS gate) at low frequency.\n\nWould you like me to work through the frequency response/pole locations or the design of $V_{b1}$ in more detail?",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "1ca572383a8778c1eb57a627fa3ceb0a9d03f1b673d34ac6d93c2e3eb2a41ef1"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-source NMOS and M2 as the common-gate NMOS cascode, and gives the equivalent ideal-load gain expression specified by the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "fa3ce3c10c3d0bf6258738fc6e9b064c896064cb851cd7f79a50e2fe2b3c822b",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1452,
        "output_tokens": 5984,
        "total_tokens": 7436,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4330,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1452,
        "output_tokens": 5984,
        "total_tokens": 7436,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4330,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Cascode Amplifier Analysis\n\n## 1. Topology Identification\n\nThis is an **NMOS telescopic cascode stage**:\n\n- **M₁**: common-source input device (gate = v_in, source grounded) — converts input voltage to drain current\n- **M₂**: common-gate \"cascode\" device (gate at DC bias V_b1) — passes M₁'s current to the output while boosting output impedance\n- **I₁**: ideal current-source load setting the bias current\n- **Node X**: internal node between M₁'s drain and M₂'s source\n\n## 2. DC Bias Conditions\n\nBoth transistors carry I₁. For proper operation both must stay in saturation:\n\n- **M₁ saturated:** V_X ≥ V_GS1 − V_TH1 = V_OV1, where V_X = V_b1 − V_GS2\n → requires **V_b1 ≥ V_GS2 + V_OV1**\n- **M₂ saturated:** V_out ≥ V_b1 − V_TH2\n\nIf V_b1 is chosen at its minimum, the lowest allowable output voltage is:\n\n$$V_{out,min} = V_{OV1} + V_{OV2}$$\n\ni.e., the cascode costs **one extra overdrive voltage of swing** compared to a simple CS stage.\n\n## 3. Small-Signal Gain\n\n**Transconductance:** M₂ simply relays M₁'s drain current, so\n\n$$G_m \\approx g_{m1}$$\n\n**Output resistance** (looking into M₂'s drain, with r_O1 degenerating its source; note g_mb2 appears because M₂'s source is not grounded → body effect):\n\n$$R_{out} = r_{O2} + r_{O1} + (g_{m2} + g_{mb2})\\,r_{O1} r_{O2} \\approx (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{O1} r_{O2}$$\n\n**Voltage gain** (ideal current source → load impedance is infinite):\n\n$$A_v = -G_m R_{out} \\approx -g_{m1}(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{O1} r_{O2} \\;\\sim\\; -(g_m r_O)^2$$\n\nThe cascode **multiplies the intrinsic gain of a simple CS stage (~g_m r_O) by another factor of g_m r_O**.\n\n> ⚠️ In practice, a real current source has finite output resistance R_P, so A_v = −g_m1(R_out ∥ R_P). To actually realize the huge gain, I₁ must also be implemented as a **cascoded PMOS current source**.\n\n## 4. Role of Node X\n\n- Resistance at X: r_O1 in parallel with the resistance looking into M₂'s source, (R_D + r_O2)/[1 + (g_m2 + g_mb2)r_O2]. With a finite load this is low (≈ 1/g_m2), so node X is a **low-impedance, low-swing node**.\n- M₂ thus **shields** M₁'s drain from output swings: variations at v_out barely disturb V_X, which suppresses channel-length modulation in M₁ — the physical origin of the high R_out.\n\n## 5. Frequency-Response Benefits\n\n- **Miller effect suppressed**: in a plain CS stage, C_GD1 is multiplied by (1 + |A_v|). Here, at high frequencies the gain from M₁'s gate to node X is only ≈ −g_m1/(g_m2 + g_mb2) ≈ −1, so C_GD1 sees a Miller factor of only ≈ 2.\n- Pole at node X is high-frequency: ω_X ≈ (g_m2 + g_mb2)/C_X; the dominant pole sits at the (high-impedance) output.\n- Excellent **reverse isolation** (output-to-input feedthrough blocked by M₂).\n\n## 6. Summary of Trade-offs\n\n| Property | Result |\n|---|---|\n| Gain | ≈ −g_m1(g_m2+g_mb2)r_O1r_O2 (very high) |\n| Input impedance | ∞ (MOS gate) |\n| Output impedance | ≈ (g_m2+g_mb2)r_O1r_O2 (very high) |\n| Output swing | Reduced: v_out ≥ V_OV1 + V_OV2 |\n| Bandwidth | Improved (Miller effect ~eliminated) |\n| Cost | Extra headroom, extra bias voltage V_b1 |\n\n**Bottom line:** this circuit trades voltage headroom for a dramatic (×g_m r_O) increase in gain and much better high-frequency behavior compared with a simple common-source amplifier.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "9d21071216879ac27b15ab171d3c7ad128d43d3895fbe5fc6c67a3cdec252a0c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-source NMOS and M2 as the common-gate NMOS cascode, and gives the equivalent ideal-load gain expression. The node-X discussion is a secondary imprecision and does not affect full credit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "fa3ce3c10c3d0bf6258738fc6e9b064c896064cb851cd7f79a50e2fe2b3c822b",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1452,
        "output_tokens": 4762,
        "total_tokens": 6214,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3198,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1452,
        "output_tokens": 4762,
        "total_tokens": 6214,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3198,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Cascode Amplifier Analysis\n\n## 1. Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **telescopic cascode stage** (from Razavi's *Design of Analog CMOS ICs*):\n\n- **M₁** — common-source input device (gate = $v_{in}$, source grounded): converts input voltage to current\n- **M₂** — common-gate \"cascode\" device (gate = fixed bias $V_{b1}$): passes M₁'s current to the output\n- **I₁** — current-source load setting the bias current of both transistors\n\n## 2. DC Bias Conditions\n\nSince the devices are in series:\n$$I_{D1} = I_{D2} = I_1$$\n\nNode X sits at $V_X = V_{b1} - V_{GS2}$. For both devices to stay saturated:\n\n| Device | Condition | Result |\n|--------|-----------|--------|\n| M₁ | $V_X \\geq V_{GS1} - V_{TH1}$ | $V_{b1} \\geq V_{GS2} + V_{ov1}$ |\n| M₂ | $V_{out} \\geq V_{b1} - V_{TH2}$ | $V_{out,min} = V_{ov1} + V_{ov2}$ (with minimum $V_{b1}$) |\n\nSo the price of cascoding is **one extra overdrive voltage of swing** consumed at the bottom of the output range.\n\n## 3. Small-Signal Gain\n\n**Transconductance:** Looking into M₂'s source we see a low impedance $\\approx 1/(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}) \\ll r_{O1}$, so essentially all of M₁'s signal current flows through M₂:\n$$G_m \\approx g_{m1}$$\n\n**Output resistance** (looking into M₂'s drain, with M₂ degenerated by $r_{O1}$):\n$$R_{out} = r_{O2} + r_{O1} + (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{O2}\\,r_{O1} \\;\\approx\\; (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{O2}\\,r_{O1}$$\n\n**Voltage gain** (ideal current source load):\n$$\\boxed{A_v = -G_m R_{out} \\approx -g_{m1}(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{O1} r_{O2} \\approx -(g_m r_O)^2}$$\n\nThe cascode boosts the gain from one intrinsic gain ($g_m r_O$) to roughly its **square**. If I₁ has finite resistance $R_P$, then $A_v = -g_{m1}(R_{out} \\| R_P)$, and $R_P$ typically dominates unless the load is also cascoded.\n\n## 4. The \"Shielding\" Property of Node X\n\nM₂ isolates node X from the output:\n$$\\frac{\\Delta V_X}{\\Delta V_{out}} \\approx \\frac{1}{(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,r_{O2}} \\ll 1$$\n\nConsequences:\n- M₁'s drain voltage barely moves → M₁'s operating point is insensitive to output swing (better linearity, less channel-length modulation effect on M₁).\n- The small-signal gain from $v_{in}$ to node X is only $\\approx -g_{m1}/(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}) \\approx -1$.\n\n## 5. Frequency Response Advantage\n\nBecause the gain across M₁ (gate → drain) is only ≈ −1, the **Miller multiplication of $C_{GD1}$ is nearly eliminated**:\n$$C_{in} \\approx C_{GS1} + \\left(1 + \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\\right)C_{GD1} \\approx C_{GS1} + 2C_{GD1}$$\n\nversus $C_{GS1} + (1+g_{m1}r_O)C_{GD1}$ in a simple CS stage. The pole at node X, $\\omega_X \\approx (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})/C_X$, is high-frequency; the dominant pole is at the output: $\\omega_{p,out} \\approx 1/(R_{out}C_{out})$.\n\n## 6. Summary of Trade-offs\n\n**Gains:** ✔ Output resistance and voltage gain ↑ by factor $\\sim g_{m2}r_{O2}$ ✔ Suppressed Miller effect / better high-frequency input behavior ✔ Output–input isolation\n\n**Costs:** ✘ Output swing reduced by $V_{ov2}$ (plus more headroom if I₁ is a real transistor) ✘ Requires extra bias voltage $V_{b1}$ ✘ Body effect of M₂ (source not at ground) slightly modifies $g_{m2} \\to g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "8eada9e7b0181a2e97e07130e7f9ca0c1cadcec25143ed64e601ab4f73426f2f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-source NMOS and M2 as the common-gate NMOS cascode, and gives the equivalent ideal-load gain expression required for full credit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "fa3ce3c10c3d0bf6258738fc6e9b064c896064cb851cd7f79a50e2fe2b3c822b",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1452,
        "output_tokens": 5247,
        "total_tokens": 6699,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3627,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1452,
        "output_tokens": 5247,
        "total_tokens": 6699,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3627,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-021-cascode-structure",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 21,
      "question": "Is the circuit shown in the figure a cascode structure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-021-cascode-structure/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**No — despite its appearance, this is not a cascode.**\n\n**Why it looks like one:** Two stacked transistors between $R_D$ and ground, with the input at the bottom gate and a bias $V_{b1}$ at the top gate — the classic cascode \"silhouette.\"\n\n**Why it isn't one:** Look at the source arrows. $M_2$ is an NMOS with its source at the bottom (fine for a common-gate device), but $M_1$ is a **PMOS whose source is on top and whose drain is tied to ground**. This means:\n\n- The intermediate node connects the **source of $M_2$ to the source of $M_1$**. A true cascode requires the cascode device's source to connect to the **drain** of the input device.\n- With its gate driven by $V_{in}$ and its drain at AC ground, $M_1$ operates as a **source follower**, not as a common-source transconductor.\n\nSo the circuit is actually a *source follower ($M_1$) cascaded with a common-gate stage ($M_2$)*, giving roughly\n\n$$\n\\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} \\approx \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}\\cdot g_{m2}R_D \\approx \\frac{g_m R_D}{2}\\quad (\\text{if } g_{m1}=g_{m2})\n$$\n\nIt also loses the hallmark cascode benefit: looking into $M_2$'s drain you see only\n\n$$\nR_{out} \\approx r_{O2} + (1+g_{m2}r_{O2})\\frac{1}{g_{m1}} \\approx 2r_{O2},\n$$\n\nnot the boosted $\\;r_{O2} + (1+g_{m2}r_{O2})r_{O1} \\approx g_{m2}r_{O2}r_{O1}$ of a real cascode.\n\n**To make it a cascode:** replace $M_1$ with an NMOS whose source is grounded and whose drain feeds the source of $M_2$ (common-source + common-gate).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "b180f3ab66b57eaacbd840d5f5ae23db4fad897530f303663f3aedf9d661ee10"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as a PMOS source follower, not a common-source input device, and explains that the structure lacks cascode resistance boosting. Its approximate output-resistance expression and comparison are consistent with the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "7f9e0f88c009a8a25ec2184287032d702e4ac63736a803d1b8f3b4092778054c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1524,
        "output_tokens": 14375,
        "total_tokens": 15899,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13711,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1524,
        "output_tokens": 14375,
        "total_tokens": 15899,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13711,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-021-cascode-structure",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 21,
      "question": "Is the circuit shown in the figure a cascode structure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-021-cascode-structure/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**No — despite the \"stacked\" appearance, this is not a cascode.**\n\n**What the circuit actually is**\n\nLook carefully at the source/drain orientations (the arrows):\n\n- **M2** is an NMOS with its **source at the bottom** (node X) and drain at the output — fine so far, it acts as a common-gate device.\n- **M1**, however, is a **PMOS whose source is on top** (node X) and whose **drain is grounded**.\n\nSo the two transistors are joined **source-to-source**, not drain-to-source. With its drain at AC ground and the input applied to its gate, M1 operates as a **source follower (common-drain)**, not as a common-source transconductor. The circuit is therefore a *source follower driving a common-gate stage*.\n\n**Why that disqualifies it as a cascode**\n\nA true cascode requires the input device in a **common-source** configuration, with its **drain** feeding the **source** of the common-gate (cascode) device. That is what produces the key cascode properties, and this circuit loses them:\n\n- **No output-impedance boosting.** The degeneration seen at the source of M2 is the impedance looking into M1's *source*, which is only ≈ 1/g_m1 (not r_O1). Thus\n$$R_{out,M2} \\approx r_{O2} + (1+g_{m2}r_{O2})\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\,\\|\\,r_{O1}\\right) \\approx \\left(1+\\frac{g_{m2}}{g_{m1}}\\right) r_{O2} \\approx 2r_{O2},$$\nfar below the cascode's ≈ g_m2·r_O2·r_O1.\n\n- **Reduced, non-inverting gain.** Follower gain × common-gate gain gives\n$$A_v \\approx +\\frac{R_D}{\\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}}+\\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}}} \\approx +\\frac{g_m R_D}{2}\\quad (g_{m1}=g_{m2}),$$\ni.e., about *half* the gain of even a simple common-source stage, and positive in sign — instead of the cascode's $-g_{m1}R_D$.\n\n**How to make it a real cascode:** M1 should be an NMOS with its **source grounded** and its **drain** tied to the source of M2 (telescopic cascode). (Even a *folded* cascode with a PMOS input would require M1's *drain* — not its source — to drive M2's source, along with a bias current source.)",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "065bc7fbe23e8b1ec03998168a3d2bb4deb21aa4f26bdee31b69c9c6a6abb2d8"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as a PMOS source follower rather than a common-source input device, so the circuit is not a cascode and lacks cascode output-resistance boosting. The resistance expression is also consistent with the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "7f9e0f88c009a8a25ec2184287032d702e4ac63736a803d1b8f3b4092778054c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1524,
        "output_tokens": 13307,
        "total_tokens": 14831,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12486,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1524,
        "output_tokens": 13307,
        "total_tokens": 14831,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12486,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-021-cascode-structure",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 21,
      "question": "Is the circuit shown in the figure a cascode structure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-021-cascode-structure/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**No — despite the stacked appearance, this is not a cascode.**\n\n**Why it looks like one:** Two transistors are in series with the load $R_D$, the top device $M_2$ has a DC bias $V_{b1}$ on its gate (a proper common‑gate connection), and the input drives the bottom device.\n\n**Why it isn't one:** Look at the orientation of $M_1$. It is a **PMOS whose drain is tied to ground and whose source is tied to node X** (the source of $M_2$). A true cascode requires the input transistor to act as a **common-source** transconductor, with its *source* at AC ground and its *drain* feeding the source of the cascode device. Here, with its drain grounded, $M_1$ instead operates as a **source follower (common-drain stage)**.\n\nSo the circuit is a **CD–CG cascade (source follower + common-gate)**, not the CS–CG cascade that defines a cascode.\n\n**Consequences (ignoring $r_O$ and body effect):**\n\n- Voltage gain:\n$$\\frac{V_{out}}{V_{in}} \\approx +\\frac{R_D}{\\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}}+\\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}}}$$\ni.e., *non-inverting* and with a reduced equivalent transconductance $G_m = \\dfrac{g_{m1}g_{m2}}{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}$ — compared with $-g_{m1}R_D$ for a real cascode.\n\n- No output-impedance boosting: the source of $M_2$ sees the low impedance $\\approx 1/g_{m1}$ of $M_1$'s source, so looking into $M_2$'s drain:\n$$R_{out} \\approx r_{O2} + (1+g_{m2}r_{O2})\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\,\\|\\,r_{O1}\\right) \\approx r_{O2}\\left(1+\\frac{g_{m2}}{g_{m1}}\\right) \\approx 2r_{O2},$$\nnowhere near the $\\sim g_{m2}r_{O2}r_{O1}$ of a true cascode.\n\nThe circuit is still a functional amplifier, but it provides none of the cascode's hallmark benefits (high output resistance, gain enhancement, shielding of the input device's drain).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "46563065fd2a8c07ba2cbefec918236b269ebe143b826397567a18eb13d542d6"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as a PMOS source follower, not a common-source input device, and concludes the structure lacks cascode output-resistance boosting. Its output-resistance expression is also consistent with the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "7f9e0f88c009a8a25ec2184287032d702e4ac63736a803d1b8f3b4092778054c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1524,
        "output_tokens": 22716,
        "total_tokens": 24240,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 21942,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1524,
        "output_tokens": 22716,
        "total_tokens": 24240,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 21942,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-022-explain-why-miller-effect-less-pronounced-cascode",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 22,
      "question": "Explain why the Miller effect is less pronounced in a cascode.",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Quick recap of the Miller effect\n\nIn a plain common-source (or common-emitter) stage, the gate–drain capacitance $C_{gd}$ bridges the input and the output. Since the stage inverts with gain $-A_v$, a small input change $\\Delta v$ makes the drain swing by $-A_v\\,\\Delta v$, so the voltage *across* $C_{gd}$ changes by $(1+A_v)\\Delta v$. The input must supply all of that charge, so it effectively sees\n\n$$C_{in} = C_{gs} + (1 + g_m R_L)\\,C_{gd}$$\n\nWith $g_m R_L$ in the tens or hundreds, this multiplied capacitance plus the source resistance forms a low-frequency dominant pole — the classic gain–bandwidth tradeoff.\n\n## What the cascode changes\n\nA cascode stacks a common-gate device M2 on top of the common-source input device M1. The key consequence:\n\n**The drain of M1 no longer swings.** M1's drain now looks into the *source* of M2, which presents a low impedance of roughly $1/g_{m2}$. The gain from M1's gate to M1's drain collapses to\n\n$$A_{v1} \\approx -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}} \\approx -1$$\n\nSo the Miller multiplication of $C_{gd1}$ is only a factor of about 2:\n\n$$C_{in} \\approx C_{gs1} + 2\\,C_{gd1}$$\n\ninstead of $(1 + g_m R_L)C_{gd1}$. Intuitively: the far plate of $C_{gd1}$ barely moves, so the input doesn't have to pump extra charge into it.\n\n**The large swing moves to a node with no feedback path.** The full output swing now occurs at M2's drain. But M2's gate is at AC ground, so its $C_{gd2}$ is just a capacitor from output to ground — it can't feed the output back to the input, hence no Miller multiplication. Its $C_{gs2}$ sits at the low-impedance cascode node, where it creates only a high-frequency, non-dominant pole near $g_{m2}/(2\\pi C_{node})$.\n\n## Why you keep the gain\n\nM1 still converts $v_{in}$ into a current $g_{m1}v_{in}$; M2 acts as a near-unity current buffer that passes this current to the load. The overall gain remains $\\approx -g_{m1}R_{out}$ (and the cascode's output resistance $\\approx g_{m2}r_{o2}r_{o1}$ can actually *increase* it). The cascode's trick is decoupling **where the voltage gain develops** (M2's drain) from **where the input-bridging capacitor sits** (M1's drain).\n\n## Caveats\n\n- With a very high-impedance load (e.g., a cascoded current source), the impedance at the cascode node rises to roughly $1/g_{m2} + R_L/(g_{m2}r_{o2})$, so the node gain can exceed unity and a bit of Miller effect returns — still far less than the single-stage case.\n- A bonus effect: breaking the capacitive feedthrough path greatly improves reverse isolation, which is why cascodes are standard in RF amplifiers to prevent instability.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bfcf4f1b68cb77d5b3c8d328f2e016945efca14f585d95a0c237d89ea00005da"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the low-impedance cascode node and derives a gate-to-drain gain near −1, so Cgd1 is multiplied by about 2 rather than the full stage gain. Saying the drain barely swings overstates the effect, but the answer’s quantitative explanation is correct and this is a minor flaw.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0d298300029d3b4545999675d8ec4b4c83532fca89fa9878f9898848f75f534f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 28,
        "output_tokens": 4634,
        "total_tokens": 4662,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3552,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 28,
        "output_tokens": 4634,
        "total_tokens": 4662,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3552,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-022-explain-why-miller-effect-less-pronounced-cascode",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 22,
      "question": "Explain why the Miller effect is less pronounced in a cascode.",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nThe Miller multiplication of a capacitance depends on the voltage gain *across that capacitance*. In a cascode, the input transistor's drain no longer swings with the full stage gain—it only swings about as much as the input itself—so its gate–drain capacitance is multiplied by ~2 instead of by the full gain.\n\n## The problem in a plain common-source (or common-emitter) stage\n\nThe gate–drain capacitance Cgd (Cμ in a BJT) bridges input and output. The stage inverts with gain Av ≈ −gm·RL, so when the gate moves by ΔV, the drain moves by −gm·RL·ΔV. The voltage *across* Cgd therefore changes by (1 + gm·RL)·ΔV, and the input source must supply all that charge. Effectively:\n\n  Cin = Cgs + (1 + gm·RL)·Cgd\n\nWith a gain of 100, a 0.1 pF Cgd looks like ~10 pF at the input. Together with the source resistance Rs, this sets a low-frequency input pole that kills bandwidth.\n\n## What the cascode changes\n\nStack a common-gate transistor M2 (gate at AC ground) on top of the common-source device M1, and take the output at M2's drain. Cgd1 still connects M1's gate to M1's drain—but M1's drain is no longer the high-swing output node. It looks into the *source* of M2, whose impedance is only about 1/gm2.\n\nThe gain from M1's gate to its drain is therefore:\n\n  Av1 ≈ −gm1·(1/gm2) ≈ −1  (for similar devices)\n\nso the Miller factor collapses from (1 + gm·RL) to about 2:\n\n  Cin ≈ Cgs1 + 2·Cgd1\n\nPhysically: since the drain barely moves, the voltage across Cgd1 barely changes, so the input only has to supply a little charge through it—the capacitor no longer \"looks big.\"\n\n## Why you don't lose the gain\n\nM2 acts as a current buffer: essentially all of M1's signal current (gm1·vin) passes through it into the load, so the overall gain is still ≈ −gm1·RL. The large voltage swing simply occurs at M2's drain instead. Crucially, the capacitance at that node, Cgd2, connects to M2's gate—an AC ground—so it just loads the output to ground and sees no Miller multiplication. There is no longer a capacitive feedback path from the swinging output back to the input: the common-gate stage provides reverse isolation, breaking the feedback mechanism that creates the Miller effect in the first place.\n\n## Consequences and one caveat\n\n- The input pole 1/(2π·Rs·Cin) moves up dramatically → much wider bandwidth for the same gain.\n- The new internal node's pole sits near gm2/Cnode (close to fT), usually non-dominant.\n- The improved reverse isolation also helps stability, which is why cascodes are standard in RF amplifiers.\n\nCaveat: if the load is a very high impedance (e.g., a cascoded current source), the resistance looking into M2's source rises to ≈ (RL + ro2)/(gm2·ro2), so the intermediate-node gain can exceed unity. The Miller suppression is then strong but not perfect.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "19c89f7669e5e27e7e2abcc1b6da3ff5d9e121bdfbe583ad998c14d7a4e5a0ff"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the low-impedance source of M2 and the roughly −1 gain to M1’s drain, giving Cgd1 a Miller factor near 2 rather than the full-stage gain. The phrase “barely moves” slightly overstates the effect, but the answer’s explicit gain and capacitance estimates are correct.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0d298300029d3b4545999675d8ec4b4c83532fca89fa9878f9898848f75f534f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 28,
        "output_tokens": 5916,
        "total_tokens": 5944,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4830,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 28,
        "output_tokens": 5916,
        "total_tokens": 5944,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4830,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-022-explain-why-miller-effect-less-pronounced-cascode",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 22,
      "question": "Explain why the Miller effect is less pronounced in a cascode.",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Quick recap of the Miller effect\n\nIn a common-source (or common-emitter) stage, the gate–drain capacitance $C_{gd}$ (or $C_\\mu$ for a BJT) bridges the input and output. Because the stage has large inverting gain $-A_v$, an input wiggle $\\Delta V$ causes the far plate to swing by $-A_v \\Delta V$, so the capacitor sees $(1+A_v)\\Delta V$ across it. The input must supply the corresponding charge, so it sees an effective capacitance:\n\n$$C_{\\text{Miller}} = C_{gd}(1 + A_v) \\approx C_{gd}(1 + g_m R_L)$$\n\nWith gains of 50–100, a tiny $C_{gd}$ becomes a large input capacitance, which together with the source resistance forms a dominant low-frequency pole that kills bandwidth.\n\n## What the cascode changes\n\nThe cascode stacks a common-gate (common-base) device on top of the input device. Now the input transistor's drain no longer drives the load — it drives the **source of the cascode device**, which presents a very low impedance of roughly $1/g_{m2}$.\n\nThe voltage gain from the input transistor's gate to *its own drain* therefore collapses:\n\n$$A_{v1} = -g_{m1} \\cdot \\frac{1}{g_{m2}} \\approx -1$$\n\nso the Miller multiplication becomes:\n\n$$C_{\\text{Miller}} \\approx C_{gd1}(1 + 1) = 2\\,C_{gd1}$$\n\ninstead of $\\sim 100\\,C_{gd1}$.\n\n## Where did the gain go?\n\nThe overall gain is preserved: the cascode device has a current gain of ≈1, so the signal current $g_{m1}v_{in}$ still flows into the load and produces the full output swing $-g_{m1}R_L\\,v_{in}$ — but at the **cascode device's drain**. Crucially, no capacitor connects that high-swing node back to the input:\n\n- $C_{gd2}$ of the cascode device runs from the output to its gate, which is at **AC ground** — it's just ordinary load capacitance, with no multiplication.\n- The intermediate node (drain of M1 / source of M2) is low-impedance, so its pole sits at a high frequency and doesn't become dominant.\n\n## Intuition\n\nMiller multiplication requires a large inverting voltage swing on the far plate of the feedback capacitor. The cascode device acts as a **current buffer** that pins the input device's drain at a nearly constant voltage while relaying the signal current to the output. Since the far plate of $C_{gd1}$ barely moves, there's almost nothing to multiply.\n\nThe payoff: the input pole moves out by roughly the gain factor, greatly extending bandwidth — plus you get improved reverse isolation, which is why cascodes are ubiquitous in RF amplifiers.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f46f908162631caab619ddb84736e7f26885a15e5eafb4139916071748b6237a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the low-impedance intermediate node and gives a gate-to-drain gain near −1, so the Miller factor is about 2 rather than the full stage gain. But the later claim that the drain barely moves and there is “almost nothing” to multiply overstates the reduction; its swing is not negligible.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0d298300029d3b4545999675d8ec4b4c83532fca89fa9878f9898848f75f534f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 28,
        "output_tokens": 4281,
        "total_tokens": 4309,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3316,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 28,
        "output_tokens": 4281,
        "total_tokens": 4309,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3316,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 23,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\n- **M₂ (NMOS, bottom):** gate tied to the fixed bias **V_b1** (AC ground), input **V_in** applied at the **source**, output taken at the **drain** → **common‑gate (CG) stage**.\n- **M₁ (PMOS, top):** source at V_DD, gate at fixed bias **V_b2**, so V_SG1 = V_DD − V_b2 is constant → **current-source (active) load** presenting resistance r_o1 at the output.\n\n**⇒ This is a common-gate amplifier with a PMOS current-source load.**\n\n# DC / Bias Conditions\n\nThe bias current is set by M₁:\n\n$$I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_{DD}-V_{b2}-|V_{THP}|)^2$$\n\nFor both devices to stay in saturation:\n\n| Device | Condition | Constraint on V_out |\n|---|---|---|\n| M₁ (PMOS) | V_SD1 ≥ V_SG1 − \\|V_THP\\| | $V_{out} \\le V_{b2} + |V_{THP}|$ |\n| M₂ (NMOS) | V_DS2 ≥ V_GS2 − V_THN | $V_{out} \\ge V_{b1} - V_{THN}$ |\n\nAllowed output window: $V_{b1}-V_{THN} \\;\\le\\; V_{out} \\;\\le\\; V_{b2}+|V_{THP}|$. Note also that the input source must carry the DC bias current I_D, since it connects directly to M₂'s source.\n\n# Small-Signal Gain\n\nWith V_b1, V_b2 at AC ground, M₁ reduces to just **r_o1** from the output to ground. For M₂: $v_{gs2} = -v_{in}$, and (if the body is grounded) $v_{bs2} = -v_{in}$.\n\nKCL at the output node:\n\n$$-\\frac{v_{out}}{r_{o1}} = g_{m2}v_{gs2} + g_{mb2}v_{bs2} + \\frac{v_{out}-v_{in}}{r_{o2}}$$\n\nSolving:\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+\\frac{1}{r_{o2}}\\right)\\big(r_{o1}\\,\\|\\,r_{o2}\\big) \\;\\approx\\; g_{m2}\\,(r_{o1}\\,\\|\\,r_{o2})}$$\n\n- The gain is **positive (non-inverting)** — the hallmark of a CG stage.\n- Its magnitude is comparable to a common-source stage with the same active load.\n- Body effect *helps* here: g_mb adds to the effective transconductance.\n- Channel-length modulation must be retained (λ ≠ 0); with ideal current sources the gain would be unbounded.\n\n# Port Impedances\n\n**Input resistance** (looking into the source of M₂, with the drain loaded by r_o1):\n\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{r_{o1}+r_{o2}}{1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}} \\;\\approx\\; \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}\\left(1+\\frac{r_{o1}}{r_{o2}}\\right)$$\n\nImportant subtlety: because the load is a **high** impedance (r_o1), R_in is *not* simply 1/g_m — if r_o1 ≈ r_o2, then R_in ≈ **2/g_m2**.\n\n**Output resistance** (input driven by an ideal source):\n\n$$R_{out} = r_{o1}\\,\\|\\,r_{o2}$$\n\nIf the signal source has finite resistance R_S, the overall gain becomes\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{\\big[(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}+1\\big]\\,r_{o1}}{r_{o1}+r_{o2}+\\big[(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}+1\\big]R_S}$$\n\n# Key Takeaways\n\n1. **Function:** CG voltage amplifier with active load; gain ≈ g_m2(r_o1‖r_o2), non-inverting.\n2. **Low input impedance** — well-suited to low-impedance sources (e.g., 50 Ω front ends, LNAs) or as the cascode device receiving a current signal.\n3. **Good high-frequency behavior:** the gate is grounded, so there is **no Miller multiplication** of C_GD2; the input node sees only C_GS2 + C_SB2.\n4. **Biasing sensitivity:** two stacked current sources make the DC output level sensitive to mismatch between I_D1 and I_D2 — practical designs set it with feedback or replica biasing.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "72938f090eef421a95e57187cef413db1b26a688a6cb80c675b1133ad1cc8ce3"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-gate NMOS with PMOS current-source load, places the input at M₂’s source, identifies the bias voltages, and gives the non-inverting gain and low input resistance. The detailed expressions are consistent with the stated topology; minor extra claims do not alter the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "bef1a8379b057bee5021488ff4aa65884dec1cb905b95a6d1d764f0128473407",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1336,
        "output_tokens": 11403,
        "total_tokens": 12739,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9772,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1336,
        "output_tokens": 11403,
        "total_tokens": 12739,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9772,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 23,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **common-gate (CG) amplifier with a current-source (active) load** — a classic single-stage topology (it appears as an example in Razavi's *Design of Analog CMOS ICs*).\n\n| Device | Type | Terminals | Function |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| **M₂** | NMOS | Gate = V_b1 (AC ground), Source = V_in, Drain = V_out | Common-gate input device |\n| **M₁** | PMOS | Source = V_DD, Gate = V_b2, Drain = V_out | Current-source load (presents r_O1 to the output) |\n\nSince the input enters the *source* and the gate is held at a DC bias, the stage is **non-inverting**.\n\n# DC Operating Point\n\n- **Bias current is set by M₁:**\n\n$$I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_{DD}-V_{b2}-|V_{THP}|)^2$$\n\n- M₂ must conduct this same current, so the **DC level of V_in** must satisfy\n$$V_{b1}-V_{in} = V_{GS2} = V_{THN}+\\sqrt{\\frac{2I_D}{\\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)_2}}$$\n(Note: the input source carries the full bias current I_D unless AC-coupled.)\n\n- **Saturation conditions → output swing:**\n  - M₁ in saturation: $V_{out} \\le V_{b2} + |V_{THP}|$\n  - M₂ in saturation: $V_{out} \\ge V_{b1} - V_{THN}$\n\n# Small-Signal Gain\n\nWith $v_{gs2}=v_{bs2}=-v_{in}$ (body effect included), KCL at the output node:\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{r_{O1}} + \\frac{v_{out}-v_{in}}{r_{O2}} - (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})v_{in}=0$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+\\frac{1}{r_{O2}}\\right)(r_{O1}\\parallel r_{O2}) = \\frac{\\big[1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{O2}\\big]\\,r_{O1}}{r_{O1}+r_{O2}}}$$\n\n$$A_v \\approx +(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})(r_{O1}\\parallel r_{O2})$$\n\nKey points:\n- **Positive gain**, comparable in magnitude to a common-source stage with the same load.\n- **Body effect *helps* here** (g_mb adds to g_m), unlike in a source follower.\n\n# Port Impedances\n\n**Output resistance** (ideal input source):\n$$R_{out} = r_{O1}\\parallel r_{O2}$$\n\n**Input resistance** (looking into the source of M₂):\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{r_{O1}+r_{O2}}{1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{O2}} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\\left(1+\\frac{r_{O1}}{r_{O2}}\\right)$$\n\n⚠️ Important insight: because the load is a *high* impedance (r_O1), the input resistance is **larger than the naive 1/(g_m+g_mb)** — e.g., ≈ 2/(g_m+g_mb) if r_O1 = r_O2. The CG stage \"reflects\" the load impedance to the input, divided by (g_m+g_mb)r_O2.\n\n**With a finite source resistance R_S**, the gain degrades to:\n$$A_v = \\frac{\\big[1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{O2}\\big]r_{O1}}{r_{O1}+r_{O2}+\\big[1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{O2}\\big]R_S}$$\n\n# Other Observations\n\n- **No Miller effect:** C_GS2 sees the low-impedance input node and C_GD2 is grounded at the gate side → the stage has excellent high-frequency behavior (poles simply at input node: R_in·(C_GS2+C_SB2), and output node: R_out·(C_DG2+C_DB2+C_GD1+C_DB1)).\n- **Typical uses:** current buffer, cascoding, high-speed amplification, and situations requiring a low/controlled input impedance.\n- **Trade-off:** low input impedance loads the driving source, and the DC bias current must flow through the input path.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0bbc8fade6828629fd3bea5de204acfa56393c3da65dcce9b8726aff7ac2475a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-gate NMOS with PMOS current-source load, places Vin at M2’s source, identifies the bias voltages, and gives non-inverting gain with the equivalent gm·(ro1 || ro2) expression and low input resistance. Additional detail does not contradict the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "bef1a8379b057bee5021488ff4aa65884dec1cb905b95a6d1d764f0128473407",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1336,
        "output_tokens": 11315,
        "total_tokens": 12651,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9746,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1336,
        "output_tokens": 11315,
        "total_tokens": 12651,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9746,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 23,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **common-gate (CG) amplifier with a current-source load**:\n\n| Device | Type | Terminals | Role |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| $M_2$ | NMOS | Gate at $V_{b1}$ (AC ground), **input at source**, output at drain | Common-gate amplifying device |\n| $M_1$ | PMOS | Source at $V_{DD}$, gate at fixed $V_{b2}$ | Current-source load (sets $I_D$, presents $r_{O1}$) |\n\nThe signal enters the **source** of $M_2$ while its gate is held at a constant bias — the defining feature of a common-gate stage.\n\n# DC Biasing\n\n- $M_1$ sets the bias current:\n$$I_D = \\tfrac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_{DD}-V_{b2}-|V_{THP}|)^2$$\n- $V_{b1}$ (together with the input DC level) sets $V_{GS2} = V_{b1}-V_{IN}$.\n- **Saturation conditions** (allowed output range):\n$$\\underbrace{V_{b1}-V_{TH2}}_{M_2 \\text{ sat.}} \\;\\le\\; V_{out} \\;\\le\\; \\underbrace{V_{b2}+|V_{TH1}|}_{M_1 \\text{ sat.}}$$\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis\n\nWith $v_{gs2}=-v_{in}$ and $v_{bs2}=-v_{in}$, KCL at the output node ($V_{DD}$ = AC ground):\n\n$$-(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})v_{in} + \\frac{v_{out}-v_{in}}{r_{O2}} = -\\frac{v_{out}}{r_{O1}}$$\n\n**Voltage gain:**\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\Big[(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})+\\frac{1}{r_{O2}}\\Big](r_{O1}\\parallel r_{O2}) \\;\\approx\\; +\\,g_{m2}\\,(r_{O1}\\parallel r_{O2})}$$\n\nThe gain is **positive (non-inverting)** and comparable in magnitude to a common-source stage. Note that the body effect *helps* here, boosting the effective transconductance to $g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$.\n\n**Input resistance** (looking into the source of $M_2$, with $r_{O1}$ as drain load):\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{r_{O1}+r_{O2}}{1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{O2}} \\;\\approx\\; \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\\left(1+\\frac{r_{O1}}{r_{O2}}\\right)$$\n\nThis is **low** (on the order of $1/g_m$), but notice it is *raised* above $1/g_m$ because the load is a high-impedance current source rather than a small $R_D$.\n\n**Output resistance** (ideal input source, $R_S = 0$):\n$$R_{out} = r_{O1}\\parallel r_{O2}$$\n\n(If the input source has resistance $R_S$, then $R_{out} = r_{O1}\\parallel\\big[r_{O2}+R_S+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{O2}R_S\\big]$, and the gain drops due to division between $R_S$ and $R_{in}$.)\n\n# Key Properties of This Stage\n\n- **Non-inverting gain** $\\approx g_{m2}(r_{O1}\\parallel r_{O2})$ — limited by channel-length modulation of both devices, since the load is a realistic (finite-$r_O$) current source.\n- **Low input impedance** — suitable as a current buffer, for impedance matching (e.g., to a 50 Ω line), or as the cascode device in a cascode amplifier.\n- **Excellent high-frequency behavior** — the gate is grounded, so $C_{GD2}$ sees no Miller multiplication, unlike a common-source stage.\n- $V_{b2}$ controls the bias current; $V_{b1}$ positions the DC operating point and output swing window $[\\,V_{b1}-V_{TH2},\\; V_{b2}+|V_{TH1}|\\,]$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6fa8f2ab3978873433632cc02a8aadbbece92c770a439eb71dc9d00a92dc0d26"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-gate NMOS with PMOS current-source load, places the input at M2’s source, identifies both bias voltages, and gives the non-inverting gain and low input resistance. The gain expression matches the golden solution; additional details do not contradict the essential analysis.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "bef1a8379b057bee5021488ff4aa65884dec1cb905b95a6d1d764f0128473407",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1336,
        "output_tokens": 9161,
        "total_tokens": 10497,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7694,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1336,
        "output_tokens": 9161,
        "total_tokens": 10497,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7694,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-024-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 24,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-024-many-poles-have/figure-18.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Answer: **Two poles**\n\n### Reasoning\n\n**Step 1 – Identify the AC grounds.**\nThe supply rail and the bias voltage at the gate of $M_2$ are AC grounds. Therefore:\n\n- $C_{GD2}$, $C_{DB2}$, and $C_{DB}$ all connect the **output node to AC ground**, so they simply add in parallel:\n$$C_{out} = C_{DB} + C_{GD2} + C_{DB2}$$\n\n**Step 2 – Reduce the circuit.**\nAfter this simplification, the circuit has only **two independent nodes**:\n\n| Node | Capacitances |\n|------|-------------|\n| **X** (gate of $M_1$) | $C_{GS}$ to ground |\n| **Y** (output) | $C_{out}$ to ground |\n| X ↔ Y | $C_{GD}$ (floating) |\n\n**Step 3 – Count the independent states.**\nAlthough three equivalent capacitors remain ($C_{GS}$, $C_{GD}$, $C_{out}$), they form a **closed loop** (ground → X → Y → ground). KVL imposes one constraint:\n$$V_{C_{GS}} = V_{C_{GD}} + V_{C_{out}}$$\n\nso only **two** capacitor voltages are independent. The exact transfer function confirms this — the denominator is second order:\n\n$$\\frac{V_{out}}{V_{in}}(s) = \\frac{(C_{GD}s - g_m)R_L}{R_S R_L \\xi\\, s^2 + \\big[R_S(1+g_m R_L)C_{GD} + R_S C_{GS} + R_L(C_{GD}+C_{out})\\big]s + 1}$$\n\nwhere $\\xi = C_{GS}C_{GD} + C_{GS}C_{out} + C_{GD}C_{out}$.\n\n### Conclusion\nThe circuit has **2 poles** — roughly, one associated with the input node (where $C_{GD}$ is Miller-multiplied and adds to $C_{GS}$, driven by $R_S$) and one associated with the output node — despite containing five physical capacitors.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "260f74828c15525aa2b05810f1e05b6520546d8841a18589a2f641a74f7d4041"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the two independent nodes—the M1 gate and output—and assigns the capacitors to them, including CGD as the coupling capacitor. The resulting two-pole conclusion is correct.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a186c7d78b22ed309b07c9b6c97e61997ddf23f0ee23de6faa3536cb2c682d8c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1906,
        "output_tokens": 2809,
        "total_tokens": 4715,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2089,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1906,
        "output_tokens": 2809,
        "total_tokens": 4715,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2089,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-024-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 24,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-024-many-poles-have/figure-18.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Answer: **Two poles**\n\n## Reasoning\n\n**Step 1 – Simplify the capacitances.** \nSince the gate of $M_2$ and the supply rail are both AC grounds, the capacitors $C_{GD2}$ and $C_{DB2}$ simply appear in parallel with $C_{DB}$ at the output. The circuit therefore reduces to:\n\n- **Node X** (gate of $M_1$): $C_{GS}$ to ground, driven by $V_{in}$ through $R_S$\n- **Output node**: $C_{out} = C_{DB} + C_{GD2} + C_{DB2}$ to ground\n- $C_{GD}$ coupling the two nodes together\n\n**Step 2 – Count independent nodes/states.** \nAlthough the circuit contains **five** capacitors, only **two** circuit nodes carry time-varying voltages (node X and $V_{out}$). Equivalently, the three effective capacitors ($C_{GS}$, $C_{GD}$, $C_{out}$) form a closed loop, so only two capacitor voltages are independent → the denominator of the transfer function is **second order**.\n\n**Step 3 – Verify from the transfer function.** \nWriting KCL at the two nodes gives (Razavi, CS stage with $R_S$):\n\n$$\n\\frac{V_{out}}{V_{in}}(s)=\\frac{(C_{GD}s-g_m)R_D}{R_S R_D\\,\\xi\\, s^{2}+\\big[R_S(1+g_mR_D)C_{GD}+R_SC_{GS}+R_D(C_{GD}+C_{out})\\big]s+1}\n$$\n\nwhere $\\xi = C_{GS}C_{GD}+C_{GS}C_{out}+C_{GD}C_{out}$.\n\nThe denominator is quadratic in $s$ → **the circuit has exactly two poles** (one associated with the input node, one with the output node), plus one zero at $s_z = +g_m/C_{GD}$ due to the feedforward path through $C_{GD}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0700a438cba9e0c21226694fe26e62d6202393e36f00eb72ed6baa1bf1d1a1a7"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the two dynamic nodes, assigns the capacitances to the right nodes, and shows a second-order denominator. The optional transfer-function details are also consistent.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a186c7d78b22ed309b07c9b6c97e61997ddf23f0ee23de6faa3536cb2c682d8c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1906,
        "output_tokens": 1881,
        "total_tokens": 3787,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1191,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1906,
        "output_tokens": 1881,
        "total_tokens": 3787,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1191,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-024-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 24,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-024-many-poles-have/figure-18.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Counting the Poles\n\n**Answer: Two poles.**\n\n## Reasoning\n\nAlthough the circuit contains **five capacitors** (C_GS, C_GD, C_GD2, C_DB, C_DB2), the number of poles equals the number of *independent* capacitor voltages (state variables), not the number of capacitors.\n\n**Step 1 — Identify the signal nodes.** Since M₂'s gate is tied to a fixed bias (AC ground) and the supplies are AC grounds, only two nodes carry signal:\n- **Node A:** gate of M₁\n- **Node B (output):** drains of M₁ and M₂\n\n**Step 2 — Combine parallel capacitors.** All capacitors from the output node to AC ground merge into one:\n\n$$C_{out} = C_{GD2} + C_{DB2} + C_{DB}$$\n\nThis leaves three effective capacitors:\n- $C_{GS}$: node A → ground  \n- $C_{GD}$: node A → node B  \n- $C_{out}$: node B → ground  \n\n**Step 3 — Check for capacitor loops.** These three capacitors form a closed loop (A → ground → B → A), so their voltages are not all independent:\n\n$$\\text{poles} = 3 \\text{ capacitors} - 1 \\text{ loop} = \\boxed{2}$$\n\n## Result\n\nThe transfer function is second order:\n\n$$\\frac{V_{out}}{V_{in}}(s) = \\frac{(C_{GD}\\,s - g_m)R_{out}}{R_S R_{out}\\,\\xi\\, s^2 + \\left[R_S(1+g_m R_{out})C_{GD} + R_S C_{GS} + R_{out}(C_{GD}+C_{out})\\right]s + 1}$$\n\nwhere $\\xi = C_{GS}C_{GD} + C_{GS}C_{out} + C_{GD}C_{out}$.\n\nSo the circuit exhibits **two poles** (typically one dominant pole at the input node, magnified by the Miller effect on C_GD, and one at the output), plus one zero at $s_z = +g_m/C_{GD}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "879fdee2a9de913f1cd59c9f6616503fc21430ec086bc20cd7c101cce768e7df"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the gate and output as the two signal nodes, assigns the capacitors to the right nodes, and explains why the three effective capacitors yield two independent capacitor voltages. The resulting two-pole conclusion is correct.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a186c7d78b22ed309b07c9b6c97e61997ddf23f0ee23de6faa3536cb2c682d8c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1906,
        "output_tokens": 2053,
        "total_tokens": 3959,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1348,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1906,
        "output_tokens": 2053,
        "total_tokens": 3959,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1348,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 25,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel/figure-19.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Analysis: CS Stage with MOS (Triode) Degeneration\n\n## 1. Topology Identification\n\nAt first glance this looks like a cascode (two stacked NMOS devices), but **it is not** — in a cascode, M₂'s gate would be tied to a DC bias. Here **both gates are driven by V_in**. The circuit is actually a **common-source amplifier (M₂) whose source is degenerated by M₁**, with M₁ acting as a voltage-controlled resistor.\n\n## 2. Operating Regions\n\nLet node **X** = source of M₂ = drain of M₁. Note:\n\n$$V_{GS1} = V_{in}, \\qquad V_{GS2} = V_{in} - V_X, \\qquad V_{DS1} = V_X$$\n\n**Claim: M₁ must operate in the triode region.**\n\nFor M₂ to conduct:\n$$V_{GS2} > V_{TH2} \\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_X < V_{in} - V_{TH2}$$\n\nBut M₁ saturation would require:\n$$V_{DS1} = V_X \\ge V_{in} - V_{TH1}$$\n\nThese are contradictory (with $V_{TH2} \\gtrsim V_{TH1}$ due to M₂'s body effect, the contradiction is even stronger). Therefore:\n\n- **M₁: triode region** → behaves as a resistor\n$$R_{on1} \\approx \\frac{1}{\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_1 (V_{in} - V_{TH1})}$$\n- **M₂: saturation**, provided $V_{out} \\ge V_{in} - V_{TH2}$ (this sets the upper limit of the input/output swing).\n\n## 3. Bias (Large-Signal) Equations\n\nA single current $I_D$ flows through $R_D$, M₂, and M₁:\n\n$$I_D = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_2 (V_{in} - V_X - V_{TH2})^2 = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\right)_1\\left[(V_{in}-V_{TH1})V_X - \\tfrac{V_X^2}{2}\\right]$$\n\n$$V_{out} = V_{DD} - I_D R_D$$\n\n## 4. Small-Signal Gain\n\nReplacing M₁ with $R_{on1}$, this is a standard **degenerated CS stage** ($\\lambda = 0$):\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = -\\frac{g_{m2}R_D}{1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})R_{on1}} \\;\\approx\\; -\\frac{R_D}{\\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}} + R_{on1}}}$$\n\n(the $g_{mb2}$ term accounts for M₂'s body effect, since its source is not at ground; the simplified form neglects it).\n\n**Port impedances:**\n- $R_{in} = \\infty$ (gate input)\n- $R_{out} = R_D$ for $\\lambda = 0$; with channel-length modulation: $R_{out} = R_D \\,\\|\\, \\left[r_{o2}\\big(1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})R_{on1}\\big) + R_{on1}\\right]$\n\n## 5. Key Observations\n\n**Composite-transistor view:** Since both gates are tied together, if $W_1 = W_2 = W$ (and body effect is ignored), the stack is exactly equivalent to a **single NMOS of length $L_1 + L_2$** — M₁ is the \"source end\" of the channel, M₂ the pinched-off \"drain end.\" A full small-signal analysis (including M₁'s triode transconductance) confirms:\n\n$$A_v = -\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L_1+L_2}(V_{in}-V_{TH})\\,R_D = -g_{m,eq}R_D$$\n\n**Design implications:**\n- The degeneration **reduces gain but improves linearity** and desensitizes the gain to $g_{m2}$ variations — and uses a transistor instead of a bulky physical resistor.\n- However, $R_{on1}$ itself **depends on $V_{in}$**, so the linearization is imperfect (a residual source of nonlinearity).\n- Swing limits: circuit is off for $V_{in} < V_{TH1}$ ($V_{out}=V_{DD}$); for large $V_{in}$, $V_{out}$ drops until M₂ also enters triode ($V_{out} < V_{in}-V_{TH2}$), ending amplifier operation.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f632d66b690d1b5be22fe89f17cb6489ffe192b872f5e9fc445d05345fd0b113"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the shared-gate stack, places M1 in triode and M2 in saturation, and clearly gives the effective-channel result L_eff ≈ L1 + L2, meeting the golden full-credit criterion. The extra gain analysis is not needed for that essential conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f4c42a319616e7d942081a3389417d0f1c64822932dcec21eebd003d9f6660ad",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1529,
        "output_tokens": 9802,
        "total_tokens": 11331,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8238,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1529,
        "output_tokens": 9802,
        "total_tokens": 11331,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8238,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 25,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel/figure-19.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **common‑source amplifier built from two stacked NMOS devices whose gates are tied together** to $V_{in}$, with a resistive drain load $R_D$. It *looks* like a cascode, but it is not one: in a true cascode, M₂'s gate sits at a fixed bias (AC ground). With both gates driven by the input, the M₁–M₂ pair behaves as a single **composite (\"self‑cascode\" / split‑length) transistor**.\n\nSignal path: $V_{in}\\uparrow \\Rightarrow$ both devices conduct harder $\\Rightarrow I_D\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_{out}=V_{DD}-I_D R_D \\downarrow$. → **Inverting amplifier.**\n\n# Bias / Regions of Operation (the key subtlety)\n\nLet $X$ = drain of M₁ = source of M₂. For current to flow, M₂ must be on:\n\n$$V_{GS2}=V_{in}-V_X>V_{TH2}\\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_X<V_{in}-V_{TH2}$$\n\nBut M₁ saturation would require $V_X\\ge V_{in}-V_{TH1}$. Since $V_{TH2}\\ge V_{TH1}$ (body effect raises $V_{TH2}$), these conditions are **incompatible**. Therefore:\n\n- **M₁ operates in the triode region** (it acts as the \"source end\" of a long channel),\n- **M₂ operates in saturation**, provided $V_{out}\\ge V_{in}-V_{TH2}$ (this also sets the lowest allowed output swing).\n\n# Large‑Signal Behavior: Composite Transistor\n\nWith square‑law devices ($\\lambda=\\gamma=0$), equating the triode current of M₁ and saturation current of M₂ gives\n\n$$I_D=\\tfrac12\\,\\mu_n C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_{eq}(V_{in}-V_{TH})^2,\\qquad \n\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_{eq}^{-1}=\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_1^{-1}+\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_2^{-1}$$\n\ni.e., for equal widths the pair is exactly **one NMOS of length $L_1+L_2$**. Then $V_{out}=V_{DD}-R_D I_D$, and the internal node sits at $V_X=(V_{in}-V_{TH})\\big(1-\\sqrt{\\beta_1/(\\beta_1+\\beta_2)}\\big)$.\n\n# Small‑Signal Gain\n\nUsing $i_{D1}=i_{D2}=-v_{out}/R_D$ with $i_{D1}=g_{m1}v_{in}+v_x/r_{o1}$ and $i_{D2}=g_{m2}(v_{in}-v_x)+(v_{out}-v_x)/r_{o2}$, solving the two KCL equations yields the general result (body effect neglected):\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;A_v=-\\,\\frac{R_D\\big[g_{m1}r_{o1}+g_{m2}r_{o2}+g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\big]}{R_D+r_{o1}+r_{o2}+g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}}\\;}$$\n\nThis is neatly interpreted as $A_v=-G_m\\,(R_D\\parallel R_{up})$ with\n\n$$R_{up}=r_{o2}+(1+g_{m2}r_{o2})\\,r_{o1},\\qquad \nG_m=\\underbrace{\\frac{g_{m2}r_{o2}}{R_{up}}}_{\\text{M}_2\\text{ as degenerated CS}}+\\underbrace{\\frac{g_{m1}r_{o1}(1+g_{m2}r_{o2})}{R_{up}}}_{\\text{M}_1\\text{ CS }\\to\\text{ M}_2\\text{ CG (cascode path)}}$$\n\n**M₂ simultaneously acts as a common‑source and a common‑gate device**, and the two signal paths add in phase.\n\n**Limiting cases:**\n- Ideal devices ($r_o\\to\\infty$): $A_v\\to -g_{m1}R_D$ (M₁ sets the current; M₂ merely passes it).\n- Physically consistent case (M₁ triode, $\\lambda_2=0$): $A_v=-g_{m2}R_D\\,\\dfrac{1+g_{m1}r_{ds1}}{1+g_{m2}r_{ds1}}$, which evaluates *exactly* to\n$$A_v=-g_{m,eq}R_D,\\qquad g_{m,eq}=\\mu_nC_{ox}\\Big(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\Big)_{eq}(V_{in}-V_{TH})=\\sqrt{2\\mu_nC_{ox}\\big(\\tfrac{W}{L}\\big)_{eq}I_D}$$\nconfirming the composite‑transistor picture.\n\n# Port Impedances\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx\\infty \\text{ (gate input)},\\qquad \nR_{out}=R_D\\,\\big\\|\\,\\big[r_{o2}+(1+g_{m2}r_{o2})r_{ds1}\\big]\\approx R_D$$\n\n(For $\\gamma\\neq0$, replace $g_{m2}\\to g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$ in the stack‑resistance/CG terms.)\n\n# Design Remarks\n\n- **Pros:** The stack behaves like a longer‑channel device → smaller effective $\\lambda$, boosted drain resistance $r_{o2}(1+g_{m2}r_{ds1})$ \"for free,\" with the *same* minimum output voltage as a single long device ($V_{out}\\gtrsim V_{in}-V_{TH}$). This \"split‑length\" trick is popular in low‑voltage design.\n- **Cons vs. a true cascode:** Because M₂'s gate follows the input, $C_{GD2}$ bridges input and output and is **Miller‑multiplied** by $(1+|A_v|)$ — the cascode's main speed advantage is lost. Gain is only $\\approx -g_{m,eq}R_D$, lower than a cascode of the same stack.\n- Converting it into a real cascode simply requires tying M₂'s gate to a fixed bias $V_b$ instead of $V_{in}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "698ae6ce58636d1b6b62d4a4eabd3fe0c1c0e2b353091368ab65933c3a38cc19"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-gate-driven series NMOS pair, with M1 in triode and M2 saturated, and derives the longer effective channel (equal widths: L_eff ≈ L1 + L2). Its added small-signal analysis retains the lower device’s triode resistance and does not overturn the essential conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f4c42a319616e7d942081a3389417d0f1c64822932dcec21eebd003d9f6660ad",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1529,
        "output_tokens": 25316,
        "total_tokens": 26845,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 23117,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1529,
        "output_tokens": 25316,
        "total_tokens": 26845,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 23117,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 25,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel/figure-19.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Analysis: A \"Cascode‑Looking\" Stage That Isn't a Cascode\n\n## 1. Topology Recognition\n\nAt first glance this looks like a cascode (M1 common-source, M2 stacked on top). **But both gates are tied to $V_{in}$** — a true cascode requires M2's gate at a *fixed DC bias*. With common gates, M1 and M2 are simply two series NMOS devices sharing one gate: a **composite transistor**.\n\n*Assumptions:* square-law devices, equal $V_{TH}$, body effect and $\\lambda$ neglected unless noted, equal widths $W$, lengths $L_1, L_2$.\n\n## 2. Operating Regions — the Key Insight\n\nLet $V_X$ = drain of M1 / source of M2. For M2 to conduct:\n\n$$V_{GS2} = V_{in} - V_X > V_{TH} \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; V_X < V_{in} - V_{TH}$$\n\nBut $V_{DS1} = V_X$ and $V_{GS1}-V_{TH} = V_{in}-V_{TH}$, so:\n\n$$V_{DS1} < V_{GS1} - V_{TH} \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; \\boxed{\\text{M1 is always in triode}}$$\n\nM2 remains saturated as long as $V_{out} > V_{in} - V_{TH}$. (Assuming both saturated — a common mistake — is physically impossible here.)\n\n## 3. Equivalent Composite Device\n\nEquating M1's triode current to M2's saturation current (for $L_1=L_2=L$) gives:\n\n$$V_X = \\left(1-\\tfrac{1}{\\sqrt 2}\\right)(V_{in}-V_{TH}) \\approx 0.29\\,V_{OV}, \\qquad I_D = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L_1+L_2}(V_{in}-V_{TH})^2$$\n\n**The stack behaves exactly like one NMOS of length $L_1+L_2$** (series rule: $1/\\beta_{eq} = 1/\\beta_1 + 1/\\beta_2$). So this is just a **common-source amplifier with a \"2L\" transistor**.\n\n## 4. Transfer Characteristic\n\n| Region | Condition | $V_{out}$ |\n|---|---|---|\n| Cutoff | $V_{in}<V_{TH}$ | $V_{DD}$ |\n| **Amplifier** (M1 triode, M2 sat) | $V_{out}>V_{in}-V_{TH}$ | $V_{DD}-\\frac{1}{2}\\mu_nC_{ox}\\frac{W}{2L}(V_{in}-V_{TH})^2 R_D$ |\n| Both triode | $V_{out}<V_{in}-V_{TH}$ | small; $\\approx V_{DD}\\frac{R_{on,tot}}{R_{on,tot}+R_D}$ |\n\n## 5. Small-Signal Gain\n\nDifferentiating $I_D(V_{in})$, or via KCL at node X (where one finds $G_m = \\frac{g_{m1,\\text{tri}}+g_{m2}}{2}$):\n\n$$G_m = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{2L}(V_{in}-V_{TH}) = \\sqrt{\\mu_n C_{ox}\\tfrac{W}{L} I_D}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = -G_m\\,(R_D \\,\\|\\, R_{out}) \\approx -\\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_{in}-V_{TH})\\,R_D}$$\n\n- $R_{in} = \\infty$ (gate input);  $R_{out,\\text{stage}} \\approx R_D$\n- Looking into M2's drain: $R_{out} = r_{o2}(1+g_{m2}R_{ds1}) + R_{ds1} \\approx 2r_{o2}$ — consistent with a $2L$ device having $\\lambda/2$.\n- Node X moves *in phase*: $v_x \\approx 0.29\\,v_{in}$ (no cascode \"shielding\").\n\n## 6. Why This Is Worse Than Both a CS Stage and a Real Cascode\n\n| Metric | M1 alone (same $I_D$) | This circuit | True cascode ($V_{G2}=V_b$) |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| $G_m$ | $g_{m}$ | $g_m/\\sqrt 2$ (≈29% less) | $g_{m1}$ |\n| $R_{out}$ of stack | $r_o$ | $\\approx 2r_o$ | $\\approx g_m r_o \\cdot r_o$ |\n| Headroom | $V_{OV}$ | $\\sqrt 2\\, V_{OV}$ | $\\approx 2V_{OV}$ |\n| Miller effect | $C_{GD1}$ multiplied | $C_{GD2}$ gets **full** Miller multiplication | suppressed |\n\n**Bottom line:** Tying M2's gate to the input defeats every purpose of cascoding — M2 merely lengthens the effective channel, *reducing* transconductance and gain. To obtain a cascode, M2's gate must go to a DC bias $V_b$, yielding $|A_v| \\approx g_{m1}(R_D \\| g_{m2}r_{o2}r_{o1})$.\n\n*(This series-gate connection is used intentionally elsewhere: NAND-gate stacks, \"split-length\" composite devices for matching, and voltage-stress sharing.)*",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "73c8998e30f947f9f520d395a3deaf5b2006095d1094d1e9af1c04b88a83aa62"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-gate series NMOS stack, with M1 in triode and M2 in saturation, and concludes that it behaves approximately like a device of length L1 + L2. The additional analysis is consistent with the stated long-channel assumptions.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f4c42a319616e7d942081a3389417d0f1c64822932dcec21eebd003d9f6660ad",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1529,
        "output_tokens": 17619,
        "total_tokens": 19148,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15715,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1529,
        "output_tokens": 17619,
        "total_tokens": 19148,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15715,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 26,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate/figure-20.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Analysis: Source Follower + Common-Gate Cascade\n\n## 1. Topology Recognition\n\nThis circuit is a cascade of two stages sharing a common tail current source $I_1$:\n\n- **M₁ — source follower (common drain):** input $V_{in}$ at the gate, drain tied directly to $V_{DD}$, output taken at the source (node *P*, the shared source node).\n- **M₂ — common-gate stage:** gate held at DC bias $V_b$ (AC ground), input at its source (node *P*), output at its drain through $R_D$.\n\nSignal path: $V_{in} \\rightarrow$ gate of M₁ $\\rightarrow$ source of M₁ $\\rightarrow$ source of M₂ $\\rightarrow$ drain of M₂ $= V_{out}$.\n\n**Key insight:** This is exactly a *differential pair* driven single-endedly (one gate gets the signal, the other gets AC ground) with a single-ended output — just viewed from a different perspective.\n\n## 2. DC (Bias) Analysis\n\n- $I_1$ splits between M₁ and M₂. If the devices are matched and $V_{in,DC} = V_b$:\n\n$$I_{D1} = I_{D2} = \\frac{I_1}{2}, \\qquad V_{out,DC} = V_{DD} - \\frac{I_1}{2}R_D$$\n\n- Node *P* sits at $V_P = V_b - V_{GS2}$.\n- **Saturation condition for M₂:** $V_{out} \\ge V_b - V_{TH}$, i.e. $V_{DD} - I_{D2}R_D \\ge V_b - V_{TH}$. (M₁ is essentially always saturated since its drain is at $V_{DD}$.)\n\n## 3. Small-Signal Gain (λ = 0, no body effect)\n\n**KCL at node P** (the ideal current source forces the total small-signal current to zero):\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in} - v_P) - g_{m2}\\,v_P = 0 \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; v_P = \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}\\,v_{in}$$\n\nThis is the follower gain — M₁ is loaded by the $1/g_{m2}$ resistance looking into M₂'s source.\n\n**Common-gate stage:** $v_{out} = g_{m2} R_D\\, v_P$. Therefore:\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_{m1}\\,g_{m2}\\,R_D}{g_{m1}+g_{m2}} = \\frac{R_D}{\\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}}+\\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}}}}$$\n\nFor matched devices ($g_{m1}=g_{m2}=g_m$):\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_m R_D}{2} \\quad (\\text{positive — noninverting})$$\n\nThis matches the differential-pair view: a single-ended input/output pair gives half the full differential gain.\n\n**With body effect** (bulks grounded), the result generalizes to:\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_{m1}(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})R_D}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}$$\n\n## 4. Port Impedances\n\n| Quantity | Value |\n|---|---|\n| Input resistance | $R_{in} = \\infty$ (gate of M₁) |\n| Resistance at node *P* | $\\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}} \\parallel \\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}}$ (low) |\n| Output resistance | $R_{out} \\approx R_D$ (with finite $r_o$, M₂ looks like a degenerated cascode, so its drain resistance is large and $R_D$ dominates) |\n\n## 5. Large-Signal Behavior\n\nActing as a differential pair, the circuit steers $I_1$ between M₁ and M₂:\n\n- $V_{in} \\gg V_b$: all current flows in M₁, M₂ off → $V_{out} = V_{DD}$\n- $V_{in} \\ll V_b$: all current flows in M₂ → $V_{out} = V_{DD} - I_1 R_D$\n\nSo the output swings between $V_{DD}-I_1R_D$ and $V_{DD}$, increasing monotonically with $V_{in}$.\n\n## 6. Why Use This Topology?\n\n- **High input impedance** (unlike a bare common-gate stage, whose input resistance is only $\\sim 1/g_m$).\n- **Excellent high-frequency behavior:** no Miller multiplication anywhere — M₁'s $C_{GD}$ goes to AC ground ($V_{DD}$), M₂'s gate is at AC ground, and node *P* is low-impedance, pushing its pole to high frequency.\n- **Trade-off:** the gain is halved ($g_mR_D/2$ instead of $g_mR_D$ for a common-source stage), since half the signal current is \"lost\" to the follower/CG voltage division.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "3b57422e7b553f401f7f3ccdd01756ac99a946558dc0a88003ba5346a0356606"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-follower/common-gate topology (also a source-coupled differential pair) and gives the correct non-inverting gain. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5f76b34ca8287a0570c6f002e2eadb7a24e8054bf59e90b39e7d140a788b3c2c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2475,
        "output_tokens": 6075,
        "total_tokens": 8550,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4354,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2475,
        "output_tokens": 6075,
        "total_tokens": 8550,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4354,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 26,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate/figure-20.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **differential pair (M₁, M₂) driven single-endedly**, which is best understood as a cascade of:\n\n- **M₁: source follower (common-drain)** — gate driven by $V_{in}$, drain tied to $V_{DD}$\n- **M₂: common-gate stage** — gate held at AC ground by bias $V_b$, output taken at the drain through $R_D$\n\nThe two sources share node *P*, biased by the tail current source $I_1$.\n\n**Signal path:** $V_{in}$ → gate of M₁ → source of M₁ (node *P*) → source of M₂ → drain of M₂ → $V_{out}$\n\n# DC Operating Point\n\nWith $V_{in}$ and $V_b$ at comparable levels, the tail current splits equally:\n\n$$I_{D1} = I_{D2} = \\frac{I_1}{2}, \\qquad V_{out,DC} = V_{DD} - R_D\\frac{I_1}{2}, \\qquad V_P = V_b - V_{GS2}$$\n\n# Small-Signal Gain (neglecting $\\lambda$, body effect)\n\n**Step 1 — Follower stage:** The load seen at node *P* is the resistance looking into M₂'s source, $1/g_{m2}$ (ideal $I_1$ → open). \n\n$$A_{v1} = \\frac{1/g_{m2}}{1/g_{m2} + 1/g_{m1}} = \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}$$\n\n**Step 2 — Common-gate stage:**\n\n$$A_{v2} = g_{m2}R_D$$\n\n**Total gain:**\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{R_D}{\\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}} + \\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}}} \\;\\;\\xrightarrow{\\;g_{m1}=g_{m2}=g_m\\;}\\;\\; A_v = +\\frac{g_m R_D}{2}}$$\n\nThe gain is **positive (non-inverting)**: $V_{in}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_P\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_{GS2}\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow I_{D2}\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow V_{out}\\!\\uparrow$. This matches the differential-pair result $g_mR_D/2$ for single-ended input/output.\n\n**With body effect included:**\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_{m1}(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})R_D}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}$$\n\n# Port Impedances\n\n| Port | Value |\n|------|-------|\n| Input | $R_{in} \\approx \\infty$ (MOS gate) |\n| Output | $R_{out} \\approx R_D \\,\\|\\, \\big[r_{o2} + R_P + g_{m2}r_{o2}R_P\\big] \\approx R_D$, where $R_P = \\tfrac{1}{g_{m1}}\\|r_{o1}$ |\n\n# Large-Signal Behavior\n\n- $V_{in} \\gg V_b$: M₂ turns **off**, all of $I_1$ flows in M₁ → $V_{out} = V_{DD}$ (max)\n- $V_{in} \\ll V_b$: M₁ turns **off**, all of $I_1$ flows in M₂ → $V_{out} = V_{DD} - I_1R_D$ (min)\n- **Saturation condition for M₂:** $V_{out} \\ge V_b - V_{TH}$; M₁ is always saturated when on (drain at $V_{DD}$)\n\n# Key Properties of This Topology\n\n1. **Gain penalty:** only half that of a common-source stage ($g_mR_D/2$ vs. $g_mR_D$).\n2. **Excellent bandwidth — no Miller effect:** M₁'s $C_{GD}$ goes to AC ground ($V_{DD}$), and M₂ is common-gate. Node *P* is low-impedance ($\\approx 1/(g_{m1}+g_{m2})$), pushing its pole to high frequency.\n3. **Non-inverting** amplifier with near-infinite input impedance.\n4. $V_b$ sets the bias point of M₂ and (together with $V_{GS2}$) the tail-node voltage, providing inherent level shifting between input and output.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "24d616039d34b8c7b996bfe28beff0d1101a67606c8b40fdb874d8dbd34da42f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-coupled pair as M1’s source follower driving M2’s common-gate stage, with M2’s gate biased at Vb and output at its drain. The gain is correctly non-inverting; the golden solution’s full-credit rule applies.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5f76b34ca8287a0570c6f002e2eadb7a24e8054bf59e90b39e7d140a788b3c2c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2475,
        "output_tokens": 8214,
        "total_tokens": 10689,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6726,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2475,
        "output_tokens": 8214,
        "total_tokens": 10689,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6726,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 26,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate/figure-20.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **source follower (M₁, common-drain) cascaded with a common-gate stage (M₂)** — equivalently, a differential pair in which one input is driven (V_in), the other gate is held at a DC bias (V_b), M₁'s drain is tied directly to V_DD, and the single-ended output is taken at M₂'s drain through R_D. The tail current source I₁ biases both devices.\n\n**Signal path:** V_in → gate of M₁ → source of M₁ (follower action) → source of M₂ → drain of M₂ = V_out (common-gate action).\n\n# DC (Bias) Operation\n\n- I₁ splits between M₁ and M₂ depending on V_in − V_b.\n- If devices are matched and V_in = V_b: \n\n$$I_{D1} = I_{D2} = \\frac{I_1}{2}, \\qquad V_{out} = V_{DD} - \\frac{I_1 R_D}{2}$$\n\n- The common-source node P sits at $V_P = V_b - V_{GS2}$ (also $= V_{in} - V_{GS1}$ at balance).\n\n# Small-Signal Gain\n\n**Step 1 — Resistance seen at node P looking into M₂'s source** (ideal I₁ → infinite impedance):\n\n$$R_P = \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}$$\n\n**Step 2 — Source-follower gain of M₁** loaded by R_P:\n\n$$\\frac{v_P}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}$$\n\n**Step 3 — Common-gate gain of M₂:**\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{v_P} = (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\,R_D$$\n\n**Overall:**\n\n$$\\boxed{A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_{m1}\\,(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\\,R_D}$$\n\nNeglecting body effect and with matched devices ($g_{m1}=g_{m2}=g_m$):\n\n$$A_v = +\\frac{g_m R_D}{2}$$\n\nThis is exactly the result obtained by treating the circuit as a differential pair driven single-endedly — half the gain of a common-source stage, and **non-inverting** (V_out rises when V_in rises, since increasing V_in steals current from M₂).\n\n# Port Impedances\n\n- **Input impedance:** essentially infinite (MOS gate), at low frequency.\n- **Output impedance:** $R_{out} \\approx R_D$ (M₂'s drain resistance is boosted by source degeneration through 1/g_{m1}, so R_D dominates).\n\n# Large-Signal Transfer Characteristic\n\nBehaves like a differential pair's current steering:\n\n- **V_in ≫ V_b:** M₁ takes all of I₁, M₂ off → $V_{out} = V_{DD}$\n- **V_in ≪ V_b:** M₂ takes all of I₁ → $V_{out} = V_{DD} - I_1 R_D$\n- Transition occurs over roughly $|V_{in}-V_b| \\le \\sqrt{2}\\,V_{OV}$ (square-law devices), centered at V_in = V_b.\n\n**Swing/headroom limits:** V_out must stay above $V_b - V_{TH}$ to keep M₂ saturated; node P must stay high enough for I₁ to operate.\n\n# Why Use This Topology\n\n- **No Miller effect:** M₁'s drain is at AC ground (V_DD), so C_GD1 is not Miller-multiplied; M₂ is common-gate. This makes the stage attractive for **high-speed/wideband** applications.\n- Provides a **non-inverting** gain with very high input impedance, at the cost of half the gain of a simple common-source stage ($g_mR_D/2$ vs. $g_mR_D$).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "270abb0770ba0055d5f1942837c5127763f3b05ae2bf992c2400c43a26fd4b0a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-follower/common-gate topology (equivalently a source-coupled pair), gives the non-inverting gain and appropriate signal path. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5f76b34ca8287a0570c6f002e2eadb7a24e8054bf59e90b39e7d140a788b3c2c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2475,
        "output_tokens": 5066,
        "total_tokens": 7541,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3701,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2475,
        "output_tokens": 5066,
        "total_tokens": 7541,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3701,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 27,
      "question": "Explain why the output impedance of the circuit shown in the figure can be inductive.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive/figure-21.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **source follower**: M₁ is the follower device driven through a source resistance $R_S$, and M₂ is just the bias current source. The output impedance is found by looking into the **source of M₁**. The key players are $R_S$, the gate–source capacitance $C_{gs}$ of M₁, and its transconductance $g_m$ (neglect $r_O$, body effect, and $C_{GD}$, which goes to AC ground anyway).\n\n## Derivation of Z_out\n\nSet $V_{in} = 0$, apply a test voltage $V_X$ at the output, and find $I_X$.\n\n**KCL at the gate** (current from $R_S$ must flow into $C_{gs}$):\n\n$$-\\frac{V_G}{R_S} = (V_G - V_X)\\,sC_{gs} \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; V_G = V_X\\,\\frac{sR_SC_{gs}}{1 + sR_SC_{gs}}$$\n\n**KCL at the source** (test current flows through $C_{gs}$ and the $g_m$ generator):\n\n$$I_X = (V_X - V_G)(sC_{gs} + g_m)$$\n\nCombining:\n\n$$\\boxed{Z_{out} = \\frac{V_X}{I_X} = \\frac{1 + sR_SC_{gs}}{g_m + sC_{gs}}}$$\n\n## Why This Is Inductive\n\nCheck the two frequency extremes:\n\n$$Z_{out}(0) = \\frac{1}{g_m}, \\qquad Z_{out}(\\infty) = R_S$$\n\nThe zero sits at $\\omega_z = 1/(R_SC_{gs})$ and the pole at $\\omega_p = g_m/C_{gs}$. \n\n**If $R_S > 1/g_m$, then $\\omega_z < \\omega_p$**, so the magnitude of $Z_{out}$ *rises* with frequency from $1/g_m$ toward $R_S$, and the phase of $Z_{out}$ is positive (voltage leads current) in between. An impedance whose magnitude grows with frequency with positive phase is, by definition, **inductive**.\n\nIn fact, $Z_{out}$ can be modeled exactly by this passive network:\n\n- $R_1 = \\dfrac{1}{g_m}$ in series with the parallel combination of  \n- $R_2 = R_S - \\dfrac{1}{g_m}$ and $\\;L = \\dfrac{C_{gs}}{g_m}\\left(R_S - \\dfrac{1}{g_m}\\right)$\n\nwhich is physically realizable (inductive) only when $R_S > 1/g_m$.\n\n## Intuition\n\nThe source follower's low output impedance ($1/g_m$) relies on **feedback through $V_{GS}$**: when $V_{out}$ is perturbed, $V_{GS}$ changes and the transistor's drain current pushes back strongly.\n\n- **At low frequencies**, $C_{gs}$ is open, the gate is firmly held at AC ground through $R_S$, so the full perturbation appears across $V_{GS}$ → strong correction → low impedance $1/g_m$.\n- **At high frequencies**, $C_{gs}$ shorts the gate to the source, so the gate simply *follows* the output: $V_{GS} \\to 0$, the transistor stops responding, and you just see $R_S$ through the capacitor.\n\nThus the transistor's \"impedance-lowering action\" fades as frequency increases — the impedance climbs with frequency, and the correcting current lags the applied voltage. That is exactly how an inductor behaves. (Equivalently, the $g_m$ stage acts like a *gyrator*, converting the capacitive $R_S$–$C_{gs}$ network at the gate into an inductive impedance at the source.)\n\n## Practical Note\n\nThis effect is exploited deliberately to build **active inductors** (e.g., for shunt peaking), but it can also be a hazard: if the follower drives a capacitive load $C_L$, the inductive $Z_{out}$ and $C_L$ form a resonant circuit, producing **ringing or peaking** in the step response.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "06dd205153ac4e0af4939cf96be941e9c7a723052bbf9fc642e7983513a93966"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source follower, derives the output-impedance expression, and explains the transition from 1/gm at low frequency to RS at high frequency. It correctly states that the impedance rises and is inductive when RS > 1/gm.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8c59f914b88c1f25c100ef0914c7e54f6c3e86c55b273ac88a1c45724902d303",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1718,
        "output_tokens": 5072,
        "total_tokens": 6790,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3687,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1718,
        "output_tokens": 5072,
        "total_tokens": 6790,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3687,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 27,
      "question": "Explain why the output impedance of the circuit shown in the figure can be inductive.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive/figure-21.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## The circuit\n\nM1 is a **source follower** (common‑drain stage): its drain is at $V_{DD}$, the output is taken at its source, and M2 is merely a current source that biases it. The output impedance is therefore whatever we see **looking into the source of M1**, with the gate driven through the series resistance $R_S$. The key players are $R_S$ and the gate–source capacitance $C_{GS}$ of M1.\n\n## Computing $Z_{out}$\n\nSet $V_{in}=0$, apply a test voltage $V_x$ at the output, and find $I_x$ (neglect $r_O$, body effect, and other capacitances for clarity).\n\n**Gate node:** $C_{GS}$ couples the output to the gate, and $R_S$ ties the gate to AC ground:\n\n$$\\frac{V_G}{R_S} + (V_G - V_x)sC_{GS} = 0 \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; V_G = V_x\\,\\frac{sR_SC_{GS}}{1+sR_SC_{GS}}$$\n\n**Output node:** the test source supplies the current through $C_{GS}$ plus the transconductance current $g_m(V_x-V_G)$:\n\n$$I_x = (V_x - V_G)(g_m + sC_{GS})$$\n\nCombining:\n\n$$\\boxed{\\,Z_{out}(s) = \\frac{1 + sR_SC_{GS}}{g_m + sC_{GS}}\\,}$$\n\n## Why this is inductive\n\nLook at the two frequency extremes:\n\n$$Z_{out}(0) = \\frac{1}{g_m}, \\qquad Z_{out}(\\infty) = R_S$$\n\nThere is a zero at $\\omega_z = 1/(R_SC_{GS})$ and a pole at $\\omega_p = g_m/C_{GS}$. **If $R_S > 1/g_m$**, then $\\omega_z < \\omega_p$, so between them $|Z_{out}|$ *rises* with frequency and its phase is *positive* — i.e., the impedance behaves like an inductor. Indeed, $Z_{out}$ is exactly equivalent to:\n\n$$\\frac{1}{g_m} \\;\\text{in series with}\\; \\Big[\\big(R_S - \\tfrac{1}{g_m}\\big) \\parallel sL\\Big], \\qquad L = \\frac{C_{GS}}{g_m}\\Big(R_S - \\frac{1}{g_m}\\Big)$$\n\n## Physical intuition\n\n**Frequency domain (bootstrapping):** At low frequencies $C_{GS}$ is open, the gate sits at AC ground (no current flows through $R_S$), so any wiggle of $V_{out}$ appears fully across $v_{GS}$. The transistor fights it strongly → low impedance $1/g_m$. At high frequencies $C_{GS}$ shorts the gate to the source: the gate is *bootstrapped* to the output, $v_{GS}$ barely changes, and M1 loses its ability to absorb current — only $R_S$ (seen through $C_{GS}$) remains → impedance climbs to $R_S$. An impedance that grows with frequency, with positive phase, is inductive.\n\n**Time domain:** Apply a voltage step at the output. The voltage across $C_{GS}$ cannot change instantly, so the gate initially jumps *along with* the source; $v_{GS}$ is momentarily unchanged and M1's current doesn't respond. Only as $C_{GS}$ charges through $R_S$ does $v_{GS}$ recover and the transistor gradually draw its full corrective current. **The current lags the applied voltage and builds up over time — exactly what an inductor does.**\n\n## Remarks\n\n- The effect requires $R_S > 1/g_m$; for $R_S < 1/g_m$ the output impedance instead looks capacitive (falls with frequency).\n- This inductive output impedance can **resonate with a capacitive load** ($C_L$, $C_{SB}$), causing ringing or peaking in source followers driven from high source resistances.\n- Conversely, the effect is sometimes exploited deliberately: a follower with intentional gate resistance acts as an **active inductor** for bandwidth extension (shunt peaking) without using a physical coil.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "942a833ebd00b6c849ffe46abce6749f50adec811d183975c4a293b923fc5819"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source follower, derives the output-impedance expression, and explains the low- to high-frequency transition from 1/gm to RS. It correctly gives RS > 1/gm as the condition for inductive behavior; the additional remarks do not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8c59f914b88c1f25c100ef0914c7e54f6c3e86c55b273ac88a1c45724902d303",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1718,
        "output_tokens": 7640,
        "total_tokens": 9358,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6210,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1718,
        "output_tokens": 7640,
        "total_tokens": 9358,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6210,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 27,
      "question": "Explain why the output impedance of the circuit shown in the figure can be inductive.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive/figure-21.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## The Circuit\n\nM₁ is a **source follower** (M₂ is just a current‑source load), and its gate is driven through a series resistance $R_S$. The key element is the gate–source capacitance $C_{GS1}$, which couples the output node back to the gate. To find $Z_{out}$, set $V_{in}=0$, apply a test voltage $V_X$ at the output, and neglect $r_O$, body effect, and other capacitances for clarity.\n\n## Derivation\n\nWith $V_{in}$ grounded, the gate sees a divider formed by $C_{GS1}$ and $R_S$:\n\n$$V_G = V_X\\,\\frac{R_S C_{GS}s}{1+R_S C_{GS}s} \\qquad\\Rightarrow\\qquad V_{GS}= V_G - V_X = \\frac{-V_X}{1+R_S C_{GS}s}$$\n\nThe test current supplies both the $C_{GS}$ branch and the $g_m$ generator:\n\n$$I_X = \\underbrace{\\frac{sC_{GS}V_X}{1+R_SC_{GS}s}}_{\\text{through }C_{GS}} + \\underbrace{\\frac{g_m V_X}{1+R_SC_{GS}s}}_{=-g_mV_{GS}}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{Z_{out}=\\frac{V_X}{I_X}=\\frac{1+R_S C_{GS}\\,s}{g_m + C_{GS}\\,s}}$$\n\n## Why This Is Inductive\n\nExamine the two extremes:\n\n$$Z_{out}(s\\to 0)=\\frac{1}{g_m},\\qquad Z_{out}(s\\to\\infty)=R_S$$\n\nThere is a **zero at $\\omega_z = 1/(R_SC_{GS})$** and a **pole at $\\omega_p = g_m/C_{GS}$**. If\n\n$$R_S > \\frac{1}{g_m}\\quad\\Longleftrightarrow\\quad \\omega_z<\\omega_p,$$\n\nthen between these frequencies $|Z_{out}|$ **rises with frequency** and its phase is positive — exactly the behavior of an inductor.\n\nIn fact, the expression can be rewritten as an equivalent R–L network:\n\n$$Z_{out} = \\frac{1}{g_m} + \\left[\\left(R_S-\\frac{1}{g_m}\\right) \\parallel sL\\right],\\qquad L = \\frac{C_{GS}}{g_m}\\left(R_S-\\frac{1}{g_m}\\right)$$\n\nwhich is physical (positive $L$) only when $R_S > 1/g_m$.\n\n## Intuition\n\nThe low output impedance of a source follower comes from feedback through $g_m$: if $V_{out}$ moves, $V_{GS}$ changes and the drain current fights the change.\n\n- **At low frequencies**, $C_{GS}$ is open, so the gate is effectively at AC ground. Any output perturbation fully appears as $V_{GS}$ → strong correction → low impedance $1/g_m$.\n- **At high frequencies**, $C_{GS}$ shorts the gate to the source, so the gate *follows* the output and $V_{GS}$ barely changes. The $g_m$ feedback is disabled, and the output simply sees $R_S$ through the capacitor.\n\nSince the impedance climbs from a small value ($1/g_m$) to a large value ($R_S$) as frequency increases, the output port behaves inductively. (Conversely, if $R_S < 1/g_m$, the impedance falls with frequency and looks capacitive.)\n\n**Consequence:** this \"active inductance\" can be exploited for bandwidth extension (shunt peaking), but it can also resonate with a capacitive load at the output, causing ringing or instability in follower-driven buffers.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d14bcb62efc195bbc8bc6611c3d051a968b5e81c3b7f77a09d14457cfeea669b"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source follower and derives the output impedance. It explains the low-frequency 1/gm to high-frequency RS transition caused by CGS shorting gate to source, and gives the correct RS > 1/gm condition for inductive behavior.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8c59f914b88c1f25c100ef0914c7e54f6c3e86c55b273ac88a1c45724902d303",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1718,
        "output_tokens": 4526,
        "total_tokens": 6244,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3257,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1718,
        "output_tokens": 4526,
        "total_tokens": 6244,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3257,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 28,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback/figure-22.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\n- **M1 + R_D1**: a common‑source stage — input at the gate (node *X*), output at the drain (*V*out). Small‑signal gain from X to the output: $A_v = -g_{m1}R_{D1}$ (taking λ = 0).\n- **Input**: a current source $I_{in}$ driving node X ⇒ the circuit is meant to be a **transimpedance amplifier** ($V_{out}/I_{in}$, units of Ω).\n- **M2**: the feedback element. Its **gate senses $V_{out}$** (parallel/voltage sensing) and its **drain returns a current $g_{m2}v_{out}$ to node X** (parallel/current return). \n\nSo topologically this is **voltage–current (shunt–shunt) feedback** around a one‑stage inverting amplifier.\n\n# Bias and the \"Formal\" Closed-Loop Gain\n\nSince M1's gate draws no current, KCL at node X forces **all of $I_{in}$ through M2**:\n\n$$I_{D2}=I_{in}\\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_{out}=V_{GS2}=V_{TH}+\\sqrt{\\frac{2I_{in}}{\\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)_2}}$$\n\nand then $I_{D1}=(V_{DD}-V_{out})/R_{D1}$ sets $V_X = V_{GS1}$.\n\nIn small signal (λ = 0), the same KCL gives $i_{in}=g_{m2}v_{out}$, i.e.\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}}=\\frac{1}{g_{m2}},\\qquad v_X=-\\frac{i_{in}}{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}}$$\n\nThe gain apparently depends only on the feedback device — the signature of a large loop gain. **But note the red flag:** the input resistance $v_X/i_{in}=-1/(g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1})$ is *negative*.\n\n# Polarity of the Feedback — the Key Point\n\nFollow a disturbance around the loop:\n\n1. $I_{in}$ increases → extra current charges node X → $V_X\\uparrow$\n2. $I_{D1}\\uparrow$ → larger drop across $R_{D1}$ → $V_{out}\\downarrow$\n3. $V_{GS2}=V_{out}\\downarrow$ → $I_{D2}\\downarrow$\n4. M2 now pulls **less** current out of node X → $V_X$ rises **even further**\n\nThe returned signal *reinforces* the input change ⇒ **the feedback is positive.** Breaking the loop at M2's gate confirms this:\n\n$$T=+\\,g_{m1}(R_{D1}\\|r_{O1})\\cdot g_{m2}(r_{O2}\\|R_{src})\\gg 1$$\n\na regenerative loop. Adding node capacitances $C_X$, $C_{out}$ gives the characteristic equation\n\n$$s^2C_XC_{out}+s\\,\\frac{C_X}{R_{D1}}-g_{m1}g_{m2}=0$$\n\nwhose negative constant term guarantees a **right‑half‑plane pole**.\n\n# Consequence\n\nThe bias point computed above is an **unstable equilibrium**. In practice the circuit latches: e.g., $V_X$ collapses low with M2 absorbing $I_{in}$ in triode, M1 off, $V_{out}=V_{DD}$ (or the opposite rail, with X charged high and $V_{out}$ near ground). The neat result $V_{out}/I_{in}=1/g_{m2}$ is algebraically correct but **physically unrealizable** — the circuit cannot work as a linear transimpedance amplifier as drawn.\n\n# Why, and How to Fix It\n\nNegative shunt–shunt feedback requires the returned current to *subtract* from $I_{in}$. Here one inversion (M1) combined with M2's current‑sinking return yields a net non‑inverting loop. Any single added inversion fixes it:\n\n- **Add a second CS stage** (M3 + $R_{D2}$) and let M2 sense the final output → negative feedback, with $V_{out}/I_{in}\\approx +1/g_{m2}$.\n- **Replace M2 with a resistor $R_F$** from $V_{out}$ to X (classic TIA) → negative feedback,\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}}=-\\frac{R_{D1}(g_{m1}R_F-1)}{1+g_{m1}R_{D1}}\\approx -R_F$$\n- **Use a return device sensing $v_X-v_{out}$** (e.g., PMOS source at X, gate at $V_{out}$) → negative feedback, $v_{out}/i_{in}\\approx -1/g_{m2}$.\n\n**Bottom line:** the circuit *looks* like a well‑designed active‑feedback transimpedance amplifier (voltage sensed by M2's gate, current returned by its drain), but tracing the loop shows the feedback is **positive**, making it regenerative rather than an amplifier.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c634fe8cfba2ee5e405da84ce98d5b9c48245b90c8c3bf4f8b12f436e4655bae"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies that M2’s gate senses Vout, traces the positive-feedback loop, and explains the resulting instability and latching. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule; minor modeling or formula issues do not change the essential conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "966942e01d767dcc8afc948021623863d816cf7567c0ad0be0b855267f6da7e8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 37064,
        "total_tokens": 39272,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 35337,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 37064,
        "total_tokens": 39272,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 35337,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 28,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback/figure-22.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is an attempt at a **voltage–current (shunt–shunt) feedback amplifier**, i.e., a transimpedance stage:\n\n- **Forward amplifier:** $M_1$ with load $R_{D1}$ is a common‑source stage, $v_{out} = -g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,v_X$.\n- **Feedback network:** $M_2$ *senses* $V_{out}$ with its gate (shunt/voltage sensing at the output, no loading) and *returns* a current $I_{D2} = g_{m2}V_{out}$ that is pulled out of the input node $X$ (shunt/current return, subtracting from $I_{in}$).\n\nSo the intended closed-loop result would be $V_{out}/I_{in} \\approx 1/K = 1/g_{m2}$. **But first the loop polarity must be checked.**\n\n# Feedback Polarity Test\n\nFollow a disturbance around the loop:\n\n1. Assume $I_{in}$ increases → the extra current charges node $X$, so $V_X$ **rises**.\n2. $I_{D1}$ rises → $V_{out} = V_{DD} - I_{D1}R_{D1}$ **falls**.\n3. Since $V_{GS2} = V_{out}$, the current $I_{D2}$ that $M_2$ draws **out of node $X$ decreases**.\n4. With less current removed from node $X$, $V_X$ rises **even further**.\n\nThe returned signal *reinforces* the original perturbation:\n\n$$\\boxed{\\text{The feedback is positive.}}$$\n\nThis is also obvious by counting inversions: the loop contains **two** common‑source (inverting) stages — $M_1$ from $X\\!\\to\\!V_{out}$ and $M_2$ from $V_{out}\\!\\to\\!X$. An even number of inversions ⇒ positive loop.\n\n# Why the Circuit Fails\n\n**Loop gain.** The return ratio is\n\n$$T = -\\,g_{m1}(R_{D1}\\|r_{O1})\\cdot g_{m2}\\cdot r_{O2} \\;<\\; 0,\\qquad |T|\\gg 1 .$$\n\n**Negative resistance at node X.** Looking into node $X$:\n\n$$R_X = \\frac{v_X}{i_X} = -\\frac{1}{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}} \\;<\\;0 .$$\n\n**Instability.** Writing KCL at node $X$ with its capacitance $C_X$ (and $v_{out}=-g_{m1}R_{D1}v_X$):\n\n$$C_X\\frac{dv_X}{dt} = i_{in} + g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}\\,v_X \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; \\frac{V_{out}}{I_{in}}(s)=\\frac{1/g_{m2}}{\\,1-\\dfrac{sC_X}{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}}\\,}$$\n\nThe \"equilibrium\" that naive KCL gives (with $\\lambda=0$, $I_{in}=g_{m2}V_{out}$, hence $V_{out}/I_{in}=1/g_{m2}$) corresponds to a **right‑half‑plane pole** — it is an unstable operating point.\n\n**Actual behavior: latch-up.** The circuit regenerates to a state where the loop is broken. E.g., at power‑up: $V_X=0$ → $M_1$ off → $V_{out}=V_{DD}$ → $M_2$ is driven hard into deep triode, clamping $V_X \\approx I_{in}R_{on2}\\approx 0$. The circuit sits \"dead\" at $V_{out}=V_{DD}$; a large enough $I_{in}$ makes it snap regeneratively to the complementary state ($V_X$ high, $V_{out}$ low, $M_2$ off). It behaves like a latch, **not an amplifier**.\n\n# How to Fix It\n\nThe loop needs an *odd* number of inversions. Options:\n\n- **Add one more inverting stage** (a second CS stage) between $M_1$'s drain and the node sensed by $M_2$ — then the same $M_2$ connection gives negative feedback and $V_{out}/I_{in}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$.\n- **Replace $M_2$ with a feedback resistor $R_F$** from $V_{out}$ to $X$: then $I_{in}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_X\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_{out}\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow$ more current drained through $R_F$ — negative feedback, the classic TIA with $V_{out}/I_{in}\\approx -R_F$.\n- **Return the current with a source follower** ($M_2$ gate at $V_{out}$, drain at $V_{DD}$, source at $X$, with the input bias direction adjusted): then a fall in $V_{out}$ reduces the current injected into $X$, opposing the disturbance.\n\n**Bottom line:** although the circuit has the correct *topology* for voltage–current (transimpedance) feedback, the single inverting forward stage combined with the inverting return through $M_2$ makes the loop **positive**, so the apparent result $V_{out}/I_{in}=1/g_{m2}$ is unrealizable — the circuit latches instead of amplifying.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "894251c30ed41c6fa40613608c23007393140f1f36064bca5624106dec9083ac"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M2’s gate as tied to Vout, the positive-feedback loop, and its consequences: negative input resistance, instability, and latching. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "966942e01d767dcc8afc948021623863d816cf7567c0ad0be0b855267f6da7e8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 28852,
        "total_tokens": 31060,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 27044,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 28852,
        "total_tokens": 31060,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 27044,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 28,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback/figure-22.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit identification\n\n- **M1 + R_D1**: a common‑source stage — input at its gate (node *X*), output at its drain (*V*out). It is **inverting**: $v_{out} = -g_{m1}(R_{D1}\\|r_{O1})\\,v_X$.\n- **M2**: the feedback element. Its **gate senses $V_{out}$** (ideal voltage sensing — draws no current) and its **drain returns a current $g_{m2}v_{out}$ pulled out of node X** (shunt current return).\n- Input is a current, output is a voltage ⇒ this is a **voltage–current (shunt–shunt) feedback structure, i.e., a transimpedance amplifier**, with feedback factor $\\beta = g_{m2}$.\n\n# DC bias\n\nSince M1's gate carries no current, KCL at node *X* forces **all of $I_{in}$ through M2**:\n\n$$I_{D2}=I_{in}\\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_{out}=V_{GS2}=V_{TH}+\\sqrt{\\frac{2I_{in}}{\\mu_nC_{ox}(W/L)_2}}$$\n\nThen $I_{D1}=(V_{DD}-V_{out})/R_{D1}$ fixes $V_X = V_{GS1}$.\n\n# Small-signal transimpedance\n\nWith $\\lambda = 0$, the incremental input current must also flow entirely into M2's drain:\n\n$$i_{in}=g_{m2}v_{out}\\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; \\boxed{\\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}}=\\frac{1}{g_{m2}}},\\qquad \\frac{v_X}{i_{in}}=-\\frac{1}{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}}$$\n\nIncluding channel-length modulation:\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}}=\\left[g_{m2}-\\frac{1}{g_{m1}\\,r_{O2}(R_{D1}\\|r_{O1})}\\right]^{-1}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nThe gain is independent of $g_{m1}$ and $R_{D1}$ — the signature of a loop with large loop gain, where the closed-loop gain collapses to $1/\\beta$.\n\n# Feedback polarity — the critical catch\n\nTrace a disturbance around the loop:\n\n$$I_{in}\\uparrow \\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_X\\uparrow \\;\\Rightarrow\\; I_{D1}\\uparrow \\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_{out}\\downarrow \\;\\Rightarrow\\; V_{GS2}\\downarrow \\;\\Rightarrow\\; I_{D2}\\downarrow$$\n\nBut $I_{D2}$ is the current M2 *removes* from node X — so a smaller $I_{D2}$ lets $V_X$ rise **even further**. The returned signal *reinforces* the disturbance:\n\n**The feedback is positive.**\n\nEquivalently: M1 is an inverting stage, and M2 (common source loaded by the current source at X) is a *second* inverting stage — two inversions in a ring is exactly a **latch** topology. Breaking the loop at M2's gate gives a loop transmission\n\n$$T=+\\,g_{m1}g_{m2}(R_{D1}\\|r_{O1})(r_{O2}\\|R_{src})\\gg 1\\;\\;(\\text{same sign as the test signal})$$\n\n**Consequences:**\n- With a capacitance $C_X$ at node X, the pole is $s_p \\approx +\\dfrac{g_{m1}g_{m2}(R_{D1}\\|r_{O1})}{C_X} > 0$ — a right-half-plane pole. The bias point above is an **unstable equilibrium**.\n- The closed-loop port resistances come out **negative** (e.g., $R_{in}\\approx -1/(g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1})$), another signature of regeneration.\n- In practice the circuit latches: $V_X$ collapses to $\\approx I_{in}R_{on2}$ (M2 in deep triode sinking all of $I_{in}$), M1 turns **off**, and $V_{out}\\rightarrow V_{DD}$. The circuit cannot function as a linear amplifier as drawn.\n\n# How to make it a true (negative-feedback) TIA\n\nAn odd number of inversions is needed around the loop. For example:\n1. Replace M2 with a **source follower** (gate at $V_{out}$, drain at $V_{DD}$, source at X) — rising $V_{out}$ then *injects* current into X, opposing the input; or\n2. Use a **feedback resistor $R_F$** from $V_{out}$ to X (classic TIA, $v_{out}/i_{in}\\approx -R_F$); or\n3. Insert a second inverting gain stage before M2's gate.\n\n# Summary\n\n| Quantity | Result |\n|---|---|\n| Topology | Voltage-sense / current-return (shunt–shunt), transimpedance |\n| DC constraint | $I_{D2}=I_{in}$, so $V_{out}=V_{GS2}$ is pinned by $I_{in}$ |\n| Algebraic gain | $V_{out}/I_{in}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$ (independent of M1, $R_{D1}$) |\n| Loop polarity | **Positive feedback** (two inverting stages in a loop) |\n| Stability | RHP pole ⇒ regenerative; circuit latches rather than amplifies |\n\nThe elegant $1/g_{m2}$ answer describes only the (unstable) equilibrium — the key insight in analyzing this circuit is recognizing that the loop, as drawn, is positive.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "de93852b1dee09ae45141c3b35b472597e6d143ecc051aaf61028f4f7c875c1f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies that M2’s gate is tied to Vout, traces the positive-feedback loop, and states the resulting instability and latching behavior. The full-credit rule does not require exact formulas; its ancillary gain and bias claims do not overturn the essential analysis.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "966942e01d767dcc8afc948021623863d816cf7567c0ad0be0b855267f6da7e8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 43012,
        "total_tokens": 45220,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 41078,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 43012,
        "total_tokens": 45220,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 41078,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 29,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier/figure-23.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **two-stage transimpedance amplifier (TIA) with resistive shunt–shunt feedback** — a classic example of **voltage–current feedback** (it appears in Razavi's feedback chapter in this exact form):\n\n| Element | Function |\n|---|---|\n| $M_1$, $R_{D1}$ | **Common-gate** input stage (gate AC-grounded at $V_b$); input applied to its source |\n| $M_2$, $R_{D2}$ | **Common-source** gain stage, driven by node $X$ |\n| $R_F$ | Feedback network: **senses $V_{out}$** (parallel connection at output) and **returns current $i_{RF}$** to the input node (parallel mixing with $I_{in}$) |\n\nSince the input is a current and the output is a voltage, the relevant closed-loop gain is the **transresistance** $V_{out}/I_{in}$.\n\n**Polarity check (negative feedback):** $I_{in}\\uparrow \\Rightarrow v_P\\uparrow$ (source of $M_1$) $\\Rightarrow v_X\\uparrow$ (CG, non-inverting) $\\Rightarrow V_{out}\\downarrow$ (CS, inverting) $\\Rightarrow R_F$ pulls current away from the input node, opposing the initial change. ✔ One net inversion → negative feedback.\n\n# Exact Small-Signal Analysis\n\n(Neglect $r_O$, body effect; $v_P$ = input node voltage.)\n\n**KCL at the three nodes:**\n\n$$\\text{Input: } i_{in} + \\frac{v_{out}-v_P}{R_F} = g_{m1}v_P, \\qquad \\text{Node }X:\\; v_X = g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,v_P$$\n\n$$\\text{Output: } \\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D2}} + g_{m2}v_X + \\frac{v_{out}-v_P}{R_F} = 0$$\n\n**Solving:**\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;\\frac{V_{out}}{I_{in}} = -\\,\\frac{R_{D2}\\,(g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_F - 1)}{1 + g_{m1}(R_F+R_{D2}) + g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}} \\;\\xrightarrow[\\text{large loop gain}]{}\\; -R_F\\;}$$\n\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\,\\underbrace{\\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}}_{\\text{Miller-reduced }R_F\\text{ path}}, \n\\qquad R_{out} = R_{D2}\\,\\Big\\|\\,\\frac{1+g_{m1}R_F}{g_{m1}(1+g_{m2}R_{D1})}$$\n\n**Loop gain (return ratio):**\n\n$$T = \\frac{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}{1+g_{m1}(R_F+R_{D2})}$$\n\n# Two-Port Feedback View\n\nBreaking the loop and loading both ports with $R_F$:\n\n$$A_{OL} = \\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}}\\bigg|_{\\text{open}} = -\\Big(\\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\Big\\|R_F\\Big)\\cdot g_{m1}R_{D1}\\cdot g_{m2}\\,(R_{D2}\\|R_F), \\qquad \\beta = -\\frac{1}{R_F}$$\n\n$$\\frac{V_{out}}{I_{in}} = \\frac{A_{OL}}{1+\\beta A_{OL}} \\approx \\frac{1}{\\beta} = -R_F$$\n\nBecause the feedback is **shunt at both ports**, both impedances drop by $(1+T)$:\n\n$$R_{in} \\approx \\frac{\\tfrac{1}{g_{m1}}\\|R_F}{1+T}, \\qquad R_{out} \\approx \\frac{R_{D2}\\|R_F}{1+T}$$\n\n# Interpretation & Remarks\n\n- **Virtual low-impedance input:** with large $T$, $v_P \\approx 0$, so essentially all of $I_{in}$ flows through $R_F$, giving $V_{out}\\approx -R_F I_{in}$ — exactly like an op-amp TIA. The gain is set by one resistor, **desensitized** to $g_m$ and $R_D$ variations.\n- The \"$-1$\" term in the numerator is direct **feedforward** of $I_{in}$ through $R_F$ (negligible when $g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_F \\gg 1$); the two-port method ignores it.\n- **Sanity check** (e.g., $g_m = 10$ mS, $R_{D1}=R_{D2}=R_F=10$ kΩ): $T\\approx 50$, $V_{out}/I_{in}\\approx -0.98R_F$, $R_{in}\\approx 2\\,\\Omega$ (vs. $1/g_{m1}=100\\,\\Omega$ without feedback).\n- **Refinements:** body effect of $M_1$ → replace $g_{m1}\\to g_{m1}+g_{mb1}$ everywhere; channel-length modulation of $M_2$ → replace $R_{D2}\\to R_{D2}\\|r_{O2}$.\n- **Biasing:** $V_b$ sets $M_1$'s current; the DC drop across $R_{D1}$ sets $V_{GS2}$; $R_F$ also provides DC feedback that stabilizes the operating point.\n- **Why this topology:** the CG stage plus shunt feedback gives a very low input resistance — ideal for absorbing current from a capacitive source (e.g., a photodiode), pushing the input pole to high frequency. This is the standard front-end of optical-receiver/RF transimpedance amplifiers.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6dbf6c4e8aece92825ffba38782387af76374208dc1a4057e7506a6d229551e5"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate input device, M2 as the common-source stage driven by X, and RF as feedback from Vout to the input node, forming a transimpedance amplifier. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3de185b163e9067ba58585d0a347eecc50f9da3dc36d0d1a8e05a54adcc11752",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2515,
        "output_tokens": 28893,
        "total_tokens": 31408,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 26849,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2515,
        "output_tokens": 28893,
        "total_tokens": 31408,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 26849,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 29,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier/figure-23.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **two-stage transimpedance amplifier (TIA) with resistive shunt–shunt feedback** (in Razavi's terminology, *voltage–current feedback*):\n\n| Element | Role |\n|---|---|\n| $M_1$ (gate at $V_b$) | **Common-gate** input stage; input current enters its source |\n| $R_{D1}$ | Load of $M_1$; converts $I_{D1}$ to voltage at node $X$ |\n| $M_2$ | **Common-source** gain stage driven by $v_X$ |\n| $R_{D2}$ | Load of $M_2$, defines $V_{out}$ |\n| $R_F$ | **Feedback network**: *senses* $V_{out}$ (shunt at output), *returns* current $i_{RF}$ to the input node (shunt at input) |\n\nSince the input is a current and the output a voltage, the relevant closed-loop gain is the **transresistance** $V_{out}/I_{in}$.\n\n# Verifying Negative Feedback\n\nTrace a disturbance: $I_{in}\\uparrow \\Rightarrow v_A\\uparrow$ (source of $M_1$) $\\Rightarrow V_{GS1}\\downarrow \\Rightarrow I_{D1}\\downarrow \\Rightarrow v_X\\uparrow \\Rightarrow I_{D2}\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_{out}\\downarrow$. The falling $V_{out}$ pulls current *out of* the input node through $R_F$, opposing the original disturbance → **negative feedback**. ✓\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis\n\nAssumptions: $\\lambda = 0$, body effect neglected (else replace $g_{m1}\\to g_{m1}+g_{mb1}$). KCL at the input node $A$, node $X$, and the output:\n\n$$i_{in} + \\frac{v_{out}-v_A}{R_F} = g_{m1}v_A, \\qquad v_X = g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,v_A, \\qquad -\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D2}} = g_{m2}v_X + \\frac{v_{out}-v_A}{R_F}$$\n\nSolving:\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;\\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}} = \\frac{R_{D2}\\left(1-g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_F\\right)}{1+g_{m1}\\left(R_F+R_{D2}\\right)+g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}\\;}$$\n\n**Loop gain** (break at $M_2$'s gate; the denominator above factors as $[1+g_{m1}(R_F+R_{D2})](1+T)$):\n\n$$T=\\frac{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}{1+g_{m1}(R_F+R_{D2})}$$\n\n**Large loop gain limit** — with $\\beta = i_{RF}/v_{out} = -1/R_F$:\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}}\\;\\approx\\;\\frac{1}{\\beta}=-R_F$$\n\nas expected for an ideal shunt–shunt feedback TIA. (The \"$+R_{D2}$\" term in the numerator represents direct feedthrough of $i_{in}$ through $R_F$ to the output, negligible when $g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_F \\gg 1$.)\n\n# Port Impedances\n\nShunt connections at **both** ports mean feedback lowers both impedances by $(1+T)$ — exactly what a current-in/voltage-out amplifier wants:\n\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+g_{m1}(R_F+R_{D2})+g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}} \\;=\\; \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\,\\underbrace{\\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}}_{\\text{Miller-reduced }R_F}\\;\\ll\\;\\frac{1}{g_{m1}}$$\n\n$$R_{out} = \\frac{R_{D2}\\,(1+g_{m1}R_F)}{1+g_{m1}(R_F+R_{D2})+g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}} \\;\\approx\\; \\frac{R_F}{g_{m2}R_{D1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\,R_{D2}$$\n\nNote that feedback pushes $R_{in}$ even **below** the already-low common-gate value $1/g_{m1}$.\n\n# Sanity Checks\n\n- $R_F\\to\\infty$ (open loop): gain $\\to -g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}$ (CG current gain of 1 into $R_{D1}$, then CS stage) and $R_{in}\\to 1/g_{m1}$. ✓\n- Sign: negative, consistent with the inverting signal path traced above. ✓\n\n# Design Remarks\n\n- **Why this topology:** the low $R_{in}$ absorbs the input current and, with a capacitive source (photodiode, antenna parasitics), pushes the input pole to high frequency — the classic motivation for feedback TIAs in optical receivers and broadband LNAs.\n- **Desensitization:** gain $\\approx -R_F$ depends on one resistor, not on $g_m$'s or $R_D$'s → robust to PVT variation; distortion and bandwidth also improve by $(1+T)$.\n- **Bias:** $V_b$ sets $M_1$'s operating point; $I_{D1}R_{D1}$ establishes $V_X = V_{GS2}$, so $R_{D1}$ and $M_2$ sizing must keep both devices in saturation ($V_X > V_{GS1}-V_{TH1}+V_A$ margin for $M_1$, $V_{out} > V_X - V_{TH2}$ for $M_2$). Note $R_F$ also carries DC current between output and input nodes.\n- **Second-order effects:** including $r_{O1,2}$ and body effect of $M_1$ reduces $T$ slightly but doesn't change the structure of the results.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "2e3c82c6ed0edd7906c38ec389296874f95d0ba056ad97c382bb84906e3e29c8"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate input device, M2 as the common-source stage driven by X, and RF as negative feedback from Vout to the input node, forming a transimpedance amplifier. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3de185b163e9067ba58585d0a347eecc50f9da3dc36d0d1a8e05a54adcc11752",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2515,
        "output_tokens": 26632,
        "total_tokens": 29147,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 24501,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2515,
        "output_tokens": 26632,
        "total_tokens": 29147,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 24501,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 29,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier/figure-23.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **two‑stage transimpedance amplifier (TIA) with resistive shunt–shunt feedback**:\n\n- **M₁ (gate at V_b):** common‑gate stage — input current enters its source, output taken at drain (node *X*), load R_D1. Non‑inverting.\n- **M₂:** common‑source stage — driven from node *X*, output at its drain, load R_D2. Inverting.\n- **R_F:** feedback element. It **senses the output voltage** (shunt connection at the output) and **returns a current** $i_{RF} \\approx V_{out}/R_F$ to the input node (shunt connection at the input).\n\n⇒ **Voltage–current (shunt–shunt) feedback**, which stabilizes the transimpedance $V_{out}/I_{in}$ and **lowers both input and output resistance**.\n\n**Polarity check (negative feedback):**\n$I_{in}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow v_P\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow I_{D1}\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow v_X\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow I_{D2}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_{out}\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow$ R_F pulls current *out* of the input node — opposing the initial change. ✔ Negative feedback.\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis\n\nAssumptions: $\\lambda = 0$, no body effect ($g_{mb}$), $V_b$ and $V_{DD}$ are AC grounds. Let $v_P$ = input-node voltage.\n\n**KCL at the three nodes:**\n\n$$v_X = g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,v_P \\qquad \\text{(CG stage)}$$\n\n$$i_{in} + \\frac{v_{out}-v_P}{R_F} = g_{m1}v_P \\qquad \\text{(input node)}$$\n\n$$g_{m2}v_X + \\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D2}} + \\frac{v_{out}-v_P}{R_F} = 0 \\qquad \\text{(output node)}$$\n\nSolving, and defining the **loop gain** (return ratio, broken at M₂'s gate):\n\n$$\\boxed{T = \\frac{g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}{\\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}} + R_F + R_{D2}}}$$\n\n## Closed-loop transimpedance\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}} = -\\,\\frac{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_F - 1}{g_{m1}\\left(1+g_{m2}R_{D1}\\right) + \\dfrac{1+g_{m1}R_F}{R_{D2}}} \\;=\\; -R_F\\,\\frac{T}{1+T} + \\underbrace{\\varepsilon}_{\\text{small feedthrough}}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{\\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}} \\approx -R_F \\quad (T \\gg 1)}$$\n\nThe gain is set by one resistor — insensitive to $g_m$'s — the hallmark of feedback.\n\n## Input and output resistance (exact, compact forms)\n\n$$\\boxed{R_{in} = \\frac{\\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}}\\,\\Big\\|\\,(R_F+R_{D2})}{1+T} \\;\\approx\\; \\frac{1}{g_{m1}(1+T)}}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{R_{out} = \\frac{R_{D2}\\,\\Big\\|\\,\\left(R_F + \\dfrac{1}{g_{m1}}\\right)}{1+T}}$$\n\nThe numerators are exactly what each port sees with the loop disabled ($g_{m2}=0$); feedback divides both by $(1+T)$, as expected for shunt sensing/shunt return.\n\n# Sanity Check (numerical)\n\nTake $g_{m1}=g_{m2}=10$ mS, $R_{D1}=R_{D2}=1$ kΩ, $R_F=2$ kΩ:\n\n| Quantity | Value |\n|---|---|\n| $T = \\frac{(10\\,\\text{mS})(1\\text{k})(1\\text{k})}{100+2\\text{k}+1\\text{k}}$ | ≈ 3.2 |\n| $v_{out}/i_{in}$ | ≈ −1.52 kΩ (→ −R_F = −2 kΩ as T grows) |\n| $R_{in}$ (vs. $1/g_{m1}=100\\,\\Omega$) | ≈ 23 Ω |\n| $R_{out}$ | ≈ 160 Ω |\n\n# Interpretation & Design Notes\n\n- **Virtual-ground behavior:** Since $g_{m1}v_P = i_{in} + i_{RF}$ and $v_P \\approx 0$, for large $T$ nearly all input current is absorbed through R_F: $i_{RF}\\approx -i_{in}$, hence $V_{out}\\approx -R_F I_{in}$ — identical in spirit to an op-amp TIA.\n- **Why the low R_in matters:** driven by a capacitive current source (e.g., a photodiode), the input pole $1/(R_{in}C_{in})$ is pushed up by $(1+T)$, so the amplifier achieves gain $R_F$ with far more bandwidth than a passive resistor $R_F$ would allow. The same trick is used in CG LNAs to obtain a low, well-controlled input impedance without tying $g_{m1}$ rigidly to the match condition.\n- **Biasing:** $V_b$ sets $I_{D1}$ (the input branch must provide its DC path); $V_X = V_{DD} - I_{D1}R_{D1}$ conveniently self-biases M₂'s gate.\n- **Second-order effects:** with body effect, replace $g_{m1} \\rightarrow g_{m1}+g_{mb1}$ everywhere (it *helps*, since the body also acts as a grounded input terminal). Finite $r_{O1,2}$ appear essentially in parallel with $R_{D1,2}$, slightly reducing $T$.\n- **Stability:** the loop contains poles at nodes P, X, and the output; with large $T$ and heavy input capacitance, compensation (e.g., sizing $R_F$, adding $C_F$ across it) may be needed.\n\n**Summary:** a shunt–shunt feedback TIA where the CG + CS cascade provides the loop gain $T$, giving $V_{out}/I_{in}\\approx -R_F$, with input and output resistances reduced by $(1+T)$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "610864356c9198a99b725b70d19f3c2376f0244259f805020834516bee013e18"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate input device, M2 as the common-source stage driven by X, and RF as negative feedback from Vout to the input, forming a transimpedance amplifier. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3de185b163e9067ba58585d0a347eecc50f9da3dc36d0d1a8e05a54adcc11752",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2515,
        "output_tokens": 41680,
        "total_tokens": 44195,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 39443,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2515,
        "output_tokens": 41680,
        "total_tokens": 44195,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 39443,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 30,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback/figure-24.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **transimpedance amplifier built around voltage–current (shunt–shunt) feedback**:\n\n* **M₁** (NMOS, gate at the fixed bias $V_b$) is a **common-gate stage**: the signal enters its source (node $X$) and exits at its drain ($V_{out}$).\n* **I₁** is the active (current-source) load of the common-gate stage.\n* **M₂** (PMOS, source at $V_{DD}$) is the **feedback element**: its gate *senses the output voltage* and its drain *returns a proportional current* ($g_{m2}V_{out}$) into the input node $X$.\n* **I_in** is the signal (a current), the unlabeled sink sets the bias current of node $X$.\n\nSensing a **voltage** at the output (shunt) and returning a **current** to the input (shunt) ⇒ shunt–shunt feedback ⇒ the natural gain quantity is a **transresistance** $V_{out}/I_{in}$, and feedback *lowers both input and output impedance*.\n\n# DC Bias\n\n- $I_{D1} = I_1$, and KCL at node $X$ gives $I_{D2} = I_{\\text{sink}} - I_1$ (so the sink must exceed $I_1$).\n- $V_X = V_b - V_{GS1}$, $\\quad V_{out} = V_{DD} - |V_{GS2}|$. The loop also stabilizes the operating point.\n\n# Feedback Polarity Check\n\nInject extra current into $X$ → $V_X\\uparrow$ → $V_{GS1}\\downarrow$ → $I_{D1}\\downarrow$ → node $V_{out}$ is charged up by $I_1$ → $V_{out}\\uparrow$ → $|V_{GS2}|\\downarrow$ → M₂ injects *less* current into $X$, opposing the disturbance. ✅ **Negative feedback.**\n\n# Intuitive Result ($\\lambda=\\gamma=0$)\n\nWith ideal $I_1$, M₁ *must* keep carrying exactly $I_1$, so its $V_{GS}$ — and therefore $V_X$ — cannot change: **node $X$ is a virtual ground** ($R_{in}\\to 0$). The entire input current must then be absorbed by M₂:\n\n$$\\Delta I_{D2} = -I_{in}\\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; g_{m2}\\,V_{out} = I_{in} \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; \\boxed{\\frac{V_{out}}{I_{in}} = \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}}$$\n\n# Full Small-Signal Analysis\n\nLet $g'_{m1}=g_{m1}+g_{mb1}$, with finite $r_{O1}, r_{O2}$ and ideal bias sources. KCL at $V_{out}$ (ideal $I_1$ ⇒ $i_{D1}=0$) and at node $X$:\n\n$$-g'_{m1}v_X + \\frac{v_{out}-v_X}{r_{O1}} = 0 \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad v_{out} = \\big(1+g'_{m1}r_{O1}\\big)\\,v_X$$\n\n$$i_{in} = g_{m2}v_{out} + \\frac{v_X}{r_{O2}}$$\n\n**Closed-loop transresistance:**\n$$\\frac{V_{out}}{I_{in}} = \\frac{r_{O2}\\big(1+g'_{m1}r_{O1}\\big)}{1+\\underbrace{g_{m2}r_{O2}\\big(1+g'_{m1}r_{O1}\\big)}_{\\text{loop gain }T}} \\;\\approx\\; \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}$$\n\n# Feedback-Theory Cross-Check\n\n| Quantity | Expression | Approximation |\n|---|---|---|\n| Feedback factor | $\\beta = g_{m2}$ | — |\n| Open-loop transresistance (with loading $r_{O2}$ at input) | $R_0 = r_{O2}\\big(1+g'_{m1}r_{O1}\\big)$ | $\\approx g'_{m1}r_{O1}r_{O2}$ |\n| Loop gain | $T=\\beta R_0 = g_{m2}r_{O2}(1+g'_{m1}r_{O1})$ | $\\gg 1$ (product of two intrinsic gains) |\n| Closed-loop gain | $R_0/(1+T)$ | $\\approx 1/g_{m2}$ |\n| Input resistance | $\\dfrac{r_{O2}}{1+T}$ | $\\approx \\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}\\,g'_{m1}r_{O1}}$ (tiny!) |\n| Output resistance | $\\dfrac{r_{O1}+r_{O2}(1+g'_{m1}r_{O1})}{1+T}$ | $\\approx \\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}}$ |\n\n(Direct nodal analysis gives *exactly* the same expressions — there is no feedforward through M₂ at low frequency.)\n\n**Numerical feel:** with $g_m = 1\\,$mS, $r_O = 100\\,$kΩ: $T\\approx 10^4$, gain $\\approx 1\\,$kΩ, $R_{in}\\approx 10\\,\\Omega$, $R_{out}\\approx 1\\,$kΩ.\n\n# Key Takeaways\n\n1. **Gain is set by the feedback device alone:** $V_{out}/I_{in} \\approx 1/g_{m2}$ (the classic $1/\\beta$ result of strong feedback), insensitive to $r_O$'s and to M₁'s parameters.\n2. **Node $X$ becomes a virtual ground** — the input resistance of the common-gate stage ($\\approx 1/g_{m1}$) is further divided by M₁'s intrinsic gain. This makes the node ideal for summing/absorbing signal currents with negligible voltage swing (good for speed).\n3. **Low output impedance** ($\\approx 1/g_{m2}$), appropriate for a voltage output, even though the open-loop output node is very high impedance.\n4. **Headroom/validity:** all results assume M₁, M₂ in saturation, e.g. $V_{out} \\ge V_b - V_{TH1}$ and $V_{out} \\le V_{DD}-|V_{GS2}|+|V_{THP}|$.\n5. **Stability caution:** the loop contains two significant poles (nodes $X$ and $V_{out}$) and a very large $T$, so capacitive loading/compensation must be considered in practice.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d569dc8c0020ef03ce1efda40850c022bc257f1cc7c7a0ed17a19fc972a2f53e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate NMOS and M2 as the PMOS feedback device driven by Vout and returning current to the input node. It describes the feedback path and gives the key low-input-resistance and approximately 1/gm2 transimpedance/output-resistance results.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "81b07f946459ec3d1a0c51926785b2333e0320bb99c892d5929e040324abeaf8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2364,
        "output_tokens": 28124,
        "total_tokens": 30488,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 25877,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2364,
        "output_tokens": 28124,
        "total_tokens": 30488,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 25877,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 30,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback/figure-24.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is the classic **voltage–current (shunt–shunt) feedback transimpedance amplifier** (a current-in, voltage-out converter, as found in Razavi's feedback chapter):\n\n- **M₁** – NMOS **common-gate** device: gate at bias $V_b$, source at the input node (call it **X**, where $I_{in}$, the tail sink, M₂'s drain and M₁'s source meet), drain at $V_{out}$.\n- **I₁** – ideal current-source load for M₁.\n- **M₂** – PMOS **feedback device**: its gate *senses the output voltage*, its drain *returns a current* $g_{m2}v_{out}$ to the input node → feedback factor $\\beta = g_{m2}$.\n- The unlabeled sink (call it $I_2$) biases node X.\n\n**Loop polarity check:** $i_{in}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow v_X\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow I_{D1}\\!\\downarrow$ (since $V_{GS1}=V_b-v_X$) $\\Rightarrow V_{out}\\!\\uparrow$ (I₁ keeps charging the node) $\\Rightarrow |V_{GS2}|\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow$ M₂ injects *less* current into X $\\Rightarrow v_X$ pulled back. → **Negative feedback.** ✓\n\n# DC Operating Point\n\nOnly $I_1$ and M₁'s drain meet at the output node, so:\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_1,\\qquad I_{D2}=I_2-I_1 \\;(\\text{requires } I_2>I_1)$$\n$$V_X = V_b - V_{GS1}(I_1), \\qquad V_{out} = V_{DD}-|V_{GS2}|(I_2-I_1)$$\n\nThe loop *pins* node X at $V_b - V_{GS1}$.\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis\n\nSince $I_1$ is ideal, **no AC current flows through M₁**; it only \"amplifies\" node X to the output:\n\n$$-(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})v_X + \\frac{v_{out}-v_X}{r_{O1}}=0 \\;\\Rightarrow\\; v_{out}=A_0\\,v_X,\\quad A_0\\equiv 1+(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})r_{O1}$$\n\n**All of $i_{in}$ must therefore be absorbed by M₂.** KCL at X:\n\n$$i_{in} = g_{m2}v_{out} + \\frac{v_X}{r_{O2}} = \\Big(g_{m2}A_0+\\tfrac{1}{r_{O2}}\\Big)v_X$$\n\n## Results\n\n| Quantity | Exact | Approximation |\n|---|---|---|\n| Loop gain | $T = g_{m2}r_{O2}A_0$ | $\\approx (g_{m1}r_{O1})(g_{m2}r_{O2})$ (very large) |\n| Transimpedance $\\dfrac{v_{out}}{i_{in}}$ | $\\dfrac{A_0 r_{O2}}{1+T}$ | $\\boxed{+\\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}} = \\dfrac{1}{\\beta}}$ |\n| $R_{in}$ (node X) | $\\dfrac{r_{O2}}{1+T}$ | $\\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}\\,g_{m1}r_{O1}}$ (extremely low) |\n| $R_{out}$ | $\\dfrac{r_{O1}+r_{O2}+(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})r_{O1}r_{O2}}{1+T}$ | $\\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}}$ (low) |\n\nThese match feedback theory exactly: open-loop $Z_{OL}=A_0r_{O2}$, $R_{in,OL}=r_{O2}$, $R_{out,OL}= r_{O1}+r_{O2}+g_{m1}r_{O1}r_{O2}$, each divided by $(1+T)$ with $T=\\beta Z_{OL}$.\n\n**Example:** $g_m = 5\\,\\text{mS}, r_O = 20\\,\\text{k}\\Omega$: $T\\approx 10^4$, $Z_T\\approx 200\\,\\Omega$, $R_{in}\\approx 2\\,\\Omega$, $R_{out}\\approx 200\\,\\Omega$.\n\n# Intuition\n\n- M₁'s current is locked to $I_1$, so every bit of $i_{in}$ must be \"stolen\" from M₂. That requires $\\Delta|V_{GS2}| = i_{in}/g_{m2}$, hence $v_{out} = +i_{in}/g_{m2}$ — the gain is set by the feedback device alone, desensitized from $A_0$.\n- Seen from node X, the loop makes M₂ look like a **diode-connected device with $g_m$ boosted by $A_0$** → nearly a virtual ground (ideal current input).\n- Seen from the output, a test voltage changes $I_{D2}$ by $g_{m2}v_t$, and that current must be supplied *through M₁ from the output node* → $R_{out}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$ (ideal voltage output). Low impedance at **both** ports is exactly what shunt–shunt feedback predicts.\n\n# Validity / Limitations\n\n- Needs $I_2 > I_1$; signal range limited to $|i_{in}| < I_2 - I_1$ (M₂ must stay on), and $V_{out} \\ge V_b - V_{THN}$ to keep M₁ saturated.\n- $V_{out}$ is referenced to $V_{DD}$ ($V_{out}=V_{DD}-|V_{GS2}|$), so supply noise passes directly to the output.\n- Finite output resistance of the real current sources reduces $A_0$ and $T$; capacitance at the two nodes (X and output) creates a two-pole loop whose phase margin should be checked.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "66bf0083cd4440ffa307b7cd649d344e21455f464be96849e31bc8896ab595fb"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate NMOS and M2 as the PMOS feedback device driven by Vout, describes the feedback path to the input node, and gives the expected low input resistance and transimpedance/output resistance near 1/gm2. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "81b07f946459ec3d1a0c51926785b2333e0320bb99c892d5929e040324abeaf8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2364,
        "output_tokens": 26759,
        "total_tokens": 29123,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 24714,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2364,
        "output_tokens": 26759,
        "total_tokens": 29123,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 24714,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 30,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback/figure-24.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **transimpedance amplifier (TIA)**: it takes a *current* input ($I_{in}$) and produces a *voltage* output ($V_{out}$), using **shunt–shunt (voltage-sensing, current-returning) negative feedback**. It is a classic feedback example (Razavi, *Design of Analog CMOS ICs*, Ch. 8).\n\n* **$M_1$ (NMOS):** common-gate stage. Gate at bias $V_b$, input current enters its source (node $X$), output taken at its drain, loaded by current source $I_1$. This is the **forward amplifier**.\n* **$M_2$ (PMOS):** the **feedback element**. Its gate *senses* $V_{out}$ (shunt connection at output); its drain *returns a current* $g_{m2}v_{out}$ into node $X$ (shunt connection at input).\n* **$I_1$:** bias/load for $M_1$; **unlabeled sink $I_2$:** sets $M_2$'s bias current; **$V_b$:** fixes the DC level of node $X$.\n\n**Negative feedback check:** $I_{in}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow V_X\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow I_{D1}\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow V_{out}\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow |V_{GS2}|\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow$ $M_2$ injects less current into $X$ ⇒ opposes the initial rise. ✔\n\n# DC Operating Point\n\nSince $M_2$'s gate draws no current, **all of $I_1$ flows through $M_1$**: $I_{D1}=I_1$. KCL at node $X$:\n\n$$|I_{D2}| = I_2 - I_1 - I_{in,DC}, \\qquad V_X = V_b - V_{GS1}, \\qquad V_{out} = V_{DD} - |V_{GS2}|$$\n\n(requires $I_2 > I_1$; linear operation needs $I_{in} < I_2-I_1$ so $M_2$ stays on).\n\n# Key Result: Transimpedance (λ = 0)\n\nBecause $I_{D1}$ is pinned at $I_1$, $V_{GS1}$ is constant ⇒ **node $X$ is a virtual ground**. Thus every element except $M_2$ carries fixed current, so **the entire signal current $I_{in}$ is forced into $M_2$**:\n\n$$\\Delta |I_{D2}| = -\\Delta I_{in}, \\qquad \\Delta|I_{D2}| = -g_{m2}\\,\\Delta V_{out}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{\\dfrac{V_{out}}{I_{in}} = \\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}}}$$\n\nThe gain is **positive**, set by a single transconductance (programmable via $I_{D2}=I_2-I_1$). $M_2$ plays the role of the feedback resistor in an op-amp TIA, with effective value $1/g_{m2}$.\n\n# Small-Signal Analysis with Channel-Length Modulation\n\nKCL at the output (only $M_1$'s channel carries signal current there):\n$$-g_{m1}v_X + \\frac{v_{out}-v_X}{r_{O1}} = 0 \\;\\Rightarrow\\; v_{out} = (1+g_{m1}r_{O1})\\,v_X$$\n\nKCL at node $X$: $\\;i_{in} = g_{m2}v_{out} + v_X/r_{O2}$, giving:\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}} = \\frac{1}{g_{m2} + \\dfrac{1}{r_{O2}(1+g_{m1}r_{O1})}} = \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}\\cdot\\frac{T}{1+T}$$\n\nwhere the **loop gain** is $\\;T = g_{m2}\\,r_{O2}\\,(1+g_{m1}r_{O1}) \\approx g_{m1}r_{O1}\\,g_{m2}r_{O2} \\gg 1$.\n\n# Port Impedances (shunt–shunt ⇒ both reduced by $1+T$)\n\n| Quantity | Open loop | Closed loop | Approximation |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| Transimpedance | $r_{O2}(1+g_{m1}r_{O1})$ | $\\div(1+T)$ | $1/g_{m2}$ |\n| $R_{in}$ (node $X$) | $r_{O2}$ | $\\div(1+T)$ | $\\dfrac{1}{g_{m2}(1+g_{m1}r_{O1})} \\to 0$ |\n| $R_{out}$ | $r_{O1}+r_{O2}+g_{m1}r_{O1}r_{O2}$ | $\\div(1+T)$ | $1/g_{m2}$ |\n\n**Intuition for $R_{out}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$:** a test current at the output must flow through $M_1$ into $M_2$; since $M_2$'s gate is tied to the output through the loop, it behaves like a diode-connected device.\n\n# Practical Remarks\n\n* **Why it's a good TIA:** very low $R_{in}$ holds node $X$ at a fixed potential (ideal for a photodiode or current DAC), low $R_{out}$, and gain desensitized to $M_1$, $r_O$, and loading — accuracy error $\\approx 1/T$.\n* **Body effect:** replace $g_{m1}\\to g_{m1}+g_{mb1}$ in $T$ and $R_{in}$; the ideal result $1/g_{m2}$ is unchanged ($X$ remains a virtual ground; $M_2$ has no body effect with source at $V_{DD}$).\n* **Headroom:** $M_1$ saturated for $V_{out} \\ge V_b - V_{THN}$; $M_2$ saturated for $V_X \\le V_{out}+|V_{THP}|$.\n* **Stability:** the loop contains two nodes ($X$ and output); with the low closed-loop impedances, the input pole $\\sim 1/(R_{in}C_X)$ is pushed to high frequency, and the output pole $\\approx g_{m2}/C_L$ typically dominates.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "8c11307869b7bab81df34fad740addd8210cf6b08e8344de83d731b99432a211"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate NMOS and M2 as the PMOS feedback device driven by Vout, with feedback returning to the input node. It gives the low-input-resistance current-buffer/TIA behavior and the key transimpedance and output-resistance approximations, satisfying the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "81b07f946459ec3d1a0c51926785b2333e0320bb99c892d5929e040324abeaf8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2364,
        "output_tokens": 31224,
        "total_tokens": 33588,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 29102,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2364,
        "output_tokens": 31224,
        "total_tokens": 33588,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 29102,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if the three capacitors become arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\n**No.** Making the capacitors larger only lowers the oscillation frequency — it never kills the oscillation (for any *finite* $C_L$).\n\n## Why\n\nModel each inverter as an amplifier with low‑frequency gain $-A_0$ and output resistance $R$ driving its load capacitor, so each stage has one pole at $\\omega_0 = 1/(RC_L)$:\n\n$$\nH_{stage}(s) = \\frac{-A_0}{1 + s/\\omega_0}\n$$\n\n**Phase condition (Barkhausen):** The three inversions give 540° ≡ 180° at DC, so the three poles must contribute another 180°, i.e. 60° per stage:\n\n$$\n\\tan^{-1}\\!\\left(\\frac{\\omega_{osc}}{\\omega_0}\\right) = 60^\\circ \n\\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; \n\\omega_{osc} = \\sqrt{3}\\,\\omega_0 = \\frac{\\sqrt{3}}{RC_L}\n$$\n\n**Gain condition:** At $\\omega_{osc}$ each stage is attenuated by $\\sqrt{1+3} = 2$, so the loop sustains oscillation if\n\n$$\n\\left(\\frac{A_0}{2}\\right)^3 \\ge 1 \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; A_0 \\ge 2\n$$\n\n## The key observation\n\nThe gain condition $A_0 \\ge 2$ is **independent of $C_L$**. Increasing $C_L$ pushes the pole $\\omega_0$ down, but the oscillation frequency $\\omega_{osc} = \\sqrt{3}\\,\\omega_0$ moves down *with* it — the per‑stage gain at the oscillation frequency stays at $A_0/2$ no matter how large $C_L$ is.\n\nEquivalently, in the time domain: each stage delay is $t_d \\propto RC_L$, and the circuit oscillates with period $T \\approx 2\\cdot 3\\cdot t_d$. Larger capacitors just stretch the period.\n\nSo as $C_L \\to \\infty$ the frequency $f_{osc} \\propto 1/C_L \\to 0$, but the Barkhausen criteria remain satisfied — the circuit continues to oscillate, merely arbitrarily slowly. (Only in the idealized limit of truly infinite capacitance, where the nodes can never change voltage, would the \"oscillation\" have zero frequency; in practice, leakage would eventually dominate for absurdly large $C_L$.)",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "90ee8d60bafde2bc9926925746ed458d2bb8101922521a34785e67d22c5e3860"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that all three capacitors can become arbitrarily large while the ring continues oscillating at a lower frequency. The small-signal phase and gain analysis shows the oscillation condition is independent of capacitance, and the delay argument agrees.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "382bd8dbcc1993e2438bdfd3faf5268719f050e1964cb818b2278171cb2c25bf",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2398,
        "output_tokens": 2672,
        "total_tokens": 5070,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1826,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2398,
        "output_tokens": 2672,
        "total_tokens": 5070,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1826,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if the three capacitors become arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\n**No.** The ring still oscillates for *any* finite value of $C_L$ — it simply oscillates more and more slowly. Making $C_L$ huge lowers the oscillation frequency but does not violate the start‑up (Barkhausen) conditions.\n\n## Why\n\nModel each inverter as a gain stage with low‑frequency gain $-A_0$ and a single pole set by its output resistance $R_{out}$ and the load capacitor:\n\n$$\nH_{stage}(s) = \\frac{-A_0}{1 + s/\\omega_p}, \\qquad \\omega_p = \\frac{1}{R_{out}C_L}\n$$\n\n**Phase condition:** The three inversions contribute $540^\\circ \\equiv 180^\\circ$, so the three poles must supply another $180^\\circ$, i.e. $60^\\circ$ per stage:\n\n$$\n\\tan^{-1}\\!\\frac{\\omega_{osc}}{\\omega_p} = 60^\\circ \n\\;\\;\\Longrightarrow\\;\\; \n\\omega_{osc} = \\sqrt{3}\\,\\omega_p = \\frac{\\sqrt{3}}{R_{out}C_L}\n$$\n\n**Gain condition:** At that frequency each stage's gain magnitude is\n\n$$\n\\frac{A_0}{\\sqrt{1 + (\\omega_{osc}/\\omega_p)^2}} = \\frac{A_0}{\\sqrt{1+3}} = \\frac{A_0}{2},\n$$\n\nso the loop oscillates provided\n\n$$\n\\left(\\frac{A_0}{2}\\right)^3 \\ge 1 \\;\\;\\Longrightarrow\\;\\; A_0 \\ge 2 .\n$$\n\n## The key observation\n\nThe gain condition depends only on the **ratio** $\\omega_{osc}/\\omega_p = \\sqrt{3}$, which is fixed — it does not involve $C_L$ at all. Increasing $C_L$ pushes the pole frequency $\\omega_p$ down, and the oscillation frequency $\\omega_{osc}=\\sqrt{3}\\,\\omega_p$ moves down *with* it, so the loop gain at the oscillation frequency remains $A_0^3/8$ regardless of how large $C_L$ becomes.\n\nTherefore, as long as each inverter provides a low‑frequency gain of at least 2, the circuit oscillates at\n\n$$\nf_{osc} = \\frac{\\sqrt{3}}{2\\pi R_{out} C_L},\n$$\n\nwhich simply approaches zero as $C_L \\to \\infty$. (Equivalently, in the large‑signal view each stage's delay $\\propto R_{out}C_L$ grows, giving a period $\\approx 2 \\times 3 \\times t_d$ — slower, but still a valid oscillation.) The only practical penalties are an arbitrarily low frequency and an arbitrarily long start‑up time, not a failure to oscillate.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "7ac08a33ca275d45fc3bb49b9966b142d8180224e841d6ca925055a3cd596af6"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that equal loading on all three nodes preserves oscillation while lowering frequency, and supports this with the per-stage phase and gain conditions. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "382bd8dbcc1993e2438bdfd3faf5268719f050e1964cb818b2278171cb2c25bf",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2398,
        "output_tokens": 3333,
        "total_tokens": 5731,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2356,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2398,
        "output_tokens": 3333,
        "total_tokens": 5731,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2356,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if the three capacitors become arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\n**No.** Making the capacitors arbitrarily large only makes the oscillation arbitrarily **slow** — it never kills the oscillation.\n\n## Why\n\nModel each inverter as a gain stage with one pole set by its output resistance $R_{out}$ and the load capacitor:\n\n$$\nH_{stage}(s)=\\frac{-A_0}{1+s/\\omega_0},\\qquad \\omega_0=\\frac{1}{R_{out}C_L}\n$$\n\n**Phase condition (Barkhausen):** The three inversions give a DC phase of 540° ≡ 180°, so the three poles must contribute another 180°, i.e. **60° per stage**:\n\n$$\n\\tan^{-1}\\!\\left(\\frac{\\omega_{osc}}{\\omega_0}\\right)=60^\\circ \n\\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; \n\\omega_{osc}=\\sqrt{3}\\,\\omega_0=\\frac{\\sqrt{3}}{R_{out}C_L}\n$$\n\n**Gain condition:** At this frequency each stage is attenuated by $\\sqrt{1+(\\omega_{osc}/\\omega_0)^2}=\\sqrt{1+3}=2$, so the loop gain requirement is\n\n$$\n\\left(\\frac{A_0}{2}\\right)^{3}\\ge 1 \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; A_0\\ge 2\n$$\n\n## The key observation\n\nThe capacitor $C_L$ appears **only** inside $\\omega_0$. Since the oscillation frequency tracks the pole frequency ($\\omega_{osc}=\\sqrt{3}\\,\\omega_0$ always), the per-stage phase shift (60°) and per-stage attenuation (÷2) **at the oscillation frequency are completely independent of $C_L$**. The start-up condition $A_0 \\ge 2$ therefore does not change as $C_L$ grows.\n\nIncreasing $C_L$ simply slides $\\omega_0$ — and hence $\\omega_{osc}$ — down together:\n\n$$\nf_{osc}=\\frac{\\sqrt{3}}{2\\pi R_{out}C_L}\\;\\longrightarrow\\;0 \\quad \\text{as } C_L\\to\\infty\n$$\n\n## Time-domain sanity check\n\nViewed as a ring of delay stages, the period is $T \\approx 6\\,t_d$, where the per-stage delay $t_d \\propto R_{out}C_L$. A huge $C_L$ just means each node charges and discharges very slowly — the loop still has no stable DC operating point (odd number of inversions with $A_0\\ge 2$), so it must keep toggling, merely at an ever-lower frequency.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "3b612b4b805d5a394ca9c42fff0d72633cf0ffdf0b9c03f08ea492097c88c9dc"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that equal capacitors at all three nodes do not stop oscillation, and gives the valid small-signal phase and gain argument showing frequency falls as 1/CL while the oscillation condition is unchanged.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "382bd8dbcc1993e2438bdfd3faf5268719f050e1964cb818b2278171cb2c25bf",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2398,
        "output_tokens": 3423,
        "total_tokens": 5821,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2522,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2398,
        "output_tokens": 3423,
        "total_tokens": 5821,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2522,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "What happens to the phase noise if the three capacitors in the figure are doubled?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nThe oscillation frequency drops by a factor of 2, and the phase noise **at a given offset frequency improves by 6 dB** (a factor of 4) — but this comes entirely at the cost of speed, not as a \"free\" improvement.\n\n## Why\n\n**1. Frequency halves.**\nEach stage delay is set by charging/discharging $C_L$:\n\n$$t_d \\propto R\\,C_L \\quad\\text{(or } C_L \\Delta V / I\\text{)} \\qquad\\Rightarrow\\qquad f_0 = \\frac{1}{2N\\,t_d} \\propto \\frac{1}{C_L}$$\n\nSo doubling all three capacitors gives $f_0 \\rightarrow f_0/2$.\n\n**2. Phase noise falls by 6 dB.**\nThe transistor noise currents ($\\overline{i_n^2} = 4kT\\gamma g_m$) and the voltage swing are unchanged. Phase noise scales as\n\n$$\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f) \\propto \\frac{\\overline{i_n^2}}{q_{max}^2\\,\\Delta f^2}, \\qquad q_{max} = C_L V_{sw}$$\n\nDoubling $C_L$ doubles $q_{max}$, so $\\mathcal{L}$ drops by a factor of 4, i.e., **−6 dB** at a fixed $\\Delta f$. Equivalently, since $\\mathcal{L}\\propto (f_0/\\Delta f)^2$ with the injected noise density unchanged, halving $f_0$ gives the same −6 dB.\n\nA time-domain check: the jitter per transition is $\\sigma_t = \\sqrt{kT C_L}/I$, which grows only by $\\sqrt{2}$, while the period doubles — working through $\\mathcal{L} \\propto f_0^3\\,\\sigma_c^2/\\Delta f^2$ again yields a factor of 4 reduction.\n\n(Note: the common intuition \"$kT/C$ noise halves → 3 dB\" is wrong here — what matters is the noise *density* converted to phase, not the integrated node noise.)\n\n## The catch\n\n- **Power is unchanged:** $P \\propto C_L V_{DD}^2 f_0$, and $C_L \\times 2$ with $f_0 \\div 2$ cancels.\n- **FOM is unchanged:** the 6 dB improvement in $\\mathcal{L}$ is exactly offset by the 6 dB loss in $20\\log(f_0/\\Delta f)$. At the same *normalized* offset $\\Delta f/f_0$, the phase noise is identical.\n\nSo doubling the capacitors simply trades oscillation frequency for phase noise. If the application requires the original frequency, nothing has been gained.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d995ea77da2c341193720ec4b43e438bb28ef6794a3687b4210de7c11506b7bd"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that doubling the capacitors halves the oscillation frequency and reduces phase noise by about 6 dB (a factor of four) at a fixed offset, with reasoning consistent with the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c8a3a6ddcab3a54151ffe61cb3e809a6731a66beda02e9f8898ea9c435318b06",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2390,
        "output_tokens": 12289,
        "total_tokens": 14679,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11376,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2390,
        "output_tokens": 12289,
        "total_tokens": 14679,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11376,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "What happens to the phase noise if the three capacitors in the figure are doubled?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setup\n\nThe circuit is a three‑stage ring oscillator whose frequency is set by the stage delay, $t_d \\propto C_L V_{DD}/I_D$:\n\n$$f_{osc}=\\frac{1}{2N\\,t_d}\\;\\propto\\;\\frac{1}{C_L}$$\n\nSo doubling all three capacitors first of all **halves the oscillation frequency**.\n\n## Effect on phase noise\n\nTrack how noise converts to phase fluctuations when $C_L \\rightarrow 2C_L$ (same transistors, same currents, same swing):\n\n**Per-edge timing jitter:** The voltage noise at each node is $\\overline{v_n^2}\\sim kT/C_L$ and the slew rate is $I/C_L$, so the timing jitter of each transition is\n\n$$\\sigma_t^2=\\frac{\\overline{v_n^2}}{(dV/dt)^2}\\;\\propto\\;\\frac{kT\\,C_L}{I^2}\\quad\\Rightarrow\\;\\times 2$$\n\n**Phase error per edge:** $\\Delta\\phi = \\omega_{osc}\\,\\sigma_t$. Since $\\omega_{osc}$ halves and $\\sigma_t$ grows by $\\sqrt{2}$, the phase-error variance per edge **halves**.\n\n**Edges per second:** The period doubles, so the rate of noisy transitions also **halves**.\n\nThe phase-diffusion rate (which sets phase noise) therefore drops by $\\tfrac12\\times\\tfrac12=\\tfrac14$:\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f)\\;\\rightarrow\\;\\frac{1}{4}\\,\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f)\\quad\\text{i.e., a 6-dB improvement at a given offset }\\Delta f\\;}$$\n\nThis is consistent with the standard ring-oscillator result\n\n$$\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f)\\propto \\frac{kT}{P}\\left(\\frac{f_{osc}}{\\Delta f}\\right)^2 ,$$\n\nbecause the power $P = 3C_LV_{DD}^2f_{osc}$ is *unchanged* ($C_L$ doubles, $f_{osc}$ halves), while $f_{osc}^2$ falls by 4×.\n\n## The catch\n\nThere is no free lunch: the 6‑dB improvement comes entirely from the 2× lower carrier frequency. If you compare at the same *relative* offset ($\\Delta f/f_{osc}$ fixed), or compute the figure of merit\n\n$$\\text{FOM}=\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f)-20\\log\\frac{f_{osc}}{\\Delta f}+10\\log\\frac{P}{1\\,\\text{mW}},$$\n\nnothing improves — doubling the capacitors simply trades oscillation frequency for phase noise.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c4ca584db621b8d37e927c3d56d09929fd5498ae4a62574559343619e9786012"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that doubling the capacitors halves the oscillation frequency and reduces phase noise by about fourfold (6 dB) at a fixed offset, with an appropriate explanation. It also correctly notes the unchanged result at fixed relative offset.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c8a3a6ddcab3a54151ffe61cb3e809a6731a66beda02e9f8898ea9c435318b06",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2390,
        "output_tokens": 14897,
        "total_tokens": 17287,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13939,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2390,
        "output_tokens": 14897,
        "total_tokens": 17287,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13939,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "What happens to the phase noise if the three capacitors in the figure are doubled?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nAt a given offset frequency, the phase noise **drops by a factor of 4 (–6 dB)** — but note that the oscillation frequency is simultaneously **halved**.\n\n## Why\n\n**Frequency:** Each stage delay is set by charging $C_L$: $t_d \\propto C_L$ (e.g., $t_d \\approx C_L V_{DD}/(2I_D)$). Since $f_{osc} = 1/(6t_d)$ for this three-stage ring, doubling $C_L$ halves $f_{osc}$.\n\n**Phase noise:** Doubling $C_L$ (with the same devices and currents) leaves the injected noise unchanged while the \"charge swing\" of each node, $q_{max} = C_L V_{DD}$, doubles. Using the impulse-sensitivity (Hajimiri) form,\n\n$$\n\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f) \\propto \\frac{N\\,\\Gamma_{rms}^2\\,\\overline{i_n^2}/\\Delta f}{q_{max}^2\\,(\\Delta f)^2} \\;\\propto\\; \\frac{1}{C_L^2}\n\\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; \\mathcal{L} \\to \\frac{\\mathcal{L}}{4}\\;(-6\\text{ dB}).\n$$\n\nThe jitter picture gives the same result: the per-edge timing jitter is $\\sigma_t = \\sqrt{kT C_L}/I$ (slope $I/C_L$, noise $kT/C_L$), so $\\sigma_t^2$ doubles — but the period doubles and the edge rate halves, so the phase diffusion rate $\\propto f_{osc}^3\\,\\sigma_t^2$ scales as $\\tfrac{1}{8}\\times 2 = \\tfrac14$.\n\nEquivalently, with $\\mathcal{L} \\propto \\dfrac{kT\\,F}{P}\\left(\\dfrac{f_{osc}}{\\Delta f}\\right)^2$: the power is unchanged (dynamic power $\\propto 3C_L V_{DD}^2 f_{osc}$, and $C_L f_{osc}$ is constant), while $f_{osc}^2$ falls by 4.\n\n## The catch\n\nThis is not a \"free\" improvement:\n\n- The carrier is now at $f_{osc}/2$. The same 6 dB could be obtained by keeping the original oscillator and following it with a ÷2 divider.\n- Compared at the same *fractional* offset (same $\\Delta f/f_{osc}$), the phase noise is unchanged — the figure of merit (which normalizes to frequency and power) stays exactly the same.\n- The absolute rms period jitter actually *increases* by $\\sqrt{2}$, and the long-term jitter accumulation rate is unchanged.\n\nSo doubling the capacitors trades oscillation frequency for phase noise at fixed offset, with no fundamental noise-efficiency gain.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "b157568864336678beffdb5bf9a4fafc6cba5683a5b20d621d37e330914ac925"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that doubling the capacitors halves the oscillation frequency and reduces phase noise by about 6 dB at a fixed offset; it also correctly notes the unchanged result at a fixed fractional offset.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c8a3a6ddcab3a54151ffe61cb3e809a6731a66beda02e9f8898ea9c435318b06",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2390,
        "output_tokens": 11923,
        "total_tokens": 14313,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10941,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2390,
        "output_tokens": 11923,
        "total_tokens": 14313,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10941,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if CL becomes arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\n**Yes.** For inverters with finite gain, the ring stops oscillating once C_L exceeds a critical value; as C_L → ∞ the loop becomes unconditionally stable and all three nodes simply settle at the inverters' switching threshold. The reason is that Barkhausen's *phase* condition can still be met, but the *gain* condition cannot.\n\n## Analysis\n\nModel each stage as a gain −a₀ with a single pole. The loaded node has pole ω_L = 1/(RC_L); the other two nodes have poles ω₀ = 1/(RC):\n\n$$T(s) = \\frac{-a_0^3}{\\left(1+\\dfrac{s}{\\omega_L}\\right)\\left(1+\\dfrac{s}{\\omega_0}\\right)^2}$$\n\n**Phase condition:** The loop needs 180° of frequency-dependent phase. The heavily loaded node contributes at most 90°, so the two fast stages must supply the remaining ~90°, i.e., 45° each. This happens at\n\n$$\\omega_{osc} \\approx \\omega_0 = \\frac{1}{RC}$$\n\nNote the first surprise: the oscillation frequency does **not** keep dropping as C_L grows — it saturates near ω₀. (The unloaded ring runs at √3·ω₀, so loading one node buys you at most a factor of √3 in frequency.)\n\n**Gain condition:** At ω ≈ ω₀, the loaded stage is far beyond its pole and attenuates heavily, |A₁| ≈ a₀(ω_L/ω₀) = a₀C/C_L, while each fast stage gives a₀/√2. Thus\n\n$$|T(j\\omega_{osc})| \\approx \\left(\\frac{a_0}{\\sqrt 2}\\right)^2 \\cdot a_0\\frac{C}{C_L} = \\frac{a_0^3}{2}\\cdot\\frac{C}{C_L}$$\n\nRequiring |T| ≥ 1 (exactly, via Routh–Hurwitz: a₀³ ≥ 2(1+x)²/x with x = C_L/C) gives\n\n$$\\boxed{C_L \\lesssim \\frac{a_0^3}{2}\\,C}$$\n\nSince a₀ is finite, an arbitrarily large C_L violates this — the loop gain at the phase-crossover frequency falls below unity and oscillation dies.\n\n## Intuition\n\nA three-inverter ring is a **negative-feedback loop at DC** (odd number of inversions). Making one pole dominant with a huge C_L is exactly what you do to *stabilize* a feedback amplifier — it is dominant-pole compensation. The node with C_L becomes so slow that the other two inverters track it essentially instantaneously; the loop degenerates toward a first-order negative-feedback system, which cannot accumulate the required 180° of extra phase and therefore cannot oscillate. The circuit settles with every node parked at the inverter trip point (≈ V_DD/2).\n\n## Practical note\n\nReal CMOS inverters have |a₀| of a few tens, so C_L can be thousands of times the parasitic node capacitance before oscillation stops — but it *will* stop. This is also why loading a single node is a poor way to build a very low-frequency ring oscillator: before failure, the frequency drops only from √3/(RC) to about 1/(RC), while the swing on the loaded node collapses toward zero.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bbe6a5ae0f8c0696c1c754cda227bcda6a4acc66267cb4b2b3a8fea3868c8132"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that arbitrarily large single-node loading can stop oscillation and explains the dominant-pole gain roll-off causing the loop-gain condition to fail. The frequency and threshold estimates are secondary and do not contradict the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f6dd3ed123c88a59472f7a76de74df7e33b3e73498632bd24bc1ea808e4efcbc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2290,
        "output_tokens": 16253,
        "total_tokens": 18543,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15109,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2290,
        "output_tokens": 16253,
        "total_tokens": 18543,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15109,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if CL becomes arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\n**Yes.** A moderate C_L only slows the oscillation down, but beyond a certain size it kills the oscillation entirely — so an *arbitrarily large* C_L makes the ring fail.\n\n## Why\n\nModel each inverter as an inverting gain –A₀ with output resistance R, and node capacitance C at the two unloaded nodes. The loop then has three poles:\n\n$$\\omega_1=\\frac{1}{RC_L}\\ (\\text{dominant, at the loaded node}),\\qquad \\omega_{2,3}=\\frac{1}{RC}$$\n\nFor oscillation (Barkhausen), the three poles must contribute a total of **180°** of phase (on top of the net dc inversion) at a frequency where the loop gain is still ≥ 1.\n\n- As C_L → ∞, the dominant pole can contribute **at most ~90°**.\n- The remaining ~90° must come from the two fast poles, which happens only near ω ≈ ω₂ = 1/(RC). So the phase-crossover frequency stays pinned near the *fast* poles — it does **not** move down with C_L.\n- But at that frequency, the dominant pole has already rolled the gain off by a factor ≈ ω₂/ω₁ = C_L/C.\n\nThe loop-gain magnitude at phase crossover is therefore\n\n$$|H| \\approx \\frac{A_0^{3}}{\\left(\\dfrac{\\omega_2}{\\omega_1}\\right)\\cdot\\sqrt{2}\\cdot\\sqrt{2}}=\\frac{A_0^{3}}{2}\\cdot\\frac{C}{C_L}$$\n\nOscillation requires |H| ≥ 1, i.e.\n\n$$\\boxed{C_L \\lesssim \\frac{A_0^{3}}{2}\\,C}$$\n\nFor any finite inverter gain, a large enough C_L violates the gain condition, and the circuit stops oscillating.\n\n## What the circuit does instead\n\nThe huge C_L is exactly **dominant-pole compensation**: the ring becomes a *stable* three-stage negative-feedback amplifier (phase margin → ~90°). Equivalently, node X becomes so slow that the other two nodes simply track it, reducing the loop to a first-order system — and a first-order negative-feedback system cannot oscillate. All three nodes quietly settle at the inverter trip point (~V_DD/2), with the inverters drawing static current.\n\n## Two useful contrasts\n\n- **Digital intuition is misleading here.** \"The cap just adds delay, so it oscillates slower\" fails because with a very slow ramp the inverters operate as *linear amplifiers* near threshold, where the stability analysis above applies.\n- **Symmetric loading is different.** If all three nodes were loaded equally, all poles drop together, the gain condition stays A₀ ≥ 2, and the circuit oscillates (merely slower) for *any* capacitor value. The failure occurs specifically because loading **one** node splits the poles.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "24a48cb10781964308aa76b56117c044c4ae9ed54e98748021c16c6e28c65853"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that arbitrarily large loading on one node can stop oscillation and explains the dominant-pole gain roll-off and resulting Barkhausen failure. The additional pole estimate and contrasts are consistent with the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f6dd3ed123c88a59472f7a76de74df7e33b3e73498632bd24bc1ea808e4efcbc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2290,
        "output_tokens": 16924,
        "total_tokens": 19214,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15929,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2290,
        "output_tokens": 16924,
        "total_tokens": 19214,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15929,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if CL becomes arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\n**Yes.** Once C_L exceeds a critical value (and certainly as C_L → ∞), the ring stops oscillating. A very large capacitor on *one* node doesn't just slow the oscillation — it acts as **dominant‑pole compensation** and turns the ring into a *stable* three‑stage negative‑feedback amplifier.\n\n## Why\n\nModel each inverter as gain −A₀ with output resistance R. The loaded node X has pole ω₁ = 1/(RC_L); the other two nodes have poles ω_p = 1/(RC):\n\n$$H(s)=\\frac{-A_0^3}{\\left(1+\\frac{s}{\\omega_1}\\right)\\left(1+\\frac{s}{\\omega_p}\\right)^2}$$\n\n**Phase condition:** The three inversions give 180°, so the poles must supply another 180°:\n\n$$\\tan^{-1}\\frac{\\omega}{\\omega_1}+2\\tan^{-1}\\frac{\\omega}{\\omega_p}=180^\\circ$$\n\nHere is the key point: the slow node can contribute **at most 90°, no matter how large C_L is**. The remaining ≥90° must come from the two fast poles, which happens only at\n\n$$\\omega_{180}\\approx \\omega_p = \\frac{1}{RC}$$\n\nSo the phase-crossover frequency is *pinned* by the fast nodes — it does **not** drop as C_L grows.\n\n**Gain condition:** But at ω ≈ ω_p, the dominant pole has already attenuated the signal by ω_p/ω₁ = C_L/C:\n\n$$|H(j\\omega_{180})|\\approx\\frac{A_0^3}{2}\\cdot\\frac{C}{C_L}$$\n\nThe required gain grows linearly with C_L while the available gain A₀³ is fixed. Oscillation therefore requires (exactly, via Routh–Hurwitz):\n\n$$A_0^3 > 2\\frac{C_L}{C}+4+2\\frac{C}{C_L}\\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad \\boxed{C_L \\lesssim \\frac{A_0^3}{2}\\,C}$$\n\nFor arbitrarily large C_L, the loop gain falls below unity before the phase reaches 180° — positive phase margin — and the Barkhausen criterion fails.\n\n## What the circuit does instead\n\nIt quietly settles at its unique dc point: every inverter sits at its **trip point** (V_in = V_out ≈ V_DD/2), drawing static current. Intuitively, node X moves so slowly that the fast path (inv2 → inv3 → inv1) acts as high‑speed *negative* feedback that **servos node X to the trip point** before it can swing past it. Since a plain inverter has no hysteresis, there is no regenerative \"snap\" — which is why the \"it just oscillates slower\" intuition (valid for a Schmitt‑trigger relaxation oscillator) fails here.\n\nThis is exactly the mechanism used deliberately in op‑amps: make one pole dominant → stable loop.\n\n## Practical notes\n\n- With A₀ ≈ 20–30 per stage, A₀³ ~ 10⁴, so C_L must be ~10⁴× the node capacitance before oscillation dies — large, but \"arbitrarily large\" certainly gets there.\n- To lower a ring oscillator's frequency, slow **all** stages equally (load every node, or current‑starve the inverters). With identical poles the condition stays A₀ ≥ 2 and the ring oscillates at arbitrarily low frequency — it's making one pole *dominant* that kills the oscillation.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "11709ca2a3a18803837e647d8ce9d8a6d0b13306dd2ce2d009cb21b7b8ffc493"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that arbitrarily large loading on one node can stop oscillation, and explains the dominant-pole gain roll-off and resulting failure of the Barkhausen condition. The additional phase, threshold, and settling explanations are consistent with the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f6dd3ed123c88a59472f7a76de74df7e33b3e73498632bd24bc1ea808e4efcbc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2290,
        "output_tokens": 17677,
        "total_tokens": 19967,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 16470,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2290,
        "output_tokens": 17677,
        "total_tokens": 19967,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 16470,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "If we double the widths of the NMOS and PMOS devices in the figure, what happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Circuit Identification\n\nThe figure shows a **three-stage CMOS inverter ring oscillator** (output of the last stage fed back to the first).\n\n## Effect of Doubling W\n\n**Scaling consequences (2W for all devices):**\n\n| Quantity | Scaling |\n|---|---|\n| Drain current available to charge/discharge each node, $I_D$ | ×2 |\n| Transconductance $g_m$ | ×2 |\n| Node capacitance ($C_{GS}, C_{GD}, C_{DB}$) | ×2 |\n| Output swing (rail-to-rail, $\\approx V_{DD}$) | unchanged |\n\n**Oscillation frequency:** The delay per stage is\n\n$$\nt_d \\propto \\frac{C \\,\\Delta V}{I_D} \\;\\longrightarrow\\; \\frac{(2C)\\,\\Delta V}{2I_D} = t_d\n$$\n\nso $f_{osc} = \\dfrac{1}{2N t_d}$ is **unchanged**.\n\n**Phase noise:** Using the Hajimiri/ISF formulation,\n\n$$\n\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta\\omega) \\propto \\frac{\\overline{i_n^2}/\\Delta f}{q_{max}^2\\,\\Delta\\omega^2}\n= \\frac{4kT\\gamma g_m}{(C\\,V_{DD})^2\\,\\Delta\\omega^2}\n$$\n\n- Injected noise current PSD: $4kT\\gamma g_m \\rightarrow$ **doubles**\n- Maximum charge swing: $q_{max}= C\\,V_{DD} \\rightarrow$ **doubles**, so $q_{max}^2$ **quadruples**\n\n$$\n\\mathcal{L} \\;\\longrightarrow\\; \\frac{2}{4}\\,\\mathcal{L} = \\frac{\\mathcal{L}}{2}\n$$\n\n## Result\n\n**The phase noise falls by 3 dB (a factor of 2), while the oscillation frequency stays the same and the power dissipation doubles.**\n\n### Intuition\n\nDoubling all widths is equivalent to connecting **two identical copies of the original oscillator in parallel**, node by node. The signals add *coherently* (in phase), while the device noise sources are *uncorrelated* and add in power — yielding the classic 3‑dB improvement. The same argument applies to the flicker-noise region, since $\\overline{v_{n,1/f}^2} \\propto 1/(WLC_{ox})$ also halves.\n\nThis illustrates the fundamental **phase noise–power trade-off** in oscillators: for a fixed topology and supply, $\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f) \\propto 1/P_{diss}$ — every doubling of power buys 3 dB of phase noise.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f7d73b2ed59de1c9ab1920d3b420fabe89544bcf78325e30a65478a224a6fced"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly predicts a 3 dB reduction and supports it with the valid scaling: device noise current power doubles while squared signal charge increases fourfold. The parallel-rings intuition and unchanged-frequency conclusion are also consistent with the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f9299196b0b81aa8f665614cd6e16eba9d8392f73cfe6422876d92d225ddc94e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3615,
        "output_tokens": 3034,
        "total_tokens": 6649,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2110,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3615,
        "output_tokens": 3034,
        "total_tokens": 6649,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2110,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "If we double the widths of the NMOS and PMOS devices in the figure, what happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting Up the Problem\n\nThe figure is a **three-stage CMOS inverter ring oscillator**. Doubling all transistor widths (with fixed *V_DD* and channel lengths) scales the circuit as follows:\n\n| Quantity | Scaling with 2× width |\n|---|---|\n| Drive current *I_D* | × 2 |\n| Node capacitance *C* (gate + junction caps) | × 2 |\n| Stage delay ∝ *CV/I* | **unchanged** |\n| Oscillation frequency | **unchanged** |\n| Output swing | **unchanged** (still rail-to-rail) |\n| Power dissipation | × 2 |\n\n## Effect on Phase Noise\n\nThe thermal noise current PSD of each device, $\\overline{i_n^2} = 4kT\\gamma g_m$, **doubles** (since $g_m \\propto W$). However, the impedance each noise current sees is reduced: the effective resistance scales as $1/g_m$ (halved) while *C* doubles, so the noise **voltage** at each node scales as:\n\n$$\n\\overline{v_n^2} \\propto \\overline{i_n^2}\\cdot R^2 \\;\\propto\\; (2)\\times\\left(\\tfrac{1}{2}\\right)^2 = \\tfrac{1}{2}\n$$\n\nSince the carrier swing is unchanged, the phase noise **drops by a factor of 2, i.e., improves by 3 dB** — in both the $1/f^2$ region and the $1/f^3$ region (flicker noise PSD $\\propto 1/(WLC_{ox})$ is also halved).\n\n## Intuitive View\n\nDoubling all widths is exactly equivalent to **connecting two identical copies of the original oscillator in parallel**, node for node. The signals add coherently while the noise of the two copies adds incoherently (in power), so the relative noise power halves.\n\n## Bottom Line\n\n- Oscillation frequency and amplitude: **unchanged**\n- Phase noise: **reduced by 3 dB**\n- Power consumption: **doubled**\n\nThis illustrates the fundamental **phase noise–power trade-off**: linear scaling by a factor *N* buys $10\\log N$ dB of phase noise improvement at the cost of *N*× the power (the oscillator figure of merit stays constant).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0726c3458bcd6c2a6f1f80eb03063a762ed3eaaab35b5937f905d81ba42af389"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes a 3 dB phase-noise reduction and supports it with valid width-scaling and parallel-ring reasoning. The current-noise PSD doubles, while the reduced node impedance yields half the noise-voltage power; the stated power trade-off is also consistent.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f9299196b0b81aa8f665614cd6e16eba9d8392f73cfe6422876d92d225ddc94e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3615,
        "output_tokens": 2791,
        "total_tokens": 6406,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2024,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3615,
        "output_tokens": 2791,
        "total_tokens": 6406,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2024,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "If we double the widths of the NMOS and PMOS devices in the figure, what happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nThe phase noise **drops by 3 dB (a factor of 2)**, while the oscillation frequency stays the same and the power dissipation doubles.\n\n## Why\n\nThe figure is a three-stage CMOS inverter ring oscillator. Doubling all widths is equivalent to connecting **two identical ring oscillators in parallel** (node by node). Consider what scales and what doesn't:\n\n**Frequency is unchanged:**\n- Each node capacitance doubles: $C \\rightarrow 2C$\n- Each transistor's current drive doubles, so the effective switching resistance halves: $R \\rightarrow R/2$\n- The stage delay $\\propto RC$ is therefore constant, so $f_{osc}$ does not change.\n\n**Signal swing is unchanged:**\n- The inverters still swing rail to rail (set by $V_{DD}$), so the carrier power is the same.\n\n**Noise power is halved:**\n- Each device's noise current PSD doubles: $\\overline{I_n^2} \\propto 4kT\\gamma g_m \\rightarrow 2\\times$\n- But this current flows into half the impedance, so the noise *voltage* at each node scales as\n\n$$\n\\overline{V_n^2} = \\overline{I_n^2}\\,|Z|^2 \\;\\longrightarrow\\; (2\\,\\overline{I_n^2})\\left(\\frac{|Z|}{2}\\right)^2 = \\frac{1}{2}\\,\\overline{V_n^2}\n$$\n\nSince phase noise is noise power relative to (unchanged) carrier power:\n\n$$\n\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f) \\;\\rightarrow\\; \\frac{\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f)}{2} \\quad \\Rightarrow \\quad -3\\ \\text{dB}\n$$\n\nThe same conclusion holds in the $1/f^3$ region, since flicker noise PSD $\\propto 1/(WLC_{ox})$ also halves when $W$ doubles.\n\n## The trade-off\n\nThe improvement is not free: the bias currents double, so **power consumption doubles**. This illustrates a general scaling law for oscillators — scaling all device widths (and currents) by a factor $K$ reduces phase noise by $K$ at the cost of $K$ times the power, i.e., a 3 dB improvement per doubling of power.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f663a6cbe7c838c96a16aaf3a690cf4f09dedc7f01c18befbf0fc3197dbb69b5"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly gives a 3 dB phase-noise reduction, unchanged frequency, and doubled power. Its scaling argument is consistent with the golden solution: device noise current doubles while the lower node impedance reduces noise voltage power by half.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f9299196b0b81aa8f665614cd6e16eba9d8392f73cfe6422876d92d225ddc94e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3615,
        "output_tokens": 2236,
        "total_tokens": 5851,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1464,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3615,
        "output_tokens": 2236,
        "total_tokens": 5851,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1464,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Determine the small-signal resistance seen looking into the supply node of the ring oscillator in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting Up the Problem\n\nTo find the small‑signal resistance $R_X$, bias the ring at its (metastable) trip point — every inverter input/output sits at the switching threshold, both devices in saturation — apply a test voltage $\\Delta V$ at the supply node, and compute the current $\\Delta I$ drawn. Each inverter has a PMOS (source at the supply node, n‑well tied to it, so **no body effect**) and an NMOS (source grounded).\n\n## Key Observation: Symmetry\n\nThe ring is cyclically symmetric, and the supply perturbation drives all three stages identically. Therefore **all three internal nodes rise by the same amount** $\\Delta V_o$.\n\n*Check with KCL:* writing KCL at each output node $k$ (input $v_{k-1}$, output $v_k$):\n\n$$(g_{mN}+g_{mP})\\,v_{k-1} + (g_{oN}+g_{oP})\\,v_k = (g_{mP}+g_{oP})\\,\\Delta V$$\n\nThis circulant system is nonsingular and forces $v_1=v_2=v_3$. ✓\n\n## Consequence: Every Device is Diode-Connected\n\nSince the input and output of each inverter move **equally**, every transistor sees its gate and drain shorted incrementally — i.e., each behaves as a diode-connected device:\n\n$$r_P = \\frac{1}{g_{mP} + r_{oP}^{-1}}, \\qquad r_N = \\frac{1}{g_{mN} + r_{oN}^{-1}}$$\n\nSo each inverter presents, from supply to ground, the **series** path $r_P + r_N$, and the three identical stages appear in **parallel**:\n\n$$\\boxed{R_X = \\frac{1}{3}\\left[\\frac{1}{g_{mP} + r_{oP}^{-1}} + \\frac{1}{g_{mN} + r_{oN}^{-1}}\\right] \\;\\approx\\; \\frac{1}{3}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{mP}} + \\frac{1}{g_{mN}}\\right)}$$\n\nFor matched transconductances $g_{mN}=g_{mP}=g_m$:\n\n$$R_X \\approx \\frac{2}{3\\,g_m}$$\n\n## Remarks\n\n- **Verification:** Direct nodal analysis gives $\\Delta I = 3\\,\\Delta V \\dfrac{(g_{mP}+g_{oP})(g_{mN}+g_{oN})}{g_{mP}+g_{oP}+g_{mN}+g_{oN}}$, which reproduces the boxed result.\n- The internal nodes move by $\\Delta V_o \\approx \\Delta V\\, \\dfrac{g_{mP}}{g_{mN}+g_{mP}} \\approx \\Delta V/2$ — the trip point tracks roughly half the supply change, which is the root of ring-oscillator supply pushing.\n- $R_X$ is quite **low** (e.g., $g_m = 5$ mS gives $R_X \\approx 133\\ \\Omega$), meaning a ring oscillator loads its supply/regulator heavily and couples supply noise efficiently — a key reason ring VCOs usually require dedicated regulation.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "15598274c876e4cf28b918ebed8295d954276d95b3d9889a5cac36da9e746b51"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The static symmetry and diode-connected-device analysis is internally consistent, but it ignores the oscillation-driven charging and discharging of the load capacitances that sets the supply resistance. The golden solution specifically assigns this gm-based result a score of 1.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "567a4e1905413cda5af92a626cb359563db923ba665d1835ff2377a534cd5d21",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3446,
        "output_tokens": 8908,
        "total_tokens": 12354,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7830,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3446,
        "output_tokens": 8908,
        "total_tokens": 12354,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7830,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Determine the small-signal resistance seen looking into the supply node of the ring oscillator in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting Up the Operating Point\n\nFor small‑signal analysis, bias the ring at its (metastable) equilibrium: since the three identical inverters form a loop with an odd number of inversions, the only DC solution is **all inputs and outputs sitting at the inverter trip point**, $V_{in}=V_{out}=V_M$. There, *both* transistors of every inverter are in saturation, carrying the same bias current, with transconductances $g_{mn},\\,g_{mp}$ and output resistances $r_{on},\\,r_{op}$.\n\n## Key Observation: Symmetry\n\nApply a test voltage $v_x$ to the supply node and ask how the internal nodes move. The KCL equation at the output of stage $i$ is\n\n$$g_{mp}(v_x-v_{i-1})+\\frac{v_x-v_i}{r_{op}}=g_{mn}\\,v_{i-1}+\\frac{v_i}{r_{on}}$$\n\nThis has the same form for all three stages, and the loop has a unique DC solution — so **all three node perturbations are equal**: $v_1=v_2=v_3$. (For a symmetric inverter they all move by $\\approx v_x/2$.)\n\nTherefore every inverter sees $v_{in}=v_{out}$, i.e., **each transistor is effectively diode-connected** (gate tied to drain in the small-signal sense).\n\n## Resistance of One Stage\n\nEach inverter, from $V_{DD}$ to ground, thus looks like two diode-connected devices in series:\n\n$$R_{stage}= \\underbrace{\\frac{1}{g_{mp}}\\Big\\Vert r_{op}}_{\\text{PMOS}}\\;+\\;\\underbrace{\\frac{1}{g_{mn}}\\Big\\Vert r_{on}}_{\\text{NMOS}}\\;\\approx\\;\\frac{1}{g_{mp}}+\\frac{1}{g_{mn}}$$\n\n## Combining the Three Stages\n\nThe three inverters appear in parallel at the supply node:\n\n$$\\boxed{\\,R_X=\\frac{1}{3}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{mp}}\\Big\\Vert r_{op}+\\frac{1}{g_{mn}}\\Big\\Vert r_{on}\\right)\\;\\approx\\;\\frac{1}{3}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{mp}}+\\frac{1}{g_{mn}}\\right)\\,}$$\n\nFor matched devices ($g_{mn}=g_{mp}=g_m$):\n\n$$R_X\\approx\\frac{2}{3g_m}$$\n\n## Remarks\n\n- **Generalization:** an $N$-stage ring gives $R_X\\approx\\frac{1}{N}\\left(g_{mn}^{-1}+g_{mp}^{-1}\\right)$.\n- **Consistency check:** during actual oscillation, at any instant one PMOS (gate pulled low by the previous stage) is charging its load from $V_{DD}$, so $\\partial I_{DD}/\\partial V_{DD}\\approx g_{mp}$ — again a resistance on the order of $1/g_m$.\n- **Design implication:** the oscillator presents a *low* resistance (hundreds of ohms for mS-level $g_m$) to the supply — much lower than the \"DC\" value $V_{DD}/I_{DD}$ — which is important when designing a regulator/LDO to drive the ring and when evaluating supply pushing.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "102c34d1d5ba5093b95a7d5cc17d50cdeb09bad0e8589f8feb363f2263c94307"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The answer derives a static, metastable gm-based resistance and misses the dominant oscillation-driven charging and discharging of the load capacitances, which sets the supply resistance. Its brief claim about charging during oscillation does not recover the required capacitance- and frequency-dependent result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "567a4e1905413cda5af92a626cb359563db923ba665d1835ff2377a534cd5d21",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3446,
        "output_tokens": 28810,
        "total_tokens": 32256,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 27659,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3446,
        "output_tokens": 28810,
        "total_tokens": 32256,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 27659,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Determine the small-signal resistance seen looking into the supply node of the ring oscillator in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting Up\n\nAssume the three inverters are identical and consider the circuit at its small‑signal operating point (each inverter at its trip point, $V_{in}=V_{out}$, both devices in saturation). Apply a test voltage $v_x$ at the supply node and find the current $i_x$; note that $v_x$ reaches the circuit only through the three PMOS sources.\n\n**Key symmetry argument:** Since the three stages are identical and connected in a loop, a perturbation $v_x$ on the common supply moves all three output nodes by the *same* amount $v$. But each inverter's input *is* the previous stage's output, so every inverter sees\n\n$$v_{in} = v_{out} = v$$\n\ni.e., **each inverter behaves as if it were diode-connected.**\n\n## Verifying with KCL\n\nAt the output of any stage (input $v$, output $v$, supply $v_x$):\n\n$$\\underbrace{\\left(g_{mP}+\\tfrac{1}{r_{OP}}\\right)(v_x - v)}_{\\text{PMOS current}} \\;=\\; \\underbrace{\\left(g_{mN}+\\tfrac{1}{r_{ON}}\\right)v}_{\\text{NMOS current}}$$\n\n$$\\Rightarrow\\quad v = v_x\\,\\frac{g_{mP}+r_{OP}^{-1}}{g_{mN}+g_{mP}+r_{ON}^{-1}+r_{OP}^{-1}}$$\n\nEach stage draws $\\left(g_{mP}+r_{OP}^{-1}\\right)(v_x-v)$ from the supply, and three stages conduct in parallel:\n\n$$i_x = 3\\,\\frac{\\left(g_{mP}+r_{OP}^{-1}\\right)\\left(g_{mN}+r_{ON}^{-1}\\right)}{g_{mN}+g_{mP}+r_{ON}^{-1}+r_{OP}^{-1}}\\;v_x$$\n\n## Result\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;R_X=\\frac{1}{3}\\left[\\frac{1}{g_{mP}}\\,\\Big\\Vert\\, r_{OP} \\;+\\; \\frac{1}{g_{mN}}\\,\\Big\\Vert\\, r_{ON}\\right]\\;\\approx\\;\\frac{1}{3}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{mN}}+\\frac{1}{g_{mP}}\\right)}$$\n\n**Interpretation:** looking into $V_{DD}$, the ring appears as **three diode‑connected PMOS–NMOS stacks in parallel** — each stack contributing $1/g_{mP}+1/g_{mN}$. For an $N$-stage ring the $3$ simply becomes $N$.\n\nFor example, with $g_{mN}=g_{mP}=g_m$ and $g_m r_O \\gg 1$:\n\n$$R_X \\approx \\frac{2}{3g_m}$$\n\nThis is quite a *low* resistance (on the order of $1/g_m$), which is why ring oscillators load their supply/regulator heavily and exhibit significant supply sensitivity.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "29f80968728418611ef277764ed58e49abc4bdd76cd83fea13b1387d95e05f7a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The static diode-connected small-signal derivation is internally consistent, but it ignores the oscillation-driven charging and discharging of the load capacitances, the dominant mechanism setting the supply resistance. The golden solution explicitly assigns this static gm-based answer a score of 1.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "567a4e1905413cda5af92a626cb359563db923ba665d1835ff2377a534cd5d21",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3446,
        "output_tokens": 9964,
        "total_tokens": 13410,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8925,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3446,
        "output_tokens": 9964,
        "total_tokens": 13410,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8925,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-006-oscillates-change",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "For the ring oscillator in the figure, somebody computes the small-signal resistance `RX`\nseen looking into the supply node as\n\n```text\nRX ~= (1/3) (1/gmn + 1/gmp)\n```\n\nwhere `gmn` and `gmp` are the transconductances of the NMOS and PMOS devices in each\ninverter, because each inverter behaves as two diode-connected devices in series.\n\nIf the circuit oscillates, does this answer change?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-006-oscillates-change/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nYes — fundamentally. The expression\n\n$$R_X \\approx \\frac{1}{3}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{mn}}+\\frac{1}{g_{mp}}\\right)$$\n\nis the resistance of the ring **held at its DC trip point**. Once the circuit oscillates, that operating point no longer exists, and the supply node no longer presents a single, well-defined small-signal resistance.\n\n## Why the formula is correct *only* at the balanced point\n\nAt the (metastable) DC solution, all three nodes sit at the trip voltage $V_M$ where $V_{in}=V_{out}$, and all six transistors are **saturated and conducting**. If $V_X$ is perturbed by $\\Delta V_X$, symmetry forces every internal node to move by the same amount $\\Delta$. Hence for every transistor, gate and drain move together — the small-signal definition of a diode connection. Each inverter then looks like $1/g_{mp}$ in series with $1/g_{mn}$, and three such branches in parallel give the quoted $R_X$.\n\nNote that this equilibrium is **unstable** — three inverting stages satisfy the startup condition — so this is the resistance of a circuit you would have to artificially hold at balance.\n\n## What changes during oscillation\n\n1. **The operating point becomes periodic in time.** Nodes swing (nearly) rail to rail. For most of the cycle each inverter has one device **cut off** and the other in **deep triode**; both devices conduct simultaneously only during the brief switching (crowbar) intervals. The trip-point values of $g_{mn}, g_{mp}$ are irrelevant for most of the period.\n\n2. **The diode-connected equivalence collapses.** It relied on each inverter's input and output moving identically; while oscillating, the input and output move in opposite directions and at staggered times.\n\n3. **There is no quasi-static resistive path.** With one device off, an inverter provides no DC path from $V_X$ to ground. The supply current consists of periodic pulses charging the node capacitances, plus short crowbar spikes. The instantaneous incremental resistance $R_X(t)$ swings from essentially open-circuit (between transitions) down to small values (during crowbar) — it is a **periodically time-varying, nonlinear** port, not a resistor.\n\n4. **A test signal mixes with the oscillation.** A small perturbation on $V_X$ modulates the delays (supply pushing), producing current components at $f_{test}$, $f_0 \\pm f_{test}$, etc., and partly converts into frequency/phase modulation of the oscillation. A single small-signal $R_X$ is no longer even well defined.\n\n5. **The measurable \"resistance\" is set by switching, not by trip-point $g_m$'s.** What you can measure is the quasi-static slope\n\n$$R_{eff}=\\frac{dV_{DD}}{d\\bar{I}_{DD}}, \\qquad \\bar{I}_{DD}\\approx 3\\,C_{node}V_{DD}\\,f_{osc}(V_{DD}) + \\bar{I}_{crowbar},$$\n\nwhich depends on node capacitance and on how $f_{osc}$ varies with supply — generally a different value (and a different physical mechanism) than $\\tfrac{1}{3}(1/g_{mn}+1/g_{mp})$.\n\n## Bottom line\n\nThe computed $R_X$ answers the question \"what does the ring look like if it sits quietly at its trip point?\" An oscillating ring never does. Its supply port becomes a time-varying, nonlinear load dominated by dynamic charging current, so the answer indeed changes — in fact, the question \"what is $R_X$?\" ceases to have a single-number answer.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c7f57f4e6e4b331a316e48989d871e5f5f2c36f25613722414ff45e645d37824"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies capacitive switching as the source of average supply current and gives its dependence on capacitance and oscillation frequency. But it does not show that the resulting resistance remains on the order of the MOS on-resistance; instead, it emphasizes that the resistance fundamentally changes or is not well-defined, missing the key magnitude conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "41b3aba626dbabae7c16266607298d97003b7365b7c8eebf62086ccaef8b74fa",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3560,
        "output_tokens": 12073,
        "total_tokens": 15633,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10836,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3560,
        "output_tokens": 12073,
        "total_tokens": 15633,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10836,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-006-oscillates-change",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "For the ring oscillator in the figure, somebody computes the small-signal resistance `RX`\nseen looking into the supply node as\n\n```text\nRX ~= (1/3) (1/gmn + 1/gmp)\n```\n\nwhere `gmn` and `gmp` are the transconductances of the NMOS and PMOS devices in each\ninverter, because each inverter behaves as two diode-connected devices in series.\n\nIf the circuit oscillates, does this answer change?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-006-oscillates-change/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nYes — fundamentally. The result\n\n$$R_X \\approx \\frac{1}{3}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{mn}}+\\frac{1}{g_{mp}}\\right)$$\n\nis valid **only if the ring sits at its dc (metastable) operating point**. Once the circuit oscillates, that bias point no longer exists, and the whole small-signal picture collapses.\n\n## Why the formula was correct at the dc point\n\nWith the loop closed and no oscillation, the only dc solution is all three nodes at the inverter trip point, where $V_{in}=V_{out}$ for every stage. If you perturb the supply by $\\Delta V$, symmetry forces all three internal nodes to move by the *same* increment — so every transistor's gate and drain move together, i.e., each device really is incrementally diode-connected. Each inverter then presents $1/g_{mp}+1/g_{mn}$ from supply to ground, and three such branches in parallel give the stated $R_X$. (All devices are saturated and conducting the full crowbar current — this is key below.)\n\n## What changes under oscillation\n\n1. **No fixed operating point.** The nodes swing rail-to-rail along a limit cycle. A small-signal resistance is defined about a bias point; here the \"bias\" is a periodic trajectory, so the circuit is a **nonlinear, periodically time-varying** system. Strictly, a single number $R_X$ doesn't exist — the incremental resistance becomes a periodic function of time, $R_X(t)$. (A small test tone on $V_{DD}$ even produces mixing sidebands around the oscillation harmonics, not just an in-band current.)\n\n2. **The diode-connected picture breaks.** During most of each period, every inverter has its input at a rail: one device is **off** and the other is in **deep triode**. There is then *no resistive path* from $V_{DD}$ to ground — the supply only sees on-PMOS switches holding nodes that are already at $V_{DD}$, plus capacitance. The low-frequency incremental resistance is therefore very high for most of the cycle. Only during the brief switching transitions do both devices of one stage conduct (crowbar), momentarily giving a low resistance — and even then the gates are driven by the previous stage, not tied to the drains, so the value is not $1/g_{mn}+1/g_{mp}$.\n\n3. **The average loading is set by switching, not by $g_m$.** For supply variations slow compared to the oscillation, the meaningful quantity is $dV_{DD}/d\\langle I_{DD}\\rangle$, where\n\n$$\\langle I_{DD}\\rangle \\approx 3\\,f_{osc}\\,C_{node}\\,V_{DD} \\;+\\; \\text{(average crowbar current)},$$\n\nand $f_{osc}$ itself depends on $V_{DD}$. This effective resistance depends on frequency, node capacitance, and swing — quantities absent from the original formula. Typically it is **much larger** than $(1/3)(1/g_{mn}+1/g_{mp})$: the metastable point is the worst case, with all six transistors conducting static crowbar current simultaneously, whereas during oscillation that path exists only for a small fraction of each period.\n\n## Bottom line\n\nThe computed $R_X$ describes only the non-oscillating, metastable condition. When the ring oscillates, $R_X$ becomes a periodically time-varying quantity whose cycle average is governed by dynamic (switching) currents — a completely different, generally much larger, value. This is exactly why supply sensitivity (\"pushing\") of ring oscillators must be analyzed with large-signal/averaged methods rather than with the trip-point small-signal model.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "45b2878c20c024742db6384a92531a1439add46631e3f6a9da154ac101339f0d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It recognizes that oscillation introduces capacitive switching current, but reaches the opposite central conclusion: it says the effective resistance is much larger because devices are off much of the cycle. The capacitive current and oscillation frequency together leave RX on the order of the MOS on-resistance, not much higher.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "41b3aba626dbabae7c16266607298d97003b7365b7c8eebf62086ccaef8b74fa",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3560,
        "output_tokens": 13797,
        "total_tokens": 17357,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12570,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3560,
        "output_tokens": 13797,
        "total_tokens": 17357,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12570,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-006-oscillates-change",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "For the ring oscillator in the figure, somebody computes the small-signal resistance `RX`\nseen looking into the supply node as\n\n```text\nRX ~= (1/3) (1/gmn + 1/gmp)\n```\n\nwhere `gmn` and `gmp` are the transconductances of the NMOS and PMOS devices in each\ninverter, because each inverter behaves as two diode-connected devices in series.\n\nIf the circuit oscillates, does this answer change?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-006-oscillates-change/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nYes. The expression is correct **only if the ring is sitting at its dc (non‑oscillating) operating point**. Once the circuit oscillates, the assumptions behind the small‑signal calculation collapse, and the supply node no longer presents a well-defined, time-invariant resistance at all — let alone $(1/3)(1/g_{mn}+1/g_{mp})$.\n\n## Why the formula is right when the ring is quiescent\n\nAt the dc equilibrium, all three nodes sit at the inverter trip point $V_M$, and all six devices are in saturation. If the supply is perturbed by $v_x$, the three-fold symmetry forces all three internal nodes to rise by the *same* amount $\\delta$. Thus for every stage the input and the output move identically — which is exactly the diode-connected condition:\n\n$$v_{gs,n} = v_{ds,n} = \\delta, \\qquad v_{sg,p} = v_{sd,p} = v_x - \\delta$$\n\nSo each inverter really does look like $1/g_{mp}$ in series with $1/g_{mn}$, and three such branches in parallel give\n\n$$R_X = \\frac{1}{3}\\left(\\frac{1}{g_{mn}}+\\frac{1}{g_{mp}}\\right)$$\n\n(neglecting $r_O$). A full nodal analysis of the loop confirms this — the result is not an accident of the hand-waving, it follows from the symmetry.\n\n## What changes when it oscillates\n\n1. **The operating point is no longer fixed.** The nodes swing essentially rail to rail, so each transistor periodically traverses cutoff → saturation → triode. The $g_m$'s in the formula don't exist as constants; they are large-signal, periodically time-varying quantities.\n\n2. **The \"two diodes in series\" path disappears most of the time.** At almost any instant, each inverter has one device **off**: an inverter with a high output has its NMOS cut off, one with a low output has its PMOS cut off. There is then *no resistive path* from $V_{DD}$ to ground through that stage — only a switch ($R_{on}$) charging a capacitor. A conductive (crowbar) path exists only during the brief switching transitions, and the three stages switch at different phases, so the symmetry argument never applies.\n\n3. **The circuit becomes periodically time-varying, not LTI.** If you inject a small test signal at frequency $\\omega$ into the supply, the current response contains components at $\\omega \\pm k\\omega_{osc}$, the oscillation frequency itself shifts (supply pushing), and near harmonics of $\\omega_{osc}$ you can even injection-lock the ring. A single real number $R_X$ simply cannot characterize this.\n\n4. **The meaningful \"resistance\" is set by switching current, not by $g_m$.** The average supply current of the oscillating ring is dominated by dynamic charging plus crowbar current:\n\n$$I_{DD} \\approx f_{osc}\\, C_{tot}\\, V_{DD} + I_{crowbar}$$\n\nso the effective (time-averaged, large-signal) incremental resistance is\n\n$$R_{X,\\text{eff}} = \\left(\\frac{dI_{DD}}{dV_{DD}}\\right)^{-1} = \\left[C_{tot}\\left(f_{osc} + V_{DD}\\frac{df_{osc}}{dV_{DD}}\\right) + \\cdots\\right]^{-1}$$\n\nwhich depends on load capacitance, frequency, and supply sensitivity — and bears no relation to $(1/3)(1/g_{mn}+1/g_{mp})$.\n\n## One more caveat\n\nThe operating point used in the original calculation is a **metastable (unstable) equilibrium** — that instability is precisely why the ring oscillates. So the computed $R_X$ is valid only in principle (e.g., with the loop broken or the oscillation somehow suppressed); in the real, running circuit you could never even measure it.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "e3643e2c874f3e2e2208a3dfda7baab1c829c2d96e4a2d67e4bbad30c6f37d36"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies charging of the node capacitances as a source of oscillating supply current and gives a related effective-resistance expression. But it incorrectly says the resistance bears no relation to the static estimate and does not establish that it remains on the order of the MOS on-resistance.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "41b3aba626dbabae7c16266607298d97003b7365b7c8eebf62086ccaef8b74fa",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3560,
        "output_tokens": 11532,
        "total_tokens": 15092,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10220,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3560,
        "output_tokens": 11532,
        "total_tokens": 15092,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10220,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain as the width of M7 increases?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **StrongARM latch** (clocked comparator): M1–M2 form the input pair, M7 is the clocked tail transistor, M3–M6 form the cross-coupled regenerative pairs, and S1–S4 precharge the internal nodes when CK is low.\n\n## Initial Gain Analysis\n\nDuring the amplification phase (just after CK goes high), M1–M2 integrate their differential current onto the capacitances at X and Y. This phase lasts until X and Y fall by |V_THP|, turning on M5–M6 and starting regeneration:\n\n$$t_1 \\approx \\frac{C_X|V_{THP}|}{I_{D7}/2}$$\n\nThe differential voltage gain at the end of this phase is:\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_{m1,2}\\, t_1}{C_X} = \\frac{g_{m1,2}|V_{THP}|}{I_{D7}/2} = \\frac{2|V_{THP}|}{(V_{GS}-V_{TH})_{1,2}}$$\n\n## Effect of Increasing W₇\n\nA wider M7 draws a **larger tail current** $I_{D7} \\propto W_7$. This has two effects:\n\n1. **Shorter amplification time:** X and Y discharge faster, so $t_1 \\propto 1/I_{D7}$ shrinks.\n2. **Higher input-pair overdrive:** $(V_{GS}-V_{TH})_{1,2} \\propto \\sqrt{I_{D7}}$, while $g_{m1,2}$ grows only as $\\sqrt{I_{D7}}$.\n\nThe net result:\n\n$$A_v \\propto \\frac{\\sqrt{I_{D7}}}{I_{D7}} = \\frac{1}{\\sqrt{I_{D7}}} \\propto \\frac{1}{\\sqrt{W_7}}$$\n\n## Conclusion\n\n**The initial voltage gain *decreases* (roughly as $1/\\sqrt{W_7}$) as M7 is made wider.** This reflects a fundamental trade-off in the StrongARM latch: a larger tail transistor speeds up the decision (shorter integration/regeneration time) but reduces the pre-regeneration amplification, making the latch more susceptible to offset and noise contributed by M3–M6.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "9e7bc9ce1f8d1cc53cdd90b0b35f91d27197573e5a0b7634c2c78427dcd94e13"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that widening M7 increases tail current and decreases initial gain: the integration interval shortens while input-pair transconductance grows only sublinearly. Its specific threshold-based derivation is not essential to the correct trend.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3be19d840ea0028f994c70cfd93497080016f88968540a82c98a00f03980212f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4803,
        "output_tokens": 2909,
        "total_tokens": 7712,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2141,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4803,
        "output_tokens": 2909,
        "total_tokens": 7712,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2141,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain as the width of M7 increases?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **StrongARM latch** (clocked comparator). When CK goes high, M7 sinks the tail current $I_{SS}$, and M1–M2 act as a differential pair that discharges the precharged nodes P and Q. This \"amplification phase\" lasts until P and Q drop by one threshold voltage, at which point M3–M4 turn on and regeneration begins.\n\n## Gain Analysis\n\n**Amplification time:** M3/M4 switch on when P, Q fall by $V_{TH3,4}$. Since each branch discharges its node capacitance $C_{P,Q}$ at roughly $I_{SS}/2$:\n\n$$t_1 \\approx \\frac{2\\,C_{P,Q}\\,V_{TH3,4}}{I_{SS}}$$\n\n**Differential voltage built up during this time** (the input pair integrates its differential current onto $C_{P,Q}$):\n\n$$|\\Delta V_{PQ}| = \\frac{g_{m1,2}\\,\\Delta V_{in}}{C_{P,Q}}\\,t_1$$\n\n**Initial voltage gain:**\n\n$$A_{v0} = \\frac{g_{m1,2}\\,t_1}{C_{P,Q}} = \\frac{2\\,g_{m1,2}\\,V_{TH3,4}}{I_{SS}}$$\n\nSince for the square-law input pair $g_{m1,2} = \\sqrt{\\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)_{1,2}\\,I_{SS}}$:\n\n$$\\boxed{A_{v0} = 2V_{TH3,4}\\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_n C_{ox}(W/L)_{1,2}}{I_{SS}}} \\;\\propto\\; \\frac{1}{\\sqrt{I_{SS}}}}$$\n\n## Answer\n\nWidening M7 increases $I_{SS}$ roughly proportionally, so **the initial voltage gain *decreases*** — approximately as $1/\\sqrt{W_7}$.\n\n**Intuition:** A larger tail current discharges P and Q faster, shortening the integration (amplification) time in proportion to $1/I_{SS}$, while $g_{m1,2}$ grows only as $\\sqrt{I_{SS}}$. The net effect is a lower gain — a trade-off against the faster speed, and it worsens the input-referred offset/noise contributed by the regenerative stage.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "31017c637e2a852ff94aed843ca295ee429549fc8303f91bddd3cc67123199b3"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that widening M7 increases tail current and decreases initial gain, with a physically consistent explanation that current rises faster than the input-pair transconductance. The extra offset/noise aside does not affect the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3be19d840ea0028f994c70cfd93497080016f88968540a82c98a00f03980212f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4803,
        "output_tokens": 3217,
        "total_tokens": 8020,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2404,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4803,
        "output_tokens": 3217,
        "total_tokens": 8020,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2404,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain as the width of M7 increases?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Circuit Identification\n\nThis is a **StrongARM latch** (clocked comparator). M7 is the clocked tail device: when CK goes high, M7 turns on and the pair M1–M2 draws the tail current *I*SS, discharging nodes P/Q and then X/Y before the cross‑coupled pairs regenerate.\n\n## Initial Gain Analysis\n\nDuring the amplification phase (before M3/M4 switch on), M1 and M2 integrate their differential current onto the capacitance *C*P at nodes P and Q. This phase lasts until P and Q fall by one threshold, i.e.\n\n$$t_1 = \\frac{C_P V_{THN}}{I_{SS}/2}$$\n\nThe differential voltage developed in that time gives the initial gain:\n\n$$|A_v| = \\frac{g_{m1}\\, t_1}{C_P}\\cdot\\frac{1}{1} = \\frac{2\\,g_{m1} V_{THN}}{I_{SS}} = \\frac{2V_{THN}}{V_{GS1}-V_{TH1}}$$\n\nNote that *C*P cancels — the gain depends only on how much *g*m the pair provides **per unit of tail current**.\n\n## Effect of Increasing W₇\n\nA wider M7 presents a lower on-resistance, so the tail current *I*SS **increases**. However:\n\n$$g_{m1} \\propto \\sqrt{I_{SS}} \\quad\\Rightarrow\\quad |A_v| \\propto \\frac{\\sqrt{I_{SS}}}{I_{SS}} = \\frac{1}{\\sqrt{I_{SS}}}$$\n\nEquivalently, a larger *I*SS forces a larger overdrive voltage (V_GS − V_TH) on M1/M2, reducing their g_m/I_D.\n\n## Conclusion\n\n**The initial voltage gain *decreases*** (roughly as $1/\\sqrt{W_7}$) as M7 is made wider. \n\nThe trade-off: a wider M7 makes the latch *faster* (nodes discharge more quickly), but the weaker pre-amplification means the regenerative stage's offset and noise are referred to the input with less attenuation — degrading comparator accuracy.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "2e8bd0f14917ba9f26b8ae8e9793aef28954891f8d7b8641dfd61f2a9b9ccd19"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that increasing M7 width raises tail current while gm grows only roughly as the square root of current, so the initial gain decreases. This matches the essential trend and physical explanation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3be19d840ea0028f994c70cfd93497080016f88968540a82c98a00f03980212f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4803,
        "output_tokens": 3164,
        "total_tokens": 7967,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2429,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4803,
        "output_tokens": 3164,
        "total_tokens": 7967,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2429,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "In the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain if we increase the capacitance at nodes P and Q?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer: Nothing — the initial gain stays the same.\n\nThis is the StrongARM latch, and the question concerns its **amplification (integration) phase**: right after CK goes high, S₁–S₄ turn off, M₇ turns on, and M₁/M₂ discharge nodes P and Q from V_DD while M₃/M₄ are still off.\n\n**Why the capacitance cancels out:**\n\nDuring this phase the circuit acts as an integrator. The differential voltage at P and Q grows as:\n\n$$|\\Delta V_{PQ}(t)| = \\frac{g_{m1,2}\\,\\Delta V_{in}}{C_{P,Q}}\\, t$$\n\nThe phase ends at time $t_1$, when P and Q have fallen by one NMOS threshold ($V_{THN}$) and M₃/M₄ turn on. Since each node discharges at roughly $I_{SS}/2$:\n\n$$t_1 \\approx \\frac{C_{P,Q}\\, V_{THN}}{I_{SS}/2}$$\n\nThe voltage gain accumulated by the end of the phase is therefore:\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_{m1,2}\\, t_1}{C_{P,Q}} = \\frac{2\\, g_{m1,2}\\, V_{THN}}{I_{SS}} \\approx \\frac{2\\,V_{THN}}{V_{GS}-V_{TH}\\big|_{1,2}}$$\n\nThe capacitance appears in both the integration **rate** (denominator) and the integration **time** (numerator), so it cancels.\n\n**Intuition:** A larger $C_{P,Q}$ makes the differential signal build up more slowly, but it also takes proportionally longer for the common-mode level at P/Q to drop by $V_{THN}$ — so the signal integrates for a longer time. The two effects exactly offset each other.\n\n**What *does* change:** the comparator gets slower. $t_1$ grows in proportion to $C_{P,Q}$, delaying the onset of regeneration and increasing the total decision time — a speed penalty with no gain benefit.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a13e5c126f3bd924831c5ff2455a119385b15e1d2de422c03a7e2ce5720987e9"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes the initial gain is unchanged and explains that increased capacitance slows differential buildup while proportionally lengthening the amplification phase, so the capacitance cancels. It also correctly notes the speed penalty.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "181f6e0ce2e77c4df0e1602f9ce1b8891080eeecdff293462f41c7d6d66c5590",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4804,
        "output_tokens": 2717,
        "total_tokens": 7521,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2023,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4804,
        "output_tokens": 2717,
        "total_tokens": 7521,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2023,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "In the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain if we increase the capacitance at nodes P and Q?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer: Nothing — the initial gain is unchanged.\n\nThis circuit is a **StrongARM latch**, and the \"initial\" gain refers to the amplification phase right after CK goes high, when M₁–M₂ discharge nodes *P* and *Q* but M₃–M₄ have not yet turned on.\n\n## Why the capacitance cancels out\n\n**Common-mode discharge (sets the duration):**\nAfter CK rises, each input transistor pulls a current of roughly $I_{D1} \\approx I_{SS}/2$ out of its node. M₃ (and M₄) turn on when *P* and *Q* have fallen by one threshold voltage, $V_{THN}$, below the (precharged) gates at *X* and *Y*. This takes:\n\n$$t_1 = \\frac{C_P \\, V_{THN}}{I_{D1}}$$\n\n**Differential buildup (sets the slope):**\nMeanwhile, the input difference $\\Delta V_{in}$ creates a differential current $g_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}$, so the differential voltage grows as:\n\n$$\\Delta V_{PQ}(t) = \\frac{g_{m1}\\,\\Delta V_{in}}{C_P}\\, t$$\n\n**Gain at the end of this phase:**\n\n$$\\Delta V_{PQ}(t_1) = \\frac{g_{m1}\\,\\Delta V_{in}}{C_P}\\cdot\\frac{C_P\\,V_{THN}}{I_{D1}} \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; A_v = \\frac{g_{m1}}{I_{D1}}\\,V_{THN} \\approx \\frac{2V_{THN}}{V_{GS1}-V_{TH1}}$$\n\nThe $C_P$ terms **cancel**: a larger capacitance makes the differential voltage build up more slowly, but it also delays the turn-on of M₃/M₄ by exactly the same factor, giving the input pair proportionally more time to integrate.\n\n## What *does* change\n\n- **Speed:** $t_1$ increases linearly with $C_P$, so the latch takes longer to reach regeneration and the overall decision time grows.\n- **Noise:** the integrated $kT/C$-type noise at *P* and *Q* actually *decreases* with larger capacitance, which is why input-referred noise improves — at the cost of speed.\n\nSo increasing $C_P$ and $C_Q$ trades speed for noise, while leaving the initial voltage gain essentially constant.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "09ab1b275491d85c836edf5770cea4af7c659fb4917d54e3b9ce45fd4a634199"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes the initial gain is essentially unchanged: larger capacitance slows differential buildup but proportionally lengthens the amplification phase, so the capacitance cancels. The added speed/noise discussion is secondary.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "181f6e0ce2e77c4df0e1602f9ce1b8891080eeecdff293462f41c7d6d66c5590",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4804,
        "output_tokens": 2824,
        "total_tokens": 7628,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1994,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4804,
        "output_tokens": 2824,
        "total_tokens": 7628,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1994,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "In the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain if we increase the capacitance at nodes P and Q?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer: (to first order) nothing — the initial gain stays the same.\n\n**Why the capacitance cancels out**\n\nThis is a StrongARM latch. After CK goes high, M₁–M₂ act as a differential pair that *integrates* its currents onto the capacitances at P and Q. This \"amplification phase\" lasts only until P and Q have fallen by one NMOS threshold, $V_{THN}$, at which point M₃–M₄ turn on and the latch moves into regeneration.\n\nThe differential voltage built up at P/Q is:\n\n$$\\Delta V_{PQ}(t) = \\frac{g_{m1,2}\\,\\Delta V_{in}}{C_{P,Q}}\\; t$$\n\nThe amplification phase ends at the time $t_1$ when the common-mode level at P/Q has dropped by $V_{THN}$:\n\n$$t_1 \\approx \\frac{C_{P,Q}\\, V_{THN}}{I_{D1}}, \\qquad I_{D1}\\approx \\frac{I_{SS}}{2}$$\n\nSubstituting $t_1$ into the gain expression:\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_{m1,2}}{C_{P,Q}}\\cdot \\frac{C_{P,Q}\\,V_{THN}}{I_{D1}} = \\frac{g_{m1,2}\\,V_{THN}}{I_{D1}} \\approx \\frac{2V_{THN}}{V_{GS}-V_{TH}}\\bigg|_{M1,2}$$\n\nThe capacitance **cancels**: a larger $C_{P,Q}$ makes the integration slope shallower, but it *prolongs the integration time by exactly the same factor*, since P and Q now take longer to fall by $V_{THN}$.\n\n**What *does* change**\n\n- **Speed:** $t_1 \\propto C_{P,Q}$, so the latch takes longer to reach regeneration — the decision is slower.\n- **Noise (side benefit):** the longer integration window averages the noise of M₁–M₂ over more time, so the input-referred noise actually *decreases* with larger $C_{P,Q}$ — a trade-off sometimes exploited deliberately.\n\nSo increasing the capacitance at P and Q trades speed for lower noise, while the initial voltage gain $g_{m1,2}V_{THN}/I_{D1}$ remains unchanged.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "78d28a30ee6062c325e92c083b1b9eed2bb55e79a054c53c03dc5c94df73afd8"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes the initial gain is essentially unchanged and explains that the larger capacitance slows the differential buildup while proportionally extending the amplification phase, so capacitance cancels. The added speed and noise comments are secondary.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "181f6e0ce2e77c4df0e1602f9ce1b8891080eeecdff293462f41c7d6d66c5590",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4804,
        "output_tokens": 2659,
        "total_tokens": 7463,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1869,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4804,
        "output_tokens": 2659,
        "total_tokens": 7463,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1869,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "If we increase the widths of M5 and M6 in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nNeither unconditionally — there is a **trade‑off**, and beyond a modest width the latch actually gets **slower**. Wider M5/M6 raise the regeneration transconductance, but they also add capacitance to the critical nodes X and Y.\n\n## Why\n\nRecall the sequence after CK goes high in this StrongARM latch:\n\n1. **P, Q discharge** through M1/M2 (M5/M6 play no role here).\n2. **X, Y discharge** through M3/M4. The PMOS pair is still *off* until X (and Y) drop by |V_THP|.\n3. **Regeneration**: once M5/M6 turn on, the cross-coupled inverters (M3–M5 and M4–M6) regenerate with time constant\n\n$$\\tau_{reg} \\approx \\frac{C_{XY}}{g_{m3,4} + g_{m5,6}}$$\n\nIncreasing W₅,₆ affects two terms in opposite ways:\n\n**The benefit:** $g_{m5,6}$ grows roughly linearly with width, reducing $\\tau_{reg}$ — *provided* $C_{XY}$ is dominated by other capacitances (M3/M4, wiring, the next stage's input).\n\n**The penalty:** M5/M6 contribute gate, drain-junction, and overlap capacitance directly to X and Y. This:\n\n- Lengthens phase 2, since the PMOS turn-on is delayed by\n$$t_2 \\approx \\frac{C_{XY}\\,|V_{THP}|}{I_{SS}/2},$$\nwhich grows **linearly** with the added capacitance. (Interestingly, the seed voltage at the start of regeneration, $\\Delta V_0 \\approx |V_{THP}|\\cdot\\Delta I / (I_{SS}/2)$, is *independent* of $C_{XY}$ — so the extra cap buys no extra gain, only delay.)\n- Inflates the numerator of $\\tau_{reg}$, eating into the $g_m$ benefit.\n- Slightly lengthens the reset phase, since S₃/S₄ must precharge heavier nodes.\n\n## The limiting behavior\n\nIf we keep widening M5/M6, their self-capacitance eventually dominates $C_{XY}$, and the regeneration time constant saturates at the device's intrinsic limit:\n\n$$\\tau_{reg} \\rightarrow \\frac{C_{P}}{g_{mP}} \\approx \\frac{1}{\\omega_{T,P}}$$\n\ni.e., no further regeneration speedup is possible — while $t_2$ keeps growing linearly. The total decision time therefore **degrades** for large widths.\n\n## Conclusion\n\n- If X/Y are loaded mainly by *fixed* capacitance (routing, the following SR latch), a moderate increase in W₅,₆ **improves** speed.\n- Once the PMOS devices' own capacitance becomes a significant fraction of $C_{XY}$, further widening **degrades** speed.\n\nThere is thus an optimum width for M5 and M6; they should be made just large enough that their $g_m$ contribution pays for their capacitive load.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bd6bc45187ea86e21143fb57cf8c6d9c5448f106c6fc081fbce243b7b2eb08c4"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that widening M5/M6 initially improves speed by strengthening regeneration, while added node capacitance eventually limits the benefit and can cause degradation, yielding an optimum width.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5eed0194a609e5504312082df6fe7d71e18f6abfa8d0ff1bc1936ac8f33e2388",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4800,
        "output_tokens": 10534,
        "total_tokens": 15334,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9492,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4800,
        "output_tokens": 10534,
        "total_tokens": 15334,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9492,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "If we increase the widths of M5 and M6 in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nMostly it **degrades** the speed. Wider M5/M6 help only one thing (regeneration *gm*), but they hurt everything else through added capacitance at X and Y — and the capacitance penalty grows faster than the *gm* benefit. There is an optimum width, beyond which the latch slows down.\n\n## Why\n\nThis StrongARM latch operates in three phases after CK goes high:\n\n1. **P, Q discharge** through M1/M2 (M5, M6 still off).\n2. **X, Y discharge**: once M3/M4 turn on, X and Y fall from V_DD. M5/M6 remain **off** until X or Y drops by |V_THP|.\n3. **Regeneration**: M5/M6 finally conduct, and the cross-coupled pairs regenerate with time constant\n\n$$\\tau_{reg} \\approx \\frac{C_{X,Y}}{g_{m3,4}+g_{m5,6}}$$\n\nNow consider increasing W₅,₆:\n\n**The one benefit:** larger $g_{m5,6}$ → stronger positive feedback → smaller $\\tau_{reg}$ (for a *fixed* capacitance).\n\n**The costs:**\n\n- Because M5/M6 are cross-coupled, each output node is loaded by the drain capacitance of one PMOS *and* the full gate capacitance of the other. So $C_{X,Y}$ increases **linearly** with W₅,₆.\n- During phase 2, M5/M6 are **off** — they contribute *nothing but capacitance*. The time for X/Y to drop by |V_THP| is\n\n$$t \\approx \\frac{C_{X,Y}\\,|V_{THP}|}{I_{SS}/2},$$\n\nwhich grows linearly with W₅,₆. (Note the differential voltage built up by the onset of regeneration, ≈ ΔI·|V_THP|/(I_SS/2), is independent of C — so you gain nothing there, you only lose time.)\n- Even during regeneration, the current available is limited by the tail source, so $g_{m5,6} \\propto \\sqrt{W_{5,6}}$ at fixed current, while $C_{X,Y} \\propto W_{5,6}$. Hence $\\tau_{reg}$ improves sub-linearly, saturates, and for large widths actually **increases**.\n\n## Bottom line\n\nA slight increase can help if M5/M6 were initially very weak (regeneration-limited design), but in general making M5/M6 wider self-loads nodes X and Y, lengthens the amplification phase, and eventually lengthens regeneration itself. The overall delay therefore degrades — M5/M6 should be kept near the minimum size that provides adequate regeneration and pull-up to V_DD.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6b0d546ea0ec42ef1f04803171b0a3ea286afd2cdf5724aba582e8d733f91868"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the regenerative benefit of wider M5/M6 and the eventual capacitance limit, but concludes that widening generally degrades speed. The key result is that speed initially improves because the added capacitance is not dominant at first.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5eed0194a609e5504312082df6fe7d71e18f6abfa8d0ff1bc1936ac8f33e2388",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4800,
        "output_tokens": 7908,
        "total_tokens": 12708,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7000,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4800,
        "output_tokens": 7908,
        "total_tokens": 12708,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7000,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "If we increase the widths of M5 and M6 in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**In general, the speed degrades.** This is the StrongARM latch, and the key is to track what M5–M6 do during each phase of the decision.\n\n## Operation timeline (CK goes high)\n\n1. **Amplification phase:** M1–M2 draw a differential current and discharge P/Q, then X/Y (through M3–M4). During this entire phase, **M5 and M6 are OFF**, because X and Y start at V_DD and the PMOS devices cannot conduct until one node falls to V_DD − |V_THP|.\n2. **Regeneration phase:** Once X or Y crosses V_DD − |V_THP|, M5/M6 turn on and the two cross-coupled inverters regenerate with a time constant roughly\n\n$$\\tau_{reg} \\approx \\frac{C_{X,Y}}{g_{m,N} + g_{m,P}}$$\n\n## Effect of wider M5, M6\n\n**During amplification — pure penalty.** While off, M5 and M6 contribute *only capacitance* to X and Y (gate capacitance of each loads the opposite node, plus drain junction capacitance). Since the discharge current is fixed by M1/M2 and M7, the time to reach the PMOS turn-on point grows roughly in proportion to the added capacitance:\n\n$$t_1 \\approx \\frac{C_{X,Y}\\,|V_{THP}|}{I_{D1,2}} \\propto C_{X,Y}$$\n\nNote the differential voltage built up by time $t_1$ is roughly $(\\Delta I / I_{CM})|V_{THP}|$, which is *independent* of C — so the extra capacitance buys no additional pre-amplified signal; it only costs time.\n\n**During regeneration — nearly a wash.** Wider PMOS raises $g_{m5,6}$, but it raises $C_{X,Y}$ along with it, so $\\tau_{reg} = C/G_m$ improves only sublinearly and saturates at the PMOS intrinsic limit ($\\sim 1/\\omega_{T,p}$) — which is poor, since hole mobility makes the PMOS $g_m$-per-unit-capacitance about half that of the NMOS devices.\n\n## Bottom line\n\nThe added capacitance hurts linearly in the first phase while the regeneration benefit is marginal, so the total clock-to-decision time increases. M5/M6 should be sized only as large as needed to provide regeneration and restore the \"high\" output to V_DD; if more $g_m$ is desired for faster regeneration, it is better spent on the NMOS pair M3/M4. (The only exception is when X and Y are dominated by a large *external* load — then the extra $g_{m5,6}$ can pay off.)",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "b4bb7316d67a2f6c3a8aa011ce3b543ecc3d494f2be01b54116171da31aef374"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It notes both increased capacitance and increased PMOS transconductance, but concludes capacitance dominates and speed degrades. The key result is the opposite: stronger regeneration initially improves speed, with added capacitance limiting the benefit only at larger widths.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5eed0194a609e5504312082df6fe7d71e18f6abfa8d0ff1bc1936ac8f33e2388",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4800,
        "output_tokens": 7083,
        "total_tokens": 11883,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6188,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4800,
        "output_tokens": 7083,
        "total_tokens": 11883,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6188,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting Up the Trade‑off\n\nIn this dynamic ÷2 divider, the clocked transistors act as series switches between the data transistors (M₁ and the input PMOS) and the critical nodes *X* and *Y*. Making them wider has **two opposing effects**:\n\n**Benefit — lower series resistance:**\nWhen a stage is transparent, node *X* (or *Y*) charges/discharges through *two* devices in series. Widening the clocked device reduces its on‑resistance, increasing the available current.\n\n**Penalty — more capacitance:**\n- The **drains** of the clocked transistors sit directly on *X* and *Y*, so their junction capacitance loads the critical nodes in proportion to *W*.\n- Their **sources** add capacitance to the internal stack nodes, worsening charge sharing when the stage turns on.\n- Their **gates** load the clock, degrading the CK/C̅K̅ edges (or demanding a bigger clock buffer) and increasing clock feedthrough glitches at *X* and *Y*.\n\n## Why the Improvement Saturates\n\nWrite the time constant at node *X*:\n\n$$\\tau \\approx \\left(R_{M1} + \\frac{r}{W_{ck}}\\right)\\left(C_0 + c\\,W_{ck}\\right)$$\n\nwhere $C_0$ is the fixed load (next stage's gates, wiring) and $c\\,W_{ck}$ is the clocked device's junction capacitance.\n\n- As $W_{ck}$ increases, the resistance term **saturates at $R_{M1}$** — the current is ultimately limited by the data transistors M₁ and the input PMOS, which the clocked devices cannot overcome.\n- Meanwhile the capacitive term **grows without bound** ($\\propto W_{ck}$).\n\nMinimizing τ gives an optimum width:\n\n$$W_{ck,\\,opt} = \\sqrt{\\frac{r\\,C_0}{R_{M1}\\,c}}$$\n\n## Conclusion\n\nThe speed **improves only up to a moderate width** (comparable to the data devices). Beyond that optimum, the speed **degrades**: the extra drain capacitance at *X* and *Y* and the heavier clock loading outweigh the diminishing reduction in on‑resistance. Simply making the clocked transistors very wide therefore *hurts* the maximum division speed — the clocked and data devices must be sized together, not independently.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c98b2d0854a97b7e16f44f11a23a95e8fd854ef5665759ecb6d266226902f7e3"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that widening initially improves speed by reducing the clocked transistors’ on-resistance, while added capacitance at X and Y eventually limits or reverses the benefit, producing an optimum width.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "93d9b522d441668a699cc09168ad1991cf00bb982a5ad716cae0b7c7bec7c4fd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2220,
        "output_tokens": 6733,
        "total_tokens": 8953,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5934,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2220,
        "output_tokens": 6733,
        "total_tokens": 8953,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5934,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## The trade‑off\n\nThis is a ÷2 circuit built from two C²MOS (clocked‑inverter) latches in a loop with Inv₃. Its maximum clock rate is set by how quickly the stacks can charge/discharge nodes *X* and *Y*. The clocked transistors affect this in **two opposing ways**:\n\n**Benefit of wider clocked devices:**\nThey sit *in series* with the input transistors (M₁ and the top PMOS), so their on‑resistance subtracts from the available charging/discharging current. Widening them lowers this resistance and increases the stack current.\n\n**Penalty of wider clocked devices:**\n- Their drains connect *directly* to the output nodes *X* and *Y*, so their junction and gate–drain overlap capacitances load these nodes in proportion to their width.\n- The stack current cannot exceed the value set by the input transistors alone — once the clocked devices' resistance is small compared to the input devices', further widening adds **capacitance without adding current**.\n- The clock load (and clock‑feedthrough glitches on the floating nodes during the hold phase) also grows, degrading clock edges and burning more power.\n\n## A simple delay model\n\nWith input-device width $W_1$ fixed and clocked-device width $W_{ck}$:\n\n$$\n\\tau \\propto \\underbrace{\\left(\\frac{a}{W_1}+\\frac{a}{W_{ck}}\\right)}_{\\text{stack resistance}}\\cdot\\underbrace{\\left(C_0 + bW_{ck}\\right)}_{\\text{cap at } X \\text{ or } Y}\n$$\n\nwhere $C_0$ is the fixed load (next stage's gate caps, Inv₃, wiring) and $bW_{ck}$ is the clocked devices' self‑loading. Setting $d\\tau/dW_{ck}=0$ gives an optimum:\n\n$$\nW_{ck,\\,opt} = \\sqrt{\\frac{C_0 W_1}{b}}\n$$\n\n## Answer\n\n**It improves only up to a point, and then degrades.** Below the optimum width, the reduced series resistance dominates and the divider speeds up; beyond it, the current saturates at the input‑device limit while the drain capacitance at *X* and *Y* keeps growing linearly, so the delay rises again. In practice the clocked transistors should be made just wide enough that their resistance is a modest fraction of the input transistors' — making them indiscriminately large slows the circuit and wastes clock power.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "eb85888993d5a8273556257a9b884d3e7413b4f3244f7cb9255663194328a308"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that widening the clocked transistors initially improves speed by reducing their series on-resistance, while added capacitance at X and Y eventually limits or reverses the benefit, producing an optimum width.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "93d9b522d441668a699cc09168ad1991cf00bb982a5ad716cae0b7c7bec7c4fd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2220,
        "output_tokens": 6263,
        "total_tokens": 8483,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5440,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2220,
        "output_tokens": 6263,
        "total_tokens": 8483,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5440,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Identifying the circuit\n\nThis is a **÷2 (divide‑by‑two) circuit built from two C²MOS latches plus Inv₃** in a feedback loop. In each half clock cycle one latch is transparent (both its clocked devices on) while the other holds its output. The maximum clock frequency is set by how fast the transparent latch can charge/discharge nodes *X* and *Y* through the **series combination of a data transistor and a clocked transistor**.\n\n## Effect of widening the clocked transistors\n\nMaking the clocked devices wider has two *opposing* effects:\n\n**Pro:** Their on-resistance drops as 1/W, so the pull-up/pull-down paths conduct more current.\n\n**Cons:**\n- Their **drains sit directly on nodes X and Y**, so their junction capacitance — which grows linearly with W — directly loads the critical nodes (self-loading). Their source capacitance also enlarges the internal node, worsening charge sharing.\n- The **clock lines CK and CK̄ see a proportionally larger gate capacitance**, so the preceding stage (clock buffer or VCO) slows down and/or burns more power; slower clock edges further degrade the divider.\n\nCrucially, the resistance benefit *saturates* while the capacitance penalty does not. If the clocked device width is scaled by a factor $k$:\n\n$$\\tau(k) \\approx \\left(R_{data} + \\frac{R_{ck}}{k}\\right)\\left(C_{fixed} + k\\,C_{j,ck}\\right)$$\n\nThe total resistance can never fall below $R_{data}$ (the data transistor is still in series), but the node capacitance grows without bound. Expanding, $\\tau(k)$ contains a term $\\propto k$ and a term $\\propto 1/k$, so the delay **decreases, reaches a minimum at an optimum width, and then increases linearly with W**.\n\n## Conclusion\n\n- If the clocked transistors start out very narrow (they are the resistive bottleneck), modest widening **improves** speed.\n- Beyond a fairly small optimum — roughly when they are comparable to the data transistors — further widening **degrades** speed: at best the path resistance halves, while the capacitance at *X*, *Y*, and on the clock lines keeps growing linearly.\n\nSo indiscriminately increasing the clocked transistors' widths ultimately *degrades* the speed; the diminishing resistance benefit is overwhelmed by self-loading of the critical nodes and the heavier clock load.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "83ee9ab398f285d339e9933bbd2b0b520fdf8b9edce6c5d1b8391105b46d92a2"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that widening the clocked transistors initially improves speed by reducing their on-resistance, while added node capacitance eventually limits or reverses the benefit, producing an optimum width. The extra clock-loading discussion does not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "93d9b522d441668a699cc09168ad1991cf00bb982a5ad716cae0b7c7bec7c4fd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2220,
        "output_tokens": 12528,
        "total_tokens": 14748,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11702,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2220,
        "output_tokens": 12528,
        "total_tokens": 14748,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11702,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "Does the structure in the figure provide quadrature outputs?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\n**Yes — nominally.** The circuit is a master–slave divide‑by‑2 built from two C²MOS latches, and the two latch outputs (X and Y) change on *opposite* clock edges. With a 50 %‑duty‑cycle clock, that half‑clock‑period offset equals one quarter of the output period, i.e., 90°.\n\n## Why\n\n- **First latch (output X):** clocked by CK (NMOS) and $\\overline{CK}$ (PMOS) → transparent when **CK = 1**, holds when CK = 0. While it is transparent, its input Z is frozen (because the second latch is opaque), so **X can only change at CK rising edges.**\n- **Second latch (output Y):** transparent when **CK = 0**, so **Y changes only at CK falling edges.** Inv₃ gives Z = $\\overline{Y}$, closing the loop with a net inversion → the loop toggles once per clock cycle (÷2).\n\nStepping through half-cycles (each column = T_CK/2):\n\n```\nCK:  1  0  1  0  1  0  1  0\nX :  1  1  0  0  1  1  0  0    ← toggles on CK↑\nY :  1  0  0  1  1  0  0  1    ← toggles on CK↓\nZ :  0  1  1  0  0  1  1  0    ← = Y̅\n```\n\nAll nodes run at $f_{CK}/2$, and the available phases are:\n\n- **X → 0° (I)**\n- **Z → 90° (Q)** (lags X by half a clock period)\n- **Y → 270° (Q̄)**\n- 180° (Ī) is not directly available; it requires an extra inverter on X.\n\n## Practical caveats (quadrature accuracy is only moderate)\n\n- **Duty-cycle sensitivity:** the X–Y edge spacing equals the CK high time, so the phase spacing is $180°\\times D$. A duty-cycle error ΔD produces a quadrature error of $180°\\cdot\\Delta D$ (e.g., 55 % duty → ~9° error).\n- **Inv₃ delay:** Z lags Y by one inverter delay, skewing the X/Z pair; using X and Y (as I and Q̄) avoids this but gives inverted quadrature.\n- **Asymmetric nodes:** X is a dynamic, high-impedance node during CK = 0 (it floats and must be buffered; leakage also sets a minimum clock frequency), while Z is actively driven by Inv₃ — the unequal drive/loading adds systematic skew.\n\nSo the topology *does* furnish quadrature phases in principle, but with poorer I/Q accuracy than a symmetric master–slave latch divider with identically buffered outputs.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "27b7b33e0ec76ec59a7a3112bfc71c054a0b3f7bfb90e08a77063e8542374a3c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies nominal divide-by-two quadrature and the skew from Inv3 delay. It does not explain the unequal loading of the X and Y latch outputs; its X-versus-Z drive discussion is not that latch-loading mechanism.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a208e36107d3c6d3d835e897ccf309733e82f6921b41cd2eef1a21949e70e6f6",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2201,
        "output_tokens": 10216,
        "total_tokens": 12417,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9307,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2201,
        "output_tokens": 10216,
        "total_tokens": 12417,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9307,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "Does the structure in the figure provide quadrature outputs?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "**Yes—nominally it does.** This is a ÷2 stage built from two dynamic C²MOS latches closed in a loop through Inv₃ (three inversions → the loop toggles once per input cycle), and the two latch outputs, X and Y, behave like the master and slave outputs of a conventional master–slave divider.\n\n**Why X and Y are in quadrature**\n\n- The first latch (input = Z) is transparent when **CK = 1** (its clocked PMOS sees $\\overline{CK}$, its clocked NMOS sees $CK$); it holds when CK = 0.\n- The second latch (input = X) is transparent when **CK = 0**; it holds when CK = 1.\n- Consequently, X can change only on the **rising** edges of CK, while Y (and Z) change only on the **falling** edges. Each node toggles once per input period, producing square waves at $f_{CK}/2$ with 50% duty cycle.\n\nSince X and Y transitions are separated by half the input period, and half the input period equals one quarter of the *output* period, the two waveforms are 90° apart. Specifically, $Z=\\overline{Y}$ is X delayed by $T_{CK}/2$, so **X and Z form the I/Q pair** (Y is simply $\\overline{Q}$).\n\n**Practical caveats that limit quadrature accuracy**\n\n- **Clock duty cycle:** the phase spacing equals $180° \\times D$, where D is the CK duty cycle. It is exactly 90° only for D = 50%; every 1% duty-cycle error contributes ≈1.8° of quadrature error. CK and $\\overline{CK}$ must also be well aligned.\n- **Unequal loading:** X drives the four input/clock gates of the second latch, while Y drives only Inv₃. For accurate quadrature, X and Y should be buffered identically.\n- **Inverter skew:** if Z is used as the Q output, it carries the extra delay of Inv₃ relative to the ideal 90° point.\n- **Dynamic operation:** each output floats for half a cycle (e.g., X floats while CK = 0), so leakage and capacitive coupling can disturb the levels—this sets a minimum operating frequency and can corrupt the quadrature waveforms at low speeds.\n- Only single-ended phases (0°, 90°, 270°) are available; complementary outputs require additional inverters, adding mismatch.\n\nSo the topology inherently provides quadrature outputs at X and Y/Z, with accuracy governed by clock duty cycle, loading symmetry, and the feedback inverter's delay.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0a27b456710ebe4a54f0234ddd22dde2e5aaa7d1e3d56db39616bed46282126a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies nominal divide-by-two quadrature from the latches switching on opposite clock edges, and explains both key departures from exact quadrature: Inv3 delay and unequal loading of the latch outputs.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a208e36107d3c6d3d835e897ccf309733e82f6921b41cd2eef1a21949e70e6f6",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2201,
        "output_tokens": 9288,
        "total_tokens": 11489,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8434,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2201,
        "output_tokens": 9288,
        "total_tokens": 11489,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8434,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "Does the structure in the figure provide quadrature outputs?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\n**Yes — nominally.** Like any master–slave ÷2 circuit, the two latch outputs X and Y change on *opposite* edges of CK, so at the divided frequency they are spaced by 90°.\n\n## Why\n\nTrace the clocking of the two C²MOS stages:\n\n- **Left latch:** its clocked PMOS is gated by $\\overline{CK}$ and its clocked NMOS by $CK$ → it is **transparent when CK = 1** (X = $\\bar{Z}$), and holds when CK = 0.\n- **Right latch:** clocked PMOS gated by $CK$, clocked NMOS by $\\overline{CK}$ → **transparent when CK = 0** (Y = $\\bar{X}$), holds when CK = 1.\n- **Inv₃** is static: $Z=\\bar{Y}$ at all times, closing the loop.\n\nConsequently:\n\n| Clock edge | What happens |\n|---|---|\n| CK rising | X updates to $\\bar{Z}$ → **X toggles on rising edges** |\n| CK falling | Y updates to $\\bar{X}$ (and Z follows) → **Y, Z toggle on falling edges** |\n\nBoth X and Y toggle once per input cycle, so each is a 50%-duty square wave at $f_{CK}/2$, and their edges are separated by $T_{CK}/2$ — i.e., **one quarter of the output period (90°)**. The combined edges of X and Y occur every half input cycle, the signature of quadrature signals. (X and Z form the 0°/90° pair; Y = $\\bar Z$ gives 270°.)\n\n## Caveats\n\n1. **Input duty cycle:** the X–Y spacing equals the CK high time, so the quadrature accuracy is only as good as the 50% duty cycle of CK (phase error ≈ 180° × duty-cycle error).\n2. **Matching:** the two latches and their loads must match (X drives the second latch's gates; Y drives Inv₃), otherwise a systematic skew appears. Z also lags Y by Inv₃'s delay, so using Z as the \"90°\" phase adds a static error.\n3. **Incomplete phase set:** only X, Y, and Z (= $\\bar Y$) exist; the 180° phase ($\\bar X$) requires an added, delay-matched inverter.\n4. **Dynamic nodes:** X and Y float for half a cycle, so they should be buffered before driving a load (e.g., quadrature mixers).\n\nSo the ÷2 topology inherently delivers quadrature outputs at X and Y, provided the clock has 50% duty cycle and the two branches are well matched.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ca39dac04bbcb440db71a595192edab33e88a29a00fab6d255636afa8c34fef2"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies nominal divide-by-two quadrature and explains both departures from exact quadrature: Inv3 delay and unequal loading of the two latch outputs.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a208e36107d3c6d3d835e897ccf309733e82f6921b41cd2eef1a21949e70e6f6",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2201,
        "output_tokens": 11117,
        "total_tokens": 13318,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10236,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2201,
        "output_tokens": 11117,
        "total_tokens": 13318,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10236,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Circuit identification\n\nThis is a divide‑by‑2 built from two C²MOS (clocked‑inverter) latches plus a static inverter in a loop. In each branch the **clocked transistors sit next to the supply rails**, while the data-driven (inner) transistors connect to the output node. One stage is transparent while the other holds, on opposite clock phases.\n\n## Answer: the speed *improves*\n\nThe clocked devices lie **in series** in every charge/discharge path, so widening them lowers the path resistance. Crucially, because of where they sit in the stack, their added parasitics do **not** load the signal nodes:\n\n- Their **gates** load only the clock lines (CK, CK̄), not the data path.\n- Their **drain junctions** appear at the *internal* nodes (between clocked and data devices), not at the output.\n\nA quick Elmore estimate for one transition confirms this. With $R_{ck} \\propto 1/W_{ck}$ and internal-node capacitance $C_X \\approx c_1 W_{ck} + c_0$:\n\n$$\n\\tau \\approx R_{ck}(C_X + C_{out}) + R_{data}\\,C_{out} \\;=\\; \\underbrace{R_{data}C_{out} + k c_1}_{\\text{const}} \\;+\\; \\frac{k\\,(c_0 + C_{out})}{W_{ck}}\n$$\n\nThe term due to the clocked device's *own* capacitance ($R_{ck} \\cdot c_1W_{ck}$) is constant, so **τ decreases monotonically** as $W_{ck}$ increases — there is no self-loading penalty at the output, unlike widening the data transistors.\n\n## Caveats (why we don't make them arbitrarily wide)\n\n- **Diminishing returns:** once $R_{ck} \\ll R_{data}$, the delay saturates at the value set by the data transistors and $C_{out}$; further widening buys essentially nothing.\n- **Clock loading:** the clock input capacitance grows linearly, demanding larger clock buffers, more power, and — if the clock driver is fixed — slower clock edges, which can erode the gain at the system level.\n- **Charge sharing:** larger internal-node capacitance worsens the charge-sharing disturbance on the dynamically held (floating) output when a data transistor turns on during the hold phase, degrading margins.\n\n**Bottom line:** widening the clocked transistors speeds up the divider (monotonically, saturating once the data devices dominate); the price is paid in clock load, power, and hold-mode robustness rather than in signal-path delay.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "72e2a0b48a7dc5a96109e81c1e4f550bf1c14037f7e3bb919e0dcd2eca54b708"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that widening the clocked devices improves speed by reducing series resistance while adding capacitance mainly at internal nodes. It also identifies charge sharing as a swing/margin limitation and does not portray it as making the topology unusable.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "318c27e5f5623103c64ba9716043fb25f88281b2efa86f52761064364631036f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2283,
        "output_tokens": 12613,
        "total_tokens": 14896,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11763,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2283,
        "output_tokens": 12613,
        "total_tokens": 14896,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11763,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Circuit identification\n\nThis is a **÷2 dynamic divider**: two C²MOS (clocked‑CMOS) inverting latches in cascade, with the output inverted and fed back to the first stage's input. In each latch the **clocked transistors sit next to the supply rails**, while the **input transistors sit next to the output node**.\n\n## Effect of widening the clocked devices\n\nThe delay of each latch is roughly\n\n$$\n\\tau \\approx (R_{on,\\text{input}} + R_{on,\\text{clk}})\\,C_{out}\n$$\n\nConsider what each term does as $W_{clk}$ increases:\n\n**Resistance:** The clocked transistors are *in series* in every charge/discharge path. Widening them reduces $R_{on,\\text{clk}} \\propto 1/W_{clk}$, so the available pull‑up/pull‑down current increases.\n\n**Output capacitance:** Because the clocked devices are placed at the rails, their (now larger) drain junction capacitances land on the *internal* nodes — the sources of the input transistors — **not on the output node**. The output load $C_{out}$ consists of the input devices' drain junctions plus the gate capacitance of the next stage's input devices and the feedback inverter, none of which scale with $W_{clk}$.\n\n**Internal nodes:** The internal‑node time constant $R_{on,\\text{clk}} \\cdot C_{int}$ stays roughly constant ($R \\propto 1/W$, $C \\propto W$), so it does not become a new bottleneck.\n\n## Answer\n\n**The speed improves.** The series resistance in the switching path drops while the output load stays essentially unchanged, so the latch delay decreases and the maximum clock frequency rises.\n\n## Caveats\n\n- **Diminishing returns:** once $R_{on,\\text{clk}} \\ll R_{on,\\text{input}}$, further widening buys almost nothing — the delay asymptotically approaches $R_{on,\\text{input}}\\,C_{out}$.\n- **Clock loading:** the gate capacitance seen by $CK$ and $\\overline{CK}$ grows proportionally to $W_{clk}$. If the clock buffers are not scaled up accordingly, the clock edges slow down (and dynamic power increases), which can eat into or even negate the speed gain.\n\nSo in practice: widen the clocked transistors to the point where their resistance is a small fraction of the input devices' resistance, and size the clock drivers to handle the extra load.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5cd94c7c565601f52c177f4064cb5f7cf0b9aaf56b38764ce411a4e5fdbae73d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that widening the clocked transistors improves speed because it lowers series resistance without significantly loading the output. It omits the charge-sharing swing degradation, which the full-credit rule requires for a 4.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "318c27e5f5623103c64ba9716043fb25f88281b2efa86f52761064364631036f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2283,
        "output_tokens": 5524,
        "total_tokens": 7807,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4711,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2283,
        "output_tokens": 5524,
        "total_tokens": 7807,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4711,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Circuit identification\n\nThis is a divide‑by‑2 circuit built from two **C²MOS (clocked CMOS) latches** in cascade, with a static inverter closing the loop. In each latch the clocked transistors are the *outer* devices (sources tied to $V_{DD}$ and ground), while the input transistors are the *inner* devices whose drains form the output node.\n\n## Effect of widening the clocked transistors\n\n**The speed improves.** Here's why:\n\n**1. The clocked devices are in series with the signal path.**\nEvery time a latch is transparent, its output node must be charged or discharged through the *series* combination of an input transistor and a clocked transistor. The clocked transistor's on-resistance directly limits the available current. Making it wider lowers $R_{on} \\propto 1/W$, so the output node slews faster.\n\n**2. The extra capacitance does *not* land on the critical node.**\nBecause the clocked transistors sit at the outer (supply/ground) ends of the stack, their drain junction capacitance appears on the *internal* nodes, not on the output nodes. Using an Elmore-delay estimate:\n\n$$t_d \\approx R_{clk}\\,(C_{int} + C_{out}) + R_{in}\\,C_{out}$$\n\nAs $W_{clk}$ increases, $R_{clk} \\to 0$ while $C_{out}$ is essentially unchanged, so the delay monotonically *decreases*, approaching the limit set by the input transistors alone:\n\n$$t_d \\to R_{in}\\,C_{out}$$\n\n(The term $R_{clk}C_{int}$ stays roughly constant since $R_{clk} \\propto 1/W$ and $C_{int} \\propto W$.)\n\n## Caveats\n\n- **Diminishing returns:** once $R_{clk} \\ll R_{in}$, further widening buys almost nothing — the input devices dominate the delay.\n- **Clock loading:** the gate capacitance presented to $CK$ and $\\overline{CK}$ grows proportionally to $W$. The clock buffer (or LO in an RF divider) must drive this heavier load, costing power; if the clock driver is not scaled up accordingly, its edges slow down and the overall system speed can eventually suffer.\n\n**Bottom line:** within the divider itself, wider clocked transistors speed up the circuit (stronger series path, same output capacitance), but the benefit saturates and is paid for with increased clock-path loading and power.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c198572a5c08679e0198b430c90cf4b50063cb0e9fcee204cd779e84ca476d80"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that widening the clocked devices improves speed because it reduces their series resistance and adds little output loading. However, it omits the charge-sharing swing degradation that the full-credit rule requires; its clock-loading caveat is not a substitute.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "318c27e5f5623103c64ba9716043fb25f88281b2efa86f52761064364631036f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2283,
        "output_tokens": 4792,
        "total_tokens": 7075,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3984,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2283,
        "output_tokens": 4792,
        "total_tokens": 7075,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3984,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the arrangement in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## What the Circuit Is\n\nThe figure shows a **three‑inverter ring** (Inv₁ followed by two more inverters, with the last output fed back to the first input) into which **two series switches** have been inserted:\n\n- A switch clocked by **CK** in front of Inv₁\n- A switch clocked by **CK̄** between Inv₁ and the two-inverter chain\n\nSince the switches are driven by complementary phases, **the loop is never fully closed at any instant** — one switch is always open. This turns what would otherwise be a free-running ring oscillator (odd number of inversions → no stable state) into a **clocked, divide-by-two circuit built from dynamic latches**.\n\n## Phase-by-Phase Operation\n\nLet *Q* = output of the last inverter (the feedback node), and note that the two cascaded inverters act as a non-inverting buffer.\n\n| Phase | CK switch | CK̄ switch | Action |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| **CK = 1** | Closed | Open | Inv₁ **samples** Q and produces Q̄ at its output. The input of the second inverter floats, **holding** its charge → Q is frozen. |\n| **CK = 0** | Open | Closed | Inv₁'s input floats (holds the sampled value). Its output Q̄ passes through the switch and the two inverters → **Q is replaced by Q̄**. |\n\nSo each full clock cycle the output obeys:\n\n$$Q(n) = \\overline{Q(n-1)}$$\n\n**Q toggles once per clock period** (at each CK falling edge), giving:\n\n$$f_{out} = \\frac{f_{CK}}{2}, \\quad \\text{with } \\approx 50\\% \\text{ duty cycle}$$\n\n## Equivalent Interpretation\n\n- **Switch + Inv₁** = a *dynamic latch* (transparent when CK = 1, holding on node capacitance when CK = 0).\n- **Switch + remaining two inverters** = a second dynamic latch, transparent on the opposite phase.\n- Together they form a **master–slave (edge-triggered) flip-flop**; the odd number of inverters gives a net inversion around the feedback loop — i.e., a D-flip-flop with Q̄ tied to D, which is exactly a **toggle (÷2) divider**.\n\nEquivalently: the clock \"paces\" the signal around the ring — half the loop evaluates per half-period — so propagation is set by CK rather than by gate delays, as in the free-running oscillator.\n\n## Practical Considerations\n\n- **Dynamic storage:** state is held on parasitic node capacitance when a switch opens. Leakage therefore imposes a **minimum clock frequency**; the circuit cannot be stopped or run arbitrarily slowly.\n- **Clock overlap:** if CK and CK̄ are momentarily both high, the full ring closes and can race/oscillate, corrupting the state — non-overlapping or sharp complementary phases are needed.\n- **Maximum speed:** each half-period must accommodate the settling of the active path, roughly\n$$\\tfrac{T_{CK}}{2} > t_{sw} + 2\\,t_{inv}\\ \\ (\\text{slower, two-inverter phase})$$\n- **Relevance:** this compact dynamic-latch divider is the conceptual ancestor of high-speed ÷2 prescalers (e.g., TSPC dividers used in PLL/frequency synthesizers), prized for low transistor count and high operating speed.\n\n**Bottom line:** inserting the complementary-clocked switches converts an astable three-inverter ring oscillator into a synchronous **dynamic frequency divider whose output runs at half the clock frequency**.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "12d0ee5f0f9ec9ee69c8a5ba2a149f288fe15f94ea1f76dbe991ffeb3cae9f11"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies a divide-by-two circuit built from dynamic latches and explains that the output toggles to run at half the clock frequency. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule; the additional internal details are not required.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f425c26bf4178562557e147f38673688c0fa91f97a1c7cad9ab3d6417d10545f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1431,
        "output_tokens": 6773,
        "total_tokens": 8204,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5552,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1431,
        "output_tokens": 6773,
        "total_tokens": 8204,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5552,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the arrangement in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification: Dynamic ÷2 Frequency Divider\n\nThe figure shows a **loop of three inverters broken by two switches driven by complementary clock phases** (CK and $\\overline{CK}$). This is a classic **dynamic divide-by-two circuit** — effectively a master–slave toggle flip-flop built from dynamic latches.\n\n## Structural Decomposition\n\n| Block | Function |\n|---|---|\n| CK switch + Inv₁ | **Master latch**: samples when CK = 1, holds (on gate capacitance) when CK = 0 |\n| $\\overline{CK}$ switch + Inv₂ | **Slave latch**: samples when CK = 0, holds when CK = 1 |\n| Inv₃ + feedback wire | Returns the **complement** of the output to the input → toggle (T-FF) behavior |\n\nSince D = $\\overline{Q}$ in a master–slave flip-flop, the state inverts every clock cycle → **frequency division by 2**.\n\n## Phase-by-Phase Operation\n\nLabel nodes: A = Inv₁ input, B = Inv₁ output, C = Inv₂ input, E = Inv₃ output (feedback).\n\n**CK = 1** (CK switch closed, $\\overline{CK}$ switch open):\n- A = E, B = $\\overline{A}$ — new value is sampled into the first stage\n- C floats and **holds** its charge → Inv₂, Inv₃ outputs frozen\n\n**CK = 0** (switches reversed):\n- C = B — the value advances into the second stage; E = B\n- A floats and **holds** → first stage frozen\n\nTracking the state (starting with E = 0):\n\n| Half-cycle | A | B | C | E |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| CK=1 | 0 | 1 | hold (0) | 0 |\n| CK=0 | hold (0) | 1 | 1 | 1 |\n| CK=1 | **1** | 0 | hold (1) | 1 |\n| CK=0 | hold (1) | 0 | 0 | **0** |\n\n**Every node toggles once per full clock period** → each node is a square wave at $f_{CK}/2$ with ~50% duty cycle (A toggles on rising edges, E on falling edges).\n\n## Why It Doesn't Oscillate\n\nThe loop contains an **odd number of inversions (3)**, which would form a ring oscillator if closed. However, CK and $\\overline{CK}$ ensure the two switches are **never on simultaneously** — the ring is always broken at one point, so regeneration cannot occur; the circuit instead advances state once per clock edge.\n\n## Design Constraints\n\n- **Maximum frequency:** each half-period must exceed the propagation delay through the active path (switch + inverter(s)); otherwise the state fails to settle before the next phase.\n- **Minimum frequency:** storage is *dynamic* (charge on inverter input capacitance), so leakage sets a lower clock-rate limit — the circuit cannot hold state indefinitely.\n- **Clock overlap:** if CK and $\\overline{CK}$ overlap, both switches conduct briefly, momentarily closing the 3-inverter ring (race hazard); the overlap must be shorter than the loop delay.\n- **Charge injection / clock feedthrough** from the switches perturbs the held node voltages.\n\n## Practical Significance\n\nThis topology is compact, fast, and low-power, making it popular in **high-speed prescalers** (e.g., PLL frequency synthesizers). Cascading *n* such stages yields division by $2^n$, and it is the conceptual ancestor of TSPC (true single-phase clock) dividers.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "b7c9ced57add20cd2f859df79774e0d7977bf119e63badfed7f02eae5c119345"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the circuit as a divide-by-two built from dynamic latches. The golden solution makes that identification sufficient for full credit; the additional phase and implementation details are not required.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f425c26bf4178562557e147f38673688c0fa91f97a1c7cad9ab3d6417d10545f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1431,
        "output_tokens": 6129,
        "total_tokens": 7560,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4908,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1431,
        "output_tokens": 6129,
        "total_tokens": 7560,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4908,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the arrangement in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "# Circuit Identification\n\nThe loop contains **two sampling switches** driven by complementary clock phases (CK and C̄K̄) and **three inverters**. This is a **dynamic (master–slave) divide-by-2 circuit**:\n\n- **S₁ + Inv₁** → \"master\" dynamic latch (transparent when CK = 1)\n- **S₂ + Inv₂** → \"slave\" dynamic latch (transparent when CK = 0)\n- **Inv₃** → provides the *odd* (third) inversion around the loop, so the value fed back is always the **complement** of the output → the circuit toggles, i.e., it behaves as a **T flip-flop with T = 1**.\n\n# Step-by-Step Operation\n\nLabel the nodes: A = Inv₁ input, B = Inv₁ output, C = Inv₂ input, D = Inv₂ output, X = Inv₃ output (feedback node). Assume X = 0 initially.\n\n| Phase | CK | S₁ | S₂ | A | B | C | D | X |\n|-------|----|----|----|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 | 1 | on | off | 0 (=X) | 1 | holds 0 | 1 | 0 |\n| 2 | 0 | off | on | holds 0 | 1 | 1 (=B) | 0 | **1 ← toggles** |\n| 3 | 1 | on | off | 1 (=X) | 0 | holds 1 | 0 | 1 |\n| 4 | 0 | off | on | holds 1 | 0 | 0 (=B) | 1 | **0 ← toggles** |\n\n**While CK = 1:** S₁ samples the current output X; Inv₁ produces X̄ at node B. The loop is broken at S₂, so the output cannot change (held on the parasitic capacitance at C).\n\n**While CK = 0:** S₂ passes X̄ through Inv₂ and Inv₃, driving the output to X̄. The loop is now broken at S₁, so the new value cannot race back around.\n\n**Result:** The output toggles exactly once per clock period (on each falling edge of CK):\n\n$$f_{out} = \\frac{f_{CK}}{2}, \\quad \\text{with 50\\% duty cycle.}$$\n\nA useful bonus: node B toggles on *rising* edges while X toggles on *falling* edges, so (for a 50%-duty clock) the circuit inherently provides **two f/2 outputs in quadrature (90° apart)**.\n\n# Why the Third Inverter Is Essential\n\nWith only two inverters, the loop would contain an even number of inversions — it would simply *latch* its state forever. The odd inversion count makes the fed-back value the complement of the stored value, forcing a toggle every cycle. (Equivalently: with both switches permanently on, this would be a three-inverter **ring oscillator**; the clocked switches break the loop so it advances exactly one \"trip\" per clock period.)\n\n# Practical Limitations\n\n- **Dynamic storage → minimum clock frequency.** When a switch is off, data is held only as charge on an inverter's input capacitance. Leakage sets a floor: roughly $f_{min} \\approx I_{leak}/(C_{node}\\,\\Delta V_{max})$.\n- **Clock overlap hazard.** If CK and C̄K̄ overlap so both switches conduct simultaneously, the loop momentarily becomes a three-inverter ring oscillator and can \"race through,\" toggling more than once per cycle. Sharp or nonoverlapping phases are required.\n- **Maximum speed.** During CK = 0 the signal must traverse S₂, Inv₂ *and* Inv₃; during CK = 1 only S₁ and Inv₁. The slower half dominates:\n$$\\frac{T_{CK}}{2} \\gtrsim t_{sw} + 2t_{inv} \\;\\Rightarrow\\; f_{max} \\approx \\frac{1}{2(t_{sw} + 2t_{inv})}.$$\n- **Switch nonidealities.** Charge injection and clock feedthrough disturb the held levels; single-NMOS switches also degrade the high level to $V_{DD} - V_{TH}$ (transmission gates fix this). The inverters' gain regenerates levels each cycle, so small disturbances are tolerated.\n\n**Summary:** This is a compact, low-power dynamic ÷2 frequency divider (a falling-edge-triggered toggle flip-flop), valid only between a leakage-set minimum and a delay-set maximum clock frequency, and intolerant of clock-phase overlap.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "db7859fb1eeb707e86e12221d104289b21789f9a38379318b932f8b0f5e68d99"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies a dynamic-latch master–slave divide-by-two circuit and states that its output is half the clock frequency. The extra implementation details are not required for full credit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f425c26bf4178562557e147f38673688c0fa91f97a1c7cad9ab3d6417d10545f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1431,
        "output_tokens": 9661,
        "total_tokens": 11092,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8134,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1431,
        "output_tokens": 9661,
        "total_tokens": 11092,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8134,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "How does the red inverter in the figure affect the performance?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## What the red inverter does\n\nThe red inverter is connected **in positive feedback around Inv₁** (output of Inv₁ → input of the red inverter → back to Inv₁'s input). Together they form a cross‑coupled (latch) pair, converting the first stage from a **dynamic** latch into a **static** latch.\n\n## Benefit: static (robust) storage\n\nWithout the red inverter, when the *CK* switch opens, the state is held only as charge on the parasitic capacitance at Inv₁'s input. That charge leaks away, so the circuit fails if the clock is slowed down or stopped.\n\nWith the red inverter:\n- The state is **held indefinitely** by regeneration — the divider now works down to arbitrarily low clock frequencies (even DC).\n- The stored node is actively driven to the rail, improving immunity to **leakage, charge sharing, and noise**.\n\n## Cost: reduced speed\n\nThe price is **contention during the write (sampling) phase**:\n\n- When the *CK* switch closes to write a new value, the red inverter is still driving the node with the *old* value. The preceding stage (through the switch's on-resistance) must **overpower the keeper** — this is ratioed operation.\n- The fight between the two prolongs the transition at Inv₁'s input, increasing the effective time constant and **lowering the maximum clock frequency** at which the divider toggles correctly.\n- The red inverter also adds **extra capacitance** at both the input and output of Inv₁, further slowing the stage, and the momentary contention draws **crowbar current**, raising power.\n\n## Design implication\n\nThe red inverter must therefore be made **weak** (small W/L, possibly long channel) — just strong enough to hold the state against leakage, but weak enough to be easily overridden during sampling. The design trades a modest loss in maximum speed for robust static operation and no lower limit on clock frequency.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "608a15ee3b2113d7271241271195a86417cd18cf1a22c33d08e35c404c3f91a7"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The answer misidentifies the red inverter as a keeper/latch rather than an unclocked feedforward path that bypasses part of the first latch. It reverses both key effects: the path improves high-speed operation but raises the minimum usable clock frequency at low rates; it does not provide DC operation or reduce maximum speed.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "09f12aa6905fa83982420dcd1602844314d44b4575734bb31f92f5ccf31131d2",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1230,
        "output_tokens": 2627,
        "total_tokens": 3857,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2014,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1230,
        "output_tokens": 2627,
        "total_tokens": 3857,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2014,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "How does the red inverter in the figure affect the performance?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## What the Red Inverter Does\n\nThe red inverter is connected **back‑to‑back with Inv₁** (its input at Inv₁'s output, its output at Inv₁'s input). Together they form a cross‑coupled pair — i.e., a **static latch (a \"keeper\")** — converting what was a *dynamic* latch into a *static* one.\n\n## Benefits\n\n- **State retention:** When the CK switch opens, the stored bit no longer sits on a floating capacitor. The positive feedback holds the node voltages indefinitely, so the circuit is immune to **charge leakage, charge sharing, and noise**.\n- **No minimum clock frequency:** A dynamic latch fails if the clock is too slow (the stored charge leaks away). With the keeper, the divider/latch works down to **arbitrarily low frequencies (even DC)**.\n- **Regeneration:** The positive feedback restores full logic levels and sharpens transitions.\n\n## Costs\n\n- **Contention (\"fighting\"):** When the CK switch closes to write a *new* value, the input must **overpower the red inverter**, which is actively holding the old state. This prolongs the transition at Inv₁'s input node.\n- **Extra capacitive loading:** The red inverter adds gate capacitance at Inv₁'s output and drain capacitance at Inv₁'s input, slowing both nodes.\n- **Higher power:** During the write, a crowbar/contention current flows between the driver and the keeper.\n\n## Net Effect on Performance\n\nThe red inverter **trades maximum speed for robustness**:\n\n$$f_{max} \\downarrow \\qquad f_{min} \\rightarrow 0$$\n\nFor this reason, the feedback inverter is typically made **deliberately weak** (minimum width, sometimes long channel) so it can hold the state during the hold phase but is easily overpowered during the write phase — minimizing the speed and power penalty while keeping the latch static.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d5eaf162daf05afb8c5422635ef80b95fbfba56babe3fc557670a1d50eeb3f19"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The answer misidentifies the red inverter as a cross-coupled keeper. It is an unclocked feedforward path that bypasses part of the latch, improving high-speed operation but raising the minimum usable clock frequency—not lowering it toward DC.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "09f12aa6905fa83982420dcd1602844314d44b4575734bb31f92f5ccf31131d2",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1230,
        "output_tokens": 2043,
        "total_tokens": 3273,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1409,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1230,
        "output_tokens": 2043,
        "total_tokens": 3273,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1409,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "How does the red inverter in the figure affect the performance?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## What the Red Inverter Is\n\nThe red inverter is placed in feedback around Inv₁, so the two form a **back‑to‑back (cross‑coupled) inverter pair** — i.e., a *keeper* that turns this stage from a **dynamic latch** into a **static latch**.\n\n## The Benefit: Removes the Lower Speed Limit\n\nWithout the red inverter, when the *CK* switch opens (hold mode), the input node of Inv₁ simply **stores charge on parasitic capacitance**. That charge leaks away (junction leakage, subthreshold conduction), so the circuit fails if the clock is too slow — a dynamic divider has a **minimum operating frequency**.\n\nWith the red inverter, positive feedback **regenerates and holds the logic level indefinitely**. The circuit now:\n\n- Works at arbitrarily low clock frequencies (down to DC)\n- Retains its state if the clock stops\n- Is robust against leakage, especially at high temperature\n\n## The Cost: Degrades Maximum Speed\n\n1. **Contention (\"fighting\"):** When the *CK* switch closes to write a new value, the driving stage must **overpower the red inverter**, which is actively holding the old state. The node voltage changes more slowly, lengthening the latch's settling time.\n\n2. **Extra capacitance:** The red inverter loads both the input and output nodes of Inv₁, further slowing the transitions.\n\n3. **Extra power:** During the write, both the driver and keeper conduct simultaneously, drawing crowbar current.\n\n## Design Implication\n\nThe red inverter must be made **weak** (small W/L, or long channel) — strong enough to counteract leakage, but weak enough that the input can still flip the latch. The result is a trade‑off:\n\n| | Dynamic (no red inverter) | Static (with red inverter) |\n|---|---|---|\n| Max frequency | Higher | Somewhat lower |\n| Min frequency | Limited by leakage | None (works to DC) |\n\nSo the red inverter **extends operation to low frequencies at the expense of some maximum speed and power**.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "4ec21b81428fc36185b20afef809ffd674000629753cf2e65d5a9c62a33c1358"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The answer misidentifies the red inverter as a keeper in a feedback latch. It misses the feedforward speed-up and reverses the key low-frequency result: the unclocked branch raises, rather than eliminates, the minimum usable clock frequency.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "09f12aa6905fa83982420dcd1602844314d44b4575734bb31f92f5ccf31131d2",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1230,
        "output_tokens": 3022,
        "total_tokens": 4252,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2335,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1230,
        "output_tokens": 3022,
        "total_tokens": 4252,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2335,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "In the figure, somebody answers:\n\n> The red inverter acts as a keeper, forming a cross-coupled latch with `Inv1`.\n> This removes the minimum clock frequency requirement due to leakage.\n\nDo you agree with this answer? What is the actual role of the red inverter?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## First, read the topology carefully\n\nLabel the nodes:\n\n- **X** = node to the left of the *CK* switch (this is also the divider's feedback/output node, driven by the last inverter)\n- **Y** = input of Inv₁ (right side of the *CK* switch)\n- **Z** = output of Inv₁ (left side of the $\\overline{CK}$ switch)\n- **W** = input of the third inverter\n\nThe circuit is the classic **dynamic ÷2**: two pass-switch latches with three inversions in the loop. The *dynamic* (floating) nodes are **Y** (when *CK* = 0) and **W** (when $\\overline{CK}$ = 0).\n\nNow look at the red inverter: its **input is at X** (before the *CK* switch) and its **output is at Z** (after Inv₁).\n\n## Why the quoted answer is wrong\n\n1. **It is not cross-coupled with Inv₁.** A keeper would have to be *anti-parallel* with Inv₁, i.e., connected from **Z back to Y**, forming a bistable pair. Here both inverters point the *same* direction (Inv₁: Y→Z, red: X→Z). Two inverters driving the same output node in parallel cannot store anything.\n\n2. **The floating nodes are untouched.** Z is *never* floating — Inv₁ always drives it. The leakage-sensitive nodes Y and W still float every half cycle, so the state still decays at low clock rates. **The minimum clock frequency requirement remains**; the circuit is still dynamic.\n\n3. **It even fights the stored value.** During the $\\overline{CK}$ phase, the loop forces X = Z (through the last two inverters), so the red inverter pulls Z toward $\\overline{X}$ = opposite of what Inv₁ (holding from the floating Y) is driving. A \"keeper\" that opposes the held data half the time is clearly not a keeper — this also tells you it must be sized **weak**.\n\n## The actual role: a feed-forward \"assist\" for high-speed operation\n\nNote that **X already carries the value that Y will receive at the next CK rising edge**. The red inverter exploits this:\n\n- During the $\\overline{CK}$ phase, once X toggles, the red inverter starts (weakly) pre-driving Z toward its *next* logic value, $\\overline{X}$.\n- When *CK* closes, Inv₁ joins in and both devices pull Z together — and the red path **bypasses the pass switch entirely** (no switch RC, no degraded level passed through the switch).\n\nSo the red inverter is a **feed-forward / speed-up element**: it sharpens and completes the transitions at Z, restores full swing when the switch passes a weak level, and thereby **extends the *maximum* operating frequency** of the divider. It must be weak enough to lose the brief ratioed contention against Inv₁, otherwise it would corrupt the data being written into W.\n\n**Bottom line:** disagree. The red inverter helps at the *high*-frequency end (fmax), not the low end. The divider remains dynamic, and a true fix for the leakage/minimum-frequency problem would require genuinely cross-coupled (Z→Y) weak inverters around each latch.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ad378cdbad603f2c9aa6b48b86a07ddcaa3c88a593d39d3f1d06238c49967bae"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "Correctly rejects the keeper interpretation and identifies the red inverter as a feedforward path that bypasses part of the latch path. However, it misses the key low-frequency failure: the unclocked branch can dominate the intended latch behavior (and form a regenerative loop), raising the minimum usable clock rate. It instead attributes the limit to leakage and says the branch does not affect the low-frequency end.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "172cbb780508db2c8965d08eedaac49be4edfaf50993cf59fb05d5d161e1fa3c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1305,
        "output_tokens": 39931,
        "total_tokens": 41236,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 38879,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1305,
        "output_tokens": 39931,
        "total_tokens": 41236,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 38879,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "In the figure, somebody answers:\n\n> The red inverter acts as a keeper, forming a cross-coupled latch with `Inv1`.\n> This removes the minimum clock frequency requirement due to leakage.\n\nDo you agree with this answer? What is the actual role of the red inverter?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer: No, I don't agree\n\nThe answer is wrong on both points: the red inverter is **not** cross‑coupled with `Inv1`, and it does **not** remove the minimum clock frequency.\n\n## Why it is not a keeper\n\nLabel the nodes: **A** = node *before* the CK switch (= output of the last inverter, the loop feedback node), **B** = input of `Inv1` (after the CK switch), **C** = output of `Inv1`.\n\n* A keeper forming a cross-coupled latch with `Inv1` would have to be connected **anti-parallel** around `Inv1`: input at **C**, output at **B**.\n* The red inverter is instead connected from **A** to **C** — i.e., **in parallel with the series branch (CK switch + Inv1), in the same signal direction**. It is a *feed-forward* path that bypasses the clocked switch, not a feedback path. No bistable (storage) element is formed.\n* The nodes that actually float — **B** when CK = 0, and the input of the second inverter when CK = 1 — **still float**. Leakage still corrupts them, so the minimum-frequency limitation of the dynamic divider is not fixed. (Even a true keeper around `Inv1` alone wouldn't suffice; the second latch's node would still be dynamic.)\n\n## What the red inverter actually does\n\n**CK = 1:** the red inverter is simply in parallel with (switch + `Inv1`), both driving C = Ā. Redundant, slightly stronger drive.\n\n**CK = 0:** the C̄K switch is closed, so the red inverter closes a loop:\n\n$$C \\rightarrow \\text{Inv}_2 \\rightarrow \\text{Inv}_3 \\rightarrow A \\xrightarrow{\\text{red inv}} C$$\n\n— **three inversions → a ring oscillator**. The circuit therefore *self-oscillates* in the absence of a clock, and with the clock applied it behaves as an **injection-locked ÷2 divider**: the clock locks the natural ring oscillation.\n\nThe real purpose is to **extend the maximum operating frequency**:\n\n* During CK = 0, node A flips, so the red inverter immediately starts pulling **C toward its *next* state** (fighting the weak hold by `Inv1`, whose input B is floating). When CK rises, `Inv1` joins in and C completes its transition much faster — the clocked path only has to \"finish\" an already-started transition.\n* In the locked regime the internal nodes swing at the ring's natural rate; the clock only synchronizes them, so the circuit divides at frequencies beyond the conventional dynamic-divider limit and can even be driven by a small/sinusoidal clock.\n\n## Consequences (the opposite of the claimed benefit)\n\n* The divider now works only within the **lock range around twice the ring's self-oscillation frequency**. If the clock is too *slow*, the ring free-runs during the long CK = 0 phase and flips C before the next clock edge — the output is no longer CK/2. So a **minimum clock frequency still exists** (now set by injection locking rather than only by leakage).\n* There is deliberate **contention** at node C during CK = 0 (red inverter vs. `Inv1`), so the red inverter must be sized weaker than `Inv1`, and it burns some static current.\n\n## Bottom line\n\nThe red inverter is a **speed-enhancement (feed-forward) device** that turns the dynamic divider into a self-oscillating, injection-locked ÷2 circuit, raising the *maximum* speed. If one truly wanted to eliminate the leakage-based minimum frequency, weak inverters would have to be placed **anti-parallel across `Inv1` and across the second inverter** (making both latches static) — which is not what is drawn.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "eef00943bc5d74ab671c8a4c3d3edbe5a86a2a3f5ff5e4accd9055b1452f72bd"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly rejects the keeper interpretation, identifies the red inverter as a feedforward path bypassing the CK switch and Inv1, and explains both the high-speed benefit and the low-frequency corruption that raises the minimum usable clock rate. The ring/injection-lock description is allowed by the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "172cbb780508db2c8965d08eedaac49be4edfaf50993cf59fb05d5d161e1fa3c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1305,
        "output_tokens": 25420,
        "total_tokens": 26725,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 24179,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1305,
        "output_tokens": 25420,
        "total_tokens": 26725,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 24179,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "In the figure, somebody answers:\n\n> The red inverter acts as a keeper, forming a cross-coupled latch with `Inv1`.\n> This removes the minimum clock frequency requirement due to leakage.\n\nDo you agree with this answer? What is the actual role of the red inverter?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer: No, I don't agree\n\nThe red inverter is **not** cross‑coupled with Inv₁, it does **not** form a keeper, and it does **not** remove the minimum clock frequency. If anything, it threatens correct operation of the divider.\n\nLet me label the nodes: **A** = feedback node (left of the CK switch), **X** = input of Inv₁, **B** = output of Inv₁.\n\n## Why the \"cross-coupled keeper\" claim is wrong\n\n**1. Topologically, there is no cross-coupling.**\nA cross-coupled pair requires the output of each inverter to drive the input of the other (a two-inversion loop → bistable). Here:\n\n- Inv₁: X → B\n- Red inverter: A → B\n\nBoth inverters *drive the same node* B; the red inverter's input is not connected to B at all. There is no regenerative loop between them. In fact, when CK is high (switch closed, A = X), the red inverter is simply **in parallel** with Inv₁ — same input, same output — i.e., just a redundant, wider inverter.\n\n**2. It \"keeps\" the wrong node.**\nThe dynamic storage nodes of this divider are **X** (floats when CK is low) and **Y**, the node after the C̄K̄ switch (floats when CK is high). Node **B is always actively driven by Inv₁ and never floats** — it needs no keeper. Since the red inverter only drives B, leakage at X and Y is completely unaffected → **the minimum clock frequency requirement remains**. (Even a genuine keeper around Inv₁ wouldn't suffice: Y would still leak during the CK-high phase.)\n\n## What the red inverter actually does\n\n- **CK high:** A = X, so it harmlessly parallels Inv₁ (extra drive on B).\n\n- **CK low:** this is where it misbehaves. During this phase the loop (B → C̄K̄-switch → two inverters → A) updates A to the *toggled* value. The red inverter then forces B toward Ā — the **opposite** of the value Inv₁ is holding via the charge stored on X. So instead of \"keeping\" the state, it **fights** it (ratioed contention at B).\n\n- Worse: with CK low, the path **red inverter → C̄K̄ switch → inverter → inverter → back to A** contains **three inversions in a closed loop**. Three inversions is negative feedback — that's a **ring oscillator**, not a latch (a latch needs an even number of inversions). If the red inverter is strong enough to overpower Inv₁'s held output, the circuit oscillates during the entire CK-low phase and division fails. Note that if the clock is *stopped* low and X leaks away, this is exactly what happens — the opposite of the claimed \"static\" behavior.\n\n- Even if sized very weak, it degrades the levels at B (and thus at Y) and pre-biases B toward its next value, aggravating the race at the CK rising edge where B must not flip before the C̄K̄ switch opens.\n\nSo the red inverter is effectively a **feedforward bypass of the clocked switch** — it tends to make the first latch *transparent all the time*, which is the opposite of a keeper.\n\n## What the correct fix would look like\n\nTo truly remove the minimum clock frequency, the circuit must be made static at the *storage* nodes:\n\n- a **weak (or clocked) inverter from B back to X**, genuinely anti-parallel with Inv₁, and\n- a similar keeper around the second stage to hold **Y**,\n\ni.e., convert both dynamic latches into static latches — at the usual cost of contention/speed.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "79f0b5f5fba027c1e5af0962b85b7908994a9ec0725920afa9343ced0c6fae69"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "Correctly rejects the keeper interpretation and identifies the feedforward bypass, contention with Inv1, and possible three-inversion loop. However, it omits the key tradeoff that the branch can improve high-speed operation but raises the minimum usable clock rate at low frequencies, and it attributes the remaining frequency limit mainly to leakage.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "172cbb780508db2c8965d08eedaac49be4edfaf50993cf59fb05d5d161e1fa3c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1305,
        "output_tokens": 32894,
        "total_tokens": 34199,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 31715,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1305,
        "output_tokens": 32894,
        "total_tokens": 34199,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 31715,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "How do we optimize the circuit shown in the figure for the NF if Rin must remain equal to 50 Ohm?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Recognizing the key constraint\n\nThis is an inverter‑type (current‑reuse) feedback LNA: M1 and M2 both amplify, so the stage has\n\n- total transconductance: $G_m = g_{m1}+g_{m2}$\n- feedback resistor $R_F$ from output to input (it also self‑biases the stage; it carries **no DC current**).\n\nNeglecting channel‑length modulation, all of the drain signal current must return through $R_F$, which gives the important result:\n\n$$R_{in}=\\frac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}$$\n\n**independent of $R_F$.** Therefore the matching requirement $R_{in} = R_S = 50\\,\\Omega$ *pins the total transconductance*:\n\n$$g_{m1}+g_{m2} = \\frac{1}{50\\,\\Omega} = 20\\ \\text{mS}$$\n\n## What this does to the noise figure\n\nWith $G_m R_S = 1$, computing the output noise due to $R_S$, the two transistors ($\\overline{i_n^2}=4kT\\gamma(g_{m1}+g_{m2})$), and $R_F$ gives:\n\n$$\\text{NF} = 1+\\gamma\\left(\\frac{R_F+R_S}{R_F-R_S}\\right)^{2}+\\frac{4R_SR_F}{(R_F-R_S)^2}\\;\\xrightarrow{R_F\\gg R_S}\\;1+\\gamma+\\frac{4R_S}{R_F}$$\n\nInterpretation:\n\n- The **transistor contribution ($\\approx \\gamma$) is fixed** — we cannot raise $G_m$ to reduce it, because matching locks $G_m$ at 20 mS. (Current reuse only helps by achieving the 20 mS at half the bias current; if $\\gamma_P \\ne \\gamma_N$, skew the $g_m$ split toward the lower‑$\\gamma$ device while keeping the sum at 20 mS.)\n- The **only remaining free parameter is $R_F$**, whose contribution falls as $4R_S/R_F$.\n\n## The optimization\n\n**Keep $g_{m1}+g_{m2}=20$ mS and make $R_F$ as large as possible.** This:\n\n1. Drives the $R_F$ noise term $4R_S/R_F \\rightarrow 0$, so $\\text{NF} \\rightarrow 1+\\gamma$ (e.g., ≈ 2.2 dB for $\\gamma = 2/3$, ≈ 3 dB for $\\gamma = 1$);\n2. Simultaneously raises the gain, $|A_v| \\approx \\dfrac{1}{2}\\left(\\dfrac{R_F}{R_S}-1\\right)$, which further suppresses the noise contribution of the following stage;\n3. Costs no voltage headroom, since $R_F$ conducts no DC current (the inverter self‑biases at $V_{in}=V_{out}$).\n\n## Practical limits on $R_F$\n\n- **Finite $r_o$:** in reality $R_{in}=(R_F+r_{o1}\\|r_{o2})/(1+G_m r_{o1}\\|r_{o2})$, so a very large $R_F$ raises $R_{in}$ above 50 Ω unless $G_m$ (and hence power) is increased.\n- **Bandwidth:** $R_F$ together with input/output and Miller capacitances sets poles that degrade gain and $S_{11}$ at high frequency.\n\nSo the design recipe is: fix $g_{m1}+g_{m2}=20$ mS for the match, then push $R_F$ to the largest value the bandwidth/$r_o$ budget allows; the NF then asymptotically approaches its floor of $1+\\gamma$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "9f436a0213b5e9bfa81344682e2c54048078584b5876e6c45a43f6d4ba2b1938"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The topology and finite-r_o input-resistance relation are recognized, but the proposed optimization pins g_m=1/R_s and concludes NF cannot go below 1+\\gamma. The key result is to increase g_m above 1/R_s and adjust R_F to keep the match, allowing lower NF.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "6801650fd2054e7d374317849fcda2881c563a35f3d14b44d310d3d32f91b1cd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2687,
        "output_tokens": 12906,
        "total_tokens": 15593,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11656,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2687,
        "output_tokens": 12906,
        "total_tokens": 15593,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11656,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "How do we optimize the circuit shown in the figure for the NF if Rin must remain equal to 50 Ohm?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting up the constraint\n\nWith channel‑length modulation neglected, this self‑biased inverter LNA (both gates driven, so M₁ and M₂ amplify in parallel) has\n\n$$R_{in} = \\frac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}$$\n\nSo the matching requirement **pins the total transconductance**:\n\n$$g_{m1}+g_{m2} = \\frac{1}{R_S} = \\frac{1}{50\\,\\Omega} = 20\\ \\text{mS}$$\n\nWe have no freedom in the transistors' $g_m$. The *only* remaining design knob is $R_F$.\n\n## NF dependence on R_F\n\nFor the matched condition ($g_m R_S = 1$), the noise factor works out to\n\n$$F = 1 + \\gamma\\left(\\frac{R_F+R_S}{R_F-R_S}\\right)^2 + \\frac{4R_S R_F}{(R_F-R_S)^2} \\;\\approx\\; 1 + \\gamma + \\frac{4R_S}{R_F}\\quad (R_F \\gg R_S)$$\n\nBoth $R_F$-dependent terms fall monotonically as $R_F$ grows: the feedback resistor's own noise contribution shrinks as $4R_S/R_F$, and the transistor term converges to $\\gamma$.\n\n## The answer: maximize R_F\n\n**Increase $R_F$ as much as possible.** Note that this costs nothing in headroom: since $C_1$ blocks DC and the gates draw no current, $R_F$ carries **zero bias current** — it merely self-biases the inverter at its trip point. In the limit:\n\n$$NF_{min} \\rightarrow 1 + \\gamma$$\n\ne.g., ≈ 3 dB for $\\gamma \\approx 1$ (short channel), ≈ 2.2 dB for $\\gamma = 2/3$. This floor is fundamental to the topology — the matching condition $g_m R_S = 1$ fixes the transistor noise contribution.\n\n## Practical limits on R_F\n\n- **Gain rises**: $|A_v| \\approx \\tfrac{1}{2}(g_m R_F - 1) \\approx R_F/(2R_S)$, so linearity/compression degrades.\n- **Output resistance rises**: $R_{out} \\approx (R_F + R_S)/2$, limiting bandwidth with load capacitance and the ability to drive the next stage.\n- **Channel-length modulation**: once $R_F$ becomes comparable to $r_{O1}\\|r_{O2}$, the $\\lambda = 0$ assumption fails; finite $r_O$ also alters $R_{in}$ and caps the benefit.\n\nA secondary note: the *split* between $g_{m1}$ and $g_{m2}$ doesn't affect the NF to first order (noise and transconductance both scale with the sum), though if $\\gamma_p < \\gamma_n$ one can skew the allocation slightly toward the PMOS. The current reuse simply lets you reach 20 mS at lower bias current.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c7eb5d934eb82a1e7e02d8fbd974d43b130e9bca7d48acddcfafe5d88b8e30a3"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It assumes Rin≈1/gm pins gm at 1/Rs and concludes NF cannot beat 1+γ, missing the key finite-output-resistance result: gm can be increased while RF is adjusted to preserve the 50 Ω match, reducing NF below 1+γ.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "6801650fd2054e7d374317849fcda2881c563a35f3d14b44d310d3d32f91b1cd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2687,
        "output_tokens": 14584,
        "total_tokens": 17271,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13574,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2687,
        "output_tokens": 14584,
        "total_tokens": 17271,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13574,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "How do we optimize the circuit shown in the figure for the NF if Rin must remain equal to 50 Ohm?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setting up the constraint\n\nFor this self‑biased inverter LNA (M₁ and M₂ both act as transconductors, R_F provides feedback), neglecting channel-length modulation:\n\n$$R_{in} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}$$\n\nThe 50 Ω match therefore **pins the total transconductance**:\n\n$$g_{m1}+g_{m2} = \\frac{1}{50\\,\\Omega} = 20\\ \\text{mS}$$\n\nThis removes the usual NF knob — you *cannot* lower the transistors' noise contribution by burning more current to raise $g_m$, because that would destroy the match.\n\n## What's left to optimize\n\nWith the input matched ($G_m R_S = 1$, where $G_m = g_{m1}+g_{m2}$), the noise factor works out to:\n\n$$\\text{NF} = 1 + \\gamma\\left(\\frac{R_F+R_S}{R_F-R_S}\\right)^2 + \\frac{4R_S R_F}{(R_F-R_S)^2} \\;\\approx\\; 1 + \\gamma + 4(1+\\gamma)\\frac{R_S}{R_F}\\quad (R_F \\gg R_S)$$\n\nEvery term involving $R_F$ **decreases monotonically as $R_F$ increases**. So the answer is:\n\n**Maximize $R_F$, while re-sizing/re-biasing M₁ and M₂ to keep $g_{m1}+g_{m2} = 20$ mS.**\n\nAs $R_F \\to \\infty$, the NF approaches its floor of $1+\\gamma$ (≈ 3 dB for γ ≈ 1; ≈ 2.2 dB for γ = 2/3). For example, with γ = 1:\n\n| $R_F$ | NF |\n|---|---|\n| 500 Ω | ≈ 4.8 dB |\n| 1 kΩ | ≈ 3.9 dB |\n| → ∞ | → 3.0 dB |\n\nA large $R_F$ is feasible here because it carries **no DC current** (it connects to the gates, so it self-biases the inverter without headroom penalty). It also raises the gain, $|A_v| \\approx R_F/(2R_S)$, which further suppresses the noise of following stages.\n\n## Secondary measures\n\n- **Current reuse is already the point of M₂:** since $G_m$ is fixed at 20 mS, splitting it between NMOS and PMOS delivers the required transconductance at roughly half the bias current, and the \"load\" device's noise is accompanied by useful gain instead of being pure penalty.\n- If $\\gamma_n \\neq \\gamma_p$, skew the split toward the lower-γ device, since the transistor term is really $(\\gamma_n g_{m1} + \\gamma_p g_{m2})R_S / (G_m R_S)^2$.\n- Make $C_1$ large enough to be transparent at the signal frequency, and minimize physical gate resistance (multi-finger layout), since it adds directly to NF.\n\n## Practical limits on $R_F$\n\n- **Finite $r_O$:** more exactly, $R_{in} = (R_F + r_{O1}\\|r_{O2})/(1 + G_m\\, r_{O1}\\|r_{O2})$, so as $R_F$ grows, $G_m$ must be increased (more current) to hold 50 Ω.\n- **Bandwidth:** $R_{out} \\approx (R_F + R_S)/2$, so a large $R_F$ with load capacitance limits the bandwidth.\n\nBottom line: with the match clamping $g_{m1}+g_{m2}$, the *only* NF degree of freedom is $R_F$ — push it as high as bandwidth and bias current allow, accepting that this topology cannot do better than $\\text{NF} = 1 + \\gamma$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "58a00fac675f9707df283a2650f39eccdae0483fa892ac9317d83430c0d29221"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The answer reaches the rejected conclusion that the match pins gm at 1/Rs and NF cannot improve below 1+γ. Although it gives the finite-ro input-resistance relation and notes gm must rise as RF grows, it fails to connect that adjustment to NF falling below 1+γ.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "6801650fd2054e7d374317849fcda2881c563a35f3d14b44d310d3d32f91b1cd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2687,
        "output_tokens": 17528,
        "total_tokens": 20215,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 16253,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2687,
        "output_tokens": 17528,
        "total_tokens": 20215,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 16253,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-017-compute-input-impedance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Compute the input impedance of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-017-compute-input-impedance/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Recognizing the Topology\n\nThis is a feedback **transimpedance amplifier (TIA)**:\n\n* **Stage 1:** $M_1$ + $R_{D1}$ = common‑source stage → gain from $P$ to $X$: $\\;-g_{m1}R_{D1}$\n* **Stage 2:** $M_2$–$M_3$ = differential pair (tail $I_{SS}$), driven single‑endedly at $M_2$'s gate, output taken at $M_3$'s drain → gain from $X$ to output: $\\;+\\dfrac{g_{m2,3}}{2}R_{D2}$, with output resistance $R_{D2}$\n* **Feedback:** $R_F$ returns $V_{out}$ to the input node $P$ (shunt–shunt feedback).\n\nSo the core amplifier is inverting with open‑loop gain\n\n$$A_0=g_{m1}R_{D1}\\cdot\\frac{g_{m2,3}}{2}R_{D2}$$\n\n(neglecting $r_O$, body effect, and device capacitances; $I_{SS}$ ideal).\n\n## Computing $R_{in}$\n\nApply a test voltage $v_x$ at node $P$. Since the gate of $M_1$ draws no current, the entire test current flows through $R_F$:\n\n$$i_x=\\frac{v_x-v_{out}}{R_F}$$\n\nModel the amplifier output as a Thévenin source $-A_0v_x$ behind $R_{D2}$. The current $i_x$ entering the output node through $R_F$ raises $v_{out}$:\n\n$$v_{out}=-A_0v_x+i_xR_{D2}$$\n\nSubstituting:\n\n$$i_xR_F=v_x+A_0v_x-i_xR_{D2}\\;\\;\\Longrightarrow\\;\\; i_x\\left(R_F+R_{D2}\\right)=(1+A_0)\\,v_x$$\n\n$$\\boxed{R_{in}=\\frac{v_x}{i_x}=\\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+A_0}=\\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+\\dfrac{g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,g_{m2,3}R_{D2}}{2}}}$$\n\n## Remarks\n\n* **Interpretation:** The feedback resistor is \"Miller‑divided\" — the input sees $R_F$ (plus the amplifier's output resistance $R_{D2}$) reduced by the loop gain.\n\n* **Typical approximation** (large $A_0$, $R_{D2}\\ll R_F$):\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx\\frac{R_F}{1+A_0}$$\n\nwhich is exactly why the TIA presents a low impedance to the photodiode.\n\n* **Impedance seen by the source $I_{in}$** (including the diode capacitance):\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)=R_{in}\\parallel\\frac{1}{sC_{in}}=\\frac{R_{in}}{1+sR_{in}C_{in}}$$\n\n— the small $R_{in}$ pushes the input pole $\\dfrac{1+A_0}{2\\pi (R_F + R_{D2})C_{in}}$ to a much higher frequency than $R_F$ alone would allow.\n\n(If $M_2$, $M_3$ are not matched, replace $g_{m2,3}/2$ by $\\dfrac{g_{m2}g_{m3}}{g_{m2}+g_{m3}}$.)",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c7df0c22dd3b292fb88cb88e689c32fed9768bd304d111de4cde33a5b63f029d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Gives the exact input resistance, Rin = (RF + RD2)/(1 + A0), and the correct unloaded gain definition. The test-source derivation correctly accounts for RD2 in the feedback path.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d478f09ce99c16f2ada89711c88d0564aa20ae775a06fad0c89d6658dc32fb99",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 225,
        "output_tokens": 27763,
        "total_tokens": 27988,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 26599,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 225,
        "output_tokens": 27763,
        "total_tokens": 27988,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 26599,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-017-compute-input-impedance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Compute the input impedance of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-017-compute-input-impedance/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Recognizing the topology\n\nThis is a **shunt–shunt feedback TIA**: \n\n* **Stage 1:** $M_1$ + $R_{D1}$ = common‑source amplifier (input $P$, output $X$)\n* **Stage 2:** $M_2$–$M_3$ = differential pair biased by $I_{SS}$, driven single‑endedly at the gate of $M_2$, output taken at the drain of $M_3$ across $R_{D2}$\n* **Feedback:** $R_F$ returns $V_{out}$ to the input node $P$\n\n## Open-loop gain (λ = γ = 0, ideal $I_{SS}$)\n\n**Stage 1:**\n$$v_X=-g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,v_P$$\n\n**Stage 2:** With an ideal tail source, $M_2$ is degenerated by the impedance looking into $M_3$'s source ($1/g_{m3}$), so the current delivered to the output node is\n\n$$i_{out}=\\frac{g_{m2}g_{m3}}{g_{m2}+g_{m3}}\\,v_X \\;\\xrightarrow{\\,g_{m2}=g_{m3}\\,}\\; \\frac{g_{m2,3}}{2}v_X ,$$\n\nand the output resistance of this stage is simply $R_{D2}$. Hence the total (unloaded) gain is\n\n$$A_0=\\;g_{m1}R_{D1}\\cdot\\frac{g_{m2,3}}{2}R_{D2}\\qquad(\\text{inverting overall — negative feedback }\\checkmark)$$\n\n## Input resistance\n\nInject a test current $i_x$ into node $P$. Since the gate of $M_1$ draws no current, **all of $i_x$ flows through $R_F$** into the output node:\n\n$$v_{out}=v_P-i_xR_F$$\n\nModeling the amplifier output as a Thévenin source $-A_0v_P$ behind $R_{D2}$, the same current entering the output node gives:\n\n$$v_{out}=-A_0v_P+i_xR_{D2}$$\n\nEquating:\n\n$$(1+A_0)\\,v_P=i_x\\,(R_F+R_{D2})$$\n\n$$\\boxed{R_{in}=\\frac{v_P}{i_x}=\\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+\\dfrac{g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,g_{m2,3}\\,R_{D2}}{2}}}$$\n\n(With unequal devices, replace $g_{m2,3}/2$ by $g_{m2}g_{m3}/(g_{m2}+g_{m3})$.)\n\n## Including $C_{in}$\n\nThe full input impedance seen by $I_{in}$ is this resistance in parallel with the input capacitance:\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)=\\frac{1}{sC_{in}}\\,\\Big\\Vert\\,\\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+\\tfrac{1}{2}g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m2,3}R_{D2}}$$\n\n**Sanity check:** for $A_0\\gg1$ and $R_{D2}\\ll R_F$, this reduces to the classic TIA result $R_{in}\\approx R_F/(1+A_0)$ — the feedback resistor divided by the loop gain, which is exactly why the feedback makes the input node low-impedance (fast) despite the large transimpedance $\\approx R_F$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6c33beacd9f17e95ede20fd6fa1ca26e3f544336742d94c9f83d1c497cb62b78"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Gives the exact input resistance, (RF + RD2)/(1 + A0), and the correct unloaded-gain expression for the stated model. The additional capacitance and limiting-case discussion do not undermine the result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d478f09ce99c16f2ada89711c88d0564aa20ae775a06fad0c89d6658dc32fb99",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 225,
        "output_tokens": 16201,
        "total_tokens": 16426,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15042,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 225,
        "output_tokens": 16201,
        "total_tokens": 16426,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15042,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-017-compute-input-impedance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Compute the input impedance of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-017-compute-input-impedance/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Recognizing the topology\n\nThis is a **feedback transimpedance amplifier (TIA)**:\n\n* **$M_1$ + $R_{D1}$**: common‑source stage → gain from $P$ to $X$ is $-g_{m1}R_{D1}$ (the gate of $M_2$ draws no current).\n* **$M_2$–$M_3$ + $I_{SS}$ + $R_{D2}$**: a differential pair driven at one input ($M_2$'s gate at $X$, $M_3$'s gate at AC ground $V_b$). Equivalently, $M_2$ is a source follower driving $M_3$ as a common‑gate stage. With $g_{m2}=g_{m3}\\equiv g_{m2,3}$ and an ideal tail source, the gain from $X$ to the output is $+\\tfrac{1}{2}g_{m2,3}R_{D2}$.\n* **$R_F$** closes the loop from $V_{out}$ back to the input node $P$.\n\nSo the core amplifier is inverting, with open-loop gain\n\n$$-A_0,\\qquad A_0 = g_{m1}R_{D1}\\cdot\\frac{g_{m2,3}R_{D2}}{2},$$\n\nand output resistance $R_{D2}$. (Negative feedback: $v_P\\!\\uparrow \\Rightarrow v_X\\!\\downarrow \\Rightarrow v_{out}\\!\\downarrow$, pulling $P$ back down through $R_F$.)\n\n## Computing $R_{in}$\n\nApply a test voltage $v_P$ at node $P$. Since the gate of $M_1$ draws no current, **all test current flows through $R_F$**:\n\n$$i_t=\\frac{v_P-v_{out}}{R_F}$$\n\nFirst stage: $v_X=-g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,v_P$. The pair steers a current $\\tfrac{g_{m2,3}}{2}v_X$ into the output node, so KCL at $V_{out}$ gives:\n\n$$\\frac{g_{m2,3}}{2}v_X+\\frac{v_P-v_{out}}{R_F}=\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D2}}\n\\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\;\nv_{out}=\\frac{R_{D2}-A_0R_F}{R_F+R_{D2}}\\,v_P$$\n\nTherefore:\n\n$$i_t=\\frac{v_P-v_{out}}{R_F}=\\frac{(1+A_0)\\,v_P}{R_F+R_{D2}}$$\n\n$$\\boxed{\\,R_{in}=\\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+A_0}\n=\\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+\\dfrac{g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,g_{m2,3}R_{D2}}{2}}\\;\\approx\\;\\frac{R_F}{1+A_0}\\,}$$\n\n(The approximation holds since typically $R_F\\gg R_{D2}$.) The impedance actually seen by the current source also includes the photodiode capacitance:\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)=\\frac{1}{sC_{in}}\\ \\Big\\|\\ \\frac{R_F+R_{D2}}{1+A_0}$$\n\n## Interpretation\n\n$R_F$ bridges the input and output of an inverting amplifier, so it is **Miller‑multiplied**: $R_{in}\\approx R_F/(1+A_0)$. This is the whole point of the feedback TIA — it provides a transimpedance gain $v_{out}/i_{in}\\approx -R_F$ while presenting a *low* input resistance, pushing the input pole $\\;\\omega_{in}\\approx \\dfrac{1+A_0}{(R_F+R_{D2})C_{in}}\\;$ to a much higher frequency than a simple resistor would allow.\n\n*(Assumptions: $\\lambda=0$, ideal $I_{SS}$, matched $M_2,M_3$, no body effect. With channel-length modulation, replace $R_{D1}\\to R_{D1}\\|r_{O1}$, $R_{D2}\\to R_{D2}\\|r_{O3,eff}$.)*",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a046447f3bab3cfda6fcc0c7adc7f5b241cc0b5ee9ac07fd1dc7fb5e437a3309"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Gives the exact input-resistance result, \\(R_{in}=(R_F+R_{D2})/(1+A_0)\\), with the correct unloaded gain \\(A_0=\\tfrac12 g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m2,3}R_{D2}\\).",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d478f09ce99c16f2ada89711c88d0564aa20ae775a06fad0c89d6658dc32fb99",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 225,
        "output_tokens": 21750,
        "total_tokens": 21975,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 20341,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 225,
        "output_tokens": 21750,
        "total_tokens": 21975,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 20341,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "If the LDO regulator in the figure generates thermal noise with spectrum Sth, how do we compute the VCO output phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setup\n\nModel the LDO's output noise as a small series voltage source $v_n(t)$ (PSD $S_{th}(f)$, in V²/Hz) riding on $V_{out}$. Because the two inductors carry this voltage to nodes X and Y, **supply noise moves the common-mode level of the tank**, and since the varactors $M_{v1}$, $M_{v2}$ have their other terminal tied to the ground-referenced $V_{cont}$, the noise directly changes the voltage across the varactors — i.e., it modulates the oscillation frequency exactly as $V_{cont}$ would (drain junction caps of $M_1$, $M_2$ contribute too).\n\n## Step 1: Define the supply pushing (sensitivity)\n\n$$K_{VDD} = \\frac{\\partial f_{osc}}{\\partial V_{out}} \\quad [\\text{Hz/V}]$$\n\nIn this topology, $|K_{VDD}| \\approx K_{VCO}$ because the varactor modulation path dominates.\n\n## Step 2: Noise → frequency modulation\n\n$$f_{osc}(t) = f_0 + K_{VDD}\\, v_n(t)$$\n\n## Step 3: Frequency → phase (integration)\n\nThe excess phase is the integral of the frequency deviation:\n\n$$\\phi_n(t) = 2\\pi K_{VDD}\\int v_n(t)\\,dt \\;\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\; \\Phi_n(f) = \\frac{K_{VDD}}{jf}V_n(f)$$\n\nThe $1/f$ factor from integration means the PSD is divided by $f^2$:\n\n$$\\boxed{S_{\\phi}(f) = \\frac{K_{VDD}^2}{f^2}\\,S_{th}(f)} \\quad [\\text{rad}^2/\\text{Hz}]$$\n\nand the single-sideband phase noise at offset $\\Delta f$:\n\n$$\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f) = 10\\log_{10}\\!\\left[\\frac{K_{VDD}^2\\,S_{th}(\\Delta f)}{2\\,\\Delta f^2}\\right] \\;\\;\\text{dBc/Hz}$$\n\n## Equivalent view (narrowband FM)\n\nA supply tone $V_m\\cos(2\\pi f_m t)$ produces sidebands at $f_0 \\pm f_m$ with relative magnitude $K_{VDD}V_m/(2f_m)$; replacing the tone power $V_m^2/2$ with $S_{th}$ per unit bandwidth gives the same result.\n\n## Observations\n\n- Since thermal noise $S_{th}$ is flat, the supply-induced phase noise falls at **–20 dB/dec**, i.e., it is indistinguishable in shape from the VCO's own white-noise-induced phase noise and directly adds to it.\n- **Example:** $K_{VDD} = 50$ MHz/V, LDO output noise $10\\ \\text{nV}/\\sqrt{\\text{Hz}}$, at $\\Delta f = 1$ MHz:\n$$\\mathcal{L} = 10\\log\\frac{(5\\times10^7)^2 (10^{-16})}{2(10^6)^2} \\approx -129\\ \\text{dBc/Hz}$$\nwhich can easily dominate a good LC VCO's intrinsic noise.\n- To reduce this contribution: lower $S_{th}$ (larger error-amp $g_m$, filtered bandgap reference, output decoupling) and/or lower $K_{VDD}$ (smaller varactors, moving to digitally dominated tuning via banks $B_1$, $B_2$).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c632435ef0d47e11b066c99e8b63fbfc4a26fcf318e6985fe2a5e87e4afdcd3d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly models LDO noise as supply pushing, converts it through dfosc/dVout and FM-to-phase integration with the required 1/Δf² dependence, and gives the matching SSB expression. It also captures the direct varactor coupling and the benefit of reducing supply sensitivity/KVCO; minor secondary details do not affect correctness.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f40f5d47fc68dc67261745b47ef8f93ebeabc96a5ea084c1e3fcf7bea12e1811",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3732,
        "output_tokens": 6605,
        "total_tokens": 10337,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5385,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3732,
        "output_tokens": 6605,
        "total_tokens": 10337,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5385,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "If the LDO regulator in the figure generates thermal noise with spectrum Sth, how do we compute the VCO output phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setup\n\nThe LDO's thermal noise appears in series with the VCO supply:\n\n$$V_{out}(t) = V_{out,0} + v_n(t), \\qquad S_{v_n}(f) = S_{th}$$\n\nSince the inductors carry no DC drop, the common-mode voltage at **X** and **Y** tracks $V_{out}$. The varactors $M_{v1,2}$ see the voltage $V_{XY,CM} - V_{cont}$, so supply noise modulates the varactor capacitance exactly as control-line noise would. The circuit therefore has a **supply pushing gain**\n\n$$K_{VDD} = \\frac{\\partial f_{osc}}{\\partial V_{out}} \\;\\;\\left[\\tfrac{\\text{Hz}}{\\text{V}}\\right], \\qquad |K_{VDD}| \\approx |K_{VCO}|$$\n\n(obtained by simulation/measurement: perturb $V_{out}$ slightly and observe $\\Delta f_{osc}$).\n\n## Noise → FM → Phase Noise\n\nThe supply noise frequency-modulates the carrier:\n\n$$x(t) = A\\cos\\!\\Big(\\omega_0 t + 2\\pi K_{VDD}\\!\\int_0^t v_n(\\tau)\\,d\\tau\\Big)$$\n\nThe integration converts to $1/(j\\omega)$ in the frequency domain, so the excess-phase spectrum at offset $\\Delta f$ is\n\n$$S_{\\phi}(\\Delta f) = \\frac{(2\\pi K_{VDD})^2}{(2\\pi \\Delta f)^2}\\,S_{th} = \\left(\\frac{K_{VDD}}{\\Delta f}\\right)^{\\!2} S_{th}\\quad \\left[\\tfrac{\\text{rad}^2}{\\text{Hz}}\\right]$$\n\nFor small phase deviation (narrowband FM), the single-sideband phase noise is\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;\\mathcal{L}(\\Delta f) = \\frac{1}{2}\\,\\frac{K_{VDD}^2}{\\Delta f^{2}}\\,S_{th}\\;}\\qquad \\mathcal{L}\\big|_{dBc/Hz} = 10\\log_{10}\\!\\left(\\frac{K_{VDD}^2\\,S_{th}}{2\\,\\Delta f^2}\\right)$$\n\n(the factor ½ comes from the SSB convention $\\mathcal{L} = S_\\phi/2$; it is sometimes omitted).\n\n## Observations\n\n- **Slope:** $S_{th}$ is white, so this contribution falls at **–20 dB/dec**, adding directly on top of the VCO's intrinsic $1/f^2$ phase noise region. (LDO *flicker* noise would similarly produce a $1/f^3$ term.)\n- **Why the sensitivity is high:** because the varactors reference $V_{cont}$ to the output common mode, the supply path is as strong as the tuning path ($K_{VDD}\\approx K_{VCO}$) — this is precisely why a low-noise LDO is needed here.\n- **Filtering:** if the LDO output pole / decoupling capacitor shapes the noise, use the *shaped* spectrum $S_{th}(\\Delta f)$ at each offset in the formula.\n- **Total noise:** add this term (in power) to the oscillator's inherent phase noise, since the two mechanisms are uncorrelated.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "9f2c930567754475edd8440ce42c0efa22b5cb1fbc9ce0e9b32f3c752ba79062"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies supply pushing through the varactors, relates the sensitivity to KVCO, and derives the expected 1/Δf² phase-noise conversion with an appropriate SSB expression. The additional observations are consistent with the solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f40f5d47fc68dc67261745b47ef8f93ebeabc96a5ea084c1e3fcf7bea12e1811",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3732,
        "output_tokens": 6902,
        "total_tokens": 10634,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5749,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3732,
        "output_tokens": 6902,
        "total_tokens": 10634,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5749,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "If the LDO regulator in the figure generates thermal noise with spectrum Sth, how do we compute the VCO output phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Setup: LDO noise acts as supply pushing (FM) on the VCO\n\nThe LDO's output noise rides on $V_{out}$, the oscillator's supply node. Because the inductors carry this voltage to nodes $X$ and $Y$, the **common-mode level of the tank equals $V_{out}$**. Since the varactors $M_{v1,2}$ see $V_{X,CM} - V_{cont} = V_{out} - V_{cont}$, noise on $V_{out}$ modulates the varactor capacitance exactly like noise on $V_{cont}$ — i.e., the supply sensitivity here is roughly equal in magnitude to the VCO gain:\n\n$$K_{VDD} = \\frac{\\partial f_{osc}}{\\partial V_{out}} \\approx -K_{VCO} \\quad \\text{(Hz/V, plus junction-cap contributions)}$$\n\nIn practice, $K_{VDD}$ (\"supply pushing\") is obtained by simulation: perturb $V_{out}$ slightly and record $\\Delta f_{osc}$.\n\n## Step 1: Noise → frequency modulation\n\nThe instantaneous frequency becomes\n\n$$f_{osc}(t) = f_0 + K_{VDD}\\, v_n(t)$$\n\n## Step 2: Frequency → phase (integration)\n\nThe excess phase is the integral of the frequency deviation:\n\n$$\\phi_n(t) = 2\\pi K_{VDD} \\int_0^t v_n(\\tau)\\, d\\tau$$\n\nIntegration multiplies the spectrum by $1/(2\\pi f_m)^2$, so the phase spectrum at offset $f_m$ is\n\n$$S_{\\phi}(f_m) = \\frac{K_{VDD}^2\\, S_{th}}{f_m^2} \\quad [\\text{rad}^2/\\text{Hz}]$$\n\n## Step 3: Phase noise\n\nTreating a 1-Hz slice of noise at $f_m$ as a sinusoid of amplitude $\\sqrt{2S_{th}}$, narrowband FM gives sidebands of relative amplitude $K_{VDD}\\sqrt{2S_{th}}/(2f_m)$, hence\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;\\mathcal{L}(f_m) = 10\\log_{10}\\!\\left(\\frac{K_{VDD}^2\\, S_{th}}{2 f_m^2}\\right)\\ \\text{dBc/Hz}\\;}$$\n\n(equivalently $\\mathcal{L} = S_\\phi/2$ in the one-sided convention).\n\n## Observations\n\n- **Shape:** Since thermal noise $S_{th}$ is white, this contribution falls at **–20 dB/dec**, adding directly on top of the oscillator's intrinsic $1/f_m^2$ (Leeson) region. The LDO's *flicker* noise would similarly produce a $1/f_m^3$ component.\n- **Design implication:** Because $|K_{VDD}| \\approx K_{VCO}$ in this topology, the LDO output noise is as harmful as noise on $V_{cont}$. For a target $\\mathcal{L}$ at offset $f_m$, the LDO must satisfy $S_{th} < 2 f_m^2 \\cdot 10^{\\mathcal{L}/10} / K_{VCO}^2$.\n- **Caveat:** Supply noise also amplitude-modulates the oscillation; AM-to-PM conversion through the varactors can add to the above, but the first-order result is the $K_{VDD}$ term computed here.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "e9f6c8938462ebbda73a9e149abfe652cd4701b0921e82a672ea8a5e5bc63e03"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies supply pushing, relates the sensitivity to KVCO, and converts LDO noise through frequency-to-phase integration to the expected 1/fm² phase-noise contribution. The formula and design implication match the golden solution; additional observations do not undermine the result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f40f5d47fc68dc67261745b47ef8f93ebeabc96a5ea084c1e3fcf7bea12e1811",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3732,
        "output_tokens": 6691,
        "total_tokens": 10423,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5500,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3732,
        "output_tokens": 6691,
        "total_tokens": 10423,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5500,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "We add CT to the tail node, as in the figure. What happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nIt's a trade‑off — and usually the phase noise actually gets **worse**, not better.\n\n## The intended benefit\n\nThe common‑source node *P* moves at **2ω₀** (the pair acts as a frequency doubler for common-mode signals). Noise of the tail current source around **2ω₀** is mixed down by the switching pair and shows up as phase noise sidebands around ω₀. \n\nSince C_T shunts the current‑source noise at high frequencies, it does suppress this **2ω₀ tail-noise contribution**. (Note it does *nothing* for the low-frequency/flicker noise of I_SS, which still modulates the amplitude and converts to phase noise through the varactors.)\n\n## The hidden penalty\n\nC_T turns node *P* into an **AC ground**. This hurts in two ways:\n\n**1. Tank Q degradation.** With large swings, M₁ and M₂ alternately enter the deep triode region. \n- *Without* C_T: the triode device's on-resistance appears **in series** with the high impedance of the current source, so the tank is barely loaded.\n- *With* C_T: the on-resistance R_on of the triode device now connects the tank node (X or Y) **directly to AC ground** for part of every cycle. The average tank Q drops, and phase noise rises across the board.\n\n**2. Pair noise injection.** With the source node grounded by C_T, the \"on\" transistor behaves like a common-source device whose channel noise flows straight into the tank, instead of being degenerated/blocked by the high tail impedance.\n\n## Net result\n\nUnless the swing is kept small enough that M₁ and M₂ never enter triode, the Q-loading mechanism dominates and the **overall phase noise degrades**. The impedance at *P* must be *low* to filter the tail noise but *high* at 2ω₀ to avoid loading the tank — a contradiction a single capacitor can't resolve.\n\nThis is why the proper fix is the **tail noise filter** (Hegazi et al.): an inductor in series with the tail, resonating with the node-*P* capacitance at 2ω₀ (high impedance where it matters), plus a large capacitor across the current source to kill its noise.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "41764b82e8d21d454fac7c680e3b2df6c9d5aa98c9a78151df309917394c22fd"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It recognizes that CT filters tail noise and identifies triode operation as a possible penalty, but misses the class-C mechanism that can improve phase noise and concludes that CT usually worsens it. This is only partial credit for the tradeoff and a relevant degradation mechanism.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "30f6431c053d0ebf26268170667295ea7bd412e72a78ea0b3247e5803cbdfc8a",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3854,
        "output_tokens": 7353,
        "total_tokens": 11207,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6630,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3854,
        "output_tokens": 7353,
        "total_tokens": 11207,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6630,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "We add CT to the tail node, as in the figure. What happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\n\nA tail capacitor mainly **suppresses the phase‑noise contribution of the tail current source**, because it shunts the source's noise — most importantly the thermal noise around **2ω₀** — to ground before the differential pair can commutate it into the tank. But it's a double‑edged sword: if C_T is made large, it also creates a mechanism that *degrades* phase noise.\n\n## Why the tail node matters\n\n- M₁–M₂ steer I_SS back and forth at ω₀, so they act as a **single‑balanced mixer** for anything injected at node *P* (which itself bounces at 2ω₀).\n- Tail noise near the **even harmonics, chiefly 2ω₀ ± Δω**, is mixed down to ω₀ ± Δω, flows differentially into the tank, and appears as phase sidebands → a significant part of the 1/f² phase noise.\n- Low-frequency (flicker) tail noise modulates the **amplitude**, and converts to phase noise only through AM–PM conversion (e.g., varactors).\n\n## What C_T does (the benefit)\n\nAt 2ω₀ the capacitor presents a small impedance, 1/(2ω₀C_T), forming a current divider with the impedance looking into the common source (≈ 1/g_m of the \"on\" transistor). If\n\n$$\\frac{1}{2\\omega_0 C_T} \\ll \\frac{1}{g_m},$$\n\nessentially all of the current source's high-frequency noise is absorbed by C_T instead of being commutated to the output. **The tail-noise contribution to the 1/f² region drops**, and the 2ω₀ bounce at *P* is smoothed as a bonus.\n\n## What it does *not* fix, and the hidden cost\n\n- **Flicker noise of I_SS is untouched** — C_T is an open circuit at small Δω, so the close-in 1/f³ noise (via AM–PM conversion) remains.\n- **Node P becomes an AC ground.** With large swings, each transistor is driven into the **triode region** for part of every cycle (gate at the high tank swing, drain at the low swing). Its small on-resistance then connects the tank to AC ground through C_T, periodically discharging the tank. The *average* tank Q falls, and since phase noise ∝ 1/Q², a very large C_T can make the phase noise **worse**, not better. The circuit also drifts toward voltage-biased behavior (less well-defined current, more supply pushing).\n\n## Net effect and the standard remedy\n\n- Moderate C_T: net **improvement** in the thermal (1/f²) region, since tail noise at 2ω₀ is usually a major contributor.\n- Overly large C_T: the triode-mode de-Qing can dominate and **raise** phase noise.\n- The classic fix decouples the two effects: keep a large capacitor across the current source, but insert an **inductor between the current source and node P** that resonates with the tail capacitance at **2ω₀** (the Hegazi–Sjöland–Abidi \"noise filter\"). The tail then looks like a high impedance at 2ω₀ — no Q degradation, no noise commutation — while the source's noise is still filtered, typically buying several dB of phase-noise improvement.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "80c456e4b0e1639f45c0f695aac520c2c7eeaeefa3da37100b29a161ade095ad"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It captures a non-monotonic moderate-benefit/large-capacitance penalty, but makes tail-noise filtering the main improvement mechanism and misattributes triode-mode degradation to excessive CT. It misses the class-C-like switching with peak tank currents above ISS and the actual flicker-noise-upconversion or low-frequency-instability effects.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "30f6431c053d0ebf26268170667295ea7bd412e72a78ea0b3247e5803cbdfc8a",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3854,
        "output_tokens": 17466,
        "total_tokens": 21320,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 16399,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3854,
        "output_tokens": 17466,
        "total_tokens": 21320,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 16399,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "We add CT to the tail node, as in the figure. What happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Short answer\nC_T **shunts the tail‑current‑source noise around 2ω₀ to ground, so the phase‑noise contribution of I_SS drops** — but it also turns node *P* into an AC ground, which lets the switching transistors load the tank when they enter triode, **degrading the tank Q**. The net result is a trade‑off.\n\n## Why it helps\n- M₁/M₂ commutate the tail current like a single‑balanced mixer. Tail noise near **even harmonics — chiefly 2ω₀ —** is mixed down to ω₀ ± Δω and appears as phase noise (noise near DC mostly produces AM). Node *P* itself naturally bounces at 2ω₀.\n- With C_T present, the impedance at *P* near the second harmonic, ≈ 1/(2ω₀C_T), becomes much smaller than the impedance looking into the coupled sources (≈ 1/g_m). The current source's noise at 2ω₀ (and all higher frequencies) therefore flows into C_T instead of being injected into the pair.\n- ⇒ The 1/f² phase noise due to I_SS thermal noise is strongly attenuated.\n\n## What it does *not* fix\n- **Flicker (low‑frequency) noise of I_SS** is far below C_T's corner frequency and still gets through — it still modulates the amplitude and, in a VCO with varactors, still becomes close‑in 1/f³ phase noise via AM→PM conversion.\n\n## Why it can hurt\n- At RF, *P* is now grounded, so the circuit behaves like a **voltage‑biased oscillator**. With large swings, each transistor spends part of every cycle in the **triode region**; its channel resistance then connects the tank node (X or Y) through C_T to ground, periodically loading the resonator.\n- This lowers the **effective tank Q**, raising the phase noise from the tank/switch noise, and the bias current is no longer well defined (current pulses can exceed I_SS, swing becomes supply‑sensitive).\n\n## Bottom line / standard remedy\n- If the oscillator stays in the current‑limited regime (devices remain in saturation), C_T improves phase noise; in the voltage‑limited regime it can make it **worse overall**.\n- The classic fix is the **tail noise filter** (Hegazi et al.): insert an inductor between *P* and the current source so that it resonates with C_T at 2ω₀. Node *P* then sees a high impedance at 2ω₀ (no Q degradation) while the capacitor still shunts the current source's noise — giving the benefit without the penalty.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5d937ab4279a3695fd8b03ba60b62864197cfa2f64268a0b2c2fdd15ee1e2c73"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It gives a conditional tradeoff and identifies triode-related tank loading as a possible degradation. However, it attributes the improvement to shunting tail-source noise rather than the key class-C mechanism: peak tank currents exceeding I_SS. It also misses the specified flicker-noise upconversion and large-C_T instability effects.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "30f6431c053d0ebf26268170667295ea7bd412e72a78ea0b3247e5803cbdfc8a",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3854,
        "output_tokens": 11326,
        "total_tokens": 15180,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10460,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3854,
        "output_tokens": 11326,
        "total_tokens": 15180,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10460,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Estimate the oscillation frequency of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Recognizing the circuit\n\nThis is a **quadrature oscillator**: two identical cross‑coupled LC oscillators (tail current $I_{SS}$), each also containing a second differential pair (tail current $I_1$) driven by the *other* oscillator's outputs. The crossing of one pair of coupling wires makes the coupling *antiphase*, which forces the two tanks to run **90° out of phase** ($V_{X2,Y2}$ in quadrature with $V_{X1,Y1}$).\n\n## Why the frequency shifts away from resonance\n\nAssume both pairs switch completely. Then each tank receives two square‑wave currents, whose fundamentals are:\n\n- From its **own** cross‑coupled pair: amplitude $\\propto \\frac{4}{\\pi}I_{SS}$, **in phase** with its own tank voltage (this is the negative‑resistance current).\n- From the **coupling** pair: amplitude $\\propto \\frac{4}{\\pi}I_{1}$, aligned with the *other* oscillator's voltage, i.e. **in quadrature**.\n\nThe total tank current is therefore the phasor sum of these two, making an angle with the tank voltage of\n\n$$\n\\theta=\\tan^{-1}\\!\\left(\\frac{I_1}{I_{SS}}\\right).\n$$\n\nFor $V = Z_{tank}\\,I$ to be satisfied, **the tank must supply a phase shift of $-\\theta$**, which is possible only *off* resonance.\n\n## Quantifying the shift\n\nNear resonance, a parallel RLC tank has\n\n$$\n\\angle Z_{tank}(\\omega)\\approx-\\tan^{-1}\\!\\left[\\frac{2Q(\\omega-\\omega_0)}{\\omega_0}\\right],\n\\qquad \\omega_0=\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{LC}},\\quad Q=\\frac{R_p}{L\\omega_0}.\n$$\n\nEquating this phase to $\\mp\\theta$:\n\n$$\n\\frac{2Q\\,\\Delta\\omega}{\\omega_0}= \\pm\\frac{I_1}{I_{SS}}\n\\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad\n\\boxed{\\;\\omega_{osc}\\approx \\frac{1}{\\sqrt{LC}}\\left(1\\pm\\frac{I_1}{2Q\\,I_{SS}}\\right)\\;}\n$$\n\nequivalently, a shift of\n\n$$\n\\Delta\\omega = \\pm\\frac{\\omega_0}{2Q}\\cdot\\frac{I_1}{I_{SS}} \\;=\\; \\pm\\frac{I_1}{2R_pC\\,I_{SS}}.\n$$\n\nHere $C$ is the total (mostly parasitic) capacitance at nodes $X$, $Y$, and $R_p$ the equivalent parallel tank resistance.\n\n## Remarks\n\n- The $\\pm$ sign is real: the circuit can oscillate **above or below $\\omega_0$** (corresponding to $V_2$ leading or lagging $V_1$ by 90°) — a well‑known mode ambiguity of quadrature oscillators.\n- Operating off resonance means the tank phase slope is not at its peak, which degrades phase noise.\n- For weak coupling ($I_1\\ll I_{SS}$), $\\omega_{osc}\\to \\omega_0 = 1/\\sqrt{LC}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "843b1d20ce1c59c8aa9380d5382340e33b459754305b36846320a804f419418c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "{\"score_0_to_4\":4,\"rationale\":\"The answer gives the tank resonance and the coupling-induced shift \\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u007f\\u",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9fb09917ae8858f8003213ac52eae9cc4403612167903aff6685adcc43ddd686",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2007,
        "output_tokens": 9382,
        "total_tokens": 11389,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8256,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2007,
        "output_tokens": 9382,
        "total_tokens": 11389,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8256,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Estimate the oscillation frequency of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Recognizing the Circuit\n\nThis is a **quadrature LC oscillator**: two identical cross‑coupled LC oscillators (core pairs biased at $I_{SS}$) that are coupled to each other through second differential pairs (biased at $I_1$). Because one of the two coupling paths is \"twisted\" (inverted), going around the two‑oscillator loop gives a net 180°, which forces the two tanks to run **90° out of phase**:\n\n$$V_{XY2} = \\pm j\\,V_{XY1}$$\n\n## Current Phasors at Each Tank\n\nAssume both pairs switch completely. Then each tank (e.g., at $X_1,Y_1$) receives two fundamental current components:\n\n- From its **own cross‑coupled pair**: $\\;i_{core}\\propto \\frac{4}{\\pi}I_{SS}$, **in phase** with its tank voltage $V_1$ (the pair is switched by $V_1$ itself).\n- From the **coupling pair**: $\\;i_{inj}\\propto \\frac{4}{\\pi}I_{1}$, in phase with $V_2$, i.e. **in quadrature** with $V_1$.\n\nThe total tank current therefore makes an angle $\\theta$ with the tank voltage:\n\n$$\\tan\\theta = \\frac{I_1}{I_{SS}}$$\n\n## The Tank Must Supply This Phase Shift\n\nSince $V_1 = Z_T(j\\omega)\\,(i_{core}+i_{inj})$, the tank impedance must rotate the current back onto the voltage:\n\n$$\\angle Z_T(j\\omega_{osc}) = \\mp\\theta \\neq 0$$\n\nA parallel RLC tank has zero phase only **at** resonance, so the circuit must oscillate **off resonance**. Near $\\omega_0$:\n\n$$\\angle Z_T \\approx -\\tan^{-1}\\!\\left[\\frac{2Q(\\omega-\\omega_0)}{\\omega_0}\\right]$$\n\nEquating the two phase expressions:\n\n$$\\frac{2Q\\,\\Delta\\omega}{\\omega_0} = \\frac{I_1}{I_{SS}}$$\n\n## Result\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;\\omega_{osc}\\;\\approx\\;\\frac{1}{\\sqrt{LC}}\\left(1 \\pm \\frac{I_1}{2Q\\,I_{SS}}\\right)\\;}$$\n\nwhere $\\omega_0 = 1/\\sqrt{LC}$ (with $C$ = total capacitance at each output node) and $Q = R_p/(\\omega_0 L)$ is the tank Q.\n\n**Remarks:**\n\n- *Example:* for $I_1 = 0.2\\,I_{SS}$ and $Q = 10$, the frequency shifts about 1% from tank resonance.\n- The **± sign** reflects a real ambiguity: both frequencies (above or below $\\omega_0$) satisfy the phase condition with equal loop gain, so the oscillator may settle at either one depending on initial conditions — a well-known drawback of quadrature coupling.\n- Incidentally, the amplitude is roughly unchanged: $|Z_T| = R_p\\cos\\theta$, so $V_{osc}\\approx \\frac{4}{\\pi}\\sqrt{I_{SS}^2+I_1^2}\\,R_p\\cos\\theta = \\frac{4}{\\pi}I_{SS}R_p$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "b73b1022325b26fbf6ea08adf407be3f2e5dae0ce10043b0299ea00dd30013cc"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly gives the tank resonance and the coupling-induced shift, yielding Δω/ω₀ ≈ I₁/(2Q I_SS). The discussion of the two possible frequency sides is consistent with the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9fb09917ae8858f8003213ac52eae9cc4403612167903aff6685adcc43ddd686",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2007,
        "output_tokens": 7262,
        "total_tokens": 9269,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6123,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2007,
        "output_tokens": 7262,
        "total_tokens": 9269,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6123,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Estimate the oscillation frequency of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "max",
        "api_model": "anthropic/claude-fable-5",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "## Recognizing the Circuit\n\nThis is a **quadrature (coupled) LC oscillator**: two identical cross‑coupled oscillators, each with a core pair biased at $I_{SS}$ and a *coupling pair* biased at $I_1$ that injects the other oscillator's output into its tank. The coupling loop contains one net inversion (the crossed wires between the two cores), so in steady state the two oscillators run at the same frequency with outputs in **quadrature**:\n\n$$V_{X2,Y2} = V_{X1,Y1}\\,\\angle(\\pm 90^\\circ)$$\n\n## Key Point: The Tanks Do *Not* Run at Resonance\n\nEach tank is driven by **two** switched currents:\n\n- The core pair injects a current of amplitude $\\propto I_{SS}$ **in phase** with its own tank voltage.\n- The coupling pair injects a current of amplitude $\\propto I_1$ that is **in quadrature** with the tank voltage (since it comes from the other oscillator).\n\nThe total tank current is therefore rotated with respect to the tank voltage by\n\n$$\\theta = \\tan^{-1}\\!\\frac{I_1}{I_{SS}}$$\n\n(the $4/\\pi$ square‑wave factors cancel in the ratio). For the loop to sustain oscillation, **the tank must rotate the phasor back by $-\\theta$**, which forces operation off resonance.\n\n## Computing the Frequency Shift\n\nThe phase of a parallel RLC tank is\n\n$$\\angle Z_T = -\\tan^{-1}\\!\\left[Q\\left(\\frac{\\omega}{\\omega_0}-\\frac{\\omega_0}{\\omega}\\right)\\right] \\approx -\\tan^{-1}\\!\\left(\\frac{2Q\\,\\Delta\\omega}{\\omega_0}\\right)$$\n\nSetting the tank phase equal to $\\mp\\theta$:\n\n$$\\frac{2Q\\,\\Delta\\omega}{\\omega_0} = \\frac{I_1}{I_{SS}} \\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad \\Delta\\omega = \\frac{\\omega_0}{2Q}\\cdot\\frac{I_1}{I_{SS}}$$\n\n## Result\n\n$$\\boxed{\\;\\omega_{osc} \\approx \\omega_0\\left(1 \\pm \\frac{1}{2Q}\\,\\frac{I_1}{I_{SS}}\\right), \\qquad \\omega_0 = \\frac{1}{\\sqrt{LC}}\\;}$$\n\nwhere $C$ is the total capacitance at each output node (including both differential pairs) and $Q$ is the tank quality factor.\n\n**Remarks:**\n- The frequency shifts *away* from $1/\\sqrt{LC}$ in proportion to the coupling ratio $I_1/I_{SS}$ and inversely with $Q$.\n- Both signs ($V_2$ leading or lagging $V_1$ by $90^\\circ$) satisfy the oscillation conditions, so the circuit may oscillate at **either** of the two frequencies — a well-known ambiguity of quadrature oscillators.\n- Operating off resonance also means the tank phase slope is not exploited at its peak, which degrades phase noise — the price paid for quadrature generation.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "e04d1bd2c0659c2beb090e468c44478daf43fa30b3e3aa680972e5603a2d9871"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly gives the tank resonance and the coupling-induced shift, with the expected large-signal estimate Δω ≈ (I₁/I_SS)ω₀/(2Q) and either sign for the two quadrature modes.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9fb09917ae8858f8003213ac52eae9cc4403612167903aff6685adcc43ddd686",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2007,
        "output_tokens": 7428,
        "total_tokens": 9435,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6343,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2007,
        "output_tokens": 7428,
        "total_tokens": 9435,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6343,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    }
  ]
}
