{
  "model_key": "muse_spark_12",
  "display_name": "Muse Spark 1.2",
  "provider": "meta",
  "evaluation_model_ids": [],
  "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
  "configuration_note": "Muse Spark 1.2 answered the 50 tasks in three rollouts through OpenRouter's chat completions route (meta/muse-spark-1.2) at reasoning effort xhigh, the highest it offers. Requests set max_tokens to 943,718, the model's output limit. Each request was one user message holding only the question text and its figure: no title, headings or system prompt. Answers cut off at the output limit were re-run; every attempt is counted in tokens and cost. Answers were graded by GPT-6 Luna at maximum reasoning effort. Cost uses OpenRouter's list price for Muse Spark 1.2 on 2026-11-10 ($1.25 input, $0.15 cached input, $4.25 output per 1M tokens).",
  "mode": "direct_qa",
  "summary": {
    "rollout_count": 3,
    "answer_count": 150,
    "scores": {
      "overall": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "response_count": 150,
          "correct_count": 105,
          "incorrect_count": 45,
          "partial_credit_count": 38,
          "zero_count": 7,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.3466666666666667,
          "score_percent": 83.66666666666667,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 7,
            "1": 9,
            "2": 14,
            "3": 15,
            "4": 105
          }
        },
        "active": {
          "response_count": 150,
          "correct_count": 105,
          "incorrect_count": 45,
          "partial_credit_count": 38,
          "zero_count": 7,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.3466666666666667,
          "score_percent": 83.66666666666667,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 7,
            "1": 9,
            "2": 14,
            "3": 15,
            "4": 105
          }
        }
      },
      "part1": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "response_count": 90,
          "correct_count": 72,
          "incorrect_count": 18,
          "partial_credit_count": 14,
          "zero_count": 4,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.511111111111111,
          "score_percent": 87.77777777777777,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 4,
            "1": 4,
            "2": 6,
            "3": 4,
            "4": 72
          }
        },
        "active": {
          "response_count": 90,
          "correct_count": 72,
          "incorrect_count": 18,
          "partial_credit_count": 14,
          "zero_count": 4,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.511111111111111,
          "score_percent": 87.77777777777777,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 4,
            "1": 4,
            "2": 6,
            "3": 4,
            "4": 72
          }
        }
      },
      "part2": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "response_count": 60,
          "correct_count": 33,
          "incorrect_count": 27,
          "partial_credit_count": 24,
          "zero_count": 3,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.1,
          "score_percent": 77.5,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 3,
            "1": 5,
            "2": 8,
            "3": 11,
            "4": 33
          }
        },
        "active": {
          "response_count": 60,
          "correct_count": 33,
          "incorrect_count": 27,
          "partial_credit_count": 24,
          "zero_count": 3,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.1,
          "score_percent": 77.5,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 3,
            "1": 5,
            "2": 8,
            "3": 11,
            "4": 33
          }
        }
      }
    },
    "by_rollout": {
      "1": {
        "response_count": 50,
        "correct_count": 35,
        "incorrect_count": 15,
        "partial_credit_count": 13,
        "zero_count": 2,
        "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.4,
        "score_percent": 85.0,
        "score_distribution": {
          "0": 2,
          "1": 2,
          "2": 5,
          "3": 6,
          "4": 35
        }
      },
      "2": {
        "response_count": 50,
        "correct_count": 36,
        "incorrect_count": 14,
        "partial_credit_count": 11,
        "zero_count": 3,
        "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.38,
        "score_percent": 84.5,
        "score_distribution": {
          "0": 3,
          "1": 2,
          "2": 4,
          "3": 5,
          "4": 36
        }
      },
      "3": {
        "response_count": 50,
        "correct_count": 34,
        "incorrect_count": 16,
        "partial_credit_count": 14,
        "zero_count": 2,
        "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.26,
        "score_percent": 81.5,
        "score_distribution": {
          "0": 2,
          "1": 5,
          "2": 5,
          "3": 4,
          "4": 34
        }
      }
    },
    "tokens": {
      "response_count": 150,
      "usage_record_count": 150,
      "complete_usage_count": 150,
      "missing_usage_count": 0,
      "missing_cached_input_count": 0,
      "complete": true,
      "totals": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 83943,
        "input_tokens": 296919,
        "output_tokens": 1489096,
        "total_tokens": 1786015
      },
      "known_totals": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 83943,
        "input_tokens": 296919,
        "output_tokens": 1489096,
        "total_tokens": 1786015
      }
    },
    "by_rollout_part": {
      "part1": {
        "1": {
          "response_count": 30,
          "correct_count": 26,
          "incorrect_count": 4,
          "partial_credit_count": 3,
          "zero_count": 1,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.6333333333333333,
          "score_percent": 90.83333333333333,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 1,
            "1": 1,
            "2": 2,
            "4": 26
          }
        },
        "2": {
          "response_count": 30,
          "correct_count": 24,
          "incorrect_count": 6,
          "partial_credit_count": 5,
          "zero_count": 1,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.566666666666667,
          "score_percent": 89.16666666666667,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 1,
            "1": 1,
            "2": 2,
            "3": 2,
            "4": 24
          }
        },
        "3": {
          "response_count": 30,
          "correct_count": 22,
          "incorrect_count": 8,
          "partial_credit_count": 6,
          "zero_count": 2,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.3333333333333335,
          "score_percent": 83.33333333333334,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 2,
            "1": 2,
            "2": 2,
            "3": 2,
            "4": 22
          }
        }
      },
      "part2": {
        "1": {
          "response_count": 20,
          "correct_count": 9,
          "incorrect_count": 11,
          "partial_credit_count": 10,
          "zero_count": 1,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.05,
          "score_percent": 76.25,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 1,
            "1": 1,
            "2": 3,
            "3": 6,
            "4": 9
          }
        },
        "2": {
          "response_count": 20,
          "correct_count": 12,
          "incorrect_count": 8,
          "partial_credit_count": 6,
          "zero_count": 2,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.1,
          "score_percent": 77.5,
          "score_distribution": {
            "0": 2,
            "1": 1,
            "2": 2,
            "3": 3,
            "4": 12
          }
        },
        "3": {
          "response_count": 20,
          "correct_count": 12,
          "incorrect_count": 8,
          "partial_credit_count": 8,
          "zero_count": 0,
          "mean_score_0_to_4": 3.15,
          "score_percent": 78.75,
          "score_distribution": {
            "1": 3,
            "2": 3,
            "3": 2,
            "4": 12
          }
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "answers": [
    {
      "question_id": "part1-001-double-length-and-width-mosfet-its-intrinsic",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "If we double the length and width of a MOSFET, what happens to its intrinsic gain?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With fixed inversion level the width\ndrops out to first order\n\n$$A_{v0}\\equiv g_{m}r_{o}=g_{m}/g_{ds}$$\n\nin saturation\n\n$$g_{m}\\approx \\mu C_{ox}{W\\over L}V^{\\ast}=\n{2I_{D}\\over V^{\\ast}}=\n\\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}{W\\over L}I_{D}}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$g_{ds}= \\lambda I_{D} \\tag{2}$$\n\n$$r_{o}={1\\over g_{ds}}={V_{A}\\over I_{D}}\\approx\n{1\\over \\lambda I_{D}}\\approx {V_{E}L\\over I_{D}} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$V^{\\ast}=V_{GS}-V_{T}$ is the overdrive,\n$V_{A}=1/\\lambda \\propto L$ is the Early voltage,\nin long channel $ \\lambda \\approx \\lambda^{\\prime}/L$.\n\nSo to first order, at fixed $V^{\\ast}$, {\\it i. e.} fixed\n$g_{m}/I_{D}$,\n\n$$A_{v0} = {2V_{A}\\over V^{\\ast}} \\approx {2\\over \\lambda V^{\\ast}}\n\\propto {L\\over V^{\\ast}} \\tag{4}$$\n\nindependent of $W$.\n\nAt fixed absolute current\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nA_{v0} &= {1\\over \\lambda}\\sqrt{{2\\mu C_{ox}\\over I_{D}}{W\\over L}}\\cr\n&\\propto {1\\over \\lambda}\\sqrt{{W\\over L}}\\propto L\\sqrt{{W\\over L}}\n= \\sqrt{WL}} \\tag{5}$$\n\nIn subthreshold\n\n$$g_{m}=I_{D}/nV_{T}\\;\\;,\\;\\;r_{o}=V_{A}/I_{D}\\;\\;,A_{v0}=V_{A}/nV_{T}\\propto L$$\n\nthe same.\n\nIn words: $W$ by itself does {\\it not} give you\ngain, $L$ does.\n\nFor the conventional analog bias, fixed $I_{D}$ or fixed\n$V^{\\ast}$ with $W/L=$ const:\n\n* $W\\to 2W$ alone at fixed $I_{D}$: $g_{m}\\propto \\sqrt{W}$,\n  $r_{o}=$ const, $A_{v0}\\propto \\sqrt{W}$.\n  At fixed $V^{\\ast}$: $I_{D}\\propto W$, $g_{m}\\propto W$,\n  $r_{o}\\propto 1/W$, $A_{v0}=$ const.\n\n* $L\\to 2L$ alone at fixed $I_{D}$: $g_{m}\\propto 1/\\sqrt{L}$,\n  $r_{o}\\propto L$, $A_{v0}\\propto \\sqrt{L}$.\n  At fixed $V^{\\ast}$: $I_{D}\\propto 1/L$, $g_{m}\\propto 1/L$,\n  $r_{o}\\propto L^{2}$, $A_{v0}\\propto L$.\n\nFormally, from (4)-(5):\n\n> {\\it Ideal long channel, saturation, $I_{D}$ or $V^{\\ast}$ held\n> constant, $W/L=$ const: $A_{v0}\\propto L\\propto \\sqrt{WL}$.}\n\nSo with $W\\to 2W$ {\\it and} $L\\to 2L$\n\n$$A_{v0}^{\\prime}\\approx 2A_{v0}\\approx +6{\\rm dB}$$\n\nideal.\n$I_{D}(W/L,V^{\\ast})$ is unchanged, $g_{m}$ is unchanged,\n$r_{o}$ is doubled.\n\nIf you re-bias to keep the {\\it current density}\n$J=I_{D}/W=$ const, so $V^{\\ast}\\propto \\sqrt{L}$, usual\nwhen you scale power with $W$,\n\n$$g_{m}\\propto W/\\sqrt{L}\\;\\;,r_{o}\\propto L/W\\;\\;,A_{v0}\\propto \\sqrt{L}$$\n\nso\n\n$$A_{v0}^{\\prime}\\approx \\sqrt{2}A_{v0}\\approx +3{\\rm dB}$$\n\nfor $2W,2L$.\n\nIn a modern short channel $V_{A}$ is sub-linear in $L$\nbecause of DIBL, velocity saturation makes $g_{m}\\propto W$\nand essentially $L$ independent, so you get $<2\\times$,\ntypically $1.3-1.8\\times$ for a $2\\times$ in $L$ in\nnanoscale bulk/FinFET, going to $\\approx 1$ in a fully\nvelocity saturated device.\n\nYou pay for it with $\\propto WL$, $4\\times$, gate capacitance,\nso $f_{T}=g_{m}/2\\pi C_{gg}\\propto 1/WL$ goes down by\n$\\sim 4\\times$ at fixed $I_{D}$. The $A_{v0}f_{T}$ product is\napproximately conserved.\n\nThe naive $``W/L=$ const so nothing changes$''$ neglects\n$r_{o}\\propto L$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bc7805c95f9acf8b71346a3e144799e9fe372ed770b9381c66613d42c48fdb87"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "The requested scaling is correct: with both dimensions doubled, W/L and (under the stated bias assumptions) gm remain roughly unchanged, while ro roughly doubles, so intrinsic gain roughly doubles. The extra side discussions do not change that conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b623efa74b67c0787641e221f1d6de9d7318205927fbcd9490d3ed132b5450df",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 26,
        "output_tokens": 4784,
        "total_tokens": 4810,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3632,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 26,
        "output_tokens": 4784,
        "total_tokens": 4810,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3632,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-001-double-length-and-width-mosfet-its-intrinsic",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "If we double the length and width of a MOSFET, what happens to its intrinsic gain?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With a square law model:\n\n$$A_{o} = g_{m}r_{o} = \\dfrac{g_{m}}{g_{ds}}=\n\\dfrac{2I_{D}/V_{ov}}{I_{D}/V_{A}}\\approx \\dfrac{2V_{A}}{V_{ov}}$$\n\n$$V_{A}=1/\\lambda = V_{E}L \\propto L$$\n$$V_{ov}= \\sqrt{\\dfrac{2I_{D}}{\\mu C_{ox}W/L}}$$\n$$g_{m}= \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}W/L\\cdot I_{D}} = \\mu C_{ox}W/L\\cdot V_{ov}$$\n\nSo to first order $W$ cancels for\nfixed $W/L$ and $A_{o}\\propto L/V_{ov}\\propto\n\\sqrt{WL/I_{D}}$.\n\n* {\\it For fixed bias - fixed $I_{D}$ or \nfixed $V_{ov}$ or fixed $g_{m}/I_{D}$:}\n\n$W/L = {\\rm const}$ so $V_{ov}={\\rm const}$ and\n$I_{D}={\\rm const}$ and\n\n$$g_{m}={\\rm const}$$\n\n$$r_{o}= \\dfrac{V_{A}}{I_{D}}\\propto L \\tag{1/\\lambda \\propto L}$$\n\nso\n\n$$A_{o}^{\\prime}\\approx 2A_{o}$$\n\n$+6\\,{\\rm dB}$ ideal. In a modern\nshort channel $\\lambda \\ne k/L$ and you get\n$1.5-1.8\\times$ due to DIBL, CLM not $\\propto 1/L$.\n$$A_{o}\\propto \\sqrt{WL}\\;\\;{\\rm for\\;}I_{D}={\\rm const}$$\n\nso $2W\\times 2L \\to 4WL \\to 2\\sqrt{WL}$.\n\nYou pay for it with $C_{gs}\\propto WL\\to 4\\times$,\nso $f_{T}=g_{m}/2\\pi C_{gg}\\approx 1/2 f_{T}$ \nand $f_{T}\\times A_{o}\\approx {\\rm const}$.\n\nIn subthreshold $g_{m}=I_{D}/nV_{T}$ and\n$A_{o}= V_{A}/nV_{T}=V_{E}L/nV_{T}\\propto L$ independent\nof $W,I_{D}$ to first order, so again $\\propto L\\to 2\\times$.\n\n> {\\it Remark: } That is for the same power.\n\nIf you want to keep the same {\\it current density} and the\nsame inversion level, $g_{m}/I_{D}={\\rm const}$, you will\nnormally re-bias to $I_{D}^{\\prime}=2I_{D}$ when you make\n$W^{\\prime}=2W$. Then\n\n$$g_{m}^{\\prime}= \\sqrt{2}\\,g_{m}$$\n$$r_{o}^{\\prime}= r_{o}$$\n\n$$A_{o}^{\\prime}= \\sqrt{2}A_{o}\\approx 1.41 A_{o}\\;\\;+3{\\rm dB}$$\n\nlong channel square law, $\\propto \\sqrt{L}$.\nFor a velocity saturated short channel\n$g_{m}\\propto W$, $r_{o}\\propto L/W$, $A_{o}\\propto L$\nso you still get $A_{o}^{\\prime}\\approx 2A_{o}$ at\nconstant $J=I_{D}/W$ and $A_{o}^{\\prime}\\approx 4A_{o}$\nat constant $I_{D}$.\n\nIn normal language: $L$ gives you $r_{o}$ and $V_{A}$,\n$W$ almost doesn't give you gain. Making the device\n$4\\times$ the area to get $3-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ is normally\nvery inefficient.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f0258dcabb5d6e54dea0058b6482b11d13484ab2c06595f47623eb01c7948c05"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The main result is correct: with W/L and overdrive held constant, gm and ID stay approximately unchanged, ro doubles, and intrinsic gain doubles. However, some extra claims are inconsistent: in the square-law case, doubling ID does not preserve gm/ID, and with gm unchanged and Cgg quadrupled, fT would fall to about one quarter, not one half.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b623efa74b67c0787641e221f1d6de9d7318205927fbcd9490d3ed132b5450df",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 26,
        "output_tokens": 4582,
        "total_tokens": 4608,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3732,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 26,
        "output_tokens": 4582,
        "total_tokens": 4608,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3732,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-001-double-length-and-width-mosfet-its-intrinsic",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "If we double the length and width of a MOSFET, what happens to its intrinsic gain?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "Intrinsic gain is\n\n$$A_{0}= g_{m}r_{o}=g_{m}/g_{ds}\\approx \\frac{2}{\\lambda V_{ov}}=\\frac{V_{A}}{V_{ov}/2}$$\n\nin square law, long channel\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ng_{m} &= \\mu C_{ox} \\frac{W}{L}V_{ov}= \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}I_{D}}= \\frac{2I_{D}}{V_{ov}}\\cr\nr_{o} &= \\frac{1}{\\lambda I_{D}}\\approx \\frac{L}{\\lambda^{\\prime}I_{D}} \\cr\nI_{D} &= \\frac{1}{2}\\mu C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}V_{ov}^{2} \\cr}$$\n\n$$\\lambda \\propto 1/L \\;\\;,\\;\\; V_{A}=1/\\lambda \\propto L$$\n\nso to 1st order\n\n$$A_{0}= \\frac{2}{\\lambda V_{ov}} = \\frac{2L}{\\lambda^{\\prime} V_{ov}} \\propto \\frac{L}{V_{ov}} \\approx \\sqrt{\\frac{WL}{I_{D}}}$$\n\n$W$ cancels for fixed $V_{ov}$ or fixed $I_{D}$.\n\n* $W$ alone: For fixed $L,I_{D}$ or fixed $V_{ov}$,\n$g_{m}\\propto \\sqrt{W}$, $r_{o}\\propto 1/I_{D} \\propto 1$, \n$A_{0}\\propto \\sqrt{W}$ if you neglect $V_{ov}$ change, and\n$\\propto W^{0}$ if you keep $V_{ov}$ constant.\nIn a velocity saturated or sub-threshold device \n$g_{m}\\propto W$ and $r_{o}\\propto 1/W$ so $W$ has {\\it no}\neffect on $A_{0}$ at all. Normally quoted as: doubling $W$\nleaves $A_{0}$ unchanged.\n\n* $L$ alone: $A_{0}\\propto L$ for fixed $V_{ov}$, \n$\\propto \\sqrt{L}$ for fixed $I_{D}/W$. So doubling $L$\ndoubles $A_{0}$ for fixed $V_{ov}$.\n\n> {\\it If you treat $\\lambda =$ constant, $A_{0}$ is proportional\n> to $\\sqrt{W/L}$ for fixed $I_{D}$.}\n\nIn particular for the usual case you keep the {\\it same}\nbias point:\n\n* constant $I_{D}$: $V_{ov}\\propto\\sqrt{L/W}$ so\n$$A_{0}\\propto \\sqrt{WL}$$\n* constant $V_{ov}$ - i.e. constant $W/L$: $I_{D}=$ constant so\n$$A_{0}\\propto L$$\n\nso for $W\\rightarrow 2W$, $L\\rightarrow 2L$, $W/L=$ const:\n\n* Ideal textbook with $\\lambda =$ const: $$A_{0}\\rightarrow A_{0}$$ no change.\n{\\it This is the answer most undergrad courses want.}\n\n* With $\\lambda \\propto 1/L$: $$A_{0}\\rightarrow 2A_{0} \\approx +6{\\rm dB}$$\n\n> For fixed $I_{D}$ or fixed $V_{ov}$ the intrinsic gain\n> doubles. For fixed $I_{D}/W$ - fixed $g_{m}/I_{D}$ - it goes as\n> $\\sqrt{L}$, i.e. $+\\sqrt{2}\\approx +3{\\rm dB}$.\n\nIn a modern short channel/velocity saturated/sub-threshold\ndevice it is even simpler: $A_{0}\\approx 1/nV_{T}\\lambda \\propto L$\nindependent of $W$, so $2L \\approx 2\\times A_{0}$.\n\nYou pay for it with $\\approx 4\\times$ gate area,\n$\\approx 2\\times$ $C_{gs},\\,C_{gd}$ and $\\approx 1/2\\times$ $f_{T}=g_{m}/2\\pi C_{gg}$.\n\nIn practice due to DIBL, mobility degradation, fringe etc.\n$\\sim 1.5-1.8\\times$, not quite $2.0\\times$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "94585c8fb336f8ab35391556752b171909dba0f1894140f04ea6dbba43581c1c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It derives the expected doubling when W and L are both doubled, with fixed overdrive and λ decreasing roughly as 1/L. However, it also emphasizes a conflicting no-change result under constant λ and presents the answer ambiguously; that assumption does not match the expected length-dependent ro scaling.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b623efa74b67c0787641e221f1d6de9d7318205927fbcd9490d3ed132b5450df",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 26,
        "output_tokens": 4204,
        "total_tokens": 4230,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3181,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 26,
        "output_tokens": 4204,
        "total_tokens": 4230,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3181,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-002-student-says-transconductance-mosfet-goes-up-as",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "Student A says the transconductance of a MOSFET goes up as the overdrive voltage increases. Student B says it goes down. Who is correct?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "For a {\\it given} ${\\rm W/L}$ Student A, for {\\it given}\n$I_{D}$ Student B. That is the whole confusion.\n\nIn saturation, long channel square law:\n\n$$I_{D} = \\frac12 \\mu C_{ox} \\frac{W}{L} V_{ov}^{2} \\qquad V_{ov}=V_{GS}-V_{TH}$$\n\n$$g_{m} = \\left.\\frac{\\partial I_{D}}{\\partial V_{GS}}\\right|_{Q} = \\mu C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}V_{ov} = \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}I_{D}} = \\frac{2I_{D}}{V_{ov}}$$\n\nThose 3 forms are identical, but leave different things constant.\n\n* {\\bf Form 1: $g_{m}= \\mu C_{ox}(W/L)V_{ov}$} \n  For a {\\it given geometry} $W/L=$ const, $I_{D}\\propto V_{ov}^{2}$ is allowed to increase. Then\n\n  $$g_{m} \\propto V_{ov}$$\n\n  Turn up $V_{GS}$ on the same device, you get more inversion charge, more current, and a steeper $I_{D}-V_{GS}$ slope. In this literal sense {\\bf A is correct}. $g_{m}$ is monotonic increasing with $V_{ov}$, linear in long channel, sub-linear and eventually saturating to\n\n  $$g_{m} \\approx W C_{ox} v_{sat}$$\n\n  in a velocity saturated short channel device. With vertical field mobility degradation it can even roll over very slightly at very high $V_{ov}$, but it never goes as $1/V_{ov}$ for the same device.\n\n* {\\bf Form 3: $g_{m}=2I_{D}/V_{ov}$}\n  If you compare {\\it different} $W/L$ that are re-sized to keep {\\it bias current $I_{D}=$ const}, then for the same current a large $V_{ov}$ means you made the device small and\n\n  $$g_{m} \\propto 1/V_{ov} \\qquad I_{D}=const$$\n\n  and\n\n  $$ \\frac{g_{m}}{I_{D}} = \\frac{2}{V_{ov}} \\propto 1/V_{ov}$$\n\nThis is how analog designers normally talk. High $V_{ov}$ = low $g_{m}$ efficiency, low gain, but high speed and large swing. Low $V_{ov}$ = high $g_{m}/I_{D}$ efficiency.\n\nSo B is confusing $g_{m}$ with $g_{m}/I_{D}$ or with $g_{m}$ at constant current.\n\n> {\\it Unqualified, on the same transistor with the bias allowed to move, A is correct: $g_{m}$ goes up with $V_{ov}$. If the question is Sedra/Smith style ``for a given bias current what $V_{ov}$ gives more $g_{m}$?'' B is what is wanted.}\n\nIn weak inversion $g_{m}=I_{D}/nV_{T}$ independent of $V_{ov}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ed8f216093b9d1dbe64f270393e7db6bd234da31407cbad290f29f32f13bdeec"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly explains that for fixed W/L, increasing overdrive raises drain current and gm, so Student A is right; Student B applies when current is held constant and device size changes. The extra operating-regime comments do not alter the central answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "e805626814432e31b3628b4bf4073fa0c2304a7c8ea8bad4f0422be86c312f74",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 38,
        "output_tokens": 2512,
        "total_tokens": 2550,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1748,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 38,
        "output_tokens": 2512,
        "total_tokens": 2550,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1748,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-002-student-says-transconductance-mosfet-goes-up-as",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "Student A says the transconductance of a MOSFET goes up as the overdrive voltage increases. Student B says it goes down. Who is correct?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the ideal long channel textbook, {\\bf A} is correct.\n\nBy definition in saturation, $V_{ov} = V_{GS}-V_{TH}$:\n\n$$I_D = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu C_{ox} \\frac{W}{L} V_{ov}^2 (1+\\lambda V_{DS}) \\approx \\frac12 k_n V_{ov}^2$$\n\n$$g_m = \\left. \\frac{\\partial I_D}{\\partial V_{GS}} \\right|_{V_{DS}} = \\mu C_{ox} \\frac{W}{L} V_{ov} = k_n V_{ov} = \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L} I_D} = \\frac{2I_D}{V_{ov}}$$\n\nFor a {\\it given} transistor - $W/L$ fixed - as you increase $V_{GS}$ and therefore $V_{ov}$, $I_D \\propto V_{ov}^2$ and the {\\it slope} of the $I_D-V_{GS}$ parabola, $g_m$, increases linearly with $V_{ov}$.\n\nStudent B is confusing $g_m$ with $g_m/I_D$ or with $g_m$ {\\it at constant $I_D$}.\n\nBecause\n\n$$g_m = \\frac{2I_D}{V_{ov}}$$\n\n{\\it If you hold $I_D$ constant} and increase $V_{ov}$ by making the device narrower - smaller $W/L$ - $g_m$ goes {\\it down} as $1/V_{ov}$.\n\nThat quantity $g_m/I_D = 2/V_{ov}$ is the transconductance {\\it efficiency} and it always goes down with $V_{ov}$. High $V_{ov}$ = fast, power hungry, low gain per mA. Low $V_{ov}$ = slow, low power, high gain per mA. That's what B is remembering.\n\n> Textbook: $g_m \\propto V_{ov}$ for fixed geometry.\n> Constant current design: $g_m \\propto 1/V_{ov}$ for fixed $I_D$.\n\nIn real modern short channel devices B becomes half right anyway:\n\nIdeal $g_m = k_n V_{ov}$ saturates to $g_m \\approx W C_{ox} v_{sat}$ due to velocity saturation and then due to mobility degradation with vertical field, $\\mu_{eff} = \\mu_0/(1+\\theta V_{ov})$, it actually rolls over and {\\it decreases} at very high $V_{ov}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "4101b74c8d15951b61ce7415be45b179366c2dc1827d82a303a8774e10f51897"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies A for fixed device geometry and explains that increasing overdrive raises drain current and gm. It also correctly distinguishes the fixed-current case where gm falls; the added short-channel discussion does not change the central answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "e805626814432e31b3628b4bf4073fa0c2304a7c8ea8bad4f0422be86c312f74",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 38,
        "output_tokens": 2521,
        "total_tokens": 2559,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1976,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 38,
        "output_tokens": 2521,
        "total_tokens": 2559,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1976,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-002-student-says-transconductance-mosfet-goes-up-as",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "Student A says the transconductance of a MOSFET goes up as the overdrive voltage increases. Student B says it goes down. Who is correct?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "It's a trick question - both are right depending on what you hold constant.\n\nFor a long channel device in saturation:\n\n$$I_D = \\frac{1}{2} \\mu_n C_{ox} \\frac{W}{L} V_{ov}^2$$\n\nwhere $V_{ov} = V_{GS}-V_{TH}$ is the overdrive voltage.\n\n$$g_m = \\frac{\\partial I_D}{\\partial V_{GS}} = \\mu_n C_{ox} \\frac{W}{L} V_{ov} $$\n\nThis can also be written in two other useful forms by eliminating $V_{ov}$ or $W/L$:\n\n$$g_m = \\sqrt{2 \\mu_n C_{ox} \\frac{W}{L} I_D} $$\n$$g_m = \\frac{2I_D}{V_{ov}}$$\n\nWhich is why there is so much confusion:\n\n* **1. For a *given device* - W/L fixed:** $g_m \\propto V_{ov}$\n\nIf you take the same transistor and just increase $V_{GS}$, so you increase $V_{ov}$, you get more $I_D$ and a steeper $I_D$ vs $V_{GS}$ curve. So $g_m$ ***increases*** linearly with $V_{ov}$.\n\nThis is what most textbooks mean when they just say \"$g_m$ vs $V_{ov}$\". **Student A is correct in this sense.** This is the correct answer for an undergraduate exam.\n\n* **2. For a *given bias current* - $I_D$ fixed:** $g_m \\propto 1/V_{ov}$\n\nThis is how analog designers think. If you want to bias the same $I_D$ but at a higher $V_{ov}$ you have to *make the device smaller* - reduce $W/L \\propto 1/V_{ov}^2$. Then $g_m = 2I_D/V_{ov}$ so $g_m$ ***decreases*** with $V_{ov}$.\n\nThen efficiency $g_m/I_D = 2/V_{ov}$ goes down. Low $V_{ov}$ = high $g_m/I_D$ but large, slow device. High $V_{ov}$ = low $g_m/I_D$ but small, fast device with more headroom/speed.\n\n> So: At fixed geometry, turning up the gate increases $g_m$. At fixed current, re-sizing for higher overdrive decreases $g_m$.\n\nIn a modern short channel device velocity saturation makes $g_m$ saturate to $g_m \\approx W C_{ox} v_{sat}$ and becomes almost independent of $V_{ov}$ for large $V_{ov}$ - so neither holds perfectly.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "941f2cf0d6571916c858fbfb7d20f0f55243385baa8da07bf502a1b334c1a37b"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies Student A as right for a fixed device size and explains that increasing overdrive also increases drain current, so gm rises. The fixed-current qualification is also correct; the extra short-channel note does not alter the answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "e805626814432e31b3628b4bf4073fa0c2304a7c8ea8bad4f0422be86c312f74",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 38,
        "output_tokens": 1924,
        "total_tokens": 1962,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1295,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 38,
        "output_tokens": 1924,
        "total_tokens": 1962,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1295,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-003-small-signal-model-pmos-device-identical-nmos",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Is the small-signal model of a PMOS device identical to that of an NMOS device?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "Yes, topologically, but with reversed reference polarity.\n\nFor AC signals $V_{DD}$ and $GND$ are both $AC$ ground, so you can treat them interchangeably. If you define voltages *positive at the source* for both devices, the model is indistinguishable.\n\n> **NMOS:** controlled by $v_{gs}$ and $v_{bs}$ \n> **PMOS:** controlled by $v_{sg} = -v_{gs}$ and $v_{sb}= -v_{bs}$\n\nIf you insist on keeping the $v_{gs}$, $v_{ds}$, $i_d$ reference directions the same for both devices - gate to source, drain to source, current *entering* the drain - then $g_m$ for the PMOS is negative and the current source points the other way.\n\n### Low frequency hybrid-pi\n\n**NMOS:**\n```\nG o---||---+\n           |\nD o--------+----[gm*vgs]--->----+\n           |     |               |\n           |    [gmb*vbs]        [ro=1/gds]\n           |     |               |\nS o--------+----<---[gm*vbs]-----+----+\n           |                     |\nB o--------+---------------------+\n```\n$$i_d = g_m v_{gs} + g_{mb} v_{bs} + g_{ds} v_{ds}$$\n$$g_m = \\frac{\\partial I_D}{\\partial V_{GS}} >0 \\qquad g_{mb} = \\frac{\\partial I_D}{\\partial V_{BS}} \\qquad r_o = \\frac{1}{\\lambda I_D}$$\n\n**PMOS with SAME $v_{gs},v_{ds},i_d$ reference:**\n\n$$i_d = -g_m v_{sg} - g_{mb} v_{sb} + g_{ds} v_{ds} = g_{m,p} v_{gs} + g_{mb,p} v_{bs} + g_{ds} v_{ds}$$\n\nwhere $g_{m,p} = \\partial I_D / \\partial V_{GS} <0$ if $I_D$ is defined entering the drain. In magnitude $|g_{m,p}| = \\sqrt{2 \\mu_p C_{ox} W/L |I_D|} = \\mu_p C_{ox} W/L |V_{SG}-|V_{THP}||$ etc.\n\nIn practice we define for PMOS:\n\n$$|i_s| = g_m v_{sg} + g_{mb} v_{sb} + g_{ds} v_{sd}$$\n\nwith $g_m, g_{mb}, g_{ds} >0$, all voltages positive at the source. Then it is *literally* the same circuit as NMOS, just drawn upside down with the source at the top toward $V_{DD}$:\n\n```\n       S o----+ \n              |----+\n       B o----+    |\n                  [ro]\n              |    |\n              [gm*vsg]\n              [gmb*vsb]\n              |    |\n       D o----+----+\n              |\n       G o---|| \n```\n\nSo for any AC analysis you can replace a PMOS by the NMOS small signal model:\n\n* flip it vertically - source is the more positive supply\n* replace $v_{gs}$ by $v_{sg}$\n* replace $v_{bs}$ by $v_{sb}$\n* keep $g_m = |g_m|$, $g_{mb}=|g_{mb}|$, $r_o = 1/(\\lambda |I_D|)$\n\nThis applies to the $T$-model and the high frequency model with $C_{gs}, C_{gd}, C_{gb}, C_{sb}, C_{db}$ as well - all capacitors are identical in place.\n\nThat's why a PMOS common-source, common-gate, source follower has the same gain formulas as the NMOS versions, e.g. common-source $A_v = -g_m (r_{o,n} || r_{o,p})$ .",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "9d64b820fb4c6b54a787d4bfce51c185752601bf6e82b92bbfa3d64b1c1800c3"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly answers that the PMOS small-signal model has the same form with consistent polarity conventions, satisfying the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "ad8a01fc96398ca5ab0993a444ff64ba0cfcb88738d2a52872ea47f671e0635e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 27,
        "output_tokens": 2329,
        "total_tokens": 2356,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1421,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 27,
        "output_tokens": 2329,
        "total_tokens": 2356,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1421,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-003-small-signal-model-pmos-device-identical-nmos",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Is the small-signal model of a PMOS device identical to that of an NMOS device?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "For AC signals, yes. Topologically and mathematically\nidentical.\n\nDifferences are only DC bias polarity and reference\ndirection for currents/voltages. Once linearized the $n$ or $p$ nature disappears and it is just a voltage controlled current source.\n\nIn most books, e.g. Sedra/Smith, Razavi:\n\n> *The small signal model of the PMOS is identical to that of the NMOS.*\n\nIf you define voltages positive at the source for PMOS, i.e. $V_{SG} >0$, $V_{SD}>0$:\n\n### Low frequency hybrid-$\\pi$\n\n```\nNMOS:                          PMOS:\n\n       G                             G\n       |                             |\n       |                             |\n  +----+----+                   +----+----+\n  |         |                   |         |\n  |   vgs   |                   |   vsg   |\n  S         D                   S         D\n  |  gm*vgs |                   |  gm*vsg |\n  |  gmb*vbs|  ro=1/gds         |  gmb*vsb|  ro=1/gds\n  |    ro   |                   |    ro   |\n  +----+----+                   +----+----+\n       |                             |\n       B                             B\n```\n\n* $g_m = \\partial I_D / \\partial V_{GS}$ at the $Q$ point\n* $g_{mb} = \\partial I_D / \\partial V_{BS}$\n* $g_{ds} = 1/r_o = \\partial I_D / \\partial V_{DS} = \\lambda I_D$\n\nFor NMOS in saturation:\n\n$$I_{Dn} = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_{GS}-V_{tn})^2(1+\\lambda_n V_{DS})$$\n\n$$g_{mn} = \\mu_n C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_{GS}-V_{tn}) = \\sqrt{2\\mu_nC_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}I_{Dn}} = \\frac{2I_{Dn}}{V_{OV}}$$\n\nFor PMOS in saturation, with $|V_{tp}|$ and $V_{SG} = -V_{GS} >0$, $V_{SD}=-V_{DS}>0$:\n\n$$I_{Dp} = \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_p C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_{SG}-|V_{tp}|)^2(1+\\lambda_p V_{SD})$$\n\nwhere by convention $I_{Dp}$ is defined *leaving* the drain or *entering* the source, opposite to NMOS.\n\n$$g_{mp} = \\mu_p C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}(V_{SG}-|V_{tp}|) = \\sqrt{2\\mu_pC_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}I_{Dp}} = \\frac{2I_{Dp}}{V_{OV}}$$\n\nSame form with $|V_{GS}|$, $|V_{DS}|$, $|I_D|$.\n\nSame for high frequency: $C_{gs}, C_{gd}, C_{gb}, C_{sb}, C_{db}$ have same topology.\n\nIf you insist on keeping the *same* reference polarities as for NMOS, i.e. $v_{gs}$ defined as $v_G - v_S$ which is negative for a PMOS in active mode, and $i_d$ defined as *entering* the drain for both devices, then\n\n$$i_{d,p} = -g_m v_{gs} - g_{mb}v_{bs} - g_{ds}v_{ds}$$\n\ni.e. formally a negative $g_m$ or a current source pointing from drain to source to source to drain. That is just a sign convention. If you define $v_{sg}=-v_{gs}$ and $i_{sd}=-i_{ds}$ the minus sign disappears and the model is $100\\%$ identical.\n\n> For AC analysis $V_{DD}$ and $V_{SS}$ are both ac ground, so a PMOS with source to $V_{DD}$ looks exactly like an NMOS with source to ground.\n\nWhat *is* different in practice are the *values* : $ \\mu_p \\approx 0.3-0.5\\mu_n$, $|V_{tp}|\\ne V_{tn}$, $\\lambda_p \\ne \\lambda_n$, so for same $W/L$ and $I_D$, $g_{mp} < g_{mn}$ and $r_{op} \\ne r_{on}$.\n\nThe large signal DC model is complementary, not identical.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "76111cd5c8c41d5c2b1a63b260793bbb767b0dfa78ab604566c1b83510e4d03a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that the PMOS small-signal model is identical in form to the NMOS model under consistent polarity conventions, which earns full credit under the golden rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "ad8a01fc96398ca5ab0993a444ff64ba0cfcb88738d2a52872ea47f671e0635e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 27,
        "output_tokens": 2677,
        "total_tokens": 2704,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1699,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 27,
        "output_tokens": 2677,
        "total_tokens": 2704,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1699,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-003-small-signal-model-pmos-device-identical-nmos",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Is the small-signal model of a PMOS device identical to that of an NMOS device?",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "For AC purposes yes, up to an arrow reversal. Topologically it is\nthe same circuit.\n\nIn the strict passive sign sense {\\it not} identical, in the\n``turn it upside down'' sense it {\\it is} identical.\n\n> The low frequency linearized hybrid-$\\pi$ is the same network\n> of $g_{m}$, $g_{mb}$, $g_{ds}=1/r_{o}$ and for HF $C_{gs},C_{gd},C_{gb},C_{sb},C_{db}$ with all magnitudes positive.\n\nThe difference is only the DC reference polarity which disappears on linearization.\n\nFor a NMOS in saturation with the normal reference $I_{D}$ {\\it into}\nthe drain:\n\n$$I_{D,n}=f_{n}(V_{GS},V_{DS},V_{BS})\\approx I_{D0}+ g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}$$\n\n$$g_{m}= \\left.\\frac{\\partial I_{D}}{\\partial V_{GS}}\\right|_{Q} >0 \\;\\; g_{mb}= \\left.\\frac{\\partial I_{D}}{\\partial V_{BS}}\\right|_{Q} \\;\\; g_{ds}= \\left.\\frac{\\partial I_{D}}{\\partial V_{DS}}\\right|_{Q}=1/r_{o}$$\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}$$\n\nLow frequency hybrid-$\\pi$ with source as reference:\n\n```\n      g\n      |\n   +--||--+\n   |      |\n  Cgs    gmb*vbs\n   |      |\ns--+--gm*vgs--d\n   |  ||     |\n   +--ro----+\n   |\n   b\n```\n$v_{gs}$ controls a current source from drain to source, in parallel with $r_{o}=1/g_{ds}$ between drain and source, gate open. $T$-model $1/g_{m}$ between source and gate etc. is the same.\n\nFor a PMOS at DC:\n\n$$I_{SD,p}=f_{p}(V_{SG},V_{SD},V_{SB}) = \\frac{k_{p}}{2}(V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}(1+\\lambda_{p}V_{SD})>0$$\n\nso with the {\\it same} reference $I_{D}$ into the drain\n\n$$I_{Dp} = -f_{p}(-V_{GS},-V_{DS},-V_{BS})$$\n\nLinearizing:\n\n$$i_{d}= \\frac{\\partial I_{Dp}}{\\partial V_{GS}}v_{gs}+ \\frac{\\partial I_{Dp}}{\\partial V_{DS}}v_{ds}+...$$\n\n$$\\frac{\\partial I_{Dp}}{\\partial V_{GS}}= -\\frac{\\partial f_{p}}{\\partial V_{SG}}\\frac{\\partial V_{SG}}{\\partial V_{GS}} = -g_{m,p}^{\\prime}\\cdot(-1)=+g_{m,p}^{\\prime} >0$$\n\n$$\\frac{\\partial I_{Dp}}{\\partial V_{DS}}= -\\frac{\\partial f_{p}}{\\partial V_{SD}}\\frac{\\partial V_{SD}}{\\partial V_{DS}} = -g_{ds,p}^{\\prime}\\cdot(-1)=+g_{ds,p}^{\\prime} >0$$\n\nso formally\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}+g_{mb}v_{bs}$$\n\n{\\it with the same sign} if $g_{m},g_{ds}$ are defined as derivatives of $I_{D}$ {\\it into the drain} w.r.t. $V_{GS},V_{DS}$.\n\nIf, as is usual in text books, you define for the PMOS\n\n$$g_{m,p}= \\left.\\frac{\\partial I_{SD}}{\\partial V_{SG}}\\right|_{Q}>0 \\qquad g_{ds,p}= \\left.\\frac{\\partial I_{SD}}{\\partial V_{SD}}\\right|_{Q}$$\n\nthen\n\n$$i_{sd}=g_{m,p}v_{sg}+g_{mb}v_{sb}+g_{ds,p}v_{sd}$$\n\nand the current source points from {\\it source to drain}, $v_{sg}=-v_{gs}$ controls it.\n\nThat is the ``mirror image'' often drawn as:\n\n```\n      g\n      |\n   +--||--+\n   |      |\n  Csg    gmb*vsb\n   |      |\nd--+--gm*vsg--s  =  s--+--gm*vgs--d with arrow reversed\n   |  ||     |\n   +--ro----+\n   |\n   b -> n-well to VDD\n```\n\nSo for AC small signal analysis you can just re-use the NMOS model by substituting:\n\n$$v_{sg} \\leftrightarrow v_{gs} \\quad , \\quad v_{sd} \\leftrightarrow v_{ds} \\quad , \\quad I_{SD} \\leftrightarrow I_{DS}$$\n\nand drawing the source at the top to $V_{DD}$.\n\nPhysically the values are of course different for the same $W/L$ and $I_{D}$ because $\\mu_{p}\\approx 1/2$ to $1/3 \\mu_{n}$, $ |V_{Tp}|\\ne V_{Tn}$, $\\lambda_{p}\\ne \\lambda_{n}$ etc., so\n\n$$g_{m,n}= \\sqrt{2k_{n}I_{D}} \\ne g_{m,p}= \\sqrt{2k_{p}I_{SD}}$$\n\nbut the {\\it form} of the model is identical.\n\n> Motto: Linearization forgets $n$ vs $p$. The small signal model is a linear voltage controlled current source. $n$ or $p$ only tells you which DC supply polarity forward biases it.\n\nFor hand analysis we therefore say: ``PMOS small signal model = NMOS small signal model turned upside down.''",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "48c2c26f88bdffbdee4ba1489ac707e39b614f2ce3f1e0ed5d0fd951e871e771"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly states that the PMOS small-signal model has the same form as the NMOS model, with current-arrow and polarity conventions reversed.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "ad8a01fc96398ca5ab0993a444ff64ba0cfcb88738d2a52872ea47f671e0635e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 27,
        "output_tokens": 3130,
        "total_tokens": 3157,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1782,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 27,
        "output_tokens": 3130,
        "total_tokens": 3157,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1782,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-01.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the (usual) passive sign convention\n\n$${\\cal I}_{D}>0\\;{\\rm into\\; the\\; drain}$$\n\n$${\\rm put}\\;\\;V_{D}=V_{G}=V_{X}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{S}=V_{B}=0$$\n\n$$V_{GS}=V_{X}\\qquad V_{DS}=V_{X}$$\n\n$$V_{DS}{\\gtrless}V_{GS}-V_{T} =V_{X}-V_{T}$$\n\nfor $V_{T}=V_{T0}>0$ {\\it enhanc.\\; NMOS\\/}\n\n$$V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{T}\\;\\;{\\rm iff}\\;\\;V_{T}\\ge 0$$\n\nso that, if it is on at all, it is saturated.\n\nIn first order, $\\lambda =0$:\n\n$${\\cal I}_{D}=0\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{GS}<V_{T}$$\n\n$${\\cal I}_{D}={\\displaystyle {k\\over 2}\\left(V_{GS}-\nV_{T}\\right)^{2}={k_{n}^{\\prime}\\over 2}{W\\over L}\n\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{GS}>V_{T} } \\tag{1}$$\n\n$$k_{n}^{\\prime}=\\mu _{n}C_{ox}\\qquad k=k_{n}^{\\prime}W/L$$\n\nin saturation. ${\\cal I}_{D}\\ne f(V_{DS})$ to\nfirst order. \n\nWith ${\\cal I}_{D}$ as in Fig. at the high\nimpedance node\n\n$$-{\\cal I}_{D}-I_{X}=0$$\n\ni. e. with the $I_{X}$ reference in the figure\n\n$$I_{X}=-{\\cal I}_{D}$$\n\non the passive sign convention $I_{X}^{\\prime}=-I_{X}=+{\\cal I}_{D}$\nthe conventional diode forward characteristic is recovered.\nNeglecting the sign that is\n\n$$I_{X}^{\\prime}\\approx {k\\over 2}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\nu\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right) \\tag{2}$$\n\n$u$ the unit step. \n\n> {\\it Up to the sign the circuit is a MOS\n> diode. $0$ current for $V_{X}<V_{T}$ and\n> square law current for $V_{X}>V_{T}$. To first\n> order the device never goes into the triode,\n> $V_{DS}=V_{GS}$.}\n\nWith the reference of the figure the current is\nnegative for $V_{X}>V_{T}$ and goes like $-\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}$.\n\nIn the customary ${\\cal I}_{D}$ into the\ndiode convention in quadrant I:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{X}^{\\prime} &\\cr\n{\\big |}\\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\; / \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\; /\\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\;/ \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\;/ \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}/ \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}/ \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}/ \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\cr\n{\\hbox{----------}}&{\\hbox{----------}}{\\big |}{\\hbox{----------}}V_{X}\\cr\n{}&{}&{0}&{V_{T}}}$$\n\nand, with $\\lambda \\ne 0$,\n$I_{X}^{\\prime}=(k/2)(V_{X}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{X})$ for\n$V_{X}>V_{T}$ and finite slope,\n$R_{X}=1/g_{m}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx 1/g_{m}$.\n\nWith the $I_{X}$ reference drawn the parabola is\nin quadrant IV\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{X} &\\cr\n{\\big |}\\cr\n{\\hbox{----------}}&{\\hbox{----------}}{\\big |}{\\hbox{----------}}V_{X}\\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\backslash \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\; \\backslash \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\;\\; \\backslash \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\;\\; \\;\\backslash \\cr\n{}&{\\big |}\\;\\; \\;\\; \\backslash  \\cr\n}$$\n\ni. e. $I_{X}=-(k/2)(V_{X}-V_{T})^{2}$ for $V_{X}>V_{T}$,\n$0$ otherwise.\n\nIn more detail: $I_{X}=0$ is replaced with\nexponential sub threshold current $\\propto \\exp\n\\left[(V_{X}-V_{T})/\\zeta V_{T}\\right]$ for\n$V_{X}\\sim V_{T}$ and with a linear law,\n$I_{X}\\propto V_{X}-V_{T}$, in velocity\nsaturation. With $V_{X}\\ll 0$ the $N^{+}$ drain-\n$P$ substrate junction forward biases, Fig. dotted,\n\n$$I_{X}\\propto -\\exp \\left[-V_{X}/V_{T}\\right]\\;\\;,\n\\;\\;V_{X}<-0.6{\\rm V}$$\n\nwhich normally clamps the negative excursion at\n$-0.7{\\rm V}$. Neglecting the junction the\nsquare law can be continued to $I_{X}=0$ for all\n$V_{X}<V_{T}$, including $V_{X}<0$. For the\nconventional $f$ the junction current is\n$\\propto +\\exp \\left[-V_{X}/V_{T}\\right]$ for\n$V_{X}<0$.\n\nWith $\\lambda \\ne 0$ the $I_{X}=0$ plateau has\nsmall slope $1/r_{o}$.\n\nFor a depl. device $V_{T}<0$ shift origin to\n$V_{T}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6d0ee90942b0184a3d2fe15dda0c978a887db899bf821da4298d1bd174b39421"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The diode-connected NMOS, saturation operation, and square-law magnitude are identified correctly. However, the answer makes the figure-referenced IX negative above threshold and sketches a downward branch, whereas the golden answer requires IX to rise quadratically; that reverses the requested I–V trend.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "769af5ac610bb7825c7abce92bf56d510d018662cbce83d47eef1dee2597750d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1221,
        "output_tokens": 4399,
        "total_tokens": 5620,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2962,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1221,
        "output_tokens": 4399,
        "total_tokens": 5620,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2962,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-01.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With $M_{1}$ $n-$ channel\n$V_{B}=0$, $V_{S}=0$, $V_{D}=V_{G}=V_{X}$\n\n$$V_{GS}=V_{X}\\qquad V_{DS}=V_{X}\\qquad\nV_{BS}=0$$\n\n$$I_{G}=0\\tag*{$I_{D}$ into $D$}$$\n$$I_{X}({\\rm into}\\;{\\rm node}) =I_{D}\\tag*{KCL}$$\nWith the reference direction as drawn\n\n$$\\;I_{X}=-I_{D}\\;$$\n\nto within a sign.  In magnitude $\\left|I_{X}\\right|=I_{D}$.\n\n{\\it 1. At large} $|I_{D}|$, {\\it what is $M_{1}$ doing?}\n\nIn conventional terms $S$ is the lowest $n$ potential.\nFor $V_{X}>0$:\n\n* ${\\rm off}$ : \n\n$$V_{GS}<V_{T}\\qquad V_{X}<V_{TN}$$\n\n$$I_{D}\\approx 0\\;\\;{\\rm weak\\;inv.\\;}\\propto \n\\exp \\left[(V_{X}-V_{T})/nV_{t}\\right]\\approx 0$$\n\n* ${\\rm on}$ :\n\n$$V_{GS}>V_{T}\\qquad V_{X}>V_{TN}$$\n\n$$V_{DS}=V_{GS}>V_{GS}-V_{T}\\;\\;{\\rm if}\\;V_{T}>0$$\n\nso if it is on it is in saturation. There is no\nnormal triode - linear - region\n\n$$I_{D}= {1\\over 2}k_{n}(V_{GS}-V_{T})^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right]\\tag*{sat}$$\n\n$$|I_{X}|\\approx {1\\over 2}\\mu _{n}C_{ox}{W\\over L}\n\\left(V_{X}-V_{TN}\\right)^{2}\\left[1+\\lambda V_{X}\\right]\n\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;V_{X}>V_{TN}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$|I_{X}|\\approx 0\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;V_{X}<V_{TN}\\tag{2}$$\n\nmodulo the sign. With the $I_{X}$ arrow drawn\nfrom the node into the $+$ terminal of $V_{X}$,\n\n$$I_{X}\\approx 0\\;\\;V_{X}<V_{TN}$$\n$$I_{X}\\approx -{1\\over 2}k_{n}(V_{X}-V_{TN})^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda V_{X}\\right]\\;\\;V_{X}>V_{TN}$$\n\ni. e. the negative of (1).  If you define $I_{X}$\nas into the ${\\rm D,G}$ node $I_{X}=+I_{D}>0$ for\n$V_{X}>V_{TN}$.\n\nIdeal $\\lambda =0$:\n\nIdeal long channel the characteristic is flat\n$0$ up to $V_{T}$ and then a parabola with\nzero slope at $V_{T}$, Fig.a. With\n$ {\\rm CLM}\\;\\ne 0$, $r_{o}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$,\nthe parabola acquires the finite slope\n$g_{ds}=\\lambda I_{D}$, Fig.b.  In weak inversion\nit is exponential for $0<V_{X}<V_{T}$.\n\nThat is the normal diode connected load characteristic.\nSmall signal\n\n$$R_{X}={{\\rm d}V_{X}\\over {\\rm d}I_{X}}=\n{1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\n\\propto |I_{X}|^{-1/2}$$\n\n```\n         | IX |  into D,G                  IX as drawn\n         |                               |\n         |             /                 |      VT\n         |            /                  |-------|------------ VX\n   |IX|  |           /              0 ---|-------/------------\n         |          /                    |      / \n         |         /                     |     /   IX = -ID\n         |________/______ VX             |    /    < 0 for VX>VT\n                  VT                     |   /\n         0 for VX < VT                   |  / \n  Fig.a ideal lambda=0                   | /\n         Fig.b with lambda>0 slope       |/  flat 0 for VX < VT\n          weak inv. exponential not shown\n```\n\nFor $V_{X}<0$ the transistor is off also with\nsource drain interchanged, the top $n$ now being\nthe source, $V_{GS}=0<V_{T}$.  Ideally $I_{X}=0$\nfor all $V_{X}<V_{T}$, negative as well, so the\ndevice is rectifying like a diode with forward\ndirection $V_{X}>0$.\n\nIn silicon if you go negative enough the parasitic\ndrain $n$ - $p$ substrate diode forward biases\n\n$$V_{BD}=V_{B}-V_{D}=-V_{X}>V_{f}\\approx 0.6-0.7{\\rm V}$$\n\n$$I_{BD}=I_{S}\\left[e^{-V_{X}/V_{t}}-1\\right]$$\n\nentering the ${\\rm D}$ node from the substrate and\nflowing out through $I_{X}$.  With $I_{X}$ as drawn\nto the right this is a large exponential {\\it positive}\ncurrent for $V_{X}<-0.7{\\rm V}$.  With $I_{X}$ defined\ninto the node it is a large {\\it negative} current.\nNormally operation is restricted to $V_{X}>-0.6{\\rm V}$\nso it can be ignored and (2) holds for all\n$V_{X}<V_{T}$.\n\nNeglecting that diode this is the square law\nMOS diode\n\n$$I\\propto (V-V_{T})^{2}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;V>V_{T}\\;\\;0\\;{\\rm otherwise}$$\n\nwith zero current in reverse direction.  Interchanging\nthe sign of $I_{X}$ mirrors the curve about the\n$V_{X}$ axis.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6e36023eadf2c9d57b4e5e2629a943589bf3173dced2005b996030787994b6d1"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the diode-connected NMOS as off up to threshold and in saturation above threshold, giving a quadratic current rise. The sign convention is addressed, and the extra CLM and negative-voltage discussion does not undermine the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "769af5ac610bb7825c7abce92bf56d510d018662cbce83d47eef1dee2597750d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1123,
        "input_tokens": 1221,
        "output_tokens": 6581,
        "total_tokens": 7802,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5223,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1123,
        "input_tokens": 1221,
        "output_tokens": 6581,
        "total_tokens": 7802,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5223,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-004-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-01.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the sign as drawn the current in the voltage source\nis the negative of the drain current, Fig.1.\n\nPut\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{D}&=I_{DS}(V_{GS},V_{DS})\\cr\nV_{GS}&=V_{DS}=V_{X}}$$\n\nfor the conventional positive into the drain\n\n$$I_{D}= \\left\\{\\eqalign{\n0 & V_{X}<V_{T}\\cr\n{\\beta \\over 2}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\\left[1+\\lambda V_{X}\\right]\n& V_{X}>V_{T} }\\right.\\tag*{in SAT}$$\n\n$V_{T}=V_{TN}>0$, $\\beta =k_{n}=\n\\mu _{n}C_{ox}W/L$ .  In fact\n\n$$V_{DS}=V_{GS}>V_{GS}-V_{T}\\qquad V_{T}>0$$\n\nso that if it is on it is saturated.  Neglecting ${\\rm CLM}$,\n$\\lambda =0$,\n\n$$I_{D}={k_{n}\\over 2}\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\n\\qquad V_{GS}>V_{T}$$\n\nand $0$, ${\\rm to}\\;O\\left(e^{V_{GS}/V_{t}}\\right)$, for\n$V_{GS}<V_{T}$.\n\nAt the top node, $I_{G}=0$,\n\n$$I_{D}+I_{X}=0$$\n\nso that with the reference polarity in the figure the\nlarge signal rectifying characteristic is , to first\norder,\n\n$$I_{X} =-I_{D}= -\\cases{\n0 & $V_{X}<V_{T}$ \\cr\n{\\displaystyle {k_{n}\\over 2}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda V_{X}\\right]} & $V_{X}>V_{T}$ } \\tag{1}$$\n\nto within the subthreshold exponential tail.\nIn absolute value, $|I_{X}|=I_{D}$, the conventional\ndiode connected quadratic diode,\n\n$$|I_{X}|\\approx {k_{n}\\over 2}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\n {\\cal U}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)\\tag{2}$$\n\n${\\cal U}$ the unit step, Fig.2$a$.  With the sign of\nFig.1 it is the same parabola turned upside down, Fig.2$b$.\n\nIn normal operation $V_{X}>0$ the source $V_{X}$ is delivering\npower, $V_{X}I_{X}<0$, and $|I_{X}|$ flows from $V_{X}$\ninto the drain, through the channel to ground.\n\n> {\\it Remark on $V_{X}<0$:}  In first order the {\\it MOS}\n> current is $0$ for $V_{X}<V_{T}$ so Eq.1 is often quoted as\n> $I_{X}=0$ for $V_{X}<V_{T}$ and in particular for $V_{X}<0$.\n> Physically the $n^{+}$ drain $p$ substrate junction goes\n> forward for $V_{X}<-V_{D}\\approx -0.7\\,{\\rm V}$, Fig.2\n> dotted.  With $V_{B}=0$,\n> $$I_{X}^{({\\rm j})}=I_{S}\\left[e^{-V_{X}/V_{t}}-1\\right]\n> \\qquad V_{X}\\ll 0$$\n> becomes large and positive, {\\it i. e.} flowing as drawn,\n> into the $+$ terminal of $V_{X}$, Fig.2$b$ dotted.  With\n> the ideal ${\\rm MOS}$ model this is normally neglected and\n> $I_{X}\\approx 0$ is quoted for all $V_{X}<V_{T}$.\n\nPut $V_{GS}=V_{X}$ in Fig.2 the device is off for\n$V_{X}<V_{T}$ and looks like\n\n$$R_{X}={1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}$$\n\nfor small signals, $g_{m}=k_{n}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)$,\nwhereas large signal $R_{X}=V_{X}/I_{X}\\propto \n1/\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}$.  Including ${\\rm CLM}$ the\nparabola is multiplied by $1+\\lambda V_{X}$, Fig.2 dashed.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{\\rm Ideal:}\\;\\;I_{X}&=0\\;,\\;V_{X}<V_{T}\\cr\n|I_{X}|&={\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}\\mu_{n}C_{ox}{W\\over L}\n\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\\;,\\;V_{X}>V_{T}\\cr\n& {\\rm saturated\\;for\\;all\\;}V_{X}>V_{T}}$$\n\napart from the sign $I_{X}=-|I_{X}|$ with the\nreference polarity of the figure.  Any proportionality\nconstant $k_{n}/2$ may be used.  The subthreshold\nregion rounds the corner at $V_{X}=V_{T}$ over $\\sim\n100\\,{\\rm mV}$ like $\\exp \\left(V_{X}/V_{t}\\right)$.  The\nnormal rectifying diode characteristic is $|I_{X}|$\nversus $V_{X}$, $0$ for $V_{X}<V_{T}$ and $\\propto\n\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}$ for $V_{X}>V_{T}$.\n\n```\n IX                     |IX| = -IX\n ^                      ^      \n |                      |     / \n |                      |    /  \n |                      |   /   \n |                      |  /    \n |                      | /     \n |                      |/      \n |                      /--------> VX\n |      dotted jn.      |       VT\n |     /                |\n |    /  ---------------|------> VX\n |   /   0         VT   |\n |  /                   |\n | /                    |     \\\n |/                     |      \\\n +--------> VX          |       \\\n0   VT                  |        \\\n                        |         \\\n                        |  -|IX| vs VX as drawn\n(a) |IX| conventional   (b) IX with ref. polarity in Fig.1\n     positive into drain.  Dotted: drain - bulk forward\n     for VX < -0.6V. Dashed: lambda >0.\n```\n\nFor textbook purposes the minus sign is often dropped and\nFig.2$a$ is quoted as $I_{X}$ versus $V_{X}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bedbacebd5582f172b25a1ae14371f5fbd00d9fea0aa9fa74e65687b2a7e172e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the diode-connected NMOS, cutoff below threshold, and square-law saturation above threshold. But it explicitly makes IX negative and plots a downward branch, whereas the expected IX characteristic rises quadratically; the requested signed current is therefore wrong.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "769af5ac610bb7825c7abce92bf56d510d018662cbce83d47eef1dee2597750d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1221,
        "output_tokens": 5564,
        "total_tokens": 6785,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3971,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1221,
        "output_tokens": 5564,
        "total_tokens": 6785,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3971,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-02.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With $V_{X}=V_{GS}$ and $V_{DS}=V_{DD}=1{\\rm V}$\nput $V_{SB}=0$ the conventional long channel\nsquare law can be used for illustration\n\n$$I_{D}= \\cases{\n0 & :{\\rm cut\\;off}\\cr\nk_{n}^{\\prime}W/2L\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\n\\left(1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right) & : {\\rm sat.}\\cr\nk_{n}^{\\prime}W/L\\left[(V_{GS}-V_{T})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}/2\\right]\n\\left(1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right)& : {\\rm triode}}$$\n\n$$k_{n}^{\\prime}=\\mu _{n}C_{ox}\\qquad \n{\\rm sat.}\\iff V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{T}$$\n\nneglecting $\\lambda$\n\n$${\\rm sat.}\\iff 1\\ge V_{X}-V_{T}\\iff V_{X}\\le V_{T}+1$$\n\nso that apart from the sign convention for $I_{X}$\n$I_{X}\\approx \\pm I_{D}$ is the conventional\n$I_{D}-V_{GS}$ characteristic at constant $V_{DS}$, Fig. 1.\n\n* $V_{X}<V_{T}$ {\\it e. g.} $0.3-0.7{\\rm V}$ enhancement :\n${\\bf M_{1}\\;{\\rm off}}$\n\n$$I_{X}\\approx 0\\qquad {\\rm leakage}\\;\\propto\n  \\exp (V_{X}-V_{T})/\\zeta V_{T}\\;{\\rm in\\;subthreshold}$$\n\n$g_{m}=dI_{X}/dV_{X}=0$.\n\n* $V_{T}<V_{X}<V_{T}+V_{DS}$ : $V_{DS}>V_{GST}$ {\\it saturation}\n\n$$I_{X}=+I_{D}= {1\\over 2}k_{n}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\n\\tag{1}$$\n$$k_{n}=k_{n}^{\\prime}W/L$$\n\nparabolic, \n\n$$g_{m}=k_{n}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)$$\n\nlinear in $V_{X}$.  With $\\lambda \\ne 0$\n$I_{X}= {\\textstyle {1\\over 2}}k_{n}(V_{X}-V_{T})^{2}\n(1+\\lambda V_{DS})$.\n\nAt $V_{X}=V_{T}+V_{DS}$\n\n$$I_{X}(sat)=I_{X}(triode)={1\\over 2}k_{n}V_{DS}^{2}$$\n\ne. g. with normalisation $k_{n}=1{\\rm mA/V^{2}}$,\n$V_{T}=0.5{\\rm V}$, $I_{X}=0.5{\\rm mA}$ at the\nknee.\n\nIn the usual drawing $I_{X}$ is shown entering the\ndrain, $I_{X}>0$.  If as drawn $I_{X}$ is taken\nleaving the drain $I_{X}=-I_{D}$ the whole picture\nis inverted $I_{X}\\le 0$.\n\n* $V_{X}>V_{T}+V_{DS}$ : $V_{DS}<V_{GST}$ linear\nor triode\n\n$$I_{X}=k_{n}\\left[(V_{X}-V_{T})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}/2\\right]\n\\tag{2}$$\n$$=k_{n}V_{DS}\\left[V_{X}-V_{T}-V_{DS}/2\\right]$$\n\nlinear in $V_{X}$ with\n\n$$g_{m}=dI_{X}/dV_{X}=k_{n}V_{DS}={\\rm const.}$$\n\ntangent to the parabola at $V_{X}=V_{T}+V_{DS}$,\nEq.1 and 2 have the same value and the same\nslope\n\n$$\\left. {dI_{X}\\over dV_{X}}\\right|_{\\rm sat}=k_{n}V_{DS}$$\n\nat the boundary. For $V_{DS}=1{\\rm V}$\n\n$$I_{X}=k_{n}\\left[V_{X}-V_{T}-{1\\over 2}\\right]\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;\nV_{X}>V_{T}+1 \\tag{3}$$\n\n$V_{SB}=0$ so there is no back gate modulation.\nWith velocity saturation and mobility degradation the\nparabola 1 becomes quasi linear for large $V_{X}$\nand the straight line 3 is bent downward.\n\nQualitatively, with $I_{X}$ taken in the conventional\ndrain current sense $+I_{D}$:\n\n```\nI_X\n ^                          /\n |                         /  triode I ~ V_X\n |                        /\n |                       / g_m = k_n V_DS = const\n |                      /\n |                     /_ _ _ _ _ _ _ saturation\n |                    . I ~ (V_X-V_T)^2\n |                   .\n |                 .\n |               .\n |             .\n |           .\n |         .\n |       .\n |     .\n |   .\n | .\n +------------------------------------> V_X\n 0   V_T            V_T+V_DS= V_T+1V\n     cut off         parabolic  linear\n     I=0  g_m=0      g_m~V_X   g_m=const\n```\n\nWith the reference direction as drawn in the figure,\nif $I_{X}$ is defined flowing {\\it out} of the drain\ninto the $+1{\\rm V}$ supply, $I_{X}=-I_{D}$ and the\ncurve is mirrored about the $V_{X}$ axis, $I_{X}\\le 0$,\n$I_{X}=0$ for $V_{X}<V_{T}$, $I_{X}=-{\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}\nk_{n}(V_{X}-V_{T})^{2}$ in saturation and\n$I_{X}=-k_{n}[(V_{X}-V_{T})-1/2]$ in triode.\n\nAny $V_{T}>0$ for enhancement, $V_{T}<0$ just shifts\norigin so $I_{X}\\ne 0$ at $V_{X}=0$.  For $\\lambda\\ne 0$\nmultiply by $1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\approx 1+\\lambda$.  The\nsubthreshold region rounds the sharp corner at $V_{T}$.\nVery large $V_{X}$ is limited by oxide reliability.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a1e7947fedeaa9505159e5715cd86bd8cf91499dfcf54bf1b08cbac9bd867906"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly gives a quadratic rise from threshold through the saturation region, then a roughly linear rise in triode beyond $V_X=V_T+1\\,\\mathrm{V}$. It also notes the zero-current region below threshold; the sign-convention discussion does not change the essential curve.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "da000995f2032c3caf224acfa4963413c96cebf89a3cc792e76c3a444d327ffc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1399,
        "output_tokens": 7426,
        "total_tokens": 8825,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5797,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1399,
        "output_tokens": 7426,
        "total_tokens": 8825,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5797,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-02.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With ${\\rm M_{1}}$\n\n$${\\rm V_{GS}}=V_{X}\\qquad {\\rm V_{DS}}=1.0{\\rm V}\n\\qquad {\\rm V_{BS}}=0$$\n\nput for simplicity\n\n$$K_{N}= \\mu _{n}C_{ox}W/L\\qquad I_{{D}_{0}}=\n{K_{N}\\over {2}}\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}$$\n\nfor the normal $+\\;V_{DS}$ ${\\rm M_{1}}$ is the\n$n$ channel device, drain on top.\n\n$${\\rm saturation:}\\;\\;V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{T}$$\n$${\\rm triode:}\\;\\;V_{DS}<V_{GS}-V_{T}$$\n\nso that with $V_{DS}\\equiv 1{\\rm V}$\n\n$$V_{X}<V_{T} : {\\rm cut\\;off}$$\n\n$$V_{T}<V_{X}<V_{T}+1 :{\\rm saturation}$$\n\n$$V_{X}>V_{T}+1 :{\\rm triode}$$\n\nIn first order, $\\lambda =0$, $V_{BS}=0$\n\n$$I_{X}=I_{D} \\approx \\tag{*}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n0 & V_{X}<V_{T} \\cr\n{{K_{N}}\\over {2}}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\\left[1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right]\n & V_{T}\\le V_{X}\\le V_{T}+V_{DS}\\cr\nK_{N}\\left[\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)V_{DS}-{{V_{DS}^{2}}\\over {2}}\\right]\n & V_{X}>V_{T}+V_{DS}\\cr}$$\n\nwith $V_{DS}=1{\\rm V}$.  With $\\lambda \\ne 0$ the\nsecond line is $\\propto 1+\\lambda $ and the slope in\nsaturation at the boundary is $K_{N}(1+\\lambda )$ to be\ncompared with the triode slope $K_{N}V_{DS}=K_{N}$.\nIn first order the slope is continuous.\n\n$$I_{X}=0\\;\\;V_{X}<V_{T}$$\n$$I_{X}\\propto \\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\\;\\;{\\rm to}\\;\\;\nV_{X}=V_{T}+1$$\n$$I_{X}=K_{N}\\left[V_{X}-V_{T}-{1\\over {2}}\\right]\\;\\;V_{X}>V_{T}+1$$\n\ni. e. the normal transfer characteristic for $V_{DS}=1{\\rm V}$.\n\n$$\\left. {{dI_{X}}\\over {dV_{X}}}\\right|_{sat}=K_{N}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)\n\\qquad \\left. {{dI_{X}}\\over {dV_{X}}}\\right|_{tri}=K_{N}V_{DS}$$\n\nso that at $V_{X}=V_{T}+1$ the two slopes join,\nparabolic to linear.\n\n```\nIX\n^\n|                              / triode\n|                             /  IX = KN[(VX-VT)-1/2]\n|                            /\n|                           /\n|                          / saturation\n|                         /  IX = KN/2 (VX-VT)^2\n|                        /\n|                      ./\n|                    ./\n|                  ./\n|                ./\n|              ./\n|            ./\n|          ./\n|        ./\n|      ./\n|    ./\n|  ./\n|./\n+------------------------------------------------> VX\n0               VT              VT+1.0V\n   cut off      |  saturation   |  triode\n    IX=0        |  parabolic    |  linear\n                |  gm=KN(VX-VT) |  gm=KN.VDS\n```\n\nIn detail with sub threshold conduction $I_{X}\\propto\n\\exp \\left[(V_{X}-V_{T})/nV_{T_{h}}\\right]$ for\n$V_{X}<V_{T}$ instead of $0$ and, for a short channel\ndevice, velocity saturation makes the ``parabolic''\nportion quasi linear for $V_{X}-V_{T}>V_{DSAT}$,\n$I_{Dsat}\\approx W C_{ox}v_{sat}\\left(V_{X}-V_{T}-\nV_{DSAT}/2\\right)$.  Nominally $V_{T}\\approx 0.3-0.7{\\rm V}$\nso the break point is at $V_{X}\\approx 1.3-1.7{\\rm V}$.\n\nE. {\\rm g.} $K_{N}=2{\\rm mA/V^{2}}$, $V_{T}=0.4{\\rm V}$,\n$\\lambda \\approx 0$:\n\n$I_{X}=0$ to $0.4{\\rm V}$, $I_{X}=1.0\\left(V_{X}-0.4\\right)^{2}{\\rm mA}$\nto $V_{X}=1.4{\\rm V}$, $I_{X}=1.0{\\rm mA}$ at the\nboundary, $I_{X}=2.0\\left[V_{X}-0.9\\right]{\\rm mA}$ for\n$V_{X}>1.4{\\rm V}$, slope $2{\\rm mA/V}$.\n\nAny $V_{X}<0$ just keeps the $n$ channel off.\nThe $n^{+}$ drain to $p$ substrate diode stays reverse\nbiased.  $I_{X}>0$ in the reference direction is the\nconventional $D\\to S$ current.  With the conventional\nsign $I_{D}=-I_{X}$ if you take $I_{D}$ out of the drain.\nWith $\\lambda >0$ the saturation parabola is multiplied\nby $1+\\lambda \\times 1{\\rm V}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "978d7f1a4acfd86a2c68fad111bfcae7af8d4ecc3efc0dcfecc3ea9316f0ad44"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies cutoff below threshold, the quadratic saturation-region rise through VX = VTH + 1 V, and the roughly linear triode-region rise beyond it. The extra modeling details do not undermine the essential sketch.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "da000995f2032c3caf224acfa4963413c96cebf89a3cc792e76c3a444d327ffc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1399,
        "output_tokens": 4808,
        "total_tokens": 6207,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3420,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1399,
        "output_tokens": 4808,
        "total_tokens": 6207,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3420,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Sketch IX versus VX in the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-005-sketch-ix-versus-vx/figure-02.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the conventional enhancement symbol the\nvertical bar is the channel and the arrow is\nthe $p-$ substrate. $GROUND\\equiv {\\rm body}= \n{\\rm source}$ so\n\n$$V_{BS}=0\\qquad V_{GS}=V_{X}\\qquad V_{DS}=\n1.0{\\rm V}$$\n\nis a grounded source $n-$ channel device,\na $1.0{\\rm V}$ ${\\rm common\\; source}$ measured\nat constant $V_{DS}$ i. e. the conventional\n$I_{D}-V_{GS}|_{V_{DS}}$ characteristic.\nPut, for the long channel square law,\n\n$$V_{T}=V_{T0}>0 \\tag*{$\\approx 0.3-0.7{\\rm V}$}$$\n$$K_{n}= \\mu _{n}C_{ox}W/L$$\n$$I_{D}=K_{n}\\left[(V_{GS}-V_{T})V_{DS}-{1\\over 2}V_{DS}^{2}\n\\right]\\;\\;V_{DS}<V_{GS}-V_{T}$$\n$$I_{D}={1\\over 2}K_{n}(V_{GS}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{DS})\n\\;\\;V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{T}$$\ncut--off $I_{D}\\approx 0$ for $V_{GS}<V_{T}$ \nexpon. subthreshold.\n\nIn this circuit $V_{DS}=V_{DD}=1.0{\\rm V}={\\rm const.}$\n\n> {\\it I. e. with the reference polarity drawn in\n> the figure $I_{X}$ is the current flowing {\\it out}\n> of the drain into the battery,\n> $$I_{X}=-I_{D}$$\n> conventionally positive {\\it into} the drain.\n> For $|I_{X}|$ delete the minus sign.}\n\nHence for $|I_{X}|=I_{D} $:\n\n* $V_{X}<V_{T}$ : OFF\n\n$$|I_{X}|\\approx 0\\tag*{{\\rm drain bulk reverse\n$\\approx 1{\\rm V}$}}$$\n\napart from $\\exp [(V_{X}-V_{T})/\\zeta V_{T}]$ subthreshold\nleakage.\n\n* $V_{T}<V_{X}<V_{DD}+V_{T}$ : SATURATION\n\n$$V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{T}$$\n\n$$|I_{X}|={1\\over 2}K_{n}(V_{X}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{DD})\n \\approx {1\\over 2}K_{n}(V_{X}-V_{T})^{2}\\tag{1}$$\n\nparabolic start with zero slope at $V_{X}=V_{T}$.\n\nWith $\\lambda =0$ the $V_{DS}$ dependence drops out.\n\n* $V_{X}>V_{DD}+V_{T}$ : TRIODE, linear\n\n$$V_{DS}<V_{GS}-V_{T}$$\n$$|I_{X}|=K_{n}\\left[(V_{X}-V_{T})V_{DD}-{1\\over 2}V_{DD}^{2}\n\\right] \\tag{2}$$\nfor $V_{DD}=1{\\rm V}$\n\n$$|I_{X}|=K_{n}\\left[V_{X}-V_{T}-{1\\over 2}\\right]\\qquad \nV_{X}>1+V_{T}$$\n\nstraight line of slope\n\n$${{d|I_{X}|}\\over {dV_{X}}}=K_{n}V_{DD}=K_{n}\\;\\;{\\rm in\\; triode}$$\n$${{d|I_{X}|}\\over{ dV_{X}}}=K_{n}(V_{X}-V_{T})\\;\\;{\\rm in\\; sat.}$$\n\nso the parabola joins the straight line with\ncontinuous value and slope at the edge of\nsaturation\n\n$$V_{X(sat)}^{*}=V_{DD}+V_{T}\\approx 1.3-1.7{\\rm V}$$\n$$|I_{X}^{*}|={1\\over 2}K_{n}V_{DD}^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{DD})\n\\approx {1\\over 2}K_{n}\\tag{{\\rm for $1{\\rm V}$}}$$\n\nE. {\\rm g.} for $V_{T}=0.4{\\rm V}$, $K_{n}=1.0{\\rm mA/V^{2}}$:\n\n$|I_{X}|=0$ to $0.4{\\rm V}$, $0.18{\\rm mA}$ at\n$V_{X}=1.0{\\rm V}$, $0.5{\\rm mA}$ at $V_{X}^{*}=1.4{\\rm V}$,\n$1.1{\\rm mA}$ at $V_{X}=2.0{\\rm V}$ on Eq.2.\n\nSchematically for the conventional positive $I_{D}$\ninto the drain, $|I_{X}|$:\n\n```\n|I_X| = I_D\n  ^\n  |                    /\n  |                   / triode\n  |                  / dI/dV = Kn.VDD\n  |                 /\n  |                /\n  |               / sat.\n  |              / 1/2Kn(Vx-Vt)^2\n  |            ./\n  |          ./\n  |        ./\n  |      ./\n  |    ./\n  |  ./\n  |./\n  +--------------------------> Vx\n  0   Vt      Vt+ VDD ~=1+Vt\n      OFF |  SATURATION | TRIODE\n```\n\nWith the reference arrow as normally drawn from\ndrain to $V_{DD}$ the measured current is\n\n$$I_{X}=-I_{D}\\le 0$$\n\ni. e. the mirror image below the $V_{X}$ axis,\n$0$ for $V_{X}<V_{T}$, negative going parabola to\n$V_{X}=V_{T}+1{\\rm V}$ and negative going straight\nline thereafter.\n\n```\n I_X  0\n  ^--------------------------------> Vx\n  |   Vt      Vt+1\n  |  .\\\n  |    .\\\n  |      .\\\n  |        .\\\n  |          .\\\n  |            \\     \n  |             \\     \n  |              \\    \n  v               \\  triode\n```\n\nAny normalisation of $K_{n}$ just scales the\nvertical axis. $\\lambda \\ne 0$ adds the factor\n$1+\\lambda V_{DD}\\approx 1.05-1.1$ in saturation.\n$\\theta $ mobility degradation and $v_{sat}$ will\nround the parabola to quasi linear for\n$V_{X}-V_{T}\\gg E_{c}L$ and limit the triode slope\nto $W C_{ox}v_{sat}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "3179e5f2db6ffe703f0d7b16e7ea94e6db8c7a99953a9a4cb4cd4730d59b6e60"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The cutoff, saturation-to-triode transition at VX = VT + 1 V, and quadratic-to-linear magnitude are all correct. However, it sketches the signed IX as negative-going, whereas the golden characteristic is rising; the sign convention is the remaining error.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "da000995f2032c3caf224acfa4963413c96cebf89a3cc792e76c3a444d327ffc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1399,
        "output_tokens": 6872,
        "total_tokens": 8271,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5213,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1399,
        "output_tokens": 6872,
        "total_tokens": 8271,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5213,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-006-device-act-as-current-source",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "Can the device shown in the figure act as a current source?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-006-device-act-as-current-source/figure-03.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the ordinary 3 term symbol the arrow is on\nthe source.  So that the one high resistance\nterminal is nominally in the air.\n\n$${\\rm top}=S, {\\rm bottom }=D, G= D=0\\tag*{$P$ - ${\\rm MOS}$ in\nthe drawing}$$\n\n$${\\rm top}=D,{\\rm bottom }=S= G=0\\tag*{$N$ - ${\\rm MOS}$ if you\ncall the arrow the bulk }$$\n\nIn either normalisation the 2 terminal $I_{X}(V_{X})$\nis\n\n$${\\rm NMOS:}\\;\\;V_{GS}=0\\tag*{}$$\nso that for the conventional $V_{T}>0$ enhancement\ndevice\n\n$$I_{X}=0\\qquad V_{X}<V_{T} \\tag{{\\rm cut off}}$$\n$$I_{X}\\approx 0+{{V_{X}}\\over {r_{o}}}+{\\rm leakage}\\qquad \n{\\rm on\\;the\\;verge\\;of\\;saturation}$$\n\nin the conventional square law, long channel,\nfirst order model, i. e. the large signal\ncurrent is zero.  In small signal, with the\ngate $ac$ ground, the impedance looking into\nthe {\\it drain} is formally the usual common\ngate - common source output impedance\n\n$$R_{X}\\equiv {{dV_{X}}\\over {dI_{X}}}=r_{o}\\qquad V_{GS}=0\\tag*{$N$ MOS\ndrain in}$$\n\nso that you can {\\it call} the cut off device a\n``current source'' of $I_{X}\\approx 0$ and\n$R_{o}=r_{o}$, Fig.1a.  As soon as you try to make\nit carry current $V_{GS}\\ne 0$ you have to move\n$V_{X}$.  Put $V_{T}<0$, {\\it i. e.} a depletion\ndevice, and you get the usual saturated load\n\n$$I_{DSS}={1\\over 2}k_{n}\\left|V_{T}\\right|^{2}\\qquad \nR_{o}=r_{o}={1\\over {\\lambda I_{DSS}}}$$\n\nloosely called a current source in $n$ MOS\nlogic.\n\nFor the polarity drawn, $P$ MOS, the source is\nin the air.  Put $V_{T}=-\\left|V_{T}\\right|$\n\n$$V_{SG}=V_{S}-V_{G}=V_{X}\\tag*{}$$\n$$V_{SD}=V_{S}-V_{D}=V_{X}\\tag*{}$$\n\n$$I_{X}=0\\qquad V_{X}<\\left|V_{T}\\right| \\tag{{\\rm cut off}}$$\n$$I_{X}={1\\over 2}k_{p}\\left(V_{X}-\\left|V_{T}\\right|\\right)^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda V_{X}\\right]\\qquad V_{X}>\\left|V_{T}\\right| \\tag{1}$$\n\nand the saturation condition\n\n$$V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}-\\left|V_{T}\\right|\\tag*{$P$ sat.}$$\n\n$$V_{X}\\ge V_{X}-\\left|V_{T}\\right|$$\n\nis satisfied as soon as the device is on.  So\nthe device {\\it is} saturated for every\n$V_{X}>\\left|V_{T}\\right|$.  In the\n``the saturated MOS is a current source'' jargon\nyou can call it a current source.  But c. f. (1)\nthe current is $\\propto \\left(V_{X}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}$\nand, in small signal, looking into the {\\it source},\n\n$$v_{sg}=v_{x}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{sd}=v_{x}\\tag*{}$$\n\n$$i_{x}=g_{m}v_{sg}+g_{mb}v_{sb}+g_{o}v_{sd}\n      =\\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{o}\\right)v_{x} \\tag*{}$$\n\n$$R_{X}\\equiv {{v_{x}}\\over {i_{x}}}={1\\over {g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{o}}}\n      \\approx {1\\over {g_{m}}}\\ll r_{o} \\tag{2}$$\n\n$g_{m}=k_{p}\\left(V_{X}-\\left|V_{T}\\right|\\right)$,\n$g_{o}= \\lambda I_{X}=r_{o}^{-1}$.\nWith the bulk tied to $D=G=0$, $V_{SB}=V_{X}$ and\n\n$$\\left|V_{T}\\right| =\\left|V_{T0}\\right|\n       +\\gamma \\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}+V_{X}}-\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}}\\right)$$\n\nso (1) is even more $V_{X}$ dependent.\n\nIn the ordinary language an {\\it ideal} current\nsource is a 2 terminal with $I_{X}\\ne f(V_{X})$ and\n$R_{X}\\to \\infty $.  In that sense (1)-(2) is {\\it\nnot} a current source at all, and in the $N$ MOS,\n$V_{T}>0$ normalisation it is the trivial $I_{X}=0$\ncurrent source.  It is normally said to be ''not a\nuseful current source''; at best a very poor\nsaturated load.  If you count $R_{X}=r_{o}$ as a\ncurrent source it is a current source of zero,\n$I_{DSS}$ for depletion, current.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} Interchanging $S$ and $D$ the\n> conventional $N$ MOS drain in the air does give\n> $R_{X}=r_{o}$ when forced into saturation, but\n> with $V_{GS}=0$ the enhancement device is off.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6e181f66e1630f79cdbaa0545b715316d7a9a84060d40814f510647cd1af850f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the drawn device as a PMOS with its source at the top and gate/drain grounded, and concludes it is not a useful current source because its input resistance is about 1/gm (with body effect included, even lower). The qualified mention of loose saturation-current-source terminology does not change its clear conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "20b0fcb71c5ac038622c26f3ac86aaf2af15f4064029312681192c8362271780",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 527,
        "output_tokens": 9119,
        "total_tokens": 9646,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7626,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 527,
        "output_tokens": 9119,
        "total_tokens": 9646,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7626,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-006-device-act-as-current-source",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "Can the device shown in the figure act as a current source?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-006-device-act-as-current-source/figure-03.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual somewhat sloppy 3 terminal symbol\nthe arrow is the source, Fig. 1 {\\it e. g.} for the $p$\nchannel\n\n$${\\bf S}\\equiv {\\rm arrow}\\;\\;D\\equiv {\\rm no\\; arrow}\\;\\;\nB\\equiv S\\tag{*}$$\n\nin the figure\n\n$${\\rm G}=0\\;\\;\\;{\\rm D}=0\\;\\;\\;{\\rm S}\\equiv {I_{x}}\n\\;\\;{\\rm B}\\equiv {\\rm S}\\;\\;{\\rm for\\; the\\;}p{\\rm -most}$$\n\nand vice versa for the $n$ most.\n\nIn either case ${I_{x}}$ is taken from the\nsource.  Up to the interchange $n\\leftrightarrow p$ that is\na grounded gate, grounded drain, source driven common\ngate stage.\n\nPut a ${\\rm d}{\\rm v}_{x}$ on the ${\\rm S}$ and put\n${\\rm v}_{g}=0$, ${\\rm v}_{d}=0$.  For definiteness the\n$p$ channel:\n\n$${\\rm v}_{sg}={\\rm v}_{s}-{\\rm v}_{g}={\\rm v}_{x}\\qquad\n  {\\rm v}_{sb}=0\\qquad {\\rm v}_{sd}={\\rm v}_{x}$$\n\n$${\\rm i}_{s}= {\\rm i}_{d} $$\n\nin saturation\n\n$${I_{D}}= {1\\over 2}k_{p}\\left({V_{SG}}-|{V_{Tp}}|\\right)^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda {V_{SD}}\\right]\\qquad {V_{SG}}={V_{S}}\\;,\\;\n{V_{SD}}={V_{S}} $$\n\n$${\\rm i}_{d}=g_{m}{\\rm v}_{sg}+g_{mb}{\\rm v}_{sb}+\ng_{{\\rm d}s}{\\rm v}_{sd}\\tag{1}$$\n\nso that with ${V_{SB}}=0$, ${\\rm v}_{sb}=0$,\n\n$${\\rm i}_{d}= \\left(g_{m}+g_{ds}\\right){\\rm v}_{x}\n\\qquad {\\rm with\\; body\\; effect\\;\\;}g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}\\tag{2}$$\n\nand ${\\rm i}_{x}$, the current that enters the\nsource, is ${\\rm i}_{d}$,\n\n$${\\rm i}_{x}= \\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}\\right){\\rm v}_{x}$$\n\n$${R_{x}\\equiv {{\\rm v}_{x}\\over {\\rm i}_{x}}={1\\over\ng_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\ll r_{0}\\tag{3}}$$\n\nand normally $r_{0}=1/g_{ds}\\gg 1/g_{m}$.\nE. {\\it g.} for the long channel $g_{ds}=0$,\n\n$$R_{x}=1/g_{m}\\;,\\;1/(g_{m}+g_{mb})$$\n\nwith body effect.\n\nThat is the conventional diode connected load, a\nsource follower load, of order ${10^{2}-10^{3}}\\Omega $.\nIt is not the $r_{0}\\sim {10^{4}-10^{6}}\\Omega $ high\nimpedance normally meant by a {\\it current source}.\nIn the saturated small signal sense the {\\it drain}\nis the high impedance,\n\n$${R_{d}}=r_{0}\\tag{4}$$\n\nbut ${I_{x}}$ is not taken from the drain.\n\nFor the conventional $n$ channel reading of the symbol\n${\\rm S}$ is the grounded end, ${\\rm D}$ is the ${I_{x}}$\nend, ${\\rm B}$ is grounded,\n\n$${\\rm G}=0\\;\\;{\\rm S}=0\\;\\;{\\rm B}=0\\;\\;{\\rm D}={V_{x}}$$\n\n$${V_{GS}}=0<{V_{Tn}}\\tag{5}$$\n\nthe device is nominally cut off\n\n$${I_{D}}=0\\tag{6}$$\n\nin saturation\n\n$${V_{DS}}={V_{x}}\\ge {V_{GS}}-{V_{Tn}}=-{V_{Tn}}$$\n\nso that for ${V_{x}}>0$ it is saturated but cut off.\nThe small signal impedance looking into the drain is\nindeed the usual\n\n$$R_{d}=r_{0}=1/\\lambda {I_{D}}\\to \\infty \\tag{7}$$\n\nbut with ${I_{D}}=0$.  There is no, process\nindependent, finite ${I_{D}}$ to be a source of.  For\n${V_{x}}<0$ it goes triode.  In no case is there a\nnormal, finite, saturated ${I_{D}}$ with $R_{d}=r_{0}$\navailable at the low impedance source terminal.\n\nIn the $p$ channel notation the device is on for\n\n$${V_{SG}}={V_{x}}>|{V_{Tp}}|,\\qquad {V_{SD}}={V_{x}}$$\n\nand (5) is satisfied in the form\n${V_{SD}}\\ge {V_{SG}}+{V_{Tp}}$, i. e. saturated, with\n\n$${I_{x}}={I_{D}}={1\\over 2}k_{p}\\left({V_{x}}-|{V_{Tp}}|\n\\right)^{2}\\left[1+\\lambda {V_{x}}\\right]\\tag{8}$$\n\nso that the {\\it DC} value of ${I_{x}}$ is not fixed by\nthe device, it is fixed by the external ${V_{x}}$,\nand the small signal impedance at the ${I_{x}}$ port is\nagain (3).\n\nPut normally: with the source tied to the supply,\n${\\rm S}\\to {V_{DD}}$ or ${V_{SS}}$, the gate biased at\nAC ground and the drain taken as the output the device\nis the conventional common gate current source of\n${R_{0}}=r_{0}$ , cascodable to $g_{m}r_{0}^{2}$ etc.\nAs drawn, with ${\\rm G}$ and ${\\rm D}$ at AC ground and\nthe output taken from the source, it is the conventional\n$1/g_{m}$ diode load.  With ${\\rm G}$ and ${\\rm S}$ at\nground it is cut off.  In neither case is it a useful,\nhigh impedance, well defined DC current source in the\nordinary sense.  If you want to call (3) a {\\it current\nsource} its Norton resistance is $1/g_{m}$ and, for the\n$n$ most, its Norton current is nominally zero.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  Up to $n\\leftrightarrow p$ the\n> conventional text book symbol has the arrow pointing {\\it\n> in} for $n$ and {\\it out} for $p$.  With that convention\n> Fig. 1 is an $n$ channel with ${\\rm D}$ on top, ${\\rm S}\n> \\equiv {\\rm B}$ on the bottom, ${V_{GS}}=0$, cut off.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "e416aa8137f93e6afdce36e641f331cdd4c776d2a03ddce8fe9cf5dc9dc277a8"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly explains that the source-input, diode-connected PMOS presents about 1/gm and is not a useful current source. But it later identifies the figure as an NMOS with the device cut off, contradicting the required PMOS identification and terminal reading; the golden solution caps this at 2.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "20b0fcb71c5ac038622c26f3ac86aaf2af15f4064029312681192c8362271780",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 483,
        "input_tokens": 527,
        "output_tokens": 8533,
        "total_tokens": 9060,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6799,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 483,
        "input_tokens": 527,
        "output_tokens": 8533,
        "total_tokens": 9060,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6799,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-006-device-act-as-current-source",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "Can the device shown in the figure act as a current source?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-006-device-act-as-current-source/figure-03.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the 3 terminal version the arrow is the\n${\\rm source+bulk}$ terminal. ${\\rm bulk}-{\\rm channel}$\nis $p-n$ for a $n{\\rm MOS}$ and $n-p$ for a $p{\\rm MOS}$.\nThe direction in the figure is $p\\to n$ to the\nchannel so that the $n$ bulk can be at $V_{X}>0$ and\nthe $p$ drain at $0$ with the junction reverse biased.\nIt is a $p$ device\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nS &\\equiv B\\equiv X\\cr\nD &\\equiv 0\\cr\nG &\\equiv 0}$$\n\nwith the conventional $p{\\rm MOS}$ positive\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{SG}&=V_{S}-V_{G}=V_{X}\\cr\nV_{SD}&=V_{S}-V_{D}=V_{X}}$$\n\nso that for $V_{X}<\\left|V_{Tp}\\right|$\n\n$$I_{X}=0\\qquad {\\rm cut\\,off}\\tag1$$\n\nand for $V_{X}>\\left|V_{Tp}\\right|$\n\n$$I_{D}=I_{X}= {k_{p}\\over 2}{\\left(V_{SG}\n-\\left|V_{Tp}\\right|\\right)^{2}}\\left(1+\\lambda V_{SD}\\right)$$\n\n$$I_{X}= {k_{p}\\over 2}{\\left(V_{X}\n-\\left|V_{Tp}\\right|\\right)^{2}}\\left(1+\\lambda V_{X}\\right)\n\\qquad V_{X}>\\left|V_{Tp}\\right| \\tag2$$\n\nin the normal ${\\rm SAT}$ law.\nIndeed the ${\\rm SAT}$ condition\n\n$$V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}+V_{Tp}=V_{SG}-\\left|V_{Tp}\\right|$$\n\nis\n\n$$V_{X}\\ge V_{X}-\\left|V_{Tp}\\right|$$\n\nidentically satisfied when the device is on.\nIt is on in saturation but\n\n* it is connected as a two terminal device $X-0$\n* $G$ is shorted to $D$.\n\nIt is the $p$ version of the so called\ndiode connected load. Shorting $G$ to $D$ makes\n$V_{SG}=V_{SD}$ and the device ceases to have\na separate, ${\\rm const.}$ $V_{SG}$ bias.\nPut $\\Delta V_{X}=v_{x}$, $\\Delta I_{X}=i_{x}$.\n\nFor the $p{\\rm MOS}$ in small signal\n\n$$i_{sd}=g_{m}v_{sg}+g_{mb}v_{sb}+g_{ds}v_{sd}$$\n\nwith $i_{sd}$ from $S$ to $D$. Here with the bulk\ntied to $S$\n\n$$v_{sb}=0,\\;\\;v_{sg}=v_{x},\\;\\;v_{sd}=v_{x}$$\n\nSo that, with $i_{x}=i_{sd}$ entering $S$,\n\n$$i_{x}= \\left(g_{m}+g_{ds}\\right)v_{x}+g_{mb}\\times 0$$\n\n$$R_{X}\\equiv {v_{x}\\over i_{x}}={1\\over g_{m}+g_{ds}}\n\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\tag3$$\n\nIf the $n$ well is returned to the highest\nsupply and not to $S$\n\n$$R_{X}={1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}}$$\n\nIn any case\n\n$$R_{X}\\sim g_{m}^{-1}\\ll r_{o}=g_{ds}^{-1}$$\n\nby a factor $g_{m}r_{o}\\approx 20-100$.\n\nAn ideal current source has\n\n$${\\partial I_{X}\\over \\partial V_{X}}=0\\qquad \nR_{X}\\to \\infty $$\n\nin small signal and $I_{X}\\ne f\\left(V_{X}\\right)$ in\nlarge signal. Here (2) is $\\propto V_{X}^{2}$ in\nlarge signal and (3) is a low, $\\sim 1{\\rm k}$,\nimpedance in small signal. The current follows the\nvoltage.\n\nIn normal language it is not a current source at\nall, it is a forward diode, a small active resistor,\nabout $1/g_{m}$, to ground. It is very often used as\nthe active load of a common source stage.\n\nWith the opposite convention for the arrow, it is\nan $n{\\rm MOS}$ with $D\\equiv X$, $S\\equiv G\\equiv 0$.\nThen\n\n$$V_{GS}=0<V_{Tn}$$\n\nand the conventional enhancement device is quite off,\n\n$$I_{X}\\approx I_{{\\rm leak}}\\approx 0$$\n\napart from sub threshold leakage. Its small signal\nimpedance is $r_{o}$ in parallel with the off\nchannel but with no dc bias current it is of no use\nas a bias current source. With a depletion\n$V_{Tn}<0$ device $V_{GS}=0$ can be $>V_{Tn}$ and the\ndevice can be made to pass\n\n$$I_{DSS}={k_{n}\\over 2}V_{Tn}^{2}$$\n\nin saturation with $R_{X}=r_{o}$ at the drain.\nThat is a very poor, $r_{o}$ and not cascoded, and\nnot tunable current source.\n\nFor a normal $V_{Tn}>0$ enhancement device to be a\ncurrent source you want\n\n* $S$ {\\it to the supply}, $D$ to the output node\n* $G$ to a fixed dc bias $V_{B}$ so $V_{GS}={\\rm const.}$\n* $D$ is the high impedance node, $R_{o}=r_{o}$,\n  $r_{o}{\\rm casc}$ if cascoded\n\nso that $I_{D}=f\\left(V_{GS}\\right)$ is essentially\nindependent of $V_{DS}$ for $V_{DS}>V_{GS}-V_{T}$\nin saturation. The circuit in the figure looks\ninto the $S$ with $G-D$ shorted, the reciprocal of\na current source.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "1c27912a4069fc22fbfb9ce0cd2c13969c70740d5a706055fc76e51274745a7b"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the device as a PMOS with source at X and gate and drain grounded, and explains that the diode connection presents a low small-signal resistance of about 1/gm, so it cannot act as a current source. The extra discussion does not undermine the conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "20b0fcb71c5ac038622c26f3ac86aaf2af15f4064029312681192c8362271780",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 483,
        "input_tokens": 527,
        "output_tokens": 10019,
        "total_tokens": 10546,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8458,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 483,
        "input_tokens": 527,
        "output_tokens": 10019,
        "total_tokens": 10546,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8458,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration/figure-04.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the $P$ complement of the $N$ MOS\n{\\it common source stage with series current feedback}\n{\\it source degeneration}. $V_{DD}$ is $AC$ ground.\n\nSmall signal $v_{dd}=0$, $v_{ss}=0$ so $R_{S}$ goes to\n$AC$ ground at top and $R_{D}$ to $AC$ ground at bottom.\n\n$$V_{in}=V_{G}\\;\\;\\;V_{out}=V_{D}=I_{D}R_{D}$$\n$$V_{S}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S}\\;\\;{\\rm so}\\;\\;V_{SG}=V_{S}-V_{G}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S}-V_{G}$$\n$$V_{SD}=V_{S}-V_{D}=V_{DD}-I_{D}(R_{S}+R_{D}) $$\n\n> Cut off: $V_{SG}< |V_{Tp}|$, $I_{D}=0$, $V_{out}=0$.\n\n> Saturation, square law to fix ideas :\n\n$$I_{D}={\\frac{1}{2}}k_{p}{\\frac{W}{L}}(V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{SD})$$\n\n$$ {\\rm saturation}\\;\\;V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$V_{S}-V_{D} \\ge V_{S}-V_{G}-|V_{Tp}|$$\n\n$$V_{D}\\le V_{G}+|V_{Tp}|=V_{G}-V_{Tp}\\;\\;V_{Tp}<0\\tag{1}$$\n\nat the operating point $Q$ with $I_{DQ}$.\n\n$$V_{SQ}=V_{DD}-I_{DQ}R_{S}$$\n$$V_{DQ}=I_{DQ}R_{D}=V_{outQ}$$\n\nmust satisfy (1). If $V_{G}$ is lowered $I_{D}\\uparrow $, $V_{out}\n\\uparrow $ so $V_{SD}\\downarrow $ and eventually\n\n$$V_{SD}< V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|$$\n\ntriode\n\n$$I_{D}=k_{p}{\\frac{W}{L}}\\left[(V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|)V_{SD}\n-{\\frac{1}{2}}V_{SD}^{2}\\right]$$\n\nFor $V_{G}\\to -\\infty $, $r_{on}\\to 0$\n\n$$V_{out,max}\\approx V_{DD}{\\frac{R_{D}}{R_{S}+R_{D}+r_{on}}}\n\\to V_{DD}{\\frac{R_{D}}{R_{S}+R_{D}}}$$\n\nThe DC voltage transfer is therefore inverting, $0$ for\n$V_{G}>V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$ rising with slope\n\n$${\\frac{dV_{out}}{dV_{G}}}<0$$\n\nto a low gain triode plateau.\n\nFor small signal about $Q$ put $VDD=0$ $AC$.\n\n$$M_{1}:g_{m}={\\frac{\\partial I_{D}}{\\partial V_{SG}}},\n\\;g_{mb}={\\frac{\\partial I_{D}}{\\partial V_{SB}}},\n\\;r_{o}=1/g_{ds}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$$\n\n$$v_{sg}=v_{s}-v_{g}=v_{s}-v_{in}\\qquad \nv_{sb}=v_{s}-v_{b}\\qquad v_{sd}=v_{s}-v_{d}=v_{s}-v_{out}$$\n\ncurrent from source to drain\n\n$$i_{sd}=g_{m}v_{sg}+g_{mb}v_{sb}+g_{ds}v_{sd} \\tag{2}$$\n\nwith the usual polarity $i_{sd}>0$ for $P$ MOS.\n\n```\n              0 AC\n              |\n              RS\n              |\n          s<--+--b  if b=s no gmb, if b=VDD vb=0\n              |  M1  gm vsg  , gds=1/ro\n          g---+\n          |   |\n          d---+\n              |\n              RD\n              |\n              0 AC\n              vout\n```\n\n$G$ draws no current so the $AC$ current in $R_{S}$ is\nthe current in $R_{D}$ is the transistor current.\n\n$$i_{Rs}= {\\frac{v_{s}}{R_{S}}}\\;\\;{\\rm leaving\\; }s{\\rm \\;node\n\\;to\\;ground}$$\n$$i_{Rd}= {\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D}}}\\;\\;{\\rm leaving\\; }d{\\rm \\;node\n\\;to\\;ground}$$\n\nKCL $s$: $v_{s}/R_{S}+i_{sd}=0$ so $i_{sd}=-v_{s}/R_{S}$\nKCL $d$: $i_{sd}=v_{out}/R_{D}$ for the circuit as drawn,\nwith no external test source.\n\nHence for the closed circuit\n\n$$-{\\frac{v_{s}}{R_{S}}}= {\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D}}}=i_{sd} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$$v_{s}=-i_{sd}R_{S}\\qquad v_{out}=i_{sd}R_{D}$$\n\nFrom (2)(3)\n\n$${\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D}}}=g_{m}(v_{s}-v_{in})+g_{mb}v_{sb}+\n{\\frac{v_{s}-v_{out}}{r_{o}}}$$\n\nPut $v_{s}=-v_{out}R_{S}/R_{D}$ :\n\n$${\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D}}}= -g_{m}v_{in}\n+v_{s}(g_{m}+g_{mb})+{\\frac{v_{s}-v_{out}}{r_{o}}}$$\n\n$${\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D}}}= -g_{m}v_{in}\n-{\\frac{v_{out}R_{S}}{R_{D}}}(g_{m}+g_{mb})\n-{\\frac{v_{out}(R_{S}/R_{D}+1)}{r_{o}}}$$\n\n$$v_{out}\\left[{\\frac{1}{R_{D}}}+{\\frac{R_{S}}{R_{D}}}\n(g_{m}+g_{mb})+{\\frac{1+R_{S}/R_{D}}{r_{o}}}\\right]=-g_{m}v_{in}$$\n\n$$\\;A_{v}={\\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}}}=-\n{\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+R_{S}(g_{m}+g_{mb})+(R_{S}+R_{D})/r_{o}}}\\;\n\\tag{4}$$\n\nSpecial cases:\n\n* $b$ tied to $s$, drawn arrow on source, $v_{sb}=0$, $g_{mb}=0$:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -{\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+g_{m}R_{S}+(R_{S}+R_{D})/r_{o}}}$$\n\n* $r_{o}\\to\\infty $: \n\n$$A_{v0}=-{\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}}}\n\\;\\xrightarrow{g_{mb}=0}\\;-{\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+g_{m}R_{S}}}\\tag{5}$$\n\n* $R_{S}=0$: $A_{v}=-g_{m}(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o})$, ordinary CS.\n\n* $g_{m}R_{S}\\gg 1$:\n\n$$A_{v}\\to -{\\frac{R_{D}}{R_{S}}}{\\frac{g_{m}}{g_{m}+g_{mb}}}\n\\to -{\\frac{R_{D}}{R_{S}}}$$\n\ndetermined by the resistor ratio. This is series\nfeedback: $R_{S}$ senses $i_{d}$ and feeds back a voltage\n$v_{s}=-i_{d}R_{S}$ in series with $v_{sg}$, linearising\nthe stage.\n\nEffective transconductance\n\n$$G_{m}={\\frac{i_{d}}{v_{in}}}= {\\frac{g_{m}}{1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}}}$$\n\nso $A_{v}=-G_{m}R_{D}$.\n\nInverting, $180^{0}$ phase.\n\n{\\it Input impedance:} Gate oxide\n\n$$Z_{in}=\\infty \\;\\;{\\rm low\\;frequency},\\;\\;\nC_{in}=C_{gs}+(1-G_{m}R_{D})C_{gd}\\;\\;{\\rm Miller}$$\n\n{\\it Output impedance:} Zero $v_{in}$, $v_{g}=0$, apply $v_{x}$\nat $d$ and measure $i_{x}$.\n\nWith $R_{D}$ removed, from $v_{s}/R_{S}+g_{m}v_{s}+g_{mb}v_{sb}+\n(v_{s}-v_{x})/r_{o}=0$\n\n$$R_{d}\\equiv {\\frac{v_{x}}{i_{x}}}\\Bigl|_{R_{D}\\to\\infty}\n =r_{o}+R_{S}\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}\\right]\\tag{6}$$\n\n$g_{mb}=0$ if $b=s$. For $r_{o}\\to\\infty$, $R_{d}\\to\\infty$,\nideal current source. \n\nFor the complete stage\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{d}\n =R_{D}\\parallel\\left\\{r_{o}+[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}]R_{S}\\right\\}\n \\approx R_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm if}\\;r_{o}{\\rm \\;large}\\tag{7}$$\n\nIf $r_{o}$ large the pole at the output is\n$\\omega_{p}\\approx 1/R_{out}C_{L}$, $C_{L}=C_{db}+C_{gd}+C_{load}$.\n\nIn words: common source with source degeneration.\n$R_{S}$ provides local series-series negative feedback.\nIt lowers the voltage gain from $-g_{m}R_{D}$ to\n$-g_{m}R_{D}/(1+g_{m}R_{S})$, raises the impedance looking\ninto the drain by $\\approx g_{m}r_{o}R_{S}$, improves\nlinearity, extends bandwidth, and makes the gain less\nsensitive to $g_{m}$, approaching $-R_{D}/R_{S}$, at the\nexpense of headroom $I_{DQ}(R_{S}+R_{D})$ and gain. Up to\nbody effect the formulas are unchanged except\n$g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$ if the $N$-well is tied to $V_{DD}$\ninstead of to the source.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6af7824faf08acec85175a0379d91b096af7f14d366f46613ce58a862b932eae"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the PMOS common-source stage with source degeneration and gives the inverting gain, including valid body-effect and output-resistance refinements.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "cd8fcec5f92210366117d02bce0f4174b55a012666155b3dfc965be2c669f3a3",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1475,
        "output_tokens": 11612,
        "total_tokens": 13087,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9231,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1475,
        "output_tokens": 11612,
        "total_tokens": 13087,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9231,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration/figure-04.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "That is a $p$ channel ${\\rm MOS}$\n{\\it common source} with {\\it un bypassed source\nresistance} $R_{S}$ and resistive load $R_{D}$\nto $AC$ ground. $+V_{DD}$ is $AC$ ground.\n\nFor the symbol drawn bulk $=S$, i. e. $V_{SB}=0$,\n$\\gamma =0$. If the $n$ well is returned to $V_{DD}$,\n$g_{mb}\\ne 0$ and\n\n$$V_{T}=V_{T0}+\\gamma \\left[\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{SB}}-\n\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}}\\right],\\qquad V_{SB}=V_{S}-V_{DD}>0\\;{\\rm dc}$$\n\nand $g_{mb}= \\gamma g_{m}/2\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{SB}}$ has\nto be carried along.\n\nPut $V_{thp}<0$, $|V_{T}|=-V_{T}$ for the $p$.\n$$|I_{D}| = I_{S}=I_{D}$$\n\nin the conventional positive direction $S\\to D\\to R_{D}\\to 0$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{S}&=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S} \\cr\nV_{D}&=V_{o}=I_{D}R_{D} \\cr\nV_{SG}&=V_{S}-V_{G}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S}-V_{I} \\cr\nV_{SD}&=V_{S}-V_{D}=V_{DD}-I_{D}(R_{S}+R_{D})}$$\n\n{\\it D.C. large signal:}\n\n* {\\bf Cut off:} $V_{SG}<|V_{T}|$\n\n$$I_{D}=0\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{o}=0$$\n$$V_{SG}=V_{DD}-V_{I}<|V_{T}|\\;:\\;V_{I}>V_{DD}-|V_{T}|$$\n\nupto $R_{S}$ drop at the edge.\n\n* {\\bf Saturation :} $|V_{SD}|\\ge |V_{SG}|-|V_{T}|$,\ni. e.\n\n$$V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}-|V_{T}|$$\n\n$$V_{S}-V_{D}\\ge V_{S}-V_{G}-|V_{T}|$$\n$$V_{D}\\le V_{G}+|V_{T}|\\;:\\;V_{o}\\le V_{I}+|V_{T}|$$\n\n$$|I_{D}| =\\tfrac12 \\mu_{p}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\n\\left(V_{SG}-|V_{T}|\\right)^{2}\\left(1+\\lambda V_{SD}\\right)\n\\tag{1}$$\n\nwith $V_{SG}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S}-V_{I}$. Eq.(1) is\nquadratic in $I_{D}$ for $\\lambda =0$.\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{I}=|V_{T}|+\\sqrt{\\frac{2I_{D}}{\\mu_{p}C_{ox}W/L}}\n+I_{D}R_{S}$$\n\n* {\\bf Triode:} $V_{SD}<V_{SG}-|V_{T}|$, $V_{o}>\nV_{I}+|V_{T}|$\n\n$$|I_{D}| =\\mu_{p}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\\left[\n\\left(V_{SG}-|V_{T}|\\right)V_{SD}-\\tfrac12 V_{SD}^{2}\\right]\n\\left(1+\\lambda V_{SD}\\right)$$\n\nIn normal bias $V_{o}$ is in saturation,\n$V_{o}<V_{I}+|V_{T}|$. As $V_{I}$ is lowered\n$V_{SG}$ grows, $I_{D}$ grows, $V_{o}=I_{D}R_{D}$\nrises and the device is driven towards triode\nfor large $I_{D}R_{D}$.\n\nThe useful $VTC$ is inverter like, $V_{o}\\approx 0$\nfor $V_{I}$ high, rising with slope $<0$ when the\ndevice turns on, compressed by the $I_{D}R_{S}$ drop.\n\n$$P_{DC}=V_{DD}I_{D}$$\n\n$$g_{m}= \\left.\\frac{\\partial I_{D}}{\\partial V_{SG}}\n\\right|_{Q}= \\mu_{p}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\n\\left(V_{SG}-|V_{T}|\\right)\\left(1+\\lambda V_{SD}\\right)\n\\approx \\sqrt{2\\mu_{p}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}I_{D}}$$\n\n$$r_{o}=1/g_{ds}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$$\n\n{\\it Small signal $AC$:}\n\n$V_{DD}=0$ AC. Gate $v_{i}$, source $v_{s}$,\ndrain $v_{o}$.\n\n$$v_{sg}=v_{s}-v_{i}\\qquad v_{sd}=v_{s}-v_{o}\\qquad\nv_{sb}=v_{s}-v_{b}$$\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{sg}+g_{mb}v_{sb}+g_{ds}v_{sd}$$\n\nFor the symbol $v_{b}=v_{s}\\;,\\;g_{mb}=0$.\nFor well to $V_{DD}$, $v_{b}=0$, $v_{sb}=v_{s}$.\n\n$$v_{s}= -i_{d}R_{S}\\tag{2}$$\n$$v_{o}= i_{d}R_{D}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$R_{D}$ to $AC$ ground, $R_{S}$ to $AC$ ground.\nSo $R_{S}$ is source degeneration, $R_{D}$ is the load.\n\nFrom (2)-(3):\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}(v_{s}-v_{i})+g_{mb}v_{s}+g_{ds}(v_{s}-v_{o})$$\n\n$$i_{d}= -\\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}\\right)i_{d}R_{S}\n-g_{m}v_{i}-g_{ds}i_{d}R_{D}$$\n\n$$i_{d}\\left[ 1+\\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}\\right)R_{S}+g_{ds}R_{D}\n\\right]=-g_{m}v_{i}$$\n\n> $$A_{v}\\equiv \\frac{v_{o}}{v_{i}}=\n> -\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}+g_{ds}(R_{S}+R_{D})}\\tag{4}$$\n\nFor bulk $=S$, $g_{mb}=0$:\n\n> $$A_{v}= -\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+g_{m}R_{S}+(R_{S}+R_{D})/r_{o}}\n> =-\\frac{g_{m}r_{o}R_{D}}{r_{o}+R_{S}+R_{D}+g_{m}r_{o}R_{S}}$$\n\nIn the usual $r_{o}\\gg R_{S},R_{D}$:\n\n> $$A_{v}\\approx -\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+g_{m}R_{S}}\n> =-\\frac{R_{D}}{R_{S}+1/g_{m}} \\tag{5}$$\n\nInverting amplifier. Without degeneration $R_{S}=0$:\n\n$$A_{v0}=-g_{m}(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o})\\approx -g_{m}R_{D}$$\n\nfor $r_{o}\\to\\infty$.\n\nStrong degeneration $g_{m}R_{S}\\gg 1$:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -R_{D}/R_{S}$$\n\nset by resistance ratio, linearised by negative\nseries feedback. $R_{S}$ stabilises $Q$\npoint at the price of gain, improves linearity,\nreduces distortion and increases bandwidth.\n\nIncluding $r_{o}$ the more common form of (5) is\n\n$$A_{v}= -\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+g_{m}R_{S}}\\;\n\\frac{1}{1+\\dfrac{R_{S}+R_{D}}{r_{o}(1+g_{m}R_{S})}}$$\n\n{\\it Terminal resistances, low frequency:}\n\n$$R_{in}=R_{G}\\approx \\infty \\;{\\rm for\\;MOS\\;gate}$$\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)=1/sC_{g}\\;\\;{\\rm at\\;high\\;frequency}$$\n\nLooking into the drain with $v_{i}=0$:\n\n$$R_{d}=r_{o}+\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}\\right]R_{S}\n\\approx r_{o}\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}\\right]$$\n\nSource degeneration boosts the impedance seen at the\ndrain by $\\approx g_{m}R_{S}$.\n\nAt the output node\n\n> $$R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{d}\n> =R_{D}\\parallel \\left\\{r_{o}+[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}]R_{S}\\right\\}\n> \\approx R_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm if}\\;R_{D}\\ll R_{d} \\tag{6}$$\n\nIf $R_{D}\\gg r_{o}$, $R_{out}\\approx R_{d}$.\n\nWith a capacitive load $C_{L}$ the dominant pole is\n\n$$\\omega_{p o}\\approx 1/R_{out}C_{L}\\qquad\n  \\omega_{p s}\\approx \\frac{1+g_{m}R_{S}}{R_{S}C_{s}}$$\n\nwhere $C_{s}$ is the capacitance at the source node.\nThe un-bypassed $R_{S}$ gives a zero/pole doublet.\n\nIf $R_{S}$ is bypassed by $C_{S}$, $R_{S}$ disappears\nfor $ \\omega \\gg 1/R_{S}C_{S}$ and $A_{v}\\to -g_{m}\n(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o})$.\n\nIn short: single-stage, inverting, $g_{m}R_{D}$ class\namplifier with series feedback $R_{S}$. Voltage gain\nnegative, magnitude $ \\sim g_{m}R_{D}/(1+g_{m}R_{S})$,\ncurrent gain $\\approx 0$, power gain $\\approx |A_{v}|$,\nhigh $R_{in}$, $R_{out}\\approx R_{D}$, good for\nlevel shifting, resistive load driver, with the\nusual $PMOS$ $\\approx 2$--$3\\times$ lower $g_{m}$ than\n$NMOS$ for same size.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "52eb13af567fc87bc27236bf5be97051747b6d726e4d4651c68abc6e4ea67d6e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the PMOS common-source stage with source degeneration and derives the inverting gain, including appropriate refinements for body effect and finite output resistance.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "cd8fcec5f92210366117d02bce0f4174b55a012666155b3dfc965be2c669f3a3",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1475,
        "output_tokens": 6412,
        "total_tokens": 7887,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3906,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1475,
        "output_tokens": 6412,
        "total_tokens": 7887,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3906,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-007-pmos-common-source-source-degeneration/figure-04.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a ${\\rm P}$ channel, common\nsource with series feedback $:R_{S}$ i.e.\nsource degenerated ${\\rm C.S.}$ with resistive\nload. $V_{DD} = AC$ ground.\n\n$$M_{1} : {\\rm S\\;top,\\;D\\;bottom,\\;G}=V_{in}$$\n\n$${\\rm S}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S}\\qquad D\\equiv V_{out}=I_{D}R_{D}$$\n$${\\rm S-D\\;\\;voltage\\;\\;} V_{SD}=V_{S}-V_{out}=V_{DD}\n-I_{D}\\left(R_{S}+R_{D}\\right)$$\n\n$${\\rm S-G\\;\\;voltage\\;\\;} V_{SG}=V_{S}-V_{in}\n=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S}-V_{in}$$\n\n> If $R_{S}=0$ it is the conventional resistively loaded\n> ${\\rm C.S.}$ inverter/amplifier with\n> voltage gain $-g_{m}R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$ and\n> $180^{0}$ phase shift. $R_{S}$ is series-series\n> feedback.\n\n\\subsection*{1. DC - large signal}\n\nWith normal polarities $V_{th,p}<0$, $|V_{th,p}|=-V_{th,p}$\n\n* {\\it Cut off} $V_{SG}<|V_{th,p}|$\n\n$$V_{in}>V_{S}-|V_{th,p}| \\approx V_{DD}-|V_{th,p}|$$\n$$I_{D}=0\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{out}=0$$\n\n* {\\it Saturation} $V_{SG}>|V_{th,p}| ,\\;V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}-|V_{th,p}|$\n\n$$I_{D}=k_{p}(V_{SG}-|V_{th,p}|)^{2}\\left(1+\\lambda_{p}V_{SD}\\right)$$\n$$k_{p}=\\frac12\\mu_{p}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}$$\n\nso with $\\lambda =0$:\n\n$$I_{D}=k_{p}\\left(V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S}-V_{in}-|V_{th,p}|\\right)^{2}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$V_{out}=I_{D}R_{D} \\tag{2}$$\n\n(1) is quadratic in $I_{D}$. It is made more linear\nand less $k_{p}$ sensitive by the $I_{D}R_{S}$ term.\n\nSaturation is maintained for\n\n$$V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}-|V_{th,p}|$$\n$$V_{DD}-I_{D}(R_{S}+R_{D})\\ge V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S}-V_{in}-|V_{th,p}|$$\n$$V_{in}\\ge I_{D}R_{D}-|V_{th,p}| =V_{out}-|V_{th,p}|$$\n\n* {\\it Triode} $V_{SD}<V_{SG}-|V_{th,p}|$\n\n$$I_{D}=2k_{p}\\left[(V_{SG}-|V_{th,p}|)V_{SD}-\\tfrac12V_{SD}^{2}\\right]$$\n\nFor very low $V_{in}$ the device is a small\n$r_{on}=1/[2k_{p}(V_{SG}-|V_{th,p}|)]$ to $V_{DD}$\n\n$$I_{D}\\approx \\frac{V_{DD}}{R_{S}+R_{D}+r_{on}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\nV_{out}\\approx V_{DD}\\frac{R_{D}}{R_{S}+R_{D}+r_{on}} \\rightarrow\nV_{DD}\\frac{R_{D}}{R_{S}+R_{D}}$$\n\nSo the large signal $V_{out}-V_{in}$ is $0$\nfor $V_{in}$ high, rising $\\propto (V_{DD}-V_{in}-|V_{th}|)^{2}$\nin saturation and flattening in triode.\n\n$$V_{out}\\approx R_{D}k_{p}\\left(V_{DD}-V_{in}-|V_{th,p}|\\right)^{2}\n\\;{\\rm for}\\;g_{m}R_{S}\\ll 1$$\n\nand with degeneration much more linear.\n\nHeadroom cost: $I_{D}R_{S}$ is lost from the available\n$V_{SD}$ swing.\n\n\\subsection*{2. Small signal}\n\nGate $Z_{in}= \\infty $ at low frequency, $C_{gs},C_{gd}$\nat high frequency.\n\n$$g_{m}= \\left.\\frac{\\partial I_{D}}{\\partial V_{SG}}\\right|\n_{Q}=2\\sqrt{k_{p}I_{DQ}}= \\frac{2I_{DQ}}{V_{SGQ}-|V_{th}|}$$\n$$r_{o}=1/\\lambda_{p}I_{DQ}\\;\\;,\\;\\;g_{mb}= \\eta g_{m}$$\n$\\eta \\approx 0.1-0.3$ if body to $V_{DD}$, $0$ if\nbody tied to ${\\rm S}$.\n\nAC ground $V_{DD}=0$. \n\n$$\\begin{aligned}\nv_{sg} &= v_{s}-v_{in} \\\\\nv_{sd} &= v_{s}-v_{out} \\\\\ni_{d} &= g_{m}v_{sg}+g_{mb}v_{sb}+ \\frac{v_{sd}}{r_{o}} \n\\end{aligned}$$\n\nWith body to $V_{DD}$, $v_{sb}=v_{s}-0=v_{s}$.\nWith body to ${\\rm S}$, $g_{mb}=0$.\n\nResistor constraints AC:\n\n$$v_{s}= -i_{d}R_{S}\\qquad v_{out}= i_{d}R_{D}$$\n\nHence\n\n$$i_{d}= g_{m}(v_{s}-v_{in})+g_{mb}v_{s}+ \\frac{v_{s}-v_{out}}{r_{o}}$$\n$$i_{d}\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}+\\frac{R_{S}}{r_{o}}\\right]\n+\\frac{v_{out}}{r_{o}}=-g_{m}v_{in}$$\n\nWith $v_{out}=i_{d}R_{D}$:\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}}=\n-\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}r_{o}}{r_{o}\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}\\right]\n+R_{S}+R_{D}} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${\\rm Commonly\\; }A_{v}= -\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}\n{1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}+ \\dfrac{R_{S}+R_{D}}{r_{o}}}$$\n\n* Body to source: $g_{mb}=0$\n\n$$A_{v}= -\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+g_{m}R_{S}+ (R_{S}+R_{D})/r_{o}}$$\n\n* $r_{o}\\rightarrow \\infty $:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}}\n\\approx -\\frac{R_{D}}{R_{S}}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;g_{m}R_{S}\\gg 1$$\n\n* No degeneration $R_{S}\\rightarrow 0$:\n\n$$A_{v0}= -g_{m}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\right)\n\\approx -g_{m}R_{D}$$\n\ninverting. $R_{S}$ trades gain for:\n\n* linearisation, reduction of distortion $\\propto 1/(1+g_{m}R_{S})$\n* desensitisation to $g_{m},\\,k_{p}$\n* larger input linear range $\\Delta V_{in}\\approx I_{D}R_{S}$\n* higher output resistance and bandwidth $f_{-3dB}\\approx 1/R_{out}C_{L}$\n\nThe source degeneration can be by-passed with $C_{S}$ for\nAC: $R_{S}(AC)=R_{S}\\parallel 1/sC_{S}$ so DC stability\nis kept and AC gain $A_{v0}$ is recovered for $f\\gg 1/R_{S}C_{S}$.\n\n\\subsection*{3. Output and input impedance}\n\n$$Z_{in}=1/sC_{g}\\rightarrow \\infty \\;{\\rm LF}$$\n\nLooking into the drain with $v_{in}=0$ the impedance\nseen is the well known common gate with source resistance:\n\n$$R_{d}= r_{o}+\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}\\right]R_{S}\n\\approx \\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}\\right]r_{o}$$\n\nAt the output node\n\n$$R_{out}= R_{D}\\parallel R_{d}= R_{D}\\parallel\n\\left\\{r_{o}+[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}]R_{S}\\right\\} $$\n\n$$\\approx R_{D}\\parallel [1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}]r_{o}$$\n\nFor $R_{S}=0$, $R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$.\n\nSimilarly impedance looking into the source with drain\nload $R_{D}$ is $\\approx (R_{D}+r_{o})/(1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o})$.\n\nAt high frequency $C_{gs},C_{gd},C_{db},C_{sb}$ create\na dominant pole at the output $\\omega_{p1}\\approx 1/R_{out}C_{L}$\nand a pole/zero at the source $\\omega_{p2}\\approx (1+g_{m}R_{S})/R_{S}C_{s}$.\n\nIn feedback terms $R_{S}$ samples the current and feeds\nback a voltage $i_{d}R_{S}$ in series with $v_{in}$.\n\n> Bias $I_{D}$ chosen to give required $g_{m}$, swing\n> $I_{D}R_{D}<V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{S}-V_{DSsat}$ and power\n> $P=V_{DD}I_{D}$.\n\nIf you give $W/L,\\;V_{DD},\\;R_{S},R_{D},\\;V_{th},\\;k_{p},\\;\\lambda$\n(3) can be evaluated numerically. E.g. $g_{m}=1\\,{\\rm mS}$,\n$R_{D}=5\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$, $R_{S}=0.5\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$,\n$r_{o}\\gg R_{D}$: $A_{v0}\\approx -5$, $A_{v}\\approx\n-5/(1+0.5)=-3.3$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a6a0a47f039791d4feff11fe78133aaf8b4522536445306c1f02bb1f43b1863e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies a PMOS common-source stage with source degeneration and derives the inverting gain, including valid body-effect and finite-output-resistance refinements.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "cd8fcec5f92210366117d02bce0f4174b55a012666155b3dfc965be2c669f3a3",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1475,
        "output_tokens": 7325,
        "total_tokens": 8800,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4780,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1475,
        "output_tokens": 7325,
        "total_tokens": 8800,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4780,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-008-source-follower",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-008-source-follower/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a **NMOS Common Drain / Source Follower**. \n$100\\%$ voltage series feedback amplifier, Gain $<1$ but used as a `Voltage Buffer`.\n\n> Drain is at AC ground $V_{DD}$, Gate is input, Source is output. \n> $V_{out}$ *follows* $V_{in}$ with a DC level shift $V_{GS}$.\n\n### 1. Large Signal Operation\n\n$$V_{GS} = V_{in} - V_{out}$$\n$$V_{DS} = V_{DD} - V_{out}$$\n$$I_D = I_{R_S} = \\frac{V_{out}}{R_S}$$\n\nFor $N$-MOS enhancement in Saturation, $\\lambda = 0$:\n\n$$I_D = \\frac{1}{2}k_n (V_{GS}-V_{TH})^{2} = \\frac{k_n}{2}(V_{in}-V_{out}-V_{TH})^{2}$$\n\nwhere $k_n = \\mu_n C_{ox} W/L$.\n\nSo:\n$$ \\frac{V_{out}}{R_S} = \\frac{k_n}{2}(V_{in}-V_{out}-V_{TH})^{2} $$\n\n**Voltage Transfer Characteristic:**\n\n* $V_{in} < V_{TH}$ : $M_1$ OFF, $I_D = 0$, $V_{out}=0$\n* $V_{TH} < V_{in} < V_{DD}+V_{TH}$ : $M_1$ in Saturation, $V_{out} = V_{in} - V_{GS} \\approx V_{in} - V_{TH} - \\sqrt{2I_D/k_n}$\n\nSaturation condition: $V_{DS} \\ge V_{GS}-V_{TH}$\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{out} \\ge V_{in}-V_{out}-V_{TH} \\implies V_{in} \\le V_{DD}+V_{TH}$$\n\nSo for all practical $V_{in} < V_{DD}$ it is in saturation. It enters triode only for $V_{in} > V_{DD}+V_{TH}$.\n\nIf the bulk is to GND, not to source as drawn, there is **Body Effect**:\n$$V_{TH} = V_{TH0} + \\gamma \\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi_F + V_{SB}}-\\sqrt{2\\phi_F}\\right)$$\nwith $V_{SB}=V_{S}-V_{B}=V_{out}-0 = V_{out}$. So $V_{TH}$ increases with $V_{out}$ causing more non-linearity. If bulk is tied to source as the symbol suggests, $V_{SB}=0$ and $V_{TH}=V_{TH0}$.\n\nSwing is limited to: $0 < V_{out} < V_{DD} - V_{DS,sat}$\n\n### 2. Small Signal Model\n\nGate draws no current. At the output node:\n\n$$g_m v_{gs} + g_{mb}v_{bs} + g_{ds}v_{ds} = \\frac{v_{out}}{R_S}$$\n\nwith $v_{gs}= v_{in}-v_{out}$, $v_{bs} = -v_{out}$ if bulk to GND, $0$ if bulk to source, $v_{ds}= -v_{out}$.\n\nLet $r_o = 1/g_{ds}=1/\\lambda I_D$.\n\n**Ideal - No body effect, $r_o \\to \\infty$:**\n\nSmall signal equivalent: $g_m(v_{in}-v_{out}) = v_{out}/R_S$\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_m R_S}{1+g_m R_S}$$\n\n$$g_m = k_n(V_{GS}-V_{TH}) = \\sqrt{2k_n I_D}$$\n\nIf $g_m R_S \\gg 1$, $A_v \\to 1$. Typically $0.7 - 0.95$.\n\nInput resistance: $R_{in} = \\infty$ ideal, in practice $R_{G} \\parallel 1/sC_{gs}$\n\nOutput resistance: Short $v_{in}=0$, apply $v_x$ at output:\n\n$$R_{out} = \\frac{1}{g_m} \\parallel R_S \\approx \\frac{1}{g_m} \\text{ for } R_S \\gg 1/g_m$$\n\n**With Body Effect and $r_o$:**\n\n$$A_v = \\frac{g_m (r_o \\parallel R_S)}{1+(g_m+g_{mb}) (r_o \\parallel R_S)}$$\n\n$$R_{out} = \\frac{1}{g_m+g_{mb}+g_{ds}} \\parallel R_S = \\left(\\frac{1}{g_m+g_{mb}}\\parallel r_o \\right) \\parallel R_S$$\n\n$$g_{mb} = \\chi g_m = \\frac{\\gamma g_m}{2\\sqrt{2\\phi_F+V_{SB}}}$$\n\nBody effect **lowers gain and lowers $R_{out}$ only slightly**, but it is usually detrimental to gain:\n\n$$A_v \\approx \\frac{g_m}{g_m+g_{mb}} = \\frac{1}{1+\\chi} < 1$$ even for $R_S \\to \\infty$.\n\n**Typical values:** $g_m = 1-10 mS$, $R_S= 1-10k\\Omega$ => $R_{out}= 100-1000 \\Omega$, very low compared to common source.\n\nPhase is $0^{\\circ}$, non-inverting.\n\n### 3. Properties Summary\n\n| Parameter | Expression (no body, $r_o=\\infty$) | With body, $r_o$ |\n| :--- | :--- | :--- |\n| **Type** | Common Drain, Class A | |\n| **$A_v$** | $g_mR_S/(1+g_mR_S) < 1$ | $g_m(r_o\\parallel R_S)/[1+(g_m+g_{mb})(r_o\\parallel R_S)]$ |\n| **$R_{in}$** | $\\infty$ | $\\infty$ |\n| **$R_{out}$** | $(1/g_m)\\parallel R_S$ | $1/(g_m+g_{mb}+g_{ds})\\parallel R_S$ |\n| **$A_i$** | Large, $ \\approx g_m R_S $ | |\n\n### 4. What is it used for?\n\n* **Impedance transformer / Buffer:** High $R_{in}$, Low $R_{out}$ can drive low impedance loads / large capacitive loads without loading the previous stage.\n* **Level shifter:** $V_{out} = V_{in} - V_{GS}$\n* **Output stage** of op-amps, source follower.\n\nIt provides **no voltage gain**, but **current and power gain**.\n\n**Limitations:**\n\n1. DC level shift of $\\approx V_{TH}+V_{ov}$\n2. Cannot pull down fast - pull down limited by $R_S$. Sinking current is limited. Push-pull complementary follower is used to fix this.\n3. Strong body effect if in n-well / p-sub process and bulk grounded.\n4. Gain never exceeds 1. Replacing $R_S$ with an ideal current source $I_{SS}$ gives $R_S \\to r_{o,current}$ and $A_v \\to g_m/(g_m+g_{mb}+g_{ds}) \\approx 0.9-0.99$ and $R_{out} \\approx 1/(g_m+g_{mb})$.\n\n> In feedback terms, it is $100\\%$ voltage-series feedback, which is why distortion is low, bandwidth is wide and $R_{out}$ is divided by $1+loop\\_gain$.\n\nIf you give me $V_{DD}, R_S, W/L, k_n, V_{TH0}, \\gamma$, I can calculate the exact Q-point, $g_m$, $A_v$ and $R_{out}$ for you.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bff8f76bacb569ab5853e2d48615b6b21402aee5ad769804e6ae73929e54346d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source follower and gives its positive, less-than-unity gain as gmRs/(1 + gmRs), satisfying the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8f23ff232475a4bec79b12629414fe11fc7b9c6e9609b2ebcfc0e4ed2a0839d7",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 3892,
        "total_tokens": 5150,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2091,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 3892,
        "total_tokens": 5150,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2091,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-008-source-follower",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-008-source-follower/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the {\\it Common Drain} or {\\it Source\nFollower} stage, the MOS analog of the\nemitter/collector follower. $100\\%$ voltage\nseries feedback.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nD &\\to V_{DD}, {\\rm AC\\; ground} \\cr\nG &\\to V_{in} \\cr\nS &\\to V_{out}\\to R_{S}\\to GND}$$\n\n$R_{S}$ is the bias load, in practice often a\ncurrent source $I_{SS}$. In the symbol drawn\nthe $n$-bulk is strapped to the source, $V_{BS}=0$,\nno back gate effect. In normal bulk CMOS $V_{B}=0$\nand $g_{mb}\\ne 0$.\n\n### 1. Large signal - DC\n\n$$V_{OUT}=I_{D}R_{S}$$\n$$V_{GS}=V_{IN}-V_{OUT}$$\n\nFor $M_{1}$ off, $V_{IN}<V_{TH}$: $I_{D}=0$, $V_{OUT}=0$.\n\nFor $M_{1}$ saturated in strong inversion, ignoring\n$\\lambda $:\n\n$$I_{D}= {k_{n}\\over 2}\\left(V_{GS}-V_{TH}\\right)^{2}\n      ={k_{n}\\over 2}\\left(V_{IN}-V_{OUT}-V_{TH}\\right)^{2}\n       ={V_{OUT}\\over R_{S}} \\tag{1}$$\n\n$$k_{n}= \\mu_{n}C_{ox}W/L$$\n\nQuiescent point $Q$ for a DC bias $V_{IN}=V_{BIAS}$ is\nsolution of (1). In saturation:\n\n$$V_{DS}=V_{DD}-V_{OUT}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{TH}=V_{IN}-V_{OUT}-V_{TH}$$\n\n$$V_{IN}\\le V_{DD}+V_{TH}$$\n\nalways satisfied for $V_{IN}\\le V_{DD}$, so saturation\ncan be maintained over the whole useful swing until\ncut-off at low $V_{IN}$. In triode for very large $V_{IN}$:\n\n$$I_{D}=k_{n}\\left[(V_{GS}-V_{TH})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}/2\\right]$$\n\nHence $DC$ level shift:\n\n$$V_{OUT}=V_{IN}-V_{GS}(I_{D})\\approx V_{IN}-V_{TH}\n        -\\sqrt{2I_{D}/k_{n}}$$\n\nNon linear follower with $\\approx 0.3-0.8{\\rm V}$ shift.\n\nLimits:\n\n* $V_{OUT,max}\\approx V_{DD}-V_{DS,sat}\\approx V_{DD}-0.2{\\rm V}$\nclipped when $M_{1}$ goes deep triode, $R_{S}$ cannot pull up.\n* $V_{OUT,min}\\approx 0$ clipped when $M_{1}$ cuts off, \n$R_{S}$ pulls to ground with $R_{S}C_{L}$ time constant.\nNo negative swing without negative supply.\n\n### 2. Small signal\n\nHybrid $\\pi$ at $Q$: $v_{gs}=v_{g}-v_{s}=v_{in}-v_{out}$\n\n$$g_{m}= {\\partial I_{D}\\over \\partial V_{GS}}=\n\\sqrt{2k_{n}I_{D}}={2I_{D}\\over V_{GS}-V_{TH}}$$\n\n$$g_{mb}= \\eta g_{m}, \\qquad \\eta \\approx 0.1-0.3$$\n$$r_{o}=1/g_{ds}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$$\n\n$$ \n\\begin{array}{c}\ng \\;\\; o\\;  -v_{gs}-+s\\\\\n \\;\\;\\;|\\; \\\\ \n  g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}\n\\end{array}\n$$\n\nWith bulk to source $v_{bs}=0,\\;g_{mb}=0$.\nWith bulk to GND $v_{bs}= -v_{out}$.\n\nKCL at output node:\n\n$$(g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds})+{v_{out}\\over R_{S}}=0$$\n\n$$v_{ds}= -v_{out}\\;\\;{\\rm drain\\; AC\\; ground}$$\n\n#### Voltage gain\n\nIdeal $r_{o}\\to\\infty $, bulk to source:\n\n$$v_{out}=g_{m}v_{gs}R_{S}=g_{m}(v_{in}-v_{out})R_{S}$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}={g_{m}R_{S}\\over 1+g_{m}R_{S}}\n      ={1\\over 1+1/g_{m}R_{S}}<1\\tag{2}$$\n\nIn general:\n\n$$A_{v}= {g_{m}R_{S}^{\\prime}\\over 1+(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds})R_{S}^{\\prime}}$$\n\n$$R_{S}^{\\prime}=R_{S}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx R_{S}\\parallel 1/g_{ds}$$\n\ni.e.\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx {g_{m}\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}+R_{S}^{-1}}$$\n\nIf $g_{m}R_{S}^{\\prime}\\gg 1$,\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx {1\\over 1+(g_{mb}/g_{m})}\\approx 0.8-1.0$$\n\nTypical $0.85$ with body effect, $0.95-0.99$ without.\nWith active load $R_{S}\\to r_{o2}$, $A_{v}=g_{m1}/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\n+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2})\\to \\approx 1$.\n\n* No phase inversion, follower action.\n* $100\\%$ feedback makes it very linear for small signals.\n* Distortion for large $v_{in}$ is $g_{m}$ modulation.\n\n#### Input impedance\n\nGate draws no DC current:\n\n$$Z_{in}= {v_{in}\\over i_{g}} =\\infty \\;\\; {\\rm ideal}$$\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)= {1\\over sC_{gs}+sC_{gd}}\\;\\;{\\rm at\\; high\\; f}$$\n\nNormally $>{\\rm M\\Omega}$, capacitive $\\sim$ fF-pF.\nWith bias resistor $R_{G}$ to set $V_{BIAS}$, $R_{in}=R_{G}$.\n\n#### Output impedance\n\nPut $v_{in}=0$, apply $v_{x}$ at source, measure $i_{x}$.\n\n$$v_{gs}= -v_{x},\\;v_{bs}= -v_{x}\\;{\\rm if\\; bulk\\; to\\; GND}$$\n\n$$i_{x}= {v_{x}\\over R_{S}}+{v_{x}\\over r_{o}}+(g_{m}+g_{mb})v_{x}$$\n\n$$R_{out}= {v_{x}\\over i_{x}}={1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}}\\parallel R_{S}\n        \\approx {1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}}\\parallel R_{S}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$${\\rm For\\;}g_{mb}=0:\\;R_{out}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\parallel r_{o}\\parallel R_{S}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}$$\n\nTypically $20-200\\,\\Omega$, very low. That is the whole point.\nOutput impedance is low, capable of driving capacitive/resistive\nloads with current gain\n\n$$A_{i}\\approx g_{m}R_{S}\\gg 1$$\n\nVoltage gain $\\approx 1$ but power gain $\\gg 1$.\n\nWith source resistance $R_{sig}$ driving the gate:\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{S}\\parallel r_{o}\\parallel \\left[{1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}}+{R_{sig}\\over 1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}}\\right]\\approx R_{S}\\parallel {1\\over g_{m}}$$\n\nfor $R_{sig}=0$.\n\n### 3. Properties and use\n\n* Voltage buffer / impedance transformer: high $Z_{in}$, low $Z_{out}$\n* Level shifter $V_{OUT}=V_{IN}-V_{GS}$\n* No voltage amplification, but current and power amplification.\n* Very wide bandwidth: dominant pole at output\n\n$$\\omega_{p,out}\\approx {1\\over R_{out}C_{L}}={g_{m}\\over C_{L}}$$\n\nMiller multiplication of $C_{gd}$ is $1-A_{v}\\approx 0$, so input\npole $\\approx 1/R_{sig}C_{gd}$ is high.\n\n* Feedback makes $THD$ low and $PSRR$ good if $V_{DD}$ is clean, drain is AC ground.\n\n> Replacing $R_{S}$ by a bias current source $I_{SS}$ with\n> impedance $r_{o2}\\gg R_{S}$ gives $A_{v}\\to 1$ more closely,\n> $R_{out}=1/(g_{m}+g_{mb})\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$ and allows\n> DC coupling. The PMOS follower with $n$-well process can have\n> bulk tied to source free of body effect and is often preferred.\n\nIn short, to first order:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx \\dfrac{g_{m}R_{S}}{1+g_{m}R_{S}}\\to 1,\\quad\n  R_{in}\\to\\infty,\\quad R_{out}\\to 1/g_{m}\\parallel R_{S}$$\n\nwith zero phase shift, used as a unity gain buffer that can source\nlarge current into a low impedance load.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "aeaa494b5890d07933cbfe62d6bb2be1ddb7b66eccb488b3ac3d71b7646a7a84"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source follower and gives its positive, less-than-unity gain as gmRS/(1 + gmRS), satisfying the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8f23ff232475a4bec79b12629414fe11fc7b9c6e9609b2ebcfc0e4ed2a0839d7",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 4534,
        "total_tokens": 5792,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2285,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 4534,
        "total_tokens": 5792,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2285,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-008-source-follower",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-008-source-follower/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a {\\it Common Drain} or {\\it Source Follower} or {\\it Grounded Drain Stage} with passive load $R_{S}$. In CMOS with isolated $n$-well it is often drawn with bulk to source:\n\n> $$Bulk(M1) \\equiv Source(M1) \\rightarrow g_{mb}=0$$\n\nIf it is a discrete or $p-Sub$ technology $Bulk = GND$ and body effect $g_{mb} \\ne 0$ must be kept.\n\nIt is $100\\%$ voltage series feedback, no voltage gain $>1$, work as voltage buffer-impedance transformer, level shifter.\n\n### 1. Qualitative - Large signal\n\n$$V_{GS}=V_{G}-V_{S}=V_{in}-V_{out}$$\n$$V_{out}=I_{D}\\cdot R_{S}$$\n$$I_{D}= \\begin{cases}\n0 & V_{GS}< V_{TH}\\;\\; {\\rm cutoff}\\\\\nk_{n}(V_{GS}-V_{TH})^{2} & V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{TH}\\;\\; {\\rm SAT}\\\\\nk_{n}[2(V_{GS}-V_{TH})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}] & {\\rm Triode}\n\\end{cases}$$\n\n$$k_{n}= \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_{n}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}$$\n\nneglecting Channel Length Modulation $\\lambda \\approx 0$.\n\nWith $V_{DS}=V_{DD}-V_{out}$\n\n$$V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{TH} \\iff V_{DD}-V_{out}\\ge V_{in}-V_{out}-V_{TH}$$\n$$V_{in}\\le V_{DD}+V_{TH}$$\n\nso for all $0<V_{in}<V_{DD}$ it is in saturation once on.\n\n* $V_{in}<V_{TH}$ : $M_{1}$ OFF, $I_{D}=0$, $V_{out}=0$ pulled to $GND$ by $R_{S}$.\n\n* $V_{in}>V_{TH}$ : $M_{1}$ ON in SAT\n\n$$I_{D}=k_{n}(V_{in}-I_{D}R_{S}-V_{TH})^{2} \\tag{1}$$\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{in}-V_{GS}=V_{in}-V_{TH}-\\sqrt{\\frac{I_{D}}{k_{n}}}$$\n\ni.e. $V_{out}$ {\\it follows} $V_{in}$ with a DC level shift $\\approx V_{GS0}=V_{TH}+V_{OV}$ where $V_{OV}= \\sqrt{I_{DQ}/k_{n}}$ is the overdrive.\n\nTransfer characteristic is quasi linear with square law non linearity. The $R_{S}$ provides DC bias and local series feedback that linearizes.\n\nSolution of (1) for the $Q$ point for a $DC$ bias $V_{IN,Q}$:\n\n$$I_{DQ}= \\frac{1}{R_{S}^{2}k_{n}}\\left[1+k_{n}R_{S}(V_{INQ}-V_{TH})-\\sqrt{1+2k_{n}R_{S}(V_{INQ}-V_{TH})}\\right]$$\n\n$$V_{OUT,Q}=I_{DQ}R_{S}$$\n\n$$g_{m}= \\left.\\frac{\\partial I_{D}}{\\partial V_{GS}}\\right|_{Q}=2k_{n}V_{OV}= \\sqrt{2\\mu_{n}C_{ox}W/L\\cdot I_{DQ}}= \\frac{2I_{DQ}}{V_{OV}}$$\n\n$$r_{o}=1/g_{ds}\\approx 1/\\lambda I_{DQ} \\;\\to \\infty \\;{\\rm for\\; long\\; channel}$$\n\nVoltage swing:\n\n$$0\\le V_{out}\\le V_{DD}-V_{OV1}$$\n\nat low swing cut-off, at high swing $M_{1}$ remains in saturation up to $V_{DD}$ but $R_{S}$ cannot pull up beyond $V_{DD}-V_{GS}$.\n\nIt can {\\it source} large current $I_{D}$ but can only {\\it sink} $V_{out}/R_{S}$. Class A.\n\n### 2. Small signal model\n\n```\nVin o---||---+\n             | vgs\n            +-+\n             |  gm.vgs      ro\nD=VDD ac gnd ----+---||----+----o Vout\n                  |       |\n                  +--gmb.vbs\n                  |\n                 Rs to GND + CL\n```\n\n$v_{gs}=v_{in}-v_{out}$, $v_{bs}= -v_{out}$ if bulk = GND, $=0$ if bulk = source.\n\nKCL at output node:\n\n$$g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}(v_{out}-0)+ \\frac{v_{out}}{R_{S}}=0$$\n\nwith $v_{gs}=v_{in}-v_{out}$\n\n$$(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}+G_{S})v_{out}=g_{m}v_{in}$$\n\n$$G_{S}=1/R_{S}$$\n\n> $$A_{v}\\equiv \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = \\frac{g_{m}}{g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}+G_{S}} \\tag{2}$$\n\nIf bulk tied to source $g_{mb}=0$:\n\n$$A_{v}= \\frac{g_{m}}{g_{m}+g_{ds}+G_{S}} = \\frac{g_{m}(r_{o}||R_{S})}{1+g_{m}(r_{o}||R_{S})}$$\n\nFor $r_{o}>>R_{S}$ :\n\n> $$A_{v}\\approx \\frac{g_{m}R_{S}}{1+g_{m}R_{S}} = \\frac{1}{1+1/g_{m}R_{S}} <1$$\n\nTypically $0.8-0.95$. $A_{v}\\to 1$ for $g_{m}R_{S}>>1$.\n\nWith body effect to $GND$, $g_{mb}= \\eta g_{m}$, $\\eta \\approx 0.1-0.3$ :\n\n$$A_{v}= \\frac{g_{m}R_{S}'}{1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}'} \\approx \\frac{1}{1+\\eta+1/g_{m}R_{S}} < 0.8$$\n\nNo phase inversion. With active load $R_{S}\\to r_{o2}$ :\n\n$$A_{v}= \\frac{g_{m}}{g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}} \\approx \\frac{1}{1+\\eta}$$\n\nInput impedance:\n\n> $$Z_{in}= \\frac{v_{in}}{i_{g}} \\approx \\frac{1}{sC_{gg}} \\to \\infty \\; {\\rm at\\; low\\; freq.}$$\n\nOnly capacitive $C_{gs}+C_{gd}$. No Miller multiplication because $A_{v}\\approx 1$:\n\n$$C_{in}\\approx C_{gd}+(1-A_{v})C_{gs}\\approx C_{gd}$$\n\nOutput impedance - turn $V_{in}=0$, apply $v_{x}$ at source:\n\n$$i_{x}= (g_{m}+g_{mb})v_{gs}+g_{ds}v_{x}+ G_{S}v_{x}$$\n$$v_{gs}= -v_{x}$$\n\n> $$R_{out}= \\frac{v_{x}}{i_{x}} = R_{S}||\\frac{1}{g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}} \\approx R_{S}||\\frac{1}{g_{m}} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m}} \\tag{3}$$\n\nfor $g_{m}R_{S}>>1$. Typically $50-500\\,\\Omega$. Low.\n\nHence voltage buffer: high $R_{in}$, low $R_{out}$, current and power gain $\\approx g_{m}R_{S}$.\n\nNo Miller effect, wide bandwidth. Dominant pole at output:\n\n$$p_{out}\\approx \\frac{1}{R_{out}C_{L}} = \\frac{g_{m}+g_{mb}+G_{S}}{C_{L}}$$\n$$p_{in}\\approx \\frac{1}{R_{sig}C_{gd}}$$\n\n### 3. Properties and Use\n\n* Buffer stage between high impedance node and low impedance load. As output stage of op-amp.\n* Level shifter by $V_{GS}\\approx 0.5-1V$.\n* Feedback : voltage-shunt? The $R_{S}$ is series current feedback sampling $V_{out}$.\n* Linearity improved by feedback, distortion $\\propto 1/(1+g_{m}R_{S})$.\n* Disadvantages: $A_{v}<1$, not for voltage amplification, limited negative swing and sinking capability, DC shift, body effect degrades gain if $n$-MOS in $p$-sub.\n* To get $A_{v}\\approx 0.99$ and larger swing replace $R_{S}$ by $NMOS/PMOS$ current source $I_{SS}$ with $r_{o2}>>1/g_{m}$.\n\nWant a numeric design give $V_{DD}$, $W/L$, $R_{S}$ or $I_{DQ}$ and $C_{L}$ and $A_{v}$, $R_{out}$, swing and $BW$ can be calculated from (1)-(3).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f5020390d4d0bf5452cdbde1123a7abab2ce389c09a3b32a9baedac4f71848ce"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source follower and gives its positive, less-than-unity gain as gm·RS/(1 + gm·RS), matching the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8f23ff232475a4bec79b12629414fe11fc7b9c6e9609b2ebcfc0e4ed2a0839d7",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 4060,
        "total_tokens": 5318,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1907,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 4060,
        "total_tokens": 5318,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1907,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-009-common-gate-source-input",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-009-common-gate-source-input/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "It is the grounded gate - common gate - stage:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}&: n{\\hbox -}{\\rm MOS}\\cr\nS&= B =V_{in}\\cr\nG&=V_{DD} = {\\rm gnd}_{ac}\\cr\nD&=V_{out}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}\\cr}$$\n\nIf the $n$ substrate does not allow\n$B=S$ you get the conventional CG with $B=0$,\n$g_{mb}\\ne 0$ in {\\it ac}. The $B=S$ connexion\nsuppresses the $g_{mb}$ term.\n\n> {\\it Gate is $ac$ ground, signal in at the\n> low $Z$ source, signal out at the high $Z$\n> drain through $R_{D}$. A voltage controlled\n> current source. A current buffer - voltage\n> amplifier with $A_{v}>0$ and $A_{i}\\approx 1$.}\n> The building block of the cascode and of\n> the $50\\,{\\rm \\Omega }$ wide band LNA.}\n\nIn small signal $V_{DD}=0$.\n\n* {\\it dc - Large signal} ${\\rm .}$\n\nLet for ${\\rm NMOS}$ $V_{GS}=V_{G}-V_{S}=V_{DD}-V_{in}$,\n$V_{DS}=V_{D}-V_{S}=V_{out}-V_{in}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}\n-V_{in}$, $V_{BS}=0$. With long channel\n\n$$I_{D}={k_{n}\\over 2}\\left(V_{GS}-V_{Tn}\\right)^{2}\n\\left(1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right)\\;\\;{\\rm SAT.}$$\n\n$$I_{D}=k_{n}\\left[\\left(V_{GS}-V_{Tn}\\right)V_{DS}-\n{V_{DS}^{2}\\over 2}\\right]\\;\\;{\\rm TRIODE}$$\n\n$$\\beta =k_{n}= \\mu_{n}C_{ox}W/L$$\n\nCut off for\n\n$$V_{GS}<V_{Tn}\\;\\;:\\;\\;V_{in}>V_{DD}-V_{Tn}\\;\\;I_{D}=0,\n\\;V_{out}=V_{DD}$$\n\nSaturation $V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{Tn}$ i. e.\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{in}-I_{D}R_{D}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{in}-V_{Tn}$$\n\n$$I_{D}R_{D}\\le V_{Tn}\\tag{1}$$\n\nat the edge\n\n$${k_{n}\\over 2}\\left(V_{DD}-V_{in}-V_{Tn}\\right)^{2}\nR_{D}=V_{Tn}$$\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{in}-V_{Tn}= \\sqrt{{2V_{Tn}\\over {k_{n}R_{D}}}}$$\n\ni. e. a very narrow $\\sim 50-200\\,{\\rm mV}$ window\nbelow cut off is saturated. For larger $V_{GS}$,\n{\\it i. e.} $V_{in}$ low, (1) fails and the device is\nin triode. With $V_{GS}=A=V_{DD}-V_{in}$ and\n$X=V_{DS}=V_{out}-V_{in}$\n\n$${V_{DD}-V_{out}\\over {R_{D}}}=I_{D}\n= k_{n}\\left[(A-V_{Tn})X-X^{2}/2\\right] \\tag{2}$$\n\nand $V_{out}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}$.\nPutting $A=V_{DD}-V_{in}$, $X=V_{out}-V_{in}$\n\n$${A-X\\over {R_{D}}}=k_{n}\\left[(A-V_{Tn})X-X^{2}/2\\right]$$\n\n$${k_{n}R_{D}\\over 2}X^{2}-[k_{n}R_{D}(A-V_{Tn})+1]X+A=0$$\n\ntwo roots, the physical $X<V_{Tn}$ branch is the VTC.\nIn SAT.\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}-{k_{n}R_{D}\\over 2}\\left(V_{DD}-V_{in}\n-V_{Tn}\\right)^{2}\\tag{3}$$\n\nparabolic, rising with $V_{in}$, $dV_{out}/dV_{in}>0$.\nFor $V_{in}\\to -\\infty $ (2) $\\to V_{out}\\approx\nV_{in}+V_{DS(sat)}$, $I_{D}$ limited by $R_{D}$.\n\nIn a normally biased amplifier you bias in the\nnarrow SAT. window, e. g. $V_{inQ}\\approx V_{DD}-V_{Tn}\n-\\Delta V$, $\\Delta V =\\sqrt{2V_{Tn}/k_{n}R_{D}}$,\nso that the signal sits on a $\\pm {\\rm few}\\times 10\\,{\\rm mV}$\nswing. This is the reason the gate is normally {\\it not}\ntied to $V_{DD}$ but to a lower bias $V_{B}\\approx\n0.5-1.0\\,{\\rm V}$ to allow a source DC level near\nground and $V_{DS}\\sim V_{DD}/2$ with current source\nload. Tying $G$ to $V_{DD}$ sacrifices headroom and puts\nthe device in triode for any normal $R_{D}$ and/or\n$g_{m}R_{D}>1$.\n\n* {\\it ac - Small signal} ${\\rm .}$\n\nIn SAT. with $\\lambda \\ne 0$, $r_{o}=1/g_{ds}\n=1/\\lambda I_{DQ}$,\n\n$$g_{m}=k_{n}\\left(V_{GSQ}-V_{Tn}\\right)=\\sqrt{2k_{n}I_{DQ}}$$\n$$g_{mb}= \\chi g_{m},\\;\\;\\chi \\approx 0.1-0.3$$\n\n$g_{mb}=0$ for the $B=S$ connexion of the figure.\nOtherwise $g_{mb}\\ne 0$ and $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$\nbelow.\n\nLow frequency model $g=0$, $s=v_{in}$, $d=v_{out}$,\n$v_{gs}=-v_{in}$, $v_{bs}=0\\;( -v_{in}$ if $B=0)$,\n$v_{ds}=v_{out}-v_{in}$,\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}$$\n\nKCL at $D$ : $v_{out}/R_{D}+i_{d}=0$ {\\it i. e.}\n$i_{d}=-v_{out}/R_{D}$, so with $g_{mb}=0$,\n\n$$-{v_{out}\\over {R_{D}}}=-g_{m}v_{in}+g_{ds}(v_{out}-\nv_{in})$$\n\n$$v_{out}\\left({1\\over {R_{D}}}+g_{ds}\\right)\n=v_{in}\\left(g_{m}+g_{ds}\\right)$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over {v_{in}}}\n={g_{m}+g_{ds}\\over {g_{ds}+1/R_{D}}}\n=\\left(g_{m}+g_{ds}\\right)\\left(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\right)$$\n\n$$\\approx g_{m}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\right)\n\\approx g_{m}R_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;R_{D}\\ll r_{o}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand $A_{v}>0$, non inverting, with\n\n$$g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}\\;\\;{\\rm if}\\;B={\\rm GND.}$$\n\ni. e. $A_{v}\\approx (g_{m}+g_{mb})(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o})$\nfor bulk to GND, numerically the same to $10-20\\%$.\n\nIn triode $g_{m}=k_{n}V_{DSQ}$, $g_{ds}=\nk_{n}(V_{GSQ}-V_{Tn}-V_{DSQ})$ and (4) is still\nformally valid but $g_{ds}\\gg g_{m}$ and\n\n$$A_{v,{\\rm tri}}\\approx {g_{m}\\over {g_{ds}}}\\,\n{ R_{D}g_{ds}\\over {1+R_{D}g_{ds}}}<1$$\n\nexplaining the low gain if (1) is violated.\n\nCurrent gain, $i_{in}$ at the source. KCL at\n$S$ for a test source $v_{x}=v_{in}$, $i_{x}$ into\n$S$, $v_{d}=v_{x}(g_{m}+g_{ds})/(g_{ds}+1/R_{D})$:\n\n$$i_{x}=-i_{d}= -\\left[-g_{m}v_{x}+g_{ds}(v_{d}-v_{x})\\right]$$\n\n$$i_{x}=v_{x}(g_{m}+g_{ds}){1/R_{D}\\over {g_{ds}+1/R_{D}}}$$\n\n$$R_{in}\\equiv {v_{x}\\over {i_{x}}}={1+g_{ds}R_{D}\\over\n{g_{m}+g_{ds}}} = {1+R_{D}/r_{o}\\over {g_{m}+g_{ds}}}$$\n\n$$={R_{D}+r_{o}\\over {1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}}}\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx {1\\over {g_{m}+g_{mb}}}\\parallel r_{o}\n\\approx {1\\over {g_{m}}}\\;\\;R_{D}\\ll r_{o}$$\n\n$20-200\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$ typical. It is the low\nimpedance input that makes the CG attractive as a\n$50\\,{\\rm \\Omega }$ terminated LNA and as a current\nbuffer. With a source resistance $R_{S}$ in series\nwith $v_{in}$ the over all voltage gain becomes\n\n$$A_{vT}={R_{in}\\over {R_{in}+R_{S}}}\\,A_{v}\n\\approx {g_{m}R_{D}\\over {1+g_{m}R_{S}}}$$\n\nOutput resistance, de-activate $v_{in}$,\n$R_{S}=0$, $g=0$, $s=0$:\n\n$$R_{o}|_{D}= r_{o}\\tag{6}$$\n\nso at the $V_{out}$ node\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx R_{D}$$\n\nIf the source is driven through a finite $R_{S}$\n\n$$R_{o}=r_{o}\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}\\right]+R_{S}\n\\approx (g_{m}r_{o})R_{S}$$\n\nwhich is exploited in the cascode to get\n$R_{o}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$ on top of a CS device.\n\nInput capacitance $\\approx C_{gs}+C_{sb}$, output\ncapacitance $\\approx C_{gd}+C_{db}$, no Miller\nmultiplication of $C_{gd}$ because $g$ is $ac$\nground, so bandwidth\n\n$$\\omega_{p,in}\\approx {1\\over {R_{S}\\parallel R_{in}\\,\nC_{in}}},\\;\\;\\omega_{p,out}\\approx {1\\over\n{R_{out}C_{out}}}$$\n\nboth high, $f_{T}$ limited, wide band.\n\nIn short\n\n> $A_{v}\\approx +g_{m}R_{D}$, $A_{i}\\approx -1$,\n> $R_{in}\\approx 1/g_{m}$ low, $R_{out}\\approx R_{D}$\n> high, non inverting, no Miller, good high frequency\n> current buffer. For practical bias the gate must be\n> returned to $V_{B}<V_{DD}$ or $R_{D}$ replaced by a\n> $p{\\rm MOS}$ current source; the cascade of a CS\n> stage driving this CG stage is the telescopic cascode.\n\nReplacing $R_{D}$ by an active $p{\\rm MOS}$ load\n$r_{op}$ gives $A_{v}\\approx g_{m}(r_{o}\\parallel r_{op})\n\\approx g_{m}r_{o}/2$, $20-40\\,{\\rm dB}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a41cdbf9468dd0f464358968d29c2b516d5cc0217e833e0b5546c81a689f1d5f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-driven common-gate topology and derives the positive voltage gain and low input resistance in agreement with the golden solution. The additional analysis does not alter the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "1b3a848197667846074404db3b3d8871ff2129384f8d686f3624e0319ea90d69",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1158,
        "output_tokens": 15329,
        "total_tokens": 16487,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12372,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1158,
        "output_tokens": 15329,
        "total_tokens": 16487,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12372,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-009-common-gate-source-input",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-009-common-gate-source-input/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the grounded gate - common base\nof MOS. $V_{D}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}$ is\ntaken as o/p . $V_{G}=V_{DD}$ is\na. c. ground.\n\n$$V_{g}=0\\;\\;{\\rm for\\;signals}\\;\\;V_{d}=V_{out}\\;\\;V_{s}=V_{in}$$\n\n$$v_{gs}=v_{g}-v_{s}=-v_{s}\\quad v_{ds}=v_{d}-v_{s}$$\n\nIn ordinary use $M_{1}$ is in saturation\nin inversion, ${\\rm NMOS}$, ${\\rm body}=\n{\\rm source}$ in the 3T symbol shown.\nIf the $4{\\rm T}$ device is taken with\n$p$ sub to $GND$, $V_{SB}=V_{S}>0$ and\n$V_{T}=V_{T0}+\\gamma \\left[\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{SB}}\n-\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}}\\right]$,\n$g_{m}^{^{\\prime}}=g_{m}+g_{mb}$ is to\nbe substituted for $g_{m}$.\n\nWith $\\left|V_{DS}\\right|\\ge \\left|V_{GS}\n-V_{T}\\right|$, $\\left|V_{GS}\\right|> \\left|\nV_{T}\\right|$\n\n$$I_{D}\\approx {1\\over 2}k_{n}\\left(V_{GS}-\nV_{T}\\right)^{2}\\left[1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right]\n\\tag{DC}$$\n\n$$V_{GS}=V_{G}-V_{S}=V_{DD}-V_{I\\,DC}$$\n$$V_{DS}=V_{D}-V_{S}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}-V_{I\\,DC}$$\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}-R_{D}{1\\over 2}k_{n}\n\\left(V_{DD}-V_{in}-V_{T}\\right)^{2},\\,{\\rm sat.}$$\n\nCut off for $V_{in}>V_{DD}-V_{T}\\;:\\;V_{GS}<V_{T},\n\\;I_{D}=0,\\;V_{out}=V_{DD}$.\n\nTriode for $V_{out}<V_{DD}-V_{T}\\;:\\;V_{DS}<\nV_{GS}-V_{T}$.\n\nNormal amplifying bias $V_{out}\\approx V_{DD}\n-I_{D}R_{D} \\ge V_{G}-V_{T}=V_{DD}-V_{T}$.\n\nIn small signal, gate is a.c. ground:\n\n```\n          RD\n   0 -----/\\/\\/\\------o Vout = vd\n                      |\n        vg=0 o----|   |\n                  |G  |\n                  M1  |\n              D --|   |-- S---o vs=vin\n                  |   vs\n                 _|_\n```\n\nHybrid $\\pi $: $g_{m}v_{gs}$ from $D\\to S$,\n$r_{o}=1/g_{ds}\\approx 1/\\lambda I_{D}$\nbetween $D$ and $S$, $v_{gs}=-v_{s}$.\n\nAt the $D$ node, $V_{DD}=0$ for a.c.,\n\n$${{v_{d}}\\over {R_{D}}}+{{v_{d}-v_{s}}\\over{r_{o}}}\n+g_{m}v_{gs}=0\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$v_{gs}=-v_{s}$$\n\n$${{v_{d}}\\over {R_{D}}}+{{v_{d}-v_{s}}\\over{r_{o}}}\n-g_{m}v_{s}=0$$\n\n$$\\;v_{d}\\left({1\\over{R_{D}}}+{1\\over{r_{o}}}\\right)\n=v_{s}\\left(g_{m}+{1\\over{r_{o}}}\\right)\\; \\tag{2}$$\n\n> $${A_{v}\\equiv {{v_{out}}\\over{v_{in}}}={{v_{d}}\\over{v_{s}}}=\n> {{g_{m}+g_{ds}}\\over{g_{ds}+G_{D}}}={{g_{m}r_{o}+1}\\over{1+r_{o}/R_{D}}}\n> ={{R_{D}}\\over{r_{o}+R_{D}}}\\left(1+g_{m}r_{o}\\right) } \\tag{3}$$\n\n$G_{D}=1/R_{D}$, $g_{ds}=1/r_{o}$.\nFor $g_{mb}\\ne 0$ put $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\n\nIn particular\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx g_{m}R_{D}{\\,1\\over{1+R_{D}/r_{o}}}\n\\approx g_{m}(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o})>0$$\n\nfor $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$.  With $r_{o}\\gg R_{D}$\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx +\\,g_{m}R_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm including\\; }R_{L}\\;:\\;\nA_{v}\\approx +g_{m}(R_{D}\\parallel R_{L})$$\n\nto be compared with the $CS$ stage $A_{v}\\approx\n-g_{m}(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o})$. The common gate is\n{\\it non inverting} current buffer - voltage\namplifier. Large signal: $V_{in}\\uparrow \\to\nV_{GS}\\downarrow \\to I_{D}\\downarrow \\to\nI_{D}R_{D}\\downarrow \\to V_{out}\\uparrow $.\n\nNeglecting feedback through $r_{o}$,\n$v_{gs}=-v_{in}$, $i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}=-g_{m}v_{in}$,\n$v_{out}=-i_{d}R_{D}=g_{m}R_{D}v_{in}$.\n\nInput resistance at the source. Put $v_{x}$ at\n$S$, $v_{g}=0$, $D$ terminated in $R_{D}$ to\na.c. ground, measure $i_{x}$ entering $S$.\n\nFrom (1) $v_{d}=-R_{D}I_{DS}$, $I_{DS}=g_{m}v_{gs}\n+(v_{d}-v_{s})/r_{o}$ is the $D\\to S$ current.\nAt $S$: $i_{x}=-I_{DS}$ so that\n\n$$i_{x}={{v_{d}}\\over{R_{D}}}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand with (2)\n\n$${R_{in}\\equiv {{v_{x}}\\over{i_{x}}}={{v_{s}}\\over{v_{d}}}R_{D}\n={{R_{D}}\\over{A_{v}}}={{1+R_{D}/r_{o}}\\over{g_{m}+g_{ds}}} }$$\n\n> $${R_{in}={{r_{o}+R_{D}}\\over{1+g_{m}r_{o}}}\\approx {1\\over{g_{m}}}{1\\over{1+1/g_{m}r_{o}}}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx {1\\over{g_{m}}}\\;\\;r_{o}\\gg R_{D} } \\tag{5}$$\n\nIn general, with $g_{mb}$,\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx {1\\over{g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}}}\\approx\n{1\\over{g_{m}+g_{mb}}}$$\n\nA low impedance, $\\sim 10-10^{2}\\Omega$ for\ntypical $g_{m}$. It is often sized to give\n$R_{in}=R_{s}=50\\Omega$ for RF matching:\n$g_{m}\\approx 20\\,{\\rm mS}$.\n\nWith a source generator resistance $R_{S}$ the\neffective voltage gain to the source node is\ndivided:\n\n$$A_{v,tot}={{v_{d}}\\over{v_{sig}}}=A_{v}{{R_{in}}\\over{R_{in}+R_{S}}}\n\\approx {{g_{m}R_{D}}\\over{1+g_{m}R_{S}}}\\xrightarrow{R_{S}=1/g_{m}} {1\\over 2}g_{m}R_{D}$$\n\nThe short circuit current gain $i_{d}/i_{s}\\approx -1$.\n\nOutput resistance at the drain. Deactivate\n$v_{sig}$, $R_{S}$ from $S$ to ground, apply\n$v_{x}$ at $D$, measure $i_{x}$.\n\n$$-{{v_{s}}\\over{R_{S}}}+I_{DS}=0,\\;\\;\nI_{DS}=g_{m}(-v_{s})+{{v_{x}-v_{s}}\\over{r_{o}}}$$\n\n$${{v_{x}}\\over{r_{o}}}=v_{s}\\left(g_{m}+g_{ds}+G_{S}\\right)\n\\;\\;G_{S}=1/R_{S}$$\n\n$$I_{DS}=v_{s}/R_{S}$$\n\nFor the impedance looking {\\it into} the drain\nalone, $i_{x}=I_{DS}$:\n\n$$R_{o,d}= {{v_{x}}\\over{I_{DS}}}=r_{o}+\\left(1+g_{m}r_{o}\\right)R_{S}\n\\;\\xrightarrow{g_{mb}}\\;r_{o}+\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}\\right]R_{S}\\tag{6}$$\n\nIncluding the $R_{D}$ to $V_{DD}$,\n\n$${R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{o,d}=R_{D}\\parallel \\left[r_{o}+(1+g_{m}r_{o})R_{S}\\right] }$$\n\nFor an ideal voltage drive $R_{S}\\to 0$, $R_{out}\\to\nR_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx R_{D}$; for a high\nimpedance drive the drain impedance is boosted by\n$g_{m}r_{o}$, as in a cascode,\n$R_{out}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}R_{S}$.\n\nRemarks:\n\n* No Miller multiplication of $C_{gd}$ because\n$G$ is a.c. ground. $C_{gd}$ is from o/p to\nground, $C_{gs}$ is from i/p to ground. Poles are\n\n$$\\omega _{p,in}\\approx {1\\over{(R_{S}\\parallel R_{in})C_{in}}},\\;\\;\nC_{in}\\approx C_{gs}+C_{sb}$$\n$$\\omega _{p,out}\\approx {1\\over{(R_{D}\\parallel R_{L})C_{out}}},\\;\\;\nC_{out}\\approx C_{gd}+C_{db}+C_{L}$$\n\nWide band, dominant pole usually at the\no/p. This is why the $CG$ and the cascode\n$CS-CG$ are the workhorses of wide band and\nRF LNAs, current buffers, impedance translators.\n\n* Power gain $\\approx A_{v}^{2}R_{in}/R_{out}\\approx\ng_{m}R_{D}^{2}/R_{out}$ is modest because of\nlow $R_{in}$.\n\n* With $V_{G}=V_{DD}$ the available swing at\nthe source is limited to $V_{DD}-V_{GS}$.\nUsually $V_{G}=V_{B}<V_{DD}$ is provided by a\nbias network and $V_{in}$ is a.c. coupled to\nthe source through a capacitor, $S$ biased by a\ncurrent source $I_{B}$.\n\nIn the active load version $R_{D}$ is replaced\nby a $p{\\rm MOS}$ current source $r_{op}\\parallel\nr_{on}$, $A_{v}\\approx g_{m}(r_{on}\\parallel r_{op})$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bc90ecdc9c2e37325c0c4cd79d71b3cf663e1c9c1a4e3e9a518620a131b63592"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-input, AC-grounded-gate common-gate stage and gives the non-inverting gain and approximately 1/gm input resistance, including reasonable ro refinements.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "1b3a848197667846074404db3b3d8871ff2129384f8d686f3624e0319ea90d69",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1158,
        "output_tokens": 9910,
        "total_tokens": 11068,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7130,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1158,
        "output_tokens": 9910,
        "total_tokens": 11068,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7130,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-009-common-gate-source-input",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-009-common-gate-source-input/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the grounded gate - {\\it Common Gate}\nstage with ${\\rm R_{D}}$ load. For small signals\n${\\rm V_{DD}}$ is $ac$ ground so $v_{g}=0$.\n\n> $${\\rm M_{1}}: n-{\\rm MOS}, \\;V_{GS}=V_{G}-V_{S}=V_{DD}-V_{in}$$\n> $${\\rm M_{1}}\\; {\\rm ON}\\iff V_{GS}>V_{Tn} \\iff\n> V_{in}<V_{DD}-V_{Tn}$$\n> Body is drawn shorted to source. If it is to $GND$\n> $V_{SB}=V_{in}$ and $V_{T}=V_{T0}+\\gamma \\left[\n> \\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}+V_{SB}}-\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}} \\right]$.\n\n```\n AC ground\n   |\n   RD\n   |  Vout\n   +---o\n   |\n   D\n  M1 G---AC ground = VDD\n   S\n   |\n  Vin\n```\n\nSmall signal, saturation, $i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}$\n$g_{ds}=1/r_{o}=\\lambda I_{D}$ , $g_{m}= \\mu_{n}C_{ox}{W\\over L}\n\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)=\\sqrt{2\\mu_{n}C_{ox}{W\\over L}I_{D}}\n=2I_{D}/V_{ov}$ .\n\nWith source-bulk short $g_{mb}=0$. With bulk to $GND$\nreplace $g_{m}\\rightarrow g_{m}+g_{mb}$,\n$g_{mb}= \\eta g_{m}$, $\\eta =\\gamma /2\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}+V_{SB}}$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nv_{gs}&=v_{g}-v_{s}=-v_{in}\\cr\nv_{ds}&=v_{d}-v_{s}=v_{out}-v_{in}}$$\n\nKCL at $D$, currents leaving $D$:\n\n$${v_{out}\\over R_{D}}+{v_{out}-v_{in}\\over r_{o}}+g_{m}v_{gs}=0$$\n\n$${v_{out}\\over R_{D}}+{v_{out}-v_{in}\\over r_{o}}-g_{m}v_{in}=0\\tag{1}$$\n\n$${v_{out}\\over v_{in}}={g_{m}+g_{ds}\\over G_{D}+g_{ds}}=\n{(g_{m}r_{o}+1)R_{D}\\over R_{D}+r_{o}}=(g_{m}r_{o}+1){R_{D}\\Vert r_{o}\\over r_{o}}$$\n\n> $$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}\\approx g_{m}(R_{D}\\Vert r_{o})\n> \\xrightarrow[r_{o}\\gg R_{D}]{} g_{m}R_{D}>0 \\tag{2}$$\n\nNon inverting. ${v_{in}}\\uparrow \\rightarrow V_{GS}\\downarrow\n\\rightarrow I_{D}\\downarrow \\rightarrow I_{R_{D}}\\downarrow\n\\rightarrow v_{out}\\uparrow $. With $g_{mb}\\ne 0$,\n$A_{v}\\approx (g_{m}+g_{mb})(R_{D}\\Vert r_{o})$.\n\nCurrent gain $\\approx 1$. The stage is a {\\it current buffer}\n{\\it voltage amplifier}. It is the dual of the common\ndrain, low $R_{in}$ , high $R_{out}$.\n\nKCL at $S$: $i_{in}$ entering $S$\n\n$${v_{in}-v_{out}\\over r_{o}}-g_{m}v_{gs}-i_{in}=0$$\n\n$$i_{in}={v_{in}-v_{out}\\over r_{o}}+g_{m}v_{in}\\tag{3}$$\n\nWith (1),\n\n$$i_{in}=v_{in}{1+g_{m}r_{o}\\over r_{o}+R_{D}}$$\n\n> $$R_{in}\\equiv {v_{in}\\over i_{in}}={r_{o}+R_{D}\\over 1+g_{m}r_{o}}\n> \\approx {1\\over g_{m}}{1+R_{D}/r_{o}\\over 1+1/g_{m}r_{o}}\n> \\xrightarrow[r_{o}\\gg R_{D}]{} {1\\over g_{m}} \\tag{4}$$\n\nWith $g_{mb}$: $R_{in}\\approx 1/(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds})$.\n$R_{in}\\approx 50-500\\, \\Omega$ typ. so it can terminate\ne.g. $50\\Omega$ line. Driven from a source with\n$R_{Sig}$ the effective gain is\n\n$$A_{v,tot}={R_{in}\\over R_{in}+R_{Sig}}A_{v}\n\\approx {g_{m}R_{D}\\over 1+g_{m}R_{Sig}}$$\n\nso a high $R_{Sig}$ kills the gain. It is a good\n{\\it voltage} amplifier only for low $R_{Sig}$.\n\nOutput resistance: de-activate $v_{in}$, $R_{Sig}$ from source\nto ground. Impedance looking into $D$:\n\n$$R_{d}=r_{o}+(1+g_{m}r_{o})R_{Sig}\\;\\; \\left[+(1+g_{mb}r_{o})R_{Sig}\\right]$$\n\nAt the output node\n\n> $$R_{out}=R_{D}\\Vert R_{d}\\approx R_{D}\\Vert r_{o}\\xrightarrow[R_{Sig}=0]{}\n> R_{D}\\Vert r_{o}\\approx R_{D} \\tag{5}$$\n\nfor ideal $V_{in}$ source $R_{Sig}=0$, $R_{out}\\approx r_{o}\\Vert R_{D}$,\nhigh.\n\n### Large signal - DC bias window\n\nLet ${k_{n}\\over 2}= {\\mu_{n}C_{ox}\\over 2}{W\\over L}$.\n\nCut-off: $V_{in}>V_{DD}-V_{T}$ : $I_{D}=0$, $V_{out}=V_{DD}$.\n\nSaturation: $V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{T}$\n\n$$V_{DS}=V_{D}-V_{S}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}-V_{in}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{in}-V_{T}$$\n\n$$I_{D}R_{D}\\le V_{T}\\tag{6}$$\n\n$$I_{D}=k_{n}(V_{DD}-V_{in}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{DS})$$\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}=V_{DD}-k_{n}R_{D}(V_{DD}-V_{in}-V_{T})^{2}$$\n\nin saturation, a rising parabola to $V_{DD}$.\nThe saturation condition is\n\n$$k_{n}R_{D}(V_{DD}-V_{in}-V_{T})^{2}\\le V_{T}$$\n\n$$V_{in}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{T}-\\sqrt{V_{T}/k_{n}R_{D}}$$\n\nand $V_{in}<V_{DD}-V_{T}$ for ON. The bias window is\nnarrow and set by the DC value of $V_{in}$ itself.\nIn practice the source is biased with a DC current\nsource through a capacitor or with a $R_{S}$ to ground\nso that $V_{GS}$ is set independent of the signal source.\n\nFor\n\n$$V_{in}<V_{DD}-V_{T}-\\sqrt{V_{T}/k_{n}R_{D}}$$\n\n$I_{D}R_{D}>V_{T}$, $V_{out}<V_{DD}-V_{T}$ $\\rightarrow$ triode:\n\n$$I_{D}=k_{n}\\left[2(V_{GS}-V_{T})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}\\right]$$\n\ngain collapses.\n\nIn saturation the small signal gain is essentially\n$g_{m}R_{D}$, with $g_{m}\\propto \\sqrt{I_{D}}$ set\nby the $Q$-point.\n\n### Remarks\n\n* No Miller multiplication of $C_{gd}$. Input pole\n$\\omega_{p,in}\\approx 1/R_{in}C_{in}$, $R_{in}\\approx 1/g_{m}$\nsmall $\\rightarrow$ very high frequency pole. Output pole\n$\\omega_{p,out}\\approx 1/R_{out}C_{L}$. CG is inherently\nwide band. Used as RF LNA input stage, $50\\Omega$ match\nby $1/g_{m}=50\\Omega$, as current buffer and as the\nupper device of a cascode - it shields the input device\nfrom the output giving high $R_{out}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$\nand suppressing Miller effect.\n\n* Dual of common drain; dual of common source in impedance.\n\n* Disadvantage: low $R_{in}$ is bad for voltage source\nwith high $R_{Sig}$, DC level shifting problem because\n$V_{S,DC}=V_{DD}-V_{GS,DC}\\approx V_{DD}-V_{T}-V_{ov}$ is\nhigh.\n\nAddition of a source bias current $I_{B}$ or $R_{S}$ to\nground decouples $Q$-point from $V_{in,DC}$ and is the\nusual practical form.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "4ca40e476b4df10087b40caea7cd92615e1be80a840d8aae1b95fedf847a29c6"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-driven common-gate topology, gives the non-inverting gain and the approximately 1/gm input resistance. Its central analysis matches the golden solution.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "1b3a848197667846074404db3b3d8871ff2129384f8d686f3624e0319ea90d69",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1158,
        "output_tokens": 8459,
        "total_tokens": 9617,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6172,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1158,
        "output_tokens": 8459,
        "total_tokens": 9617,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6172,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual convention that is the circuit\nas drawn is degenerate it is instructive. In\nnormal form it is the {\\it grounded gate}\nor {\\it common gate} stage\n\n```\n                    V_{DD}(ac=0)\n                     |\n                    R_{D}\n                     | D\n                +----o----+\n                |    || G vb(ac=0)\n                |   M_{1}\n                |    || S<^ B\n               C_{L}  |\n                |  +--o--+\n                |  |     |  if the wire is taken\n               R_{L} C_{1}   literally R_{S}=0\n                |  |     |  normally\n                gnd + Vin  R_{S} or I_{S}gnd\n                       -     |\n                       gnd  gnd\n```\n\nwith $V_{B}$ signal ground.\n\n> {\\it Remark on the figure:} As literally drawn\n> $ S\\equiv ac\\; {\\rm ground}$. $v_{S}=0$ for all\n> $v_{in}$ and the stage has $A_{v}=0$.\n> $C_{1}$ is shorted by the wire to ground.\n> Normally the wire to ground is a dc bias\n> impedance, high for $ac$, $R_{S}$ in the figure\n> to the right, most often an $n$MOS current source\n> $I_{S}$, $r_{OS}>>1/g_{m}$ . In the following\n> $R_{S}$ is put $=0$ for DC but $=\\infty $ for\n> AC , i. e. the textbook $CG$.\n> If you keep the literal short $R_{S}=0$ also for\n> $ac$ put $R_{S}=0$ in the formulas below.\n> You get $R_{in}=0\\parallel 1/g_{m}=0$,\n> $A_{v}=0$.\n\n{\\bf 1. DC bias} Take $M_{1}$ to be $n$MOS,\nbulk $=p$ sub. {\\rm ,} $S$ is the arrow terminal.\n\n$$V_{GS0}=V_{B}-V_{S0}$$\n\nand with the idealisation above $V_{S0}=0$\n\n$$V_{GS0}=V_{B}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$I_{D0}= {1\\over 2}{\\mu _{n}C_{ox}}{W\\over L}\n\\left(V_{B}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\\left(1+\\lambda V_{DS0}\\right)\n\\tag{2}$$\nfor $V_{B}>V_{T}$ in saturation and\n\n$$V_{DS0}=V_{D0}-V_{S0}=V_{DD}-I_{D0}R_{D} \\tag{3}$$\n\nSaturation, $V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{T}$, requires:\n\n$$V_{DD}-I_{D0}R_{D} \\ge V_{B}-V_{T} \\tag{4}$$\n\nand determines the maximum symmetric swing\n\n$$V_{o,max}=V_{DD}-I_{D0}R_{D} -V_{DS,sat}$$\n$$V_{o,min}=V_{DS,sat}\\approx V_{GS}-V_{T}$$\n\n$V_{B}$ is the whole bias control. The\ncircuit has no source degeneration to desensitize\n(2) and is very $V_{T}$ sensitive. In practice\n$R_{S}$ or $I_{S}$ is used to set $I_{D0}$ and\n$V_{B}=V_{S0}+V_{GS0}$.\n\nFor the 3 terminal symbol $B$ is strapped to $S$\n$$V_{BS0}=0\\qquad g_{mb}=0$$\nIf the bulk is to the global $gnd$ and $R_{S}\\ne\n0$, $V_{BS}\\ne 0$, the threshold is\n\n$$V_{T}=V_{T0}+\\gamma \\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}-V_{BS}}\n-\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}}\\;\\right)$$\n\nand an extra $g_{mb}= \\eta g_{m}$ appears in $ac$.\n\n{\\bf 2. Low frequency $ac$ model} $V_{B}=ac\\,0$,\n$V_{DD}=ac\\,0$, $C_{1}=ac$ short for\n$\\omega >> \\omega _{H}=1/R_{in}C_{1}$.  $R_{D}$\nis the $ac$ load, in general $R_{D}^{\\prime}=R_{D}\\parallel\nR_{L}\\parallel C_{L}$.\n\nStandard $ac$ model of the $n$MOS in saturation\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}\\tag{5}$$\n$$g_{m}= \\left.{\\partial I_{D}\\over \\partial V_{GS}}\\right|_{Q}\n= \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}{W\\over L}I_{D0}}={2I_{D0}\\over V_{GS0}-V_{T}}$$\n$$g_{ds}=r_{o}^{-1}= \\lambda I_{D0}$$\n$$g_{mb}= -{\\partial I_{D}\\over \\partial V_{BS}}=\n{g_{m}\\gamma \\over 2\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}-V_{BS}}}$$\n\nPut $v_{g}=0$, $v_{b}=0$, $v_{s}=v_{in}$,\n$v_{d}=v_{out}$.\n\n$$v_{gs}= -v_{in}\\tag{6a}$$\n$$v_{bs}= -v_{in}\\;\\;{\\rm if}\\;B=gnd\\tag{6b}$$\n$$v_{ds}=v_{out}-v_{in}\\tag{6c}$$\n\nKCL at the $D$ node, current $i_{d}$ entering the\ndrain, $i_{R_{D}}=-v_{out}/R_{D}$ entering the drain\nfrom $R_{D}$:\n\n$$i_{d}+v_{out}/R_{D}^{\\prime}=0 \\tag{7}$$\n\nfor the unloaded stage $R_{D}^{\\prime}=R_{D}$.\nWith (5)-(6)\n\n$$-g_{m}v_{in}-g_{mb}v_{in}+g_{ds}(v_{out}-v_{in})\n+{v_{out}\\over R_{D}^{\\prime}}=0$$\n\n$$\\left(g_{ds}+{1\\over R_{D}^{\\prime}}\\right)v_{out}\n=\\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}\\right)v_{in}\\tag{8}$$\n\nHence the mid band voltage gain, non inverting,\n\n$${A_{v}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=\n{g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}\\over g_{ds}+1/R_{D}^{\\prime}}\n=\\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}\\right)\\,\n\\left(r_{o}\\parallel R_{D}^{\\prime}\\right) \\tag{9}}$$\n\n> $$A_{v}\\approx \\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}\\right)\n> \\left(r_{o}\\parallel R_{D}^{\\prime}\\right)\n> \\approx g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\qquad {\\rm for}\\;\\;\n> r_{o}>>R_{D}^{\\prime},\\,g_{m}>>g_{ds},g_{mb}=0\\tag{9a}$$\n\npositive. No Miller multiplication of $C_{gd}$.\n\nIf $R_{S}$ is finite between $S$ and $ac$ ground\nthe usual voltage divider $R_{S}/(R_{S}+R_{in})$\nappears:\n\n$$A_{v, overall}= {R_{S}\\over R_{S}+R_{in}}A_{v}\\tag{9b}$$\n\nwith $R_{in}$ below. For $R_{S}\\to 0$,\n$A_{v, overall}\\to 0$, the degenerate case of the\nfigure, and for $R_{S}\\to\\infty $ (ideal current\nsource bias) $A_{v, overall}\\to A_{v}$.\n\nInput resistance looking into the source with the\ndrain load present. KCL at $S$:\n\n$$i_{in}= -i_{s}= -i_{d}\\;\\;+i_{g}\\approx -i_{d}$$\n\nmore precisely with (5) $i_{s}=-i_{d}$.\n\n$$i_{in}= g_{m}v_{in}+g_{mb}v_{in}+g_{ds}(v_{in}-v_{out})$$\n\nUse (8) to eliminate $v_{out}$:\n\n$$R_{in}\\equiv {v_{in}\\over i_{in}}=\n{1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}}\\,\n{1+g_{ds}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\over 1+R_{D}^{\\prime}/r_{o,eff}}$$\n\nIn compact form\n\n$${R_{in}= {R_{D}^{\\prime}+r_{o}\\over\n1+\\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}\\right)r_{o}}\\approx\n{1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\tag{10}}$$\n\nfor $r_{o}>>R_{D}^{\\prime}$.  Without body effect\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\parallel r_{o} \\approx\n{1\\over g_{m}}\\;\\; 20-500\\,{\\rm \\Omega\\;typical}\\tag{10a}$$\n\nSo the $CG$ is a low $Z_{in}$ stage, current buffer,\noften used for $50\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$ matching, as\ncascode device and as wide band stage because\n$C_{gd}$ is not Miller multiplied.\n\nWith a finite source bias resistor $R_{S}$ to $ac$\nground the resistance seen by the source $v_{in}$\n\n$$R_{in,tot}=R_{S}\\parallel R_{in}\\approx R_{S}\\parallel\n{1\\over g_{m}}\\tag{10b}$$\n\nFor the literal figure $R_{S}=0$, $R_{in,tot}=0$.\n\nOutput resistance looking into the drain with source\nresistance $R_{S}$ ($R_{sig}$) :\n\n$$R_{o,drain}=r_{o}\\left[1+\\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}\\right)\nR_{S}^{\\prime}\\right]+R_{S}^{\\prime}\\tag{11}$$\n\nwhere $R_{S}^{\\prime}=R_{S}\\parallel R_{sig}$.\nFor $R_{S}^{\\prime}=0$:\n\n$${R_{o,drain}=r_{o}\\tag{11a}}$$\n\nand the total $ac$ resistance at the output node\n\n$${R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{o,drain}\\approx R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\n\\approx R_{D}\\tag{12}}$$\n\nFor $R_{S}^{\\prime}\\ne 0$ the $CG$ boosts $r_{o}$ by\n$g_{m}r_{o}$, the cascode effect.\n\n{\\bf 3. Frequency response}\n\n* Low frequency: $C_{1}$ gives the input high pass\n\n$$f_{L}= {1\\over 2\\pi R_{in,tot}C_{1}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nwith $R_{in,tot}$ from (10b). For the ideal\n$R_{S}=\\infty $ case $f_{L}= g_{m}/2\\pi C_{1}$.\n$C_{1}$ must be chosen $\\gg 1/\\omega R_{in}$.\n\n* High frequency: dominant pole at the output\n\n$$\\omega_{p,o}\\approx {1\\over R_{out}C_{out}},\\qquad\nC_{out}=C_{db}+C_{gd}+C_{L}\\tag{14}$$\n\nand pole at the low $Z$ input\n\n$$\\omega_{p,in}\\approx {g_{m}+g_{mb}\\over C_{gs}+C_{sb}+C_{in}}\n\\approx {g_{m}\\over C_{gs}} =\\omega_{T}\\tag{15}$$\n\nvery high, which is why the $CG$ and cascode are\nwide band. Zero $\\approx g_{m}/C_{gd}$.\n\nIntrinsic voltage gain $\\times$ bandwidth $\\approx\ng_{m}/C_{out}$.\n\nCorrected practical $CG$ stage therefore consists of\nFig. 1 with the direct ground wire replaced by\n$R_{S}$ to ground or better $I_{S}$ to $-V_{SS}$,\n$R_{S}=r_{OS}$, $C_{1}$ coupling to $S$, $R_{D}$\nto $V_{DD}$. With $I_{S}$ bias $V_{S0}$ self\nadjusts to $V_{B}-V_{GS0}(I_{S})$.\n\nIn words: common gate $=$ common base bipolar,\ncurrent follower, voltage gain $+g_{m}R_{D}$, current\ngain $\\approx 1$, low input, moderate high output\nimpedance, non-inverting, excellent high frequency\nperformance, used as $50\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$ input,\ncurrent buffer, and as the upper device of a\ncascode. As drawn it is shorted and the $ac$\ngain is zero; the short must be replaced by a\nhigh $ac$ impedance bias.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a151db3b53fec828996553bb1c985f45e057ec2af6c56fe9171303a2aa6b62c8"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It explicitly notices that the source is hard-shorted to ground and concludes that the as-drawn circuit has ideally zero gain. The additional common-gate analysis is clearly identified as applying to a corrected, nonliteral circuit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "4fa501e147a166a71d6aa33565bbe693318d65c0c8c788e7a5087eb13c71d3ea",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1898,
        "output_tokens": 8689,
        "total_tokens": 10587,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5770,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1898,
        "output_tokens": 8689,
        "total_tokens": 10587,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5770,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "The device is an $N$ ch. and the conventional\nsymbol is used with ${\\rm arrow}=S=B$.\nIn conventional form:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nD &\\to R_{D}\\to V_{DD} \\cr\nG &\\to V_{B}={\\rm const.} \\cr\nS=B &\\to C_{1}\\to V_{in} \\cr\n{\\rm and} &S\\to {\\rm ground} }$$\n\nis a grounded gate stage.\n$V_{B}$ makes $G$ an a. c. ground {\\it if\nproperly decoupled} and $C_{1}$ is the\nd.c. block, $Z_{C1}=1/sC_{1}\\to 0$ for\n$s\\to j\\omega $ in band.\n\nPut $v_{b}=0$ for signals.\n\n> {\\it As drawn in the literal sense the\n> amplifier is degener at because the $S$\n> node is hard wired to a.c. ground in\n> parallel with $V_{in}$.\n> For $Z_{C1}\\to 0$ $v_{s}=v_{in}\\parallel 0\\equiv 0$\n> so that $v_{gs}=0$ and $v_{o}=0$.\n> In practice the wire marked ground on the\n> $S$ node is a high impedance d.c. bias\n> element, a resistance $R_{S}$ or, ideally,\n> a d.c. current sink $I_{SS}$ with\n> $r_{SS}\\to \\infty $ for signals.\n> With an ideal voltage source driving $C_{1}$\n> you must interpose a finite generator\n> resistance $R_{sig}$. In the following $R_{S}$\n> denotes the total resistance from $S$ to\n> a.c. ground external to the transistor.\n> In the figure $R_{S}=0$ and the formulae\n> can be put $R_{S}=0$. With $R_{S}=0$ the\n> input {\\it looking into} the source is\n> shorted out.}\n\nWith that understanding it is the conventional\ncommon gate, gate common, source in, drain out,\ncurrent buffer, wide band stage.\n\n\\subsubsection*{1. D.C.}\n\n$$V_{GS0}=V_{B}-V_{S0}$$\n\nWith the figure $V_{S0}=0$,\n\n$$V_{GS0}=V_{B}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$I_{D0}={1\\over 2}k_{n}\\left(V_{GS0}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda V_{DS0}\\right]\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$k_{n}= \\mu_{n}C_{ox}{W\\over L}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{T}=V_{T0}\n+\\gamma \\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{SB}}-\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}}\\right)$$\n\nIf $B=S$ as drawn $V_{SB}=0$, $V_{T}=V_{T0}$,\n$g_{mb}=0$.  If $B$ is the substrate ground\n$V_{SB}=V_{S0}$ and $g_{mb}=\\chi g_{m}\\ne 0$.\n\n$$V_{DS0}=V_{DD}-I_{D0}R_{D}-V_{S0}\\tag{3}$$\n\nSaturation, long channel,\n\n$$V_{DS0}\\ge V_{GS0}-V_{T} \\tag{4}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$V_{DD}-I_{D0}R_{D}\\ge V_{B}-V_{T}$$\n\nin the figure, which fixes the permissible\n$V_{B},R_{D}$.\n\n$$g_{m}={\\partial I_{D}\\over \\partial V_{GS}}\n=k_{n}\\left(V_{GS0}-V_{T}\\right)\\left(1+\\lambda V_{DS0}\\right)\n\\approx \\sqrt{2k_{n}I_{D0}} \\tag{5}$$\n\n$$g_{mb}=\\chi g_{m}\\;\\;,\\;\\;r_{o}=1/g_{ds}=1/\\lambda I_{D0}\\tag{6}$$\n\nPower $P_{DC}\\approx V_{DD}I_{D0}$.\n\n\\subsubsection*{2. Low frequency small signal}\n\nFor $\\omega $ in band $C_{1}$ is a short,\n$C_{1}\\gg 1/\\omega R_{in}$.\n\nModel, $v_{g}=0$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nv_{gs}&=v_{g}-v_{s}=-v_{s}\\cr\nv_{bs}&=v_{b}-v_{s}\\cr\nv_{ds}&=v_{d}-v_{s}\\cr\ni_{d}&=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}}$$\n\nwith $g_{mb}=0$ if $B=S$.\nAt the $D$ node, $V_{DD}$ a.c. ground,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{i_{R_{D}}}&={-v_{d}\\over R_{D}}\\cr\n{i_{R_{D}}}&=i_{d}}$$\n\nso that, for $g_{mb}=0$,\n\n$$-{v_{d}\\over R_{D}}= -g_{m}v_{s}+{v_{d}-v_{s}\\over r_{o}} \\tag{7}$$\n\n$${v_{d}\\over v_{s}} ={{g_{m}r_{o}+1\\over r_{o}}R_{D}\\over\n1+R_{D}/r_{o}} = {(g_{m}r_{o}+1)R_{D}\\over r_{o}+R_{D}} \\tag{8}$$\n\n$$A_{v0}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{s}}=\ng_{m}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\right)+{R_{D}\\over r_{o}+R_{D}}\n\\approx g_{m}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\right)\\approx g_{m}R_{D}\n\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;r_{o}\\gg R_{D}\\tag{9}$$\n\nIn phase.  With $B\\ne S$ replace $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\nIn general with a source resistance $R_{S}$,\n\n$$A_{v}= {v_{d}\\over v_{in}}={v_{d}\\over v_{s}}{v_{s}\\over v_{in}}$$\n\nand $v_{s}=v_{in}R_{in}/(R_{sig}+R_{in})$,\nsee below.\n\nNominally $A_{v}>0$.  $v_{s}\\uparrow\\to v_{gs}\\downarrow\n\\to i_{d}\\downarrow\\to V_{R_{D}}\\downarrow\\to v_{d}\\uparrow$.\n\nCurrent gain\n\n$$A_{i}={i_{R_{D}}\\over i_{s}}\\approx -{g_{m}R_{D}\\over 1+g_{m}R_{S}}\n\\cdot {1\\over R_{D}}\\,R_{in}\\approx 1 \\tag{10}$$\n\nfor $r_{o}\\to\\infty $, $R_{S}\\to 0$. It is a current\nfollower, power gain $\\approx A_{v}$.\n\nWith normal $R_{D}$ the voltage gain is $10$ to $30\\,{\\rm\ndB}$.\n\n\\subsubsection*{3. Terminal impedances}\n\nLooking {\\it into} the source with $R_{D}$ loading the\ndrain, $v_{test}$ at $S$, $R_{D}$ to ground:\n\n$$R_{in0}\\equiv {v_{s}\\over i_{s}}\\Bigl|_{v_{g}=0}\n={{R_{D}+r_{o}}\\over {1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}+r_{o}/R_{D}}\\,}}\n\\approx {1\\over g_{m}+g_{mb}}\\parallel r_{o} \\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\n\\tag{11}$$\n\nfor $r_{o}\\gg R_{D}$.  Low, $20-200\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$ typical.\nIf the hard wire to ground in the figure is counted\n$R_{in}=R_{in0}\\parallel 0 =0$.\n\nTotal resistance seen by $V_{in}$ through $C_{1}$ is\n$R_{in,tot}=R_{S}\\parallel R_{in0}$. In the figure\n$R_{S}=0$.\n\nLooking {\\it into} the drain with generator resistance\n$R_{sig}$ in series with $S$,\n\n$$R_{out0}\\equiv {v_{d}\\over i_{d}}\\Bigl|_{v_{in}=0}\n= r_{o}\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}^{\\prime}\\right]+R_{S}^{\\prime}\n\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$R_{S}^{\\prime}=R_{sig}\\parallel R_{S}$$\n\nSeen at the output terminal through $R_{D}$:\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{out0}\\tag{13}$$\n\nFor $R_{S}^{\\prime}=0$, $R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx R_{D}$.\nFor $R_{S}^{\\prime}\\ne 0$ the output is boosted by\n$\\approx g_{m}r_{o}$; this is the cascode effect.\nThat is why $CG$ is used as the upper device of a\ncascode.\n\nIf $R_{S}=0$ as drawn $R_{out0}=r_{o}$.\n\n\\subsubsection*{4. Frequency response}\n\nAdd $C_{1}$:\n\n$$H(s)={sC_{1}R_{in,tot}\\over 1+sC_{1}R_{in,tot}}\\,\nA_{v0}\\,{1\\over 1+sR_{out}C_{L}} \\tag{14}$$\n\nwith $C_{L}$ the load at $D$ including $C_{gd},C_{db}$.\nLow cut off\n\n$$f_{L}\\approx {1\\over 2\\pi R_{in,tot}C_{1}} \\tag{15}$$\n\nvery high because $R_{in,tot}$ is small.\nHigh cut off dominated by $R_{out}C_{L}$,\n\n$$f_{H}\\approx {1\\over 2\\pi R_{out}C_{L}} \\tag{16}$$\n\nNo Miller multiplication of $C_{gd}$ because $G$ is\ngrounded. Hence the $CG$ is intrinsically wide band,\nused as RF LNA input stage with $1/g_{m}=50\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$\nmatch, as current buffer and as cascode device.\n\nFor the literal figure $R_{in,tot}=0$, $f_{L}\\to\\infty $,\nno signal is transmitted at any finite $C_{1}$.\n\nIn practice replace the hard ground by e.g.\n\n$$\\;S\\to R_{S}\\to {\\rm ground\\;or}\\;S\\to I_{SS}\\to {\\rm ground}\\;$$\n\nwith $R_{S}=V_{S0}/I_{D0}$ or $I_{SS}=I_{D0}$, choose $V_{B}$\nso that (4) is satisfied, decouple $V_{B}$ to ground with a\nlarge $C_{B}$ so that $v_{g}=0$, and choose $C_{1}\\gg\n1/2\\pi f_{min}R_{in0}$.  Then (9),(11),(13) are the\nuseful design equations.  With body effect $g_{m}\\to\ng_{m}+g_{mb}$ throughout.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "2604443c599e1c84c27c6e8affe94552903a35f18bdc3444ad255832e4992cea"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly notices that the source is hard-shorted to ground and concludes that the input signal is nulled, giving ideally zero output gain. The additional common-gate discussion does not change that conclusion for the circuit as drawn.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "4fa501e147a166a71d6aa33565bbe693318d65c0c8c788e7a5087eb13c71d3ea",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1891,
        "input_tokens": 1898,
        "output_tokens": 10135,
        "total_tokens": 12033,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7394,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1891,
        "input_tokens": 1898,
        "output_tokens": 10135,
        "total_tokens": 12033,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7394,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-010-source-input-shorted-to-ground/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a nominally $Grounded$ $Gate$, \n$Source$ $Driven$, $Drain$ $Loaded$ stage.\ni.e. a $Common$ $Gate$ $CG$ voltage / current\nbuffer. As drawn it is degenerate.\n\n```\n               VDD AC gnd\n                |\n               RD\n                | Vout = VDD-ID.RD -id.RD\n                D\n        Vb --- G M1   vgs = vg-vs\n                S <-- body if 3T\n                |\n Vin --C1--+----o---- GND DC = Vs = 0\n           |         AC = vs (?)\n           GND ?\n```\n\n> The circuit as drawn ties the signal source `Vin`\n> through `C1` to a hard `GND`. `GND` is `AC` $0$.\n> So for `AC` $vs =0$ identically, $v_{gs}=0$,\n> $i_{d}=0$, $v_{out}=0$. Voltage gain $ =0$.\n> Input is shorted. It is a drafting error.\n\nThe {\\it intended} circuit is\n\n```\nVin --C1-- S M1 D --RD-- VDD\n            G --Vb AC gnd\n            |\n           ZB -- GND\n```\n\nwhere $Z_{B}$ is the DC bias impedance for the\nsource, $R_{S}$ resistor or $I_{S}$ current source,\n$Z_{B} \\rightarrow \\infty$ for $AC$ if it is a\ncurrent source and $\\approx R_{S}$ if it is a\nresistor. In the limit of the drawing $Z_{B}=0$,\nso the comments below are for $Z_{B}\\ne 0$ and\nfor $C_{1}$ $AC$ short. Put $R_{sig}$ = Thevenin\nresistance of $V_{in}$. For $C_{1}$ short,\n$r_{sig}=R_{sig}$ seen by the source.\n\n### 1. DC bias\n\n$$V_{S,DC}=0\\;{\\rm if}\\;Z_{B}=0$$\n\n$$V_{GS,DC}=V_{G,DC}-V_{S,DC}=V_{b}$$\n\n$$I_{D}= \\frac12 \\mu_{n}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\n\\left(V_{b}-V_{th}\\right)^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right] $$\n\nin saturation\n\n$$V_{DS,DC}=V_{D,DC}-V_{S,DC}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}$$\n\nSaturation condition:\n\n$$V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{th}=V_{ov}$$\n\n$$V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D} \\ge V_{b}-V_{th}$$\n\n$V_{b}$ is chosen to set $I_{D}$ and hence\n$g_{m}$.\n\n$$g_{m}= \\mu_{n}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}V_{ov}\n      =\\sqrt{2\\mu_{n}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}I_{D}}\n      =\\frac{2I_{D}}{V_{ov}}$$\n\n$$g_{mb}= \\chi g_{m}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\\chi =\\frac{\\gamma}\n{2\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}+V_{SB}}}\\approx 0.1-0.3$$\n\n$$r_{o}=1/g_{ds}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$$\n\nIf as symbolised the body is tied to the source\n$V_{SB}=0$, $g_{mb}=0$. If in a $n$-well process\nthe body is the global $GND$, $V_{SB}= -v_{s}$\nfor $AC$ and $g_{mb}\\ne 0$.\n\n$C_{1}$ is a DC block. Its $DC$ value is $0$\nso it does not enter the bias. If the source\n$V_{in}$ has DC component it is blocked.\n\n### 2. Small signal $AC$ - $C_{1}$ short, $V_{DD},V_{b}$ $AC$ $0$\n\nGate grounded, source $=v_{in,ac}=v_{s}$,\ndrain $=v_{out}$.\n\nModel:\n\n$$v_{gs}=v_{g}-v_{s}=-v_{s}$$\n$$v_{bs}=v_{b}-v_{s}=-v_{s}\\; {\\rm if\\; body=GND}$$\n$$=0\\; {\\rm if\\; body=source}$$\n$$v_{ds}=v_{d}-v_{s}=v_{out}-v_{s}$$\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}$$\n\nKCL at drain: $AC$ current in $R_{D}$ + $i_{d}=0$\n\n$$ -\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D}} = i_{d}$$\n\nwith sign $I_{R_{D}}=(V_{DD}-V_{out})/R_{D}$ downwards.\n\n#### Voltage gain\n\n$$-\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D}} = -g_{m}v_{s}-g_{mb}v_{s}\n+g_{ds}(v_{out}-v_{s})$$\n\n$$-\\frac{v_{out}}{R_{D}}-g_{ds}v_{out}=\n-(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds})v_{s}$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{s}}=\n\\frac{g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}}{g_{ds}+G_{D}}$$\n\nwhere $G_{D}=1/R_{D}$\n\n$$A_{v}= (g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds})\\, R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\n      \\approx (g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$$\n\nIf body tied to source $g_{mb}=0$:\n\n$$\\;A_{v}\\approx g_{m}R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx g_{m}R_{D}\\;,\n\\;r_{o}\\gg R_{D}\\; {\\rm non-inverting}$$\n\nPositive, no phase inversion, same as source\nfollower but with voltage amplification.\nCurrent gain $A_{i}=i_{d}/i_{in}\\approx 1$ - it is\na current buffer.\n\nWith finite source resistance $R_{sig}$ in series\nwith $C_{1}$ the divider with $R_{in}$ gives\n\n$$A_{v,eff}= \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = A_{v}\n\\frac{R_{in}}{R_{in}+R_{sig}}=\n\\frac{g_{m}R_{D}}{1+g_{m}R_{sig}}\\; {\\rm approx.}$$\n\nFor $R_{sig}=0$, $A_{v}=g_{m}R_{D}$.\n\nIn the degenerate $Z_{B}=0$, $R_{sig}=0$ drawing,\n$$R_{in}=0$$ as seen from $C_{1}$, $v_{s}=0$ so\n$$A_{v,eff}=0$$ .\n\n#### Input resistance at the source\n\nBy definition $R_{in}=v_{s}/-i_{s}$, $i_{s}=-i_{d}$\nneglecting body.\n\nGeneral:\n\n$$R_{in}= \\frac{R_{D}+r_{o}}{1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}+g_{ds}R_{D}}\n \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m}+g_{mb}} \\parallel r_{o}$$\n\nMore exactly including $R_{D}$:\n\n$$R_{in} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m}+g_{mb}}\\left(1+\\frac{R_{D}}{r_{o}}\\right)\n\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m}+g_{mb}}$$\n\ntypically $20-500\\Omega$. Body tied to source:\n\n$$\\;R_{in}\\approx 1/g_{m}\\;$$\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx 1/g_{m}\\parallel R_{S}\\; {\\rm if}\\;Z_{B}=R_{S}$$\n\nThis low $Z_{in}$ is used for $50\\Omega$ input\nmatching in LNAs: set $g_{m}=20mS$.\n\n#### Output resistance at the drain\n\nLooking into drain with $R_{sig}$ at source:\n\n$$R_{o,drain}= r_{o}\\left[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{sig}\\right]+R_{sig}$$\n\nTotal:\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{o,drain}$$\n\nFor $R_{sig}=0$:\n\n$$R_{o,drain}=r_{o}\\;\\;,\\;\\;R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx R_{D}$$\n\nFor $R_{sig}\\ne 0$, $R_{out}$ is boosted to\n$\\approx g_{m}r_{o}R_{sig}$ - high impedance\ncurrent source, good for cascode.\n\n### 3. Frequency response\n\n* $C_{1}$ with $R_{sig}+R_{in}$ forms input high pass:\n\n$$f_{L}= \\frac{1}{2\\pi C_{1}(R_{sig}+R_{in})}\\approx\n\\frac{g_{m}}{2\\pi C_{1}}$$\n\nmust be $\\ll f_{sig}$. Usually $C_{1}$ large.\n\n* Output pole:\n\n$$f_{H,out}\\approx \\frac{1}{2\\pi (R_{D}\\parallel r_{o})C_{L}}$$\n\nwhere $C_{L}=C_{db}+C_{gd}+C_{load}$.\n\n* No Miller multiplication of $C_{gd}$ because gate\ngrounded. Hence $CG$ has much wider band than $CS$.\n\nIntrinsic input pole $1/2\\pi R_{sig}C_{gs}$ etc.\nis at very high frequency.\n\n### 4. Summary for the intended $CG$\n\n| Parameter | Expression $r_{o}\\to\\infty$ | With $r_{o}$ |\n|-----------|------------------------------|--------------|\n| $A_{v}$ | $+g_{m}R_{D}$ | $+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$ |\n| $A_{i}$ | $\\approx 1$ | $g_{m}/(g_{m}+G_{D})$ |\n| $R_{in}$ | $1/g_{m}$ | $1/(g_{m}+g_{mb})\\parallel r_{o}$ |\n| $R_{out}$| $R_{D}$ | $R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{sig}]$ |\n| Phase | non-inverting $0^{\\circ}$ | |\n| Bandwidth | very wide | |\n\nAdvantages: low $R_{in}$, high $R_{out}$, no Miller,\nwideband, current buffer, good for cascode and\nfor RF $50\\Omega$ matched LNA.\n\nDisadvantages: $R_{in}$ too low for voltage amplifier,\nvoltage gain limited by $R_{D}$.\n\n### 5. Fix\n\nRemove hard $GND$ short at source. Replace by\n\n$$S -- R_{S} -- GND$$ or $$S -- I_{S} -- GND$$\n\nwith $R_{S}=V_{S}/I_{D}$ or $I_{S}=I_{D}$. Then\n$C_{1}$ couples $v_{in}$ to $S$ across $R_{in}\n\\approx 1/g_{m}$ without short. Gate $V_{b}$ should\nbe bypassed to $GND$ with large capacitor if it\ncomes from a resistive divider.\n\nExample: $I_{D}=1mA$, $g_{m}=5mS$, $R_{D}=2k\\Omega$\n$\\Rightarrow A_{v}\\approx 10$, $R_{in}\\approx 200\\Omega$.\n\nThat is the classical common-gate / grounded-gate\namplifier.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "3035819ade6651a8aa312370365f19569c6e19a3759606af5f36f27f152c5866"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies that the source node is hard-shorted to ground, so the input is shorted and the ideal voltage gain from Vin is zero. The additional discussion concerns a hypothetical corrected circuit and does not undermine the essential conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "4fa501e147a166a71d6aa33565bbe693318d65c0c8c788e7a5087eb13c71d3ea",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1898,
        "output_tokens": 8738,
        "total_tokens": 10636,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5952,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1898,
        "output_tokens": 8738,
        "total_tokens": 10636,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5952,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-011-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-011-many-poles-have/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "If you want to count the ${\\rm s}=\\infty $ pole the\ncircuit is a 4 energy store, 4 pole, circuit.  One of the\nstores,\n\n$${\\cal N}_{C}=4\\qquad C_{GS}\\;,\\;C_{GD}\\;,\\;C_{DB}\\;,\\;C_{SB}\n\\tag*{Fig.}$$\n\nis shorted out by the {\\it a. c.} earth on the source so that\nin conventional language it is a 3 store circuit, Fig. 1.  At\nfinite frequencies it is a 2 store circuit, {\\it i. e.} a low\npass of nominal second order, one zero, Fig. 2.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In the conventional ``one pole per capacitor''\n> jargon the circuit is normally quoted as a {\\it three}, {\\it\n> four} with $C_{SB}$, {\\it pole} circuit.  The conventional\n> count includes the pole at ${s}=\\infty $ associated with the\n> shorted $C_{SB}$, and, for $C_{DB}\\ne C_{GD}$, counts $C_{GD}$\n> and $C_{DB}$ as two different poles, although in an exact\n> analysis they coalesce into one second order denominator,\n> Fig. 2.\n\nPut ${R_{0}}^{-1}=0$ for brevity.  With\n\n$$V_{g}\\equiv V_{G}\\qquad V_{d}\\equiv V_{o}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{\\left({{1}\\over {R_{S}}}+{\\rm s}C_{GS}+{\\rm s}C_{GD}\\right)V_{g}\n-{\\rm s}C_{GD}V_{d}}&={{V_{i}}\\over {R_{S}}}\\cr\n{\\left(g_{m}-{\\rm s}C_{GD}\\right)V_{g}\n+\\left({{1}\\over {R_{D}}}+{\\rm s}C_{DB}+{\\rm s}C_{GD}\\right)V_{d}}&=0\\cr}\\tag 1$$\n\nso that, e. {\\it g.}, with\n\n$${\\cal D}({\\rm s})=\\left|{\\matrix{\n{{1}\\over {R_{S}}}+{\\rm s}\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\right) &-{\\rm s}C_{GD}\\cr\ng_{m}-{\\rm s}C_{GD} &{{1}\\over {R_{D}}}+{\\rm s}\\left(C_{DB}+\nC_{GD}\\right)\\cr}}\\right| \\tag 2$$\n\n$${\\cal D}({\\rm s})={{1}\\over {R_{S}R_{D}}}\n+{\\rm s}\\left[{{C_{DB}+C_{GD}}\\over {R_{S}}}+{{C_{GS}+C_{GD}}\\over\n{R_{D}}}+g_{m}C_{GD}\\right]\n+{\\rm s}^{2}\\left[C_{GS}C_{DB}+C_{GS}C_{GD}+C_{GD}C_{DB}\\right] \\tag 3$$\n\nand\n\n$$V_{o}/V_{i}=-{{g_{{m}}-{\\rm s}C_{GD}}\\over {R_{S}{\\cal D}({\\rm\ns})}}\\tag 4$$\n\nis nominally second order with the familiar RHP zero\n\n$${\\rm s}_{z}=+{{g_{m}}\\over {C_{GD}}}\\tag 5$$\n\nThe ${\\rm s}^{2}$ coefficient in (3) is\n\n$$\\Delta_{2}=C_{GS}C_{GD}+C_{GS}C_{DB}+C_{GD}C_{DB}\\tag 6$$\n\nso that, if you want to keep the ${\\rm s}=\\infty $ pole\nassociated with the shorted\n\n$$C_{SB}\\tag 7$$\n\nin the count, (3) is normally written in the conventional\n``${{1}\\over {R_{S}}}+{\\rm s}C_{GS}$ is the input pole and\n${{1}\\over {R_{D}}}+{\\rm s}C_{DB}$ is the output pole and\n${\\rm s}C_{GD}$ Miller multiplies to $C_{GD}(1+g_{m}R_{D})$''\nform as a {\\it three} pole denominator,\n\n$${\\cal D}({\\rm s})\\propto \n\\left(1+{{\\rm s}\\over {{\\rm s}_{GS}}}\\right)\n\\left(1+{{\\rm s}\\over {{\\rm s}_{GD}}}\\right)\n\\left(1+{{\\rm s}\\over {{\\rm s}_{DB}}}\\right) \\tag 8$$\n\nwith, to first order in the Miller approximation,\n\n$${\\rm s}_{GS}^{-1}\\approx R_{S}\\left[C_{GS}+C_{GD}(1+g_{m}R_{D})\\right]\n\\qquad \n{\\rm s}_{DB}^{-1}\\approx R_{D}\\left[C_{DB}+C_{GD}\\right]\\tag 9$$\n\nthe third, $C_{GD}$, pole coalescing with (9) to give the\nsecond order (3).  Including the conventional $s=\\infty $ pole\nof the shorted $C_{SB}$ the circuit is quoted as a four pole\ncircuit with\n\n$${\\rm s}_{SB}^{-1}=R_{SB}C_{SB}\\;\\;,\\;\\;R_{SB}\\rightarrow 0\\tag{10}$$\n\nat infinity.  With $R_{SB}\\ne 0$, {\\it e. g.} with ordinary\nsource degeneration $R_{S}\\rightarrow R_{S}^{\\,\\prime}$,\n$R_{SB}\\ne 0$ (3) becomes third order in the conventional\ncount, fourth order with (10), and (4) exhibits two finite\nzeros.  In the $R_{SB}\\rightarrow 0$ limit the $C_{SB}$ pole\ngoes to ${\\rm s}_{SB}\\rightarrow \\infty $ and the finite\ndeterminant collapses to the second order, one zero, function\n(3)--(4) above, normally referred to for brevity as the\n``two pole'', Miller split input and output pole, plus one RHP\nzero response of the conventional common source stage.  Any\nfinite $R_{o}=r_{o}\\ne \\infty $ just puts $R_{D}\\rightarrow\nR_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$ in (1)--(9).\n\n> {\\it N. B.:} If you count $C_{GD}$ and $C_{DB}$ as distinct\n> poles and keep the $s=\\infty $ pole the textbook answer is\n> ``three finite poles, four poles in toto, one RHP zero'';\n> ``two finite poles plus the pole at infinity'' in exact\n> analysis.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "903cec0c419d462442d5310cf57e89abbc91cf4dc7b41b9d92f66e6118856c11"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The derivation correctly identifies a second-order finite-frequency transfer function and notes that C_SB is shorted, but it then counts spurious poles at infinity and gives three- or four-pole totals. The circuit has two poles.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d6e2d72c604ae3c83e7b25306ecb7ec85736574c7dd1a3f26a206b697a6dabfe",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2122,
        "output_tokens": 5215,
        "total_tokens": 7337,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3658,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2122,
        "output_tokens": 5215,
        "total_tokens": 7337,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3658,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-011-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-011-many-poles-have/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the conventional small signal model the energy\nstorage element which is put in evidence in the\nfigure is\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nC_{GS}&{\\rm gate/node}\\cr \nC_{GD}&{\\rm feed back}\\cr \nC_{DB}&{\\rm drain/node}\\cr \nC_{SB}&{\\rm source/node\\;\\;shorted}}$$\n\nput $g_{o}=0$ for brevity.  With $V_{G}=V_{g}$,\n$V_{D}=V_{o}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{{V_{g}-V_{i}}\\over {R_{S}}}+sC_{GS}V_{g}+sC_{GD}\\left(V_{g}-V_{o}\\right)&=0 \\cr \n{{V_{o}}\\over {R_{D}}}+sC_{DB}V_{o}+sC_{GD}\\left(V_{o}-V_{g}\\right)+g_{m}V_{g}&=0}$$\n\ni. {\\it e.}\n\n$$\\left[ \\matrix{\n{1\\over {R_{S}}}+s\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\right) &-sC_{GD}\\cr \ng_{m}-sC_{GD}&{1\\over {R_{D}}}+s\\left(C_{DB}+C_{GD}\\right)\\cr}\\right]\n\\left[ \\matrix{V_{g}\\cr V_{o}\\cr}\\right] =\\left[ \\matrix{V_{i}/R_{S}\\cr 0\\cr}\\right]\\tag{*}$$\n\nso that, with $D(s)={\\rm det}(*)$,\n\n$$D(s)={1\\over {R_{S}R_{D}}}+s\\left[{{C_{GD}+C_{DB}}\\over {R_{S}}}+\n{{C_{GS}+C_{GD}}\\over {R_{D}}}+g_{m}C_{GD}\\right]+s^{2}\n\\left[C_{GS}C_{DB}+C_{GD}\\left(C_{GS}+C_{DB}\\right)\\right] \\tag{**}$$\n\nand\n\n$${{V_{o}}\\over {V_{i}}}={{-g_{m}+sC_{GD}}\\over {R_{s}D(s)}}\\tag{***}$$\n\nis {\\it a priory} second order in $s$ with one finite\n{\\it feed forward} zero at $s=+g_{m}/C_{GD}$.  In $(**)$\nthe $s^{2}$ coefficient is\n\n$$\\Delta =\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\right)\\left(C_{DB}+C_{GD}\\right)-C_{GD}^{2}\n>0\\tag{+}$$\n\nso that the three capacitors put in evidence in the\nfigure, $C_{GS},C_{GD},C_{DB}$, form the conventional\ncapacitive loop\n\n$$C_{GS}-C_{GD}-C_{DB}-{\\rm earth}-C_{GS}\\tag{++}$$\n\nand $(+)$ is the $\\Delta $ of the loop.  Normally\n$(**)$ is written in the familiar zero value time\nconstant, Miller, form as the product of three,\nformally first order, associated poles.  Putting\nformally $D(s)\\approx \\left(1+s\\tau_{GS}\\right)\n\\left(1+s\\tau _{GD}\\right)\\left(1+s\\tau_{DB}\\right)$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\tau_{GS}&=R_{S}C_{GS}\\cr\n\\tau_{GD}&=\\left(R_{S}+R_{D}\\right)C_{GD}\\approx \nR_{S}C_{GD}^{{\\rm Miller,in}}+R_{D}C_{GD}^{{\\rm Miller,out}}\\cr\n\\tau_{DB}&=R_{D}C_{DB}\\cr} \\tag{+++}$$\n\nso that in the conventional {\\it one time constant per\ncapacitor} language the circuit is normally quoted as\n{\\it three pole, one zero}, {\\it i. e.} in the Miller\napproximation\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\omega_{p,in}^{-1}&\\approx R_{S}\\left[C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\left(1+g_{m}R_{D}\\right)\\right]\\cr\n\\omega _{p,out}^{-1}&\\approx R_{D}\\left[C_{DB}+C_{GD}\\right]\\cr\n\\omega _{p,GD}^{-1}&\\approx \\left(R_{S}\\parallel R_{D}\\right)C_{GD}\\cr}$$\n\nand $(***)$ is normally quoted, with $(+++)$, as\n\n$${{V_{o}}\\over {V_{i}}}\\approx -{{g_{m}R_{D}}\\over {\n\\left(1+s/\\omega_{p,in}\\right)\\left(1+s/\\omega_{p,out}\\right)\n\\left(1+s/\\omega_{p,GD}\\right)}}\\left(1-s/\\omega_{z}\\right)\\tag{++++}$$\n\nwith $\\omega_{z}=g_{m}/C_{GD}$, {\\it i. e.} two\ndominant Miller poles $\\omega_{p,in}$, $\\omega_{p,out}$\nand the normally non dominant feed back pole\n$\\omega_{p,GD}$.  Formally $(**)$ is second order,\nso that one of the three poles in $(++++)$ is\ndependent on the other two through the loop relation\n$(+)$--$(++)$.\n\nIf you keep the normal fourth small signal capacitor,\nthe source bulk capacitor $C_{SB}$ in the figure, the\nconventional count is four capacitors, four associated\ntime constants,\n\n$$\\tau_{SB}=R_{S,S}C_{SB}\\tag{+++++}$$\n\nNormally, as in the figure, the source is a\nconventional earth, $R_{S,S}=0$, so that\n\n$$\\omega_{p,SB}={1\\over {R_{S,S}C_{SB}}}\\rightarrow \\infty \\tag{++++++}$$\n\nand $C_{SB}$ is normally said to be {\\it shorted out}\nor {\\it at infinity} and does not appear in $(*)$--\n$(++++)$.  With $R_{S,S}\\ne 0$, {\\it e. g.} with a\nsource degeneration resistor $R_{S,S}$, $(**)$ becomes\nthird order, $D(s)=D_{0}+sD_{1}+s^{2}D_{2}+s^{3}D_{3}$\nwith $D_{3}=R_{S}R_{D}R_{S,S}\\Delta C_{SB}\\ne 0$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In compact form: two finite poles and\n> one finite RHP zero, three associated first order time\n> constants, $C_{GS},C_{GD},C_{DB}$, four with the\n> normally shorted $C_{SB}$.  In the conventional\n> open circuit time constant - Miller jargon the circuit\n> is quoted as a three pole - four pole with $C_{SB}$ -\n> one zero circuit.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ff2da37c067525461000f8b6ceaa28350cd36ab8b8b53c74df442a390b193ab8"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "The exact nodal determinant is second order, and the answer correctly notes that CSB is shorted while CGS, CGD, and CDB form a capacitor loop. Thus the circuit has two poles; the approximate three-time-constant discussion does not change the exact count.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d6e2d72c604ae3c83e7b25306ecb7ec85736574c7dd1a3f26a206b697a6dabfe",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2122,
        "output_tokens": 5194,
        "total_tokens": 7316,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3600,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2122,
        "output_tokens": 5194,
        "total_tokens": 7316,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3600,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-011-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-011-many-poles-have/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the Miller approxiamtion the small signal\ncircuit is second order. Put ${\\rm g}_{o}\\rightarrow 0$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{\\rm KCL}G:&\\;{{V_{g}-V_{i}}\\over {R_{S}}}+V_{g}sC_{GS}+\n\\left(V_{g}-V_{d}\\right)sC_{GD}=0\\cr\n{\\rm KCL}D:&\\;{{V_{d}}\\over {R_{D}}}+V_{d}sC_{DB}+\n\\left(V_{d}-V_{g}\\right)sC_{GD}+{\\rm g}_{m}V_{g}=0\\tag{*}}$$\n\nso that with\n\n$${\\cal D}(s)={\\rm det}\\left|\\matrix{\n{1\\over {R_{S}}}+s\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\right) &-sC_{GD}\\cr\n{\\rm g}_{m}-sC_{GD} &{1\\over {R_{D}}}+s\\left(C_{DB}+C_{GD}\\right)}\\right|$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{\\cal D}(s)&=s^{2}R_{S}R_{D}\\left[C_{GS}C_{DB}+C_{GD}\n\\left(C_{GS}+C_{DB}\\right)\\right] \\cr\n&+s\\left[R_{S}\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\right)+R_{D}\\left(C_{DB}+\nC_{GD}\\right)+{\\rm g}_{m}R_{S}R_{D}C_{GD}\\right]+1\\cr\n&\\propto \\left(1+{s\\over {\\omega _{{p}_{1}}}}\\right)\n\\left(1+{s\\over {\\omega _{{p}_{2}}}}\\right)}$$\n\nis second order in $s$.  E. {\\rm g}. in the conventional\nMiller approximation\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\omega _{{p}_{1}}^{-1}&\\approx R_{S}\\left[C_{GS}+\nC_{GD}\\left(1+{\\rm g}_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\right)\\right]\\cr\n\\omega _{{p}_{2}}^{-1}&\\approx R_{D}^{\\prime}\\left[C_{DB}+\nC_{GD}{{1+C_{GS}/C_{GD}}\\over {1+{\\rm g}_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}}}\\right]\n\\approx R_{D}^{\\prime}C_{DB}\\qquad {\\rm g}_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\gg 1\\cr\nR_{D}^{\\prime}&=R_{D}\\Vert r_{o}\\approx R_{D}}$$\n\nand, from the ${\\rm g}_{m}-sC_{GD}$ term in $(*)$ a\n{\\it bona fide} right half plane zero,\n\n$${\\cal N}(s)\\propto {\\rm g}_{m}-sC_{GD}\\tag{**}$$\n\ni. {\\rm e}.\n\n$${{V_{o}}\\over {V_{i}}}(s)\\propto -{{{\\rm g}_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\n\\left(1-sC_{GD}/{\\rm g}_{m}\\right)}\\over \n{\\left(1+s/\\omega _{{p}_{1}}\\right)\\left(1+s/\\omega _{{p}_{2}}\n\\right)}}\\tag{***}$$\n\nnormalised to $-{\\rm g}_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}$ at $s=0$, viz.\na two pole and one zero small signal circuit.  In\nparticular the {\\lq\\lq} Miller'' zero is at\n\n$$\\omega _{z}=+{{{\\rm g}_{m}}\\over {C_{GD}}}\\tag{****}$$\n\nin the RHP.  Topologically there are three\n[four] small signal storage elements in the drawer,\n$C_{GS}$, $C_{GD}$ and $C_{DB}$ [and $C_{SB}$] so that\nthe network is normally quoted as third [fourth] order.\n$C_{SB}$ is connected between two incremental grounds,\nFig. 1, so that its pole is normally said to have been\npushed to\n\n$$\\omega _{{p}_{SB}}={1\\over {R_{SB}}C_{SB}}\\rightarrow \\infty\n\\qquad R_{SB}=0\\tag{\\dag }$$\n\nand is normally neglected, neglected altogether in $(*)$.\nIf you want to keep the count it is a $3$ pole [$4$\npole] network with $\\left|\\omega _{{p}_{SB}}\\right|=\n\\infty $.  In the conventional language the circuit is\nnormally referred to as a {\\lq\\lq} $3$ pole'' circuit,\ntwo finite poles plus the pole at infinity associated\nwith the short circuited $C_{SB}$.  With the zero $(**)$\ncounted as a pole at infinity it is a fourth order\nnetwork.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  With $r_{o}<\\infty $ put $R_{D}\\rightarrow\n> R_{D}\\Vert r_{o}=R_{D}^{\\prime}$ {\\it passim.}\n\nIn most text books the $\\left|\\omega _{{p}_{SB}}\\right|\n\\rightarrow \\infty $ pole is simply neglected and the\ncircuit is quoted as the conventional two pole Miller\namplifier $(***)$--$(****)$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "53a8e69d4b6d379af69f700ac405776bd9778112c9287e23d2c3b5524aadc39a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The determinant correctly gives a second-order denominator and two finite poles, but the answer then explicitly counts a third pole from the shorted C_SB (and even a fourth order by counting the zero). C_SB contributes no pole, so this conflicting pole count is a major error.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d6e2d72c604ae3c83e7b25306ecb7ec85736574c7dd1a3f26a206b697a6dabfe",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2019,
        "input_tokens": 2122,
        "output_tokens": 4605,
        "total_tokens": 6727,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3351,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2019,
        "input_tokens": 2122,
        "output_tokens": 4605,
        "total_tokens": 6727,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3351,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the 1 transistor series - shunt\n{\\it voltage - series } feedback amplifier.\nUsually drawn as\n\n$$V_{in}\\to {\\rm Source}~~,~~{\\rm Gate}=V_{F}=\n{\\cal F}(V_{out})~~,~~{\\rm Drain}=V_{out}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{D}&=I_{D}(V_{GS},V_{DS})\\cr\nV_{F}&=V_{out}{\\cal F}\\cr\nV_{GS}&=V_{F}-V_{in}\\cr\nV_{DS}&=V_{out}-V_{in}}$$\n\nFor $R_{1},R_{2}>>R_{D}$ the feedback network is\nalmost unilateral and\n$${\\cal F}_{0}\\approx \\beta ={R_{2}\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}\\tag{1}$$\nand\n$$V_{F}= \\beta V_{out} \\qquad i_{G}=0$$\n\nIn the more exact low frequency unilateral model the\noutput node is loaded by $R_{1}+R_{2}$ so that with\nAC ground on $V_{DD}$\n\n$$R_{p}=R_{D}\\parallel (R_{1}+R_{2})\\parallel r_{o}\\approx R_{D}$$\n$${\\cal F}= \\beta =R_{2}/(R_{1}+R_{2})$$\n\nM1 is supposed in saturation, bulk to source so no\n$g_{mb}$:\n\n$$I_{D}={k_{n}\\over 2}(V_{GS}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{DS})$$\nfor hand calculation $\\lambda =0$\n\n$$I_{D0}(V_{F0}-V_{in0},V_{out0})={V_{DD}-V_{out0}\\over R_{D}}\n- {V_{out0}\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}\\approx {V_{DD}-V_{out0}\\over R_{D}}$$\n\n$$V_{GS0}=V_{F0}-V_{in0}>V_{T}\\tag{2}$$\n$$V_{DS0}=V_{out0}-V_{in0}>V_{GS0}-V_{T}\\tag{3}$$\n\n(2)(3) + $V_{F0}=\\beta V_{out0}$ determine the Q sec bias.\nPut $V_{GS0}=V_{F0}-V_{in0}$ in $I_{D}$, $V_{out}=V_{DD}-R_{D}I_{D}$\nthe usual quadratic for $V_{GS0}$.\nE.{\\it g.} for $\\lambda =0$\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}-R_{D}{k_{n}\\over 2}(\\beta V_{out}-V_{in}-V_{T})^{2}$$\n\n$$V_{out}(V_{in})\\;\\;{\\rm decreasing\\;with\\;}V_{in}.$$\n\nFor $V_{in}$ large $V_{GS}<V_{T}$, $M_{1}$ off\n\n$$V_{out,off}=V_{DD}{R_{1}+R_{2}\\over R_{D}+R_{1}+R_{2}}\\approx V_{DD}$$\n\nfor $V_{in}$ very negative $M_{1}$ in triode.\n\nIn normal bias with $R_{1}+R_{2}>>R_{D}$ it is approx.\ncommon gate.\n\n> Negative feedback: $V_{out}\\uparrow \\to V_{F}\\uparrow\n\\to V_{GS}\\uparrow \\to I_{D}\\uparrow \\to R_{D}I_{D}\\uparrow\n\\to V_{out}\\downarrow $\n\nde-sensitised.\n\n### Small signal - loop\n\n$$g_{m}=\\left.{\\partial I_{D}\\over \\partial V_{GS}}\\right|_{Q}\n\\qquad g_{ds}=1/r_{o}=\\left.{\\partial I_{D}\\over \\partial V_{DS}}\\right|_{Q}\n\\qquad g_{mb}=0$$\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}\n      =g_{m}(v_{f}-v_{in})+g_{ds}(v_{out}-v_{in})\\tag{4}$$\n\nand, AC,\n\n$$v_{f}=\\beta v_{out}\\tag{5}$$\n\nKCL at the output, no test source:\n\n$$i_{D\\;{\\rm into\\;D}}+i_{R_{D}}+i_{R_{1}}=0$$\n\n$${\\rm AC:}\\;\\;i_{d}+{v_{out}\\over R_{D}}+{v_{out}-v_{f}\\over R_{1}}=0$$\n\n$$ -i_{d}=v_{out}\\left({1\\over R_{D}}+{1\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}\\right)\n       =v_{out}/R_{p0}\\tag{6}$$\n$$R_{p0}=R_{D}\\parallel (R_{1}+R_{2})$$\n\nNeglecting $1/(R_{1}+R_{2})$ vs $1/R_{D}$, $R_{p0}\\approx R_{D}$.\n\nFrom (4)(5)(6)\n\n$$-g_{m}(\\beta v_{out}-v_{in})-g_{ds}(v_{out}-v_{in})=v_{out}/R_{p0}$$\n\n$$v_{in}(g_{m}+g_{ds})=v_{out}\\left({1\\over R_{p0}}+g_{ds}+g_{m}\\beta\\right)$$\n\n> $$\\;A_{vf}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=\n{g_{m}+g_{ds}\\over g_{ds}+1/R_{p0}+g_{m}\\beta }\\; \\tag{7}$$\n\nFor $r_{o}\\to \\infty ,\\;R_{1}+R_{2}\\to \\infty ,\\;R_{p0}\\to R_{D}$\n\n> $$A_{vf}\\approx {g_{m}R_{D}\\over 1+g_{m}R_{D}\\beta }\n={1\\over \\beta}{L\\over 1+L}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$$L=g_{m}R_{p0}\\beta \\approx g_{m}R_{D}\\beta \\tag{9}$$\n\nis the loop gain. The open loop, $\\beta =0$, gate AC\nground, is the ordinary common gate stage\n\n$$A_{v0}= (g_{m}+g_{ds})R_{p0}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx g_{m}R_{D}$$\npositive, non inverting at the source.\n\n$$A_{vf}= {A_{v0}\\over 1+A_{v0}\\beta}$$\n\nde-sensitised to $g_{m},R_{D}$.\n\nFor large $L>>1$\n\n$$A_{vf}\\to A_{vf,ideal}=1/\\beta ={R_{1}+R_{2}\\over R_{2}}\n=1+{R_{1}\\over R_{2}}\\tag{10}$$\n\nas for the non inverting op-amp.\nNormally $L\\sim 2-10$ for a single MOS so (10) is\nonly approx. E.g. $g_{m}=5{\\rm mA/V},R_{D}=2{\\rm k},\n\\beta =0.2$, $L=2$, $A_{vf}=g_{m}R_{D}/(1+L)=3.3$\nvs $A_{ideal}=5$.\n\nWith finite $r_{o}$\n\n$$L = g_{m}\\beta \\,R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}\\parallel (R_{1}+R_{2})$$\n$$A_{vf}= {(g_{m}r_{o}+1)\\over 1+r_{o}/R_{p0}+g_{m}r_{o}\\beta}$$\n\nIf bulk to GND, $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\n\nFeedback is {\\it voltage sampled, series mixed} ,\nseries-shunt in 2 port terminology. Ideal\nfeedback theory:\n\n* voltage sampling $\\to Z_{out}$ lowered by $1+L$\n* series mixing $\\to Z_{in}$ raised by $1+L$\n\nIndeed, with input shorted $v_{in}=0$, inject $v_{x}$ at\noutput, $v_{f}=\\beta v_{x}$\n\n$$i_{x}= {v_{x}\\over R_{p0}}+i_{d}=v_{x}/R_{p0}+g_{m}\\beta v_{x}+g_{ds}v_{x}$$\n\n> $$Z_{out,f}= {v_{x}\\over i_{x}}={1\\over 1/R_{p0}+g_{ds}+g_{m}\\beta }\n={R_{p0}\\parallel r_{o}\\over 1+L}\\approx {R_{D}\\over 1+g_{m}R_{D}\\beta}\\tag{11}$$\n\nWithout feedback, $Z_{out,0}=R_{p0}\\parallel r_{o}\\approx R_{D}$\nas expected. Feedback makes the output a good voltage\nsource, $Z_{out,f}\\to 1/g_{m}\\beta$ for large $L$.\n\nLooking into the source with $v_{in}=v_{x}$, $v_{out}=A_{vf}v_{x}$,\nthe current injected into the source is $i_{x}=-i_{d}$\nand from (6) $-i_{d}=v_{out}/R_{p0}$ so that\n\n$$i_{x}=v_{out}/R_{p0}=A_{vf}v_{x}/R_{p0}$$\n\nMore directly $i_{x}=-g_{m}(\\beta v_{out}-v_{x})-g_{ds}(v_{out}-v_{x})$.\nUsing (7)\n\n> $$Z_{in,f}={v_{x}\\over i_{x}}={1/R_{p0}+g_{ds}+g_{m}\\beta\\over (g_{m}+g_{ds})1/R_{p0}}\n={1+g_{m}\\beta R_{p0}+g_{ds}R_{p0}\\over g_{m}+g_{ds}}\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$Z_{in,0}= {1+g_{ds}R_{p0}\\over g_{m}+g_{ds}}\\approx 1/g_{m}$$\n\nis the ordinary low CG input resistance.\n\n> $$Z_{in,f}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}+ \\beta R_{p0}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}+{R_{D}R_{2}\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}\\tag{13}$$\nfor $r_{o}\\to\\infty$.\n\ni.e. increased by $\\approx (1+L)/g_{m}R_{p0}\\times R_{p0}$.\nThis is used to get $50\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$ match with modest\n$g_{m}$ for wide band LNA, etc.\n\nIn Blackman form $Z_{in}=Z_{in,0}(1+L_{sc})/(1+L_{oc})$.\n\nConsequences: gain stabilized to resistor ratio, linearity\nand PSRR improved by $1+L$, bandwidth extended by $1+L$,\ndominant pole at output $\\omega_{p,out}=1/R_{p0}C_{out}$\npushed to $\\omega_{p,f}=(1+L)/R_{p0}C_{out}$.\n\nSingle pole loop, unconditionally stable, phase margin\n$\\sim 90^{o}$ if $R_{1}+R_{2}$ parasitic small.\n\nIn large signal the circuit is the basic shunt regulator\n/LDO error amplifier, wide band voltage amplifier,\nregulated cascode input stage. With $R_{1},R_{2}\\to\\infty$\nit reverts to open loop common gate $A_{v}=g_{m}R_{D}$,\n$Z_{in}=1/g_{m}$, $Z_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f72fe5d8e86d7b49f2984002698783fb76e5b678f7ae021e571a55c8128d538c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-driven transistor, output-divider feedback to the gate, and negative feedback. Its closed-loop gain is consistent with the golden result, approaching 1/β = 1 + R1/R2 at high loop gain; extra secondary discussion does not undermine the essential analysis.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c4eb57e96a0e70ff6aa718bcfd4e80be89f93bd2bf97d638ee206a2ecd64f575",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1766,
        "output_tokens": 10878,
        "total_tokens": 12644,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8291,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1766,
        "output_tokens": 10878,
        "total_tokens": 12644,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8291,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In its essential form it is a shunt at the output\nseries at the input, voltage series feedback\n$=$ series shunt in Gray-Meyer\n${\\rm sampling}- {\\rm shunt} \\; :{\\rm voltage}$\n${\\rm mixing}-{\\rm series}\\;:{\\rm voltage}$ amplifier.\nIn discrete form it is a common gate with its\ngate slaved to the output by $R_{1},R_{2}$ so\nthat it looks like a non inverting ${\\rm OP AMP}$\nwith gain $1+R_{1}/R_{2}$. In the ideal\nfeedback sense it is a transconductance\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}-CG & {\\rm forward\\; path}\\cr\nR_{1}-R_{2} & {\\rm feedback\\; path} \\cr}$$\n\n$$V_{F}= \\beta V_{o}\\qquad \n\\beta ={{V_{F}}\\over {V_{o}}}\\bigg|_{{g_{m}=0}}$$\n\nIf the gate draws no current\n\n$${{(V_{o}-V_{F})}\\over {R_{1}}}={{V_{F}}\\over {R_{2}}}$$\n\n$$V_{F}={{R_{2}}\\over {R_{1}+R_{2}}}V_{o}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$\\beta _{0}={{R_{2}}\\over {R_{1}+R_{2}}}= {1\\over {1+R_{1}/R_{2}}}\\tag{2}$$\n\nin the conventional two port sense the $R_{1}+R_{2}$\nloads the output so that with $V_{DD}$ a.c. ground\n\n$$R_{D}^{\\prime}=R_{D}\\parallel (R_{1}+R_{2})\\parallel\nR_{L} \\tag{3}$$\n\nis the load seen by the drain for $R_{L}=\\infty $,\n$R_{D}^{\\prime}=R_{D}\\parallel (R_{1}+R_{2})$.\nFor $R_{1}+R_{2}\\gg R_{D}$, $R_{D}^{\\prime}\\approx\nR_{D}$.\n\nLet for $M_{1}$\n\n$$I_{D}=F(V_{GS},V_{DS})\\qquad V_{GS}=V_{F}-V_{in}\\qquad\nV_{DS}=V_{o}-V_{in}$$\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}\n\\tag{4}$$\n\nwhere in the usual 4 terminal $n$MOS\n$v_{bs}=-v_{in}$ if the bulk is to\nac ground and $v_{bs}=0$ if the bulk is\nstrapped to the source as drawn.\nPut $g_{m}^{\\prime}=g_{m}+g_{mb}$ for the\nformer and $g_{m}^{\\prime}=g_{m}$ for the\nlatter and $g_{o}=g_{ds}=r_{o}^{-1}$.\n\nIn small signal for ac ground on $V_{DD}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nv_{gs}&=v_{F}-v_{in}= \\beta v_{o}-v_{in}\\cr\nv_{ds}&=v_{o}-v_{in}\\cr\ni_{d}&=g_{m}(\\beta v_{o}-v_{in})+g_{mb}(-v_{in})\n+g_{o}(v_{o}-v_{in})\\cr\n&= (g_{m}\\beta +g_{o})v_{o}-(g_{m}^{\\prime}+g_{o})v_{in}\n\\tag{5}}$$\n\nKCL at the $V_{o}$ node, $i_{d}$ taken as\nfrom $D$ to $S$ {\\it i. e.} out of the\n$V_{o}$ node into the drain\n\n$$i_{d}+{{v_{o}-v_{F}}\\over {R_{1}}}+{{v_{o}}\\over {R_{D}}}=0\n\\tag{6}$$\n\nwith the gate open\n\n$${{v_{o}-v_{F}}\\over {R_{1}}}={{v_{F}}\\over {R_{2}}}\n={{v_{o}}\\over {R_{1}+R_{2}}} \\tag{7}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$i_{d}=-v_{o}\\left[{1\\over {R_{D}}}+{1\\over {R_{1}+R_{2}}}\\right]\n=-{v_{o}\\over {R_{D}^{\\prime}}} \\tag{8}$$\n\n$$v_{o}=-R_{D}^{\\prime}i_{d} \\tag{9}$$\n\nThe conventional common gate voltage\nfall is recovered for $\\beta =0$, $R_{1}+R_{2}\\to \\infty $,\n$v_{o}=-g_{m}R_{D}v_{gs}$ with sign taken\nwith $v_{gs}=-v_{in}$.\n\nInsert (5) in (8):\n\n$$(g_{m}\\beta +g_{o})v_{o}-(g_{m}^{\\prime}+g_{o})v_{in}\n=-{v_{o}\\over {R_{D}^{\\prime}}}$$\n\n$$v_{o}\\left[g_{m}\\beta +g_{o}+{1\\over {R_{D}^{\\prime}}}\\right]\n=(g_{m}^{\\prime}+g_{o})v_{in} \\tag{10}$$\n\n$$\\;A_{v}\\equiv {{v_{o}}\\over {v_{in}}}=\n{{g_{m}^{\\prime}+g_{o}}\\over {g_{m}\\beta +g_{o}+1/R_{D}^{\\prime}}}\\;\n>0 \\tag{11}$$\n\nFor $r_{o}\\to \\infty $, $g_{o}\\to 0$ and\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx {{g_{m}^{\\prime}}\\over {g_{m}\\beta +1/R_{D}^{\\prime}}}\n={1\\over \\beta }{{g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\beta }\n\\over {1+g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\beta }}{g_{m}^{\\prime}\\over g_{m}} \\tag{12}$$\n\nE.g. with the bulk to source, $g_{m}^{\\prime}=g_{m}$,\n\n$$A_{v}= {1\\over \\beta }{T\\over {1+T}}\\qquad \nT=g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\beta \\tag{13}$$\n\n$T$ is the return ratio, loop gain, of the\ncircuit. In two port loop language the\ncommon source forward gain is\n\n$$A_{0}= -g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\tag{14}$$\n\nwith inversion, so that the loop gain is\n\n$$LG = -A_{0}\\beta = g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\beta =T \\tag{15}$$\n\nand (13) is the Blackman asymptotic gain formula\n$A_{v}=A_{0}/(1-LG\\cdot {\\rm sign})=1/\\beta \\times\nT/(1+T)$.\n\nFor\n\n$$T=g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}{{R_{2}}\\over {R_{1}+R_{2}}}\\gg 1$$\n\n$$A_{vf}\\approx {1\\over \\beta }={{R_{1}+R_{2}}\\over {R_{2}}}\n=1+{{R_{1}}\\over {R_{2}}} \\tag{16}$$\n\nindependent of $g_{m},R_{D}$ to first order.\nThe feedback is negative: $\\uparrow V_{in}\\to\n\\downarrow V_{GS}\\to \\downarrow I_{D}\\to \\uparrow\nV_{o}\\to \\uparrow V_{F}\\to \\uparrow V_{GS}$ which\nopposes the initial decrease. The closed loop\ngain is desensitized $dA_{vf}/A_{vf}=\n(1/1+T)dA_{0}/A_{0}$, non linear distortion\nreduced by $1+T$, bandwidth increased by\n$1+T$. With the usual sign taken with respect\nto the gate, $v_{o}/v_{g}=-g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}$\ninverting, so that with $v_{in}$ applied to the\ngate $A_{vf}\\approx -R_{1}/R_{2}$ the familiar\ninverting ${\\rm OP}$.\n\nWith the bulk to ground $g_{m}^{\\prime}=g_{m}+g_{mb}$\n\n$$A_{vf}\\approx {1\\over \\beta }\\left(1+{{g_{mb}}\\over {g_{m}}}\\right)\n \\approx {1+{R_{1}/R_{2}}\\over {1+g_{mb}/g_{m}}^{-1}} \\tag{16a}$$\n\nnormally $<20\\%$ correction.\n\n> {\\it Remarks:} The $+1+R_{1}/R_{2}$ is the ideal\n> non inverting gain. If the input is taken at the\n> gate and the source grounded, the same circuit\n> becomes the inverting shunt-shunt amplifier with\n> $A_{v}\\approx -R_{1}/R_{2}$.\n\nInput resistance at the source: $R_{i0}\\approx\n1/(g_{m}^{\\prime}+g_{o})$ for the open loop CG\nstage. Series mixing raises it:\n\nPut $v_{in}=v_{x}$ test at the source, $v_{o}=-i_{d}\nR_{D}^{\\prime}$. From (5) $i_{d}=-i_{in}$ the\ncurrent entering the source\n\n$$i_{in}=-i_{d}= -g_{m}\\beta v_{o}+g_{m}^{\\prime}v_{x}\n-g_{o}v_{o}+g_{o}v_{x}$$\n\n$$i_{in}=v_{x}(g_{m}^{\\prime}+g_{o})+v_{o}(g_{m}\\beta +g_{o})$$\n\nwith $v_{o}=-i_{d}R_{D}^{\\prime}=i_{in}R_{D}^{\\prime}$\n\n$$i_{in}\\left[1-R_{D}^{\\prime}(g_{m}\\beta +g_{o})\\right]\n=v_{x}(g_{m}^{\\prime}+g_{o})$$\n\nWith sign consistent with (8) $i_{in}= -i_{d}$,\n\n$$\\,R_{if}\\equiv {{v_{x}}\\over {i_{in}}}=\n{{1+(g_{m}\\beta +g_{o})R_{D}^{\\prime}}\\over {g_{m}^{\\prime}+g_{o}}}\\, \\tag{17}$$\n\n$$\\approx {1\\over {g_{m}^{\\prime}}}+ \\beta {g_{m}\\over\ng_{m}^{\\prime}}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\approx {1\\over {g_{m}}}\n+{{R_{2}}\\over {R_{1}+R_{2}}}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\qquad g_{o}\\to 0 \\tag{18}$$\n\n$$R_{if}=R_{i0}(1+T)\\tag{19}$$\n\nvoltage series feedback raises $R_{in}$.\nE.g. $R_{D}^{\\prime}=2\\,{\\rm k}\\Omega $,\n$R_{1}=9\\,{\\rm k}$, $R_{2}=1\\,{\\rm k}$, $\\beta =0.1$,\n$g_{m}=5\\,{\\rm mS}$: $R_{i0}=200\\,\\Omega$, $T=1$,\n$R_{if}\\approx 400\\,\\Omega$; for large $T$,\n$R_{if}\\approx \\beta R_{D}\\sim 0.2-1\\,{\\rm k}\\Omega $,\nusable for wide band $50\\,\\Omega $ matching\nby proper choice of $R_{D}$ and $\\beta $.\n\nOutput resistance: With $v_{in}=0$ put $v_{x}$ at\nthe output, bulk to source for simplicity,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nv_{gs}&=\\beta v_{x}\\cr\nv_{ds}&=v_{x}\\cr\ni_{d}&=g_{m}\\beta v_{x}+g_{o}v_{x}\\cr\ni_{x}&={{v_{x}}\\over {R_{D}}}+i_{d}+{{v_{x}}\\over {R_{1}+R_{2}}}\\cr\n&={{v_{x}}\\over {R_{D}^{\\prime}}}+v_{x}(g_{m}\\beta+g_{o})\n\\tag{20}}$$\n\n$${R_{of}\\equiv {{v_{x}}\\over {i_{x}}}=\n{1\\over {1/R_{D}^{\\prime}+g_{m}\\beta+g_{o}}}\\tag{21}}$$\n\nthe impedance seen looking into the whole\nstage including $R_{D}$. The impedance looking\ninto the drain itself, $R_{o}^{\\ast}=v_{x}/(i_{x}-\nv_{x}/R_{D})$,\n\n$$R_{o}^{\\ast}={1\\over {1/(R_{1}+R_{2})+g_{m}\\beta+g_{o}}}\n\\approx {1\\over {g_{m}\\beta}}\\qquad T\\gg 1 \\tag{22}$$\n\n$$\\;R_{of}=R_{o0}/(1+T)\\parallel R_{D}\\;$$\n\nwith $R_{o0}\\approx r_{o}$ for $R_{S}=0$;\nshunt, voltage, sampling lowers $R_{out}$ by\n$1+T$, as expected for a voltage amplifier.\nWith a finite source resistance $R_{S}$ at the\ninput the familiar CG formula\n$R_{o0}\\approx r_{o}[1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}]+R_{S}$\nis divided by $1+T$.\n\nDC bias: $V_{o}=V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{D}$,\n$V_{F}=V_{o}R_{2}/(R_{1}+R_{2})$,\n$V_{GS}=V_{F}-V_{in,DC}$,\n$I_{D}=(k_{n}/2)(V_{GS}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{DS})$\nin saturation, $V_{DS}=V_{o}-V_{in,DC}>V_{GS}-V_{Tn}$.\nSolved self consistently it sets the gate bias\nwithout extra supply.\n\nFrequency and stability: Loop $T(s)=g_{m}Z_{D}(s)\\beta(s)$,\n$Z_{D}=R_{D}^{\\prime}\\parallel 1/sC_{L}$,\n$\\beta(s)=R_{2}\\parallel 1/sC_{F}$/$[(R_{1}\\parallel 1/sC_{F})+\\cdots]$\nUsually $p_{1}\\approx 1/R_{D}^{\\prime}C_{L}$ dominant at\nthe output, $p_{2}\\approx 1/(R_{1}\\parallel R_{2})C_{gg}$\nat the gate. With $p_{2}\\gg GBW=T_{0}p_{1}$ the\namplifier is single pole stable with $\\approx 90^{o}$\nphase margin and closed loop bandwidth\n$BW_{f}\\approx (1+T_{0})BW_{0}$. $C_{gd}$ gives a\nfeed forward zero. Elaborated with $r_{o}$ it is\nthe low voltage regulated cascode building block\nused for wide band LNA input matching, as level\nshifter, and as error amplifier in LDO's.\n\nIn short the circuit is a stable negative\nfeedback voltage amplifier whose closed loop gain\nis set by the resistor ratio and whose $Z_{in}$\nis raised and $Z_{out}$ lowered by the return\nratio $T=g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}R_{2}/(R_{1}+R_{2})$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "3bab18c632e44cf6777392b36a1e3bb5f228177261bb62fcaab189d787be6d10"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source input, output-divider feedback to the gate, and negative feedback; its high-loop-gain result is the correct non-inverting gain, 1 + R1/R2.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c4eb57e96a0e70ff6aa718bcfd4e80be89f93bd2bf97d638ee206a2ecd64f575",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1766,
        "output_tokens": 13077,
        "total_tokens": 14843,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9503,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1766,
        "output_tokens": 13077,
        "total_tokens": 14843,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9503,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-012-source-input-resistive-feedback/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the 1 transistor realization of the\n\n$${V_{o}/V_{i}}\\approx 1/{\\beta }$$\n\nvoltage sampling, series mixing, $=$\nseries shunt $=$ voltage series feedback\n$={\\cal R}_{vi}$ N. I. amplfier.\n\nWith the usual notation : $k\\equiv \\beta $\n\n>$$\\beta ={V_{F}\\over V_{out}}\\Bigl |_{I_{F}=0}$$\n$${\\cal A}_{0}= {V_{out}\\over V_{id}}$$\n$$V_{id}=V_{F}-V_{in}=V_{gs}$$\n\nIn ordinary terminology, Fig. 1 is a\ncommon gate stage whose gate is not $ac$ ground\nbut is driven with a sample of its own drain\nvoltage through the divider $R_{1},R_{2}$.\n\n```\n             VDD ac gnd\n              |\n              RD\n              | Vout = Vd\n              +---------+------o Vout\n              |         |      |\n              D        R1      R1+R2\n             M1         |      |\n              S----+    V_F =kVout\n              |    |     |\n             Vin  Vgs   R2\n                   |     |\n                  gnd   gnd\n```\n\n$V_{gs}=V_{F}-V_{in}$ is the error voltage.\n\n$${\\rm if}\\;V_{in}\\uparrow \\to V_{gs}\\downarrow \n\\to I_{D}\\downarrow \\to I_{RD}\\downarrow \\to V_{out}\\uparrow \n\\to V_{F}\\uparrow \\to V_{gs}\\uparrow $$\n\nnegative feedback for $0<k<1$.  $M_{1}$ is in effect\na differential transconductor with $+$ input $V_{F}$,\n$-$ input $V_{in}$ and single ended\n$v_{o}=-g_{m}v_{gs}r_{o}\\parallel R_{D}$, i. e.\nthe one transistor op. amp. in the non inverting\nconfiguration.  For $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$ you get the\nop. amp. result ${\\cal A}_{CL}\\to 1/\\beta $.\n\n### DC bias\n\nGate current $\\approx 0$,\n\n$$V_{F}=V_{G}=V_{out}{R_{2}\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}=kV_{out}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}-R_{D}I_{D}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$I_{D}={1\\over 2}\\mu C_{ox}{W\\over L}\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\n\\left(1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right)\\;{\\rm sat.}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$V_{GS}=V_{G}-V_{S}=kV_{out}-V_{S}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$V_{DS}=V_{out}-V_{S}\\tag{5}$$\n\nWith $V_{S}=V_{in,DC}$, (1)-(4) defines the $Q$ point\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{out}=R_{D}{\\beta _{0}\\over 2}\\left(kV_{out}-V_{S}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}$$\n\nin saturation $V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{T}$.\nIt is a self bias through $R_{1}R_{2}$ and is\nDC $100\\%$ negative feedback so the $Q$ point is\nstabilized.  In small signal we normally consider\n$V_{in}=V_{s}+v_{in}$ superposed on the $Q$ point.\n\nUp to the biasing details it is the usual CG\nstage if you put $k=0$, $V_{G}=0$.\n\n### Small signal with loading\n\nPut $V_{DD}\\;ac\\;0$, $r_{o}=1/g_{ds}$, ignore\n$C_{gs},C_{gd}$ at low frequency, $r_{g}=\\infty $,\nin Fig.1 body to source so $g_{mb}=0$, if not\nreplace $g_{m}$ by $g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\n\n$$v_{gs}=v_{f}-v_{in}\\tag{6}$$\n$$v_{ds}=v_{out}-v_{in}\\tag{7}$$\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}\\;\\;{\\rm into\\; D,\n\\; out\\; of\\; S}\\tag{8}$$\n\nKCL at $V_{F}$: $i_{g}=0$,\n\n$${v_{f}-v_{out}\\over R_{1}}+{v_{f}\\over R_{2}}=0$$\n\n$${\\rm so }\\;v_{f}=v_{out}{R_{2}\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}=kv_{out}\\tag{9}$$\n\n$$k={R_{2}\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}\\qquad 1-k={R_{1}\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}\\tag{10}$$\n\nKCL at the output node, currents leaving the node:\n\n$${v_{out}\\over R_{D}}+{v_{out}-v_{f}\\over R_{1}}+i_{d}=0\\tag{11}$$\n\ni.e. with (8)(9)\n\n$${v_{out}\\over R_{D}}+v_{out}{1-k\\over R_{1}}+g_{m}\\left(kv_{out}-v_{in}\\right)\n+g_{ds}\\left(v_{out}-v_{in}\\right)=0\\tag{12}$$\n\n$${1-k\\over R_{1}}={1\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nHence\n\n$$v_{out}\\left[{1\\over R_{D}}+{1\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}+g_{m}k+g_{ds}\\right]\n=v_{in}\\left(g_{m}+g_{ds}\\right)\\tag{14}$$\n\n>$$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=\n{{g_{m}+g_{ds}}\\over {g_{ds}+{1\\over R_{D}}+{1\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}+g_{m}k}}\\tag{15}$$\n\nFor $r_{o}\\to \\infty $,\n\n>$$A_{v}\\approx {g_{m}\\over {1/R_{D}+1/(R_{1}+R_{2})+g_{m}k}}\\tag{15a}$$\n\n$${1\\over R_{D}}+{1\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}={1\\over R_{D}\\parallel \\left(R_{1}+R_{2}\\right)}\n\\equiv {1\\over R_{D}'}\\tag{16}$$\n\nIf the loop is built $g_{m}kR_{D}'\\gg 1$,\n\n$$A_{v}\\to {1\\over k}={R_{1}+R_{2}\\over R_{2}}=1+{R_{1}\\over R_{2}}>0\\tag{17}$$\n\nthe non inverting op. amp. result.\nThe sign is $+$ .  A rise in $v_{in}$ at the\nsource cuts $v_{gs}$, cuts $i_{d}$ and pulls\n$v_{out}$ up.  Normally $R_{1}+R_{2}\\gg R_{D}$\nand $1/(R_{1}+R_{2})$ can be neglected\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx {g_{m}R_{D}\\over 1+g_{m}R_{D}k}=\n{1\\over k}{T\\over 1+T}\\tag{18}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$T=g_{m}k\\,R_{D}\\parallel \\left(R_{1}+R_{2}\\right)\\parallel r_{o}\\tag{19}$$\n\nis the usual ${\\cal A}_{0}\\beta /1+{\\cal A}_{0}\\beta $ form.\n\nIncluding $R_{1}+R_{2}$ as part of the load,\n\n$${\\cal A}_{0}= -g_{m}R_{D}'\\;\\;{\\rm for\\; gate\\; drive }$$\n$${\\cal A}_{0}= +g_{m}R_{D}'\\;\\;{\\rm for\\; source\\; drive }$$\n$$\\beta =k$$\n\nThe exact feedback expression with loading is (15).\nIn ideal feedback language, to first order,\nopen circuit gain loaded by the feedback network is\n\n$$A_{vo}=g_{m}R_{D}'\\approx g_{m}R_{D}$$\n\nclosed loop gain (15a) is $A_{vo}/(1+A_{vo}\\beta )$ seen\nfrom the source, i. e. $1/\\beta $ for $A_{vo}\\beta \\gg 1$.\nThe resistors set the gain, its sensitivity to\n$g_{m},r_{o}$ to $dA_{v}/A_{v}=dA_{vo}/A_{vo}/(1+T)$\nis made small. Linearity is improved by $1+T$.\n\nNumerically e. g. $R_{D}=5\\,{\\rm k}$,\n$R_{1}=9\\,{\\rm k}$, $R_{2}=1\\,{\\rm k}$, $k=0.1$,\n$g_{m}=2\\,{\\rm mA/V}$, $r_{o}\\to\\infty $,\n$R_{D}'=3.3\\,{\\rm k}$, $T\\approx 0.66$,\n$A_{v}\\approx 4$ , $T=6.6$ for $g_{m}=20\\,{\\rm mA/V}$\n$\\to A_{v}\\approx 8.7\\to 10$ ideal.\n\nReturn ratio: break the loop at the gate,\nground the source for $ac$, drive $v_{t}$ at the\ngate, $v_{out}=-g_{m}v_{t}R_{D}'$,\n$v_{r}=kv_{out}=-g_{m}kR_{D}'v_{t}$,\n$T=-v_{r}/v_{t}=g_{m}kR_{D}'$ as above.\nSingle pole at the output, unconditionally\nstable, phase margin $ \\approx 90^{o}$.\n\n### Input and output impedance - Blackman\n\nVoltage sampling wants $Z_{out}\\downarrow $,\nseries mixing wants $Z_{in}\\uparrow $.\n\nLet $v_{x}$ be injected at the output, $v_{in}=0$.\nFrom (11) with $v_{out}=v_{x}$,\n\n$$i_{x}={v_{x}\\over R_{D}}+{v_{x}-v_{f}\\over R_{1}}+g_{m}v_{f}+g_{ds}v_{x}$$\n\nwith (9) $v_{f}=kv_{x}$,\n\n$$i_{x}=v_{x}\\left[{1\\over R_{D}}+{1\\over R_{1}+R_{2}}+g_{m}k+g_{ds}\\right]$$\n\n>$$Z_{out}\\equiv {v_{x}\\over i_{x}}=\n{1\\over g_{ds}+1/R_{D}+1/(R_{1}+R_{2})+g_{m}k}\n={R_{D}'\\parallel r_{o}\\over 1+T}\\tag{20}$$\n\n$Z_{out}$ without feedback but with the $R_{1}+R_{2}$\nload is $R_{D}'\\parallel r_{o}$ and is divided by\n$1+T$.  For $T\\gg 1$ $Z_{out}\\approx 1/g_{m}k\\ll R_{D}$.\n\nFor the impedance looked into the source define\n$i_{x}$ entering the source.  Device source\ncurrent entering the device is $-i_{d}$.  So\n$i_{x}= -i_{d}$.\n\nFrom above $i_{d}=(g_{m}k+g_{ds})v_{out}-(g_{m}+g_{ds})v_{in}$\nand with (15) $v_{out}=A_{v}v_{in}$,\n\n$$i_{d}=-(g_{m}+g_{ds})\\left[{1/R_{D}+1/(R_{1}+R_{2})\\over g_{ds}+1/R_{D}+1/(R_{1}+R_{2})+g_{m}k}\\right]v_{in}$$\n\nso for current entering the source\n\n$$Z_{in}\\equiv {v_{in}\\over i_{x}}={v_{in}\\over -i_{d}}\n={g_{ds}+1/R_{D}+1/(R_{1}+R_{2})+g_{m}k\\over (g_{m}+g_{ds})\\left(1/R_{D}+1/(R_{1}+R_{2})\\right)}\\tag{21}$$\n\n$$Z_{in}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}+k\\,R_{D}' = {1+T\\over g_{m}}\\tag{22}$$\n\nfor $g_{ds}\\to 0$, $T=g_{m}kR_{D}'$.\nThe CG low impedance $\\approx 1/g_{m}$ without feedback\n$(k\\to 0)$ is raised by $\\approx kR_{D}'$ or by $1+T$.\nThis can be used for $50\\,{\\rm \\Omega }$ matching with\nmuch smaller $g_{m}$.  With body effect $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\n\nIn summary to order $r_{o}\\to\\infty $,\n$R_{1}+R_{2}\\gg R_{D}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\beta &=R_{2}/(R_{1}+R_{2})\\cr\nT &=g_{m}\\beta R_{D}\\parallel (R_{1}+R_{2}) \\cr\nA_{CL}&\\approx (1/\\beta )\\,T/(1+T)\\cr\nR_{in,CL}&\\approx (1+T)/g_{m}\\cr\nR_{out,CL}&\\approx R_{D}/(1+T)\\cr}$$\n\ni. e. all the usual series-shunt virtues:\naccurate resistor defined voltage gain, desensitivity,\nlow $R_{out}$, high $R_{in}$, improved linearity and\nbandwidth by $1+T$ at the expense of gain.  The\nprice is the DC coupling of $Q$ point to $R_{1},R_{2}$\nand output swing limited by $R_{D}I_{D}$ headroom.\nWith $R_{1}+R_{2}$ not $\\gg R_{D}$ replace $R_{D}$\nby $R_{D}'=R_{D}\\parallel (R_{1}+R_{2})$ and include\n$r_{o}$ in parallel.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6e2185367982044e5c9f7e4d7f502316bdd7fd2c002d777f2b4993809d73b271"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source as the input, the output divider as gate feedback, and the loop as negative feedback. Its closed-loop gain also approaches 1/β = 1 + R1/R2.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c4eb57e96a0e70ff6aa718bcfd4e80be89f93bd2bf97d638ee206a2ecd64f575",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1766,
        "output_tokens": 12405,
        "total_tokens": 14171,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9004,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1766,
        "output_tokens": 12405,
        "total_tokens": 14171,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9004,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the {\\it active loaded\ncommon drain} or {\\it source follower} Class $A$\nvoltage buffer. In discrete form:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}&{\\rm driver} \\cr\nM_{2}&:I_{SS}{\\rm  current source}}$$\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{SS}$$\n\n> {\\it Remark on symbol:} As drawn the arrow is the\nsource. The bulk is strapped to the source so\nin principle $V_{BS1}=V_{BS2}=0$ and there is\nno bulk modulation. If realized in a normal\n$p-{\\rm sub}$ $n-{\\rm well}$ CMOS process the\n$p-{\\rm sub}$ is $GND$ and $M_{1}$ suffers\nbulk modulation $V_{BS1}=-V_{o}$ with\n$V_{T1}=V_{T0}+\\gamma \\left[\\sqrt{2\\Phi_{F}+V_{o}}-\n\\sqrt{2\\Phi_{F}}\\right]$ .\n\nIn normal operation both devices are in saturation.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{SS}&={1\\over 2}\\mu_{n}C_{ox}\\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{2}\n\\left(V_{b}-V_{T2}\\right)^{2}\\left(1+\\lambda_{2}V_{o}\\right) \\cr\nI_{D1}&={1\\over 2}\\mu_{n}C_{ox}\\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{1}\n\\left(V_{GS1}-V_{T1}\\right)^{2}\\left(1+\\lambda_{1}V_{DS1}\\right)}$$\n\n$$V_{GS1}=V_{in}-V_{o} \\qquad V_{DS1}=V_{DD}-V_{o}\n \\qquad V_{DS2}=V_{o}$$\n\nso large signal\n\n$$V_{o}=V_{in}-V_{GS1}=V_{in}-V_{T1}-\\sqrt{{2I_{SS}\\over\n\\mu_{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}}}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$V_{T1}=V_{T10}+{\\rm bulk\\;if\\;not\\;strapped}$$\n\nSaturation conditions\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{2}:&V_{DS2}\\ge V_{GS2}-V_{T2}\\;\\;{\\rm i.e.}\\;\\;\nV_{o}\\ge V_{b}-V_{T2}=V_{ov2}\\cr\nM_{1}:&V_{DS1}\\ge V_{GS1}-V_{T1}\\;\\;{\\rm i.e.}\\;\\;\nV_{DD}-V_{o}\\ge V_{in}-V_{o}-V_{T1}\\cr\n&V_{in}\\le V_{DD}+V_{T1}}$$\n\nHence the $DC$ transfer is a level shift by $\\approx V_{GS1}$\nwith unity slope until\n\n* $V_{in}$ low : $M_{1}$ cuts off, $V_{o}=I_{SS}r_{o2}$\npulled to $0$ through $M_{2}$\n* $V_{in}$ high : $M_{1}$ goes triode $V_{o,max}\\approx\nV_{DD}-V_{ov1}$ and for $V_{o}>V_{b}-V_{T2}$ $M_{2}$ stays\nsaturated.\n\nUsable swing to first order\n\n$$V_{ov2}< V_{o} < V_{DD}-V_{ov1}$$\n\nSmall signal with $V_{b}$ $AC$ ground:\n\n```\n          D1=VDD AC gnd\n           |\n          gds1\n    G1 o---||---+---o Vout\n           |gm1+gmb1\n           |  gds2\n          D2----+\n           |gm2 gds2\n          S2=GND AC gnd\n```\n\n$G_{2}$ $AC$ gnd, so $M_{2}$ is simply $r_{o2}=1/g_{ds2}$\nto ground in parallel with $r_{o1}=1/g_{ds1}$.\n\nKCL at output:\n\n$$g_{m1}v_{gs1}+g_{mb1}v_{bs1}+g_{ds1}(v_{o}-0)+g_{ds2}v_{o}=0$$\n$$v_{gs1}=v_{in}-v_{o}\\qquad v_{bs1}=-v_{o}\\;{\\rm if\\;bulk=GND},\n\\;0\\;{\\rm if\\;bulk=source}$$\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in}-v_{o})-g_{mb1}v_{o}-(g_{ds1}+g_{ds2})v_{o}=0$$\n\n> $$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{o}\\over v_{in}}=\n> {g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}=\n> {g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}\\,{1\\over 1+{g_{o}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}}$$\n\nwhere $g_{o}=g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}=r_{o1}^{-1}+r_{o2}^{-1}$.\n\nIf bulk strapped to source $g_{mb1}=0$:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx {g_{m1}r_{o}\\over 1+g_{m1}r_{o}}\\qquad \nr_{o}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}={1\\over g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}$$\n\nFor $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx 0.8-0.95 {\\rm \\;without\\;bulk\\;,\\; 0.6-0.8 \\;with\\;bulk}\n<1, {\\rm \\;non\\;inverting}$$\n\nand to first order $A_{v}\\to 1$ if $r_{o}\\to \\infty$.\n\nSmall signal impedances by driving $v_{x}$ at output\nwith $v_{in}=0$:\n\n$$i_{x}=(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})v_{x}+g_{ds1}v_{x}+g_{ds2}v_{x}$$\n\n> $$R_{out}={v_{x}\\over i_{x}}={1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\n> \\approx {1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\n> \\approx {1\\over g_{m1}} $$\n\ntypically $50$ to $500\\;\\Omega$.\n\n> $$R_{in}= \\infty \\;\\;{\\rm capacitive\\;\\; }C_{in}\\approx C_{gs1}\n> +(1-A_{v})C_{gd1} \\approx C_{gs1}$$\n\n$$C_{out}\\approx C_{gs1}+C_{sb1}+C_{db1}+C_{db2}+C_{L}$$\n\nDominant pole\n\n$$p_{1}\\approx {1\\over R_{out}C_{L}}={g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o}\\over C_{L}}$$\n\nNon dominant pole at the gate $p_{2}\\approx 1/R_{sig}C_{in}$.\n\nProperties:\n\n* Voltage buffer, impedance transformer $R_{in}\\gg R_{out}$\n* Current gain, power gain $\\approx g_{m}R_{L}$\n* No voltage gain\n* Class $A$: can source\n$I_{max}\\approx {1\\over 2}\\mu C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}(V_{DD}-V_{o}-V_{T})^{2}$\nbut can only sink $I_{SS}$. Slew rate $SR_{-}=I_{SS}/C_{L}$.\n* Distortion determined by $g_{m}$ variation with $I_{D1}$.\n\nUsed universally as output stage, source follower buffer,\nlevel shifter, second stage of op-amp after high gain\nstage, etc. Replacing $M_{2}$ by a resistor gives\nsame analysis with $r_{o2}\\to R_{S}$, but $M_{2}$ gives\nmuch higher $r_{o}$ and better $A_{v}\\to 1$, better\n$PSRR$ and smaller area.\n\nWith $M_{1}$ as $PMOS$ the circuit becomes the familiar\ncommon source high gain inverter with active load\n$A_{v}=-g_{m1}r_{o}$ .",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0a92b7e2a92e32ab8b403c0e22ba5182cd3dce8e0943fa23e0a4ec07102736ec"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as a source follower and M2 as its current-source load, and gives a positive gain below but approaching unity with body effect and finite output resistance included.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9c0eaf5035e4eafe98a151f1035fd6512be41f7b78831b9e6cd3dd9618a8eb67",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 5165,
        "total_tokens": 6423,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3182,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 5165,
        "total_tokens": 6423,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3182,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "The diagram is often drawn as\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{2}&= {\\rm actire}\\;{\\rm load}\\cr \nM_{1}&= {\\rm driver}}$$\n\nwith the conventional $4$ terminal MOS symbol.\nThe supply connections ${\\rm B}_{1}\\to V_{DD}$,\n${\\rm B}_{2}\\to {\\rm GND}$ identify\n\n* $M_{2}$ : $n-$ channel, ${\\rm S}_{2}={\\rm GND}$,\n${\\rm D}_{2}=V_{out}$, ${\\rm G}_{2}=V_{b}=$ d.c.\nbias $=$ d.c. current source\n\n* $M_{1}$ : $p-$ channel, ${\\rm S}_{1}=V_{DD}$,\n${\\rm D}_{1}=V_{out}$, ${\\rm G}_{1}=V_{in}$ in the\nusual CMOS notation.\n\nWith the symbol as drawn the arrow is on the source,\ni. e. it is a $n-$MOS source follower,\n${\\rm D}_{1}=V_{DD}$, ${\\rm S}_{1}=V_{out}$,\n${\\rm D}_{2}=V_{out}$, ${\\rm S}_{2}={\\rm GND}$.\nThe two are duals to each other and differ only by\nthe ${\\rm B}_{1}$ connection and the sign of the\ngain.  In what follows ${\\rm CS}$ means $pM_{1}$,\ncommon source with active load, ${\\rm CD}$ means\n$nM_{1}$ common drain, source follower with active\nload.  Put ${\\rm B}_{1}={\\rm S}_{1}$ for the ${\\rm CS}$.\nFor the ${\\rm CD}$ with ${\\rm B}_{1}=V_{DD}\\ne\n{\\rm S}_{1}$ the back gate transconductance $g_{mb1}$\nmust be kept.\n\n> In many text books the circuit is quoted as\n> {\\it the} single transistor high gain stage, or\n> as the $n{\\rm MOS}$ source follower with current\n> source bias.  $M_{2}$ is {\\it not} diode\n> connected and presents a small signal resistance\n> $r_{o2}=1/g_{ds2}\\gg 1/g_{m}$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{D}&={1\\over 2}\\mu C_{ox}{W\\over L}\n\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\\left(1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right)  \\cr\ng_{m}&=\\left.{\\partial I_{D}\\over \\partial V_{GS}}\\right|_{Q}\n =\\mu C_{ox}{W\\over L}\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)\n =\\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}{W\\over L}I_{D}}={2I_{D}\\over V_{ov}}\\cr\ng_{mb}&=\\eta g_{m}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\\eta ={g_{mb}\\over g_{m}}\n\\approx {\\gamma \\over 2\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{SB}}}\\cr\nr_{o}&={1\\over g_{ds}}={1\\over \\lambda I_{D}}\\propto {L\\over I_{D}}}$$\n\nwith $V_{ov}=V_{GS}-V_{T}$ for $n$MOS,\n$V_{ov}=V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|$ for $p$MOS.\n\n### 1. Large signal - d.c. bias\n\nPut both devices in saturation, strong inversion.\n\n* $n$-load:\n\n$$I_{D2}={1\\over 2}k_{n}^{\\prime}{\\left({W\\over L}\\right)}_{2}\n\\left(V_{b}-V_{Tn}-V_{ov2}\\right)^{2}\\left(1+\\lambda _{n}V_{out}\\right)\n\\approx {1\\over 2}k_{n}{\\left({W\\over L}\\right)}_{2}\n\\left(V_{b}-V_{Tn}\\right)^{2} \\tag{1}$$\n\nfixes the bias current $I_{D0}$. $V_{b}$ is normally\ngenerated by a $n$MOS current mirror and $V_{b}>V_{Tn}$,\n$V_{b}-V_{Tn}=V_{ov2}$ a few $100\\,{\\rm mV}$.\n\n* $p$-driver, ${\\rm CS}$:\n\n$$I_{D1}={1\\over 2}k_{p}^{\\prime}{\\left({W\\over L}\\right)}_{1}\n\\left(V_{DD}-V_{in}-|V_{Tp}|\\right)^{2}\n\\left(1+\\lambda _{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out})\\right) \\tag{2a}$$\n\n* $n$-driver, ${\\rm CD}$ source follower:\n\n$$I_{D1}={1\\over 2}k_{n}^{\\prime}{\\left({W\\over L}\\right)}_{1}\n\\left(V_{in}-V_{out}-V_{Tn}(V_{SB})\\right)^{2}\n\\left(1+\\lambda _{n}(V_{DD}-V_{out})\\right) \\tag{2b}$$\n\n$$V_{Tn}(V_{SB})=V_{T0}+\\gamma\\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}+V_{SB}}\n-\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}}\\right)\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{SB}=V_{S}-V_{B}$$\n\nFor the ${\\rm CS}$ with ${\\rm B}_{1}={\\rm S}_{1}$,\n$V_{SB1}=0$, $g_{mb1}=0$. For the follower with\n${\\rm B}_{1}=V_{DD}$ or ${\\rm GND}$, \n$V_{SB1}=V_{out}-0\\ne 0$ for $n$MOS with ${\\rm B}={\\rm GND}$,\n$V_{SB1}=V_{B}-V_{S}=V_{DD}-V_{out}$ for the drawing,\nthreshold is modulated and\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{in}-V_{GS1}=V_{in}-V_{Tn}(V_{SB1})-V_{ov1} \\tag{3}$$\n\ni.e. a level shift $\\approx V_{T}+V_{ov}$.\n\nIn the steady state $I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{D0}$.\n\nSaturation conditions, $\\lambda =0$ for illustration:\n\n* $M_{2}$ saturated: $V_{DS2}\\ge V_{GS2}-V_{Tn}$\n\n$${\\rm CS/CD:}\\;\\;V_{out}\\ge V_{b}-V_{Tn}=V_{ov2}\\tag{4}$$\n\notherwise $M_{2}$ triode.\n\n* $M_{1}$ saturated\n\n$${\\rm CS}\\;p{\\rm MOS:}\\;V_{SD1}\\ge V_{SG1}-|V_{Tp}|$$\n$$V_{DD}-V_{out}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{in}-|V_{Tp}|\\;\\;,\\;\\;\nV_{out}\\le V_{in}+|V_{Tp}| \\tag{5a}$$\n\n$${\\rm CD}\\;n{\\rm MOS:}\\;V_{DS1}\\ge V_{GS1}-V_{Tn}$$\n$$V_{DD}-V_{out}\\ge V_{in}-V_{out}-V_{Tn}\\;\\;\nV_{in}\\le V_{DD}+V_{Tn} \\tag{5b}$$\n\nnormally satisfied. For the ${\\rm CS}$\n\n$$V_{ov2}\\le V_{out}\\le V_{in}+|V_{Tp}|$$\n\nis the high gain window. Outside it one device\nenters triode and the small signal resistance collapses.\nBecause $r_{o1}||r_{o2}$ is very large the d.c.\nvalue of $V_{out}$ in the ${\\rm CS}$ version is very\nsensitive to $W/L$ mismatch and to $\\lambda $ and is\nnormally stabilised by feedback.  In the follower\nversion $V_{out}$ is well defined by (3).\n\nLarge signal voltage transfer, ${\\rm CS}$:\n\n* $V_{in}\\approx V_{DD}$ : $pM_{1}$ off, $M_{2}$\npulls $V_{out}\\to V_{ov2}\\approx 0$\n* $V_{in}$ lowered by $|V_{Tp}|+V_{ov1}$ : $M_{1}$\nturns on, $V_{out}$ rises sharply with slope\n$-g_{m1}(r_{o1}||r_{o2})$\n* $V_{in}\\ll V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$ : $M_{1}$ triode,\n$V_{out}\\to V_{DD}-V_{SD,sat1}$\n\nFor the follower $V_{out}$ follows $V_{in}$ with a\nd.c. shift, slope $\\approx +1$.\n\nIt is a class A stage, static power\n$P_{D}=V_{DD}I_{D0}$.\n\n### 2. Small signal low frequency\n\nGate draws no current.\n\n$$R_{in}= \\infty \\;\\;{\\rm at\\; d.c.}\\;\\;,\\;\\;Z_{in}=1/sC_{gs1}\n+{\\rm Miller\\; }C_{gd}$$\n\nSmall signal model: $V_{dd}=gnd$ for a.c.\n\n```\n         Vin o---||---+----+\n                 Cgs  |   gmb1*Vbs1\n                      g_m1*Vgs1  gds1\n                      |    |      |\n                      +--+-+------+---o Vout\n                                 |   |\n                                gds2 C_L\n                                 |   |\n                                GND GND\n```\n\n* ${\\rm CS}\\;pM_{1}$ with ${\\rm B}_{1}={\\rm S}_{1}$:\n\n$V_{sg1}= -V_{gs1}=V_{in}$ with sign.  KCL at\n$V_{out}$:\n\n$$g_{m1}v_{sg1}+g_{ds1}v_{out}+g_{ds2}v_{out}=0$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=-{g_{m1}\\over g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\n=-g_{m1}\\left(r_{o1}||r_{o2}\\right)\n=-{g_{m1}\\over (\\lambda_{n}+\\lambda_{p})I_{D}} \\tag{6}$$\n\nTypical $20-60\\,{\\rm dB}$ for a single stage.\nIf $\\lambda\\to 0$, $|A_{v}|\\to\\infty$ - the\nload is an ideal current source. In practice\n\n$$|A_{v}|\\approx {2\\over (\\lambda_{n}+\\lambda_{p})V_{ov1}}\n\\approx {1\\over V_{ov}}\\sqrt{{2\\mu C_{ox}W/L\\over \\lambda^{2}I_{D}}}$$\n\nand can be increased by increasing $L$, decreasing\n$I_{D}$.  Sign is inverting, $180^{o}$ phase shift.\nNo $g_{mb}$ because $V_{bs1}=0$.\n\nOutput resistance seen from $V_{out}$ with $v_{in}=0$:\n\n$$R_{out}=r_{o1}||r_{o2}={1\\over g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\approx {1\\over \\lambda I_{D}}\n\\tag{7}$$\n\n$10\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$ to $>1\\,{\\rm M\\Omega}$.  $R_{out}$ is\nhigh - the stage must drive a capacitive load $C_{L}$.\n\nDominant pole\n\n$$\\omega_{p}= {1\\over R_{out}C_{L}}={g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}\\over C_{L}}\n\\;\\;,\\;\\;GBW\\approx {g_{m1}\\over C_{L}} \\tag{8}$$\n\nMiller capacitance $C_{gd1}$ gives input pole\n$\\omega_{in}\\approx 1/R_{sig}C_{gd1}(1+|A_{v}|)$.\n\n* ${\\rm CD}\\;nM_{1}$ source follower:\n\n$$v_{gs1}=v_{in}-v_{out}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{bs1}=v_{b1}-v_{s1}\n=-v_{out}\\;\\;{\\rm if}\\;B_{1}=GND\\;(AC\\;gnd)$$\n\nKCL:\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in}-v_{out})-g_{mb1}v_{out}\n- g_{ds1}v_{out}-g_{ds2}v_{out}=0$$\n\n$${A_{v}= {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=\n{g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\n={g_{m1}r_{o1}||r_{o2}\\over 1+(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})r_{o1}||r_{o2}}\n\\approx {g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}<1 \\tag{9}}$$\n\nFor $r_{o}\\to\\infty$\n\n$$A_{v0}={1\\over 1+\\eta}\\approx 0.7-0.9$$\n\nBody effect is the main loss.  If the $n$-well allows\n${\\rm B}_{1}={\\rm S}_{1}$, $g_{mb1}=0$,\n\n$$A_{v}= {g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\approx 0.95-0.99$$\n\nand is non-inverting, no Miller multiplication.\n\nOutput resistance, $v_{in}=0$, test source $v_{x}$ at\n$V_{out}$:\n\n$$R_{out}={1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}||r_{o2}\n\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}} \\tag{10}$$\n\n$ \\sim 1/g_{m}= 100\\,{\\rm\\Omega}-1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$.\nHence the follower is a voltage buffer: high\n$R_{in}$, low $R_{out}$, current gain.\n\nInput resistance remains $\\infty$ at low frequency,\ncapacitive $C_{gs1}+C_{gb1}$ at high frequency.\n\nIn either case $M_{2}$ provides an active load whose\nsmall signal resistance $r_{o2}$ is $\\sim 1/\\lambda I_{D}$\nmuch larger than a resistive or diode connected load\n$1/g_{m}$, giving the maximum possible voltage gain\nfor a single device or the lowest $R_{out}$ for a\nfollower without extra power.  Cascoding $M_{1}$ or\n$M_{2}$ raises $R_{out}$ to $g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$ and\n$|A_{v}|$ to $g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$ for the ${\\rm CS}$.\n\n> In short: with the conventional CMOS assignment\n> $M_{1}=p$MOS, $M_{2}=n$MOS the circuit is the\n> CMOS inverter used as a high gain common source\n> voltage amplifier $A_{v}=-g_{m1}(r_{o1}||r_{o2})$,\n> $R_{out}=r_{o1}||r_{o2}$, $R_{in}=\\infty$, inverting.\n> With the symbol literally as drawn $M_{1}=n$MOS it is\n> the common drain/source follower voltage buffer\n> $A_{v}\\approx g_{m1}/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}) \\approx 1$,\n> $R_{out}\\approx 1/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})$, non-inverting,\n> wide band, no Miller effect.\n> Both are the core of operational amplifiers, source\n> follower as output buffer, CS stage as gain stage.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0b8251c0cece42b226bcf9fbcd0773ecd5723af52bbdb39af246a1dd0190d174"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Identifies the circuit as drawn as an NMOS source follower with an NMOS current-source load and gives the correct positive, slightly sub-unity gain. The extra discussion of an alternative common-source topology is unnecessary, but the answer’s final identification of the actual circuit is correct.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9c0eaf5035e4eafe98a151f1035fd6512be41f7b78831b9e6cd3dd9618a8eb67",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 10873,
        "total_tokens": 12131,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7200,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 10873,
        "total_tokens": 12131,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7200,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-013-source-follower-current-source-load/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is nominally a {\\it $n-$ channel}\n{\\it common drain with $n$ channel active load},\ni.e. a {\\bf source follower - voltage buffer}\nand, by interchanging the reading of the symbol,\na {\\bf $p-${\\rm common} source with active load},\nthe elementary CMOS voltage gain stage.\nWith the conventional $4T$ symbol as drawn it is the\nformer. $V_{DD}$ is $ac$ ground.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}&:g_{1}-d_{1}-s_{1}= V_{in}-V_{DD}-V_{out}\\cr\nM_{2}&:g_{2}-d_{2}-s_{2}= V_{b}-V_{out}-0}$$\n\n> {\\it Remark on the symbol:} $M_{2}$ is unambiguously\nan $nMOS$, $d=V_{out}$, $s=GND$, $b=GND$ ${\\rm arrow}\\;b\\to {\\rm channel}$.\n$M_{1}$ is drawn with $d=V_{DD}$, $s=V_{out}$ and\n$b\\to s$, i. e. $nMOS$ with bulk tied to source in order\nto cancel the $g_{mb}$ body effect.  In a normal\n$p-sub$ process $b=GND$ and $g_{mb1}\\ne 0$.\nIf you read $M_{1}$ as a $pMOS$, $s=V_{DD}$, $b=V_{DD}$,\n$d=V_{out}$, ${\\rm arrow}\\;s\\to b$, the circuit is the\ncomplementary common source voltage amplifier, Fig.2.\nThe analysis is dual with $g_{m1}\\rightarrow g_{mp}$.\n\nIn the following $1\\equiv n_{1}$ follower, $2\\equiv n_{2}$\nload. For $pMOS$ common source replace $Av\\approx +1$\nby $Av\\approx -g_{m1}r_{01}\\!\\parallel\\! r_{02}$.\n\n```\nVDD ac gnd\n  |\n  d\n  M1  gm1,gmb1,gds1=1/ro1  Cgs1,Cgd1\n  s ___ Vout\n  |   |\n  d   |\n  M2  gm2,gds2=1/ro2     Vb ac gnd for\n  s                     signal\n  |\n GND ac gnd\n```\n\n### 1. D.C. large signal\n\nPut in saturation, long channel, $\\lambda =0$ for first\norder:\n\n$$I_{D}= {k_{n}\\over 2}\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\\qquad \nk_{n}= \\mu_{n}C_{ox}W/L$$\n\n$M_{2}$ is diode connected as a current source:\n\n$$I_{D2}= {k_{2}\\over 2}\\left(V_{b}-V_{T2}\\right)^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda_{2}V_{out}\\right] =I_{B}= {\\rm const}$$\n\n$$V_{GS2}=V_{b}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$I_{D1}= {k_{1}\\over 2}\\left(V_{GS1}-V_{T1}\\right)^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda_{1}(V_{DD}-V_{out})\\right] \\tag{2}$$\n\nand $I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{B}$ in series.\n\nHence\n\n$$V_{GS1}=V_{in}-V_{out}=V_{T1}\n+\\sqrt{{2I_{B}\\over k_{1}}}$$\n\n$$\\;V_{out}=V_{in}-V_{T1}-\\sqrt{{2I_{B}\\over k_{1}}}\\;\n\\approx V_{in}-V_{T1}-\\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}\\,(V_{b}-V_{T2})\\tag{3}$$\n\ni. e. $V_{out}$ {\\it follows} $V_{in}$ with a\nlevel shift $V_{GS1}$. Ideal follower $dV_{out}/dV_{in}=1$.\n\nWith bulk to $GND$,\n\n$$V_{T1}=V_{T0}+\\gamma \\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}+V_{SB1}}-\n\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}}\\right),\\qquad V_{SB1}=V_{out}-0$$\n\nfor $b=s$, $V_{SB1}=0$, $V_{T1}=V_{T0}$ constant and\n$g_{mb1}=0$, $g_{mb}=g_{m}\\gamma /2\\sqrt{2\\phi+V_{SB}}$ otherwise.\n\nSaturation conditions:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}:& V_{DS1}\\ge V_{GS1}-V_{T1}\\cr\n& V_{DD}-V_{out}\\ge V_{in}-V_{out}-V_{T1}\\cr\n& V_{in}\\le V_{DD}+V_{T1}\\tag{4a}\\cr\nM_{2}:& V_{DS2}\\ge V_{GS2}-V_{T2}\\cr\n& V_{out}\\ge V_{b}-V_{T2}=V_{ov2}\\tag{4b}}$$\n\nand $V_{GS1}>V_{T1}\\Rightarrow V_{in}>V_{out}+V_{T1}$ for\n$M_{1}$ on. Normally (4a) is always satisfied.\nThe useful swing is therefore\n\n$$V_{ov2}\\le V_{out}\\le V_{DD}-V_{ov1}\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$V_{ov}=V_{GS}-V_{T}= \\sqrt{2I_{D}/k}$$\n\nBelow $V_{ov2}$ $M_{2}$ triodes and $r_{o2}$ collapses,\nabove $V_{DD}-V_{ov1}$ $M_{1}$ triodes. Cut-off for low\n$V_{in}$.\n\n$V_{b}$ is normally generated by a $nMOS$ current mirror\nreference, so $I_{B}$ is well defined.\n\nThat is why $M_{2}$ is often drawn with $W/L$ ratioed to\nthe reference device.\n\n### 2. Small signal low frequency\n\n$V_{b}$ ac ground, $V_{DD}$ ac ground, $M_{1}$ common drain,\n$M_{2}$ common gate load $=r_{o2}$ to ground.\n\nSmall signal model, gate $v_{in}$, source $v_{out}$:\n\n$$v_{gs1}=v_{in}-v_{out}$$\n$$g_{m1}v_{gs1}+g_{mb1}v_{bs1}+g_{ds1}v_{ds1}+g_{ds2}v_{out}=0$$\n\nwith $v_{bs1}=-v_{out}$ if $b_{1}=GND$ and $0$ if $b_{1}=s_{1}$,\n$v_{ds1}=-v_{out}$, $v_{ds2}=v_{out}$.\n\n$$\\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}\\right)v_{out}=\ng_{m1}v_{in} $$\n\n$$\\;A_{v}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}\n={g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\;\n\\tag{6}$$\n\n$$={g_{m1}r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\over \n1+\\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\right)r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}}$$\n\nIf bulk tied to source $g_{mb1}=0$,\n\n$$A_{v}={g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\n={g_{m1}r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\over 1+g_{m1}r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}}\n\\approx 1-{1\\over g_{m1}r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}}<1\\tag{7}$$\n\nNormally $g_{m}r_{o}\\sim 20-100$, so\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx 0.8-0.98$$\n\nwithout body effect, $0.6-0.8$ with body effect because\n$g_{mb}\\approx (0.1-0.3)g_{m}$.\n\nWith $\\lambda\\to 0$, $r_{o}\\to\\infty$, $A_{v}\\to g_{m1}/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})\n\\to 1$.\n\nPhase non-inverting.\n\nIf read as $pMOS$ common source, $M_{1}$ $s=V_{DD}$ $ac$ gnd,\n$d=V_{out}$, $g=v_{in}$:\n\n$$A_{v}=-g_{m1}\\,r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\approx -20{\\rm\\;to\\;}\n-100 \\tag{6p}$$\n\ninverting high gain stage, the core of the CMOS op-amp.\n\nInput impedance:\n\n$$\\;Z_{in}=1/sC_{g1}\\to\\infty\\;{\\rm low\\;freq}\\tag{8}$$\n\nessentially the gate capacitance.\n\nOutput impedance: zero $v_{in}$, apply $v_{x}$ at output,\nmeasure $i_{x}$.\n\n$$i_{x}= \\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}\\right)v_{x}$$\n\n$$\\;R_{out}= {1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\n\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}\n\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}}\\;\n\\tag{9}$$\n\nTypically $1/g_{m}\\sim 0.1-1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$, $r_{o}\\sim 10-100\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$.\nSo low impedance, can drive capacitive / small resistive loads.\nNo current gain is $ \\approx g_{m1}R_{L}$.\n\nFor the $pMOS$ common source reading\n$R_{out}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$ high impedance.\n\n### 3. High frequency\n\nDominant poles:\n\n* input pole $1/R_{sig}C_{g1}$ - very high because $R_{sig}$ sees $C_{gs1}+C_{gd1}(1-A_{v})\\approx C_{gs1}$ small Miller.\n* output pole $1/R_{out}C_{L}$ with $C_{L}=C_{s1}+C_{d2}+C_{load}+C_{sb1}$\n\nBecause $R_{out}\\approx 1/g_{m}$ is small, the follower is\nintrinsically wide band, can be used as source follower buffer\nto drive large $C_{L}$. Approx unity gain bandwidth\n$\\approx g_{m1}/C_{L}$.\n\n### 4. Properties and use\n\n* voltage gain $\\approx 1$, no voltage amplification\n* current / power amplification $ \\gg 1$\n* high $Z_{in}$, low $Z_{out}$ - ideal voltage buffer, impedance transformer\n* level shift by $V_{GS}\\approx V_{T}+V_{ov}$\n* very linear if $I_{B}$ constant, distortion $\\propto v_{out}/V_{ov}$\n* poor swing compared to rail-to-rail if $b=GND$ due to body effect $V_{T}(V_{out})$.\n\nApplications: output stage of op-amps, source follower buffer\nbetween common source gain stage and load, level shifter,\n$DC$ shifter in cascades, input stage of voltage regulator.\n\nTo increase swing and $A_{v}\\to 1$, use $pMOS$ follower in\n$n$-well with bulk to source, or triple well $nMOS$ with\ndeep $n$-well bulk to source, or use super source follower,\nflipped voltage follower.\n\nIn its complementary reading as $pMOS$ input / $nMOS$ load\nit is the elementary unbuffered CMOS OTA gain stage, $A_{v}\\approx -g_{m}r_{o}$, used in every CMOS op-amp with active load.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ec98cd767bba23c3dd7d02d9c66fa2907c54676d16ba40ae37e9de70fb6849e7"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the drawn circuit as an NMOS source follower, places the output at M1’s source, and derives a positive gain slightly below unity with body effect and finite output resistance. The speculative pMOS common-source discussion and the “diode connected” label for M2 are extraneous or mistaken, but do not change the correct analysis of the shown circuit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9c0eaf5035e4eafe98a151f1035fd6512be41f7b78831b9e6cd3dd9618a8eb67",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 9066,
        "total_tokens": 10324,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6217,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1258,
        "output_tokens": 9066,
        "total_tokens": 10324,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6217,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-014-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-014-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "The circuit is the **Complementary MOS In - NOT - {\\it Inverter}**. \nIt is the basic ${\\it ratioless}$ static CMOS logic\ngate. $M_{1}= n-MOS$ , $M_{2}= p-MOS$, enhancement mode.\n\n$$S_{1}= {\\rm GND}, B_{1}= {\\rm GND} \\;\\;,\\;\\; S_{2}= V_{DD}, B_{2}=V_{DD}$$\n\nso source-body junctions always reverse biased. \nGates common $=V_{in}$ , Drains common $=V_{out}$ - push - pull\ncommon source with active load.\n\nIn digital terms:\n\n$$V_{out}= \\bar V_{in}$$\n\n| $V_{in}$ | $M_{1}$ nMOS | $M_{2}$ pMOS | $V_{out}$ |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| $0 = GND =``0\"$ | $V_{GS1}=0<V_{Tn}$ {\\it OFF} | $V_{SG2}=V_{DD}>|V_{Tp}|$ {\\it ON} lin. | $V_{DD}=``1\"$ |\n| $V_{DD}=``1\"$ | $V_{GS1}=V_{DD}>V_{Tn}$ {\\it ON} lin. | $V_{SG2}=0<|V_{Tp}|$ {\\it OFF} | $0=``0\"$ |\n\nNo DC path $V_{DD}\\to GND$ in either stable logic state. Static current $I_{DD}=0$ except leakage and during transition. High input impedance $\\approx \\infty$, rail to rail output swing, large noise margin.\n\n### 1. DC Transfer Characteristic $V_{out}=f(V_{in})$ $0\\le V_{in}\\le V_{DD}$\n\nWith $I_{Dn}= -I_{Dp}$ current:\n\n* nMOS: $I_{Dn}=0$ if $V_{GS}<V_{Tn}$, $k_{n}(V_{GS}-V_{Tn})^{2}/2$ in saturation, $k_{n}[2(V_{GS}-V_{Tn})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}]/2$ in triode.\n\n* pMOS: $I_{Dp}=0$ if $V_{SG}<|V_{Tp}|$, analogous with $V_{SG}, V_{SD}$\n\nwhere $k_{n,p}= \\mu_{n,p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{n,p}= \\beta_{n,p}$\n\n$$V_{Tn}>0 \\;\\;,\\;\\; V_{Tp}<0$$\n\nIn the sweep $V_{in}:0\\to V_{DD}$ 5 regions:\n\n1.  $0\\le V_{in}<V_{Tn}$ : $M_{1}$ cut-off, $M_{2}$ triode\n    $$I_{D}=0,\\; V_{out}=V_{DD}=V_{OH}$$\n\n2.  $V_{Tn}<V_{in}< V_{IL}$ : $M_{1}$ saturation, $M_{2}$ triode\n\n3.  $V_{IL}<V_{in}<V_{IH}$ : **both saturation** - high gain transition. $I_{D}$ maximum. \n    The logic threshold $V_{M}$ defined by $V_{in}=V_{out}$ and $I_{Dn}=-I_{Dp}$ in saturation:\n    $$\\frac{k_{n}}{2}(V_{M}-V_{Tn})^{2}= \\frac{k_{p}}{2}(V_{DD}-V_{M}+V_{Tp})^{2}$$\n    $$V_{M}= \\frac{V_{Tn}+ \\sqrt{k_{p}/k_{n}}\\,(V_{DD}+V_{Tp})}{1+\\sqrt{k_{p}/k_{n}}}$$\n    For symmetric inverter $V_{Tn}=|V_{Tp}|=V_{T}$ and matched $\\beta$ ,\n    $$V_{M}\\approx V_{DD}/2$$\n    Condition for $V_{M}=V_{DD}/2$:\n    $$\\frac{(W/L)_{p}}{(W/L)_{n}} = \\frac{\\mu_{n}}{\\mu_{p}}\\approx 2-3$$\n\n4.  $V_{IH}<V_{in}<V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$ : $M_{1}$ triode, $M_{2}$ saturation\n\n5.  $V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|<V_{in}\\le V_{DD}$ : $M_{2}$ cut-off, $M_{1}$ triode\n    $$I_{D}=0,\\; V_{out}=0=V_{OL}$$\n\nThis gives the familiar sharp, inverting VTC with three points $V_{IL},V_{M},V_{IH}$ defined by $dV_{out}/dV_{in}=-1$.\n\n$$V_{OH}=V_{DD},\\;V_{OL}=0$$\n$$NM_{L}=V_{IL}-V_{OL}\\approx V_{M},\\; NM_{H}=V_{OH}-V_{IH}\\approx V_{DD}-V_{M}$$\nIdeal $\\approx V_{DD}/2$ - maximum noise immunity.\n\n> In current domain $I_{DD}(V_{in})$ is $\\approx 0$ in regions 1,5 and is a narrow peaked pulse $\\approx k(V_{M}-V_{T})^{2}/2$ in region 3 - the short circuit current during switching.\n\n### 2. Small signal - Analog amplifier\n\nBiased at $V_{in}=V_{M}$, both in saturation:\n\n$$A_{v}= \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = -\\frac{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}{g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}} = -(g_{m1}+g_{m2})(r_{o1}||r_{o2})$$\n\nTypical $|A_{v}| \\approx 10-100$, inverting common source. $g_{m}=k(V_{GS}-V_{T})$, $r_{o}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$. Used as high gain inverting stage, crystal oscillator, etc.\n\nInput capacitance $C_{in}=C_{gs1}+C_{gs2}+C_{gd1}+C_{gd2}$ Miller, output resistance $r_{o1}||r_{o2}$.\n\n### 3. Dynamic - Transient\n\nCapacitive load $C_{L}$ at $V_{out}$.\n\n* Pull-up through $M_{2}$ : $t_{pLH}\\approx 0.69\\,R_{p}C_{L}$\n* Pull-down through $M_{1}$ : $t_{pHL}\\approx 0.69\\,R_{n}C_{L}$\n\nwith $R_{n,p}\\approx 1/k_{n,p}(V_{DD}-V_{T})$ in triode.\n\nDynamic power :\n\n$$P_{D}= P_{stat}+P_{sc}+P_{dyn}\\approx C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f + V_{DD}I_{sc,av}$$\n\n$P_{stat}\\approx V_{DD}I_{leak}\\to 0$ is the great advantage of CMOS.\n\nInverter is ratioless, can be scaled, fundamental cell for NAND, NOR, SRAM, ring oscillators and every CMOS digital IC. Equal sized $W_{p}\\approx 2-3\\,W_{n}$ gives symmetric rise/fall times.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "7ddb4710c2ba2ffb70792984c09f4658c538f0e1ea8d6320e2a10ce573fcdb82"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the standard CMOS inverter with an NMOS pull-down and PMOS pull-up, and describes its inverting operation. Minor imprecision in secondary details does not contradict the inverter’s operation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "840046eac3d7c03b675f1189f0c155481e30a0dabe801adc9eba216a9a4a04f4",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 318,
        "output_tokens": 3204,
        "total_tokens": 3522,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1626,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 318,
        "output_tokens": 3204,
        "total_tokens": 3522,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1626,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-014-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-014-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the fundamental CMOS logic building\nblock - the {\\it Complementary MOS Inverter} or {\\it NOT Gate}\nand at the same time a {\\it class A push-pull inverting amplifier}.\n\n$$M_{1}: NMOS\\;\\; ,S=GND \\;\\; V_{BS1}=0$$\n$$M_{2}: PMOS\\;\\; ,S=V_{DD} \\;\\; V_{BS2}=0$$\n\nno body effect if $n-$ well/$p-$ substrate is tied to the\nsource. Common gate input $V_{in}$, common drain output $V_{out}$.\n\nIt is {\\it ratio-less}, {\\it rail to rail} logic with ideally\n{\\it zero static power}.\n\n### 1. Principle of operation\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm in\\;d.c.\\;steady\\;state}$$\n\nFor a long channel, neglect $\\lambda$ for first order:\n\n$$I_{Dn}=k_{n}(V_{GSn}-V_{Tn})^{2}/2\\;\\; {\\rm sat.}$$\n$$k_{n}= \\mu_{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}\\;\\;,k_{p}= \\mu_{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{2}$$\n$$I_{Dp}=k_{p}(V_{SGp}+V_{Tp})^{2}/2\\;\\; {\\rm sat.}\\;\\;V_{Tp}<0$$\n\n* $V_{in}=0 = V_{OL}<V_{Tn}$:\n\n$V_{GS1}=0<V_{Tn}\\to M_{1}$ {\\bf OFF}, $V_{SG2}=V_{DD}>|V_{Tp}|\\to M_{2}$ {\\bf ON}\nNo DC path to GND. $M_{2}$ charges the output capacitance to $V_{DD}$ through its low $R_{on}$, in steady state $V_{OH}=V_{DD}$, $I_{DD}=0$ ( leakage only). $M_{2}$ is in triode/linear because $V_{SD2}=0< V_{SG2}+V_{Tp}$.\n\n* $V_{in}=V_{DD}=V_{OH}>V_{Tn}$:\n\n$V_{GS1}=V_{DD}>V_{Tn}\\to M_{1}$ {\\bf ON}, $V_{SG2}=0<|V_{Tp}|\\to M_{2}$ {\\bf OFF}\nNo DC path to $V_{DD}$. $M_{1}$ discharges the load to $GND$, $V_{OL}=0$, $I_{DD}=0$. $M_{1}$ is in triode.\n\nIn words: Pull-up network ($M_{2}$) and pull-down network ($M_{1}$) are never ON simultaneously in steady state. Logic function:\n\n$$V_{out} = \\bar V_{in}$$\n\n| $V_{in}$ | $M_{1}$ NMOS | $M_{2}$ PMOS | $V_{out}$ |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| $0$ | OFF | Linear | $V_{DD}$ |\n| $L$ | OFF/Sat | Linear | $\\approx V_{DD}$ |\n| $V_{M}$ | Sat | Sat | $V_{M}\\approx V_{DD}/2$ |\n| $H$ | Linear | Sat/OFF | $\\approx 0$ |\n| $V_{DD}$ | Linear | OFF | $0$ |\n\n### 2. Voltage Transfer Characteristic - VTC\n\nFive regions for increasing $V_{in}$ $0\\to V_{DD}$:\n\n1.  $M1$ off, $M2$ linear : $V_{out}=V_{DD}$\n2.  $M1$ saturation, $M2$ linear\n3.  $M1$ {\\bf saturation}, $M2$ {\\bf saturation} : High gain transition. Both saturated only for a narrow $V_{in}$ around the logic threshold.\n4.  $M1$ linear, $M2$ saturation\n5.  $M1$ linear, $M2$ off : $V_{out}=0$\n\nIdeal VTC is very steep in region 3, approximating an ideal inverter.\n\nThe logic threshold or switching point $V_{M}$ defined by $V_{in}=V_{out}=V_{M}$ where $I_{Dn}=|I_{Dp}|$ both in saturation:\n\n$$\\frac{k_{n}}{2}(V_{M}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{n}V_{M}) = \\frac{k_{p}}{2}(V_{DD}-V_{M}+V_{Tp})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{M}))$$\n\nFor $\\lambda\\approx 0$:\n\n$$V_{M}= \\frac{V_{Tn}+ \\sqrt{k_{p}/k_{n}}\\,(V_{DD}+V_{Tp})}{1+\\sqrt{k_{p}/k_{n}}}$$\n\nIf inverter is symmetric $k_{n}=k_{p}$, $V_{Tn}=|V_{Tp}|=V_{T}$:\n\n$$V_{M}=V_{DD}/2$$\n\nNoise margins are obtained from $dV_{out}/dV_{in}=-1$ points $V_{IL},V_{IH}$:\n\n$$NM_{L}=V_{IL}-V_{OL}\\approx V_{IL}$$\n$$NM_{H}=V_{OH}-V_{IH}\\approx V_{DD}-V_{IH}$$\n\nFor symmetric design $NM_{L}=NM_{H}\\approx 0.4\\,V_{DD}$, excellent noise immunity and full $0$ to $V_{DD}$ swing.\n\nCurrent characteristic is a narrow peak at $V_{M}$ with\n$I_{D,max}\\approx k(V_{DD}/2-V_{T})^{2}/2$, zero elsewhere. Hence static power $P_{s}=V_{DD}I_{leak}\\approx 0$.\n\n### 3. Small signal - analog amplifier view\n\nBiased at $V_{M}$ in region 3, both devices saturated, the circuit is a high gain push-pull common source amplifier.\n\nSmall signal model: Gates common, drains common.\n\n$$g_{m}=g_{m1}+g_{m2}$$\n$$g_{o}=g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}= \\lambda_{n}I_{D}+ \\lambda_{p}I_{D}$$\n$$r_{o}=1/g_{o}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$$\n\n$$A_{v}= \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = -\\frac{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}{g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}} = -(g_{m1}+g_{m2})(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2})$$\n\nTypically $20$ to $>40\\,dB$ with $r_{o}\\sim 10k - 100k\\Omega$, $g_{m}\\sim 0.1-1\\,mA/V$. Input resistance $\\to \\infty$, output resistance $r_{o}$.\n\nTransition gain in large signal:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -\\frac{1}{(V_{M}-V_{Tn})\\lambda_{n}+ (V_{DD}-V_{M}+V_{Tp})\\lambda_{p}}$$\n\nBandwidth limited by load capacitance $C_{L}$ at output node:\n\n$$f_{-3dB}\\approx 1/2\\pi r_{o}C_{L}$$\n\nSlew rate $SR = I_{D}/C_{L}$.\n\nDynamic power when switching at frequency $f$:\n\n$$P_{D}= C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f + V_{DD}I_{sc}$$\n\nwhere $I_{sc}$ is short circuit current during transition when both conduct, and propagation delay for a step input:\n\n$$t_{pLH}\\approx 0.69 R_{p}C_{L}\\;\\;,\\;\\;t_{pHL}\\approx 0.69 R_{n}C_{L}$$\n$$t_{p}= (t_{pLH}+t_{pHL})/2$$\n\nwith $R_{n,p}\\approx 1/k_{n,p}(V_{DD}-V_{T})$.\n\n> In digital application it is used as a NOT gate, buffer, and the basic element for NAND/NOR, SRAM, latch, ring oscillator. In analog it is the simplest CMOS operational transconductance inverter stage, often used as output stage or as a high gain stage with active load - essentially $M_{1}$ is the driver and $M_{2}$ is its active load and vice versa.\n\nIdeal characteristics: full logic swing, regenerative VTC, high $NM$, zero static current, ratioless design - area and operation independent of transistor sizing ratio except for $V_{M}$ and speed.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "2f8cbb5b1e59e7021f5227f99c61b79d4cc9a76cb255a13788cfd8fafb523bf1"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the CMOS inverter and its NMOS pull-down/PMOS pull-up operation. However, it incorrectly says the devices are never on simultaneously in steady state: at an intermediate DC input both conduct and draw static current, contradicting its own discussion of the switching point.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "840046eac3d7c03b675f1189f0c155481e30a0dabe801adc9eba216a9a4a04f4",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 318,
        "output_tokens": 2848,
        "total_tokens": 3166,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 938,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 318,
        "output_tokens": 2848,
        "total_tokens": 3166,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 938,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-014-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-014-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the Complementary MOS, CMOS, NOT gate - {\\bf Inverter} the basic building block of all static CMOS logic.\n\n$$M_{1}= NMOS\\; driver \\;\\; ; \\;M_{2}= PMOS\\; active\\; load$$\n$$M_{1}: V_{GS1}= V_{in} \\;, \\;V_{DS1}=V_{out}$$\n$$M_{2}: V_{SG2}= V_{DD}-V_{in}\\;, \\; V_{SD2}=V_{DD}-V_{out}$$\n\nBulk of $M_{1}$ to $GND$ and bulk of $M_{2}$ to $V_{DD}$ so for this connection $V_{SB}=0$ no body effect. Both are enhancement mode, $V_{Tn}>0 ,\\;V_{Tp}<0$.\n\n$$I_{Dn}= \\begin{cases}\n0 & V_{GS}<V_{Tn}\\;\\;cut-off\\\\\nk_{n}\\left[(V_{GS}-V_{Tn})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}/2\\right] & V_{DS}<V_{GS}-V_{Tn}\\;\\;triode\\\\\n\\frac{k_{n}}{2}(V_{GS}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{n}V_{DS}) & V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{Tn}\\;\\;saturation\n\\end{cases}$$\n\n$$k_{n}= \\mu_{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1} \\quad , \\quad k_{p}= \\mu_{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{2}$$\n\nand dual for $M_{2}$ with $V_{SG},V_{SD},|V_{Tp}|$.\n\nIn DC steady state $I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{D}$.\n\n### 1. Logic Operation\n\n| $V_{in}$ | $M_{1}$ NMOS | $M_{2}$ PMOS | $V_{out}$ | Logic |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| $0 = GND$ | $V_{GS}<V_{Tn} \\rightarrow OFF$ | $V_{SG}=V_{DD} >|V_{Tp}|\\rightarrow ON$ | $V_{out}=V_{DD}$ through $M_{2}$ | $0 \\rightarrow 1$ |\n| $V_{DD}$ | $V_{GS}=V_{DD} \\rightarrow ON$ | $V_{SG}=0 \\rightarrow OFF$ | $V_{out}=0$ through $M_{1}$ | $1 \\rightarrow 0$ |\n\nHence $V_{out}= \\bar V_{in}$ . In static state one transistor is always OFF so ideal {\\it static current $=0$} and static power $P_{stat}\\approx 0$.\n\n$$V_{OH}=V_{DD} \\quad , \\quad V_{OL}=0$$\n\nFull rail to rail swing - ratioless logic.\n\n### 2. Voltage Transfer Characteristic - 5 Regions\n\nWith $V_{in}$ swept $0 \\to V_{DD}$:\n\n* {\\bf A: $0 \\le V_{in} < V_{Tn}$} \n  $M_{1}$ OFF, $M_{2}$ triode. $I_{D}=0$, $V_{out}=V_{DD}$.\n\n* {\\bf B: $V_{Tn} < V_{in} < V_{in,1}$}\n  $M_{1}$ saturation, $M_{2}$ triode.\n\n* {\\bf C: $V_{in} \\approx V_{M}$} \n  Both saturation. Very high gain region. This is the switching threshold where $I_{D1}=I_{D2}$.\n\n  Ignoring $\\lambda$:\n  $$\\frac{k_{n}}{2}(V_{M}-V_{Tn})^{2}= \\frac{k_{p}}{2}(V_{DD}-V_{M}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}$$\n\n  $$V_{M}= \\frac{V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|+ \\sqrt{k_{n}/k_{p}}\\;V_{Tn}}{1+\\sqrt{k_{n}/k_{p}}}= \\frac{V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|+ \\sqrt{\\beta_{R}}V_{Tn}}{1+\\sqrt{\\beta_{R}}}$$\n\n  with $\\beta_{R}=k_{n}/k_{p}$. For matched device $k_{n}=k_{p}$ and $V_{Tn}=|V_{Tp}|=V_{T}$:\n\n  $$V_{M}=V_{DD}/2$$\n\n  Commonly $(W/L)_{p} \\approx 2-3 (W/L)_{n}$ to compensate $\\mu_{n}\\approx 2-3\\mu_{p}$ and get symmetric $V_{M}$.\n\n* {\\bf D: $V_{in,2} < V_{in} < V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$}\n  $M_{1}$ triode, $M_{2}$ saturation.\n\n* {\\bf E: $V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}| < V_{in} \\le V_{DD}$}\n  $M_{1}$ triode, $M_{2}$ OFF. $I_{D}=0$, $V_{out}=0$.\n\n> VTC is a sharp inverted S. Slope $dV_{out}/dV_{in} \\approx 0$ in regions A and E, slope $<<-1$ in C.\n\n```\nVout\nVDD |******\n    |      *\n    |       *\n    |        *\n    |         *\n    |          *******\n    +------------------ Vin\n    0   VIL VM VIH  VDD\n```\n\nNoise margins defined by $|dV_{out}/dV_{in}|=1$:\n\n$$N_{M_{L}} = V_{IL}-V_{OL} \\quad , \\quad N_{M_{H}} = V_{OH}-V_{IH}$$\n\nFor ideal symmetric inverter $N_{M_{L}} \\approx N_{M_{H}} \\approx 0.4\\,V_{DD}$ - maximum.\n\n### 3. Analog Small Signal Behaviour\n\nIf biased at $V_{in}=V_{M}$ region C both devices in saturation it is a high gain push-pull common source amplifier. Loaded by $C_{L}$:\n\n$$A_{v} = \\left.\\frac{dV_{out}}{dV_{in}}\\right|_{V_{M}} = -\\frac{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}{g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}} = -\\frac{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}{r_{o1}^{-1}+r_{o2}^{-1}}$$\n\n$$g_{m}=k(V_{GS}-V_{T})\\;\\;,\\;\\; r_{o}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$$\n\nTypically $|A_{v}| = 20$ to $100$ for long channel, $>10$ for short channel. This is why the transition is so sharp.\n\n### 4. Dynamic Behaviour\n\nNo DC path, current only flows during switching when both transistors briefly conduct, short circuit current spike + charging/discharging $C_{L}$.\n\n$$P_{dyn}= C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f + V_{DD}I_{sc} + P_{leak}$$\n\nPropagation delay for $C_{L}$ load approx:\n\n$$t_{pLH} \\approx \\frac{C_{L}V_{DD}}{2I_{Dp,sat}} \\quad , \\quad t_{pHL} \\approx \\frac{C_{L}V_{DD}}{2I_{Dn,sat}}$$\n\n$$t_{p}= \\frac{t_{pLH}+t_{pHL}}{2}$$\n\nDesigned for $t_{pLH}=t_{pHL}$ via $k_{n}=k_{p}$ sizing.\n\nIn short: As {\\bf digital gate} it is an ideal inverter with near zero static power, full logic swing and regenerative VTC. As {\\bf analog circuit} at $V_{M}$ it is a high gain inverting amplifier.\n\nIf you give $V_{DD}, V_{Tn}, |V_{Tp}|, (W/L)_{1,2}, k_{n}',k_{p}'$ the $V_{M}, V_{IL},V_{IH}$, gain and $t_{p}$ can be calculated numerically.\n\nWant the numeric VTC/current for a specific technology? Provide $V_{DD}$ and transistor parameters.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "73059c88a9b40d4749e10afa663a41fae8b794d0a14c2b89548b1132dcb56389"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the CMOS inverter and its NMOS pull-down/PMOS pull-up operation, including the inverted logic levels. The additional analysis is not needed for full credit and does not contradict the essential inverter operation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "840046eac3d7c03b675f1189f0c155481e30a0dabe801adc9eba216a9a4a04f4",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 227,
        "input_tokens": 318,
        "output_tokens": 3578,
        "total_tokens": 3896,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1719,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 227,
        "input_tokens": 318,
        "output_tokens": 3578,
        "total_tokens": 3896,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1719,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the symbology as drawn the circuit is\n{\\it not} a complementary stage but the {\\sl pseudo}\nratioed stage of Fig.1. In the literature the upper\ndevice is normally drawn as a ${\\cal P}$ device and the\ncircuit is then the conventional ${\\cal C}{\\cal MOS}$\n``NOT''.\n\n\\begin{center}\n{\\tt M1 = load, M2 = driver } \n\\end{center}\n\n{\\rm I} will put the analysis in the form most text\nbooks want it, i.e. with\n\n$${\\rm M1}={\\cal P}-{\\rm MOS}\\;\\; {\\rm on\\;top},\\qquad \n  {\\rm M2}={\\cal N}-{\\rm MOS}\\;\\; {\\rm on\\;bottom}$$\n\nIf you take the figure literally, ${\\rm M1}\\equiv {\\cal\nN}$ put ${\\rm |V_{Tp}|=V_{Tn}=V_{T}>0}$ and\n${\\rm g_{m1}\\rightarrow -g_{m1}}$ in what follows.\n\n\\begin{figure}[h]\nVin=0 -> M1 ON, M2 OFF -> Vo=VDD\nVin=VDD -> M1 OFF, M2 ON -> Vo=0\n\\end{figure}\n\n> {\\it Normally the arrow on ${\\rm M1}$ is reversed\n> with respect to ${\\rm M2}$. With the arrow as drawn\n> ${\\rm M1}$ and ${\\rm M2}$ are the same polarity and\n> the stage is ratioed, has a $Hi-Z$ state for\n> $V_{in}<V_{T}$ and can never pull to $V_{DD}$. It is\n> normally rejected as a logic gate.}\n\n\\subsection*{1. Large signal - ideal ${\\cal C}{\\cal MOS}$}\n\nLet\n\n$${\\rm M1}:S=V_{DD},\\; D=V_{o},\\;G=V_{i}\\;\\;{\\cal P},\n\\;\\;|V_{T1}|=|V_{Tp}|$$\n$${\\rm M2}:D=V_{o},\\;S=0,\\;G=V_{i}\\;\\;{\\cal N},\n\\;\\;V_{T2}=V_{Tn}$$\n\n$$I_{Dn}=k_{n}\\left[(V_{GS}-V_{Tn})V_{DS}-{\\frac12}V_{DS}^{2}\n\\right]\\;{\\rm triode}$$\n$$I_{Dn}= {\\frac12}k_{n}(V_{GS}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda _{n}V_{DS})\n\\;{\\rm sat.},\\;V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{Tn}$$\n$$I_{Dp}= {\\frac12}k_{p}(V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}(1+\\lambda _{p}V_{SD})\n\\;{\\rm sat.}$$\nwith $k=\\mu C_{ox}W/L$, $\\beta =k$.\n\nPut $I_{Dn}=I_{Dp}=I_{D}$ for the series connection.\n\nIn static operation one device is always {\\it off}}:\n\n* {\\bf A: $0\\le V_{i}<V_{Tn}$ :} ${\\rm M2}$ cut off,\n${\\rm M1}$ linear - in fact $V_{SG1}=V_{DD}-V_{i}>\n|V_{Tp}|$, $V_{SD1}=V_{DD}-V_{o}$ small. No DC path\nto ground. $I_{D}=0$ and\n\n$$V_{o}=V_{OH}=V_{DD}\\tag{1}$$\n\nwithin the leakage current.\n\n* {\\bf B: $V_{Tn}<V_{i}<V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$ :} both on.\nFor low $V_{o}$ ${\\rm M2}$ sat., ${\\rm M1}$ linear,\nfor high $V_{o}$ vice versa. In the middle\n\n$$V_{Tn}<V_{i}<V_{DD}/2\\;\\;{\\rm approx.}$$\n\nboth are saturated. This is the high gain transition\nregion.\n\n* {\\bf C: $V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|<V_{i}\\le V_{DD}$ :} ${\\rm M1}$\ncut off, ${\\rm M2}$ linear,\n\n$$V_{o}=V_{OL}=0\\tag{2}$$\n\nHence\n\n$$\\begin{array}{c|c|c|c}\nV_{i} & {\\rm M1(P)} & {\\rm M2(N)} & V_{o}\\\\ \\hline\n0 & {\\rm ON} & {\\rm OFF} & 1\\equiv V_{DD}\\\\\nV_{DD} & {\\rm OFF} & {\\rm ON} & 0\\equiv 0\n\\end{array}\\tag{3}$$\n\ni.e. the Boolean\n\n$$V_{o}= \\bar V_{i}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand the voltage transfer characteristic, VTC, of\nFig.2 is obtained, with 5 regions:\n\n1. M1 linear, M2 off\n2. M1 linear, M2 sat.\n3. M1 sat., M2 sat. - high gain\n4. M1 sat., M2 linear\n5. M1 off, M2 linear\n\nIn region 3, $I_{Dn}(sat)=I_{Dp}(sat)$,\n\n$$\\frac12 k_{n}(V_{i}-V_{Tn})^{2}=\n\\frac12 k_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}\\tag{5}$$\n\nat the logic threshold where by definition\n$V_{i}=V_{o}=V_{M}$,\n\n$$V_{M}= \\frac{V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|+V_{Tn}\\sqrt{k_{n}/k_{p}}}\n{1+\\sqrt{k_{n}/k_{p}}}\\tag{6}$$\n\nFor the symmetric $k_{n}=k_{p}$, $|V_{Tp}|=V_{Tn}=V_{T}$\n\n$$V_{M}=V_{DD}/2\\tag{7}$$\n\n$$V_{IL},V_{IH}:\\; \\left.\\frac{dV_{o}}{dV_{i}}\\right|_{V_{IL},V_{IH}}=-1$$\n\n$$NM_{L}=V_{IL}-V_{OL}\\qquad NM_{H}=V_{OH}-V_{IH}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$NM_{L},NM_{H}\\approx 0.4\\,V_{DD}$ for the symmetric\ncase. No static current in state {\\bf A} or {\\bf C},\n\n$$P_{stat}=0\\;\\;{\\rm ideally}\\tag{9}$$\n$$P_{dyn}=C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f_{clk}+V_{DD}I_{sc}\\tag{10}$$\n\n$C_{L}$ is the load capacitance, $I_{sc}$ the short\ncircuit current in region 3.\n\nSmall signal at $V_{M}$ with both sat., $V_{DD}$ AC\nground,\n\n$$v_{gs1}=v_{sg1}= -v_{i},\\;v_{gs2}=v_{i}$$\n\n$$g_{m1}v_{sg1}+g_{ds1}v_{o}+g_{m2}v_{gs2}+g_{ds2}v_{o}=0$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv \\frac{v_{o}}{v_{i}}= -\\,\\frac{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}\n{g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}= -\\,\\frac{g_{m1}+g_{m2}}{g_{o1}+g_{o2}}\\tag{11}$$\n\n$$|A_{v}|\\approx \\frac{2}{(\\lambda _{n}+\\lambda _{p})(V_{GS}-V_{T})}\n\\approx 20-50\\,{\\rm dB}$$\n\n$$r_{o}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\tag{12}$$\n\nThe bodies are strapped to the supplies, $S\\equiv B$,\nso there is no back gate effect, $g_{mb}=0$.\n\n\\subsection*{2. What the figure actually draws: ${\\rm M1}={\\rm M2}={\\cal N}$}\n\nPut now ${\\rm M1}$ also ${\\cal N}$: $D_{1}=V_{DD}$,\n$S_{1}=V_{o}$, $G_{1}=V_{i}$ so $V_{GS1}=V_{i}-V_{o}$,\n$V_{DS1}=V_{DD}-V_{o}$; $V_{GS2}=V_{i}$, $V_{DS2}=V_{o}$.\n\n* $V_{i}<V_{T}$: both cut off. $V_{o}$ is {\\it\nfloating, $Hi-Z$}. It is held by the previous charge on\n$C_{L}$. It is not a logic level - the circuit is not\nrestoring.\n\n* $V_{i}>V_{T}$: both on. KCL $I_{D1}=I_{D2}$.\n\nE.G. both saturated,\n\n$$\\frac12k_{1}(V_{i}-V_{o}-V_{T1})^{2}= \n\\frac12k_{2}(V_{i}-V_{T2})^{2}\\tag{13}$$\n\n$$V_{o}=V_{i}-V_{T1}-\\sqrt{\\frac{k_{2}}{k_{1}}}\\,(V_{i}-V_{T2})\n\\tag{14}$$\n\nIn any case $V_{o}$ is a voltage divider,\n\n$$V_{o}\\approx V_{DD}\\frac{R_{2}}{R_{1}+R_{2}}<V_{DD}\\tag{15}$$\n\nand there is static current\n\n$$I_{stat}\\approx \\frac12k_{2}(V_{i}-V_{T})^{2}\\tag{16}$$\n\nfor $V_{i}=V_{DD}$.\n\nSmall signal, $V_{o1}=0$ AC,\n\n$$I_{d1}=g_{m1}(v_{i}-v_{o})+g_{o1}(-v_{o})$$\n$$I_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{i}+g_{o2}v_{o}$$\n\n$$I_{d1}=I_{d2}\\Rightarrow A_{v}= \\frac{v_{o}}{v_{i}}=\n\\frac{g_{m1}-g_{m2}}{g_{m1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}\\tag{17}$$\n\nIf $k_{1}=k_{2}$, $g_{m1}\\approx g_{m2}$ and\n$|A_{v}|\\ll 1$, typically $<1$. The stage degenerates\nto a source follower loaded by a common source device.\nIt can never pull to $V_{DD}$, $V_{OH}=V_{i}-V_{T}$ at\nbest, has $\\approx V_{T}$ loss, finite $V_{OL}>0$\ngiven by the $k_{1}/k_{2}$ ratio, dissipates DC power\nwhen $V_{i}=1$ and is $Hi-Z$ when $V_{i}=0$. \n\nFor that reason the circuit is not used as a logic\ninverter. The useful ${\\cal N}{\\cal MOS}$ inverter is\nobtained by connecting $G_{1}$ to $V_{DD}$ [depletion\nload, $V_{T1}<0$] or to $V_{o}$ [saturated enhancement\nload] to give a ratioed inverter with $V_{OH}=V_{DD}$,\n$V_{OH}=V_{DD}-V_{T1}$ respectively.\n\n> In short: {\\it intended} as drawn as a ${\\cal P}$ on\n> top, ${\\cal N}$ on bottom it is the textbook\n> ${\\cal C}{\\cal MOS}$ inverter, the basis of all\n> ${\\cal C}{\\cal MOS}$ logic, with rail to rail swing,\n> essentially zero static power and high noise margin.\n> {\\it Literally} as drawn with two ${\\cal N}$ devices\n> it is a non-restoring, ratioed, $Hi-Z$ for $V_{i}=0$,\n> source follower / common source divider with $\\approx 0$\n> small signal gain and threshold loss, and is not a\n> usable inverter without rewiring ${\\rm M1}$ as a load\n> device.\n\nIf you give $W/L$, $V_{T}$, $k_{n},k_{p}$ and $V_{DD}$\nthe 5 region VTC, $V_{M}$, $V_{IL},V_{IH}$, $V_{OL},V_{OH}$\nand $t_{pLH},t_{pHL}\\approx 0.69R_{on}C_{L}$ can be\nevaluated quantitatively.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "886927ef22ae76019dfd015ccf0691c1ab0b0eace07db3d4ab68540e72d4f090"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "The answer explicitly identifies both devices as NMOS, describes the upper source-follower and lower pull-down roles, and concludes the circuit is not a normal CMOS inverter. The extra conventional-inverter discussion and imperfect detailed analysis do not override the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b598ce9b14c47387d9b8d874c626add0f845d3b4bc6f5ad44a431e7ddf11ad3d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 284,
        "output_tokens": 5607,
        "total_tokens": 5891,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2823,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 284,
        "output_tokens": 5607,
        "total_tokens": 5891,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2823,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In normal {\\it CMOS} technology this is\nwith the standard assign convention\n\n$$M_{1}= {\\rm PUN}\\sim PMOS\\qquad M_{2}= {\\rm PDN}\\sim NMOS$$\n\nthe complementary {\\it push pull inverter},\ni. e. the {\\bf NOT gate}. With the literal\nbulk connexion as drawn it is miss drawn.\n\n> {\\it R. m.:} In the conventional symbol the\n> arrow is on the {\\it source} , resp. on the {\\it $n$-bulk--$p$-channel}\n> junction. I. e. for a $PMOS$ the arrow is\n> {\\it out} of the channel and for a $NMOS$ {\\it in} to the\n> channel. With that convention the upper transistor has\n> its arrow on the wrong side in Fig. and the $n$-well\n> must go to $V_{DD}$, not $V_{out}$. Otherwise the\n> source to bulk $p-n$ junction goes forward for\n> $V_{out}<V_{DD}-0.6{\\rm V}$, body effect\n> $$V_{T}=V_{T0}+\\gamma\\left[\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}+V_{SB}}-\n> \\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}}\\right] $$\n> makes $M_{1}$ signal dependent and the circuit\n> latches. Taken litteraly as two $NMOS$ with\n> $B_{1}=V_{out}$ $B_{2}=0$ and $D_{1}=V_{DD}\\;S_{1}=V_{out}\n> \\;D_{2}=V_{out}\\;S_{2}=0$ the circuit has\n> no complementary action. For $V_{in}<V_{T}$ it is\n> high $Z$ and for $V_{in}>V_{T}$ a ratioed divider. Normally it\n> is used as in Fig. 1 {\\it corr}.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nS_{1}&=V_{DD}\\cr D_{1}&=V_{out}\\cr S_{2}&=0\\cr D_{2}&=V_{out}\\cr\nG_{1}&=G_{2}=V_{in}\\cr B_{2}&=0\\;,\\;B_{1}=V_{DD}\\;{\\rm corr.}}$$\n\n{\\it Put $M_{1}PMOS$, $M_{2}NMOS$ enhancement, $|V_{T}|\\ll V_{DD}$}\n\n* {\\it Digital operation:}\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{in}=0&\\to V_{GS2}=0<V_{Tn}\\;M_{2}{\\rm OFF}\\cr\n&V_{SG1}=V_{DD}>|V_{Tp}|\\;M_{1}{\\rm ON\\;triode}\\cr\n&I_{D1}=I_{D2}=0\\;\\;V_{out}=V_{OH}\\approx V_{DD}\\cr\nV_{in}=V_{DD}&\\to V_{SG1}=0<|V_{Tp}|\\;M_{1}{\\rm OFF}\\cr\n&V_{GS2}=V_{DD}>V_{Tn}\\;M_{2}{\\rm ON\\;triode}\\cr\n&V_{out}=V_{OL}\\approx 0\\cr}$$\n\nTruth table\n\n$$\\begin{array}{|c|c|c|c|}\nV_{in} & M_{1} & M_{2} & V_{out}\\\\ \\hline\nL\\simeq 0 & ON & OFF & H\\simeq V_{DD}\\\\\nH\\simeq V_{DD} & OFF & ON & L\\simeq 0\\\\\n\\hline\n\\end{array}\\qquad V_{out}= \\bar V_{in}$$\n\nStaticaly no DC path $V_{DD}\\to 0$ except leakage,\n$$P_{stat}\\approx I_{leak}V_{DD}\\approx 0$$\nrail to rail logic swing, $R_{in}\\approx \\infty $ at\nDC.\n\nWith long channel square law, $k= k^{\\prime}W/L$,\nneglecting body effect,\n\n* {\\it VTC:} 5 regions, Fig.\n\n{\\bf A:} $0\\le V_{in}<V_{Tn}$ \\;\\; $M_{2}$ off, $M_{1}$\ntriode $V_{out}=V_{DD}$\n\n{\\bf B:} $M_{2}$ sat., $M_{1}$ triode\n\n{\\bf C:} $M_{2}$ sat., $M_{1}$ sat., high gain\n\n{\\bf D:} $M_{2}$ triode, $M_{1}$ sat.\n\n{\\bf E:} $V_{in}>V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$ \\;\\; $M_{1}$ off,\n$M_{2}$ triode $V_{out}=0$\n\nSwitching threshold defined by $V_{in}=V_{out}=V_{M}$\nand $I_{Dn}=|I_{Dp}|$ saturated:\n\n$$k_{n}(V_{M}-V_{Tn})^{2}=k_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{M}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}$$\n\n$$(1+\\lambda {\\rm corr:})$$\n\n$$V_{M}={\\displaystyle V_{Tn}+ \\sqrt{k_{p}/k_{n}}\\;(V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|)\n\\over 1+\\sqrt{k_{p}/k_{n}} }$$\n\nFor matched $k_{n}=k_{p}$, $V_{Tn}=|V_{Tp}|=V_{T}$\n\n$$V_{M}\\approx V_{DD}/2$$\n$$V_{IL}\\approx {1\\over 8}\\left(3V_{DD}+2V_{T}\\right)\\;\\;\n  V_{IH}\\approx {1\\over 8}\\left(5V_{DD}-2V_{T}\\right)$$\n\nin first order. So\n\n$$NM_{L}=V_{IL}-V_{OL}\\qquad NM_{H}=V_{OH}-V_{IH}\\approx\nV_{DD}/2-V_{T}$$\n\nlarge.\n\nUnit gain points $dV_{out}/dV_{in}=-1$ delimit the\ntransition region {\\bf B-C-D}.\n\n* {\\it Analog - small signal:}\n\nBias at $V_{M}$ both saturated, common source with\nactive load.\n\n$$g_{m}=k(V_{GS}-V_{T})\\qquad r_{o}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nA_{v}&={v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=-{g_{m1}+g_{m2}\\over g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\n\\approx -{g_{m}\\over g_{ds}}\\approx -30{\\rm \\;to\\;} -80{\\rm dB}\\cr\nR_{in}&\\approx \\infty\\cr\nR_{out}&=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\cr}$$\n\ninverting high gain amplifier, can be used as linear\n$CMOS$ inverter amplifier.\n\nDynamically $C_{L}$ at the output, Fig.,\n\n$$P_{dyn}=C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f_{clk}+V_{DD}I_{sc}+P_{leak}$$\n\nwith short circuit current $I_{sc}$ during {\\bf C} when\nboth conduct,\n\n$$I_{sc,max}\\approx {k\\over 2}(V_{DD}/2-V_{T})^{2}$$\n\nRise/fall time first order\n\n$$t_{pLH}\\approx 0.69 R_{p}C_{L}\\qquad t_{pHL}\\approx 0.69 R_{n}C_{L}$$\n\n$$t_{p}={t_{pLH}+t_{pHL}\\over 2}\\qquad \nR_{p,n}\\approx {1\\over k_{p,n}(V_{DD}-V_{T})}$$\n\nEqual $t_{pLH}=t_{pHL}$ requires\n$(W/L)_{p}\\approx \\mu_{n}/\\mu_{p}\\;(W/L)_{n}\\approx 2-3\\;(W/L)_{n}$.\n\nThat is the workhorse of $CMOS$ logic: $NOT$, and\nwith the same PUN/PDN duality $NAND$, $NOR$, etc., and\nthe simplest $CMOS$ class $B$ push pull output stage/analog\ninverter. Proper layout: $M_{2}$ in $p$-substrate $B= GND$,\n$M_{1}$ in $n$-well $B=V_{DD}$, separated to avoid\nlatch up.\n\n> With the {\\it litteral} $B_{1}=V_{out}$ the threshold\n> of $M_{1}$ is modulated $V_{Tp}(V_{out})=V_{Tp0}+\n> \\gamma[\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}+V_{DD}-V_{out}}-\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}}]$\n> and $D_{B1}$ forward biases for low $V_{out}$.\n> The circuit will not pull correctly low. Do not connect\n> the $PMOS$ bulk to the output.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d90d8fc900d9790e631dd034b11256665212a73679d0384ba55429741e6df1d4"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "Although it briefly notes that the literal circuit has two NMOS devices, the answer mainly analyzes a corrected PMOS/NMOS push-pull inverter rather than the shown circuit. The required topology and device actions are not analyzed.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b598ce9b14c47387d9b8d874c626add0f845d3b4bc6f5ad44a431e7ddf11ad3d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 227,
        "input_tokens": 284,
        "output_tokens": 5750,
        "total_tokens": 6034,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3691,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 227,
        "input_tokens": 284,
        "output_tokens": 5750,
        "total_tokens": 6034,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3691,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-015-malformed-cmos-inverter/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is with conventional notation the\n{\\it Complementary MOS PUSH-PULL } {\\it static Inverter}\n{\\tt NOT} gate. In normal drawing\n\n* $M_{2}$ is the $N$ driver, $S_{2}\\to {\\rm GND}$, $D_{2}\\to V_{out}$\n* $M_{1}$ is the $P$ load, $S_{1}\\to V_{DD}$, $D_{1}\\to V_{out}$\n\n$$G_{1}=G_{2}=V_{in}\\;\\;\\;\\;D_{1}=D_{2}=V_{out}$$\n\n> {\\it Note on the symbol:} As drawn on your figure\n> both transistors have the $N$ arrow. With two\n> enhancement $N$ MOS the circuit as drawn is\n> {\\it not} ratioless logic. $V_{in}=0$ leaves\n> both devices {\\it OFF} and $V_{out}$ floating\n> and for $V_{in}=V_{DD}$, $V_{out}=V_{DD}-V_{Tn}$\n> on account of the $V_{T}$ drop in the common\n> drain $M_{1}$. In $n$ MOS technology $M_{1}$ must\n> be a {\\it depletion} load, $V_{T1}<0$, with\n> $G_{1}$ to $S_{1}$ or to $D_{1}$. The normal\n> use today is $M_{1}=p$ MOS, $M_{2}=n$ MOS and the\n> arrow of $M_{1}$ is reversed. It is assumed in\n> the following.\n\nIn $CMOS$ the bulks are to the supplies:\n$B_{1}\\to V_{DD}$, $B_{2}\\to {\\rm GND}$ so that the\nsource - bulk junctions are reverse biased.\n\nPut in saturation for long channel, neglect\nmodulation:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{Dn}&=k_{n}\\left(V_{GSn}-V_{Tn}\\right)^{2}\\;\\;V_{GSn}>V_{Tn}\\cr\nI_{Dp}&=k_{p}\\left(V_{SGp}-|V_{Tp}|\\right)^{2}\\;\\;V_{SGp}>|V_{Tp}|\\cr}\n\\qquad k=\\tfrac12 \\mu C_{ox}W/L$$\n\n$$V_{GSn}=V_{in}\\qquad V_{SGp}=V_{DD}-V_{in}$$\n\n$$I_{Dn}=I_{Dp}=I_{D}$$ in D.C. steady state.\n\n#### 1. Logical operation - large signal\n\n| $V_{in}$ | $M_{1}P$ | $M_{2}N$ | $V_{out}$ | $I_{D}$ |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| $0 = GND = {\\rm L}$ | $V_{SG}=V_{DD}>\\vert V_{Tp}\\vert$ ON | $V_{GS}=0<V_{Tn}$ OFF | $\\approx V_{DD}= {\\rm H}$ through $R_{on,p}$ | $0$ |\n| $V_{DD}={\\rm H}$ | $V_{SG}=0$ OFF | $V_{GS}=V_{DD}>V_{Tn}$ ON | $\\approx 0 ={\\rm L}$ through $R_{on,n}$ | $0$ |\n\n$$V_{out}= \\bar V_{in}$$\n\nIdeal levels: $V_{OH}=V_{DD}$, $V_{OL}=0$ {\\it ratioless}\nfull swing. Static power $P_{s}=V_{DD}I_{D}\\approx 0$\nexcept during transition, only leakage.\n\nIn between there is a high gain transition.\n\n#### 2. Voltage transfer characteristic\n\n5 regions for increasing $V_{in}$ $0\\to V_{DD}$:\n\n{\\bf I:} $0\\le V_{in}< V_{Tn}$ : $M_{2}$ cut off,\n$M_{1}$ deep triode: $V_{out}=V_{DD}$.\n\n{\\bf II:} $V_{in}>V_{Tn}$ : $M_{2}$ saturation,\n$M_{1}$ triode. $I_{D}$ rises $\\propto (V_{in}-V_{Tn})^{2}$.\n\n{\\bf III:} Both saturation: $V_{in}\\approx V_{M}$\n\n$$k_{n}(V_{M}-V_{Tn})^{2}=k_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{M}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}$$\n\n$$V_{M}= {V_{Tn}+ \\sqrt{k_{p}/k_{n}}\\left(V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|\\right)\n\\over 1+\\sqrt{k_{p}/k_{n}} }$$\n\nFor matched device\n\n$$k_{n}=k_{p}\\;\\;V_{Tn}=|V_{Tp}|=V_{T}\\; \\Rightarrow\\; V_{M}=V_{DD}/2$$\n\nand\n\n$$-A_{v}= {dV_{out}\\over dV_{in}}\\approx {g_{m1}+g_{m2}\\over g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\gg 1$$\n\ntypically 20-50, used as linear amplifier about $V_{M}$.\n\n{\\bf IV:} $M_{2}$ triode, $M_{1}$ saturation.\n\n{\\bf V:} $V_{in}> V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$ : $M_{1}$ cut off,\n$M_{2}$ triode: $V_{out}=0$.\n\nSketch:\n\n```\nVout\nVDD |******\n    |      *\n    |       *\n    |        *\n    |         *\n    |          *\n    |           ******\n    +------------------ Vin\n    0   VIl  VM  VIh  VDD\n```\n\nNoise margins\n\n$$NM_{L}=V_{IL}-V_{OL}\\qquad NM_{H}=V_{OH}-V_{IH}$$\n\n$\\approx 0.4\\,V_{DD}$ for $V_{M}=V_{DD}/2$, maximum.\n\n#### 3. Dynamical\n\n$$P_{dyn}=C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f + V_{DD}I_{sc}$$\n\nwhere $C_{L}$ is load capacitance at $V_{out}$ and\n$I_{sc}$ is short circuit current in region III.\n\nPropagation delay for $C_{L}$ load, to first order\n\n$$t_{pLH}\\approx 0.69R_{p}C_{L}\\qquad t_{pHL}\\approx 0.69R_{n}C_{L}$$\n\n$$t_{p}= \\tfrac12\\left(t_{pLH}+t_{pHL}\\right)$$\n\nwith $R_{n,p}\\approx 1/k_{n,p}(V_{DD}-V_{T})$ in triode.\n\n> In short: with $M_{1}=p$, $M_{2}=n$ it is the\n> fundamental $CMOS$ inverter, inverting, full swing,\n> zero static power, high input impedance, low output\n> impedance in both states, high gain in the transition.\n> It is the basis of all static $CMOS$ logic and of\n> the $CMOS$ analog push-pull OTA inverter amplifier.\n\nIf you keep literally the $n-n$ symbol as drawn,\nreplace $M_{1}$ by a depletion $n$ MOS with\n$V_{T1}<0$ to get the classic $n$ MOS inverter\nwith enhancement driver $M_{2}$ and depletion\nload $M_{1}$. Its $VTC$ is ratioed, $V_{OH}<V_{DD}$,\n$V_{OL}>0$ and $P_{s}>0$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "2bd052f4f214b333f906a7daff50609ac6036972e1bd0f777455fc568f88ab71"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The answer primarily analyzes a complementary CMOS inverter and even suggests replacing the upper device with a depletion load. Although it notices the drawn devices are both NMOS, it misses the lower pull-down’s current-balance interaction with the upper source follower and gives an incorrect output conclusion for the as-drawn circuit. The golden solution explicitly assigns 0 for this topology error.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b598ce9b14c47387d9b8d874c626add0f845d3b4bc6f5ad44a431e7ddf11ad3d",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 284,
        "output_tokens": 3887,
        "total_tokens": 4171,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2167,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 284,
        "output_tokens": 3887,
        "total_tokens": 4171,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2167,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the {\\it common source stage with\ndiode connected load} also described as a\n{\\it pseudo MOS inverter with $P$-active load}.\nSometimes described loosely as a $CMOS$ inverter\nwith diode connection.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}&: driver, nMOS, CS, S\\equiv GND, {\\rm bulk}\\equiv GND\\cr\nM_{2}&: active load, pMOS, G\\equiv D , S\\equiv V_{DD},\n{\\rm bulk}\\equiv V_{DD}\\cr}$$\n\nso that $M_{2}$ is always $S=D$ when it conducts\n\n$${V_{S2}=V_{DD}\\atop V_{G2}=V_{D2}=V_{out}} \n\\;\\;V_{SG2}=V_{DD}-V_{out}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{SD2}=V_{DD}-V_{out}=V_{SG2}$$\n\n> For a $p$MOS in saturation $V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}+V_{Tp}\\;\\;V_{Tp}<0$\n> $V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|$.\n> Hence $V_{SD}=V_{SG}\\Rightarrow $ if\n> $M_{2}$ is $ON$ it is $SAT$. It is $OFF$ for\n> $V_{SG2}<|V_{Tp}|$ i. e. $V_{out}>V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$.\n\nSmall signal to $ac$ ground $V_{DD}$ is ground, $M_{2}$\nis a one terminal impedance to ground.\n\n{\\it Logic function:---} Inverted. $V_{in}=0\\Rightarrow V_{out}=\nH$, $V_{in}=1\\Rightarrow V_{out}=L$.\n\n### 1. Large signal - Voltage Transfer Characteristic\n\nPut $K_{n}=\\mu_{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}$ , $K_{p}=\\mu_{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{2}$\n$I_{Dn}=K_{n}/2\\,(V_{GS}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{n}V_{DS})$ in $SAT$,\n$I_{Dn}=K_{n}\\left[(V_{GS}-V_{Tn})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}/2\\right]$ in triode\nand similarly for $p$MOS with $V_{SG},V_{SD},|V_{Tp}|$.\n\n$I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{D}$ by KCL.\n\n* {\\bf I : $V_{in}<V_{Tn}$ :} $M_{1}$ $OFF$. $I_{D}=0$. \n$V_{SG2}=0\\Rightarrow M_{2}$ $OFF$. The output node is\nfloating in first order. Any leakage to ground pulls\n$V_{out}$ down till $M_{2}$ supplies it. In steady state\n\n$$V_{OH}\\approx V_{DD}\\;\\; {\\rm ideal}\\;\\;,V_{OH}=V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|\n\\;{\\rm with\\;leakage\\;to\\;maintain\\;}I_{D}>0$$\n\nIn most digital hand calculations $V_{OH}=V_{DD}$.\n\n* {\\bf II : $V_{Tn}<V_{in}<V_{out}+V_{Tn}$ :} $M_{1}$ $SAT$, $M_{2}$\n$SAT$, high gain region\n\n$$ {1\\over 2}K_{n}(V_{in}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{n}V_{out})\n      ={1\\over 2}K_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}(1+\\lambda_{p}\n        (V_{DD}-V_{out})) \\tag{1}$$\n\nNeglecting $\\lambda$:\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|-\\sqrt{K_{n}/K_{p}}\\,(V_{in}-V_{Tn})$$\n\nso $V_{out}$ falls linearly with $V_{in}$ with slope\n$\\sqrt{K_{n}/K_{p}}$.\n\nThe inverter threshold $V_{M}$ defined by\n$V_{in}=V_{out}=V_{M}$ in saturation:\n\n$$\\sqrt{K_{n}}(V_{M}-V_{Tn})=\\sqrt{K_{p}}(V_{DD}-V_{M}-|V_{Tp}|)$$\n\n$$V_{M}={\\sqrt{K_{n}/K_{p}}\\,V_{Tn}+V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|\n        \\over 1+\\sqrt{K_{n}/K_{p}}} \\approx\n        {V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|+V_{Tn}\\sqrt{(W/L)_{1}\\mu_{n}/(W/L)_{2}\\mu_{p}}\n        \\over 1+\\sqrt{(W/L)_{1}\\mu_{n}/(W/L)_{2}\\mu_{p}}}$$\n\nNormally sized for $V_{M}\\approx V_{DD}/2$ requires\n$K_{n}>K_{p}$ because $|V_{Tp}|\\approx V_{Tn}$.\n\n* {\\bf III : $V_{in}>V_{out}+V_{Tn}$ :} $M_{1}$ triode, $M_{2}$ $SAT$\n\n$$K_{n}\\left[(V_{in}-V_{Tn})V_{out}-{V_{out}^{2}\\over 2}\\right]\n   ={1\\over 2}K_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2} \\tag{2}$$\n\nFor $V_{in}=V_{DD}$\n\n$$V_{OL}{\\rm \\;solves\\;(2)\\;with\\;}V_{in}=V_{DD}$$\n\nE. g. neglecting $V_{OL}$ on RHS to first order\n\n$$V_{OL}\\approx {K_{p}\\over 2K_{n}(V_{DD}-V_{Tn})}\n            (V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;V_{OL}\\ll V_{DD}$$\n\nExact quadratic solution of (2) must be used for accurate value.\n$V_{OL}>0$, typically $0.1-0.3\\,{\\rm V}$. \nTo make $V_{OL}$ small need $K_{n}\\gg K_{p}$,\ni.e. $(W/L)_{1}\\gg (W/L)_{2}\\cdot \\mu_{p}/\\mu_{n}$.\n\nThis gives the familiar inverter VTC with sharp high gain\ntransition between $V_{OH}\\approx V_{DD}$ and $V_{OL}>0$,\nasymmetric, with reduced low noise margin.\n\n> Static current $I_{D}>0$ flows whenever $M_{1}$ is $ON$.\n> $P_{DC}=V_{DD}I_{D}$ in the $L$ state. This is why the\n> complementary $CMOS$ inverter with $G_{2}\\equiv V_{in}$\n> replaced it for logic.\n\nConceptually:\n\n```\nVout\n VDD |------------------\\\n      |                   \\\n      |                    \\\n      |                     \\  II - high gain\n      |                      \\\nVOL  |_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _\\_________\n      0  VTn                VM       VDD Vin\n```\n\n### 2. Small signal\n\n$V_{DD}$ is $ac$ ground. Hybrid pi for $M_{1}$: $g_{m1}v_{in}$\nfrom $D$ to $S$, $r_{o1}=1/g_{ds1}=1/\\lambda_{n}I_{D}$.\nFor $M_{2}$ $G\\equiv D$, $V_{g2}=v_{out}$:\n\n$$i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{sg2}+g_{mb2}v_{sb2}+g_{ds2}v_{sd2}$$\n$$v_{sg2}=-v_{out}\\;\\;,v_{sd2}=-v_{out}$$\n\nIf bulk $\\equiv$ source $v_{sb2}=0$, otherwise\n$v_{sb2}=-v_{out}$. Hence $M_{2}$ looks like a conductance to\nground\n\n$$G_{2}=g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2} \\approx g_{m2}+g_{ds2}$$\n\n$$Z_{2}= {1\\over G_{2}}={1\\over g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m2}}$$\n\nOutput resistance at $V_{out}$ node\n\n$$R_{out}=r_{o1}\\parallel Z_{2}= {1\\over g_{ds1}}\\parallel\n          {1\\over g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\n          \\approx {1\\over g_{m2}} \\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$$\n\nFor $\\lambda\\approx 0$, $R_{out}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$.\n\nVoltage gain:\n\n$$A_{v}={v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=-g_{m1}R_{out}\n      =-{g_{m1}\\over g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}$$\n\n$$\\left|A_{v}\\right|\\approx {g_{m1}\\over g_{m2}} \n        = \\sqrt{{K_{n}\\over K_{p}}}=\n          \\sqrt{{\\mu_{n}(W/L)_{1}\\over \\mu_{p}(W/L)_{2}}}$$\n\nneglecting $\\lambda$ and body effect, independent of bias\ncurrent to first order. Including $\\lambda$,\n\n$$|A_{v}|={g_{m1}\\over g_{m2}+(\\lambda_{n}+\\lambda_{p})I_{D}}$$\n\nTypically $5$ to $20$ depending on sizing and $L$. Much less\nthan a current source load $g_{m1}r_{o}$. Including body\neffect $|A_{v}|=g_{m1}/(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})$ is even smaller.\n\nInput impedance $Z_{in}\\approx \\infty$ , capacitive\n$C_{gs1}$. Output pole $\\omega_{p}=1/R_{out}C_{L}$ where\n$C_{L}=C_{db1}+C_{db2}+C_{gd1}+C_{gd2}+C_{wire}$.\n\nThis is a Class A inverting amplifier. It inverts phase\n$180^{o}$ at low frequency, has moderate gain set by geometry\nratio, limited output swing $V_{OL}$ to $V_{DD}$, finite\nstatic dissipation, and $R_{out}\\sim 1/g_{m}$.\n\nIt is useful as an analog gain stage, as a load in a\ndifferential pair with diode connected load, for biasing,\nand as a textbook active load. As a logic inverter it is the\npre-$CMOS$ ``enhancement load'' or ``diode load'' inverter,\nnow superseded by the complementary $CMOS$ inverter\n$M_{2}$ gate $=V_{in}$ which gives rail to rail swing,\n$r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$ gain and zero static power.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "8d625b0e7d348806ed5fdb0755a694bb882f937fff33e2c6299aa810a23b294f"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-source NMOS stage with a diode-connected PMOS load and gives the inverting gain as approximately −gm1/gm2. Its channel-length-modulation expression includes both devices’ output conductances; the body-effect nuance does not alter the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "890a218dd592ccc44d29c47d073a2630294c84b195016d665cdb5f09108c1fc5",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 731,
        "output_tokens": 5528,
        "total_tokens": 6259,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3004,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 731,
        "output_tokens": 5528,
        "total_tokens": 6259,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3004,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "It is the prototype of a MOS analog stage,\na $n$ - channel common source - common gate\nwith {\\it active load} - a $p$ channel\nload in {\\it diode conection} .\n\n$${\\cal M}_{1}:n{\\rm -MOS}  ~~ g=g(V_{in}),s=0,d=V_{out}$$\n$${\\cal M}_{2}:p{\\rm -MOS} ~~ s=V_{DD},g=d=V_{out}$$\n\ni.e. the normal CMOS inverter with the gate of the\n$p$ tied to the output. In analog language the\nCS driver loaded by $1/g_{m}$.\n\n$$V_{GS1}=V_{in} \\;\\; ,V_{DS1}=V_{out}$$\n$$V_{SG2}=V_{SD2}=V_{DD}-V_{out}\\;\\; ,V_{G2}=V_{D2}$$\n$$V_{SB1}=0\\;\\;,V_{SB2}=0$$\n\nNo body effect to first order, $p$ well to $GND$\nand $n$ well to $V_{DD}$ if twin well process.\n\nFor the $p$, $${\\rm sat} : V_{SD} \\ge V_{SG}+V_{Tp}\n= V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|$$ with $V_{Tp}<0$.\n\nBut $V_{SD2}=V_{SG2}$, so if it conducts\n\n$$V_{SG2}\\ge V_{SG2}-|V_{Tp}|$$\n\nis always satisfied. The $p$ is\n\n* OFF for $V_{SG2}<|V_{Tp}|$, $V_{out}>V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$\n* SAT for $V_{SG2}>|V_{Tp}|$, $V_{out}<V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$\n\nFor the $n$ $${\\rm sat} : V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{Tn}$$\n\n$$V_{out} \\ge V_{in}-V_{Tn}\\;\\;{\\rm sat} \\qquad \n  V_{out} \\le V_{in}-V_{Tn}\\;\\;{\\rm triode}$$\n\n$$V_{in}<V_{Tn}\\;\\;{\\rm cut off}$$\n\nIn ordinary first order square law, $\\lambda =0$:\n\n$$I_{D1}= \\begin{cases}\n0 & V_{in}<V_{Tn}\\\\\nk_{n}(V_{in}-V_{Tn})^{2} & V_{in}>V_{Tn}\\;{\\rm sat}\\\\\nk_{n}\\left[ 2(V_{in}-V_{Tn})V_{out}-V_{out}^{2}\\right] \n& {\\rm triode}\n\\end{cases}$$\n\n$$k_{n}=\\tfrac12\\mu_{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}\\;\\;,\n  k_{p}=\\tfrac12\\mu_{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{2}$$\n\n$$I_{D2}= \\begin{cases}\n0 & V_{out}>V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|\\\\\nk_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2} & V_{out}<V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|\n\\end{cases}$$\n\nand $I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{D}$ in DC steady state.\n\n* 1. $V_{in}<V_{Tn}$ : ${\\cal M}_{1}$ OFF, $I_{D}=0$,\n${\\cal M}_{2}$ OFF.\n\nAny $V_{out}<V_{DD}$ turns ${\\cal M}_{2}$ ON and\ncharges the output node to $V_{DD}$. Strictly\n$I_{D}=0$, $V_{SG2}=0$.\n\n> $$V_{out}=V_{OH}=V_{DD}\\tag{a}$$\n\nNeglecting leakage/subthreshold.\n\n* 2. $V_{in}>V_{Tn}$ small so that both SAT:\n\n$$k_{n}(V_{in}-V_{Tn})^{2}=k_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}$$\n\n> $$V_{out}=V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|-\\sqrt{\\frac{k_{n}}{k_{p}}}\\,\n\\left(V_{in}-V_{Tn}\\right) \\tag{b}$$\n\nlinear $V_{in}-V_{out}$ characteristic. This is the\nuseful {\\it amplifier} region.\n\nIt is valid while $V_{out}\\ge V_{in}-V_{Tn}$, i. e.\n\n$$V_{in}\\le V_{Tn}+\\frac{V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|}\n{1+\\sqrt{k_{n}/k_{p}}}=V_{I\\,sat}$$\n\nAt $V_{in}=V_{I\\,sat}$ , $V_{out}=V_{I\\,sat}-V_{Tn}$.\n\n* 3. $V_{in}>V_{I\\,sat}$ : ${\\cal M}_{1}$ triode,\n${\\cal M}_{2}$ sat:\n\n$$k_{n}\\left[2(V_{in}-V_{Tn})V_{out}-V_{out}^{2}\\right]\n      =k_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}\\tag{c}$$\n\nwhich gives low\n\n$$V_{OL}$$\n\nfor $V_{in}=V_{DD}$ as the root of (c). For\n$V_{OL}\\ll V_{in}-V_{Tn}$,\n\n$$V_{OL}\\approx \\left(V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|\\right)\n \\sqrt{\\frac{k_{p}}{k_{n}}}\\Big/ \\sqrt{2(V_{DD}-V_{Tn})}$$\n\nmore generally solution of the quadratic in $V_{OL}$.\n$V_{OL}>0$, static current $\\ne 0$, so poor logic\ninverter. The DC voltage transfer curve is\n\n```\nVout\nVDD |********\n    |        *\n    |         \\\n    |          \\  both sat, slope -sqrt(kn/kp)\n    |           \\\n    |            * triode\n    |             ******** VOL\n    +------------------------ Vin\n    0   VTn   VIsat   VDD\n```\n\nWith $\\lambda >0$, $I_{D}=k(V_{GS}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{DS})$,\nthe slope is rounded and a finite output conductance appears.\n\nSmall signal at a bias $Q$ in (b):\n\n$${\\cal M}_{1}: g_{m1},g_{ds1}=r_{o1}^{-1}=\\lambda_{n}I_{D},\n\\qquad {\\cal M}_{2}: g_{m2},g_{ds2}=r_{o2}^{-1}=\\lambda_{p}I_{D}$$\n\nDiode connected : $g_{2}$ tied to $d_{2}$.\n\n$$Z_{2}= \\frac{v_{x}}{i_{x}}\\Big|_{s_{2}=ac\\,gnd} \n      =\\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nIf well to source, $g_{mb2}=0$.\nAt the output node\n\n> $$R_{out}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\parallel \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{ds2}+g_{mb2}}\n      \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\tag{d}$$\n\nSince $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$, $R_{out}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$,\nvery low for a CS stage, wide band.\n\nVoltage gain:\n\n> $$A_{v}= \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}}=-g_{m1}R_{out}\n      = -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+g_{mb2}} \\tag{e}$$\n\n$$\\approx -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}} \n      =-\\sqrt{\\frac{k_{n}}{k_{p}}}\\,\n        \\sqrt{\\frac{1+\\lambda_{n}V_{out}}{1+\\lambda_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out})}}$$\n\n$$\\;A_{v0}\\approx -\\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_{n}(W/L)_{1}}{\\mu_{p}(W/L)_{2}}}\\;\n      =-\\sqrt{\\frac{(W/L)_{1}}{(W/L)_{2}}}\\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_{n}}{\\mu_{p}}}\\;$$\n\nfor $\\lambda =0$ and $(V_{GS}-V_{T})$ elimination using\n$g_{m}=2k(V_{GS}-V_{T})= \\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}(W/L)I_{D}}$.\n\nTypically $|A_{v}|\\sim 2-20$ depending on sizing.\nTo get gain magnitude $>1$ you need\n$(W/L)_{1} > (\\mu_{p}/\\mu_{n})(W/L)_{2}$.\nIntrinsic gain $g_{m}r_{o}\\sim 20-100$ is killed by the\n$1/g_{m}$ load.\n\nInput resistance $\\approx \\infty$ at low frequency,\n$C_{in}=C_{gs1}+(1-A_{v})C_{gd1}$ with Miller.\n\nFrequency response: dominant pole at output\n\n$$\\omega_{p}\\approx \\frac{1}{R_{out}C_{L}} \\approx \\frac{g_{m2}}{C_{L}}$$\n\nwith $C_{L}=C_{db1}+C_{db2}+C_{gd1}+C_{gd2}+C_{ext}$,\nso GBW $\\approx g_{m1}/C_{L}$.\n\nRemarks:\n\n* Non inverting from $V_{DD}$ - good PSRR is poor.\n* Burns static power $I_{D}V_{DD}$ when ${\\cal M}_{1}$ is ON.\n  Not ratio-less logic like complementary CMOS inverter.\n* Used where low gain, low $R_{out}$, large swing to\n $V_{DD}$ on top is wanted and simplicity prevails over\n gain: level shifter, $V_{GS}$ multiplier, wide band\n CS stage, $I$ to $V$ converter, load for differential\n pair when diode connected load differential pair is needed.\n For high gain the load is replaced by a current source\n $r_{o2}$, $A_{v}=-g_{m1}(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2})$ or\n cascode.\n\nWith body effect if bulk not tied, $g_{mb2}\\ne 0$,\n$A_{v}=-g_{m1}/(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2})$ still lower.\nThe $p$ load is preferred to $n$ diode load precisely\nbecause its $n$-well can be strapped to $V_{DD}$ eliminating\n$g_{mb}$.\n\nThis is sometimes called NMOS inverter with PMOS\nenhancement active load or pseudo-NMOS with saturated load.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0a38afe89f7f0632c39f2e70378cbb6e3c67fc5fc2a3b4157fe696919b2bc288"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-source NMOS with a diode-connected PMOS load and gives the inverting gain, including a consistent form with both devices’ output conductances. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule; the extra large-signal analysis is not essential.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "890a218dd592ccc44d29c47d073a2630294c84b195016d665cdb5f09108c1fc5",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 731,
        "output_tokens": 5045,
        "total_tokens": 5776,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2583,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 731,
        "output_tokens": 5045,
        "total_tokens": 5776,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2583,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-016-common-source-diode-connected-load/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the saturation loaded or diode loaded\ncommon source stage\n\n$$M_{1} : N ~{\\rm driver}~~~M_{2}: P~ {\\rm load,\n~~}G_{2}\\equiv D_{2}$$\n\n> For small signal often drawn ``upside down''\n> $M_{1}$ with $S_{1}=0$, $G_{1}=V_{in}$,$D_{1}=V_{out}$,\n> $M_{2}$ with $S_{2}=V_{DD}$, $G_{2}=D_{2}=V_{out}$.\n> $n-$well of $M_{2}$ to $V_{DD}$, $p-$sub of $M_{1}$\n> to $GND$, so $V_{BS1}=V_{BS2}=0$ if ideal.\n\nIt is the CMOS version of the $nMOS$ saturated\nenhancement load inverter. It is ratioed, it draws\nstatic current and it is to-day used only as a\nwide band small signal amplifier or as the active\nresistor load of a differential pair. With normal\nnotation $K_{n}=k_{n}W_{1}/L_{1}$, $k_{n}=\\mu _{n}C_{ox}$,\n$K_{p}=k_{p}W_{2}/L_{2}$, $V_{TN}>0$, $V_{TP}=-|V_{TP}|<0$.\n\nIn long channel square law, $ \\lambda =0$ first order\n\n$$I_{D} = \\frac{1}{2}K(V_{GS}-V_{T})^{2} ~~{\\rm sat.}$$\n$$I_{D} = K\\left[(V_{GS}-V_{T})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}/2\\right]~~{\\rm triode}$$\n$$g_{m}=K(V_{GS}-V_{T}) =\\sqrt{2KI_{D}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;r_{o}=1/g_{ds}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$$\n\nFor $M_{2}$\n\n$$V_{SG2}=V_{DD}-V_{out}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{SD2}=V_{DD}-V_{out}=V_{SG2}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$V_{SD2}\\ge V_{SG2}+V_{TP}=V_{SG2}-|V_{TP}|\\tag{*}$$\n\nis identically satisfied for $|V_{TP}|>0$. {\\it The\ndiode transistor is always saturated when on.}\n\nFor $M_{1}$\n\n$$V_{DS1}=V_{out}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{GS1}=V_{in}$$\n\nsaturation:\n\n$$V_{out}\\ge V_{in}-V_{TN}\\tag{**}$$\n\n### 1. Large signal $V_{TC}$\n\n$I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{D}$.\n\n{\\rm I:}$V_{in}<V_{TN}$ : $M_{1}$ off. $I_{D}=0$.\n$M_{2}$ can be off with $V_{SG2}<|V_{TP}|$ and the\noutput node is pulled to the rail\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}\\qquad V_{OH}=V_{DD}$$\n\nIn this region $M_{2}$ is off or in subthreshold.\n\n{\\rm II:}$V_{in}>V_{TN}$ and (**) satisfied: Both saturated.\nNeglecting $r_{o}$:\n\n$$\\frac12 K_{n}(V_{in}-V_{TN})^{2}= \\frac12 K_{p}\n\\left(V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{TP}|\\right)^{2}$$\n\n$$\\;V_{out}=V_{DD}-|V_{TP}|-\\sqrt{\\frac{K_{n}}{K_{p}}}\\,\n\\left(V_{in}-V_{TN}\\right)\\; \\tag{1}$$\n\nin saturation. Linear decreasing characteristic with\nincremental slope\n\n$$\\frac{dV_{out}}{dV_{in}}=-\\sqrt{\\frac{K_{n}}{K_{p}}}\n =-\\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_{n}}{\\mu_{p}}\\frac{(W/L)_{1}}{(W/L)_{2}}}$$\n\nThis is already the low frequency large signal\nvoltage gain. If $K_{n}=K_{p}$ the slope is $-1$.\nNormally $\\mu_{n}\\approx 2-3\\mu_{p}$ so with equal\ngeometry $|A_{v}|\\approx 1.5-2$.\n\nWith $\\lambda \\ne 0$\n\n$$K_{n}(V_{in}-V_{TN})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{n}V_{out})\n =K_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{TP}|)^{2}(1+\\lambda_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out}))$$\n\nto first order the same Eq.1.\n\nRegion II exists while (**) holds, i.e.\n\n$$V_{DD}-|V_{TP}|-\\sqrt{\\frac{K_{n}}{K_{p}}}(V_{in}-V_{TN})\n \\ge V_{in}-V_{TN}$$\n\n$$V_{in}\\le V_{TN}+ \\frac{V_{DD}-|V_{TP}|}{1+\\sqrt{K_{n}/K_{p}}}=V_{IL}$$\n\nand $V_{in}\\ge V_{TN}$.\n\n{\\rm III:}$V_{in}$ large, $V_{out}<V_{in}-V_{TN}$ : $M_{1}$\ntriode, $M_{2}$ saturation.\n\n$$K_{n}\\left[(V_{in}-V_{TN})V_{out}-V_{out}^{2}/2\\right]\n =\\frac12 K_{p}\\left(V_{DD}-V_{out}-|V_{TP}|\\right)^{2} \\tag{2}$$\n\nquadratic in $V_{out}$, $V_{out}$ falling slowly to a\nfinite\n\n$$V_{OL}>0$$\n\nSolution of (2) for $V_{in}=V_{DD}$ gives the logic\nlow level. E.G. for $K_{n}=K_{p}$, $V_{DD}=1.8\\,{\\rm V}$,\n$V_{TN}=|V_{TP}|=0.4\\,{\\rm V}$, $V_{OL}\\approx 0.3-0.4\\,{\\rm V}$.\n$V_{OL}$ can be lowered only by making\n$K_{n}\\gg K_{p}$, i.e. a ratioed inverter.\n\nHence the familiar $VTC$:\n\n$$V_{DD}\\xrightarrow{V_{in}<V_{TN}}{\\rm flat}\\xrightarrow{\\rm II}\n{\\rm linear\\;with\\;slope\\;-\\sqrt{K_{n}/K_{p}}}\\xrightarrow{\\rm III}\n{\\rm triode\\;tail\\;to\\;}V_{OL}$$\n\nMaximum swing $V_{OH}-V_{OL}<V_{DD}$, limited on\nthe low side. No rail to rail operation.\n\nIn normal amplifier use the $Q-$point is put in region\nII by biasing $V_{in}=V_{BIAS}>V_{TN}$ so that\n$I_{D}= {\\tfrac12}K_{n}(V_{BIAS}-V_{TN})^{2}$ and\n$V_{out}=V_{DD}-|V_{TP}|-\\sqrt{K_{n}/K_{p}}(V_{BIAS}-V_{TN})$\nin the middle of the allowed $V_{out}$ range.\n\nPower dissipation in the on state\n\n$$P_{DC}=V_{DD}I_{D}$$\n\n### 2. Small signal\n\nGate input, $R_{in}= \\infty $ at low frequency.\n\nFor small signal $m_{2}$ has $g_{2}\\equiv d_{2}$ so\n\n$$v_{gs2}= -v_{out}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{ds2}= -v_{out}$$\n\n$$i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{sg2}+g_{ds2}v_{sd2}= (g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2})v_{out}\n\\approx (g_{m2}+g_{ds2})v_{out}$$\n\ni.e. the impedance looking into the source of a\ndiode is $1/(g_{m}+g_{ds}+g_{mb})$. To ground from the\noutput node the load is\n\n$$Z_{2}= \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;g_{m2}\\gg g_{ds2}$$\n\nThe driver $M_{1}$ is a normal $g_{m1}$ stage with\n$g_{ds1}$ to ground.\n\nSmall signal equivalent at $V_{out}$: current source\n$g_{m1}v_{in}$ to ground in parallel with $g_{ds1}$\nand $Z_{2}^{-1}$ .\n\n$$v_{out}\\left[g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}\\right] = -g_{m1}v_{in}$$\n\n$$\\;A_{v}\\equiv \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}}=\n -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\;$$\n\nWith no body effect $g_{mb}=0$ and\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}}\\frac{1}{1+(g_{ds1}+g_{ds2})/g_{m2}}$$\n\nIf $r_{o}=\\infty$,\n\n$$\\;A_{v0}= -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}}=\n -\\sqrt{\\frac{K_{n}}{K_{p}}}\\,\n   \\sqrt{\\frac{1+\\lambda_{n}V_{out}}{1+\\lambda_{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out})}}\n \\approx -\\sqrt{\\frac{\\mu_{n}(W/L)_{1}}{\\mu_{p}(W/L)_{2}}}\\;$$\n\ntypically $5-10$ with reasonable ratio, $20$ at most\nbefore the swing is killed. Including $r_{o}$\n\n$$|A_{v}| = \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}}\\frac{1}{1+\\frac{\\lambda_{n}+\\lambda_{p}}{g_{m2}}I_{D}} < g_{m1}/g_{m2}$$\n\nOutput resistance at the output node\n\n$$\\;R_{out}= r_{o1}\\parallel \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\n \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}\\parallel r_{o1}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}\\;$$\n\nNormally $1/g_{m2}\\sim {\\rm k\\Omega }$.\n\nInput capacitance $C_{gs1}+C_{gd1}(1+|A_{v}|)$ Miller,\noutput pole\n\n$$p_{out}\\approx \\frac{1}{R_{out}C_{L}} \\approx \\frac{g_{m2}}{C_{L}+C_{db1}+C_{db2}+C_{gd1}+C_{gd2}}$$\n\nwide band, low gain stage. Gain $\\times$ bandwidth\n$\\approx g_{m1}/C_{L}$.\n\nIn short: inverter with low, ratio dependent gain,\nlow $R_{out}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$, infinite $R_{in}$,\ninverting, class A, static power, reduced logic\nswing. It can be used as a simple transconductance\nto resistance converter.\n\nHigh gain $\\gg 10$ requires replacing the diode by\na true current source $r_{o2}$ load, cascode, or\ndifferential active current mirror load.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "695eab98eb641b9e2d2f88877b165f14377ba3860ddba16a88c8e81176b818e6"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-source NMOS stage with a diode-connected PMOS load and gives the inverting gain −gm1/gm2, with both output conductances included in its channel-length-modulation form. The extra body-effect detail does not change the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "890a218dd592ccc44d29c47d073a2630294c84b195016d665cdb5f09108c1fc5",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 611,
        "input_tokens": 731,
        "output_tokens": 5140,
        "total_tokens": 5871,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2537,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 611,
        "input_tokens": 731,
        "output_tokens": 5140,
        "total_tokens": 5871,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2537,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the 3 electrode convention the arrow\nis the source.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{2}&:{\\rm source} \\equiv V_{{\\rm DD}}\\cr\n&:{\\rm drain}\\equiv V_{o}\\cr\n&:{\\rm gate}\\equiv V_{i}\\cr\nM_{1}&:{\\rm source}\\equiv V_{o}\\cr\n&:{\\rm drain}\\equiv 0\\cr\n&:{\\rm gate}\\equiv 0}$$\n\nboth $p$ channel.\nPut $|V_{T}|=-V_{T}>0$\n\n$$I_{D}^{p}={k_{p}\\over 2}(V_{SG}-|V_{T}|)^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda V_{SD}\\right] $$\ntriode\n$$I_{D}^{p}=k_{p}\\left[(V_{SG}-|V_{T}|)V_{SD}-{1\\over 2}V_{SD}^{2}\n\\right]$$\n$$k_{p}=\\mu _{p}C_{ox}W/L\\qquad g_{m}=k_{p}(V_{SG}-|V_{T}|)=\n\\sqrt{2k_{p}I_{D}}\\qquad g_{ds}=\\lambda I_{D}=r_{o}^{-1}$$\n\n$${\\rm sat:}\\;V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}-|V_{T}|\\tag{*}$$\n\nFor $M_{1}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{SG1}&=V_{S1}-V_{G1}=V_{o}-0=V_{o}\\cr\nV_{SD1}&=V_{S1}-V_{D1}=V_{o}-0=V_{o}}$$\n\nso that if it is on\n\n$$V_{SD1}=V_{SG1}$$\n\nand {\\rm (*)} is $V_{o}\\ge V_{o}-|V_{T}|$ always in\nsaturation :\n\n$$I_{D1}={k_{1}\\over 2}(V_{o}-|V_{T1}|)^{2}\\;\\;V_{o}>|V_{T1}|\n\\tag{1}$$\n$$I_{D1}=0\\;\\;V_{o}\\le |V_{T1}|\\tag{1a}$$\ncut off.\n\n$$I_{S1}=g_{m1}v_{sg1}+g_{ds1}v_{sd1}+g_{mb1}v_{sb1}$$\n\nWith the normal 3 T connection the $n$ well is on the\nsource $v_{sb1}=0$.  If the well is on $V_{DD}$,\n$v_{sb1}=V_{DD}-V_{o}$, $g_{mb1}\\ne 0$ and\n\n$$|V_{T1}|=|V_{T0}|+\\gamma \\left[\n\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{SB1}}-\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}}\\right],\\qquad\nV_{SB1}=V_{o}-V_{B}$$\n\nIn the small signal sense $M_{1}$ is a diode\n\n$$i_{s1}=(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1})v_{o} \\approx g_{m1}v_{o}$$\n\ni. e. a resistance to ground\n\n$$R_{1}={1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}}\n\\tag{2}$$\n\nwith the body to source $g_{mb1}=0$.\n\nFor $M_{2}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{SG2}&=V_{DD}-V_{i}\\cr\nV_{SD2}&=V_{DD}-V_{o}}$$\n\nsaturation {\\rm (*)} is\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{o}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{T2}|$$\n\n$$V_{o}\\le V_{i}+|V_{T2}|\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$I_{D2}^{sat}={k_{2}\\over 2}(V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{T2}|)^{2}\n\\tag{4}$$\n$$I_{D2}^{tri}=k_{2}\\left[(V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{T2}|)(V_{DD}-V_{o})\n-{1\\over 2}(V_{DD}-V_{o})^{2}\\right] \\tag{5}$$\n\nThe circuit is a ratioed $p$ only inverter, the $p$\ncommon source stage $M_{2}$ loaded by the $p$ diode\n$M_{1}$.  The old $p{\\rm MOS}$ saturated load\ninverter, the $p$ analogue of the $n{\\rm MOS}$\nenhancement load inverter or of the pseudo $n{\\rm MOS}$\ninverter.  $KCL$ at the output, neglecting $\\lambda $,\n\n$$I_{D2}(V_{i},V_{o})=I_{D1}(V_{o})\\tag{6}$$\n\ngives the large signal voltage transfer characteristic.\n\n* $V_{i}>V_{DD}-|V_{T2}|$ : $V_{SG2}<|V_{T}|$, $M_{2}$\ncut off, $I_{D2}=0$.  From (1a) $I_{D1}=0$ for\n$V_{o}\\le |V_{T1}|$.  The output node is high\nimpedance. In the ideal square law model any\n$V_{o}<|V_{T1}|$ satisfies (6). Leakage pulls the\nnode to ground, in strong inversion analysis\n\n$$V_{OL}\\approx |V_{T1}| \\tag{7}$$\n\nwith body to $V_{DD}$ $V_{OL}=|V_{T1}(V_{OL})|> |V_{T0}|$.\nThis is the source follower limit of the $p$ load:\na $p$ device with gate at $0$ can pull no lower than\n$V_{G}+|V_{T}|$.  The analogue of $V_{OH}=V_{DD}-V_{Tn}$\nfor the $n{\\rm MOS}$ enhancement load inverter.\n\nOn raising $V_{DD}-V_{i}$ above $|V_{T2}|$, $M_{2}$\nturns on in saturation, (3) satisfied because $V_{o}$\nis low.\n\n* Both saturated. From (1) (4)\n\n$${k_{2}\\over 2}(V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{T2}|)^{2}=\n{k_{1}\\over 2}(V_{o}-|V_{T1}|)^{2}$$\n\n$$V_{o}=|V_{T1}|+\\sqrt{{k_{2}\\over k_{1}}}\n\\left(V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{T2}|\\right)\\tag{8}$$\n\nlinear $V_{o}(V_{i})$ with incremental slope\n\n$${dV_{o}\\over dV_{i}}=-\\sqrt{{k_{2}\\over k_{1}}}\n=-{g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}} \\tag{9}$$\n\nwhich is the low frequency small signal voltage gain\nwith $\\lambda =0$.\n\nThe both saturated regime ends when (3) is violated,\ni. e.\n\n$$V_{o}=V_{i}+|V_{T2}|\\tag{10}$$\n\n* $M_{2}$ triode, $M_{1}$ saturated. From (1)(5)\n\n$$k_{2}\\left[(V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{T2}|)(V_{DD}-V_{o})\n-{1\\over 2}(V_{DD}-V_{o})^{2}\\right]=\n{k_{1}\\over 2}(V_{o}-|V_{T1}|)^{2}\\tag{11}$$\n\nparabolic $VTC$, gain falling.\n\nFor $V_{i}\\to 0$, $V_{SG2}=V_{DD}$, $M_{2}$ in deep\ntriode, $V_{o}$ approaches $V_{DD}$ to within the\ndrop on $R_{on2}$.  E. {\\rm g}. $k_{1}=k_{2}$, $|V_{T1}|\n=|V_{T2}|=|V_{T}|$, $y=V_{DD}-|V_{T}|$, $x=V_{DD}-V_{o}$,\n(11) gives\n\n$$yx-{1\\over 2}x^{2}={1\\over 2}(y-x)^{2}$$\n\n$$2x^{2}-4yx+y^{2}=0$$\n\n$$x=y\\left(1-{1\\over\\sqrt{2}}\\right)\\approx 0.29y$$\n\n$$V_{OH}=V_{DD}-0.29\\left(V_{DD}-|V_{T}|\\right)\n\\approx 0.70V_{DD}+0.30|V_{T}|<V_{DD}\\tag{12}$$\n\nin general $V_{OH}$ is the solution of (11) for\n$V_{i}=V_{IL}\\approx 0$.  $V_{OH}\\to V_{DD}$ only for\n$k_{2}/k_{1}\\gg 1$, $R_{on2}\\ll R_{1}$.\n\nSo the $VTC$ is inverter like, Fig.1, but ratioed\nand of very limited swing:\n\n$$|V_{T1}|\\le V_{o}\\le V_{OH}<V_{DD}$$\n\nthe high level is $V_{DD}-I_{D}R_{on2}$, the low level\nis the $V_{T}$ drop of the $p$ source follower.\nFor $k_{1}=k_{2}$ the logic threshold $V_{i}=V_{o}=V_{M}$\nfrom (8) is\n\n$$V_{M}= {V_{DD}+|V_{T1}|-|V_{T2}|\\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}\n\\over 1+\\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}}$$\n\nfor $|V_{T1}|=|V_{T2}|$ and $k_{1}=k_{2}$, $V_{M}=V_{DD}/2$,\nas usual.\n\n> {\\it Small signal:}  Ac ground $V_{DD}$.\n\n$M_{2}$: common source, $v_{sg2}=-v_{i}$,\n$v_{sd2}=-v_{o}$\n\n$M_{1}$: common gate, source input, gate and drain ac\nground.\n\nNodal at $v_{o}$:\n\n$$\\left(g_{m2}v_{sg2}+g_{ds2}v_{sd2}\\right)=\n\\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}\\right)v_{o}$$\n\n$$-g_{m2}v_{i}-g_{ds2}v_{o}=(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1})v_{o}$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{o}\\over v_{i}}=\n-{g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nand with $g_{mb1}=0$ for body to source,\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -{g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}}\n= -\\sqrt{{k_{2}\\over k_{1}}}\\;\n{\\sqrt{I_{D2}}\\over\\sqrt{I_{D1}}}=\n-\\sqrt{{(W/L)_{2}\\over (W/L)_{1}}}$$\n\nat the both saturated bias point $I_{D1}=I_{D2}$.\nNeglecting $\\lambda $ the magnitude is the square\nroot of the aspect ratio.  To get gain $>1$,\n$(W/L)_{2}>(W/L)_{1}$.  With body effect,\n$A_{v}=-g_{m2}/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})$ reduced $10-30\\%$.\nIncluding $r_{o}$,\n\n$$R_{out}=r_{o2}\\parallel {1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}}\n\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}}\\tag{14}$$\n\n$$R_{in}= \\infty ,\\;\\;C_{in}\\approx C_{gs2}+C_{gd2}(1+|A_{v}|)$$\n\nSingle pole at the output\n\n$$A_{v}(s)={A_{v0}\\over 1+sR_{out}C_{L}}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{-3{\\rm dB}}={1\\over R_{out}C_{L}}\n\\approx {g_{m1}\\over C_{L}}\\tag{15}$$\n\n$$GBW = |A_{v0}|\\omega _{-3{\\rm dB}}\\approx g_{m2}/C_{L}$$\n\nStatic power\n\n$$P_{DC}=V_{DD}I_{D}\\approx {V_{DD}k_{1}\\over 2}\n(V_{o}-|V_{T1}|)^{2}>0$$\n\nalways dissipates in the both on state; class A.\nThe circuit is therefore obsolete for dense digital\nCMOS - it is ratioed, draws static current, has\n$|A_{v}|\\sim 1-5$ and reduced logic swing and noise\nmargins - but historically the basic $p{\\rm MOS}$\nlogic inverter and still used as a low gain wideband\ntransimpedance/active load, level shifter, or as the\nload device in a differential pair with $p$ active\nload where the $1/g_{m}$ load gives\n$A_{d}=g_{m,in}/(g_{m,load}+g_{ds})$.\n\nWith $V_{i}$ biased at $V_{M}$ so that both devices\nare saturated the circuit is a small signal amplifier\nwith voltage gain (13), output resistance (14) and\nbandwidth (15). Any other bias puts one device in\ntriode/cut off and the gain collapses.  Cascoding\n$M_{1}$ or using a current source load is required\nfor high gain.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "9ee82f69a6cfc006b858f984bdc135a7944afaa9ad14e1d32b90867ea51545f5"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies both devices as PMOS, M2 as the common-source input device, M1 as the diode-connected PMOS load, and derives the gm/gm gain (approximately −gm2/gm1). Extra logic-level discussion does not replace or contradict the essential interpretation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b9bd40d93897263d8f8ec48e8a570180ddbbc0962f905b31861c1d4b96315bc9",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1757,
        "output_tokens": 12671,
        "total_tokens": 14428,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9431,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1757,
        "output_tokens": 12671,
        "total_tokens": 14428,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9431,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a {\\it ratioed} $p$-only inverter in\nenhancement - saturated load\nconfiguration. i. e. $p$ channel common-source with\n$p$ channel diode load.\n\n$$M_{2}: {\\rm driver} ~S=V_{DD}{\\rm ,\\;G}=V_{in}{\\rm ,\\;D}=V_{out}$$\n\n$$M_{1}: {\\rm load} ~S=V_{out}{\\rm ,\\;D}=0{\\rm ,\\;G}=0,\\;\n{\\rm diode\\; connected\\;}G\\equiv D$$\n\nBoth are $p{\\rm MOS}$, $|V_{T}|=-V_{Tp}>0$, \n$k_{p}=\\mu _{p}C_{ox}W/L$,\n$I_{SD}=(k_{p}/2)(V_{SG}-|V_{T}|)^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{SD})$\nin saturation. For the symbol as drawn $B\\equiv S$\nso $V_{SB}=0$, $V_{T}=V_{T0}$, $g_{mb}=0$ on the\nsignal. If the two devices share the $n$ - well\n$B_{1}=V_{DD}$, $V_{SB1}=V_{DD}-V_{out}\\ne 0$ and\n\n$$V_{T1}=V_{T0}+\\gamma \\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi _{f}+V_{SB}}-\n\\sqrt{2\\phi _{f}}\\right) \\;\\;,g_{mb}\\ne 0$$\n\nis to be added.\n\nIn 3T language the arrow is the source :\n\n> $M_{2}$ CS device $S_{2}=V_{DD}$ ac ground\n> $M_{1}$ CG device $S_{1}=V_{out}$,$G_{1}=$ ac ground,\n> $D_{1}=$ ac ground.\n\nSo $M_{1}$ looks from its source as a small\nnon linear resistor.\n\n### 1. Large signal\n\n$$V_{SG1}=V_{out}-0=V_{out}$$\n$$V_{SG2}=V_{DD}-V_{in}$$\n$$V_{SD1}=V_{out}-0=V_{out}$$\n$$V_{SD2}=V_{DD}-V_{out}$$\n\n$p{\\rm MOS}$ saturation\n\n$$V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}+V_{Tp}=V_{SG}-|V_{T}|$$\n\n*For $M_{1}$:* $V_{SD1}=V_{SG1}$ so if ON,\n$V_{SG1}>|V_{T}|$, it is {\\it always saturated},\n\n$$I_{1}={\\frac{k_{1}}{2}}(V_{out}-|V_{T1}|)^{2}\n\\left(1+\\lambda _{1}V_{out}\\right)\\;\\;V_{out}>|V_{T}|$$\n$$I_{1}=0\\;\\;V_{out}\\le |V_{T}|$$\n\n*For $M_{2}$:* ON for $V_{DD}-V_{in}>|V_{T}|$\n\nSAT for $V_{DD}-V_{out}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{in}-|V_{T}|$\n\n$$V_{out}\\le V_{in}+|V_{T}|$$\n\nWith $I_{1}=I_{2}$ :\n\n* a) $V_{in}>V_{DD}-|V_{T}|$ : $M_{2}$ cut-off.\nNo dc path except leakage. $M_{1}$ discharges $V_{out}$\nuntil it cuts off:\n\n$$V_{OL}\\approx |V_{T1}|\\ne 0$$\n\nwith $\\lambda$ and subthreshold it goes $\\to 0$ with\nsmall current. Not rail to rail.\n\n* b) Both saturated, $\\lambda =0$ for illustration:\n\n$${\\frac{k_{1}}{2}}(V_{out}-|V_{T}|)^{2}=\n{\\frac{k_{2}}{2}}(V_{DD}-V_{in}-|V_{T}|)^{2}$$\n\n$$\\;V_{out}=|V_{T}|+\\sqrt{{\\frac{k_{2}}{k_{1}}}}\n\\left(V_{DD}-|V_{T}|-V_{in}\\right)\\;tag{1}$$\n\nstraight line slope\n\n$${\\frac{dV_{out}}{dV_{in}}}= -\\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}\n=-\\sqrt{{(W/L)_{2}\\over (W/L)_{1}}}$$\n\nValid to\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{in}+|V_{T}|$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$V_{in,t}= {\\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}\\over 1+\\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}}\n\\left(V_{DD}-|V_{T}|\\right)$$\n\n* c) $V_{in}<V_{in,t}$ : $M_{2}$ triode, $M_{1}$ sat.\n\n$$I_{2}=k_{2}\\left[(V_{SG2}-|V_{T}|)V_{SD2}-V_{SD2}^{2}/2\\right]\n= I_{1}$$\n\n$V_{out}\\to V_{DD}$ and saturates.\n\n$$V_{OH}\\approx V_{DD}$$\n\nIn practice for $(W/L)_{1}=(W/L)_{2}$ the whole\nSAT region is $0<V_{in}<V_{DD}-|V_{T}|$ with\n$V_{out}(0)=V_{DD}$, $V_{out}(V_{DD}-|V_{T}|)=|V_{T}|$.\nIf $(W/L)_{2}>(W/L)_{1}$, the high side clips in\ntriode to $V_{DD}$. Fig. is normal inverter VTC but\nwith low $\\left|dV_{out}/dV_{in}\\right|\\approx 1-3$\nand $V_{OL}=|V_{T}|$.\n\nIt is ratioed logic. The trip point $V_{in}=V_{out}$\nfrom (1)\n\n$$V_{M}= { |V_{T}|(1-\\,{\\rm ratio}) + {\\rm ratio}\\,V_{DD}\\over\n1+{\\rm ratio}} \\qquad {\\rm ratio}=\\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}$$\n\n### 2. Small signal ac\n\n$V_{DD}$ ac ground. $R_{i}=\\infty $ at the gate.\n\nHybrid $\\pi $: $i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}$,\n$g_{m}=k(V_{SG}-|V_{T}|)$ in SAT, $g_{ds}=1/r_{o}=\\lambda I_{D}$.\n\n* $M_{2}$ : $v_{gs2}=v_{in}$, $v_{ds2}=v_{out}$,\n$v_{bs2}=0$,\n\n$$i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{in}+g_{ds2}v_{out}\\;\\;{\\rm into\\;drain}$$\n\n* $M_{1}$ : $v_{gs1}=-v_{out}$, $v_{ds1}=-v_{out}$,\n$v_{bs1}=0$ if $B\\equiv S$, $=-v_{out}$ if $B=V_{DD}$,\n\n$$i_{d1}= -g_{m1}v_{out}-g_{mb1}v_{bs1}-g_{ds1}v_{out}$$\n\nKCL at $V_{out}$: $i_{d2}=i_{d1}$ with $i_{s1}=-i_{d1}$,\nor $i_{d2}+i_{s1}=0$, gives\n\n$$g_{m2}v_{in}+g_{ds2}v_{out}+ (g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1})v_{out}=0$$\n\n$$A_{v}={v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=\n- {g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\tag{2}$$\n\nWith separate well $g_{mb1}=0$:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -{g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}} \n{1\\over 1+(g_{ds1}+g_{ds2})/g_{m1}}\\approx -{g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}}$$\n\nIn SAT $g_{m}= \\sqrt{2k_{p}I_{D}}$ and $I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{D}$\n\n$$|A_{v}|\\approx \\sqrt{{k_{2}\\over k_{1}}}=\n\\sqrt{{(W/L)_{2}\\over (W/L)_{1}}}$$\n\nin agreement with large signal slope. Can be made $>1$\nby $(W/L)_{2}>(W/L)_{1}$ at the expense of area and\nstatic current.\n\nOutput resistance is the resistance seen looking into\n$S_{1}$ in parallel with $r_{o2}$ :\n\n$$R_{out}=r_{o2}\\parallel\n{1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}}\\approx\n{1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}}$$\n\ntypically $1-10\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$, low.\nInput capacitance $C_{in}\\approx C_{gs2}+C_{gbo}$, output\npole $p_{o}=-1/R_{out}C_{L}$, $GBW\\approx g_{m2}/C_{L}$\ndivided by $g_{m1}R_{out}$.\n\nIn words: $M_{2}$ is a $g_{m2}$ voltage to current converter,\n$M_{1}$ is a diode load $\\approx 1/g_{m1}$ to ground.\n$A_{v}=-g_{m2}\\times R_{out}$.\n\nIdeal $\\lambda =0$, no body effect:\n\n$$A_{v}=-g_{m2}r_{o2}\\parallel {1\\over g_{m1}}\n\\approx -{g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}}$$\n\nWith body effect the gain is reduced to\n$-g_{m2}/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})$.\n\n### 3. Properties\n\n* Inverting, single stage, open loop, no Miller multiplication.\nDominant pole at the output.\n* Ratioed, static dissipation $P_{DC}=V_{DD}I_{D}>0$ even\nwhen $V_{in}$ high. Standby current $\\approx\n(k_{1}/2)(V_{OL}-|V_{T}|)^{2}$ small but non zero.\n* Limited swing $ |V_{T}|<V_{out}<V_{DD}$, low noise margin,\nlow voltage gain $1-10$ typical. Poor $PSRR$.\n* Can be used as a very simple $p$-only inverting\namplifier, level shifter, pseudo-$p$MOS inverter,\nor as active load for $p$MOS logic where CMOS is not\navailable. For analog use bias $V_{in}$ in the middle\nof region b) so both devices saturated.\n* For high gain replace the diode load by a current\nsource $g_{m}=0$ load: $A_{v}=-g_{m2}(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2})$\nor by a current mirror. Increase $L_{1}$ to reduce\n$g_{ds1}$ and $g_{m1}$.\n\nThis is the $p$-channel dual of the classic $n$MOS\nenhancement-saturated-load inverter. In modern CMOS\nit is normally superseded by the complementary CMOS\ninverter/CS stage with $n$MOS driver / $p$MOS load\ngiving $A_{v}=-g_{m}(r_{on}\\parallel r_{op})$ and\nrail to rail swing with zero static power.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bb43337218a9bc5dd03f7af4c5c24a2144b4b51e10576cbbda67afe2307db2b4"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies both devices as PMOS, M2 as the common-source input device, and M1 as a diode-connected PMOS load with gate and drain grounded. It derives the expected gm/gm gain, approximately Av = -gm2/gm1; the extra inverter framing does not replace or contradict the essential interpretation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b9bd40d93897263d8f8ec48e8a570180ddbbc0962f905b31861c1d4b96315bc9",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1757,
        "output_tokens": 13414,
        "total_tokens": 15171,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10652,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1757,
        "output_tokens": 13414,
        "total_tokens": 15171,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10652,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-017-pmos-input-invalid-pulldown/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a {\\it ratioed} PMOS only\ninverter. In CMOS terminology it is a\n$$CS+CG \\;\\;{\\rm stage}\\approx CS+{\\rm sat.}{\\rm Enh.}{\\rm load}$$\n\n$$M_{2}: PMOS\\; driver,\\;\\; S\\equiv V_{DD},\\;D\\equiv V_{o},\\;G\\equiv V_{i},\\;B\\equiv V_{DD}$$\n$$M_{1}: PMOS\\; load,\\;\\; S\\equiv B\\equiv V_{o},\\; D\\equiv GND,\\;G\\equiv GND$$\n\ni. e. a $PMOS$ with $G=D$ {\\it diode connected}\nbetween $V_{o}$ and ground, with $B$ strapped to\n$S$ so that $V_{BS1}=0$.\n\n> Note on symbolism: The arrow is the $B\\to $ channel\njunction. In a normal $p$-sub process both $PMOS$ are\nin $n$-wells. For $M_{2}$ the well is at the highest\npotential $V_{DD}$: $S-B$ short, $D-B$ reverse.\nFor $M_{1}$ the well must follow $V_{o}$ otherwise the\n$p^{+}/n$ junctions would forward bias. I. e. $M_{1}$\nneeds its own $n$-well. With $B=S=V_{o}$,\n$$V_{SB1}=0\\;\\; , \\;\\; V_{DB1}=V_{o}>0$$\nboth junctions reverse for $0<V_{o}<V_{DD}$. \n$g_{mb1}=0$. If you tie $B_{1}$ to $GND$ you get a\nforward $S-B$ diode for $V_{o}>0.6{\\rm V}$ and a very\nlarge $g_{mb}$.\n\nNeglecting for the moment $\\lambda \\ne 0$ in square law:\n\n$$I_{D}= \\frac12\\mu_{p}C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}\n\\left(V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|\\right)^{2}\n\\left(1+\\lambda V_{SD}\\right) \\;\\;V_{SG}>|V_{Tp}|$$\n$$0\\;\\;{\\rm else}$$\n\n$$V_{SG1}=V_{S1}-V_{G1}=V_{o}-0=V_{o}$$\n$$V_{SD1}=V_{o}-0=V_{o}$$\n$$V_{SG2}=V_{DD}-V_{i}$$\n$$V_{SD2}=V_{DD}-V_{o}$$\n\nSaturation:\n\n$$PMOS:\\;V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}+V_{Tp}=V_{SG}-|V_{Tp}|$$\n\n$$M_{1}:V_{o}\\ge V_{o}-|V_{Tp}|\\;\\;{\\rm always\\;sat.\\;if\\;ON}$$\n$$M_{2}:V_{DD}-V_{o}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{Tp}|\\iff V_{o}\\le V_{i}+|V_{Tp}|$$\n\nSo for low $V_{o}$ $M_{2}$ is saturated, for high\n$V_{o}$ $M_{2}$ goes triode.\n\n### D. C. large signal - $VTC$\n\n$I_{D1}=I_{D2}$ in series.\n\n* $V_{i}\\approx V_{DD}:\\;V_{SG2}\\approx 0<M_{2}$\ncut off. No d.c. path to $V_{DD}$. $M_{1}$ discharges\n$C_{L}$ to\n\n$$V_{OL}\\approx 0\\;\\;{\\rm subthreshold\\;leakage\\;only}$$\n\nIn square law $M_{1}$ also off for $V_{o}<|V_{Tp}|$.\n\n* Decrease $V_{i}$ so $V_{SG2}>|V_{Tp}|$. Both saturated:\n\n$$k_{1}(V_{o}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}\\approx k_{2}(V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}$$\n\n$$k_{i}=\\mu_{p}C_{ox}W_{i}/L_{i}$$\n\n$$V_{o}\\approx |V_{Tp}|+\\sqrt{\\frac{k_{2}}{k_{1}}}\n\\left(V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{Tp}|\\right)\\tag{1}$$\n\nlinear inverting. Clipped to $0$ and to the boundary\n$V_{o}=V_{i}+|V_{Tp}|$.\n\n* For $V_{i}\\ll V_{DD}$ $M_{2}$ triode:\n\n$$k_{1}(V_{o}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}\\approx 2k_{2}\\left[(V_{DD}-V_{i}-|V_{Tp}|)\n(V_{DD}-V_{o})-\\tfrac12(V_{DD}-V_{o})^{2}\\right]$$\n\n$$V_{OH}<V_{DD}$$\n\nproduced by the divider $M_{2}({\\rm triode})/M_{1}({\\rm sat})$.\nTypical\n\n$$V_{OH}\\approx V_{DD}-\\Delta,\\;\\;\n\\Delta\\sim |V_{Tp}| {\\rm\\;for\\;}k_{2}\\sim k_{1}$$\nand only $\\to V_{DD}$ for $k_{2}\\gg k_{1}$.\nThis is the classic ratioed inverter: $V_{OH}$, the\nswitching threshold $V_{M}$ where $V_{o}=V_{i}$ and\n$V_{OL}$ depend on $k_{2}/k_{1}$.\n\nE.g. with $\\lambda =0$, $V_{M}$ from (1) with $V_{o}=V_{i}=V_{M}$:\n\n$$V_{M}= \\frac{|V_{Tp}|+\\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}\\,(V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|)}\n{1+\\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}}$$\n\n$V_{M}\\to V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|$ for $k_{2}\\gg k_{1}$,\n$V_{M}\\to |V_{Tp}|$ for $k_{2}\\ll k_{1}$.\nNormally $k_{2}>k_{1}$ to get gain $>1$.\n\nThe circuit draws static current\n\n$$I_{DD}=I_{D1}=I_{D2}\\approx \\frac{k_{1}}{2}(V_{o}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}$$\n\nwhen $M_{2}$ is on. Unlike CMOS it is {\\it not} ratioless\nand not rail to rail.\n\nIn $NMOS$ terms it is the exact complement of the\n$NMOS$ inverter with enhancement saturated load,\n$V_{OH}=V_{DD}-V_{Tn}$. Here $V_{OL}\\approx 0$,\n$V_{OH}=V_{DD}- {\\rm drop}$.\n\n### Small signal\n\nBias at $V_{I}=V_{M}$ both saturated. AC $V_{DD},GND=0$.\n\n$M_{2}:$ common source, $v_{sg2}=-v_{i}$, $v_{sd2}=-v_{o}$\n\n$$i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{sg2}+g_{ds2}v_{sd2}= -g_{m2}v_{i}-g_{ds2}v_{o}$$\n\n$M_{1}:$ gate and drain ac ground, source $=v_{o}$,\n$b=s$ so $v_{bs1}=0$, $v_{sg1}=v_{o}$, $v_{sd1}=v_{o}$\n\n$$i_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{sg1}+g_{ds1}v_{sd1}= (g_{m1}+g_{ds1})v_{o}\n\\;+\\;g_{mb1}v_{bs1}$$\n\n$g_{mb1}=0$ with $B=S$. If $B=GND$ add $g_{mb1}$:\n\n$$i_{d1}=(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1})v_{o}$$\n\nKCL at $v_{o}$: $i_{d2}=i_{d1}$,\n\n$$-g_{m2}v_{i} = \\left(g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}(+g_{mb1})\\right)v_{o}$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv \\frac{v_{o}}{v_{i}}=\n-\\frac{g_{m2}}{g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+g_{mb1}}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$\\approx -\\frac{g_{m2}}{g_{m1}}\\;\\;{\\rm if}\\;g_{m}\\gg g_{ds},g_{mb}$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -\\sqrt{\\frac{(W/L)_{2}}{(W/L)_{1}}}$$\n\nbecause $g_{m}=\\sqrt{2\\mu_{p}C_{ox}(W/L)I_{D}}$ and\n$I_{D1}=I_{D2}$,\n\n$$|A_{v}|\\approx \\sqrt{k_{2}/k_{1}}$$\n\nTo get $|A_{v}|>1$ need $k_{2}>k_{1}$. Typical 3-10\ngives $5-10\\,{\\rm dB}$, much less than\nCMOS $-g_{m}(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2})$.\n\nOutput impedance at $V_{o}$ is $M_{2}$ drain\n$\\parallel$ impedance looking into $S_{1}$.\n\nFor $M_{1}$\n\n$$Z_{s1}= \\frac{v_{x}}{i_{x}}=\n\\frac{1}{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}$$\n\nWith $B=S$, $g_{mb1}=0$:\n\n$$R_{out}= \\left(g_{m1}+g_{ds1}\\right)^{-1}\\parallel r_{o2}\n\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}\\parallel r_{o2}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}}$$\n\nfor $r_{o2}=1/g_{ds2}\\gg 1/g_{m1}$.\n\nInput impedance $Z_{in}\\approx 1/sC_{gs2}\\to\\infty$ at d.c.\n\nPole at output:\n\n$$\\omega_{p}\\approx \\frac{1}{R_{out}C_{L}}\\approx\n\\frac{g_{m1}}{C_{L}}$$\n\nInput pole $\\approx 1/R_{sig}C_{gs2}$, Miller multiplication of\n$C_{gd2}$ by $|A_{v}|$.\n\nIn words: a very low gain, low $R_{out}$ inverting\nstage, class A, with static dissipation. It can be used\nas an analog inverting gain cell, as a level shifter,\nor historically as a PMOS-only logic inverter before\ncomplementary CMOS, and in modern CMOS as a\npseudo-PMOS load when only PMOS is available or as a\nsimple $1/g_{m}$ active load for a PMOS CS stage.\n\nImprovements: replace $M_{1}$ by current mirror,\ncascode, or use $NMOS$ to make true CMOS inverter\n$$A_{v}=-g_{m}(r_{on}\\parallel r_{op})$$\nrail to rail, no static power, gain 20-40 dB.\n\nIf the intent was a normal CMOS inverter $M_{1}$ should be\n$NMOS$ with $S=GND$, $D=V_{o}$, $G=GND$? - i.e. with arrow\nreversed - then $M_{1}$ as enhancement pull down would be\noff and the circuit would be the usual CMOS inverter after\nswapping $M_{1}$ type. As drawn it is deliberately PMOS-PMOS.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "e9febd66366057c771697c5d59f98a2878a11d4cfddbbf7bc91f8756d0a98404"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It identifies both devices as PMOS, M2 as the common-source input device, and M1 as a diode-connected PMOS load, and derives the required gm/gm gain. These satisfy the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "b9bd40d93897263d8f8ec48e8a570180ddbbc0962f905b31861c1d4b96315bc9",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1757,
        "output_tokens": 11991,
        "total_tokens": 13748,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9232,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1757,
        "output_tokens": 11991,
        "total_tokens": 13748,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9232,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-018-find-rout",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "Find Rout in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-018-find-rout/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With a ${\\rm ac}$ short on the $Vb_{i}$\nthe small signal circuit is, for the $p$ device\n\n$$i_{sd}=g_{m}v_{sg}+g_{mb}v_{sb}+g_{o}v_{sd}\\qquad \ng_{o}=r_{o}^{-1}$$\n\nPut $V_{DD}={\\rm ac}\\;0$ and put a current $I_{x}$\nin the $M_{1}$ drain , Fig.1, with a voltage $V_{x}$ .\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{2}:&V_{sg2}=0\\;\\;V_{sd2}=-V_{{\\rm x}}\\cr\n&I_{2}=g_{o2}V_{sd2}=-g_{o2}V_{X}\\cr\nM_{1}:&V_{sg1}=V_{X}\\;\\;V_{sb1}=V_{X}-{\\rm ac}\\;V_{B}\\cr\n&V_{sd1}=V_{X}-V_{x}\\cr\n&I_{1}=g_{m1}V_{X}+g_{mb1}V_{sb1}+g_{o1}(V_{X}-V_{x})}$$\n\nIn the Fig. $B_{1}\\equiv X$, {\\it i. e.} the $n$ well\nof $M_{1}$ is strapped to its source so that in the\nFig. $g_{mb1}=0$.  With the conventional $n$ well to\n$V_{DD}$ keep $g_{mb1}$.\n\nAt the internal node\n\n$$I_{2}=I_{1}\\tag{1}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$-g_{o2}V_{X}=(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1})V_{X}-g_{o1}V_{x}$$\n\n$$V_{X}={g_{o1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}V_{x}\\tag{2}$$\n\nand\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{1}&=(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1})V_{X}-g_{o1}V_{x}\\cr\n&= -{g_{o1}g_{o2}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}V_{x}}$$\n\nwith the conventional sign $I_{1}$ is the\nsource to drain current, {\\it i. e.} $I_{x}=-I_{1}$ for\nthe current normally taken as entering the output node.\nIn magnitude\n\n$$|I_{x}|=|I_{1}|={g_{o1}g_{o2}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}V_{x}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nR_{o}&={V_{x}\\over |I_{x}|}={g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}\\over \ng_{o1}g_{o2}}\\cr\n&={1\\over g_{o1}}+{1\\over g_{o2}}+{g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\over \ng_{o1}g_{o2}}\\cr\n&=r_{o1}+r_{o2}+(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})r_{o1}r_{o2}\\cr\n&=r_{o1}+\\left[1+(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})r_{o1}\\right]r_{o2}\\tag{3}}$$\n\nthe usual cascode multiplication of the impedance that\nis seen in the source of the common gate device.\nFor the connection of the Fig. $B_{1}=S_{1}$, $g_{mb1}=0$,\n\n$$R_{o}=r_{o1}+r_{o2}+g_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}\n      =r_{o1}+\\left(1+g_{m1}r_{o1}\\right)r_{o2}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand for $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx (g_{m1}+g_{mb1})r_{o1}r_{o2}\\;\\;{\\rm with}\\;\nB_{1}\\to V_{DD}\\tag{5a}$$\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx g_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\;\\;{\\rm with}\\;B_{1}=S_{1}\n\\;{\\rm as\\;drawn}\\tag{5b}$$\n\nFor $M_{1}\\equiv M_{2}\\equiv M$, $g_{o1}=g_{o2}=g_{o}$,\n$r_{o1}=r_{o2}=r_{o}$, $g_{m1}=g_{m}$,\n\n$$R_{o}=2r_{o}+g_{m}r_{o}^{2}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}^{2}\\tag{6}$$\n\nnormally ${\\cal O}(1\\,{\\rm M}\\Omega )$, the intrinsic\ngain $g_{m}r_{o}$ times the $r_{o}$ of a simple\ncurrent source.  With $B_{1}\\to V_{DD}$ put\n$g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$.  Interchanging the\nlabels $1\\rightleftharpoons 2$, {\\it i. e.} calling the\ncascode device $M_{2}$,\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o1}r_{o2}$$\n\nin the conventional notation.  Any resistance from\n$V_{b}{\\rm ac}$ to ground is in parallel with (3).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "1b1acae47c7cba3e7c3cdd7c0bf71400aa60635e38b3f24b53c8338b5e7d7ef5"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly treats the devices as PMOS, identifies M1 as the common-gate cascode, and derives Rout = ro1 + ro2 + (gm1 + gmb1)ro1ro2, with the correct approximation. The body-effect discussion is optional.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0e58951a444fd5eb5a81c93c3c94eef4ae9b6f921b6512a0c0fecf7f946efcb1",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2822,
        "output_tokens": 9212,
        "total_tokens": 12034,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7949,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2822,
        "output_tokens": 9212,
        "total_tokens": 12034,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7949,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-018-find-rout",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "Find Rout in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-018-find-rout/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With ${\\rm ac\\; ground}$\non $V_{DD}$ put $v_{x}=0$ on $V_{b1,2}$ and drive the\noutput, Fig. 1, with $v_{o}$ and let $i_{o}$ be the current\npulled out of the drain of ${\\rm M}_{1}$.\n\n$$i_{o}=i_{d1}=i_{d2}\\tag {*}$$\n\nin the first order.  Put for the ${\\rm p}$ ${\\rm MOST}$\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{sg}+g_{mb}v_{sb}+g_{os}v_{sd}\\qquad \ng_{os}=1/r_{o}\\tag{1}$$\n\nfor the ${\\rm n}$ ${\\rm MOST}$\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{mb}v_{bs}+g_{os}v_{ds}\\tag{1a}$$\n\nthe two are dual.  Put $r_{o1}=1/g_{o1}$, $r_{o2}=1/g_{o2}$.\n\nFor ${\\rm M}_{2}$\n\n$$v_{sg2}=0\\qquad v_{sd2}=v_{x}\\tag{2}$$\n\nmodulo the body effect of ${\\rm M}_{2}$ which is $0$ because\n${\\rm S}_{2}$ is on ${\\rm ac}$ ground,\n\n$$i_{d2}=g_{o2}v_{x}=v_{x}/r_{o2}\\tag{3}$$\n\nFor ${\\rm M}_{1}$ with its source on $x$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nv_{sg1}&=v_{x}\\cr\nv_{sd1}&=v_{x}-v_{o}\\cr\nv_{sb1}&=v_{x}-v_{b1}\\cr} \\tag{4}$$\n\nup to the sign, $g_{m}$ is taken positive, so that\n\n$$i_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{sg1}+g_{mb1}v_{sb1}+g_{o1}v_{sd1}\\tag{5}$$\n\ni. {\\it e.} for the conventional $+$ from\ndrain to source in an ${\\rm n}$ ${\\rm MOST}$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{d1}&=-g_{m1}v_{x}-g_{mb1}v_{x}+g_{o1}\\left(v_{o}-v_{x}\\right)\n\\;\\;{\\rm with}\\;v_{b}=0\\cr\ni_{d1}&=-g_{m1}v_{x}+g_{o1}\\left(v_{o}-v_{x}\\right)\n\\;\\;{\\rm with}\\;v_{b}=v_{x}\\tag{6}}$$\n\nThe second is the case drawn in the figure, the $n$ well of\n${\\rm M}_{1}$ is strapped to its source, $v_{sb1}\\equiv 0$,\n$g_{mb1}\\equiv 0$.  In a normal $n$ well process the well is\non $V_{DD}$, {\\it i. e.} on ${\\rm ac}$ ground and\n$g_{mb1}\\ne 0$ and $v_{sb1}= -v_{x}$.  With $*$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{o}&=i_{d2}=v_{x}/r_{o2}\\cr\ni_{o}&=i_{d1}=g_{o1}v_{o}-\\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1}\\right)v_{x}\\cr\n&{\\rm or}\\;g_{o1}v_{o}-\\left(g_{m1}+g_{o1}\\right)v_{x}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\ng_{mb1}=0\\tag{7}}$$\n\nEliminating $v_{x}=i_{o}r_{o2}$\n\n$$i_{o}=g_{o1}v_{o}-i_{o}r_{o2}\\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1}\\right) \\tag{8}$$\n\n$${{v_{o}}\\over {i_{o}}}=R_{o}=r_{o1}+r_{o2}+\\left(g_{m1}+\ng_{mb1}\\right)r_{o1}r_{o2} \\tag{9}$$\n\n$$R_{o}=r_{o1}+\\left[1+\\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\right)r_{o1}\\right]r_{o2}\n\\tag{9a}$$\n\nnormalised to $g_{mb1}=0$ for the connection drawn,\n\n$$R_{o}=r_{o1}+r_{o2}+g_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}\n      =r_{o1}+\\left(1+g_{m1}r_{o1}\\right)r_{o2}\\tag{10}$$\n\nFor $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx \\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\right)r_{o1}r_{o2}\n\\tag{11}$$\n\nand for the strapped well\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx g_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\gg r_{o1},r_{o2} \\tag{12}$$\n\nthe conventional cascode multiplication by the intrinsic gain\n$g_{m}r_{o}$ of the cascode device.  E. {\\it g.} with\n$r_{o}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx {{g_{m}}\\over {\\lambda ^{2}I_{D}^{2}}} \\tag{13}$$\n\nFor matched devices $r_{o1}=r_{o2}=r_{o}$,\n$g_{m1}=g_{m}$,\n\n$$R_{o}= \\left(2+g_{m}r_{o}\\right)r_{o}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}^{2}\\tag{14}$$\n\nwith the body on ground $g_{m}\\rightarrow g_{m}+g_{mb}\n=(1+\\chi )g_{m}$, $\\chi =g_{mb}/g_{m}\\approx 0.1-0.3$.\n\nIn the ideal square law with no channel length modulation\n$r_{o}\\rightarrow \\infty $, $R_{o}\\rightarrow \\infty $ as it\nshould for a current source.  Any $R_{L}\\ll R_{o}$ to ground at\nthe output sees essentially the short circuit cascode current\n$I_{D1}=I_{D2}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  In most text books Eq. {\\rm 9a} is quoted in\n> the form $R_{o}\\approx \\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\right)r_{o1}r_{o2}$.\n> For the triple well or {\\it p} well with the well of  ${\\rm M}_{1}$\n> on $X$, $g_{mb1}=0$ as drawn.\n\nThe source follower resistance seen looking into the source of\n${\\rm M}_{1}$ with $r_{o2}$ on its source is\n$R_{x}=r_{o2}$ and Eq. 9a is $R_{o}=r_{o1}+(1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o1})\nR_{x}$.  Looking into the source {\\it per se},\n$R_{s1}=1/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{o1})\\approx 1/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "09bcf400b86ec7c26a03cc2eb07f9c1c43d3118e336ff7c20c0754f9c9043a06"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Identifies the PMOS cascode action of M1 and gives the correct output resistance, including the optional body-effect term and the usual approximation. The body-connection discussion does not change the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0e58951a444fd5eb5a81c93c3c94eef4ae9b6f921b6512a0c0fecf7f946efcb1",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2822,
        "output_tokens": 9812,
        "total_tokens": 12634,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7976,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2822,
        "output_tokens": 9812,
        "total_tokens": 12634,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7976,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-018-find-rout",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "Find Rout in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-018-find-rout/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With ${\\rm  AC\\;ground}$ on the two gates, in the\nsmall signal sense the {\\it upper} transistor is the\n${R_{S}}$ that degenerates the ${\\rm CG}$\n{\\it lower} transistor. Put ${V_{b1}}=V_{b2}=0$ and\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nr_{oi}&={1\\over {g_{dsi}}}={1\\over {\\lambda _{i}I_{D}}}\\cr\ng_{oi}&=g_{dsi}\\cr}$$\n\nfor the normal sign convention,\n\n$${\\rm Fig.\\;1\\over R_{o}}={\\rm Fig.\\;2}\\tag*{Fig.2}$$\n\nPut a $V_{x}$ on the drain of $M_{1}$ and call $V_{s1}=V_{X}$\nthe ${\\rm S}$ of $M_{1}\\equiv {\\rm D}$ of $M_{2}$.\nNeglecting for the moment the well effect\n\n$$I_{d2}=g_{o2}V_{X}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$I_{d1}=g_{m1}V_{gs1}+g_{o1}V_{ds1}\n      =-g_{m1}V_{X}+g_{o1}\\left(V_{x}-V_{X}\\right) \\tag{2}$$\n\nand for the current injected in the output\n\n$$I_{x}=I_{d1}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$${\\rm KCL}\\;\\;{\\rm at}\\;\\;X:\\;\\;I_{s1}=I_{d2}\\;\\;{\\rm i.\\;e.}\\;\\;\nI_{d1}=I_{d2}\\tag{4}$$\n\nso that from (1)(2)\n\n$$g_{o1}V_{x}=V_{X}\\left(g_{m1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}\\right) \\tag{5}$$\n\n$$V_{X}={{g_{o1}}\\over {g_{m1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}}V_{x}\\tag{6}$$\n\nand e. {\\rm g.} from (1) and (3)\n\n$$I_{x}=g_{o2}V_{X}={{g_{o1}g_{o2}}\\over\n{g_{m1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}}V_{x} \\tag{7}$$\n\n$${{V_{x}}\\over {I_{x}}}={{g_{m1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}\\over {g_{o1}g_{o2}}} \\tag{8}$$\n\ni. e., in $r$'s,\n\n$$R_{o}= {1\\over {g_{o}}}\\;\\;{\\rm with}\\;\\;g_{o}={{g_{o1}g_{o2}}\n\\over {g_{m1}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}}$$\n\n$$R_{o}={{1}\\over {g_{o1}}}+{{1}\\over {g_{o2}}}+\n{{g_{m1}}\\over {g_{o1}g_{o2}}}\\tag{9}$$\n\n$$R_{o}=r_{o1}+r_{o2}+g_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}\n      =r_{o1}+\\left(1+g_{m1}r_{o1}\\right)r_{o2}\\tag{10}$$\n\nthe well known impedance of a ${\\rm CG}$ stage degenerated\nby $R_{S}=r_{o2}$,\n\n$$R_{o}=R_{S}+\\left[1+\\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}\\right)r_{o}\\right]R_{S}\n       +r_{o}\\tag*{in general}$$\n\nIn (9)(10) $g_{m1}$ is the $g_{m}$ of the cascode , i. e.\nbottom, device.  With $g_{o}r_{o}=1$ and $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx g_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\tag{11}$$\n\nFor the matched case $r_{o1}\\approx r_{o2}=r_{o}$,\n$g_{m1}=g_{m}$,\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx \\left(2+g_{m}r_{o}\\right)r_{o}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}^{2}\n      ={{g_{m}}\\over {\\left(\\lambda I_{D}\\right)^{2}}}\n      ={{2}\\over {\\lambda^{2}I_{D}\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)}} \\tag{12}$$\n\nnormally ${{10}^{5}}-{{10}^{7}}{\\rm \\Omega }$, to first order\ninfinity if $\\lambda \\rightarrow 0$, the ideal cascode current\nsource.  In ordinary $0.5-0.18\\mu$ CMOS\n$g_{m}r_{o}\\sim 20-100$, so that the cascode increases the\n$r_{o}$ of the simple mirror by $1-2$ orders of magnitude.\n\nWith the $n$ well normally returned to the most positive\nsupply the source of $M_{1}$ is not at AC ground for the\nsubstrate and $V_{bs1}=-V_{X}$.  In (2)\n\n$$I_{d1}=g_{m1}V_{gs1}+g_{mb1}V_{bs1}+g_{o1}V_{ds1}$$\n\n$$I_{d1}=-\\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\right)V_{X}+g_{o1}\\left(V_{x}-V_{X}\\right)$$\n\nso that everywhere\n\n$$g_{m1}\\rightarrow g_{m1}+g_{mb1}=g_{m1}\\left(1+\\eta \\right)\n      =g_{m1}\\left(1+{{\\gamma }\\over {2\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{SB}}}}\\right) \\tag{13}$$\n\nand, e. {\\rm g.},\n\n$$R_{o}=r_{o1}+r_{o2}+\\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\right)r_{o1}r_{o2}\n     =r_{o1}+\\left[1+\\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\right)r_{o1}\\right]r_{o2}\n     \\approx \\left(g_{m}+g_{mb}\\right)r_{o}^{2} \\tag{14}$$\n\nfor $r_{o1}=r_{o2}$.  $\\eta =g_{mb}/g_{m}\\approx 0.1-0.3$.\nIf as drawn the $n$ well of $M_{1}$ is strapped to its source,\n$V_{bs1}\\equiv 0$, $g_{mb1}\\equiv 0$ and (9)-(12) apply as\nwritten.  Interchanging the labels $1\\leftrightarrow 2$,\n\n$$R_{o}=r_{o2}+\\left[1+\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}\\right)r_{o2}\\right]r_{o1}$$\n\nis the form most often quoted.  Any finite impedance\nfrom the bias lines $V_{b1},V_{b2}$ to ground appears in\nparallel with $r_{o2}$ and/or as source degeneration of the\n${\\rm CG}$ device and rapidly degrades (14).  Put\n$R_{b2}=0$ in (14) to first order.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  $g_{m}r_{o}=2V_{A}/(V_{GS}-V_{T})$ with\n> $r_{o}=V_{A}/I_{D}$, $g_{m}=2I_{D}/(V_{GS}-V_{T})$ in strong\n> inversion saturation, $\\propto \\sqrt{W/LI_{D}}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5f90ce7f60d912301017b2b95dd7f91ba9dee3eca148b80ca167e26ae4498bd0"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate cascode and derives Rout = ro1 + ro2 + gm1 ro1 ro2, with the appropriate body-effect extension. This matches the golden result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0e58951a444fd5eb5a81c93c3c94eef4ae9b6f921b6512a0c0fecf7f946efcb1",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2822,
        "output_tokens": 6498,
        "total_tokens": 9320,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4657,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2822,
        "output_tokens": 6498,
        "total_tokens": 9320,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4657,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "How do we ensure that M2 is in saturation in the figure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the (p) threshold voltage negatively counted the\ncascode has only a high $R_{o}$ if {\\it both \\/} devices\nremain, for the normal signal swing of $V_{o}$, in\nthe pentode region, Fig.1. For the $p$ channel with\n$V_{T}<0$:\n\n$${\\rm sat}\\;\\;:\\;\\;|V_{DS}|>|V_{GS}|-|V_{T}| \\tag{*}$$\n\ni. e. $V_{SD}\\ge V_{SG}+V_{T}$ , $V_{T}<0$, or\n\n$$V_{D}\\le V_{G}-V_{T}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$V_{T}=-|V_{T}| \\qquad V_{D}\\le V_{G}+|V_{T}|$$\n\nup to the $\\gamma$ correction.  Let\n\n$$V_{EB}=V_{SG}=V_{S}-V_{G}>0\\qquad \nV_{EC}=V_{SD}=V_{S}-V_{D}>0$$\n$$V_{EB}=|V_{T}|+V_{ov}\\qquad V_{ov}=\\sqrt{2I_{D}/k_{p}}=\nV_{EB}+V_{T}>0\\tag{2}$$\n$$I_{D}={{k_{p}}\\over {2}}V_{ov}^{2}\\qquad \nk_{p}=k_{p}^{\\prime}W/L\\tag{3}$$\n$$V_{ov}=V_{EC,{\\rm sat}}\\tag{4}$$\nis the saturation - triode limit.  For $M_{2}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{EB2}&=V_{DD}-V_{b2}\\cr\nV_{EC2}&=V_{DD}-V_{X}} \\tag{5}$$\n\nso that (*) is\n\n$$V_{EC2}\\ge V_{EB2}+V_{T2}\\tag{6}$$\n\n$${\\rm i.\\,e.}\\;\\;V_{DD}-V_{X}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{b2}+V_{T2}$$\n\n$$V_{X}\\le V_{b2}-V_{T2}=V_{b2}+|V_{T2}|\\tag{7}$$\n\nand, with $|V_{T}|$,\n\n$$V_{EC2}\\ge V_{ov2}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{DD}-V_{X}\\ge V_{ov2}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$$V_{X}\\le V_{DD}-V_{ov2}\\tag{9}$$\n\nThe drain of $M_{2}$ is the source of $M_{1}$.  Neglecting\nfor the moment the $n$ well body effect\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{EB1}&=V_{X}-V_{b1}=|V_{T1}|+V_{ov1}\\cr\nV_{EC1}&=V_{X}-V_{o}} \\tag{10}$$\n\nso that, in saturation,\n\n$$V_{X}=V_{b1}+|V_{T1}|+V_{ov1}=V_{b1}-V_{T1}+V_{ov1}\\tag{11}$$\n\nand for $M_{1}$ itself, (1),\n\n$$V_{o}\\le V_{b1}-V_{T1}=V_{b1}+|V_{T1}|\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$V_{EC1}=V_{X}-V_{o}\\ge V_{ov1}\\tag{13}$$\n\nIn saturation the voltage on the inter cascode node is\nfixed, for a fixed $I_{D}$, by the $V_{b1}$ bias via\n(11).  Putting (11) in (7)\n\n$$V_{b1}+|V_{T1}|+V_{ov1}\\le V_{b2}+|V_{T2}| \\tag{14}$$\n\nfor equal, body tied to source, $|V_{T}|$\n\n$$V_{b2}\\ge V_{b1}+V_{ov1} \\tag{15}$$\n\n$$V_{b2}-V_{b1}\\ge \\sqrt{{{2I_{D}}\\over {k_{p1}}}}\\tag{16}$$\n\nIn terms of the conventional $V_{DD}$ referred bias\n\n$$V_{EB2}=|V_{T}|+V_{ov2}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{b2}=V_{DD}-|V_{T}|-V_{ov2}\\tag{17}$$\n\n(11) becomes\n\n$$V_{b1}=V_{X}-|V_{T}|-V_{ov1}=V_{DD}-|V_{T}|-V_{ov2}-V_{ov1}\\tag{18}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$V_{b1}=V_{b2}-V_{ov1}\\tag{19}$$\n\nis the bias for the minimum voltage drop across the\ncascode, the ``wide swing'' cascode.  Any $V_{b2}$\nhigher than (15) by $\\Delta V$ just adds $\\Delta V$\nto the minimum voltage that must be dropped across the\ncascode to keep $M_{2}$ pentode.  Any $V_{b2}$ lower\nthan (15) puts $M_{2}$ in the triode for the current\ndefined by $V_{b1},(W/L)_{1}$.  Normally $V_{b1,2}$\nare generated by a replica bias so that (19) tracks with\nprocess, $I_{D}$ and temperature.\n\nWith (12)(13)\n\n$$V_{o}\\le V_{b1}+|V_{T1}|\\le V_{DD}-V_{ov1}-V_{ov2}\\tag{20}$$\n\ni. e. the conventional\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{o}\\ge V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}=V_{EB1}+V_{EB2}+V_{T1}+V_{T2}\\tag{21}$$\n\nmust be dropped across the cascode to keep {\\it both\\/}\ndevices pentode.  If $V_{o}$ is allowed to rise, go\nmore positive, toward $V_{DD}$ so that (12) fails,\n$M_{1}$ goes triode, its $V_{X}$ is pulled up toward\n$V_{o}$ toward $V_{DD}$ and (7)(9) fails and $M_{2}$\ngoes triode as well.  The $R_{o}$ looking into the\ndrain of $M_{1}$,\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx g_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\qquad {\\rm sat/sat}\\tag{22}$$\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx r_{o1}\\qquad {\\rm sat/triode}\\tag{23}$$\n\ncollapses.\n\nIn the usual form $V_{T1}$ is increased by body effect\nif the $n$ well is common to $V_{DD}$,\n\n$$|V_{T1}|=|V_{T0}|+\\gamma \\left[\n\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{SB1}}-\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}}\\right]\\tag{24}$$\n\n$$V_{SB1}=V_{SB1}=V_{B}-V_{S1}=V_{DD}-V_{X}>0\\tag{25}$$\n\nnormally quoted as $V_{S1}-V_{B}<0$, and (14)(20) become\n\n$$V_{X}\\le V_{b2}+|V_{T0}|$$\n$$V_{X}=V_{b1}+|V_{T1}(V_{X})|+V_{ov1}\\tag{26}$$\n\nsolved iteratively, normally $\\Delta |V_{T}|\\sim 0.1-0.3\\,{\\rm V}$.\nWith separate $n$ wells, Fig.1 as drawn, $V_{SB}=0$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} For the $n$ channel dual interchange\n> $V_{DD}\\leftrightarrow Gnd$, $V_{b}\\to V_{b}$ positive\n> with respect to $Gnd$, $|V_{T}|\\to V_{T}$, $V_{X}\\ge\n> V_{b2}-V_{T}$, $V_{o}\\ge V_{b1}-V_{T}$, $V_{o}\\ge\n> V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}$, $V_{b2}\\le V_{b1}-V_{ov1}$, etc.\n\nThe conventional wide swing replica bias is e.{\\rm g}. a\ndiode connected $p$ device $(W/L)_{2}$ carrying $I_{D}$\ngenerating (17) and a source follower level shift of\n$V_{ov1}+|V_{T1}|$ to generate (18).  Any bias with\n(15) satisfied and with $V_{o}$ constrained by (20) will\nkeep $M_{2}$, and $M_{1}$, pentode and the output\nimpedance high.  Making $(W/L)_{1,2}$ large, $V_{ov1,2}\n\\sim 100-200\\,{\\rm mV}$, minimises the headroom (21)\nrequired to keep the cascode pentode.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a6853c6ccd47aeef2916f112ce9857d9cac632815d8c080aa832ed05ed49686c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly gives M2’s PMOS saturation condition and relates the interstage voltage to Vb1 through M1, yielding Vb2 − Vb1 ≥ M1’s overdrive for equal thresholds.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "519fe1851b4fd9a0e83d2b184c82583260701cb7382ec5e7c6bdd728b4cc9a0f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2679,
        "output_tokens": 8328,
        "total_tokens": 11007,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6172,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2679,
        "output_tokens": 8328,
        "total_tokens": 11007,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6172,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "How do we ensure that M2 is in saturation in the figure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "For a ${\\rm p}$ channel\n\n$$V_{SG}> \\vert V_{T}\\vert \\tag {on}$$\n$$V_{SD}\\ge V_{SD{\\rm sat}}=V_{SG}-\\vert V_{T}\\vert \\tag {sat.}$$\nwith $V_{T}<0$.\nWith the sign as in the figure , the conventional\n$n$ channel $V_{DS{\\rm sat}}=V_{GS}-V_{TN}$\nbecomes with $1\\to 2$ , $D\\to S$\n\n$$V_{{D_{2}}}\\le V_{{G_{2}}}-V_{T}\\tag *$$\n\nFor $M_{2}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{S_{2}}&=V_{DD}\\cr\nV_{G_{2}}&=V_{b2}\\cr\nV_{D_{2}}&=V_{X}}$$\n\n$$V_{SD_{2}}=V_{DD}-V_{X}\\tag1$$\n$$V_{SG_{2}}=V_{DD}-V_{b2}\\tag2$$\n\nso that at the edge of saturation\n\n$$V_{SD_{2}{\\rm sat}}=V_{SG_{2}}-\\vert V_{Tp2}\\vert \\tag3$$\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{X}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{b2}-\\vert V_{Tp2}\\vert $$\n\n$${{V_{X}\\le V_{b2}+\\vert V_{Tp2}\\vert =V_{b2}-V_{Tp2}}}\\tag4$$\n\nin the conventional $V_{Tp}<0$ notation $V_{X}\\le V_{b2}\n-V_{Tp2}$.\nWith $\\vert V_{Tp}\\vert +V_{ov}=V_{SG}$\n\n$$V_{X}\\le V_{DD}-V_{ov2}\\tag{4a}$$\n\ni. e. the drain of $M_{2}$ must be at least one\noverdrive below $V_{DD}$.\nThat voltage is the source voltage of $M_{1}$.\n\nIf $M_{1}$ itself is on\n\n$$V_{X}=V_{S_{1}}=V_{b1}+V_{SG_{1}}=V_{b1}+\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert\n+V_{ov1}\\tag5$$\n\n$$\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert +V_{ov1}= \\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert +\n\\sqrt{{2I_{D}\\over {\\mu _{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}}}} \\tag6$$\n\nwith the body effect\n\n$$\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert =\\vert V_{Tp0}\\vert\n+\\gamma \\left[\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{SB_{1}}}-\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}}\\right]\n\\qquad V_{SB_{1}}=V_{X}-V_{DD}$$\n\nif the $n$ well of $M_{1}$ is common with $M_{2}$.\nIf you put $M_{1}$ in its own $n$ well and strap the well\nto $X$, $V_{SB_{1}}=0$ and $\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert =\\vert V_{Tp2}\n\\vert =\\vert V_{Tp0}\\vert $.\n\nPutting (5) in (4)\n\n$$V_{b1}+\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert +V_{ov1}\\le V_{b2}+\\vert V_{Tp2}\\vert $$\n\n$${{V_{b2}\\ge V_{b1}+V_{ov1}+\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert -\\vert V_{Tp2}\\vert }}\\tag7$$\n\nWith no body effect and $\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert =\\vert V_{Tp2}\\vert$,\n\n$${{V_{b2}\\ge V_{b1}+V_{ov1}}}\\tag{7a}$$\n\n$${{V_{b1}\\le V_{b2}-V_{ov1}}}\\tag{7b}$$\n\n$${{V_{b1}\\le V_{DD}-\\vert V_{Tp}\\vert -V_{ov2}-V_{ov1}}}\\tag{7c}$$\n\nwhen $V_{b2}$ is normally set to put $M_{2}$ itself about\nsaturated\n\n$$V_{b2}=V_{DD}-\\vert V_{Tp2}\\vert -V_{ov2}\\tag8$$\n\ni. e. $V_{b2}$ is about one overdrive voltage {\\it above}\n$V_{b1}$. In normal design $V_{ov}\\approx 0.1-0.3{\\rm V}$ so\n\n$$V_{b2}\\approx V_{b1}+0.15\\pm 0.1{\\rm V}$$\n\nwith $50-100{\\rm mV}$ of margin left for $PVT$.\n\nAt the optimum high swing bias $M_{2}$ is left at the\nedge of saturation so\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{X}&=V_{DD}-V_{ov2}=V_{b2}+\\vert V_{T}\\vert \\cr\nV_{b1}&=V_{X}-\\vert V_{T}\\vert -V_{ov1}=V_{b2}-V_{ov1}}$$\n\nAny $V_{X}>V_{b2}+\\vert V_{T}\\vert $ puts $M_{2}$ in the triode\nand the impedance looking into the drain of $M_{1}$\n\n$$R_{out}\\approx g_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\;\\;{\\rm sat/sat}$$\n\ncollapses to $\\approx r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$.\n\nIn practice $V_{b1},V_{b2}$ are made to track (7) by\ngenerating them from a replica bias branch that carries\nthe same $I_{D}$ : a diode connected $M_{2R}\\equiv M_{2}$\ngives (8) and a level shift of $V_{ov1}+ \\Delta V_{T}$\n{\\it down} from $V_{b2}$, normally a $M_{1R}\\equiv M_{1}$\ndiode or a source follower, gives (7) over corners.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} For $M_{1}$ itself to stay saturated\n> $$V_{SD_{1}}\\ge V_{SG_{1}}-\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert $$\n> $$V_{X}-V_{out}\\ge V_{X}-V_{b1}-\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert $$\n> $$V_{out}\\le V_{b1}+\\vert V_{Tp1}\\vert  \\tag9$$\n> so the allowable swing at the output is (9).  Keeping\n> (9) satisfied keeps $V_{X}$ given by (5) essentially\n> constant and (4) satisfied.  Going beyond (9) pushes\n> $M_{1}$ into triode, $V_{X}$ is pulled up to $V_{out}$\n> and $M_{2}$ goes triode as well.\n\nWith body effect (7) becomes\n\n$$V_{b2}\\ge V_{b1}+ \\Delta \\vert V_{T}\\vert _{body}+V_{ov1}$$\n\nwhich can be $0.3-0.4{\\rm V}$.  It is customary to remove\nit by putting $M_{1}$ in a separate $n$ well tied to $X$,\nor to allow for it by increasing $V_{b2}-V_{b1}$ or by\nmaking $(W/L)_{2}> (W/L)_{1}$ i. e. $V_{ov2}<V_{ov1}$.\n\nWith normal $0.18\\mu $ numbers $V_{DD}=1.8$,\n$\\vert V_{Tp}\\vert \\approx 0.4$, $V_{ov}\\approx 0.2$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{b2}&\\approx 1.2{\\rm V}\\cr\nV_{X\\,{\\rm max}}&\\approx 1.6{\\rm V}\\cr\nV_{b1\\,{\\rm max}}&\\approx 1.0{\\rm V}\\cr\nV_{out\\,{\\rm max}}&\\approx 1.4{\\rm V}}$$\n\nAny $V_{b1}$ lower than that lowers $V_{X}$ and helps\n(4) at the expense of $W_{1}$ for the same $V_{ov1}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "fadfefff81b9a898a66afc654a65c21e33fd6c600d328628d531e4167945b229"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies both devices as PMOS, gives M2’s saturation condition, and relates VX to Vb1 to derive the required bias inequality. Extra body-effect discussion does not alter the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "519fe1851b4fd9a0e83d2b184c82583260701cb7382ec5e7c6bdd728b4cc9a0f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2659,
        "input_tokens": 2679,
        "output_tokens": 5893,
        "total_tokens": 8572,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4008,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2659,
        "input_tokens": 2679,
        "output_tokens": 5893,
        "total_tokens": 8572,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4008,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "How do we ensure that M2 is in saturation in the figure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-019-ensure-m2-saturation/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "For a $P$ the pinch off is at the $D$ end\n\n$$\\left |V_{SD}\\right| > \\left |V_{SG}\\right|-\n\\left |V_{Tp}\\right| \\tag{*}$$\n\n$V_{Tp}<0$.  With $\\left |V_{T}\\right|=-V_{Tp}$\nand overdrive $V_{ov}=V_{SG}-\\left |V_{T}\\right|>0$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{SG} &=V_{S}-V_{G} \\cr\nV_{SD} &=V_{S}-V_{D}\\cr\nV_{ov} &=V_{SD{sat}}}$$\n\n$(*)$ is $V_{SD}\\ge V_{ov}$ .\n\nPut $D\\equiv X$ for $M_{2}$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nS_{2}&=V_{DD}\\cr\nG_{2}&=V_{b2}\\cr\nD_{2}&=V_{X}\\cr\nV_{SG2}&=V_{DD}-V_{b2}\\cr\nV_{SD2}&=V_{DD}-V_{X}}$$\n\n$$V_{SD2}\\ge V_{SG2}-\\left |V_{T2}\\right| \\tag {1}$$\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{X}\\ge V_{DD}-V_{b2}-\\left |V_{T2}\\right|$$\n\n$$\\;V_{X}\\le V_{b2}+\\left |V_{T2}\\right|\\; \\tag{2}$$\n\nin $N{\\rm MOS}$ notation $V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{T}$,\nfor the $P$, $V_{DS}\\le V_{GS}-V_{Tp}$, $V_{Tp}<0$,\n$V_{X}\\le V_{b2}-V_{Tp}$.\n\nIn words: keep the drain of $M_{2}$ at least\na $V_{ov2}=V_{SG2}-\\left |V_{T2}\\right|$ below $V_{DD}$,\ni. {\\it e.} at least $V_{SD{sat2}}$ of headroom on\n$M_{2}$.\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{X}\\ge V_{ov2}$$\n\nat pinch off\n\n$$V_{X{sat}}=V_{DD}-V_{ov2}=V_{b2}+\\left |V_{T2}\\right|\n      =V_{b2}-V_{T2}$$\n\n$V_{b2}$ must be low enough to turn the $P$ on,\n$V_{SG2}>\\left |V_{T2}\\right|$, i. e. $V_{b2}<V_{DD}-\n\\left |V_{T2}\\right|$, but high enough to satisfy\n(2). The normal way to write (2) is in terms of the\n$V_{X}$ imposed by $M_{1}$.\n\nIf $M_{1}$ is itself saturated\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{S1}&=V_{X}\\cr\nV_{G1}&=V_{b1}\\cr\nV_{D1}&=V_{o}\\cr\nV_{SG1}&=V_{X}-V_{b1}= \\left |V_{T1}\\right|+V_{ov1}\\cr\nV_{SD1}&=V_{X}-V_{o}\\ge V_{ov1}\\cr\nV_{o}&\\le V_{b1}+\\left |V_{T1}\\right|}$$\n\nis the compliance for the cascode.  Neglecting\n$\\lambda $,\n\n$$I_{D}= {\\tfrac12}\\mu_{p}C_{ox}{\\left({W\\over L}\\right)}_{1}\n        V_{ov1}^{2}= {\\tfrac12}\\mu_{p}C_{ox}{\\left({W\\over L}\\right)}_{2}V_{ov2}^{2}$$\n\n$$V_{X}=V_{b1}+V_{SG1}=V_{b1}+\\left |V_{T1}\\right|+V_{ov1}\n      =V_{b1}+\\left |V_{T1}\\right|+\n        \\sqrt{{2I_{D}\\over \\mu_{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}}} \\tag{3}$$\n\nin (2):\n\n$$V_{b1}+\\left |V_{T1}\\right|+V_{ov1}\\le V_{b2}+\n      \\left |V_{T2}\\right| \\tag{4}$$\n\nFor the normal $n-$well process the $n-$well of $M_{2}$\nis $V_{DD}$, the $n-$well of $M_{1}$ is $V_{X}$ if the\nwell is strapped to the source, so $\\left |V_{T1}\\right|\n=\\left |V_{T2}\\right|=\\left |V_{T}\\right|$ and $V_{SB}=0$.\nThen (4) is\n\n$$\\;V_{b2}\\ge V_{b1}+V_{ov1}\\; \\tag{5}$$\n\nwith $50-150\\,{\\rm mV}$ of margin over $PVT$.\nMore generally with the well of $M_{1}$ to $V_{DD}$\n\n$$\\left |V_{T1}\\right|=\\left |V_{T0}\\right|+\n      \\gamma\\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}+V_{DD}-V_{X}}-\n                  \\sqrt{2\\phi_{F}}\\right)>\\left |V_{T2}\\right|$$\n\nand (4) is $V_{b2}\\ge V_{b1}+V_{ov1}+\n\\left |V_{T1}\\right|-\\left |V_{T2}\\right|$.\n\nSo you cannot normally put $V_{b1}=V_{b2}$.  With\n$V_{b1}=V_{b2}$ (4) would require $V_{ov1}\\le 0$.\nYou make the cascode {\\it wide swing} by level\nshifting $V_{b2}$ {\\it up} - for a $P$ closer to\n$V_{DD}$ - by one $V_{ov}$ from $V_{b1}$.\n\nAt the edge of saturation\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{b2{sat}} &= V_{X{sat}}-\\left |V_{T2}\\right|\n            = V_{DD}-V_{ov2}-\\left |V_{T2}\\right|\\cr\nV_{b1{sat}} &= V_{X{sat}}-\\left |V_{T1}\\right|-V_{ov1}\n            = V_{DD}-V_{ov1}-V_{ov2}-\\left |V_{T1}\\right|\\cr\nV_{b2{sat}}-V_{b1{sat}} &= V_{ov1}+\\left |V_{T1}\\right|-\n                         \\left |V_{T2}\\right|}$$\n\nE. {\\it g.} for $\\left |V_{T}\\right|\\approx 0.4-0.5\\,{\\rm V}$,\n$V_{ov}\\approx 0.15-0.25\\,{\\rm V}$,\n\n$$V_{b2}\\approx V_{DD}-\\left |V_{T}\\right|-V_{ov2}$$\n$$V_{b1}\\approx V_{DD}-\\left |V_{T}\\right|-V_{ov1}-V_{ov2}$$\n$$V_{X}\\approx V_{DD}-V_{ov2}$$\n$$V_{o{max}}\\approx V_{b1}+\\left |V_{T}\\right|\n            \\approx V_{DD}-V_{ov1}-V_{ov2}$$\n\nand $V_{X}\\approx V_{b2}+\\left |V_{T}\\right|-{\\rm margin}$.\n\nIn practice $V_{b1},V_{b2}$ are generated from a replica\nbias branch carrying the same $I_{D}$ : a diode connected\n$P$ for $V_{b2}$ and a diode connected $P$ in series with\na $V_{ov1}$ level shift - a source follower or a large\n$W/L$ diode - to generate $V_{b1}=V_{b2}-V_{ov1}-{\\rm margin}$\nor vice versa.  Any bias that satisfies (1)-(5) with\n$\\sim 100\\,{\\rm mV}$ margin will keep $M_{2}$ saturated,\nand with (1) satisfied\n\n$$R_{out}\\approx g_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\parallel r_{o1}\\approx\ng_{m1}r_{o1}r_{o2}$$\n\notherwise $R_{out}\\approx r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2{\\rm ,triode}}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} Interchanging the labels $M_{1},M_{2}$\n> the usual statement is: the cascode gate must be\n> $V_{ov}$ {\\it above} - less $V_{SG}$ - than the\n> current source gate for a $P$ cascode, $V_{ov}$\n> {\\it below} for an $N$ cascode.  Making $(W/L)_{2}\n> \\gg (W/L)_{1}$ makes $V_{ov2}\\ll V_{ov1}$ and lets you\n> tie the gates together at the price of area and\n> capacitance.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bad4e2999ace7c5f02230fd08f5c03a1e5f38816cdf765371e224a9213cda633"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly treats both devices as PMOS, states M2’s saturation condition, and relates VX to Vb1 to derive the required bias inequality.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "519fe1851b4fd9a0e83d2b184c82583260701cb7382ec5e7c6bdd728b4cc9a0f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2679,
        "output_tokens": 7443,
        "total_tokens": 10122,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5294,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2679,
        "output_tokens": 7443,
        "total_tokens": 10122,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5294,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a {\\it single ended telescopic NMOS cascode}\nwith active load, the most common high gain cell in CMOS.\n\n$$M_{1}: Common~Source~input~{\\rm device} - {\\rm transconductor}$$\n$$M_{2}: Common~Gate~cascode~device - {\\rm current~buffer}$$\n$$I_{1}: DC~bias~and~AC~load.\\; r_{o3}= 1/\\lambda_{p}I_{1}\\; if\\; PMOS$$\n$$V_{b1}: DC\\; bias\\; to\\; keep\\; M_{2}\\; {\\rm on\\;and\\;saturated}$$\n\nIf $I_{1}$ ideal $R_{o3}= \\infty$. In practice\n$R_{o3}$ is in parallel with the impedance looking into $M_{2}$.\n\n> Bias $I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{1}$ in normal amplifier mode.\n\n### 1. Large signal - DC operation\n\nFor $V_{in}<V_{Tn}$ :\n\n$$M_{1}\\; OFF\\; , I_{D1}=0$$\n\nNo DC path for $I_{1}$. Ideal circuit charges $V_{out}\\to V_{DD}-V_{I_{1},sat}$. In reality $M_{2}$ goes deep triode to try to sink $I_{1}$.\n\nFor $V_{in}>V_{Tn}$ in saturation:\n\n$$I_{D1}= \\frac{1}{2}\\mu_{n}C_{ox}\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_{1}(V_{in}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{n}V_{X}) $$\n$$I_{D2}=I_{D1}=I_{1}\\; {\\rm fixed}$$\n\nSo the transfer $V_{out}$ vs $V_{in}$ is very steep once $M_{1}$ turns on.\nIn saturation $V_{in}$ controls $V_{X}$ only logarithmically, the cascode\nimposes $V_{X}$:\n\n$$V_{X}=V_{b1}-V_{GS2}$$\n\n$$V_{GS2}=V_{Tn}+V_{ov2}=V_{Tn}+\\sqrt{2I_{1}/\\mu_{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{2}}$$\n\nConditions for saturation:\n\n$$\\left. {\\rm M_{1}\\;sat}: V_{X} \\ge V_{GS1}-V_{Tn}=V_{ov1}\\right.$$\n$$\\left. {\\rm M_{2}\\;sat}: V_{DS2}=V_{out}-V_{X} \\ge V_{ov2}\\right.$$\n\nHence\n\n$$V_{b1}=V_{X}+V_{GS2}\\ge V_{ov1}+V_{GS2}=V_{Tn}+V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}$$\n\nNormal choice $V_{b1}=V_{Tn}+1.5\\,to\\,2\\,V_{ov}$ with margin.\nMinimum permittable output:\n\n$$V_{out,min}=V_{X}+V_{ov2}=V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}$$\n\nMaximum permittable output:\n\n$$V_{out,max}=V_{DD}-V_{ov3}$$\n\nwhere $V_{ov3}$ is the saturation voltage of the $I_{1}$ PMOS source.\nSwing $=V_{DD}-V_{ov1}-V_{ov2}-V_{ov3}$. Main disadvantage of telescopic \ncascode: stack of 3 $V_{ov}$.\n\nSmall signal $M_{1}$ and $M_{2}$ must remain saturated for amplification.\n\n### 2. Small signal model\n\nGate of $M_{2}$ AC ground, source of $M_{1}$ AC ground.\nLet $g_{m1},r_{o1}$ ; $g_{m2},r_{o2}$ ; $R_{o3}=r_{o,I1}$.\n\nWith body effect for $M_{2}$: $g_{m2}\\to g_{m2}'=g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$ if bulk is to\nGND. If as drawn $M_{2}$ is in its own $p$-well with bulk tied to source\n$X$, $g_{mb2}=0$.\n\nNode $X$:\n\n$$R_{X}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}'+r_{o1}^{-1}+r_{o2}^{-1}}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}'}\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2} \\approx 1/g_{m2}'$$\n\n$$A_{v,X}= \\frac{v_{x}}{v_{in}} = -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}'+r_{o1}^{-1}+r_{o2}^{-1}}\\approx -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}'}\\approx -1$$\n\nfor matched devices. So $M_{1}$ sees a low gain load $\\approx 1/g_{m2}$.\n\nThat kills Miller multiplication of $C_{gd1}$:\n\n$$C_{in}\\approx C_{gs1}+C_{gd1}(1-A_{v,X})\\approx C_{gs1}+2C_{gd1}$$\n\ninstead of $C_{gs1}+ (1+g_{m1}r_{o1})C_{gd1}$ for a simple $CS$.\n\nOutput impedance looking into drain of $M_{2}$ with source degenerated\nby $r_{o1}$:\n\nPut $v_{in}=0$, apply $v_{x}$ at output, measure $i_{x}$.\n\n$$\\begin{aligned}\nR_{o,cas} &= r_{o2} + \\left(1+g_{m2}'r_{o2}\\right)r_{o1} \\\\\n&\\approx g_{m2}'r_{o2}r_{o1} \\gg r_{o1},r_{o2}\n\\end{aligned}$$\n\nTotal output resistance:\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{o,cas}\\parallel R_{o3} \\approx g_{m2}'r_{o2}r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o3}$$\n\nIf $I_{1}$ ideal $\\;R_{out}\\approx g_{m2}'r_{o2}r_{o1}$.\n\nVoltage gain:\n\n$$A_{v}= \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = -G_{m}R_{out}$$\n\nEffective transconductance $G_{m}\\approx g_{m1}\\frac{R_{o3}}{R_{o3}+R_{o,cas}}\\approx g_{m1}$ when $R_{o,cas}<R_{o3}$, otherwise $G_{m}r_{o3}$ limited.\n\nHence ideal:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}\\left(g_{m2}'r_{o2}r_{o1}\\parallel R_{o3}\\right)$$\n\n$$\\left|A_{v}\\right|\\approx g_{m1}g_{m2}'r_{o1}r_{o2}\\; {\\rm for\\; ideal\\; load}$$\n\n$x\\, g_{m}r_{o}$ larger than simple $CS$ stage $A_{v0}=-g_{m1}(r_{o1}\\parallel R_{o3})$.\n\nExample: $g_{m}=1mS$, $r_{o}=100k$ $\\to |A_{v0}|=50$, $|A_{v,cas}|= 10^{4}\\approx 80dB$.\n\n$$Z_{in}\\approx \\infty \\;at\\; low\\; frequency\\; \\left(C_{gs1}\\right)$$\n$$Z_{out}=R_{out}$$\n\nIsolation is excellent, reverse transmission $C_{gd2}$ small.\n\n### 3. Frequency response\n\nTwo poles:\n\nP1 dominant at output:\n\n$$\\omega_{p,out}= \\frac{1}{R_{out}C_{L}}\\;,\\;C_{L}=C_{db2}+C_{gd2}+C_{o3}+C_{load}$$\n\nP2 non dominant at cascode node $X$:\n\n$$\\omega_{p,X}\\approx \\frac{g_{m2}'}{C_{X}}\\;,\\;C_{X}=C_{gs2}+C_{sb2}+C_{gd1}+C_{db1}+C_{db2?}$$\n\n$$\\omega_{p,X}\\gg \\omega_{p,out}$$\n\nbecause $R_{X}\\approx 1/g_{m2}'$ is small. The cascode pushes the internal\npole to very high frequency giving much larger bandwidth and $GBW\\approx g_{m1}/C_{L}$ compared to $CS$ with Miller pole.\n\nZero due to $C_{gd2}$ at $\\approx g_{m2}'/C_{gd2}$ usually beyond $f_{T}$.\n\nBandwidth: $\\omega_{-3dB}= \\omega_{p,out}$, $GBW = |A_{v}|\\omega_{p,out}=g_{m1}/C_{L}$\n\nSlew rate $SR = I_{1}/C_{L}$.\n\n### 4. Other properties\n\n* Noise: Input referred noise dominated by $M_{1}$, $M_{2}$ contribution\ndivided by $g_{m1}^{2}$, negligible: $\\overline{v_{n}^{2}}\\approx 8kT/3g_{m1}$\n\n* PSRR: Sensitive to $V_{DD}$ via $R_{o3}$.\n\n* Gain boosting / regulated cascode can raise $R_{out}$ to $\\sim g_{m}^{2}r_{o}^{3}$ by\nadding auxiliary amplifier $A_{aux}$ to gate of $M_{2}$.\n\nIn short: high $R_{out}$, high $A_{v}$, wide band, low Miller effect, but\nlimited output swing and headroom, requiring $V_{DD}>V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}+V_{ov3}$,\nand the bias $V_{b1}$ must be carefully generated, normally with a\ndiode connected replica.\n\nWant the full derivation with test source, body effect included, or a\nnumerical/SPICE example for a $0.18\\mu m$ bias point?",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "666c309c0e0c17136426c9a4fd966fb65b6ef9f7cd99ee2ea7c4620e7573ec3c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-source NMOS and M2 as the common-gate NMOS cascode, and gives the equivalent ideal-load gain magnitude. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "fa3ce3c10c3d0bf6258738fc6e9b064c896064cb851cd7f79a50e2fe2b3c822b",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1371,
        "output_tokens": 4553,
        "total_tokens": 5924,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2314,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1371,
        "output_tokens": 4553,
        "total_tokens": 5924,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2314,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the elementary {\\it telescopic cascode} - \na common source $M_{1}$ loaded by a common gate\n$M_{2}$ and an AC current source load $I_{1}$.\n\nIn ideal form $I_{1}$ is $AC$ $gnd$ with\n$R_{I1}=r_{o3}=1/g_{ds3}= \\infty $. In practice\n$R_{I1}=r_{o3}< \\infty $ of the PMOS that implements\n$I_{1}$.\n\n$$R_{oI}= \\frac{1}{\\lambda_{p}I_{1}}\\;\\;,\\;\\; r_{o1,2}=1/\\lambda_{n}I_{1}$$\n\n$$g_{m1,2}= \\sqrt{2\\mu_{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1,2}I_{1}}=\n\\frac{2I_{1}}{V_{ov1,2}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;g_{mb2}= \\chi g_{m2}$$\n\n> $M_{1}$ = transconductor, $M_{2}$ = current buffer,\n> cascode device.\n\n### 1. DC bias\n\nBy KCL\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{1}\\;\\;\\; {\\rm if\\; both\\; saturated}$$\n\nSo $V_{GS1}$ is fixed by $I_{1}$:\n\n$$I_{1}= \\frac{1}{2}k_{n1}(V_{GS1}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{n}V_{DS1})$$\n$$V_{in,DC}=V_{GS1}=V_{Tn}+V_{ov1}\\approx V_{Tn}+\\sqrt{\\frac{2I_{1}}{k_{n1}}}$$\n\nwith $k_{n}= \\mu_{n}C_{ox}W/L$.\n\n$$V_{X}=V_{S2}=V_{b1}-V_{GS2}=V_{b1}-V_{Tn}-V_{ov2}$$\n\nSaturation constraints:\n\n* $M_{1}$ sat: $V_{DS1}=V_{X}\\ge V_{ov1}$\n\n$$V_{b1}\\ge V_{Tn}+V_{ov1}+V_{ov2} \\tag{1}$$\n\n* $M_{2}$ sat: $V_{DS2}=V_{out}-V_{X}\\ge V_{ov2}$\n\n$$V_{out}\\ge V_{b1}-V_{Tn} \\tag{2}$$\n\nwith finite $I_{1}$:\n\n* $I_{1}$ sat: $V_{SD3}=V_{DD}-V_{out}\\ge V_{ov3}$\n\n$$V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}\\le V_{out}\\le V_{DD}-|V_{ov3}| \\tag{3}$$\n\nis the usable swing.  $V_{b1}$ is normally generated\nso as to put $V_{X}\\approx V_{ov1}$ and $V_{out,min}=V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}$.\nTypically $V_{b1}=V_{GS1}+V_{ov2}+ \\Delta \\approx 2V_{Tn}+2-3V_{ov}$.\n\nLarge signal $V_{out}$ vs. $V_{in}$:\n\n* $V_{in}<V_{Tn}$: $M_{1},M_{2}$ OFF, $I_{1}$ charges $C_{L}$ to $V_{DD}-|V_{ov3}|$, $I_{1}$ in triode.\n* $V_{in}=V_{GS1}$: both saturated, high gain region\n* $V_{in}\\gg V_{Tn}$: $M_{1}$ demands $>I_{1}$, $V_{X}$ and $V_{out}$ fall, $M_{1}$ then $I_{1}$ goes triode, $V_{out}\\to V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}$ limit.\n\nSo for linear amplification $v_{in}=V_{in,DC}+v_{id}$ with $v_{id}\\ll V_{ov1}$.\n\n### 2. Small signal\n\n```\nvin -o---|G M1 D|---X---|S M2 D|---o vout\n         |S     |      |G     |    |\n        gnd    ro1     Vb1(AC gnd) ro2\n                       gm2,gmb2    |\n                                   R_I1 -> VDD AC gnd\n```\n\n$M_{2}$ is $CG$ with source degeneration $r_{o1}$.\n\nImpedance looking into source of $CG$:\n\n$$R_{X1}= \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nImpedance looking into drain of cascode:\n\nNeglecting $R_{I1}$:\n\n$$R_{oc}= \\frac{v_{x}}{i_{x}}\\Bigl|_{v_{in}=0}$$\n\n$$R_{oc}= r_{o1}+r_{o2}+ (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o1}r_{o2}$$\n\n$$R_{oc}\\approx (1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2})r_{o1}$$\n\nWithout body effect $g_{mb}=0$:\n\n$$R_{oc}\\approx g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\gg r_{o1}$$\n\nThat is the cascode multiplication by $g_{m2}r_{o2}\\sim 20-100$.\n\nWith load:\n\n$$R_{out}= R_{oc}\\parallel R_{I1}=R_{oc}\\parallel r_{o3}$$\n\nFor ideal $I_{1}$, $R_{out}=R_{oc}\\to \\infty$ to first\norder.\n\nInput resistance $R_{in}= \\infty$ gate.\n\nResistance at intermediate node $X$:\n\n$$R_{X}= \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$$\n\nlow impedance, which is the point.\n\n### 3. Voltage gain\n\n$$A_{v}= \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = -g_{m1}R_{out}$$\n\ni.e.\n\n$$A_{v}= -g_{m1}\\left[ r_{o1}+r_{o2}+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o1}r_{o2}\\right]\\parallel r_{o3}$$\n\n$$\\left|A_{v}\\right|\\approx g_{m1}(g_{m2}r_{o2}r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o3})$$\n\nIf $r_{o3}\\gg R_{oc}$:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}= -(g_{m1}r_{o1})(g_{m2}r_{o2})$$\n\nversus $A_{v0}=-g_{m1}r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o3}$ for simple\ncommon source. Increase by $g_{m2}r_{o2}$.\n\nIf $R_{oc}\\gg r_{o3}$ the gain is limited by the PMOS load:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}r_{o3}$$\n\nIn practice $r_{o1}\\approx r_{o2}\\approx r_{o3}=r_{o}$,\n$g_{m}r_{o}= 2/\\lambda V_{ov}\\sim 50$,\n\n$$|A_{v}|\\sim 50-80\\,{\\rm dB}$$\n\nagainst $\\sim 30-40\\,{\\rm dB}$ for CS.\n\nOutput phase is inverting, $CG$ is non-inverting.\n\nBody effect: if p-sub NMOS $M_{2}$ has bulk to GND,\n$g_{mb2}\\ne 0$, $R_{oc}$ is increased slightly to\n$(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o}$ but effective transconductance\nfrom source to drain is $g_{m}/(1+\\chi)$. Some texts\nwrite $R_{oc}= (1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o2})r_{o1}+r_{o2}$.\nIf $M_{2}$ is in isolated p-well with bulk tied to $X$,\n$g_{mb2}=0$.\n\n### 4. Frequency response - Miller\n\n$$C_{X}= C_{gs2}+C_{sb2}+C_{db1}+C_{gd1}$$\n$$C_{L}= C_{db2}+C_{gd2}+C_{dbo3}+C_{gdo3}+C_{L,ext}$$\n\n$$p_{out}= \\frac{1}{R_{out}C_{L}}\\;\\; {\\rm dominant}$$\n\n$$p_{X}= \\frac{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}{C_{X}}\\approx \\frac{g_{m2}}{C_{X}}\\;\\; {\\rm non\\; dominant}$$\n\nBecause $R_{X}$ is small, $p_{X}\\gg p_{out}$ . GBW $\\approx g_{m1}/C_{L}$ same as CS, but\npole splitting is much better.\n\nMiller multiplication of $C_{gd1}$:\n\n$$C_{in}= C_{gs1}+C_{gd1}(1-A_{v1})$$\n\nwhere $A_{v1}= v_{X}/v_{in}= -g_{m1}/(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\approx -1$.\nSo $C_{gd1}$ sees $\\sim 2\\times$, not $1+|A_{v}|$ as in\nsimple CS. Large bandwidth improvement.\n\nApproximate transfer:\n\n$$A_{v}(s)\\approx \\frac{A_{v0}}{(1+s/p_{out})(1+s/p_{X})}$$\n\nA RHP zero at $g_{m2}/C_{gd2}$ far away.\n\n### 5. Merit\n\n* High $R_{out}$, high voltage gain without stacking gain stages\n* Suppresses Miller effect -> higher $f_{T}$\n* Good PSRR if $I_{1}$ is cascode itself\n* Cost: reduced output swing by $V_{ov2}$, needs $V_{b1}$ bias, needs headroom $V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}+|V_{ov3}|$, not suitable for low $V_{DD}$. Input common mode limited.\n\nUsed as core gain stage of telescopic / folded cascode op-amps, wideband LNAs. To increase swing and $R_{I1}$ the current source is itself cascoded, giving $R_{out}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}^{2}\\parallel g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$.\n\nIf you give $W/L$, $I_{1}$, $\\lambda$, $C_{L}$ the numbers can be evaluated for $g_{m}$, $r_{o}$, $A_{v}$, $p_{out}$, $p_{X}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "17946ff19a91e2b1620c2df4c0308e18e88d5b14949432268ed015feabcab481"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-source NMOS and M2 as the common-gate NMOS cascode, and gives the cascode gain as approximately −gm1Rout (including the ideal-load expression). This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule; the overstatement about Rout/X is secondary.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "fa3ce3c10c3d0bf6258738fc6e9b064c896064cb851cd7f79a50e2fe2b3c822b",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1371,
        "output_tokens": 5277,
        "total_tokens": 6648,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2893,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1371,
        "output_tokens": 5277,
        "total_tokens": 6648,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2893,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-020-nmos-cascode-gain-stage/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the elementary $N$ MOS cascode\ngain stage with active load $I_{1}$. Often\nrealized with $I_{1}=P$ MOS current mirror.\n\n$$M_{1}= {\\rm common\\; source\\; driver} \\qquad \n  M_{2}= {\\rm common\\; gate\\; cascode} \\qquad \n  I_{1}\\approx AC\\; {\\rm open}$$\n\nLet\n\n$$g_{m} = \\mu C_{ox}\\frac{W}{L}V_{ov}\\;\\;\\;,\\;\\;\\; r_{o}= \\frac{1}{\\lambda I_{D}}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{ds}}$$\n$$V_{ov}=V_{GS}-V_{TH} \\;\\;\\;,\\;\\;\\; A_{i}=g_{m}r_{o}={\\rm intrinsic\\; gain} \\approx 20-100$$\n\n$W/L_{1},W/L_{2}$ carry same $DC$ current\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{1}=I_{D}$$\n\non bias $V_{b1}= {\\rm const}$ so $v_{b1}=0$ for $AC$.\n\n> In small signal $M_{1}$ is a $V \\to I$ converter\n> $M_{2}$ is a current buffer that presents a\n> low $Z$ to the drain of $M_{1}$ and a high $Z$\n> to the output and transfers the $AC$ current\n> $g_{m1}v_{in}$ essentially unattenuated to $R_{out}$.\n\n### 1. DC conditions - stay in saturation\n\nNormal $N$ MOS, bulk = GND. Then $M_{1}$ has $V_{SB1}=0$\n$M_{2}$ has $V_{SB2}=V_{X}>0$ body effect $\\ne 0$\nunless triple well.\n\n$$S_{AT} : V_{DS}\\ge V_{GS}-V_{TH} = V_{ov}$$\n\n$$\\begin{aligned}\nM_{1}: V_{X} &\\ge V_{ov1} \\\\\nM_{2}: V_{out}-V_{X} &\\ge V_{b1}-V_{X}-V_{TH2} \\\\\nV_{out} &\\ge V_{b1}-V_{TH2}\n\\end{aligned}$$\n\nso\n\n$$V_{out,min}\\approx V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}$$\n\n$$V_{X}=V_{b1}-V_{GS2}=V_{b1}-V_{TH2}-V_{ov2}$$\n\nFor maximum swing $V_{b1}$ is chosen\n\n$$V_{b1}\\approx V_{TH2}+2V_{ov}$$\n\nthen $V_{X}\\approx V_{ov1}$ edge of saturation.\n\nUpwards\n\n$$V_{out,max}=V_{DD}-V_{ov,I1}$$\n\n$V_{ov,I1}$ is saturation voltage of the $P$MOS\nthat implements $I_{1}$. With ideal $I_{1}$, $V_{out,max}\\to V_{DD}$.\n\nLarge signal class A: $i_{d1}=I_{1}+g_{m1}v_{in}+...$\nmust stay $0< i_{d1} < 2I_{1}$ before one device\nleaves saturation, clips.\n\n### 2. Small signal model\n\n```\n         vout\n          o\n          |\n         roI\n          |\n     D2 o-+--- ro2 ---+--X S2\n          |          |      |\n         gm2*vgs2  gmb2*vbs2 |\n          |          |      |\n         GND(vb1)    +------+\n                    X o\n                    |\n               D1 o-+--- ro1 --- GND\n                    |\n                   gm1*vin\n                    |\n                   GND\n```\n\n$ v_{gs2}= -v_{x}\\;,\\;v_{bs2}= -v_{x}\\;,\\;v_{ds2}=v_{out}-v_{x}$\n\n### 3. Impedance levels\n\nImpedance looking into source of $CG$ with load $r_{o2}$ to\ndrain:\n\n$$R_{x}= \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}$$\n\nCapacitance at $X$ sees that low $R$. Hence\n\n$$C_{X}\\approx C_{gs2}+C_{sb2}+C_{gd1}+C_{db1}+C_{db2?}$$\n\nImpedance looking into drain of cascode with\nsource degeneration $r_{o1}$:\n\nPut $v_{in}=0$, apply $v_{t}$ at $v_{out}$, measure $i_{t}$.\n\n$$\\;R_{o,cas}= r_{o2}+ \\left[1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}\\right]r_{o1}\\;$$\n\n$$\\approx (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o1}r_{o2}\\;\\; {\\rm for}\\;(g_{m}r_{o})\\gg 1$$\n\nIf bulk tied to source for $M_{2}$, $g_{mb2}=0$ :\n\n$$R_{o,cas}\\approx g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}$$\n\nThis is $A_{i}$ times larger than a simple $CS$\nstage $r_{o1}$.\n\nTotal output resistance with load current source\n$r_{oI}=r_{o1,P}$ finite:\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{o,cas}\\parallel r_{oI}$$\n\nIdeal $I_{1}$ : $r_{oI}\\to\\infty$, $R_{out}=R_{o,cas}$.\n\nInput resistance at gate $M_{1}$:\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx \\infty \\;{\\rm capacitive}\\; C_{in}=C_{gs1}+C_{gd1}(1-A_{vX})$$\n\nbut $A_{vX}=v_{x}/v_{in}$ is small:\n\n$$A_{vX}= -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\approx -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}} \\approx -1$$\n\nso Miller multiplication of $C_{gd1}$ is $\\sim 2\\times$\nnot $1+|A_{v}|\\gg 1$. This is the bandwidth advantage\nof cascode.\n\n### 4. Voltage gain\n\nKCL at $X$ and at output gives well known result\n\n$$i_{d}\\approx g_{m1}v_{in}$$\n\n$$v_{out}= -i_{d}\\,R_{out}$$\n\n$$\\;A_{v}= \\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}} = -g_{m1}R_{out}\\;$$\n\nExplicitly\n\n$$A_{v}= -g_{m1}\\left\\{\\left[r_{o2}+(1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2})r_{o1}\\right]\\parallel r_{oI}\\right\\}$$\n\nIdeal:\n\n$$A_{v,ideal}\\approx -g_{m1}(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o1}r_{o2} \\approx -g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}$$\n\n$$|A_{v}|\\approx A_{i1}\\cdot A_{i2}\\approx 500-10\\,000\\;\\; 54-80{\\rm dB}$$\n\nvs simple $CS$ with same load $A_{v0}=-g_{m1}(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{oI})\\approx -A_{i}/2$.\n\nIn other words cascode multiplies the gain by\n$g_{m2}r_{o2}$.\n\nIf $r_{oI}$ dominates, e.g. $r_{oI}\\ll R_{o,cas}$ :\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}r_{oI}$$\n\nno benefit. So $I_{1}$ must be cascoded itself to keep\n$r_{oI}\\sim R_{o,cas}$ . Then telescopic / double cascode\n$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}(g_{m}r_{o}^{2}\\parallel g_{m}r_{o}^{2})$.\n\nWith body effect gain is divided by $1+\\eta$ where\n$\\eta = g_{mb}/g_{m}\\approx 0.2-0.3$.\n\n### 5. Frequency response\n\nTwo main poles:\n\n* Dominant pole at high $Z$ output:\n\n$$\\omega_{p,out}= \\frac{1}{R_{out}C_{L}}\\;,\\; C_{L}=C_{db2}+C_{gd2}+C_{oI}+C_{load}$$\n\n* Non dominant pole at low $Z$ node $X$:\n\n$$\\omega_{pX}\\approx \\frac{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}{C_{X}}$$\n\nBecause $g_{m2}/C_{X}\\gg 1/R_{out}C_{L}$ the cascode is\nessentially single-pole. Condition for good settling:\n\n$$\\omega_{pX}> 3\\omega_{u}\\approx 3g_{m1}/C_{L}$$\n\nTransfer function $\\approx$\n\n$$A_{v}(s)\\approx \\frac{A_{v0}}{(1+s/\\omega_{p,out})(1+s/\\omega_{pX})}$$\n\nplus RHP zero $\\approx g_{m2}/C_{gd2}$ very high.\n\nReverse isolation $S_{12}\\approx 0$ because $CG$\nshields $M_{1}$ from $v_{out}$ variations. $V_{DS1}$ almost\nconstant $\\to$ suppress channel length modulation on $M_{1}$.\n\n### 6. What it is good / bad for\n\nPro: very high DC gain without extra stage, high\noutput $R$, wide bandwidth for given gain, low\nMiller, good PSRR, good isolation.\n\nCon: limited output swing $\\approx V_{DD}-(V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}+V_{ovI})$,\nneeds extra bias $V_{b1}$, headroom stacking, not\nsuitable for low $V_{DD}$ without folding, body\neffect degrades $R_{out}$ if $n$-well not available.\n\nUsed as building block of telescopic op-amp,\nfolded-cascode op-amp, $LNA$ load, current mirror\nwith $> r_{o}$ accuracy.\n\n> With $V_{b1}$ AC ground and $I_{1}$ ideal the circuit\n> is a single-stage high-gain transconductance amplifier\n> $G_{m}=g_{m1}$ loaded by $R_{out}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$.\n\nIf you have a numerical $W/L$, $I_{1}$ and process\n$g_{m},r_{o}$ the formulas above give quantitative\n$A_{v}, R_{out}, \\omega_{p}$ directly.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a47d7a9b0b6b2558d81f90e29f50eb9ce4dd5cc1731179a102b1fad7d9d6207a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-source NMOS and M2 as the common-gate NMOS cascode, and gives the required gain relation and ideal-load expression. The full-credit rule applies.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "fa3ce3c10c3d0bf6258738fc6e9b064c896064cb851cd7f79a50e2fe2b3c822b",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1371,
        "output_tokens": 5980,
        "total_tokens": 7351,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3478,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1371,
        "output_tokens": 5980,
        "total_tokens": 7351,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3478,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-021-cascode-structure",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 21,
      "question": "Is the circuit shown in the figure a cascode structure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-021-cascode-structure/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the normal abuse of language {\\it yes}\nit is what every text book calls the {\\it telescopic}\n{\\rm CS}+{\\rm CG} {\\rm stack} and with the symbols as\nthey are {\\it normally} drawn it is what is normally called\nthe {\\rm NMOS} - or with $V_{DD}\\leftrightarrow 0$ the\n{\\rm PMOS} - telescopic cascode.  Pedantically as drawn\nin Fig.1 it is not.\n\n{\\it Topologically} $M_{1}$ is the ordinary transconductor,\n{\\rm C}{\\rm S}, stage\n\n$$v_{g1}=v_{in}\\;\\;\\;v_{s1}=0$$\n\nand $M_{2}$ is the ordinary current buffer, {\\rm C}{\\rm G},\nstage\n\n$$v_{g2}=V_{b1}={\\rm ac}\\;0\\;\\;v_{s2}=v_{d1}$$\n\nstacked on top of it on the same {\\rm dc} current\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{R_{D}}$$\n\nand loaded conventionally in $R_{D}$ to $V_{DD}$,\nFig.2.14 in Razavi.  In small signal\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx R_{D}\\parallel R_{cas}$$\n$$R_{cas}= r_{o1}+r_{o2}+g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}\n\\approx g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\tag{1}$$\nfor $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$, $r_{o1}\\ne r_{o2}$ in\ngeneral, with $r_{o2}$ the $r_{o}$ of the cascode\ndevice and $r_{o1}$ the $r_{o}$ of the ${\\rm CS}$\ndevice, so that for the ordinary $R_{D}\\gg R_{cas}$\nor $R_{D}\\sim R_{cas}$\n\n$$A_{v}={{v_{out}}\\over {v_{in}}}\\approx -g_{m1}R_{o}\n\\approx -g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\parallel R_{D} \\tag{2}$$\n\nwith the usual cascode advantages: $R_{o}$ $\\times\ng_{m}r_{o}$ over the simple ${\\rm CS}$ stage,\nMiller multiplication of $C_{gd1}$ divided by\n$\\approx g_{m2}r_{o2}$, greatly improved reverse\nisolation, {\\it etc.}  Any ${\\rm CS}\\rightarrow {\\rm\nCG}$ stack on the same bias current is normally\nreferred to, loosely, as {\\it a cascode}.\n\nIn the strict single well, single type, sense the\ncircuit as {\\it literally} drawn is a\ncomplementary, {\\rm CMOS}, or {\\it pseudo},\n{\\it folded} cascode.  With the conventional\n${\\rm NMOS}\\;{\\rm in}\\; \\to {\\rm channel}$,\n${\\rm PMOS}\\;{\\rm out}\\; \\leftarrow {\\rm channel}$\narrow convention the arrow is on the source.\n$M_{2}$ is drawn conventionally with the source,\nthe arrow, at the low, cascode, node.\n$M_{1}$ is drawn upside down, or as a ${\\rm PMOS}$,\nwith the source, the arrow, at the {\\it high},\ncascode, node, its drain at ground.  The two\nsources are commoned at the cascode node and the\ntwo drains are at $0$ and at $V_{out}$.  The\nconventional current can go ${\\rm D}\\to {\\rm S}$\nin $M_{2}$ and ${\\rm S}\\to {\\rm D}$ in $M_{1}$\n\n$$V_{DD}\\to R_{D}\\to {\\rm D_{2}}\\to {\\rm S_{2}}\n\\to {\\rm S_{1}}\\to {\\rm D_{1}}\\to 0$$\n\nso it does function, with $M_{1}$ a ${\\rm PMOS}$\n${\\rm CS}$ transconductor and $M_{2}$ an ${\\rm NMOS}$\n${\\rm CG}$ buffer, as a ${\\rm PMOS}$ input\ncomplementary cascode inverter with resistive load.\nIt has (1)-(2) {\\it mutatis mutandis} but it is not\nthe conventional $n{\\rm MOS}+n{\\rm MOS}$ or\n$p{\\rm MOS}+p{\\rm MOS}$ cascode with\n${\\rm D_{1}}={\\rm S_{2}}$, ${\\rm S_{1}}=0$,\n${\\rm B_{1}}=0$, ${\\rm B_{2}}=0$ or\n${\\rm B_{2}}={\\rm S_{2}}$, Fig.1b.  Put $M_{1}$\nthe right way up, arrow, source, at ground,\ndrain at the cascode node, $B_{1}=0$, $B_{2}=S_{2}$\nin twin well, and it is the text book $n{\\rm MOS}$\nor $p{\\rm MOS}$ telescopic cascode {\\it sensu\nstrictu.}\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In normal ${\\rm CMOS}$ the $n{\\rm MOS}$\n> $B=p{\\rm -sub}=0$ so $M_{2}$ with $B_{2}=S_{2}\\ne 0$\n> needs a triple well.  $M_{1}$ as drawn with\n> $B_{1}=D_{1}$ has $V_{BS1}\\ne 0$ and suffers full\n> body effect.  Interchanging nominal source and drain\n> on a ${\\rm MOS}$ transistor is of course immaterial\n> to first order - the more negative, $n{\\rm MOS}$,\n> or more positive, $p{\\rm MOS}$, terminal {\\it is}\n> the source - so the circuit will normally be\n> re-drawn with $M_{1}$ source at ground.\n\nIn loose parlance it is universally called\n{\\it the cascode}.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c68fb7274702b040bfe471ade7df2f1182d59d1362d3fb81e36ef2018e86dd79"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The answer ultimately calls the circuit a cascode and treats M1 as a common-source transconductor. As drawn, M1 is a PMOS source follower, so the structure lacks cascode resistance boosting.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "7f9e0f88c009a8a25ec2184287032d702e4ac63736a803d1b8f3b4092778054c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1474,
        "output_tokens": 10969,
        "total_tokens": 12443,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9668,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1474,
        "output_tokens": 10969,
        "total_tokens": 12443,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9668,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-021-cascode-structure",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 21,
      "question": "Is the circuit shown in the figure a cascode structure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-021-cascode-structure/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the 4 terminal device it is, with the 3\nterminal device as drawn it is {\\it not}.\n\nIt is normally {\\it illustrated} as\n\n> {\\it the $n$ - channel resistively loaded\n> telescopic {\\rm ``}cascode{\\rm ''} - a $CS$ device\n> casoded by a $CG$ device}\n\nin the form\n\n$${\\rm V}_{DD}-R_{D}-D_{2}\\equiv M_{2}\\equiv\nS_{2}-D_{1}\\equiv M_{1}\\equiv S_{1}-{\\rm GND}\\tag*{$R_{D}\\ne \\infty$}$$\n\nwith\n\n* $M_{1}$ the $g_{m1}$ common {\\it source},\n  $v_{i}\\equiv V_{in}$ on $G_{1}$, $S_{1}$ $ac$\n  ground\n* $M_{2}$ the $g_{m2}$ common {\\it gate},\n  $G_{2}\\equiv V_{b1}$ $ac$ ground, $D_{2}\\equiv\n  V_{out}$ on $R_{D}$\n* $I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{R_{D}}$\n\nand, body to {\\it ground} for $n{\\rm MOS}$,\nnormally\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nR_{o}&\\approx \\left[1+g_{m2}r_{o2}\\right]r_{o1}+r_{o2}\\cr\nA_{v}&\\approx -g_{m1}\\left[R_{D}\\parallel R_{o}\\right]\n\\approx -g_{m1}R_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;R_{D}\\ll R_{o}\\cr}$$\n\nand normally quoted as the textbook {\\it cascode}\nin e. {\\rm g.} Razavi Ch. 3.\n\nAs {\\it literally} drawn with the conventional\n3 terminal, body tied to source, symbology that\nis a {\\it complementary} $CD-CG$ stack.\n\n* with the ${\\rm IEEE}$ arrow convention $M_{2}$\n  is $n$ channel, source $\\equiv S_{2}$ is the\n  lower, arrowed, terminal, body $\\equiv S_{2}$,\n* $M_{1}$ is $p$ channel, or $n$ channel upside\n  down, source $\\equiv S_{1}$ is the {\\it upper},\n  arrowed, terminal, body $\\equiv S_{1}$,\n\nso that, small signal,\n\n* $M_{1}$ : $G_{1}\\equiv V_{in}$, $D_{1}\\equiv\n  {\\rm GND}$ $ac$ ground, $S_{1}\\equiv S_{2}$,\n  {\\it i. e.} a common {\\it drain}, source follower\n  and\n* $M_{2}$ : $G_{2}\\equiv V_{b1}$ $ac$ ground,\n  $S_{2}\\equiv S_{1}$, $D_{2}\\equiv V_{out}$,\n  {\\it i. e.} a conventional common {\\it gate}\n\nwith a common current\n\n$$I_{S1}=I_{S2}=I_{R_{D}}\\;\\;{\\rm top\\;to\\;bottom}$$\n\nIt is a $p$ on $n$, {\\it pseudo, complementary,\ninverted,} cascode, a $CMOS$ inverter with a\nresistive pull up, sometimes loosely called a\n{\\it folded} cascode. In the conventional $n$ on\n$n$ or $p$ on $p$ nomenclature it is {\\it not}\na cascode in the sense $R_{o}\\propto g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$.\nE. {\\rm g.} with $g_{m1}=g_{m2}$\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\parallel R_{D}\n\\qquad A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}\\left[r_{o1}\\parallel\nr_{o2}\\parallel R_{D}\\right]$$\n\nPut the arrow, {\\it i. e.} the body tie, of $M_{1}$\non the lower, grounded, terminal and tie the\nbodies to ${\\rm GND}$, ${\\rm V}_{DD}$, in the 4\nterminal version, and you get the conventional\n$n{\\rm MOS}$ - $n{\\rm MOS}$ telescopic cascode\nnormally denoted by that figure. In that loose\n{\\it ideal device} sense the figure is normally\nreferred to simply as {\\it the cascode.}\n\n> {\\it Remark:} A lot of text books are very sloppy\n> about the 3 versus 4 terminal symbology and show\n> Fig.1 as {\\it the} $NMOS$ cascode.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c62a3367ce055659079d54b5fd3e1aef155106b64c0e511dd96f5d8bb2922b4e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly says the circuit as drawn is not a cascode and identifies grounded-drain PMOS M1 as a source follower feeding M2’s common-gate stage, so it lacks cascode resistance boosting. The optional resistance and gain estimates are inaccurate, but do not change the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "7f9e0f88c009a8a25ec2184287032d702e4ac63736a803d1b8f3b4092778054c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1474,
        "output_tokens": 8387,
        "total_tokens": 9861,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7164,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1474,
        "output_tokens": 8387,
        "total_tokens": 9861,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7164,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-021-cascode-structure",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 21,
      "question": "Is the circuit shown in the figure a cascode structure?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-021-cascode-structure/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the loose textbook sense {\\it yes}\nin the strict $3/4\\,T$ symbol sense {\\it no}.\nIt is the block diagram that every body calls\n\n$${\\rm CS}\\left[M_{1}\\right]+ {\\rm CG}\\left[M_{2}\\right]$$\n\n{\\it telescopic} {\\it cascode} with $I_{D1}=I_{D2}$,\nfig. $3.12$ in Razavi.\n\n> {\\it NB:} As it is normally drawn in a CMOS technology\n> the two devices are the same polarity.\n\nWith the conventional $4\\,T$ symbology the NMOS\nconventional cascode is\n\n```\n            VDD\n             |\n             RD\n             |\n             D   G=Vb1\n            M2  CG \n             S\n             D\n            M1  CS G=Vin\n             S\n            GND n bulk GND\n```\n\ni. e. the {\\it drain} of the $g_{m}$ device $M_{1}$ goes to\nthe {\\it source} of the $g_{m}r_{o}$ device $M_{2}$.\nPut $M_{2}$ in saturation by $V_{b1}$ and you get\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}\\left[R_{D}\\parallel R_{o}\\right]$$\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx g_{m2}r_{o2}r_{o1}\\;\\;,\n\\;\\;r_{o}^{-1}=g_{ds}$$\n\nin the conventional small signal reduction of the\nMiller effect, $C_{gd1}$ sees $1/g_{m2}$ at the\nintermediate node, etc.\n\nTaken {\\it literally} as you have drawn it with the\n$3\\,T$ ${\\rm arrow}={\\rm source}$ convention you\nhave drawn a complementary or pseudo cascode, Fig.1b\n\n* $M_{2}$: arrow at the lower terminal $=$ source\nat the interstage node $V_{X}$ to $M_{1}$, conventional\nNMOS CG, $D=V_{out}$.\n\n* $M_{1}$: arrow at the {\\it upper} terminal $=$ source\nat $V_{X}$, drain $=$ {\\sc gnd}.  I. e. with the normal\n$\\{{\\rm arrow\\;in}=n\\}\\{{\\rm arrow\\;out}=p\\}$ convention\na $p$ device or, if you want to keep it $n$, the device\nis upside down, {\\it source follower} $-$ {\\it common\ngate} source to source connection, not drain to source.\n\nIn conventional CMOS you would call that a\nCMOS inverter stack, a complementary cascode,\na source to source pseudo cascode, {\\it etc.},\nnormally unusable as a linear amplifier with the\nbulks strapped to $V_{X}$ because at least one\nbulk diode is forward biased and you get full body\neffect on $M_{1}$.  Turn $M_{1}$ upside down,\nput the arrow on the {\\sc gnd} side, body to {\\sc gnd},\n$M_{2}$ body to {\\sc gnd}, both $n$ - or both $p$\nto $V_{DD}$ - and you get the conventional integrated\ncascode normally meant.  In that normal form it is\nproperly called the common source cascode.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In many text books the bulk connection\n> is simply omitted and the circuit of Fig.1 is loosely,\n> and with that omission correctly, called {\\it the}\n> cascode.\n\nWith the bulk correctly shown the NMOS cascode is\n\n* $M_{1}$ $n$, $S=$ {\\sc gnd}, $D=V_{X}$, $B=${\\sc gnd}\n* $M_{2}$ $n$, $S=V_{X}$, $D=V_{out}$, $B=${\\sc gnd}\n\nand the PMOS cascode is the dual.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5b7cb47b2599fc79aa014a16361b43749df59f4c999b4d6585b4e97941633b81"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It explicitly answers “yes” in the loose sense and calls the circuit a telescopic cascode, contradicting the required conclusion. Although it later correctly identifies M1 as a source follower, that does not undo the affirmative classification.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "7f9e0f88c009a8a25ec2184287032d702e4ac63736a803d1b8f3b4092778054c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1474,
        "output_tokens": 7556,
        "total_tokens": 9030,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6493,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1379,
        "input_tokens": 1474,
        "output_tokens": 7556,
        "total_tokens": 9030,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6493,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-022-explain-why-miller-effect-less-pronounced-cascode",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 22,
      "question": "Explain why the Miller effect is less pronounced in a cascode.",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In a simple inverting amplifier the Miller effect is large because the feedback capacitance sees the full voltage gain. The `cascode` breaks that condition.\n\n### 1. Recall: Miller Multiplication\n\nFor any impedance $Z_f$ connected between input and output of an inverting amplifier with voltage gain $A_v = V_o/V_i < 0$:\n\nBy Miller's Theorem, seen from the input it looks like:\n\n$$Z_{in,Miller} = \\frac{Z_f}{1-A_v} \\approx \\frac{Z_f}{|A_v|}$$\n\nFor a capacitance $C_f$:\n\n$$C_{M} = C_f(1-A_v) = C_f(1+|A_v|)$$\n\nIn a Common Source/Emitter amplifier $C_f = C_{gd} / C_{\\mu}$ between gate/base and drain/collector.\n\nWith a normal CS stage:\n\n$$A_v = -g_m R_D' = -g_m (r_o || R_D)$$\n\ntypically $-20$ to $-100$.\n\nSo\n\n$$C_{in} \\approx C_{gs} + C_{gd}(1+g_m R_D')$$\n\nIf $C_{gd}= 50fF$ and $|A_v|=50$, you see $2.5pF$ at the input. That with source resistance $R_{sig}$ creates a low frequency input pole:\n\n$$f_{p,in} \\approx \\frac{1}{2\\pi R_{sig} C_{in}}$$\n\nThis dominates and limits bandwidth. It also causes pole splitting - input pole moves down, output pole moves up.\n\nThe Miller effect requires **large voltage swing across $C_f$**.\n\n### 2. Cascode Topology\n\nA cascode is a Common Source - Common Gate stack, or Common Emitter - Common Base stack:\n\n```\n           Vout\n            |\n           (D2)\n      G2 ___|___ AC ground\n            |\n           (S2/D1)  <- intermediate node X, low swing\n            |\n           (D1)\n            |\n           (S1)\n            |\n           Vin -> G1\n```\n\n$M1$ is the input CS device, $M2$ is the CG device with its gate at AC ground. The load $R_D$ is now at the drain of $M2$, not $M1$.\n\nTotal gain is still high:\n\n$$A_{v,tot} = -g_{m1} (g_{m2} r_{o2} r_{o1} || R_D) \\approx -g_{m1} R_{out}$$\n\nBut $C_{gd1}$ does **not** see $A_{v,tot}$. It only sees the *local* gain of stage 1, $A_{v1}=V_x/V_i$.\n\n### 3. Why $A_{v1}$ is $\\approx -1$\n\nThe load seen by $M1$ is not $R_D$, but the input impedance of a common-gate stage looking into its source:\n\n$$R_{in2} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}} || r_{o2} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nThis is very low, $\\sim 100-1000$ ohms.\n\nTherefore:\n\n$$A_{v1} = -g_{m1} (r_{o1} || R_{in2}) \\approx -g_{m1} \\cdot \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nIf $M1$ and $M2$ have similar bias current and size, $g_{m1}\\approx g_{m2}$ so:\n\n$$A_{v1} \\approx -1$$\n\nNow apply Miller to $C_{gd1}$:\n\n$$C_{M1} = C_{gd1}(1 - A_{v1}) \\approx C_{gd1}(1 - (-1)) = 2 C_{gd1}$$\n\nInstead of $50 \\times C_{gd1}$, you get $2 \\times C_{gd1}$. The input capacitance becomes:\n\n$$C_{in,cascode} \\approx C_{gs1} + 2C_{gd1} << C_{gs1} + (1+g_m R_D)C_{gd1}$$\n\n> Physically: The drain of $M1$, node X, is held almost constant in voltage by the low impedance source of $M2$ acting as a current buffer. Since $V_x$ hardly moves, there is almost no voltage swing across $C_{gd1}$, so almost no displacement current is pulled through it from the input. No large Miller current = no large Miller capacitance.\n\nWhat about $C_{gd2}$ of the cascode device?\n\nIt is connected between $V_{out}$ and AC ground (gate of $M2$). Both terminals: one is ground, so $K = V_o/V_{g2}=0$. There is **no Miller multiplication at all**.\n\n$$C_{gd2} \\text{ appears un-multiplied at the output node as } C_{gd2}$$\n\nIt just adds to the total output capacitance $C_L'$ along with $C_{db}$.\n\n### 4. Consequence\n\nThe cascode breaks the gain-bandwidth trade-off of a single stage:\n\n* Single stage: High gain $\\implies$ large Miller $\\implies$ low $f_{p,in}$\n* Cascode: High total gain $A_{v,tot}$ kept, but input Miller factor is decoupled from total gain and kept $\\sim 2$.\n\nThe dominant pole is now usually at the output:\n\n$$f_{p,out} \\approx \\frac{1}{2\\pi R_{out} C_{out}}$$\n\nAnd a second non-dominant pole appears at the intermediate node X:\n\n$$f_{p,x} \\approx \\frac{g_{m2}}{2\\pi (C_{gs2}+C_{sb2}+C_{gd1}+C_{db1})}$$\n\nwhich is very high because $g_{m2}$ is large and capacitance is small. The input pole is pushed up by ~ $|A_v|/2$ times.\n\nThis gives much wider bandwidth, better reverse isolation $S_{12}$, and better stability. This is why almost all wideband, RF, and high-gain op-amp stages use a cascode/telescopic/folded-cascode.\n\nIn short: **The Miller effect needs inverting voltage gain across the capacitor. The cascode gives the input device a low-impedance load so it has $\\sim$ unity gain, so its $C_{gd}$ is not multiplied, while the high-gain device has no feedback capacitor to the input.**",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0a58612c572ac91b0d20ef62a9c66fc06d9cbd6f3f931d5e8db9973df44266eb"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the low-impedance common-gate source load, the local gain across M1’s Cgd as roughly −1, and the resulting Miller factor of about 2 rather than the full-stage gain. Its wording that the intermediate node hardly moves and Cgd is nearly unmultiplied overstates the reduction, but the answer gives the correct factor; the golden solution treats this overstatement as a minor flaw.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0d298300029d3b4545999675d8ec4b4c83532fca89fa9878f9898848f75f534f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 21,
        "output_tokens": 3339,
        "total_tokens": 3360,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1883,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 21,
        "output_tokens": 3339,
        "total_tokens": 3360,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 1883,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-022-explain-why-miller-effect-less-pronounced-cascode",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 22,
      "question": "Explain why the Miller effect is less pronounced in a cascode.",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In a Common Source/Emitter `CS/CE` the `Cgd/Cbc` is a ***Miller* capacitance** - not less pronounced, it is multiplied.\n\nBy Miller's theorem a capacitor $C$ connected between input and output\n\n$$Z_M = \\frac{Z}{1-A_v}$$\n\nFor a capacitor $C_{gd}$ between gate and drain with voltage gain $A_v = v_d/v_g <0$:\n\n$$C_{M,input} = C_{gd}(1-A_v) = C_{gd}(1+|A_v|)$$\n$$C_{M,output} = C_{gd}(1-1/A_v) \\approx C_{gd}$$\n\nIn a normal CS/CE with resistive/active load $R_D$:\n\n$$A_v = -g_m R_D \\approx -g_m r_o >> 1$$\n\ne.g. 20 to 100.\n\n$$C_{in} = C_{gs} + C_{gd}(1+g_m R_D)$$\n\nYou may have $2-100\\times C_{gd}$ at the input. That large $C_{in}$ with the source resistance $R_{sig}$ creates the dominant low frequency pole:\n\n$$\\omega_{p,in} \\approx \\frac{1}{R_{sig} C_{in}}$$\n\nand kills bandwidth. This is the Miller effect. It requires two things: 1) A capacitor bridging input-output and 2) Large *inverting* voltage gain across it.\n\nA cascode destroys 2.\n\n### Cascode = CS driving CG\n\n```\nVout\n |\n D2\n G2 --- AC GND\n S2 --- D1  <- internal node X\n        G1 --- Vin\n        S1 --- GND\n```\n\n$Q1/M1$ is CS, $Q2/M2$ is Common Gate/Base with gate/base at AC ground.\n\nConsider the Miller capacitance that matters: $C_{gd1}$ of the *input* device $M1$, between $Vin = v_{g1}$ and $v_x = v_{d1} = v_{s2}$.\n\nIts Miller multiplication is $1-A_{v1}$ where\n\n$$A_{v1} = \\frac{v_x}{v_{g1}}$$\n\nis the gain of $M1$ *alone*, not the gain of the whole amplifier.\n\nWhat load does $M1$ see? Not $R_D$, but the impedance looking into the source of a CG stage with gate grounded.\n\n$$R_{in2} = \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}} \\parallel r_{o2} // R_D \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nif $R_D$ is not extremely large. On the order of $50-500\\ \\Omega$, not $k\\Omega$.\n\nSo\n\n$$A_{v1} = -g_{m1} \\cdot (r_{o1} \\parallel R_{in2}) \\approx -g_{m1} \\frac{1}{g_{m2}} \\approx -1$$\n\nif $g_{m1} \\approx g_{m2}$.\n\nMore exactly with $r_o$:\n\n$$A_{v1} \\approx \\frac{-g_{m1}}{g_{m2}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}} \\approx -0.5 \\text{ to } -2$$\n\nTherefore\n\n$$C_{M1} = C_{gd1}(1-A_{v1}) \\approx C_{gd1}(1-(-1)) = 2 C_{gd1}$$\n\nInstead of $C_{gd1}(1+g_m R_D) \\approx 50-100\\,C_{gd1}$.\n\nThe input capacitance becomes:\n\n$$C_{in,cascode} \\approx C_{gs1} + 2 C_{gd1} \\ll C_{gs1}+g_m R_D C_{gd1} = C_{in,CS}$$\n\nReduction by factor $\\approx g_m R_D /2$.\n\nIntuitively: Miller multiplication is charge. $i = C\\, d(V_g-V_d)/dt$. If $V_d$ moves opposite and much more than $V_g$, you need much more charge from the input to charge $C_{gd}$. In a CS, $V_d = -g_m R_D V_g$ swings wildly. In a cascode, node $X$ barely moves - the CG transistor holds the drain of $M1$ almost constant because its source is low impedance. Little $\\Delta V$ across $C_{gd1}$, little extra current, little extra capacitance.\n\nWhat about the overall gain?\n\n$$A_{v2} = \\frac{v_{out}}{v_x} \\approx g_{m2} R_{out}$$\n\nwhere $R_{out} \\approx g_{m2} r_{o2} r_{o1} \\parallel R_D$ is very high.\n\n$$A_{v,tot} = A_{v1} \\times A_{v2} \\approx -g_{m1} R_{out}$$\n\nYou still get the full high gain $g_m R_{out}$, but the large gain is now developed in the CG stage where $C_{gd2}$ is connected between AC ground and output. $A_v$ for that capacitor is $0$ to output, so there is no Miller multiplication:\n\n$$C_{gd2} \\text{ sees } v_{g2}=0 \\to \\text{ no } (1-A_v) \\text{, just } C_{gd2} \\text{ to ground at output.}$$\n\nAnd there is no capacitor directly bridging $Vin$ at $G1$ to $Vout$ at $D2$. The feedback path is broken. The CG device acts as an electrostatic shield.\n\nResult: The input pole $\\omega_{p,in}=1/R_{sig}C_{in}$ moves up by $10-50\\times$, the so called pole-splitting of the CS disappears, bandwidth is greatly extended. This is why the cascode is often called a Miller killer.\n\nIdeal cascode with $g_{m2} \\to \\infty$: $R_{in2} \\to 0, A_{v1} \\to 0, C_{M1} \\to C_{gd1}$ - Miller effect completely eliminated. In practice $\\approx 2 C_{gd1}$ remains.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6b46f8bce0b6fc8c082c5473631d3059782d7291a54c0dc11718d5893f38d7fd"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the low-impedance cascode node and the roughly −1 gain across M1’s Cgd, giving about 2× rather than full-stage-gain Miller multiplication. The claim of “little ΔV across Cgd1” overstates the effect, but the answer also gives the correct practical factor, and this is only a minor flaw.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0d298300029d3b4545999675d8ec4b4c83532fca89fa9878f9898848f75f534f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 21,
        "output_tokens": 3420,
        "total_tokens": 3441,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2073,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 21,
        "output_tokens": 3420,
        "total_tokens": 3441,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2073,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-022-explain-why-miller-effect-less-pronounced-cascode",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 22,
      "question": "Explain why the Miller effect is less pronounced in a cascode.",
      "figures": [],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In a single device the inverting voltage gain multiplies a feedback $C$ into a large input $C$. The cascode removes the large gain from the device that has the $C$ across it.\n\nRecall Miller's Theorem: An impedance $Z$ bridging input and output nodes with voltage gain $A_v = V_2/V_1$ can be split into\n\n$$Z_1 = \\frac{Z}{1-A_v} \\;\\; \\text{to ground at input}$$\n$$Z_2 = \\frac{Z}{1-1/A_v} \\;\\; \\text{to ground at output}$$\n\nFor a capacitor $Z=1/sC$ this is a capacitance multiplication:\n\n$$C_M = C(1-A_v)$$\n\nFor an inverting amplifier $A_v = -|A_v|$:\n\n$$C_{M,in} = C(1+|A_v|)$$\n\n$$C_{M,out} = C(1+1/|A_v|) \\approx C$$\n\n### 1. Common Source/Emitter alone\n\nHigh frequency model: $C_{gd}$ or $C_{\\mu}$ bridges gate/base = input and drain/collector = output. $C_{gs}$ or $C_{\\pi}$ is already input to ground.\n\n$$ C_{in} = C_{gs} + C_{gd}(1-A_v) = C_{gs} + C_{gd}(1+g_m R_D)$$\n\nwhere $A_v = -g_m R_D$ is the low frequency voltage gain, typically 10 to 100.\n\nE.g. $g_m R_D = 50 \\rightarrow C_{in} = C_{gs} + 51 C_{gd}$\n\nThis huge $C_{in}$ with source resistance $R_{sig}$ creates the dominant low frequency input pole:\n\n$$\\omega_{p,in} \\approx \\frac{1}{R_{sig} C_{in}} = \\frac{1}{R_{sig}[C_{gs}+C_{gd}(1+g_m R_D)]}$$\n\nBandwith is severely limited. Physically a large inverted swing at the drain pulls a large displacement current $I = C_{gd} d(V_g - V_d)/dt \\approx C_{gd}(1+|A_v|) dV_g/dt$ through $C_{gd}$.\n\n### 2. Cascode - CS driving CG, CE driving CB\n\n```\n         VDD\n          |\n          RD\n          |\nVin -G1  D2 - Vout  High gain node\n     S1--D1\n     |   S2\n     |   G2--- AC GND\n    GND\n```\nQ1 is Common-Source, Q2 is Common-Gate with gate at AC ground.\n\nConsider them separately.\n\n**a) Q1 - The device that suffers Miller effect**\n\nQ1 does NOT see $R_D$ as its load. It sees the input impedance looking into the source of Q2.\n\nFor a common-gate stage:\n\n$$R_{in2} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}} \\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}$$\n\nvery low, typically 50-500 ohms.\n\nSo the voltage gain of the Q1 stage alone is:\n\n$$A_{v1}= \\frac{V_{d1}}{V_{g1}} = -g_{m1} R_{in2} = -\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}} \\approx -1$$\n\nif devices are sized similarly. With body effect, $\\approx -0.5$ to $-1$.\n\nTherefore Miller multiplication for $C_{gd1}$ is:\n\n$$C_{M1} = C_{gd1}(1-A_{v1}) = C_{gd1}\\left(1+\\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m2}}\\right) \\approx 2 C_{gd1}$$\n\ninstead of $C_{gd1}(1+g_m R_D)$.\n\nIf $g_m R_D = 50$, you have reduced the Miller capacitance from $51 C_{gd}$ to $\\sim 2 C_{gd}$, a factor of 25x. The input pole moves up by the same factor:\n\n$$\\omega_{p,in,cascode} \\approx \\frac{1}{R_{sig}[C_{gs1}+2C_{gd1}]}$$\n\nPhysically: The drain of Q1 is pinned by the low impedance source of Q2. It cannot swing much. Therefore $V_{g1} - V_{d1} \\approx V_{g1}$, there is very little extra voltage to drive current through $C_{gd1}$. The feedback is effectively killed. Q2 acts as a current buffer and voltage shield.\n\n**b) Q2 - The device that provides the gain**\n\nQ2 provides the large voltage gain:\n\n$$A_{v2} = g_{m2} R_D \\;\\; \\text{and}\\;\\; A_{v,tot}= A_{v1}A_{v2} \\approx -g_{m1} R_D$$\n\nSo the circuit still has high overall gain.\n\nBut Q2 has no Miller effect. Its $C_{gd2}$ is between drain = output and gate = AC ground. It is just a capacitor to ground at the output, $C_{M,out}\\approx C_{gd2}$. Its $C_{gs2}$ is between source = low impedance node and gate = ground. It loads the intermediate node, not the input. There is no capacitance bridging input and output of an inverting amplifier to be Miller multiplied.\n\n> The overall gain $-g_{m1}R_D$ is split into a low-gain stage where Miller $C$ exists but not multiplied, and a high-gain stage where Miller $C$ does not exist.\n\nThat is why the triode was replaced by the tetrode/pentode and why RF amplifiers are almost always cascodes.\n\nThe bandwidth limitation is now the poles at the intermediate node $ \\omega_{pX} \\approx g_{m2}/C_X$ where $C_X = C_{gd1}+C_{gs2}+C_{sb2}+C_{db1}$ and at the output $\\omega_{p,out} \\approx 1/R_D C_{out}$. Both are at much higher frequency than the Miller input pole of the single device, and can be made similar for maximal flat bandwidth.\n\nIn short: **Cascode does not eliminate Miller capacitance, it eliminates Miller multiplication by giving the input device a low impedance load so $1-A_{v1} \\approx 2$ instead of $1+g_m R_D$.**",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a3f4b77788b9b1977db9c31cc4c545ae14b058e9e31c2f443302b076270541bf"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the low-impedance cascode node and the roughly −1 gain across the input transistor’s Cgd, giving about 2× Miller multiplication rather than multiplication by the full stage gain. It also says the effect is reduced, not eliminated. Some wording overstates how little the node swings, but the core explanation and quantitative result are correct.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "0d298300029d3b4545999675d8ec4b4c83532fca89fa9878f9898848f75f534f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 21,
        "output_tokens": 3545,
        "total_tokens": 3566,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2105,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 21,
        "output_tokens": 3545,
        "total_tokens": 3566,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2105,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 23,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a ${\\rm grounded~gate}\\approx{\\rm common~gate}\n\\approx {\\rm current~buffer}$ with active load. In\nmost technologies\n\n> $$M_{1}={\\rm P~currents~source} \\qquad M_{2}={\\rm N~CG~device}$$\n> $$Vb_{2}=V_{SG1,DC}\\qquad Vb_{1}=V_{GS2,DC}+V_{in,DC}$$\n\nwith $M_{2}$ normally laid out with $B_{2}\\equiv S_{2}\\equiv V_{in}$\nin the figure so that $g_{mb2}\\approx 0$.\nIf the symbol is taken literally as $2\\times {\\rm P}$ the\ndescription is the same with $p\\leftrightarrow n$ and a\nd.c. path $V_{DD}\\to M_{1}\\to M_{2}\\to R_{sig}\\to {\\rm GND}$\nthrough the signal source. The complementary case\n$P$ on top of $N$ is the normal one. With \n$g_{di}=g_{dsi}=1/r_{oi}=\\lambda _{i}I_{D}$.\n\n{\\rm DC:} in saturation long channel\n\n$$I_{D1}= {k_{p}\\over 2}{W_{1}\\over L_{1}}{(V_{DD}-Vb_{2}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}}\n(1+\\lambda _{p}(V_{DD}-V_{out}))$$\n\n$$I_{D2}= {k_{n}\\over 2}{W_{2}\\over L_{2}}{(Vb_{1}-V_{in}-V_{Tn})^{2}}\n(1+\\lambda _{n}(V_{out}-V_{in}))$$\n\nand for the series connection with no other d.c. load\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{D}\\tag{1}$$\n\nat the $Q$ point. So $Vb_{2}$ fixes $I_{D}$ and, with\n$V_{in,DC}$ given, $Vb_{1}$ must be\n\n$$Vb_{1}=V_{in,DC}+V_{Tn}+\\sqrt{2I_{D}/k_{n}(W/L)_{2}}$$\n\nSaturation requires\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{out}-V_{in} &> Vb_{1}-V_{in}-V_{Tn}=V_{ov2}\\cr\nV_{DD}-V_{out} &> V_{DD}-Vb_{2}-|V_{Tp}|=|V_{ov1}|}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$Vb_{1}-V_{Tn}<V_{out}<V_{DD}-|V_{ov1}|$$\n\nso headroom is $V_{DD}>V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}+V_{in,DC}$ plus\nsignal swing. $V_{in,DC}$ must be low enough to keep\n$M_{2}$ on: $Vb_{1}-V_{in}>V_{Tn}$ and high enough to keep\n$M_{1}$ saturated. The small signal current must be\nsunk/sourced by the source resistance $R_{sig}$ of the\n$V_{in}$ generator. I. e. $R_{sig}$ is the d.c. path to\nground. On large signal with $V_{in}\\uparrow $,\n\n$$V_{GS2}=Vb_{1}-V_{in}\\downarrow \\;\\;,\\;I_{D2}\\downarrow$$\n\n$M_{1}$ wants to keep $I_{D1}\\approx I_{B}$. $V_{out}$\nmust rise to reduce $I_{D1}$ through $\\lambda _{p}$ and\nto increase $I_{D2}$ through $\\lambda _{n}$ until (1) is\nagain satisfied. So\n\n$${{dV_{out}}\\over {dV_{in}}}>0$$\n\nnon-inverting. Large signal:\n\n$$V_{out}\\approx V_{DD}- {\\rm solution~of~}I_{D1}(V_{out})=\nI_{D2}(V_{in},V_{out})$$\n\nquasi quadratic.\n\n{\\rm Small signal:} $Vb_{1},Vb_{2}$ ac ground, $R_{L}$\nac load to ground at $V_{out}$ including $C_{L}$.\n\nHybrid $\\pi$ for $M_{2}$: $v_{gs2}= -v_{in}$ for\n$R_{sig}=0$, $v_{bs2}= -v_{in}$ with body to GND,\n$0$ with body to $S$, $v_{ds2}=v_{out}-v_{in}$.\n\nKCL at $V_{out}$:\n\n$$g_{ds1}v_{out}+g_{ds2}(v_{out}-v_{in})+g_{m2}v_{gs2}\n+g_{mb2}v_{bs2}=0\\tag{2}$$\n\nWith $v_{gs2}=v_{bs2}=-v_{in}$ if $B\\to {\\rm GND}$,\n\n$$\\left(g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}\\right)v_{out}=\n\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}\\right)v_{in}$$\n\nso for $R_{sig}=0$, $R_{L}=\\infty $\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {{v_{out}}\\over {v_{in}}}=\n{{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\\over {g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}}\n\\approx {{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\\over {g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}}\n= \\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}\\right)r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}>0\n\\tag{3}$$\n\nWith $B_{2}=S_{2}$, $g_{mb2}=0$:\n\n$$A_{v0}\\approx g_{m2}\\,r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\parallel R_{L}$$\n\ntypical $20-40\\,{\\rm dB}$ single stage.\nWith finite $R_{sig}$ in series with $v_{in}$:\n\n$$A_{v}= {{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\\over {g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}}\n{1\\over {1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})R_{sig}}}\\approx\n{{r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}}\\over {R_{sig}+1/(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})}}$$\n\nThe familiar $g_{m}R_{D}$ form. No Miller multiplication\nof $C_{gd2}$ because gate is ac ground.\n\n{\\rm Input impedance:} put $v_{x}$ on source of $M_{2}$,\nground $V_{DD}$ ac, $R_{L}$ to ground at drain.\nFrom (2) with $v_{in}\\to v_{x}$, $v_{out}=v_{d}$,\n\n$$v_{d}=v_{x}{{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\\over {g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+G_{L}}}$$\n\n$$i_{x}= -\\left[g_{m2}(-v_{x})+g_{mb2}(-v_{x})+g_{ds2}(v_{d}-v_{x})\\right]$$\n\n$$i_{x}=v_{x}\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}\\right)\n- g_{ds2}v_{d}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nR_{in}&={{v_{x}}\\over {i_{x}}}=\n{{g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+G_{L}}\\over \n{(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2})g_{ds1}+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})G_{L}+g_{ds2}G_{L}}}\\cr\n&\\approx {1\\over {g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}}{{1+G_{L}/g_{ds2}}\\over \n{1+{g_{ds1}\\over g_{ds2}}{1\\over {1+g_{m2}/g_{ds2}}}+{G_{L}\\over g_{m2}}}}\\cr\n&\\to {1\\over {g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;g_{ds}r_{o}\\gg 1,\n\\;G_{L}\\ll g_{m} } \\tag{4}$$\n\nand $1/g_{m2}$ if $B=S$.\nE. g. $g_{m}=20\\,{\\rm mS}\\to 50\\,\\Omega$ for matched RF\nLNA. Low $Z_{in}$, current input.\n\nMore generally with $R_{sig}$ the impedance seen\n{\\it into} the source is (4) in parallel with $R_{sig}$.\n\n{\\rm Output impedance:} De-activate $v_{in}$, $v_{x}$ on\ndrain, $R_{sig}$ from source to ground.\n\n$$R_{out}=r_{o1}\\parallel R_{o,cg}$$\n\n$$R_{o,cg}=r_{o2}+R_{sig}+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}R_{sig}\n\\approx r_{o2}\\left[1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})R_{sig}\\right] \\tag{5}$$\n\nFor $R_{sig}=0$, $R_{out}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$ high\n$Z$ current output. For $R_{sig}=50\\,\\Omega$,\n$R_{out}\\approx r_{o1}\\parallel g_{m}r_{o2}R_{sig}\\gg r_{o}$.\n\nSo the stage is a {\\it current buffer}: $i_{in}\\approx\n-i_{d2}\\approx -i_{out}$ with current gain $\\approx 1$,\ntransimpedance $\\approx r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$, voltage\ngain as above.\n\n{\\rm Frequency:} Input pole\n\n$$\\omega_{p,in}\\approx {{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\\over {C_{gs2}+C_{sb2}+C_{p,in}}}$$\n\nvery high because $R_{in}$ small. Output dominant pole\n\n$$\\omega_{p,out}\\approx {1\\over {(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\parallel R_{L})C_{L}}}$$\n\nwith $C_{L}=C_{db1}+C_{db2}+C_{gd2}+C_{L,ext}$.\nZero due to $C_{gd2}$ feedforward. No Miller effect.\nHence wide band, good for GHz LNA, $f_{T}$ limited by\n$p_{in}$.\n\n{\\rm Properties:}\n\n* non-inverting $A_{v}>0$\n* low $R_{in}\\approx 1/g_{m}$, high $R_{out}$\n* moderate $A_{v}=g_{m}r_{o}$\n* excellent reverse isolation, $y_{12}\\approx 0$, unconditionally stable\n* low Miller $C$, wideband\n* noise figure $F\\approx 1+\\gamma g_{m2}R_{sig}+...$,\n  $\\gamma\\approx 2/3$ long channel, requires\n  $g_{m}R_{sig}\\approx 1$ for match so $F\\ge 3\\,{\\rm dB}$\n  in simple form, can be improved with inductive\n  degeneration, etc.\n* suffers body effect if $B\\neq S$, $R_{in}\\downarrow$,\n  $A_{v}\\downarrow$ by $g_{mb}/g_{m}$.\n\n{\\rm Application:} Tuned or wideband LNA with $50\\,\\Omega$\nantenna matching, current buffer in cascode/telescopic\nop-amp, impedance translator, level shifter, wideband\nIF stage. Often followed by common source to make\ncascode for higher gain and isolation.\n\nIn short, for $B_{2}=S_{2}$:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx +g_{m2}(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\parallel R_{L}),\\;\nR_{in}\\approx 1/g_{m2},\\;\nR_{out}\\approx r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\;{\\rm for}\\;R_{sig}=0$$\n\nwith $g_{mb}$ correction $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$ if body\nis grounded.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "7cb1baa47d0266ff324fd29a0233fc731496ecf5849a76e3622773f81fdaa079"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-gate NMOS with PMOS current-source load, places Vin at M2’s source, and gives the non-inverting gain and low input resistance. Its gain expression is equivalent to gm2(ro1 || ro2); the extra impedance and body-effect details are not needed for full credit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "bef1a8379b057bee5021488ff4aa65884dec1cb905b95a6d1d764f0128473407",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1289,
        "output_tokens": 14078,
        "total_tokens": 15367,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11180,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1289,
        "output_tokens": 14078,
        "total_tokens": 15367,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11180,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 23,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the {\\rm common gate} with active\nload, the building block of the cascode, telescopic and\nfolded cascode OPAMP and of the ${\\rm CG}-{\\rm LNA}$.\nWith the usual convention\n\n$$M_{1}-P{\\rm MOS}\\;\\;{\\rm load}, S_{1}=V_{DD}\n\\;{\\rm ac\\;gnd},\\;\\;G_{1}=V_{b2}\\;{\\rm ac\\;gnd}$$\n\n$$M_{2}-{\\rm N\\-MOS}\\;\\;{\\rm CG\\;device},\\;\\;\nD_{2}=V_{out},\\;\\;S_{2}=V_{in},\\;\\;G_{2}=V_{b1}\n\\;{\\rm ac\\;gnd}$$\n\nIn the drawing the bulk of $M_{2}$ is drawn tied to\n$S_{2}$. If it is tied to the $P$ substrate $g_{mb2}\\ne 0$.\nWith bulk tied to source $g_{mb2}=0$.\nThe comments are identical with $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\n$M_{2}$ ${\\rm P}$ is the dual. In that case $S_{2} > D_{2}$\nin $DC$ and the DC current must be sunk by the driving\nsource.\n\n> {\\it N.B. :} As drawn with two $P$ symbols the\n> DC path is $V_{DD}\\to M_{1}\\to M_{2}\\to V_{in}$.\n> The input source must sink the $DC$ bias current\n> $I_{D}$. Normally this is a ${\\rm N}{\\rm MOS}{\\rm CG}+\n> {\\rm P}{\\rm MOS}$ load. The operation is complementary.\n\nLet $I_{D}=I_{D1}=I_{D2}$ in $DC$.\n\n$$I_{D}= \\tfrac12\\mu C_{ox}(W/L)(V_{GS}-V_{T})^{2}\n\\left[1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right]$$\n\n$$g_{m}=\\sqrt{2\\mu C_{ox}(W/L)I_{D}}=\n\\frac{2I_{D}}{V_{ov}}\\qquad \ng_{ds}= \\lambda I_{D}=r_{o}^{-1}\\qquad \ng_{mb}= \\eta g_{m}\\;\\; \\eta\\approx 0.1-0.3$$\n\nIn $DC$ saturation\n\n* $M_{1}:$ $V_{SG1}=V_{DD}-V_{b2}>|V_{Tp}|$ ,\n  $V_{SD1}=V_{DD}-V_{out}\\ge V_{SG1}-|V_{Tp}|=V_{ov1}$\n* $M_{2}:$ $V_{GS2}=V_{b1}-V_{in}>V_{Tn}$ ,\n  $V_{DS2}=V_{out}-V_{in}\\ge V_{GS2}-V_{Tn}=V_{ov2}$\n\n$$V_{b1}=V_{in}+V_{Tn}+V_{ov2}\\qquad \n|V_{b2}-V_{DD}|\\approx|V_{Tp}|+|V_{ov1}|$$\n\nso $V_{out}$ must satisfy\n\n$$V_{in}+V_{ov2}\\le V_{out}\\le V_{DD}-|V_{ov1}|$$\n\notherwise one device goes triode. $V_{b1},V_{b2}$ normally\ngenerated by ${\\rm N}{\\rm MOS}$ and ${\\rm P}{\\rm MOS}$\ndiode connected replica bias.\n\n### Small signal low frequency\n\nGate and $V_{DD}$ are ac ground.  $M_{1}$ is a\nresistor to ground\n\n$$Z_{1}=r_{o1}=1/g_{ds1}\\;\\;{\\rm to\\;ac\\;gnd}$$\n\nwith no $g_{m1}$ contribution for $v_{sg1}=0$.\n\nFor $M_{2}$\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m2}v_{gs2}+g_{mb2}v_{bs2}+g_{ds2}v_{ds2}$$\n\n$$v_{gs2}= -v_{s}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{bs2}=\n\\begin{cases}\n -v_{s} & {\\rm bulk\\;to\\;gnd}\\\\\n 0      & {\\rm bulk\\;to\\;source}\n\\end{cases}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{ds2}=v_{d}-v_{s}$$\n\n$$v_{s}=v_{in}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{d}=v_{out}$$\n\nKCL at $V_{out}$:\n\n$$\\frac{v_{out}}{r_{o1}}+i_{d}=0$$\n\n$$ \\frac{v_{out}}{r_{o1}}+g_{m2}(-v_{in})+\ng_{mb2}v_{bs2}+g_{ds2}(v_{out}-v_{in})=0 \\tag{1}$$\n\nHence, with $G_{m}=g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$ if bulk grounded,\n$G_{m}=g_{m2}$ if bulk tied to source,\n\n$$v_{out}(g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}) = v_{in}(G_{m}+g_{ds2})$$\n\n$$\\,A_{v0}=\\frac{v_{out}}{v_{in}}=\n\\frac{G_{m}+g_{ds2}}{g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\approx\n\\frac{G_{m}}{g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}=G_{m}\\,R_{out}\\,>0\\,$$\n\n$$R_{out}{\\big |}_{R_{S}=0}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\n\\approx \\frac{1}{2}r_{o}$$\n\nif $r_{o1}\\approx r_{o2}=r_{o}$.\nFor long channel\n\n$$|A_{v0}|\\approx g_{m}(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2})\n\\approx \\frac{g_{m}r_{o}}{2}= \\frac{1}{\\lambda V_{ov}}\\approx\n20-40\\,{\\rm dB}$$\n\n{\\it Non inverting.}  Physically $v_{in}\\uparrow\\to\nv_{gs}\\downarrow\\to i_{d}\\downarrow$ the $P$ load\npulls $v_{out}\\uparrow$ until $g_{ds}\\Delta v_{out}= \nG_{m}\\Delta v_{in}$.\n\nCurrent gain $\\approx 1$. The stage is a {\\it current\nbuffer - voltage amplifier - impedance transformer}.\n\nKCL at the source with a test voltage $v_{x}$ and\n$R_{D}=r_{o1}$ to ground:\n\n$$v_{out}=v_{x}\\frac{G_{m}+g_{ds2}}{g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}$$\n\n$$i_{x}= -i_{s}=G_{m}v_{x}+g_{ds2}(v_{x}-v_{out})\n\\approx v_{x}\\frac{G_{m}}{1+g_{ds2}R_{D}}R_{D}^{-1}$$\n\nMore exactly\n\n$$\\,R_{in}=\\frac{v_{x}}{i_{x}}=\n\\frac{1+g_{ds2}R_{D}}{G_{m}+g_{ds2}+g_{ds1}G_{m}R_{D}/(?)}\\approx\n\\frac{1+R_{D}/r_{o2}}{G_{m}}\\,$$\n\nNormally quoted for $R_{D}\\ll r_{o2}$, or to first order,\n\n$$\\,R_{in}\\approx \\frac{1}{G_{m}+g_{ds2}}\n\\approx\\frac{1}{G_{m}}=\\frac{1}{g_{m}+g_{mb}}\\;\\;\n\\to\\; \\frac{1}{g_{m}}\\;{\\rm with\\;bulk\\;tied\\,}$$\n\n$10^{1}-10^{2}\\,\\Omega$. With $R_{D}=r_{o1}$\n$$R_{in}\\approx \\frac{1+r_{o1}/r_{o2}}{G_{m}}\\approx\n\\frac{2}{G_{m}}$$\nthe familiar $\\approx 50\\,\\Omega$ matching $1/g_{m}=50\\,\\Omega$ of the ${\\rm CG}{\\rm -LNA}$.\n\nIn general with a source resistance $R_{S}$ to ground the\nimpedance looking into the drain is\n\n$$R_{d}=r_{o2}+ \\left[1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}\\right]R_{S}$$\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{d}=r_{o1}\\parallel\n\\left\\{r_{o2}+\\left[1+G_{m}r_{o2}\\right]R_{S}\\right\\}$$\n\nSo for $R_{S}=0$, $R_{out}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$,\nfor $R_{S}\\ne 0$, e.g. $50\\,\\Omega$, $R_{d}\\gg r_{o}$ and\n$R_{out}\\approx r_{o1}$.\n\n### Frequency, noise, application\n\n* No Miller multiplication, $C_{gd}$ is between output and\nac ground.  Dominant pole at the output\n\n$$\\omega_{p,out}\\approx \\frac{1}{R_{out}C_{L}}$$\n\nInput pole\n\n$$\\omega_{p,in}\\approx \\frac{1}{R_{in}(C_{gs2}+C_{sb2}+C_{S})}\n\\approx \\frac{G_{m}}{C_{gs}} =\\omega_{T}$$\n\nvery high. Hence wide band, good isolation $S_{12}\\approx 0$.\n\n* Input referred thermal noise $\\overline{v_{n}^{2}}\\approx\n4kT\\gamma/G_{m}$ plus load noise $4kT\\gamma g_{m1}R_{out}^{2}$.\nNoise figure of the $50\\,\\Omega$ matched ${\\rm CG}{\\rm -LNA}$\n$\\approx 1+\\gamma$.\n\n* Used where low $R_{in}$, high $R_{out}$, wide band and\nno phase inversion is wanted: RF input termination, current\nbuffer, the input device of a cascode, folded cascode, current\nmirror OTA, level shifter. Load can be resistively replaced by\n$R_{D}$ with $A_{v}=G_{m}R_{D}\\parallel r_{o2}$.\n\nCascoding $M_{1}$ or regulating the gate of $M_{2}$ raises\n$R_{out}$ and gain to $G_{m}g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$.\n\nIdeal bias $G_{m}R_{S}=1$ gives simultaneous power and noise\nmatch only to first order; modifications - e.g. capacitive\nfeedthrough, $g_{m}$ boosting - are used for pure RF LNA.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "8544707cca8b417c0127d549806b7b3dad3dbae38990c134fdd4c327b8513a6d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-gate NMOS stage with a PMOS current-source load, places Vin at M2’s source and Vb1/Vb2 at the gates, and gives the non-inverting gain equivalent to gm2(ro1 || ro2) with low input resistance. The extra detailed discussion does not undermine the essential analysis.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "bef1a8379b057bee5021488ff4aa65884dec1cb905b95a6d1d764f0128473407",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1289,
        "output_tokens": 15635,
        "total_tokens": 16924,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13316,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1289,
        "output_tokens": 15635,
        "total_tokens": 16924,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13316,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 23,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-023-common-gate-pmos-load/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the grounded gate stage, Fig.1\n\n$$M_{1}={\\rm load}~~~M_{2}={\\rm driver}$$\n\nIn $CMOS$ normally $M_{1}{\\rm ,}p-$\n$M_{2}{\\rm ,}n-$ , with $p$ bulk to $V_{DD}$,\n$n$ bulk to $V_{SS}=0$ . With the conventional\n3 terminal symbol the arrow is on the {\\it source}.\nThe conventional representation is\n\n* $M_{1}$: $S\\to V_{DD}$ , $G=V_{b2}=V_{GS1}+V_{DD}$ ,\n$D=V_{o}$ . $V_{SG1}>|V_{Tp}|$, $V_{SD1}>V_{SG1}-|V_{Tp}|$\nso that $M_{1}$ in saturation is to first order a\n$DC$ current\n\n$$I_{o}= {1\\over 2}\\mu _{p}C_{ox}\\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{1}\n\\left(V_{SG1}-|V_{Tp}|\\right)^{2}\\left(1+\\lambda _{p}V_{SD1}\\right)$$\n\nand for signals\n\n$$g_{m1}= \\mu _{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}(V_{SG1}-|V_{Tp}|)$$\n$$r_{o1}=1/g_{ds1}=1/\\lambda _{p}I_{o}$$\n\ni. e. $M_{1}$ is the $\\approx r_{o1}$ to $a.c.$\nground $V_{DD}$ active load, current source load.\nIts bulk is strapped to $S$ so no $g_{mb1}$ .\n\n* $M_{2}$: $G=V_{b1}= {\\rm const}$ $a.c.$ ground,\n$S=V_{i}$ $D=V_{o}$ . \n\n$$V_{GS2}=V_{b1}-V_{i}>V_{Tn}$$\n$$V_{DS2}=V_{o}-V_{i}>V_{GS2}-V_{Tn}=V_{ov2}$$\n\nso that for correct $V_{b1},V_{b2}$ both devices are in\nsaturation and\n\n$$I_{o}= {1\\over 2}\\mu _{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{2}\n\\left(V_{GS2}-V_{Tn}\\right)^{2}\\left(1+\\lambda _{n}V_{DS2}\\right)$$\n\nfixes the $DC$ level $V_{o(DC)}$ and the $DC$ level\n$V_{i(DC)}=V_{b1}-V_{GS2}$ .  Head room\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{o,max}&= V_{DD}-|V_{ov1}|\\cr\nV_{o,min}&= V_{i(DC)}+V_{ov2}\\cr\nV_{i,max}&= V_{b1}-V_{Tn}-V_{ov2}\\cr}$$\n\nand $V_{b1}$ is normally chosen $V_{Tn}+V_{ov2}$\nabove the wanted $V_{i(DC)}$ . For signals $G$ is\ngrounded. It is the {\\it common gate - $CG$,\ngrounded gate} amplifier, the $n-$ complement of a\ncommon base stage. $\\delta V_{i}=-\\delta V_{GS2}$ and\nany $\\delta V_{i}$ modulates $I_{D2}$.\n\nSmall signal with $r_{o}\\ne \\infty $ and\n$g_{mb}\\ne 0$ if the $n-$ bulk goes to $GND$ :\n\n$$v_{gs2}= -v_{i}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{bs2}= -v_{i}\\;\\;{\\rm to}\\;GND\\;\\;,\n0\\;{\\rm if\\; bulk}\\;{\\rm strapped\\; to}\\;S$$\n$$v_{ds2}=v_{o}-v_{i}$$\n$$i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{gs2}+g_{mb2}v_{bs2}+g_{ds2}v_{ds2}$$\n\n$$i_{d2}=-(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2})v_{i}+g_{ds2}v_{o}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$CG$ is {\\it non inverting}.\n\n$$g_{m}={{\\partial I_{D}}\\over {\\partial V_{GS}}}$$\n$$g_{mb}=\\eta g_{m}={{\\gamma g_{m}}\\over {2\\sqrt{2\\Phi _{F}+V_{SB}}}}$$\n$$g_{ds}= \\lambda I_{D}=1/r_{o}$$\n\nAt the output node $v_{o}$ :\n\ntube $r_{o1}$ to $a.c.$ ground and $i_{d2}$ into the\ntube. With $i_{d2}$ defined into the $D$:\n\n$${{v_{o}}\\over {r_{o1}}}+i_{d2}=0\\tag{2}$$\n\nfor $R_{L}\\to \\infty $. If an external load $R_{L}$ to\nground is present replace $r_{o1}\\to r_{o1}\\parallel R_{L}$.\n\nFrom (1)-(2)\n\n$${{v_{o}}\\over {r_{o1}}}+g_{ds2}v_{o}-(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2})v_{i}=0$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {{v_{o}}\\over {v_{i}}}=\n{{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}}\\over {g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}}>0\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2})\n      \\approx g_{m2}(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2})\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;\n      g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1\\tag{4}$$\n\n$\\approx +\\,$ intrinsic gain of the process.\nE. g. $g_{m}=1\\,{\\rm mS}$, $r_{o}=10-50\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$\n$A_{v}=10-50$, $20-34\\,{\\rm dB}$ for a single stage.\nIf bulk strapped to source $g_{mb2}=0$.\n\nWith a signal source resistance $R_{sig}$ in series\nwith $v_{i}$\n\n$$A_{v}= {{(g_{m}+g_{mb})(r_{o1}\\parallel R_{L})}\n\\over {1+(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds})R_{sig}+R_{sig}/r_{o2}+R_{L}/r_{o2}}}$$\n\nso for $R_{sig}=0$ (3) is recovered. The $CG$ has no\nMiller multiplication of $C_{gd}$.\n\nInput resistance at the source, $R_{in}=v_{x}/i_{x}$\nwith $v_{x}$ applied to the $S$ of $M_{2}$ and $D$\nterminated in $R_{D}=r_{o1}\\parallel R_{L}$ :\n\nPut $v_{x}=v_{i}$, $v_{d}=v_{o}$ in (1) and\n$v_{d}/R_{D}+i_{d2}=0$ , and $i_{x}=i_{d2}$ in magnitude,\n\n$$i_{x}=-(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds})v_{x}+g_{ds}v_{d}$$\n$$v_{d}=-R_{D}i_{d2}$$\n\neliminating $v_{d}$\n\n$$R_{in}= {{v_{x}}\\over {i_{x}}}=\n{{1+g_{ds}R_{D}}\\over {g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds}+g_{ds}g_{ds1}R_{D}}}\n      \\approx {{R_{D}+r_{o2}}\\over {1+(g_{m}+g_{mb})r_{o2}}}\\tag{5}$$\n\nFor the circuit as drawn $R_{D}=r_{o1}$ :\n\n$$R_{in}= {{r_{o1}+r_{o2}}\\over {1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}}}\n       ={{1+r_{o1}/r_{o2}}\\over {g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+1/r_{o2}}}\\tag{6}$$\n\nSo that\n\n* $R_{D}\\ll r_{o2}$ : $R_{in}\\approx 1/(g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds})\n      \\approx 1/(g_{m}+g_{mb})$\n* $R_{D}\\sim r_{o}$ : $R_{in}\\approx 2/(g_{m}r_{o})\\,r_{o}\n      \\approx 2/g_{m}$\n* $R_{D}\\gg g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$ : $R_{in}\\to R_{D}/(g_{m}r_{o})$\n      i. e. large.\n\nNormally $g_{m}r_{o}\\approx 20-100$ so up to\n$R_{D}\\sim r_{o}$ the $CG$ remains a low impedance\ninput, of order $50\\,\\Omega$ to $1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$,\nwhich is its main use as a $50\\,\\Omega $ wide band\ntermination for $RF$ $LNA$'s, $R_{in}=1/g_{m}=50\\,\\Omega $.\n\nNeglecting $r_{o}$ and $g_{mb}$ simply\n\n$$R_{in0}\\approx 1/g_{m2}\\tag{7}$$\n\nOutput resistance at $v_{o}$ with a source resistance\n$R_{sig}$ driving the source:\n\nBy duality\n\n$$R_{out}=r_{o1}\\parallel \\left\\{ r_{o2}+ \\left[1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}\\right]R_{sig}\\right\\}\\tag{8}$$\n\n* $R_{sig}=0$, ideal voltage drive, $R_{out}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$\n\n* $R_{sig}\\ne 0$ the impedance looking into the\n  drain of $M_{2}$ is boosted to\n  $\\approx g_{m}r_{o}R_{sig}$, the cascode effect.\n  The circuit then becomes the cascode device.\n\nFrequency response: two open circuit poles\n\n$$p_{in}\\approx -{{1}\\over {(R_{sig}\\parallel R_{in})C_{in}}}\\;\\;,\n  C_{in}\\approx C_{gs2}+C_{sb2}+C_{sig}$$\n\n$$p_{out}\\approx -{{1}\\over {R_{out}C_{out}}}\\;\\;,\n  C_{out}\\approx C_{db1}+C_{db2}+C_{gd2}+C_{gd1}+C_{L}$$\n\nBecause $R_{in}$ is low, $p_{in}$ is at very high\nfrequency. There is no Miller $C_{gd}$ multiplier\nbecause $G$ is grounded. The $CG$ is inherently wide\nband, the dominant pole is normally $p_{out}$.\n\n$$\\omega_{-3{\\rm dB}}\\approx 1/R_{out}C_{out}$$\n\n$$GBW\\approx A_{v}\\omega_{-3{\\rm dB}}\\approx g_{m}/C_{out}$$\n\nLarge signal, $v_{o}$ follows $v_{i}$ in phase, the\nstage is a {\\it current buffer}: low $R_{in}$, high\n$R_{out}$, voltage gain $>1$, current gain $\\approx 1$,\nand a {\\it voltage non-inverting amplifier}.\n\nIn $PMOS$-only version interchange $V_{DD}\\leftrightarrow GND$,\n$|V_{Tp}|\\leftrightarrow V_{Tn}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} Interchanging $S$ and $D$ as drawn\n> does not change the small signal result to first order.\n> Strapping the bulk of $M_{2}$ to its $S$ eliminates\n> $g_{mb2}$. In a $p-$ substrate twin well process the\n> $nMOST$ bulk is $GND$ by construction and $g_{mb}$ is\n> unavoidable unless a triple well is used.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "014b7a16f3929e957304b25791a4c8545bf269efea27e11f4eaaaa2c1aa4ee28"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the common-gate NMOS stage with a PMOS current-source load, places Vin at M2’s source, and identifies both bias voltages. It gives the non-inverting gain as approximately gm2(ro1 || ro2) and describes the low input resistance; its additional detail does not alter the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "bef1a8379b057bee5021488ff4aa65884dec1cb905b95a6d1d764f0128473407",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1289,
        "output_tokens": 13939,
        "total_tokens": 15228,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11046,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1289,
        "output_tokens": 13939,
        "total_tokens": 15228,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11046,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-024-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 24,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-024-many-poles-have/figure-18.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual lumped h.f. model the\ncircuit is a second order circuit.  The $5$\nenergy storing elements\n\n$${\\rm C}_{GS}\\;\\;{\\rm C}_{GD}\\;\\;{\\rm C}_{DB}\\;\\;\n{\\rm C}_{GD_{2}}\\;\\;{\\rm C}_{DB_{2}} \\tag{*}$$\n\nhave the graph\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nQ_{G}&=C_{GS}V_{G}+C_{GD}(V_{G}-V_{D})\\cr\nQ_{D}&=C_{DB}V_{D}+C_{DB_{2}}V_{D}+C_{GD_{2}}V_{D}\n      +C_{GD}(V_{D}-V_{G})}$$\n\n$$ {\\bf C}=\\left\\Vert \\matrix{\nC_{GS}+C_{GD}&-C_{GD}\\cr\n-C_{GD}&C_{DB}+C_{DB_{2}}+C_{GD_{2}}+C_{GD}\\cr}\\right\\Vert \\tag{1}$$\n\n${\\rm det}\\,{\\bf C}\\ne 0$.\n$C_{DB}\\parallel C_{DB_{2}}\\parallel C_{GD_{2}}:=C_{o}$ are\nall to the {\\it a.c. earth} at the drain node {\\it e.g.}\n$C_{GD_{2}}$ is to the ${\\rm a.c.}$ earth at the gate of\n${\\rm M}_{2}$, and the ${{C}_{GS}-C_{GD}-C_{DB}}$\nloop ${\\rm det}{\\bf C}=0$ removes one state, so there are\nin the normal language only two different natural\nfrequencies.  Putting\n\n$$C_{T}=C_{o}+C_{GD}\\qquad g_{o}=g_{ds_{1}}+g_{ds_{2}}\\qquad \nR_{o}=g_{o}^{-1}$$\n\nthe nodal equations in the low frequency small signal\nmodel, Fig. 1, are, with $V_{g}\\equiv V_{G_{1}}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{{V_{g}-V_{i}}\\over {R_{S}}}+sC_{GS}V_{g}+sC_{GD}(V_{g}-V_{o})&=0\\cr\ng_{m}V_{g}+g_{o}V_{o}+sC_{o}V_{o}+sC_{GD}(V_{o}-V_{g})&=0\\cr} \\tag{2}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$\\left\\Vert \\matrix{\n{1\\over {R_{S}}}+s(C_{GS}+C_{GD}) &-sC_{GD}\\cr\ng_{m}-sC_{GD} &g_{o}+sC_{T}\\cr}\\right\\Vert \n\\left\\Vert \\matrix{V_{g}\\cr V_{o}\\cr}\\right\\Vert =\n\\left\\Vert \\matrix{{V_{i}\\over {R_{S}}}\\cr 0\\cr}\\right\\Vert \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${{V_{o}}\\over {V_{i}}}(s)={1\\over {R_{S}}}{{sC_{GD}-g_{m}}\\over \n{\\Delta (s)}} \\tag{4}$$\n\nand, from (3),\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\Delta (s)&=\\left[{1\\over {R_{S}}}+s(C_{GS}+C_{GD})\\right]\n\\left[g_{o}+sC_{T}\\right]+sC_{GD}\\left(g_{m}-sC_{GD}\\right)\\cr\n&={g_{o}\\over {R_{S}}}+s\\left[{C_{T}\\over {R_{S}}}+g_{o}(C_{GS}+C_{GD})\n+g_{m}C_{GD}\\right]+s^{2}\\left[(C_{GS}+C_{GD})C_{T}-C_{GD}^{2}\\right]\\cr\n&={g_{o}\\over {R_{S}}}+s\\left[{C_{T}\\over {R_{S}}}+g_{o}(C_{GS}+C_{GD})\n+g_{m}C_{GD}\\right]+s^{2}\\left[C_{GS}C_{T}+C_{GD}C_{o}\\right] } \\tag{5}$$\n\nis ${\\cal O}(s^{2})$.  I. e. in the ordinary sense the\nvoltage transfer function is a low pass second order\nfunction with, from (4), the conventional Miller RHP\nzero at\n\n$$s_{z}=+{{g_{m}}\\over {C_{GD}}}\\tag{6}$$\n\nIn the Miller approximation (5) is normally written as\n\n$$\\Delta (s)\\approx {g_{o}\\over {R_{S}}}\\left[1+sR_{S}\n\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}(1+g_{m}R_{o})\\right)\\right]\\left[1+sR_{o}C_{o}^{\\ast}\\right] \\tag{7}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\omega _{p_{i}}^{-1}&\\approx R_{S}\\left[C_{GS}+C_{GD}(1+g_{m}R_{o})\\right]\n\\tag{8a}\\cr\n\\omega _{p_{o}}^{-1}&\\approx R_{o}\\left[C_{DB}+C_{DB_{2}}+C_{GD_{2}}\n+C_{GD}\\left(1-{1\\over {g_{m}R_{o}}}\\right)\\right]\\approx R_{o}C_{o} \\tag{8b}}$$\n\nthe conventional Miller multiplied input pole and the\noutput pole.  For $R_{S}\\to 0$ (8a) goes to infinity and\nthe circuit becomes the familiar dominant pole\n$R_{o}C_{o}$ single pole circuit, Fig. 2.\n\nIf you want to count $C_{DB}\\parallel C_{DB_{2}}\\parallel\nC_{GD_{2}}$ as different poles (7)--(8) is normally\nquoted as a three capacitance, three pole, one zero,\ncircuit, the output pole being triple,\n$C_{o}=C_{DB}+C_{DB_{2}}+C_{GD_{2}}$, and with the usual\nabuse of language the $C_{GD}$ Miller pole counted as a\nthird pole.  Counting every physical capacitance in\n$(\\ast )$ separately (5) is formally ${\\cal O}(s^{5})$,\n${\\cal O}(s^{4})$ with the $C_{GS}-C_{GD}-C_{DB}$ all\ncapacitance loop removed, with three coincident poles at\n$\\omega _{p_{o}}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  In most text books the three coincident\n> output capacitances are lumped as $C_{o}$ and the circuit\n> is quoted as a {\\it three pole, one zero} circuit,\n> {\\it i. e.} as a {\\it two pole} low pass function in the\n> strict network theoretic sense.\n\nFor $R_{S}=0$ the conventional single pole dominant pole\napproximation\n\n$${{V_{o}}\\over {V_{i}}}(s)\\approx -{{g_{m}R_{o}}\\over {1+sR_{o}C_{o}}}\n{{1-sC_{GD}/g_{m}}\\over {1+sR_{S}(C_{GS}+C_{GD}g_{m}R_{o})}} \\tag{9}$$\n\nis recovered.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "37be31d8f16147583b4dcd098b2ca2e6cda6a9491f9f06bf3ef56b23b7594374"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the gate and output as the two independent capacitive nodes, assigns the capacitors to the right nodes, and derives a quadratic denominator. Its loose discussion of informal pole counting does not change the strict answer of two poles.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a186c7d78b22ed309b07c9b6c97e61997ddf23f0ee23de6faa3536cb2c682d8c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1902,
        "output_tokens": 5951,
        "total_tokens": 7853,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4245,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1902,
        "output_tokens": 5951,
        "total_tokens": 7853,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4245,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-024-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 24,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-024-many-poles-have/figure-18.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the ideal ${\\rm  ac.\\,ground}$ on the gate of\n${\\cal M}_{2}$ the only high ${\\rm d.\\,c.}$ impedance\n${\\rm nodes}$ are\n\n$${\\rm N}_{1}= {\\cal G}_{1}\\qquad {\\rm N}_{2}=\n{\\cal D}_{1}\\equiv {\\cal D}_{2}\\equiv V_{o}\\tag*{1}$$\n\nso that with\n\n$$R_{D}^{\\prime}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\qquad \nC_{L}=C_{DB}+C_{DB2}+C_{GD2}\\tag{2}$$\n\nthe ${\\rm a.\\,c.}$ small signal circuit is Fig. 1\nand, putting e. {\\rm g.} $g_{mb}=0$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{\\rm N}_{1}:&\\;(V_{1}-V_{i})/R_{S}+sC_{GS}V_{1}\n+sC_{GD}(V_{1}-V_{o})=0\\cr\n{\\rm N}_{2}:&\\;V_{o}/R_{D}^{\\prime}+sC_{L}V_{o}\n+sC_{GD}(V_{o}-V_{1})+g_{m1}V_{1}=0\\cr} \\tag{3}$$\n\ni. e. with\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nA(s)&=R_{S}^{-1}+s\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\right)\\cr\nB(s)&=R_{D}^{\\prime -1}+s\\left(C_{L}+C_{GD}\\right)\\cr}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$\\left[\\,{\\rm M}(s)\\,\\right]\n\\left[\\,{\\rm V}\\,\\right]=\\left[\\,{\\rm I}\\,\\right]\\qquad \n\\left[\\,{\\rm M}\\,\\right]=\\left\\Vert\n\\matrix{A &-sC_{GD}\\cr\ng_{m1}-sC_{GD} &B\\cr}\\right\\Vert \\tag{5}$$\n\n$${\\rm det\\,}{\\rm M}(s)=D(s)=A(s)B(s)\n+sC_{GD}\\left(g_{m1}-sC_{GD}\\right) \\tag{6}$$\n\n$$D(s)=R_{S}^{-1}R_{D}^{\\prime -1}\n+s\\left[{{C_{GS}+C_{GD}}\\over {R_{D}^{\\prime}}}\n+{{C_{L}+C_{GD}}\\over {R_{S}}}+g_{m1}C_{GD}\\right]\n+s^{2}\\left[C_{GS}C_{L}+C_{GS}C_{GD}+C_{GD}C_{L}\\right] \\tag{7}$$\n\nand, e. {\\rm g.},\n\n$${{V_{o}}\\over {V_{i}}}(s)={{R_{S}^{-1}\\left(sC_{GD}\n-g_{m1}\\right)}\\over {D(s)}}\\tag{8}$$\n\nso that, in the conventional lumped terminology, the\nfinite transfer function is second order with a\nright half plane feed through zero at\n\n$$s_{z}=+{{g_{m1}}\\over {C_{GD}}}\\tag{9}$$\n\nThe quadratic $D(s)=0$, $D(s)\\propto (s-p_{1})(s-p_{2})$,\nis conventionally spoken of as the {\\it input,}\nMiller multiplied, pole and the {\\it output} pole,\n\n$$p_{1}\\approx -{{1}\\over {R_{S}\n\\left[C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\left(1+g_{m1}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\right)\n\\right]}}\\tag{10a}$$\n\n$$p_{2}\\approx -{{1}\\over {R_{D}^{\\prime}\n\\left[C_{L}+C_{GD}{{1+g_{m1}R_{S}C_{GS}/\n\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\right)}\\over {1+g_{m1}R_{D}^{\\prime}}}\n\\right]}}\\approx -{{1}\\over {R_{D}^{\\prime}\n\\left(C_{L}+C_{GD}\\right)}}\\quad {\\rm for}\\;\\;\ng_{m1}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\gg 1 \\tag{10b}$$\n\nwith the obvious $g_{m}R_{D}^{\\prime}\\rightarrow \\infty $\nMiller limits\n\n$$p_{1}\\rightarrow -{{1}\\over {R_{S}\n\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\right)}}\\qquad \np_{2}\\rightarrow -{{1}\\over {R_{D}^{\\prime}C_{L}}}\n\\tag{11}$$\n\nif the Miller multiplication is exhibited explicitly.\n\nIn terms of physical capacitors there are\n\n* $C_{GS}$ ${\\cal G}_{1}-{\\rm gnd}$\n* $C_{GD}$ ${\\cal G}_{1}-{\\cal D}_{1}$ - the Miller\nfeedback capacitor\n* $C_{DB}$ ${\\cal D}_{1}-{\\rm gnd}$\n* $C_{GD2}$ ${\\cal D}_{2}-{\\rm gnd}$ [${\\cal G}_{2}=\n{\\rm ac\\,gnd}$]\n* $C_{DB2}$ ${\\cal D}_{2}-{\\rm ac\\,gnd}$\n\ni. e. five physical capacitors.  For ${\\rm a.\\,c.}$\n${\\rm gnd}\\equiv V_{DD}$ the last three are in\nparallel between the same electrical node ${\\rm N}_{2}$\nand ${\\rm ac\\,gnd}$,\n\n$$C_{L}=C_{DB}\\parallel C_{GD2}\\parallel C_{DB2}\\tag{12}$$\n\nso that three pole frequencies are conventionally\ndistinguished, one at the gate, one Miller and one\ntriple at the drain.  With the parallel combination\n(12) carried out there are two independent state\nvariables, i. e. two independent poles in the\nstrict determinant sense, Eq.\\,(7).  Loosely the\ncircuit is often quoted as a three pole  - two pole\nplus RHP zero - Miller amplifier, five poles with\nthree coincident at the output if every physical\ncapacitor is counted separately.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  Counting distinct $R\\,C$ products\n> before the $C_{L}$ parallel combination is carried\n> out the circuit is normally abbreviated to the\n> familiar dominant pole - non dominant pole\n> two pole low pass with the Miller zero (9).  With\n> distinct capacitors exhibited it is a three\n> frequency, $C_{GS}$, $C_{GD}$, $C_{L}$, amplifier,\n> five capacitors with $C_{DB}\\parallel\n> C_{DB2}\\parallel C_{GD2}$.  Any other\n> degeneracies, e. {\\rm g.} $R_{S}=0$, $R_{D}^{\\prime}\n> =0$, remove one of the poles in the usual way.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5844d000530ca13a13a4bc417d6f5364b3fa5a5d8a898d6b927cce70960e1f4a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies two independent nodes and derives a second-order determinant, but then explicitly claims three or five poles by counting capacitor-related frequencies. That contradicts the required two-pole answer and the golden solution’s limit for answers giving another pole count.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a186c7d78b22ed309b07c9b6c97e61997ddf23f0ee23de6faa3536cb2c682d8c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1902,
        "output_tokens": 7690,
        "total_tokens": 9592,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6062,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1902,
        "output_tokens": 7690,
        "total_tokens": 9592,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6062,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-024-many-poles-have",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 24,
      "question": "How many poles does the circuit shown in the figure have?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-024-many-poles-have/figure-18.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the (ac) short on the $2$ gates and on the\ntop plate of the two drift bulk capacities there is,\nac, only one high impedance node in the circuit, the\ncommon drain node, ${\\rm D}_{1}\\equiv {\\rm D}_{2}\\equiv\n{\\rm O}$, Fig.1, and one low impedance node, the gate\nof ${\\rm M}_{1}$.  Putting ${\\rm V}_{i}=0$,\n\n$${\\rm G}_{1}\\left(R_{s}{\\rm\\;to\\;earth}\\right)\n \\left\\{\\eqalign{\nC_{GS}&{\\rm G}_{1}-{\\rm earth}\\cr\nC_{GD}&{\\rm G}_{1}-{\\rm O}\\cr}\\right.\n\\qquad \n{\\rm O}\\left\\{\\eqalign{\nC_{DB}&{\\rm O}-{\\rm earth}\\cr\nC_{DB_{2}}&{\\rm O}-{\\rm earth}\\cr\nC_{GD_{2}}&{\\rm O}-{\\rm earth}\\cr}\\right.\\tag{*}$$\n\nso that for distinct elements you have four, ac\nphysical, capacities but $C_{DB}\\parallel C_{DB2}\\parallel\nC_{GD2}\\equiv C_{o}$ is a single ac capacity to earth.\nFor independent capacities you have the three capacities\n\n$$C_{GS}\\;\\;,\\;\\;C_{GD}\\;\\;,\\;\\;C_{o}=C_{DB}+C_{DB2}+\nC_{GD2}\\tag{**}$$\n\nwith the capacitive loop $C_{GS}-C_{GD}-C_{o}$.\nHence two independent state variables.  In the\nnodal equations, with $R_{o}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{{V_{1}-V_{i}}\\over {R_{s}}}+V_{1}sC_{GS}+(V_{1}-V_{o})\nsC_{GD}&=0\\cr\ng_{m}V_{1}+{{V_{o}}\\over {R_{o}}}+(V_{o}-V_{1})sC_{GD}+\nV_{o}sC_{o}&=0\\cr}\\tag{***}$$\n\n$$\\left| \\matrix{\n{{1}\\over {R_{s}}}+s\\left(C_{GS}+C_{GD}\\right) &-sC_{GD}\\cr\ng_{m}-sC_{GD}&{{1}\\over {R_{o}}}+s\\left(C_{o}+C_{GD}\\right)\\cr}\\right|\n\\cdot \\left| \\matrix{V_{1}\\cr V_{o}\\cr}\\right| =\n\\left| \\matrix{{{V_{i}}\\over {R_{s}}}\\cr 0\\cr}\\right| $$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{{V_{o}}\\over {V_{i}}}(s)&=-{{g_{m}-sC_{GD}}\\over {R_{s}}}\\cr\n&\\times \\left\\{ s^{2}\\left[C_{GS}C_{o}+C_{GD}\\left(C_{GS}+\nC_{o}\\right)\\right]+s\\left[{{C_{GS}+C_{GD}}\\over {R_{o}}}+\n{{C_{o}+C_{GD}}\\over {R_{s}}}+g_{m}C_{GD}\\right]+{{1}\\over\n{R_{s}R_{o}}}\\right\\}^{-1}\\cr}\\tag{****}$$\n\ni. e. in strict mathematics a two pole, one zero,\nsecond order, system, third order if you keep\n$C_{DB}$ and $C_{DB2}$ distinct, fourth order if you\nkeep $C_{GD2}$ distinct, the three, four, capacities\nhanging on the ${\\rm O}$ node being coincident.\nWith $C_{o}\\to C_{DB}+C_{DB2}$ the system is normally\nquoted as a three pole - one zero system, the\nwell known RHP feed forward zero\n\n$$s_{z}=+{{g_{m}}\\over {C_{GD}}}\\tag{1}$$\n\nWith $g_{m}R_{o}\\gg 1$ the two, three, poles can be\nsplit in the Miller approximation as an {\\it input\npole\\/} and a {\\it , dominant, output pole\\/},\n\n$$s_{p1}\\approx -{{1}\\over {R_{s}\\left[C_{GS}+\n\\left(1+g_{m}R_{o}\\right)C_{GD}\\right]}}\\tag{2a}$$\n\n$$s_{p2}\\approx -{{1}\\over {R_{o}\\left[C_{o}+\n{{C_{GS}C_{GD}}\\over {C_{GS}+C_{GD}}}\\right]}}\n\\approx -{{1}\\over {R_{o}C_{o}}}\\tag{2b}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$C_{o}=C_{DB}+C_{DB2}+C_{GD2}+C_{GD}\\left(1+{{1}\\over\n{g_{m}R_{o}}}\\right)\\approx C_{DB}+C_{DB2}+C_{GD2}\\tag{3}$$\n\nso that, $R_{s}\\ll R_{o}$, the normal hand calculation\nis a dominant pole amplifier\n\n$$\\left| s_{p2}\\right| ={1\\over {R_{o}C_{o}}}\\ll \\left|\ns_{p1}\\right| \\tag{4}$$\n\nand, with (1), the familiar one pole Miller\napproximated transfer function\n\n$${{V_{o}}\\over {V_{i}}}(s)\\approx\n-{{g_{m}R_{o}}\\over {1+sR_{o}C_{o}}}{{1-sC_{GD}/g_{m}}\n\\over {1+sR_{s}\\left[C_{GS}+g_{m}R_{o}C_{GD}\\right]}}\n\\tag{5}$$\n\nNormally quoted simply as {\\it a two pole amplifier\nwith a RHP zero, effectively a single dominant pole\namplifier with $\\omega _{-3{\\rm dB}}\\approx 1/R_{o}C_{o}$\n\\/}.  Keeping $C_{DB}$ and $C_{DB2}$ and $C_{GD2}$\ndistinct this is three coincident output poles plus the\ninput Miller pole, i. e. four poles plus one zero\ncoincident to two finite pole frequencies, normally\nabbreviated to {\\it three poles and one zero\\/},\n$C_{GS}\\to p_{1}$, $C_{GD}\\to p_{2}$,\n$C_{o}=C_{DB}\\parallel C_{DB2}\\parallel C_{GD2}\\to\np_{o}$, the last, dominant, often the only one quoted.\n\n> {\\it Remark:\\/}  With the conventional\n> $R_{s}\\rightarrow 0$ signal source the input pole\n> $\\left|s_{p1}\\right|\\rightarrow \\infty $ and the\n> circuit is normally quoted as a one pole, dominant\n> output pole, circuit,\n> $$|s_{p}|\\approx {1\\over {(r_{o1}\\!\\parallel\\! r_{o2})\n> \\left(C_{DB}+C_{DB2}+C_{GD2}\\right)}}\\tag{6}$$\n> to which, in the exact analysis, the Miller pole\n> (2a) and the RHP zero (1) have to be added.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5731ac6eacf9264e8ad67d5fda05dcc8b67632c2f15209b5c5b4d50c92c828a8"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It initially identifies the two independent nodes and correctly derives two poles, but then incorrectly claims that separate capacitors on the same output node create three or four poles and calls the circuit three-pole. That contradicts the central answer; the golden solution caps such pole-count errors at 1.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a186c7d78b22ed309b07c9b6c97e61997ddf23f0ee23de6faa3536cb2c682d8c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1891,
        "input_tokens": 1902,
        "output_tokens": 7017,
        "total_tokens": 8919,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5294,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1891,
        "input_tokens": 1902,
        "output_tokens": 7017,
        "total_tokens": 8919,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5294,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 25,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel/figure-19.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a ${\\rm ``self~cascode''}$\nor {\\it composite} $NMOS$ common source\nwith $R_{D}$ load. The $2T$ pull down can\nbe considered as $1T$ with\n\n$$L_{eq}=L_{1}+L_{2}\\;\\;\\;{\\rm and}\\;\\;\\;\n{(W/L)}_{eq}^{-1}={(W_{1}/L_{1})}^{-1}+\n{(W_{2}/L_{2})}^{-1}$$\n\nin first approximation. i. e. a long channel\ndevice made by stacking.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}&: V_{GS1}=V_{in}\\cr\n& V_{DS1}=V_{x}\\cr\nM_{2}&: V_{GS2}=V_{in}-V_{x}\\cr\n& V_{DS2}=V_{out}-V_{x}} \\qquad V_{x}=V_{D1}=V_{S2}$$\n\nPut $I_{D}=V_{DD}-V_{out}/R_{D}=I_{D1}=I_{D2}$,\n$k_{n}= \\mu _{n}C_{ox}$, $\\lambda =1/V_{A}$\nin the conventional\n\n$$I_{D,sat}={1\\over 2}k_{n}{W\\over L}\n\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\\left[1+\\lambda V_{DS}\\right]$$\n$$I_{D,lin}=k_{n}{W\\over L}\\left[\\left(V_{GS}-V_{T}\\right)V_{DS}\n-{1\\over 2}V_{DS}^{2}\\right]$$\n\n* {\\it Cut off} $V_{in}<V_{T}$ :\n\n$$I_{D}=0\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{out}=V_{DD}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{x}\\approx 0$$\n\n* {\\it On} $V_{in}>V_{T}$ , for $\\lambda\\to 0$,\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_{D2}$$\n\nWith $a=V_{in}-V_{T}$ .\n\nE. {\\rm g}. for $k_{1}=k_{2}=k$ and $M_{2}$ sat,\n$M_{1}$ lin:\n\n$$k\\left(aV_{x}-{1\\over 2}V_{x}^{2}\\right)=\n{1\\over 2}k\\left(a-V_{x}\\right)^{2}$$\n\n$$2V_{x}^{2}-4aV_{x}+a^{2}=0$$\n\n$$V_{x}=a\\left(1-{\\sqrt{2}\\over 2}\\right)\\approx 0.29a>0$$\n\n$$V_{GS2}=a-V_{x}\\approx 0.71a$$\n\n$$I_{D}={1\\over 2}k\\left(0.71a\\right)^{2}\n\\approx {1\\over 2}\\left({1\\over 2}k\\,a^{2}\\right)$$\n\ni. e. the {\\it composite} carries $\\approx 1/2$\nthe current of a single $W/L$ device for the same\n$a$, the same as a $W/L_{eq}=W/2L$ device.\nIn general\n\n$$V_{x}=a\\left[1-\\sqrt{{(W_{1}/L_{1})\\over (W_{2}/L_{2})}}\\;\\right]\n\\qquad \\lambda =0$$\n\nso $V_{x}<a$. Hence\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{DS1}&=V_{x}<V_{GS1}-V_{T}\\cr\n& M_{1}\\;{\\rm is\\;in\\;triode}}$$\n\n$$V_{DS2}=V_{out}-V_{x}\\ge V_{GS2}-V_{T}=a-V_{x}$$\n\n$$\\;V_{out}\\ge a=V_{in}-V_{T}\\;:\\;M_{2}\\;{\\rm sat.}$$\n\nis the saturation condition of the {\\it composite}\ndevice. I. e. the composite is {\\it saturated}\nwhen $M_{2}$ is saturated, although $M_{1}$ is\nin triode. Its $I_{D}$ is essentially flat with\n$V_{out}$. For\n\n$$V_{out}<V_{in}-V_{T}$$\n\n$M_{2}$ also goes triode and\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}-R_{D}I_{D,lin1,lin2}\\to \\approx 0$$\n\nfor $V_{in}\\gg V_{T}$. The large signal\ntransfer $V_{out}\\left(V_{in}\\right)$ is the\nconventional $R_{D}$ inverter transfer with\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}-R_{D}I_{D}\\left(V_{in},V_{out}\\right)$$\n\nhigh $=V_{DD}$ for $V_{in}<V_{T}$, sharp\ntransition around $V_{in}\\approx V_{T}+\n\\sqrt{2I_{D}/k_{eq}}$ and low $\\approx R_{on,eq}/\n\\left(R_{D}+R_{on,eq}\\right)V_{DD}$ for\n$V_{in}\\to V_{DD}$.\n\n> Remark: With the same $V_{T}$ the two devices\n> can never be saturated together. With\n> $V_{GS2}=V_{in}-V_{x}$, $V_{x}\\ge a$ to saturate\n> $M_{1}$ implies $V_{GS2}-V_{T}\\le 0$ and $M_{2}$\n> is off. The normal operating {\\it amplifying}\n> bias has $M_{1}$ linear , $M_{2}$ saturated.\n> By ratioing $(W_{2}/L_{2})\\gg (W_{1}/L_{1})$\n> $V_{x}$ can be made large and $M_{1}$ can be\n> brought close to saturation, but never fully.\n\n### Small signal\n\nFor the signal put $V_{DD}\\;ac\\;0$, $v_{in}$ on\nboth gates.\n\n{\\small\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{d1}&=g_{m1}v_{in}+g_{ds1}v_{x}\\cr\ni_{d2}&=g_{m2}\\left(v_{in}-v_{x}\\right)+\n       g_{mb2}\\left(-v_{x}\\right)+g_{ds2}\\left(v_{out}-v_{x}\\right)\\cr\n& {\\rm with\\;body\\;to\\;ground.\\;If\\;as\\;drawn\\;\nbody\\;of\\;M_{2}\\;{\\rm to}\\;V_{x},\\;g_{mb2}=0}\n}$$\n\n}\nKCL at $V_{x}$ and $V_{out}$:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{d2}&=i_{d1}\\tag{1}\\cr\n{v_{out}\\over R_{D}}+i_{d2}&=0\\tag{2}}$$\n\nFrom (1)-(2) $i_{d1}= -v_{out}/R_{D}$\n\n$$v_{x}=-r_{ds1}\\left[g_{m1}v_{in}+{v_{out}\\over R_{D}}\\right]\n\\tag{3}$$\n\nwith $r_{ds1}=1/g_{ds1}$. In saturation $r_{ds1}=r_{o1}$,\nin triode $r_{ds1}=1/\\left[k_{1}\\left(a-V_{x}\\right)\\right]\n\\ll r_{o1}$.\n\nPutting (3) in (2):\n\n$$ {v_{out}\\over R_{D}}+g_{m2}v_{in}\n-g_{m2}v_{x}+g_{ds2}\\left(v_{out}-v_{x}\\right)\n+g_{mb2}(-v_{x})=0$$\n\n$$g_{m2}v_{in}+v_{out}\\left(g_{ds2}+{1\\over R_{D}}\\right)\n-v_{x}\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}\\right)=0$$\n\nWith $v_{x}$ from (3), for $g_{mb2}=0$:\n\n$${v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=\n- R_{D}{\\,r_{o1}g_{m1}\\left(g_{m2}+g_{ds2}\\right)\n+g_{m2}\\,\\over R_{D}+r_{o2}+r_{o1}\\left(1+g_{m2}r_{o2}\\right)}\n\\tag{4}$$\n\nincluding $g_{mb2}$ replace $g_{m2}\\to g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$.\n\nFor the usual $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$:\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx\n-R_{D}{\\,g_{m2}r_{o2}r_{o1}g_{m1}\\,\\over\nr_{o1}g_{m2}r_{o2}}=-g_{m1}R_{D}\\,\n{1\\over 1+{R_{D}+r_{o2}\\over r_{o1}g_{m2}r_{o2}}}\n\\tag{5}$$\n\nIf $R_{D}\\ll r_{o1}g_{m2}r_{o2}$\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel R_{o}\\right)$$\n\nwhere\n\n$$R_{o}=r_{o2}+r_{o1}+g_{m2}r_{o2}r_{o1}\n\\approx g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\tag{6}$$\n\nis the impedance looking into the drain of $M_{2}$\nwith $v_{in}=0$, i. e. the normal cascode\nformula. If $M_{1}$ is triode $r_{o1}\\to r_{ds1}$:\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx g_{m2}r_{o2}r_{ds1}+r_{o2}+r_{ds1}\n\\approx g_{m2}r_{o2}r_{ds1}$$\n\nstill $\\gg r_{o2}$ but $\\ll g_{m}r_{o}^{2}$.\n\nMore compactly\n\n$$A_{v}=-G_{m}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel R_{o}\\right)$$\n\nwith short circuit transconductance\n\n$$G_{m}={i_{sc}\\over v_{in}}\\Biggr|_{v_{out}=0}\n\\approx g_{m1}$$\n\nIndeed from (1) with $v_{out}=0$:\n\n$$g_{m2}(v_{in}-v_{x})-g_{ds2}v_{x}=g_{m1}v_{in}+g_{ds1}v_{x}$$\n\n$$v_{x}=v_{in}{g_{m2}-g_{m1}\\over g_{m2}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}}\\approx 0\n\\;{\\rm for}\\;g_{m1}\\approx g_{m2}$$\n\n$$i_{sc}=g_{m1}v_{in}+g_{ds1}v_{x}\\approx g_{m1}v_{in}$$\n\nSo the composite has essentially the $g_{m}$ of the\nbottom device, but the $r_{o}$ of a cascode.\n\nWith $g_{mb}\\ne 0$ :\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx \\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}\\right)r_{o1}r_{o2}\\;\\;,\n\\;\\;A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel R_{o}\\right)$$\n\nIntrinsic gain of the composite itself, $R_{D}\\to\\infty$:\n\n$$A_{o}=-G_{m}R_{o}\\approx -g_{m1}r_{o1}g_{m2}r_{o2}$$\n\n$\\approx (g_{m}r_{o})^{2}$, a factor $g_{m}r_{o}$\nlarger than a single device, but with $r_{ds1}$\nin place of $r_{o1}$ if $M_{1}$ is linear the\nimprovement is $g_{m2}r_{o2}\\,(r_{ds1}/r_{o1})$.\n\nIn practice this gives $2$ to $5\\times$ larger\n$R_{o}$ than a simple $L=L_{1}+L_{2}$ device\nfor the same current, without paying the\n$1/(L_{1}+L_{2})$ reduction in $g_{m}$ that a\ntrue long device would give, and it can be used\nat low $V_{DD}$ because $V_{DS,sat,eq}\\approx\nV_{GS}-V_{T}+V_{x}$, only a few $100\\,{\\rm mV}$\nlarger than a single device, versus $2(V_{GS}-V_{T})$\nfor a conventional cascode with separate bias.\n\nDrawbacks: $M_{1}$ in triode adds its thermal\nnoise as $4kTg_{ds1}$ and the swing is reduced\nby $V_{x}$, headroom $V_{out,min}\\approx\nI_{D}r_{ds1}+V_{DS,sat2}$.\n\nFor hand calculation with $\\lambda =0$,\n$A_{v}=-g_{m1}R_{D}$, the same as a simple\ncommon source with $R_{D}$, but the real\n$\\lambda\\ne 0$ gain is higher because\n$R_{D}\\parallel R_{o}\\approx R_{D}$ is larger\nthan $R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$ of the simple stage.\nIf $R_{D}$ is replaced by a $PMOS$ current source\n$R_{D}=r_{op}$, the gain improvement is fully\nrealized: $A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}(r_{op}\\parallel\ng_{m2}r_{o2}r_{ds1})$.\n\nThis is widely used as a low voltage high gain\nload, ``double length'' or ``composite''\ntransistor in $CMOS$ $op$-amps.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d36152704a163338b027c8d91e169cf7a14bda1e2df19dff09d34559a993622a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the common-gated series NMOS structure, the lower device in triode, and the effective length L1+L2. But it then claims cascode-like output-resistance and gain multiplication, contrary to the modest output-resistance increase expected here; that is a significant design-consequence error.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f4c42a319616e7d942081a3389417d0f1c64822932dcec21eebd003d9f6660ad",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1523,
        "output_tokens": 11040,
        "total_tokens": 12563,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7777,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1523,
        "output_tokens": 11040,
        "total_tokens": 12563,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7777,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 25,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel/figure-19.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a ${\\ldouble }N$ type ${\\it self\\;cascode}$ or\n${\\it composite\\; }W/L$ common source stage.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}&: CS \\;\\;S_{1}=0\\;\\;D_{1}=S_{2}\\;\\;G_{1}=V_{in}\\cr\nM_{2}&: CG \\;\\;D_{2}=V_{out}\\;\\;G_{2}=V_{in}\\cr\nR_{D}&: passive\\;load\\;to\\;V_{DD}}$$\n\nDrawn as laid out the bulks are\n\n* $B_{1}=0$ on $S_{1}$\n* $B_{2}=S_{2}$ on arrow\n\nso $g_{mb2}=0$. In a bulk $n$ substrate\n$B_{2}=0$ and you have to keep $g_{mb2}\\ne\n0$ and $V_{T2}=V_{T0}+\\gamma \\left(\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}+V_{x}}-\n\\sqrt{2\\phi _{F}}\\right)$ . Formally replace $g_{m2}$ by\n$g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$ below.\n\nIt is normally used as a 2 $T$ composite\ndevice $M_{eq}=M_{1}+M_{2}$ in series with\ncommon gate.\n\n### 1. Large signal - composite $W/L$\n\nPut $k_{i}=\\mu C_{ox}W_{i}/L_{i}$, $V_{Gx}=V_{x}=$\nvoltage at $D_{1}=S_{2}$.\n\n$$V_{GS1}=V_{in}\\;\\;\\;V_{DS1}=V_{x}$$\n$$V_{GS2}=V_{in}-V_{x}\\;\\;\\;V_{DS2}=V_{out}-V_{x}$$\n\nCut off:\n\n$$V_{in}<V_{T}\\;:\\;I_{D}=0\\;,\\;V_{out}=V_{DD}$$\n\nAbove $V_{T}$ the two currents must be\nequal\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{D}= {V_{DD}-V_{out}\\over R_{D}}$$\n\nIf the composite is saturated as a whole the\nupper device is saturated and the lower device\nis in triode. E. g. $k_{1}=k_{2}=k$,\n$\\lambda =0$ :\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{D}&=k\\left[(V_{in}-V_{T})V_{x}-V_{x}^{2}/2\\right]\n      = {k\\over 2}(V_{in}-V_{x}-V_{T})^{2}\\cr\nV_{x}&\\approx 0.29\\;(V_{in}-V_{T})\\cr\nI_{D}&\\approx {k\\over 4}(V_{in}-V_{T})^{2}\n      ={k_{eq}\\over 2}(V_{in}-V_{T})^{2}}$$\n\nIn general for $V_{out}>V_{in}-V_{T}$, composite\nsaturation :\n\n$$I_{D}\\approx {1\\over 2}\\mu C_{ox}\\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{eq}\n(V_{in}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{eq}V_{out})$$\n\nwith\n\n$${1\\over (W/L)_{eq}}={1\\over (W_{1}/L_{1})}+{1\\over (W_{2}/L_{2})}\n\\qquad {\\rm e.g.}\\;(W/L)_{eq}=(W/L)/2\\;{\\rm for}\\;W_{1}=W_{2},L_{1}=L_{2}$$\n\n$$L_{eq}\\approx L_{1}+L_{2}\\qquad V_{A,eq}\\approx V_{A1}+V_{A2}$$\n$$r_{o,eq}\\approx {1\\over \\lambda_{eq}I_{D}}\\gg r_{o1},r_{o2}$$\n\ni. e. the stack acts like a single long channel\ndevice to first order. The condition for the\nstack to stay saturated is\n\n$$V_{out}\\ge V_{GS,eq}-V_{T}=V_{DSAT1}+V_{DSAT2}$$\n\nso it costs one $V_{DSAT}$ more head room than\na single $T$.\n\nFor $V_{out}< V_{in}-V_{T}$ $M_{2}$ goes triode,\nfor large $V_{in}$ both $M_{1},M_{2}$ triode\n\n$$R_{on,i}\\approx \\left[ k_{i}(V_{in}-V_{T})\\right]^{-1}$$\n$$V_{OL}=V_{DD}{R_{on1}+R_{on2}\\over R_{D}+R_{on1}+R_{on2}} > V_{OL,1T}$$\n\nThe DC transfer $V_{out}(V_{in})$ is the normal\n$NMOS$ inverter with $R_{D}$ load, threshold\n\n$$V_{M}:V_{in}=V_{out}\\;:\\;{V_{DD}-V_{M}\\over R_{D}}=\n{k_{eq}\\over 2}(V_{M}-V_{T})^{2}$$\n\nwith $V_{OH}=V_{DD}$,\n$V_{OL}$ above, high small signal gain at $V_{M}$.\n\n### 2. Small signal - low frequency\n\nGate impedance $=\\infty$.\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx \\infty $$\n\nSmall signal with channel length modulation,\n$g_{ds}=1/r_{o}$ :\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{d1}&=g_{m1}v_{in}+g_{ds1}v_{x}\\cr\ni_{d2}&=g_{m2}(v_{in}-v_{x})+g_{mb2}(-v_{x})+g_{ds2}(v_{out}-v_{x})\\cr\ni_{d1}&=i_{d2}\\cr\ni_{d2}&=-v_{out}/R_{D}}$$\n\ngives in exact form for $g_{mb2}=0$:\n\n$$A_{v}={v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=\n -R_{D}{g_{m1}r_{o1}+g_{m2}r_{o2}+g_{m1}r_{o1}g_{m2}r_{o2}\n \\over R_{D}+r_{o1}+r_{o2}+g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}} \\tag{1}$$\n\nwith $g_{mb2}\\ne 0$ replace $g_{m2}\\to g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$\nin the denominator and $g_{m2}r_{o2}\\to (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}$ in\nthe cross term.\n\nFor $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$ :\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}\\;R_{D}\\;{1+{\\cal O}(1/g_{m}r_{o})\\over\n1+{R_{D}\\over r_{o,eq}}}$$\n\nwhere the impedance looking into $D_{2}$ with\n$v_{in}=0$, i. e. $G_{2}$ ac ground, is the normal\ncascode resistance\n\n$$R_{o,eq}= r_{o1}+r_{o2}+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o1}r_{o2}\n\\approx (g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o1}r_{o2}\\gg r_{o1},r_{o2}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel R_{o,eq}\\right)$$\n\nand for the usual $R_{D}\\ll R_{o,eq}$\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}R_{D}$$\n\n$$|A_{v0}|\\approx g_{m,eq}r_{o,eq}\\approx g_{m1}r_{o,eq}\n\\gg g_{m1}r_{o1}$$\n\nFormally $g_{m,eq}\\approx g_{m1}$ - the upper\ngate being driven does ${\\it not}$ double $g_{m}$\nbecause $v_{x}$ follows $v_{in}$ and\n$V_{GS2}=v_{in}-v_{x}$ is small. The short circuit\ncurrent is $\\approx g_{m1}v_{in}$.\n\nWith an active $PMOS$ load $R_{D}\\to r_{op}$\nthe improvement is large: $A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}\n\\left(r_{o,eq}\\parallel r_{op}\\right)$ which can be\n$10-20\\,{\\rm dB}$ higher than a single $T$\n$CS$ stage of the same $W/L$.\n\nThe output resistance at the $V_{out}$ node is\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{o,eq}\\approx R_{D}\\quad{\\rm if\\;\nR_{D}\\;is\\;passive}$$\n\n### 3. Remarks\n\n* To first order the circuit can be analysed as a\nnormal $CS$ stage with device $M_{eq}$ : $W_{eq}$ above,\n$L_{eq}=L_{1}+L_{2}$, $g_{m}=g_{m1}$, $r_{o}=R_{o,eq}$.\n* Advantage over a single device: $r_{o}$ increased by\n$\\times g_{m}r_{o}$, short channel effects, DIBL,\n$\\lambda $ reduced by channel length doubling without\nrequiring a separate cascode bias. Compact layout - shared\ndiffusion.\n* The same composite is widely used as high swing\nself-biased cascode current mirror / load,\nband-gap, op-amp input stage, etc. where no extra bias\nvoltage is available and low voltage operation is required.\n* Cost: $V_{DSAT,eq}=V_{DSAT1}+V_{DSAT2}$, lower $I_{D}$ for\ngiven $W$, larger $C_{gg}=C_{gs1}+C_{gs2}+C_{gd2}(1-A_{v})$\nMiller, extra pole at $v_{x}$ :\n\n$$p_{out}\\approx -{1\\over R_{out}C_{L}}\\;,\\;\np_{x}\\approx -{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}\\over C_{x}}$$\n$$C_{x}\\approx C_{gs2}+C_{sb2}+C_{db1}+C_{gd1}$$\n\nwhich is non dominant if $g_{m2}/C_{x} \\gg 1/R_{out}C_{L}$.\n* Noise: ${\\overline {v_{n}^{2}}}\\approx 4kT\\gamma\n(g_{m1}+g_{m2})/g_{m1}^{2}+K_{F}/WLC_{ox}f$.\n\nIn short: DC inverter $V_{OH}=V_{DD}$, $V_{OL}$ slightly\nhigher than $1T$ case, AC it is a common source\namplifier with effective transconductance $g_{m1}$, effective\noutput impedance $g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}$ and voltage gain\n$\\approx -g_{m1}R_{D}$ for $R_{D}$ load, $\\approx\n-g_{m1}R_{o,eq}$ for active load, input impedance\ncapacitive $\\infty$ at DC.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ba5775450ee7d0ba832e044ebd4d2affa92a38a8bf015d1a4b4b4457caac62bf"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the common-gate-driven stack, the lower device’s triode operation, and the effective channel length of approximately L1 + L2. However, it then analyzes the stack as a true cascode and claims a gm·ro-multiplied output resistance, a major error that contradicts the actual modest output-resistance increase.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f4c42a319616e7d942081a3389417d0f1c64822932dcec21eebd003d9f6660ad",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1523,
        "output_tokens": 12309,
        "total_tokens": 13832,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9597,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1523,
        "output_tokens": 12309,
        "total_tokens": 13832,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9597,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 25,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-025-series-nmos-effective-long-channel/figure-19.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the $M_{1} \\times M_{2}$ {\\it composite}\nor {\\it self cascoded} common source stage.\nWith small $R_{D}$ it is the normal $C.S$.\nWith large $R_{D}$ it is formally a cascode with\n$R_{D}\\parallel R_{o}\\approx R_{o}$.\n\n$$S_{1}= {\\rm bulk}-S_{1}\\;\\;,\\;\\;S_{2}={\\rm bulk}-S_{2}$$\n\nso that ideally $g_{mb}=0$ for small signal.\nIf the bulk is to $GND$ $g_{m2}\\rightarrow g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark} on large signal: With long channel\n> square law and $V_{T1}=V_{T2}$ the two devices\n> can {\\it not} both be saturated with $V_{G1}=V_{G2}$.\n> For\n\n$$I_{D1}= {\\beta_{1}\\over 2}(V_{in}-V_{T})^{2}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\n  I_{D2}= {\\beta_{2}\\over 2}(V_{in}-V_{x}-V_{T})^{2}$$\n\n$I_{D1}=I_{D2}\\Rightarrow $\n\n$$V_{x}=V_{DS1}=(1-\\sqrt{\\beta_{1}/\\beta_{2}})(V_{in}-V_{T})<V_{in}-V_{T}$$\n\nso $M_{1}$ is linear, $M_{2}$ is saturated for the\nnormal high $V_{out}$ bias, Fig.1.  The composite as a\nwhole is saturated.  Let $Y=V_{in}-V_{T}$\n\n$$ \\beta_{1}(YV_{x}-V_{x}^{2}/2)= {\\beta_{2}\\over 2}(Y-V_{x})^{2}$$\n\n$$\\;V_{x}=Y\\left[1-\\sqrt{{\\beta_{1}\\over \\beta_{1}+\\beta_{2}}}\\right]\\;  $$\n\n$$\\;I_{D}= {\\beta_{c}\\over 2}Y^{2}\\;\\;,\\;\\;{\\beta_{c}={\\beta_{1}\\beta_{2}\\over \\beta_{1}+\\beta_{2}}}\\;$$\n\nFor $\\beta_{1}=\\beta_{2}=\\beta$\n\n$$V_{x}\\approx 0.30\\,Y\\qquad I_{D}\\approx {\\beta\\over 4}Y^{2}$$\n\ni.e. the series combination is equivalent to one\ndevice with\n\n$$\\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{c}^{-1}=\\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{1}^{-1}\n      +\\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{2}^{-1}\\qquad L_{c}=L_{1}+L_{2}$$\n\nin first order.  If you keep both devices\nin saturation by e.g. different $V_{T}$ or short\nchannel effects the small signal description below\nwith both $r_{o}'s$ is conventionally used in\ntext books. In that idealised case $M_{1}$ is taken\nas saturated. The formulas remain formally the same\nwith $g_{m1},g_{o1}$ taken as triode values,\n$g_{o1}\\gg g_{o2}$.\n\n### 1. Small signal model\n\nPut $v_{in}=v_{g1}=v_{g2}$, $v_{x}=v_{d1}=v_{s2}$,\n$v_{o}=v_{d2}$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{d1}&=g_{m1}v_{in}+g_{o1}v_{x}\\cr\ni_{d2}&=g_{m2}(v_{in}-v_{x})+g_{o2}(v_{o}-v_{x})\\cr\ni_{d1}&=i_{d2}=i_{o}\\cr\nv_{o}&=-i_{o}R_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm if}\\;R_{D}{\\rm\\;is\\;the\\;load}}$$\n\n$$ (g_{o1}+g_{m2}+g_{o2})v_{x}=(g_{m2}-g_{m1})v_{in}+g_{o2}v_{o}$$\n$$ (1+g_{o2}R_{D})v_{o}+g_{m2}R_{D}v_{in}=(g_{m2}+g_{o2})R_{D}v_{x}$$\n\nEliminating $v_{x}$\n\n$$v_{o}\\left[g_{o1}+g_{m2}+g_{o2}+g_{o1}g_{o2}R_{D}\\right]\n      =-R_{D}\\left[g_{m1}g_{m2}+g_{m1}g_{o2}+g_{m2}g_{o1}\\right]v_{in}$$\n\n$$\\;A_{v}={v_{o}\\over v_{in}}=\n   -R_{D}{{g_{m1}g_{m2}+g_{m1}g_{o2}+g_{m2}g_{o1}}\n               \\over {g_{m2}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}+g_{o1}g_{o2}R_{D}}}\\; \\tag{1}$$\n\nFor $g_{m}\\gg g_{o}$  numerator $\\approx g_{m1}g_{m2}$,\ndenominator $\\approx g_{m2}+g_{o1}g_{o2}R_{D}$.\n\n### 2. Output resistance\n\nPut $v_{in}=0$, apply $v_{x}=V_{test}$ at drain of\n$M_{2}$.\n\n$$g_{o1}v_{x1}= -g_{m2}v_{x1}+g_{o2}(V_{test}-v_{x1})$$\n\n$$v_{x1}= {g_{o2}\\over g_{o1}+g_{m2}+g_{o2}}V_{test}$$\n\n$$I_{test}=g_{o1}v_{x1}= {g_{o1}g_{o2}\\over g_{o1}+g_{m2}+g_{o2}}V_{test}$$\n\n$$\\;R_{o}\\equiv {V_{test}\\over I_{test}}\n        ={g_{o1}+g_{m2}+g_{o2}\\over g_{o1}g_{o2}}\n        =r_{o1}+r_{o2}+g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2}\\; \\tag{2}$$\n\nwith body effect $g_{m2}\\rightarrow g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$,\n\n$$R_{o}=r_{o1}+r_{o2}+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o1}r_{o2}\\approx\n (g_{m2}r_{o2})r_{o1}$$\n\nThis is formally the cascode resistance.  With\n$g_{in}=0$, $v_{in}=0$ it is the same as a cascode\nbecause the two gates are AC ground for $R_{o}$.\n\nFor the real bias $M_{1}$ linear,\n$g_{o1}=\\beta_{1}(Y-V_{x})\\approx g_{m2}\\sim \\beta Y$,\n$g_{o2}= \\lambda I_{D}\\ll g_{o1}$ ,\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx {g_{o1}+g_{m2}\\over g_{o1}g_{o2}}\\approx {2\\over g_{o2}}=2r_{o2}$$\n\ni.e. only $\\times 2$ over a single device.  If both\ndevices are forced saturated e.g. by $V_{T}$ engineering\n$R_{o}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}^{2}\\gg r_{o}$.\n\nEq.(1) can be written with (2) as\n\n$$A_{v}= -(R_{D}\\parallel R_{o})\\,\n        {{g_{m1}g_{m2}+g_{m1}g_{o2}+g_{m2}g_{o1}\\over g_{o1}+g_{m2}+g_{o2}}}$$\n\n$$\\;A_{v}\\approx -(R_{D}\\parallel R_{o})\\,G_{m}\\;$$\n\n$$G_{m}={g_{m1}g_{m2}+g_{m1}g_{o2}+g_{m2}g_{o1}\\over g_{m2}+g_{o1}+g_{o2}}\n \\xrightarrow[g_{o}\\ll g_{m}]{}g_{m1}$$\n\nand for matched devices $G_{m}=g_{m}$ exactly.\nI.e.\n\n$$\\;A_{v}\\approx -g_{m1}\\,(R_{D}\\parallel R_{o})\\;\n      \\approx -g_{m1}R_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;R_{D}\\ll R_{o}\\; \\tag{3}$$\n\nNormal cascode gain $-g_{m1}(R_{D}\\parallel g_{m2}r_{o1}r_{o2})$\nis recovered. With ideal current source load\n$R_{D}\\rightarrow \\infty$\n\n$$|A_{v0}|\\approx g_{m1}R_{o}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}\\;{\\rm for\\;triode\\;}M_{1}\n  \\approx g_{m}^{2}r_{o}^{2}\\;{\\rm for\\;ideal\\;saturated\\;}M_{1}M_{2}$$\n\n### 3. Large signal inverter characteristic\n\n* $V_{in}<V_{T}$ : $M_{1},M_{2}$ off, $I_{D}=0$, $V_{out}=V_{DD}$\n* $V_{T}<V_{in}<V_{DD}-|V_{T}|+V_{x}$ : $M_{1}$ linear,\n  $M_{2}$ saturated. $V_{out}=V_{DD}-R_{D}I_{D}(V_{in})$,\n  $I_{D}=(\\beta_{c}/2)(V_{in}-V_{T})^{2}$, inverting\n  high gain region with slope (3).\n* $V_{out}<V_{in}-V_{T}$ : $M_{2}$ enters triode,\n  both linear, $V_{out}=V_{OL}=I_{D}R_{on}\\approx 0$.\n\n$V_{M}$ where $V_{in}=V_{out}$ is shifted to higher\n$V_{in}$ with respect to a single $W/L$ device because\n$\\beta_{c}<\\beta_{1}$.\n\nInput impedance $Z_{in}\\approx 1/s(C_{gs1}+C_{gs2}+C_{gd2}(1-A_{v}))$\ncapacitive, very high at DC.  Miller multiplication is\nessentially by $C_{gd2}$ only; $C_{gd1}$ is between\n$v_{in}$ and $v_{x}\\approx 0.3v_{in}$ so Miller $\\approx 0.7$.\n\nIn short: at DC it is a logic inverter / common source\namplifier whose pull down is a composite NMOS of effective\nlength $L_{1}+L_{2}$. To first order it gives the same\n$g_{m}$ as $M_{1}$ but with $r_{o}$ multiplied by\n$g_{m}r_{o}$ in the ideal saturated limit, and by $\\sim 2$\nin the ordinary $V_{T}$ matched long channel bias. It is\nwidely used as self cascode current mirror, high swing\ncascode load and as a way to get a long $L$ device without\na long $L$ layout. Drawbacks: $\\sim C_{gs1}+C_{gs2}$ input\ncap, limited headroom $V_{DS,sat,c}=V_{DS,sat1}+V_{DS,sat2}$,\nsomewhat lower $f_{T}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "459afba110516e406c69779052ae9e6267961426c7ca6f6aad4a948aa06d5015"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the common-gate series NMOS composite, places M1 in triode and M2 in saturation, and derives the effective channel length as approximately L1 + L2. Its actual-bias output resistance is also correctly distinguished from the hypothetical both-saturated cascode case.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f4c42a319616e7d942081a3389417d0f1c64822932dcec21eebd003d9f6660ad",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1507,
        "input_tokens": 1523,
        "output_tokens": 13346,
        "total_tokens": 14869,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10533,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1507,
        "input_tokens": 1523,
        "output_tokens": 13346,
        "total_tokens": 14869,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10533,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 26,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate/figure-20.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the $NMOS$, $n-$ channel\n{\\it long tail} or {\\it source coupled pair} with\nsingle sided resistive load. In bipolar form the\nvacuum tube form.\n\n$$M_{1}-M_{2}:{\\rm pair}\\;\\;{\\rm sources\\;common}\\;\\;{\\rm on}\\;I_{1}$$\n$$M_{1}:G=V_{in}\\;\\;D=V_{DD}{\\rm\\;ac\\;0}\\equiv {\\rm CD}$$\n$$M_{2}:G=V_{b}{\\rm\\;ac\\;0}\\;\\;D=R_{D}{\\rm\\;to\\;}V_{DD}\\equiv {\\rm CG}$$\n\nso the circuit is a ${\\rm CD}$ driving a ${\\rm CG}$.\nWith $V_{b}= {\\rm ac\\;0}$ it is a non inverting\nvoltage amplifier and with $V_{b}\\ne 0$ it is\na $V_{in}-V_{b}$ differential to single ended\ntransducer. For $|V_{in}-V_{b}|$\nsmall enough both devices are saturated.\n\n> In the normal form both drains have a $R_{D}$ and\n> the balanced differential output is $g_{m}R_{D}(V_{in}-V_{b})$.\n> With one $R_{D}$ omitted the single ended output is\n> $1/2$ of that.\n\n### 1. Qualitative\n\n$I_{1}=I_{D1}+I_{D2}= {\\rm const}$ for ideal tail.\n\nIncrease $V_{in}\\to$ $V_{GS1}\\uparrow \\to I_{D1}\\uparrow \\to$\nsince $I_{1}$ const $I_{D2}\\downarrow \\to $ drop on\n$R_{D}$ $\\downarrow \\to V_{out}=V_{DD}-I_{D2}R_{D}\\uparrow$.\nInverting w.r.t. $M_{2}$, non inverting w.r.t. $M_{1}$.\n\nIn square law, $W/L$ matched:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{D1}&={1\\over 2}\\mu_{n}C_{ox}{W\\over L}\\left(V_{GS1}-V_{T}\\right)^{2} \\cr\nI_{D2}&={1\\over 2}\\mu_{n}C_{ox}{W\\over L}\\left(V_{GS2}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}}$$\n\nPut $K={1\\over 2}\\mu_{n}C_{ox}W/L$, $\\Delta V=V_{in}-V_{b}$\n\n$$V_{GS1}-V_{GS2}=\\Delta V$$\n\n$$I_{D1,2}={I_{1}\\over 2}\\pm {\\Delta V\\over 2}\\sqrt{2KI_{1}-K^{2}\\Delta V^{2}}$$\n\n$$|\\Delta V| <\\sqrt{2I_{1}/K}= \\sqrt{2}V_{ov}$$\n\nlinear for $|\\Delta V|\\ll V_{ov}$ and one device cuts\noff for $|\\Delta V| >\\sqrt{2}V_{ov}$. Then\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{DD}-R_{D}I_{D2} \\tag{*}$$\n\nis the large signal transfer characteristic. At balance\n$\\Delta V=0$\n\n$$I_{D10}=I_{D20}=I_{1}/2\\qquad V_{outQ}=V_{DD}-{I_{1}\\over 2}R_{D}$$\n\n$$V_{DS1}=V_{DD}-V_{X}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{DS2}=V_{outQ}-V_{X}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$V_{X}=V_{in}-V_{GS1}=V_{b}-V_{GS2}$$\n\nmust stay $>V_{ov}$ for saturation and\n\n$$V_{X}>V_{DSAT(I_{1})}$$\n\nto keep the tail in saturation. Hence\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{in(min)} &\\approx V_{GS}+V_{DSATtail}\\cr\nV_{in(max)} &\\approx V_{DD}+V_{T}\\;\\;{\\rm CD\\;can\\;go\\;to\\;}V_{DD}\\cr\nV_{out(min)}&=V_{X}+V_{DSAT2}\\cr\nV_{out(max)}&=V_{DD}}$$\n\n### 2. Small signal, differential mode\n\nPut $v_{b}=0$, $v_{dd}=0$. Neglect for the moment\n$g_{ds}=r_{o}^{-1}$, $g_{mb}$ and $R_{tail}=r_{oI_{1}}$.\n\n$$v_{gs1}=v_{in}-v_{x}\\qquad v_{gs2}=-v_{x}$$\n\n$$i_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{gs1}\\qquad i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{gs2}$$\n\nTail ac KCL: ideal $R_{tail}=\\infty$\n\n$$i_{d1}+i_{d2}=0\\tag{1}$$\nfor finite $R_{tail}$, $i_{d1}+i_{d2}=v_{x}/R_{tail}$.\n\nOutput KCL:\n\n$$i_{d2}= -v_{out}/R_{D}\\tag{2}$$\nmore exactly $i_{d2}= -v_{out}/R_{D}+g_{ds2}(v_{out}-v_{x})$ etc.\n\nFrom (1)\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in}-v_{x})-g_{m2}v_{x}=0$$\n\n$$v_{x}={g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}v_{in} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$CD$ voltage follower gain $<1$ loaded by the $CG$ input\n$1/g_{m2}$.\n\nFrom (2)-(3)\n\n$$v_{out}= -i_{d2}R_{D}=g_{m2}R_{D}v_{x}$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}={g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}R_{D} \\tag{4}$$\n\nFor $g_{m1}=g_{m2}=g_{m}$\n\n$$A_{v0}=+{1\\over 2}g_{m}R_{D}\\tag{5}$$\n\nnon inverting. This is $1/2$ the balanced\ndifferential pair gain $g_{m}R_{D}$.\n\nIn general if $v_{b}\\ne 0$\n\n$$v_{out}={g_{m}R_{D}\\over 2}\\left(v_{in}-v_{b}\\right)=A_{d}(v_{in}-v_{b})\\tag{6}$$\n\n$$A_{d}=g_{m}R_{D}/2$$\n\nWith $r_{o}$:\n\n$$A_{v}= {g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}g_{m2}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel R_{o2}\\right)$$\n\n$$R_{o2}\\approx r_{o2}+(1+g_{m2}r_{o2})R_{S}$$\n\n$$R_{S}=R_{tail}\\parallel {1\\over g_{m1}}\\parallel r_{o1}$$\n\nso for $R_{tail}\\gg 1/g_{m}$\n\n$$R_{o2}\\approx r_{o2}+{1+g_{m2}r_{o2}\\over g_{m1}}\\approx 2r_{o}\\;\\;{\\rm matched}$$\n\nNormally $R_{D}\\ll R_{o2}$ and\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx {1\\over 2}g_{m}(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o})\\tag{7}$$\n\nWith body effect, bulk $=GND$, $v_{bs1}=v_{bs2}=-v_{x}$,\n$g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$ for the source node:\n\n$$v_{x}={g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}v_{in}$$\n\n$$v_{out}=(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})R_{D}v_{x}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nA_{v}&={g_{m1}(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\over \\sum (g_{m}+g_{mb})}R_{D}\\cr\n&\\approx {g_{m}R_{D}\\over 2(1+\\chi/2)}\\;\\;,\\;\\chi=g_{mb}/g_{m}\\approx 0.2-0.3}$$\n\nIf the $n$-well process ties bulk to source, $g_{mb}=0$.\n\n> No Miller multiplication: $C_{gd1}$ is from input to\n> ac ground, $C_{gd2}$ from output to ac ground.\n> So bandwith is $CD-CG$ i.e. cascode like.\n\n### 3. Impedances\n\n$$Z_{in}=1/sC_{gs1}\\approx \\infty \\;{\\rm low\\;freq.}$$\n\nOutput seen by $R_{D}$ is the $CG$ output\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{o2}\\approx R_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm if}\\;R_{D}\\ll r_{o}$$\n\n$$R_{out}\\approx R_{D}\\parallel \\left[{1\\over g_{ds2}}+(1+{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}\\over g_{ds2}}) (R_{tail}\\parallel {1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}})\\right]$$\n\n### 4. Common mode\n\nPut $v_{in}=v_{b}=v_{cm}$. By symmetry $i_{d1}=i_{d2}=v_{x}/2R_{tail}$\nand $v_{x}\\approx v_{cm}$. More exactly\n\n$$A_{cm}={v_{out}\\over v_{cm}}\\approx -{R_{D}\\over 2R_{tail}}{1\\over 1+g_{mb}/g_{m}}$$\n\n$$|A_{cm}|\\approx {R_{D}\\over 2R_{tail}}\\ll |A_{d}|$$\n\n$$CMRR=|A_{d}/A_{cm}|\\approx g_{m}R_{tail}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$10^{2}-10^{3}$ with simple tail, $10^{4}$ with cascode tail.\n$PSRR\\approx A_{d}$ for supply on $R_{D}$.\n\n### 5. Frequency response\n\nDominant pole $p_{o}=1/R_{D}C_{L}$ at output,\nnon dominant pole at common source node\n\n$$p_{s}\\approx {g_{m1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb1}+g_{mb2}\\over C_{X}}$$\n\n$$C_{X}=C_{sb1}+C_{sb2}+C_{gs1}+C_{gs2}+C_{tail}$$\n\n$p_{s}\\gg p_{o}$ giving single pole behavior to high\nfrequency, which is why the pair is universally used\nas the input stage of op amps, comparators, $CML$,\nsource coupled logic, Gilbert mixers, etc.\n\nIn short: a high $Z_{in}$, moderate $Z_{out}\\approx R_{D}$,\nmoderate non-inverting voltage gain $g_{m}R_{D}/2$,\nexcellent common mode and supply rejection if $R_{tail}$\nis large, wide common mode input range to $V_{DD}$,\nno Miller effect. Replacing $R_{D}$ by a $PMOS$\ncurrent mirror gives $g_{m}r_{o}$ gain and full\ndifferential to single ended conversion.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bf648d810e63a0d00b4993ece1e499edbb20f1df03c907977d012daf3cd2c95b"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-coupled pair as a source follower driving a common-gate stage, with M2’s gate at Vb and output at its drain. It also gives the correct non-inverting signal behavior and gain; extra details do not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5f76b34ca8287a0570c6f002e2eadb7a24e8054bf59e90b39e7d140a788b3c2c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2469,
        "output_tokens": 8470,
        "total_tokens": 10939,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5921,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2469,
        "output_tokens": 8470,
        "total_tokens": 10939,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5921,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 26,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate/figure-20.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the NMOS resistive load differential\npair in single ended form and, up to a\nd.c. level shift, the $M_{1}-M_{2}$\nsource coupled common drain-common gate\ncascade.\n\n$$M_{1}:CD\\;\\;{\\rm or}\\;SF\\qquad M_{2}:CG$$\n\n$$D_{1}\\to {\\rm ac\\;ground}\\;\\;G_{2}\\to {\\rm ac\\;ground}=V_{b}$$\n$$S_{1}=S_{2}=P\\to I_{1},R_{T}=r_{oT}$$\n\nin small signal $v_{b}=0$.\n\nLarge signal quiescent if $M_{1}=M_{2}$ and\n$V_{inQ}=V_{b}$:\n\n$$I_{D1Q}=I_{D2Q}=I_{1}/2$$\n\n$$V_{GS}=V_{T}+V_{ov}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{ov}=\\sqrt{\\frac{I_{1}}\n{\\mu _{n}C_{ox}(W/L)}}$$\n\n$$g_{m}=\\sqrt{2\\mu _{n}C_{ox}(W/L)I_{DQ}}=\n\\frac{2I_{DQ}}{V_{ov}}$$\n\n$$V_{SQ}=V_{inQ}-V_{GS1}=V_{b}-V_{GS2}$$\n\n$$V_{outQ}=V_{DD}-I_{D2Q}R_{D}=V_{DD}-\\frac{I_{1}R_{D}}{2}$$\n\nfor square law\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{D1}-I_{D2} &\\approx {\\cal G}(V_{in}-V_{b})\n\\sqrt{1-\\left({\\cal G}(V_{in}-V_{b})/I_{1}\\right)^{2}}\\cr\n|V_{in}-V_{b}|&<\\sqrt{2}V_{ov}}$$\n\nso steering of $I_{1}$ from $M_{2}$ to $M_{1}$\nfor $v_{in}>0$.\n\n> $${\\rm sign:}\\;v_{in}\\uparrow \\to v_{P}\\uparrow\n> \\to |v_{gs2}|\\downarrow \\to i_{d2}\\downarrow\n> \\to i_{R_{D}}\\downarrow \\to v_{out}\\uparrow $$\n> non inverting.\n\n$$I_{T}=I_{D1}+I_{D2}={\\rm cst.}\\;\\;{\\rm to}\\;1/R_{T}$$\n\nIn saturation\n\n$$V_{P}>V_{in}-V_{T}-V_{ov1}\\qquad \nV_{P}>V_{b}-V_{T}-V_{ov2}$$\nand for $I_{1}$ to stay saturated\n\n$$V_{P}>V_{oT}+V_{ovT}$$\nand for $M_{2}$ to stay saturated\n\n$$V_{out}>V_{P}+V_{ov2}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{out}<V_{DD}$$\n\ni. e. limited common mode range.\n\n### Small signal\n\n$$v_{gs1}=v_{in}-v_{p}\\qquad v_{gs2}=-v_{p}\\qquad\nv_{bsi}=-v_{p}$$\n$$v_{ds1}=-v_{p}\\qquad v_{ds2}=v_{out}-v_{p}$$\n\n$$i_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{gs1}+g_{mb1}v_{bs1}+g_{ds1}v_{ds1}$$\n$$i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{gs2}+g_{mb2}v_{bs2}+g_{ds2}v_{ds2}$$\n\nwith $g_{dsi}=r_{oi}^{-1}$.\n\nNodal ${\\rm ac\\;ground}=V_{DD}$.\n\n$$P: \\;i_{d1}+i_{d2}=v_{p}G_{T}\\tag{1}$$\n$$D_{2}: \\;v_{out}G_{D}+i_{d2}=0\\;\\;{\\rm i.e.}\\tag{2}$$\n$$v_{out}/R_{D}+(v_{out}-v_{p})g_{ds2}\n+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})(-v_{p})=0$$\n\nFrom (2)\n\n$$v_{out}\\left(G_{D}+g_{ds2}\\right)=\nv_{p}\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}\\right) \\tag{3}$$\n\n$$v_{out}=v_{p}\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}\\right)\nR_{D}\\parallel r_{o2}$$\n\nFrom (1)\n\n$$g_{m1}v_{in}+v_{out}g_{ds2}=\nv_{p}\\left[G_{T}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+\ng_{m2}+g_{mb2}\\right]\\tag{4}$$\n\nand with (3)\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{out}\\over v_{in}}=\n{{g_{m1}\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}\\right)\nR_{D}\\parallel r_{o2}}\\over\n{G_{T}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}\n-\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+g_{ds2}\\right){R_{D}\\parallel r_{o2}\\over r_{o2}}}}$$\n\n$$A_{v}=\ng_{m1}R_{D}{\\left[(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}+1\\right]\\over\n(R_{D}+r_{o2})\\left(G_{T}+g_{ds1}+g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\right)\n+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}+1}\\tag{5}$$\n\nNormally $r_{oi}\\gg R_{D}$ , $G_{T}\\ll g_{m}$\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx {{g_{m1}\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}\\right)\nR_{D}}\\over {g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+G_{T}}}\n\\;{1\\over 1+{\\cal O}(G_{D}r_{o}^{-1})}\\tag{6}$$\n\nIn the usual neglect $g_{mb}=0$, $r_{o}\\to \\infty $,\n$R_{T}\\to \\infty $\n\n$${{v_{p}\\approx {g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}v_{in}}}$$\n\nis the source follower division on to the\ncommon source node, and\n\n$$v_{out}\\approx g_{m2}R_{D}v_{p}$$\n\nis the common gate gain, so that\n\n$$A_{v0}\\approx {g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}R_{D}>0 \\tag{7}$$\n\nFor the matched pair $g_{m1}=g_{m2}=g_{m}$,\n\n$$A_{v0}\\approx {1\\over 2}g_{m}R_{D}\\tag{8}$$\n\nwith $g_{mb}\\ne 0$\n\n$$A_{v0}\\approx {g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\n\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}\\right)R_{D}$$\n\nand for the matched case $g_{mb1}=g_{mb2}=g_{mb}$\n\n$$A_{v0}\\approx {1\\over 2}g_{m}R_{D}$$\n\nto first order $g_{mb}$ cancels, the more exact\n(5) gives $A_{v}\\approx\ng_{m}R_{D}/2\\left[1-(g_{mb}/g_{m})R_{D}/r_{o}\\right]$.\n\nI. e. half the gain of the common source stage with\nthe same $R_{D}$ and same bias current.\nIf the tail is not ideal $G_{T}=1/R_{T}\\ne 0$\n\n$$A_{v}= {A_{v0}\\over 1+G_{T}/(g_{m1}+g_{m2})}$$\n\nCommon mode gain with $v_{in}=v_{b}=v_{cm}$:\n\n$$A_{cm}\\approx -{R_{D}\\over 2R_{T}}{g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}\n\\approx -{R_{D}\\over 4R_{T}}\\to 0\\;{\\rm for}\\;R_{T}\\to \\infty $$\n\nso\n\n$${\\rm CMRR}=|A_{d}/A_{cm}|\\approx g_{m}R_{T}$$\n\ndifferential pair behaviour.\n\n* Input resistance: Gate input\n\n$$R_{in}=1/j\\omega C_{gs1}\\approx \\infty \\;{\\rm at\\;LF}$$\n\nof the order of ${\\rm G\\Omega }$.\n\n* Output resistance: at $v_{in}=0$ looking into $D_{2}$\n\n$$R_{o}=R_{D}\\parallel R_{o2}$$\n\n$$R_{o2}=r_{o2}+ \\left[1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}\\right]\n\\left(r_{o1}\\parallel R_{T}\\parallel {1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}\\right)$$\n\n$$\\approx r_{o2}\\left[1+{g_{m2}+g_{mb2}\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}}\\right]\n\\approx 2r_{o2}\\;\\;{\\rm matched}$$\n\nso normally\n\n$$R_{o}\\approx R_{D}\\qquad R_{D}\\ll r_{o}$$\n\nif $R_{D}$ is replaced by an active $r_{o}$ load,\n$A_{v}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}/2$.\n\nWith capacitive load $C_{L}$ at the output and\ncapacitance $C_{P}$ at the common source node\n\n$$p_{1}\\approx -{1\\over R_{o}C_{L}}\\qquad\np_{2}\\approx -{g_{m1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb1}+g_{mb2}\\over C_{P}}$$\n\n$p_{2}$ is normally non dominant.\n\nIn frequency compensated form this is the classic\nfirst stage of a CMOS op. amp. Replacing $R_{D}$\nby a $p$MOS current mirror gives the conventional\n5-transistor OTA with\n\n$$A_{v}=g_{m}\\,(r_{on}\\parallel r_{op})$$\n\nSlew rate is limited by $I_{1}/C_{L}$.\n\n> Remark: With $R_{D}=0$, $M_{1}$ is a normal source\n> follower with gain\n> $A_{SF}=g_{m1}/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+G_{T}+G_{L})<1$.\n> The present circuit is that follower loaded by the\n> low input impedance $\\approx 1/(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})$ of the\n> CG stage instead of a resistor.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "1a0174b7d44bab056847bb33a90f8345192cfe24483252e3e0a1b9dd34c5a3be"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-follower/common-gate cascade (equivalently, a source-coupled differential pair) and gives the correct non-inverting gain.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5f76b34ca8287a0570c6f002e2eadb7a24e8054bf59e90b39e7d140a788b3c2c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2469,
        "output_tokens": 10250,
        "total_tokens": 12719,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7615,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2469,
        "output_tokens": 10250,
        "total_tokens": 12719,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7615,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 26,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-026-source-follower-drives-common-gate/figure-20.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the $N$ channel long tailed\nsource coupled pair with single ended resistive load.\n$V_{b}=V_{B0}$ is the $ac$ ground if the pair\nis driven single ended.\n\n$$\nM_{1}:CD\\qquad M_{2}:CG\\qquad S_{1}=S_{2}=S\n$$\n\npair in $CC-CB$ cascade.\n\n> * D. C. : $I_{D1}+I_{D2}=I_{1}={\\rm const}$\n>   A. C. : $i_{d1}+i_{d2}=0$ for $R_{EE}\\rightarrow \\infty $.\n>   $M_{1}$ is a source follower loaded by\n>   $1/(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\parallel r_{o2}$ ,\n>   $M_{2}$ is a common gate driven by that\n>   follower.\n\nPut for definiteness both $M$ in saturation\n\n$$I_{D}=K_{n}(V_{GS}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda V_{DS})\\qquad \n  K_{n}={1\\over 2}\\mu _{n}C_{ox}W/L$$\n\n$$g_{m}=2\\sqrt{K_{n}I_{D}}=2I_{D}/V_{ov}\\qquad \n  r_{o}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$$\n\nNormal bias for $ \\Delta V_{I}=V_{in}-V_{b}=0$\n\n$$I_{D01}=I_{D02}=I_{1}/2\\qquad g_{m1}=g_{m2}=g_{m}$$\n\n$$V_{S}=V_{G}-V_{GS}=V_{CM}-V_{T}-V_{ov}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$V_{o}=V_{DD}-I_{D2}R_{D}\\tag{2}$$\n\nFor saturation\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{DS1}&=V_{DD}-V_{S}\\ge V_{GS1}-V_{T}\\cr\nV_{DS2}&=V_{o}-V_{S}\\ge V_{GS2}-V_{T}\\cr}\n\\qquad {\\rm i.e.}\\qquad \n\\eqalign{\nV_{in}&\\le V_{DD}+V_{T}\\cr\nV_{o}&\\ge V_{b}-V_{T}\\cr\nV_{S}&\\ge V_{SS}+V_{DS,sat}(I_{1})\\cr}$$\n\n$V_{S}$ fixes the common mode range.\nNormal linear common mode range $\\approx V_{ov}<|\\Delta V_{I}|\n<\\sqrt{2}V_{ov}$.\n\nWith $R_{EE}=r_{oI_{1}}<\\infty $ :\n\n$$-V_{ov}\\sqrt{2}<V_{in}-V_{b}<+V_{ov}\\sqrt{2}$$\n\nfor both in saturation. Outside one device cuts off\n\n$$V_{o,max}=V_{DD}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;V_{in}-V_{b}\\gg V_{ov}\\;\\;,\n  I_{D1}=I_{1},I_{D2}=0$$\n$$V_{o,min}=V_{DD}-I_{1}R_{D}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;\n  V_{b}-V_{in}\\gg V_{ov}\\;\\;,\n  I_{D1}=0,I_{D2}=I_{1}$$\n\nso nominal swing $\\Delta V_{o}=I_{1}R_{D}$.\n\nIn square law\n\n$$I_{D1,2}={I_{1}\\over 2}\\pm \n\\sqrt{K_{n}I_{1}}\\Delta V_{I}\\sqrt{1-{K_{n}\\Delta V_{I}^{2}\\over 2I_{1}}}\n\\qquad |\\Delta V_{I}|\\le \\sqrt{I_{1}/K_{n}}$$\n\nand\n\n$$V_{o}=V_{DD}-R_{D}I_{D2}(\\Delta V_{I})$$\n\nwhich is $\\tanh $ like, linear for \n$|\\Delta V_{I}|\\ll V_{ov}$ :\n\n$$i_{d1}=-i_{d2}\\approx {g_{m}\\over 2}\\Delta V_{I}$$\n\n### Small signal - differential\n\nPut $v_{b}=0\\;ac$.  $v_{gs1}=v_{in}-v_{s}$,\n$v_{gs2}=-v_{s}$, $v_{bs1}=v_{bs2}=-v_{s}$ if\nbulk $=GND$, $0$ if bulk $=S$.\n\nIdeal $r_{o}\\rightarrow \\infty ,\\;R_{EE}\\rightarrow \\infty $,\nbulk $=S$ for simplicity:\n\nKCL $S$:\n\n$$g_{m1}(v_{in}-v_{s})+g_{m2}(-v_{s})=0$$\n\n$$v_{s}={g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}v_{in}\\tag{3}$$\n\nFor $g_{m1}=g_{m2}=g_{m}$, $v_{s}=v_{in}/2$.\nThe source is {\\it not} a virtual ground for single\nended drive. It is for pure differential drive\n$v_{in}=-v_{b}$.\n\nKCL drain $2$:\n\n$$v_{o}=-i_{d2}R_{D}\\qquad i_{d2}=g_{m2}(-v_{s})$$\n\n$$v_{o}=g_{m2}R_{D}v_{s}=\n  {g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}R_{D}v_{in}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {v_{o}\\over v_{in}}=\n  {g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}g_{m2}R_{D}>0\\tag{5}$$\n\nnon inverting.  For the matched pair\n\n$$A_{v0}\\approx +{1\\over 2}g_{m}R_{D} \\tag{6}$$\n\n$6\\,{\\rm dB}$ less than a common source with the same\n$R_{D}$ and $I_{D}=I_{1}/2$, $1/2$ the $G_{m}$.\n\nIn fact the circuit is follower $M_{1}$ with\n\n$$A_{v1}={v_{s}\\over v_{in}}={g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}}\n      \\approx {1\\over 2}$$\n\ndriving a $CG$ stage $M_{2}$ with\n\n$$A_{v2}={v_{o}\\over v_{s}}=g_{m2}R_{D}$$\n\nso $A_{v}=A_{v1}A_{v2}$.\n\nDifferentially\n\n$$v_{o}=A_{d}(v_{in}-v_{b})\\qquad \n  A_{d}= {1\\over 2}g_{m}R_{D}\\tag{7}$$\n\nDouble if taken differentially $v_{o1}-v_{o2}=g_{m}R_{D}\\Delta V_{I}$.\n\nWith $r_{o1},r_{o2},R_{EE}$ and body effect $g_{mb}$:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{d1}&=g_{m1}(v_{in}-v_{s})+g_{mb1}(-v_{s})+( -v_{s})/r_{o1}\\cr\ni_{d2}&=g_{m2}(-v_{s})+g_{mb2}(-v_{s})+(v_{o}-v_{s})/r_{o2}\\cr}$$\n\n$$i_{d1}+i_{d2}=v_{s}/R_{EE}\\tag{8}$$\n$$i_{d2}=-v_{o}/R_{D}\\tag{9}$$\n\nwhich gives to first order for $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$\n\n$$A_{v}={g_{m1}R_{D}\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+1/r_{o2}\\right)\n\\over \\left(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+1/r_{o1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+1/r_{o2}\\right)\n      \\left(1+R_{D}/r_{o2}\\right)+R_{D}/r_{o1}\\left(g_{m2}+g_{mb2}+1/r_{o2}\\right)}$$\n\n$$\\approx {g_{m1}(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})\\over \n          g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{m2}+g_{mb2}}\\,\n          \\left(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o2}\\right) \\tag{10}$$\n\nFor $r_{o}\\gg R_{D}$ and $g_{mb}=0$, (10) $\\rightarrow$ (5).\nFor a matched pair $g_{m1}=g_{m2}=g_{m}$,\n$g_{mb1}=g_{mb2}=g_{mb}$ and $r_{o}\\gg R_{D}$\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx {g_{m}\\over 2}\\left(R_{D}\\parallel r_{o2}\\right)\n      \\tag{11}$$\n\nthe body effect drops out to first order.\nIn general\n\n$$G_{m}\\equiv {i_{o}\\over v_{id}}={A_{v}\\over R_{D}}\\approx {g_{m}\\over 2}$$\n\n$$Z_{in}=1/sC_{gs}\\rightarrow \\infty \\;{\\rm at\\;DC}\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$Z_{out}\\approx R_{D}\\parallel r_{o2}\\parallel\n  \\left[r_{o2}+ \\left(1+(g_{m2}+g_{mb2})r_{o2}\\right)\n         \\left(r_{o1}\\parallel R_{EE}\\parallel 1/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})\\right)\\right]\n  \\approx R_{D}\\parallel r_{o2}\\approx R_{D}\\tag{13}$$\n\nDominant pole\n\n$$\\omega_{p o}\\approx 1/R_{D}C_{L}\\qquad \n  \\omega_{p s}\\approx (g_{m1}+g_{m2})/C_{S}$$\n\nwith $C_{S}$ at the common source.\n\n### Common mode\n\nFor $v_{in}=v_{b}=v_{cm}$ and $R_{EE}<\\infty $\n\n$$A_{cm}={v_{o}\\over v_{cm}}\\approx\n  -{g_{m}R_{D}\\over 1+2g_{m}R_{EE}}\\approx -{R_{D}\\over 2R_{EE}}\n  \\tag{14}$$\n\nfor $g_{m}R_{EE}\\gg 1$.  Ideally $R_{EE}\\rightarrow\\infty $,\n$A_{cm}\\rightarrow 0$,\n\n$$CMRR=\\left|{A_{d}\\over A_{cm}}\\right|\\approx g_{m}R_{EE}\\tag{15}$$\n\n$$PSRR\\approx g_{m}r_{o}$$\n\nHence the interest of a high impedance tail source,\ncascode $I_{1}$, and of an active $PMOS$ mirror load\ninstead of $R_{D}$ to get\n\n$$A_{v}\\approx g_{m}(r_{on}\\parallel r_{op})/2$$\n\nto $50$--$60\\,{\\rm dB}$.\n\nIn modern $CMOS$ the bulk $=GND$ for $NMOS$,\n$R_{EE}=r_{oI_{1}}$, $R_{D}$ often replaced by a\n$PMOS$ current mirror, and the circuit is the\nstandard input stage/phase splitter of the\n$CMOS$ operational amplifier.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c4389c81ac9e98bc4b6dcc41a962a28dbdd50a1c39e817059c76cf37eb0924fe"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the source-coupled pair as a source follower driving a common-gate stage and gives the correct non-inverting gain.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5f76b34ca8287a0570c6f002e2eadb7a24e8054bf59e90b39e7d140a788b3c2c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2469,
        "output_tokens": 10820,
        "total_tokens": 13289,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8049,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2469,
        "output_tokens": 10820,
        "total_tokens": 13289,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8049,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 27,
      "question": "Explain why the output impedance of the circuit shown in the figure can be inductive.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive/figure-21.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With $R_{S}=0$ the source is resistive $\\approx\ng_{m}^{-1}$ and capacitive. ${\\rm Im}Z_{o}<0$.\nWith $Z_{g}\\ne 0$ the capacitance $C_{gs}$ is a\nfeedback element and becomes a gyrator.\n\nPut $v_{i}=0$ for $Z_{o}$ and apply $v_{x}$ on the\nsource, Fig.1.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}: & g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{ds1}v_{ds}+sC_{gs}(v_{g}-v_{s})\n      +sC_{gd}(v_{g}-v_{d})+sC_{ds1}(v_{d}-v_{s})=0\\cr\nM_{2}: & g_{ds2}v_{x}+sC_{o}v_{x}\\approx i_{2}}$$\n\n$D$ of $M_{1}$ is ac ground, $S\\equiv v_{x}$, \n$G\\equiv v_{g}$:\n\n$$ {v_{g}\\over R_{S}}+sC_{gs}(v_{g}-v_{x})+sC_{gd}v_{g}=0\\tag{1}$$\n$$i_{x}+i_{M1}=i_{M2}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$i_{M1}=g_{m}(v_{g}-v_{x})-(g_{ds1}+sC_{ds1})v_{x}\n        +sC_{gs}(v_{g}-v_{x})\\tag{3} {\\rm\\;into\\;}S$$\nfrom (1)\n\n$$v_{g}=v_{x}{sC_{gs}\\over {1\\over R_{S}}+sC_{g}}\\qquad \nC_{g}=C_{gs}+C_{gd}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand e.g. to $C_{gd}=C_{o}=g_{ds}=0$ for clarity\n\n$$i_{x}=v_{x}g_{m}+sC_{gs}v_{x}-(g_{m}+sC_{gs})v_{g}$$\n\n$$Z_{o}={v_{x}\\over i_{x}}=\n{g_{m}+sC_{gs}-(g_{m}+sC_{gs}){sC_{gs}R_{S}\\over 1+sC_{gs}R_{S}}}^{-1}\n={1+sC_{gs}R_{S}\\over g_{m}+sC_{gs}}\\tag{5}$$\n\nWith $R_{S},g_{ds},C_{gd},C_{o}$ kept\n\n$$Z_{o}(s)={1+sR_{S}C_{g}\\over N(s)}\\tag{6}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nN(s)=&g_{0}+sC_{1}+s^{2}R_{S}(C_{g}C_{o}+C_{gd}C_{gs})\\cr\ng_{0}=&g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}\\cr\nC_{1}=&C_{o}+C_{gs}+R_{S}C_{g}g_{0}-R_{S}C_{gs}g_{m}\\cr\n&\\approx C_{o}+C_{gs}+R_{S}C_{gd}g_{m}}$$\n\nwhere $C_{o}=C_{ds1}+C_{ds2}+C_{L}$.\nPut $s=j\\omega$, for $\\omega$ small enough that\n$s^{2}$ can be neglected,\n\n$$Z_{o}(j\\omega)\\approx {1+j\\omega R_{S}C_{g}\\over g_{0}+j\\omega C_{1}}\n={g_{0}+\\omega ^{2}R_{S}C_{g}C_{1}+j\\omega (R_{S}C_{g}g_{0}-C_{1})\n\\over g_{0}^{2}+\\omega ^{2}C_{1}^{2}} \\tag{7}$$\n\nNormal low frequency resistance\n\n$$R_{o0}={1\\over g_{0}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\;\\;||r_{o1}||r_{o2}$$\n\nand to first order in $s$\n\n$$Z_{o}\\approx {1\\over g_{0}}+s{R_{S}C_{g}g_{0}-C_{1}\\over g_{0}^{2}}\n=R_{o0}+sL_{eq}+O(s^{2})\\tag{8}$$\n\n$$L_{eq}={R_{S}C_{g}g_{0}-C_{1}\\over g_{0}^{2}}\n={R_{S}g_{m}C_{gs}-C_{gs}-C_{o}\\over g_{0}^{2}} \\tag{9}$$\n\nIn the stripped model (5)\n\n$$Z_{o}={1\\over g_{m}}{1+j\\omega C_{gs}R_{S}\\over\n1+j\\omega C_{gs}/g_{m}}\\tag{10}$$\n\n$$ {\\rm Re}Z_{o}={g_{m}+\\omega^{2}C_{gs}^{2}R_{S}\\over\ng_{m}^{2}+\\omega^{2}C_{gs}^{2}}>0$$\n\n$${\\rm Im}Z_{o}= \\omega C_{gs}{R_{S}g_{m}-1\\over\ng_{m}^{2}+\\omega^{2}C_{gs}^{2}}\\tag{11}$$\n\n$${\\rm Im}Z_{o}>0\\iff R_{S}g_{m}>1+{C_{o}\\over C_{gs}}\\approx 1$$\n\ni.e. the zero $\\omega _{z}=1/R_{S}C_{g}$ lies below the\npole $\\omega _{p}=g_{m}/C_{gs}$.  For\n\n$${1\\over R_{S}C_{g}}<\\omega <{g_{m}\\over C_{gs}}$$\n\n$|Z_{o}|$ rises with $\\omega$, phase $+\\arctan\n\\omega L_{eq}/R_{o0}>0$, inductive.  In that band\n\n$$Z_{o}\\approx R_{o0}+j\\omega L_{eq}\\qquad \nL_{eq}\\approx {C_{gs}\\over g_{m}}\\left(R_{S}-{1\\over g_{m}}\\right)\n\\approx {R_{S}C_{gs}\\over g_{m}}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;R_{S}\\gg g_{m}^{-1}\n\\tag{12}$$\n\ncomplete with $g_{mb}$ : $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\nUp to a factor the drain capacitance of $M_{2}$, $C_{g}$\nappears as an inductance when seen from the source.\nIt is the ordinary gyrator action of the $g_{m}$ device:\n$Z_{g}=R_{S}+1/sC$ at the gate is transformed to\n\n$$Z_{s}\\approx {Z_{g}\\over g_{m}r_{o}}+{1\\over g_{m}}$$\n\nso $1/sC_{gs}$ becomes $sL$.\n\nPhysically: let $v_{x}$ jump $+\\Delta V$.  $C_{gs}$\npushes $v_{g}$ up with it.  If $R_{S}$ is large $v_{g}$\nfollows $v_{x}$ instantaneously, $v_{gs}\\approx 0$ so\n$g_{m}v_{gs}$ supplies essentially no current: high\n$Z_{o}$.  $v_{g}$ then decays to $0$ with\n$\\tau =R_{S}C_{g}$ and $v_{gs}\\to -v_{x}$, $g_{m}v_{gs}$\nbuilds up with delay $\\tau$.  Current lags voltage by\n$\\approx 90^{\\circ}$.  That is $v=Ldi/dt$.  For\n$R_{S}=0$, $v_{g}=0$ instantaneously, $i=g_{m}v_{x}$\ninstantaneously, resistive and, from (11) with $R_{S}=0$,\n${\\rm Im}Z_{o}= -\\omega C_{gs}/(g_{m}^{2}+\\omega^{2}\nC_{gs}^{2})<0$, capacitive.\n\nAt very low $\\omega$, $C_{gs}$ open, $Z_{o}=R_{o0}$,\nat $\\omega _{z}<\\omega <\\omega _{p}$ the $|Z_{o}|$\n$\\propto \\omega$, $+\\,j\\omega L_{eq}$ lossy inductor\n$Q\\approx \\omega L_{eq}/R_{o0}\\approx \\omega R_{S}C_{gs}$,\nat $\\omega \\gg \\omega _{p}$ $C_{gs}$ shorts $G$ to $S$,\n$Z_{o}\\to R_{S}$ and then shunted by $C_{o}$, i.e.\nsecond order $R_{o0}+sL_{eq}\\;||\\;1/sC_{o}$, resonance\n$\\omega_{0}\\approx 1/\\sqrt{L_{eq}C_{o}}$.\n\nIt is an active inductor made from $R_{S}$ and $C_{gs}$\nby the $g_{m}$ gyrator.  With a capacitive load $C_{L}$\nit resonates and produces the familiar source follower\npeaking, ringing and, if $R_{S}g_{m}C_{gd}$ is large\nenough to make ${\\rm Re}Z_{o}<0$, even oscillation.  It\nis used intentionally as a cheap on-chip shunt peaking\ninductor $L_{eq}\\sim 0.1$ to $10\\,{\\rm nH}$ for\n$C_{gs}\\sim 50\\,{\\rm fF}$, $g_{m}\\sim 1\\,{\\rm mS}$,\n$R_{S}\\sim 1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$, bandwidth extension.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bdff3f16ba84e6a883904691dd957eea1f3c6646246128325e33d150ed206a85"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly derives the simplified output impedance and explains that it rises from about 1/gm to RS as Cgs couples the gate to the source, producing inductive behavior when RS > 1/gm. The extra parasitic-model discussion does not undermine this central result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8c59f914b88c1f25c100ef0914c7e54f6c3e86c55b273ac88a1c45724902d303",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1709,
        "output_tokens": 10076,
        "total_tokens": 11785,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7742,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1709,
        "output_tokens": 10076,
        "total_tokens": 11785,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7742,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 27,
      "question": "Explain why the output impedance of the circuit shown in the figure can be inductive.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive/figure-21.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In common drain with $R_{S}=0$ it is not.\n\nPut $V_{in}=0$ for $Z_{o}$ and put small\nsignal test ${\\cal E}_{x}$ on $V_{out}$.\n\n$$Z_{o}=Z_{o1}\\parallel Z_{o2}\\qquad Z_{o2}\\approx r_{o2}\\parallel\n 1/sC_{o2}$$\n\nand the essentially new thing is $Z_{o1}$.\nNeglect at first $r_{o1}$ and $C_{gd},C_{bd}$,\nbody tied to source so $g_{mb}=0$ for the\nsake of writing. The claim remains with $g_{m}\\rightarrow\ng_{m}+g_{mb}$.\n\n\\begin{center}\n$M_{1}$: $g_{m}V_{gs}$ $D\\rightarrow S$, $R_{S}$ in series\nwith $G$ to ground, $C_{gs}$ $G-S$.\n\\end{center}\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{g}&= sC_{gs}(v_{g}-v_{x})+sC_{gd}v_{g} \\cr\ni_{d}&=g_{m}(v_{g}-v_{x})+g_{ds}(-v_{x})+{\\rm caps}}$$\n\nIn low frequency form:\n\nKCL at $G$:\n\n$${{v_{g}\\over R_{S}}+sC_{gd}v_{g}+sC_{gs}(v_{g}-v_{x})=0 \\tag{1}}$$\n\nKCL at $S$ with external current $i_{x}$ injected\nin $v_{x}$:\n\n$$i_{x}= -i_{s}=i_{d}+i_{g}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$i_{s}({\\rm into}\\;M_{1})=-g_{m}v_{gs}-sC_{gs}v_{gs}+\\cdots $$\n\nTo first order keep only $g_{m},C_{gs}$:\n\n$$v_{g}\\left({1\\over R_{S}}+sC_{gs}\\right)=sC_{gs}v_{x}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$v_{g}=v_{x}{sC_{gs}R_{S}\\over 1+sC_{gs}R_{S}} \\tag{4}$$\n\n$$i_{x}= (g_{m}+sC_{gs})(v_{x}-v_{g}){\\rm \\;with\\; sign\\;\nconvention}\\tag{5}$$\n\ni. e. with (4)\n\n$$i_{x}= (g_{m}+sC_{gs})\\left[v_{x}-v_{x}{sC_{gs}R_{S}\\over\n1+sC_{gs}R_{S}}\\right]=(g_{m}+sC_{gs}){v_{x}\\over\n1+sC_{gs}R_{S}} \\tag{6}$$\n\n$$\\;Z_{o1}(s)={v_{x}\\over i_{x}}={1+sC_{gs}R_{S}\\over g_{m}+sC_{gs}}\\;\n \\tag{7}$$\n\nWith $r_{o}$ :\n\n$$Z_{o1}={1+sC_{gs}R_{S}\\over g_{m}+g_{ds}+sC_{gs}}\\approx\n{r_{o1}\\,(1+sC_{gs}R_{S})\\over 1+g_{m}r_{o1}+sC_{gs}r_{o1}}$$\n\n$\\parallel r_{o2}$ in total. Including $C_{gd}$ simply\nreplaces $C_{gs}\\rightarrow C_{gs}+C_{gd}$ in (1) with\nsmall $sC_{gd}R_{S}g_{m}$ corrections. With body effect\n$g_{m}\\rightarrow g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\n\n$${\\rm zero:}\\;s_{z}=-1/R_{S}C_{gs}\\qquad \n{\\rm pole:}\\;s_{p}=-g_{m}/C_{gs} \\tag{8}$$\n\n$$Z_{o1}(s)={1\\over g_{m}}{1+s/s_{z}\\over 1+s/s_{p}}\n     = {1\\over g_{m}}{1+sC_{gs}R_{S}\\over 1+sC_{gs}/g_{m}} \\tag{9}$$\n\nwhich is $1/g_{m}$ at $s\\rightarrow 0$ and $R_{S}$ at\n$s\\rightarrow \\infty$.\n\nPut $s=j\\omega$:\n\n$$Z_{o1}(j\\omega)={1+j\\omega C_{gs}R_{S}\\over g_{m}+j\\omega C_{gs}}\n={g_{m}+\\omega^{2}C_{gs}^{2}R_{S}+j\\omega C_{gs}(g_{m}R_{S}-1)\n\\over g_{m}^{2}+\\omega^{2}C_{gs}^{2}} \\tag{10}$$\n\n$$R(\\omega)={g_{m}+\\omega^{2}C_{gs}^{2}R_{S}\\over\ng_{m}^{2}+\\omega^{2}C_{gs}^{2}}\\qquad \nX(\\omega)=\\omega C_{gs}{g_{m}R_{S}-1\\over\ng_{m}^{2}+\\omega^{2}C_{gs}^{2}} \\tag{11}$$\n\n$R>0$ always, $X$ changes sign with $g_{m}R_{S}-1$.\n\n* If $R_{S}=0$, $v_{g}=0$,\n\n$$Z_{o1}= {1\\over g_{m}+sC_{gs}}={1/g_{m}\\over 1+sC_{gs}/g_{m}}\n\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\parallel {1\\over sC_{gs}}$$\n\ncapacitive, ${\\rm Im}\\,Z_{o}<0$.\n\n* If $\\;g_{m}R_{S}>1\\;$ more generally\n$(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}>1$ or $(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}>1-g_{ds}R_{S}$,\n\n$${\\rm Im}\\,Z_{o1}>0$$\n\nfor $\\omega >0$ . The impedance looks inductive in the\nband\n\n$$\\omega_{z}=1/R_{S}C_{gs}<\\omega<\\omega_{p}=g_{m}/C_{gs}\n\\tag{12}$$\n\nwhere $|Z_{o}|$ rises with frequency. For\n$\\omega\\ll \\omega_{p}$ :\n\n$$Z_{o1}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\left[1+sC_{gs}(R_{S}-1/g_{m})\\right]\n\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}+sL_{eq}\\tag{13}$$\n\n$$L_{eq}\\approx {C_{gs}\\over g_{m}}\\left(R_{S}-{1\\over g_{m}}\\right)\n\\approx {R_{S}C_{gs}\\over g_{m}}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;R_{S}\\gg 1/g_{m} \\tag{14}$$\n\nwith finite $r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}$:\n\n$$Z_{o}\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\n+ s\\,{C_{gs}R_{S}\\over g_{m}}\\;\\;\\;{\\rm up\\;to}\\;1/\\omega_{p}$$\n\nSo about $Q\\sim \\omega L_{eq}/R_{eq}$. At $\\omega\\gg\\omega_{p}$,\n$Z_{o1}\\rightarrow R_{S}$ resistive again; in practice\n$C_{gd},C_{db},C_{gs2}$ etc. ultimately shunt $Z_{o}$ capacitively at very high frequency, so the impedance is\n$R\\parallel L\\parallel C$ - band pass.\n\nPhysical: It is the source follower feedback through $C_{gs}$.\nA change $\\Delta v_{x}$ is fed back to the gate through\n$C_{gs}$ and the divider $R_{S}-1/sC_{gs}$. If the gate were\nideal ac ground, $i_{x}=g_{m}\\Delta v_{x}$ . With $R_{S}\\ne 0$\nthe gate follows $\\Delta v_{x}$, $v_{g}=v_{x}sC_{gs}R_{S}/\n(1+sC_{gs}R_{S})$, lagging $v_{x}$.\n\nIn time domain: $\\;v_{x}\\uparrow$ pulls $v_{g}\\uparrow$ through\n$C_{gs}$ but $R_{S}$ delays the charging of $C_{gs}$.\nInstantaneously $v_{gs}=v_{g}-v_{x}<0$ so $g_{m}v_{gs}$ decreases,\nthe transistor supplies {\\it less} current when you try to\nraise its source voltage. $d i_{x}/dt$ lags $d v_{x}/dt$.\nThat is $v=L\\,di/dt$, $i$ lags $v$. In frequency domain the\nloop gain $T\\approx g_{m}R_{S}/(1+sR_{S}C_{gs})$ has a pole,\nso the closed loop output impedance $Z_{ocl}=Z_{ol}/(1+T)$\nacquires a zero before its pole, i.e. a $+90^{0}$ phase.\n\n$M_{2}$ is essentially $r_{o2}\\parallel C_{o2}$ to ground.\nIt limits the $Q$ and together with the inductive $Z_{o1}$ and\nany capacitive load $C_{L}$ on $V_{out}$ makes a parallel\n$RLC$ circuit,\n\n$$Z_{o}(s)\\approx \\left[sC_{L}+{1\\over r_{o2}}+{g_{m}+sC_{gs}\\over\n1+sC_{gs}R_{S}}\\right]^{-1}$$\n\nwhich resonates at $\\omega_{0}\\approx 1/\\sqrt{L_{eq}C_{L}}$,\ngiving inductive peaking, ringing and possibly oscillation.\nThat is why a source - emitter - follower with resistive source\nand capacitive load is a well known ``active inductor'' and is\nwidely used for shunt peaking / bandwidth extension and as\ngyrator based inductor in $LC$ VCOs and filters without coils.\nWith $R_{S}=R_{source}$ of the previous stage it is often\nparasitic. The same mechanism holds for bipolar emitter follower.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "904fb9f12f7e7ed035045ae512815e1921ad046b7adaca91db9423a35826927c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly derives the key impedance and explains its transition from about 1/gm at low frequencies to RS at high frequencies as Cgs couples the gate to the source. It identifies the inductive rise when RS > 1/gm; extra discussion does not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8c59f914b88c1f25c100ef0914c7e54f6c3e86c55b273ac88a1c45724902d303",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1709,
        "output_tokens": 7178,
        "total_tokens": 8887,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4774,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1709,
        "output_tokens": 7178,
        "total_tokens": 8887,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4774,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 27,
      "question": "Explain why the output impedance of the circuit shown in the figure can be inductive.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-027-explain-why-output-impedance-be-inductive/figure-21.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In common drain with ${\\rm g}_{ds}^{-1}\n\\gg 1/g_{m}$ the only singularity is\n$V_{gs}$. Put $V_{i}=0$ for ${\\rm Z}_{o}$.\nLet ${\\rm Z}_{g}=R_{S}$ at the gate and\n${\\rm C}_{gs}\\approx {\\rm C}=C_{gs1}$ to first\norder, $G_{m}=g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\n\n$${\\rm C}_{gd}, {\\rm C}_{gb}, {\\rm C}_{db}\\to 0\\qquad\nr_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}=r_{o}\\to \\infty $$\ncan be put in parallel afterwards.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}:\\;\\;i_{d}&=G_{m}v_{gs}+sCv_{gs}\\cr\n{\\rm KCL}\\;g:\\;\\;{{v_{g}}\\over {R_{S}}}+sC(v_{g}-v_{x})&=0\\cr\n{\\rm KCL}\\;x:\\;\\;i_{x}+G_{m}v_{gs}+sCv_{gs}&=0\\;\n{\\rm with}\\;v_{gs}=v_{g}-v_{x}\\cr}$$\n\n$v_{x}$ is the test voltage at the source,\n$i_{x}$ the current injected into the source,\n$d\\to {\\rm AC\\, grd}$.\n\n$${{v_{g}}\\over {R_{S}}}=-sC(v_{g}-v_{x})$$\n\n$$v_{g}\\left({1\\over {R_{S}}}+sC\\right)=sCv_{x}$$\n\n$$v_{g}=v_{x}{{sCR_{S}}\\over {1+sCR_{S}}} \\tag{1}$$\n\n$$i_{x}=-(G_{m}+sC)v_{gs}=(G_{m}+sC)(v_{x}-v_{g}) \\tag{2}$$\n\n$$i_{x}=(G_{m}+sC)v_{x}\\left[1-{{sCR_{S}}\\over {1+sCR_{S}}}\\right]\n     ={{G_{m}+sC}\\over {1+sCR_{S}}}v_{x}$$\n\nSo looking into the source alone\n\n$$\\;Z_{1}(s)={{v_{x}}\\over {i_{x}}}={{1+sCR_{S}}\\over {G_{m}+sC}}\\; \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${\\rm Z}_{o}(s)=Z_{1}(s)\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\n   \\parallel {1\\over {sC_{L}}}\\parallel \\cdots $$\n\nwhere $r_{oi}=1/g_{dsi}$ and $C_{L}$ is the load and\n${\\rm C}_{db},{\\rm C}_{gd}$ etc.  The essential physics is\nin (3).\n\nPut $s=j\\omega $\n\n$$Z_{1}(j\\omega)={{1+j\\omega CR_{S}}\\over {G_{m}+j\\omega C}}\n ={{(1+j\\omega CR_{S})(G_{m}-j\\omega C)}\\over {G_{m}^{2}\n   +\\omega^{2}C^{2}}}$$\n\n$$Z_{1}= {{G_{m}+\\omega^{2}C^{2}R_{S}}\\over {G_{m}^{2}\n   +\\omega^{2}C^{2}}}+j{{\\omega C\\,(G_{m}R_{S}-1)}\\over \n   {G_{m}^{2}+\\omega^{2}C^{2}}} \\tag{4}$$\n\n$$Z_{1}(s)={1\\over {G_{m}}}{{1+s/\\omega _{z}}\\over {1+s/\\omega _{p}}},\n\\qquad \\omega _{z}={1\\over {R_{S}C}},\\qquad \n       \\omega _{p}={G_{m}\\over {C}} \\tag{5}$$\n\nLow frequency:\n\n$$Z_{1}(0)={1\\over {G_{m}}}\\approx {1\\over {g_{m}}}$$\n\nHigh frequency:\n\n$$Z_{1}(\\infty )={R_{S}C\\over {C}}=R_{S}$$\n\nIn ordinary voltage follower analysis $R_{S}=0$,\n$\\omega _{z}\\to \\infty $ and\n\n$$Z_{1}={1\\over {G_{m}+sC}}={1/G_{m}\\over {1+sC/G_{m}}}$$\n\ncapacitive, ${\\rm Im}\\,Z_{1}<0$, a ${\\rm C}=C/G_{m}$\nin parallel with $1/G_{m}$.\n\nIn general ${\\rm Im}\\,Z_{1}$ in (4) is\n\n$${\\rm Im}\\,Z_{1}\\propto G_{m}R_{S}-1$$\n\n> {\\it If the resistance seen in the gate is large\n> enough}\n\n$$G_{m}R_{S}>1,\\;\\;{\\rm more\\;exactly\\;(g_{m}+g_{mb})R_{S}>1}$$\n\n$${\\rm Im}\\,Z_{1}>0\\;\\;{\\rm for\\;}\\omega >0$$\n\ni. e. inductive.  In $s$-plane the zero\n$\\omega _{z}$ is below the pole $\\omega _{p}$.\nBetween zero and pole the phase of $Z_{1}$ goes\npositive, $+90^{\\circ}$ maximum, i. e. $+j\\omega L$.\n\nFor $\\omega \\ll \\omega _{p}$ we can expand (4):\n\n$$Z_{1}\\approx {1\\over {G_{m}}}+j\\omega {{C\\,(G_{m}R_{S}-1)}\n      \\over {G_{m}^{2}}}+{\\cal O}(\\omega ^{2})$$\n\n$$Z_{1}\\approx R_{eq}+j\\omega L_{eq}$$\n\n$$R_{eq}\\approx {1\\over {G_{m}}}\\parallel r_{o}$$\n\n$$L_{eq}\\approx {{R_{S}C_{gs}-C_{gs}/G_{m}}\\over {G_{m}}}\n        \\approx {{R_{S}C_{gs}}\\over {G_{m}}}\\quad {\\rm for}\\;\n           G_{m}R_{S}\\gg 1 \\tag{6}$$\n\nmore exactly $L_{eq}(\\omega)=C(G_{m}R_{S}-1)/\n(G_{m}^{2}+\\omega^{2}C^{2})$.\nWith parasitics $C\\to C_{gs}+C_{gd}$ etc. but the\nform is unchanged.  Including $r_{o}$,\n\n$${\\rm Z}_{o}(s)\\approx {{1+sCR_{S}}\\over {G_{m}+g_{o}+sC}}\n   \\parallel {1\\over {sC_{L}}}$$\n\ni. e. a series $R_{eq}+sL_{eq}$ shunted by $r_{o}$ and\n$C_{L}$.\n\nIn time domain: let $v_{x}=V_{out}$ jump up by\n$\\Delta V$. $v_{gs}=v_{g}-v_{x}$ wants to go negative,\nso the drain current $G_{m}v_{gs}$ wants to fall.\nBut $v_{g}$ cannot follow $v_{x}$ instantaneously\nbecause it is coupled only through $C_{gs}$ and the\nimpedance $R_{S}$. For a fast edge $C_{gs}$ looks\nlike a short but $R_{S}$ holds $v_{g}$ almost constant,\nso initially $\\Delta v_{gs}\\approx -\\Delta v_{x}$,\n$\\Delta i\\approx -G_{m}\\Delta v_{x}$ is large.\nOnly with time constant $R_{S}C_{gs}$ does $v_{g}$\ncharge up through $C_{gs}$ toward $v_{x}$, $v_{gs}\\to 0$\nand the current recovers towards its DC value.\nCurrent lags voltage - the definition of an inductor,\n$v=Ldi/dt$. The capacitance $C_{gs}$ is gyrated by\nthe transconductance into an inductance $R_{S}C_{gs}/G_{m}$.\n\nThe impedance stays $\\approx R_{eq}+j\\omega L_{eq}$ up to\nabout the pole $\\omega _{p}=G_{m}/C_{gs}$, typically\n${\\rm GHz}$, after which it becomes $\\approx R_{S}$\nresistive, eventually capacitive again when $C_{gd}$,\n$C_{db}$, $C_{L}$ dominate.\n\nIn particular with a capacitive load $C_{L}$ the\ncircuit is a $R\\,L\\,C$ second order low pass. The\ninductor resonates with $C_{L}$ giving shunt peaked\nfrequency response, often used deliberately as an\n``active inductor'' for bandwidth extension, and, if\n$Q$ is high, ringing or oscillation of the source\nfollower with capacitive load. Damping requires\n$R_{S}<1/G_{m}$ or an explicit series $R$.\n\nWith $R_{S}=0$ the zero moves to infinity, $\\omega_{z}>\\omega_{p}$\nand $Z_{o}$ is always capacitive. The finite source\nresistance of the driving stage is what makes the\nfollower look inductive. The same duality gives the\ncommon gate input impedance inductive when the source\nis capacitively loaded.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "7ebcfcc0b99d2d945f41d0ccc8f7cbfedf3ab8b643ec2e93d6115313078f668a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly derives the source-follower impedance and explains its transition from about 1/gm at low frequency to Rs at high frequency as Cgs couples the gate to the source. It identifies the rising, inductive behavior when the gate resistance is sufficiently large; the extra body-effect and loading approximations do not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "8c59f914b88c1f25c100ef0914c7e54f6c3e86c55b273ac88a1c45724902d303",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1709,
        "output_tokens": 5406,
        "total_tokens": 7115,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3294,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1709,
        "output_tokens": 5406,
        "total_tokens": 7115,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3294,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 28,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback/figure-22.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a ${\\rm shunt}/{\\rm shunt}\\equiv $ voltage sampling\ncurrent mixing transimpedance on two high\nimpedance invertors in cascade.\n\n$$M_{1}:G\\equiv X,S=GND,D\\equiv V_{o},R_{D1}\\,{\\rm to\\,ac\\,GND}$$\n$$M_{2}:G\\equiv V_{o},S=GND,D\\equiv X$$\n\ni.e. two common source stages in a loop,\nFig.1b.\n\n> $$v_{o}=-g_{m1}v_{x}Z_{o}\\tag{1}$$\n> $$i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{o}+g_{ds2}v_{x}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$g_{o1}=g_{ds1}+1/R_{D1}$, $g_{o2}=g_{ds2}$ in\nparallel with $C_{x},C_{o}$ at the two nodes.\n\nWith the normal ${\\rm body}=S$ small signal model,\n$r_{o}=1/g_{ds}=1/\\lambda I_{D}$,$g_{m}=\\sqrt{2k_{n}I_{D}}$,\n$g_{m}^{*} =g_{m}+g_{mb}$ with body effect.\n\nIn saturation\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{D1}&={1\\over 2}k_{n1}(V_{x}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{1}V_{o})\\cr\nI_{D2}&={1\\over 2}k_{n2}(V_{o}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{2}V_{x})\\cr\nV_{o}&=V_{DD}-I_{D1}R_{D1}\\cr\nI_{in}&=I_{D2}+I_{G1}\\approx I_{D2}} \\tag{3}$$\n\nat dc where $I_{G}=0$.\nFor $\\lambda =0$, $V_{o}=V_{T}+\\sqrt{2I_{in}/k_{n2}}$ and\n$I_{D1}=(V_{DD}-V_{o})/R_{D1}$. The coupling is only\nthrough $\\lambda $. In saturation\n\n$$V_{DS1}=V_{o}\\ge V_{GS1}-V_{T}=V_{x}-V_{T}$$\n$$V_{DS2}=V_{x}\\ge V_{GS2}-V_{T}=V_{o}-V_{T} \\tag{4}$$\n\notherwise one device goes triode and $g_{ds}$ rises\ndramatically.\n\n### Small signal - nodal\n\nPut $G_{R}=g_{ds1}+1/R_{D1}=1/(r_{o1}\\parallel R_{D1})$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{\\rm at\\;}X:&\\;i_{in}=v_{x}(sC_{x}+g_{ds2})+g_{m2}v_{o}\\cr\n{\\rm at\\;}V_{o}:&\\;0=v_{o}(sC_{o}+G_{R})+g_{m1}v_{x}} \\tag{5}$$\n\n$C_{x}=C_{gs1}+C_{db2}+C_{gd2}$, $C_{o}=C_{db1}+C_{gd1}+C_{gs2}+C_{gb2}$.\nIn matrix form\n\n$$\\pmatrix{sC_{x}+g_{ds2}&g_{m2}\\cr g_{m1}&sC_{o}+G_{R}}\n\\pmatrix{v_{x}\\cr v_{o}}=\\pmatrix{i_{in}\\cr 0} \\tag{6}$$\n\nSo that with $\\Delta =A\\,B-g_{m1}g_{m2}$,\n$A=sC_{x}+g_{ds2}$, $B=sC_{o}+G_{R}$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nv_{x}&=i_{in}{B\\over \\Delta}\\cr\nv_{o}&=i_{in}{-g_{m1}\\over \\Delta}} \\tag{7}$$\n\nHence the closed loop transresistance and the two\ndriving point impedances, $i_{in}=0$ for $Z_{o}$ test,\n\n$$R_{m}(s)\\equiv {v_{o}\\over i_{in}}={-g_{m1}\\over AB-g_{m1}g_{m2}}\n ={g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}-AB}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$$Z_{x}(s)\\equiv {v_{x}\\over i_{in}}={B\\over AB-g_{m1}g_{m2}} \\tag{9a}$$\n\n$$Z_{o}(s)\\equiv {v_{o}\\over i_{t}}\\Bigl|_{i_{in}=0}={A\\over AB-g_{m1}g_{m2}} \\tag{9b}$$\n\nby Blackman, the same denominator. Explicitly\n\n$$R_{m}(s)={-g_{m1}\\over s^{2}C_{x}C_{o}+s[C_{x}G_{R}+C_{o}g_{ds2}]\n+g_{ds2}G_{R}-g_{m1}g_{m2}} \\tag{10}$$\n\nAt dc, $s\\to 0$,\n\n$$R_{m0}={-g_{m1}\\over g_{ds2}G_{R}-g_{m1}g_{m2}}\n={1\\over g_{m2}-g_{ds2}G_{R}/g_{m1}} \\tag{11}$$\n\n$$R_{x0}={G_{R}\\over g_{ds2}G_{R}-g_{m1}g_{m2}}=\n{1\\over g_{ds2}-g_{m1}g_{m2}/G_{R}} \\tag{12a}$$\n\n$$R_{o0}={g_{ds2}\\over g_{ds2}G_{R}-g_{m1}g_{m2}}=\n{1\\over G_{R}-g_{m1}g_{m2}/g_{ds2}} \\tag{12b}$$\n\nWith $g_{mb}\\ne 0$, $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$.\n\nFor the ideal square law $g_{ds}\\to 0$,\n$\\Delta\\to -g_{m1}g_{m2}$ and with $C\\to 0$\n\n$$R_{m0}\\to +{1\\over g_{m2}},\\;\\;R_{x0}\\to -{G_{R}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}},\\;\\;\nR_{o0}\\to -{g_{ds2}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}}\\to 0 \\tag{13}$$\n\ni.e. formally a finite $+1/g_{m2}$ but the\ndenominator has changed sign.\n\n### Feedback interpretation\n\nPut the forward path with the feedback killed,\n$g_{m2}=0$:\n\n$$a_{0}\\equiv {v_{o}\\over i_{in}}\\Bigl|_{g_{m2}=0}\n={-g_{m1}\\over g_{ds2}G_{R}}=-g_{m1}r_{o2}(R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1})\n\\tag{14}$$\n\nlarge, inverting. The feedback current fed back to the\ninput node is\n\n$$i_{f}=g_{m2}v_{o}\\;\\;{\\rm so\\;\\;}\\beta\\equiv {i_{f}\\over v_{o}}=g_{m2}\\tag{15}$$\n\nsampling $v_{o}$, shunt mixing $i_{f}$ at $X$: shunt-shunt.\nNominally\n\n$$a_{0}\\beta ={-g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over g_{ds2}G_{R}}\\equiv -T_{0}\\tag{16}$$\n\n$$T(s)={g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over AB}\\tag{17}$$\n\nis the usual return ratio. Two CS stages are each\ninverting: $v_{x}\\to v_{o}$ inverting,\n$v_{o}\\to v_{x}$ inverting via the $r_{o2}$ load,\nso the loop is non-inverting: positive feedback.\n\nIn standard form\n\n$$\\Delta =AB\\,(1-T),\\qquad \nR_{m}={a_{0}\\over 1+a_{0}\\beta}={a_{0}\\over 1-T_{0}}\\tag{18}$$\n\nso that the characteristic equation is $1-T=0$,\n\n$$AB=g_{m1}g_{m2}\\tag{19}$$\n\n### Stability - positive feedback\n\n$$p_{1,2}={-[C_{x}G_{R}+C_{o}g_{ds2}]\\pm\n\\sqrt{[C_{x}G_{R}-C_{o}g_{ds2}]^{2}+4C_{x}C_{o}g_{m1}g_{m2}}\n\\over 2C_{x}C_{o}} \\tag{20}$$\n\nThe discriminant $>0$ : both poles are real.\nFor a Hurwitz polynomial $a_{2}s^{2}+a_{1}s+a_{0}$,\n$a_{i}>0$ for l.h.p. Here $a_{2}=C_{x}C_{o}>0$,\n$a_{1}=C_{x}G_{R}+C_{o}g_{ds2}>0$ always, but\n\n$$a_{0}=g_{ds2}G_{R}-g_{m1}g_{m2}=g_{ds2}G_{R}(1-T_{0})\\tag{21}$$\n\n$a_{0}>0\\iff T_{0}<1$ for stable l.h.p. poles.\n$a_{0}<0\\iff T_{0}>1$ one pole is in the right half plane,\nexponential growth.\n\n$$T_{0}={g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over g_{ds2}G_{R}}\n=g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o2}(R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1})<1\\;\\;{\\rm stable}\\tag{22}$$\n\nFor $r_{o}\\to\\infty$, $T_{0}\\to\\infty$ : the\nideal long channel circuit is inherently unstable.\nFinite $g_{ds}$ is needed to stabilise it as a\nlinear amplifier. For $T_{0}<1$ the positive\nfeedback enhances the magnitude:\n\n$$R_{m0}= {a_{0}\\over 1-T_{0}},\\;\\;|R_{m0}|>|a_{0}|\n\\;\\;{\\rm and}\\;\\;R_{m0}<0\\tag{23}$$\n\ne.g. $g_{m1}r_{o1}=g_{m2}r_{o2}=20$,\n$R_{D1}=r_{o1}$, $G_{R}=2/r_{o1}$,\n$T_{0}=200$, far into the unstable region.\nReducing $g_{m}r_{o}$ to $\\sim 1$ by low $r_{o}$\nor degeneration $g_{m}R_{S}<1$ can make $T_{0}<1$.\nThen e.g. $T_{0}=0.5$, $a_{0}=-g_{m1}/g_{ds2}G_{R}$,\n$R_{m0}=2a_{0}<0$ : an increase of $i_{in}$ drives\n$v_{o}$ negative, as expected for the CS inversion.\n\nIn the unstable $T_{0}>1$ region the small signal\nslope about the metastable bias is\n\n$$R_{m0}\\approx +1/g_{m2}>0\\tag{24}$$\n\nthe well known negative input resistance\n\n$$R_{x0}={1\\over g_{ds2}(1-T_{0})}<0\\tag{25}$$\n\ncan cancel a passive load and is used as an active\ninductor/NIC. Large signal the circuit snaps to the\nsupply rails: it is the NMOS latch of the SRAM sense\namplifier. With $T_{0}>1$ three dc solutions exist\nfor a given $I_{in}$: two stable with one device in\ntriode, one metastable with both saturated and\n${\\rm d}V_{o}/{\\rm d}I_{in}>0$. Sweeping $I_{in}$\ngives hysteresis. This is a current mode Schmitt\ntrigger / comparator with memory.\n\nIf linear transimpedance operation is required the\nusual remedy is to make the feedback negative:\nreplace $M_{2}$ by a PMOS source follower or\nresistor $R_{F}$ from $V_{o}$ to $X$: $R_{m}\\approx -R_{F}$,\n$R_{x}\\approx R_{F}/(1+g_{m1}R_{D1})$, stable for any\n$R_{F}$.\n\nIn summary, with the NMOS $M_{2}$ as drawn the\ncircuit is a shunt-shunt positive feedback\ntransimpedance stage, loop gain $g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o2}\n(R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1})$. For $T_{0}<1$ it is a\nstable but gain enhanced $R_{m}\\approx -g_{m1}/\ng_{ds2}G_{R}/(1-T_{0})$ with enhanced $R_{x},R_{o}$.\nFor the usual high gain technology $T_{0}>1$ it is\nregenerative, shows negative input resistance,\nhysteresis and acts as a latch/comparator, not as a\nlinear amplifier, unless $g_{ds}$ is made artificially\nlarge or degeneration is added.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "10bc2817fe9af3adf3243d471b6ec13cf34fc6c63e00f13b00d22605e05449b8"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M2’s gate as tied to Vout (not diode-connected), explains the positive-feedback loop, and gives the correct consequences: negative input resistance, instability, and latching.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "966942e01d767dcc8afc948021623863d816cf7567c0ad0be0b855267f6da7e8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2202,
        "output_tokens": 17830,
        "total_tokens": 20032,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14635,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2202,
        "output_tokens": 17830,
        "total_tokens": 20032,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14635,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 28,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback/figure-22.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With capacities neglected this is the $Y-Z$\ncombination\n\n* samplig $Z$, $$V_{o}=V_{D1}$$\n* mixing $Y$, $$I_{e}=I_{in}-I_{F}$$ on the\nhigh impedance node\n\n$$X\\equiv G_{1}\\equiv D_{2}$$\n\nso that in the ideal limit it is a transresistance\n$R_{M}=V_{o}/I_{in}$. The device used as ${\\cal R}_{F}$\nis $M_{2}$\n\n$$I_{F}=I_{D2}=f(V_{o}),\\qquad g_{F}\\approx g_{m2}$$\n\n$$V_{o}=-g_{m1}V_{X}R_{D1}^{\\prime}, \\qquad \nR_{D1}^{\\prime}=R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1}\\tag {1}$$\n\n$$I_{F}=g_{m2}V_{o}+g_{o2}V_{X}\\tag {2}$$\n\n$g_{oi}=r_{oi}^{-1}=\\lambda _{i}I_{Di}$.\n\nIn conventional notation $M_{1,2}$ are $n$MOS,\n$S_{1,2}$ grounded, $B_{1,2}$ grounded so $g_{mb}=0$.\nPut $G_{D1}=R_{D1}^{-1}$. For the small signal\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{\\rm KCL}_{X}:& I_{in}=g_{o2}V_{x}+g_{m2}V_{o}\\cr\n{\\rm KCL}_{o}:& 0=g_{m1}V_{x}+ \\left(G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\right)V_{o}} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$I_{in}$ ideal $\\;R_{in\\,S}=\\infty $ , $V_{DD}$ AC\nground neglected. In matrix form\n\n$$\\left[ \\matrix{g_{o2}&g_{m2}\\cr g_{m1}&G_{D1}+g_{o1}}\\right]\n\\left[ \\matrix{V_{x}\\cr V_{o}}\\right]=\\left[ \\matrix{I_{in}\\cr 0}\\right] \\tag{4}$$\n\n$$\\Delta =g_{o2}\\left(G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\right)-g_{m1}g_{m2} \\tag{5}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{o}&=-g_{m1}{\\Delta^{-1}}I_{in}\\cr\nV_{x}&=\\left(G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\right){\\Delta^{-1}}I_{in}} \\tag{6}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$R_{M}\\equiv {V_{o}\\over I_{in}}=\n-{g_{m1}\\over \\Delta }=\n{g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}-g_{o2}\\left(G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\right)} \\tag{7}$$\n\n$$R_{X}\\equiv {V_{x}\\over I_{in}}=\n{G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\over \\Delta} \\tag{8}$$\n\nOutput resistance, $I_{in}=0$, $I_{x}$ injected at $o$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n0&=g_{o2}V_{x}+g_{m2}V_{o}\\cr\nI_{x}&=g_{m1}V_{x}+\\left(G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\right)V_{o}} \\tag{9}$$\n\n$$R_{o}\\equiv {V_{o}\\over I_{x}}={g_{o2}\\over \\Delta} \\tag{10}$$\n\nThat is Blackman with\n\n$$R_{M0}\\to \\infty ,\\;\\;R_{X0}\\to r_{o2}\\;\\;,R_{o0}\\to R_{D1}^{\\prime}$$\n\nand, with the usual sign convention,\n\n$${\\cal R}= {V_{r}\\over V_{t}}=\n{g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over g_{o2}\\left(G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\right)}\n={g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\,g_{m2}r_{o2}} \\tag{11}$$\n\nis the {\\it return ratio} or loop gain $T$.\nBreak the loop at $G_{1}$, $I_{in}=0$,\n$V_{t}=V_{X}$,\n\n$$V_{o}=-g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}V_{t}$$\n$$V_{r}= -g_{m2}V_{o}r_{o2}=+g_{m1}g_{m2}\nR_{D1}^{\\prime}r_{o2}V_{t}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$1-{\\cal R}=1-T={\\Delta\\over g_{o2}\\left(G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\right)} \\tag{12}$$\n\nand (7)-(10) can be written as e.g.\n\n$$R_{M}= {g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}r_{o2}\\over 1-{\\cal R}}\n{1\\over g_{m2}r_{o2}}= {R_{M\\infty}\\over 1-{\\cal R}^{-1}} \\tag{13}$$\n\nwith the {\\it ideal} transresistance\n\n$$R_{M\\infty }={1\\over g_{m2}}\\approx {1\\over \\beta},\n\\qquad \\beta \\equiv {I_{F}\\over V_{o}}=g_{m2} \\tag{14}$$\n\napart from sign. In the conventional\nvoltage - current or shunt - shunt nomenclature $A=R_{M}$,\n$\\beta =1/R_{M\\infty}$.\n\nIn particular for ${r_{o}}^{-1}\\rightarrow 0$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nR_{M}&\\rightarrow +{1\\over g_{m2}}\\cr\nR_{X}&\\rightarrow {1\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}}\\cr\nR_{o}&\\rightarrow 0} \\tag{15}$$\n\nwith the normal convention for the reference direction of\n$I_{F}$, $R_{M}=-1/g_{m2}$, $R_{X}=-1/g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}$,\nthe circuit is nominally a low $Z_{in}$ - low\n$Z_{o}$ TIA. With $r_{o}$ finite\n\n$$R_{M}\\approx {1\\over g_{m2}}{1\\over 1-\n\\left[g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}r_{o2}\\right]^{-1}} \\tag{16}$$\n\n$$R_{X}\\approx {R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\over 1-{\\cal R}},\\qquad\nR_{o}\\approx {R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\over 1-{\\cal R}} \\tag{17}$$\n\nto first order.\n\n> {\\it Remark on sign:} With $M_{2}$ $n$MOS CS as drawn\n> $V_{X}\\uparrow \\to V_{o}\\downarrow $ via $M_{1}$ and\n> $V_{o}\\downarrow \\to I_{F}\\downarrow $ via $M_{2}$ so that\n> $\\delta I_{F}$ {\\it subtracts} from the KCL at $X$ in the\n> same sense as $\\delta I_{in}$. i. e. the return signal\n> is {\\it in phase} with the test signal, ${\\cal R}>0$.\n> It is a {\\it positive} or regenerative shunt - shunt loop.\n> A normally stable negative feedback TIA is obtained by\n> making $M_{2}$ a source follower, i. e. $p$MOS with\n> $S_{2}=X$, $D_{2}=GND$, or $n$MOS $D_{2}=V_{DD}$,\n> $S_{2}=X$, so that $V_{o}\\downarrow\\to V_{SG2}\\uparrow\\to\n> I_{F}\\uparrow$ and ${\\cal R}<0$, $R_{M}\\approx -1/g_{m2}$.\n> In most text books Eq. 14 is quoted as\n> $R_{M}\\approx -R_{F}\\approx -1/g_{m2}$ for the negative\n> feedback version. The analysis above is identical up to\n> $g_{m2}\\to -g_{m2}$. With the $n$MOS $M_{2}$ to ground\n> as drawn the loop is regenerative.\n\n> Large signal DC: $I_{D2}=I_{in}=(k_{n2}/2)(V_{o}-V_{Tn})^{2}\n> (1+\\lambda _{2}V_{X})$, $I_{D1}=(V_{DD}-V_{o})/R_{D1}\n> =(k_{n1}/2)(V_{X}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda _{1}V_{o})$.\n> $V_{o}=V_{Tn}+\\sqrt{2I_{in}/k_{n2}}$, $V_{X}=V_{Tn}+\n> \\sqrt{2(V_{DD}-V_{o})/k_{n1}R_{D1}}$.\n\nStability: From (5) the DC denominator changes sign for\n\n$${\\cal R}=1, \\qquad g_{m1}g_{m2}=g_{o2}\\left(G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\right)\n\\tag{18}$$\n\n$${\\cal R}>1 \\;\\; \\Longleftrightarrow\\;\\;\ng_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}r_{o2}>1 \\tag{19}$$\n\nis the regenerate condition. With normal $g_{m}r_{o}\\approx\n50-100$ and $g_{m}R_{D1}\\approx 2-5$, ${\\cal R}\\gg 1$ and the\ncircuit as drawn is normally {\\it latching}. Including the\ndominant poles\n\n$$p_{o}\\approx {1\\over R_{D1}^{\\prime}C_{o}},\\qquad\nC_{o}=C_{db1}+C_{gd1}+C_{gs2}+C_{gb2}+C_{L}$$\n$$p_{x}\\approx {1\\over r_{o2}C_{x}},\\qquad\nC_{x}=C_{gs1}+C_{gd2}+C_{db2}$$\n\nthe loop transfer is second order\n\n$${\\cal R}(s)={{\\cal R}_{0}\\over (1+s/p_{o})(1+s/p_{x})} \\tag{20}$$\n\nFor ${\\cal R}_{0}>1$ the closed loop polynomial\n\n$$D(s)=1-{\\cal R}(s)=0$$\n\nhas a right half plane root and the circuit is astable.\nIt becomes a bistable latch / Schmitt trigger / regenerative\ncomparator with hysteresis\n\n$$I_{in\\,hyst}\\approx {\\Delta V_{o}\\over R_{M}}\\approx\ng_{m2}\\Delta V_{o}$$\n\nand can be used as a high gain - narrow band regenerative\nTIA only for ${\\cal R}_{0}<1$, i.e.\n\n$$R_{D1}<{1\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o2}}\\tag{21}$$\n\nif negative resistance operation is not desired.\nCompensation is normally obtained by making $p_{o}$ dominant,\n$C_{L}\\gg C_{x}R_{D1}^{\\prime}/r_{o2}$, and/or by\ndegenerating $M_{2}$ to lower $\\beta =g_{m2}/(1+g_{m2}R_{S})$.\n\nWith the sign flipped to obtain normal negative shunt-shunt\nfeedback, $g_{m2}\\to -|g_{m2}|$, $\\Delta =g_{o2}(G_{D1}+g_{o1})+\ng_{m1}|g_{m2}|$, ${\\cal R}_{0}=-g_{m1}|g_{m2}|R_{D1}^{\\prime}r_{o2}$\nand\n\n$$R_{M}=-{|g_{m1}|\\over g_{o2}(G_{D1}+g_{o1})+|g_{m1}g_{m2}|}\n\\approx -{1\\over |g_{m2}|}{1\\over 1+1/|{\\cal R}_{0}|}$$\n\n$$R_{X}={G_{D1}+g_{o1}\\over g_{o2}(G_{D1}+g_{o1})+g_{m1}|g_{m2}|}\n\\approx {1\\over |g_{m1}g_{m2}|R_{D1}^{\\prime}}\\parallel r_{o2}\\approx 0$$\n\n$$R_{o}={g_{o2}\\over g_{o2}(G_{D1}+g_{o1})+g_{m1}|g_{m2}|}\n\\approx {R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\over |{\\cal R}_{0}|}\\approx 0$$\n\nthe usual desensitized, low input and low output impedance\nTIA with phase margin determined by $p_{x},p_{o}$ and\n$|{\\cal R}_{0}|\\gg 1$, $GBW\\approx |g_{m1}|/C_{o}$.\n\nAny moderate $R_{D1}$ then gives stable operation,\n$|R_{M}|\\approx R_{F}$ where $R_{F}=1/g_{m2}$ is the synthetic\nfeedback resistor. Adding a physical resistor $R_{F}$ from\n$o$ to $X$ in parallel with $M_{2}$ gives $R_{M}\\approx\n-R_{F}\\parallel 1/g_{m2}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6d23fc2c57d69bd406964f1c3781d2db832e47b2010d7047ff3f0da5008ad39a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly treats M2 as a common-source device with its gate driven by Vout, identifies the regenerative loop through M1 and M2, and states that the usual loop gain causes latching. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "966942e01d767dcc8afc948021623863d816cf7567c0ad0be0b855267f6da7e8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2202,
        "output_tokens": 12513,
        "total_tokens": 14715,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9310,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2202,
        "output_tokens": 12513,
        "total_tokens": 14715,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9310,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 28,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-028-current-input-positive-feedback/figure-22.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "The device is a ${\\rm sh}{\\rm -sh}$ i.e.\n${\\cal V}-{\\cal I}$ i.e. transresistance amplifier.\n$I_{in}\\rightarrow V_{out}$.\n\n$$R_{M}=V_{out}/I_{in}\\;\\;\\;{\\rm dim}: \\Omega $$\n\nForward amplifier:\n\n$$M_{1}:v_{g1}=V_{x}\\;\\;v_{d1}=V_{out}\\;\\;\ni_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{x}+g_{o1}v_{out}+g_{mb1}v_{bs}$$\n\n$$g_{o}=1/r_{o}\\approx \\lambda I_{D}$$\n\nin this 3 T symbol bulk to $GND$ so $v_{bs}=0$\nfor $M_{1},M_{2}$. With bulk effect replace\n$g_{m2}\\rightarrow g_{m2}+g_{mb2}$.\n\nFeedback amplifier:\n\n$$M_{2}:v_{g2}=V_{out}\\;\\;v_{d2}=V_{x}\\;\\;\ni_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{out}+g_{o2}v_{x}$$\n\n$$R_{D1}$$ to $ac$ $GND$ at $V_{DD}$.\n\nSmall signal at $X$ the gate of $M_{1}$ is open:\n\n$$ I_{in}=i_{d2}\\tag{1}$$\n\nat $V_{out}$ the gate of $M_{2}$ is open:\n\n$$ {V_{out}\\over R_{D1}}+i_{d1}=0\\tag{2}$$\n\ni. e. $V_{out}=-i_{d1}R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1}$,\ninverting common source.\n\nFrom (1)(2) neglecting bulk for simplicity\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{in}&=g_{m2}V_{out}+g_{o2}V_{x}\\cr\n0&=V_{out}\\left({1\\over R_{D1}}+g_{o1}\\right)+g_{m1}V_{x}} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${1\\over R_{D1}}+g_{o1}=1/R_{D1}^{\\prime}=\n1/(R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1})$$\n\nElimination of $V_{x}$:\n\n$$V_{x}=-V_{out}{1/R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\over g_{m1}} $$\n\n$$I_{in}=V_{out}\\left[g_{m2}-g_{o2}{1/R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\over\ng_{m1}}\\right] \\tag{4}$$\n\n$$R_{M}\\equiv {V_{out}\\over I_{in}}=\n{1\\over \\displaystyle g_{m2}-g_{o2}{1/R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\over g_{m1}}}\n={1\\over g_{m2}}{1\\over 1-g_{o2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}/g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}} \\tag{5}$$\n\nWith $r_{o}\\rightarrow \\infty $:\n\n$$R_{M0}= {1\\over g_{m2}}\\;\\;{\\rm to\\;first\\;order}\\tag{6}$$\n\nThe sign depends on the reference direction of $I_{in}$.\nWith the passive sign $V_{out}=-|R_{M}|I_{in}$,\n$|R_{M}|\\approx 1/g_{m2}$.  I.e. the\nfeedback transistor synthesises a feedback\nresistance\n\n$$R_{F}\\equiv 1/g_{m2}\\parallel r_{o2}$$\n\nThe ideal resistive ${\\rm sh}-{\\rm sh}$ TIA is\n$R_{M}=-R_{F}/(1+1/LG)\\approx -R_{F}$.  Here\n$R_{F}$ is active and tunable by the bias\n$I_{D2}=I_{in,DC}$ :\n\n$$g_{m2}=\\sqrt{2k_{n}I_{D2}}=\\sqrt{2k_{n}I_{in,DC}}$$\n\nSo the transresistance is electronically tunable.\n\nThe DC bias, in saturation:\n\n$$I_{D2,DC}=I_{in,DC}={k_{2}\\over 2}(V_{out}-V_{T})^{2}\n(1+\\lambda_{2}V_{x})$$\n$$I_{D1,DC}={V_{DD}-V_{out}\\over R_{D1}}=\n{k_{1}\\over 2}(V_{x}-V_{T})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{1}V_{out})$$\n$$V_{x}=V_{DS2}\\;\\;,\\;\\;V_{out}=V_{DS1}$$\n\nSaturation requires\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{out}&\\ge V_{x}-V_{T}\\cr\nV_{x}&\\ge V_{out}-V_{T}\\cr\n&\\left|V_{out}-V_{x}\\right|\\le V_{T}}$$\n\nOtherwise $M_{2}$ goes triode\n\n$$I_{D}=k_{n}\\left[(V_{GS}-V_{T})V_{DS}-V_{DS}^{2}/2\\right]$$\n\n$$g_{m}=k_{n}V_{DS}\\;\\;,\\;\\;g_{o}=k_{n}(V_{GS}-V_{T}-V_{DS})$$\n\nand $M_{2}$ is a voltage controlled resistor\n$1/g_{o2}$ from $X$ to $GND$.\n\n### Loop gain - nature of the feedback\n\nForward gain\n\n$$A_{v}= {V_{out}\\over V_{x}}=-g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}$$\n\nFeedback gain\n\n$$i_{f}=g_{m2}V_{out}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\n\\beta \\equiv {i_{f}\\over V_{out}}=g_{m2}$$\n\nClosing the loop in the usual ${\\rm sh}-{\\rm sh}$\nsense $V_{out}=A(V_{x})$ , $i_{f}=\\beta V_{out}$\n\n$$T\\equiv -A\\beta = g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}g_{m2}r_{o2}$$\n\nmore exactly from (3)\n\n$$T_{0}= {g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over g_{o2}R_{D1}^{\\prime\\,-1}}\n=g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\times g_{m2}r_{o2} \\tag{7}$$\n\n$V_{x}\\to M_{1}\\to V_{out}$ is inverting, \n$V_{out}\\to M_{2}\\to V_{x}$ is also inverting,\ncommon source.  Two inversions $=0$ deg.\n\n> The loop is {\\it positive} feedback.\n\nIndeed let $\\Delta I_{in}>0\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\n\\Delta V_{x}>0\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\\Delta V_{out}=\n-g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\Delta V_{x}<0\\;\\Rightarrow\\;\n\\Delta i_{d2}=g_{m2}\\Delta V_{out}<0$.\nA decrease of the current sunk by $M_{2}$ from\nnode $X$ leaves more of $I_{in}$ to raise $V_{x}$.\nRegenerative.\n\nNormal negative ${\\rm sh}-{\\rm sh}$ uses a\nnon inverting feedback stage, e.g. common gate\nsource of $M_{2}$ to $X$, drain to $V_{out}$,\nor a source follower, or a resistor, or a $PMOS$\n$M_{2}$.\n\nWith positive feedback the closed loop\ndenominator is $1-T$ not $1+T$.\n\nFrom (5)\n\n$$R_{M}={A\\over 1-T^{-1}} \\propto {1\\over 1-T}$$\n\n$$Z_{in}\\equiv {V_{x}\\over I_{in}}=\n{1\\over g_{o2}-g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}}=\n-{R_{D1}^{\\prime}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}}\n{1\\over 1-T^{-1}}\\approx -{1\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}}\\tag{8}$$\n\nfor large $T$.\n\n$$Z_{out}\\equiv {V_{test}\\over I_{test}}\\Bigg|_{I_{in}=0}\n={1\\over R_{D1}^{\\prime\\,-1}-g_{m1}g_{m2}/g_{o2}}\n=-{r_{o2}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}}\n{1\\over 1-T^{-1}}\\approx -{1\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o2}}g_{o2}^{-1}\\tag{9}$$\n\ni.e. with the usual design values\n$g_{m}R_{D}\\gg 1$, $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$,\n\n$$|T|\\approx 10-100\\gg 1$$\n\nthe input and output impedances are {\\it negative}\nand small. The ideal ${\\rm sh}-{\\rm sh}$ result\n$Z_{in}=R_{F}/(1+LG)\\rightarrow 0$,\n$Z_{out}=R_{D}/(1+LG)\\rightarrow 0$ is recovered\nin magnitude but with a sign reversal due to the\npositive return ratio.\n\n### Stability\n\nFor a one dominant pole loop positive feedback is stable\niff\n\n$$T_{0}<1$$\n\n$$g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}r_{o2}<1\\tag{10}$$\n\nOtherwise the circuit latches as a bistable or\noscillates when the two poles\n\n$$p_{x}\\approx {1\\over r_{o2}C_{x}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\np_{out}\\approx {1\\over R_{D1}^{\\prime}C_{out}}$$\n\nadd $180^{o}$ to the $0^{o}$ $dc$ phase, i.e.\nthe usual $360^{o}$ $Barkhausen$ condition.\n\nIn practice with $r_{o2}\\to\\infty$ the ideal\nmodel is singular, $T_{0}\\to\\infty$, the circuit is\ninherently unstable as a linear amplifier.\nIt is usable as:\n\n* a tunable negative resistance\n$R_{in}\\approx -1/g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}$ to cancel\nloss or to make an active inductor/gyrator,\n* a regenerative latch/Schmitt trigger when\n$T>1$,\n* a very low $1/g_{m2}$ transimpedance stage\nif $R_{D1}$ is made small enough or degenerated\nso that (10) is satisfied.\n\nTo get conventional negative feed-back TIA swap\nthe feedback device to common gate/drain:\nsource of $M_{2}$ to $X$, drain to $V_{out}$ or\nto $V_{DD}$, gate to $ac$ $GND$ or use $PMOS$\n$M_{2}$. Then $A\\beta =-g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}\n\\times (-1)$ and\n\n$$R_{M}\\approx -{1\\over g_{m2}}\\parallel R_{F},\\;\\;\nZ_{in}\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}}\\,{1\\over 1+LG}>0,\\;\\;\nZ_{out}\\approx {R_{D1}\\over 1+LG}>0$$\n\nstable for any $LG>0$.\n\nWith the circuit as drawn include $r_{o}$ and\nparasitic $C_{gs},C_{gd},C_{db}$ to evaluate\n\n$$LG(s)= {g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}r_{o2}\\over\n(1+sR_{D1}^{\\prime}C_{out})(1+sr_{o2}C_{x})}$$\n\nand compensate with a dominant $C_{c}$ at $V_{out}$\nor by source degeneration of $M_{1}$ to reduce $T$.\n\n> In short: $M_{1}+R_{D1}$ is the $A_{v}=-g_{m1}\nR_{D1}^{\\prime}$ voltage gain stage, $M_{2}$ is a\n$g_{m2}$ shunt feedback transconductor synthesizing\n$R_{F}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$.  As drawn the two stage\nloop is non-inverting $\\to$ positive ${\\rm sh}-{\\rm sh}$\nfeedback, $|R_{M}|\\approx 1/g_{m2}$,\n$Z_{in},Z_{out}$ negative $\\propto -1/T$, stable\nonly for $g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}r_{o2}<1$.\nFor normal negative feedback operation the phase of\nthe feedback stage must be inverted.\n\nIf $\\lambda =0$, $r_{o}\\to\\infty$ form gives\n$R_{M}=1/g_{m2}$, $V_{x}=-I_{in}/g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}$,\nformal $Z_{in}=0^{-}$, $Z_{out}=0^{-}$. Finite\n$r_{o}$ must be retained to get finite\n$T$ and finite negative $Z$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "cb155c92a2bb988d193c165e8d0ac983b139e492fb854009b6ad6e6c53533888"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies that M2’s gate is tied to Vout, recognizes the positive-feedback loop through M1 and M2, and states the resulting negative input impedance and instability/latching. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "966942e01d767dcc8afc948021623863d816cf7567c0ad0be0b855267f6da7e8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2202,
        "output_tokens": 13858,
        "total_tokens": 16060,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10769,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2202,
        "output_tokens": 13858,
        "total_tokens": 16060,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10769,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 29,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier/figure-23.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "The circuit is a shunt-shunt, voltage sampling\ncurrent mixing, transresistance feedback amplifier,\nnormally used as a Transimpedance Amplifier, TIA.\nIt can be regarded as a regulated cascode.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}&:{\\rm C.G.}, R_{D1} {\\rm load} \\cr\nM_{2}&:{\\rm C.S.}, R_{D2} {\\rm load}\\cr\nR_{F}&:{\\rm global }\\;{\\rm feedback}\\;\\;V_{o}\\to I_{i}}\n\\tag{1}$$\n\nDC can be made $V_{GS1}=V_{b}-V_{A}$,\n$V_{DS1}=V_{X}-V_{A}>V_{GS1}-V_{T}$,\n$V_{DS2}=V_{o}>V_{GS2}-V_{T}$ by choice of\n$V_{b},R_{D1},R_{D2}$ and the d.c. value of\n$I_{in}$ and the d.c. drop in $R_{F}$,\n$I_{D1}=I_{in,DC}+(V_{A}-V_{o})/R_{F}$,\n$I_{D2}=(V_{DD}-V_{o})/R_{D2}$.\nIn a.c. $V_{DD}$ is ground and $V_{b}$ is ground.\nPut $G_{D1}=R_{D1}^{-1},G_{D2}=R_{D2}^{-1},\nG_{F}=R_{F}^{-1},g_{ds}=r_{o}^{-1}$.\n\nFor the nMOS version the bulk is\nstrapped to the source so that in first order\n$g_{mb}=0$. With $g_{mb}\\ne 0$ put\n$g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb},R_{D}\\to R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$.\n\n> Bias is irrelevant for the feedback\n> classification. For a.c. the small signal\n> circuit is Fig.1\n\n$$v_{gs1}=-v_{a}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{gs2}=v_{x}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\nv_{ds1}=v_{x}-v_{a}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{ds2}=v_{o}$$\n\n$${\\rm drain\\;current}=g_{m}v_{gs}+g_{ds}v_{ds}\n\\tag{2}$$\nfrom drain to source.\n\nWith the signs of Fig.1, currents leaving a node\n$>0$:\n\n* $X$:\n\n$$ {v_{x}\\over R_{D1}}+{v_{x}-v_{a}\\over r_{o1}}\n+g_{m1}v_{gs1}=0 \\tag{3a}$$\n$$v_{x}\\left(G_{D1}+g_{ds1}\\right)-v_{a}\\left(g_{m1}+g_{ds1}\\right)=0$$\n$$v_{x}=v_{a}\\,{g_{m1}+g_{ds1}\\over G_{D1}+g_{ds1}}\n\\approx g_{m1}\\left(R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1}\\right)v_{a}\n\\tag{3b}$$\ni.e. the current $i_{s}=g_{m1}v_{a}$ driven\ninto the source of the CG is converted to\n$v_{x}=i_{s}(R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1})$.\n\n* $a\\equiv$ input, $o\\equiv$ output:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\na:&{v_{a}-v_{o}\\over R_{F}}+{v_{a}-v_{x}\\over r_{o1}}\n-g_{m1}v_{gs1}-I_{in}=0\\cr\n &v_{a}\\left(G_{F}+g_{ds1}+g_{m1}\\right)-v_{x}g_{ds1}\n -v_{o}G_{F}=I_{in}\\tag{4a}\\cr\no:&{v_{o}\\over R_{D2}}+{v_{o}\\over r_{o2}}+g_{m2}v_{x}\n+{v_{o}-v_{a}\\over R_{F}}=0\\cr\n &v_{o}\\left(G_{D2}+g_{ds2}+G_{F}\\right)+v_{x}g_{m2}\n -v_{a}G_{F}=0\\tag{4b}}$$\n\nFor $r_{o}\\to \\infty $:\n\n$$ \\eqalign{\nv_{x}&=g_{m1}R_{D1}v_{a}\\cr\nI_{in}&=v_{a}\\left(g_{m1}+G_{F}\\right)-v_{o}G_{F}\\cr\n0&=v_{o}\\left(G_{D2}+G_{F}\\right)+v_{a}\\left(g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}-G_{F}\\right)}\\tag{5}$$\n\nEliminating $v_{a},v_{x}$,\n\n$${V_{o}\\over I_{in}}=-{1\\over\nG_{F}+{G_{F}+g_{m1}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}-G_{F}}\n\\left(G_{D2}+G_{F}\\right)}\\tag{6}$$\n\nwith $r_{o}$ finite replace $R_{Di}\\to R_{Di}\\parallel r_{oi}$,\n$g_{m1}\\to g_{m1}+g_{ds1}$etc. Eq.(6) is the exact\nclosed loop transresistance $R_{M}=V_{o}/I_{in}$.\n\nIt is a shunt-shunt feedback amplifier.\n$Y$ - parameters of $R_{F}$:\n\n$$Y_{F}=\\pmatrix{G_{F}&-G_{F}\\cr -G_{F}&G_{F}} \\tag{7}$$\n\nso that the feedback is\n\n$$ I_{f}=G_{F}V_{o}\\;\\;{\\rm with\\;a\\;minus\\;sign},\\qquad\n\\beta ={I_{f}\\over V_{o}}=-G_{F}=-{1\\over R_{F}} \\tag{8}$$\n\n$$R_{M}={V_{o}\\over I_{in}}={A_{0}\\over 1+\\beta A_{0}}\n\\equiv -{1\\over \\beta}{T\\over 1+T}\\tag{9}$$\n\nwhere $A_{0}=V_{o}/I_{in}\\vert_{R_{F}=0}$ is the\nopen loop transresistance. From (5) with $G_{F}=0$,\n\n$$A_{0}= -g_{m2}R_{D2}R_{D1}\\;\\;{\\rm in\\;the\\;limit}\\;\nr_{o}\\to\\infty \\tag{10}$$\nmore generally $A_{0}\\approx -g_{m2}(R_{D2}\\parallel r_{o2})\n(R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1})$, the cascade of the\n$I\\to V_{x}$ conversion $R_{D1}$ and the C.S. gain\n$-g_{m2}R_{D2}$.\n\nThe loop gain $T=-\\beta A_{0}$ is in the ideal limit\n\n$$T_{0}\\approx {A_{0}\\over R_{F}}={g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\over\nR_{F}(g_{m1}+G_{F})}\\left(G_{D2}+G_{F}\\right)\n\\approx {g_{m2}R_{D1}\\over 1+R_{D2}/R_{F}} \\tag{11}$$\n\nfor $g_{m1}R_{F}\\gg 1$, $g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}\\gg G_{F}$.\n\nIndeed from (6) with $g_{m1}\\gg G_{F}$,\n\n$${V_{o}\\over I_{in}}=\n-{1\\over G_{F}+{G_{D2}+G_{F}\\over g_{m2}R_{D1}}}\n=-{R_{F}\\over 1+{1+R_{F}/R_{D2}\\over g_{m2}R_{D1}}}\n=-R_{F}{T\\over 1+T}\\tag{12}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$T\\approx {g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\over R_{F}}\\,\n{1\\over 1+R_{D2}/R_{F}}={g_{m2}R_{D1}\\over 1+R_{F}/R_{D2}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nIncluding $r_{o}$,\n\n$$T\\approx {g_{m2}(R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1})\n(R_{D2}\\parallel r_{o2})\\over R_{F}} \\tag{14}$$\nup to the loading of $R_{F}$.\n\nHence for $|T|\\gg 1$, i.e.\n\n$$g_{m2}R_{D1}\\gg 1+{R_{F}\\over R_{D2}},\\qquad\ng_{m1}R_{F}\\gg 1 \\tag{15}$$\n\n$$\\;R_{M}\\approx -R_{F}\\; \\tag{16}$$\n$$i_{RF}={v_{a}-v_{o}\\over R_{F}}\\approx -{v_{o}\\over R_{F}}\n\\approx I_{in}\\tag{17}$$\n\nthe usual shunt-shunt result: the feedback current\nalmost cancels the input current, the input node is\na virtual ground for current. The sign is inverting:\na positive $I_{in}$ flowing into the source of $M_{1}$\nraises $v_{x}$, lowers $v_{o}$.\n\nThe error with finite $T$ is from (12)\n\n$${R_{M}+R_{F}\\over R_{F}}\\approx\n{1+R_{F}/R_{D2}\\over g_{m2}R_{D1}}\n+{1\\over g_{m1}R_{F}}+{\\cal O}(g_{ds}R_{D}) \\tag{18}$$\n\nIn the high gain limit the dependence on $g_{m1}$\ncancels to first order because the forward\n$I_{in}\\to V_{x}$ gain is $R_{D1}$, not\n$g_{m1}R_{D1}$: $v_{a}=I_{in}/g_{m1}$,\n$v_{x}=g_{m1}R_{D1}v_{a}=R_{D1}I_{in}$.\n\nExample: $g_{m1}=g_{m2}=1\\,{\\rm mS}$,\n$R_{D1}=R_{D2}=5\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$,\n$R_{F}=10\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$, $r_{o}\\to\\infty$,\n\n$$A_{0}=-25\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}\\times 5= -125\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$$\n$$T\\approx {g_{m2}R_{D1}\\over 1+R_{F}/R_{D2}}=5/3=1.7$$\n$$R_{M}\\approx -10\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}/(1+1/T)=-6.2\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$$\nincreasing $R_{D1}$ to $20\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$ gives\n$T\\approx 6.7$, $R_{M}\\approx -8.7\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}\\to -R_{F}$.\n\nWith $g_{m}=5\\,{\\rm mS}$, $T\\approx 8-25$,\n$R_{M}\\approx -0.9R_{F}$.\n\nInput resistance at the source of $M_{1}$.\nOpen loop $R_{in0}\\approx 1/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1})\n\\parallel r_{o1}\\approx 1/g_{m1}$.\nClosed loop, from (5),\n\n$$R_{in}={v_{a}\\over I_{in}}=\n{R_{M}\\over -g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m2}R_{D2}}\\,\n\\left(G_{D2}+G_{F}\\right)\\approx\n{1+R_{F}/R_{D2}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}}\n\\approx {R_{F}\\over T\\,g_{m1}R_{D2}}\\tag{19}$$\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx {R_{D2}+R_{F}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}\n\\parallel {1\\over g_{m1}}\\,{1\\over 1+T}\\tag{20}$$\n\nvery low, ${\\cal O}(10-100\\,\\Omega)$ for\n$g_{m}R_{D}\\sim 10-20$. This is the regulated\ncascode action: $M_{2}$ regulates the gate of\n$M_{1}$ via $R_{F}$ to lower the input impedance\nby $1+T$.\n\nOutput resistance, voltage sampling, is lowered:\n\nInject $v_{t}$ at the output, $I_{in}=0$.\n\n$$0=v_{a}(g_{m1}+G_{F})-v_{t}G_{F},\\;\\;\nv_{x}=g_{m1}R_{D1}v_{a}$$\n$$i_{t}=v_{t}(G_{D2}+G_{F})+g_{m2}v_{x}-v_{a}G_{F}$$\n\n$$R_{out}={v_{t}\\over i_{t}}=\n{1\\over G_{D2}+G_{F}+{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}-G_{F}\\over 1+g_{m1}R_{F}}}\n\\tag{21}$$\n\n$$\\approx {1\\over G_{D2}+{1+g_{m2}R_{D1}\\over R_{F}}}\n= R_{D2}\\parallel {R_{F}\\over 1+g_{m2}R_{D1}}\n\\approx {R_{D2}\\over 1+T'}\\tag{22}$$\n\nwhere $T'\\approx g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}/R_{F}$.\nFor $g_{m2}R_{D1}\\gg 1$, $R_{out}\\approx\nR_{F}/g_{m2}R_{D1}\\parallel R_{D2}$, a few\n$100\\,\\Omega$.\n\nFrequency response. Two dominant poles:\n\n$$p_{x}\\approx {1\\over (R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1})C_{x}},\\;\nC_{x}=C_{gd1}+C_{db1}+C_{gs2}+C_{gb2}+C_{gd2}(1+g_{m2}R_{D2})$$\n$$p_{o}\\approx {1\\over (R_{D2}\\parallel r_{o2}\\parallel R_{F})C_{o}},\\;\nC_{o}=C_{db2}+C_{gd2}+C_{L}+C_{F}$$\n$$p_{in}\\approx {1\\over R_{in}C_{in}},\\;C_{in}=C_{gs1}+C_{sb1}+C_{F}$$\n\nvery high because $R_{in}$ is small.\nThe loop gain is two-pole,\n\n$$T(s)\\approx {T_{0}\\over (1+s/p_{x})(1+s/p_{o})}\\tag{23}$$\n\nwith unity gain frequency $\\omega_{u}\\approx T_{0}p_{x}$\nif $p_{x}<p_{o}$. Phase $\\approx -180^{\\circ}$ at\n$\\omega\\approx\\sqrt{p_{x}p_{o}}$, so the two stage\nshunt-shunt TIA can be underdamped or unstable if\n$p_{x}\\approx p_{o}$. Normally $p_{o}$ is made\ndominant by load $C_{L}$ or a Miller $C_{c}$ between\n$v_{o}$ and $v_{x}$ or a series $R_{c}$ with $R_{F}$\nis used for compensation. The closed loop\n$-3{\\rm dB}$ frequency is $\\approx (1+T_{0})\\min(p_{x},p_{o})$,\ni.e. bandwidth extension by feedback, the classic\ngain-bandwidth trade-off of the TIA.\n\nIn summary, up to output swing and headroom\nlimitations, the circuit is a negative\nvoltage-shunt feedback amplifier whose ideal\nclosed loop behaviour is a transimpedance\n\n$$V_{out}\\approx -I_{in}R_{F},\\qquad Z_{in}\\to 0,\\qquad\nZ_{out}\\to 0$$\n\nwith finite loop gain corrections (12),(19),(22) and\nstability determined by the poles at $X$ and at the\noutput. It is widely used as a wideband low $Z_{in}$\ncurrent buffer, optical front end, $RGC$ TIA, with\nnoise, power and bandwidth set by $g_{m1},g_{m2},\nR_{D1},R_{D2}$ and $R_{F}$. Including $r_{o}$ and\n$g_{mb}$ replace $R_{D}\\to R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$,\n$g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "0929903f6ce715cf5736800f2ff6da4e2ed56a946244a3e0309b35dbd196a8da"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate input device, M2 as a common-source stage driven by X, and RF as feedback from Vout to the input, forming a transimpedance amplifier. This meets the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3de185b163e9067ba58585d0a347eecc50f9da3dc36d0d1a8e05a54adcc11752",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2509,
        "output_tokens": 21324,
        "total_tokens": 23833,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 17318,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2509,
        "output_tokens": 21324,
        "total_tokens": 23833,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 17318,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 29,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier/figure-23.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "{\\it The $R_{F}$ $X\\to V_{o}\\to R_{F}$ amplifier\nis the normal ${\\rm shunt\\, (at\\, the\\, input)}\\times \n{\\rm shunt\\, (at\\, the\\, output)}$ or voltage/current\nfeedback transimpedance amplifier - current in\nvoltage out - in its 2 transistor realisation -\nthe regulated cascode. }With $R_{F}=0$ it is\na conventional cascade $CG-CS$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nM_{1}&:g_{m1},r_{o1}:{\\rm CG\\; }X-R_{D1}{\\rm\\; load}\\cr\nM_{2}&:g_{m2},r_{o2}:{\\rm CS\\; }R_{D2}{\\rm\\; load, }v_{G2}=\nV_{X}\\cr}$$\n\n$V_{b}$ ac ground fixes $I_{D1}$, $I_{D2}$ through\n$R_{D1},R_{D2}$.\n\n$$V_{X0}=V_{DD}-I_{D1}R_{D1}\\qquad V_{o0}=V_{DD}-I_{D2}R_{D2}$$\n$$V_{S1}\\approx V_{b}-V_{GS1}\\approx V_{b}-V_{TH}\n-\\sqrt{2I_{D1}/k_{n}}$$\nin saturation if $V_{X}>V_{S1}+V_{ov1}$ ,\n$V_{o}>V_{ov2}$.\n\nSmall signal $V_{DD}=0$, $V_{b}=0$.\n\n>$$v_{gs1}=-v_{a}\\qquad v_{gs2}=v_{x}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$i_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{gs1}+g_{ob1}v_{ds1}\\qquad \ni_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{gs2}+g_{ob2}v_{ds2}$$\n$g_{ob}=r_{o}^{-1}$.  $r_{o}=\\infty $ at first.\n\nThe $R_{F}$ is the feedback\ntwo port ${\\bf Y}_{F}=\\left[\\,{\\scriptstyle 1/R_{F}\\;\\;\n-1/R_{F}\\atop\\scriptstyle -1/R_{F}\\;\\;1/R_{F}}\\,\\right]$.\nIt samples\n\n$$v_{o}\\tag{2}$$\n\nand mixes\n\n$$i_{F}= {v_{a}-v_{o}\\over R_{F}}\\approx -{v_{o}\\over R_{F}}\\tag{3}$$\n\nin shunt with the signal current $I_{in}$ at the low\nimpedance source node $a$ of $M_{1}$ and in shunt\nwith $v_{o}$ at the output.  It is voltage-sampling,\ncurrent mixing, shunt-shunt, $Y-Z$ feedback.\n$\\beta =i_{f}/v_{o}\\approx -1/R_{F}$.\n\nWith $i_{F}$ as in (3) the $a$ port KCL is\n\n$$I_{in}+i_{F}= i_{s1}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand $v_{o}=Z_{m}I_{in}$, $Z_{m}$ the transresistance,\n{\\it transimpedance}, ideally $Z_{m}=-R_{F}$.\n\nCutting $R_{F}$ the forward amplifier loaded by the\nfeedback is, for $r_{o}\\to\\infty$,\n\n$$v_{x}=g_{m1}R_{D1}'v_{a}\\tag{5}$$\n$$v_{o}=-g_{m2}R_{D2}'v_{x}=-g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}'R_{D2}'v_{a}\n\\tag{6}$$\nwith\n\n$$R_{D1}'=R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1}\\qquad \nR_{D2}'=R_{D2}\\parallel r_{o2}\\tag{7}$$\n\nif $r_{o1}$ is taken between $X$ and $a$.  More\nexactly\n\n$$v_{x}\\left({1\\over R_{D1}}+{1\\over r_{o1}}\\right)\n-v_{a}\\left({1\\over r_{o1}}+g_{m1}\\right)=0\\tag{8}$$\n\ni. e. $v_{x}=g_{m1}(R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1})v_{a}$ to\n$g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$.  Open loop voltage gain\n$A_{v}=v_{o}/v_{a}=-g_{m1}R_{D1}'g_{m2}R_{D2}'$.\nOpen loop transimpedance {\\it with the $R_{F}$\nloading at both ports grounded},\n\n$$Z_{mo}= {v_{o}\\over I_{in}}\\Bigl|_{R_{F}{\\rm \\;as\\;\nload}}\\approx -{1\\over g_{m1}}g_{m1}R_{D1}'g_{m2}R_{D2}'\n =-R_{D1}'g_{m2}R_{D2}'\\tag{9}$$\n\nsince without feedback $R_{in,ol}\\approx 1/g_{m1}\n\\parallel R_{F}$.\n\nIndeed for $r_{o}\\to\\infty$ nodal analysis without\napproximation gives\n\n* $X$ :\n\n$${v_{x}\\over R_{D1}}+i_{d1}=0\\qquad \ni_{d1}=-g_{m1}v_{a}\\tag{10}$$\n\n$$v_{x}=g_{m1}R_{D1}v_{a}\\tag{11}$$\n\n* $o$ :\n\n$${v_{o}\\over R_{D2}}+g_{m2}v_{x}+{v_{o}-v_{a}\\over R_{F}}=0\n\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$v_{a}\\left(g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}-{1\\over R_{F}}\\right)+\nv_{o}\\left({1\\over R_{D2}}+{1\\over R_{F}}\\right)=0\\tag{13}$$\n\n* $a$ :\n\n$${v_{a}-v_{o}\\over R_{F}}-i_{d1}=I_{in}\\tag{14}$$\n\n$${v_{a}-v_{o}\\over R_{F}}+g_{m1}v_{a}=I_{in}\\tag{15}$$\n\nHence from (13)\n\n$$v_{a}=-v_{o}{1/R_{D2}+1/R_{F}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}\n-1/R_{F}}\\tag{16}$$\n\nand\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{in}&=v_{a}\\left(g_{m1}+{1\\over R_{F}}\\right)-{v_{o}\\over R_{F}}\\cr\n&=-v_{o}\\left[{1\\over R_{F}}+\\left(g_{m1}+{1\\over R_{F}}\\right)\n{1/R_{D2}+1/R_{F}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}-1/R_{F}}\\right]\\cr}\\tag{17}$$\n\ni. e. the exact closed loop transresistance for\n$r_{o}\\to\\infty$:\n\n$$\\;\nZ_{m}={v_{o}\\over I_{in}}=\n-{{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}-1/R_{F}}\\over \n{{1\\over R_{F}R_{D2}}+{g_{m1}\\over R_{D2}}+{g_{m1}\\over R_{F}}\n+{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}\\over R_{F}}}}\\;\n\\tag{18}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nZ_{m}&=-{R_{D2}R_{F}\\left(g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}-1/R_{F}\\right)\\over\n1+g_{m1}R_{F}+g_{m1}R_{D2}+g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}\\cr\n&=-R_{F}{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}-R_{D2}/R_{F}\\over\n1+g_{m1}\\left(R_{F}+R_{D2}+g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\right)}\\cr}\\tag{19}$$\n\nFor $g_{m1}R_{F}\\gg 1$, $g_{m2}R_{D1}\\gg 1$,\n\n$$Z_{m}\\approx -R_{F}{g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\over\nR_{F}+R_{D2}+g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}\n=-R_{F}{1\\over 1+{R_{F}+R_{D2}\\over g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}}\\tag{20}$$\n\nand for large loop gain\n\n$$g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\gg R_{F},R_{D2}\\tag{21}$$\n\n$$\\;Z_{m}\\approx -R_{F}\\; \\tag{22}$$\n\nthe well known $R_{F}$ transimpedance. More generally\n\n$$Z_{m}={Z_{mo}\\over 1+\\beta Z_{mo}},\\qquad \n\\beta\\approx -1/R_{F}\\tag{23}$$\n\nwith $Z_{mo}\\approx -g_{m2}R_{D2}R_{D1}$.\n\nIncluding $r_{o}$ $R_{D1}\\to R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1}$,\n$R_{D2}\\to R_{D2}\\parallel r_{o2}$ and (18) becomes\n\n$$Z_{m}\\approx -{\\,R_{F}\\parallel R_{D2}'\\,g_{m2}R_{D1}'\\,\n\\over 1+g_{m1}(R_{F}\\parallel\\ldots)}\\approx -R_{F}$$\nto the same order.\n\nThe closed loop port impedances follow from\nBlackman.  E. g. with a test $v_{x}$ at the\noutput, $I_{in}=0$, from (15) $v_{a}=v_{o}/(1+g_{m1}R_{F})$,\n$v_{x}=g_{m1}R_{D1}v_{a}$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nR_{in}&={v_{a}\\over I_{in}}=\n{R_{F}+R_{D2}\\over 1+g_{m1}\\left(R_{F}+R_{D2}\n+g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\right)}\\approx\n{1\\over g_{m1}}{1\\over 1+g_{m2}R_{D2}R_{D1}/(R_{F}+R_{D2})}\\cr\n&\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}(1+g_{m2}R_{D2})}\n\\quad R_{F}\\gg R_{D2}\\cr}\\tag{24}$$\n\nwithout feedback $R_{in,ol}\\approx 1/g_{m1}$.\nThe extra $1+g_{m2}R_{D2}$ is the regulation.\nIn RGC terminology $G_{m,eff}=g_{m1}(1+g_{m2}R_{D2})$,\nthe cascode is ``regulated''.\n\n$$\\;\nR_{out}={v_{o}\\over i_{t}}\\Bigl|_{I_{in}=0}\n={R_{D2}\\left(1+g_{m1}R_{F}\\right)\\over\n1+g_{m1}\\left(R_{F}+R_{D2}+g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\right)}\n\\approx {R_{D2}\\over 1+g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}/R_{F}}\n\\approx {R_{F}\\over g_{m2}R_{D1}}\\;\n\\tag{25}$$\n\nfor $g_{m1}R_{F}\\gg 1$.  Without feedback $R_{out,ol}\n=R_{D2}'$.  Both port impedances are divided by\n$1+T$, $T$ the loop gain.  From (24)\n\n$$1+T\\approx 1+{g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\over R_{F}+R_{D2}}\n\\approx {g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\over R_{F}}\\tag{26}$$\n\nmore exactly $T=g_{m2}R_{D2}R_{D1}/(R_{F}+1/g_{m1})$\nfrom breaking the loop at $G_{2}$.  Typically\n$10-20\\,{\\rm dB}$.\n\nFrequency: with $C_{X}$ at $X$, $C_{o}$ at the output\nand $C_{in}$ at the input - dominated by the\nphotodiode -,\n\n$$\\omega_{pX}\\approx {1\\over R_{D1}'C_{X}},\\qquad\n\\omega_{po}\\approx {1\\over R_{D2}'C_{o}},\\qquad\n\\omega_{pa}\\approx {1\\over R_{in}C_{in}}\\tag{27}$$\n\nFeedback moves the low frequency input pole up by\n$1+T$ and splits the $X$ and $o$ poles, giving\nlarge bandwidth for a capacitive source.  The\nloop is two pole, $L(s)\\approx L_{0}/(1+s/\\omega_{pX})\n(1+s/\\omega_{po})$, so phase margin must be checked.\nUsually a small $C_{F}$ in parallel with $R_{F}$ is\nadded to create a zero and stabilise, at the expense\nof a little peaking.\n\nIn short the circuit is a wide band low $Z_{in}$,\nmedium $Z_{out}$ transimpedance amplifier,\n$I_{in}\\to V_{out}\\approx -R_{F}I_{in}$, input current\n- e. g. photodiode - is sunk mainly in $R_{F}$,\n$i_{RF}\\approx -I_{in}$, voltage is generated across\n$R_{F}$.  It is universally used as CMOS optical\nreceiver front-end, TIA, RGC TIA. Noise, referred to\nthe input, $\\overline{i_{n,in}^{2}}\\approx\n4kT/R_{F}+4kT\\gamma g_{m1}+4kT\\gamma g_{m2}\n(R_{D1}/R_{F})^{2}+\\dots$ dominated by $R_{F}$ and\n$M_{1}$.\n\nWith $r_{o}$ finite replace $R_{D}\\to R_{D}\\parallel\nr_{o}$, $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}+g_{o}$; the expressions\nabove remain qualitatively. Body effect $M_{1}$ is\ncancelled if $n$-well is tied to $S_{1}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ab1aee95c58f3c7721a83ac9dcd34c7a9477086490b023f7cc8a112399de687c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate input device, M2 as a common-source stage driven by X, and RF as feedback from Vout to the input node, forming a transimpedance amplifier. The golden solution’s full-credit rule applies; the feedback sign and detailed calculations are not required.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3de185b163e9067ba58585d0a347eecc50f9da3dc36d0d1a8e05a54adcc11752",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2509,
        "output_tokens": 16486,
        "total_tokens": 18995,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12955,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2509,
        "output_tokens": 16486,
        "total_tokens": 18995,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12955,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 29,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-029-feedback-transimpedance-amplifier/figure-23.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "Made with the customary small signal model:\n\n$$M_{1}-CG~~~~M_{2}-CS~~~~R_{F}:{\\rm global}$$\n\n{\\it N.B.} In ordinary operation $M_{1}$ must be\n${\\rm N}$ so that $A_{1}=v_{x}/v_{s}>0$ so that\nwith $A_{2}=v_{o}/v_{x}=-g_{m2}R_{D2}'<0$ the\nreturn through $R_{F}$ be degenerative.\nWith the symbol as drawn $M_{1}$ is $P$ and the\nloop is regenerative. In what follows the useful\nform, $M_{1}$ ${\\rm N}$, $M_{2}$ ${\\rm N}$,\nis assumed, Fig. 1 with $r_{o}\\to \\infty $ for\nbrevity, $g_{ds}=r_{o}^{-1}$ can be put\n$R_{D}'=R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$.\n\n> {\\it Low Frequency Hybrid-$\\pi $}  $V_{b}=ac~0$,\n> $V_{DD}=ac~0$,\n\n$$v_{gs1}=v_{g1}-v_{s1}=-v_{a}\\tag{1}$$\n$$i_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{gs1}+g_{ds1}v_{ds1}\n      =-g_{m1}v_{a}+g_{ds1}(v_{x}-v_{a})\\tag{2}$$\n$$i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{x}+g_{ds2}v_{o}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$${\\rm KCL}\\;X: {v_{x} \\over R_{D1}}+i_{d1}=0\\tag{4}$$\n$${\\rm KCL}\\;o: {v_{o} \\over R_{D2}}+i_{d2}\n        +{v_{o}-v_{a} \\over R_{F}}=0\\tag{5}$$\n$${\\rm KCL}\\;a: I_{in}+i_{d1}-{v_{a}-v_{o} \\over R_{F}}=0\\tag{6}$$\nthe last because $i_{d1}$ enters $a$ at the source,\n$i_{RF}=(v_{a}-v_{o})/R_{F}$ leaving $a$ toward $o$.\n\nFrom (4)\n\n$$v_{x}\\left({1\\over R_{D1}}+g_{ds1}\\right)\n      -v_{a}\\left(g_{m1}+g_{ds1}\\right)=0$$\n\n$$v_{x}=v_{a}\\,{g_{m1}+g_{ds1}\\over G_{D1}+g_{ds1}}\n      \\approx g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}v_{a}>0 \\tag{7}$$\n\n$CG$ non inverting $A_{1}\\approx g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime}$.\nFor $r_{o}\\to \\infty $ $v_{x}=g_{m1}R_{D1}v_{a}$.\n\nPut $G_{Di}=1/R_{Di}$.\n\n(5): $g_{m2}v_{x}+v_{o}(G_{D2}+g_{ds2}+R_{F}^{-1})\n      -v_{a}R_{F}^{-1}=0$ (8)\n\n(6): $I_{in}+g_{ds1}v_{x}-v_{a}(g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+R_{F}^{-1})\n      +v_{o}R_{F}^{-1}=0$ (9)\n\n(7)-(9) is the exact closed loop system.  In matrix\nform $M_{c}{\\bf v}= {\\bf i}$,\n\n$$M_{c}=\\pmatrix{\nG_{D1}+g_{ds1}&0&-(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})\\cr\ng_{m2}&G_{D2}+g_{ds2}+R_{F}^{-1}&-R_{F}^{-1}\\cr\ng_{ds1}&R_{F}^{-1}&-(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})-R_{F}^{-1}\\cr}$$\n\n$${\\rm det}M_{c}= -\\left[\nG_{D1}(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})(G_{D2}+g_{ds2})\n+{G_{D1}(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})+(G_{D1}+g_{ds1})(G_{D2}+g_{ds2})\n+(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})g_{m2}\\over R_{F}}\\right] \\tag{10}$$\n\nIf the two shunt feedback branches are cut the\n$R_{F}$ loads remain but the cross terms\n$-R_{F}^{-1}v_{a}$ in (8) and $+R_{F}^{-1}v_{o}$\nin (9) disappear:\n\n$$M_{o}=\\pmatrix{\nG_{D1}+g_{ds1}&0&-(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})\\cr\ng_{m2}&G_{D2}+g_{ds2}+R_{F}^{-1}&0\\cr\ng_{ds1}&0&-(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})-R_{F}^{-1}\\cr}$$\n\n$${\\rm det}M_{o}=-(G_{D2}+g_{ds2}+R_{F}^{-1})\n\\left[ G_{D1}(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})+{G_{D1}+g_{ds1}\\over R_{F}}\\right]\n\\tag{11}$$\n\nFor the customary $r_{o}\\to \\infty $\n\n$${\\rm det}M_{o}\\approx -(G_{D2}+R_{F}^{-1})G_{D1}g_{m1}$$\n$${\\rm det}M_{c}\\approx -\n\\left[G_{D1}g_{m1}G_{D2}+{G_{D1}g_{m1}+G_{D1}G_{D2}+g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over R_{F}}\\right]$$\n\nThe ordinary one loop relation\n\n$${\\rm det}M_{c}={\\rm det}M_{o}(1+T)\\tag{12}$$\n\ngives the return ratio $T$ or loop gain.\nE.g. $r_{o}\\to \\infty $\n\n$$1+T={{\\rm det}M_{c}\\over {\\rm det}M_{o}}\n      =1+{G_{D1}G_{D2}+g_{m1}g_{m2}\\over R_{F}G_{D1}g_{m1}\n      (G_{D2}+R_{F}^{-1})}$$\n\n$$T={g_{m1}g_{m2}+G_{D1}G_{D2}\\over R_{F}G_{D1}g_{m1}\n      (G_{D2}+R_{F}^{-1})}\\approx\n      {g_{m2}\\over R_{F}G_{D1}(G_{D2}+R_{F}^{-1})}\n      ={g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}\\over R_{F}+R_{D2}}\n      =g_{m2}R_{D1}{R_{D2}\\parallel R_{F}\\over R_{F}} \\tag{13}$$\n\nIn general, with $R_{Di}^{\\prime}=R_{Di}\\parallel r_{oi}$\n\n$$T_{0}\\approx {g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}R_{D2}^{\\prime}\\over R_{F}}\n      \\quad R_{F}\\gg R_{D2}^{\\prime}\\tag{14}$$\n$$T_{0}\\approx {g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}(R_{D2}^{\\prime}\\parallel R_{F})\n      \\over R_{F}}\\quad {\\rm in\\; general}$$\n\n$T_{0}>0$ for the $N-CG+N-CS$ chain, i. e.\ndegenerative.  With the opposite sign of $A_{1}$\nthe loop is $T_{0}<0$ regenerative.\n\nThe $Y$ matrix of the feedback two port $R_{F}$ is\n\n$$Y_{F}=\\pmatrix{R_{F}^{-1}&-R_{F}^{-1}\\cr -R_{F}^{-1}&R_{F}^{-1}}$$\n\nso that in the shunt--shunt, $Y$, representation\n\n$$I_{in}=Y_{11}V_{a}+Y_{12}V_{o},\\qquad\n  I_{o}=Y_{21}V_{a}+Y_{22}V_{o}$$\n\nthe feedback factor is\n\n$$\\beta =Y_{12}=-{1\\over R_{F}},\\qquad \n  I_{F}\\approx {V_{o}\\over R_{F}}\\tag{15}$$\n\ni. e. voltage sampling, current mixing,\nshunt at the input, shunt at the output,\ncurrent in--voltage out, transimpedance or\ntransresistance amplifier.\n\n> {\\it Forward transimpedance} with $R_{F}$ loaded\n> to ground at both ports, $I_{F}=0$,\n\n$$R_{M0}={V_{o}\\over I_{in}}\\Biggr|_{R_{F}{\\rm loaded}}\n       \\approx -g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}R_{D2}^{\\prime}\n       \\parallel R_{F}\\approx -g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime}R_{D2}^{\\prime}\n       \\tag{16}$$\n\nthe $CG$ transfers $I_{in}$ almost unattenuated to\n$R_{D1}$, $V_{x}\\approx I_{in}R_{D1}^{\\prime}$,\n$V_{o}=-g_{m2}R_{D2}^{\\prime}V_{x}$.\n\nElimination of $v_{x},v_{a}$ from (7)-(9) gives the\nclosed loop transimpedance.  For $r_{o}\\to\\infty$\n\n$$R_{M}\\equiv {V_{o}\\over I_{in}}\n      =-{{\\rm N}\\over {\\rm D}}\\tag{17}$$\n\n$${\\rm N}=g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{F}-1$$\n$${\\rm D}=1+{R_{D2}+R_{F}\\over R_{D2}R_{F}}g_{m1}^{-1}\n        +{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}+1\\over g_{m1}R_{D2}}$$\n\ni.e.\n\n$$R_{M}=-R_{F}{T\\over 1+T}+{\\cal O}(g_{m}^{-1})\\tag{18}$$\n\nExplicitly, $r_{o}\\to\\infty$,\n\n$$R_{M}=-{R_{D2}\\left(g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{F}-1\\right)\n        \\over 1+g_{m1}R_{D2}+g_{m1}R_{F}+g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}\n        \\tag{19}$$\n\nwith $R_{Di}\\to R_{Di}^{\\prime}$ if $r_{oi}$ is kept.\nFor $T_{0}\\gg 1$,\n\n$$R_{M}\\to -R_{F}{1\\over 1+T_{0}^{-1}}\\approx -R_{F}\n      \\left(1-{1\\over T_{0}}\\right) \\tag{20}$$\n\nthe ideal shunt--shunt result $R_{M}^{id}=-1/\\beta\n=-R_{F}$.  The current $I_{in}$ is forced to flow\nin $R_{F}$: $I_{in}\\approx -I_{RF}=(V_{o}-V_{a})/R_{F}\n\\approx V_{o}/R_{F}$ because $V_{a}\\to 0$ for large\n$T$.\n\nNumerical example: $g_{m1}=g_{m2}=2\\,{\\rm mA/V}$,\n$R_{D1}=R_{D2}=1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$, $R_{F}=5\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$,\n$r_{o}\\to\\infty$ gives $T_{0}\\approx g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}/\n(R_{D2}+R_{F})\\approx 0.33$, $R_{M}\\approx -1.2\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$\nfar from $-R_{F}$; $g_{m}R_{D}=10$ gives $T_{0}\\approx\n8$, $R_{M}\\approx -0.89R_{F}$.\n\nInput impedance:\n\nOpen loop, $R_{F}$ to ground,\n\n$$Z_{in0}= {V_{a}\\over I_{in}}\\Biggr|_{o}\n        \\approx {1\\over g_{m1}+g_{mb1}+g_{ds1}+R_{D1}^{-1}}\n        \\parallel R_{F}\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}}\\parallel R_{F}\n        \\tag{21}$$\n\nthe well known $CG$ $1/g_{m}$.  Blackman's theorem\n\n$$Z_{in}=Z_{in0}{1+T_{sc}\\over 1+T_{oc}}\\approx\n        {Z_{in0}\\over 1+T_{0}}\\tag{22}$$\n\nshunt mixing divides by $1+T$.  Explicitly from\n(7)-(9)\n\n$$Z_{in}={V_{a}\\over I_{in}}=\n        {G_{D2}+g_{ds2}+R_{F}^{-1}\\over\n        (G_{D2}+g_{ds2}+R_{F}^{-1})(g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+R_{F}^{-1}\n        -g_{ds1}^{2}/(G_{D1}+g_{ds1}))\n        +g_{m2}(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})/(G_{D1}+g_{ds1})R_{F}^{-1}}$$\n\n$\\approx$\n\n$$Z_{in}\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}+R_{F}^{-1}\n        +g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}/[R_{F}(R_{D2}+R_{F})]}\n        \\approx {R_{F}+R_{D2}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}\n        \\approx {R_{F}\\over g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}R_{D2}}\n        ={1\\over g_{m1}}{1\\over T_{0}}{R_{D2}\\over R_{F}}\n        \\tag{23}$$\n\ne. very low, ideal $0$ for $T_{0}\\to\\infty$,\nthe virtual ground of the $TIA$.\n\nOutput impedance:  $Z_{out0}\\approx R_{D2}^{\\prime}\n\\parallel R_{F}$; shunt sampling also divides,\n\n$$Z_{out}=Z_{out0}{1+T_{sc}^{(o)}\\over 1+T_{oc}^{(o)}}\n        \\approx {R_{D2}^{\\prime}\\over 1+T_{0}}\\tag{24}$$\n\nideal $0$ for a voltage output.\n\nFrequency response: with $C_{x}$ at $X$, $C_{o}$ at\n$o$, $C_{in}$ at $a$,\n\n$$p_{x}\\approx -{1\\over R_{D1}^{\\prime}C_{x}},\\quad\n  C_{x}=C_{gd1}+C_{gs2}+C_{db1}+C_{sb2}$$\n$$p_{o}\\approx -{1\\over R_{D2}^{\\prime}C_{o}},\\quad\n  C_{o}=C_{gd2}+C_{db2}+C_{L}$$\n\n$$T(s)\\approx {T_{0}\\over (1+s/p_{x})(1+s/p_{o})}$$\n\n$$R_{M}(s)\\approx -R_{F}{T(s)\\over 1+T(s)}$$\n\na second order loop.  For $T_{0}\\gg 1$ the closed\nloop poles are approximately the roots of\n$s^{2}+s(p_{x}+p_{o})+p_{x}p_{o}(1+T_{0})=0$,\nbandwidth $\\approx p_{x}p_{o}(1+T_{0})/(p_{x}+p_{o})$,\ni. e. bandwidth extension by $\\approx 1+T_{0}$ at the\nexpense of gain desensitivity.  If $p_{x}\\approx p_{o}$\npeaking and inadequate phase margin,\n$PM\\approx 90^{\\circ}-\\tan^{-1}(GBW/p_{x})-\n\\tan^{-1}(GBW/p_{o})$, may require compensation,\ne.g. $C_{F}$ across $R_{F}$ or $C_{c}$ at $X$ to\nsplit poles.  The $R_{F}-C_{F}$ zero can be used to\ncancel $p_{x}$.\n\nIn the literature this is the prototype\nshunt--shunt $TIA$, photodiode -- $CG$ front end,\nvoltage--current feedback pair, often used as a\nwideband transimpedance stage with low $Z_{in}$ to\nabsorb the photo current.  With $M_{2}$ feeding back\nto the gate of $M_{1}$ it becomes the regulated\ncascode RGC $TIA$.\n\nAny finite $r_{o},g_{mb}$ is introduced by\n$R_{D}\\to R_{D}^{\\prime}=R_{D}\\parallel r_{o1}\\parallel\nr_{o2}$, $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$ in $A_{1}$ for body\neffect.  The sign discussion above remains.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f49a6193acc828a4a0b8e6c26ff29205ee5602a46e70a6c94c5093c9d6f3db30"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It identifies the common-gate/common-source stages, RF feedback, and transimpedance function, but wrongly says the circuit as drawn has a PMOS M1 and regenerative feedback, then analyzes an assumed NMOS version instead. The actual circuit has an NMOS common-gate input and negative feedback, so this central error limits the score.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3de185b163e9067ba58585d0a347eecc50f9da3dc36d0d1a8e05a54adcc11752",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2403,
        "input_tokens": 2509,
        "output_tokens": 23971,
        "total_tokens": 26480,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 19831,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2403,
        "input_tokens": 2509,
        "output_tokens": 23971,
        "total_tokens": 26480,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 19831,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 30,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback/figure-24.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a ${\\rm sh-sh}$ transimpedance feedback\npair. $M_{1}$ is the $\\left[{\\rm CG}\\right]$ \nfeedforward amp, $M_{2}$ is the ${\\rm CS}$ transconductance\nfeedback $V-A$ converter, Fig.1.\n\n```\n             VDD ac gnd\n              |               I1\n        |-----|----||--S M2 D---|-----o Vout\n        |     S    |G           |G   |\n        |          Vout         |   C Y\n        |                      D M1  R1=ro1||roI1\n        |                      |S  G=0 Vb\n        X-----------------------|\n        |  Cx RB=roB             gm1vgs\n Iin>---|---X --- GB -----------o    \n              |\n             GND\n```\n\n$G_{1}=g_{ds1}=r_{o1}^{-1}$ , $G_{2}=g_{ds2}$ ,\n$G_{I}=g_{oI1}=r_{oI1}^{-1}$ , $G_{B}=g_{oB}=r_{oB}^{-1}$\n$C_{X},C_{Y}$ the total capacitance at $X$ and $Y$,\n$g_{m1}^{\\prime}=g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\approx g_{m1}$ if\n$M_{1}$ $B$ to $S$.\n\nSmall signal $V_{b}=0$.\n\n$$v_{gs1}=-v_{x}\\;\\;v_{bs1}=-v_{x}\\;\\;v_{ds1}=v_{y}-v_{x}$$\n$$i_{d1}=g_{m1}^{\\prime}v_{gs1}+G_{1}v_{ds1}\n=-g_{m1}^{\\prime}v_{x}+G_{1}(v_{y}-v_{x})\\;\\;D\\to S\\tag{1}$$\n$M_{2}$ $S=V_{DD}=0$\n\n$$v_{sg2}=-v_{y}\\;\\;v_{sd2}=-v_{x}$$\n$$i_{s2d2}=g_{m2}v_{sg2}+G_{2}v_{sd2}\n=-g_{m2}v_{y}-G_{2}v_{x}\\;\\;S\\to D\\tag{2}$$\nenters node $X$, leaves $V_{DD}$.\nCurrents $i_{d1}$ and $i_{s2d2}$ both enter $X$ and\n$i_{d1}$ leaves $Y$.\n\nKCL ac:\n\n$$i_{in}+i_{d1}+i_{s2d2}-(G_{B}+sC_{X})v_{x}=0\\tag{3}$$\n$$-(G_{I}+sC_{Y})v_{y}-i_{d1}+i_{t}=0\\tag{4}$$\n$i_{t}$ test current at $Y$. For closed loop signal\n$i_{t}=0$.\n\nPut (1)(2) in (3)(4):\n\n$$\\left.\\begin{aligned}\ni_{in}+(G_{1}-g_{m2})v_{y}-\n\\left[g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1}+G_{2}+G_{B}+sC_{X}\\right]v_{x}=0\\\\\n\\left[g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1}\\right]v_{x}\n-\\left[G_{1}+G_{I}+sC_{Y}\\right]v_{y}+i_{t}=0\n\\end{aligned}\\right\\}\\tag{5}$$\n\n#### D.C. bias\n\n$$V_{GS1}=V_{b}-V_{X}\\qquad V_{X}\\approx V_{b}-V_{Tn}-V_{ov1}$$\n$$I_{D1}=I_{1}\\tag{6}$$\n$$I_{D2}=I_{B}-I_{1}-I_{in,DC}\\tag{7}$$\nin saturation\n\n$$V_{DS1}=V_{Y}-V_{X}>V_{ov1}\\;\\;V_{SD2}=V_{DD}-V_{X}>V_{ov2}$$\n$$r\\approx V_{DD}-|V_{ov,I1}|>V_{Y}>V_{X}+V_{ov1}$$\nNormal design $I_{B}>I_{1}>0$, $M_{1},M_{2}$ saturated.\n$V_{in}=V_{X}$ sets the input common mode by $V_{b}$.\n\nThe loop is negative:\n$\\uparrow v_{x}\\to \\downarrow v_{gs1}\\to \\downarrow i_{d1}\n\\to \\uparrow v_{y}\\to \\downarrow v_{sg2}\\to\n\\downarrow i_{s2d2}\\to \\downarrow v_{x}$.\n\n#### Feedforward amp and loop gain\n\nTo first order, with the loop broken, the ${\\rm CG}$\nstage loaded by $R_{D}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{oI1}=\n1/(G_{1}+G_{I})$ has\n\n$$A_{v}=v_{y}/v_{x}\\approx g_{m1}^{\\prime}R_{D}\\quad\nR_{m0}=v_{y}/i_{in}\\approx R_{D}\\tag{8}$$\n\nin shunt-shunt ${\\rm Y}$ model.\n\nFeedback\n\n$$\\beta =i_{f}/v_{y}\\approx -g_{m2}\\tag{9}$$\n\nLoop gain with $X$ and $Y$ loaded\n\n$$T_{0}=A_{m0}\\beta \\approx -g_{m2}R_{D}\n=-\\frac{g_{m2}}{G_{1}+G_{I}}\\gg 1\\tag{10}$$\nif $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$.\nUsually $|T_{0}|\\approx 20$-$50\\,{\\rm dB}$.\n\n#### Closed loop - small signal stationary, $s=0$\n\nFrom (5) with $i_{t}=0$\n\n$$v_{x}=v_{y}\\frac{G_{I}+G_{1}}{g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1}}\\tag{11}$$\n\n$$i_{in}=v_{y}\\left[g_{m2}+G_{I}+\n\\frac{(G_{I}+G_{1})(G_{2}+G_{B})}{g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1}}\\right]\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$\\;R_{m}\\equiv \\frac{v_{out}}{i_{in}}=\n\\frac{1}{g_{m2}+G_{I}+{\\displaystyle\n\\frac{(G_{I}+G_{1})(G_{2}+G_{B})}{g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1}}}}\\;\n\\tag{13}$$\n\nIn the ideal limit $r_{o}\\to\\infty$,\n$G\\to 0$,\n\n$$R_{m0}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}\\tag{14}$$\n$$v_{x}\\approx 0\\;{\\rm virtual\\;ground}\\tag{15}$$\ni.e. the current is forced through the feedback\n$g_{m2}$.  With Blackman\n$R_{m}=R_{m0}/(1+T_{0})\\approx -1/\\beta$.\n\n$$R_{in}= \\frac{v_{x}}{i_{in}}=\nR_{m}\\frac{G_{I}+G_{1}}{g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1}}\n\\approx \\frac{G_{I}+G_{1}}{g_{m1}^{\\prime}g_{m2}}\n=\\frac{1}{g_{m1}^{\\prime}}\\frac{1}{1+T_{0}}\\tag{16}$$\n\nIdeal:\n\n$$R_{in}\\to 0 \\tag{17}$$\n\nIn practice\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}^{\\prime}g_{m2}R_{D}}\n\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m1}^{\\prime}|T_{0}|}\\ll \\frac{1}{g_{m1}^{\\prime}}$$\n\ne.g. $g_{m1}=g_{m2}=1\\,{\\rm mS}$, $R_{D}=50\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$,\n$|T_{0}|=50$, $1/g_{m1}=1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}\\to R_{in}\\approx\n20\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$.\n\nThat is the regulated ${\\rm CG}$ principle: low $R_{in}$\nwithout burning current in $g_{m1}$ for wide band\nphotodiode ${\\rm TIA}$ operation.\n\nOutput impedance, set $i_{in}=0$, inject $v_{t}=v_{y}$\nfrom (5):\n\n$$v_{x}=v_{t}\\frac{G_{1}-g_{m2}}\n{g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1}+G_{2}+G_{B}+sC_{X}}\\tag{18}$$\n\n$$i_{t}=v_{t}(G_{I}+sC_{Y})+g_{m1}^{\\prime}v_{x}\n+G_{1}(v_{t}-v_{x})\\tag{19}$$\n\n$$Z_{out}(s)=\\frac{v_{t}}{i_{t}} \\tag{20}$$\n$$R_{out}=Z_{out}(0)=\n\\frac{g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1}+G_{2}+G_{B}}\n{(g_{m2}+G_{I})(g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1})\n+(G_{I}+G_{1})(G_{2}+G_{B})}\\tag{21}$$\n\nIdeal $G\\to 0$\n\n$$R_{out}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}+G_{I}}\\approx \\frac{1}{g_{m2}}\n\\parallel r_{oI1}\\tag{22}$$\n\nagain shunted by $1+T_{0}$ :\n\n$$R_{out}=R_{D}/(1+T_{0})$$\n\nIn the ideal shunt at input, shunt at output both\nimpedances are divided by the loop gain.\n\nFinite $r_{o}$ correction is $O(1/g_{m}r_{o})$.\n\n#### Poles - stability\n\nPut $G_{B},G_{2}\\to 0$ for clarity.\nFrom (5) the characteristic polynomial is\n\n$$D(s)=(G_{I}+G_{1}+sC_{Y})\n(g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1}+sC_{X})+(g_{m1}^{\\prime}+G_{1})\n(g_{m2}-G_{1})\\approx 0\\tag{23}$$\n$$D\\approx s^{2}C_{X}C_{Y}+s\\left[C_{Y}g_{m1}^{\\prime}\n+C_{X}(G_{I}+G_{1})\\right]+g_{m1}^{\\prime}(g_{m2}+G_{I})\\tag{24}$$\n\nTwo real poles for $|T_{0}|\\gg 1$\n\n$$p_{o}\\approx -\\frac{g_{m2}+G_{I}}{C_{Y}}\\approx -\\frac{1}{R_{out}C_{Y}}$$\n\n$$p_{i}\\approx -\\frac{g_{m1}^{\\prime}}{C_{X}}\n\\tag{25}$$\nwith the node $X$ pole pushed to very high\nfrequency because $R_{in}$ is small. The loop\nhas $\\approx 90^{o}$ phase shift at each pole,\n$\\approx 180^{o}$ total, the circuit is conditonally\nstable. If\n\n$$p_{i}\\approx p_{o}$$\n\nlarge peaking and ringing occurs. Usually\n$C_{X}\\gg C_{Y}$ is the photodiode case so\n$p_{i}<p_{o}$ and the dominant pole is at the input.\nBecause $R_{in}$ is tiny the dominant pole is\npushed out $\\times |T_{0}|$, extending bandwidth\nby the regulation factor compared to a simple ${\\rm CG}$\n$1/g_{m1}C_{X}$ TIA.  $Z_{in}(s)$ looks inductive,\n$Z_{in}\\approx sC_{Y}/g_{m1}^{\\prime}g_{m2}$, usable as\nactive inductor peaking.\n\nA small compensation $C_{c}$ at $Y$ or series resistor\ncan be added for phase margin $>60^{o}$.\n\n> *Regulated cascode / flipped voltage follower TIA*\n> : sh-sh voltage-sampling current-mixing feedback,\n> ideal transresistance $1/g_{m2}$, ideal $R_{in}=0$,\n> ideal $R_{out}=1/g_{m2}$, large bandwidth because\n> both poles are at $g_{m}/C$.\n\nNon-ideally add $r_{o}$ corrections (13)(16)(21).\nIncluding $g_{mb1}$ just replace $g_{m1}\\to g_{m1}+g_{mb1}$.\nNoise is dominated by $M_{1},M_{2}$ and $R_{B},R_{I}$,\ninput referred $\\overline{i_{n}^{2}}\\approx\n4kT\\gamma(g_{m1}+g_{m2})/|T_{0}|^{2}+4kT/R_{D}|T_{0}|^{2}$.\n\nLarge signal swing: $I_{in,peak}<I_{D2}$ positive,\n$|I_{in,peak}|<I_{1}$ negative before $M_{1}$ or $M_{2}$\ntriodes / cuts off.\n\nApplication: low power low impedance current buffer,\ncurrent conveyor ${\\rm CCII}$, optical receiver\nfront end, active inductor load.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "821c09deefef81be06f79a9c2048c8877267b30bc2ac338c18fdcd9e2b73bbda"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate input device and M2 as the output-driven feedback device, describes the loop back to the input node, and derives very low input resistance with transimpedance and output resistance approximately 1/gm2. The additional analysis does not undermine the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "81b07f946459ec3d1a0c51926785b2333e0320bb99c892d5929e040324abeaf8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2262,
        "output_tokens": 17166,
        "total_tokens": 19428,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14259,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2262,
        "output_tokens": 17166,
        "total_tokens": 19428,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14259,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 30,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback/figure-24.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "Circuit is the {\\it regulated cascode} or\nshunt-shunt active feedback transimpedance amplifier.\nIn its present form it is also called the flipped\nvoltage follower TIA.\n\n$$M_{1} :N\\;CG\\qquad M_{2}:P\\;CS$$\n$$V_{GS1}=V_{b}-V_{X}\\qquad V_{SG2}=V_{DD}-V_{Y}$$\n$$V_{DS1}=V_{Y}-V_{X}\\qquad V_{SD2}=V_{DD}-V_{X}$$\n\nIdeal small signal $C_{gs},C_{gd}=0$, $r_{ob}=1/g_{b}=\\infty\n,$$V_{b}~ac=0$ , $V_{DD}~ac=0$ . Bodies on the sources so that\n$g_{mb}=0$. With bodies to supply\n\n$$g_{m}\\rightarrow g_{m}+g_{mb}\\tag*$$\n\n> $$ {\\rm ideal: }g_{b1}=g_{b2}=0\\;\\; ,r_{oI1}=1/G_{I1},\nr_{oIb}=1/G_{Ib}\\rightarrow \\infty {\\rm  for\\;hand\\;calc.}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{M1}&=g_{m1}v_{gs1}+g_{ds1}v_{ds1}\\cr\n&=-g_{m1}v_{x}+g_{ds1}(v_{y}-v_{x})\\cr\n&=-(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})v_{x}+g_{ds1}v_{y}\\;\\;{\\rm D\\rightarrow S}\\cr\nI_{M2}&=g_{m2}v_{sg2}+g_{ds2}v_{sd2}\\cr\n&=-g_{m2}v_{y}+g_{ds2}(-v_{x})\\cr\n&=-g_{ds2}v_{x}-g_{m2}v_{y}\\;\\;{\\rm S\\rightarrow D} }$$\n\nwhere $I_{M1}$ is the conventional NMOS $D\\rightarrow S$ current\nleaving $Y$ and entering $X$ and $I_{M2}$ the PMOS $S\\rightarrow D$\ncurrent entering $X$.\n\n```\nY=Vout o----+----g M2\n            |     |\n           ro1   gm2,ro2\n            |     |\nM1 D--------+-+   +---X----o Iin\n |  gm1,ro1 | |   |   |\n M1 S-------+-----+---o--Ib , Cib\n            |         |\n           Cx        Cy\n```\n\nNodal $ac$ KCL, $G_{I1}=g_{oI1}$ , $G_{Ib}=g_{oIb}$,\n\n$$Y:\\;\\;I_{M1}+G_{I1}v_{y}=I_{testY}\\tag{1}$$\n$$X:\\;\\;I_{M1}+I_{M2}-G_{Ib}v_{x}+I_{in}=0\\tag{2}$$\n\nFor $I_{test}=0$\n\n$$-(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})v_{x}+(g_{ds1}+G_{I1})v_{y}=0\\tag{3}$$\n\n$${{v_{y}}\\over{v_{x}}}={{g_{m1}+g_{ds1}}\\over{g_{ds1}+G_{I1}}}\n\\equiv A_{v0} \\approx g_{m1}r_{o1}\\parallel R_{I1}>0 \\tag{4}$$\n\nThe $CG$ stage is non inverting. With\n$R_{Y}=1/(g_{ds1}+G_{I1})=r_{o1}\\parallel R_{I1}$\n\n$$A_{v0}\\approx g_{m1}R_{Y}\\gg 1$$\n\nFrom (2)-(3)\n\n$$I_{in}= \\left[g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+G_{Ib}\n+{{(g_{m2}-g_{ds1})(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})}\\over{g_{ds1}+G_{I1}}}\\right]v_{x}\n\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nZ_{in}&={{v_{x}}\\over{I_{in}}}=\n{{g_{ds1}+G_{I1}}\\over{(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})(g_{m2}+G_{I1})\n+(g_{ds1}+G_{I1})(g_{ds2}+G_{Ib})}}\\cr\n&\\approx {{G_{I1}+g_{ds1}}\\over{g_{m1}g_{m2}}}\n={{1}\\over{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{Y}}}\\approx {{1}\\over{g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o1}}}\n\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;G_{I1},G_{Ib}\\ll g_{ds} } \\tag{6}$$\n\nSo called $1/g_{m}$ boosted by the loop gain.\nWithout $M_{2}$\n\n$$Z_{in0}\\approx {1\\over{g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+G_{Ib}}}\n\\approx 1/g_{m1}$$\n\nWith regulation\n\n$$Z_{in}={{Z_{in0}}\\over{1+T_{0}}}\\qquad \nT_{0}\\approx g_{m2}R_{Y} \\tag{7}$$\n\n$$R_{m}={{v_{y}}\\over{I_{in}}}={{g_{m1}+g_{ds1}}\\over\n{(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})(g_{m2}+G_{I1})+(g_{ds1}+G_{I1})(g_{ds2}+G_{Ib})}}\n\\tag{8}$$\n\n$$R_{m}\\approx {1\\over{g_{m2}+G_{I1}}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m2}}\\tag{9}\n {\\rm ideal\\;shunt-shunt\\;value\\;}R_{M,ideal}=-1/\\beta ,\\,\n\\beta \\approx g_{m2}$$\n\nSign is $>0$ for the $P/N$ choice. In the usual $n-n$\nimplementation $R_{M}\\approx -1/g_{m2}$ inverting.\nMore generally with a finite load $R_{D}$ to ground at $Y$,\n\n$$R_{M}\\approx -R_{D}\\;{{T_{0}}\\over{1+T_{0}}}\\rightarrow -R_{D}\n\\;{\\rm for}\\;T_{0}\\gg 1\\;\\;{\\rm and}\\;\\;\nR_{M}\\rightarrow -1/g_{m2}\\;{\\rm for}\\;R_{D}\\rightarrow \\infty $$\n\nFrom (1) with $I_{in}=0$ and a test source at $Y$\n\n$$Z_{out}={{v_{y}}\\over{I_{test}}}=\n{{g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+G_{Ib}}\\over\n{(g_{m1}+g_{ds1})(g_{m2}+G_{I1})+(g_{ds1}+G_{I1})(g_{ds2}+G_{Ib})}}\n\\tag{10}$$\n\n$$Z_{out}\\approx {1\\over g_{m2}}\\;{{g_{m1}R_{Y}}\\over{1+g_{m2}R_{Y}}}\n+{\\cal O}(r_{o}^{-1})\\approx {1\\over g_{m2}}\\tag{11}$$\n\nagain ${{R_{Y}}\\over{1+T_{0}}}$. The open loop output\nresistance without feedback is $R_{Y}=r_{o1}\\parallel R_{I1}$.\n\nThat is the classical shunt-shunt result:\n\nsampling voltage at $Y$, mixing shunt at $X$.\nLoop gain with the loop broken at the gate of $M_{2}$:\n\n$$T(s)\\approx {{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{Y}Z_{X}(s)}\\over{1+g_{m1}Z_{X}(s)}}\n{1\\over{1+sR_{Y}C_{Y}}}{1\\over{1+sZ_{X}C_{X}}}$$\n\nlow frequency\n\n$$T_{0}\\approx g_{m2}R_{Y}\\;{{g_{m1}Z_{X0}}\\over{1+g_{m1}Z_{X0}}}\n\\approx g_{m2}R_{Y}\\gg 1\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$Z_{X0}=1/(g_{ds2}+G_{Ib})$$\n\nExact second order:\n\n$$T(s)\\approx {{g_{m1}g_{m2}}\\over{(g_{ds1}+G_{I1}+sC_{Y})\n(g_{m1}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+G_{Ib}+sC_{X})}} \\tag{13}$$\n\n### DC bias\n\n$$V_{X}=V_{b}-V_{GS1}\\tag{14}$$\n$$V_{Y}=V_{DD}-V_{SG2}\\tag{15}$$\n$$I_{D1}\\approx I_{1}\\tag{16}$$\n$$I_{D1}={1\\over 2}\\mu_{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}(V_{GS1}-V_{Tn})^{2}(1+\\lambda_{n}V_{DS1})$$\n$$I_{D2}={1\\over 2}\\mu_{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{2}(V_{SG2}-|V_{Tp}|)^{2}(1+\\lambda_{p}V_{SD2})$$\n$$I_{Ib}=I_{D1}+I_{D2}+I_{in,DC}\\tag{17}$$\n\nNeeded for saturation\n\n$$V_{DS1}\\ge V_{GS1}-V_{Tn}\\;,\\;\\;V_{SD2}\\ge V_{SG2}-|V_{Tp}|$$\n$$V_{b}>V_{X}+V_{Tn}+V_{ov1}\\;,\\;\\;\nV_{Y}<V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|-V_{ov2}$$\n\nHeadroom $V_{DD,min}\\approx V_{ov1}+V_{ov2}+|V_{Tp}|+V_{Tn}$.\n\n### High frequency\n\nLet $C_{X}=C_{gs1}+C_{sb1}+C_{db2}+C_{Ib}+C_{PD}$ ,\n$C_{Y}=C_{gd1}+C_{gd2}+C_{db1}+C_{I1}+C_{L}$ .\n\nClosed loop poles are the roots of $1+T(s)=0$,\n\n$$\\omega_{pY}\\approx {1\\over R_{Y}C_{Y}}(1+T_{0})^{-1}\\approx\n{g_{m2}\\over C_{Y}}$$\n\n$$\\omega_{pX}\\approx {g_{m1}\\over C_{X}}(1+T_{0})\\approx\n{g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{Y}\\over C_{X}}$$\n\nso the former dominant $R_{Y}C_{Y}$ pole is pushed to\n$\\sim g_{m2}/C_{Y}$ and the input pole\n$1/g_{m1}C_{X}$ is pushed out by $T_{0}$.\nBandwidth is hence $\\sim \\min (\\omega_{pX},\\omega_{pY})$\nand can be made much larger than a simple $CG$ stage\nwith $R_{in}=1/g_{m1}$ which is limited by $C_{PD}R_{in}$.\n\nBoth poles in the left half plane for $T_{0}>0$ - negative\nfeedback. Two-pole system may have peaking if\n$\\omega_{pX}\\approx \\omega_{pY}$. Usually $C_{X}\\gg C_{Y}$\nin photoreceiver use so $\\omega_{pY}>\\omega_{pX}$ and the\nresponse is stable; otherwise a capacitance to ground at $Y$\nor series peaking resistor is added for phase margin.\n\n### Remarks\n\n* Low $Z_{in}\\propto 1/g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{Y}$ isolates the large\nphotodiode capacitance from bandwidth.\n* Moderate transimpedance $\\approx 1/g_{m2}$ without an\nexplicit resistor. To obtain larger $R_{M}$ add $R_{D}$ from\n$Y$ to $ac$ ground: $R_{M}\\rightarrow -R_{D}$ for $T_{0}\\gg 1$.\nThis is the conventional RGC TIA.\n* Input referred current noise $\\approx 4kT\\gamma(g_{m1}+g_{m2})\n+4kT/R_{Y}$ dominated by $M_{2}$ reflected as\n$\\overline{i_{n,in}^{2}}\\approx 4kT\\gamma g_{m2}$.\n* Can be seen as a flipped voltage follower FVF: $M_{1}$\nis the follower device, $M_{2}$ the level shifter that\nkeeps $V_{X}$ constant.\n* With ideal $R_{I1},R_{Ib}\\rightarrow \\infty$:\n\n$$Z_{in}\\approx 1/g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o1},\\;\nZ_{out}\\approx 1/g_{m2},\\;\nR_{m}\\approx 1/g_{m2},\\;\nA_{v}=v_{y}/v_{x}\\approx g_{m1}r_{o1}$$\n\nE.g. $g_{m}=1\\,{\\rm mS},r_{o}=10\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}\\rightarrow\nZ_{in}\\sim 100\\,\\Omega ,\\,R_{m}\\sim 1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega},\\,\nA_{v}\\sim 10$.\n\nThat is the small-signal, low-frequency analysis. Inclusion of\nbody effect: $g_{m1}\\rightarrow g_{m1}+g_{mb1}$, i.e.\n$$Z_{in}\\approx (g_{ds1}+G_{I1})/(g_{m1}+g_{mb1})g_{m2}.$$\nAny finite $C$ restores the exact second-order expressions\nabove.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "b7daefdca703a80b23e3f8c3066e13b56ddd31034192c0f97e0e19a5b4eec2d3"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate NMOS and M2 as the PMOS feedback device, describes feedback from the output node to the input node, and gives the expected very low input resistance and transimpedance/output resistance of approximately 1/gm2.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "81b07f946459ec3d1a0c51926785b2333e0320bb99c892d5929e040324abeaf8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2262,
        "output_tokens": 18248,
        "total_tokens": 20510,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14991,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2262,
        "output_tokens": 18248,
        "total_tokens": 20510,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14991,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback",
      "part": "part1",
      "question_number": 30,
      "question": "Analyze the circuit shown in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part1-030-pmos-current-input-feedback/figure-24.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With ideal current sources $g_{I1}=1/r_{I1}\\to 0$\n$g_{I2}=1/r_{I2}\\to 0$ put\n\n$${\\rm M_{1}}: n{\\rm MOST}\\;\\;D\\equiv {\\rm out}\\;,\\;S\\equiv x\\;,\\;G\\equiv\nV_{b}\\approx {\\rm ac\\;gnd}$$\n$${\\rm M_{2}}: p{\\rm MOST}\\;\\;S\\equiv V_{DD}\\approx {\\rm ac\\;gnd}\\;,\\;\nD\\equiv x\\;,\\;G\\equiv {\\rm out}$$\n\n$$g_{m1,2}\\;\\;g_{ds1,2}=1/r_{o1,2}\\;\\;g_{mb1}$$\n\n$$I_{D1}=I_{1}\\qquad I_{D2}=I_{B}-I_{D1}-I_{in}\\approx I_{B}-I_{1}$$\n\non dc $I_{in}=0$ for bias. Saturation requires\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{GS1}&=V_{b}-V_{x} >V_{Tn}\\cr\nV_{DS1}&=V_{out}-V_{x} >V_{GS1}-V_{Tn}=V_{ov1}\\cr\n\\left|V_{SG2}\\right|&=V_{DD}-V_{out}> \\left|V_{Tp}\\right|\\cr\nV_{SD2}&=V_{DD}-V_{x}> \\left|V_{SG2}\\right|-\\left|V_{Tp}\\right|=V_{ov2}}$$\n\n$$V_{x}\\approx V_{b}-V_{GS1}\\qquad \nV_{out}\\approx V_{DD}-\\left|V_{SG2}\\right|$$\n\n$$g_{m1}=\\sqrt{2\\mu _{n}C_{ox}(W/L)_{1}I_{1}}\\;\\;,\\;\ng_{m2}=\\sqrt{2\\mu _{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{2}I_{D2}}$$\n\nis the normal regulated - cascode, super common\ngate, flipped voltage follower, shunt - shunt\nfeedback TIA. In ac\n\n```\n                VDD ac gnd ----o----o\n                               |    |\n                              roI1  S M2 G---o Vout\n                               |    D      |\n                               o----o------o\n                               |    |\n                              D M1  Cgs2+ro2\n                              S |\n              Vb---G M1       o----o Vx ---- Iin + IB roI2 to gnd\n                     gmb1 ro1 Cgs1 Cgd1 Cgd2 Cx\n```\n\n*Forward amplifier:* $M_{1}$ common gate\n$x\\to out$\n\n$$v_{gs1}=-v_{x}\\;\\;v_{ds1}=v_{out}-v_{x}$$\n\n$$i_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{gs1}+g_{mb1}v_{bs1}+g_{ds1}v_{ds1}$$\n\nwith $v_{bs1}=-v_{x}$ put $g_{m1}^{\\prime}=g_{m1}+g_{mb1}$\n\n$$i_{d1}=-g_{m1}^{\\prime}v_{x}+g_{ds1}(v_{out}-v_{x})\\tag{1}$$\n\n*Feed back amplifier:* $M_{2}$ common source\n$out\\to x$\n\n$$v_{sg2}=-v_{out}\\;\\;v_{sd2}=-v_{x}$$\n\nsmall signal {\\it source to drain } current entering\n$x$ :\n\n$$i_{d2}=g_{m2}v_{sg2}+g_{ds2}v_{sd2}\n      =-g_{m2}v_{out}-g_{ds2}v_{x}\\tag{2}$$\nenters $x$.\n\nKCL at $out$ , current $I_{1}$ to ac gnd $g_{I1}$:\n\n$$i_{d1}+g_{I1}v_{out}=0\\tag{3}$$\n\n$1\\to 3$:\n\n$$-(g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1})v_{x}+(g_{ds1}+g_{I1})v_{out}=0\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$v_{x}= {g_{ds1}+g_{I1}\\over g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1}}v_{out}\n      \\approx {1\\over g_{m1}^{\\prime}r_{o1}}v_{out}\\propto v_{out}$$\n\nfor $g_{I1}\\ll g_{ds1}$. So voltage gain $x\\to out$\n\n$$A_{vx}= {v_{out}\\over v_{x}}={g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1}\\over\ng_{ds1}+g_{I1}}\\approx g_{m1}^{\\prime}r_{o1}\\parallel r_{I1}\\gg 1\\tag{5}$$\n\n{\\it non inverting}.\n\nGain of $M_{2}$, loaded by $x$ :\n\n$$A_{2}= {v_{x}\\over v_{out}}\\vert_{I_{in}=0}\n      \\approx -{g_{m2}\\over g_{m1}^{\\prime}}\\;\\;{\\rm inverting}$$\n\nLoop gain broken at $G_{2}$:\n\n$$T_{0}\\approx A_{vx}A_{2}\\approx -g_{m2}(r_{o1}\\parallel r_{I1})\n\\qquad |T_{0}|\\gg 1\\tag{6}$$\n\nKCL at $x$ , $I_{in}$ entering:\n\n$$I_{in}+i_{d1}+i_{d2}-g_{I2}v_{x}=0\\tag{7}$$\n\n$$I_{in}-(g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+g_{I2})v_{x}\n      +(g_{ds1}-g_{m2})v_{out}=0\\tag{8}$$\n\nWith $4$ eliminates $v_{x}$\n\n$$I_{in}= \\left[ g_{I1}+g_{m2}+{(g_{ds2}+g_{I2})(g_{ds1}+g_{I1})\n\\over g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1}}\\right] v_{out}\\tag{9}$$\n\nHence shunt - shunt closed loop transimpedance\n\n$$R_{m}={v_{out}\\over I_{in}}=\n{1\\over g_{m2}+g_{I1}+{(g_{ds1}+g_{I1})(g_{ds2}+g_{I2})\\over\ng_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1}}} \\tag{10}$$\n\nFor $r_{I1},r_{I2}\\to \\infty $\n\n$$R_{m0}\\approx {1\\over g_{m2}+{g_{ds1}g_{ds2}\\over g_{m1}^{\\prime}}}\n\\approx {1\\over g_{m2}} >0\\tag{11}$$\n\n$I_{in}>0\\to v_{x}\\uparrow\\to v_{gs1}\\downarrow\\to\ni_{d1}\\downarrow\\to i_{I1}{\\rm \\;excess\\;charges\\;}\nv_{out}\\uparrow$.\nFeedback $v_{out}\\uparrow\\to v_{sg2}\\downarrow\\to i_{d2}\\downarrow\n\\to v_{x}\\downarrow$ {\\it negative} feedback.\n\nIf $g_{I1}\\ne 0$ the load at $out$ is $r_{I1}$ so (11) is\n$1/(g_{m2}+g_{I1})$. To get large $R_{m}$ the load must be a\nresistor $R_{D}=1/g_{I1}$ and (11) is really $R_{D}/(1+g_{m2}R_{D})$\nin parallel with the feedback. With the ideal current source\nload the asymptotic $R_{m}$ is limited to $1/g_{m2}$, typically\n$0.2-2\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$. Normally $R_{D}$ is kept as $R_{D}=\nr_{o1}\\parallel r_{I1}$ and the RGC is used as {\\it input\nstage} to get very low $R_{in}$ without losing the $R_{D}$\ngain. In the simple circuit shown the large $A_{vx}$ is degenerated\nto $1/g_{m2}$ because most of $I_{in}$ is shunted by the feedback\ndevice. More generally with a $R_{D}$ to $V_{DD}$ at $out$,\n$R_{m}\\approx R_{D}$ for $|T_{0}|\\gg 1$.\n\nBy (4)(9)\n\n$$R_{in}={v_{x}\\over I_{in}}=\n{g_{ds1}+g_{I1}\\over g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1}}R_{m}\n={g_{ds1}+g_{I1}\\over (g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1})(g_{m2}+g_{I1})\n+(g_{ds1}+g_{I1})(g_{ds2}+g_{I2})}\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$R_{in0}\\approx {g_{ds1}\\over g_{m1}^{\\prime}g_{m2}}\n={1\\over g_{m1}^{\\prime}g_{m2}r_{o1}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nA simple common gate has $R_{in,CG}\\approx 1/g_{m1}^{\\prime}$.\nRegulation improves it by the loop gain\n\n$$R_{in,RGC}\\approx {R_{in,CG}\\over 1+|T_{0}|}\n\\approx {1\\over g_{m1}^{\\prime}g_{m2}r_{o1}}\\;\\;10-50\\times{\\rm lower}$$\n\nTypically $50-200\\,\\Omega$, capable of absorbing the large\nphotodiode capacitance $C_{PD}$ at the input.\n\nOutput resistance seen at $v_{out}$ for $I_{in}=0$, test source\n$v_{t}=v_{out}$ injecting $i_{t}$:\n\n$$i_{t}= (g_{ds1}+g_{I1})v_{t}-(g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1})v_{x}$$\n$$0=-(g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+g_{I2})v_{x}+(g_{ds1}-g_{m2})v_{t}$$\n\n$$R_{out}={v_{t}\\over i_{t}}=\n{g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1}+g_{ds2}+g_{I2}\\over\n(g_{m1}^{\\prime}+g_{ds1})(g_{m2}+g_{I1})+(g_{ds1}+g_{I1})(g_{ds2}+g_{I2})}\n\\tag{14}$$\n\n$$R_{out0}\\approx {1\\over g_{m2}+g_{I1}}\\approx {1\\over g_{m2}}\\tag{15}$$\n\nif $g_{I1}=0$. Low impedance, the RGC is a good voltage driver.\nIf the output is taken at $x$ - the flipped voltage follower\nusage - $R_{out,x}=R_{in}$, ultra low $\\approx 1/g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o}$,\nvoltage follower gain $\\approx 1$.\n\nPoles: with $C_{x}=C_{gs1}+C_{sb1}+C_{gd2}+C_{db2}+C_{PD}$ at $x$\nand $C_{out}=C_{gd1}+C_{db1}+C_{gs2}+C_{db2}+C_{L}$ at out\n\n$$p_{x}\\approx -{1\\over R_{in}C_{x}}\\qquad \n  p_{out}\\approx -{1\\over R_{out}C_{out}} \\tag{16}$$\n\nBecause $R_{in}$ is $\\propto 1/|T_{0}|$ the input pole is pushed\nout by $|T_{0}|$, extending bandwidth by $g_{m2}r_{o1}$ over the CG.\nNormally\n\n$$|p_{x}|\\approx {g_{m1}^{\\prime}g_{m2}r_{o1}\\over C_{x}}\\;\\;,\n  |p_{out}|\\approx {g_{m2}\\over C_{out}}$$\n\nboth at high frequency, giving GHz bandwidth for $C_{PD}\\sim 100{\\rm fF}$.\nThe two poles are close, loop is second order. Need\n\n$$|p_{out}|>2|p_{x}|\\;\\;{\\rm or\\;capacitive\\;compensation\\;at\\;}out$$\n\nfor $PM>60^{\\circ}$. Peaking and possible oscillation for large\n$C_{PD}$.\n\nLarge signal swing: $\\Delta V_{out}^{+}$ limited by $M_{1}$ entering\ntriode, $\\Delta V_{out}^{-}$ by $M_{2}$ entering triode, typically\n$V_{DD}-2V_{ov}-V_{Tn}-|V_{Tp}|\\approx 0.5-1\\,{\\rm V}$ in low $V_{DD}$.\n\nNoise: input referred current noise\n\n$$\\overline{i_{n,in}^{2}}\\approx 4kT\\gamma(g_{m1}+g_{m2})+\n4kT/R_{B}+ \\overline{i_{n,I1}^{2}}+\\overline{i_{n,I2}^{2}}$$\n\ndominated by $M_{1},M_{2}$.\n\nIn summary the circuit is the {\\it regulated cascode / super\ncommon gate / active feedback common gate transimpedance stage}.\nIt samples the output voltage with $M_{2}$ and mixes a current at the\ninput, shunt-shunt feedback, giving\n\n* $R_{m}\\approx 1/g_{m2}$ - low but wideband, can be increased to\n$R_{D}$ with a resistive load,\n* $R_{in}$ reduced by $1+|T_{0}|\\approx g_{m2}r_{o1}$ to $1/g_{m}g_{m}r_{o}$\n$\\sim 10^{1}-10^{2}\\Omega$,\n* $R_{out}\\sim 1/g_{m2}$,\n* bandwidth $\\times |T_{0}|$ over simple CG, used almost universally\nas the low $Z_{in}$ front end of CMOS optical receivers, current\nconveyors CCII, and low voltage flipped voltage followers. With\noutput taken at $x$ it is the $g_{m}$-boosted source follower with\ngain $\\approx 1$ and $R_{out}\\approx 1/g_{m1}g_{m2}r_{o}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f61718b74975b0d83da3f4790b05f63e88216741fd75bcc57f8bd138dfa852a6"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies M1 as the common-gate NMOS and M2 as the PMOS feedback device driven by Vout, describes feedback to the input node, and gives the very low input resistance and vout/iin and Rout ≈ 1/gm2 results. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "81b07f946459ec3d1a0c51926785b2333e0320bb99c892d5929e040324abeaf8",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2262,
        "output_tokens": 21144,
        "total_tokens": 23406,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 17724,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2262,
        "output_tokens": 21144,
        "total_tokens": 23406,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 17724,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if the three capacitors become arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual first order small signal model\nthe statement is, in the strict sense, false.\nPut, for the $i$ th inverter,\n\n$$A_{v}=-g_{m}R_{o}\\qquad R_{o}=r_{on}\\parallel r_{op}\n\\qquad \\tau =R_{o}C_{L}$$\n\nso that with the ``load'' $C_{L}$\n\n$$A(s)= {{-A_{v}}\\over {1+s\\tau}} \\tag{*}$$\n\nand, open the loop e. {\\it g.} at the input of\n$I_{1}$,\n\n$$L(s)=A(s)^{3}= -{{A_{v}^{3}}\\over {(1+s\\tau )^{3}}}\\tag{1}$$\n\nat $s=0$, $L(0)=-A_{v}^{3}$, $180^{{\\rm o}}$\nmod. $360^{{\\rm o}}$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n|{L(j\\omega )} |&={{A_{v}^{3}}\\over {\\left[1+(\\omega \\tau )^{2}\n\\right]^{3/2}}}\\cr\n{\\rm arg}L(j\\omega )&= 3\\pi -3{\\rm arctan}\\,\\omega \\tau\n\\equiv \\pi -3{\\rm arctan}\\,\\omega \\tau \\;{\\rm mod}\\;2\\pi \\cr} \\tag{2}$$\n\nThe conventional Barkhausen\n$L(j\\omega _{0})=+1$ is\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\pi -3{\\rm arctan}\\,\\omega _{0}\\tau &\\equiv 0\\;{\\rm mod}\\;2\\pi\\cr\n{{A_{v}^{3}}\\over {\\left[1+(\\omega _{0}\\tau )^{2}\\right]^{3/2}}}&=1\n\\cr} \\tag{3}$$\n\ni. {\\it e.} put ${\\rm arg}L=\\,0$,\n\n$${\\rm arctan}\\,\\omega _{0}\\tau ={\\pi \\over 3}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{0}\\tau =\\sqrt{3}\\tag{5}$$\n\nand, at that $\\omega _{0}$,\n\n$$|L(j\\omega _{0})|={{A_{v}^{3}}\\over {8}}=1\\tag{6}$$\n\nSo that the circuit is normally put as\n\n$$A_{v}>2\\tag{7}$$\n\nfor oscillation.\nIn terms of closed loop poles $1-L(s)=0$,\n\n$$(1+s\\tau )^{3}+A_{v}^{3}=0\\tag{8}$$\n\n$$1+s\\tau =A_{v}\\root 3 \\of {-1}=A_{v}\\times\n\\cases{-1\\cr \n{1\\over 2}\\pm j{{\\sqrt{3}}\\over 2}\\cr}\\tag{9}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ns_{1}\\tau &= -1-A_{v}\\cr\ns_{2,3}\\tau &= -1+{{A_{v}}\\over 2}\\pm j{{\\sqrt{3}}\\over 2}A_{v}\\cr}\\tag{10}$$\n\n${\\rm Re}s_{2,3}>0$ for $A_{v}>2$.  The conventional\nlogic inverter has $A_{v}\\sim 10-30$ at the trip point\n$V_{in}=V_{out}=V_{DD}/2$, so the bias point $V_{1}=\nV_{2}=V_{3}=V_{trip}$ is a repellor with a complex pair\nin the RHP, Fig.1.\n\nThe value of $\\tau =R_{o}C_{L}$ cancels out of (7).  It\nonly scales the frequency,\n\n$$\\omega _{0}={{\\sqrt{3}}\\over {R_{o}C_{L}}}\\tag{11}$$\n\nin the small signal picture, and the large signal\n``propagation delay''\n\n$$t_{p}\\approx 0.69R_{o}C_{L}\\approx {{I_{av}}\\over {C_{L}V_{DD}}}\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$f_{osc}\\approx {1\\over {6t_{p}}}\\propto {1\\over {C_{L}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nmore exactly, in large signal, $T\\approx 3C_{L}V_{DD}/I_{av}$,\nso for any {\\it finite} $C_{L}$ the RHP poles stay in the\nRHP with\n\n$${\\rm Re}s_{2,3}={{A_{v}/2-1}\\over {R_{o}C_{L}}}>0\\qquad\n{\\rm Im}s_{2,3}={{\\sqrt{3}A_{v}}\\over {2R_{o}C_{L}}}\\tag{14}$$\n\nand the small signal amplitude grows as\n$\\exp \\left[({\\rm Re}s_{2,3})t\\right]$.\nIncreasing $C_{L}$ simply pushes $\\omega _{0}\\to 0$ and\n${\\rm Re}s_{2,3}\\to 0^{+}$.  There is no finite critical\n$C_{L,{\\rm crit}}$ beyond which $|L|<1$ when\n${\\rm arg}L=0$.\n\nIn the mathematical limit\n\n$$C_{L}\\to \\infty \\qquad \\tau \\to \\infty \\tag{15}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{0}\\to 0\\qquad s_{2,3}\\to 0\\qquad T_{osc}\\to \\infty \\tag{16}$$\n\nthe circuit becomes ``frozen'' at the trip point.\nThe start up time constant\n\n$$\\tau _{st}\\approx 1/{\\rm Re}s_{2,3}\\propto C_{L}\\to \\infty \\tag{17}$$\n\nso that any normally negligible shunt loss $G_{p}$,\nleakage, finite $g_{o}$, supply noise, etc.,\n\n$$(1+s\\tau )^{3}+A_{v}^{3}{{1}\\over {1+G_{p}R_{o}}}\\approx 0\\tag{18}$$\n\nwill pull the poles back into the LHP for\n$C_{L}$ large enough in a physical circuit and the\ncircuit will sit, to all intents and purposes, on its\nmetastable dc point $V_{trip}$ with $f_{osc}\\approx 0$.\nIn that practical sense it can be said to have\n``stopped oscillating''.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  If the inverter is idealised as\n> $R_{o}\\to 0$, $A(s)=-A_{v}$, ($*$) is $C_{L}$\n> independent.  The conventional odd number Boolean\n> loop has no stable dc state and with $R_{o}=0$\n> formally oscillates with $f\\to \\infty $.  A\n> finite $R_{o}$ is what makes ($*$) a low pass and\n> what makes $f_{osc}\\propto 1/C_{L}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "4fb4d755ec6044a3c3852defb7d0a7fc8945f1a43607f3a629a6f8c6b073a872"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The core small-signal analysis is correct: the oscillation condition is independent of capacitance, and the frequency falls as capacitance increases. However, the claim that any small parasitic loss will eventually move the poles into the LHP as capacitance grows is not supported by the model and muddies the central conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "382bd8dbcc1993e2438bdfd3faf5268719f050e1964cb818b2278171cb2c25bf",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2278,
        "output_tokens": 5375,
        "total_tokens": 7653,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3905,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2278,
        "output_tokens": 5375,
        "total_tokens": 7653,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3905,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if the three capacitors become arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the idealised theory the ${\\rm sh.}-C$ is\nnot a ${\\rm sh.}-C$.  Put the customary small signal\nmodel on the inverter,\n\n$${\\rm out}= -g_{m}{\\rm in}\\;Z_{o}\\qquad\nZ_{o}=R_{o}\\parallel {1\\over {sC_{L}}}$$\n\nso that for the $N=3$ loop, Fig.1,\n\n$${\\cal L}(s)=\\left[-g_{m}Z_{o}(s)\\right]^{N}\n=-{(g_{m}R_{o})^{N}\\over {\\left(1+sR_{o}C_{L}\\right)^{N}}}\\tag{*}$$\n\nin the conventional one pole per stage approximation.\n$R_{o}$ is the small signal, large signal, mean,\n$V_{DD}/I_{DD}$ output resistance of the inverter.\nFor a hard CMOS inverter $R_{o}\\sim 1/g_{m}$,\n$A_{v}=g_{m}R_{o}\\gg 1$ at the trip point.  For $N$ odd\nthe unique d. c. solution\n\n$$V_{1}=f(V_{3})\\;,\\;V_{2}=f(V_{1})\\;,\\;V_{3}=f(V_{2})\\tag{**}$$\n\n$$V\\equiv f\\circ f\\circ f(V)\\qquad f^{\\prime}<0$$\n\nis $V_{1}=V_{2}=V_{3}=V_{{\\rm trip}}\\approx V_{DD}/2$\nand its small signal loop gain is $(-A_{v})^{N}$,\n${\\cal L}(0)={\\cal O}(-10^{3})$, i. e. the d. c.\nequilibrium is metastable - unstable - for any\n$C_{L}$.\n\nPut $s=j\\omega $ in $({*})$,\n\n$$|{\\cal L}(j\\omega )|={(g_{m}R_{o})^{N}\\over \n\\left[1+(\\omega R_{o}C_{L})^{2}\\right]^{N/2}} \\tag{1}$$\n\n$${\\rm arg}{\\cal L}(j\\omega )=N\\pi -N{\\rm arctg}\n\\omega R_{o}C_{L}\\tag{2}$$\n\nmod $2\\pi $.  Barkhausen, ${\\cal L}(j\\omega _{0})=1\n+{\\rm j}0$, is\n\n$$N{\\rm arctg}\\omega_{0}R_{o}C_{L}= \\pi \\;\\;{\\rm mod}\\;2\\pi \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${{|{\\cal L}(j\\omega_{0})|>1}\\over{{\\rm for\\;start\\;up}}}$$\n\nFor the conventional $0<{\\rm arctg}<\\pi /2$ solution\n\n$$\\omega _{0}R_{o}C_{L}= {\\rm tg}{\\pi \\over N}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$|{\\cal L}(j\\omega _{0})|=\n\\left[{g_{m}R_{o}\\over {\\sqrt{1+{\\rm tg}^{2}{\\pi /N}}}}\\right]^{N}\n=\\left[g_{m}R_{o}\\cos {\\pi \\over N}\\right]^{N}>1\\tag{5}$$\n\nfor oscillation to be able to build up.\nFor $N=3$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\omega_{0} &={1\\over {R_{o}C_{L}}}{\\rm tg}{\\pi \\over 3}\n ={\\sqrt{3}\\over {R_{o}C_{L}}}\\cr\n|{\\cal L}(j\\omega_{0})|&={(g_{m}R_{o})^{3}\\over 8}>1\\cr\ng_{m}R_{o}&>2\\tag{6}}$$\n\n$c.{\\rm f.}$ the conventional aperiodic condition\n$g_{m}R_{o}>1/\\cos \\pi /N$.  With the customary\n$A_{v}\\approx 10-30$ it is very well satisfied.\nIn particular {\\it (5) is $C_{L}$ independent}.  By\nchoosing $\\omega_{0}\\propto C_{L}^{-1}$ the loop\n contrives to keep\n\n$$\\omega_{0}C_{L}={\\rm tg}{\\pi /N}\\over R_{o}={\\rm const.}\\tag{7}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$|Z_{o}(j\\omega_{0})|={R_{o}\\over \n\\sqrt{1+{\\rm tg}^{2}{\\pi /N}}}=R_{o}\\cos {\\pi\\over N}\\tag{8}$$\n\nis finite even for $C_{L}\\to \\infty $.\n\nIn large signal, digital, language the inverter\ntakes a time\n\n$$t_{d}\\approx 0.69R_{o}C_{L}\\approx  {C_{L}V_{DD}\\over\n2I_{D}} \\tag{9}$$\n\nto charge the next $C_{L}$ to the trip point\n$V_{DD}/2$ and the familiar\n\n$$f_{{\\rm osc}}\\approx {1\\over {2Nt_{d}}}\\approx\n{1\\over {1.38NR_{o}C_{L}}}\\tag{10}$$\n\n${\\rm more\\;accurately}\\;f_{0}=\\omega_{0}/2\\pi $ in\n(4), is obtained.  E. {\\rm g.} for $N=3$\n\n$$f_{0}={\\sqrt{3}\\over {2\\pi R_{o}C_{L}}}\\approx\n{0.28\\over {R_{o}C_{L}}}\\tag{11}$$\n\nto be compared with $1/6t_{d}\\approx 0.24/R_{o}C_{L}$.\n\nIn particular for every finite $C_{L}$ the pole\n\n$$\\omega_{p}={1\\over {R_{o}C_{L}}}\\tag{12}$$\n\nis finite and (3) has a finite solution $\\omega_{0}$.\nIncreasing $C_{L}$ just pushes $\\omega_{p}$ and\n$\\omega_{0}$ down proportional to $C_{L}^{-1}$.\nMathematically the circuit never ceases to satisfy\nBarkhausen if it satisfied it for small $C_{L}$.\nIn the strict $C_{L}\\to \\infty $ limit\n\n$$f_{0}\\to 0\\qquad T_{0}={1\\over {f_{0}}}\\to \\infty \\tag{13}$$\n\nand, what is more important for the bench, the\ncomplex poles of the closed loop\n\n$$1-{\\cal L}(s)=0\\tag{14}$$\n\ngo to\n\n$$s_{p}= {1\\over {R_{o}C_{L}}}\\left[-1+\ng_{m}R_{o}e^{j2k\\pi /N}\\right]\\qquad k=0\\ldots N-1\n\\tag{15}$$\n\nso that for the unstable pair $k=1,N-1$,\n\n$${\\cal R}{\\rm e}\\,s_{p}= {g_{m}R_{o}\\cos 2\\pi /N-1\n\\over {R_{o}C_{L}}}>0\\tag{16}$$\n\ngoes to $0^{+}$ as $C_{L}^{-1}$.  The build up\ntime constant\n\n$$\\tau_{{\\rm bu}}\\approx 1/{\\cal R}{\\rm e}\\,s_{p}\n\\propto C_{L}\\to \\infty \\tag{17}$$\n\ngoes to infinity.  Loosely speaking the circuit\nfreezes on its metastable d. c. point (**) and for\nall practical purposes, on any finite observation\ntime, looks as if it were latched and not\noscillating.  For $C_{L}\\equiv \\infty $, i. e. an a.\nc. short to ground, the loop is of course broken\nand\n\n$$|{\\cal L}(j\\omega )|\\equiv 0\\qquad \\omega\\ne 0\\tag{18}$$\n\nso that there is no a. c. feedback at all.\n\n{\\it Remark on the modelling:} (1)-(2) presume a\nfinite $R_{o}$ - i. e. a finite charging current -\nto make a $R_{o}C_{L}$ low pass interstage.\nAn ideal digital gate normally idealised as a\nzero output impedance voltage source with a\nlumped propagation delay $t_{pd}$,\n\n$$V_{o}(t)=f\\!\\left(V_{i}(t-t_{pd})\\right)\\tag{19}$$\n\nhas $Z_{o}\\equiv 0$ and a ${\\rm sh.}\\,C_{L}$ to\nground draws current but does not develop voltage\nand does not introduce a linear pole in ${\\cal L}(s)$.\nThe linearised ${\\cal L}(s)=-A_{v}e^{-sNt_{pd}}$ has\nno finite $\\omega_{0}$ satisfying (3) with $C_{L}$.\nThe circuit then oscillates - in the digital\nsimulation sense - as the conventional odd inverter\nchain at\n\n$$f_{0}\\approx {1\\over {2Nt_{pd}}}\\tag{20}$$\n\nessentially $C_{L}$ independent, apart from the\ntrivial $t_{pd}(C_{L})$ dependence normally put in\nby hand.  In that idealisation the ${\\rm sh.}\\,C_{L}$\nof Fig.1 is not a phase shift network at all.  The\nconventional $RC$ phase shift oscillator is the high\npass $C_{{\\rm series}}-R_{{\\rm shunt}}$ network.  With\nfinite $R_{o}$ the ${\\rm sh.}\\,C_{L}$ plus $R_{o}$ is\nits low pass dual and (4)-(6) apply.\n\n> {\\it In short: with the usual $R_{o}-C_{L}$ low\n> pass model the Barkhausen magnitude at the\n> $360^{\\rm o}$ frequency is $C_{L}$ independent,\n> (5)-(6), so that if the loop oscillates for small\n> $C_{L}$ it oscillates for arbitrarily large finite\n> $C_{L}$, but at a frequency $f_{0}\\propto\n> 1/C_{L}\\to 0$ and with a start up time $\\propto\n> C_{L}\\to \\infty $, so that in the $C_{L}=\\infty $\n> limit and for all practical bench purposes the\n> circuit is frozen on the metastable\n> $V_{DD}/2$ point and can be said to have\n> ``stopped oscillating''.  With ideal\n> $R_{o}=0$ voltage source inverters the shunt\n> $C_{L}$ introduces no pole at all.}",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "84290dbe0096e39f97d4fa8dc124bb8ed242f9263e42b3971b935149ec0bafea"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly concludes that equal capacitors at all three nodes do not stop oscillation for any finite capacitance. The RC/Barkhausen analysis gives a capacitance-independent oscillation condition and frequency proportional to 1/CL, consistent with the delay argument; the literal infinite-capacitance caveat does not change that conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "382bd8dbcc1993e2438bdfd3faf5268719f050e1964cb818b2278171cb2c25bf",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2278,
        "output_tokens": 7351,
        "total_tokens": 9629,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4885,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2278,
        "output_tokens": 7351,
        "total_tokens": 9629,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4885,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 1,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if the three capacitors become arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-001-fail-oscillate-three-capacitors-become-arbitrarily-large/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual lumped text book model the\ncondition for the birth of the limit cycle has\nnothing to do with $C_{L}$.\n\nPut\n\n$${\\cal A}_{v}(s)=-{{g_{m}R_{0}}\\over {1+sR_{0}C_{L}}}\n=-{{A_{0}}\\over {1+s/\\omega _{p}}}\\qquad \\omega _{p}^{-1}=\nR_{0}C_{L}\\tag{*}$$\n\nfor one loaded inverter in the neighbourhood of\nthe $V_{I}=V_{O}=V_{M}$ bias point.\nFor the normal CMOS inverter $A_{0}=g_{m}R_{0}\\gg 1$.\nThe normal $3$ phase shift oscillator has\n\n$${\\cal L}(s)={\\cal A}_{v}^{3}(s)=\n-{{A_{0}^{3}}\\over {(1+s/\\omega _{p})^{3}}}\\tag{**}$$\n\nso that, on $s=j\\omega $,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n|{\\cal L}|&={{A_{0}^{3}}\\over {\\left[1+(\\omega /\\omega _{p})^{2}\\right]^{3/2}}}\\cr\n\\angle {\\cal L}&=-3\\pi -3{\\rm tg}^{-1}(\\omega /\\omega _{p})\\equiv\n-3{\\rm tg}^{-1}(\\omega /\\omega _{p})\\;({\\rm mod}\\;2\\pi )\\cr}$$\n\n$$|{\\cal L}|=1\\;\\;{\\rm at}\\;\\;3{\\rm tg}^{-1}\\omega /\\omega _{p}=\\pi\n\\;{\\rm mod}\\;2\\pi \\tag{***}$$\n\ni.e.\n\n$${\\rm tg}^{-1}\\omega_{0}/\\omega _{p}={\\pi\\over 3}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{0}= \\sqrt{3}\\,\\omega _{p}={\\sqrt{3}\\over {R_{0}C_{L}}}\\tag{2}$$\n\nis the {\\it small signal\\/} frequency at which the loop\ncan give $2\\pi $ of phase shift, the $-\\pi $ being\nsupplied by the d.c. inversion.  At that frequency\n\n$$|{\\cal L}(j\\omega_{0})|={{A_{0}^{3}}\\over 8}\\tag{3}$$\n\nso that the Barkhausen {\\it modulus\\/} condition is\n\n$$A_{0}=g_{m}R_{0}\\ge 2\\tag{4}$$\n\nand, within $(*)$, has nothing to do with $C_{L}$.\n\nIn terms of the conventional pole pattern that is the\nconventional Hopf bifurcation.  Put $x_{i}=V_{i}-V_{M}$,\n$\\tau =R_{0}C_{L}$, $a=g_{m}R_{0}$ and, linearised,\n\n$$\\tau \\dot x_{i+1}+x_{i+1}=-ax_{i}\\qquad i=1,2,3\\;{\\rm mod}\\;3 \\tag{5}$$\n\nso that with $x\\propto e^{st}$\n\n$$(1+s\\tau )^{3}+a^{3}=0\\tag{6}$$\n\n$$s_{k}={-1-ae^{j2k\\pi /3}\\over {\\tau }}\\qquad k=0,1,2 \\tag{7}$$\n\n$$s_{1,2}={-1+a/2\\mp ja{\\sqrt{3}}/2\\over {\\tau }}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$${\\cal R}s_{1,2}>0\\iff a>2\\tag{9}$$\n\nwhich is ($4$) and $\\tau $ only scales the\n{\\it magnitude\\/} of ${\\cal R}s$ and ${\\cal I}s$.\nFor $a<2$ the d.c. solution $x_{i}\\equiv 0$, i. e.\n$V_{i}\\equiv V_{M}$, is a normal stable node and the\ncircuit latches on $V_{M}$ on the $1/\\tau $ time scale.\nFor\n\n$$a=g_{m}R_{0}>2\\tag{10}$$\n\nthe d.c. solution is a saddle with a two dimensional\nunstable manifold spanned by the complex pair ($8$).\nThe normal supercritical Hopf bifurcation gives birth\nfor $a>2$ to a stable essentially sinusoidal limit cycle\nof {\\it small signal\\/} angular frequency\n\n$$\\omega_{0s}=a{\\sqrt{3}}\\over {2\\tau }={\\sqrt{3}\\over {R_{0}C_{L}}}\n\\tag{11}$$\n\ncollapsing to ($2$) at the bifurcation.\n\nIn large signal the limit cycle rapidly becomes the\nnormal astable square wave relaxation oscillation.\nWith the conventional $0-V_{DD}$ idealisation the\ninverter can be idealised as a threshold $V_{M}\\approx\nV_{DD}/2$ comparator with a Thevenin $R_{0}$ charging\nthe $C_{L}$.  E.{\\it g}. with $R_{0}^{p}=R_{0}^{n}=R_{0}$\n\n$$T_{0}\\approx 2\\times 3R_{0}C_{L}\\log 2\\approx 4.2R_{0}C_{L}\n\\tag{12}$$\n\nnormalised to\n\n$$f_{0}={1\\over {T_{0}}}\\propto {1\\over {R_{0}C_{L}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nand ($11$) is normally quoted, allowing for a shape\nfactor, as\n\n$$f_{0}\\approx {1\\over {5\\sim 7R_{0}C_{L}}}\\tag{14}$$\n\nSo that, {\\it in the model $(*)$}, increasing $C_{L}$\njust displaces the pole $\\omega_{p}$ to lower and lower\nfrequency and the {\\it small signal\\/}\n$\\omega_{0}= {\\sqrt{3}}\\omega_{p}$ and the large signal\nastable frequency ($13$)--($14$) go to zero as\n$1/C_{L}$.  The start up time constant\n\n$$\\tau_{s}^{-1}={\\cal R}s_{1,2}={a/2-1\\over {\\tau }}\\propto {1\\over {C_{L}}}\n\\tag{15}$$\n\ngoes to infinity as $C_{L}$.\n\nIn ordinary language the circuit goes on oscillating\nbut slower and slower and it takes longer and longer to\nstart.\n\nFor $R_{0}\\rightarrow 0$, the usual ``digital'' idealisation,\n$\\tau \\rightarrow 0$ for any finite $C_{L}$ and the $C_{L}$\nhas no effect at all to this order.  You have to put in\nthe intrinsic unloaded pole $\\omega_{0}^{\\ast }$ of the\ninverter,\n\n$${\\cal A}_{v}=-{{A_{0}}\\over {(1+s/\\omega_{0}^{\\ast })\n(1+s/\\omega_{p})}}\\tag{16}$$\n\nto get an effect, and then for $\\omega_{p}\\ll \\omega_{0}^{\\ast }$\n($16$) goes back to $(*)$.\n\nThat is the mathematics.  In the laboratory, of course,\na $f_{0}\\rightarrow 0$ square wave with a $\\tau_{s}\\rightarrow\n\\infty $ start up time and a $I_{pk}=C_{L}dV/dt$ current drive\nrequirement $\\propto C_{L}$ looks very much like\n``no oscillation''.  The $V_{M}$ metastable state lives\nfor a time $\\propto C_{L}$, the available small signal\ngain at $\\omega_{0}\\propto C_{L}^{-1}$ falls below the\nwide band noise floor, the second pole $\\omega_{0}^{\\ast }$,\nsupply leakage, the finite slew rate $I_{0}/C_{L}$ etc.\ndominate, and the circuit will normally be quoted as\nlatched.  If you want to be pedantic the circuit\n``fails to oscillate in any finite observation time'' for\n\n$$C_{L}>C_{L{\\rm max}}\\approx {I_{0}\\over {V_{DD}}}\\,\n{1\\over {f_{{\\rm min}}}}\\tag{17}$$\n\nwhere $f_{{\\rm min}}$ is the lowest frequency you are\nprepared to wait for.  With the conventional $a<2$ low\ngain inverter the circuit fails to oscillate at all,\nfor any $C_{L}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:\\/}  With the usual $A_{0}\\gg 1$ CMOS inverter\n> the textbook statement is often abbreviated to:  the\n> loaded $3$ inverter loop is unconditionally unstable\n> and always oscillates, with $f_{0}\\propto 1/C_{L}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "202d588f8f060c22794911dbbd13a8703d912e4c292dcaa13b69bddddb63511d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that the three-node-loaded ring continues oscillating at a frequency that falls roughly as 1/CL. Its small-signal phase and gain analysis supports that result; the practical caveats do not change the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "382bd8dbcc1993e2438bdfd3faf5268719f050e1964cb818b2278171cb2c25bf",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2275,
        "input_tokens": 2278,
        "output_tokens": 6048,
        "total_tokens": 8326,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4074,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2275,
        "input_tokens": 2278,
        "output_tokens": 6048,
        "total_tokens": 8326,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4074,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "What happens to the phase noise if the three capacitors in the figure are doubled?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With ideal square law devices the circuit is\n\n$${{f_{0}}\\approx {1\\over 2NT_{d}}\\approx {1\\over {2N{{C_{L}}\\over\n{g_{m}}}}}\\propto {1\\over {C_{L}}}} \\tag{*}$$\n\nso that, to first order, $R_{o}={\\rm const}$,\n\n$$f_{0}{\\cal \\to}{1\\over 2}f_{0}\\qquad \n{\\cal P}_{D}=NC_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f_{0}={\\rm const}\\tag{1}$$\n\napart from the trivial ${\\rm Leesson}\\;\\;20\\,{\\rm log}\\,\nf_{0}/\\Delta f$ factor.  Put in the ${\\rm Hajimiri}$ form\nthe normal {\\it white} ${\\cal SSB}$ phase noise at a Fourier\nfrequency $\\Delta \\omega $ from the carrier is\n\n$${\\cal L}\\{\\Delta \\omega \\}={1\\over 2}{\\,{{\\overline{i_{n}^{2}}}\n\\over {\\Delta f}}\\,{\\Gamma_{{\\rm rms}}^{2}\\over\n{q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}\\Delta \\omega ^{2}}} \\tag{2}$$\n\nmodulo the $1/f$ up conversion, $q_{{\\rm max}}=C_{L}V_{DD}$ is\nthe maximum charge on the load and $i_{n}^{2}/\\Delta f\\approx\n4kT\\gamma g_{m}$ is the white current noise of the inverter.\n$\\Gamma _{{\\rm rms}}$ is the rms value of the impulse\nsensitivity function.  For the $N=3$ ring $\\Gamma (t)$ is a\nperiodic train of pulses of width $\\approx t_{r}$,\n$t_{r}\\propto R_{o}C_{L}$ and period $T_{0}=1/f_{0}\\propto\nR_{o}C_{L}$, so that $\\Gamma _{{\\rm rms}}^{2}\\propto\nt_{r}/T_{0}={\\rm const}$ to first order.  I. e. to first order\nthe only $C_{L}$ dependence in (2) is in $q_{{\\rm max}}$\n\n$${\\cal S}_{\\phi }\\propto {\\cal L}\\propto {1\\over {q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}}}\n\\propto {1\\over {C_{L}^{2}}}\\qquad {\\rm at\\;given\\;\n}\\Delta \\omega \\tag{3}$$\n\nso that at the same {\\it absolute} Fourier frequency\n\n$${\\cal L}{\\cal \\to}{1\\over 4}{\\cal L}\\approx {\\cal L}-6{\\rm dB}\n\\tag{4}$$\n\nin power, $3\\,{\\rm dB}$ in voltage.  In terms of the normal\ntime jitter put $\\Delta V_{n}^{2}=kT/C_{L}$ on the capacitor and\n${\\rm SR}=I_{0}/C_{L}$ for the slewing so that the one\ntransition r. m. s. jitter is\n\n$$\\sigma _{t}^{2}={{\\overline{\\Delta V_{n}^{2}}}\\over {{\\rm SR}^{2}}}\n={{kTC_{L}}\\over {I_{0}^{2}}}\\propto C_{L}\\tag{5}$$\n\nso that the absolute period jitter, $\\sigma _{T}^{2}=N\\sigma\n_{t}^{2}\\propto C_{L}$, {\\it increases} by $3\\,{\\rm dB}$, a factor\n$\\sqrt{2}$ in r. m. s. value, on doubling $C_{L}$.\n\nThe phase jitter in one period is\n\n$$\\sigma _{\\phi }^{2}= \\left(2\\pi f_{0}\\right)^{2}\\sigma _{T}^{2}\n\\propto {1\\over {C_{L}^{2}}}C_{L}\\propto {1\\over {C_{L}}}\\tag{6}$$\n\ni. e. $3\\,{\\rm dB}$ {\\it better} in phase, $6\\,{\\rm dB}$ better\nin ${\\cal S}_{\\phi }$.  Indeed, for the diffusion constant of\nthe Wiener phase random walk $D_{\\phi }=\\sigma _{\\phi\n}^{2}f_{0}\\propto 1/C_{L}^{2}$,\n\n$${\\cal S}_{\\phi }(\\Delta \\omega )={{D_{\\phi }}\\over {\\Delta\n\\omega ^{2}}}\\propto {1\\over {C_{L}^{2}\\Delta \\omega ^{2}}}\\tag{7}$$\n\nwhich is (2).  Referred to the new carrier, i. e. at\n$\\Delta \\omega \\propto \\omega _{0}$,\n\n$${\\cal L}\\left\\{{\\Delta \\omega \\over {\\omega _{0}}}={\\rm const}\n\\right\\}\\approx {\\rm const}\\tag{8}$$\n\nso that the usual figure of merit\n\n$${\\rm FoM}= {\\cal L}-20\\,{\\rm log}\\,{{f_{0}}\\over {\\Delta f}}\n+10\\,{\\rm log}\\,{{{\\cal P}_{D}}\\over {1{\\rm mW}}}\\tag{9}$$\n\nis, to first order, $C_{L}$ independent.  With (1) this is\nnormally quoted as a $3\\,{\\rm dB}$ improvement of the\nnormalized phase noise, $6\\,{\\rm dB}$ at the same absolute\n$\\Delta f$, for a capacitance doubling.  If the extra $20\\,{\\rm\nlog}\\,f_{0}/\\Delta f$ is factored out the improvement is\nnormally quoted as\n\n> {\\it At constant $\\Delta f/f_{0}$, at constant power,\n> doubling the total tank energy, $E\\propto C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}$,\n> halves the normalized white phase noise power, $\\propto\n> 1/E$, i. e. $10\\,{\\rm log}\\,2\\approx 3\\,{\\rm dB}$ better.\n> At constant $\\Delta f$ the $20\\,{\\rm log}\\,f_{0}$ Leeson\n> factor adds a further $6\\,{\\rm dB}$, for a total of\n> $\\approx 6\\,{\\rm dB}$ at the same absolute offset.}\n\nIn particular with $R_{o}={\\rm const}$ the unbiased ring goes\nfrom $f_{0}$ to $f_{0}/2$ and from ${\\cal L}(\\Delta f)$ to\n${\\cal L}(\\Delta f)-20\\,{\\rm log}\\,2\\approx {\\cal L}-6\\,{\\rm\ndB}$ in the $1/f^{2}$ region.  Modulo the $20\\,{\\rm log}\\,\nf_{0}/\\Delta f$ normalisation this is a $3\\,{\\rm dB}$\nimprovement of ${\\cal S}_{\\phi }$, ${\\cal L}$ and of\n$\\sigma _{\\phi }$, no improvement of the ${\\rm FoM}$,\nand, from (5), a $3\\,{\\rm dB}$ {\\it degradation} of the\nabsolute period jitter $\\sigma _{T}$.  If you keep $f_{0}$\nconstant by doubling the device widths, $g_{m}\\propto 1/R_{0}\n\\propto C_{L}$, $i_{n}^{2}\\propto g_{m}\\propto C_{L}$, the\nfamiliar $3\\,{\\rm dB}$ per energy doubling is obtained at\nconstant $f_{0}$, ${\\cal L}\\propto 1/C_{L}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  The $1/f^{3}$ close in noise scales in\n> the same way, ${\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}\\propto 1/q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}\n> \\propto 1/C_{L}^{2}$ at given $\\Delta \\omega $, but the\n> $1/f^{3}$ corner, $\\Delta \\omega _{1/f^{3}}\\propto 1/C_{L}$,\n> moves in by a factor $2$, so that very close to the carrier\n> the $1/f^{3}$ noise can appear to degrade.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "89dee03985406042b6d0b7bd84a60f36884b8fe2ac255733c4f13dc6c777fa31"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that doubling the capacitors halves the oscillation frequency and reduces phase noise by a factor of four (about 6 dB) at a fixed absolute offset, with supporting charge/edge-rate reasoning.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c8a3a6ddcab3a54151ffe61cb3e809a6731a66beda02e9f8898ea9c435318b06",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 10884,
        "total_tokens": 13160,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8892,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 10884,
        "total_tokens": 13160,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8892,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "What happens to the phase noise if the three capacitors in the figure are doubled?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual somewhat white noise\nmodel the circuit is {\\it not} improved.\nIn first order\n\n$${T_{D}\\propto R_{o}C_{L}\\propto {C_{L}V_{DD}\\over I_{D}}\n\\qquad f_{0}={1\\over {2NT_{D}}}\\propto {1\\over C_{L}} \\tag{1}$$\n\n$$P_{av}=Nf_{0}C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}\\propto N{C_{L}\\over C_{L}}=\n{\\rm const.}\\tag{2}$$\n\nfor $N=3$ on the $CV^{2}f$ power.\nFor the normal Hajimiri - Lee - Abidi white\n${\\rm FM}$ noise, e. {\\rm g.} in the form\n\n$${\\cal L}\\left\\{\\Delta \\omega \\right\\}\n={{{\\bar {i_{n}^{2}}}/\\Delta f}\\over {8q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}\\Delta\n\\omega ^{2}}}{\\bar {\\Gamma _{rms}^{2}}}\\qquad \nq_{{\\rm max}}=C_{L}V_{DD} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$\\Gamma _{rms}\\approx 0.3-1$ for the large signal\nrail to rail ring and $i_{n}^{2}/\\Delta f =4kT\\gamma g_{m}\n\\approx 4kT/R_{o}$ is to first order independent of the\nexternal $C_{L}$,\n\n$${\\cal L}\\propto {1\\over q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}}\\propto \n{1\\over C_{L}^{2}}\\propto f_{0}^{2}\\tag{4}$$\n\nin the more familiar Leeson form\n\n$${\\cal L}\\left\\{\\Delta f\\right\\}\\propto {FkT\\over P_{av}}\n\\left({f_{0}\\over 2Q\\Delta f}\\right)^{2}\\propto\n{f_{0}^{2}\\over P_{av}}\\tag{5}$$\n\nso that, with $P_{av}=$ const. from (2),\n\n$${\\cal L}\\propto f_{0}^{2}\\propto {1\\over C_{L}^{2}}\\tag{6}$$\n\nin power.  I. {\\rm e.} at {\\it the same absolute}\n${\\cal L}\\left\\{\\Delta f\\right\\}$ e. {\\rm g.} at\n$1\\,{\\rm MHz}$ from the {\\it new} carrier\n\n$$f_{0}\\rightarrow f_{0}/2\\qquad \n{\\cal L}\\rightarrow {\\cal L}/4\\tag{7}$$\n\nabout $-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ in conventional ${\\rm dBc/Hz^{-1}}$.\nNormalised to the carrier, i.e. at the same\n$\\Delta f/f_{0}$ or, what is the same thing, in terms\nof the conventional figure of merit\n\n$${\\rm FoM}={\\cal L}-20\\log {f_{0}\\over \\Delta f}\n+10\\log {P_{av}\\over 1{\\rm mW}} \\tag{8}$$\n\n(2) cancels (6) to\n\n$${\\rm FoM}= {\\rm const.}\\tag{9}$$\n\nso that at the same {\\it fractional} offset,\n$\\Delta f\\propto f_{0}$, e. {\\rm g.} $\\Delta f/f_{0}\n=10^{-2}$,\n\n$${\\cal L}_{n}\\propto {1\\over C_{L}}\\;,\\qquad \n{\\cal L}(2C_{L})={1\\over 2}{\\cal L}(C_{L})\\tag{10}$$\n\n$-3\\,{\\rm dB}$ in power, $1/\\sqrt{2}$ in voltage,\nnormally quoted in text books in the shorthand\nform\n\n$${\\cal L}\\approx {{kT}\\over {C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}}}\n\\left({f_{0}\\over \\Delta f}\\right)^{2}\\tag{11}$$\n\nas {\\it $3\\,{\\rm dB}$ per doubling of $C$ if the\ncomparison is made at the same $f_{0}$}.\nIf you want to keep $f_{0}$ constant you have to\ndouble the $W$'s, $I_{D}\\propto C_{L}$, $P_{av}\n\\propto C_{L}$ and (6) becomes (10)-(11), the\ncustomary $1/C_{L}$ law.\n\nIn the time domain the {\\it absolute} jitter,\nthe $kT/C$ voltage noise divided by the slew rate\n$S=I_{D}/C_{L}$ at threshold,\n\n$$\\sigma _{V}^{2}={{kT}\\over {C_{L}}}\\qquad \nS={{I_{D}}\\over {C_{L}}}\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$\\sigma _{t}={{\\sigma _{V}}\\over S}={{\\sqrt{kTC_{L}}}\n\\over {I_{D}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nper transition, variance\n\n$$\\sigma _{t}^{2}\\propto C_{L}\\tag{14}$$\n\nso that for the $2N$ transitions per period\n\n$$\\sigma _{T}^{2}=2N\\sigma _{t}^{2}\\propto C_{L}\\tag{15}$$\n\n$$\\sigma _{T}(2C_{L})=\\sqrt{2}\\,\\sigma _{T}(C_{L})\\tag{16}$$\n\n$+3\\,{\\rm dB}$ in variance, $+1.5\\,{\\rm dB}$, a factor\n$\\sqrt{2}\\approx 1.4$, in rms seconds.  The often\nquoted {\\it improvement} in ${\\cal L}$ is the\nimprovement in {\\it fractional} jitter\n\n$${{\\sigma _{T}}\\over {T_{0}}}\\propto {{\\sqrt{C_{L}}}\n\\over {C_{L}}}={1\\over {\\sqrt{C_{L}}}}\\tag{17}$$\n\n$$T_{0}\\sigma _{T}^{-1}\\propto \\sqrt{C_{L}}\\tag{18}$$\n\n$-1.5\\,{\\rm dB}$ rms, $-3\\,{\\rm dB}$ in power,\n$-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ at fixed absolute $\\Delta f$,\ncf. (7).  Any $1/f$ induced $1/f^{3}$ component,\n${\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}\\propto K\\,f_{0}^{2}/C_{L}^{2}\n\\Delta f^{3}$, scales in the same way, to first\norder $-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ at fixed $\\Delta f$, $-3\\,{\\rm dB}$\nat fixed $\\Delta f/f_{0}$, ${\\rm FoM}=$ const.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In the text book shorthand (11)\n> this is normally phrased as {\\it the {\\rm (white)}\n> phase noise power is halved, $-3\\,{\\rm dB}$, for a\n> doubling of the {\\rm (total)} tank capacitance at\n> constant $f_{0}$ and ${\\rm FoM}$}.  With the\n> inverters left alone the carrier itself is halved\n> and the conventional ${\\cal L}\\{\\Delta f\\}$ at the\n> same {\\it absolute} $\\Delta f$ is quartered,\n> $-6\\,{\\rm dB}$.  The price is $\\sqrt{2}$ more\n> absolute period jitter.  Second order effects,\n> short channel excess noise $\\gamma >2/3$, supply\n> and substrate noise, the $R_{o}(V_{DD})$ non\n> linearity, etc., will normally make the improvement\n> less than the ideal $1/C$ - $1/C^{2}$ law.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "66103c897a32a1e9f9f0e82fee285ce2cd2151b847beb1b221587e3923adbc38"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly explains that doubling the capacitors halves f0 and reduces phase noise by about a factor of four (−6 dB) at a fixed offset, meeting the full-credit rule. The extra fractional-offset discussion is not needed for the central result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c8a3a6ddcab3a54151ffe61cb3e809a6731a66beda02e9f8898ea9c435318b06",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2275,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 8171,
        "total_tokens": 10447,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6331,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2275,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 8171,
        "total_tokens": 10447,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6331,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 2,
      "question": "What happens to the phase noise if the three capacitors in the figure are doubled?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-002-phase-noise-three-capacitors-doubled/figure-05.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "For a first order 3 invertor model put\n$R_{o}\\approx 1/g_{m}$ , $t_{D}\\approx 0.69R_{o}C_{L}\n\\approx C_{L}V_{DD}/2I_{D}$ and\n\n$${\\rm f}_{0}\\approx {1\\over 6t_{D}}\\propto {1\\over C_{L}}\\tag *$$\n\nso that apart from second order changes of the\nwave form\n\n$$f_{0}^{\\prime }\\approx {1\\over 2}f_{0}\\qquad \nP\\approx Nf_{0}C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}={\\rm const.}\\tag {**}$$\n\nin first order.  Put e. {\\rm g.} the conventional\nLeeson - Hajimiri estimate\n\n$${\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )\n      \\approx 10\\log \\left[{{{\\bar \\Gamma}_{rms}^{2}\\over 2}\n                 {{{\\overline{i_{n}^{2}}}/\\Delta f}\\over {q_{max}^{2}\n                 \\Delta \\omega ^{2}}}}\\right] \\tag{*}$$\n\n$\\Gamma $ is the impulse sensitivity function,\n$q_{{\\rm max}}=C_{L}V_{{\\rm max}}$ the maximum charge\nswing on the load and ${\\overline{i_{n}^{2}}/\\Delta f}\n=4kT\\gamma g_{m}$ the white drain current noise of\nthe invertor which to first order does not know about\n$C_{L}$.\n\n$$S_{\\phi }(\\Delta \\omega )\\propto \n     {{\\overline{i_{n}^{2}}}/\\Delta f\\over q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}\n            \\Delta \\omega ^{2}}\\propto {1\\over {C_{L}^{2}}}\n            {1\\over {\\Delta \\omega ^{2}}}\\tag{1}$$\n\nso that at {\\it the same absolute\\/} $\\Delta \\omega $\n$${\\cal L}^{\\prime }={\\cal L}-20\\log 2\\approx {\\cal L}-6{\\rm dB}\n\\qquad {\\rm white\\;FM}\\;\\propto 1/\\Delta \\omega ^{2} \\tag{2}$$\nand in power $\\propto 1/4$.\nWith the normal ${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}$ normalisation\n\n$${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}={\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )\n      -20\\log {{f_{0}}\\over {\\Delta f}}+10\\log P\\tag{3}$$\n\n(2) is the ${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}={\\rm const}$ law.\nAt the same {\\it fractional\\/} off set $\\Delta \\omega\n\\propto \\omega_{0}$, $\\Delta \\omega ^{\\prime }=\n\\Delta \\omega /2$, (1) is normally quoted with the\n$\\omega_{0}$ taken out,\n\n$$S_{\\phi }\\propto {{kT}\\over {C_{L}V^{2}}}\n        \\left({{\\omega_{0}}\\over {\\Delta \\omega }}\\right)^{2}\n        {1\\over {\\Delta \\omega^{2}}}\\propto {1\\over {C_{L}}}\n        \\tag{4}$$\n\ni. e. the familiar $kT/C$ law\n\n$${\\cal L}(k\\omega_{0})\\approx {\\cal L}(k\\omega_{0}^{\\prime })\n      -10\\log 2\\approx {\\cal L}-3{\\rm dB}\\tag{5}$$\n\nin power, a factor $2$ , in the loose normal\nlanguage ``the phase noise does not change, the\n${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}$ is invariant''.\nIn text book shorthand (5) is quoted as ``$3\\,{\\rm dB}$\nbetter phase noise'' for $C\\to 2C$.\n\nIn the time domain the {\\it absolute\\/} jitter gets\nworse.  With e. {\\rm g.} the $RC$ noise\n\n$${\\overline{v_{n}^{2}}}=kT/C_{L}\\tag{6}$$\n\nand, at the threshold, the slew rate\n\n$$SR=\\left.{{dV}\\over {dt}}\\right|_{V_{th}}\\approx\n{I_{D}\\over C_{L}}\\approx {V_{DD}\\over {R_{o}C_{L}}}\\tag{7}$$\n\n$${\\overline{\\delta t^{2}}}\\approx \n   {{{\\overline{v_{n}^{2}}}}\\over {SR^{2}}}\\approx\n   {{kT/C_{L}}\\over {I_{D}^{2}/C_{L}^{2}}}={{kTC_{L}}\\over {I_{D}^{2}}}\n   \\propto C_{L}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$${\\sigma _{T}^{\\prime }}^{2}=2\\sigma _{T}^{2}\\qquad \n  \\sigma _{T}^{\\prime }=\\sqrt{2}\\,\\sigma _{T}\\tag{9}$$\n\n$\\approx +3\\,{\\rm dB}$ in power, $+1.5\\,{\\rm dB}$ in rms\nvalue.  The period jitter, sometimes loosely called\n``phase noise'', is $\\sqrt{2}$ larger.  The phase\njitter,\n\n$$S_{\\phi }(\\Delta \\omega )\\propto f_{0}^{3}\\sigma _{T}^{2}\n/\\Delta \\omega ^{2}\\propto 1/C_{L}^{2}\\tag{10}$$\n\ngoes as (1) and is $\\approx 6\\,{\\rm dB}$, $3\\,{\\rm dB}$\nfractional, better, ${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}={\\rm const}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  With (**) $P={\\rm const}$ this is\n> normally expressed as ${\\cal L}\\propto (kT/P)\n> (\\omega_{0}/\\Delta\\omega )^{2}$.  Any $1/f^{3}$\n> flicker induced component scales $\\propto 1/C_{L}$ at\n> fixed absolute $\\Delta \\omega $ and is ${\\cal F}{\\cal O}\n> {\\cal M}$ invariant at fixed $\\Delta \\omega /\\omega_{0}$.\n\nIn round numbers: $f_{0}\\to f_{0}/2$, ${\\rm CV^{2}f}$\npower $\\approx {\\rm const}$, spot $1/f^{2}$ noise\n$\\approx -3\\,{\\rm dB}$ at $k\\,f_{0}$, $-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ at\nfixed $\\Delta f$, ${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}$ invariant to\nfirst order, rms period jitter $+\\sqrt{2}$.  With the\nusual $10\\log $ shorthand the oscillator is said to be\n``$3\\,{\\rm dB}$ quieter'', and with the $\\Delta f\\propto\nf_{0}$ normalisation ``unchanged''; the $6\\,{\\rm dB}$\nnumber is for comparison at the same absolute frequency\noff set.  Neglecting the $\\omega_{0}$ shift this is\nquoted as ${\\cal L}\\propto kT/C_{L}$, i. e. half the\nnoise power for $2C_{L}$.  The absolute cycle to cycle\njitter is $\\sqrt{2}$ larger.  Any statement that the\nphase noise is ``unchanged'' or ``$3\\,{\\rm dB}$ better\n($6\\,{\\rm dB}$ at fixed $\\Delta f$)'' is the same\n${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}={\\rm const}$ statement to\nwithin the normal textbook approximations.  Including\nwave form and $\\Gamma_{rms}$ changes the improvement is\nnormally $2$--$4\\,{\\rm dB}$, $4$--$6\\,{\\rm dB}$ absolute.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5445c0a50d3f2020d8e0a898f2f88e66d5e615af0fb4bd7f8742d9a19b34c6a0"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly predicts frequency halving and a fourfold (6 dB) phase-noise reduction at a fixed absolute offset, supported by charge/noise scaling. Its extra fixed-fractional-offset discussion is muddled, but does not change the required conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "c8a3a6ddcab3a54151ffe61cb3e809a6731a66beda02e9f8898ea9c435318b06",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 10528,
        "total_tokens": 12804,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8677,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 10528,
        "total_tokens": 12804,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8677,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if CL becomes arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "If you want to be very pedantic about it the\nanswer is: {\\it in the linear, small signal, near\nsinusoidal, Barkhausen sense} yes and {\\it in the\nlarge signal, rail to rail, {\\it digital} sense}\nno.  What is normally quoted as ``the ring does\nnot have a stable Boolean state'' remains true.\n\nPut $R_{0},C_{0}$ for the output resistance and the\n{\\it intrinsic} output capacitance of one inverter,\n$A_{0}=g_{m}R_{0}>>1$ for its small signal\nvoltage gain and\n\n$$p_{0}={1\\over {R_{0}C_{0}}}\\qquad \n  p_{1}={1\\over {R_{0}(C_{0}+C_{L})}}=k\\,p_{0}\\tag{*}$$\n\n$$k={{C_{0}}\\over {C_{0}+C_{L}}}<1$$\n\nfor the pole at the loaded node.  With the usual\none pole model for the inverter the loop gain is\n\n$${\\cal L}(s)={{(-A_{0})^{3}}\n     {\\left(1+s/p_{1}\\right)\\left(1+s/p_{0}\\right)^{2}}}\n     =-{A_{0}^{3}\\over {\\left(1+s/kp_{0}\\right)\n        \\left(1+s/p_{0}\\right)^{2}}}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$${\\cal L}(j\\omega )=\n   {{A_{0}^{3}e^{{j\\pi}}}\\over {\n      \\sqrt{1+(\\omega /kp_{0})^{2}}\n      \\left[1+(\\omega /p_{0})^{2}\\right]}}\n      e^{-j\\left[\\tan ^{-1}\\!\\omega /kp_{0}+\n                  2\\tan ^{-1}\\!\\omega /p_{0}\\right]} \\tag{2}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$\\angle {\\cal L}= \\pi -\\tan ^{-1}{\\omega\\over {kp_{0}}}\n                    -2\\tan ^{-1}{\\omega\\over {p_{0}}}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$|{\\cal L}|=A_{0}^{3}/\\sqrt{1+(\\omega /kp_{0})^{2}}\n\\left[1+(\\omega /p_{0})^{2}\\right]$.\nFor $k=1$ the $0\\pmod{2\\pi }$ cross over is at\n\n$$3\\tan ^{-1}x=\\pi \\;\\;,\\;\\;x=\\omega /p_{0}=\\sqrt{3}\n\\tag{4}$$\n\nand, with $x=\\omega /p_{0}$,\n\n$$\\tan ^{-1}{x\\over k}+2\\tan ^{-1}x =\\pi \\tag{5}$$\n\nalways has a solution. For $k\\ll 1$, $\\tan ^{-1}x/k\n\\approx \\pi /2$ and (5) is at $x\\approx 1$, $\\omega\n\\approx p_{0}$.  At that $\\omega $\n\n$$|{\\cal L}(j\\omega _{0})|\\approx\n  {{A_{0}^{3}k}\\over {x\\left(1+x^{2}\\right)}}\\approx\n  {{A_{0}^{3}}\\over 2}k=\n  {{A_{0}^{3}}\\over 2}{{C_{0}}\\over {C_{0}+C_{L}}}\\tag{6}$$\n\ni. e. the gain at the Barkhausen phase cross over\nrolls off as $1/C_{L}$.\n\nThe closed loop characteristic $1-{\\cal L}=0$,\n\n$$\\left(1+{s\\over {kp_{0}}}\\right)\\left(1+{s\\over {p_{0}}}\n  \\right)^{2}+A_{0}^{3}=0\\tag{7}$$\n\nis with $y=s/p_{0}$\n\n$$y^{3}+(2+k)y^{2}+(1+2k)y+k\\left(1+A_{0}^{3}\\right)=0\n\\tag{8}$$\n\nwhich is Hurwitz iff\n\n$$(2+k)(1+2k)>k\\left(1+A_{0}^{3}\\right)\\tag{9}$$\n\nThe Hopf bifurcation $y=j\\omega_{0}$ is at\n\n$$ \\omega _{0}^{2}=1+2k \\tag{10}$$\n$$kA_{0}^{3}=2(1+k)^{2}\\tag{11}$$\n\ni. e. up to $k\\approx 1$\n\n$$A_{0}^{3}\\approx {2\\over k}\\tag{12}$$\n\nfor $k\\ll 1$.  In ordinary language\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nC_{L,{\\rm crit}}&\\approx C_{0}\\left({A_{0}^{3}\\over 2}-1\\right)\n\\cr\n&\\approx {{g_{m}R_{0}}^{3}\\over 2}C_{0}\\tag{13}}$$\n\nand for $C_{L}>C_{L,{\\rm crit}}$ all three\nclosed loop poles are in the ${\\rm Re}\\,s<0$ half\nplane, the $V_{M}$ equilibrium where all three\ninverters are in the high gain region is small\nsignal stable and a small perturbation, noise,\ndecays to $V_{M}$.  In the ${\\cal L}\\to \\infty $,\n$C_{L}\\to \\infty $ limit $p_{1}\\to 0$ the loaded\nnode is an a. c. ground, $|{\\cal L}|\\to 0$, and,\nlinearly, the loop is broken.  In that linear\nBarkhausen sense the ``nice'' quasi sinusoidal\noscillation does disappear for\n\n$$k<k_{c}=2/A_{0}^{3}\\tag{14}$$\n\nFor a normal CMOS inverter $A_{0}\\sim 10-30$,\n$A_{0}^{3}\\sim 10^{3}-3\\times 10^{4}$, so that\n\n$$C_{L,{\\rm crit}}\\sim 5\\times 10^{2}-10^{4}\\;C_{0}\\tag{15}$$\n\nis astronomically large on the scale of the normal\nparasitic.  For any normal design value the circuit\nis small signal unstable and starts up.\n\nIf the inverters are idealized as high gain\ncomparators, $A_{0}\\to \\infty $, $k_{c}\\to 0$,\n$C_{L,{\\rm crit}}\\to \\infty $, the phase condition\n(5) can always be satisfied with $|{\\cal L}|>1$ and\nthe circuit is astable for any finite $C_{L}$.\nLarge signal the three inverters saturate rail to\nrail.  Putting $\\tau_{L}=R_{0}C_{L}\\gg \\tau_{0}=\nR_{0}C_{0}$ and eliminating the two fast poles\nadiabatically, $V_{B}\\approx f(V_{A})$, $V_{C}\\approx\nf(V_{B})$,\n\n$$\\tau_{L}\\dot V_{A}=f\\!\\left(f\\!\\left(f(V_{A})\\right)\\right)\n      -V_{A}\\equiv h(V_{A})-V_{A}\\tag{16}$$\n\n$h$ is monotone decreasing, $h(0)=V_{DD}$,\n$h(V_{DD})=0$, so $h(V_{M})=V_{M}$ is the unique\n(Boolean inconsistent) d. c. solution, but (16) is\nnormally operated saturated.  Idealising $f$ as\n$V_{DD}$ for $V_{in}<V_{M}-\\epsilon $ and $0$ for\n$V_{in}>V_{M}+\\epsilon $ the loaded node ramps\nexponentially towards the rail dictated by the two\ninverter buffer with time constant $\\tau_{L}$,\ncrosses $V_{M}$, the buffer snaps, the drive\nreverses and the ramp reverses.  I. e. the circuit\ngoes over into the familiar $R_{0}C_{L}$ relaxation\noscillator with, to first order,\n\n$$T\\approx 2\\tau_{L}\\ln {2V_{DD}\\over {V_{DD}-V_{M}}}\n      \\approx 2R_{0}C_{L}\\ln 2\\tag{17}$$\n\nfor $V_{M}\\approx V_{DD}/2$, $f_{osc}\\propto 1/C_{L}\n\\to 0$ as $C_{L}\\to \\infty $, but $\\ne 0$ for any\nfinite $C_{L}$.  In a conventional SPICE large\nsignal transient simulation the circuit will keep\nswitching rail to rail for any finite $C_{L}$ if you\nkick it out of the $V_{M}$ metastable point.  With\nfinite $A_{0}$ that metastable point is small\nsignal stable for $C_{L}>C_{L,{\\rm crit}}$ so that\nit will not start up from noise, but it is still\nlarge signal astable - the normal digital `` the\nodd ring has no stable Boolean state'' - and a\nlarge kick will put it on the relaxation limit\ncycle.\n\nIn particular for all practical values $C_{L}\\sim\n{\\cal O}(C_{0})$ the ring oscillates, just more\nslowly, $f_{osc}\\approx 1/2N\\tau_{0}\\to 1/2\\tau_{L}$\nwhen the loaded stage dominates.  The textbook\n``it stops oscillating'' is the $C_{L}\\to \\infty $\na.c. short, $k\\to 0$, $|{\\cal L}|\\to 0$ linear\nresult (13)-(14).  With $A_{0}\\to\\infty $ that\nlimit is pushed to infinity.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "80771edc00f5beda0541dac6f3805e9b7a1c1eefd831e6c5ca8daf96a412ae7c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the dominant pole from loading only one node and shows that, for finite inverter gain, the loop gain at phase crossover falls below unity beyond a finite CL, stabilizing the small-signal equilibrium. The large-signal relaxation-oscillation caveat is additional and does not negate that core result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f6dd3ed123c88a59472f7a76de74df7e33b3e73498632bd24bc1ea808e4efcbc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 15387,
        "total_tokens": 17663,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13100,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 15387,
        "total_tokens": 17663,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13100,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if CL becomes arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the ideal rail to rail picture {\\it no};\nin the small signal pole picture {\\it yes} and the\ntwo pictures coincide in $C_{L}=\\infty $.\nPut, for the normal analysis $g_{ds}=g$,\n\n$$Z_{o1}={1\\over g+sC_{1}}\\qquad Z_{o2,3}={1\\over g+sC_{0}}\\qquad \nC_{1}=C_{0}+C_{L}$$\n\nand, at the metastable, $V_{DD}/2$, bias\n\n$$A_{v}=g_{m}r_{o}=g_{m}/g\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$L(s)=-A_{v}^{3}{(1+s\\tau_{0})^{-2}(1+s\\tau_{1})^{-1}}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$\\tau_{0}=C_{0}/g\\;\\;,\\;\\;\\tau_{1}=C_{1}/g=K\\tau_{0}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$L(j\\omega )$ can have $\\angle L=0\\;{\\rm mod}\\;2\\pi $\niff\n\n$$\\pi -\\sum_{1}^{3}{\\rm atan}\\;\\omega \\tau_{i}=0\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$ \\sum {\\rm atan}\\;\\omega \\tau_{i}=\\pi \\tag{4a}$$\n\nFor $K=1$\n\n$$\\omega_{0}={\\sqrt{3}\\over {\\tau_{0}}}\\qquad \n|L(j\\omega_{0})|={A_{v}^{3}\\over 8}\\tag{5}$$\n\nand $A_{v}>2$ will start.  For $K\\gg 1$\n${\\rm atan}\\;\\omega \\tau_{1}\\rightarrow \\pi /2$ and (4a)\nis\n\n$${\\pi \\over 2}+2{\\rm atan}\\;\\omega \\tau_{0}=\\pi \\tag{6}$$\n\n$$\\omega_{1}\\approx {1\\over {\\tau_{0}}}\\tag{7}$$\n\nand\n\n$$|L(j\\omega_{1})|={{A_{v}^{3}}\\over\n{\\sqrt{1+\\omega_{1}^{2}\\tau_{1}^{2}}\\left(1+\\omega_{1}^{2}\\tau_{0}^{2}\n\\right)} }={{A_{v}^{3}}\\over {2\\sqrt{1+K^{2}}}}\n\\approx {{A_{v}^{3}}\\over {2K}}\\tag{8}$$\n\nfor $K\\gg 1$.  I. e. the 180 deg. frequency is\nstill there, ${\\cal O}(1/\\tau_{0})$, but the gain\nthere goes as $1/K\\propto 1/C_{L}$.\n\nIn closed loop form the poles are the roots of\n\n$$1-L(s)=0\\tag{9}$$\n\n$$(1+s\\tau_{1})(1+s\\tau_{0})^{2}+A_{v}^{3}=0\\tag{10}$$\n\n$$K\\tau_{0}^{3}s^{3}+(2K+1)\\tau_{0}^{2}s^{2}+(K+2)\\tau_{0}s+\n1+A_{v}^{3}=0\\tag{11}$$\n\nRouth:\n\n$$a_{3}=K\\;\\;a_{2}=2K+1\\;\\;a_{1}=K+2\\;\\;a_{0}=1+A_{v}^{3}\\tag{12}$$\n\nstable $=$ all ${\\rm Re}\\,s<0$ iff $a_{2}a_{1}>a_{3}a_{0}$.\n\n$$\\left(2K+1\\right)\\left(K+2\\right)>K\\left(1+A_{v}^{3}\\right)\\tag{13}$$\n\nI. e. for sufficiently large $K$\n\n$$K>K_{{\\rm crit}}\\approx {1\\over 2}A_{v}^{3}\\;\\;,\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;\nA_{v}\\gg 1\\tag{14}$$\n\n$$C_{L{\\rm crit}}\\approx \\left({A_{v}^{3}\\over 2}-1\\right)C_{0}\\tag{15}$$\n\nthe linearised circuit is stable.\nWith $A_{v}=10-20$, $A_{v}^{3}=10^{3}-8\\times 10^{3}$,\n$C_{L{\\rm crit}}\\sim 5\\times 10^{2}-4\\times 10^{3}C_{0}$.\nFor $C_{L}>C_{L{\\rm crit}}$ a small noise ${\\rm e}^{st}$\nis damped to the metastable\n\n$$V_{1}=V_{2}=V_{3}\\approx V_{DD}/2\\tag{16}$$\n\nbias where all three devices are in saturation.\nIn that conventional small signal, Barkhausen,\ndescribing function sense the oscillator is\n{\\it dead} to noise.  For $C_{L}\\rightarrow \\infty $\n$Z_{o1}\\rightarrow 0$ ac, the loop is ac open, $L\\equiv 0$.\n\nThat is the conventional textbook ``it stops\noscillating''.\n\nIf the inverters are idealised as infinite gain\nhard comparators, $V_{o}=V_{DD}{\\rm sgn}\\left(V_{TH}-V_{i}\\right)$,\nwith an $R\\,C_{L}$ charge at the loaded node, the\nequation is non linear and (15) is irrelevant.\nPut $T_{d}=t_{d2}+t_{d3}$ the delay of the two\nunloaded inverters and $R=1/g$, $V_{TH}=V_{DD}/2$.\nWith the notation of the figure $B\\equiv V_{o1}$,\n$C\\equiv V_{o2}$, $A\\equiv V_{o3}$: $C=\\bar B$ after\n$t_{d2}$, $A=\\bar C$ after $t_{d3}$.  For $A=0$, $B$\ncharges to $V_{DD}$ as\n\n$$B(t)=V_{DD}-(V_{DD}-V_{L}){\\rm e}^{-t/RC_{L}}\\tag{17}$$\n\nand for $A=1$ discharges as $B(t)=V_{H}{\\rm e}^{-t/RC_{L}}$.\nContinuity at the switching gives\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{L}&=V_{TH}{\\rm e}^{-T_{d}/RC_{L}}\\cr\nV_{H}&=V_{DD}-\\left(V_{DD}-V_{TH}\\right){\\rm e}^{-T_{d}/RC_{L}}\\cr\nt_{r}&=t_{f}=RC_{L}\\log {{V_{H}\\over {V_{TH}}}}\n      =RC_{L}\\log {{V_{DD}-V_{L}\\over {V_{DD}-V_{TH}}}\n      =RC_{L}\\log \\left(2-{\\rm e}^{-T_{d}/RC_{L}}\\right)\\cr}\\tag{18}$$\n\nso that a full period is, $R\\,C_{L}\\ne 0$,\n\n$$T=2\\left(t_{r}+T_{d}\\right)=\n2RC_{L}\\log \\left(2-{\\rm e}^{-T_{d}/RC_{L}}\\right)+2T_{d}\\tag{19}$$\n\nFor $RC_{L}\\ll T_{d}$, $T\\approx 2RC_{L}\\log 2+2T_{d}\n\\approx 2\\sum t_{di}$ the normal $2N\\,t_{d}$ ring.\nFor $RC_{L}\\gg T_{d}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\Delta V &=V_{H}-V_{TH}=V_{TH}-V_{L}={V_{DD}\\over 2}\n\\left(1-{\\rm e}^{-T_{d}/RC_{L}}\\right)\\approx {V_{DD}\\over 2}\n{T_{d}\\over {RC_{L}}}\\rightarrow 0\\cr\nt_{r}&\\approx T_{d}\\cr\nT&\\approx 4T_{d}=4\\left(t_{d2}+t_{d3}\\right)\\approx 8t_{d0}\\cr}\\tag{20}$$\n\nI. e. with ideal comparators a limit cycle exists for\nevery finite $C_{L}$.  Its saw tooth at $B$ collapses as\n$1/C_{L}$ and its frequency asymptotes to a constant\ndetermined by the two fast inverters, ${\\cal O}(1/T_{d})$,\nnormally a little larger than the $6t_{d0}$ unloaded\n$3$ stage frequency.  In describing function language the\nlarge signal gain $N(A)\\approx 4V_{DD}/\\pi A$ can be\nmade arbitrarily large for small $A$, so (8) can always\nbe made $>1$ if you allow $A\\rightarrow 0$.\n\nIn a real CMOS inverter the comparator gain is finite,\n$\\approx A_{v}$, and (20) ceases to be valid once\n$\\Delta V$ becomes comparable with the linear transition\nwidth $\\approx V_{DD}/A_{v}$.  Then $C$ and $A$ no longer\nswitch rail to rail and (8) takes over.  In SPICE you\nwill continue to see the $4T_{d}$ relaxation oscillation\nwith $\\Delta V\\propto 1/C_{L}$ for a long while, but its\nstart up from noise becomes exponentially slow for\n$C_{L}>C_{L{\\rm crit}}$ and for all practical purposes\nthe circuit looks latched at (16).  With an ideal\n$C_{L}=\\infty $ ac short it is latched in any picture.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  Many textbooks quote the first, ideal,\n> result as ``the odd ring never stops, it just gets\n> slower and its loaded node swing vanishes''.\n> Strictly Barkhausen wise the second result is the\n> correct small signal one.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "653cd82222fe11c22fdb737f3338f7c6f959bc91c29b409436c6c05b108d41cb"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the extra pole from the one-node load, shows that loop gain falls below unity at the phase crossover for sufficiently large CL, and concludes that the finite-gain circuit settles near its DC operating point. The ideal-comparator caveat is explicitly distinguished from the real finite-gain behavior and does not overturn the essential conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f6dd3ed123c88a59472f7a76de74df7e33b3e73498632bd24bc1ea808e4efcbc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2275,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 12198,
        "total_tokens": 14474,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9879,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2275,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 12198,
        "total_tokens": 14474,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9879,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 3,
      "question": "Does the circuit in the figure fail to oscillate if CL becomes arbitrarily large?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-003-fail-oscillate-cl-becomes-arbitrarily-large/figure-06.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With ideal switches it does not. With\nlinearised $g_{m}$'s it does.  In the text\nbooks the first is called oscillation.\n\nPut $Z_{o}=R_{o}\\parallel 1/sC_{0}$ for an\nunloaded inverter and\n\n$$Z_{o1}=R_{o}\\parallel 1/s\\left(C_{0}+C_{L}\\right)$$\n\nfor the loaded one and linearise the $3-T$\nabout $V_{DD}/2$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nA_{v}&=g_{m}R_{o}\\cr\n\\omega _{0}&=1/R_{o}C_{0}\\cr\n\\omega _{1}&=1/R_{o}\\left(C_{0}+C_{L}\\right)=1/b\\cr}$$\n\nBreak the loop at $C$.\n\n$$L(s)=-A_{v}^{3}{(1+s/a)^{-2}(1+s/b)^{-1}}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$a=R_{o}C_{0}\\qquad b=R_{o}(C_{0}+C_{L})$$\n\nThe closed loop equation $1-L(s)=0$ is\n\n$$(1+sb)(1+sa)^{2}+A_{v}^{3}=0\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$s^{3}a^{2}b+s^{2}(a^{2}+2ab)+s(2a+b)+1+A_{v}^{3}=0\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$A_{3}s^{3}+A_{2}s^{2}+A_{1}s+A_{0}=0\\qquad A_{i}>0$$\n\nBy Routh the c. c. is LHP iff\n\n$$A_{2}A_{1}>A_{3}A_{0}\\tag{4}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$\\left(a^{2}+2ab\\right)\\left(2a+b\\right)>a^{2}b\\left(1+A_{v}^{3}\\right)\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$2a^{2}+5ab+2b^{2}>ab\\left(1+A_{v}^{3}\\right) \\tag{6}$$\n\n$$2{b\\over a}+5+2{a\\over b}<1+A_{v}^{3} \\tag{7}$$\n\nfor instability, i. e. for a pair of\npoles in the RHP.  For $b=a$, ${C_{L}=0}$,\n\n$$A_{v}^{3}>8\\qquad A_{v}>2\\tag{8}$$\n\nin the normal way.  Eq.7 is the ordinary\nBarkhausen condition in disguise.  Put\n$s=j\\omega $ in (1)\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n|L(j\\omega )|&=A_{v}^{3}\\left[1+(\\omega b)^{2}\\right]^{-1/2}\n\\left[1+(\\omega a)^{2}\\right]^{-1}\\cr\n{\\rm arg}L&=\\pi -\\tan ^{-1}\\omega b-2\\tan ^{-1}\\omega a\\cr}\\tag{9}$$\n\nOscillation in the Barkhausen sense needs\n${\\rm arg}L=2k\\pi $,\n\n$$\\tan ^{-1}\\omega_{0}b+2\\tan ^{-1}\\omega_{0}a=\\pi \\tag{10}$$\n\n$0<{\\rm arg}<{3\\pi /2}$, so (10) has a\nsolution for every $b$, nominally\n\n$$\\omega_{0}\\approx {1\\over a}\\tag{11}$$\n\nfor $b\\gg a$, because $\\tan ^{-1}\\omega_{0}b\n\\to \\pi /2$ and $2\\tan ^{-1}\\omega_{0}a\\to\n\\pi /2$.  At that $\\omega_{0}$\n\n$$|L(j\\omega_{0})|\\approx {A_{v}^{3}\\over\n\\sqrt{1+(b/a)^{2}}\\;2}\\approx A_{v}^{3}{a\\over 2b}\n\\tag{12}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$|L(j\\omega_{0})|>1\\iff A_{v}^{3}>2{b\\over a}\n\\tag{13}$$\n\nwhich is (7) for $b\\gg a$.  In other words the\ndominant pole compensation kills the loop gain\nat the $0\\,{\\rm deg}$ crossover.  There is an\n\n$$b_{c}\\approx {1\\over 2}A_{v}^{3}a\\tag{14}$$\n\n$$C_{Lc}\\approx \\left({1\\over 2}A_{v}^{3}-1\\right)C_{0}\\tag{15}$$\n\n${\\cal O}(10^{2}-10^{3})C_{0}$ for a normal\n$A_{v}\\sim 10-20$, beyond which the small\nsignal pole pair is in the ${\\rm Re}\\,s<0$\nhalf plane.  The meta stable $V_{A}=V_{B}=\nV_{C}=V_{T}$ point becomes small signal stable.\nFor $b\\to \\infty $,\n\n$$L(s)\\to -{A_{v}^{3}\\over sb(1+sa)^{2}}\\tag{16}$$\n\na two pole amplifier dominant pole compensated,\nwhich is stable; $C_{L}\\to\\infty $ shorts the\nloop for $a.\\,c.$  The normal $360^{0}$ linear\nsinusoidal ring mode is extinguished and the\ncircuit will not start up from thermal noise.\n\nThat is the {\\it linear\\/} story.\n\nPut the inverters back as large signal relays,\n$I_{o}=I$ when on, $V_{T}=V_{DD}/2$,\n$T_{d}=t_{p2}+t_{p3}$ the delay of the two\nunloaded inverters.  With\n\n$$C_{L}{{dV_{A}}\\over {dt}}=I_{1}(V_{C})\\tag{17}$$\n\n$$V_{C}(t)= {\\rm sgn}\\left[V_{A}(t-T_{d})-V_{T}\\right]\\tag{18}$$\n\nin the ideal relay approximation the circuit is\na first order plus delay relay.  Let $V_{A}$\ncross $V_{T}$ upward at $t=0$.  $V_{C}=1$ for\n$T_{d}$ more, so\n\n$$V_{A}=V_{T}+I\\,T_{d}/C_{L}\\equiv V_{T}+\\Delta\n\\tag{19}$$\n\nat $t=T_{d}$ when $V_{C}$ flips to $0$ and\n$V_{A}$ ramps down with $dV_{A}/dt=-I/C_{L}$,\nrecrosses $V_{T}$ at $t=2T_{d}$, continues to\n$V_{T}-\\Delta $ at $t=3T_{d}$ etc.  The system\nhas a limit cycle\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\Delta &= I\\,T_{d}/C_{L}\\cr\nT_{0}&\\approx 4T_{d}\\cr}\\tag{20}$$\n\nfor {\\it any\\/} finite $C_{L}$.  For $C_{L}$\nsmall $\\Delta \\gg V_{DD}$ the relay saturates\nand you get the ordinary rail to rail\n$T_{0}\\approx 2N\\,t_{p}+k\\,R_{o}C_{L}$ ring\noscillator.  For $C_{L}$ large\n\n$$\\Delta \\propto 1/C_{L}\\to 0\\tag{21}$$\n\nso the large signal swing collapses to an\ninfinitesimal triangle about $V_{T}$ of period\n$\\approx 4T_{d}$ and (20) ceases to be valid\nas soon as $\\Delta $ becomes of the order of the\nlinear transition width of the inverter,\n${\\cal O}(V_{DD}/A_{v})$.  Inside the transition\nwidth the relay model has to be replaced by the\nlinear model (1) which, as we have seen, is\ndamped.  The infinitesimal limit cycle is then\ndamped to the stable $V_{T}$ DC point.\n\nIn text book digital language that is normally\nphrased as {\\it the circuit continues to oscillate\nfor any $C_{L}$, only more and more slowly\\/}.\nIf oscillation is meant as a robust, self starting\nrail to rail clock that grows out of noise, the\nstatement is: beyond (15) the conventional ring\nmode disappears, the amplitude $\\Delta \\to 0$,\nand for all engineering purposes the ring has\nstalled at $V_{A}\\approx V_{B}\\approx V_{C}\n\\approx V_{DD}/2$.\n\nWith $C_{L}\\to\\infty $ {\\it qua\\/} $a.\\,c.$\nshort the familiar $RC$ astable consisting of\none inverter loaded by $C_{L}$ buffered by the\nother two is recovered as the $a.\\,c.$\ndegenerate form of (20).  It is normally drawn\nas the one inverter $RC$ relaxation oscillator\nand, with ideal comparators, it does oscillate\nfor any $R\\,C$.  With normal CMOS inverters the\noscillation is vanishingly small once (15) is\nexceeded.\n\n> {\\it Remark:\\/}  In most introductory treatments\n> the ${\\cal O}(1/C_{L})$ collapse of the swing\n> is neglected and the circuit is said {\\it not\\/}\n> to fail to oscillate: $f_{0}\\approx\n> \\left[2Nt_{p}+0.7R_{o}C_{L}\\right]^{-1}\\to 0$ but\n> $\\ne 0$.  The linear, Barkhausen, start up\n> failure described above is the correct analog\n> description.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "991434dc3e7c47acce4d61268210756ed4b5c221fbae14ac165756b1c55ebe6d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the dominant pole from the one-node load, the resulting loop-gain loss and small-signal stabilization beyond a load threshold, and concludes that a real CMOS ring can fail to start or sustain oscillation for arbitrarily large CL. The ideal-relay limit-cycle discussion is explicitly qualified and does not undermine that conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f6dd3ed123c88a59472f7a76de74df7e33b3e73498632bd24bc1ea808e4efcbc",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 13311,
        "total_tokens": 15587,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11020,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2276,
        "output_tokens": 13311,
        "total_tokens": 15587,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11020,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "If we double the widths of the NMOS and PMOS devices in the figure, what happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual ${\\rm ideal~self~loaded}$ language\nthe circuit is the textbook Hajimiri Lee inverter ring.\n\nPut $W_{p}/W_{n}$ so that the rise and the fall are\nsymmetric and change it with $W_{p}/W_{n}={\\rm const}$\n\n$${C_{L}\\approx C_{g}+C_{d}\\propto W\\qquad \nR_{o}\\approx 1/g_{m}\\propto 1/W\\qquad \nI_{av}\\propto W}$$\n\nso that to first order\n\n$$t_{d}\\approx 0.69R_{o}C_{L}\\approx \n{{C_{L}V_{DD}}\\over {I_{av}}}={\\rm const.}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{0}\\approx {1\\over {2Nt_{d}}}={\\rm const.}\\tag{*}$$\n\nfor the $W$ dependent, intrinsic, load.\nWith a fixed wiring load $C_{\\rm ext}$\n\n$$C_{L}=C_{\\rm ext}+Wc_{0}\\qquad \n\\omega _{0}\\propto {W\\over {C_{\\rm ext}+Wc_{0}}}\\tag{**}$$\n\nand ($*$) is the $C_{\\rm ext}\\ll Wc_{0}$ limit.\nThe normal, saturated, short channel, current\nis still $\\propto W$ so that\n\n$$P_{DC}=NC_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f_{0}\\propto Wf_{0}\\tag{***}$$\n\ni. e. in the self loaded limit $f_{0}={\\rm const.}$\nand you burn twice the power.\n\nFor the Hajimiri-Lee ISF\n\n$${\\cal L}\\{\\Delta \\omega \\}=10\\log \\left[\n{1\\over {8\\pi ^{2}\\Delta f^{2}}}\\,\n{{{\\overline{i_{n}^{2}}}\\over {\\Delta f}}\\,\n{\\Gamma _{rms}^{2}\\over {q_{max}^{2}}}}\\right] \\tag{1}$$\n\n$$q_{max}=C_{L}V_{DD}\\propto W\\tag{2}$$\n\n$${{{\\overline{i_{n}^{2}}}\\over {\\Delta f}}=\n4kT\\gamma g_{d0}+K_{f}{{g_{m}^{2}}\\over {WLC_{ox}} }{1\\over f}\n\\propto W\\tag{3}}$$\n\nin white and in the normal $S_{v}=K_{f}/WLC_{ox}f$,\n$S_{i}=g_{m}^{2}S_{v}$, flicker model.\n$g_{d0}\\propto g_{m}\\propto W$ in the square law\nor in the velocity saturated limit.\n$\\Gamma _{rms}$ and $c_{0}$, the rms and the\nd.c. value of the impulse sensitivity function, depend\nonly on the normalized wave form and stay {\\it pro\nforma} constant if the symmetry $W_{p}/W_{n}$ is kept,\ni. e. if the wave form stays symmetric the ${\\rm 1/f}$\nup conversion $c_{0}\\approx 0$ stays suppressed.\n\nHence from (1)-(3)\n\n$${\\cal L}\\propto {{{\\overline{i_{n}^{2}}}}\\over\n{q_{max}^{2}}}\\propto {W\\over {W^{2}}}={1\\over W}\\tag{4}$$\n\nin power.  In the familiar Leeson form, for the\n$N$ stage ring, Razavi,\n\n$${\\cal L}\\{\\Delta \\omega \\}\\approx\n{8\\over {3\\eta }}{{kT}\\over {P_{DC}}}{{V_{DD}}\\over\n{V_{{\\rm char}}}}\\left({{\\omega _{0}}\\over {\\Delta\n\\omega }}\\right)^{2}\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$P_{DC}= {\\rm (***)} $$\n\nthe same $1/P_{DC}\\propto 1/W$ law.\n\nI. e. in ($*$) $f_{0}$ does not move, $P_{DC}$ doubles\nand the white, ${1\\over {f^{2}}}$, side band power is\nhalved,\n\n$${\\cal L}_{w}\\rightarrow {1\\over 2}{\\cal L}_{w}\\;\\;\n-3\\,{\\rm dB~in~}{\\cal L},-6\\,{\\rm dB~in~}{\\cal L}^{1/2}\n\\tag{6}$$\n\n$$\\sigma _{J}^{2}= {{\\kappa ^{2}}t}\\qquad \n\\kappa ^{2}\\propto {{kT}\\over {C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}}}\\propto\n{1\\over W}\\tag{7}$$\n\n$$\\kappa \\propto {1\\over {\\sqrt{W}}}\\qquad \n\\sigma _{T}= \\kappa \\sqrt{T_{0}}\\propto {1\\over {\\sqrt{W}}}$$\n\nfor the period jitter.  Colloquially you have put two\nidentical rings in parallel.\n\nFor the ${\\rm 1/f}$ induced ${1\\over {f^{3}}}$ skirt\n(1) is normally written with the $c_{0}$ term,\n\n$${\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}\\propto c_{0}^{2}\n{{{\\overline{i_{n,1/f}^{2}}}}\\over {q_{max}^{2}}}\n{1\\over {\\Delta f^{3}}}\\propto {1\\over W}\\tag{8}$$\n\nin the $S_{i}\\propto W$ model, i. e. another $3\\,{\\rm\ndB}$ per octave of $W$.  Writing the flicker explicitly\nas $K_{f}/WL$,\n\n$${\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}\\propto {{K_{f}}\\over {WLC_{ox}}}\n{{g_{m}^{2}}\\over {q_{max}^{2}}}\\propto\n{1\\over {W}}\\,{{W^{2}}\\over {W^{2}}}={1\\over W}\\tag{9}$$\n\nand, if you count the $WL$ in the denominator as an\nindependent area factor, often quoted as\n\n$${\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}\\propto {1\\over {W^{2}L}}\\approx\n{6\\,{\\rm dB~per~octave~of}~W}\\tag{10}$$\n\nand with $q_{max}^{2}\\propto W^{2}$ as ${1\\over {W^{3}}}$,\n$9\\,{\\rm dB}$ per octave, in the current\n$S_{i}=K_{f}I_{D}^{2}/WLC_{ox}f$ notation.  Any of (8)-(10)\nis quoted as {\\it the close in noise goes down\n$6-9\\,{\\rm dB}$ per doubling of area.}\n\nIn Leeson FoM language\n\n$${\\rm FoM}={\\cal L}\\{\\Delta f\\}\n-20\\log \\left({{f_{0}}\\over {\\Delta f}}\\right)\n+10\\log \\left({{P_{DC}}\\over {1\\,{\\rm mW}}}\\right)\n\\approx {\\rm const.}\\tag{11}$$\n\nso that the ${\\rm FoM}$ is to first order $W$\nindependent.  You buy the $3\\,{\\rm dB}$, $6\\,{\\rm dB}$\nclose in, at the price of twice the dissipation and,\nin the ideal ($*$) limit, at the same $f_{0}$.\nNormalised to $f_{0}$, i. e. at the same fractional\noffset $\\Delta f/f_{0}$ or the same jitter FoM,\nthere is no net improvement.\n\nWith ($**$) the absolute side band at a fixed absolute\n$\\Delta f$ is\n\n$${\\cal L}\\{\\Delta f\\}\\propto \n20\\log f_{0}-10\\log P_{DC}\\tag{12}$$\n\nso that with an extrinsic, $W$ independent, load the\n$f_{0}$ increase $\\propto 20\\log f_{0}$ eventually\nwins and the absolute ${\\cal L}\\{\\Delta f\\}$ gets\n{\\it worse} by $\\approx +3\\,{\\rm dB}$ per octave of $W$\nwhile ${\\cal L}\\{\\Delta f/f_{0}\\}$ and the jitter FoM\nremain $\\approx $ flat.  In deep sub $\\mu$ the $g_{m}\n\\propto W^{\\alpha }$, $\\alpha <1$, wiring $C$ and\ngate leakage make the $3\\,{\\rm dB}$ an upper bound.\nLoosely phrased as {\\it doubling the device has, to\nfirst order, no effect on the oscillator FoM.}\n\n> {\\it Remark:} For a current starved, fixed $I_{SS}$,\n> ring $P_{DC}={\\rm const.}$, $f_{0}\\propto 1/C_{L}\\propto\n> 1/W$ in ($*$) and (5) gives ${\\cal L}\\{\\Delta f\\}\n> \\propto f_{0}^{2}\\propto 1/W^{2}$, $-6\\,{\\rm dB}$\n> at fixed $\\Delta f$, $-3\\,{\\rm dB}$ at fixed\n> $\\Delta f/f_{0}$, i. e. the same $1/W$ law for the\n> fractional side band.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "e9d48583fbdc4f2490890fcd484a885303eecb3ec30d830094fc207e7e2bf4fb"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly gives the approximately 3 dB phase-noise reduction for the self-loaded ring and supports it with the right scaling: signal charge grows with width while device noise power grows only linearly. The extra discussion is not needed to answer the question and does not change that central result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f9299196b0b81aa8f665614cd6e16eba9d8392f73cfe6422876d92d225ddc94e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3484,
        "output_tokens": 9268,
        "total_tokens": 12752,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7081,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3484,
        "output_tokens": 9268,
        "total_tokens": 12752,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7081,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "If we double the widths of the NMOS and PMOS devices in the figure, what happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the (text book) ${\\cal C}_{L}\\propto W$\nnormalisation the ring is a constant ${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}$\noscillator.  In Leeson's form\n\n$$ {\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )\\propto \n{\\overline {i_{n}^{2}}\\over q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}}\n{1\\over {\\Delta \\omega }^{2}}\\propto \n{FkT\\over P_{{\\rm diss}}}{\\omega _{0}^{2}\\over {\\Delta \\omega }^{2}}\\tag\n{*}$$\n\n$P_{{\\rm diss}}$ is the D.C. plus the dynamic power\n\n$$P_{{\\rm diss}}\\approx NP_{av}\\approx Nf_{0}{\\cal C}_{L}V_{DD}^{2}\n+N I_{av}V_{DD}\\propto {\\cal C}_{L}\\propto W \\tag{1}$$\n\n$$f_{0}\\approx {1\\over {2Nt_{d}}}\\qquad \nt_{d}\\approx {{\\cal C}_{L}V_{DD}\\over I_{av}}\\approx \n{{\\cal C}_{L}\\over g_{m}}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$${\\cal C}_{L}=N_{S}W{\\cal C}_{{\\rm ox}}+{\\cal C}_{w}\\propto W\\qquad \nI_{av}\\propto W\\qquad g_{m}\\propto W\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$\\overline {i_{n}^{2}}=4kT\\gamma g_{m}\\propto W\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$q_{{\\rm max}}={\\cal C}_{L}V_{DD}\\propto W\\tag{5}$$\n\nfor the white noise and, for the conventional\n${\\overline {v_{n,1/f}^{2}}}=K_{F}/WLC_{{\\rm ox}}f$,\n\n$$\\overline {i_{n,1/f}^{2}}=g_{m}^{2}{\\overline {v_{n,1/f}^{2}}}\n\\propto W^{\\alpha }\\tag{6}$$\n\nSo that in the normal time domain language the\nr.m.s. threshold jitter in one transition\n\n$${\\sigma _{t}^{2}}={{\\overline {v_{n}^{2}}}\\over S^{2}}\n={{kT/{\\cal C}_{L}}\\over {\\left(I_{av}/{\\cal C}_{L}\\right)^{2}}}\n={{kT{\\cal C}_{L}}\\over {I_{av}^{2}}}\\propto {1\\over W}\\tag{7}$$\n\n$S=I_{av}/{\\cal C}_{L}$ is the slew rate at the\nthreshold, and for the $N$ stage ring\n\n$${\\sigma _{T}^{2}}\\approx N{\\sigma _{t}^{2}}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$${\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )\\approx\n{{\\omega _{0}^{2}{\\sigma _{T}^{2}}}\\over {2T_{0}{\\Delta \\omega }^{2}}}\n\\approx {{\\Gamma _{{\\rm rms}}^{2}}\\over {8\\pi ^{2}{\\Delta \\omega }^{2}}}\n{{\\overline {i_{n}^{2}}}\\over {q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}}}\\propto \n{{\\overline {i_{n}^{2}}}\\over {q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}}}\\tag{9}$$\n\ncf. Hajimiri-Lee, {\\it JSSC} {\\bf 33}, 179 (1998)\n\n$${\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )={8\\over 3\\eta }N{{kT}\\over P}\n{{V_{DD}}\\over {V_{{\\rm char}}}}{{\\omega _{0}^{2}}\\over {\\Delta \\omega\n^{2}}}\\tag{10}$$\n\n$$V_{{\\rm char}}=E_{c}L/\\gamma \\tag{11}$$\n\nfor the $1/f^{2}$ region and with (6) for the\n$1/f^{3}$ region.  I. e. to first order on a $W/L=$\nconst, $V_{DD}=$ const. basis\n\n$$f_{0}\\propto {g_{m}\\over {\\cal C}_{L}}={\\rm const.}\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$ {\\cal L}_{{\\rm white}}\\propto {1\\over P}\\propto {1\\over W}\n\\qquad {\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}\\propto {1\\over {W^{1\\to 2}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nThe often quoted form is ($*$): the oscillator\nfigure of merit\n\n$${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}= {\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )\n+10\\log {{P_{{\\rm diss}}}\\over {1{\\rm mW}}}\n-20\\log {{\\omega _{0}}\\over {\\Delta \\omega }} ={\\rm const.}\\tag{14}$$\n\nis (to first order) independent of $W$.  If you are\nwilling to burn the $\\times 2$ power the absolute\n(single side band) phase noise power ${\\cal L}$,\n${\\rm dBcHz^{-1}}$, goes down by\n\n$${{{\\cal L}(2W)}\\over {{\\cal L}(W)}}\\approx {1\\over 2}\\;\\;\n{\\rm in\\;power}\\approx {1\\over {\\sqrt{2}}}\\;\\;{\\rm in\\;\nvoltage\\;or\\;jitter}\\tag{15}$$\n\n$10\\log 2\\approx 3\\,{\\rm dB}$ in power,\n$20\\log \\sqrt{2}\\approx 3\\,{\\rm dB}$ in amplitude, for\nthe normal $1/f^{2}$ thermal region, $\\approx 3-6\\,{\\rm dB}$\nfor the $1/f^{3}$ region according as $A_{F}\\approx\n2\\to 1$ in ${\\overline {i_{n,1/f}^{2}}}\\propto\nI_{D}^{A_{F}}/WL$, at the expense of a $\\times 2$ in\n$I_{DD}$ and in $P_{{\\rm diss}}$.  Normally quoted,\nloosely, as {\\it no (first order) change in (normalised)\nphase noise} or {\\it no change in ${\\cal F}{\\cal O}{\\cal M}$}.\n\nIn particular for the textbook $3\\times C_{g}$\nloaded loop (12) $f_{0}$ stays put and you get the full\n$3\\,{\\rm dB}$ ($1/f^{2}$) $3-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ ($1/f^{3}$)\nimprovement for $P\\to 2P$.\n\nIf the comparison is made at {\\it fixed external}\n(white) load, ${\\cal C}_{L}\\approx {\\cal C}_{w}={\\rm\nconst.}$,\n\n$$f_{0}\\propto g_{m}\\propto W\\tag{16}$$\n\nso that with (10)\n\n$${\\cal L}\\propto {{f_{0}^{2}}\\over P}\\propto W\\tag{17}$$\n\nthe $20\\log f_{0}$ increase eats the $10\\log P$\ndecrease and\n\n$${\\cal L}(2W)\\approx {\\cal L}(W)\\;\\;{\\rm to\\;}{\\cal O}(1)\n\\tag{18}$$\n\nformally ${\\cal L}(2W)\\approx 2{\\cal L}(W)$, $+3\\,{\\rm dB}$,\nin the ${\\cal C}_{w}$ dominated limit, i. e. to within\n$\\pm 3\\,{\\rm dB}$ the un--normalised ${\\cal L}$ is flat\nwith $W$.  With the usual renormalisation to constant\n$f_{0}$, e. g. by adding ${\\cal C}_{{\\rm ext}}\\propto\nW$ to keep (12) satisfied, (15) is recovered.  This is\nnormally abbreviated to {\\it doubling $W$ does\n(essentially) nothing to the phase noise.}  The $3\\,{\\rm dB}$\nin (15) is the textbook {\\it nothing.}\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  With ${\\cal L}$ in ${\\rm dBcHz^{-1}}$\n> (noise power) the improvement is $10\\log 2=3\\,{\\rm dB}$;\n> often quoted as $6\\,{\\rm dB}$ in voltage (field)\n> units.  Any $F\\propto \\gamma $ increase with short\n> channel excess noise will erode $1-2\\,{\\rm dB}$ from the\n> numbers above.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "cdb26fb369f14a225382bdd9c2773a4e249237942a448142eb8fc1b07f577f8c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "For the figure’s device-dominated capacitance, the answer correctly gives about a 3 dB phase-noise reduction: width scaling keeps the frequency roughly constant while signal charge grows faster than white-noise power. Its fixed-external-load discussion is a separate condition and does not change the answer for this figure.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f9299196b0b81aa8f665614cd6e16eba9d8392f73cfe6422876d92d225ddc94e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 3427,
        "input_tokens": 3484,
        "output_tokens": 8204,
        "total_tokens": 11688,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6204,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 3427,
        "input_tokens": 3484,
        "output_tokens": 8204,
        "total_tokens": 11688,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6204,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 4,
      "question": "If we double the widths of the NMOS and PMOS devices in the figure, what happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-004-double-widths-nmos-and-pmos-devices-phase/figure-07.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the normal {\\it rail to rail, ${\\cal\nE}\\ne {\\cal E}_{sat}$} idealisation the ring\nis a\n\n$${\\cal L}\\propto {{S_{i,n}}\\over {q_{max}^{2}}}\n\\propto {{S_{v,n}}\\over {S^{2}}}$$\n\noscillator.  In the familiar notation e. {\\it g.}\nHajimiri-Lee\n\n$${\\cal L}\\left(\\Delta \\omega \\right)=\n{1\\over {8\\pi ^{2}}}{{{\\bar I_{n}^{2}}\\over {\\Delta f}}\n\\Gamma_{rms}^{2}\\over {q_{max}^{2}\\Delta \\omega ^{2}}}\\tag{*}$$\n\nfor the $1/f^{2}$ region and\n\n$${\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}\\propto {{c_{0}^{2}}\\over {8\\pi ^{2}}}\n{{{\\bar I_{n,1/f}^{2}}\\over {\\Delta f}}\\over\n{q_{max}^{2}\\Delta \\omega ^{3}}}$$\n\nfor the $1/f^{3}$ region.  For the\nconventional inverter\n\n$$q_{max}=CV_{DD}\\qquad C=C_{G}+C_{D}\\propto W_{n}+W_{p}$$\n$$S_{i,n}^{2}/\\Delta f =4kT\\gamma g_{m}\\qquad \ng_{m}\\propto W\\tag{{\\rm sat.}}$$\n$$S_{v,1/f}^{2}/\\Delta f ={{K}\\over {WLC_{ox}}}{{1}\\over {f}}\n\\qquad S_{i,1/f}^{2}=g_{m}^{2}S_{v,1/f}^{2}$$\n\nand\n\n$$f_{0}={1\\over {2NT_{d}}}\\qquad \nT_{d}\\approx {{CV_{DD}}\\over {I_{D}}}\\propto {W\\over W}\\approx\n{\\rm const.}$$\n\nThe form factor $\\Gamma _{rms}$ , $c_{0}$, depends only\non the wave shape and to first order does not scale.\nHence to first order $f_{0}$ and $\\Gamma _{rms}$ do not\nscale.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nS_{v,n}^{2}&=kT/C\\cr\n\\sigma _{t}^{2}&=S_{v,n}^{2}/S^{2}\\propto {{kT/C}\\over {(I/C)^{2}}}\n={{kTC}\\over {I^{2}}}}$$\n\nso that apart from the change of $q_{max}$\n\n$${\\cal L}_{1/f^{2}}\\propto {{S_{i,n}^{2}}\\over {q_{max}^{2}}}\n\\propto {{W}\\over {W^{2}}}\\propto {1\\over W}\\tag{1}$$\n$${\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}\\propto {{S_{i,1/f}^{2}}\\over {q_{max}^{2}}}\n\\propto {{g_{m}^{2}K/WL}\\over {W^{2}}}\\propto {{W^{2}/W}\\over {W^{2}}}\n\\propto {1\\over W}\\tag{2}$$\n\non a power spectral density basis.  Putting $S_{i,n}^{2}\n\\propto g_{m}\\propto \\sqrt{W}$ in the long channel square\nlaw language $g_{m}\\propto \\sqrt{WI_{D}}$, (1) becomes\n${\\cal L}\\propto W^{-3/2}$.  The often quoted\nHajimiri form\n\n$${\\cal L}\\left(\\Delta \\omega \\right)\\approx\n{8\\over {3\\eta }}N{{kT}\\over P}{{V_{DD}}\\over {V_{char}}}^{2}\n\\left({{\\omega_{0}}\\over {\\Delta \\omega}}\\right)^{2}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$P=NCI_{D}V_{DD}/C\\propto W$ is the dc power,\nmakes the power trade explicit: $P{\\cal L}\\propto N$ is\n$W$ independent.\n\nIn round numbers for the usual $I_{D}\\propto W$,\n$g_{m}\\propto W$, velocity saturated, argument, {\\it at\nconstant $V_{DD}$, i. e. at twice the dc power},\n\n* {\\it White FM, $1/f^{2}$, region:}  from (*) $q_{max}\n\\to 2q_{max}$, $S_{i,n}^{2}\\to 2S_{i,n}^{2}$ so that\n\n$${\\cal L}_{1/f^{2}}\\to {1\\over 2}{\\cal L}_{1/f^{2}}$$\n\n$-10\\log 2\\approx -3\\,{\\rm dB}$ single side band,\n$-20\\log 2\\approx -6\\,{\\rm dB}$ in $S_{\\varphi}=2{\\cal L}$\nor in rms period jitter.  In power variance\n\n$$\\sigma_{T}^{2}\\propto {{kTC}\\over {I^{2}}}\\to {1\\over 2}\n\\sigma_{T}^{2}\\qquad \\sigma _{T}\\to \\sigma_{T}/\\sqrt{2}$$\n\ni. e. $6\\,{\\rm dB}$ in $S_{\\varphi }$.\n\nIf you count ${\\cal L}\\propto 1/q_{max}^{2}\\propto 1/C^{2}$\nand keep $S_{i,n}^{2}$ fixed the text book $6\\,{\\rm dB}$\nSSB, $12\\,{\\rm dB}$ DSB, number is often quoted.\nNormalised to dc power ${\\cal F}={\\cal L}+10\\log P_{\\rm\nmW}-20\\log \\left(f_{0}/\\Delta f\\right)$ is invariant.\nThat is the usual loose statement {\\it the {\\rm FoM}\nphase noise does not change}.\n\nWith the $C_{w},C_{int}$ fringe and interconnect\ncapacitance that does not scale and with the slight drop\nin $f_{0}$ because $C_{w}$ is now a smaller fraction of\n$C_{tot}$ the net absolute improvement is\n\n$${\\cal L}_{new}\\approx {\\cal L}_{old}-2{\\rm \\;to\\;}3\\,{\\rm dB}\n\\;\\;{\\rm SSB}\\approx {\\cal L}_{old}-4{\\rm \\;to\\;}6\\,{\\rm dB}\n\\;\\;{\\rm DSB}\\;\\;{\\rm at}\\;\\;2\\times P_{DC}$$\n\nand ${\\cal F}\\approx {\\rm const.}$ to within a dB.\nNeglecting $C_{w}$ and the $f_{0}^{2}$ factor this is\nnormally abbreviated to {\\it no {\\rm FoM} improvement}.\nFor constant $P_{DC}$, i. e. constant\n$WI_{D}$, $g_{m}\\propto \\sqrt{W}$ and ${\\cal L}{\\cal F}$\nis $\\propto \\sqrt{W}$ - it gets worse.\n\n* {\\it $1/f$ induced $1/f^{3}$ region:}  From (2)\n\n$${\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}\\to {1\\over 2}{\\cal L}_{1/f^{3}}$$\n\n$-3\\,{\\rm dB}$ SSB, $-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ DSB, per octave of\n$W$, i. e. $S_{\\varphi ,1/f^{3}}\\propto K/WLC^{2}$, at\nconstant $K$.  With $K\\propto 1/WL$ sometimes absorbed in\nthe $K$ the $1/f^{3}$ ${\\cal L}$ is quoted as $\\propto\n1/(WL)^{2}\\propto 1/W^{2}$ or $-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ SSB,\n$-12\\,{\\rm dB}$  DSB, per $W$ octave.  The $1/f^{3}$\ncorner $\\omega _{1/f^{3}}\\propto c_{0}^{2}K/WL$ moves down\n$\\propto 1/W$.\n\nIn particular to first order the oscillation frequency,\nthe small signal loop gain $g_{m}R$, $R\\propto 1/g_{m}$,\nand the loaded $Q\\approx 1$ do not scale, so that\nLeeson's\n\n$${\\cal L}\\propto {{FkT}\\over {2P_{s}}}{{f_{0}}\\over\n{2Q\\Delta f}}^{2}$$\n\ngives ${\\cal L}\\propto 1/P_{s}\\propto 1/W$ at constant\n$V_{DD}$, ${\\cal L}P_{s}\\approx {\\rm const.}$\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  What is normally meant by {\\it the phase\n> noise does not improve} is ${\\cal L}P_{DC}\\approx {\\rm\n> const.}$  The absolute, un-normalised, SSB ${\\cal L}$\n> at the same $V_{DD}$ and the same $\\Delta f$ does go\n> down $\\propto 1/W$, $3\\,{\\rm dB}$ per $W$ octave,\n> $6\\,{\\rm dB}$ in $S_{\\varphi }$, at the expense of\n> $3\\,{\\rm dB}$ more $P_{DC}$.  Including the normally\n> non scaling $C_{int}$ the absolute improvement is\n> normally $<3\\,{\\rm dB}$ and is quite often neglected\n> altogether in hand waving discussions.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "48dda8e3c7b04ddc36fb6df1de1261d20bea6e6e765e89ddc2da84badd8594fd"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly concludes that doubling device widths gives about a 3 dB phase-noise reduction: the signal charge doubles while white-noise current power doubles, yielding a factor-of-two reduction in the noise-to-signal ratio. The extra DSB/jitter conversion comments are secondary and do not change the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f9299196b0b81aa8f665614cd6e16eba9d8392f73cfe6422876d92d225ddc94e",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3484,
        "output_tokens": 9351,
        "total_tokens": 12835,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7140,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3484,
        "output_tokens": 9351,
        "total_tokens": 12835,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7140,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Determine the small-signal resistance seen looking into the supply node of the ring oscillator in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the customary ${\\cal G}_{m}=g_{m}+g_{mb}$\nput a $V_{x}$ on the $V_{DD}$ rail, Fig. 1, and\nlet $V_{1},V_{2},V_{3}$ be the small signal\noutputs.\n\n$${\\rm Fig.\\;1:}\\;\\;V_{i+1}= -A_{v}V_{i}+A_{DD}V_{x}\\tag{1}$$\n\nFor the $k$-th ${\\rm CMOS}$ inverter\n\n$${\\eqalign{\ni_{dn}&=g_{mn}v_{g}+g_{dsn}v_{d}\\cr\ni_{dp}&=g_{mp}v_{sg}+g_{dsp}v_{sd}\\cr\nv_{sg}&=V_{x}-v_{g}\\quad v_{sd}=V_{x}-v_{d}\\cr}} \\tag{2}$$\n\nso that with\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ng&=g_{dsn}+g_{dsp}=r_{on}^{-1}+r_{op}^{-1}\\cr\ng_{m}&=g_{mn}+g_{mp}\\cr\n{\\cal G}_{p}&=g_{mp}+g_{dsp}\\approx g_{mp}\\cr\n{\\cal G}_{n}&=g_{mn}+g_{dsn}\\approx g_{mn}\\cr} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${\\cal G}_{p}V_{x}-g_{mp}V_{gk}-g_{dsp}V_{dk}\n      =g_{mn}V_{gk}+g_{dsn}V_{dk}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand, with $v_{dk}=V_{k}$ and $v_{gk}=V_{k-1}$,\n$V_{0}\\equiv V_{3}$,\n\n$$gV_{k}+g_{m}V_{k-1}={\\cal G}_{p}V_{x}\n      -sC_{k}V_{k}-sC_{2k}\\left(V_{k}-V_{x}\\right)\\tag{5}$$\n\n$C_{1k}$ is the $\\,V_{k}-0\\,$ capacitance,\n$C_{2k}$ the $V_{k}-V_{x}$ capacitance,\n$C_{k}=C_{1k}+C_{2k}$.\nFor $s=0$\n\n$$gV_{k}+g_{m}V_{k-1}={\\cal G}_{p}V_{x}\\qquad k=1\\ldots N\n\\tag{6}$$\n\nAdding the $N$ equations, $S=\\sum V_{k}$,\n\n$$\\left(g+g_{m}\\right)S=N{\\cal G}_{p}V_{x}\\tag{7}$$\n\nso that, for $s=0$, all the $V_{k}$ are equal,\n$V_{k}= {\\cal G}_{p}V_{x}/(g+g_{m})$.\nWith $C_{k}\\ne 0$\n\n$$S=N\\left({\\cal G}_{p}+sC_{2}\\right)V_{x}/\\left(g+g_{m}+sC\\right)\n\\tag{8}$$\n\nThe current that $V_{x}$ has to furnish is the sum\nof the $p$ source currents and, at $s\\ne 0$, of the\n$C_{2k}$ currents,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{x}&=\\sum_{k}\\left[g_{mp}\\left(V_{x}-V_{k-1}\\right)\n      +g_{dsp}\\left(V_{x}-V_{k}\\right)\n      +sC_{2}\\left(V_{x}-V_{k}\\right)\\right]\\cr\n     &=\\left({\\cal G}_{p}+sC_{2}\\right)\\left(NV_{x}-S\\right)} \\tag{9}$$\n\nso that, with (8),\n\n$$I_{x}=N\\left({\\cal G}_{p}+sC_{2}\\right)\n      \\left({\\cal G}_{n}+sC_{1}\\right)V_{x}/\n      \\left(g+g_{m}+sC\\right) \\tag{10}$$\n\nand\n\n$$Z_{x}(s)={V_{x}\\over I_{x}}\n      ={g+g_{m}+sC\\over N\\left({\\cal G}_{p}+sC_{2}\\right)\n                          \\left({\\cal G}_{n}+sC_{1}\\right)} \\tag{11}$$\n\n$${\\cal G}_{n}=g_{mn}+g_{dsn}\\qquad \n  {\\cal G}_{p}=g_{mp}+g_{dsp}\\qquad \n  g+g_{m}={\\cal G}_{n}+{\\cal G}_{p}\\tag{12}$$\n\nIn the conventional $r_{o}\\to \\infty ,\\;C\\to 0$\nlow frequency incremental form, $s\\to 0$,\n\n$$R_{X0}={{\\cal G}_{n}+{\\cal G}_{p}\\over N{\\cal G}_{n}{\\cal G}_{p}}\n      ={1\\over N}\\left({1\\over {\\cal G}_{n}}+{1\\over {\\cal G}_{p}}\\right)\n\\tag{13}$$\n\ni. e. the $N$ $p$-sources $\\approx 1/{\\cal G}_{p}$ in\nparallel in parallel with the $N$ $n$-sources\n$\\approx 1/{\\cal G}_{n}$ in parallel.\nWith $g_{mb}$ put in ${\\cal G}$,\n\n$$R_{X0}={1\\over N}\\left[\n{1\\over g_{mn}+g_{mbn}+g_{dsn}}+\n{1\\over g_{mp}+g_{mbp}+g_{dsp}}\\right] \\tag{14}$$\n\n$$R_{X0}={1\\over 3}\\left[{r_{on}\\over 1+(g_{mn}+g_{mbn})r_{on}}\n                +{r_{op}\\over 1+(g_{mp}+g_{mbp})r_{op}}\\right] \\tag{15}$$\n\nif the current is taken as leaving the $V_{DD}$\nnode the sign is reversed.\nNeglecting $r_{o}^{-1}$ against $g_{m}$,\n\n$$R_{X0}\\approx {1\\over N}\\left({1\\over g_{mn}}+{1\\over g_{mp}}\\right)\n      ={g_{mn}+g_{mp}\\over Ng_{mn}g_{mp}} \\tag{16}$$\n\nFor the usual symmetric design $g_{mn}\\approx g_{mp}=g_{m0}$\n\n$$R_{X0}\\approx {2\\over Ng_{m0}}\\approx {1\\over Ng_{m}} \\tag{17}$$\n\nwhere in the last form $g_{m}=g_{mn}+g_{mp}$ is\ncounted as {\\it the} inverter $g_{m}$.\n\nE. {\\rm g.} for $N=3$, $r_{o}\\to \\infty$,\n\n$$R_{X}(0)\\approx {g_{mP}+g_{mN}\\over 3g_{mP}g_{mN}}\n          \\approx {2\\over 3g_{m0}}\\approx {1\\over 3g_{m}} >0\\tag{18}$$\n\nas seen with the current {\\it entering} the\n$V_{DD}$ terminal.  With the passive sign\nconvention $I_{x}$ leaving the terminal\n\n$$R_{X}\\approx -{1\\over N}\\left({1\\over g_{mN}}+{1\\over g_{mP}}\\right)\n      \\approx -{2\\over 3g_{m0}}\\approx -{1\\over 3g_{m}}\\tag{19}$$\n\nis normally quoted.  E. {\\rm g.} $g_{m0}=2-5\\,{\\rm mA/V}$,\n$|R_{X}|\\approx 130-330\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$,\n$|R_{X}|\\approx 65-170\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$ with the\n$g_{m}=2g_{m0}$ definition.  In compact form\n\n$$|R_{X}|\\sim {1\\over g_{m1}+g_{m2}+g_{m3}}\\sim {1\\over 3g_{m}}$$\n\nand, in general,\n\n$$|Z_{x}(s)|\\approx {1\\over N}{1+sC/g_{m}\\over g_{m}+sC}$$\n\ncapacitive for $s=j\\omega$,\n\n$${\\rm Re}Z_{x}(j\\omega)=\n{ {\\cal G}_{n}{\\cal G}_{p}({\\cal G}_{n}+{\\cal G}_{p})\n  +\\omega^{2}\\left({\\cal G}_{p}C_{1}^{2}+{\\cal G}_{n}C_{2}^{2}\\right)\n \\over N|{\\cal G}_{p}+j\\omega C_{2}|^{2}\n        |{\\cal G}_{n}+j\\omega C_{1}|^{2}}({\\cal G}_{n}+{\\cal G}_{p})>0\\tag{20}$$\n\nfor the ideal ${\\rm LTI}$ bias at the meta stable\n$V_{DD}/2$ point.  The large signal periodic steady\nstate conversion resistance around $\\pm \\omega _{osc}$\nis the negative of (13)-(19) and will cancel the\nloss of a series $V_{DD}$ inductor, the familiar\ninductive peaking of the ring.  Any factor $2$ is\njust whether $g_{mN}$ or $g_{mN}+g_{mP}$ is called\n$g_{m}$.  Including ${\\cal G}_{n},{\\cal G}_{p}$ the\nusual textbook form is $R_{X}\\approx 1/3g_{mP}\\approx\n1/3g_{m}$.  With $g_{mb}$ included replace $g_{m}$\nby $g_{m}+g_{mb}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "55dccff66097a066510e9789d3a1e93340fad3c73d6d841ab4431f9cc3ff4733"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The answer derives a static, gm-based supply resistance, but misses the dominant oscillation-driven charging and discharging of the load capacitances. The expected resistance is approximately 1/(3 f0 CL), not the static gm-based result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "567a4e1905413cda5af92a626cb359563db923ba665d1835ff2377a534cd5d21",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3314,
        "output_tokens": 23977,
        "total_tokens": 27291,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 21620,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3314,
        "output_tokens": 23977,
        "total_tokens": 27291,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 21620,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Determine the small-signal resistance seen looking into the supply node of the ring oscillator in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual ``analogue'' schematic, Fig.1, put\n\n$${\\rm PM}:~i_{p}=g_{mp}v_{sg}+g_{op}v_{sd}\\qquad \n{\\rm NM}:~i_{n}=g_{mn}v_{gs}+g_{on}v_{ds}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$C_{L}$ the total capacitance on one inverter\noutput to earth, $N=3$.\nFor the $k$ th. inverter\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nv_{sgk}&=v_{x}-v_{ik}\\cr\nv_{sdk}&=v_{x}-v_{ok}\\cr\nv_{gsk}&=v_{ik}\\cr\nv_{dsk}&=v_{ok}} \\tag{2}$$\n\nand, at the $k$th. output\n\n$$i_{pk}=i_{nk}+sC_{L}v_{ok}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$${g_{mp}}(v_{x}-v_{ik})+{g_{op}}(v_{x}-v_{ok})\n =g_{mn}v_{ik}+g_{on}v_{ok}+sC_{L}v_{ok}\\tag{4}$$\n\nPut\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nG_{m}&=g_{mn}+g_{mp}\\cr\nG_{o}&=g_{on}+g_{op}\\cr\nG_{p}&=g_{mp}+g_{op}} \\tag{5}$$\n\nso that from (4)\n\n$$G_{p}v_{x}=G_{m}v_{ik}+(G_{o}+sC_{L})v_{ok}\n\\qquad k=1\\dots N\\tag{6}$$\n\ni. e., with $A_{v}=G_{m}/(G_{o}+sC_{L})$ the normal\ninverter gain and $A_{s}=G_{p}/(G_{o}+sC_{L})$ the\n{\\it supply} gain,\n\n$$v_{ok}=-A_{v}v_{ik}+A_{s}v_{x}\\tag{7}$$\n\nFor the closed ring\n\n$$v_{i1}=v_{oN}\\;, \\qquad v_{ik}=v_{ok-1}\\tag{8}$$\n\nso that, e. g. for $N=3$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nG_{m}v_{o3}+(G_{o}+sC_{L})v_{o1}&=G_{p}v_{x}\\cr\nG_{m}v_{o1}+(G_{o}+sC_{L})v_{o2}&=G_{p}v_{x}\\cr\nG_{m}v_{o2}+(G_{o}+sC_{L})v_{o3}&=G_{p}v_{x}} \\tag{9}$$\n\nThe $N$ equations (9) are circulant.  The excitation\n${\\bf G_{p}}v_{x}[1\\,1\\dots 1]^{T}$ is the ${\\bf k}=0$\nFourier vector.  Only the common mode\n\n$$v_{o1}=v_{o2}=\\dots =v_{oN}=v_{c}\\tag{10}$$\n\nis excited.  Putting $S=\\sum v_{ok}=Nv_{c}$ and adding\n(9),\n\n$$S\\,(G_{m}+G_{o}+sC_{L})=NG_{p}v_{x}\\tag{11}$$\n\n$$S=N\\,{\\dfrac{G_{p}}{G_{m}+G_{o}+sC_{L}}}\\,v_{x}\\tag{12}$$\n\nand, from (6), for any $k$\n\n$$v_{c}={\\dfrac{G_{p}}{G_{m}+G_{o}+sC_{L}}}\\,v_{x}\\tag{13}$$\n\nThe total current furnished by the test generator\n$v_{x}$ is the sum of the $N$ $p$ currents.  From (1)\n(2)\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{x}&=\\sum_{k}^{N}i_{pk}\n      =\\sum_{k}^{N}\\left[ G_{p}v_{x}-g_{mp}v_{ik}-g_{op}v_{ok}\\right]\\cr\n     &=NG_{p}v_{x}-G_{p}S\\tag{14}}$$\n\nbecause $\\sum v_{ik}=\\sum v_{ok}=S$.  With (12)\n\n$$I_{x}=NG_{p}v_{x}\\left[1-{\\dfrac{G_{p}}\n{G_{m}+G_{o}+sC_{L}}}\\right] \\tag{15}$$\n\nso that the closed loop admittance seen at the common\n$V_{DD}$ rail is, for $N$ stages,\n\n$$Y_{x}(s)={{I_{x}}\\over {v_{x}}}\n      =N\\,G_{p}\\,{{G_{m}+G_{o}-G_{p}+sC_{L}}\\over \n            {G_{m}+G_{o}+sC_{L}}}\\tag{16}$$\n\nand, since $G_{m}+G_{o}-G_{p}=g_{mn}+g_{on}$,\n\n$$Y_{x}(s)=N\\,(g_{mp}+g_{op})\\,\n     {{g_{mn}+g_{on}+sC_{L}}\\over \n      {g_{mn}+g_{mp}+g_{on}+g_{op}+sC_{L}}}\\tag{17}$$\n\n$$Z_{x}(s)=Y_{x}^{-1}(s)\\tag{18}$$\n\nis a conventional $R\\parallel C$ impedance with a\npole\n\n$$\\omega _{p}={{G_{m}+G_{o}}\\over {C_{L}}}\\tag{19}$$\n\nand a zero\n\n$$\\omega _{z}={{g_{mn}+g_{on}}\\over {C_{L}}}\\tag{20}$$\n\n$\\omega _{p}$ is, to within $G_{o}$, the ``oscillation''\npole\n\n$$s_{1,2}={{-\\,G_{o}+G_{m}/2\\pm j{{\\sqrt{3}}\\over {2}}G_{m}}\n      \\over {C_{L}}}\\tag{21}$$\n\nof the linearised metastable point, i. e. \n${\\rm Im}\\,s_{1,2}= \\omega _{osc}\\approx {{\\sqrt{3}}G_{m}/\n2C_{L}}$.\n\nIn particular, for $|s|C_{L}\\ll G_{m}$, the normal low\nfrequency, $d-c$, resistance is\n\n$$R_{x0}=Y_{x}^{-1}(0)={{G_{m}+G_{o}}\\over \n            {NG_{p}(g_{mn}+g_{on})}}\\tag{22}$$\n\n$$R_{x0}={1\\over N}\n      {{g_{mn}+g_{mp}+g_{on}+g_{op}}\\over \n       {(g_{mp}+g_{op})(g_{mn}+g_{on})}}\\tag{23}$$\n\nWith the passive sign convention, $I_{x}$ into the\ncircuit, $R_{x0}>0$.  With the generator sign convention\nnormally used in oscillator theory, $I_{x}$ out of the\ncircuit, $R_{x0}<0$.  Neglecting channel length\nmodulation, $g_{o}\\to 0$,\n\n$$R_{x0}={1\\over N}\\left({1\\over {g_{mn}}}+{1\\over {g_{mp}}}\n      \\right) \\tag{24}$$\n\nFor the conventional symmetric design $g_{mn}=g_{mp}=g_{m}$\n\n$$|R_{x0}|\\approx {2\\over {Ng_{m}}}\\tag{25}$$\n\nso that for the three stage ring in the figure\n\n$$|R_{x0}|\\approx {2\\over {3g_{m}}}\\approx {1\\over {g_{m}}}\n\\;\\;{\\rm to\\;within\\;a\\;factor\\;2}\\tag{26}$$\n\nin the generator convention\n\n$$R_{x0}\\approx -{2\\over {3g_{m}}}\\tag{27}$$\n\noften quoted simply as $R_{x}\\approx -1/g_{m}$ or\n$|R_{x}|\\approx 1/g_{m}$.  Keeping $g_{o}=1/r_{o}$,\n\n$$R_{x0}={2\\over {3g_{m}}}{1\\over {1+g_{o}/g_{m}}}\n      \\approx {2\\over {3g_{m}}}\\left(1-{1\\over {g_{m}r_{o}}}\n      \\right)\\tag{28}$$\n\nand in general $|R_{x}|\\sim 50-500\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$ for a\nnormal $g_{m}\\sim 1-10\\,{\\rm mS}$ per device.\n\nWell above the common mode pole, $|s|C_{L}\\gg G_{m}$,\n\n$$Y_{x}(\\infty )=NG_{p}\\approx Ng_{mp}\\tag{29}$$\n\n$$|R_{x\\infty }|\\approx {1\\over {Ng_{mp}}}\\to {1\\over \n      {3g_{m}}}\\;\\;{\\rm sym.}\\tag{30}$$\n\nso that, up to the $2\\times $ factor,\n\n$$|Z_{x}(s)|\\approx |R_{x0}|{{1+s/\\omega _{z}}\\over \n       {1+s/\\omega _{p}}}\\tag{31}$$\n\ngoes from $\\approx 2/3g_{m}$ at $d-c$ to $\\approx\n1/3g_{m}$ for $\\omega \\gg \\omega _{p}$ with\n${\\rm Re}\\,Z_{x}>0$ for the passive reference arrow.\nThe magnitude at the (small signal) oscillation\nfrequency $s=j\\omega _{osc}$ is the same order of\nmagnitude,\n\n$$Y_{x}(j\\omega _{osc})\\approx Ng_{mp}\n      {{1+j\\omega _{osc}/\\omega _{z}}\\over \n       {1+j\\omega _{osc}/\\omega _{p}}}\\tag{32}$$\n\nwith ${\\rm Re}\\,Y_{x}>0$.\n\nAny expression of the form $R_{x}\\sim 1/Ng_{m}$ to\n$2/Ng_{m}$ i. e. $R_{x}\\sim 1/g_{m}$ in order of\nmagnitude is accepted as correct.  With the bulk effect\nincluded $g_{mp}\\to g_{mp}+g_{mbp}$.\n\nTime averaged over the large signal limit cycle the\ncircuit draws on the average\n\n$$I_{DD,av}\\approx N\\,C_{L}V_{DD}f_{osc}\\approx \n      {{N\\,I_{Dsat}}\\over 2}\\tag{33}$$\n\nso that the large signal, $V_{DD}$ to $I_{DD,av}$,\nresistance is\n\n$$R_{x,LS}={{V_{DD}}\\over {I_{DD,av}}}\\approx \n      {{2V_{DD}}\\over {NI_{Dsat}}}\\approx {{R_{on,p}}\\over N}\n      \\approx {1\\over {N\\mu _{p}C_{ox}(W/L)_{p}\n      (V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|)}}\\tag{34}$$\n\nagain a few $10\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$ to a few $100\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$\nper stage, positive in the passive convention, negative\nin the generator convention.  E. g. $g_{m}=2\\,{\\rm mS}$,\n$|R_{x0}|\\approx 330\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$, \n$|R_{x\\infty }|\\approx 170\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$;\n$g_{m}=5\\,{\\rm mS}$, $|R_{x0}|\\approx 130\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$,\netc.  In round numbers the supply sees a low impedance\n$\\sim 1/g_{m}$ to ground which, as an active impedance,\nis normally written with a minus sign, $Z_{x}\\approx\n-1/g_{m}$.  Closing $Z_{x}$ on an inductor\n$L_{x}=1/\\omega _{osc}^{2}C_{x}$ gives the familiar\nsupply tuned $LC$ VCO.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "09fb39285702c3fdd030b4d8b67878bdfc7e095dc3e35c82ec8929bc3b36b284"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "The limit-cycle relation I_DD,av ≈ N C_L V_DD f_osc and R = V_DD/I_DD,av imply R ≈ 1/(N C_L f_osc), or 1/(3 C_L f_0) for this ring, matching the full-credit rule. The metastable g_m analysis is extraneous, but the correct oscillation-driven capacitive mechanism and resistance form are present.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "567a4e1905413cda5af92a626cb359563db923ba665d1835ff2377a534cd5d21",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 3299,
        "input_tokens": 3314,
        "output_tokens": 14916,
        "total_tokens": 18230,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12062,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 3299,
        "input_tokens": 3314,
        "output_tokens": 14916,
        "total_tokens": 18230,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12062,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 5,
      "question": "Determine the small-signal resistance seen looking into the supply node of the ring oscillator in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-005-determine-small-signal-resistance-seen-looking-into/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual ``metastable'' linearisation the\n${\\rm V}_{DD}$ node is a common mode node.\nPut ${\\rm V}_{DD}={\\rm V}_{x}+v_{x}$ , $v_{o_{i}}$\nthe small signal output of the $i$th. inverter, Fig.1,\n${\\rm C}$ the total capacitance on the node, ${\\rm W}$ the\n$p$ device ${\\rm S}$, ${\\rm G}$, ${\\rm D}$ $={\\rm V}_{x}$,\n$v_{i}$, $v_{o}$ and the $n$ device ${\\rm G}$, ${\\rm D}$,\n${\\rm S}$ $=v_{i},v_{o},0$.\n\n$${\\eqalign{\ni_{Dp}&=g_{mp}(v_{x}-v_{i})+g_{op}(v_{x}-v_{o})\\cr\ni_{Dn}&=g_{mn}v_{i}+g_{on}v_{o}\\cr}} \\tag{1}$$\n\n$${\\rm KCL}_{o}:\\;i_{Dp}=i_{Dn}+sCv_{o}\\tag{2}$$\n\nso that with\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nA&=g_{mp}+g_{op}\\cr\nB&=g_{mp}+g_{mn}\\cr\nC_{0}&=g_{op}+g_{on}\\cr\nC(s)&=C_{0}+sC\\cr}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$\\,A\\,v_{x}=Bv_{i}+C(s)v_{o}\\,\\tag{4}$$\n\nand, for the closed loop,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nC(s)v_{o1}+Bv_{o3}&=Av_{x}\\cr\nBv_{o1}+C(s)v_{o2}&=Av_{x}\\cr\nBv_{o2}+C(s)v_{o3}&=Av_{x}\\cr}\\tag{5}$$\n\nwhose determinant is $C^{3}+B^{3}\\ne 0$.\nFor the common mode excitation $v_{x}{\\bf 1}$ the\nsymmetric solution\n\n$$v_{o1}=v_{o2}=v_{o3}=v_{o}={A\\over {B+C(s)}}v_{x}\\tag{6}$$\n\nsatisfies (5).\n\n$${v_{o}\\over {v_{x}}}\\approx {{g_{mp}}\\over\n{g_{mp}+g_{mn}}}\\approx {1\\over 2}\\qquad g_{o}\\ll g_{m} \\tag{7}$$\n\nthe conventional small signal inverter supply to output\n{\\it positive} gain.  The small signal current taken from\nthe $v_{x}$ source is the sum of the three $p$ source\ncurrents\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{x}&=\\sum_{1}^{3}i_{Dpi}\n      =\\sum_{1}^{3}\\left[ A\\,v_{x}-g_{mp}v_{i}-g_{op}v_{o}\\right] \n       =3Av_{x}-3Av_{o}\\cr\n     &=3A\\left[1-{A\\over {B+C(s)}}\\right]v_{x}\n      =3A{{B+C(s)-A}\\over {B+C(s)}}v_{x} \\cr\n     &=3A{{g_{mn}+g_{on}+sC}\\over {B+C(s)}}v_{x} \\tag{8}}$$\n\nso that, in the low frequency metastable bias, the small\nsignal impedance seen looking into the common ${\\rm V}_{DD}$\nrail is\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nZ_{x}(s)&={v_{x}\\over {i_{x}}}\n        ={1\\over {3A}}{{B+C(s)}\\over {g_{mn}+g_{on}+sC}}\\cr\n        &={{g_{mn}+g_{mp}+g_{on}+g_{op}+sC}\\over\n                {3(g_{mp}+g_{op})(g_{mn}+g_{on}+sC)}} \\tag{9}}$$\n\nI. e. the ${\\rm V}_{DD}$ node sees three diode connected\ninverters in parallel.  At $s=0$\n\n$$R_{x0}=Z_{x}(0)={{B+C_{0}}\\over {3A(g_{mn}+g_{on})}}\n      ={{g_{mn}+g_{mp}+g_{on}+g_{op}}\\over\n             {3(g_{mp}+g_{op})(g_{mn}+g_{on})}} \\tag{10}$$\n\n$${R_{x0}={1\\over 3}\\left[{1\\over {g_{mn}+g_{on}}}+\n                 {1\\over {g_{mp}+g_{op}}}\\right] } \\tag{11}$$\n\nin parallel with $r_{on}\\Vert r_{op}$.\nFor $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$\n\n$$\\;R_{x0}\\approx {1\\over 3}\\left({1\\over {g_{mn}}}+{1\\over\n{g_{mp}}}\\right)={{g_{mn}+g_{mp}}\\over {3g_{mn}g_{mp}}}\\; \\tag{12}$$\n\nIf the inverter transconductance is put $G_{m}=g_{mn}+\ng_{mp}$, (12) is $R_{x0}\\approx 1/3G_{m}$ per stage.\nFor the conventional symmetric bias\n$g_{mn}=g_{mp}=g_{m}$, $g_{o}\\to 0$,\n\n$$R_{x0}\\approx {2\\over {3g_{m}}}={4\\over {3G_{m}}}\\approx\n{1\\over {3g_{m}}}{\\rm \\;\\;per\\;side}\\tag{13}$$\n\npositive with the passive sign convention, i.{\\rm e.}\n$|R_{x}|\\sim g_{m}^{-1}$, normally a few $10^{2}{\\rm \\Omega}$,\ne. {\\rm g.} $g_{m}=1\\,{\\rm mA/V}$, $R_{x0}\\approx 0.66\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}\n\\approx 0.33\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$ per $g_{m}$.\n\nWith the oscillator large signal active sign convention the\nsame magnitude is normally quoted as a negative resistance,\n\n$$|R_{x}|\\approx {1\\over {N\\,g_{m}}}\\approx {1\\over {3g_{m}}}\n\\;\\;{\\rm per\\;device,}\\;\\;|R_{x}|\\approx {2\\over {3g_{m}}}\n\\approx {1\\over {G_{m}}}{\\rm \\;for\\;the\\;CMOS\\;inverter,} \\tag{14}$$\n\nso that, e. {\\rm g.}\n\n$$R_{x}\\approx -\\,{1\\over {3g_{m}}}\\;\\;{\\rm to}\\;\\;-{2\\over {3g_{m}}}\n\\approx -\\,{1\\over {G_{m}}}\\tag{15}$$\n\nin the $g_{o}\\to 0$ square law form, and, retaining\n$r_{o}=1/g_{o}$,\n\n$$R_{x}\\approx -\\,{{(g_{m}r_{o})^{2}}\\over {3g_{m}}}\\approx\n-\\,{r_{o}\\over 3}\\tag{16}$$\n\nat the oscillation frequency, ${\\rm Re}\\,Z_{x}(j\\omega _{{\\rm\nosc}})<0$, $|\\,{\\rm Re}\\,Z_{x}(j\\omega _{{\\rm osc}})\\,|\n\\approx r_{o}/3\\sim g_{m}^{-1}$.\n\nIn round numbers the ${\\rm V}_{DD}$ node looks like\n$N=3$ diode connected inverters in parallel, i. {\\rm e.}\nlike a resistance $\\sim 1/G_{m}$ to ground, normally quoted\nsimply as $|R_{x}|\\sim 1/g_{m}$, more precisely (11)--(13).\nWith the passive reference direction $R_{x}>0$; with the\nusual negative resistance oscillator convention\n$R_{x}\\approx -|R_{x}|$.  Any of the equivalent forms\n(9)--(15) is acceptable; e. {\\rm g.} for $r_{o}\\to \\infty $\n\n$$Z_{x}(s)\\approx {1\\over 3}{1\\over {g_{mp}}}\n{{g_{mp}+g_{mn}+sC}\\over {g_{mn}+sC}}\\approx\n{2/3g_{m}}\\,{1\\over {1+sC/g_{m}}}$$\n\nfor $g_{mn}=g_{mp}=g_{m}$, so that $Z_{x}(0)\\approx\n2/3g_{m}\\approx 1/3G_{m}$ and $|Z_{x}(j\\omega _{{\\rm osc}})|\n\\approx 1/g_{m}$ negative in the active convention.  For\nhand calculation $|R_{x}|\\approx 1/3g_{m}\\approx 1/G_{m}$\nis often quoted, i. {\\rm e.} $R_{x}\\approx -1/g_{m}$ in\nmagnitude, $\\approx -1/3g_{m}$ per stage.  The $+$\nsign is the conventional passive small signal resistance.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d144dc1360e8addbc069d55fc9d172a100f7745791f9f4fab92976e1f3d03571"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It derives a gm-based resistance from a static metastable linearization, rather than the oscillation-driven charging and discharging of the node capacitances that set the supply resistance. The later negative-resistance claims do not supply the missing dominant mechanism.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "567a4e1905413cda5af92a626cb359563db923ba665d1835ff2377a534cd5d21",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3314,
        "output_tokens": 17207,
        "total_tokens": 20521,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14996,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3314,
        "output_tokens": 17207,
        "total_tokens": 20521,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14996,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-006-oscillates-change",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "For the ring oscillator in the figure, somebody computes the small-signal resistance `RX`\nseen looking into the supply node as\n\n```text\nRX ~= (1/3) (1/gmn + 1/gmp)\n```\n\nwhere `gmn` and `gmp` are the transconductances of the NMOS and PMOS devices in each\ninverter, because each inverter behaves as two diode-connected devices in series.\n\nIf the circuit oscillates, does this answer change?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-006-oscillates-change/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual abuse of language the ``$R_{X}$'' is\nill defined for an autonomous circuit.  What is\nnormally called $R_{X}$ is\n\n$${{dV_{DD}}\\over {dI_{DD}}}\\Bigl|_{0}\\eqno{*}$$\n\nat the {\\it metastable} d.c. {\\it equilibrium}\n$V_{o1}=V_{o2}=V_{o3}=V_{T}\\approx V_{DD}/2$.\nPut\n\n$$i_{p}=g_{mp}(v_{i}-v_{x})+g_{op}(v_{o}-v_{x})\\tag{1}$$\n$$i_{n}=g_{mn}v_{i}+g_{on}v_{o}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$i_{p}+i_{n}+sCv_{o}=0\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$v_{i\\,k}=v_{o\\,k-1}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand, for the $v_{x}$\nperturbation, $v_{ok}=v_{o}\\;\\forall k$,\n$v_{ik}=v_{o}$, the ``common mode'' mode of the\ncirculant $3\\times 3$ system.  From (1)-(3)\n\n$$(g_{m}+g_{o})v_{o}-(g_{mp}+g_{op})v_{x}\n+sCv_{o}=0\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$g_{m}=g_{mp}+g_{mn}\\qquad g_{o}=g_{op}+g_{on}$$\n\nso that for $s\\to 0$\n\n$$v_{o}={g_{mp}+g_{op}\\over g_{m}+g_{o}}v_{x}\n\\approx {g_{mp}\\over g_{m}}v_{x} \\tag{6}$$\n\n$$i_{x\\,k}= (g_{mp}+g_{op})v_{x}-g_{mp}v_{i\\,k}\n-g_{op}v_{o\\,k}=(g_{mp}+g_{op})(v_{x}-v_{o}) \\tag{7}$$\n\n$${{v_{x}}\\over {i_{x\\,k}}}=\n{g_{m}+g_{o}\\over (g_{mp}+g_{op})(g_{mn}+g_{on})}\n\\approx {g_{m}\\over g_{mp}g_{mn}}\n={1\\over {g_{mp}}}+{1\\over {g_{mn}}}\\tag{8}$$\n\ni. e. the PMOS, common gate, loaded with the\nNMOS common gate, i. e. the two ``diode connected''\ndevices in series, and for $N=3$ in parallel\n\n$$R_{X0}\\approx {1\\over N}\\left({1\\over {g_{mp}}}+\n{1\\over {g_{mn}}}\\right)\\;\\;N=3\\tag{9}$$\n\nwith $g_{m}=g_{m}(V_{T})$, the small signal $g_{m}$\nat the trip point.\n\nThat $R_{X0}$ is the resistance seen at the\n{\\it unstable} equilibrium.  It is the resistance\nthat has to be used for the linear, time invariant,\n{\\it start up} stability analysis, the $s\\to 0$\npole of the $3\\times 3$ system.  It is what you\nget out of a conventional $.AC$ analysis linearized\nabout the d.c. solution $V_{o}=V_{T}$.\n\nIt is not what you measure on a free running\noscillator.  On the stable periodic orbit the\ncircuit is a large signal, periodically time\nvarying, nonlinear circuit.  Linearised about the\norbit it is a linear periodically time variant,\ncyclostationary, circuit in the sense of Floquet.\nE.g. with obvious notation\n\n$$g_{m}(t)=g_{m}\\bigl(V_{I}(t)\\bigr)\\tag{10}$$\n\n$$g_{m}(t+T_{0})=g_{m}(t),\\qquad \nT_{0}=2N\\bar\\tau _{d}=1/f_{0}\\tag{11}$$\n\nis periodic at the oscillation frequency.\nFormally\n\n$$\\delta i_{x}(t)=Y_{x}(t)\\,\\delta v_{x}(t)\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$Y_{x}(t)=\\sum_{k}g_{x\\,k}(t),\\qquad \nY_{x}(t+T_{0})=Y_{x}(t)\\tag{13}$$\n\nso that a tone at $\\omega _{x}$\n\n$$\\delta v_{x}= {\\rm Re}\\,V_{x}e^{j\\omega _{x}t}\\tag{14}$$\n\nproduces\n\n$$\\delta i_{x}= {\\rm Re}\\sum_{n}Y_{n}(j\\omega _{x})\nV_{x}e^{j(\\omega _{x}+n\\omega _{0})t}\\tag{15}$$\n\ni. e. a conversion matrix $Y_{n,m}=Y_{n-m}(j\\omega\n+m\\omega _{0})$.  The ``$R_{X}$'' is not a number\nbut the $(0,0)$ element $Z_{0,0}=Y_{0,0}^{-1}$ plus\nan infinite set of conversion impedances $Z_{n,0}$.\n\nIn the time domain the instantaneous small signal\nimpedance is\n\n$$r_{x}(t)=1/Y_{x}(t)\\approx \n\\left[\\sum_{k=1}^{N}{1\\over {r_{pk}(t)+r_{nk}(t)}}\\right]^{-1}\n\\tag{16}$$\n\n$$r_{pk}(t)\\approx 1/g_{mp\\,k}(t)\\;{\\rm sat.},\\;\n\\approx 1/g_{op\\,k}(t)\\;{\\rm triode},\\;\n\\to \\infty \\;{\\rm off}$$\n\nand similarly for $r_{nk}$.  In normal rail to\nrail oscillation a gate spends most of its time with\none device OFF, $r_{x}=\\infty$ d.c., and only during\nthe transition, of duration $t_{r}$, are both\ndevices on in saturation and (16) $\\approx\n1/g_{mp}+1/g_{mn}\\equiv r_{0}$.  For the ideal\n$3$ stage ring at any $t$ at most one gate is\ncommutating, so\n\n$$r_{x}(t)=\\cases{\nr_{0} & during commutation\\cr\n\\infty & otherwise\\cr}\\tag{17}$$\n\nIn particular\n\n$$\\langle Y_{x}\\rangle ={1\\over {T_{0}}}\\int_{T_{0}}\nY_{x}(t)dt = D\\,Y_{0},\\qquad \n\\langle r_{x}\\rangle \\approx r_{0}/D\\tag{18}$$\n\nwhere $D$ is the fractional conduction duty\ncycle of the crow bar current,\n$Y_{0}=1/r_{0}$.\nIf $t_{r}$ is the $0-100\\%$ rise time and the\ntransitions do not overlap\n\n$$D = {2Nt_{r}\\over T_{0}}{1\\over N}\n      ={2t_{r}\\over T_{0}}\\quad {\\rm per\\;stage}\\tag{19}$$\n\nfor the total\n\n$$D_{tot}= {{N_{tr}t_{r}}\\over {T_{0}}}\\approx\n{{6t_{r}}\\over {T_{0}}}\\tag{20}$$\n\nso that, on the average,\n\n$$\\langle G_{x}\\rangle = D_{tot}G_{0},\\qquad\n\\langle R_{x}\\rangle = R_{X0}{N\\over {D_{tot}}}\n      =R_{X0}{T_{0}\\over {2t_{r}}}\\tag{21}$$\n\nFor the often quoted $t_{r}\\approx \\bar\\tau_{d}\n\\approx T_{0}/2N$,\n\n$$\\langle R_{x}\\rangle \\approx N\\,R_{X0}\n      = {1\\over {g_{mp}}}+{1\\over {g_{mn}}}\\tag{22}$$\n\ni. e. the factor $1/N$ in (9) disappears.  In\ngeneral $\\langle R_{x}\\rangle =R_{X0}(T_{0}/6t_{r})$\nfor $N=3$.  For abrupt, square wave, switching\n$t_{r}\\to 0$, $D\\to 0$,\n\n$$\\langle R_{x}\\rangle \\to \\infty \\tag{23}$$\n\nexcept for the train of short current spikes\n$I_{x}(t)$.  The d.c., large signal, incremental\nresistance that you get by changing $V_{DD}$ and\nmeasuring the change of the {\\it averaged}\nsupply current,\n\n$$R_{X,DC}={{dV_{DD}}\\over {d\\langle I_{x}\\rangle}}\n      \\approx {V_{DD}\\over {\\langle I_{x}\\rangle}}\n      \\propto {1\\over {N C V_{DD}f_{0}}}\\tag{24}$$\n\n$$\\langle I_{x}\\rangle \\approx N C V_{DD}f_{0}\n      +I_{sc},\\qquad f_{0}\\approx 1/2N\\bar\\tau_{d}$$\n\n$$\\bar\\tau_{d}\\approx {{C V_{DD}}\\over {I_{D}}}$$\n\nis $\\propto 1/\\langle g_{m}\\rangle$, the\n{\\it large signal}, describing function, averaged\n$g_{m}$,\n\n$$\\langle g_{m}\\rangle ={1\\over {T_{0}}}\\int g_{m}(t)dt\n      < g_{m}(V_{T})\\tag{25}$$\n\ntypically $0.3-0.7\\,g_{m}(V_{T})$, not the small\nsignal $g_{m}$ in (9).\n\nIn a $PSS/PAC$ simulation the $(0,0)$ common mode\nsmall signal $R_{X}$ at $\\omega_{x}\\ll\\omega_{0}$ is\nstill ${\\cal O}(1/g_{m})$ but numerically\n(21)-(25), a factor $\\approx 3$ large for the\n$3$ stage ring and formally infinite for ideal\nswitching, and, for $\\omega_{x}\\approx\nn\\omega_{0}\\pm\\Delta\\omega$, $Z_{x}(\\omega_{x})$\nhas a large conversion component.  To first order\nthe common mode $Z_{0,0}$ and the differential\noscillation mode are orthogonal, so the magnitude\n$|Z_{0,0}(0)|$ stays ${\\cal O}(1/g_{m})$, but the\nfull $N\\times N$ harmonic transfer matrix has\npoles at $\\pm j\\omega_{0}$ where\n${\\rm Re}\\,Z_{n,0}<0$.  Physically a $\\Delta\\omega$\nperturbation of the supply at $\\omega_{0}\\pm\n\\Delta\\omega$ FM modulates the oscillator,\n$\\Delta\\omega =K_{VDD}\\Delta V_{DD}$, and appears\nas a negative resistance $-K_{VDD}/\\Delta\\omega$\nin the conversion impedance.  That is the supply\npushing induced phase noise / injection pulling\nmechanism.  This is normally quoted as ``the supply\nimpedance becomes negative near the carrier''.\n\nIn short: (9) is the correct small signal $R_{X}$\nlinearised about the metastable d.c. point and is\nthe one to use for start up/loop gain.  The impedance\nyou actually measure on the running, hard switching,\noscillator is cyclostationary, $r_{x}=r_{x}(t)$,\n(17).  Averaged over many periods at low frequency it\nis larger than (9) by $1/D\\approx T_{0}/2t_{r}$,\n$\\approx 3\\times$ for a normal $3$ stage ring,\n$\\to\\infty$ for ideal square wave switching, and with\nlarge signal $g_{m}\\to\\langle g_{m}\\rangle$.  At\nr.f. it is a frequency converting impedance with\n$Z(\\omega_{x})\\to Z(\\omega_{x}+n\\omega_{0})$ and,\naround $f_{0}$, with a negative real part.  A\nconventional $.AC$ $R_{X0}=(1/3)(1/g_{mn}+1/g_{mp})$\nis unobservable on the free running oscillator.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "914066dc08209842afb26eaff92c0b8e85aa2aa9fd792c6d56fffc4621e6b011"
      },
      "model_call_count": 2,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly distinguishes the startup small-signal result from the running oscillator and includes the capacitive switching-current scaling, giving an RX on the order of 1/gm. However, its duty-cycle averaging and claim that RX diverges in the hard-switching limit overstate the effect of devices being off and conflict with the capacitive-current result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "41b3aba626dbabae7c16266607298d97003b7365b7c8eebf62086ccaef8b74fa",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 6784,
        "output_tokens": 29982,
        "total_tokens": 36766,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 24300,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3392,
        "output_tokens": 14991,
        "total_tokens": 18383,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12150,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 2,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-006-oscillates-change",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "For the ring oscillator in the figure, somebody computes the small-signal resistance `RX`\nseen looking into the supply node as\n\n```text\nRX ~= (1/3) (1/gmn + 1/gmp)\n```\n\nwhere `gmn` and `gmp` are the transconductances of the NMOS and PMOS devices in each\ninverter, because each inverter behaves as two diode-connected devices in series.\n\nIf the circuit oscillates, does this answer change?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-006-oscillates-change/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the time invariant sense it is not defined.\nPut $V_{x}=V_{DD}+v_{x}$, $V_{i}=V_{I}+v_{i}$\n$G_{m}=g_{m{\\rm n}}+g_{m{\\rm p}}$, $G_{p}=g_{m{\\rm p}}$\nfor the $i$ th inverter, with parasitic $C$\n\n$${\\rm KCL}\\;\\;{\\rm at}\\;\\;v_{i}: G_{p}(v_{x}-v_{i-1})\n= g_{mn}v_{i-1}+g_{ds}v_{i}+sCv_{i} \\tag{*}$$\n\nin the conventional manner.  Neglect $g_{ds}$ for\nthe argument.  $i={\\rm mod}\\;3$.\n\n$$sCv_{1}=G_{p}v_{x}-G_{m}v_{3}$$\n$$sCv_{2}=G_{p}v_{x}-G_{m}v_{1}$$\n$$sCv_{3}=G_{p}v_{x}-G_{m}v_{2}$$\n\nPut $S=v_{1}+v_{2}+v_{3}$:\n\n$$sCS =3G_{p}v_{x}-G_{m}S$$\n\n$$S={3G_{p}\\over{sC+G_{m}}}v_{x}\\tag{1}$$\n\nThe current supplied to the $i$th inverter is the $p$\nchannel current\n\n$$i_{xi}=G_{p}(v_{x}-v_{i-1})$$\n\n$$I_{x}=\\sum i_{xi}=3G_{p}v_{x}-G_{p}S\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$Y_{x}={I_{x}\\over v_{x}}=3G_{p}{sC+g_{mn}\\over sC+G_{m}} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${1\\over{Y_{x}}}=R_{x}(s)={1\\over 3}{sC+G_{m}\\over{G_{p}(sC+g_{mn})}} \\tag{4}$$\n\nFor a probe at {\\it d. c.} and {\\it at the metastable\nd.c. bias point}, $V_{I}=V_{O}=V_{M}$,\n$$sC\\ll G_{m}\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$Y_{x}(0)=3{G_{p}g_{mn}\\over G_{m}}={3\\over{1/g_{mn}+1/g_{mp}}}$$\n\n$$R_{x}(0)={1\\over 3}\\left({1\\over{g_{mn}}}+{1\\over{g_{mp}}}\\right)\\tag{6}$$\n\nSo formally it is the parallel of $3$ ``diodes''\n${1/g_{mn}}+{1/g_{mp}}$.\n\nIt looks like each inverter is diode connected.\nIt is not.  The input of inverter $i$ is not its\nown output but the output of $i-1$.  It is only\nbecause at $s=0$, (1), $v_{1}=v_{2}=v_{3}$,\nso $v_{i-1}\\propto v_{i}$ with the same coefficient\nfor the three phases that $\\sum i_{xi}$ looks like\nthree diodes in parallel.  For any $s\\ne 0$,\n$v_{i}\\ne v_{j}$ and (4) is complex and $s$ dependent.\nAt $sC\\sim G_{m}$, i.e. at the frequency where\n${{{\\rm arg}}\\, G_{m}/sC\\sim 60^{o}}$, the three phasors\nare $120^{o}$ apart.  The Barkhausen frequency.\nThen e.g. $S\\approx 0$ for a probe at $\\approx\n\\omega _{0}$ and\n\n$$Y_{x}(j\\omega _{0})\\approx 3G_{p}\\ne 3G_{p}g_{mn}/G_{m}$$\n\nIn general there is no single time invariant number\n$R_{x}$.\n\nThat $R_{x}(0)$ is the impedance about the {\\it\nd.c. equilibrium} $V_{I}=V_{O}$.  The equilibrium is\nunstable.  $A_{v}^{3}>1$.  The linearized time invariant\ncircuit has a pair of poles in the ${\\rm Re}\\,s>0$.\nIt is unobservable.  The observable steady state is\nthe large signal limit cycle, Fig.1, essentially\nrail to rail.\n\nLinearisation must be about the periodic trajectory,\n${\\rm LPTV}$ - Floquet - ${\\rm PSS/PAC}$, periodic\n$g_{m}(t),g_{ds}(t),C(t)$.\n\nInstantaneously\n\n$$R_{x}(t)\\approx {1\\over{g_{mp}(t)}}+{1\\over{g_{mn}(t)}}\n\\parallel r_{o}(t)$$\n\nand it is {\\it periodically time varying} with\nperiod $T_{0}=1/f_{0}\\approx 6t_{d}$.\n\nFor most of the period a static inverter has\neither its $p$ off, $v_{O}=0$, or its $n$ off,\n$v_{O}=V_{DD}$.  E.g. for $v_{O}=V_{DD}$,\n$r_{p}\\sim r_{{\\rm on\\,triode}}\\ll 1/g_{m}$ but\n$r_{n}=\\infty $, for $v_{O}=0$, $r_{p}=\\infty $.\nNo d.c. path to ground.  The supply sees an\nopen except during the narrow cross over, crow bar,\nwhere both devices are in saturation for a time\n$t_{tr}\\ll T_{0}$.  I.e.\n\n$$g_{m}(t)=\\cases{\ng_{m} & for $t$ in $t_{tr}$\\cr\n0 & otherwise\\cr}\\tag{7}$$\n\nHence the {\\it cycle averaged} conductance for a\nlow frequency probe, $\\omega _{p}\\ll \\omega _{0}$,\nwhere the oscillator can be regarded as quasi static,\nis\n\n$$\\langle Y_{x}\\rangle ={1\\over{T_{0}}}\\int_{0}^{T_{0}}\nY_{x}(t)\\,dt \\approx {t_{tr}\\over T_{0}}Y_{x}(0)\\ll Y_{x}(0) \\tag{8}$$\n\n$$\\langle R_{x}\\rangle \\approx {T_{0}\\over{t_{tr}}}\nR_{x}(0)\\gg R_{x}(0) \\tag{9}$$\n\nIn the ideal square wave limit $t_{tr}\\to 0$,\n$\\langle Y_{x}\\rangle \\to 0$, $\\langle R_{x}\\rangle\n\\to \\infty $ except for the capacitive charging\ncurrent.  More accurately a slow, $\\omega _{p}\\ll\n\\omega _{0}$, ``d.c.'' measurement of $\\langle I_{DD}\n\\rangle $ {\\it vs} $V_{DD}$ gives the {\\it incremental\nlarge signal} resistance\n\n$$R_{X,{inc}}^{-1}={d\\langle I_{DD}\\rangle \\over dV_{DD}}$$\n\n$$\\langle I_{DD}\\rangle =NCV_{DD}f_{0}(V_{DD})+\nI_{cr}(V_{DD}) \\tag{10}$$\n\ndynamic $CVf$ plus crow bar, with\n\n$$f_{0}\\approx {1\\over{NCV_{DD}/I_{Av}(V_{DD})}}\\tag{11}$$\n\n$I_{Av}\\propto (V_{DD}-V_{t})^{\\alpha }$.\nThis is not $3g_{m}$.\n\nFor $\\omega _{p}\\sim \\omega _{0}$ the LPTV\nprobe suffers frequency translation.  A tone at\n$\\omega _{p}$ creates sidebands at $\\omega_{p}\\pm\nn\\omega _{0}$.  There is no single $Z_{x}(\\omega_{p})$\nbut a conversion matrix $Z_{mn}=V(\\omega _{p}+m\\omega _{0})/\nI(\\omega _{p}+n\\omega _{0})$.  At $\\approx n\\omega _{0}$\nthe $N=3$ currents are $\\approx 120^{o}$ apart and\ncancel to first order for $n\\ne 3k$.  The supply\ncurrent ripple is dominantly at $3f_{0}$.  The\nconventional small signal $Y_{x}$ splits into\n\n$$Y_{x}(\\omega _{p},\\omega _{p}\\pm \\omega_{0}\\dots )$$\n\nIn ${\\rm PSS/PAC}$ language the $0,0$ term,\n$\\langle Y_{x}\\rangle $ at $\\omega _{p}$ is (8)-(9),\nthe $0,\\pm 1$ terms give supply pushing, AM to PM\nconversion, and can show a {\\it negative} real part\nabout $\\omega _{0}$ - the oscillator must generate\npower.\n\nOnly in the limit of vanishing oscillation amplitude,\nthe linear limit cycle $\\to $ the metastable point,\n$t_{tr}\\to T_{0}$, is (6) recovered as the time\naverage.  To first order $R_{x}=R_{x}(0)[1+O(A^{2})]$\nfor amplitude $A$.  For normal rail to rail CMOS\nthe $O(1)$ correction is $\\sim T_{0}/t_{tr}\\sim 5-10$.\nIn simulation it requires a periodic steady state\nplus periodic AC, ${\\rm pss+pac}$, or transient\nwith a small step on $V_{DD}$ averaged over many\nperiods, to see it.  A normal ${\\rm AC}$ analysis\nabout the d.c. operating point gives only the\nunstable (6), (4).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "333a857a4a30a3c831e5401da235d7449828c55be9cdb90dee60ebf81594df5c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 2,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It notes the dynamic CVf supply current, but concludes that the average resistance is much higher because the devices conduct only during brief crossover. The golden solution instead shows that capacitive charging keeps RX on the order of the MOS on-resistance, so the central conclusion is wrong.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "41b3aba626dbabae7c16266607298d97003b7365b7c8eebf62086ccaef8b74fa",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 6598,
        "input_tokens": 6784,
        "output_tokens": 21720,
        "total_tokens": 28504,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 17106,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 3299,
        "input_tokens": 3392,
        "output_tokens": 10860,
        "total_tokens": 14252,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8553,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 2,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-006-oscillates-change",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 6,
      "question": "For the ring oscillator in the figure, somebody computes the small-signal resistance `RX`\nseen looking into the supply node as\n\n```text\nRX ~= (1/3) (1/gmn + 1/gmp)\n```\n\nwhere `gmn` and `gmp` are the transconductances of the NMOS and PMOS devices in each\ninverter, because each inverter behaves as two diode-connected devices in series.\n\nIf the circuit oscillates, does this answer change?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-006-oscillates-change/figure-08.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the sense of ${\\cal L}{\\cal T}{\\cal I}$\nit is the resistance to common mode at the un\nstable d.c. equilibrium with the loop killed.\nPut\n\n$$v_{D}=V_{DD}+v_{x}\\;\\;,\\;\\;v_{i}\\;\\;i=1,3$$\n\nfor the three nodes.  For the $k$th CMOS\ninverter\n\n$$i_{pk}=g_{mp}(v_{x}-v_{k-1})+g_{op}(v_{x}-v_{k})\n      \\tag{1a}$$\n$$i_{nk}=g_{mn}v_{k-1}+g_{on}v_{k}\\tag{1b}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$v_{k}=A_{s}v_{x}-A_{v}v_{k-1}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$A_{v}={{g_{mn}+g_{mp}}\\over {g_{o}+sC}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\n  A_{s}={{g_{mp}+g_{op}}\\over {g_{o}+sC}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\n  g_{o}=g_{on}+g_{op}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$1$ in, $1$ out.\nCyclic\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nv_{1}+A_{v}v_{3}&=A_{s}v_{x}\\cr\nv_{2}+A_{v}v_{1}&=A_{s}v_{x}\\cr\nv_{3}+A_{v}v_{2}&=A_{s}v_{x}\\cr}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand, e.g. at $s=0$,\n\n$$v_{1}=v_{2}=v_{3}={{A_{s}}\\over {1+A_{v}}}v_{x}\\tag{5}$$\n\ni. e. $v_{k-1}=v_{k}$ to ${\\cal O}(g_{o}/g_{m})$.\nFor $s=0$, $A_{s}/A_{v}=g_{mp}/(g_{mn}+g_{mp})$,\n\n$$v_{k}={{g_{mp}}\\over {g_{mn}+g_{mp}}}v_{x}+{\\cal O}(g_{o}/g_{m})\n\\tag{6}$$\n\nso that for a perturbation with $\\omega \\ll\n\\omega _{p}=g_{o}/C\\ll \\omega _{0}$ all\nthree nodes move together.  In small signal\n\n$${\\rm gate}={\\rm drain}\\tag{7}$$\n\nfor every device and the device looks diode\nconnected ${1/g_{m}}$.\n\nTotal current taken from the $V_{DD}$ terminal,\nwith (1),\n\n$$I_{x}=\\sum_{k}i_{pk}\n      =3(g_{mp}+g_{op})v_{x}-(g_{mp}+g_{op})\\sum v_{k}\n        -g_{mp}\\sum v_{k-1}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$$I_{x}=3(g_{mp}+g_{op})\\left[v_{x}-v_{1}\\right]\\tag{9}$$\n\nwith (5)\n\n$$I_{x}=3{{(g_{mp}+g_{op})(g_{mn}+g_{on})}\\over\n       {g_{o}+g_{mn}+g_{mp}}}\\,v_{x}\\tag{10}$$\n\nFor $g_{o}\\ll g_{m}$\n\n$$G_{x}={1\\over R_{x}}={{I_{x}}\\over {v_{x}}}\n      =3\\,{{g_{mn}g_{mp}}\\over {g_{mn}+g_{mp}}}\\tag{11}$$\n\n$$R_{x}={1\\over 3}\\left[{1\\over {g_{mn}}}+{1\\over {g_{mp}}}\\right]\n      \\tag{12}$$\n\nin parallel of three\n\n$$R_{1}={1\\over {g_{mn}}}+{1\\over {g_{mp}}}=\\left[\n     g_{mp}\\vert \\vert g_{mn}\\right]^{-1} \\tag{13}$$\n\ndiode resistances in series between $V_{DD}$ and\n$GND$.  This is the ${\\cal L}{\\cal T}{\\cal I}$\nincremental resistance linearised about the\nmetastable $V_{1}=V_{2}=V_{3}\\approx V_{DD}/2$\nd.c. equilibrium, $g_{m}=g_{m}(V_{DD}/2)$, with\nthe loop gain ${\\cal L}_{0}=-A_{v}^{3}(0)\\gg 1$\nbut the circuit constrained not to leave the\nequilibrium - the normal small signal resistance\nwith the ring killed.  It is valid for a test\nfrequency\n\n$$|s|\\ll \\omega _{p}\\ll \\omega _{0}\\approx \n      \\sqrt{3}\\,\\omega _{p}\\tag{14}$$\n\n$\\omega _{0}$ the normal mode frequency,\n$(-A_{v}(j\\omega _{0}))^{3}=1$, and for\n$|v_{x}|\\ll V^{\\ast}$ so that (1) is valid.\n\nOnce the loop is closed and the circuit is\nallowed to go to the stable large signal limit\ncycle (14) is no longer the linearisation point.\nThe operation becomes large signal,\nrail to rail to ${\\cal O}(V_{DD})$, and the\nlinearised circuit becomes linear periodically\ntime varying, ${\\cal L}{\\cal P}{\\cal T}{\\cal V}$.\nFormally there is no single ${\\cal L}{\\cal T}{\\cal I}$\n$R_{x}$.  E.g. with $v_{D}=V_{DD}+v_{x}(t)$\n\n$$i_{x}=G_{x}(t)v_{x}+{\\cal O}(v_{x}^{2})\\tag{15}$$\n\n$$G_{x}(t+T_{0})=G_{x}(t)\\;\\;,\\;\\;T_{0}=2\\pi /\\omega _{0}\\tag{16}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$G_{x}(t)=\\sum_{k} {{g_{mp,k}(t)g_{mn,k}(t)}\\over\n                {g_{mp,k}(t)+g_{mn,k}(t)}}\\tag{17}$$\n\n$$g_{m,k}(t)=g_{m}\\left(V_{GS,k}(t)\\right)\\tag{18}$$\n\nthe instantaneous large signal, cyclostationary\ntransconductance at the phase of the limit\ncycle.  In particular $v_{k-1}(t)\\ne v_{k}(t)$.\nAt $\\omega \\approx \\omega _{0}$\n\n$$v_{k}(t)=V_{k}(t)+{\\rm Re}\\,{\\hat v}_{k}e^{j\\omega t}\\tag{19}$$\n\n$${\\hat v}_{k-1}={\\hat v}_{k}e^{\\pm j2\\pi /3}\\tag{20}$$\n\nthe three small signal phasors are $120^{o}$\napart and the gate is no longer ${\\cal A}{\\cal C}$\nshorted to the drain.  Putting $s=j\\omega $ in\n(4)\n\n$${\\bf v}={A_{s}(s)\\over {1+A_{v}(s)}}{\\bf 1}v_{x}\n      \\tag{21}$$\n\nfor the common mode, and ${\\bf v}=\n[1+A_{v}^{3}(s)]^{-1}\\cdots v_{x}$ for the\ndifferential mode.  The denominator $1+A_{v}(s)$\nis not $1+A_{v}^{3}(s)$ but e.g.\n\n$$R_{x}(s)={v_{x}\\over I_{x}(s)}\n        ={1\\over {3(g_{mp}+g_{op})}}\n         {{1+A_{v}(s)}\\over {1+A_{v}(s)-A_{s}(s)}}\\tag{22}$$\n$$={1\\over 3}{{g_{o}+sC+g_{mn}+g_{mp}}\\over\n               {(g_{mp}+g_{op})(g_{mn}+g_{on})}}\\tag{23}$$\n\nwhich at $s=j\\omega _{0}$ is complex,\n${\\rm Arg}\\,R_{x}\\approx -60^{o}$, and in the\nsideband picture\n\n$$v_{x}(t)={\\rm Re}\\,{\\hat v}_{x}e^{j(\\omega _{0}+\\Delta \\omega )t}\n      \\tag{24}$$\n\ncreates currents at $\\omega _{0}+\\Delta\\omega\\pm\nn\\omega _{0}$.  I. e. the impedance is a\nharmonic transfer matrix $Z_{mn}(\\Delta\\omega)$,\n$m,n\\in {\\bf Z}$, with frequency conversion.\nIts $0,0$ element for $|\\Delta\\omega|\\ll\n\\omega _{0}$ can exhibit ${\\rm Re}\\,Z<0$ and an\ninductive component because of the active loop.\nThat is the normal Floquet or Hajimiri-Lee\nconversion matrix.  A single real $R_{x}$\nis meaningless at ${\\cal R}{\\cal F}$.\n\nWhat is normally quoted as ``$R_{x}$ while\noscillating'' is either\n\n* (a) the derivative of the {\\it averaged},\n  ${\\cal D}{\\cal C}$, supply current\n\n  $$\\bar I_{x}={1\\over {T_{0}}}\\int_{0}^{T_{0}}I_{x}(t)dt\n        \\approx 3C_{L}V_{DD}f_{0}\\tag{25}$$\n\n  with respect to the ${\\cal D}{\\cal C}$ supply,\n\n  $$R_{x,av}^{-1}={{\\partial \\bar I_{x}}\\over {\\partial V_{DD}}}\n                =\\langle G_{x}(t)\\rangle\n                ={1\\over {T_{0}}}\\int_{0}^{T_{0}}G_{x}(t)dt\n                \\tag{26}$$\n\n  or\n* (b) the $0,0$ element of the conversion\n  matrix at $\\Delta\\omega\\to 0$, i. e. the\n  response to a perturbation $\\omega _{x}\\ll\n  \\omega _{0}$ averaged over many oscillation\n  periods.\n\nIn both cases (12) survives {\\it in form} with\n$g_{m}$ replaced by the effective, conduction\nangle averaged, describing function\ntransconductance,\n\n$$R_{x,av}={1\\over 3}\\left[{1\\over {\\langle g_{mn}\\rangle}}+\n                         {1\\over {\\langle g_{mp}\\rangle}}\\right]\n        ={R_{x,0}\\over \\eta}\\tag{27}$$\n\n$$\\langle g_{m}\\rangle ={1\\over {T_{0}}}\\int_{0}^{T_{0}}\n                       g_{m}(t)dt =\\eta\\,g_{m0}\\tag{28}$$\n\n$\\eta<1$ the duty factor during which the\ninverter is in the high gain crowbar region.\nFor a conventional rail to rail hard switched\nring $\\eta = \\tau _{r,f}/T_{0}\\ll 1$, typically\n$0.1-0.3$, and\n\n$$R_{x,av}\\approx {1\\over \\eta}R_{x,0}\\gg R_{x,0}\\tag{29}$$\n\nIdeally, zero rise-fall time, $\\langle G_{x}\\rangle\n\\to 0$, $R_{x,av}\\to\\infty$ at ${\\cal D}{\\cal C}$.\nNo ${\\cal D}{\\cal C}$ path exists between\n$V_{DD}$ and $GND$ except during the transition:\nfor half the period the PMOS is off, for half\nthe period the NMOS is off,\n\n$$G_{x}(t)\\approx \\cases{\n        g_{mp}\\vert \\vert g_{mn}&{\\rm in\\;transition}\\cr\n        0&{\\rm otherwise}}\\tag{30}$$\n\nso the instantaneous supply sees an open circuit\nabout $1-\\eta$ of the time and ${1/g_{m}}$ about\n$\\eta$ of the time.  For a sinusoidal\ndescribing function approximation\n$v_{k}= (V_{DD}/2)\\cos\\omega _{0}t$,\n$\\langle g_{m}\\rangle = (2/\\pi)g_{m0}$ so that\ne.g.\n\n$$R_{x,av}\\approx {\\pi\\over 2}R_{x,0}\\approx 1.57R_{x,0}\\tag{31}$$\n\nmore generally $1.5-3\\times R_{x,0}$, and\n$\\to\\infty$ for square wave switching.\nIn most hand calculations the factor $\\eta^{-1}$\nis ignored and (12) is still quoted as the\norder of magnitude low frequency averaged supply\npushing resistance.\n\nIn short: the ${\\cal L}{\\cal T}{\\cal I}$ (12)\nis the small signal resistance {\\it about the\nunstable equilibrium with oscillation suppressed}.\nAbout the stable limit cycle the circuit is\n${\\cal L}{\\cal P}{\\cal T}{\\cal V}$; the\ninstantaneous $R_{x}(t)$ is periodically\nmodulated between $R_{x,0}$ and $\\infty$,\nits low frequency time average is (27), a factor\n$1/\\eta={\\cal O}(2-\\infty)$ larger than (12),\nand its ${\\cal R}{\\cal F}$ impedance is a\ncomplex frequency converting impedance with\n${\\rm Re}\\,Z_{x}(\\omega _{0}+\\Delta\\omega)$\nthat can become negative.  To ${\\cal O}(1)$\nthe {\\it form} (12) with $g_{m}\\to\\langle g_{m}\\rangle$\nremains a useful estimate for\n$|s|\\ll\\omega _{0}$ after averaging over\n$T_{0}\\gg 2\\pi/|s|$.  Neglecting the averaging\nthe claim ``each inverter is two diodes in\nseries'' fails because $v_{in}\\ne v_{out}$ when\nthe ring is oscillating.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "f245101809038fb3fd6ceebb6eb2657289598456feca6d2efbbc0b85de84468d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 2,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It recognizes the capacitive average supply-current relation, but ultimately claims the resistance becomes much higher by a factor of 1/η because devices are off much of the cycle. That contradicts the central result that the charging-current relation keeps RX on the order of the MOS on-resistance.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "41b3aba626dbabae7c16266607298d97003b7365b7c8eebf62086ccaef8b74fa",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 6784,
        "output_tokens": 28132,
        "total_tokens": 34916,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 21820,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3392,
        "output_tokens": 14066,
        "total_tokens": 17458,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 10910,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 2,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain as the width of M7 increases?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With ${\\rm S}_{3}{\\rm S}_{4}$ OFF the\nconventional quasi static small signal gain at the\nhigh ${\\cal Z}$ nodes is the normal\n\n$${{A}_{v}}(s)\\approx {{g}_{m1}}{r_{o}}\\approx\n{{g}_{m1}}\\left[ {{g}_{ds1}}+{{g}_{ds3}}+{{g}_{ds5}}\n\\right]^{-1}\\tag{1}$$\n\nso that with the conventional\n\n$${{I}_{T}}\\approx {{I}_{D7}}={{1\\over {2}}}\n{\\mu}_{n}{C_{ox}}{{W_{7}}\\over {L_{7}}}{\\left[\n{V_{GS7}}-{V_{T}}\\right]^{2}}\\tag{2}$$\n\nin strong inversion\n\n$${{g}_{{m1}}}\\approx \\sqrt{2{k_{1}}{{I}_{D1}}}}=\n\\sqrt{{k_{1}}{{I}_{T}}} \\propto \\sqrt{{W_{7}}}\\tag{3}$$\n\nin weak inversion ${{g}_{{m1}}}={{I}_{D1}}/n{V_{T}}\\propto\n{{W}_{7}}$ so that in the normal text book sense\n\n$${{A}_{v}}\\propto {{g}_{{m1}}}\\propto \\sqrt{{{W}_{7}}}\n\\;\\;{\\rm in\\;strong\\;inversion}\\propto {{W}_{7}}\\;\\;\n{\\rm in\\;weak\\;inversion}\\tag{4}$$\n\nin so far as ${{g}_{ds}}\\propto {{I}_{T}}$.\nThat is the ``${{g}_{m}}$ goes up'' statement that is\nnormally quoted.\n\nFor the clocked operation the figure of merit is not\n(1) but the charge that can be integrated on the\nparasitic capacitance ${{C}_{P}}\\approx {{C}_{X}}$ in\nthe time the circuit is allowed to stay in the high\nimpedance amplifying region.  In the normal\nStrongArm timing, Fig.1, with $CK=0$\n${\\rm S}_{1}-{\\rm S}_{4}$ ON, $P,Q,X,Y={V_{DD}}$,\n${\\rm M}_{7}$ OFF.  With $CK:0\\to 1$, ${\\rm S}_{1}-\n{\\rm S}_{4}$ OFF, ${\\rm M}_{7}$ ON, $P$ and $Q$ are\ndischarged through ${\\rm M}_{1}{\\rm M}_{2}$ with\n\n$${{C}_{P}}{{d{{V}_{P,Q}}}\\over {dt}}=-{{I}_{D1,2}}\\tag{5}$$\n\n$${{I}_{D1}}={{I_{T}}\\over 2}+{{1\\over 2}}{{g}_{{m1}}}\n{{v}_{id}}\\qquad {{I}_{D2}}={{I_{T}}\\over 2}-{{1\\over 2}}\n{{g}_{{m1}}}{{v}_{id}} \\tag{6}$$\n\nso that differentially\n\n$${d\\over {dt}}\\left( {{V}_{P}}-{{V}_{Q}}\\right)=\n-{{{{g}_{{m1}}}{{v}_{id}}}\\over {{{C}_{P}}}}\\tag{7}$$\n\nand, for a time ${{T}_{{\\rm int}}}$,\n\n$$\\Delta {{V}_{PQ}}({{T}_{{\\rm int}}})=\n{{{{g}_{{m1}}}{{v}_{id}}{{T}_{{\\rm int}}}}\\over\n{{{C}_{P}}}}\\tag{8}$$\n\ni. e. $q=Cv$ gain\n\n$${{A}_{{\\rm int}}}={{\\Delta {{V}_{PQ}}}\\over {{{v}_{id}}}}\n={{1\\over {{{C}_{P}}}}\\int_{0}^{{{T}_{{\\rm int}}}}\n{{{g}_{{m1}}}dt}\\approx {{{{g}_{{m1}}}{{T}_{{\\rm int}}}}\n\\over {{{C}_{P}}}}\\tag{9}$$\n\n${{T}_{{\\rm int}}}$ is not a free variable.  The\ncircuit stays high ${\\cal Z}$ only until the common\nmode of $P,Q$ has fallen enough to turn ${\\rm\nM}_{3}{\\rm M}_{4}$ on, $\\Delta {{V}_{CM}}\\approx\n{{V}_{TN}}$, and then until the common mode of $X,Y$\nhas fallen enough to turn ${\\rm M}_{5}{\\rm M}_{6}$ on,\n$\\Delta {{V}_{CM}}\\approx \\left| {{V}_{TP}}\\right|$.\nTo first order\n\n$${{T}_{1}}\\approx {{{{C}_{P}}{{V}_{TN}}}\\over\n{{{I}_{T}}/2}}\\qquad {{T}_{2}}-{{T}_{1}}\\approx\n{{{{C}_{X}}\\left| {{V}_{TP}}\\right|}\\over {{{I}_{T}}/2}}\n\\tag{10}$$\n\nso that, e. {\\rm g.} at the moment ${\\rm M}_{3}$ turns\non,\n\n$${{A}_{{\\rm int}}}({{T}_{1}})\\approx\n{{{{g}_{{m1}}}}\\over {{{C}_{P}}}}{{2{{C}_{P}}{{V}_{TN}}}\n\\over {{{I}_{T}}}}=2{{V}_{TN}}{{{{g}_{{m1}}}}\\over\n{{{I}_{T}}}}\\tag{11}$$\n\nand with (3) in square law strong inversion\n${{g}_{{m}1}}=2{{I}_{D1}}/{{V}_{ov1}}={{I}_{T}}/\n{{V}_{ov1}}$\n\n$${{A}_{{\\rm int}}}({{T}_{1}})\\approx\n2{{{{V}_{TN}}}\\over {{{V}_{ov1}}}}\\tag{12}$$\n\n$${{V}_{ov1}}=\\sqrt{{{2{{I}_{D1}}}\\over {{k_{1}}}}}\\propto\n\\sqrt{{{I}_{T}}}\\propto \\sqrt{{{W}_{7}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nIn weak inversion ${{g}_{{m1}}}/{{I}_{T}}=1/n{{V}_{T}}=\n{\\rm const}$ and\n\n$${{A}_{{\\rm int}}}({{T}_{1}})\\approx {{{{V}_{TN}}}\\over\n{n{{V}_{T}}}}={\\rm const.}\\tag{14}$$\n\nMore completely, including the ${\\rm M}_{3}{\\rm M}_{4}$\npositive feedback between ${{T}_{1}}$ and ${{T}_{2}}$,\nRazavi, JSSC 92,\n\n$$\\Delta {{V}_{XY}}({{T}_{2}})\\approx \\Delta\n{{V}_{PQ}}({{T}_{1}})\\exp \\left[ {{{{T}_{2}}-{{T}_{1}}}\n\\over {{{\\tau }_{{\\rm reg}}}}}\\right]\\tag{15}$$\n\n$${{\\tau }_{{\\rm reg}}}\\approx {{{{C}_{X}}}\\over\n{{{g}_{{m3}}}}}\\propto 1/\\sqrt{{{I}_{T}}}$$\n\n$${{A}_{{\\rm int}}}({{T}_{2}})\\approx\n{{{{g}_{{m1}}}}\\over {{{g}_{{m3}}}}}\\;\n{\\rm or}\\;2{{{{V}_{TN}}}\\over {{{V}_{ov1}}}}\\;\n{{{{V}_{TP}}}\\over {{{V}_{ov3}}}}\\;{\\rm etc.}\\tag{16}$$\n\ni. e. the normal $1/{{V}_{ov}}\\propto 1/\\sqrt{{{I}_{T}}}$\nvoltage gain.  The ${\\rm dc}$ ${{g}_{m}}{{r}_{o}}$ goes\nup with ${{I}_{T}}$ but the integration time (10) goes\ndown $\\propto 1/{{I}_{T}}$ and, because\n\n$${{T}_{{\\rm int}}}\\propto 1/{{I}_{T}}\\qquad\n{{g}_{{m}}}\\propto \\sqrt{{{I}_{T}}}\\;\\;{\\rm s.i.}\\;\n\\propto {{I}_{T}}\\;\\;{\\rm w.i.}\\tag{17}$$\n\n$${{A}_{{\\rm int}}}\\propto {{{{g}_{m}}{{T}_{{\\rm int}}}}\n\\over C}\\propto {{{{g}_{m}}}\\over {{{I}_{T}}}}\\propto\n\\cases{\n{\\rm const.}&w. i.\\cr\n1/\\sqrt{{{I}_{T}}}\\propto 1/\\sqrt{{{W}_{7}}}&s. i.\\cr}\\tag{18}$$\n\nIn words: in weak/moderate inversion the useful\npre-regeneration, offset determining, ``initial'' gain is\nto first order independent of the tail device size; in\nconventional strong inversion sizing it falls as\n$1/\\sqrt{{W_{7}}}$, $1/{{V}_{ov1}}$.  The curve is\nvery flat, it exhibits a shallow maximum for a small\ntail device, ${{V}_{ov1}}\\approx 0.1-0.2\\,{\\rm V}$, and\nthen falls monotonically.  If ${\\rm M}_{7}$ is made so\nwide that ${\\rm M}_{1}{\\rm M}_{2}$ - and then ${\\rm\nM}_{3}{\\rm M}_{4}$ - are driven into the triode region\nbefore ${\\rm M}_{5}{\\rm M}_{6}$ can turn on, ${{r}_{o}}$\ncollapses and ${{A}_{{\\rm int}}}\\to 0$.  Neglecting the\n${{T}_{{\\rm int}}}\\propto 1/{{I}_{T}}$ factor this is\nnormally quoted simply as (4), ${{A}_{v}}\\propto\n\\sqrt{{W_{7}}}$, ${{A}_{v}}\\propto {W_{7}}$ in weak\ninversion.\n\nThe total latch gain after the regeneration interval\n${{T}_{ev}}$\n\n$${{G}_{{\\rm tot}}}({{T}_{ev}})\\approx {{A}_{{\\rm int}}}\n\\exp \\left[ {{{{T}_{ev}}-{{T}_{{\\rm int}}}}\\over\n{{{\\tau }_{{\\rm reg}}}}}\\right]\\qquad \n{{\\tau }_{{\\rm reg}}}\\approx C/{{g}_{m,{\\rm latch}}}\n\\propto 1/\\sqrt{{{W}_{7}}}\\tag{19}$$\n\ncan still increase with ${{W}_{7}}$ because\n${{\\tau }_{{\\rm reg}}}$ shrinks, i. e. the usual\nspeed - offset, ${{A}_{{\\rm int}}}-{{\\tau }_{{\\rm\nreg}}}$, trade-off: wide ${\\rm M}_{7}$ is fast, narrow\n${\\rm M}_{7}$ is sensitive, low offset.  With\n${{T}_{{\\rm int}}}$ neglected this is quoted as\n``the initial - low frequency - gain increases with\n${{W}_{7}}$''.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In many text books the\n> ${{T}_{{\\rm int}}}$ shortening is neglected and (1) is\n> quoted as the ``initial gain'' : ${{A}_{v0}}\\approx\n> {{g}_{{m1}}}{{r}_{o1}}|\\,|{{r}_{o3}}|\\,|{{r}_{o5}}\\propto\n> {{g}_{{m1}}}\\propto \\sqrt{{W_{7}}}$, $\\propto {W_{7}}$\n> sub-threshold, i. e. widening ${\\rm M}_{7}$ nominally\n> increases the small signal gain until velocity\n> saturation/sub-threshold is reached.  The clocked,\n> integrating, offset setting gain (9)--(12) does the\n> opposite.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "9be485a8aee2f23dde22af5600de795f0fd29e2d7a7b7c21b4d8f30082796d25"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies that the clocked, pre-regeneration gain scales roughly as gm/IT and falls with increasing M7 width in strong inversion. However, it also makes a contradictory claim that the initial gain increases in a quasi-static interpretation, and its weak-inversion qualification makes the overall answer less consistent with the requested trend.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3be19d840ea0028f994c70cfd93497080016f88968540a82c98a00f03980212f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4062,
        "output_tokens": 10817,
        "total_tokens": 14879,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8145,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4062,
        "output_tokens": 10817,
        "total_tokens": 14879,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8145,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain as the width of M7 increases?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the Long Chanel, square law, ${\\rm sat.}$\napproximation the circuit can be reduced for\n${\\rm CK}=1$ to the ${\\rm n}$ - channel pair ${\\rm M1-M2}$\nloaded by the ${\\rm n}$ - chanel latch ${\\rm M3-M4}$,\n${\\rm M5-M6}$ is {\\it off}, $C_{P}$ is the capacity at\n$P,Q$, $C_{X}$ the capacity at $X,Y$, Fig.1,\n\n$${\\rm M1:}\\;\\;i_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{i1}+g_{d1}(v_{P}-v_{S})$$\n$${\\rm M3:}\\;\\;i_{d3}=g_{m3}(v_{Y}-v_{P})+g_{d3}(v_{X}-v_{P}) \\tag{*}$$\n\netc.  For the differential half circuit $v_{S}\\approx 0$\nfor ${\\rm M7}$ a good ${\\rm C.S.}$\n\n$${{v_{x}}\\over {v_{i}}}{\\Bigl |}_{0}\\approx\n{{g_{m1}}\\over {g_{d1}+g_{d3}+g_{d5}}}=\n{{2}\\over {(\\lambda _{n}+\\lambda _{p})V_{ov1}}}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$V_{ov1}=V_{GS1}-V_{T}= \\sqrt{{{2I_{D1}}\\over\n{\\mu _{n}C_{ox}W_{1}/L_{1}}}} \\tag{2}$$\n\n$$I_{D1}\\approx {\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}I_{T}\\qquad \nI_{T}= {\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}\\mu _{n}C_{ox}{{W_{7}}\\over {L_{7}}}\n\\left( V_{CK}-V_{T}-V_{S}\\right)^{2}\\;\\;{\\rm sat.}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$${{W_{7}}\\!\\uparrow}\\;\\; I_{T}\\!\\uparrow\\;\\;V_{ov1}\\!\\uparrow\n\\;\\;A_{v0}\\!\\downarrow \\tag{4}$$\n\nand, e. {\\it g.} in the conventional ``integrating''\npicture, with ${\\rm M3-M4}$ {\\it off} for\n$0<t<t_{1}$,\n\n$$C_{P}{{dV_{P}}\\over {dt}}=-I_{D1}\\qquad \nC_{P}{{d\\Delta V_{P}}\\over {dt}}=-g_{m1}\\Delta V_{i} \\tag{5}$$\n\n$$\\Delta V_{P}(t)=-{{g_{m1}\\Delta V_{i}}\\over {C_{P}}}\\,t \\tag{6}$$\n\nSo that at the moment $t_{1}$ at which $V_{P}=V_{DD}-\nV_{Tn}$ and ${\\rm M3-M4}$ come on\n\n$$t_{1}\\approx {{C_{P}V_{Tn}}\\over {I_{0}}}\\qquad \nI_{0}={\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}I_{T} \\tag{7}$$\n\n$$\\Delta V_{P1}= {{g_{m1}V_{Tn}}\\over {I_{0}}}\\Delta V_{i}\n= {{2V_{Tn}}\\over {V_{ov1}}}\\Delta V_{i}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$$G_{P}\\equiv {{\\Delta V_{P1}}\\over {\\Delta V_{i}}}=\n{{2V_{Tn}}\\over {V_{ov1}}}\\propto I_{T}^{-1/2}\\propto\nW_{7}^{-1/2}\\;\\;{\\rm l.ch.}\\tag{9}$$\n$$\\propto W_{7}^{-1}\\;\\;{\\rm w.i.}\\tag{9a}$$\n\nFor $t_{1}<t<t_{2}$ the same thing happens at $X,Y$,\n\n$$C_{X}{{d\\Delta V_{X}}\\over {dt}}\\approx -g_{m1}^{\\ast}\n\\Delta V_{i}\\tag{10}$$\n\n$$t_{2}-t_{1}\\approx {{C_{X}V_{Tp}}\\over {I_{0}}}\\tag{11}$$\n\nand, to within a factor of order unity,\n\n$$\\Delta V_{X2}\\approx \n{{g_{m1}^{\\ast}\\left( t_{2}-t_{1}\\right)}\\over {C_{X}}}\n\\Delta V_{i}+ \\Delta V_{P1}\\approx \n\\left[{{g_{m1}^{\\ast}V_{Tp}}\\over {I_{0}}}+\n{{g_{m1}V_{Tn}}\\over {I_{0}}}\\right]\\Delta V_{i} \\tag{12}$$\n\ni. e. the large signal differential voltage that is\npresented to the back to back inverters ${\\rm M3-M6}$\nwhen the ${\\rm p}$ - channel cross coupled pair comes\non,\n\n$$G_{0}\\equiv {{\\Delta V_{X2}}\\over {\\Delta V_{i}}}\n\\approx {{V^{\\ast}}\\over {V_{ov1}}}\\propto \n{{g_{m1}}\\over {I_{T}}}\\propto \nI_{T}^{-1/2}\\propto W_{7}^{-1/2}\\tag{13}$$\n\nIn the velocity saturated, short chanel limit\n$g_{m1}\\propto W_{1}$ , $I_{T}\\propto W_{7}$,\n\n$$G_{0}\\propto W_{7}^{0}\\tag{14}$$\n\nmore generally $G_{0}\\propto W_{7}^{-1/4\\div 1/2}$.\nIf the output resistance in (1) is artificially kept\nconstant\n\n$$|A_{v0}|\\propto g_{m1}\\propto \\sqrt{I_{T}}\\propto\n\\sqrt{W_{7}}\\;\\;{\\rm s.i.}\\tag{15}$$\n$$\\propto I_{T}\\propto W_{7}\\;\\;{\\rm w.i.}\\tag{15a}$$\n\nis the conventional low frequency, small signal voltage\ngain.  In words: the ${\\rm a.c.}$ $g_{m}R_{0}$ gain\nformally goes up as $\\sqrt{W_{7}}$, $W_{7}$ in weak\ninversion, while the time the circuit has to integrate\nthat $g_{m}$ on $C_{P},C_{X}$ goes down as\n$1/I_{T}$.  The net, usable, dynamic or integrating\ngain handed to the regenerative latch goes as\n$g_{m}T_{int}/C\\propto g_{m}/I_{T}\\propto 1/V_{ov1}$,\ni. e. to first order it is independent of the tail\ncurrent and to second order it falls as $W_{7}^{-1/2}$,\n$W_{7}^{-1}$ in weak inversion.\n\nWith the finite headroom included the $G_{0}(W_{7})$\ncurve is ${\\rm n}$ - shaped.  For a very narrow\n${\\rm M7}$ the common source node $S$ sits high,\n$V_{ov1}$ is small but ${\\rm M1-M2}$ hit the triode\nregion after a very small drop of $V_{P,Q}$ and (9)\n(13) collapse.  Widening ${\\rm M7}$ pulls $S$ down,\n${\\rm M1-M2}$ stay saturated for the whole\n$V_{Tn}+V_{Tp}$ swing and $G_{0}$ rises a little to a\nbroad maximum, typically a few times $(W_{7})_{\\min}$,\nand then follows (9)(13), i. e. falls as\n$W_{7}^{-1/2}$, more or less flat in the fully\nvelocity saturated limit.  Once ${\\rm M7}$ itself is\ndriven into the triode region $I_{T}$ ceases to go as\n$W_{7}$, $R_{T}=1/g_{d7}$ collapses, the differential\ntail ceases to be a virtual ground and (1)(9)(13) fall\nmuch more rapidly.  To within the usual engineering\naccuracy the circuit is normally operated at or beyond\nthe maximum and the statement is normally abbreviated\nto: to first order the initial, integrating gain is\nindependent of $W_{7}$, in normal design it goes\nweakly down with $W_{7}$.  With $R_{0}=$ const. the\ntext book $A_{v0}=g_{m1}R_{0}$ of course goes as\n(15).\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  In the conventional square law notation\n> the textbook small signal gain (1) is often quoted\n> simply as $A_{v0}\\propto g_{m1}\\propto \\sqrt{W_{7}}$.\n> That is the $R_{0}=$ const. form of (15).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ca252753269945787803410fb7624ee566c60a4a761dde06e038579d7a1d50e2"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It identifies that a wider M7 raises tail current and reduces the usable integrating gain through the lower gm/ICM ratio, concluding that the gain is weakly lower in normal operation. Its small-signal and operating-range caveats do not change that central conclusion.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3be19d840ea0028f994c70cfd93497080016f88968540a82c98a00f03980212f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 3939,
        "input_tokens": 4062,
        "output_tokens": 11943,
        "total_tokens": 16005,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9800,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 3939,
        "input_tokens": 4062,
        "output_tokens": 11943,
        "total_tokens": 16005,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9800,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 7,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain as the width of M7 increases?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-007-initial-voltage-gain-as-width-m7-increases/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the (square law) counting the circuit is\nessentially a ${\\rm G}_{m}\\int {\\rm d}t/{\\rm C}$ amplifier\n\n$${\\rm G}_{0}={{g_{m1,2}T_{a}}\\over {{\\rm C}_{{\\rm X,Y}}}}\n\\tag {*}$$\n\n$T_{a}$ is the time that you have to integrate on\n${\\rm C}_{{\\rm X,Y}}$ before the $n$ - latch, ${\\rm M}_{3}\n{\\rm -M}_{4}$, and the $p$ - latch, ${\\rm M}_{5}{\\rm\n-M}_{6}$, can take over.  In reset, ${\\rm CK}=0$,\n${\\rm S}_{1}\\dots {\\rm S}_{4}$ on, $P\\approx Q\\approx\nX\\approx Y\\approx V_{DD}$.  ${\\rm M}_{1}{\\rm -M}_{4}$ are\noff.  Put ${\\rm CK}=1$, ${\\rm M}_{7}$ saturated\n\n$${\\rm I}_{T}\\approx {1\\over 2}\\mu _{n}{\\rm C}_{ox}\n{W_{7}\\over {\\rm L}_{7}}\\left(V_{DD}-V_{T}\\right)^{2}\n\\propto W_{7}\\tag{1}$$\n\nat $t=0^{+}$ ${\\rm X,Y}$ stay at $V_{DD}$ and\n$P,Q$ are discharged with\n\n$${{\\rm d}V_{P,Q}\\over {\\rm d}t}=-{{\\rm I}_{D1,2}\\over\n{\\rm C}_{P}}\\qquad {\\rm I}_{D1,2}\\approx {\\rm I}_{T}/2 \\tag{2}$$\n\nso that, for a differential input $\\Delta V_{i}$,\n\n$$\\Delta V_{P,Q}(t)={{g_{m1,2}\\Delta V_{i}}\\over \n{\\rm C}_{P}}t \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${\\rm M}_{3}{\\rm -M}_{4}$$ get ${\\rm V}_{GS}>0$ when\n$P$($Q$) has fallen by $|V_{Tn}|$,\n\n$$T_{1}\\approx {{{\\rm C}_{P}|V_{Tn}|}\\over {{\\rm I}_{D1,2}}}\n\\propto {1\\over {\\rm I}_{T}}\\propto {1\\over W_{7}} \\tag{4}$$\n\nand, for $t>T_{1}$, $X,Y$ are discharged through\n${\\rm M}_{1}{\\rm -M}_{3}$ and ${\\rm M}_{2}{\\rm -M}_{4}$\nwith, to first order,\n\n$$\\Delta V_{XY}(t)\\approx {{g_{m1,2}\\Delta V_{i}}\\over\n{\\rm C}_{X}}(t-T_{1})\\tag{5}$$\n\nRegeneration can start when $\\Delta V_{XY}\\sim V_{Tp}$\nor, in any case, after a time\n\n$$T_{a}\\approx T_{1}+{{{\\rm C}_{X}|V_{Tp}|}\\over \n{\\rm I}_{D1,2}}\\propto {1\\over {\\rm I}_{T}} \\tag{6}$$\n\nSo that the differential voltage that is presented\nto the back to back inverters ${\\rm M}_{3}{\\rm -M}_{6}$\nat the moment they go into the high gain region is,\nfrom (*) (5) (6),\n\n$${\\rm G}_{0}={{\\Delta V_{XY}(T_{a})}\\over {\\Delta V_{i}}}\n\\approx {{g_{m1,2}T_{a}}\\over {\\rm C}_{X}}\n\\approx {{g_{m1,2}}\\over {{\\rm I}_{T}}}{{{\\rm C}_{X}|V_{T}|\n+{\\rm C}_{P}|V_{T}|}\\over {\\rm C}_{X}} \\tag{7}$$\n\nFor a conventional square law ${\\rm M}_{1,2}$ in saturation\n\n$$g_{m1,2}= \\sqrt{2\\mu _{n}{\\rm C}_{ox}{W_{1}\\over\n{\\rm L}_{1}}{\\rm I}_{D1}}\\propto \\sqrt{{\\rm I}_{T}}\n\\propto \\sqrt{W_{7}} \\tag{8}$$\n\n$${\\rm G}_{0}\\propto {{g_{m1,2}}\\over {{\\rm I}_{T}}}\n\\propto {1\\over {\\sqrt{{\\rm I}_{T}}}}\\propto\n{1\\over {\\sqrt{W_{7}}}}\\tag{9}$$\n\ni. e. $g_{m}$ goes up as $\\sqrt{W_{7}}$ but the time\nyou have to use it goes down as $1/W_{7}$.  E.G.\n\n> {\\it double $W_{7}$ $\\rightarrow$ ${\\rm I}_{T}\\times 2$,\n> $g_{m}\\times 1.4$, $T_{a}/2$, net sampled gain\n> $/1.4$.}\n\nFormally the ordinary small signal voltage gain of the\ncascode ${\\rm M}_{1}{\\rm -M}_{3}$,\n\n$${\\rm A}_{v0}={{g_{m1}}\\over {g_{ds1}+g_{ds3}+g_{m3}}}\\approx\n{{g_{m1}}\\over {g_{ds1}}}\\approx {2\\over {\\lambda V_{ov1}}}\n\\propto {1\\over {\\sqrt{{\\rm I}_{D1}}}}\\propto {1\\over\n{\\sqrt{W_{7}}}} \\tag{10}$$\n\nalso falls as ${\\rm I}_{T}^{-1/2}$.\n\nIn a modern velocity saturated short channel technology\n\n$$g_{m}\\approx W_{1}{\\rm C}_{ox}v_{sat}\\propto {\\rm I}_{D}$$\n\nso that $g_{m}/{\\rm I}_{T}={\\rm const.}$ and (7) becomes\nto first order independent of $W_{7}$,\n\n$${\\rm G}_{0}\\approx {{v_{sat}{\\rm C}_{ox}W_{1}}\\over\n{{\\rm I}_{T}}}T_{a}\\approx {\\rm const.}\\tag{11}$$\n\nIn no case do you {\\it gain} (sampled) voltage gain\nby widening the tail device.  The text book shorthand\nis often quoted as\n\n> {\\it The (dynamic) voltage gain of the Strong ARM is,\n> to first order, independent of the tail current.  With\n> square law counting it falls as $W_{7}^{-1/2}$.}\n\nWhat you gain by $W_{7}\\uparrow $ is speed,\n$latch$ time\n\n$$T_{latch}\\propto {{\\rm C}_{XY}\\over {g_{m3,5}}}\\log\n{{\\Delta V_{logic}}\\over {\\Delta V_{XY}(T_{a})}}$$\n\nat the expense of pre amplifier gain, input referred\noffset\n\n$$V_{os}\\propto {\\rm G}_{0}^{-1}\\propto \\sqrt{W_{7}}$$\n\ninput referred noise, power, clock loading and kick back.\nIf the ${\\rm M}_{1,2}$ current is made large enough to\ndrive ${\\rm M}_{1,2}$ into the triode region at $T_{a}$,\n${\\rm G}_{0}$ collapses even faster.  There is an optimum\n$W_{7}$ for minimum $V_{os}$.\n\nIf by ${\\rm A}_{v}$ you mean the conventional LTI\n${\\rm A}_{v}=g_{m}r_{o}$ with $r_{o}$ held fixed,\n${\\rm A}_{v}\\propto g_{m}\\propto \\sqrt{W_{7}}$ naively\n{\\it increases} as $\\sqrt{W_{7}}$.  The quantity that is\nnormally quoted as the {\\it initial}, {\\it pre amp.} or\n{\\it integration} gain of the Strong ARM, Eq.(*), is the\ndecreasing, at best flat, function (9) (11).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "a225f2263384c728ed515c69d09900a423e48bd370be80efda12ac88d8fcad13"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly concludes that increasing M7 width lowers the initial integration gain: tail current rises while the integration time falls, and under square-law operation the net gain scales approximately as 1/√W7. The short-channel caveat is secondary and does not undermine the main answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "3be19d840ea0028f994c70cfd93497080016f88968540a82c98a00f03980212f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4062,
        "output_tokens": 8687,
        "total_tokens": 12749,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6764,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4062,
        "output_tokens": 8687,
        "total_tokens": 12749,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6764,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "In the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain if we increase the capacitance at nodes P and Q?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In a conventional reset it is the so called\n{\\it Strong Arm} latch, Fig.1 in\n\n\\vbox{\\ninerm J. Montanaro {\\it et al.} {\\it A $160{\\rm MHz}$\n$32{\\rm b}\\;0.5{\\rm W}$ CMOS RISC microprocessor},\n{\\ninerm ISSCC 1996} }\n\n\\vbox{\\ninerm\nT. Kobayashi {\\it et al.} {\\it A current controlled latch sense\namplifier and a static power saving input buffer for low power\narchitecture}, {\\ninerm JSSC 28, 523 1993 }}\n\nIt can be considered as a dynamic\n$T_{int}$ integrator followed by a regenerative latch.\nWith $CK=0$ $M_{7}$ is off and $S_{1}-S_{4}$ put\n\n$$V_{P}=V_{Q}=V_{X}=V_{Y}=V_{DD}\\tag{1}$$\n\nWith $CK\\uparrow $ $M_{7}$ goes on with\n\n$$I_{T}=I_{1}+I_{2}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$S_{1}-S_{4}$ go off.  For\n\n$$0<t<t_{1}\\qquad |V_{GS3}|\\approx |V_{GS4}|\\approx 0\\tag{3}$$\n\n$X$ and $Y$ stay at ${{V_{DD}}}$ on the ${\\rm C}_{x}=\nC_{X}=C_{Y}$ and $P$ and $Q$ integrate the signal\ncurrent of $M_{1}-M_{2}$ on the ${{C_{p}}=C_{P}=C_{Q}}$,\n\n$$C_{p}{\\dot V}_{P}=-I_{1}\\qquad C_{p}{\\dot V}_{Q}=-I_{2}\n\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$V_{P}=V_{DD}-I_{1}t/C_{p}\\qquad V_{Q}=V_{DD}-I_{2}t/C_{p}\n\\tag{5}$$\n\nso that for a differential signal\n\n$$I_{1}-I_{2}=g_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}\\tag{6}$$\n\n$$\\Delta V_{PQ}(t)=V_{P}-V_{Q}=-g_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}t/C_{p}\n\\tag{7}$$\n\nis the usual $g_{m}/sC_{p}$ integrator.\nIn small signal language\n\n$${\\cal A}_{p}(s)={{g_{m1}}\\over{sC_{p}}}\\parallel r_{o1}\\qquad\n\\omega _{p}={1\\over {r_{o1}C_{p}}}\\qquad\n{\\rm GBW}={g_{m1}\\over {C_{p}}}\\tag{8}$$\n\nand for a fixed integration time $T_{{\\rm int}}$\n\n$${\\cal A}_{1}=g_{m1}T_{{\\rm int}}/C_{p}\\propto 1/C_{p}\\tag{9}$$\n\nis the ''initial'' or ''pre amplification'' gain, bandwidth\n$\\propto 1/C_{p}$.\n\nIn normal operation $T_{{\\rm int}}$ is not fixed.  $M_{3}$\nwith $V_{G}=V_{Y}$, $V_{S}=V_{P}$ and $M_{4}$ with\n$V_{G}=V_{X}$, $V_{S}=V_{Q}$ stay off until\n\n$$V_{P}(t_{1})=V_{Q}(t_{1})=V_{DD}-V_{Tn}\\tag{10}$$\n\ni. {\\it e.}\n\n$$t_{1}=C_{p}V_{Tn}/I_{cm}\\qquad I_{cm}=I_{T}/2 \\tag{11}$$\n\nlinearly increasing with $C_{p}$ and\n\n$$\\Delta V_{PQ}(t_{1})=-{{g_{m1}V_{Tn}}\\over{I_{cm}}}\\Delta V_{in}\n\\tag{12}$$\n\n$${\\cal A}_{1}={{\\Delta V_{PQ}(t_{1})}\\over{\\Delta V_{in}}}=\n{{g_{m1}V_{Tn}}\\over{I_{cm}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nnominally $C_{p}$ independent {\\it at the trip point}.\nIn normal text book language the ''initial gain'' is\n$C_{p}$ independent to first order.\n\nFor $t>t_{1}$ put, for the increments,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nC_{p}\\dot v_{p}&=-g_{m1}v_{in1}+g_{m3}(v_{y}-v_{p})\\cr\nC_{p}\\dot v_{q}&=-g_{m1}v_{in2}+g_{m3}(v_{x}-v_{q})\\cr\nC_{x}\\dot v_{x}&=-g_{m3}(v_{y}-v_{p})\\cr\nC_{x}\\dot v_{y}&=-g_{m3}(v_{x}-v_{q})\\cr}\\tag{14}$$\n\nwith $g_{m3}=g_{m4}$.  For the differential quantities\n$\\Delta v_{p}=v_{p}-v_{q}$, $\\Delta v_{x}=v_{x}-v_{y}$,\n$\\Delta v_{in}=v_{in1}-v_{in2}$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nC_{p}\\Delta \\dot v_{p}&=-g_{m1}\\Delta v_{in}-g_{m3}\n\\left(\\Delta v_{p}+\\Delta v_{x}\\right)\\cr\nC_{x}\\Delta \\dot v_{x}&=+g_{m3}\\left(\\Delta v_{p}+\\Delta v_{x}\n\\right)\\cr}\\tag{15}$$\n\nPut $S=\\Delta v_{p}+\\Delta v_{x}$,\n\n$$\\dot S-{{g_{m3}}\\over{C_{x}}}{{C_{p}-C_{x}}\\over{C_{p}}}S=\n-{{g_{m1}}\\over{C_{p}}}\\Delta v_{in}\\tag{16}$$\n\n$$a=g_{m3}\\left({1\\over{C_{x}}}-{1\\over{C_{p}}}\\right) \\tag{17}$$\n\n$$S(t)=\\left[S(t_{1})+b/a\\right]e^{a(t-t_{1})}-b/a\\tag{18}$$\n\n$$b=-g_{m1}\\Delta v_{in}/C_{p}\\qquad S(t_{1})=\\Delta V_{PQ}(t_{1})\n\\tag{19}$$\n\n$$C_{x}\\Delta \\dot v_{x}=g_{m3}S\\tag{20}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$\\Delta v_{x}(t)={{g_{m3}}\\over{C_{x}}}\\int_{t_{1}}^{t}S(t')dt'\n\\tag{21}$$\n\nFor $C_{p}\\gg C_{x}$, $a\\approx g_{m3}/C_{x}>0$ and\n\n$$S(t)\\approx S(t_{1})e^{g_{m3}(t-t_{1})/C_{x}}\\tag{22}$$\n\n$$\\Delta v_{x}(t)\\approx S(t_{1})\\left[e^{g_{m3}(t-t_{1})/C_{x}}-1\n\\right]\\tag{23}$$\n\nthe normal regenerative exponential with\n\n$$\\tau _{n}=C_{x}/g_{m3}\\tag{24}$$\n\nFor $C_{p}\\approx C_{x}$, $a\\approx 0$,\n\n$$S(t)\\approx S(t_{1})-g_{m1}\\Delta v_{in}(t-t_{1})/C_{p}\\tag{25}$$\n\n$$\\Delta v_{x}(t)\\approx {{g_{m3}}\\over{C_{x}}}S(t_{1})(t-t_{1})\n\\tag{26}$$\n\nIn either case if the circuit is allowed to go to the\nsecond trip point where\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{X}(t_{2})&=V_{Y}(t_{2})=V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|\\cr\nt_{2}-t_{1}&\\approx C_{x}|V_{Tp}|/I_{cm}\\cr}\\tag{27}$$\n\nwhen $M_{5}-M_{6}$ go on, the voltage that has been\ndeveloped differentially at $X-Y$ at $t=t_{2}$, {\\it i. e.} the\nnormally quoted {\\it available} small signal gain before the\nPMOS latch regenerates, is, to first order,\n\n$${\\cal A}_{2}={{g_{m3}(t_{2}-t_{1})}\\over{C_{x}}}=\n{{g_{m3}|V_{Tp}|}\\over{I_{cm}}}\\tag{28}$$\n\nagain $C_{x}$ independent, so that the total nominal\npre regenerative gain\n\n$${\\cal A}_{0}={\\cal A}_{1}{\\cal A}_{2}\\approx\n{{g_{m1}V_{Tn}}\\over{I_{cm}}}{{g_{m3}|V_{Tp}|}\\over{I_{cm}}}\n\\tag{29}$$\n\nin the $a\\to 0$ linear limit and\n\n$${\\cal A}_{0}\\propto {{g_{m1}V_{Tn}}\\over{I_{cm}}}\n\\exp \\left[{{g_{m3}|V_{Tp}|}\\over{I_{cm}}}\n\\left(1-{{C_{x}}\\over{C_{p}}}\\right)\\right]\\tag{30}$$\n\nin the $C_{p}\\gg C_{x}$ exponential limit, is nominally\nindependent of $C_{p},C_{x}$ and depends only on\n$g_{m}/I$ and $V_{T}$.  The $C_{p}$ dependence in (30) is\n\n$${\\cal A}_{0}(C_{p})\\propto \n\\exp \\left[{{g_{m3}|V_{Tp}|}\\over{I_{cm}}}{{C_{x}}\\over{C_{p}}}\n\\right]^{-1}\\tag{31}$$\n\nmonotonically increasing with $C_{p}$, $\\to \\exp\n\\left[g_{m3}|V_{Tp}|/I_{cm}\\right]$ for $C_{p}\\gg C_{x}$,\n$\\to 1$ for $C_{p}=C_{x}$, {\\it i. e.} a very weak,\nlogarithmic increase of the available trip point voltage\nwith added $C_{p}$.\n\nWhat does increase linearly with $C_{p}$ is the time\nneeded to get there, (11), and the pole frequency (8)\nmoves down as $1/C_{p}$.  The gain band width product\n\n$${\\rm GBW}_{p}=g_{m1}/C_{p}\\tag{32}$$\n\ngoes as $1/C_{p}$.  For a given clock frequency, {\\it i. e.}\nfor fixed $T_{{\\rm int}}$, (9) the usable initial\nintegration gain goes as $1/C_{p}$, the $-3{\\rm dB}$\nband width goes as $1/C_{p}$ and the decision delay\n\n$$T_{d}\\approx t_{1}+(t_{2}-t_{1})+\\tau_{0}\\ln {{V_{DD}}\\over\n{\\Delta V_{X}(t_{2})}}\\tag{33}$$\n\n$$\\tau_{0}^{-1}\\approx {{g_{m3}}\\over{C_{x}}}+{{g_{m5}}\\over{C_{x}}}\n\\tag{34}$$\n\ngoes up $\\propto C_{p}$.  In everyday language: you\nlose speed, you lose gain per unit time and you increase\nthe $kT/C_{p}$, clock feed through $C_{gd}/C_{p}$ and\n$C_{p}$ mismatch $\\Delta C_{p}/C_{p}$ offset for\npractically no increase in DC trip point voltage.\n\nThat is why in text books the statement is normally\nshortened to: {\\it the initial $g_{m}/C$ gain goes down as\n$1/C_{p}$}, or, with the trip point definition, {\\it the\ninitial gain is to first order $C_{p}$ independent and any\nadded $C_{p}$ just slows the comparator}.  If you insist\non waiting until $M_{5}-M_{6}$ switch, the small signal\nvoltage that is present at $X-Y$ at that instant does go\nup slowly with $C_{p}$ as (30)–(31), which is sometimes\nused intentionally, $5-20{\\rm fF}$ at $P-Q$, to get a few\n${\\rm dB}$ more pre amp. gain and less kick back at the\nexpense of $C_{p}V_{T}/I_{T}$ more delay.  The conventional\nway to cure it is the double tail or Elzakker latch which\nisolates $C_{p}$ from $C_{x}$.  Cf. any text on the\nStrong Arm latch, {\\it e. g.} Razavi, {\\it Design of Analog\nCMOS Integrated Circuits}, Chap. 12.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "9476c59879cea0c7799a5e56627908cf00ea271c57619ab0a3f357fe3be78d7d"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly explains that larger node capacitance lengthens the integration interval in proportion, canceling its effect on the accumulated P–Q differential gain at the onset of regeneration. It also notes the increased delay; the later-stage gain discussion does not change the answer for the initial gain.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "181f6e0ce2e77c4df0e1602f9ce1b8891080eeecdff293462f41c7d6d66c5590",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 16798,
        "total_tokens": 20859,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13749,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 16798,
        "total_tokens": 20859,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13749,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "In the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain if we increase the capacitance at nodes P and Q?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "At the transition it is a\n$${g_{m}VT^{-1}}$$\nintegrator.  In the familiar piece wise linear\npicture, Fig. 12.20 of Razavi, with ${\\rm CK}=0$\n\n$$V_{P,Q}=V_{X,Y}=V_{DD}\\tag{reset}$$\n\n$$M_{7}={\\rm OFF}\\qquad S_{1-4}={\\rm ON}$$\n\nwith ${\\rm CK}=1$\n\n$$S_{1-4}={\\rm OFF}\\tag{evaluate}$$\n$$M_{7}={\\rm ON}$$\n\nlet\n\n$$I_{0}=I_{7}\\qquad I_{D1}=I_{D2}=I_{0}/2\\tag{1}$$\n\n$${{dV_{P}}\\over {dt}}=-{{I_{D1}}\\over {C_{P}}}\\qquad\n  {{dV_{Q}}\\over {dt}}=-{{I_{D2}}\\over {C_{Q}}} \\tag{2}$$\n\nso that for a differential input\n\n$$\\Delta V_{PQ}(t)=V_{P}-V_{Q}=-{{I_{D1}-I_{D2}}\\over {C_{P}}}t\n        \\approx -{{g_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}}\\over {C_{P}}}t \\tag{3}$$\n\n$X,Y$ stay at $V_{DD}$ because for\n\n$$V_{GS3}=V_{Y}-V_{P}<V_{TN}\\qquad V_{GS4}=V_{X}-V_{Q}<V_{TN}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$M_{3},M_{4}$ are off.  $M_{3}$ {\\it resp.} $M_{4}$\ncomes on when\n\n$$V_{Y}-V_{P}=V_{TN}\\tag{5}$$\n\ni. e. when the common mode at $P,Q$ has fallen by\n\n$$|\\Delta V_{CM}|=V_{TN}\\tag{6}$$\n\n$$T_{1}=\\int_{V_{DD}}^{V_{DD}-V_{TN}}{{C_{P}dV_{P}}\\over {I_{0}/2}}\n      ={{2C_{P}V_{TN}}\\over {I_{0}}}\\propto C_{P}\\tag{7}$$\n\nand, from (3),\n\n$$|\\Delta V_{PQ}(T_{1})|={{g_{m1}T_{1}}\\over {C_{P}}}|\\Delta V_{in}|\n   ={{2g_{m1}V_{TN}}\\over {I_{0}}}|\\Delta V_{in}|\\tag{8}$$\n\n$C_{P}$ cancels.  To first order the differential voltage\nsampled on $P,Q$ at the instant the nMOS cross coupled pair\nfires is $C_{P,Q}$ independent.  That is the {\\it sampled}\n{\\it seed} voltage that is normally quoted as the {\\it\ninitial voltage gain}\n\n$$A_{v0}^{(P)}={{\\Delta V_{PQ}(T_{1})}\\over {\\Delta V_{in}}}\n        \\approx {{g_{m1}V_{TN}}\\over {I_{0}/2}}\\approx {{g_{m1}}\\over\n        {g_{m3}}} \\tag{9}$$\n\nin small signal form\n\n$$R_{P}\\approx {1\\over {g_{m3}}},\\qquad A_{v0}\\approx -g_{m1}R_{P}\n\\tag{10}$$\n\n$$ \\omega _{pP}\\approx {{g_{m3}}\\over {C_{P}}}\\tag{11}$$\n\nso that the low frequency small signal voltage gain at $P,Q$\nis $C_{P}$ independent, $C_{P}$ only moves the dominant pole\nat $P,Q$ down as $1/C_{P}$ and adds the delay (7).\n\nFor $t>T_{1}$ $M_{3},M_{4}$ are on.  With $C_{X}=C_{Y}$,\n$C_{P}=C_{Q}$ the incremental circuit for the differential\nsignals $v_{p}=V_{P}-V_{Q}$, $v_{x}=V_{X}-V_{Y}$ is, to\n$g_{m}$ order,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nC_{P}{\\dot v}_{p}&=-g_{m3}v_{x}-g_{m3}v_{p}-g_{m1}v_{in}\\cr\nC_{X}{\\dot v}_{x}&=g_{m3}v_{x}+g_{m3}v_{p}\\cr} \\tag{12}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$\\left[ \\matrix{C_{P}p+g_{m3}&g_{m3}\\cr -g_{m3}&C_{X}p-g_{m3}\\cr}\n        \\right]\\left[ \\matrix{v_{p}\\cr v_{x}\\cr}\\right]=\n        \\left[ \\matrix{-g_{m1}v_{in}\\cr 0\\cr}\\right] \\tag{13}$$\n\n$$\\left(C_{P}C_{X}p^{2}+g_{m3}(C_{X}-C_{P})p\\right)v_{x}\n        =-g_{m1}g_{m3}v_{in} \\tag{14}$$\n\nFor Laplace $v_{in}(s)=V_{in}/s$\n\n$$V_{x}(s)=-{{g_{m1}g_{m3}V_{in}}\\over\n          {C_{P}C_{X}s^{2}\\left(s+a\\right)}},\\qquad \n          a={{g_{m3}(C_{X}-C_{P})}\\over {C_{P}C_{X}}}\\tag{15}$$\n\n$$v_{x}(t)=-{{g_{m1}g_{m3}V_{in}}\\over {C_{P}C_{X}a^{2}}}\n          \\left[at-1+e^{-at}\\right] \\tag{16}$$\n\nFor $at\\ll 1$, $C_{P}\\approx C_{X}$,\n\n$$v_{x}(t)\\approx -{{g_{m1}g_{m3}}\\over {2C_{P}C_{X}}}V_{in}t^{2}\n                \\tag{17}$$\n\ni. e. a $t^{2}$ integrator with incremental gain\n\n$$\\left|A_{v}(t)\\right|=\\left|{{v_{x}(t)}\\over {V_{in}}}\\right|\n        \\approx {{g_{m1}g_{m3}t^{2}}\\over {2C_{P}C_{X}}}\n        \\propto {1\\over {C_{P}C_{X}}}\\tag{18}$$\n\nfor a {\\it given\\/} evaluation interval.  For $C_{X}>C_{P}$ and\n$at\\gg 1$\n\n$$v_{x}(t)\\approx -{{g_{m1}}\\over {C_{X}-C_{P}}}V_{in}t\n                \\tag{19}$$\n\n$$\\left|A_{v}(t)\\right|\\approx {{g_{m1}t}\\over {C_{X}-C_{P}}}\n        \\propto {1\\over {C_{X}-C_{P}}}\\tag{20}$$\n\nFor $C_{P}>C_{X}$, $a<0$, put $b=-a=g_{m3}(C_{P}-C_{X})/C_{P}C_{X}\n>0$,\n\n$$v_{x}(t)\\approx -{{g_{m1}C_{P}C_{X}}\\over\n                {g_{m3}(C_{P}-C_{X})^{2}}}V_{in}e^{bt}\\tag{21}$$\n\nan exponential regeneration with\n\n$$\\tau _{n}={1\\over b}={{C_{P}C_{X}}\\over {g_{m3}(C_{P}-C_{X})}}\n        \\tag{22}$$\n\nIn ordinary use the integration is stopped when the common\nmode at $X,Y$, which for $t>T_{1}$ falls with the total\ncapacitance $C_{P}+C_{X}$,\n\n$${{dV_{CMX}}\\over {dt}}\\approx -{{I_{0}}\\over {C_{P}+C_{X}}} \\tag{23}$$\n\nreaches $V_{DD}-|V_{TP}|$ and the pMOS pair $M_{5}M_{6}$\nfires,\n\n$$T_{2}\\approx T_{1}+{{C_{X}|V_{TP}|+C_{P}V_{TN}}\\over {I_{0}}}\n      \\propto C_{P}+C_{X}\\tag{24}$$\n\nso that the self timed differential seed at the onset of\nfull CMOS regeneration is, from (16) with $t=T_{2}$,\n\n$$|\\Delta V_{X}(T_{2})|\\propto {{(C_{P}+C_{X})^{2}}\\over\n        {C_{P}C_{X}}}|\\Delta V_{in}|={{C_{P}}\\over {C_{X}}}+\n        {{C_{X}}\\over {C_{P}}}+2\\tag{25}$$\n\nfor the $t^{2}$ regime and\n\n$$|\\Delta V_{X}(T_{2})|\\propto {{C_{P}+C_{X}}\\over {C_{X}-C_{P}}}\n        |\\Delta V_{in}|\\tag{26}$$\n\nfor the linear regime, i. e. to first order $C_{P}$\nindependent and to second order a very weak increase with\n$C_{P}$, $C_{P}/(C_{X}-C_{P})$, tending to the limit\n$g_{m3}/C_{X}$ for $C_{P}\\gg C_{X}$.\n\nIn engineering terms: the $DC$ $g_{m}R$ gain\n$g_{m1}/g_{m3}$ does not change.  The $GBW$,\n$g_{m}/C_{P}$, goes down as $1/C_{P}$, the dominant pole\n$\\omega _{p}=g_{m3}/C_{P}$ moves in, and for a {\\it fixed\\/}\nclock evaluation time the large signal integration gain\n(17)–(20) falls as $1/C_{P}$, $1/C_{P}C_{X}$.  The price for\nany extra seed voltage (25)–(26) is a linear increase of the\nevaluation delay (7), (24),\n\n$$\\Delta T_{D}\\approx {{V_{TN}}\\over {I_{0}/2}}\\Delta C_{P}\n        \\approx {{C_{P}V_{T}}\\over {I_{0}}}\\tag{27}$$\n\nand a corresponding increase of the input referred offset,\nthermal noise and kick back for a given throughput.\n\nIt is customary to summarise this as {\\it the usable\ninitial, pre-regeneration, voltage gain falls,\n$\\propto 1/C_{P}$, $1/C_{P}C_{X}$, and the latch slows down\n$\\propto C_{P}$}.  In the idealised $\\int g_{m}dt/C$\npicture the $C_{P}$ cancels at the sampling instant,\nEq.\\,{\\rm (8)}, so the textbook shorthand is {\\it no first\norder change in the sampled seed voltage, at best a\nmarginal $\\propto (C_{P}+C_{X})/(C_{X}-C_{P})$ increase\nbought with a $\\propto C_{P}$ delay penalty; for any\npractical fixed rate clock the effective gain is reduced}.\nWith the usual $C_{P}<C_{X}$ design the often quoted\nresult is simply\n\n$$A_{v,{\\rm int}}(t)\\approx {{g_{m1}t}\\over {C_{X}}}\\;\\;{\\rm or}\\;\\;\n  {{g_{m1}g_{m3}t^{2}}\\over {2C_{P}C_{X}}}\\;\\;{\\rm decreases\\;with\\;}\n  C_{P}$$\n\nand the $-3\\,{\\rm dB}$ gain $g_{m1}/g_{m3}$ stays put while\n$GBW\\approx g_{m1}/C_{P}$ falls.  Hence the comparator\nappears as lower gain, higher input referred offset,\n$\\propto 1/A_{v0}$, and slower regeneration,\nEqs.\\,(22),(27).  Minimising $C_{P,Q}$ is the normal\nspeed optimisation; a small intentional $C_{P,Q}$ is\nsometimes added to trade speed for improved isolation,\nkick back and a $\\sim (C_{P}+C_{X})^{2}/C_{P}C_{X}$\nincrease of the self timed seed, up to the\n$g_{m}/C_{X}$ limit.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "4c905a07d52aae7d0f10fbc345c3b25c5d772504c57e4ef759b2d0e49cee63c1"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The derivation correctly shows that the longer discharge time cancels the 1/CP slope, leaving the sampled initial gain unchanged while increasing delay. However, it later calls the usable initial gain lower as capacitance increases, conflating that result with gain at a fixed evaluation time and making the answer internally inconsistent.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "181f6e0ce2e77c4df0e1602f9ce1b8891080eeecdff293462f41c7d6d66c5590",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 3939,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 18731,
        "total_tokens": 22792,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15818,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 3939,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 18731,
        "total_tokens": 22792,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 15818,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 8,
      "question": "In the figure, what happens to the initial voltage gain if we increase the capacitance at nodes P and Q?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-008-initial-voltage-gain-increase-capacitance-at-nodes/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the conventional linearised, self timed,\nintegration picture the circuit is two cascaded $g_{m}-C$\nintegrators.  For the ${\\rm M}_{1}-{\\rm M}_{2}$ pair, Fig.Razavi\n\n$${\\rm S}_{1}-{\\rm S}_{4}\\;\\;{\\rm on}\\;\\;\nV_{P}=V_{Q}=V_{X}=V_{Y}=V_{DD}\\qquad {\\rm M}_{7}\\;\\;{\\rm off}$$\n\non ${\\rm CK}\\uparrow \\;{\\rm S}_{i}\\;{\\rm off}\\;{\\rm M}_{7}\\;{\\rm on}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nC_{P}{\\dot V}_{P}&=-I_{D1}-I_{D3}\\cr\nC_{P}{\\dot V}_{Q}&=-I_{D2}-I_{D4}\\cr\nC_{X}{\\dot V}_{X}&=-I_{D3}\\cr\nC_{Y}{\\dot V}_{Y}&=-I_{D4}\\qquad {\\rm M}_{5,6}\\;\\;{\\rm off}}$$\n\nput $\\Delta I=I_{D1}-I_{D2}=g_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}$,\n$\\;p=(V_{P}-V_{Q})/2$, $x=(V_{X}-V_{Y})/2$, $x(0)=p(0)=0$,\nlinearise ${\\rm M}_{3}$ about $V_{GS}=V_{DD}-V_{P}$,\n\n$$i_{d3}=g_{m3}(y-p)+g_{o3}(x-p)\\tag{1}$$\n\netc. and for the normal $g_{o}\\ll g_{m}$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nC_{P}s\\,p+g_{m3}p+g_{m3}x&=-g_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}/2\\cr\nC_{X}s\\,x-g_{m3}x-g_{m3}p&=0} \\tag{2}$$\n\nso that, $D(s)=C_{P}C_{X}s^{2}+g_{m3}(C_{X}-C_{P})s$,\n\n$${{x}\\over{\\Delta V_{in}}}(s)=\n-{{g_{m1}g_{m3}}\\over{2D(s)}}\\tag{3}$$\n\ni. e. for $|s|\\gg g_{m}/C$\n\n$${{x}\\over{\\Delta V_{in}}}(s)\\approx -{{g_{m1}g_{m3}}\\over\n{2C_{P}C_{X}s^{2}}}\\tag{4}$$\n\nin the time domain, for a $\\Delta V_{in}u(t)$,\n\n$$p(t)={{g_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}}\\over {C_{P}}}t \\tag{5}$$\n\n$$C_{X}{\\dot x}=g_{m3}p\\;\\;,\\;\\;x(t)={{g_{m1}g_{m3}\\Delta V_{in}}\n\\over{2C_{P}C_{X}}}t^{2}\\tag{6}$$\n\ni. e. $A_{v}(t)=x(t)/\\Delta V_{in}\\propto 1/C_{P}C_{X}$ for\na prescribed interrogation time $T_{int}$.  In the normal\ntext book shorthand\n\n$$A_{v0}(T_{int})={1\\over {C_{P}}}\\int_{0}^{T_{int}}g_{m1}dt\n\\approx {{g_{m1}T_{int}}\\over {C_{P}}}\\propto {1\\over {C_{P}}}\n\\tag{7}$$\n\nfor a fixed clock, the ``initial'' small signal gain goes\ndown like $1/C_{P}$ and the input referred contribution of\nany offset in the regenerative latch goes up like $C_{P}$,\nthe regeneration time constant $\\tau _{r}=C/g_{m}$ goes up\nlike $C_{P}$.\n\nIf you let the latch time itself the $1/C_{P}$ is to first\norder cancelled by the $C_{P}$ dependence of the time at\nwhich the ${\\rm n}$ -latch fires.  With (5) the $P$ node\nfalls\n\n$$V_{P}(t)=V_{DD}-{{I_{0}}\\over{C_{P}}}t\\tag{8}$$\n\n$I_{0}=I_{tail}/2$, so that ${\\rm M}_{3}$ turns on for\n\n$$V_{DD}-V_{P}=V_{THN}\\;\\;,\\;\\;T_{1}={{C_{P}V_{THN}}\\over{I_{0}}}\n\\tag{9}$$\n\nand\n\n$$\\Delta V_{P}(T_{1})={{g_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}}\\over{C_{P}}}T_{1}\n={{g_{m1}V_{THN}}\\over{I_{0}}}\\Delta V_{in}\\tag{10}$$\n\n$C_{P}$ independent to first order.  Carrying the second\nintegration (6) to the point where the ${\\rm p}$ -latch fires,\n\n$$V_{X}(t)=V_{DD}-{{I_{0}}\\over{C_{X}}}(t-T_{1})\\tag{11}$$\n\n$$|V_{THP}|={{I_{0}}\\over{C_{X}}}T_{2}\\;\\;,\\;\\;T_{2}=\n{{C_{X}|V_{THP}|}\\over{I_{0}}}\\tag{12}$$\n\nand from (6) with (9)(12)\n\n$$x(T_{1}+T_{2})={{g_{m1}g_{m3}\\Delta V_{in}}\\over{2C_{P}C_{X}}}\nT_{2}\\left( 2T_{1}+T_{2}\\right) \\tag{13}$$\n\ni. e. in the linear $g_{m}$ model\n\n$$A_{vX}\\equiv {{x(T_{1}+T_{2})}\\over{\\Delta V_{in}}}\n={{g_{m1}g_{m3}}\\over{2I_{0}^{2}}}\n\\left[2V_{THN}|V_{THP}|+{{C_{X}}\\over{C_{P}}}|V_{THP}|^{2}\n\\right]\\tag{14}$$\n\n$c$.f. Razavi, {\\it The StrongARM Latch} ISSCC 2015.\nTo the order most text books quote the $2V_{THN}|V_{THP}|$\nterm is the $C$ independent ``$P$ gain'' (10) and the\nnormally dominant $C_{X}/C_{P}$ term makes the usable\npre-regeneration gain at the output, $X-Y$, go as\n$C_{X}/C_{P}\\propto 1/C_{P}$.\n\nWith the more correct square law\n$I_{D3}=(\\beta _{3}/2)(V_{GS3}-V_{TH})^{2}$,\n\n$$I_{D3}(t)={\\beta_{3}\\over 2}\\left({{I_{1}t}\\over{C_{P}}}-V_{THN}\n\\right)^{2}\\;,\\;t>T_{1}\\tag{15}$$\n\n$$C_{X}{\\dot V}_{X}=-I_{D3}\\;,\\;\nV_{X}(t)=V_{DD}-{\\beta_{3}\\over{6C_{X}}}\n\\left({{I_{0}}\\over{C_{P}}}\\right)^{2}(t-T_{1})^{3}\\tag{16}$$\n\n$$|V_{THP}|={\\beta_{3}\\over{6C_{X}}}\n\\left({{I_{0}}\\over{C_{P}}}\\right)^{2}(T_{2}-T_{1})^{3}\\tag{17}$$\n\n$$T_{2}-T_{1}= \\left({{6C_{X}|V_{THP}|}\\over{\\beta_{3}}}\\right)^{1/3}\n\\left({{C_{P}}\\over{I_{0}}}\\right)^{2/3}\\propto\nC_{P}^{2/3}C_{X}^{1/3}\\tag{18}$$\n\nand for the differential signal $\\Delta I=g_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}$,\n\n$$\\Delta I_{D}=I_{D3}-I_{D4}\n={\\beta_{3}\\Delta I\\,I_{0}\\over{C_{P}^{2}}}\\,t\\,(t-T_{1})\\tag{19}$$\n\n$$|\\Delta V_{X}(T_{2})|={1\\over{C_{X}}}\\int_{T_{1}}^{T_{2}}\n|\\Delta I_{D}|dt\n={{2|V_{THP}|}\\over{I_{0}}}\\Delta I\n+{1\\over2}\\beta_{3}^{1/3}6^{2/3}\n{{V_{THN}|V_{THP}|^{2/3}}\\over{I_{0}^{4/3}}}\n{{C_{P}^{1/3}}\\over{C_{X}^{1/3}}}\\Delta I\\tag{20}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$A_{vX}={{|\\Delta V_{X}|}\\over{\\Delta V_{in}}}\n=g_{m1}{{2|V_{THP}|}\\over{I_{0}}}\n+{1\\over2}g_{m1}\\beta_{3}^{1/3}6^{2/3}\n{{V_{THN}|V_{THP}|^{2/3}}\\over{I_{0}^{4/3}}}\n{{C_{P}^{1/3}}\\over{C_{X}^{1/3}}}\\tag{21}$$\n\napart from the $C_{P}^{1/3}C_{X}^{-1/3}$ correction the\nnormally quoted term is $C$ independent.  In either model\nno appreciable increase of the voltage division\n$V_{os,latch}/A_{v0}$ of the latch offset is obtained by\nmaking $C_{P}$ large.  The $1/C_{P}$ in (7) is cancelled to\nfirst order by $T_{1}\\propto C_{P}$ ( $T_{2}\\propto\nC_{P}^{2/3}$ in the square law model) and, for the\nconventional fixed $T_{int}$ definition, $A_{v0}\\propto\n1/C_{P}$; for the complete $X-Y$ signal (14) $A_{vX}\\propto\nC_{X}/C_{P}$.  For very large $C_{P}$ the cubic law (16)\nindeed makes $A_{vX}$ collapse $\\propto 1/C_{P}$.\n\nIn the usual one line text book shorthand this is quoted as\n\n> {\\it the (fixed time) initial $g_{m}-C$ integrator gain\n> falls as $1/C_{P}$ - and in the self timed latch it is\n> to first order $C_{P}$ independent, Eq.\\,10, so that adding\n> $C_{P}$ buys you, at best, no extra pre-amplification.\n> The normally dominant $X-Y$ gain, Eq.\\,14, goes as\n> $C_{X}/C_{P}$ and therefore goes down with $C_{P}$;\n> with the square law correction Eq.\\,21 it goes as\n> $C_{P}^{1/3}C_{X}^{-1/3}$ before it eventually goes\n> $\\propto 1/C_{P}$.  In all cases the evaluation time\n> $T_{int}=T_{1}+T_{2}\\propto C_{P}\\,(C_{P}^{2/3})$ and the\n> regeneration time constant $\\tau_{r}=C/g_{m}\\propto C$\n> grow linearly with $C_{P}$, so the comparator is made\n> slower, noisier and more power hungry for (at best) the\n> same input referred latch offset.}\n\nWith the conventional $A_{v0}=g_{m}T_{int}/C_{P}$ language\nthis is normally abbreviated to ``$A_{v0}$ goes down $\\propto\n1/C_{P}$'' - the input referred offset\n$V_{os}^{in}=V_{os}^{latch}/A_{v0}$ goes up and the latch\ngets slower.  To first order the self timed sampled\n$\\Delta V_{P}(T_{1})=g_{m}V_{TH}|\\Delta V_{in}/I_{0}$ is\n$C_{P}$ independent, so the more precise statement is\n``to first order the $P$ gain does not increase at all and\nthe $X-Y$ gain decreases as $C_{X}/C_{P}$ $(C_{P}^{1/3})$;\nyou pay a $\\propto C_{P}$ increase in $T_{int}$ and in\n$\\tau _{r}=C/g_{m}$ for no (or negative) improvement in\noffset.''  This is why $C_{P},C_{Q}$ are normally kept as\nsmall as parasitics allow and, if peaking is required,\n$C_{X},C_{Y}$ is increased, not $C_{P},C_{Q}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ecac7a827cc5735248dc20c8f45c77353fb8eb2186a960208903cd79e720c4f0"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "The answer correctly identifies that the self-timed gain across P and Q is essentially independent of capacitance: the larger capacitance lengthens the discharge phase proportionally, canceling its effect on the differential voltage accumulated by regeneration onset. It also notes the transient is slower; the fixed-time and later X-Y gain discussion is secondary to the question.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "181f6e0ce2e77c4df0e1602f9ce1b8891080eeecdff293462f41c7d6d66c5590",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 23687,
        "total_tokens": 27748,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 20685,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 23687,
        "total_tokens": 27748,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 20685,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "If we increase the widths of M5 and M6 in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the normal sizing the circuit is the\nso called Strong Arm latch. With\n\n$${\\cal S}_{1}\\sim {\\cal S}_{4}$$\nthe precharge switches, ${\\cal M}_{7}$ the tail\ndevice\n\n* $${t_{1}}:CK=0\\;\\;P=Q=X=Y=V_{DD}\\;\\;,{\\cal M}_{7}\n{\\rm \\;off}$$\n* $${t_{2}}:CK=1\\;\\;{\\cal S}_{i}{\\rm \\;off\\;,}{\\cal M}_{7}\n{\\rm \\;on\\;,}\\;P,Q\\;{\\hbox{fall with}}\\;dV/dt=I_{D1,2}/C_{P,Q}$$\n  the $\\Delta V_{in}=V_{{in}1}-V_{{in}2}$ is integated as\n  $\\Delta V_{PQ}(t)=g_{m1,2}\\Delta V_{in}t/C_{P,Q}$,\n* $${t_{3}}:V_{PQ}<V_{DD}-V_{Tn}\\;\\;{\\cal M}_{3},{\\cal M}_{4}\n{\\rm \\;on\\;,\\;}X,Y\\;{\\rm fall with}\\;\ndV/dt=I_{D3,4}/C_{XY}$$\n* $${t_{4}}:V_{XY}<V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|\\;\\;{\\cal M}_{5},{\\cal M}_{6}\n{\\rm \\;on}$$\n\nand the back to back inverters ${\\cal M}_{3}{\\cal M}_{5}$,\n${\\cal M}_{4}{\\cal M}_{6}$ regenerate with\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{o}(t)&=\\Delta V_{0}{\\rm e}^{t/\\tau}\\cr\n\\tau^{-1}&={{G_{mN}+G_{mP}}\\over {C_{XY}}}\\cr\nC_{XY}&=C_{0}+C_{gd5,6}^{\\prime}W_{5,6}+C_{db5,6}^{\\prime}\nW_{5,6}+C_{gs5,6}^{\\prime}W_{6,5}+C_{gd3,4}+C_{db3,4}\n+C_{gs3,4}\\cr\nG_{mN}&=g_{m3}=g_{m4}\\propto W_{3,4}\\cr\nG_{mP}&=g_{m5}=g_{m6}\\propto W_{5,6}}$$\n\nand, to first order,\n\n$${\\cal D}=t_{CK-Q}=t_{0}+t_{latch}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nt_{0}&\\approx {{C_{XY}|V_{Tp}|}\\over {I_{D1,2}}}\n+{{C_{PQ}V_{Tn}}\\over {I_{D1,2}}}\\cr\nt_{latch}&=\\tau \\log {{V_{DD}}\\over {\\Delta V_{0}}}\\cr\n\\Delta V_{0}&\\approx {{g_{m1,2}\\Delta V_{in}}\\over {C_{XY}}}t_{0}}$$\n\nso that for $C_{XY}$ constant\n\n$$t_{latch}\\propto {1\\over {G_{mN}+G_{mP}}}\\propto {1\\over {W_{5,6}}}$$\n\n{\\it i. e.} in small signal the p -latch {\\it does}\nlatch faster the bigger $W_{5,6}$ is made.\n\nWith the self loading put in\n\n$$\\tau ={{C_{0}+C_{p}^{\\prime}W_{5,6}}\\over {G_{mN}+g_{mP}^{\\prime}\nW_{5,6}}}$$\n\nand\n\n$$t_{0}\\propto C_{XY}\\propto C_{0}+C_{p}^{\\prime}W_{5,6}$$\n\n$${\\cal D}(W_{P})=A\\left(C_{0}+C_{p}^{\\prime}W_{P}\\right)\n+{{C_{0}+C_{p}^{\\prime}W_{P}}\\over {G_{mN}+g_{mP}^{\\prime}W_{P}}}\n\\log {{V_{DD}}\\over {\\Delta V_{0}(W_{P})}}$$\n\nhas a shallow optimum at\n\n$${{d{\\cal D}}\\over {dW_{P}}}=0\\;\\;,\\;\\;W_{P,opt}\\approx\n{C_{0}\\over {C_{p}^{\\prime}}}{{G_{mN}}\\over {G_{mN}+{\\rm log\\;term}}}\n\\approx {\\cal O}(1)\\times W_{N}$$\n\nin most technologies essentially the minimum $W_{P}$ that\nstill gives regenerative switching, normally\n$W_{5,6}\\approx 0.5-1.0\\,W_{3,4}$ and in absolute value\n$1-4\\mu $ in $0.18\\mu $, {\\it i. e.} close to minimum\ngeometry.\n\n* Starting from minimum geometry a modest increase of\n$W_{5,6}$ does decrease the exponential time constant\n$\\tau $ by $\\Delta \\tau /\\tau \\approx -g_{mP}^{\\prime}\n\\Delta W_{P}/(G_{mN}+G_{mP})$ and in the textbook\n``$C_{XY}={\\rm const.}$'' sense the comparator can be\nsaid to get faster, of the order of $10-20\\%$ for a\nfactor $2$ in $W_{P}$.\n\n* The same $\\Delta W_{P}$ increases the capacitance that\nhas to be discharged in $t_{0}$ and in reset,\n$\\Delta t_{0}/t_{0}\\approx C_{p}^{\\prime}\\Delta W_{P}/C_{XY}$,\nand increases $\\tau $ through the numerator.  For any\nappreciable widening $C_{p}^{\\prime}W_{P}\\sim C_{0}$,\n$C_{p}^{\\prime}\\Delta W_{P}/C_{XY}>g_{mP}^{\\prime}\n\\Delta W_{P}/(G_{mN}+G_{mP})$ and\n\n$${{d{\\cal D}}\\over {dW_{P}}}>0$$\n\nthe conventional clock to $Q$ propagation delay,\n$${\\cal D}\\approx C_{XY}|V_{Tp}|/I_{tail}+\n\\left(C_{XY}/G_{m}\\right)\\log \\left(V_{DD}/\\Delta V_{0}\\right)$$\ngoes {\\it up}} with $W_{5,6}$ and the maximum clock rate\n$$f_{max}^{-1}\\approx t_{reset}+{\\cal D}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\nt_{reset}\\propto R_{{\\cal S}3,4}C_{XY}$$\ngoes down.  The power $C_{XY}V_{DD}^{2}f$ goes up as\n$W_{P}$.  In the normal, already optimum, sizing this is\nnormally quoted as ``making ${\\cal M}_{5}{\\cal M}_{6}$\nbigger slows the comparator down''.\n\nIn round numbers in e. {\\rm g.} $65{\\rm nm}$ with\n$W_{3,4}=4-8\\mu $, $W_{5,6}=2-4\\mu $, $C_{XY}\\approx\n10-20{\\rm fF}$, $\\tau \\approx 15-25{\\rm ps}$,\ndoubling $W_{5,6}$ lowers $\\tau $ by $\\sim 15\\%$ but\nraises $t_{0}$ by $\\sim 20-30\\%$ for a net $5-15\\%$\n{\\it increase} of $t_{CK-Q}$ for small $\\Delta V_{in}$\nand a $\\sim W_{P}$ increase of $t_{reset}$.  For\n$W_{P}\\gg W_{P,opt}$ the delay grows $\\propto W_{P}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} If the self loading $C_{p}^{\\prime}W_{P}$ is\n> neglected, the usual textbook statement is: $G_{mP}\\propto\n> W_{P}$ so $\\tau \\propto 1/W_{P}$ and the latch regenerates\n> faster, {\\it i. e.} the {\\it small signal regeneration\n> speed}} improves with $W_{5,6}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "b1ed51610092711231e6d6c7dd8d4ad11887879e8b24248d9be035f3ea5a7fc2"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the regenerative-strength benefit of wider M5/M6 and the eventual capacitance penalty, but concludes that widening slows the actual comparator from normal sizing. The golden solution says speed initially improves, with capacitance limiting the benefit only at larger widths.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5eed0194a609e5504312082df6fe7d71e18f6abfa8d0ff1bc1936ac8f33e2388",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 6692,
        "total_tokens": 10753,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4762,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 6692,
        "total_tokens": 10753,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4762,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "If we increase the widths of M5 and M6 in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual abuse of language the ``speed'' is\ntwo speeds.  Put ${\\rm CK}=0$ for reset, ${\\rm CK}=1$ for\nevaluate.  During reset\n\n$${\\rm S}_{1}\\!\\cdot\\! {\\rm S}_{2}\\;:\\;P,Q\\to V_{DD}\\qquad\n  {\\rm S}_{3}\\!\\cdot\\! {\\rm S}_{4}\\;:\\;X,Y\\to V_{DD}\\qquad \n  {\\rm M}_{7}\\;\\;{\\rm OFF}$$\n\n$$V_{GS3}=V_{Y}-V_{P}=0\\;\\;V_{GS4}=0\\;\\;V_{SG5}=V_{SG6}=0$$\n\non ${\\rm CK}\\uparrow $ ${\\rm S}_{1}-{\\rm S}_{4}$ go open,\n${\\rm M}_{7}$ goes on and $I_{D1,2}$ starts to discharge\n$C_{P,Q}$ at a rate $\\Delta I/g_{m1,2}$,\n\n$${{dV_{P}}\\over {dt}}=-{{I_{1}}\\over {C_{P}}}\\qquad\n  {{dV_{Q}}\\over {dt}}=-{{I_{2}}\\over {C_{Q}}}\\tag{1}$$\n\ntill\n\n$$V_{P}<V_{Y}-V_{Tn}\\tag{2}$$\n\nand ${\\rm M}_{3}$ or ${\\rm M}_{4}$ comes on.  From then on\n$X,Y$ are discharged through the ${\\rm M}_{1}{\\rm -M}_{3}$\n${\\rm M}_{2}{\\rm -M}_{4}$ cascode at a rate $I_{1,2}/C_{X,Y}$\nuntil\n\n$$V_{X,Y}<V_{DD}-|V_{Tp}|\\tag{3}$$\n\nand the ${\\rm M}_{5}{\\rm -M}_{6}$ $p$ -pair comes on.\nWith both pairs on the small signal circuit at $X,Y$ is,\ndifferentially,\n\n$$C_{X,Y}{{d\\Delta V}\\over {dt}}=(g_{m3}+g_{m5})\\Delta V,\n\\qquad \\Delta V=V_{X}-V_{Y} \\tag{4}$$\n\nso that, with\n\n$$\\Delta V_{0}=\\Delta V(t=t_{0})\\tag{5}$$\n\nthe initial unbalance put on $C_{X,Y}$ by the $I_{1}-I_{2}$\nintegrator (1)-(3) before the $p$ devices come on,\n\n$$\\Delta V(t)=\\Delta V_{0}\n      \\exp \\left[{{g_{m3}+g_{m5}}\\over {C_{X,Y}}}(t-t_{0})\\right] \\tag{6}$$\n\nand, e.g. for $|\\Delta V|=V_{DD}/2$,\n\n$$t_{latch}={{C_{X,Y}}\\over {g_{m3}+g_{m5}}}\n            \\ln {{V_{DD}/2}\\over {\\Delta V_{0}}}\\tag{7}$$\n\nand, to first order, from (1)-(3)\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nt_{0}&=t_{0P}+t_{0X}\\cr\n     &={{C_{P}|V_{GS3}-V_{Tn}|}\\over {I_{D1,2}}}\n      +{{C_{X,Y}|V_{Tp}|}\\over {I_{D1,2}}}+{\\cal O}(1/g_{m}) \\cr\n     &={{C_{X,Y}}\\over {I_{D1,2}}}|V_{Tp}|+{\\rm etc.}} \\tag{8}$$\n\n$$t_{d}=t_{0}+t_{latch}\\approx \n{{C_{X,Y}|V_{Tp}|}\\over {I_{D}}}\n+{{C_{X,Y}}\\over {g_{m3}+g_{m5}}}\n  \\ln {{V_{DD}/2}\\over {\\Delta V_{0}}}\\tag{9}$$\n\nwhich is normally quoted in the Razavi form\n\n$$t_{d}\\approx 2{{C_{X}V_{Tp}}\\over {I_{D}}}\n+{{C_{X}}\\over {g_{m,{\\rm eff}}}}\n \\ln \\left[{{V_{DD}}\\over 2}{\\sqrt{{2C_{X}}\\over {\\beta_{1}}}}\n           {{g_{m,{\\rm eff}}}\\over {I_{D}\\Delta V_{in}}}\\right]\n\\tag{10}$$\n\nwith $g_{m,{\\rm eff}}=g_{m3}+g_{m5}$, $\\Delta V_{0}\\propto\ng_{m1}\\Delta V_{in}t_{0}/C_{X}\\propto \\Delta V_{in}I_{D}^{-1}\n\\sqrt{\\beta_{1}/C_{X}}$, cf. {\\it e.g.} Razavi, {\\it Design\nof Analog CMOS Integrated Circuits}, Chap. 8.\n\n$$C_{X,Y}=C_{X0}+C_{j,db5}+C_{ov5}+C_{gs5}+ \\cdots \n        =C_{X0}+W_{5}c_{j}^{\\prime}+{2\\over 3}W_{5}L_{5}C_{ox}\n          +W_{5}C_{ov}^{\\prime}+ \\cdots \\propto W_{5}\\tag{11}$$\n\n$$g_{m5}\\propto \\cases{\n        \\sqrt{W_{5}} & square law\\cr\n        W_{5} & {\\rm short\\; channel,\\; }v_{sat}\\cr}\\tag{12}$$\n\nSo that for the regeneration proper\n\n$$\\tau _{l}= {{C_{X,Y}}\\over {g_{m3}+g_{m5}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\na small increase of $W_{5,6}$ from minimum size {\\it decreases}\n$\\tau _{l}$ because the denominator increases faster than the\nnumerator.  E.g. square law\n\n$$\\tau _{l}={{C_{X0}+k_{c}W_{5}}\\over {g_{m3}+k_{g}\\sqrt{W_{5}}}}\\tag{14}$$\n\n$${{d\\tau _{l}}\\over {dW_{5}}}=0\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;\n  k_{c}(g_{m3}+k_{g}\\sqrt{W_{5}})-{{k_{g}}\\over {2\\sqrt{W_{5}}}}\n        (C_{X0}+k_{c}W_{5})=0\\tag{15}$$\n\ni.e. a shallow optimum at\n\n$$g_{m5,opt}\\approx g_{m3}{{1}\\over {1+C_{X0}/k_{c}W_{5}}}\\tag{16}$$\n\nnormally quoted as $g_{m5}\\approx g_{m3}$ or $W_{5}\\approx\nW_{3}$ for matched layout, $\\mu _{n}\\approx 2\\mu _{p}$, etc.\nUp to about a factor $1.5-2$ increase from minimum $W_{5}$\n$\\tau _{l}$ can be reduced by $10-20\\%$.  Normal textbook\nshorthand: ``the latch gets faster''.\n\nThe price is (11).  The initial unbalance $\\Delta V_{0}$\nthat the latch has to regenerate goes as $1/C_{X,Y}$ and the\n``integrator'' time $t_{0}\\propto C_{X,Y}$ (8) goes {\\it up}\nlinearly with $W_{5,6}$.  The logarithmic term in (9) also\ngoes as $\\ln C_{X,Y}^{1/2}$.  Hence the {\\it total}\nStrongArm delay (9)-(10) has a shallow optimum and then {\\it\nincreases}} with $W_{5,6}$,\n\n$${{dt_{d}}\\over {dW_{5}}}={{|V_{Tp}|}\\over {I_{D}}}{{dC_{X}}\\over {dW_{5}}}\n+{{1}\\over {g_{m,{\\rm eff}}}}{{dC_{X}}\\over {dW_{5}}}\n  \\ln(\\cdots)+C_{X}{{d(1/g_{m,{\\rm eff}})}\\over {dW_{5}}}\\ln(\\cdots)\n  +\\cdots >0\\tag{17}$$\n\nfor any appreciable widening beyond the $g_{m5}\\approx g_{m3}$\noptimum.  In the normally sized circuit the $t_{0}$ term\ndominates, so the usual loose statement is that widening\n${\\rm M}_{5}{\\rm -M}_{6}$ {\\it slows the comparator down}},\nincreases the reset, $R_{on,{\\rm S}_{3,4}}C_{X,Y}$, time and\nincreases the dynamic power $C_{X,Y}V_{DD}^{2}f_{CK}$ for no\nappreciable gain in regeneration speed.  With $C_{X,Y}\\propto\nW_{5}$ and $g_{m}\\propto \\sqrt{W}$ the often quoted result is\n\n$$t_{d}\\to {\\cal O}(W_{5})\\tag{18}$$\n\nso that for $W_{5}\\gg W_{5,opt}$ the comparator is decidedly\nslower.  In the limit $W_{5}\\to \\infty $, $\\tau _{l}\\to\nk_{c}W_{5}/k_{g}\\sqrt{W_{5}}\\propto \\sqrt{W_{5}}\\to \\infty $.\n\nIf the $1/C_{X}$ dependence of $\\Delta V_{0}$ and the $t_{0}$\nterm are neglected the latch itself can be said to get\nmarginally faster, $d\\tau _{l}/dW_{5}<0$, up to the optimum\n(16).  That is the ``speed improves'' quoted in some notes.\n\nFor mismatch the $p$ -pair offset contribution goes as\n$1/\\sqrt{W_{5}L_{5}}$, so widening ${\\rm M}_{5,6}$ does\nreduce the input referred offset due to ${\\rm M}_{5,6}$ at the\nexpense of power and, beyond the optimum, of speed.  The\nconventional optimum is $W_{5}\\approx (0.5-1.0)W_{3}$,\n$g_{m5}\\approx g_{m3}$, giving the minimum $t_{d}$ in (10).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "3894ddf75598bb3b2629b5b7adbf62bb9d96d26b1b980c2db67066108b4d6c6a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies that wider M5/M6 strengthen latch regeneration and that added capacitance eventually limits the benefit. But it concludes that widening generally slows the comparator, missing the key initial trend: speed improves over an initial sizing range before reaching an optimum.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5eed0194a609e5504312082df6fe7d71e18f6abfa8d0ff1bc1936ac8f33e2388",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 6401,
        "total_tokens": 10462,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4056,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 6401,
        "total_tokens": 10462,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4056,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 9,
      "question": "If we increase the widths of M5 and M6 in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-009-increase-widths-m5-and-m6-speed-improve/figure-09.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual ${\\rm {{S{'}}s}}$ the ${\\rm {{S{'}}s}}$\nopen the operation is sometimes divided into an\ne. g. {\\it after} ${\\rm {S_{1}S_{2}}}$ open {\\it\ne. g.} as\n\n* {\\it {\\rm {P\\,Q}} discharge:} ${\\rm {M_{7}}}$ on\n${\\rm {S_{1}S_{2}}}$ off\n$${{V}_{P,Q}(t)={{V}_{DD}}-{{I}_{1,2}\\over\n{{C}_{P,Q}}}t\\tag{1}}$$\nso that a\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\Delta {{V}_{PQ}}(t) &={{g_{m1}}\\over {{C}_{PQ}}}\\Delta\n{{V}_{{\\rm {in}}}}t \\cr\n\\Delta {{V}_{i}}&={{g_{m1}}\\over {{C}_{PQ}}}{{V}_{THN}\\over\n{{I}_{1}}}\\Delta {{V}_{{\\rm {in}}}}{{C}_{PQ}} \\tag{2}}$$\n\nis built up on ${{C}_{PQ}}$ before\n${{V}_{P,Q}}={{V}_{DD}}-{{V}_{TN}}$ and ${{M}_{3}},\n{{M}_{4}}$ can come on,\n\n* {\\it {\\rm {X\\,Y}} fall:} ${{M}_{3,4}}$ on\n$${{V}_{X,Y}(t)={{V}_{DD}}-{{I}_{3,4}\\over {{C}_{XY}}}t\\tag{3}}$$\n$$\\Delta {{V}_{XY}}(t)={{g_{m3}}\\over {{C}_{XY}}}\n\\int \\Delta {{V}_{PQ}}dt\\approx \n{{g_{m1}}g_{m3}\\over {{C}_{PQ}}{{C}_{XY}}}{{t^{2}}\\over 2}\n\\Delta {{V}_{{\\rm {in}}}} \\tag{4}$$\nwith an {\\it amplification}\n\n$${{A}_{0}}\\propto {{g_{m1}}\\over {{C}_{PQ}}}\n{{g_{m3}}\\over {{C}_{XY}}}{{t_{a}}^{2}} \\tag{4a}$$\n\nuntil ${{V}_{X,Y}}={{V}_{DD}}-\\left| {{V}_{TP}}\\right|$ and\nthe ${\\rm {p}}$ -channel cross coupled pair can come\non.\n\n* {\\it latch:} ${{M}_{5}}{{M}_{6}}-{{M}_{3}}{{M}_{4}}$\nclosed.  In small signal\n\n$${{d\\over {dt}}}\\Delta {{V}_{XY}}={{g_{m3}}+g_{m5}\\over\n{{C}_{XY}}}\\Delta {{V}_{XY}}\\tag{5}$$\n\nso that with (2)(4) as the initial condition\n\n$$\\Delta {{V}_{XY}}(t)=\\Delta {{V}_{0}}\n\\exp \\left[{{t-t_{a}}\\over {{\\tau }_{R}}}\\right]\\tag{6}$$\n\n$${{\\tau }_{R}}\\approx {{{C}_{XY}}\\over {{g_{m3}}+g_{m5}\n-g_{ds3}-g_{ds5}}}\\tag{7}$$\n\nand, to conventional first order,\n\n$${{t}_{{\\rm {CK-Q}}}}\\approx {{t}_{a}}+{{\\tau }_{R}}\n\\ln {{ {{V}_{DD}}}\\over {\\Delta {{V}_{0}}}}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$${{t}_{a}}\\propto {{C}_{XY}}\\left| {{V}_{TP}}\\right|\n/{{I}_{3}}+{{C}_{PQ}}{{V}_{TN}}/{{I}_{1}}\\tag{9}$$\n\n${{C}_{XY}}$ is\n\n$${{C}_{XY}}={{C}_{gd3}}+{{C}_{db3}}+{{C}_{db5}}+{{C}_{gd5}}\n+{{C}_{gs5}}+{{C}_{gs6}}+{{C}_{dS3}}+{{C}_{w}}\\tag{10}$$\n\n$${{C}_{gs5,6}}\\approx {2\\over 3}{{W}_{5,6}}{{L}_{5,6}}\n{{C}_{ox}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;{{C}_{db5,6}}\\propto {{W}_{5,6}}\\;\\;,\n\\;\\;{{C}_{gd5,6}}\\propto {{W}_{5,6}}\\tag{11}$$\n\ni. e. to first order ${{C}_{XY}}={{C}_{0}}+{{C}_{ox}}^{{\\prime\n}}{{W}_{5,6}}$ while, square law long channel,\n\n$${{g}_{m5,6}}\\propto \\sqrt{{{W}_{5,6}}{{I}_{5,6}}}\\tag{12}$$\n\nand short channel $g_{m}\\propto {{W}_{5,6}}$.\n\nHence\n\n* ${{t}_{a}}$ (1)(3)(9) - the time to generate the\nseed voltage $\\Delta {{V}_{0}}$ for the latch and to\nbring ${{M}_{5,6}}$ to the edge of conduction - goes\n{\\it linearly} with ${{C}_{XY}}$, i. e. linearly with\n${{W}_{5,6}}$;\n\n* ${{\\tau }_{R}}$ goes as ${{C}_{XY}}/\\left(\n{{g}_{m3}}+{{g}_{m5}}({{W}_{5}})\\right)$.  Long\nchannel\n\n$${{\\tau }_{R}}\\propto {{ {{C}_{0}}+{{C}_{ox}}^{{\\prime\n}}{{W}_{5}}}\\over {{{g}_{m3}}+{{g}_{m0}}\\sqrt{{{W}_{5}}}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nand short channel\n\n$${{\\tau }_{R}}\\propto {{ {{C}_{0}}+{{C}_{ox}}^{{\\prime\n}}{{W}_{5}}}\\over {{{g}_{m3}}+{{g}_{m0}}{{W}_{5}}}}\\tag{14}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$\\left.{{\\partial {{\\tau }_{R}}}\\over {\\partial\n{{W}_{5}}}}\\right|_{\\rm lc}\\propto \n{1\\over {\\sqrt{{{W}_{5}}}}}\\left[1-{{{C}_{0}}\\over {2\n{{C}_{ox}}^{{\\prime }}{{W}_{5}}}}+{\\cal O}(1)\\right]>0\n\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;{{W}_{5}}>{{W}_{5,{\\rm opt}}}\\tag{15}$$\n\nand\n\n$${{W}_{5,{\\rm opt}}}^{\\rm lc}\\approx \n{{{C}_{0}}\\over {{{C}_{ox}}^{{\\prime }}}}\\;,\\qquad\n{{W}_{5,{\\rm opt}}}^{\\rm sc}\\approx {{{g}_{m3}}\\over\n{{{g}_{m0}}}}{{C}_{ox}^{{\\prime }}{{W}_{3}}\\over {{C}_{0}}}$$\n\nin round numbers ${{W}_{5,{\\rm opt}}}\\approx\n(0.5-1.0){{W}_{3}}$ to $\\approx 2{{W}_{3}}$, depending\non the fixed capacitance ${{C}_{0}}$.\n\nIn words: ${{M}_{5,6}}$ help the positive feed back once\nit has started, Eq. 5, but they load the very node they\nhave to help, Eq. 10, and while they are still off they\ndo nothing but add ${{C}_{XY}}$ to be discharged by the\n${{n}}$ -channel side, Eq. 3--4, and fight the\n${{n}}$ -channel pull down once they do come on.\n\nFor ${{W}_{5,6}}<{{W}_{5,{\\rm opt}}}$ the\n$\\Delta {{g}_{m}}/\\Delta {{C}}$ is $>0$ and the latch\ncan be made marginally faster by fattening ${{M}_{5,6}}$,\nfor\n\n$${{W}_{5,6}}>{{W}_{5,{\\rm opt}}}\\;\\;,\\qquad \n{{d{{t}_{{\\rm {CK-Q}}}}}\\over {d{{W}_{5,6}}}}>0\\tag{16}$$\n\nthe normal, well sized, Strong Arm is already at or\npast ${{W}_{{\\rm opt}}}$ so that any {\\it appreciable}}\nincrease of ${{W}_{5,6}}$ increases ${{C}_{XY}}$\nessentially linearly while ${{g}_{m5}}$ increases only as\n$\\sqrt{W}$ - ${\\rm {SC}}$ as $W$ - and\n\n$${{t}_{{\\rm {CK-Q}}}}\\approx \n\\left[{{C}_{0}}+{{C}_{p}}{{W}_{5,6}}\\right]\n\\left[{{\\left|{{V}_{TP}}\\right|}\\over {{{I}_{av}}}}+\n{1\\over {{{g}_{m,av}}}}\\ln {{V}_{{\\rm logic}}\\over\n{\\Delta {{V}_{0}}({{C}_{XY}})}}\\right]\\tag{17}$$\n\ngoes up.  In conventional language the circuit gets\n{\\it slower}}, its ${\\rm {CK-Q}}$ propagation - regeneration\n- time constant ${{\\tau }_{R}}$ gets larger and its\nprecharge time ${{t}_{{\\rm {pch}}}}\\approx\n0.69{{R}_{S3,4}}{{C}_{XY}}$ gets larger.  The\n${\\rm {p}}$ -channel pair going to a low ${{V}_{DS}}$ also\nreduces its output resistance and the small signal gain\n${{A}_{v}}={{g}_{m}}{{r}_{o}}$ of the back to back\ninverters stops increasing and eventually falls with $W$.\n\nThe usual textbook shorthand is therefore: ``widening\n${{M}_{5}}{{M}_{6}}$ degrades the speed'' - more precisely\nthe delay versus ${{W}_{5,6}}$ is ${\\rm {U}}$ shaped\nwith a shallow minimum at about the normal design value,\n${{W}_{5}}\\approx {{W}_{3}}$, ${{W}_{6}}\\approx\n{{W}_{4}}$, so that a small increase from the minimum\ngeometry will speed the latch up by 10--20\\% while any\nlarge increase makes ${{t}_{a}}$ and ${{\\tau }_{R}}$\ncapacitance dominated and makes the comparator slower,\nmore power hungry and harder to precharge, and, because\nthe ${{M}_{5,6}}$ drain capacitance now dominates\n${{C}_{XY}}$, more sensitive to dynamic offset.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} If the $W$ is increased keeping the\n> $S_{3}S_{4}$ precharge devices constant the\n> precharge - reset - time increases as\n> ${{R}_{S}}{{C}_{XY}}$.  If $S_{3}S_{4}$ are widened\n> with $M_{5,6}$ the clock load increases. {\\it Mutatis\n> mutandis} for $M_{3,4}$.\n\nIn the literature this is the Kobayshi-Cho-Gray StrongArm\noptimisation, see e. g. B. Razavi, {\\it Design of Analog\nCMOS Integrated Circuits}, Chap. 13, and Nikolic {\\it et\nal.}, {\\it JSSC} {\\bf 35}, 944 (2000).  Naive ``more\n$g_{m}$ is faster'' ignores the self loading\n${{C}_{gs}}+{{C}_{gd}}+{{C}_{db}}\\propto W$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "cd4dd1af874830ea04fe5ee42aab23e4e3182bc2c788ff491ad9ce0373bfe899"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It recognizes that wider M5/M6 strengthen regeneration while adding node capacitance, and describes an optimum with improvement below it. However, it asserts that a normally sized latch is already at or beyond that optimum and concludes that appreciable widening degrades speed, contrary to the required initial trend that speed improves.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "5eed0194a609e5504312082df6fe7d71e18f6abfa8d0ff1bc1936ac8f33e2388",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 6142,
        "total_tokens": 10203,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3607,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4061,
        "output_tokens": 6142,
        "total_tokens": 10203,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3607,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the ideal clock the circuit is the\n${\\cal C}^{2}{\\rm MOS}$ ${\\rm TR}$ divider of Fig.1.\nThe two ${\\cal C}^{2}$ inverters plus ${\\rm Inv}_{3}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nZ&\\to X=\\bar Z{\\rm ~if~}{\\tt CK}=1\\cr\nX&\\to Y=\\bar X{\\rm ~if~}{\\tt CK}=0\\cr\nY&\\to Z=\\bar Y}$$\n\nso that with\n\n$${\\tt CK}=1~~~~\\left\\{\\eqalign{\nM_{D}&:Z\\to X\\cr\nM_{R}&:X{\\rm ~stored~on~}C_{Y}\\cr}\\right.\n\\qquad \n{\\tt CK}=0~~~~\\left\\{\\eqalign{\nM_{D}:&{\\rm stored~on~}C_{X}\\cr\nM_{R}:&X\\to Y\\to Z\\cr}\\right.$$\n\nthe circuit divides by two.\nFree running with ${\\tt CK}\\equiv 1$ it is the\ncommon three inverter ring.  Let\n\n$R_{D}\\propto 1/W_{D}$ , $R_{{\\tt CK}}\\propto 1/W_{{\\tt CK}}$\nbe the on resistance of the normal, $M_{1}$, and of the\nclock device and\n\n$$C_{X,Y}=C_{0}+C_{{\\rm diff},{\\tt CK}}+C_{g,{\\tt CK}}\n       \\approx C_{G,M_{1}}+C_{w}+W_{{\\tt CK}}C_{j}+W_{{\\tt CK}}C_{g}$$\n\nthe capacitance on the two dynamic nodes.\n$C_{0}$ is the gate capacitance of the next\n${\\cal C}^{2}$ inverter plus wiring, $W_{{\\tt CK}}C_{j}$\nthe ${\\tt CK}$ drain diffusion capacitance on $X,Y$\nand $W_{{\\tt CK}}C_{g}$ the gate capacitance that\nloads the ${\\tt CK}$ driver.\n\nFor the transparent latch\n\n$$t_{pD}\\approx \\left(R_{D}+R_{{\\tt CK}}\\right)C_{X,Y}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$t_{p}\\approx t_{pM}+t_{pR}+t_{{\\rm Inv}_{3}}\\approx\n2t_{pD}+t_{{\\rm Inv}_{3}} \\tag{2}$$\n\nis the period of the ring, $f_{0}\\propto 1/t_{p}$, and,\nmore important, $1/2t_{p}$ is the maximum ${\\tt CK}$\nfrequency that the divider will follow.\nIn the ideal clock, $t_{r,{\\tt CK}}=t_{f,{\\tt CK}}=0$,\napproximation (1) is often written $t_{pD}\\propto \nR_{{\\tt CK}}C_{0}$, i. e. $t_{pD}\\propto 1/W_{{\\tt CK}}$,\nfattening the ${\\tt CK}$ device lowers the stack\nresistance and the circuit goes faster, saturating\nat\n\n$$t_{pD}({\\rm min})\\approx R_{D}C_{0}\\tag{3}$$\n\nthe delay of the unclocked inverter.\n\nPut in the $W_{{\\tt CK}}$ dependence of $C_{X,Y}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nt_{pD}&=\\left(R_{D}+{a\\over {W_{{\\tt CK}}}}\\right)\n        \\left(C_{0}+bW_{{\\tt CK}}\\right) \\cr\n      &=R_{D}C_{0}+ab+R_{D}bW_{{\\tt CK}}+a{{C_{0}}\\over {W_{{\\tt CK}}}} \\cr}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$a\\propto R_{\\square},\\qquad b\\propto C_{j}+C_{g}\\;.$$\n\n(4) has the usual self loaded shallow minimum\n\n$${{dt_{pD}}\\over {dW_{{\\tt CK}}}}=0:\\qquad \nW_{{\\tt CK}}^{{\\rm opt}}=\\sqrt{{{aC_{0}}\\over {R_{D}b}}}\n      \\propto \\sqrt{{{C_{0}}\\over {R_{D}}}} \\tag{5}$$\n\nFor $W_{{\\tt CK}}<W_{{\\tt CK}}^{{\\rm opt}}$\n\n$${{dt_{pD}}\\over {dW_{{\\tt CK}}}}<0$$\n\nand the normal $1/W_{{\\tt CK}}$ speed up is observed;\nfor\n\n$$W_{{\\tt CK}}>W_{{\\tt CK}}^{{\\rm opt}}\\qquad \n{{dt_{pD}}\\over {dW_{{\\tt CK}}}}>0\\tag{6}$$\n\nthe $R_{D}bW_{{\\tt CK}}$ self loading term dominates.\nIn the limit\n\n$$t_{pD}\\to R_{D}bW_{{\\tt CK}}\\to \\infty \\qquad W_{{\\tt CK}}\\to \\infty \\tag{7}$$\n\nthe dynamic node has to be charged through the\n{\\it normal} device $R_{D}$ onto the ${\\tt CK}$\ndiffusion capacitance, and the extra $R_{{\\tt CK}}$\nreduction is immaterial.\n\nFor a modern process $C_{0}\\approx C_{j}W_{D}$ and\n$R_{D}\\propto 1/W_{D}$ so that (5) is\n\n$$W_{{\\tt CK}}^{{\\rm opt}}\\approx W_{D}\\sqrt{{{R_{\\square ,{\\tt CK}}C_{j,D}}\n\\over {R_{\\square ,D}C_{j,{\\tt CK}}}}}\\approx (0.5-1.0)W_{D}\\tag{8}$$\n\ni. e. the minimum is essentially at minimum geometry.\nAny ``normal'' ${\\cal C}^{2}$ divider is normally\ndesigned with $W_{{\\tt CK}}\\approx W_{{\\tt CK}}^{{\\rm opt}}\n\\approx W_{D,min}$ for minimum clock load and minimum\narea.  On that design\n\n$${{dt_{p}}\\over {dW_{{\\tt CK}}}}>0\\tag{9}$$\n\nfattening the clock devices puts more diffusion\ncapacitance on the high impedance dynamic nodes $X$\nand $Y$ than it takes out in stack resistance.\nE. g. with $W_{D}=W_{min}$\n\n$$\\left.{{t_{pD}(2W_{{\\tt CK}})}\\over {t_{pD}(W_{{\\tt CK}})}}\\right|\n      \\approx 1.1-1.3\\tag{10}$$\n\nin SPICE, i. e. essentially no speed up and for\n$W_{{\\tt CK}}\\gtrsim 2W_{min}$ a distinct slow down.\n\nIf the finite rise and fall time of the ${\\tt CK}$\ndriver is included the effect is much more marked.\n$C_{{\\tt CK}}=W_{{\\tt CK}}C_{g}$ loads the ${\\tt CK}$\nbuffer,\n\n$$t_{r,{\\tt CK}},t_{f,{\\tt CK}}\\propto R_{{\\tt CK}buf}C_{{\\tt CK}}\n      \\propto W_{{\\tt CK}}\\tag{11}$$\n\nand $t_{r,{\\tt CK}},t_{f,{\\tt CK}}$ add directly to the\nsetup and hold time of the latches and to (2).\nThe clock power\n\n$$P_{{\\tt CK}}\\propto C_{{\\tt CK}}V_{DD}^{2}f_{{\\tt CK}}\n      \\propto W_{{\\tt CK}}\\tag{12}$$\n\ngoes up linearly with $W_{{\\tt CK}}$ for essentially no\nimprovement in $f_{max}$ and, for $W_{{\\tt CK}}>\nW_{{\\tt CK}}^{{\\rm opt}}$, for a decrease in $f_{max}$.\n\n> {\\it In the text book $R_{{\\tt CK}}C_{0}$ approximation\n> the divider is said to go faster as $1/R_{{\\tt CK}}\n> \\propto W_{{\\tt CK}}$.  With parasitics included the\n> $f_{max}$ vs. $W_{{\\tt CK}}$ curve is very shallow,\n> saturates at (3) and then falls as $1/W_{{\\tt CK}}$,\n> Eq. 7.  In any area - power optimum design the optimum\n> is at essentially minimum ${\\tt CK}$ geometry, so that\n> any appreciable fattening of the ${\\tt CK}$ devices is\n> observed as a slow down and as a large increase in\n> clock power.  Neglecting the $W_{{\\tt CK}}C_{j}$ and\n> $W_{{\\tt CK}}C_{g}$ self loading the circuit goes\n> faster, $\\Delta t_{p}\\propto -1/W_{{\\tt CK}}$, saturating\n> at the unclocked inverter delay.}",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c3fe6a409f0232cb5c78b81c81d770c211d4ef1925d3e8b65e51b3cdb81f7045"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly states that widening initially improves speed by lowering the clocked devices’ on-resistance, while added latch-node diffusion capacitance eventually limits or reverses the benefit. Its width-dependent optimum captures the required trend; extra claims about typical sizing do not negate it.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "93d9b522d441668a699cc09168ad1991cf00bb982a5ad716cae0b7c7bec7c4fd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 7922,
        "total_tokens": 10130,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5820,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 7922,
        "total_tokens": 10130,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5820,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With an ideal ${\\cal CK}$ the conventional text\nbook ${\\cal R}{\\cal C}$ says the other way round.\nIn ${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$ form bracketing the two latches in\nFig. 1 with ${\\rm Inv_{3}}$ the whole thing is the\n${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$ ${\\rm Toggle}$ ${\\rm F/F}$ normally\nused as a $:2$.\nWith ${\\cal CK}=1$, ${\\overline {\\cal CK}}=0$\n\n$${\\rm Inv}_{1}:Z\\to X\\;\\;{\\rm passes}\\qquad \n  {\\rm Inv}_{2}:X\\not\\to Y\\;\\;{\\rm off}$$\n\nand with ${\\cal CK}=0$, ${\\overline {\\cal CK}}=1$\n\n$${\\rm Inv}_{1}:Z\\not\\to X\\;\\;{\\rm off}\\qquad \n  {\\rm Inv}_{2}:X\\to Y\\to Z\\;\\;{\\rm passes}$$\n\nso that for the toggle $f_{{\\rm max}}$\n\n$${{1}\\over {f_{{\\rm max}}}}\\approx\nt_{{\\rm M}}+t_{{\\rm S}}+t_{{\\rm I3}}\\tag{*}$$\n\n$$t_{{\\rm M,S}}\\approx 0.7R_{{\\rm eff}}C_{{\\rm L}}$$\n\n$$R_{{\\rm eff}}=R_{{\\rm I}}+R_{{\\rm sw}}$$\n$$\\eqalign{\nR_{{\\rm I}}&\\propto 1/W_{{\\rm I}}\\cr\nR_{{\\rm sw}}&\\propto 1/W_{{\\rm sw}}\\cr}$$\nis the series combination of the normally driven\ndevice, the $M_{1}$ in the figure, and the ${\\cal\nCK}$ switch and\n\n$$C_{{\\rm L}}=C_{X,Y}=C_{{db}I}+C_{{db}{\\rm sw}}\n+C_{gI}^{\\prime}+C_{W}\\propto W_{{\\rm sw}}+{\\rm const.}$$\n\nis the capacitance of the dynamic node $X$ resp. $Y$:\nthe drain diffusion of the switch itself, the gate\ncapacitance of the following ${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$ inverter\nand wiring.  E. {\\it g.} for the master\n\n$$C_{X}=C_{d}\\left( W_{{\\rm swM}}\\right)+C_{g}\\left(\nW_{{\\rm IS}}\\right)+C_{0}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$R_{{\\rm M}}=R_{0}/W_{{\\rm IM}}+R_{0}/W_{{\\rm swM}}\\tag{2}$$\n\nso that, with ${\\cal CK}$ ideal, the Elmore delay\nof the transparent latch is, to first order,\n\n$$t_{{\\rm M}}\\propto \\left({{R_{0}}\\over {W_{{\\rm IM}}}}\n+{{R_{0}}\\over {W_{{\\rm sw}}}}\\right)\n\\left( C_{0}^{\\prime}+C_{0}^{\\prime\\prime}W_{{\\rm sw}}\n\\right) \\tag{3}$$\n\n$$t_{{\\rm M}}= {{A}\\over {W_{{\\rm sw}}}}+BW_{{\\rm sw}}+C\\tag{4}$$\n\n$${{dt_{{\\rm M}}}\\over {dW_{{\\rm sw}}}}=0:\n\\qquad W_{{\\rm sw}}^{{\\rm opt}}\\approx \n\\sqrt{{{A}\\over {B}}}= \\sqrt{{{R_{0}C_{0}^{\\prime}}\n\\over {R_{0}C_{0}^{\\prime\\prime}/W_{{\\rm IM}}}} }\n\\approx \\sqrt{{{C_{0}^{\\prime}W_{{\\rm IM}}}\\over\n{C_{0}^{\\prime\\prime}}}} \\tag{5}$$\n\nNeglecting the self loading $C_{db{\\rm sw}}\\propto\nW_{{\\rm sw}}$ in (1) $B=0$ and\n\n$$t_{{\\rm M,S}}\\propto {{1}\\over {W_{{\\rm sw}}}}$$\n\n{\\it i. e.} in the conventional text book\napproximation with $C_{{\\rm L}}={\\rm const.}$ and\n${\\cal CK}$ ideal the latch looks faster and $(*)$\nlooks faster the larger you make the pass transistor,\n$t_{pd}\\propto R_{{\\rm sw}}C_{{\\rm L}}\\propto\n1/W_{{\\rm sw}}$; you just lower the series resistance\nin the signal path.\n\nWith the self loading retained (3)--(4) has a shallow\nminimum (5).  Normally $R_{{\\rm I}}\\gg R_{{\\rm sw}}$,\n$C_{0}^{\\prime\\prime}W_{{\\rm sw}}\\sim C_{0}^{\\prime}$\nalready for $W_{{\\rm sw}}=W_{{\\rm min}}$ so that\n$W_{{\\rm sw}}^{{\\rm opt}}$ is essentially $W_{{\\rm min}}$\nand for any appreciable $W_{{\\rm sw}}>W_{{\\rm sw}}^{{\\rm\nopt}}$\n\n$$t_{{\\rm M,S}}\\approx BW_{{\\rm sw}}\\propto W_{{\\rm sw}}$$\n\nthe delay {\\it increases} about linearly with the\nwidth of the ${\\cal CK}$ device hung on the dynamic\nnodes $X$ and $Y$.  The same $W_{{\\rm sw}}$ hangs a\ngate capacitance\n\n$$C_{{\\cal CK}}=C_{g{\\rm swM}}+C_{g{\\rm swS}}\\propto\nW_{{\\rm swM}}+W_{{\\rm swS}}$$\n\non the ${\\cal CK}$ and ${\\overline {\\cal CK}}$ nets.\nWith a realistic ${\\cal CK}$ driver of finite\n$R_{{\\cal CK}}$ the ${\\cal CK}$ rise and fall time\n\n$$t_{r{\\cal CK}}\\propto R_{{\\cal CK}}C_{{\\cal CK}}\n\\propto W_{{\\rm sw}}$$\n\ngoes up $\\propto W_{{\\rm sw}}$ degrading $t_{su}$,\n$t_{h}$ and adding $t_{r{\\cal CK}}$ to $(*)$.  In\naddition the overlap $C_{gd{\\rm sw}}\\propto W_{{\\rm\nsw}}$ couples the ${\\cal CK}$ transition onto the\nfloating dynamic node $X$ resp. $Y$,\n\n$$\\Delta V_{X,Y}\\approx {{C_{gd{\\rm sw}}}\\over\n{C_{X,Y}}}\\;V_{{\\cal CK}}$$\n\nand the charge sharing between\n\n$$C_{{\\rm int}}=C_{s{\\rm sw}}+C_{d{\\rm I}}$$\n\nthe inter series device node, and $C_{X,Y}$ gets worse\n$\\propto W_{{\\rm sw}}$.\n\nIn normal design language the divider is said to get\nslower, more power hungry, $P_{{\\cal CK}}=C_{{\\cal\nCK}}V_{DD}^{2}f_{{\\cal CK}}\\propto W_{{\\rm sw}}$,\nand more feed through sensitive when you up size the\n${\\cal CK}$ switches.  The $1/W_{{\\rm sw}}$ resistive\nimprovement is normally already saturated with the\n${\\cal CK}$ devices at $W_{{\\rm min}}$.  E. {\\it g.}\nin $0.18\\mu $ SPICE $W_{{\\rm sw}}^{{\\rm opt}}\\approx\n1$--$2\\,W_{{\\rm min}}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In the ideal ${\\cal CK}$, $C_{{\\rm\n> L}}={\\rm const.}$ Elmore approximation normally quoted\n> in the text books this self loading and ${\\cal CK}$\n> loading is neglected and the circuit is normally\n> described as getting {\\it faster\\/} with larger\n> $W_{{\\rm sw}}$, $t_{pd}\\approx 0.7\\left(R_{{\\rm I}}+\n> R_{0}/W_{{\\rm sw}}\\right)C_{{\\rm L}}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "7d5cfa78bd80ccf5dc72de2f37f2f281da97d52ee5b240c83a7f4e6193e38bca"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies the resistance–capacitance tradeoff and derives an optimum, but its stated practical conclusion is that widening the clocked transistors slows the divider. The golden answer requires the initial speed improvement from reduced on-resistance; the candidate’s degradation conclusion earns partial credit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "93d9b522d441668a699cc09168ad1991cf00bb982a5ad716cae0b7c7bec7c4fd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 7139,
        "total_tokens": 9347,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5289,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 7139,
        "total_tokens": 9347,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5289,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 10,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-010-speed-improve-or-degrade-increase-widths-clocked/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "It is the well known frequency divider/ring.\n$C^{2}MOS$.\n\n$$\\vcenter{\n\\hbox{${\\rm Inv}_{1}\\equiv Z+{\\bar C}_{K}\\to X$}\n\\hbox{${\\rm Inv}_{2}\\equiv X+{C}_{K}\\to Y$}\n\\hbox{${\\rm Inv}_{3}\\equiv Y\\to Z$}\n}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{C}_{K}=0 & {\\rm Inv}_{1}~~{\\rm HZ}~~ {\\rm Inv}_{2}~~{\\rm ON}\\cr\n& Y=\\bar X\\;\\;Z=\\bar Y =X\\cr\n{C}_{K}=1 & {\\rm Inv}_{1}~~{\\rm ON}~~{\\rm Inv}_{2}~~{\\rm HZ}\\cr\n& X=\\bar Z\\;\\;Z^{*}= \\bar Y^{*} }$$\n\nIn the phase in which it is ${\\rm ON}$ the\ninverter is a normal $CMOS$ inverter with a $n$ and a $p$\nin series\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nR_{X}&=R_{p{\\rm D}}+R_{p{\\rm C}}~~{\\rm pull\\;up}\\cr\n     &=R_{n{\\rm D}}+R_{n{\\rm C}}~~{\\rm pull\\;down}\\cr\nR_{Y}&={\\rm ditto}}$$\n\nin Elmore sense, Fig.1,\n\n$${\\cal T}_{X}\\approx \\left(R_{D}+R_{C}\\right)C_{X}\\tag{1}$$\n$${\\cal T}_{Y}\\approx \\left(R_{D}+R_{C}\\right)C_{Y}\\tag{2}$$\n$$f_{osc}\\approx \\left[2\\left({\\cal T}_{X}+{\\cal T}_{Y}\n+{\\cal T}_{3}\\right)\\right]^{-1}\\propto \n{\\cal T}^{-1}\\tag{3}$$\n\nand, for a divider, the maximum usable ${C}_{K}$\nfrequency is $\\propto {\\cal T}^{-1}$.\n\n$$R_{C}=R_{C0}{W_{C0}\\over W_{C}}\\propto {1\\over W_{C}}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$C_{X}=C_{X0}+C_{dC}\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$C_{dC}=C_{j}+C_{jsw}+C_{ov}\\propto W_{C}\\tag{6}$$\n\nSo that {\\it e. g.} for the pull down\n\n$${\\cal T}_{Xf}\\approx \\left(R_{n1}+R_{nC0}{W_{0}\\over W_{C}}\\right)\n\\left[C_{Xf0}+C_{nC}^{\\prime}W_{C}+C_{pC}^{\\prime}W_{C}\\right]\n\\tag{7}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$C_{Xf0}\\approx C_{g,p2}+C_{g,n1,2}+C_{w}\\tag{8}$$\n\nthe {\\it fixed} gate load of the next $C^{2}MOS$\ninverter plus wiring, {\\it i. e.} independent of $W_{C}$.\n\n$${d{\\cal T}\\over dW_{C}}=-{R_{C0}W_{0}\\over W_{C}^{2}}\n\\left(C_{0}+C^{\\prime}W_{C}\\right)+\n\\left(R_{D}+R_{C0}{W_{0}\\over W_{C}}\\right)C^{\\prime}=0\\tag{9}$$\n\n$$W_{C,opt}\\approx \\sqrt{{R_{C0}W_{0}C_{0}\\over\nR_{D}C^{\\prime}}}\\tag{10}$$\n\n${\\cal T}(W_{C})$ is $1/W_{C}$ for $W_{C}$ small,\n$R_{C}\\gg R_{D}$, and $\\propto W_{C}$ for $W_{C}$\nlarge $R_{C}\\ll R_{D}$\n\n$${\\cal T}\\approx R_{C}C_{0}\\propto 1/W_{C}\\;\\;W_{C}\\to 0\\tag{11}$$\n$${\\cal T}\\approx R_{D}C_{0}+R_{D}C^{\\prime}W_{C}\n\\propto W_{C}\\;\\;W_{C}\\to \\infty \\tag{12}$$\n\nIn words: as soon as $R_{C}<R_{D}$ making $W_{C}$\nlarger does not make the $RC$ product any smaller.\nIt is dominated by the {\\it data} device $M_{1}$ and\nits complementary $p$ , $R_{D}\\approx $ constant.\nYou continue to pay linearly the drain junction,\nside wall and overlap capacitance of the clock\ndevice on the very critical dynamic nodes $X$ and $Y$\nand its gate capacitance\n\n$$C_{CK}=C_{gCK}=C_{ox}W_{C}L_{C}\\tag{13}$$\n\non the clock distribution.\n\nFor an ideal, zero impedance, ${C}_{K}$ source (9)\nhas a shallow optimum at $R_{C}\\approx R_{D}$,\n{\\it i. e.} $W_{C}\\approx W_{D}$, normally\n$W_{pC}\\approx 2W_{nC}$, of the order of the\nminimum width device.  Normalised to that optimum\nthe improvement you get by going from $W_{C}=W_{min}$\nto $W_{C,opt}$ is $10$ to $20\\%$.  Any substantial\nfactor $>2-3$ increase in $W_{C}$ makes $C_{X},C_{Y}$\nin (5)-(6) dominate and\n\n$${\\cal T}\\approx {\\cal T}_{min}+R_{D}C^{\\prime}\\Delta W_{C}\\tag{14}$$\n\nincrease , {\\it i. e.} decrease the oscillation\nfrequency, decrease the divider $f_{max}$, increase\n${\\rm CK\\to Q}$.\n\nWith a realistic clock driver\n\n$${\\cal T}_{CK}=R_{CK,drv}C_{CK}\\propto R_{CK,drv}W_{C}\\tag{15}$$\n\nhas to be added to (1)-(2).  Unless the clock\ndriver is scaled up in proportion to $W_{C}$ , with\nall the power $P_{CK}=C_{CK}V_{DD}^{2}f_{CK}$ penalty\nthat that entails, (15) degrades $t_{r},t_{f}$ of\n${C}_{K}$ directly.\n\nThat is normally quoted as: {\\it widening the clock\ndevices beyond minimum to  $1.5\\times$ {\\rm self loads}\nthe $C^{2}MOS$ latch and makes it slower.}\n\nUp sizing for speed has to be done on $M_{1}$ and on\nits $p$ complement.  $W_{C}$ is normally left at\n$W_{min}$ or $1-2\\,W_{min}$.  In text book form:\n\n> {\\it The $C^{2}MOS$ is {\\rm clock self loaded}. \n> Making the clock transistors fat does not speed the\n> circuit up.  For any useful increase it slows it\n> down.}\n\nWith an ideal clock the conventional $1/W_{C}$\nspeed up saturates at $R_{C}\\approx {1\\over 3}-\n1\\,R_{D}$ and is then swamped by the $W_{C}$\ncapacitance.  With a normal clock driver the\ncircuit is slower for essentially {\\it any}\nincrease of $W_{C}$ if the driver is not also\nwidened.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "630bc05c5dc5c1d3b10d157ba841931271769f1964f6374055c2195e108ebfa9"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It identifies the series clocked/data devices and derives the correct tradeoff: widening lowers clock-device on-resistance, improving speed initially, while added latch-node capacitance eventually limits or reverses the benefit. The practical clock-driver caveat does not negate that trend.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "93d9b522d441668a699cc09168ad1991cf00bb982a5ad716cae0b7c7bec7c4fd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 7028,
        "total_tokens": 9236,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5240,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2208,
        "output_tokens": 7028,
        "total_tokens": 9236,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5240,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "Does the structure in the figure provide quadrature outputs?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the $\\Delta \\tau =0$ approximation\nthe thing {\\it is} the ${\\rm M/S}$ ${\\rm T}-{\\rm gate}$\n${\\rm FF}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nZ&\\to D \\cr\nX&={{\\rm M} \\uparrow}\\cr\nY&={{\\rm S}\\uparrow}\\cr\nZ&=\\bar Y\\cr}$$\n\nviz. Fig 1 27 of Razavi.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{{Z=0}\\atop {X=1}}&{{Z=1}\\atop {X=0}}\\cr\n&\\cr\n{{M}_{p\\,t}=ON\\atop M_{1}=OFF}&{{M}_{p\\,t}=OFF\\atop M_{1}=ON}\\cr}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{\\rm if}\\;CK=1\\;(C{\\bar K}=0)\\;\nX&=\\bar Z\\cr\n{\\rm if}\\;CK=0\\;X&=Z_{-1} \\quad {\\rm dyn.\\;hold}\\cr}$$\n\nand\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{\\rm if}\\;CK=0\\;(C{\\bar K}=1)\\;\nY&=\\bar X\\cr\n{\\rm if}\\;CK=1\\;Y&=Y_{-1} \\quad {\\rm dyn.\\;hold}\\cr}$$\n\nso that with ${\\rm Inv}_{3}$\n\n$$Y=\\bar Z\\tag*{ideal $\\Delta \\tau _{{\\rm Inv}}=0$}$$\n\n$$Z=\\bar Y =X\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;CK=0\\quad {\\rm and}\\quad\nZ=\\bar X \\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;CK=1\\tag{1}$$\n\nPutting (1) together for a $50\\%$ $CK$\n\n{\\it e. g.} $Z_{-1}=0\\;,Y_{-1}=1\\;,X_{-1}=0$\nfor $CK=0$\n\n* $0<t<T_{CK}/2\\;\\;CK=1$ : ${\\rm M}$ transparent\n\n$$X=\\bar Z_{-1}=1\\tag{2a}$$\n$${\\rm S}\\;\\;{\\rm holds}\\;\\;Y=Y_{-1}=1\\tag{2b}$$\n$$Z=\\bar Y=0\\tag{2c}$$\n\n$X$ has toggled on the $0\\to 1$ transition\nof $CK$.\n\n* $T_{CK}/2<t<T_{CK}\\;\\;CK=0$ : ${\\rm M}$ held,\n${\\rm S}$ transparent\n\n$$X=X_{1}=1\\tag{3a}$$\n$$Y=\\bar X=0\\tag{3b}$$\n$$Z=\\bar Y=1\\tag{3c}$$\n\n$Y$ and $Z$ have toggled on the $1\\to 0$\ntransition of $CK$.  In the ${\\rm next}$ $CK=1$\n\n$$X=\\bar Z=0\\tag{4}$$\n\netc.  So that with $T_{d}=2T_{CK}$ is the\nperiod of the divided signal :\n\n* $$f_{X}=f_{Y}=f_{Z}=f_{CK}/2\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$T_{d}=2T_{CK}\\qquad D_{X}=D_{Y}=D_{Z}=D_{CK}\n{\\buildrel {D_{CK}=1/2}\\over {=}}50\\% \\;{\\rm ideal}$$\n\nand, in the $\\Delta \\tau =0$ limit,\nFig.1\n\n$$X=\n\\cases{Z & $CK=0$\\cr\n\\bar Z & $CK=1$\\cr}\\tag{6}$$\n\nis {\\it high} $T_{CK}/2+T_{CK}/2=T_{CK}$,\n{\\it low} $T_{CK}$ and\n\n* $$Y=\\bar Z\\tag{7}$$\n\nis high $T_{CK}$ low $T_{CK}$.  Put in\nengineering form the ${\\rm M}$ output\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nX(t)&=X\\left(t+T_{d}\\right)\\cr\nX\\left(t+T_{CK}/2\\right)&=\\bar X(t)\\cr}\\tag{8}$$\n\ntoggles on the rising edge of $CK$,\nwhereas the ${\\rm S}$ output\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nY(t)&=Y\\left(t+T_{d}\\right)\\cr\nY\\left(t+T_{CK}/2\\right)&=\\bar Y(t)\\cr}\\tag{9}$$\n\ntoggles on the falling edge of $CK$.\nI. e.\n\n$$\\Delta t_{X-Y}=T_{CK}/2=T_{d}/4 \\tag{10}$$\n\n$$\\Delta \\phi _{X-Y}=2\\pi \\Delta t/T_{d}= \\pi /2\\tag{11}$$\n\nnormalised to the output frequency.\nIn the textbook $0$ delay , $D_{CK}=50\\%$\n, matched $t_{pLH}=t_{pHL}$ limit $X(t)$\nand $Y(t)$ \\lbrack and $Z(t)=\\bar Y(t)$\\rbrack\nare a conventional $I,Q$ ,\n$0^{\\rm o},90^{\\rm o}\\left(270^{\\rm o}\\right),\n180^{\\rm o},270^{\\rm o}\\left(90^{\\rm o}\\right)$,\nfour phase divide by two.  E. g.  with\nthe normalisation $Z\\equiv 0^{\\rm o}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nZ(t)&=\\sin \\left(\\omega _{d}t\\right)\\qquad \n      \\omega _{d}=\\omega _{CK}/2\\cr\nY(t)&=\\bar Z(t)=\\sin \\left(\\omega _{d}t+\\pi \\right)\\cr\nX(t)&=\\sin \\left(\\omega _{d}t\\pm \\pi /2\\right)\\cr}\\tag{12}$$\n\n{\\it c. f.} the $I=\\sin \\omega _{d}t$,\n$Q=\\cos \\omega _{d}t=\\sin \\left(\\omega _{d}t+\\pi /2\n\\right)$ square wave\napproximation, Fig.2.  During $CK=1$ $X=Y$\nduring $CK=0$ $X=\\bar Y$, {\\it viz.} the normal\n$90^{\\rm o}$ square wave quadrature overlap.\n\nThat is what is normally quoted as ``the\n${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$ {\\it or} ${\\rm TSPC}$ divide\nby two is a quadrature divide by two, $X=I$,\n$Y=Q$''.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In normal language the block\n> as drawn is a {\\it single\\/} toggle ${\\rm FF}$,\n> a differential $\\div 2$, $Z$, $\\bar Z=Y$.\n> Taken as a black box it has one \\lbrack\n> differential\\rbrack output.  Taken as a\n> ${\\rm M/S}$ ${\\rm FF}$ the two {\\it internal\\/}\n> dynamic nodes, ${\\rm M}$ and ${\\rm S}$, can be\n> used as the $I$ and $Q$ phases.\n\nIn any physical implementation (10)-(11) is\ncorrupted to first order by\n\n* (a) the conventional $CK$ to $Q$ delay,\n$t_{CQ}^{M}\\ne t_{CQ}^{S}$;\n\n* (b) the extra delay of ${\\rm Inv}_{3}$,\n$t_{p}({\\rm Inv}_{3})$,\nso that, e. g.\n\n$$Z(t)=Y\\left(t-t_{p3}\\right)\\tag{13}$$\n\nand\n\n$$\\Delta \\phi _{X-Z}= \\pi /2 \\pm \n\\omega _{d}t_{p3}+{\\cal O}(\\Delta t_{CQ})\\tag{14}$$\n\nwhereas\n\n$$\\Delta \\phi _{X-Y}= \\pi /2+{\\cal O}(\\Delta t_{CQ})\\tag{15}$$\n\nis to first order independent of $t_{p3}$;\n\n* (c) any deviation of $D_{CK}$ from $50\\%$,\n\n$$\\Delta \\phi =\\pi /2\\pm \\pi \\left(D_{CK}-1/2\\right)\n\\tag{16}$$\n\n* (d) $t_{pLH}\\ne t_{pHL}$ so that $D_{X}\\ne D_{Y}\n\\ne 50\\%$ even for $D_{CK}=50\\%$;\n\n* (e) the fact that $X$ and $Y$ are {\\it\ndynamic\\/} storage nodes.  Loading $X$ or $Y$\nwith anything more than a minimum size,\nmatched, dummy compensated inverter\ndestroys the charge hold and the division\nratio.  Normally $X$ and $Y$ have to be\nbuffered with a pair of {\\it matched\\/}\ninverters $X\\to I,\\bar I$, $Y\\to Q,\\bar Q$,\nwhich then have to be ratioed so as not to\ndestroy the loop gain, and the systematic\nmismatch of the two buffers adds directly to\n(14)-(16).\n\nBecause of (a)-(e) the circuit as drawn,\nwithout matched symmetrical re timing and\nbuffering, is normally not usable as a\nprecision $I/Q$ generator.  With a pair of\nmatched output inverters/buffers on $X$ and\non $Y$ \\lbrack $Z$\\rbrack  it can be used as a\nlow accuracy, $f_{CK}/2$, nominal $50\\%$ duty,\n$90^{\\rm o}$ quadrature generator, quadrature\nerror, Fig.1,\n\n$$\\epsilon _{\\phi }\\approx \n\\omega _{d}\\left[t_{p3}+\\Delta t_{CQ}+\n\\Delta t_{pLH-pHL}\\right]+\n\\pi\\left(D_{CK}-1/2\\right) \\tag{17}$$\n\ntypically a few degrees to more than $10^{\\rm\no}$ in a conventional CMOS process, plus the\nnormal ${\\rm PRBS}$ jitter.  For precision\nquadrature the conventional remedy is to go\nto a fully static, or better a differential\n${\\rm CML}$-${\\rm M/S}$ latch pair, or to a\nJohnson counter $\\div 4$ and re time, where\nthe $I$ to $Q$ delay is set by geometry not\nby $D_{CK}$ and $t_{p3}$.  In that strict\nsense the answer is ``no''.\n\n> {\\it N. B.:} The circuit is dynamic and will\n> fail below a minimum $f_{CK}\\approx\n> I_{leak}/C_{X,Y}$ due to droop of the held\n> state.\n\nFig.1 - ideal timing $D_{CK}=50\\%$,\n$\\Delta \\tau =0$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nCK &: 01010101\\cr\nX  &: 01100110\\cr\nY  &: 11001100\\cr\nZ  &: 00110011\\cr}$$\n\n$X$ changes on $\\uparrow CK$, $Y,Z$ on\n$\\downarrow CK$, $T_{d}=2T_{CK}$.\n\nFig.2 - Square wave quadrature,\n$I=\\sin \\omega _{d}t$, $Q=\\cos\\omega _{d}t$,\n$I=Q$ half the time, $I=\\bar Q$ half the time.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "1d774d7249734e5bf95309e6d4a68f648338a7f307c5f5ece8089efd22b4c5b3"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies nominal quadrature from the latches switching half an input period apart and explains the skew from Inv3. It also notes unequal clock-to-Q timing and buffer-loading concerns, but does not clearly identify the topology-specific unequal loads seen by X and Y, which the full-credit rule requires.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a208e36107d3c6d3d835e897ccf309733e82f6921b41cd2eef1a21949e70e6f6",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2193,
        "output_tokens": 10899,
        "total_tokens": 13092,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8330,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2193,
        "output_tokens": 10899,
        "total_tokens": 13092,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8330,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "Does the structure in the figure provide quadrature outputs?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With a zero delay ${\\rm Inv}_{3}$ it is the normal\nso called {\\it quadrature } ${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$ ${\\rm TSPC}$\n${\\rm D}$ ${\\rm F/F}$ ${\\rm :}\\,2$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nL_{1}&:{\\rm all\\,\\, apart\\, from\\, }{\\rm Inv}_{3}\\cr\n{\\rm is}&{\\rm a\\,C^{2}MOS\\,latch\\,transparent\\,for\\,}CK=1\\cr\nL_{2}&:{\\rm transparent\\,for\\,}CK=0\\cr\nL_{1}+L_{2}&:{\\rm a\\,clocked\\,}{\\rm D}{\\rm F/F}}$$\n\nPut $Y=Q$, $Z={\\bar Q}$ and $X=I$.\nFor $CK=0$\n\n$$Q = {\\bar I}\\tag {\\ast}$$\n\nbecause $L_{2}$ is transparent, $L_{1}$ is in hold.\nFor $CK=1$\n\n$$I = Z = {\\bar Q}\\tag {\\ast\\ast}$$\n\nbecause $L_{1}$ is transparent, $L_{2}$ is in hold.\n{\\it e. g.} for $T_{CK}\\ne f\\left(T\\right)$ put $T_{CK}=\nT/2$, $D_{CK}=50\\%$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nCK=0&:\\;I^{n},\\,Q^{n}={\\bar I}^{n}\\cr\nCK=1&:\\;I^{n+1}={\\bar Q}^{n},\\,Q^{n+1}=Q^{n}\\cr\nCK=0&:\\;I^{n+1},\\,Q^{n+1}={\\bar I}^{n+1}=Q^{n}\\cr}$$\n\n{\\it i. e.} with the conventional zero delay inverter,\nFig.1,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nX^{n+1}&=Y^{n}\\cr\nY^{n+1}&={\\bar Y}^{n}}$$\n\nso that $X$ and $Y$ are conventional ${\\rm :}\\,2$\n${{50\\%}}$ square waves\n\n$$f_{X}=f_{Y}=f_{Z}={1\\over 2}f_{CK}\\tag {1}$$\n\nand, to within the nomenclature ${\\bar Q}=-Q$,\n\n$$Y(t)=X\\left(t-{1\\over 2}T_{CK}\\right)\n      =X\\left(t-{1\\over 4}T_{X}\\right) \\tag{2}$$\n\n{\\it i. e.} the two latches are normally described as the\n{\\it quadrature $:$2} {\\it pseudo quadrature $:$2}.\nUp to the sign, $X$ {\\it e. g.} $Z$ can be used as the\n${\\cal I}$ channel and $Y$ as the ${\\cal Q}$ channel,\nor {\\it vice versa}, at ${f_{CK}/2}$.\nIn the time domain Fig.2\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nt_{0}&:CK=0:\\;X_{0}=0,\\;Y_{0}={\\bar X}_{0}=1,\\;Z_{0}=0\\cr\nt_{1}&:CK=1:\\;X_{1}=Y_{0}=1,\\;Y_{1}=Y_{0}=1,\\;Z_{1}=0\\cr\nt_{2}&:CK=0:\\;X_{2}=X_{1}=1,\\;Y_{2}={\\bar X}_{2}=0,\\;Z_{2}=1\\cr\nt_{3}&:CK=1:\\;X_{3}=Y_{2}=0,\\;Y_{3}=Y_{2}=0,\\;Z_{3}=1\\cr\nt_{4}&:CK=0:\\;X_{4}=X_{3}=0,\\;Y_{4}={\\bar X}_{4}=1\\cr}$$\n\nso that $Y$ is the $T_{CK}/2=T_{D}/4$ delayed, {\\it i.\ne.} $90^{{\\rm o}}$ at $f_{D}=f_{CK}/2$, replica of $X$,\n$Z={\\bar Y}$ the $270^{{\\rm o}}$ replica.  The circuit is\nnormally sold as the conventional ${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$\nquadrature Miller divider.\n\nIn a real technology the $90^{{\\rm o}}$ is corrupted to\n\n$$\\phi_{XY}={\\pi \\over 2}\\pm \\delta \\phi\\qquad \n  \\delta \\phi = 2\\pi {t_{p3}\\over {T_{D}}}= \\pi {t_{p3}\\over\n  {T_{CK}}} \\tag{3}$$\n\nand, more important for ${\\cal I}{\\cal Q}$ work, the mark\nto space ratio is corrupted to $50\\%\\pm t_{p3}/T_{D}$ by\nthe unsymmetric loading of the two latches by ${\\rm\nInv}_{3}$.  In the pedantic sense the one inverter loop\nis not a {\\it true} quadrature divider.  The true\n$50\\%$, $90.0^{{\\rm o}}$ ${\\cal I}{\\cal Q}$ divider is the\ndifferential, Johnson, {\\it i. e.} two latch, ring with\nno extra inverter, ${\\bar Q}_{1}\\rightarrow D_{2}$,\n${\\bar Q}_{2}\\rightarrow D_{1}$ {\\it etc.}, normally\nimplemented in fully differential ${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$ or\n${\\rm TSPC}$ with symmetric keepers.  With $t_{p3}$ made\n$\\ll T_{CK}$ {\\it e. g.} by making ${\\rm Inv}_{3}$ a\nsmall, fast, inverter, Eq.(3) is normally neglected and\nthe circuit of Fig.1 is loosely referred to as the\nquadrature $:$2 divider.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  At $f_{CK}$ the phase shift is\n> nominally $45^{{\\rm o}}$.\n\nFig.1 ideal waveforms, $t_{p3}=0$.\nFig.2 real waveforms, $t_{p3}\\ne 0$.\n\nFor $t_{p3}\\rightarrow 0$ the answer is normally\nabbreviated to {\\it yes}.  Pedantically {\\it no}.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "09245a62688a5a9bf4478ea7f01c8d26c247c28b7ab35d152bd7b74230a33e85"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies nominal divide-by-two quadrature from the opposite-phase latches and notes finite Inv3 delay and asymmetric loading. However, it assigns the delay-induced phase error to X–Y rather than the skewed Z output, and its latch-state equations are inconsistent, so the nonideal timing explanation is not fully correct.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a208e36107d3c6d3d835e897ccf309733e82f6921b41cd2eef1a21949e70e6f6",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2193,
        "output_tokens": 7412,
        "total_tokens": 9605,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5904,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2193,
        "output_tokens": 7412,
        "total_tokens": 9605,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5904,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 11,
      "question": "Does the structure in the figure provide quadrature outputs?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-011-structure-provide-quadrature-outputs/figure-10.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the normal ${\\rm TSPC}$ idealisation the\ncircuit is normally {\\it sold\\/} as the ${\\rm TSPC}\\div 2$\n{\\it quadrature\\/} ${\\rm VCO}$ divider.  In the loss\nless ${\\cal D}=0.5$ idealisation it is a $\\div 2$ on\nopposite phases.\n\n{\\tt X} is ${\\cal D}$ on $CK=1$:\n\n$$X={\\bar Z}\\;\\;{\\rm on}\\;CK=1\\qquad {\\rm hold\\;on}\\;CK=0\\tag\n{1}$$\n\n$${\\rm i.\\,e.}\\;X={\\bar Z}.CK+ X.{\\bar CK}$$\n\nand ${\\tt Y}$ is ${\\cal D}$ on $CK=0$\n\n$$Y={\\bar X}\\;\\;{\\rm on}\\;{\\bar CK}=1\\qquad\n{\\rm hold\\;on}\\;CK=1\\tag{2}$$\n\n$${\\rm i.\\,e.}\\;Y={\\bar X}.{\\bar CK}+Y.CK$$\n\n$$Z={\\bar Y}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$1+2+3$ is a conventional master slave $D$ type with\n\n$$D=Z\\tag{4}$$\n\nPut $2$ in $1$ etc. In normal operation with\n$X$ holding:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nCK=1: & X={\\bar Z}=Y \\cr\n{\\bar CK}=1: & Y={\\bar X}\\cr\n& Z={\\bar Y}=X\\cr}$$\n\nso that with the conventional $50\\%$ $CK$,\nFig.1, $X$ changes on $CK\\uparrow $ and $Y$ changes on\n$CK\\downarrow $.\n\n{\\it e. g.} with $Y=0$, $Z=1$, $X=1$, Fig.1\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nCK\\uparrow :& X:1\\rightarrow 0\\cr\nCK\\downarrow :& Y:0\\rightarrow 1\\;,\\;Z:1\\rightarrow 0\\cr\nCK\\uparrow :& X:0\\rightarrow 1\\cr\nCK\\downarrow :& Y:1\\rightarrow 0\\;,\\;Z:0\\rightarrow 1\\cr\n& {\\rm etc.}\\cr}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nT_{X}&=T_{Y}=T_{Z}=2T_{CK}\\cr\nf_{X}&=f_{Y}=f_{Z}=f_{CK}/2\\tag{5}\\cr\nY(t)&=X(t-T_{CK}/2)\\cr\nZ(t)&={\\bar Y}(t)\\cr}$$\n\n$T_{CK}/2=T_{X}/4$.  Apart from the propagation delay\n$t_{p{\\rm Inv3}}$ of the static inverter ${\\rm Inv_{3}}$\n\n$$t_{pX}-t_{pY}=T_{CK}/2=T_{\\div 2}/4\\tag{6}$$\n\ni. e. at the divided frequency $f_{\\div 2}=f_{CK}/2$\n$X$ and $Y$ are in phase quadrature\n\n$$\\Delta \\phi _{X-Y}=2\\pi {{T_{CK}/2}\\over {T_{\\div 2}}}\n={\\pi \\over 2}\\tag{7}$$\n\nmodulo the inversion.  Up to the inversion you may call\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI &= X\\;\\;({\\rm or}\\;{\\bar X})\\cr\nQ &= Y\\;\\;({\\rm or}\\;Z={\\bar Y})\\cr}\\tag{8}$$\n\nthe $I$ and $Q$ phases at $f_{CK}/2$:\n\n$$I\\approx \\cos \\omega _{0}t/2\\qquad Q\\approx \n\\sin \\omega _{0}t/2\\tag{9}$$\n\nand the circuit is very often quoted in the literature as\nthe low power ${\\rm TSPC}$ $\\div 2$ quadrature generator\nfor a quadrature ${\\rm VCO}$.\n\nIn the strict sense the $I/Q$ so obtained are\n\n* single ended\n* dynamic - $X$ and $Y$ are floating on opposite\nphases, Fig.1, and will droop to the leakage value if\n$f_{CK}<f_{{\\rm leak}}\\approx 1/R_{{\\rm leak}}C_{X,Y}$,\n* unbalanced - only $Y$ is isolated by the static\ninverter ${\\rm Inv_{3}}$, $X$ is not,\n* duty cycle sensitive - (6) is $T_{CK}/2=\n{\\cal D}T_{CK}$ on one side and $(1-{\\cal D})T_{CK}$ on\nthe other so that with ${\\cal D}\\ne 0.5$\n\n$$\\Delta \\phi ={\\pi \\over 2}\\pm \\pi ({\\cal D}-0.5)\n+{{\\omega _{\\div 2}}t_{p{\\rm Inv3}}}\\tag{10}$$\n\n* contaminated by $C_{gd}$ feed through and charge\nsharing between the two series devices of each dynamic\nstage.\n\nWith the customary weak cross coupled keeper on $X$\nand on $Y$ and a buffer inverter on $X$ so that both\nphases are taken after a static inverter the circuit\nbecomes the conventional static ${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$\n${\\rm TSPC}$ quadrature $\\div 2$.  Without the keepers/\nbuffers it is normally referred to in the purist\nliterature as a {\\it pseudo} or {\\it dynamic\\/}\nquadrature divider and, if a $50\\%$ duty cycle rail to\nrail differential $I,{\\bar I},Q,{\\bar Q}$ quadrature\n${\\rm LO}$ is required, quoted as {\\it no\\/}.\n\nIn particular $Y$ and $Z$ as normally taken as the\n{\\it output\\/} of the divider are complementary,\n$\\Delta \\phi _{Y-Z}=\\pi $, not quadrature.  The\nquadrature pair is master versus slave, $X$ versus\n$Y\\;(Z)$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:\\/}  With the inverters added the circuit\n> is the normal $3$ stage ${\\rm TSPC}$ $D$ flip flop\n> $D=Z$ master $=X$, slave $=Y$, output $=Z$ used as a\n> Johnson $\\div 2$.  Any pair $X,{\\bar X},Y,{\\bar Y},\n> Z,{\\bar Z}$ with one member taken from the master and\n> one from the slave is a quadrature pair in the sense\n> (7) modulo $\\pi $ and modulo $t_{p{\\rm Inv3}}$.  The\n> conventional fully differential, static version is\n> normally drawn as a differential ${\\rm SCL}$ latch\n> pair.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "59d74ed69446677de24e91496913da01e2510abc5dc91af1542519ab629bd4eb"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies nominal divide-by-two quadrature from the latches switching on opposite clock phases, and notes both Inv3 delay and the asymmetric buffering/loading of the two latch outputs as sources of non-ideality.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "a208e36107d3c6d3d835e897ccf309733e82f6921b41cd2eef1a21949e70e6f6",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2193,
        "output_tokens": 10248,
        "total_tokens": 12441,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8610,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2193,
        "output_tokens": 10248,
        "total_tokens": 12441,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 8610,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "The well known ${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$ {\\it a k a\\/}\n${\\rm NORA}$,{\\it a k a\\/} ${\\rm TSPC}$ latching\ninverter is\n\n$${\\cal I}_{C}=\n{{M_{pC}}\\over {M_{pS}}}\\left |\n\\begin{matrix}\nG_{p}\\\\\nG_{n}\n\\end{matrix} \\right |{{M_{nS}}\\over {M_{nC}}}$$\n\nwith $${R_{C}=1/\\beta _{C}\\Delta V\\;\\;,\\;\\;C_{C}=C_{ox}W_{C}L+C_{ov}W_{C}\n+C_{j}W_{C}}$$\n$${R_{S}=1/\\beta _{S}\\Delta V\\;\\;,\\;\\;C_{S}=C_{ox}W_{S}L+C_{ov}W_{S}\n+C_{j}W_{S}\\tag{1}}$$\nso that conventionally\n\n$$t_{pLH}\\approx 0.69\\left[ R_{pC}C_{x}+(R_{pC}+R_{pS})C_{L}\n\\right] \\tag{2}$$\n$$t_{pHL}\\approx 0.69\\left[ R_{nC}C_{x}^{\\prime}+\n(R_{nC}+R_{nS})C_{L}\\right] $$\n\n$C_{x}=C_{dpC}+C_{spS}$ is the capacitance of the\nintermediate node $x\\equiv D_{pC}=S_{pS}$,\n$C_{L}=C_{dpS}+C_{dnS}+C_{gpS}^{\\prime}+C_{gnS}^{\\prime}+C_{w}$\nis the capacitance of the ``output'' node of the\ncell. Fig.1 is two such cells on opposite phases\n$+{\\cal I}_{S}$\n\n$${\\overline {CK}}\\;{\\cal I}_{C,1}\\;-\\;CK\\;{\\cal I}_{C,2}\\;-\\;\n{\\cal I}_{S}\\;-\\;{\\overline {CK}}\\;{\\cal I}_{C,1}\\tag{3}$$\n\ni. e. the conventional dynamic divide by two, master\nand slave latches made out of a single ${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$\ninverter plus storage capacitance plus static inverter.\nCall $C_{1}$ the storage node $Q_{m}={\\cal I}_{C,1}/{\\cal I}_{C,2}$,\n$C_{2}$ the storage node $Q_{s}={\\cal I}_{C,2}/{\\cal I}_{S}$.\nOn phase $CK=1\\;,\\overline{CK}=0$ ${\\cal I}_{C,1}$ is\ntransparent and ${\\cal I}_{C,2}$ is tri stated, $C_{1}$\nis driven through ${\\cal I}_{C,1}$, $C_{2}$ is holding.\nOn phase $CK=0\\;,\\overline{CK}=1$ ${\\cal I}_{C,2}$ is\ntransparent and ${\\cal I}_{C,1}$ is holding and $C_{2}$ is\ndriven through ${\\cal I}_{C,2}+{\\cal I}_{S}$ back to\n${\\cal I}_{C,1}$. Up to clock non overlap the loop gain\nis ${\\cal I}_{C,1}\\times {\\cal I}_{C,2}\\times {\\cal I}_{S}$.\n\nNeglecting for a moment the cost of generating $CK,\n\\overline{CK}$ put $R_{C}\\propto 1/W_{C}$,\n$C_{x}=C_{x0}+k_{x}W_{C}$,\n$C_{L}\\approx C_{L0}+k_{L}W_{S}$ independent of $W_{C}$\nto first order. From (2)\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nt_{p}&\\approx 0.69\\left[ {a\\over {W_{C}}}\\left(C_{x0}+k_{x}W_{C}\\right)\n+\\left({a\\over {W_{C}}}+R_{S}\\right)C_{L0}\\right] \\cr\n&\\approx 0.69\\left[ ak_{x}+R_{S}C_{L0}+{a\\left(C_{x0}+C_{L0}\\right)\n\\over {W_{C}}}\\right] \\tag{4}}$$\n\ni. e. $t_{p}(W_{C})$ is monotonic decreasing. You\nget less $R_{C}$ but you pay more $C_{x}$. For\n$W_{C}\\rightarrow \\infty $\n\n$$t_{p,min}\\rightarrow 0.69\\left(ak_{x}+R_{S}C_{L0}\\right) \\tag{5}$$\n\nthe delay of the data device alone plus the self\nloading $R_{C}C_{x}$ of the clock device on itself.\nWith normal layout $C_{x0}\\sim C_{L0}$, $ak_{x}\\sim\nR_{S}C_{L0}$ going e. g. from $W_{C}=W_{S}$ to\n$W_{C}=2W_{S}$ buys you $10-20\\%$ on $t_{p}$,\ngoing from $2W_{S}$ to $4W_{S}$ buys you a few\npercent, E.E. The unloaded, ideal voltage source\nclock, divider toggle frequency $f_{T}\\approx\n\\left[t_{p,1}+t_{p,2}+t_{p,S}\\right]^{-1}$ improves\nmonotonically but essentially saturates.\n\nThat is the {\\it unloaded\\/} block.  In any real\nsystem you have to make $CK$.\n\n$$C_{CK}= \\sum W_{C}L\\,C_{ox}+C_{ov}W_{C}+C_{w,CK}\\propto W_{C}\\tag{6}$$\n$$t_{r,CK}\\approx 0.69R_{CKd}C_{CK}\\propto W_{C}\\tag{7}$$\n$$T_{min}\\approx t_{p,1}(W_{C})+t_{r,CK}(W_{C})+t_{f,CK}(W_{C})\n+t_{su}+t_{margin}\\tag{8}$$\n\nThe transparency window is $T_{CK}/2-t_{r,f}$.\nIncreasing $W_{C}$ steals transparency window as fast\nas it reduces $t_{p}$.  The conventional figure of\nmerit for the system, $f_{max}$ at which the loop\nwill still regenerate, Fig.1,\n\n$$f_{max}^{-1}\\approx t_{DQ}+t_{su}\\propto \n\\left[{k_{1}\\over {W_{C}}}+k_{2}W_{C}\\right] +c^{st}\\tag{9}$$\n\nhas a minimum\n\n$${{dT_{min}}\\over {dW_{C}}}=0\\;:\\;W_{C,opt}\\approx\n\\sqrt{{k_{1}\\over {k_{2}}}}\\approx W_{S}\\tag{10}$$\n\nFor $R_{CKd}$ normalized to a ${\\rm FO4}$ inverter\n$W_{C,opt}$ is about $0.8-1.0\\,W_{nS}$ for the $n{\\rm C}$\ndevice and $1.5-2.0\\,W_{nS}$ for the $p{\\rm C}$ device\nto equalise $R_{nC}=R_{pC}$. Normal design keeps\n$W_{C}\\approx W_{S,min}$. Up to $\\sim 2\\times $ you win\na little, beyond that\n\n$$C_{L,eff}=C_{L0}+C_{dpS}+C_{dnS}\\propto W_{S}+W_{C}$$\nclock feed through $\\Delta V_{CF}=C_{ov}W_{C}/\n\\left(C_{L}+C_{ov}W_{C}\\right)\\Delta V_{CK}$ and charge\nsharing between $C_{x}$ and $C_{L}$,\n$\\Delta V_{CS}=C_{x}/\\left(C_{x}+C_{L}\\right)\\Delta V_{x}$,\nsub threshold leakage $\\propto W_{C}$ and the\ncross conduction current during the $CK \\slash\n\\overline{CK}$ overlap $\\propto W_{C}$ all increase\n$\\propto W_{C}$.\n\nSo with the customary abuse of language: you {\\it degrade\\/}\nthe usable speed.  In round numbers a ${\\rm C^{2}MOS}$\ndivider with minimum geometry clock devices will toggle\nat $f_{T0}$. Doubling the clock devices will get you\n$f_{T}\\approx 1.1-1.2f_{T0}$ ideal clock, essentially\nno improvement at system level, at twice the clock\npower, twice the clock routing capacitance and much\nworse clock slope, feed through and charge sharing\nrobustness.  Quadrupling them makes the divider slower\nat $R_{CKd}\\ne 0$.\n\n> {\\it In the text book sense of ``make $W_{C}\\gg W_{S}$,\n> does it get faster?'' the answer is NO. There is a\n> shallow optimum at about minimum width. Any substantial\n> increase is a net loss on $f_{max}$, on power and on\n> robustness. If you want it faster make $W_{S}$,\n> $W_{{\\cal I}_{S}}$ bigger, make $C_{L}$ smaller, keep\n> $W_{C}$ minimum. Low $V_{t}$, forward body bias or\n> TSPC$^{\\ast}$ helps much more than blowing up the\n> clock FETs.}\n\n$^{\\ast}$ TSPC keeps only one clock FET per cell,\nhalving (6).\n\nIf $CK,\\overline{CK}$ are taken as ideal zero impedance\nvoltage sources the pedantic answer is (4)-(5): $t_{p}$\ndecreases monotonically as $1/W_{C}$ to the asymptote\n(5). Normally quoted as ``improves but saturates''.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "dab0745c65241ab1fea806154068648d8cb96bd21e222ab175a721e790d40b63"
      },
      "model_call_count": 2,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It derives that widening the clocked devices lowers intrinsic delay, with improvement that eventually saturates, and identifies clock loading and charge sharing as practical limits at larger widths. That matches the golden solution’s allowed improvement-then-limit trend.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "318c27e5f5623103c64ba9716043fb25f88281b2efa86f52761064364631036f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 4354,
        "output_tokens": 18324,
        "total_tokens": 22678,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13576,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2177,
        "output_tokens": 9162,
        "total_tokens": 11339,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6788,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 2,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With an ideal 0 impedance generator on ${\\cal C}K$\nthe circuit is just the closed loop\n\n$$A\\equiv {{W_{p}^{a}}\\over {W_{n}^{a}}}\n\\;\\;\\xrightarrow[W_{CKp}\\atop W_{CKn}]{}\\;B\n\\;\\;\\xrightarrow[W_{\\bar CKp}\\atop W_{\\bar CKn}]{}\\;C\n\\;\\;\\xrightarrow{A_{0}}\\;A\\tag{*}$$\n\n$m\\equiv A$ is the {\\it master} tr. gate inverter,\n$s\\equiv B$ the {\\it slave} tr. gate inverter, $A_{0}$ the\nconventional inverter and $(^{*})$ is normally connected\n${\\cal D}\\equiv \\bar {\\cal Q}$ to make the conventional\n${\\cal C}^{2}{\\rm MOS}$ ${\\cal D}$ ${\\cal F}{\\cal F}$ and\n${\\cal Q}\\to \\bar {\\cal Q}\\to {\\cal Q}$ divider.  With\n${\\cal D}={\\cal Q}$ it is the 3 inverter ring.\nIn either case with\n\n$${\\cal C}K =1\\qquad W_{CK}^{a}{\\rm \\;on\\;}W_{CK}^{s}{\\rm\n\\;off\\;}$$\n\nthe $a$ inverter is low impedance, $R_{a}=R_{inv}^{a}+\nR_{CK}^{a}$ and the $s$ inverter is ${\\rm Hi}{\\rm Z}$, the\nsignal propagates $A\\to B$.  With ${\\cal C}K=0$ $R_{s}=\nR_{inv}^{s}+R_{\\bar CK}^{s}$ and the signal propagates\n$B\\to C\\to A$.  The period of the closed loop is\n\n$$T_{0}\\approx \\tau _{a}+\\tau _{s}+\\tau _{0}\\tag{1}$$\n\nWith the conventional Elmore  model Fig.2 for e. {\\it g.} the\n$n$ side\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\tau _{a}&=(R_{n,inv}^{a}+R_{n,CK}^{a})C_{L}^{a}+\n           R_{n,CK}^{a}C_{I}^{a}\\cr\nC_{I}^{a}&=C_{db,CK}^{a}+C_{db,inv}^{a}\\cr\nC_{L}^{a}&=C_{db,inv}^{a}+C_{g,inv}^{s}\\cr} \\tag{2}$$\n\nand the same with $p\\leftrightarrow n$, $a\\leftrightarrow\ns$, $CK\\leftrightarrow \\bar CK$.\n${\\cal C}_{L}$ is the useful load, the gate load of the\nfollowing inverter plus the drain load of the inverter\n{\\it per se}.  ${\\cal C}_{I}$ is the parasitic internal\nnode between the ${\\cal C}K$ switch and the inverter\ndevice, Fig.2.\n\n$${{R_{CK}\\propto {1\\over {W_{CK}}}} \\qquad \n  {C_{I}\\propto W_{CK}+W_{inv}}\\qquad \n  {C_{L}\\approx {\\rm cst.}(W_{CK})}} \\tag{3}$$\n\nso that, for given $W_{inv}$,\n\n$$\\tau _{a,s}= {{R_{0}C_{L}}\\over {W_{inv}}}+\n            {{R_{0}C_{L}}\\over {W_{CK}}}+\n            {{R_{0}k(W_{CK}+W_{inv})}\\over {W_{CK}}} \\tag{4}$$\n\n$$= \\tau _{inv}+{{R_{0}(C_{L}+kW_{inv})}\\over {W_{CK}}}+R_{0}k \\tag{5}$$\n\nFormally $\\partial \\tau /\\partial W_{CK}<0$.  For an ideal,\nzero impedance, ${\\cal C}K$ source the forward delay of the\ntransparent latch falls as $1/W_{CK}$ towards the\nasymptotic intrinsic inverter delay\n\n$$\\tau _{a,s}\\to \\tau _{inv}+R_{0}k = R_{inv}C_{L}+{\\rm cst.}\\tag{6}$$\n\nThe ${\\cal C}K$ device is just a series switch.\nNormally $R_{CK}<R_{inv}$ already for $W_{CK}=W_{inv}$\nso you gain at most\n\n$${{\\Delta \\tau}\\over {\\tau _{inv}}}\\approx\n{{R_{CK}}\\over {R_{CK}+R_{inv}}}< {1\\over 2} \\tag{7}$$\n\nand very rapidly saturates.  In first order the\nconventional ${\\cal C}^{2}{\\rm MOS}$ latch propagates with\na delay essentially independent of $W_{CK}$.\n\nIf the finite impedance of the ${\\cal C}K$ generator and\nthe load it sees is taken into account\n\n$$\\tau _{CK}=R_{CK}^{drv}C_{g,CK}\\qquad C_{g,CK}\\propto\nW_{CK}\\tag{8}$$\n\nhas to be added to (1).  $\\tau _{CK}\\propto W_{CK}$,\n$\\tau _{a,s}\\propto 1/W_{CK}$, so that the {\\it usable}\ncycle time\n\n$$T_{c}=T_{0}(W_{CK})+\\tau _{CK}(W_{CK})\\tag{9}$$\n\nhas a shallow minimum for\n\n$$W_{CK}^{opt}\\approx \\sqrt{{{R_{0}(C_{L}+kW_{inv})}\\over\n{R_{CK}^{drv}k_{g}}}}\\sim (0.5-1.0)W_{inv}\\tag{10}$$\n\nnormally quoted as ``minimum size''.  For all practical\npurposes putting $W_{CK}=2\\div 3\\,W_{\\min }$ buys you\n$10-20\\,{\\rm pS}$ of forward delay at the expense of a\nfactor $2\\div 3$ in ${\\cal C}K$ power,\n$P_{CK}\\propto C_{g,CK}V_{DD}^{2}f$, a factor $2\\div 3$\nin clock feed through\n\n$$\\Delta V_{H}\\approx {{C_{ov,CK}}\\over {C_{H}}}\\Delta V_{CK}\n\\propto W_{CK}\\tag{11}$$\n\non the high impedance storage node $H\\equiv B$ when the\nswitch goes ${\\rm Hi}{\\rm Z}$ and the extra diffusion\ncapacitance that the {\\it on} inverter has to charge\nthrough $R_{CK}$.  Beyond the optimum (10) the circuit\ngets slower, more power hungry and considerably less\nrobust versus charge sharing and race through on the\n${\\cal C}K\\leftrightarrow \\bar {\\cal C}K$ overlap.\nThat is why in the text books the ${\\cal C}K$ switches of\na ${\\cal C}^{2}{\\rm MOS}$ - ${\\rm TSPC}$ latch - divider\n- ring are always drawn minimum size.  With the usual\nabuse of language the operation is said to ``degrade with\n$W_{CK}$''.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} With $R_{CK}^{drv}\\equiv 0$ the formal\n> $1/W_{CK}$ improvement (5) remains.  It is normally\n> invisible on the bench.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "20c2dd881548383eb6b7fc9080ab44dd4c20743ac3a872343fce0229ce81951e"
      },
      "model_call_count": 2,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It identifies the initial speed improvement from reduced clock-switch resistance and a later optimum due to clock loading, and names charge sharing as a limiting effect. This matches the golden solution’s full-credit rule, despite its extra practical caveats.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "318c27e5f5623103c64ba9716043fb25f88281b2efa86f52761064364631036f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 4294,
        "input_tokens": 4354,
        "output_tokens": 14766,
        "total_tokens": 19120,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11272,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2177,
        "output_tokens": 7383,
        "total_tokens": 9560,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5636,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 2,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 12,
      "question": "In the circuit shown in the figure, does the speed improve or degrade if we increase the widths of the clocked transistors?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-012-repeat-question-10-for-topology/figure-11.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "If you count it with an ideal zero impedance\n${\\cal C}{\\cal K}$ source the 2 ${\\cal C}^{2}$ gates\nare just inverters with a series switch\n\n$${M_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\atop M_{{\\overline{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}}}+M_{p}\n\\atop M_{n}+{M_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\atop M_{{\\overline{{\\cal\nC}{\\cal K}}}}}\\tag{*}$$\n\nin Fig. 1 {\\it e.~g.} the master/slave of a\n${\\cal C}^{2}{\\rm MOS}$ toggle - ${\\rm div}$.\nby 2 - the little three inverter ring with two of\nthe inverters gated - of a gated ring oscillator\nin Fig. 2, Fig. 3.\nIn the opaque phase, Fig. 1a, the gated inverter\nis $HiZ$ and the data is held on ${{C}_{L}}$,\nin the transparent phase, Fig. 1b, it is a normal\ninverter with a series resistance.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In the customary acronym the\n> circuit is very often called a TSPC div. by 2 or\n> even a TSPC ring oscillator.  In the strict sense\n> TSPC has only one ${\\cal C}{\\cal K}$ device in\n> series with the data devices, Fig. 2.  $(*)$ is\n> ${\\cal C}^{2}{\\rm MOS}$.  TSPC is the evolution\n> of ${\\cal C}^{2}{\\rm MOS}$ gotten by throwing one\n> of the two series ${\\cal C}{\\cal K}$ devices away\n> precisely because it buys you nothing.\n\nFor the ordinary Elmore delay of the transparent\ngate, Fig. 1b,\n\n$$ \\tau _{r,f}=R_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\left(C_{int}+\nC_{L}\\right)+R_{p,n}C_{L}\\tag{1}$$\n\n${{C}_{L}}$ is the ${\\rm FO}$ load of the gate,\nessentially the gate capacitance of the next\ninverter plus the normal drain diffusions of\n${{M}_{p}},{{M}_{n}}$, $i.~e.$ to first order\nindependent of ${{W}_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}$.\n${{C}_{int}}$ is the diffusion capacitance of the\n${\\cal C}{\\cal K}$ device itself at the internal\nseries node $X$ in Fig.1b and\n\n$$R_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}={{R_{0}}\\over {W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}}\n\\qquad\nC_{int}=C_{0}^{\\prime }W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\qquad\nC_{g,{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}=C_{ox}W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}L \\tag{2}$$\n\nmodulo velocity saturation.\nSo that, for the data path alone and with an ideal,\n${{R}_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}=0$, voltage source for\n${\\cal C}{\\cal K},{\\overline{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}$,\n\n$$\\tau _{r,f}=R_{0}C_{0}^{\\prime }+R_{p,n}C_{L}+\n{{R_{0}C_{L}}\\over {W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$1/W$ toward the delay of the bare\n${{M}_{p}}-{{M}_{n}}$ inverter.  In that pedantic,\nideal clock, sense the bare loop - the\n${\\cal C}{\\cal K}\\to Q$ delay of the ${\\rm div}$.\nby 2, the frequency of the gated ring,\n\n$$f_{0}\\approx {1\\over {2\\left(\\tau _{1}+\\tau _{2}+\n\\tau _{inv}\\right)}}\\tag{4}$$\n\ngoes nominally up with ${{W}_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}$.\nThe nominal gain is $1/W$ and saturates very\nrapidly to\n\n$$\\tau _{\\infty }=R_{0}C_{0}^{\\prime }+R_{p,n}C_{L}\\tag{5}$$\n\nonce ${{R}_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}<{{R}_{p,n}}$.\nFor the normal $FO\\simeq 3-4$ inverter the\nsaturation is to all intents and purposes reached\nfor\n\n$$W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\approx (0.5-1.0)W_{p,n}\\tag{6}$$\n\nand, depending on the normalisation, the whole\navailable $W\\to \\infty $ speed up of the bare\nloop is of the order of $10-20\\%$.\n\nIn any real circuit the ${{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}$ has\nto be generated with a finite impedance driver, Fig.\n3.  The load on that driver is\n\n$$C_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}=2C_{g,{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}+\nC_{wire}\\propto W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}} \\tag{7}$$\n\nand its rise and fall time\n\n$$t_{r,f}^{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\propto\nR_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}^{drv}C_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\propto\nW_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\tag{8}$$\n\ngoes {\\it up}} with ${{W}_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}$.\nThe effective ${\\cal C}{\\cal K}\\to Q$ delay\nincluding the slope of the clock is\n\n$$\\tau _{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}\\to Q}^{eff}\\approx\n\\tau _{r,f}+k\\,t_{r,f}^{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}} \\tag{9}$$\n\nwith $k\\approx 0.3-0.5$, and the conventional\nfigure of merit $1/\\tau _{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}\\to Q}\nP_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}$ with\n\n$$P_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}=C_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}V_{DD}^{2}\nf_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\propto W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}} \\tag{10}$$\n\ndegrades linearly with ${{W}_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}$.\n\nEven with $t_{r,f}^{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\equiv 0$ the\ninternal capacitance ${{C}_{int}}\\propto\n{{W}_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}$ has to be charged and\ndischarged {\\it through}} the data devices\n${{M}_{p}},{{M}_{n}}$ every time the gate goes from\n$HiZ$ to transparent, Fig. 1a $\\to $ Fig. 1b.\nIncluding that charge sharing in (1),\n\n$$\\tau ^{{\\rm full}}\\approx R_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\nC_{L}+R_{p,n}\\left(C_{L}+C_{int}\\right) \\tag{11}$$\n\n$$=R_{p,n}C_{L}+{{R_{0}C_{L}}\\over {W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}}\n+R_{p,n}C_{0}^{\\prime }W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}} \\tag{12}$$\n\nwhich has the well known optimum\n\n$${{W}_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}^{opt}}\\approx\n\\sqrt{{{R_{0}C_{L}}\\over {R_{p,n}C_{0}^{\\prime }}} }\n\\tag{13}$$\n\nFor the normal $FO=4$ load (13) is at essentially\nminimum width.  For $W>{{W}^{opt}}$ the loop,\nwith ideal clocks, gets slower again, albeit with a\nvery shallow minimum.  With (9)-(10) included the\noptimum is at $W\\to {\\rm min}$.\n\nIn text book shorthand this is quoted as:\n\n> Making the series ${\\cal C}{\\cal K}$ switches\n> fatter buys you essentially no transparent delay\n> improvement once $R_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\lesssim\n> R_{p,n}$, i.~e. for $W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\gtrsim\n> W_{p,n}$, while it loads the ${\\cal C}{\\cal K}$\n> tree $\\propto W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}$ and adds\n> diffusion capacitance $\\propto W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}$\n> that has to be switched through the data devices.\n> The usable $f_{{\\rm max}}$ - ${\\rm div}$. by 2\n> toggle frequency, gated ring frequency - goes\n> {\\it down}} and the ${\\cal C}{\\cal K}$ power\n> $C_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}V^{2}f$ goes up $\\propto\n> W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}$.  The conventional design\n> leaves ${{M}_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}}$ at (near)\n> minimum $W/L$ and, for high speed, throws one of\n> the two series devices away altogether, the\n> ${\\cal C}^{2}{\\rm MOS}\\to {\\rm TSPC}$ evolution.\n\nIf the finite impedance of the ${\\cal C}{\\cal K}$\ndriver and the $W\\,{{C}_{int}}$ term are neglected,\nthe pedantic answer is of course the opposite: with\nan ideal ${\\cal C}{\\cal K}$ source (3) the data\npath ${\\cal C}{\\cal K}\\to Q$ delay falls\nmonotonically $\\propto 1/W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}$ to the\nasymptote (5) and the bare three inverter loop\nrings marginally faster, Fig. 4.  The $1/W$ gain\nsaturates after $W_{{\\cal C}{\\cal K}}\\approx\n(1-2)W_{{\\rm min}}$ to less than $\\sim 15\\%$ in the\nusual $FO4$ normalisation.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "7e76405225b3e4431519cb94e75957710dded4e3e55ad2e9e70faa220257b785"
      },
      "model_call_count": 2,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 1,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It notes that an idealized series-resistance model predicts an initial speedup, but its practical conclusion is that widening the clocked devices reduces usable speed and they should remain near minimum width. That overstates clock loading and charge-sharing penalties; the topology’s speed improves as the clocked devices are widened, with charge sharing degrading swing only up to a point.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "318c27e5f5623103c64ba9716043fb25f88281b2efa86f52761064364631036f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 4294,
        "input_tokens": 4354,
        "output_tokens": 19328,
        "total_tokens": 23682,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14700,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2147,
        "input_tokens": 2177,
        "output_tokens": 9664,
        "total_tokens": 11841,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7350,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 2,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 1,
        "score_percent": 25,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the arrangement in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a {\\it Ratioless Dynamic} storage\nelement. A {\\it Master-Slave $D$ - in toggle} made\nwith pass transistors.\n\nIn static form it would be $4$ inverters with\n$2$ feedbacks. Here Economy $3$ Inverters : 6T+\n2 pass gates$$={\\cal O}(10T)$$ against $20T$ for static\n$MSFF$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nA &= {\\rm in\\;of\\;} Inv_{1} \\cr\nB &= \\bar A = {\\rm out\\;of\\;} Inv_{1} \\cr\nC &= {\\rm in\\;of\\;} Inv_{2}\\cr\nD &= \\bar C \\cr\nE &= \\bar D = C\\cr}$$\n\n$$E\\rightarrow A\\;{\\rm via\\;} SW_{CK}$$\n\n$SW_{CK}$ closed on $CK=1$, open on $CK=0$\n$SW_{\\bar{CK}}$ closed on $\\bar{CK}=1$ {\\it i. e.} $CK=0$\n\nNormally $CK.\\bar{CK}=0$ - break before make -\nthe loop of $3=odd$ inverters is never closed\nstatically, if it were it is a $3$ stage ring\noscillator $f_{0}=1/6t_{pd}$.\n\nStorage is {\\it dynamic} on gate parasitics\n$C_{A}$ at $A$ and $C_{C}$ at $C$.\n\n### 2 phases. Break before make\n\n{\\bf 1: $CK=1$ , $\\bar{CK}=0$ : {\\it sample - hold}} \n\n* $SW_{CK}= ON$ , $SW_{\\bar{CK}}=OFF$\n* $A = E_{n-1}$\n* $B = \\bar A = \\bar E_{n-1}$ sampled on $C_{C}$ side of the\nopen switch. No path to $C$.\n* Slave is isolated : $C,D,E$ floating. $E_{n-1}=C_{n-1}$\nis held dynamically on $C_{C}$ at input of\n$Inv_{2}$ for $t_{hold} \\ll \\tau_{leak}=C_{C}/I_{leak}$.\nDouble inverter $Inv_{2}-Inv_{3}$ is a buffer: $E=C$.\n\nMaster is {\\it transparent}, slave is {\\it opaque}\n{\\it hold}.\n\n{\\bf 2: $CK=0$ , $\\bar{CK}=1$ : {\\it hold - transfer}} \n\n* $SW_{CK}=OFF$ , $SW_{\\bar{CK}}=ON$\n* $A,B$ floating. $B=\\bar E_{n-1}$ is held\ndynamically on $C_{A}$ at input of $Inv_{1}$.\n* $C = B$\n* $D = \\bar C = \\bar B =E_{n-1}$\n* $E = \\bar D = C = B = \\bar E_{n-1}$\n\nSo on the $1 \\rightarrow 0$ transition of $CK$\n\n> $$E_{n}= B_{n}= \\bar E_{n-1}$$\n> $$Q^{n+1}= \\bar Q^{n}\\;\\;{\\rm on\\;} CK\\downarrow$$\n\nMaster is opaque, slave is transparent. The\nslave samples the master.\n\nIn one full period $CK$ the signal has been\ninverted once.\n\nWith $D=E$ this is a $D(FF)$ with $D=\\bar Q$.\n\n$$\\begin{array}{c|c|c|c}\nCK & \\bar{CK} & {\\rm Phase} & E=Q \\\\ \\hline\n1 & 0 & M\\,T,S\\,H & Q_{n-1}\\\\\n0 & 1 & M\\,H,S\\,T & \\bar Q_{n-1}\n\\end{array}$$\n\n$$T=1 \\;\\;{\\rm Flip Flop}$$\n\nIf you break the feedback and inject $D$ at $A$:\n\n* $CK=1$ : $Q$ held, $B=\\bar D$ \n* $CK\\downarrow$ : $Q = D$ sampled\n\nit is a conventional negative edge triggered\ndynamic $DFF$, Master-Slave $D$ latch. With the\nfeedback closed as drawn it is edge triggered\n$TFF$ :: $:2$ frequency divider, the basic\ncell of a dynamic shift register, Johnson counter,\nprescaler.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nf_{Q} &= f_{CK}/2\\cr\nT_{Q} &= 2T_{CK}\\cr}$$\n\ne.g.:\n\n```\nCK  _|-|_|-|_|-|_|-|_|-|_\nB     \\bar E \\bar{\\bar E}\nQ=E ________ ----- _______ ----- __\n            \\_____/     \\_____/\n```\n\n> {\\it Transparent on $CK=1$, transfer on $CK=0$.\n> Negative edge triggered in this drawing.\n> By convention reversing the switches makes it\n> positive edge triggered.}\n\n#### Remarks\n\n* ***Dynamic not static:*** No cross coupled keeper. \nState is lost by junction leakage/subthreshold in\n$1-100ms$. $CK$ must be refreshed $f_{CK}> f_{min}\n\\approx 1kHz-1MHz$. No low frequency or DC operation.\n* In CMOS $SW$ is normally $nMOS$ pass or $CMOS$\ntransmission gate $n+p$. $n$ only passes weak $1$,\n$V_{T}$ drop, charge sharing between $C_{A},C_{C}$.\n* Advantage: Very small, fast, low power, no\nratioed load, TSPC - True Single Phase Clock,\nNORA, Yuan-Svensson, Suzuki divider families are\nbuilt on this.\n* Disadvantage: Needs non overlapping $CK/\\bar{CK}$.\nOverlap $CK=\\bar{CK}=1$ short circuits the\n$3$ inverter ring -> race, metastability, maybe\noscillation. Needs minimum clock rate, sensitive to\nnoise, clock skew, charge sharing and need for\ninitial {\\it reset} - power up state undefined.\nCan be made static/ pseudo static by adding weak\nfeedback inverter keeper on $A$ and $C$, $W_{keeper}\n\\ll W_{inv}$.\n\nUp to the addition of keepers this is the textbook\n$3$ inverter dynamic divide by $2$ : the\n$TSPC$ / $NORA$ $:2$ Johnson divider.\nCascaded $n$ times $:2^{n}$ counter/shift register.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "43ff6af2c8140fbf8aa59ee58297cbcf1e5edd75f660a9131236694e9acd39c2"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies a dynamic master-slave toggle divider and states that its output frequency is half the clock frequency. The detailed signal-path discussion is not required for full credit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f425c26bf4178562557e147f38673688c0fa91f97a1c7cad9ab3d6417d10545f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1425,
        "output_tokens": 4160,
        "total_tokens": 5585,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2662,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1425,
        "output_tokens": 4160,
        "total_tokens": 5585,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 2662,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the arrangement in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is a {\\it 1 bit dynamic memory}\nwith $D=\\bar Q$ i.e. a {\\it $f/2$ \ndivider - $T$ flip flop}. Untied it is a\n$TSPC$ $D$ - Flip Flop.\n\n```\n         CK          +-----------+\n.--o/ o--+--->O--+--o/ o-->O-->O--+--\n|        Inv1     |   Inv2 Inv3  |\n+----------------+               |\n```\n\nLet\n\n* $A$ : input $Inv_{1}$\n* $B$ : output $Inv_{1}$\n* $C$ : input $Inv_{2}$\n* $D$ : output $Inv_{2}$\n* $E=Q$ : output $Inv_{3}= \\bar D$\n\n$$B=\\bar A\\qquad D=\\bar C\\qquad E=\\bar D=C$$\n\nand let $C_{A},C_{C}$ be the stray input\ncapacitance of $Inv_{1},Inv_{2}$. Ideal\nswitch:\n\n* $CK=1\\;( \\bar{CK}=0)$ : $SW_{1}$ $ON$, $SW_{2}$ $OFF$\n* $CK=0\\;( \\bar{CK}=1)$ : $SW_{1}$ $OFF$, $SW_{2}$ $ON$\n\nNon overlapping $CK$.\n\nThere is at no time a DC closed loop.\nThe state is kept dynamically on $C_{A}$ and\n$C_{C}$.\n\n> Without the global feed back $Q\\rightarrow A$\n> this is the classical 3 inverter, 2 transmission\n> gate Dynamic Master-Slave $D$ Flip Flop:\n>\n> * Master: $SW_{1}+Inv_{1}$ transparent when $CK=1$\n> * Slave: $SW_{2}+Inv_{2}+Inv_{3}$ transparent when $CK=0$\n>\n> $Q$ is sampled on the $CK=1\\rightarrow 0$ or\n> $0\\rightarrow 1$ edge according to convention.\n> With $D = \\bar Q$ wired it becomes edge triggered\n> $T$ latch.\n\n### 1. $CK=1$\n\n$$A = E = Q_{n-1}\\;,\\qquad B=\\bar Q_{n-1}$$\n\n$$C = Q_{n-1}' = Q_{n-1}{\\rm \\;stored\\;on\\;}C_{C}$$\n\n$$D = \\bar C \\;,\\qquad E = C = {\\rm hold}$$\n\nMaster is transparent, slave is isolated\nand holds its previous state by charge on\n$C_{C}$.\n\n### 2. $CK=0$\n\n$$C = B = \\bar A$$\n\n$A$ is now isolated and held on $C_{A}$ with\nvalue $Q_{n-1}$.\n\n$$D = \\bar C = A\\;,\\qquad E = \\bar D = \\bar A$$\n\ni.e.\n\n$$ Q_{n}=E_{n}= \\bar A_{n}= \\bar Q_{n-1}$$\n\nOn the $1\\rightarrow 0$ transition of $CK$\nthe inverted contents of the Master is\ntransferred to the Slave.\n\nOn the next $0\\rightarrow 1$ transition\nthat new state is transferred back to the\nMaster:\n\n$$A_{n+1}=E_{n}= \\bar A_{n}$$\n\nHence for every full clock period\n\n$$Q_{n+1}= \\bar Q_{n}$$\n\n$$Q^{*} = \\bar Q \\cdot CK_{edge}$$\n\nCharacteristic equation of a $T$ flip flop\nwith $T=1$.\n\n$$\\begin{array}{c|c|c|c|c}\nCK & \\bar{CK} & A & C & Q=E \\\\ \\hline\n1 & 0 & Q & hold & hold \\\\\n0 & 1 & hold & \\bar A & \\bar A \\\\\n1 & 0 & Q & hold & hold \\\\\n0 & 1 & & ... &\n\\end{array}$$\n\ne.g. with $Q=0$ initially:\n\n```\nCK  _|‾|_|‾|_|‾|_|‾|_\nA   0---->0---->1---->1---->0\nB   1---->1---->0---->0---->1\nC   0---->0---->1---->1---->0\nE=Q 0---->0---->1---->1---->0\n```\n\n$Q$ changes only on the falling - for opposite\nphase convention rising - edge and needs two\n$CK$ periods for one period. I.e.\n\n$$ f_{Q}= f_{CK}/2 $$\n\n$$ T_{Q}=2T_{CK} $$\n\n50% duty cycle divider, modulo 2 Johnson\ncounter, 1 stage shift register with inversion.\nIn principle a 1 bit dynamic $RAM$ loop.\n\nIn steady state the 3 inversions make the\nglobal loop inverting, therefore bistable,\ndivides by $2^{n}$ with $n$ cascaded stages.\n\n#### Remarks\n\n* {\\it Dynamic:} When a node is floating its\nlogic level is only kept by charge on the\ngate capacitance. Leakage limits $f_{CK,min}\\sim\nkHz-MHz$ depending on process, and $f_{CK,max}$\nis limited by $t_{p,Inv}$. Needs refresh. No\nstatic power except leakage. Very economical:\n$\\sim 6T$ for inverters + $2T$ for $SW$ = $8-10T$\nagainst $\\sim 18-24T$ for static $TSPC$ divider.\n\n* $CK$ and $\\bar{CK}$ must be non overlapping,\notherwise $SW_{1}+SW_{2}$ both $ON$ gives a 3\ninverter ring oscillator $f_{osc}\\approx 1/6t_{p}$\nand race.\n\n* In CMOS as transmission gate / pass\ntransistor there is $Vt$ loss and charge\nsharing / charge injection / clock feedthrough\nwhich has to be sized out. Practically\n$Inv_{1}$ is often a clocked inverter\n$C^{2}MOS$.\n\nStandard use: high speed pre-scaler, $PLL$\ndivider, binary counter, frequency halver.\n\nBreaking the feedback $Q\\rightarrow SW_{1}$ and\ncalling $D$ the input of $SW_{1}$, $Q=E$ and\n$\\bar Q=D$ is the conventional positive edge\ntriggered dynamic $D$ master slave flip flop.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "fe47778377c84753292404aad7869828ceea107fd641c51effeed455797642e5"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the arrangement as a dynamic-latch divide-by-two (a T flip-flop with feedback), which meets the full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f425c26bf4178562557e147f38673688c0fa91f97a1c7cad9ab3d6417d10545f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1425,
        "output_tokens": 4707,
        "total_tokens": 6132,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3236,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1425,
        "output_tokens": 4707,
        "total_tokens": 6132,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3236,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 13,
      "question": "Analyze the arrangement in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-013-dynamic-latch-divide-by-two/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the loop of $2$ dynamic latches - a\n{\\it $T=1$ $D$ - Flip-Flop} - a $1\\,b$ {\\it Johnson}\n{\\it Twisted Ring} $:2$ frequency divider.\nWith $D$ injected in place of the\nfeedback it is a normal CMOS dynamic\nmaster - slave $D\\,FF$.\n\n$$S_{1}=CK\\qquad S_{2}=\\bar {CK}\\qquad\nB=\\bar A \\qquad D=\\bar C \\qquad E=\\bar D =C$$\n\n$C,E$ are buffered output of $B$.\n\n$$A\\stackrel{S_{1}}{\\longleftarrow }E\\qquad \nC\\stackrel{S_{2}}{\\longleftarrow }B$$\n\nIf $S_{1},S_{2}$ were closed together\n\n$$E =\\bar{\\bar{\\bar E}} = \\bar E$$\n\n$3$ inversions in a ring - astable\nring oscillator $f_{0}\\approx 1/2\\sum t_{p}$.\nNormal operation demands\n\n$$S_{1}.S_{2}=0$$\n\ni.e. break before make, non overlap\ncomplementary phases.\n\nThen one node is always floating and\nis held only dynamically on its\nparasitic capacitance $C_{p}$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nS_{1}{\\rm OPEN}&: A {\\rm floats}=C_{A}V_{A}\\cr\nS_{2}{\\rm OPEN}&: C {\\rm floats}=C_{C}V_{C}}$$\n\nNo DC path. Quasi static: to be refreshed\nbefore leakage $I_{leak}T_{CK}/C_{p}\\approx \\Delta V$\ndestroys the state. Upper $f$ limited by\n$t_{p1}+t_{p2}+t_{p3}+t_{sw}$.\n\nLet\n\n$$A = {\\rm input\\;of\\;}Inv_{1}$$\n$$B = {\\rm output\\;of\\;}Inv_{1}=\\bar A$$\n$$C = {\\rm input\\;of\\;}Inv_{2}$$\n$$D =\\bar C$$\n$$E =\\bar D = C = Q$$\n\n$$E =\\bar{\\bar C}=C$$\n\n$Inv_{2}+Inv_{3}$ is a non inverting buffer.\n\n* $CK=1,\\;\\bar{CK}=0$ : $S_{1}{\\rm ON},S_{2}{\\rm OFF}$\n\nTransparent master, $S_{2}$ isolates slave.\n\n$$A =E_{0}= Q_{0}$$\n$$B =\\bar A =\\bar Q_{0}$$\n$$C = C_{0}=Q_{0} {\\rm \\;held\\;on\\;}C_{C}$$\n$$D =\\bar Q_{0}$$\n$$E = Q_{0}$$\n\nMaster samples the old slave output.\n\n* $CK=0,\\;\\bar{CK}=1$ : $S_{1}{\\rm OFF},S_{2}{\\rm ON}$\n\nMaster holds on $C_{A}$, slave samples master.\n\n$$A = A_{1}=Q_{0} {\\rm \\;held}$$\n$$C =B =\\bar A_{1}= \\bar Q_{0}$$\n$$D =\\bar C = Q_{0}$$\n$$E = \\bar D =\\bar Q_{0}= \\bar A_{1}$$\n\n$$E_{CK=0}= \\bar A_{CK=0}$$\n\n* Next $CK=1$:\n\n$$A_{2}=E_{1}= \\bar A_{1}$$\n$$B_{2}= \\bar A_{2}=A_{1}$$\n$$E_{2}=E_{1}{\\rm \\;held}$$\n\n$A$ changes on the $0\\to 1$ edge, $E$\nchanges on the $1\\to 0$ edge.\n\nIn discrete time at the active edge:\n\n$$A_{n+1}=E_{n}= \\bar A_{n}$$\n$$E_{n+1}= \\bar E_{n}$$\n\n$$Q_{n+1}= \\bar Q_{n}$$\n\ni.e. $T$-flip flop with $T\\equiv 1$.\n\n| $CK$ | $S_{1}$ | $S_{2}$ | $A$ | $B$ | $C$ | $Q=E$ |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 | C | O | $Q_{old}$ | $\\bar Q_{old}$ |hold $Q_{old}$| $Q_{old}$ |\n| 0 | O | C | hold $Q_{old}$ | $\\bar Q_{old}$ | $\\bar Q_{old}$| $\\bar Q_{old}$ |\n| 1 | C | O | $\\bar Q_{old}$| $Q_{old}$ |hold $\\bar Q_{old}$| $\\bar Q_{old}$ |\n| 0 | O | C | hold $\\bar Q_{old}$| $Q_{old}$| $Q_{old}$| $Q_{old}$ |\n\n> {\\it Without the feedback} $D\\to S_{1}$ the\n> chain $D-S_{1}-Inv_{1}-S_{2}-Inv_{2}-Inv_{3}-Q$\n> is a negative $D$ flip flop\n> $$Q = \\overline{D_{sampled}}$$\n> latched on $CK$. With $D=Q$ you get\n> $$Q(n+1)=\\bar Q(n).$$\n\nIn the time domain, for a $50\\%$ $CK$ of period\n$T_{CK}$:\n\n```\nCK  _|‾|_|‾|_|‾|_|‾|_|‾|_|‾|_\nA   ‾‾‾|_____|‾‾‾‾‾|_____|‾‾  f = fck/2  rising edge triggered\nE   ___|‾‾‾‾‾|_____|‾‾‾‾‾|___  f = fck/2  falling edge triggered\nB = ~A , D = ~C = ~Q\n```\n\nTapping $A$ is a positive edge $T\\,FF$, tapping $E$\nis a negative edge $T\\,FF$. Amplitude $2T_{CK}$,\n$50\\%$ duty, i. e. divide by $2$ prescaler.\n\nThis is the basic cell of the dynamic shift\nregister, $n$ cells in series $\\times$ $2n$\nJohnson counter/divider. In static form a weak\ncross coupled keeper is added at $A$ and at $C$\nto prevent leakage, becoming a fully static\nmaster-slave TSPC divider at the cost of area\nand speed.\n\nUse: very small, very fast, very low power\n$\\propto C V^{2}f$, $1\\,b$ memory, $:2$ prescaler\nin PLL, counters, frequency synthesizers.\nMust be clocked continuously within\n$f_{min}\\approx I_{leak}/C_{p}\\Delta V < f < f_{max}\n\\approx 1/t_{p}$ with non overlapping $CK,\\bar{CK}$,\notherwise data is lost - clock feedthrough,\ncharge sharing, skew and $t_{hold}$ violations.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5cd6aedc9c178d639581623a635f26a5312fbfe6a93096aba0f7974a9f739709"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies the circuit as a divide-by-two built from two dynamic latches; the additional timing and device-level details are not required for full credit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f425c26bf4178562557e147f38673688c0fa91f97a1c7cad9ab3d6417d10545f",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1425,
        "output_tokens": 6106,
        "total_tokens": 7531,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4459,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1425,
        "output_tokens": 6106,
        "total_tokens": 7531,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4459,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "How does the red inverter in the figure affect the performance?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "It is the {\\it keeper - trickle - bleeder}\nfor the $Inv_{1}$ {\\it pseudo static}\nmaster latch. Without it:\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nCK=1~,{\\bar {CK}}=0 &: A=E,I_{1}:A\\rightarrow B ~{\\rm open~at}~{\\bar {CK}}\\cr\nCK=0~,{\\bar {CK}}=1 &: A= {\\rm floating}~,I_{1}:A\\rightarrow B\\rightarrow C\\rightarrow D\\rightarrow E }$$\n\ni.e. the conventional {\\it True Single Phase\nClock} $NORA$ dynamic divider/latch. In\nfirst order ratio-less, minimum $C$, minimum\n$I_{cc}$, minimum $t_{pLH},t_{pHL}$ and\nmaximum $f_{max}\\sim 1/2\\sum t_{p}$ ${\\cal O}(1-2\\,{\\rm GHz}$ in \n$0.18\\mu )$ but dynamic:\n\n* $A$ is high impedance when $CK=0$\n* has to stand the leakage $I_{j}+I_{sub}$,\nclock feed-through, charge sharing, $dV/dt$\nnoise, $\\alpha $ particle for $T_{L}>1/f_{min}$\n* $dV_{A}/dt = I_{leak}/C_{A}$ so\n$$V_{A}(t)=V_{A0}\\exp -t/R_{leak}C_{A}$$\nfalls in ${\\rm ms}$ to threshold and state is\nlost. In practice it will not divide below\n$\\sim 100{\\rm MHz}-10{\\rm MHz}$ depending on\n$T$ and will not tolerate slow $CK$\nslew rate\n\nWith the red $I_{R}:B\\rightarrow A$:\n\n$$I_{1}+I_{R} : A\\rightleftharpoons B$$\n\nis a $>1$ loop gain cross coupled bistable.\nFor ${\\bar {CK}}=1$, $I_{R}$ shorted at $A$ by\nlow $Z_{o}(I_{1})$, for $CK=0$, $SW_{CK}$\nopen, $I_{1}+I_{R}$ latches $A,B=\\bar A$.\n\n> staticizes the master. Pseudo static\n> $TSPC$, St $TSPC$, $C^{2}MOS$ latch.\n\n* no $f_{min}$ - DC to $f_{max}$ operation\n* no charge retention problem\n* large noise margin, no charge sharing\nerror, very much more tolerant to clock\noverlap - skew - slow edge\n* correct toggle divide by $2$ even with\ngated clock\n\nprice:\n\n* ratioed logic. $I_{R}$ contends with\n$I_{1}$ and with the $2I$ slave feedback\n$p/n$ through $SW_{CK}$ on a $0\\rightarrow 1$\nand $1\\rightarrow 0$ write.\nIt must be made {\\it weak} - small $W/L$, long\n$L$, ${\\cal O}(1/5-1/10)$ of $I_{1}$, i. e.\noverpowerable, to be able to be written.\nNormally $n$ weak $p$ weak inverter.\nThat is area, $C_{g}+C_{d}$ on the high\nspeed nodes $A,B$ and crow bar current\nduring the contention time.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nC_{A}^{\\prime} &= C_{A}+C_{gR}+C_{dR}\\cr\nC_{B}^{\\prime} &= C_{B}+C_{gR}+C_{dR}\\cr\nI_{eff} &= I_{1}-I_{R}~{\\rm on~switching}}$$\n\nso\n\n* $t_{pMaster}\\approx 0.69R_{1}(C_{B}+C_{R})$\nincreases $15-30\\%$\n* $t_{CK-Q}$ increases by same amount\n* $I_{cc}=I_{dyn}+I_{sc}$ increases due to\n$C_{R}$ and to $I_{1}\\times I_{R}$ short\ncircuit current for $t_{cont}\\sim t_{r,CK}$\n* $P_{dyn}=C^{\\prime}V_{DD}^{2}f$ increases\n* $f_{max}=1/2\\left[ t_{pM}^{\\prime}+t_{pS}\\right]$\ndecreases ${\\cal O}(20-40\\%)$\n* large $I_{R}$ kills write, division failure,\nsmall $I_{R}$ does not keep. $PVT$ ratio\ncritical.\n\nIn short: You buy DC, low frequency, leakage\nand noise robustness with speed, power and area.\nFor a high speed prescaler without the $I_{R}$\nis faster and lower power, with correctly\n$k$ ratioed weak $I_{R}$ it becomes a robust\nstatic $:2$ that will divide to DC. That is\nnormally quoted as ``static divider''.\n\n> ***Remark:*** In text book form the red\n> device is often drawn as a weak clocked\n> feedback $p$ and $n$ or as a single weak\n> $p$ pull up. Same function.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "e6d9c615ac2034f5e9770ee79bb2d60f818d5abcc8929b155ec5e357fa1200aa"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It misidentifies the red inverter as a keeper/feedback latch and claims it enables DC operation. The actual feedforward path improves high-speed operation but can raise the minimum usable clock frequency at low rates.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "09f12aa6905fa83982420dcd1602844314d44b4575734bb31f92f5ccf31131d2",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1226,
        "output_tokens": 4133,
        "total_tokens": 5359,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3032,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1226,
        "output_tokens": 4133,
        "total_tokens": 5359,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3032,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "How does the red inverter in the figure affect the performance?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With ${\\rm Inv_{1}}$ it makes a so called\n{\\it keeper, bleeder, staticizer} and the {\\it half}\n{\\it static} or {\\it pseudo static} version of the\nnormally {\\it fully dynamic} TSPC $C^{2}MOS$ master\nslave $\\,{:}\\div 2$.\n\nIn normal drawing ${\\rm Inv_{R}}$ is drawn upside\ndown with respect to ${\\rm Inv_{1}}$:\n$${\\rm Inv_{1}}:E\\to \\bar E\\qquad \n {\\rm Inv_{R}}:\\bar E\\to E$$\ni. e. a cross coupled pair.\n\n> {\\it If you have really drawn it in parallel with\n> ${\\rm Inv_{1}}$, $E\\to \\bar E$, it is simply an\n> increase of the transconductance of the master\n> inverter, $\\approx 1/2$ inverter delay less at\n> $\\approx 2\\times $ capacitance $+$ power $+$ area.}\n\nLogically no function. Normally $W_{R}/L_{R}\\ll\nW_{1}/L_{1}$ and in first order for logic the\nfunctions are identical, a conventional positive\nedge triggered $D$ with $D=\\bar Q$, i. e. a $T$, i. e.\na $:2$ prescaler.\n\nPhysically it changes the master from capacitive\n{\\it dynamic} storage on $C_{par}$ at the input of\n${\\rm Inv_{1}}$ to {\\it latched static} storage with\n$\\left |A_{v}\\right |>1$ .\n\nWithout it:\n\n* master node $M$ during $\\overline{CK}=0$,\n$CK=0$ - switch open - floats. It is kept only on\n\n$$Q_{M}=C_{M}.V_{M}$$\n\n$C_{M}$ the parasitic $C_{g}+C_{ov}+C_{j}$ at the\ninput of ${\\rm Inv_{1}}$. For $t \\gg R_{leak}C_{M}\\approx\nI_{leak}^{-1}C_{M}\\Delta V$ the charge leaks away,\nstate is lost, the divider drops out. At ambient\n$R_{leak}^{-1}\\sim {\\rm nA}$, at hot $\\mu {\\rm A}$ \n$R_{leak}C\\sim {\\rm  ns}-\\mu {\\rm s}$. I. e. a\n{\\it lower} limiting frequency $f_{min}\\sim 10^{4}-10^{6}{\\rm Hz}$\nbelow which it does not work, it is not clock\nstoppable, not gateable, very noise, $dV/dt$,\nsoft error, clock slope and $V_{DD}$, $T$ sensitive.\nClock must be free running with $f_{clk}>f_{min}$\nand with small $t_{r},t_{f}$.\n\n* in compensation it is fast, small and low\npower. No DC contention, no extra $C_{g}$. For RF\nthis is the form used e. g. as $:2$ prescaler in a\nPLL. E. g. in $65{\\rm nm}$, $f_{max,dyn}\\approx\n8-10{\\rm GHz}$ with $f_{min}\\ne 0$.\n\nWith it ${\\rm Inv_{R}}$ closes a regenerative loop\nround ${\\rm Inv_{1}}$ when $T_{G1}$ is open and holds\n$M$ actively at $V_{DD}$ or $GND$.\n\n$${\\rm Inv_{1}}\\parallel {\\rm Inv_{R}}= {\\rm latch}$$\n\n* the node is no longer floating, low impedance\nDC driven in both states. Noise margin is the normal\nstatic noise margin of a $>1$ loop, $f_{min}=0$ to\nDC, clock can be stopped indefinitely, gated,\nslowed down, slope is immaterial. Charge sharing,\ncharge injection, clock feedthrough, $V_{T}$ loss\nis restored to full swing. This is the normal\nlogic form of the divider. Price:\n\n* $C_{M}\\to C_{M}+C_{gR}+C_{jR}$ and $C_{\\bar M}\\to\nC_{\\bar M}+C_{dR}$, typically $10-30\\%$ extra load\non the high speed loop {\\it in addition} to the\nactive fight during the write phase $CK=1$.\n\nDuring $CK=1$, $I_{in}=I_{Qb}$ through the two slave\ninverters must {\\it overpower} $I_{R}$ to force $M$\nto the new value. For a time $\\sim t_{p}$ there is a\ncrow bar current $I_{1}-I_{R}$ between $V_{DD}$ and\n$GND$ and the effective $g_{m}$ driving $M$ is\n$g_{m1}-g_{mR}$.\n\n$$t_{p,stat}\\approx t_{p,dyn}\\left(1+\\frac{C_{R}}{C_{M}}\\right)\n \\frac{g_{m1}}{g_{m1}-g_{mR}} > t_{p,dyn}$$\n\n$$t_{CQ,stat}>t_{CQ,dyn}\\qquad f_{max,stat}<f_{max,dyn}$$\n\nin the conventional $\\sim 15-25\\%$ for minimum\nsize keeper. Dynamic power $CV^{2}f$ goes up with\n$C_{R}$ and short circuit power $I_{sc}V_{DD}t_{sc}f$\nduring the contention goes up. Area goes up.\n\nFor that reason ${\\rm Inv_{R}}$ is always made\n{\\it weak}, long $L$, small $W$,\n\n$$\\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_{R}\\approx \\frac{1}{5}-\\frac{1}{3}\n \\left(\\frac{W}{L}\\right)_{1}$$\n\njust strong enough to compensate $I_{leak}$ and\nnoise but weak enough to be overpowered with little\npenalty. With correct ratioing the $f_{max}$ penalty can be\nkept to $<10\\%$ while $f_{min}$ is brought from\n${\\rm MHz}$ to $0$, e. g. $8{\\rm GHz}$ dynamic to\n$7.0-7.5{\\rm GHz}$ pseudo static in $65{\\rm nm}$,\nat $\\sim 10-20\\%$ power and area cost.\n\nUnratioed, $g_{mR}\\ge g_{m1}$ the master cannot be\nwritten, the divider sticks and/or draws large DC\ncurrent.\n\nIn the figure only the master is staticized, the\nslave, the two inverters on the right, is still\ndynamic, {\\it half static} TSPC. With a second keeper\non the slave it becomes fully static.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "89222946c5d61704a8bfa04f4318bf483cf87a6a917594a062801421802abeb1"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It misidentifies the red inverter as a keeper/staticizer and claims it removes the low-frequency limit. The actual feedforward path bypasses part of the latch to improve speed, but can overwhelm the main path at low clock rates and raises the minimum usable frequency.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "09f12aa6905fa83982420dcd1602844314d44b4575734bb31f92f5ccf31131d2",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1226,
        "output_tokens": 5768,
        "total_tokens": 6994,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4185,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1226,
        "output_tokens": 5768,
        "total_tokens": 6994,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4185,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 14,
      "question": "How does the red inverter in the figure affect the performance?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-014-red-inverter-b-affect-performance/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "It is the classical {\\it weak keeper\\/} ,\n{\\it staticizer\\/} , {\\it bleeder\\/}\nof the {\\tt TSPC} $\\div 2$.\n\n$$D= \\bar Q\\;\\;{\\rm so}\\;\\;Q_{n+1}= \\bar Q_{n}$$\n\nwith master made of $TG_{1}+{\\rm Inv}_{1}$\nand slave $TG_{2}+{\\rm Inv}_{2}+{\\rm Inv}_{3}$\nclosed in a ring is normally {\\it all dynamic}.\n\nIn the ideal $CK/\\bar {CK}$ non overlap case\nwith $C_{gs}$ alone:\n\n* $CK=1\\;,\\;\\bar {CK}=0$ : $Y=X$, $Z=\\bar Y$,\n$W=$ floating, $V=\\bar W$, $X=\\bar V$ holds\n\n* $CK=0\\;,\\;\\bar {CK}=1$ : $Y=$ floating, $Z=\\bar Y$\nholds, $W=Z$, $V=\\bar W$, $X=\\bar V=Z$ copied\n\nso on every $0\\to 1\\to 0$ {\\it full} period\n\n$$Z_{n+1}= \\bar Z_{n}\\qquad X_{n+1}= \\bar X_{n}$$\n\n$\\div 2$ only so long as the charge on the\nfloating node, $Y$ in $\\Phi_{1}=0$ and $W$ in\n$\\Phi_{1}=1$, does not leak away. In normal\nCMOS\n\n$$\\tau _{leak}\\approx C_{node}V_{DD}/I_{leak}\\approx\n10^{-13}/10^{-9}\\approx 10^{-4} {\\rm s}$$\n\nso\n\n$$f_{min}\\approx 10^{4}-10^{6}{\\rm Hz},\\;\\;\nf_{max}\\approx 1/3t_{p}$$\n\nany stop of the clock, any slow clock, any\ncoupling noise, clock feed through, charge\nsharing on $Y,W$ destroys the state. It is\nnormally called {\\it dynamic\\/} and {\\it\nratioless\\/}:\n\n$$P_{dyn}=C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f\\;\\;,\\;\\;t_{CQ}=t_{TG}+t_{Inv}$$\nminimum.\n\nPutting the red ${\\rm Inv}$ in the master, in\nsign as a {\\it cross coupled latch} with\n${\\rm Inv}_{1}$\n\n$$Y \\xrightarrow{{\\rm Inv}_{1}} Z\n \\xrightarrow{{\\rm red}}X \\xrightarrow{TG_{1}}Y$$\n\nin the drawing as a {\\it parallel} driver\n$$X\\;\\xrightarrow[{\\rm red}]{{\\rm Inv}_{1}}\\;Z$$\nit is the same thing {\\it modulo} $TG_{1}$,\nmakes the master {\\it pseudo static}, {\\it\nratioed}.\n\nIn the transparent phase, $CK=1$, the two\n${\\rm Inv}$ drive $Z$ in {\\it parallel}, {\\it\na fortiori} faster. In the hold phase,\n$CK=0$, $\\bar {CK}=1$,\n\n$$Z =\\bar Y\\;\\;{\\rm from\\;Inv}_{1}\\;\\;{\\rm with\\;\\;}\nY=Q_{n}={\\rm floating\\;capacitor}$$\n\nis now held by\n\n$$Z =\\bar X\\;\\;{\\rm from\\;red\\;\\;with\\;\\;}\nX= W = Z\\;\\;{\\rm from\\;slave}$$\n\n{\\it i. e.} the red ${\\rm Inv}$ fights\n${\\rm Inv}_{1}$ on $Z$, or, if you draw it as\n$Z\\to X$, it fights the slave on $X$.\n\nSo for DC:\n\n* Pro: the loop gain $>1$ holds $Y/Z$\nfor $f\\to 0$. No $f_{min}$. The node is\nlow impedance, restored to $V_{DD}/V_{SS}$,\nnoise margin goes from $\\approx 0$ dynamic\nto $NM_{H,L}\\approx V_{DD}/3$, clock feed\nthrough and leakage insensitive, rail to\nrail, can be stopped. In modern jargon the\nconventional TSPC becomes the E-TSPC,\nextended TSPC, and can even be made faster\nbecause the series ${\\rm MOS}$ in the\nclocked ${\\rm Inv}$ can be suppressed.\n\n* Contra: ratioed logic. During the {\\it\nwrite} the driver must over power the keeper.\n\nFor the master to be writable\n\n$$ \\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{red}<<\n   \\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{Inv_{1}},\n   \\left({W\\over L}\\right)_{slave}$$\n\nnormally $1/3$ to $1/10$ and long $L$,\nhigh $V_{t}$ if possible.  If that ratio is\nnot respected the latch cannot be flipped,\nthe divider is stuck, $Q_{n+1}=Q_{n}$, it\ndoes not $\\div 2$.\n\nEven correctly ratioed:\n\n* added $C_{g}+C_{d}$ on $X,Y,Z$, about\n$20-30\\%$ extra fan out, so\n\n$$t_{CQ}^{stat}=t_{CQ}^{dyn}+ \\Delta t_{red}\n  +t_{fight}\\approx 1.1-1.5\\,t_{CQ}^{dyn}$$\n\n$$f_{max}^{stat}\\approx 0.7-0.9\\,f_{max}^{dyn}$$\n\nin $0.18\\mu$ e. {\\it g.} $5.0{\\rm GHz}\n\\to 3.5-4.5{\\rm GHz}$.\n\n* a direct $V_{DD}\\to V_{SS}$ short circuit\ncurrent during the fight\n\n$$I_{sc}\\approx {1\\over 2}\\mu C_{ox}{W\\over L}\n \\left(V_{DD}-V_{t}\\right)^{2}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;\n  t_{sc}\\approx t_{r,f}$$\n\nso\n\n$$P =C_{L}V_{DD}^{2}f +V_{DD}I_{sc}t_{sc}f$$\n\n$10-30\\%$ more power, static power\n$\\ne 0$ during transition, $PDP$ worse.\n\n* $t_{setup},t_{hold}$ of the equivalent\n$D\\,{\\rm FF}$ are degraded, essentially the\nhold time must cover the fight time.\n\n* process, $V_{DD}$, $T$ variation of the\nratio can make it fail at low $V_{DD}$ or\nhigh $T$.\n\nIn one sentence: you buy DC, leakage and\nnoise robustness and rail to rail operation\nfor area, for a small to large, depending on\nsizing, loss in $t_{p}$, $f_{max}$ and\n$P_{dyn}+P_{sc}$ and you make the circuit\nratioed. Made weak enough it is a negligible\npenalty, made as strong as ${\\rm Inv}_{1}$\nit kills the divider.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} In the literature the weak\n> red ${\\rm Inv}$ is normally gated with a\n> $TG_{2}$ so that it is disconnected during\n> the write, {\\it e. g.} the conventional\n> $TG$ static master-slave $D\\,{\\rm FF}$,\n> to suppress the $I_{sc}$.  Unclocked as\n> drawn it is the E-TSPC $\\div 2$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "ef620b6999528e21e7619ca6bc4fc3f266d1fef71cc041300fc1f2ed6fad3c71"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It recognizes that the red inverter provides a parallel path that can speed the signal, but mischaracterizes it as a keeper/staticizer and reverses the key low-frequency effect: the unclocked branch raises, rather than removes, the minimum usable clock frequency. Its overall claim that the addition reduces maximum speed also conflicts with the intended feedforward speed benefit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "09f12aa6905fa83982420dcd1602844314d44b4575734bb31f92f5ccf31131d2",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1123,
        "input_tokens": 1226,
        "output_tokens": 9282,
        "total_tokens": 10508,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7647,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1123,
        "input_tokens": 1226,
        "output_tokens": 9282,
        "total_tokens": 10508,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 7647,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "In the figure, somebody answers:\n\n> The red inverter acts as a keeper, forming a cross-coupled latch with `Inv1`.\n> This removes the minimum clock frequency requirement due to leakage.\n\nDo you agree with this answer? What is the actual role of the red inverter?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the conventional CMOS ${\\rm TG}/{\\rm C^{2}MOS}$\n{\\it pseudo static} $T$ divide by 2 turned into the\nconventional dynamic figure and somebody has tried to\n``staticize\" it. It is wrong in two ways.\n\nLet\n\n* $A$ = to the left of the $CK$ ${\\rm TG}$\n* $M$ = to the right of the $CK$ ${\\rm TG}=$ input of\n${\\rm Inv}_{1}$\n* $B$ = output of ${\\rm Inv}_{1}=$ to the left of the\n$\\bar {CK}$ ${\\rm TG}$\n* $C$ = to the right of the $\\bar {CK}$ ${\\rm TG}$\n  $=$ input of the slave ${\\rm inv}$\n* $E$ = output of the slave $=$ $A$ by the\nglobal wiring.\n\nWithout colour the circuit is the dynamic\n$T$~FF:\n\n$$A\\stackrel{CK}{\\to}M\\stackrel{{\\rm Inv}_{1}}{\\to}\nB\\stackrel{\\bar {CK}}{\\to}C\\stackrel{{\\rm Inv}}{\\to}\n\\stackrel{{\\rm Inv}}{\\to}E=A\\tag{*}$$\n\n$3$ inversions round the loop. Closed on\n$CK=1$ open on $\\bar {CK}=0$ and vice versa.\nIt is an edge triggered $D$ with $D=\\bar Q$.\n$M$ and $C$ are {\\it storage} nodes. On\n\n* $CK=1$, $\\bar {CK}=0$ $M=A=E$, $B=\\bar A$,\n$C$ is floating on $C_{C}$.\n* $CK=0$, $\\bar {CK}=1$ $M$ is floating on $C_{M}$,\n$B={\\rm Inv}_{1}(M)$, $C=B$, $E=\\bar B=A$.\n\n$C_{M}$ drives ${\\rm Inv}_{1}$ and $C_{C}$ drives the\nslave. In hold they leak with $I_{\\rm off}$ so\n\n$$ \\Delta V = I_{\\rm leak}T_{H}/C_{M,C} $$\n\nmust be $\\ll V_{DD}/2$. I.e. $f_{CK}>f_{\\min }\n\\approx I_{\\rm leak}/C_{M,C}V_{DD}$, normally\n${\\rm kHz}$ to ${\\rm MHz}$ with modern leakage.\nThat is the ``minimum frequency'' of a dynamic\ndivider.\n\nA conventional weak keeper for a ${\\rm TG}$\nlatch is\n\n$${\\rm Inv}_{1}:M\\to B\\,\\;\\;{\\rm Keeper}:\\;B\\to M$$\n\nwith the ${\\rm TG}$ {\\it in series} with the loop.\nWith $CK=1$ the loop is transparent and $A$\noverwrites it. With $CK=0$ the ${\\rm TG}$ is\nopen and ${\\rm Inv}_{1}+{\\rm keeper}$ is a\ncross coupled bistable holding $M/B$ statically.\nIt must be ratioed: keeper $W/L \\ll {\\rm Inv}_{1}$\nand $\\ll$ driver $E$ so it can be over written.\n\nNormally you need {\\it two} keepers: $B\\to M$ for\nthe master and $E\\to C$ or $D\\to C$ for the slave.\nWith one keeper only the circuit is half static.\nIt still has a $f_{\\min }$ for the other phase.\n\nAs drawn the {\\it red} inverter is $A\\to B$ in the\ndrawing, $B\\to A$ if you reverse the symbol. In\neither case it is {\\it not} $B\\to M$.\n\n* If $A\\to B$ it is a second feed forward\n${\\rm inv}$ in {\\it parallel} with $CK+{\\rm Inv}_{1}$.\nWith $\\bar {CK}=1$ you have\n\n$$A\\stackrel{\\rm red}{\\to}B \\to C \\to\\bar C\\to E=A$$\n\n$3$ inversions round a {\\it combinational} loop:\na gated ring oscillator. With $\\bar {CK}=0$ $B=\n\\bar A$ combinationally. There is no latch at\nall.\n\n* If $B\\to A$, as normally intended as a keeper,\nit goes to $A$, not to $M$.\n\n$$ {\\rm loop}: A\\stackrel{CK}{\\to} M\\stackrel{{\\rm Inv}_{1}}\n{\\to} B\\stackrel{\\rm red}{\\to}A \\tag{**}$$\n\ni.e. ${\\rm Inv}_{1}+{\\rm red}$ is a latch {\\it only}\nwith $CK=1$ closed. That is the {\\it transparent}\nphase, when you do {\\it not} need it. With $CK=0$\nopen $M$ is disconnected. $(**)$ is open.\n$M$ is left floating on $C_{M}$ driving ${\\rm Inv}_{1}$.\n${\\rm Red}$ holds $A/B$ not $M/B$. $M$ still leaks and\nwill flip ${\\rm Inv}_{1}$ after $T_{H}=C_{M}\\Delta V/\nI_{\\rm leak}$.\n\nIn the other phase $\\bar {CK}=1$\n\n$$B\\stackrel{\\bar {CK}}{\\to}E=B\\;{\\rm via\\; slave}\\qquad\nB\\stackrel{\\rm red}{\\to}A=E=\\bar B\\;{\\rm via\\; red}$$\n\nthe slave non inverting path $B\\to E$ fights the\ninverting path $B\\stackrel{\\rm red}{\\to}E$ on the\nsame node $A=E$.\n\nSo at best ${\\rm red}$ is a weak bus holder for the\n{\\it global} $A$ node. It will hold $A/B$ statically\nwhen the slave is opaque, $CK=1$, but it does not\nhold $M$ when the master is opaque and it does not\nhold $C$ at all. The circuit stays dynamic.\n$C$ is always dynamic. $M$ is dynamic for half\nthe period. The $f_{\\min}$ for $T_{H}({\\rm low})$\nand for $f_{CK}$ is essentially unchanged.\n\nWhat it does do is put a DC fight on $A=E$.\nOn $CK=0\\to 1$ $E$ must overwrite the keeper to\nwrite new data into the master and on $CK=1\\to\n0$ ${\\rm red}$ must fight $E$ while the slave is\ntrying to toggle. If ${\\rm red}$ is made with a\nnormal strong $W/L$ the divider will not toggle\nat all - it is a ratioed latch stuck in the old\nstate. If made weak, long $L$ small $W$, the\ndivider can be made to work but with large crow\nbar current during the write, degraded noise\nmargin, slower $f_{\\max }$ and still dynamic\nleakage on $M$ and $C$.\n\n> {\\it I.e. the conventional description ``red\n> with ${\\rm Inv}_{1}$ is a cross coupled keeper\n> that makes the divider static and removes the\n> $f_{\\min}$'' is false as drawn. Correctly wired\n> it would be $B\\to M$, not $B\\to A$, and even then\n> it would make only the master static. You need a\n> second keeper $E\\to C$ to make the whole\n> divider static. As drawn it is a miswired\n> half keeper that leaves the critical storage node\n> $M$ and the slave node $C$ floating, does not\n> remove the leakage induced $f_{\\min}$, makes the\n> latch ratioed and can destroy the divide by two\n> function if not made weak.} \n\nIn textbooks this is exhibited as the classic\n``keeper on the wrong side of the ${\\rm TG}$''\nmistake. The correct staticizer is to move the\nleft terminal of the red inverter from $A$ to $M$.\nThen with a weak $W/L$ and a second weak\nferedback inverter $E\\to C$ you get the usual\n``weak feedback'' pseudo static TSPC divider\nwith no $f_{\\min }$ at the expense of ratioed\nstatic power during switching.\n\nWith the wiring as shown it is at most a\npseudo static bus holder for $A$ that has to be\noverpowered on every toggle.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "64a2565b1d39cc364cac275f6fc595d9869cce19ba71380a53ebc2201e3ecfe0"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly rejects the keeper interpretation and, in one case, identifies the A-to-B feedforward path and its gated-ring behavior. But the answer is internally inconsistent and concludes that the minimum-frequency requirement is essentially unchanged, missing the key tradeoff: the branch can help at high speed but overpower the intended latch at low clock rates and raise the minimum usable frequency.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "172cbb780508db2c8965d08eedaac49be4edfaf50993cf59fb05d5d161e1fa3c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1269,
        "output_tokens": 11598,
        "total_tokens": 12867,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9837,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1269,
        "output_tokens": 11598,
        "total_tokens": 12867,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 9837,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "In the figure, somebody answers:\n\n> The red inverter acts as a keeper, forming a cross-coupled latch with `Inv1`.\n> This removes the minimum clock frequency requirement due to leakage.\n\nDo you agree with this answer? What is the actual role of the red inverter?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "No. It is a {\\it half} keeper.\n\n$$CK~{\\rm TG} + {\\rm Inv}_{1} = {\\rm master~~latch} \\qquad \n\\bar {CK}~{\\rm TG}+2{\\rm Inv} = {\\rm slave~~latch}$$\n\nwith $Q=D\\!=\\!\\bar Q$ i. e. $T$-FF/$\\div 2$.\n\n* With $CK=0$,$\\bar {CK}=1$:\n\n$$D_{M}\\equiv B\\;\\;{\\rm open}\\;\\;,\n\\;\\;C\\leftrightarrow B\\;{\\rm by\\; Inv_{1}+red}$$\nmaster opaque, stored on $B-C$.\n$C$ drives $D$ drives $E$ drives $F$,\nslave transparent:\n$$F=C,\\;\\;E=\\bar D, \\;\\;D=C\\;{\\rm driven}$$\nwhole ring closed $B-C-D-E-F$ and ${\\rm DC}$\nstatic.\n\n* With $CK=1$,$\\bar {CK}=0$:\n\n$$D\\;{\\rm open},\\;B\\!-\\!F\\;{\\rm closed}$$\nmaster transparent $B=F$, $C=\\bar B$,\nslave opaque, $D$ high impedance\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nB &=F \\cr\nC &=\\bar B\\cr\nD &= {\\rm float}\\cr\nE &=\\bar D\\cr\nF &=\\bar E = D\\cr}$$\n\ni. e. the master is still held by the\n${\\rm Inv}_{1}\\leftrightarrow {\\rm red}$ cross couple,\nthe slave storage node $D$, the input of the\nslave inverter, is {\\it dynamic}, on its\ndiffusion + gate $C_{p}$.\n\nSo ``red + ${\\rm Inv}_{1}$'' is indeed a\ncross coupled latch - normally drawn as a\n{\\it clocked} feedback inverter - here drawn\nas a direct weak feedback inverter, a weak\nkeeper, trickle inverter, bleeder,\nstaticizer, level restorer, ``semi-static'',\n``pseudo static'' latch.\n\nWhen the master is opaque, $CK=0$, it is held\nstatically against leakage, charge sharing,\ncoupling noise, power supply droop, etc. by\nthe red inverter.\n\nWhen the master is transparent, $CK=1$, the\nred inverter is overdriven by the $F$ driver\nthrough the $CK$ transmission gate.\nI. e. it {\\it must} be ratioed weak, long $L$\nsmall $W$, high $R_{out}$, so it can be\noverpowered for a correct write. While it is\nbeing overpowered it draws $I_{sc}$ crowbar\ncurrent. It is a ratioed pseudo NMOS latch.\nIf it is made normal strength the divider\njams and will not toggle, $B=\\bar F$ cannot be\nwritten.\n\nIt does {\\it not} make the whole master-slave\nFF/divider static. For $CK=1$ the $D$ node is\nfloating. If you stop the clock with $CK=1$,\n$\\bar {CK}=0$, for\n\n$$t_{H} > {C_{p}\\Delta V\\over I_{leak}} \\approx\n10^{-13}\\times 0.5/10^{-9} \\sim 10-100\\mu {\\rm s}$$\n\n$D$ leaks to $V_{DD}$ or $V_{SS}$,\n$E,F$ follow, the next $CK=0$ loads the\nwrong $F$ and the $\\div 2$ loses state.\n\nSo conventionally the circuit is still\nregarded as {\\it dynamic}. There is a maximum\nallowable $CK=1$ pulse width, i. e. a minimum\noperating frequency if the clock has $50\\%$\nduty cycle, or more precisely still a\nminimum clock frequency for $DC$ high\noperation. You can stop the circuit\nindefinitely only with $CK=0$.\n\nTo make it truly single phase fully static,\n$F_{min}=0$ for either phase, you need a\nsecond, normally clocked, weak feedback\ninverter round the slave, $F\\rightarrow D$\nor $E\\rightarrow D$.\n\nIn text books the circuit as drawn is often\ncalled the Yuan-Svensson True Single Phase\nClock, TSPC, pseudo static or half static\ndivide by two, master pseudo static, slave\ndynamic, $T$-FF. The red inverter is the\nmaster staticizer - it lets you run the\ndivider down to low frequency {\\it and} holds\nthe master node while the master is opaque\nso you do not have to refresh it every cycle -\nbut at the price of a ratioed contention write\nand without staticizing the slave.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} With ordinary sizing the divider will\ndivide correctly as a dynamic divider even\nwithout the red inverter. The red inverter is\nnot logically necessary, it is there for\nrobustness at low speed, noise, soft error\nand start up.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "b124dd2e9f55fd497fd63540333fa784cf145f0b9d2fa060b8002b36db7007db"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 0,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "The answer incorrectly treats the red inverter as a cross-coupled keeper/staticizer. It misses the actual feedforward path and its low-frequency failure mode, and reaches the opposite conclusion about low-frequency operation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "172cbb780508db2c8965d08eedaac49be4edfaf50993cf59fb05d5d161e1fa3c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1269,
        "output_tokens": 7347,
        "total_tokens": 8616,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6057,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1269,
        "output_tokens": 7347,
        "total_tokens": 8616,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6057,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 0,
        "score_percent": 0,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 15,
      "question": "In the figure, somebody answers:\n\n> The red inverter acts as a keeper, forming a cross-coupled latch with `Inv1`.\n> This removes the minimum clock frequency requirement due to leakage.\n\nDo you agree with this answer? What is the actual role of the red inverter?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-015-but-input-red-inverter-not-tied-output/figure-12.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "It is ``keeper'' in name only. Let\n\n* $N_{1}$ be the node to the {\\it right} of the $CK$\n  transfer gate $=$ input of $Inv_{1}$\n* $N_{2}$ be the node to the {\\it left} of the $\\bar {CK}$\n  transfer gate $=$ output of $Inv_{1}$\n* $N_{3}$ be the node to the {\\it right} of the $\\bar {CK}$\n  transfer gate $=$ input of the $slave$ $2\\;Inv.$\n* $N_{0}$ be the common node $=$ left of $CK$ $=$ output\n  of the $slave$ $=Q$.\n\nWithout the red $Inv.$\n\n* $CK=1$ , $\\bar {CK}=0$: $N_{1}=N_{0}$, $N_{2}=\\bar N_{1}$,\n  transparent, $N_{3}$ $Z$\n* $CK=0$, $\\bar {CK}=1$: $N_{1}$ $Z$, $N_{2}= \\bar N_{1}$\n  memorised on $C_{N1}$, $C_{N2}$, $N_{3}=N_{2}$ transparent.\n* $CK=1$, $\\bar {CK}=0$: $N_{3}$ $Z$ memorised on $C_{N3}$.\n\nSo the toggle ${\\rm DFF}$ with ${\\rm D}=\\bar Q$ is two\n{\\it dynamic} latches. The state is the charge on the\nhigh $Z$ nodes $N_{1}$ and $N_{3}$ and to a lesser\nextent $N_{2}$ which follows $N_{1}$. ${\\rm d}V/{\\rm d}t=\nI_{leak}/C\\sim $msec. The clock must be re-circulated\nbefore that. There is a minimum $f_{ck}$.\n\nA conventional weak keeper for the ${\\rm M}$ latch is\n\n$$N_{2} \\rightarrow Inv_{w} \\rightarrow N_{1}\\tag{*}$$\n\nwith $Inv_{w}$ weak, so that when $CK=0$ the loop\n$Inv_{1}+Inv_{w}$ is {\\it closed} and isolated from $N_{0}$.\n$N_{1}$ is always driven, either by $N_{0}$ through $CK=1$ or\nby $Inv_{w}$ through $(*)$ for $CK=0$. $Inv_{1}$ can\noverpower $Inv_{w}$ when $CK=1$ to write. Ditto for\nthe ${\\rm S}$ latch $N_{5}\\rightarrow Inv_{w}\\rightarrow N_{3}$.\n\nWhat is drawn in red is {\\it not} $(*)$. Up to orientation,\n\n$$\\;N_{2}\\; {\\rm or}\\; N_{0} \\rightarrow Inv_{red} \\rightarrow\n  N_{0}\\; {\\rm or}\\; N_{2}\\; \\tag{**}$$\n\nin the drawing the left plate of the red $Inv.$ is\n$N_{0}$ , the right plate, bubble, is $N_{2}$. So at\nbest\n\n$$N_{0}\\rightarrow Inv_{red}\\rightarrow N_{2} $$\n\nor vice versa $N_{2}\\rightarrow Inv_{red}\\rightarrow N_{0}$.\nIn either case the left plate is {\\it not} $N_{1}$.\n\nIn particular the often quoted $N_{2}\\rightarrow Inv_{red}\n\\rightarrow N_{1}$ ``cross coupled latch with $Inv_{1}$''\ndoes not exist. $N_{1}$ and $N_{0}$ are the same node\nonly when $CK=1$. When the latch is supposed to hold,\n$CK=0$, $N_{1}$ is open. The red loop is open. The\ncharge on $N_{1}$ is still left on a $Z$ node and will\nleak through the $n$ - or $p$ - diffusion of the $TG$\nand of $Inv_{1}$ with time constant $C_{N1}/I_{off}$.\n\n$$N_{1}\\;\\;{\\rm is\\;still\\;dynamic}$$\n\nThe only thing the red $Inv.$ does keep is $N_{2}$.\nFor $CK=0$, $N_{1}$ $Z$, $Inv_{1}$ is driving $N_{2}$\nto $\\bar N_{1}$ on the basis of a leaking input, $N_{2}$\nwould follow the leak. The red $Inv.$ now drives $N_{2}$\nfrom $N_{0}=Q$ which is low impedance. So $N_{2}$ is\nnever $Z$, it is always driven either by $Inv_{1}$ or\nby $Inv_{red}$. But it is driven to the {\\it wrong}\nvalue in hold.\n\nNormal hold: with $CK=0$, $\\bar {CK}=1$, $Q=N_{2,old}$,\n$N_{3}=N_{2,old}$.\n\nWith $N_{0}\\rightarrow N_{2}$ red: $N_{2,red}= \\bar N_{0}\n= \\bar Q = \\bar N_{2,old}$. The red $Inv.$ fights the\nvalue the ${\\rm M}$ latch is supposed to hold. Normal\noperation is only possible as {\\rm ratioed} logic: the\nred $Inv.$ must be made weak $W/L \\ll W/L_{Inv1}$,\n$W/L_{Q\\;driver}$ so that during the phase in which it\nfights it is overpowered. We get\n\n* $CK=1$: $CK$ closed, $Inv_{1}$ and $Inv_{red}$ both drive\n$N_{2}$ to $\\bar N_{0}$ - no fight.\n* $CK=0$: $CK$ open, $Inv_{1}$ drives $N_{2}$ to the\nold $\\bar N_{1,old}$, $Inv_{red}$ drives $N_{2}$ to\n$\\bar N_{0}= \\bar N_{2,old}$, opposite, $Inv_{1}$ must win\nif the leak has not yet moved $N_{1}$.\n\nThe complementary case $N_{2}\\rightarrow N_{0}$ is the\ndual: the loop $N_{1}-CK-Inv_{1}-Inv_{red}$ is a latch\n{\\it closed when $CK=1$}, i.e. precisely when the ${\\rm M}$\nlatch should be transparent. It holds when it should sample\nand is open when it should hold. Again it only works\nratioed.\n\nIn either description it is not a conventional keeper/\ncross coupled bistable isolated when $CK=0$. It is a\nweak feed through, half keeper, pseudo-NMOS, contention\nlatch. It gives a DC path $V_{DD}-V_{SS}$ through\n$Inv_{1}/Inv_{red}/Q$ driver for half the cycle and\nstatic power.\n\nEven if you accept to call the $N_{0}-N_{2}$ loop a\nweak pseudo latch that keeps $N_{2}$ defined, the\ncircuit {\\it as a frequency divider} is still dynamic:\n\n* $N_{1}$ still $Z$ for $CK=0$\n* $N_{3}$ still $Z$ for $\\bar {CK}=0\\;(CK=1)$\n\nOne weak inverter on the master can at most pseudo-\nstaticize the master intermediate node $N_{2}$, it cannot\nstaticize the true storage node $N_{1}$ nor the slave\nstorage node $N_{3}$. The divider will still lose state\nif $\\bar {CK}=0$ is kept too long, $C_{N3}$ leaking, and\nif $CK=0$ is kept too long $C_{N1}$ leaking will flip\n$Inv_{1}$ and, even though $N_{2}$ is weakly held, the\ncontention current will eventually be won by the leak if\nyou wait long enough. So a minimum $f_{ck}$ remains,\nat best moved by the ratio.\n\nA truly static toggle ${\\rm DFF}$ needs {\\it two}\nkeepers, $(*)$ for the master and the equivalent for the\nslave, both weak and isolated behind the $TG$, e.g. clocked\nfeedback inverter. Moving the left plate of the red\n$Inv.$ from $N_{0}$ to $N_{1}$ and adding the missing\nslave keeper, properly ratioed $\\sim 1/5-1/10$, is the\ntext book static TSPC/C$^{2}$MOS latch.\n\nWithout that the 3 $Inv.$ + $2\\;TG$ + global $\\bar Q\\rightarrow D$\nconnection is just the well known dynamic divide by $2$.\nAdding the red $Inv.$ as drawn does not make it static,\nit makes it a ratioed pseudo static divider with contention,\ndegraded swing, noise margin and power, and is normally\nquoted as the classic {\\it wrong place for the keeper}\nmistake. Remove it and you recover the correct low power\ndynamic divider operation.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "bcc4a4e149f697bb0f3f27881e316f58e805651c558a46f52724600771bfb626"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly rejects a conventional cross-coupled keeper and identifies the N0-to-N2 path, but mischaracterizes it as a weak pseudo-keeper and attributes the frequency limit mainly to leakage. It misses the key role as an unclocked feedforward bypass, which can speed high-rate operation yet dominate the latch path at low rates and raise the minimum usable clock frequency.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "172cbb780508db2c8965d08eedaac49be4edfaf50993cf59fb05d5d161e1fa3c",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1269,
        "output_tokens": 15736,
        "total_tokens": 17005,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13623,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1251,
        "input_tokens": 1269,
        "output_tokens": 15736,
        "total_tokens": 17005,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 13623,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "How do we optimize the circuit shown in the figure for the NF if Rin must remain equal to 50 Ohm?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the bias choke ${\\rm C}_{1}\\to {\\rm s.c.}$\nfor ${\\rm a.c.}$ put\n\n$${G_{F}=1/R_{F}\\;\\;G_{s}=1/R_{s}\\;\\;G_{o}=1/r_{o}\\;\\;\nr_{o}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\;\\;g_{m}=g_{m1}+g_{m2}\\;\\;\ni_{n}^{2}=4kT\\gamma g_{m}\\;{\\rm A^{2}/Hz}\\;\\;0.7<\\gamma <2$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{nF}^{2}&=4kTG_{F}\\cr \nv_{ns}^{2}&=4kTR_{s}\\cr}$$\n\n$${\\rm at\\;\\;input:}\\;(V_{i}-V_{s})G_{s}+(V_{i}-V_{o})G_{F}+i_{nF}=0 \\tag{1}$$\n$${\\rm at\\;\\;output:}\\;(V_{o}-V_{i})G_{F}-i_{nF}+V_{o}G_{o}+g_{m}V_{i}\n+i_{n}=0 \\tag{2}$$\n\n$$\\left| {{V_{o}}\\over {V_{i}}}\\right| _{0}=\n{{g_{m}-G_{F}}\\over {G_{F}+G_{o}}}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}\\parallel R_{F}=|A_{v}|$$\n\n$$\\left| {{V_{o}}\\over {V_{s}}}\\right| =\n{{G_{s}(g_{m}-G_{F})}\\over {G_{s}(G_{F}+G_{o})+G_{F}(G_{o}+g_{m})}}\n\\equiv A_{vs} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${{I_{x}}\\over {V_{x}}}= {{1+ g_{m}r_{o}}\\over {R_{F}+r_{o}}}\\equiv\n{{1}\\over {R_{in}}}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$$R_{in}={{R_{F}+r_{o}}\\over {1+g_{m}r_{o}}}\n      ={{G_{o}+G_{F}}\\over {G_{F}(G_{o}+g_{m})}}\\approx\n      {1\\over {g_{m}}}+{{R_{F}}\\over {g_{m}r_{o}}}\\tag{5}$$\n\nfor $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$.\n\nWith $V_{s}=0$ from (1)(2)\n\n$$V_{o}={{i_{nF}(g_{m}+G_{s})-i_{n}(G_{s}+G_{F})}\\over {D}}\\tag{6}$$\n\n$$D=G_{s}(G_{F}+G_{o})+G_{F}(G_{o}+g_{m})$$\n\nso that, $i_{nF}$ and $i_{n}$ uncorrelated\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nH_{F}&={{V_{o}}\\over {i_{nF}}}={{g_{m}+G_{s}}\\over {D}}\\cr\nH_{m}&={{V_{o}}\\over {i_{n}}}=-{{G_{s}+G_{F}}\\over {D}}\\cr}\n\\tag{7}$$\n\nand, from (3),\n\n$$S_{o,s}=A_{vs}^{2}4kTR_{s}\\tag{8}$$\n$$S_{o,F}=H_{F}^{2}4kTG_{F}\\tag{9}$$\n$$S_{o,m}=H_{m}^{2}4kT\\gamma g_{m}\\tag{10}$$\n\n$${\\cal F}={{S_{o,s}+S_{o,F}+S_{o,m}}\\over {S_{o,s}}}\n        =1+{{S_{o,F}}\\over {S_{o,s}}}+{{S_{o,m}}\\over {S_{o,s}}}\\tag{11}$$\n\nAs $D$ cancels\n\n$${\\cal F}=1+{{G_{F}(g_{m}+G_{s})^{2}}\\over\n                {G_{s}(g_{m}-G_{F})^{2}}}\n           +\\gamma {{g_{m}(G_{s}+G_{F})^{2}}\\over\n                {G_{s}(g_{m}-G_{F})^{2}}}\\tag{12}$$\n\n$$\\approx 1+{{G_{F}}\\over {G_{s}}}{{  \n            \\left(1+G_{s}/g_{m}\\right)^{2}}\\over\n            {\\left(1-G_{F}/g_{m}\\right)^{2}}}\n           +\\gamma {{g_{m}}\\over {G_{s}}}\n             {{ \\left(1+G_{F}/G_{s}\\right)^{2}}\\over\n              {g_{m}^{2}\\left(1-G_{F}/g_{m}\\right)^{2}}}(G_{s}+G_{F})^{2}/g_{m} $$\n\nFor the usual $g_{m}\\gg G_{F}$\n\n$${\\cal F}\\approx 1+{{R_{s}}\\over {R_{F}}}\n          \\left(1+{{G_{s}}\\over {g_{m}}}\\right)^{2}\n          +\\gamma {{(1+R_{s}/R_{F})^{2}}\\over {g_{m}R_{s}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nand, for $r_{o}\\to \\infty $, $R_{in}=1/g_{m}$,\n\n$${\\cal F}\\approx 1+4{{R_{s}}\\over {R_{F}}}+ \n      \\gamma\\left(1+{{R_{s}}\\over {R_{F}}}\\right)^{2}\n       \\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;g_{m}=G_{s}\\tag{14}$$\n\n$${\\cal F}\\approx 1+\\gamma \\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;R_{F}\\gg R_{s}\\tag{15}$$\n\n$g_{m}=g_{m1}+g_{m2}$,\n$\\gamma g_{m}=\\gamma _{n}g_{m1}+\\gamma _{p}g_{m2}$ for\ndifferent $\\gamma $.\n\nEq.14 makes the trade off evident:\n\n* $4kTR_{F}$ wants $R_{F}$ as large as possible,\n$ \\propto R_{s}/R_{F}$\n* $4kT\\gamma g_{m}$ wants $g_{m}$ as large as possible,\n$\\propto 1/g_{m}R_{s}$.\n\n$$S_{o,F}/S_{o,s}\\propto 1/R_{F}\\;\\;,\\;\\;S_{o,m}/S_{o,s}\\propto 1/g_{m}$$\n\nWith $R_{in}$ fixed the two are not independent.\nFrom (5)\n\n$$R_{s}=R_{in}={{R_{F}+r_{o}}\\over {1+g_{m}r_{o}}}\\tag{16}$$\n\n$$R_{F}=R_{s}(1+g_{m}r_{o})-r_{o}=r_{o}(g_{m}R_{s}-1)+R_{s}\n      \\approx g_{m}r_{o}R_{s}\\;\\;g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1 \\tag{17}$$\n\n$$g_{m}= {{R_{F}+r_{o}-R_{s}}\\over {R_{s}r_{o}}}\n        =R_{s}^{-1}+{{R_{F}-R_{s}}\\over {r_{o}R_{s}}} \\tag{18}$$\n\nI. e. for a given $r_{o}$ to keep $R_{in}=R_{s}=50\\;\\Omega $,\n$R_{F}$ and $g_{m}$ must be increased together.\nPut (17) in (13):\n\n$${\\cal F}-1 \\propto {1\\over {g_{m}r_{o}}}+{1\\over {g_{m}}}$$\n\nso ${\\cal F}$ is monotonically decreasing with $g_{m}$ and\nwith $R_{F}$. There is no finite optimum: in the limit\n\n$$R_{F}\\to \\infty \\;\\;,\\;\\;g_{m}\\to \\infty \\;\\;,\\;\\;\n{\\cal F}\\to 1\\tag{19}$$\n\nIn practice the limit is power, area, bandwidth and\nstability:\n\n* Choose the smallest $L$ that still gives acceptable\n$\\gamma \\approx 2/3-1.0$ and $1/f$ and acceptable $r_{o}$.\n$s.c.$ $\\gamma \\approx 1.5-2$ has to be traded for\n$f_{T}$. Often $L\\approx 1.2-1.5\\,L_{min}$ is used.\n\n* For a given bias current $I_{D}$, $g_{m}=g_{m1}+g_{m2}$,\n$g_{mi}\\propto \\sqrt{\\mu C_{ox}(W/L)I_{D}}$.\n$W$ is increased, multi finger to keep $R_{g}$ small,\nuntil the $C_{gs}+C_{gd}+C_{db}$ pole\n\n$$\\omega _{p}\\approx {1\\over {(R_{F}\\parallel r_{o}\\parallel R_{L})C_{L}}}$$\n\nand the input pole $\\omega _{in}\\approx 1/R_{s}C_{in}$\nstill satisfies the band and\n$$|A_{v}|=g_{m}r_{o}\\parallel R_{F}< {\\rm stability\\;limit}.$$\n$g_{m}/I_{D}$ is maximum in weak-moderate inversion,\nso low $V_{ov}\\approx 100-200\\,{\\rm mV}$ is normal.\n\n* With that $g_{m,{\\max }}$ allowed by the power budget,\nput\n\n$$R_{F,opt}=R_{in}(1+g_{m,{\\max }}r_{o})-r_{o}\\tag{20}$$\n\nNumerically for $r_{o}=0.5-1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nR_{in}=50\\;\\Omega &: g_{m}\\approx 20\\,{\\rm mS}+{{R_{F}-50}\\over {r_{o}50}}\\cr\nR_{F}=0.2-0.5\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }&: g_{m}\\approx 25-40\\,{\\rm mS}\\cr\nR_{F}=1-2\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }&: g_{m}\\approx 60-100\\,{\\rm mS}\\cr}$$\n\nand\n\n$$|A_{vs}|\\approx {{g_{m}r_{o}\\parallel R_{F}}\\over 2}\\tag{21}$$\n$${\\cal F}\\approx 1+\\gamma {{1}\\over {g_{m}R_{s}}}+{\\cal O}(R_{s}/R_{F})$$\n\ni. e. with $r_{o}\\to \\infty $, $R_{in}=1/g_{m}=R_{s}$,\n$R_{F}$ can be made arbitrarily large and\n\n$${\\cal F}_{min}\\approx 1+{{\\gamma }\\over {g_{m}R_{s}}}\\to 1+\\gamma\n\\tag{22}$$\n\n$\\approx 2.2\\,{\\rm dB}$ for long channel $\\gamma =2/3$,\n$3-4\\,{\\rm dB}$ for short channel $\\gamma \\approx 1-1.5$,\nlimit $0\\,{\\rm dB}$ for $g_{m}\\to \\infty $.\nIncreasing the intrinsic gain $g_{m}r_{o}$ by cascoding,\nlong $L$, or using a $r_{o}$ enhancing load allows a\nlarger $R_{F}$ for the same $R_{in}$ and therefore the\nsame $g_{m}$ to give lower ${\\cal F}$.\n\nThat is the conventional resistive shunt-feedback inverter\nLNA. To break the $R_{in}-{\\cal F}$ trade off the usual\ncures are, to first order noiseless feedback:\n\n* inductive or capacitive feedback $Z_{F}=1/sC_{F}$ or\n$sL_{F}$, transformer feedback,\n* $L_{g}$ series peaking at the input to resonate $C_{in}$,\nso $R_{in}$ is not $1/g_{m}$,\n* Bruccoleri noise cancelling: an auxiliary $g_{m,A}$\nsenses the noise voltage on $R_{in}$ and adds it out of\nphase at the output, cancelling to first order the noise\nof $R_{F}$ and of the matching device. With ideal\ncancellation ${\\cal F}\\to 1+{\\rm noise\\;of\\;}g_{m,A}$,\n$<2\\,{\\rm dB}$ is routinely obtained with $R_{in}=50\\;\\Omega $.\n\nIn its simplest form: maximize $g_{m}$, maximize\n$R_{F}$ with (16) satisfied, maximize $g_{m}r_{o}$,\nuse large, fingered devices with low $R_{g}$, large $C_{1}$,\nand accept the power-bandwidth penalty. Any further\nimprovement requires a noiseless feedback element or a\nnoise cancelling auxiliary amplifier and power-noise\nmatching $R_{opt}\\ne R_{in}$ with tolerable $S_{11}\\approx\n-10\\,{\\rm dB}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "56ec84bf210675f78432ddca2eb9e39604b73a28b724754cd480aeeb06d0bdc5"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Uses the finite-output-resistance match relation and explains that increasing gm above 1/Rs requires increasing RF to keep Rin at 50 Ω; along that match, NF falls below 1+gamma. This satisfies the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "6801650fd2054e7d374317849fcda2881c563a35f3d14b44d310d3d32f91b1cd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2673,
        "output_tokens": 22058,
        "total_tokens": 24731,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 19155,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2673,
        "output_tokens": 22058,
        "total_tokens": 24731,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 19155,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "How do we optimize the circuit shown in the figure for the NF if Rin must remain equal to 50 Ohm?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "This is the self biased shunt-shunt inverter, Fig 3.14\nin Razavi. \n\n$$\\eqalign{\ng_{m}&=g_{m1}+g_{m2}\\cr\nr_{o}&=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\cr\nA_{0}&=-g_{m}r_{o}}$$\n\n$$C_{1}\\approx {\\rm short}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nG_{m}v_{i}+{{v_{o}-v_{i}}\\over {R_{F}}}+{{v_{o}}\\over {r_{o}}}=0\\cr\n{\\rm for}\\;v_{i}= {\\rm input}\\;,v_{o}={\\rm output}}$$\n\n$$A_{v}\\equiv {{v_{o}}\\over {v_{i}}}={{1/R_{F}-g_{m}}\\over {1/R_{F}+1/r_{o}}}\n\\approx -g_{m}r_{o}\\parallel R_{F}\\tag{1}$$\n\nWith $R_{s}$ at the input\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{{v_{i}-v_{s}}\\over {R_{s}}}+{{v_{i}-v_{o}}\\over {R_{F}}}&=0\\cr\n-g_{m}v_{i}+{{v_{o}-v_{i}}\\over {R_{F}}}+{{v_{o}}\\over {r_{o}}}&=0}$$\n\n$$R_{in}\\equiv {{v_{i}}\\over {i_{in}}}={{v_{i}}\\over {(v_{i}-v_{o})/R_{F}}}\n={{R_{F}}\\over {1-A_{v}}}= {{r_{o}+R_{F}}\\over {1+g_{m}r_{o}}}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx {{R_{F}}\\over {1+g_{m}r_{o}}}\\approx \n{{1}\\over {g_{m}}}+{{R_{F}}\\over {g_{m}r_{o}}}\\qquad g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$$\n\ni. e. $R_{in}$ is no longer $R_{F}$ and no longer\n$1/g_{m}$. For $R_{F}\\gg r_{o}$ $R_{in}\\to 1/g_{m}$, for\n$R_{F}\\ll r_{o}$ $R_{in}\\to R_{F}/g_{m}r_{o}$.\nNormally $50\\Omega $ is obtained with $g_{m}R_{s}\\ne 1$.\n\nLet $\\overline{i_{n,R_{F}}^{2}}=4kT/R_{F}$ in parallel\nwith $R_{F}$ and \n$\\overline{i_{n,D}^{2}}=4kT\\gamma g_{m1}+4kT\\gamma g_{m2}\n=4kT\\gamma g_{m}$ at the output.\n\nWriting nodal equations with $v_{s}$, $i_{n,R_{F}}$, $i_{n,D}$\n\n$$\\left[ \\matrix{\n1/R_{s}+1/R_{F} &-1/R_{F}\\cr\ng_{m}-1/R_{F} &1/R_{F}+1/r_{o}}\\right]\n\\left[ \\matrix{v_{i}\\cr v_{o}}\\right] =\n\\left[ \\matrix{v_{s}/R_{s}-i_{n,R_{F}}\\cr i_{n,R_{F}}-i_{n,D}}\\right] $$\n\n$D=(1/R_{s}+1/R_{F})(1/R_{F}+1/r_{o})+(1/R_{F})(g_{m}-1/R_{F})$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nv_{o}\\vert_{v_{s}}&=-{{g_{m}-1/R_{F}}\\over {R_{s}D}}v_{s}\\cr\nv_{o}\\vert_{R_{F}}&={{g_{m}+1/R_{s}}\\over {D}}i_{n,R_{F}}\\cr\nv_{o}\\vert_{D}&=-{{1/R_{s}+1/R_{F}}\\over {D}}i_{n,D}}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nS_{vo,R_{s}}&={{(g_{m}-1/R_{F})^{2}}\\over {R_{s}^{2}D^{2}}}4kTR_{s}\\cr\nS_{vo,R_{F}}&={{(g_{m}+1/R_{s})^{2}}\\over {D^{2}}}{{4kT}\\over {R_{F}}}\\cr\nS_{vo,D}&={{(1/R_{s}+1/R_{F})^{2}}\\over {D^{2}}}4kT\\gamma g_{m}}$$\n\n$$F\\equiv {{S_{vo,R_{s}}+S_{vo,R_{F}}+S_{vo,D}}\\over {S_{vo,R_{s}}}}$$\n\n$$F=1+{{R_{s}}\\over {R_{F}}}\n\\left({{g_{m}+1/R_{s}}\\over {g_{m}-1/R_{F}}}\\right)^{2}\n+\\gamma g_{m}R_{s}\n\\left({{1/R_{s}+1/R_{F}}\\over {g_{m}-1/R_{F}}}\\right)^{2}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$D$ and $r_{o}$ drop out. For the usual\n$g_{m}\\gg 1/R_{F},1/R_{s}$\n\n$$F\\approx 1+{{R_{s}}\\over {R_{F}}}+{{\\gamma}\\over {g_{m}R_{s}}}\n\\left(1+{{R_{s}}\\over {R_{F}}}\\right)^{2}\n\\approx 1+{{R_{s}}\\over {R_{F}}}+{{\\gamma}\\over {g_{m}R_{s}}}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand with $\\gamma _{1}\\ne \\gamma_{2}$\n\n$$\\gamma g_{m}\\to \\gamma_{n}g_{m1}+\\gamma_{p}g_{m2}\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$F\\approx 1+{{R_{s}}\\over {R_{F}}}+\n{{\\gamma_{n}g_{m1}+\\gamma_{p}g_{m2}}\\over {g_{m}^{2}R_{s}}}$$\n\n$R_{s}=R_{in}=50\\Omega $ when matched.\nThe familiar $F\\approx 1+\\gamma$ for\n$1/g_{m}=R_{s}$, $R_{F}\\to \\infty$ is recovered.\n\nWith the match constraint (2)\n\n$$R_{F}=R_{in}(1+g_{m}r_{o})-r_{o}=R_{s}+r_{o}(g_{m}R_{s}-1)\\tag{6}$$\n\nSo $R_{F}$ and $g_{m}$ are not independent once\n$R_{in}=50\\Omega$ is imposed. Putting (6) in (4)\n\n$$F\\approx 1+{{R_{s}}\\over {R_{s}+r_{o}(g_{m}R_{s}-1)}}\n+{{\\gamma}\\over {g_{m}R_{s}}} \\tag{7}$$\n\nFor $A_{0}=g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$\n\n$$R_{F}\\approx R_{s}g_{m}r_{o}=R_{s}A_{0}$$\n\n$$F\\approx 1+{{1}\\over {g_{m}r_{o}}}+{{\\gamma}\\over {g_{m}R_{s}}}\n=1+{{1}\\over {g_{m}}}\\left({{1}\\over {r_{o}}}+{{\\gamma}\\over {R_{s}}}\\right)\\tag{8}$$\n\nI. e. for fixed $R_{in}$\n\n* {\\it increasing $R_{F}$ without increasing loop gain\ndestroys the match.}\n* decreasing $F$ needs {\\it increasing loop gain $A_{0}=g_{m}r_{o}$},\ni. e. increasing $R_{F}$ {\\it and} $g_{m}r_{o}$\ntogether according to (6).\n\nIn (8) $F\\to 1$ monotonically for $g_{m}\\to \\infty$ and\nfor $r_{o}\\to \\infty$. In practice:\n\n* Maximise $g_{m}=g_{m1}+g_{m2}$ for the power you can\nafford.  $g_{m}\\propto \\sqrt{W I_{D}}$ in strong inversion,\n$\\propto I_{D}$ in weak inversion, so weak-moderate inversion\nis $g_{m}/I_{D}$ optimum.  Increase $W_{1},W_{2}$ and $I_{D}$\nuntil the input pole\n\n$$\\omega_{in}\\approx {1\\over {R_{s}C_{in}}},\\qquad\nC_{in}\\approx C_{gs1}+C_{gs2}+(1+|A_{v}|)C_{gd}$$\n\nfalls on the band edge, Miller effect included.\nMulti finger layout to keep $R_{g}\\ll R_{s}$.\n\n* Maximise $r_{o}$ at that current: longer $L$, cascode the\ninverter - $r_{o}\\to g_{m,cas}r_{o,cas}r_{o}$ - retro-cascode\nself biased LNA. This lets you use a much larger $R_{F}$ for\nthe same $50\\Omega $, cf. (6), and kills the $R_{s}/R_{F}$\nterm. Short channel $A_{0}\\approx 8-15$, cascoded $A_{0}\\approx 30-50$.\n\nThen set\n\n$$R_{F}=50(1+g_{m}r_{o})-r_{o}$$\n\nfor the $g_{m},r_{o}$ you have. E. g. $r_{o}=300\\Omega $,\n$g_{m}=20\\,{\\rm mS}$, $A_{0}=6$, $R_{F}\\approx 50\\Omega $,\n$F\\approx 1+0.17+0.67\\approx 1.84=2.6\\,{\\rm dB}$ for\n$\\gamma\\approx 1$.  Doubling $g_{m}$ to $40\\,{\\rm mS}$ with\n$r_{o}=250\\Omega $, $A_{0}=10$, $R_{F}\\approx 300\\Omega $,\n$F\\approx 1+0.17+0.33\\approx 1.5=1.8\\,{\\rm dB}$.\n\n* Optimise the split $g_{m1}$ vs $g_{m2}$,\nEq.5.  For $\\gamma_{n}\\approx \\gamma_{p}$ the split cancels to\nfirst order.  Usually $W_{p}\\approx (\\mu_{n}/\\mu_{p})W_{n}$ for\nsymmetrical inverter $V_{o,DC}\\approx V_{DD}/2$ maximum\nswing and $g_{m1}\\approx g_{m2}$.  If $\\gamma_{p}<\\gamma_{n}$\nweight to the p-device.\n\nWith unbounded $g_{m}r_{o}$ the only limit is power and\n$C_{in}$ bandwidth and $R_{g}$, induced gate noise. Power\nconstrained optimum is\n\n$${\\rm min}\\;F\\;{\\rm s.t.}\\;R_{in}=50,\\;P_{DC}=V_{DD}I_{D}=const.,\n\\;C_{in}<1/R_{s}\\omega_{0}$$\n\nswept with $g_{m}/I_{D}$ methodology in simulation.\n\nIn a narrow band design $R_{F}$ can be made noiseless by\nreplacing it by $L_{F}$ or transformer feedback. In wide band\nthe $R_{s}/R_{F}$ vs $R_{in}$ trade off is fundamentally broken\nby {\\it noise cancelling}: sense the noise voltage at the\nmatching node with an auxiliary amplifier $A_{aux}=-1-R_{F}/R_{s}$\nand add it in phase to the signal so that $i_{n,R_{F}}$ and\n$i_{n,D}$ cancel, Bruccoleri et al. JSSC 2005. Then $R_{in}$\ncan be $50\\Omega $ with $F\\approx 1+\\gamma/g_{m}R_{s}$ with no\n$R_{s}/R_{F}$ penalty, $<2\\,{\\rm dB}$ in deep sub micron CMOS.\n\n> {\\it In short: keep $R_{in}=50$ by keeping\n> $R_{F}=R_{in}(1+g_{m}r_{o})-r_{o}$. The only way to lower\n> $F\\approx 1+R_{s}/R_{F}+\\gamma/g_{m}R_{s}$ without\n> changing $R_{in}$ is to raise the open loop gain.\n> Raise $g_{m1}+g_{m2}$ and $r_{o}$ - larger $W$, larger\n> $I_{D}$, longer $L$ or cascodes - and raise $R_{F}$\n> proportionally. In the limit $F=1+(1/r_{o}+\\gamma/R_{s})/g_{m}$.\n> Practically 20-40 mS total $g_{m}$ with $A_{0}>10$ gives\n> $R_{F}=200-500\\Omega $ and $NF=2-3\\,{\\rm dB}$ wideband,\n> $<2\\,{\\rm dB}$ with cascoding or noise cancellation. The\n> optimum power constrained $W$ is the largest $W$ that still meets\n> the $1/R_{s}C_{in}$ bandwidth.}",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "039c5e118bc1b10eb8aa42ff69e35dbf6f2900bf1e8725a1616596cf53737d33"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It uses the finite-r_o match relation and adjusts R_F as g_m rises, showing how g_m can exceed 1/R_s and reduce NF below 1+\\gamma. Minor asymptotic and numerical imprecision does not change the core recommendation.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "6801650fd2054e7d374317849fcda2881c563a35f3d14b44d310d3d32f91b1cd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2673,
        "output_tokens": 14199,
        "total_tokens": 16872,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11047,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 2673,
        "output_tokens": 14199,
        "total_tokens": 16872,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11047,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 16,
      "question": "How do we optimize the circuit shown in the figure for the NF if Rin must remain equal to 50 Ohm?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-016-optimize-for-nf-rin-must-remain-equal/figure-13.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "For a first order it is the :\n\n$${\\cal T}_{v}={\\cal T}_{i}={\\cal R}_{m}\n\\sim  -R_{F}$$ inverting shunt-shunt amplifier.\n\n$$R_{in}= {V_{t}\\over I_{t}}\\approx \n{R_{F}+r_{o}\\over 1+g_{m}r_{o}}\\approx {R_{F}\\over 1+g_{m}r_{o}\\parallel R_{F}}\n\\approx {1\\over g_{m}}\\;\\;,\\;g_{m}=g_{m1}+g_{m2}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\nr_{o}=r_{o1}\\parallel r_{o2}\\tag{1}$$\n\nin the normal high gain limit $g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$ and\n$r_{o}\\gg R_{F}$ and\n\n$$A_{v0}=-g_{m}r_{o}\\parallel R_{F}\\approx -g_{m}R_{F}\\tag{2}$$\n\n$$R_{in}\\approx {R_{F}\\over 1-A_{v0}}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$A_{v}$ is the open loop voltage gain of the\ninverter.\n\n> {\\it I.E. $R_{in}$ is $R_{F}$ divided by the amount of\n> feed back. For $r_{o}\\rightarrow \\infty$ $R_{in}\\rightarrow\n> 1/g_{m}$ independent of $R_{F}$ to first order.}\n\nWith (1) the matching condition ``50 Ohm'' {\\it fixes}\n$g_{m}$ and $R_{F}$ to one relation, for $r_{o}\\rightarrow\n\\infty$ it fixes $g_{m}$ itself:\n\n$$R_{in}=R_{s}=50\\;\\;\\to\\;\\; g_{m}\\approx 1/R_{s}=20{\\rm mS}\n\\tag{4a}$$\n\n$$R_{F}=R_{s}\\left( 1+g_{m}r_{o}\\right)-r_{o}\\approx g_{m}r_{o}R_{s}\n\\;\\;,\\;\\;r_{o}<\\infty \\tag{4b}$$\n\nSmall signal nodal with $G_{s}=1/R_{s}\\;,\\;G_{F}=1/R_{F}\\;,\\;\nG_{o}=1/r_{o}$ :\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\left(G_{s}+G_{F}\\right)V_{in}-G_{F}V_{out}&=G_{s}V_{s}\\cr\n\\left(g_{m}-G_{F}\\right)V_{in}+\\left(G_{o}+G_{F}\\right)V_{out}&=0}$$\n\n$${\\cal D}=G_{s}\\left(G_{o}+G_{F}\\right)+G_{F}\\left(G_{o}+g_{m}\\right)$$\n\n$$A_{v}={V_{out}\\over V_{s}}=-G_{s}\\left(g_{m}-G_{F}\\right)/{\\cal D}\n\\tag{5}$$\n\nPut noise current sources in parallel with $R_{F}$ and in\nparallel with $r_{o}$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\overline{I_{nF}^{2}}&=4kTG_{F}\\cr\n\\overline{I_{nD}^{2}}&=4kT\\gamma g_{m}\\cr\n&\\gamma \\approx {2\\over 3}-2-3\\;{\\rm in\\;short\\;ch.}\\cr\n\\overline{V_{nRs}^{2}}&=4kTR_{s}}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\left(G_{s}+G_{F}\\right)V_{in}-G_{F}V_{out}&=-I_{nF}\\cr\n\\left(g_{m}-G_{F}\\right)V_{in}+\\left(G_{o}+G_{F}\\right)V_{out}&=\n+I_{nF}} \\tag{6a}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\left(G_{s}+G_{F}\\right)V_{in}-G_{F}V_{out}&=0\\cr\n\\left(g_{m}-G_{F}\\right)V_{in}+\\left(G_{o}+G_{F}\\right)V_{out}&=\n-I_{nD}} \\tag{6b}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{|V_{out}|^{2}_{F}&=|I_{nF}|^{2}\\left(G_{s}+g_{m}\\right)^{2}/{\\cal D}^{2}\\cr\n|V_{out}|^{2}_{D}&=|I_{nD}|^{2}\\left(G_{s}+G_{F}\\right)^{2}/{\\cal D}^{2}\\cr\n|V_{out}|^{2}_{Rs}&=|V_{nRs}|^{2}G_{s}^{2}\\left(g_{m}-G_{F}\\right)^{2}\n/{\\cal D}^{2}}$$\n\ni. e. with $F$ the conventional $SNR_{in}/SNR_{out}$\n\n$$F=1+{ |V_{out}|^{2}_{F}+|V_{out}|^{2}_{D}\\over\n|V_{out}|^{2}_{Rs}} \\tag{7}$$\n\n$$F=1+{G_{F}\\left(G_{s}+g_{m}\\right)^{2}\\over\nG_{s}\\left(g_{m}-G_{F}\\right)^{2}}+\n\\gamma g_{m}{\\left(G_{s}+G_{F}\\right)^{2}\\over\nG_{s}\\left(g_{m}-G_{F}\\right)^{2}} \\tag{8}$$\n\nFor $g_{m}\\gg G_{F}$\n\n$$F\\approx 1+{G_{F}\\over G_{s}}\\left(1+{G_{s}\\over g_{m}}\\right)^{2}\n+\\gamma {1\\over g_{m}G_{s}^{-1}}\\left(1+{G_{F}\\over G_{s}}\\right)^{2}\n\\tag{8a}$$\n\n$$F\\approx 1+{R_{s}\\over R_{F}}\\left(1+{1\\over g_{m}R_{s}}\\right)^{2}+\n{\\gamma\\over g_{m}R_{s}}\\left(1+{R_{s}\\over R_{F}}\\right)^{2}\n\\approx 1+{\\gamma\\over g_{m}R_{s}}+{R_{s}\\over R_{F}}\\tag{8b}$$\n\nup to factors $2-4$ depending on the exact definition of\nmatching. In the literature you will find often quoted in the\nvery high gain limit $g_{m}R_{s}\\gg 1$\n\n$$F\\approx 1+{4R_{s}\\over R_{F}}+{\\gamma\\over g_{m}R_{s}}\\tag{9}$$\n\nand, with the matching constraint enforced, e. g. $G_{o}\\to 0$,\n$R_{in}=1/g_{m}=R_{s}$:\n\n$$F_{|matched, r_{o}\\to \\infty}=\n1+{G_{F}\\over G_{s}}\\left(1+1\\right)^{2}+\n\\gamma \\left(1+{G_{F}\\over G_{s}}\\right)^{2}\n\\approx 1+\\gamma +4{R_{s}\\over R_{F}}\\tag{10}$$\n\n* the $R_{s}/R_{F}$ term is the $4kTR_{F}$ noise divided\nby the loop gain. It is made small by making $R_{F}$ large.\n\n* the $\\gamma /g_{m}R_{s}$ term is the channel noise of the\ninverter referred to the source. For the usual inverter\n$\\gamma g_{m}= \\gamma_{n}g_{m1}+\\gamma_{p}g_{m2}$.\nIt is made small by making $g_{m}=g_{m1}+g_{m2}$ large.\n\nUnder the constraint (4) $R_{F}$ and $g_{m}$ are not\nindependent. Imposing $R_{in}=R_{s}$ :\n\n$${\\cal D}_{|match}=2G_{s}\\left(G_{o}+G_{F}\\right)=\n2G_{F}\\left(G_{o}+g_{m}\\right) \\tag{11}$$\n\n$$G_{F}=G_{s}{G_{o}\\over G_{o}+g_{m}-G_{s}}=\n{R_{s}^{-1}r_{o}^{-1}\\over r_{o}^{-1}+g_{m}-R_{s}^{-1}}\\tag{12}$$\n\nPut it in (8):\n\n$$F_{|match}=1+{x(1+y)^{2}+\\gamma y(1+x)^{2}\\over (y-x)^{2}}\\tag{13}$$\n\n$$x={G_{F}\\over G_{s}}={R_{s}\\over R_{F}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\ny={g_{m}\\over G_{s}}=g_{m}R_{s}\\;\\;,\\;\\;z={G_{o}\\over G_{s}}=\n{R_{s}\\over r_{o}}$$\n\nwith $z+x=x(z+y)$ from the match. For $z\\to 0$,\n$y\\to 1$. I.E. to first order fixing the match\nfixes $g_{m}$. Then (13) $\\to 1+\\gamma$ for\n$x\\to 0$, $R_{F}\\to \\infty$.\n\nFor $z\\ne 0$ you can let $x\\to 0$ and\n\n$$y\\approx 1+z/x\\gg 1\\tag{14}$$\n\n$$F_{|match}\\approx 1+ x +{\\gamma\\over y}\\to 1\\tag{15}$$\n\nI.E. in principle $F\\to 1$, $NF\\to 0\\,{\\rm dB}$ for\n$y=g_{m}R_{s}\\to \\infty$, $R_{F}\\to \\infty$ with (4b)\nsatisfied.\n\nPhysically: increase the open loop gain $|A_{v0}|=\ng_{m}r_{o}\\parallel R_{F}$ . Then for the same\n$R_{in}=R_{F}/(1+|A_{v0}|)=R_{s}$ you can afford a\nlarger $R_{F}$ - less $R_{F}$ noise - and a larger\n$g_{m}$ - less $g_{m}$ noise referred to input.\n\nSo the recipe for the topology as drawn - a self\nbiased shunt-shunt current reuse inverter - is:\n\n* current reuse is already optimum: $g_{m}=g_{m1}+g_{m2}$\nfor the same $I_{D}$. So for a given power you get\n$\\times 2$ $g_{m}$. Size $M_{1},M_{2}$ so that\n$g_{m1}\\approx g_{m2}$. I. e. $W_{p}\\approx 2-3\\,W_{n}$\nfor equal $g_{m}$.\n\n* make $g_{m}R_{s}$ as large as power allows and make\n$R_{F}$ as large as (4b) allows. In practice for\n$r_{o}=\\infty$, $R_{F}$ is free to first order and\n$$NF_{min}\\approx 10\\log\\left[1+{\\gamma\\over g_{m}R_{s}}\\right]\n\\approx 10\\log\\,(1+\\gamma)\\approx 2-3.5\\,{\\rm dB}\n\\tag{16}$$\nfor $g_{m}R_{s}=1$, $\\gamma =0.7-1.5$.\n\nWith finite $r_{o}$\n\n$$R_{F}=R_{s}+r_{o}\\left(g_{m}R_{s}-1\\right) \\tag{17}$$\n\nso every increase of $g_{m}$ must be accompanied by an\nincrease of $R_{F}$ to keep $R_{in}=50\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$.\n\nTypical $0.18\\mu$, $1.8\\,{\\rm V}$, $2-5\\,{\\rm mA}$:\n$g_{m}\\approx 20-40\\,{\\rm mS}$, $r_{o}\\approx 0.5-2\\,{\\rm k\\Omega}$,\n$|A_{v0}|\\approx 10-20$, $R_{F}\\approx 200-800\\,{\\rm \\Omega}$,\n$|A_{v}|\\approx R_{F}/R_{s}\\approx 4-16$, $NF\\approx 2.5-4\\,{\\rm dB}$.\nDoubling $g_{m}$ to $40\\,{\\rm mS}$ and putting\n$R_{F}\\approx 500-1k$ brings (8) down by $\\approx 1\\,{\\rm dB}$\nat the price of $\\approx \\times 2$ power and\n$\\propto W_{g}C_{gs}$ input capacitance.\n\nThe limits are:\n\n* power $P=V_{DD}I_{D}$, $g_{m}\\propto I_{D}/V_{ov}$,\n$g_{m}/I_{D}$ max. $\\approx 15-20\\,{\\rm S/A}$ in\nmoderate inversion.\n\n* $r_{o}\\propto 1/\\lambda I_{D}\\propto L/I_{D}$, cascode\nto boost $r_{o}$ and allow larger $R_{F}$ for the same\n$g_{m}$ without extra power.\n\n* bandwidth / stability. Input pole\n$\\omega_{in}\\approx \\left(1+g_{m}r_{o}\\right)/R_{F}C_{in}$,\n$C_{in}=C_{gs1}+C_{gs2}+C_{gd}(1+g_{m}R_{F})+C_{pad}$,\noutput pole $\\omega_{out}\\approx 1/r_{o}C_{out}$.\nLarge $R_{F},g_{m},W_{g}$ quickly make the two pole\nsystem unstable. Add $C_{F}$ compensation or series\npeaking $L_{g}$.\n\n* headroom: the self biased inverter $V_{in,DC}=V_{out,DC}$\n$\\approx V_{DD}/2$ for $ \\beta_{n}\\approx \\beta_{p}$,\nset by $R_{F}$. Large $R_{F}$ makes bias very\nsensitive.\n\nIf $2-3\\,{\\rm dB}$ is not enough, the shunt $R_{F}$\ntopology cannot be noise and power matched simultaneously\nwith a noiseless match. You have to resort to\ntransformer, inductive degeneration, capacitive\nnoiseless feedback or, most common today, noise\ncancelling: sense the $R_{F}$ and $M_{1,2}$ noise at\nthe input node with an auxiliary $g_{mA}$ stage and\nsubtract it at the output. In ideal cancellation the\n$R_{s}/R_{F}$ and a large part of $\\gamma/g_{m}R_{s}$\nterms are cancelled, $R_{in}$ remaining $\\approx 1/g_{m}$\nwhile $NF\\to 1+\\gamma_{A}/g_{mA}R_{s}$, $<2\\,{\\rm dB}$\nis routinely achieved.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "58a557cc24ebb135e89e0a07e226e6eebb75463bc01cb8ee7a41d04688a41098"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "The answer uses the finite-output-resistance input-match relation, shows that gm can exceed 1/Rs when RF is increased to preserve Rin = 50 Ω, and explains that this can reduce NF below 1 + γ. This matches the golden solution’s full-credit rule.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "6801650fd2054e7d374317849fcda2881c563a35f3d14b44d310d3d32f91b1cd",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2659,
        "input_tokens": 2673,
        "output_tokens": 16432,
        "total_tokens": 19105,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12950,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 2659,
        "input_tokens": 2673,
        "output_tokens": 16432,
        "total_tokens": 19105,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12950,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-017-compute-input-impedance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Compute the input impedance of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-017-compute-input-impedance/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the conventional notations put\n$r_{o1}=g_{ds1}^{-1},r_{o2}=g_{ds2}^{-1},r_{o3}=g_{ds3}^{-1}$\n$R_{SS}=r_{s{\\rm s}}$, $R_{D1}^{\\prime }=R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1}$,\n$R_{D2}^{\\prime }=R_{D2}\\parallel r_{o3}$ and for the\nsake of writing $g_{m2}=g_{m3}=g_{m}^{{\\prime }}$,\n$g_{m}^{{\\prime }}=g_{m}+g_{mb}$ if the bulk effect is\nkept, the feedback is voltage shunt.\n\nPut $V_{DD}=0$ for the signal.\nFor $r_{ss}\\to \\infty $ and with $R_{F}$ removed\n\n$${\\rm M}_{1}:\\qquad i_{d1}=g_{m1}v_{gs1}+g_{ds1}v_{X}\n\\tag{1}$$\n$$v_{X}=-i_{d1}R_{D1}=-g_{m1}v_{P}R_{D1}^{\\prime }\n\\qquad R_{D1}^{\\prime }={1\\over {1\\over R_{D1}}+g_{ds1}}\\tag{2}$$\n\n${\\rm M}_{2}-{\\rm M}_{3}$ is a $p$ diff. pair, ${\\rm S}$ the\ncommon source.  For the $p$ device\n\n$$i_{d}=g_{m}v_{sg}+g_{ds}v_{sd}\\;\\;,\n\\qquad v_{sg}=v_{S}-v_{G}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ni_{d2}&=g_{m2}(v_{S}-v_{X})+g_{ds2}v_{S}\\cr\ni_{d3}&=g_{m3}v_{S}+g_{ds3}(v_{S}-v_{o})\\tag{4}}$$\n\n$${v_{S}\\over R_{SS}}+i_{d2}+i_{d3}=0\\tag{5}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$\\left[{1\\over R_{SS}}+g_{m2}+g_{m3}+g_{ds2}+g_{ds3}\\right]v_{S}\n-g_{m2}v_{X}-g_{ds3}v_{o}=0 \\tag{6}$$\n\n$$v_{S}={{g_{m2}v_{X}+g_{ds3}v_{o}}\\over {G_{S}}}\\tag{7}$$\n\n$$G_{S}={1\\over R_{SS}}+g_{m2}+g_{m3}+g_{ds2}+g_{ds3}\n\\qquad A={g_{m3}+g_{ds3}\\over G_{S}}\\tag{8}$$\n\nAt the output\n\n$$i_{d3}={v_{o}\\over R_{D2}}+{v_{o}-v_{P}\\over R_{F}}\\tag{9}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$(g_{m3}+g_{ds3})v_{S}-g_{ds3}v_{o}\n-{v_{o}\\over R_{D2}}-{v_{o}-v_{P}\\over R_{F}}=0\\tag{10}$$\n\nWith (2)(7)\n\n$$A\\left[g_{m2}v_{X}+g_{ds3}v_{o}\\right]-g_{ds3}v_{o}\n-{v_{o}\\over R_{D2}}-{v_{o}-v_{P}\\over R_{F}}=0\\tag{11}$$\n\n$$v_{o}\\left[{1\\over R_{D2}}+{1\\over R_{F}}+g_{ds3}(1-A)\\right]\n+A\\,g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime }v_{P}-{v_{P}\\over R_{F}}=0\\tag{12}$$\n\ni. e. with the sign $v_{o}=-K\\,v_{P}$, $K>0,$\n\n$$K={{A\\,g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime }-{1/R_{F}}\\over\n{1\\over R_{D2}}+{1\\over R_{F}}+g_{ds3}(1-A)}}>0\\tag{13}$$\n\nIn the usual $g_{ds}R_{D}\\ll 1$, $R_{SS}\\to \\infty $\n\n$$A\\approx {g_{m3}\\over g_{m2}+g_{m3}}\\;,\\qquad \nG_{S}\\approx g_{m2}+g_{m3}\\tag{14}$$\n\nand, with $g_{ds}\\to 0$,\n\n$$\\;v_{o}\\approx -v_{P}\\,\n{A\\,g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}\\over {1\\over R_{D2}}+{1\\over R_{F}}}\\; \\tag{15}$$\n\nFor the matched pair $g_{m2}=g_{m3}=g_{m}$,\n\n$$A={1\\over 2}\\;,\\qquad \nv_{o}\\approx -v_{P}\\,\n{g_{m1}R_{D1}\\,g_{m}\\over 2\\left({1\\over R_{D2}}+{1\\over R_{F}}\\right)}\n=-v_{P}g_{m1}R_{D1}{g_{m}\\over 2}R_{D2}\\!\\parallel\\!R_{F}\\tag{15a}$$\n\nWith $R_{F}\\gg R_{D2}$\n\n$$A_{v0}={v_{o}\\over v_{P}}\\approx -{1\\over 2}g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}R_{D2}\n\\qquad {\\rm without\\; }R_{F}{\\rm \\;loading}\\tag{16}$$\n\nIf the $1/R_{F}$ and $R_{D2}\\parallel R_{F}$ loading is kept it is\nnormal to write\n\n$$A_{vL}= -g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime }\\,{g_{m2}g_{m3}\\over g_{m2}+g_{m3}}\n\\left(R_{D2}^{\\prime }\\parallel R_{F}\\right) \\tag{16a}$$\n\nand $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$ if the body effect is included.\nFor a conventional resistive loaded $n$ pair with a current\nmirror load the $1/2$ is absent, $A_{v0}=-g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m2}R_{D2}$.\n\n$R_{F}$ is the ${\\cal R}$ feedback network.  For the shunt\nmixing put $I_{in}$ at the $P$ node,\n\n$$I_{in}=v_{P}\\left({1\\over R_{in}}+sC_{in}\\right)\n+{v_{P}-v_{o}\\over R_{F}}+i_{g1}\\tag{17}$$\n\n$i_{g1}\\approx 0$, $i_{g1}=sC_{gs1}v_{P}+sC_{gd1}(v_{P}-v_{X})$\nif the MOS caps. are kept.  Neglecting $i_{g1}$,\n\n$$I_{in}=v_{P}\\left({1\\over R_{in}}+sC_{in}+{1\\over R_{F}}\\right)\n-{v_{o}\\over R_{F}}\\tag{18}$$\n\nWith $v_{o}=-K\\,v_{P}$\n\n$$I_{in}=v_{P}\\left[{1\\over R_{in}}+sC_{in}+{1+K\\over R_{F}}\\right]\n\\tag{19}$$\n\nso that the impedance seen by the source $I_{in}$\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)={v_{P}\\over I_{in}}=\n{1\\over {1\\over R_{in}}+sC_{in}+{1+K(s)\\over R_{F}}}\\tag{20}$$\n\nin parallel of $R_{in}$, $C_{in}$ and the impedance seen\nlooking into the gate itself,\n\n$$Z_{P}(s)={R_{F}\\over 1+K(s)}\\tag{21}$$\n\ni. e. the familiar $R_{F}/(1-A_{v})$ shunt--shunt result.\nExplicitly, from (13),\n\n$${1\\over Z_{P}}={1\\over R_{F}}+\n{A\\,g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}^{\\prime }\\over\nR_{F}\\left[{1\\over R_{D2}}+{1\\over R_{F}}+g_{ds3}(1-A)\\right]}\\tag{22}$$\n\nand with (14)(15)\n\n$$Z_{P}\\approx {R_{F}\\over 1+\n\\displaystyle {A\\,g_{m1}g_{m2}R_{D1}\\over {1\\over R_{D2}}+{1\\over R_{F}}}}\n\\approx {R_{F}\\over 1+|A_{vL}|}\\tag{23}$$\n\nFor the matched $g_{m}$ pair and $g_{ds}\\to 0$, $R_{SS}\\to\n\\infty $,\n\n$$Z_{P}(0)\\approx\n{R_{F}\\over 1+g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}R_{D2}\\!\\parallel\\!R_{F}/2}\\tag{24}$$\n\nso that, to first order,\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)\\approx\nR_{in}\\parallel {1\\over sC_{in}}\\parallel\n{R_{F}\\over 1+g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}R_{D2}\\!\\parallel\\!R_{F}/2}\n\\tag{25}$$\n\nAt low frequency $s\\to 0$ and with the $R_{F}$ loading\nnormally $R_{F}\\gg R_{D2}$,\n\n$$Z_{in}(0)\\approx R_{in}\\parallel\n{R_{F}\\over 1+{1\\over 2}g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}R_{D2}}\\approx\nR_{in}\\parallel {2R_{F}\\over g_{m1}g_{m}R_{D1}R_{D2}}\\tag{26}$$\n\nfor $g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}R_{D2}\\gg 1$.  Without the $1/2$, e. g.\nwith a current mirror load,\n\n$$R_{P}\\approx {R_{F}\\over g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m2}R_{D2}}\\tag{27}$$\n\nis often quoted.\n\nIn particular the amplifier becomes a transresistance\n\n$${v_{o}\\over I_{in}}=-{K\\over {1\\over R_{in}}+sC_{in}+{1+K\\over R_{F}}}\n\\approx -R_{F}{K\\over 1+K}\\xrightarrow[K\\gg 1]{}-R_{F}\\tag{28}$$\n\nand the conventional input pole is at\n\n$$p_{in}\\approx {1+K\\over R_{F}C_{in}}\\approx\n{|A_{v0}|\\over R_{F}C_{in}}={g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}R_{D2}\\over 2R_{F}C_{in}}\\tag{29}$$\n\nAny $C_{gs1},C_{gd1},C_{gs2}$ etc. add in parallel and are\nMiller multiplied by $1+|A_{v}|$, e. g. $C_{in,{\\rm eff}}\\approx\nC_{in}+C_{gs1}+C_{gd1}(1+g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime })+\\cdots $.\nPutting $R_{D1}\\to R_{D1}\\!\\parallel\\!r_{o1}$,\n$R_{D2}\\to R_{D2}\\!\\parallel\\!r_{o3}$ and\n$g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$ gives the result with finite\n$r_{o}$ and bulk effect.  With finite $R_{SS}$ replace\n$A=g_{m3}/(g_{m2}+g_{m3})$ by (8).  In Blackman form\n$Z_{in}=R_{F}(1+T_{sc})/(1+T_{oc})$ with return ratio\n$T_{0}\\approx g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime }(g_{m}R_{D2}^{\\prime }\\parallel\nR_{F})/2$.\n\nIn round numbers $Z_{P}\\ll R_{in}$ so that\n$|Z_{in}|_{LF}\\approx R_{P}\\sim {\\rm a\\;few}\\;10\\,{\\rm \\Omega}\n-{\\rm k\\Omega}$, capacitive $\\approx 1/sC_{in}$ beyond\n$p_{in}$.\n\n> *Remark:*  Many texts drop the $1/2$ and write\n> $|A_{v0}|=g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m2}R_{D2}$; the $1/2$ is the\n> single ended loss of the resistive loaded diff. pair.\n> With an $n$ mirror load $A\\to 1$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "6f3491cdd92d757dc8ecf9b7fa06db3c63aebcee9f12f503de938454e32b8f93"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It correctly identifies shunt feedback and gives the right high-gain, low-frequency approximation; its equations for K and ZP can also be combined to recover the exact result. However, it never states that result correctly, and the explicit simplification in Eq. 22 drops the output-side RD2 contribution and is inconsistent with the preceding equations.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d478f09ce99c16f2ada89711c88d0564aa20ae775a06fad0c89d6658dc32fb99",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 219,
        "output_tokens": 15673,
        "total_tokens": 15892,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12543,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 219,
        "output_tokens": 15673,
        "total_tokens": 15892,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12543,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-017-compute-input-impedance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Compute the input impedance of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-017-compute-input-impedance/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With $R_{D1}\\rightarrow R_{D1}^{\\prime }=R_{D1}\\Vert \nr_{o1}$,\n$R_{D2}\\rightarrow R_{2}^{\\prime }=R_{D2}\\Vert r_{o3}\\Vert r_{ISS}$\nand, for simplicity ${\\rm  PMOS}\\;M_{2}\\equiv M_{3}$,\n\n$$g_{m2}=g_{m3}=g_{m}\\qquad r_{o2}=r_{o3}=r_{o}\\tag*{}$$\n${\\rm NMOS}\\;g_{m1}$ the feedback is\n\n$${\\rm sample}\\;V_{o}\\qquad {\\rm mix}\\;I_{p}\\tag*{}$$\n\nshunt at the input, shunt at the output.\n${\\cal R}_{M}=V_{o}/I_{p}$ transresistance.\nPut ${\\bf V}_{DD}=0$ for $a.c.$ and $V_{b}=0$.\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nP:&I_{in}=V_{p}Y_{in}+{{V_{p}-V_{o}}\\over {R_{F}}} \\cr\n   &Y_{in}={1\\over {R_{in}}}+sC_{in}+sC_{gs1}+sC_{gd1}(1-A_{1})+\\cdots \\cr\nX:&{{V_{x}}\\over {R_{D1}^{\\prime }}}+g_{m1}V_{p}+g_{o1}V_{x}=0 \\cr\nS:&g_{m2}(V_{s}-V_{x})+g_{o2}V_{s}+g_{m3}V_{s}+g_{o3}(V_{s}-V_{o})=0\\cr\nO:&g_{m3}V_{s}+g_{o3}(V_{s}-V_{o})={{V_{o}}\\over {R_{D2}}}+{{V_{o}-V_{p}}\n\\over {R_{F}}} \\tag{1}}$$\n\n$g_{o}=1/r_{o}$.  For $g_{o}R_{D}\\ll 1$, $g_{o}R_{F}\\ll 1$,\n$g_{m}r_{o}\\gg 1$ and an ideal $I_{SS}\\to \\infty $,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{x}&=-g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\prime }V_{p}\n{{1}\\over {1+sR_{D1}^{\\prime }C_{x}}}\\cr\nV_{s}&={{g_{m2}V_{x}+g_{o3}V_{o}}\\over {g_{m2}+g_{m3}}}\\approx\n{{V_{x}}\\over 2}\\qquad g_{m2}=g_{m3}\\cr\ng_{m}V_{s}&=V_{o}\\left({1\\over {R_{2}^{\\prime }}}+{1\\over {R_{F}}}\\right)\n-{{V_{p}}\\over {R_{F}}}} \\tag{2}}$$\n\ni. e. with $Z_{Di}(s)=R_{Di}^{\\prime }/(1+sR_{Di}^{\\prime }C_{i})$\n\n$$A_{v}(s)={{V_{o}}\\over {V_{p}}}{\\Bigl |}_{R_{F}\\to \\infty }=\n-g_{m1}Z_{D1}(s){{g_{m3}Z_{D2}(s)}\\over {g_{m2}+g_{m3}}}\n\\left[ 1+{\\cal O}(g_{o}R)\\right] \\tag{3}$$\n\nand, with the conventional $r_{o}\\to \\infty $,\n\n$$\\;A_{v}(s)\\approx -g_{m1}R_{D1}{{g_{m}R_{D2}}\\over 2}\n{1\\over {(1+s/\\omega _{x})(1+s/\\omega _{o})}}\\; \\tag{4}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{x}^{-1}=R_{D1}C_{x}\\;,\\qquad \n\\omega _{o}^{-1}=R_{D2}C_{o}\\;, \\qquad \nA_{0}=|A_{v}(0)|={{g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}R_{D2}}\\over 2}\\tag{5}$$\n\nincluding the $R_{F}$ loading on (2)\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ng_{m}V_{s}&=-{{g_{m}g_{m1}R_{D1}}\\over 2}V_{p}\n      =V_{o}\\left({1\\over {R_{2}^{\\prime }}}+{1\\over {R_{F}}}\\right)\n        -{{V_{p}}\\over {R_{F}}}\\cr\nA_{vF}&={{V_{o}}\\over {V_{p}}}\n      ={{-{{g_{m}g_{m1}R_{D1}}\\over 2}+{1\\over {R_{F}}}}\\over \n            {{1}\\over {R_{2}^{\\prime }}}+{1\\over {R_{F}}}}\n      =-A_{0}{{R_{F}}\\over {R_{F}+R_{2}^{\\prime }}}\n        +{{R_{2}^{\\prime }}\\over {R_{F}+R_{2}^{\\prime }}}\\approx \n        -{{g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}(R_{2}^{\\prime }\\Vert R_{F})}\\over 2}\n        \\tag{6}}$$\n\nFor $R_{F}\\gg R_{2}^{\\prime }$, $A_{vF}\\to -A_{0}$.\nIn the general mis--matched case replace $1/2$ by\n$g_{m3}/(g_{m2}+g_{m3})$.\n\nPut (6) in the $P$ equation,\n\n$$I_{in}=V_{p}Y_{in}+{{V_{p}-A_{vF}V_{p}}\\over {R_{F}}}\n       =V_{p}\\left[\\,Y_{in}+{{1-A_{vF}}\\over {R_{F}}}\\,\\right] \\tag{7}$$\n\nso that the impedance that the source $I_{in}$ sees at the\nterminal $P$ is\n\n$$\\;Z_{in}(s)={{V_{p}}\\over {I_{in}}}\n      ={1\\over {Y_{in}(s)+{{1-A_{vF}(s)}\\over {R_{F}}}}}\\;\n      \\approx {1\\over {{1\\over {R_{in}}}+sC_{in}+{{1+|A_{v}(s)|}\n      \\over {R_{F}}}}}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$Y_{in}=1/R_{in}+sC_{in}$ is the ordinary bias-- and\ncapacitance that is in $\\,\\Vert $ with the gate.  The gate\nitself is $Z_{g}\\to \\infty $.  Neglecting $Y_{in}$ the\nimpedance looking into the gate through the feedback is\n\n$$\\;Z_{gF}(s)={{R_{F}}\\over {1-A_{vF}(s)}}\\; \\tag{9}$$\n\nthe normal Miller result $R_{F}/(1+|A_{v}|)$.\nWith (6) for $r_{o}\\to \\infty $ and at $d.c.$\n\n$$Y_{gF}(0)={{1-A_{vF}(0)}\\over {R_{F}}}\n        ={{1+A_{0}}\\over {R_{F}+R_{D2}}}\\tag{10}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$\\;R_{gF0}={1\\over {Y_{gF0}}}={{R_{F}+R_{2}^{\\prime }}\n      \\over {1+A_{0}}}=\n      {{R_{F}+R_{D2}\\Vert r_{o3}}\\over \n      {1+{{g_{m1}(R_{D1}\\Vert r_{o1})g_{m}(R_{D2}\\Vert r_{o3})}\\over 2}}}\\; \\tag{11}$$\n\nFor $g_{o}R\\ll 1$, $r_{o}\\to \\infty $\n\n$$\\;R_{gF0}\\approx {{R_{F}+R_{D2}}\\over {1+g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}R_{D2}/2}}\n      \\xrightarrow[R_{F}\\gg R_{D2}]{}{{R_{F}}\\over {1+A_{0}}}\n      \\approx {{2R_{F}}\\over {g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{m}R_{D2}}}\\; \\tag{12}$$\n\nIn general $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$ for the $p$ devices if the\n$n$ well is returned to $V_{DD}$.\n\nThe total $d.c.$ resistance seen by $I_{in}$ is $R_{gF0}$ in\nparallel with the explicit bias resistor,\n\n$$\\;R_{in}^{c}=R_{in}\\Vert R_{gF0}\\approx R_{gF0}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\;\n      A_{0}\\gg 1\\tag{13}$$\n\nnormally a few $10\\,{\\rm \\Omega }$ to a few $10^{2}{\\rm\\Omega }$,\nthe conventional virtual earth of the transimpedance\namplifier.  For $A_{0}\\to \\infty $, $R_{in}^{c}\\to 0$.\n\nIncluding $C_{in}$,\n\n$$\\;Z_{in}^{c}(s)\\approx {1\\over\n      {{1\\over {R_{in}}}+sC_{in}+{{1+A_{0}/(1+s/\\omega _{x})\n      (1+s/\\omega _{o})}\\over {R_{F}+R_{D2}}}}\\; \\tag{14}$$\n\nwhich for $|A_{v}|\\gg 1$ is\n\n$$Z_{in}^{c}(s)\\approx {{R_{F}+R_{D2}}\\over {A_{0}}}\n      (1+s/\\omega _{x})(1+s/\\omega _{o})\n      \\Vert R_{in}\\Vert {1\\over {sC_{in}}}\\tag{15}$$\n\ninductive with an apparent inductance $\\approx\n(R_{F}+R_{D2})C_{o}/A_{0}$, etc. The dominant input pole\n$1/R_{in}C_{in}$ is pushed out to\n\n$$\\omega _{in}^{c}\\approx {{1+A_{0}}\\over {(R_{F}+R_{D2})C_{in}}}\n      \\approx {{1}\\over {R_{gF0}C_{in}}}\\gg \\omega _{in}^{o} \\tag{16}$$\n\nso that the $d.c.$ transresistance is\n\n$$R_{M}^{c}={{V_{o}}\\over {I_{in}}}\\approx -R_{F}{{A_{0}}\\over {1+A_{0}}}\n      \\approx -R_{F}\\qquad A_{0}\\gg 1 \\tag{17}$$\n\nthe usual shunt--shunt feedback result\n$Z_{in}^{c}=Z_{in}^{o}/(1+\\beta A)$,\n$\\beta \\approx -1/R_{F}$, $A\\approx {\\cal R}_{M}^{o}\\approx\n-A_{0}R_{F}/(1+A_{0})$ and loop gain\n$T_{0}= -\\beta A\\approx A_{0}R_{F}/(R_{F}+R_{D2})$.\nAny explicit Miller multiplication of $C_{gd1}$,\n$C_{in,{\\rm eff}}=C_{in}+C_{gs1}+C_{gd1}(1+g_{m1}R_{D1})+\\cdots $,\nis to be added to $C_{in}$ in $Y_{in}$.\n\n> *Remark:* With $g_{mb}\\ne 0$ put $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$,\n> with $r_{o}$ finite put $R_{Di}\\to R_{Di}\\Vert r_{oi}$ in\n> $A_{0}$.  Up to the $g_{o}R$ corrections Eq.\\,8--11 is the\n> exact low frequency small signal result from Eq.\\,1.  To first\n> order $Z_{gF}\\approx R_{F}/|A_{v}|$ is a low resistance to\n> ground at $P$ which in parallel with $R_{in},C_{in}$ forms the\n> closed loop input impedance of the TIA.  The sign in (9) is\n> $1-A_{v}=1+|A_{v}|$ for the inverting amplifier.\n\nFor example $g_{m1}R_{D1}=5$, $g_{m}R_{D2}=5$,\n$A_{0}=12.5$, $R_{F}=10\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$, $R_{D2}=5\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$,\n$R_{gF0}=(15\\,{\\rm k\\Omega })/13.5\\approx 1.1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$,\n$\\approx R_{F}/A_{0}=0.8\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$ for $R_{F}\\gg R_{D2}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "4e156a138ddafba4e3e549ee26233022ba6479c86d8647898a29ab170f2f67df"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Gives the exact low-frequency Miller result, including the output-side resistance: RgF0 = (RF + RD2)/(1 + A0), with the correct two-stage unloaded gain A0. The added finite-ro and capacitance discussion does not alter the essential result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d478f09ce99c16f2ada89711c88d0564aa20ae775a06fad0c89d6658dc32fb99",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 99,
        "input_tokens": 219,
        "output_tokens": 15287,
        "total_tokens": 15506,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12225,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 99,
        "input_tokens": 219,
        "output_tokens": 15287,
        "total_tokens": 15506,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12225,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-017-compute-input-impedance",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 17,
      "question": "Compute the input impedance of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-017-compute-input-impedance/figure-14.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the conventional notation let the input probe be\n${\\cal E}$ at $P$, ${\\cal E}=V_{p}$, ${\\cal I}=I_{p}$ ${\\cal E}/{\\cal\nI}=Z_{p}$ and put $V_{b}=0$ for the signal.  Put for the\nsignal $V_{DD}=0$.  Neglect $C_{gs}$, $C_{gd}$ for the\nlow frequency calculation and put\n\n$$g_{1}=g_{m1}+g_{mb1}\\qquad g_{2}=g_{m2}\\qquad g_{3}=g_{m3}\\qquad \nG_{D1}=R_{D1}^{-1}+g_{o1}\\;\\;,\\;\\;G_{D2}=R_{D2}^{-1}+g_{o3} \\;\\;, \\;\\;\nG_{F}=R_{F}^{-1}\\;\\;,\\;\\;G_{in}=R_{in}^{-1}\\;\\;, \\;\\;\nY_{in}=G_{in}+sC_{in}$$\n\nthe conventional small signal circuit is Fig.1.  For a\n$p$ channel ${\\cal M}_{2}-{\\cal M}_{3}$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nI_{2}&=g_{2}(V_{s}-V_{x})+g_{o2}V_{s}\\cr\nI_{3}&=g_{3}V_{s}+g_{o3}(V_{s}-V_{o})\\cr}\n\\tag{1}$$\n\n$I_{SS}=0$ for the signal so that, for $g_{o2,3}\\ll g_{2,3}$,\n\n$$(g_{2}+g_{o2}+g_{3}+g_{o3})V_{s}-g_{2}V_{x}-g_{o3}V_{o}=0 \\tag{2}$$\n\n$$V_{s}={{g_{2}V_{x}+g_{o3}V_{o}}\\over {g_{2}+g_{3}}}+O(g_{o}/g)\n\\approx {{g_{2}}\\over {g_{2}+g_{3}}}V_{x}\\tag{2a}$$\n\nand for the matched pair $g_{2}=g_{3}=g_{p}$\n\n$$V_{s}\\approx {\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}V_{x}\\tag{2b}$$\n\nAt the high impedance node $X$,\n\n$$(G_{D1}V_{x}+g_{1}V_{p}=0\\tag{3}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$V_{x}=-{{g_{1}}\\over {G_{D1}}}V_{p}=-g_{1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }V_{p}\\tag{3a}$$\n\n$$R_{D1}^{\\ast }=R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1}\\approx R_{D1}\\tag{3b}$$\n\nfor $g_{o1}R_{D1}\\ll 1$.  At the output node, Fig.1,\n\n$$G_{D2}V_{o}+G_{F}(V_{o}-V_{p})-I_{3}=0\\tag{4}$$\n\nwith (1),\n\n$$(G_{D2}+G_{F}+g_{o3})V_{o}-G_{F}V_{p}-(g_{3}+g_{o3})V_{s}=0\\tag{4a}$$\n\nWith (2) and (3a)\n\n$$V_{o}{{D}}\\approx V_{p}\\left[G_{F}-\n{{g_{1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }g_{2}(g_{3}+g_{o3})}\\over {g_{2}+g_{3}}}\\right]\n\\tag{5}$$\n\n$$D=G_{D2}+G_{F}+g_{o3}-{{g_{o3}(g_{3}+g_{o3})}\\over {g_{2}+g_{3}}}\n      =G_{D2}+G_{F}+O(g_{o}) \\tag{5a}$$\n\nso that, to $O(g_{o}/g)$,\n\n$$A_{v}^{\\ast }\\equiv {{V_{o}}\\over {V_{p}}}\\Bigl|_{G_{F}=0}\n      =-{{g_{1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }g_{2}g_{3}}\\over {g_{2}+g_{3}}}\n        {{1}\\over {G_{D2}}}=-g_{1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }{{g_{2}}\\over {g_{2}+g_{3}}}\n          g_{3}R_{D2}^{\\ast } \\tag{6}$$\n\n$$R_{D2}^{\\ast }=R_{D2}\\parallel r_{o3}\\parallel r_{o2}\\approx R_{D2}$$\n\nand with the $G_{F}$ loading the usual loaded voltage gain of\nthe forward amplifier is\n\n$$A_{vL}= -g_{1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }{{g_{2}}\\over {g_{2}+g_{3}}}g_{3}\n        \\left(R_{D2}^{\\ast }\\parallel R_{F}\\right) \\tag{6a}$$\n\nFor the matched $p$ pair\n\n$$A_{vL}\\approx -{\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }g_{p}\n        \\left(R_{D2}^{\\ast }\\parallel R_{F}\\right)\\tag{6b}$$\n\nand for $R_{F}\\gg R_{D2}^{\\ast }$\n\n$$A_{v0}\\approx -{\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{p}R_{D2}\\tag{6c}$$\n\napart from the sign.  ${\\cal M}_{2}$ is a source follower,\n${\\cal M}_{3}$ a common gate device, the differential pair is a\nfollower $+$ CG stage with the well known $g_{m}R_{D}/2$ gain.\nIf the $R_{D2}$ gain is counted as part of the buffer it is\nconventional to write\n\n$$A_{v0}^{\\prime }\\approx -g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }\\tag{6d}$$\n\nfor the core $CS$ stage.\n\nAt the input node\n\n$${\\cal I}=Y_{in}V_{p}+G_{F}(V_{p}-V_{o})\\tag{7}$$\n\nso that with (5)\n\n$${{{\\cal I}}\\over {V_{p}}}=Y_{in}+G_{F}-G_{F}{{V_{o}}\\over {V_{p}}}\n =Y_{in}+G_{F}{{D-G_{F}+g_{1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }g_{2}(g_{3}+g_{o3})/(g_{2}+g_{3})}\n        \\over {D}} \\tag{8}$$\n\ni. e. $O(g_{o}/g)$,\n\n$${{1}\\over {Z_{p}}}\\approx Y_{in}+\n        G_{F}{{G_{D2}+g_{1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }g_{2}g_{3}/(g_{2}+g_{3})}\\over\n                {G_{D2}+G_{F}}}\\tag{9}$$\n\nFor the matched pair and $g_{o}R_{D}\\ll 1$, $r_{o}\\to \\infty $,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n{{1}\\over {Z_{p}}}&\\approx {{1}\\over {R_{in}}}+sC_{in}\n        +{{1}\\over {R_{F}}}{{1+R_{F}/R_{D2}+{\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}\n                g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{p}R_{D2}}\\over {1+R_{F}/R_{D2}}}\\cr\n&\\approx {{1}\\over {R_{in}}}+sC_{in}\n        +{{1}\\over {R_{F}}}\\left[1+|A_{vL}|\\right]{{R_{D2}^{\\ast }\\over\n                {R_{D2}^{\\ast }+R_{F}}}+O(1) \\cr}\\tag{10}$$\n\nIn the conventional $R_{F}\\gg R_{D2}$ large gain approximation\n\n$${{1}\\over {Z_{p}}}\\approx {{1}\\over {R_{in}}}+sC_{in}+\n        {{|A_{v0}|}\\over {R_{F}}}\\tag{10a}$$\n\n$$|A_{v0}|={\\textstyle{1\\over 2}}g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{p}R_{D2}\\tag{10b}$$\n\nso that the impedance seen looking into the gate itself,\n$Z_{p0}=Z_{p}|_{R_{in}\\to \\infty ,C_{in}\\to 0}$, is the\nfamiliar shunt--shunt result\n\n$$Z_{p0}\\approx {{R_{F}}\\over {1+|A_{vL}|}}\n      \\approx {{R_{F}\\parallel R_{D2}}\\over {1+|A_{v0}|}}\\,\n      |A_{v0}|\\gg 1\\tag{11}$$\n\ni. e.\n\n$$Z_{p0}\\approx {{2R_{F}}\\over {g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{p}R_{D2}}}\\,\n      {{R_{F}+R_{D2}}\\over {R_{D2}}}\\approx \n      {{2R_{F}}\\over {g_{m1}R_{D1}g_{p}R_{D2}}}\\qquad \n      R_{F}\\gg R_{D2}\\tag{11a}$$\n\nin parallel with $R_{in}$ and $1/sC_{in}$,\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)={{1}\\over {Y_{in}+1/Z_{p0}(s)}}=\n      {{1}\\over {sC_{in}+1/R_{in}+1/Z_{p0}(s)}}\\tag{12}$$\n\nAt low frequencies $s\\to 0$\n\n$$R_{in,CL}=R_{in}\\parallel Z_{p0}\\approx \n      R_{in}\\parallel {{R_{F}}\\over {1+|A_{vL}|}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nFor the circuit often quoted as a unity gain buffer after the\n$CS$ stage, $g_{p}R_{D2}/2\\to 1$,\n\n$$Z_{p0}\\approx {{R_{F}}\\over {1+g_{m1}R_{D1}^{\\ast }}}\\tag{14}$$\n\n$$R_{in,CL}\\approx R_{in}\\parallel {{R_{F}}\\over {1+g_{m1}R_{D1}}}\n      \\qquad {\\rm ``buffer''\\;approx.}\\tag{14a}$$\n\nIn (11)--(14) $R_{D1}^{\\ast }=R_{D1}\\parallel r_{o1}$,\n$R_{D2}^{\\ast }=R_{D2}\\parallel r_{o3}$ and $g_{m}\\to g_{m}+g_{mb}$\nif body effect is retained.\n\nWith frequency the dominant poles are at $X$ and at the output,\n\n$$A_{vL}(s)\\approx {{A_{vL}(0)}\\over \n        {\\left(1+sR_{D1}^{\\ast }C_{X}\\right)\\left(1+sR_{D2L}^{\\ast }C_{L}\n                \\right)}}\\tag{15}$$\n\n$$R_{D2L}^{\\ast }=R_{D2}^{\\ast }\\parallel R_{F}\\qquad \n  C_{X}=C_{db1}+C_{gs2}+C_{gd1}+C_{gd2}\\qquad \n  C_{L}=C_{db3}+C_{gd3}+C_{L,ext}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$Z_{p0}(s)\\approx {{R_{F}}\\over {1-A_{vL}(s)}}\\approx \n      {{R_{F}}\\over {|A_{vL}(s)|}}\\;\\;|A_{vL}|\\gg 1\\tag{16}$$\n\nand\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)\\approx \\left[sC_{in}+{{1}\\over {R_{in}}}+\n      {{1-A_{vL}(s)}\\over {R_{F}}}\\right]^{-1}\\tag{17}$$\n\nwhich is $\\approx 1/sC_{in}$ for $|s|C_{in}\\gg G_{in}+R_{F}^{-1}\n|A_{vL}(s)|$ and $\\approx R_{in,CL}$ for $s\\to 0$.\nWriting $|A_{vL}(s)|=|A_{v0}|/{\\cal D}(s)$,\n\n$$Z_{in}(s)\\approx {{R_{F}}\\over {|A_{v0}|}}{\\cal D}(s)\n      \\parallel R_{in}\\parallel {{1}\\over {sC_{in}}}\\tag{18}$$\n\nso that beyond the loop unity gain frequency the input looks\ninductive, $|Z_{in}|\\propto |s|$, before $C_{in}$ takes over.\nAny $C_{F}$ in parallel with $R_{F}$ adds a zero at\n$1/R_{F}C_{F}$.\n\nNumerically, e. g. $g_{m1}=1\\,{\\rm mS}$, $R_{D1}=5\\,{\\rm k}$,\n$g_{p}=2\\,{\\rm mS}$, $R_{D2}=5\\,{\\rm k}$, $R_{F}=50\\,{\\rm k}$,\n$|A_{v0}|\\approx 25$, $Z_{p0}\\approx R_{F}/25\\approx 2\\,{\\rm k}$,\n$R_{in,CL}\\approx 2\\,{\\rm k}\\parallel R_{in}$.  With\n$r_{o}$ finite replace $R_{D}$ by $R_{D}\\parallel r_{o}$ and\n$g_{m}$ by $g_{m}+g_{mb}$ for the usual $\\sim 10$--$30\\%$\ncorrection.  The closed loop transimpedance is\n$V_{o}/I_{in}\\approx -R_{F}A_{vL}/(1+A_{vL})\\approx -R_{F}$ for\n$|A_{vL}|\\gg 1$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "84739b8d8f77967c4515373d0fd5ea24437baf0092d4a3cf45344a065061d5c0"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "Equation (9) gives an input admittance equivalent to the exact Miller result, with the output-side resistance included and the correct unloaded gain identifiable. However, the later simplification and loaded-gain formulas are inconsistent with that result, so the final answer is muddled.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "d478f09ce99c16f2ada89711c88d0564aa20ae775a06fad0c89d6658dc32fb99",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 219,
        "output_tokens": 14755,
        "total_tokens": 14974,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11443,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 219,
        "output_tokens": 14755,
        "total_tokens": 14974,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 11443,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "If the LDO regulator in the figure generates thermal noise with spectrum Sth, how do we compute the VCO output phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In general a voltage can only $FM$ an\nautonomous circuit where the common mode to\ndifferential mode rejection is finite:\n\n$${\\cal L}_{LDO}(\\Delta \\omega )\\approx \n{{S_{\\phi}(\\Delta \\omega )}\\over {2}}$$\n\n$${{S_{\\phi}(\\Delta \\omega ) {\\rm rad^{2}/Hz} }\\over \n{S_{Vout}(\\Delta \\omega ){\\rm V^{2}/Hz}}}=\n\\left| H_{\\phi V}(\\Delta \\omega)\\right|^{2}$$\n\nwhere $H_{\\phi V}$ is the {\\it supply pushing}\n{\\it frequency modulation} transfer function.\nFor $S_{Vout}\\approx S_{th}$ white, $H\\propto 1/\\Delta \\omega $\nis an ideal integrator.\n\nFor the topology of the figure:\n\n* $V_{out}$ is the RF common mode $V_{cm}=(V_{X}+V_{Y})/2$\n  through the $R_{p}+j\\omega L_{1}$ impedance.\n  For $\\Delta \\omega \\ll \\omega _{0}=1/\\sqrt{L_{1}C_{t}}$\n\n$$Z_{cm}\\approx j\\Delta \\omega L_{1}\\rightarrow 0$$\n\nso low frequency noise on $V_{out}$ appears\nundivided on $V_{cm}$. For high frequencies\nit is divided by\n\n$$V_{cm}(\\Delta \\omega)=V_{out}(\\Delta \\omega)\n{{Z_{cm}}\\over {Z_{cm}+Z_{LDO}(\\Delta \\omega)}}=\n V_{out}H_{LPF}(\\Delta \\omega)$$\n\n$$H_{LPF}= {1\\over {1+j\\Delta \\omega R_{LDO}C_{dec}}}\n{1\\over {1+j\\Delta \\omega L_{1}/R_{p}}}+...$$\n\nNormally put a $C_{dec}\\sim 10-100{\\rm pF}$ to $>{\\rm nF}$\noff chip on that node so:\n\n$${\\rm PSD}_{Vcm}(\\Delta \\omega)=\nS_{th}(\\Delta \\omega)\\left| H_{LDO}(\\Delta \\omega)\\right|^{2}\n\\left| H_{LPF}(\\Delta \\omega)\\right|^{2}$$\n\n$$S_{th}=S_{BG}G^{2}+S_{EA}+4kTR_{on}+4kT\\gamma g_{m}^{-1}+...\\;{\\rm V^{2}/Hz}$$\n\nusual LDO white $+$ $K_{F}/f$ , $H_{LDO}$ is the\nclosed loop $V_{out}/v_{n}$ transfer function,\n$\\approx 1$ for $\\Delta \\omega <\\omega _{u,LDO}$ and\n$1/\\Delta \\omega $ above.\n\nIt $FM$'s the oscillator:\n\n$$\\omega _{0}(V_{cm})={1\\over {\\sqrt{L_{1}C_{t}(V_{cm})}}}$$\n\n$$C_{t}=C_{B1}+C_{B2}+C_{v}(V_{cm}-V_{cont})+C_{M1,2}(V_{cm})+C_{p}$$\n\n$$d\\omega _{0}= {\\partial \\omega _{0}\\over{\\partial V_{cm}}}dV_{cm}\n+{\\partial \\omega _{0}\\over{\\partial V_{cont}}}dV_{cont}$$\n\n$${\\partial \\omega _{0}\\over{\\partial V_{cm}}}=\n-{1\\over 2}{\\omega _{0}\\over{C_{t}}}{\\partial C_{t}\\over{\\partial V_{cm}}}\n\\;\\;{\\rm rad/s/V}$$\n\n$${K_{VDD}}={1\\over{2\\pi}}{\\partial \\omega _{0}\\over{\\partial V_{out}}}\n\\;\\;{\\rm Hz/V}\\approx -{1\\over 2}{f_{0}\\over{C_{t}}}\n{\\partial C_{v}\\over{\\partial V_{cm}}}~~{\\rm dominant}$$\n\nis the {\\it supply pushing coefficient}. Can be\nextracted small signal from a\n\n* dc sweep of $V_{out}$ vs $f_{0}$ in PSS\n* $p_{ss}+p_{ac}$ : $FM$ sideband on $V_{out}$\n  $\\delta V_{out}\\cos \\Delta \\omega t\\rightarrow \n  \\delta \\omega \\cos \\Delta \\omega t$\n\nTypical $10-500{\\rm MHz/V}$. In a perfectly balanced\ntank without $V_{cont}$ dependence $K_{VDD}=0$ to first\norder and pushing is second order ${\\cal O}(\\Delta C/C)$\nmismatch and ${\\rm AM-PM}$ via the Groszkowski effect,\nbut with the MOS varactor $M_{v}$ of the figure\n$C_{v}=C_{v}(V_{GS}=V_{X}-V_{cont})$ it is first order:\n\n$$\\Delta \\omega (t)=K_{0}v_{n}(t)\\;\\;\\;K_{0}=2\\pi K_{VDD}$$\n\n$$\\theta(t)=\\int^{t} \\Delta \\omega(\\tau)d\\tau$$\n\nfor the usual $|\\Delta \\omega |\\ll \\omega_{0}$\nnarrow band $FM$:\n\n$$v_{out}(t)=V_{0}\\cos [\\omega_{0}t+\\phi_{n}(t)]+{\\rm AM}$$\n\n$$\\phi_{n}(t)=\\int^{t} K_{0}v_{n}(\\tau)d\\tau$$\n\nIn the Fourier domain $j\\Delta \\omega \\Phi_{n}=K_{0}V_{n}$\n\n$$\\left| \\Phi_{n}(\\Delta \\omega)\\right|^{2}=\n{{K_{0}^{2}}\\over{\\Delta \\omega^{2}}}\\left| V_{n}(\\Delta \\omega)\\right|^{2}$$\n\nI. e. $PSD$ sense:\n\n$$ {\\cal S_{\\Delta \\omega}(\\Delta \\omega)=K_{0}^{2}{\\cal S}_{Vcm}(\\Delta \\omega)\n\\;{\\rm (rad/s)^{2}/Hz}} $$\n\n$${\\cal S}_{\\Delta f}(\\Delta \\omega)=K_{VDD}^{2}{\\cal S}_{Vcm} \\;\n{\\rm Hz^{2}/Hz}}$$\n\n$${\\cal S}_{\\phi}(\\Delta \\omega)={{{\\cal S}_{\\Delta \\omega}}\\over{\\Delta \\omega^{2}}}\n={{K_{0}^{2}}\\over{\\Delta \\omega^{2}}}{\\cal S}_{Vcm}(\\Delta \\omega)\n={{K_{VDD}^{2}}\\over{\\Delta f^{2}}}{\\cal S}_{Vcm}(\\Delta f)\n\\;{\\rm rad^{2}/Hz}} \\tag{1}$$\n\nSingle sideband to carrier ratio normally quoted:\n\n$${\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega)=10\\log_{10}{{{\\cal S}_{\\phi}(\\Delta \\omega)}\\over 2}\n\\;{\\rm dBc/Hz} $$\n\n$$ {\\cal L}_{LDO}(\\Delta \\omega)\\approx \n10\\log_{10}\\left[ {{K_{VDD}^{2}S_{th}(\\Delta \\omega)\n\\left| H_{LDO}H_{LPF}\\right|^{2}}\\over{2\\Delta f^{2}}}\\right]} $$\n\n$$=10\\log_{10}\\left[ {{K_{0}^{2}S_{th}(\\Delta \\omega)\n\\left| H_{LDO}H_{LPF}\\right|^{2}}\\over{2\\Delta \\omega^{2}}}\\right]\n\\tag{2}$$\n\nwith $K_{0}=2\\pi K_{VDD}$ if $K_{VDD}$ in ${\\rm Hz/V}$.\n\nEq.1 is the linearized {\\it Hajimiri-Lee} result.\nRigorously\n\n$$\\phi_{n}(t)=\\int_{-\\infty}^{t}\\Gamma_{cm}(\\tau)v_{n}(\\tau)d\\tau$$\n\nwhere $\\Gamma_{cm}(t)$ is the impulse sensitivity\nfunction from the common mode node. Expanding\n$\\Gamma_{cm}=c_{0}/2+\\sum c_{n}\\cos n\\omega_{0}t+...$\n\n$$c_{0}={1\\over{\\pi}}\\int_{0}^{2\\pi}\\Gamma_{cm}d\\theta\n\\approx {{K_{0}}\\over{\\omega_{0}}}$$\n\n$$ {\\cal S}_{\\phi}(\\Delta \\omega)\\approx \n{{c_{0}^{2}}\\over{4\\Delta \\omega^{2}}}{\\cal S}_{Vcm}(\\Delta \\omega)\n+\\sum_{n\\ge 1}{{c_{n}^{2}}\\over{4}}\\,{\\cal S}_{Vcm}(n\\omega_{0}\\pm\\Delta \\omega) $$\n\nThe $n=0$ term is Eq.1, the frequency translation\nof noise around $n\\omega_{0}$, in particular $2\\omega_{0}$\nfor tail noise, is normally negligible for supply\ncommon mode if $c_{n\\ge 1}\\ll c_{0}$. That is evaluated\nin ${\\rm PSS}+pnoise/pxf$ as the periodic transfer\nfunction ${\\rm PXF}_{Vout\\rightarrow \\phi}$.\n\nIn words: White $S_{th}$ becomes $1/\\Delta\\omega^{2}$,\ni.e. $-20{\\rm dB/dec}$ phase noise. $1/f$ noise of the\nLDO\n\n$$S_{th}=S_{th,0}\\left(1+{{f_{c}}\\over{f}}\\right)$$\n\nbecomes $1/f^{2}$ and $1/f^{3}$ phase noise after the\nintegration:\n\n$${\\cal L}\\propto {1\\over{\\Delta f^{2}}}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\Delta f>f_{c}$$\n\n$${\\cal L}\\propto {1\\over{\\Delta f^{3}}}\\;\\;{\\rm for}\\;\\Delta f<f_{c}$$\n\nunfiltered. The $H_{LPF}$ eventually restores $-20{\\rm dB/dec}$\nroll off above the $R_{LDO}C_{dec}$ pole.\n\n> Example: $S_{th}^{1/2}=30{\\rm nV/\\sqrt{Hz}}$,\n> ${\\cal S}_{th}=9\\times 10^{-16}{\\rm V^{2}/Hz}$,\n> $K_{VDD}=100{\\rm MHz/V}$,\n> $\\Delta f=1{\\rm MHz}$,\n> ${\\cal S}_{\\phi}=K_{VDD}^{2}{\\cal S}_{th}/\\Delta f^{2}\n> =9\\times 10^{-12}{\\rm rad^{2}/Hz}$,\n> ${\\cal L}\\approx 10\\log 4.5\\times 10^{-12}\n> \\approx -113{\\rm dBc/Hz}$,\n> to be added power wise to the intrinsic tank/MOS\n> Leeson phase noise. With $C_{dec}=100{\\rm pF}$,\n> $R_{LDO}=100\\Omega$, $f_{p}=16{\\rm MHz}$, no attenuation\n> at $1{\\rm MHz}$.\n\nThat is observable and usually requires $C_{dec}$,\n$RC$ filtering on $V_{out}$ or a high ${\\rm PSRR}$\nregulated cascode between $L_{1}$ and $V_{out}$,\nor regulation of the tail current instead of the\ntank top, to meet e.g. GSM $-165{\\rm dBc/Hz}$ at\n$20{\\rm MHz}$. In simulation simply replace $V_{out}$\nby $V_{out}+v_{n}$, run ${\\rm pss+pnoise}$ with\n$v_{n}$ as input and observe ${\\rm pnoise}$ sideband\nat $\\omega_{0}\\pm\\Delta\\omega$. The sum of intrinsic\nand supply induced:\n\n$${\\cal L}_{tot}=10\\log_{10}\\left(10^{{\\cal L}_{VCO}/10}\n+10^{{\\cal L}_{LDO}/10}\\right)$$\n\nis filtered by any subsequent $PLL$ loop\n$|1/(1+G_{PLL})|^{2}$ inside the loop bandwidth.\n\nAM sidebands ${\\cal S}_{AM}=\n\\left|H_{AM}\\right|^{2}{\\cal S}_{Vcm}$ are at the same\n$\\Delta\\omega$ but do not contribute to zero crossing\njitter to first order.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "d9a0a7c9fc78ce6320415fd4819a4a0f1b2c2fb6fc0c0391c81aaad05596103a"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly derives the supply-pushing sensitivity, converts LDO noise to phase noise with the required 1/Δf² dependence, and identifies the direct varactor modulation that links supply pushing to the tuning sensitivity. The additional filtering and spectral details do not undermine the core result.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f40f5d47fc68dc67261745b47ef8f93ebeabc96a5ea084c1e3fcf7bea12e1811",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3592,
        "output_tokens": 6600,
        "total_tokens": 10192,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4010,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3592,
        "output_tokens": 6600,
        "total_tokens": 10192,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4010,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "If the LDO regulator in the figure generates thermal noise with spectrum Sth, how do we compute the VCO output phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the narrow band sense the ${\\rm VCO}$\nis a {\\it frequency modulator} with\n\n$${\\omega_{osc}}(t)=\\omega _{0}+ {\\cal K}_{DD}v_{n}(t) \\tag{1}$$\n\n$$v_{n}(t)=V_{out}(t)-V_{out, D.C.}\\qquad \n{\\cal K}_{DD}={{\\partial \\omega_{0}}\\over {\\partial V_{out}}}\n  =2\\pi {{\\partial f_{0}}\\over {\\partial V_{DD}}}=2\\pi K_{DD}$$\n\nso that\n\n$$\\phi _{n}(t)=\\int {\\cal K}_{DD}v_{n}(t)dt\\;\\;\\;,\\;\\;H_{FM}(s)={\\cal K}_{DD}/s \\tag{2}$$\n\nmodulo the low pass filtering between the physical\nnoise source and the $V_{out}$ node.\nFor $f_{m}\\ll f_{0}$, $L_{1}$ is a short and\n$V_{n}$ is a common mode $D.C.$ shift of $X$ and $Y$.\nI. e. $S_{th}(f_{m})$, one sided, ${\\rm V^{2}Hz^{-1}}$,\nis impressed unattenuated on the tank common mode\nunless deliberately decoupled\n\n$$S_{th}^{eff}(f_{m})=S_{th}(f_{m})\n\\left| {{Z_{dec}}\\over {Z_{o,LDO}+Z_{dec}}}\\right|^{2}\n\\left| H_{LDO}(f_{m})\\right|^{2} \\tag{3}$$\n\n$H_{LDO}\\approx 1/[1+jf_{m}/f_{p,LDO}]$ and\n$Z_{o,LDO}\\parallel 1/sC_{dec}$ otherwise $S_{th}^{eff}\n\\approx S_{th}$ in the usual $10{\\rm kHz}<f_{m}<10{\\rm MHz}$\nband.\n\n${\\cal K}_{DD}$ is the normally simulated supply pushing\n\n$${\\cal K}_{DD}= {{\\Delta \\omega_{0}}\\over {\\Delta V_{out}}}$$\n\nand can be obtained by a $D.C.$ sweep\n${\\rm PSS}/{\\rm PAC}$ {\\it a.c.} injection of $1{\\rm V}$\nat $V_{out}$ or analytically to first order.\nE. g. for the dominant varactor ${\\rm AM{\\hbox{-}}PM}$\nconversion\n\n$$V_{var}=V_{X,D.C.}-V_{cont}\\approx V_{out}-V_{cont}$$\n\n$$C_{tot}=C_{fix}+C_{av}(V_{var})+C_{par}(V_{X})$$\n\n$$f_{0}= {1\\over {2\\pi\\sqrt{L_{1}C_{tot}}}}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nK_{DD}&={{\\partial f_{0}}\\over {\\partial V_{out}}}\n =-{{f_{0}}\\over {2C_{tot}}}{{\\partial C_{tot}}\\over {\\partial V_{out}}} \\cr\n &\\approx -{{f_{0}}\\over {2C_{tot}}}\n\\left[{{\\partial C_{av}}\\over {\\partial V_{var}}}\n+{{\\partial C_{par}}\\over {\\partial V_{X}}}\\right]_{Q} } \\tag{4}$$\n\ni. e. to varactor accuracy\n\n$$|K_{DD}|\\approx |K_{VCO}|\\qquad \nK_{VCO}={{\\partial f_{0}}\\over {\\partial V_{cont}}}$$\n\nup to a sign. The conventional varactor tuning gain is\na measure of supply pushing.  Any other\n${\\rm AM{\\hbox{-}}PM}$ via the Groszkowski effect\n$C_{eff}(A(V_{out}))$ and $C_{gd,db}(V_{X})$ is\nincluded in the simulated\n\n$$K_{DD}= \\left.{{\\Delta f_{0}}\\over {\\Delta V_{out}}}\\right|_{sim} \\tag{5}$$\n\nin ${\\rm HzV^{-1}}$.  For one varactor per side,\ntwo sides,\n\n$$\\Delta f_{0}\\approx -{{f_{0}}\\over {C_{tot}}}{{dC_{av}}\\over {dV}} \\Delta V_{out}$$\n\nFor a sinusoidal $v_{n}=V_{m}\\cos \\omega _{m}t$\n\n$$v_{o}(t)=V_{0}\\cos \\left[\\omega _{0}t+\n{{{\\cal K}_{DD}V_{m}}\\over {\\omega _{m}}}\\sin \\omega _{m}t\\right] \\tag{6}$$\n\nnarrow band ${\\cal K}_{DD}V_{m}/\\omega _{m}\\ll 1$\n\n$$v_{o}\\approx V_{0}\\cos \\omega _{0}t-\nV_{0}{{{\\cal K}_{DD}V_{m}}\\over {2\\omega _{m}}}\n\\left\\{ \\cos (\\omega _{0}+\\omega _{m})t\n-\\cos (\\omega _{0}-\\omega _{m})t\\right\\}$$\n\nside band / carrier $= {\\cal K}_{DD}V_{m}/2\\omega _{m}$.\nFor a random $v_{n}$ with one sided power\nspectral density $S_{th}(f_{m})$ ${\\rm V^{2}/Hz}$\n\nfrequency noise:\n\n$$S_{f}(f_{m}) = K_{DD}^{2}S_{th}^{eff}(f_{m})\\;\\;{\\rm Hz^{2}Hz^{-1}} \\tag{7a}$$\n$$S_{\\omega}(f_{m})={\\cal K}_{DD}^{2}S_{th}^{eff}(f_{m})\n\\;\\;{\\rm (rad/s)^{2}Hz^{-1}} \\tag{7b}$$\n\nphase noise. With $\\Phi _{n}(s)={\\cal K}_{DD}V_{n}(s)/s$ :\n\n$$S_{\\phi}(f_{m}) = {{{\\cal K}_{DD}^{2}}\\over {\\omega _{m}^{2}}}\nS_{th}^{eff}(f_{m})\n= {{K_{DD}^{2}}\\over {f_{m}^{2}}}S_{th}^{eff}(f_{m})\n\\;\\;{\\rm rad^{2}Hz^{-1}}\\;\\;{\\rm DSB}\\tag{8}$$\n\n$${\\cal L}(f_{m})=10\\log {{S_{\\phi}(f_{m})}\\over 2}\n=10\\log \\left[ {{K_{DD}^{2}S_{th}^{eff}(f_{m})}\n\\over {2f_{m}^{2}}}\\right]\n=10\\log \\left[ {{{\\cal K}_{DD}^{2}S_{th}^{eff}(f_{m})}\n\\over {2\\omega _{m}^{2}}}\\right]\\;{\\rm dBcHz^{-1}}\\tag{9}$$\n\nSSB. For a white $S_{th}=S_{0}=4kTR_{o,LDO}+S_{a}/g_{m}+\\cdots$\nconstant to $f_{p,LDO}$ this is $1/f_{m}^{2}$,\n$20{\\rm dB/dec}$, added in power to the intrinsic\nVCO phase noise $S_{\\phi ,VCO}$ given by Leeson/Hajimiri.\nFor a $1/f$ LDO noise $S_{th}\\propto 1/f_{m}$ it gives\n$1/f_{m}^{3}$, $30{\\rm dB/dec}$, close in.\n\nIn ISF language eq. 8 is $|H(j\\omega _{m})|^{2}S_{th}$\nwith $H={\\cal K}_{DD}/j\\omega _{m}= \\Gamma_{DD,DC}\\omega_{0}\n/\\omega_{m}$ and $\\Gamma_{DD}$ the supply ISF.\nMore generally from ${\\rm PSS}+{\\rm PNOISE}$ you inject\n$1{\\rm V\\>a.c.}$ in series with $V_{out}$ and\n$H(j\\omega _{m})= \\Delta \\Phi /\\Delta V_{out}$ is the\np.m. transfer function, so $S_{\\phi}=|H|^{2}S_{th}$.\n\n> {\\it Rigorously the periodic transfer function\n> $H(j\\omega _{m},t)=\\sum_{k}H_{k}e^{jk\\omega _{0}t}\\)\n> upconverts $S_{th}$ at $k\\omega _{0}\\pm \\omega _{m}$\n> with $H_{k}\\propto \\Gamma_{k}$.  For the supply node\n> $H_{0}$ i.e. ${\\cal K}_{DD}/j\\omega _{m}$ dominates.}\n\nIn practice: get $K_{DD}\\sim 50-500{\\rm MHz/V}$ from\nsimulation/measurement and apply (8)-(9).\nE. g. $S_{th}^{1/2}=10{\\rm nVHz^{-1/2}}$,\n$S_{th}=1.0\\times 10^{-16}{\\rm V^{2}Hz^{-1}}$,\n$K_{DD}=100{\\rm MHz/V}$:\n\n$$S_{\\phi}(1{\\rm MHz}) =10^{16}\\times 10^{-16}/10^{12}\n=10^{-12}{\\rm rad^{2}Hz^{-1}}$$\n\n$${\\cal L}(1{\\rm MHz})\\approx -123{\\rm dBcHz^{-1}}$$\n\nlow pass filtered for $f_{m}>f_{p,LDO}$ or $f_{m}>1/2\\pi R_{o}C_{dec}$.\n\nThat is the {\\it excess} phase noise due to the\nregulator.  Total ${\\cal L}_{tot}= {\\cal L}_{VCO}\n\\oplus {\\cal L}_{LDO}$ on a linear power basis.\nSuppression requires large $C_{dec}$, high\n$PSRR_{LDO}$ at $f_{m}$, low $K_{DD}$ by\ndifferential design, low $K_{VCO}$, and low\n$R_{o,LDO}$ noise. This is why a noiseless\n$V_{out}$ is normally decoupled with nF to $\\mu$F\non chip or board.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "c047b6abedb4f6e67630fc0b79c5e09175a4ecfe38b0a448de2a688dabcd232b"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies supply pushing, converts the LDO voltage-noise spectrum through the VCO sensitivity to phase noise with the required 1/offset-frequency-squared dependence, and notes that direct varactor modulation makes the pushing sensitivity closely related to KVCO. Extra modeling details do not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f40f5d47fc68dc67261745b47ef8f93ebeabc96a5ea084c1e3fcf7bea12e1811",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3592,
        "output_tokens": 6125,
        "total_tokens": 9717,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3867,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3592,
        "output_tokens": 6125,
        "total_tokens": 9717,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 3867,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 18,
      "question": "If the LDO regulator in the figure generates thermal noise with spectrum Sth, how do we compute the VCO output phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-018-ldo-regulator-generates-thermal-noise-with-spectrum/figure-15.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In general that is a {\\it quasi static}\nfrequency modulation, the differential mode being\nin first order insensitive to it, and a second order\nGroszkowski - AM/PM conversion. For $f_{m}<< f_{0}$\nyou can treat it ${\\rm LTI}$.\n\n>$$\\eqalign{\n&V_{out}=V_{out0}+v_{n}(t) \\cr\n&v_{n}^{2}/\\Delta f = S_{th}(f)\\ {\\rm in\\ } {\\rm V^{2}Hz^{-1}}\\cr\n&S_{V_{out}} = S_{th}|Z_{out}||H_{LDO}|^{2}\\cr\n&{\\rm if\\ } S_{th} {\\rm\\ is\\ in\\ A^{2}Hz^{-1}\\;\\;\nS_{V_{out}}=S_{th}|Z_{out}|^{2}\\;\\;,\nZ_{out}=R_{out}||1/sC_{out}}}$$\n\nLet\n\n$${\\omega}_{0}= {\\omega}_{0}(V_{out},V_{cont},...)$$\n\nbe the {\\it large} signal oscillation frequency.\nPut $V_{cont}={\\rm const}$ and\n\n$$K_{push}={{\\partial {\\omega}_{0}}\\over {\\partial V_{out}}}\n  =2\\pi {{\\partial f_{0}}\\over {\\partial V_{out}}}\n  \\approx -{{\\omega}_{0}\\over {2C_{T}}}{{\\partial C_{T}}\\over\n  {\\partial V_{out}}}\\quad {\\rm rad\\,s^{-1}V^{-1}} \\tag{1}$$\n\n$$K_{push}^{Hz} =K_{push}/2\\pi \\;\\;{\\rm Hz\\,V^{-1}}$$\n\n$C_{T}=C_{B}+C_{v}(V_{cont}-V_{X})+C_{M1,2}(V_{out})$.\nFor the circuit as drawn $C_{T}$ is dominated by\n${\\rm B_{1,2}}$ and the MOS varactor ${\\rm M_{v}}$ so that\nwith $V_{X,dc}\\approx V_{out}$\n\n$${{\\partial C_{T}}\\over {\\partial V_{out}}}\n      \\approx {{\\partial C_{v}}\\over {\\partial V_{X}}}\n      =-{{\\partial C_{v}}\\over {\\partial V_{cont}}}$$\n\nso that to first order\n\n$$\\left|K_{push}\\right|\\approx \\left|K_{VCO}\\right|\n      =\\left|{{\\partial {\\omega}_{0}}\\over {\\partial V_{cont}}}\\right| \\tag{2}$$\n\nIn general (1) is obtained by a ${\\rm PSS}$ sweep\n$${\\omega}_{0}\\;{\\rm vs\\;}V_{out}$$ or by a small\nsinusoidal modulation\n\n$$V_{out}=V_{out0}+\\Delta V\\cos {\\omega}_{m}t$$\n\n$${\\rm FM\\ sideband\\ }: \\;\\Delta f = K_{push}^{Hz}\\Delta V$$\n\nand includes the Groszkowski shift\n\n$${{\\Delta {\\omega}}\\over {{\\omega}_{0}}}\\approx\n  {1\\over {2Q}}{{ {\\rm Im\\;} \\{Y_{1}\\}}\\over {{\\rm Re\\;} \\{Y_{1}\\}}}$$\n\ndue to the change of the harmonic content, {\\it i. e.}\nof the amplitude\n\n$$A(V_{out})\\approx \\cases{\nI_{VCO}R_{p} & current limited \\cr\nV_{out} & voltage limited}$$\n\nand the ${\\rm AM\\!\\to\\! PM}$ conversion through\n$C_{v}(A)$ and $C_{gd}(A)$. In practice $K_{push}$\nin (1) is taken as the {\\it effective} including\nAM$\\to$PM, $K_{push}=K_{FM}+K_{AM}K_{AM-PM}$ and is\nnormally $10-100\\,{\\rm MHz/V}$ for a ${\\rm GHz}$ $LC$\n$VCO$.\n\nFor ${\\omega}_{m}=2\\pi f_{m}<< {\\omega}_{0}$ :\n\n$${\\omega}(t) ={\\omega}_{0}+K_{push}v_{n}(t) \\tag{3}$$\n\n$${\\phi}_{n}(t)=\\int^{t} K_{push}v_{n}(\\tau)d\\tau \\tag{4}$$\n\nin the frequency domain ${\\cal F}\\{ \\phi_{n}\\}=K_{push}\nV_{n}(s)/s$. I. e. a voltage noise $v_{n}$ FM modulates\nthe oscillator. In power spectral language\ndouble sided:\n\n$$S_{\\phi}(\\omega_{m}) = {{K_{push}^{2}}\\over {\\omega_{m}^{2}}}\n     S_{V_{out}}(\\omega_{m})\\left|H_{cm}(\\omega_{m})\\right|^{2}\n     \\qquad {\\rm rad^{2}Hz^{-1}} \\tag{5}$$\n\n$$S_{\\phi}(f_{m})={{K_{push}^{Hz\\,2}}\\over {f_{m}^{2}}}\n     S_{V_{out}}(f_{m})\\left|H_{cm}(f_{m})\\right|^{2} $$\n\n$H_{cm}$ is the low pass from the $LDO$ to the\ncommon mode of the tank,\n\n$$H_{cm}(s)\\approx {1\\over {1+sR_{out}C_{out}}}\\,\n      {Z_{cm}(s)\\over {Z_{cm}(s)+sL_{1}/2}} \\approx\n      {1\\over {1+sR_{out}C_{out}}}\\;\\;{\\rm for\\;}f_{m} < f_{0}$$\n\n$$Z_{cm}= \\left[ sC_{T,cm}+1/s(L_{1}/2)+G_{p,cm}\\right]^{-1}$$\n\nSo that the conventional {\\it single sideband to carrier}\nphase noise $L=10\\log {\\cal L}$,\n${\\cal L}(f_{m})=S_{\\phi}(f_{m})/2$ single sided, is\nfor white $S_{th}=S_{0}=4kTR_{n}$ at the output of the\n$LDO$:\n\n$${\\cal L}(f_{m}) =10\\log \\left[\n  {{K_{push}^{2}S_{0}}\\over {2\\omega_{m}^{2}\\left[1+(\\omega_{m}/\n  \\omega_{p})^{2}\\right]}} \\right]\\;\\;{\\rm dBcHz^{-1}} \\tag{6}$$\n\n$$\\approx 10\\log \\left[\n  {{K_{push}^{Hz\\,2}S_{0}}\\over {2f_{m}^{2}\\left[1+(f_{m}/\n  f_{p})^{2}\\right]}} \\right]$$\n\n${\\omega}_{p}=1/R_{out}C_{out}$ is the $LDO$ dominant\npole, $f_{p}={\\omega}_{p}/2\\pi $. Normally we quote in\n${\\rm dBcHz^{-1}}$\n\n>$$ {\\cal L}_{LDO}(f_{m})\\approx 20\\log {{K_{push}^{Hz}}\\over {f_{m}}}\n      +10\\log S_{Vout}(f_{m}) -3{\\rm dB} -20\\log \\sqrt{1+(f_{m}/f_{p})^{2}} $$\n\n{\\it i.e.} white supply noise becomes $1/f_{m}^{2}$,\n$20{\\rm dB/dec}$, phase noise. $1/f$ noise of the\n$LDO$ becomes $1/f_{m}^{3}$, $30{\\rm dB/dec}$.\n\nWith $K_{push}^{Hz}=50\\,{\\rm MHz/V}$,\n$S_{Vout}^{1/2}=10\\,{\\rm nV\\,Hz^{-1/2}}$,\n$S_{0}=10^{-16}{\\rm V^{2}Hz^{-1}}$,\n\n$${\\cal L}(1\\,{\\rm MHz})\\approx 10\\log{{(5\\times 10^{7})^{2}\n  10^{-16}}\\over {2\\times 10^{12}}}\\approx -96{\\rm dBcHz^{-1}}$$\n\nat $100{\\rm kHz}$, $-116+20= -76{\\rm dBcHz^{-1}}$ before\nfiltering. The intrinsic $VCO$ noise must be added in\npower.\n\nEq. 5 is the ${\\rm LTI}$ approximation. Rigorously the\n$LDO$ noise is a cyclostationary input to a linear\nperiodically time variant system. With Hajimiri-Lee\nimpulse sensitivity function $\\Gamma_{DD}(x)$,\n$q_{max}=C_{T}V_{max}$ the maximum charge swing,\n$i_{n,DD}=v_{n}/R_{out}$:\n\n$$\\Gamma_{DD}(\\theta) = \\Gamma_{0}+ \\Gamma_{2}\\cos 2\\theta+\\cdots$$\n\ncommon mode, essentially zero at $\\omega_{0}$. The\ninjection of a charge $\\Delta q$ at phase $\\theta$\nat the $V_{out}$ node produces an asymptotic phase\nshift $\\Delta \\phi =\\Gamma_{DD}(\\theta)\\Delta q/q_{max}$.\nExpanding $\\Gamma_{DD}$ in Fourier series $c_{n}$:\n\n$$S_{\\phi}(f_{m})={1\\over {8\\pi^{2}f_{m}^{2}q_{max}^{2}}}\n   \\sum_{n=-\\infty}^{\\infty}c_{n}^{2}S_{i,n}(f_{m}-nf_{0}) \\tag{7}$$\n\nFor supply noise the dominant terms are $n=0$,\nlow frequency noise converted to $1/f_{m}^{2}$, and\n$n=\\pm 2$, noise at $ \\approx 2f_{0}$ down converted\nto phase noise at $f_{0}\\pm f_{m}$.\n\n$c_{0}$ is the ${\\rm DC}$ value of $\\Gamma_{DD}$ and\n\n$$c_{0}/q_{max}= K_{push}/{\\omega}_{0}$$\n\nso that (7) reduces to (5) for $f_{m}<<f_{0}$.\n\nIn a simulator: ${\\rm PSS}+{\\rm PXF}$ or ${\\rm PSS}+{\\rm PNOISE}$\nwith the perturbation projection vector ${\\bf p}^{T}(t)$,\nDemir {\\it et al.}, extraction of ${\\bf p}^{T}{\\bf B}v_{n}$\ngives directly (7). In SpectreRF put a small voltage\nsource in series with $V_{out}$, run $pnoise$ modulated,\nPM, the result is ${\\cal L}_{LDO}(f_{m})$ within the\nLeeson factor.\n\nIn design it is the reason for a large $C_{out}$\non the $LDO$, $f_{p}<<f_{m,{\\rm min}}$, and for a\nlow $K_{push}$, {\\it i.e.} low $K_{VCO}$ and large\nfixed $C_{B}$ compared to $C_{v}$, and for a high\n$Q$ tank, low $K_{AM-PM}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "e6a184ad2fc9b1a773773981e14bd827b88ec2bea7d7d6e46ff56deac8bf344c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly identifies supply pushing, converts the LDO output-noise spectrum to phase noise with the expected 1/Δf² dependence, and notes that the direct varactor sensitivity makes Kpush closely related to KVCO, so reducing KVCO reduces the conversion. Extra modeling details and factor conventions do not undermine the essential answer.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "f40f5d47fc68dc67261745b47ef8f93ebeabc96a5ea084c1e3fcf7bea12e1811",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3592,
        "output_tokens": 6813,
        "total_tokens": 10405,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4284,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3592,
        "output_tokens": 6813,
        "total_tokens": 10405,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 4284,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "We add CT to the tail node, as in the figure. What happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the sense of Hajimiri that is the\n{\\it Hegazi} filter, Fig.2 {\\tt JSSC 12/01}\nand Samori {\\it et al.}, in first order,\nwith a dimensioning\n\n$${\\vert Z_{T}(2\\omega _{0})\\vert \\ll {\\vert Z_{T}(0)\\vert\n\\over 1+q_{max}} \\qquad Z_{T}={1\\over j\\omega C_{T}}\\parallel\nr_{0T}}$$\n\nit {\\it filters} the ${\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )$.\nIn more detail\n\n$$ {\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )=10\\log\n\\left\\{ {2FkT\\over P_{s}}\\left[1+\\left({\\omega_{0}\\over\n2Q\\Delta \\omega}\\right)^{2}\\right]\\left(1+{\\omega_{1/f^{3}}\\over\n\\vert\\Delta \\omega\\vert}\\right)\\right\\}$$\n\n$$F= 1+ \\gamma {4\\over 9}g_{m}R + \\gamma g_{mT}R\\,\n{{c_{0}^{2}+c_{2}^{2}+ \\cdots }\\over 4}\n{S_{I_{SS}}(n\\omega_{0}\\pm \\Delta \\omega)\\over 4kT}+\\cdots $$\n\nis normally dominated, close and far from carrier,\nby the bias.  $\\Gamma _{T}(t)$ is the ISF from the\ncommon source, $P$ in the figure.  For the conventional\ninductive loaded cross coupled pair\n\n$$\\Gamma _{T}(t)=c_{0}+c_{2}\\cos 2\\omega_{0}t+\\cdots\n\\qquad c_{0}\\sim 0.5-0.8\\;\\;,\\;\\;c_{2}\\sim 0.3-0.5$$\n\nand $c_{0}^{2}$ up converts the ${\\rm flicker}$,\n$1/f$, noise of $I_{SS}$ to $1/f^{3}$ close in\nby AM-FM, Groszkowski, varactor, $C_{gs,nl}$,\nmodulation, and $c_{2}^{2}$ down converts the {\\it white}\npower around $2\\omega_{0}$ to $\\omega_{0}\\pm \\Delta\\omega$\n{\\it etc.}\n$I_{SS}(t)=I_{SS}+i_{n,T}(t)$,\n$i_{n,T}(\\Delta \\omega )$ mixes with $\\omega_{0}$,\n$i_{n,T}(2\\omega_{0}\\pm \\Delta \\omega )$ mixes with\n$\\omega_{0}$ to $\\Delta \\omega$ according to\n\n$$i_{D1}+i_{D2}= I_{SS}+i_{n,T}(t) + {\\cal O}(v_{X,Y}^{2})$$\n$$v_{P}(t)=V_{P0}+V_{P2}\\cos 2\\omega_{0}t+\\cdots$$\n\nso that $S_{\\phi}(\\Delta \\omega )\\propto \n\\Gamma_{T,rms}^{2}S_{I_{SS}}(\\Delta \\omega )$.\n\n$C_{T}$ shunts $i_{n,T}$ to ground at\n$\\vert \\omega \\vert \\gg (r_{0T}C_{T})^{-1}$,\nin particular\n\n$${\\vert i_{n,T}(2\\omega_{0})\\vert^{2}\\over \\vert 1+j2\\omega_{0}\nr_{0T}C_{T}\\vert^{2}}\\approx \n{\\vert i_{n,T}(2\\omega_{0})\\vert^{2}\\over (2\\omega_{0}r_{0T}C_{T})^{2}}$$\n\nand suppresses the $c_{2}^{2}S_{I_{SS}}(2\\omega_{0})$ term\nand to a large extent the $c_{0}^{2}S_{I_{SS}}(\\Delta\\omega)$\nUPSIDE low frequency $1/f$ by decreasing $V_{P2}$\nand the effective NMF, Samori, {\\it et al}, and\ndecreasing the {\\it impulse sensitivity} during the\nzero crossing when $M_{1}-M_{2}$ are both on.\n\nIn the normal $1-5\\,{\\rm GHz}$ range that is:\n\n* $1/f^{2}$ thermal floor $\\propto c_{2}^{2}\nS_{I_{SS}}(2\\omega_{0})/P_{s}$ is reduced by\n$\\vert Z_{T}(2\\omega_{0})\\vert^{2}\\propto (2\\omega_{0}C_{T})^{-2}$.\nTypically $2-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ with $C_{T}$ alone\nfor $C_{T}\\approx (2\\omega_{0}R_{T})^{-1}$ to\n$10\\times$ that, {\\it i. e.} ${\\cal O}({\\rm pF})$\nto ${\\cal O}(10\\,{\\rm pF})$.\n\n* $1/f^{3}$, $1/f$ up conversion, $\\propto\nc_{0}^{2}S_{I_{SS},1/f}(\\Delta\\omega )$, is drastically\nreduced because $V_{P}(t)$ no longer follows\n$i_{n,T}(\\Delta\\omega )$ via the $2\\omega_{0}$\nrectification and the AM-FM conversion\n\n$$\\Delta \\omega_{0}\\approx\n{K_{0}\\over 2}{\\Delta I_{SS}\\over I_{SS}}\\approx\n{K_{0}\\over 2}{v_{P}\\over V_{ov}}$$\n\nwith $K_{0}=\\partial \\omega_{0}/\\partial V_{P}$ via the\nnon linear $C(V)$ of the tank, is suppressed.\nHegazi reports $\\sim 7-10\\,{\\rm dB}$ at\n$\\Delta\\omega = 2\\pi\\times 1\\,{\\rm MHz}$ and\n$\\omega_{1/f^{3}}$ moving from $\\sim 2\\times 10^{5}\\,{\\rm Hz}$\nto $\\sim 3\\times 10^{4}\\,{\\rm Hz}$ in $1.1\\,{\\rm GHz}$\nbipolar and $5\\,{\\rm GHz}$ CMOS, Andreani {\\it et al}\nsimilar.\n\nFormally $C_{T}$ narrows the NMF and lowers\n$\\Gamma_{T,rms}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:} With $C_{T}$ alone the circuit\n> shunts its own $2\\omega_{0}$ common mode current\n> generated by the $M_{1}-M_{2}$ commutation to ground.\n> I. e. the $Q$ at $2\\omega_{0}$ is killed,\n> $V_{P2}\\to 0$, the pair loads the tank during\n> the cross over with $2/g_{m}$ and the swing\n> $V_{X,Y}\\approx I_{SS}R_{p}$ drops.\n> The $F$ due to the $M_{1}-M_{2}$ pair itself then\n> goes up.\n> So the improvement saturates and for $C_{T}\\to\\infty$,\n> a. c. ground at $P$, it reverses.  There is an\n> optimum $C_{T,opt}\\approx 2-5\\times (2\\omega_{0}\n> R_{T})^{-1}$ for the bare circuit of the figure.\n> The full ``filtering technique'' interposes a\n> choke $L_{T}$ between $P$ and $I_{SS}$ so that\n> $L_{T}\\parallel C_{T}$ is a {\\it high} impedance\n> $\\approx \\omega_{T}L_{T}Q_{T}$ for the oscillator's\n> own $2\\omega_{0}$ current, preserving $V_{P2}$ and\n> the hard commutation, but a {\\it low} impedance to\n> ground for the $I_{SS}$ noise, {\\it i. e.} it is made\n> to resonate,\n\n> $$\\omega_{T}={1\\over \\sqrt{L_{T}C_{T}}}\\approx 2\\omega_{0}$$\n\n> $L_{T}$ can be the parasitic bond wire or an\n> explicit ${\\cal O}({\\rm nH})$ inductor and/or the\n> tail device capacitance. In that tuned form the\n> Hegazi filter gives the quoted $8-15\\,{\\rm dB}$\n> close in and $3-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ far out lower\n> ${\\cal L}$, essentially for the price of the\n> area of $C_{T}$ and $L_{T}$ and a somewhat larger\n> start up $g_{m}R>1$ requirement and cm settling time\n> $\\sim r_{0T}C_{T}$.  $kT/C_{T}$ itself mixed down is\n> normally negligible.  See E. Hegazi {\\it et al},\n> {\\it IEEE JSSC} {\\bf 36}, 1928 (2001);\n> P. Andreani {\\it et al}, {\\it JSSC} {\\bf 37}, 342\n> (2002); C. Samori {\\it et al}, {\\it JSSC} {\\bf 37},\n> 244 (2002).",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "76722d8446b63a67d863ad8cddf5f300898b09add92603b280e93d9abf64564c"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 2,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It recognizes an optimum and that excessive CT can worsen phase noise, but mainly attributes the improvement to filtering tail-current noise. It misses the class-C peak-current mechanism and Razavi's key degradation mechanisms; its tank-loading explanation does not capture them.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "30f6431c053d0ebf26268170667295ea7bd412e72a78ea0b3247e5803cbdfc8a",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3726,
        "output_tokens": 8466,
        "total_tokens": 12192,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6523,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3726,
        "output_tokens": 8466,
        "total_tokens": 12192,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6523,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 2,
        "score_percent": 50,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "We add CT to the tail node, as in the figure. What happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With ${\\rm T}={\\rm tail}$ distinguish\n$$i_{nT}({\\rm th.})~~{\\rm at}~~2\\omega _{o}~~\n{\\rm and}~~i_{nT}({\\rm LF},1/f)~{\\rm at}~\\Delta \\omega $$\nthe so called {\\it Hegazy} filter {\\it a la}\nHajimiri for the cyclostationary ${\\mit \\Gamma }(t)$.\n\nIn a normally balanced way, with ${r_{oT}\\to \\infty }$ the\ntail is a common mode.  To first order $v_{nT}$ does not\nproduce ${\\rm FM}$.\nTo second order it does\n\n* a current $I_{SS}+i_{nT}$ at $2\\omega _{o}$ develops a\nvoltage\n\n$$v_{nP}=i_{nT}Z_{P}\\qquad \nZ_{P}^{-1}=g_{oT}+j\\omega C_{P0}+j\\omega C_{T}\\tag{1}$$\n\nat $2\\omega _{o}$ which is mixed by the\n${f_{p}}(t)=I_{1}(t)/I_{SS}$ {\\it i.~e.} the\ncommutating function of the pair, whose second Fourier\ncoefficient is $c_{2}\\ne 0$, down to $\\omega _{o}$ and\nappears as additive ${\\rm AM}$ and, trough the\n${\\rm Am}\\to {\\mit \\Phi}{\\rm m}$ conversion of the\nnon linear ${\\rm C}$'s, of the varactor, of the\nGroszkowski effect and of any ${\\rm C}_{gs}-{\\rm C}_{gd}$\nmodulation as ${\\mit \\Phi}{\\rm m}$\n\n$$S_{{\\mit \\Phi}}(\\Delta \\omega )=\n \\left|c_{2}Z_{P}(2\\omega _{o})\\right|^{2}\n  S_{i_{nT}}(2\\omega _{o}\\pm \\Delta \\omega )\\tag{2}$$\n\nso that with $C_{T}=0$, $|Z_{P}|\\approx 1/\\omega C_{P0}$,\nnormally a ${\\rm k\\Omega }$ at $2\\omega _{o}$, the\nwhite noise of the tail at $2\\omega _{o}$ is normally\nthe dominant contribution to the $1/f^{2}$ ${\\cal L}$;\n\n* the ${\\rm LF}$ noise $i_{nT}(\\Delta \\omega )$ is\nup converted by the same $c_{2}$,\n\n$$S_{{\\mit \\Phi}}(\\Delta \\omega )=\n c_{0}^{2}S_{i_{nT}}(\\Delta \\omega ),\\qquad \n c_{0}={1\\over {T_{o}}}\\int_{0}^{T_{o}}{\\mit \\Gamma }\n (t){{I_{S}(t)}\\over {I_{SS}}}\\,dt \\tag{3}$$\n\n${\\mit \\Gamma }(t)$ the Hajimiri impulse sensitivity\nfunction and $I_{S}(t)=I_{1}(t)+I_{2}(t)$\nthe cyclostationary noise modulating function.  $c_{0}$\nis the ${\\rm dc}$ value of the effective ${\\rm ISF}$\n${\\mit \\Gamma }_{{\\rm eff}}={\\mit \\Gamma }(t)I_{S}(t)/I_{SS}$.\nFor $C_{P0}=0$, $I_{S}=I_{SS}={\\rm const.}$ and\n$c_{0}={1\\over {T_{o}}}\\int {\\mit \\Gamma }dt\\ne 0$ if\n${\\mit \\Gamma }$ is asymetric, {\\it i.~e.} if the\nwave form is asymetric.  Close to commutation both\n$M_{1,2}$ are on, $C_{P0}$ must be charged/discharged\nby $\\Delta Q=C_{P0}\\Delta V_{P}$. The charge comes\nfrom the tank.  The wave form becomes asymetric,\n$\\int{\\mit \\Gamma }dt\\ne 0$ and large, and (3) up\nconverts the very large $1/f$ noise of $I_{SS}$ and of\n$M_{1,2}$ to $1/f^{3}$ close in ${\\cal L}$.\n\n$$\\begin{aligned}\n{\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )&\\approx \n10\\log \\left[{1\\over {8}}{\\omega _{o}^{2}\\over {\\Delta \\omega }^{2}}\n{{\\mit \\Gamma }_{{\\rm rms}}^{2}\\over {q_{{\\rm max}}^{2}}}\n{{{\\overline {i_{n}^{2}}}\\over {\\Delta f}}\\over {\\Delta \\omega }^{2}}\n\\left(1+{\\omega _{1/f}\\over {\\Delta \\omega }}c_{0}^{2}\\right)\\right] \\\\\n&\\propto {FkT\\over {2Q^{2}}}{{\\omega _{o}^{2}}\\over {\\Delta \\omega }^{2}}\n{P_{{\\rm sig}}^{-1}}\n\\end{aligned}\\tag{4}$$\n\n$C_{T}$ {\\it shorts} (1) at $2\\omega _{o}$,\n\n$$\\left|Z_{P}(2\\omega _{o})\\right|\\approx {1\\over {2\\omega _{o}C_{T}}}\n\\ll \\left|Z_{P0}\\right|\\tag{5}$$\n\nand, if $1/r_{oT}C_{T}\\ll \\omega _{o}$ filters the\n$2\\omega _{o}$ thermal noise (2).  In the limit\n$C_{T}\\to \\infty $, $P$ is an ${\\rm a.c.}$ ground,\n${{dV_{P}}\\over {dt}}\\to 0$, $I_{S}(t)=I_{SS}+C_{T}\\dot V_{P}$\nfollows the commutation instantaneously, the memory\nassociated with $C_{P}$ disappears, the wave form can\nbe made symmetric, ${\\mit \\Gamma }(t)=-\\,{\\mit \\Gamma }\n(t+T_{o}/2)$,\n\n$$\\int_{0}^{T_{o}}{\\mit \\Gamma }_{{\\rm eff}}dt=c_{0}\\to 0\\tag{6}$$\n\nand (3) is suppressed.  In Samori {\\it et al.},\nHegazy {\\it et al.} $JSSC\\;12/01$ language $C_{T}$\n{\\it linearises} the operation of the pair and suppresses\nthe ${\\rm Am}\\to {\\mit \\Phi}{\\rm m}$ conversion due to\n${\\rm C}_{gs},{\\rm C}_{gd},{\\rm C}_{db}$ and varactor\nmodulation by $V_{P}$.  The normal result is for a\ncorrectly dimensioned, {\\it i.~e.} $C_{T}$ large enough\nthat\n\n$$\\omega _{p}={1\\over {r_{oT}C_{T}}}\\ll 2\\omega _{o}\\tag{7}$$\n\nand normally large with respect to the ordinary parasitic\n$C_{P0}\\sim 0.2-0.5\\,{\\rm pF}$, $C_{T}=2-20\\,{\\rm pF}$\nfor a ${\\rm GHz}$ oscillator,\n\n* $5-10\\,{\\rm dB}$ lowering of the $1/f^{2}$ plateau\ndue to (2) and to the increase of the tank swing,\nbecause the pair stays in saturation for a larger\nfraction of the period,\n* more than one order of magnitude lowering of the\n$1/f^{3}$ corner, typically from $200-500\\,{\\rm kHz}$\nto $20-50\\,{\\rm kHz}$, and $10-15\\,{\\rm dB}$ lowering\nof ${\\cal L}$ close in due to (6).  The published\n{\\it filtering} technique is $C_{T}\\parallel L_{T}$\nresonating at $2\\omega _{o}$ in series with $I_{SS}$,\nFig.1, so that the source of $M_{1,2}$ sees\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nZ_{P}({\\rm LF})&\\approx 0\\cr\nZ_{P}(2\\omega _{o})&\\to \\infty {\\rm \\;for\\;the\\;core}\\cr\nZ_{P}(2\\omega _{o})&\\approx 0 {\\rm \\;for\\;}I_{SS}}$$\n\nso that the noise of $I_{SS}$ is shorted to ground\nwhile the tank is not loaded at $2\\omega _{o}$.\n\n> {\\it In text book form: $C_{T}$ is a tail noise\n> filter.  Ideally ${\\cal L}(\\Delta \\omega )$ goes down.\n> The $1/f^{3}$ ${\\cal L}$ is essentially removed.}\n\nWith $C_{T}$ alone the loading effect can dominate.\nFor $Z_{P}\\to 0$ the impedance looking into the drain\nof the on device goes to $1/g_{m}\\parallel r_{o}$ and\nthe pair loads the tank for the whole conduction angle,\n$2{\\mit \\Phi}_{c}\\propto \\sqrt{I_{SS}/C_{T}}$,\nwhere both devices are on.  The effective $Q$ is\ndegraded as\n\n$${1\\over {Q_{{\\rm eff}}}}={1\\over Q_{0}}+\n{2{\\mit \\Phi}_{c}\\over {2\\pi}}{g_{m}R_{p}\\over Q_{0}}$$\n\nand the swing is reduced.  So ${\\cal L}$ {\\it vs} $C_{T}$\nis not monotonic.  From $C_{T}=0$ to $C_{T}\\approx\n(2-5)C_{P0}$ ${\\cal L}$ often goes {\\it up}} by $1-2\\,{\\rm dB}$,\nit goes down to a minimum for $C_{T}$ satisfying (7)\nor, with $L_{T}$, for\n\n$$\\omega _{T}={1\\over {\\sqrt{L_{T}C_{T}}}}=2\\omega _{o}\n\\tag{8}$$\n\nthe {\\it optimum} {\\it Hegazy} filter, and goes up\nagain for $C_{T}\\to \\infty $ because of tank loading,\nGroszkowski frequency pulling\n\n$${\\Delta \\omega \\over {\\omega _{o}}}\\approx\n-{1\\over {2Q}}{{I_{2}}\\over {I_{1}}}\\tag{9}$$\n\nwhich is ${\\rm Am}\\to {\\rm Fm}$ converted to ${\\mit \\Phi}{\\rm m}$,\nand ultimately squegging and start up failure if the\ncommon mode resonance\n\n$$\\omega _{{\\rm CM}}\\approx {1\\over {\\sqrt{(L_{1}\\parallel L_{2})C_{T}}}}\n\\tag{10}$$\n\nis pulled below $\\omega _{o}$.  In a normal design the\noptimum is broad and the improvement quoted above is\nreadily obtained.  With $C_{T}$ alone, no $L_{T}$,\nthe improvement is $3-6\\,{\\rm dB}$ at the expense of a\nsomewhat reduced tuning range and a reduced supply\npushing.  The circuit with $C_{T}\\to \\infty $, {\\it i.~e.}\nno tail, is the well known low $1/f$ ${\\rm FM}$ topology.\n\nSee E. Hegazy {\\it et al.} {\\it A filtering technique to\nlower LC oscillator phase noise} J. Solid State Circuits\n36, 1928-1934, Dec.2001; Samori {\\it et al.} {\\it ibid}\n35, 244-246, 2000; Hajimiri-Lee {\\it JSSC} 33, 179-194,\n1998.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "992acb118b9aa0e39d770ae3fbde770d182cfa1bef357d32cadd76bba71f1f77"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "Correctly describes a nonmonotonic effect: tail-noise filtering can improve phase noise, while excessive CT can cause tank loading and low-frequency instability/squegging. It omits the class-C peak-current mechanism required for full credit.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "30f6431c053d0ebf26268170667295ea7bd412e72a78ea0b3247e5803cbdfc8a",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3726,
        "output_tokens": 9123,
        "total_tokens": 12849,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6412,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3726,
        "output_tokens": 9123,
        "total_tokens": 12849,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 6412,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 19,
      "question": "We add CT to the tail node, as in the figure. What happens to the phase noise?",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-019-add-ct-tail-node-as-phase-noise/figure-16.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With the usual hand waving the so called {\\it\nfiltering} technique it is a noise filter.Say $X=-Y=\nV_{0}\\cos \\omega _{0}t$.\n$$V_{P}=V_{P0}+V_{P2}\\cos 2\\omega _{0}t+...$$\nThe tail source $I_{SS}$ with $S_{I}(f)=4kT\\gamma\ng_{mT}+K_{f}I_{SS}/f$ is normally high $Z$ and all of\nits current, current noise included, is forced through\n$M_{1}-M_{2}$ into $L_{1},L_{2}$. In the\n${\\cal L}\\left( \\Delta \\omega \\right)$ of\nLeeson-Cutler\n\n$${\\cal L}\\sim 10\\log \\left[\\left(1+\n\\left({\\omega _{0}\\over 2Q\\Delta \\omega }\\right)^{2}\n\\right){F kT\\over 2P_{s}}\\left(1+{\\omega _{1/f^{3}}\\over\n\\Delta \\omega }\\right)\\right]$$\n\n$F=F_{R}+F_{M_{1,2}}+F_{T}$\nis dominated, in a properly designed $LC$, by the tail.\n\nIn particular in the Hajimiri formulation\n\n$${\\cal L}\\propto \n\\overline {\\Gamma _{{\\rm eff}}^{2}}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\n\\Gamma _{{\\rm eff}}=\\Gamma (t)\\times \\alpha (t)$$\n\n$\\Gamma (t)$ is the impulse sensitivity function,\n$\\alpha (t)=g_{m}(t)/g_{m,max}$ is the cyclostationary\nnoise modulating function, the tail contributes through\nthe $2\\omega _{0}$ component of $\\alpha (t)\\Gamma (t)$.\n\nIts low frequency $1/f$ noise, $S_{I}(\\Delta \\omega )$,\nmixed with the $2\\omega _{0}$ component of the large\nsignal operation appears as $S_{\\phi }(\\omega _{0}\\pm\n\\Delta \\omega )$ - the $1/f^{3}$ skirt - and its white\nnoise $S_{I}(2\\omega _{0}\\pm \\Delta \\omega )$ mixed\ndown with the $2\\omega _{0}$ large signal appears as\n$S_{\\phi }(\\omega _{0}\\pm \\Delta \\omega )$ - the\n$1/f^{2}$ skirt. I. e. to first order only the noise\nof $I_{SS}$ in a band $\\Delta \\omega$ about $2\\omega\n_{0}$ and about DC matters, c. f. Samori {\\it et al.},\nHegazi {\\it et al.} {\\sl JSSC 36, 1928, 2001}, Razavi,\n{\\sl RF Microelectronics}.\n\nPutting $C_{T}$ from $P$ to {\\it a.c.} ground puts, for\n\n$$\\left| Z_{T}(\\omega )\\right| =\\left| R_{T}\\parallel\n{1\\over j\\omega C_{T}}\\right| \\ll R_{T}$$\n\na shunt for $\\omega \\sim 2\\omega _{0}$ so that\n$i_{n,T}(2\\omega _{0}\\pm \\Delta \\omega )$ does not\ndevelop a voltage at $P$ which can frequency modulate\nthe tank through\n\n* the $C_{gs}-C_{gd}-C_{db}$ non linearity at $P$\n* the Groszkowski effect $\\Delta \\omega _{0}/\n\\omega _{0}\\propto (I_{2}/I_{1})^{2}/Q^{2}$\n* the $AM-PM$ of the varactor, if any,\n  $K_{V}=d\\omega _{0}/dV_{P}$.\n\nIn more conventional terms it {\\it low pass} filters the\ntail source. For $C_{T}\\gg C_{p,P}$, the parasitic at\n$P$,\n\n$$Z_{P}(j\\omega )\\approx {1\\over j\\omega C_{T}}\\;\\;{\\rm for\n}\\;\\; \\omega \\gg (R_{T}C_{T})^{-1}$$\n\nso that for {\\it large} $C_{T}$ the $1/f^{3}$ corner\n\n$$\\omega _{1/f^{3}}\\propto \n{\\overline {\\Gamma _{dc,{\\rm eff}}^{2}}\\over\n \\overline {\\Gamma _{rms,{\\rm eff}}^{2}}}\\;\n \\omega _{1/f,T} \\tag{*}$$\n\ngoes nominally $\\propto C_{T}^{-1}$ to zero and\n\n$${\\cal L}_{1/f^{2}}\\propto \nF_{T}\\propto {S_{I}(2\\omega _{0})\\over I_{SS}^{2}}\n\\left| Z_{P}(2\\omega _{0})\\right|^{2}$$\n\ngoes as $|Z_{P}(2\\omega _{0})|^{2}\\propto\n(\\omega _{0}C_{T})^{-2}$.\n\nIn round numbers for a $1-2\\,{\\rm GHz}$ $LC$ with\n$L\\sim 2-5\\,{\\rm nH}$, $I_{SS}\\sim 2-5\\,{\\rm mA}$\n\n* $C_{T}=0$ :  ${\\cal L}(1\\,{\\rm MHz})\\approx -110$\n  ${\\rm dBc/Hz}$ , $\\omega _{1/f^{3}}/2\\pi \\approx\n  200-500\\,{\\rm kHz}$\n* $C_{T}\\sim 2-10\\,{\\rm pF}$ to ground: $\\Delta {\\cal\n  L}_{1/f^{2}}\\approx 3-6\\,{\\rm dB}$, $\\Delta {\\cal\n  L}_{1/f^{3}}\\approx 5-10\\,{\\rm dB}$, $\\omega\n  _{1/f^{3}}$ reduced by $2-5\\times$, the Hegazi\n  {\\it et al.} result.\n\nThat is the textbook result normally quoted: {\\it\na large $C_{T}$ to ground filters the tail and the\nphase noise goes down, essentially the $1/f$ induced\n$1/f^{3}$ phase noise.}\n\nWith the usual caveats that make $C_{T}$ alone\nnormally a bad idea in detail:\n\nWith $C_{T}$ the circuit has a {\\it common mode}\ntank. For $L_{1}=L_{2}=L$, $C_{D}$ the tank $C$,\n\n$$\\omega _{0}^{2}={1\\over LC_{D}}\\;\\;{\\rm diff.\\;mode}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{CM}^{2}\\approx {1\\over L_{CM}C_{T}}\\approx\n{2\\over LC_{T}}\\;\\;{\\rm com.\\;mode}$$\n\nwith finite $Q_{CM}=R_{CM}/\\omega _{CM}L_{CM}$.\nIf, as $C_{T}$ is increased from $0$,\n\n$$\\omega _{CM}(C_{T})\\approx \\omega _{0}\\;\\;{\\rm or}\\;\n2\\omega _{0}$$\n\nthe common mode $Q$ will magnify the tail noise and\n${\\cal L}$ {\\it peaks} by $10-20\\,{\\rm dB}$.\n\n$$\\left| Z_{P}(j\\omega )\\right| =\n\\left| {j\\omega L_{CM}\\over 1-\\omega ^{2}L_{CM}C_{T}}\n\\right|$$\n\nHence the customary ${\\cal L}$ versus $C_{T}$ curve,\nFig. 2 of Hegazi, goes through a pronounced maximum\nfor $C_{T}\\sim C_{D}/2$ where $\\omega _{CM}=\\omega\n_{0}$ and for $C_{T}\\sim C_{D}/8$ where $\\omega _{CM}=\n2\\omega _{0}$. Only for\n\n$$C_{T}\\gg C_{D}\\;\\;,\\;\\;\\omega _{CM}\\ll \\omega _{0}\\tag{**}$$\n\ni. e. $C_{T}\\sim 10-40\\,{\\rm pF}$ on chip or nF off\nchip, do you get the filtering action above.\n\nMoreover, made $P$ a.c. ground the sources of $M_{1,2}$\ncan no longer follow $2\\omega _{0}$. The pair spends\na larger fraction of the period in triode, the tank\nis loaded by $R_{on}=1/g_{ds}(t)$ during the zero\ncrossing, $Q_{L}$ falls, and in the rigorous\nHajimiri $\\Gamma _{{\\rm eff}}$ analysis the {\\it\nd.c.} value $\\Gamma _{dc,{\\rm eff}}\\ne 0$ that\ncontrols $(*)$ is no longer zero. I. e. the large\nsignal waveform is made more asymmetric and the\ncyclostationary $\\alpha (t)$ peaks where $\\Gamma (t)$\npeaks. For moderate $C_{T}$ the net $\\overline\n{\\Gamma _{{\\rm eff}}^{2}}$ and $\\Gamma _{dc,{\\rm\neff}}$ {\\it increase} and the $1/f^{3}$ noise\nincreases although $Z_{P}(2\\omega _{0})$ has\ndecreased. This is why Andreani, {\\it et al.},\nHajimiri, Razavi quote $C_{T}$ alone as {\\it\nincreasing} the close in phase noise.\n\nThe robust remedy is the so called Hegazi filter,\nFig. 3 of {\\sl JSSC 36,1932}: $C_{T}$ to ground {\\it\nplus} a $L_{T}$ in series with $I_{SS}$,\n\n$$Z_{P}(j\\omega )={1\\over j\\omega C_{T}+1/(j\\omega\nL_{T}+R_{T})}$$\n\ntuned so\n\n$$\\omega _{p}={1\\over \\sqrt{L_{T}C_{T}}}=2\\omega _{0}$$\n\nAt $2\\omega _{0}$ $Z_{P}$ is high, $\\approx Q_{p}^{2}\nR_{T}$, so the $2\\omega _{0}$ current of the pair is\npreserved - no triode loading, $\\Gamma _{dc}=0$ - and\nthe second harmonic is allowed to resonate in phase\nwith the fundamental to make the waveform more square,\n$\\Gamma _{rms}$ smaller. At all other frequencies\n$Z_{P}\\approx 1/j\\omega C_{T}$ small, so the broadband\nthermal and $1/f$ noise of $R_{T}$ is still shorted.\nThen\n\n$$\\Delta {\\cal L}\\approx 8-15\\,{\\rm dB}$$\n\nwith $\\omega _{1/f^{3}}$ reduced an order of\nmagnitude can be obtained reliably and is the\nconventional tail filtered $LC$ VCO. With $C_{T}$ alone\nyou get nominally $\\sim 1/2$ of that improvement for\n$(**)$ and a degradation for intermediate $C_{T}$,\ncommonly loosely described as $C_{T}$ {\\it increases\nphase noise} unless resonated with $L_{T}$ at\n$2\\omega _{0}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "67ec3d96ecddbaa2eda5a9b559fefec4f4d3e0ef915a6512d405c0d16c2e3144"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It recognizes a non-monotonic effect and describes transistor-waveform/triode-related degradation, but attributes the improvement to tail-noise filtering and misses the class-C mechanism of peak tank currents exceeding ISS. It also omits the instability possible at very large CT.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "30f6431c053d0ebf26268170667295ea7bd412e72a78ea0b3247e5803cbdfc8a",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3726,
        "output_tokens": 7666,
        "total_tokens": 11392,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5151,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 3726,
        "output_tokens": 7666,
        "total_tokens": 11392,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 5151,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Estimate the oscillation frequency of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 1,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the small signal sense the {\\it cold} circuit is\na parallel $G\\parallel L\\parallel C_{T}$ with\n\n$$C_{T}=C_{MIM}+C_{db}+C_{gd}+C_{gs}+...$$\n\nthe total capacity to ground at $X_{i},Y_{i}$ and\n$G=1/R_{p}=1/Q\\omega _{0}L$, $B=\\omega C_{T}-1/\\omega L$,\n$\\omega _{0}^{2}=1/LC_{T}$ in the differentiated form\n$L_{d}=2L$, $C_{d}=C_{T}/2$ so that $L_{d}C_{d}=LC_{T}$.\nPut\n\n$$V_{1}=X_{1}-Y_{1}\\qquad V_{2}=X_{2}-Y_{2}$$\n\nand, with the usual square law normalisation,\n$g_{m}\\propto I_{SS}$, $g_{m1}\\propto I_{1}$,\n$g_{m1}/g_{m}=I_{1}/I_{SS}$ for equal geometries,\nthe small signal KCL at the two tanks is, to within a\nsign which is the $\\pm 90^{0}$ wiring of the figure,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nYV_{1}&=g_{m}V_{1}+g_{m1}V_{2}\\cr\nYV_{2}&=g_{m}V_{2}\\mp g_{m1}V_{1}\\cr}\\qquad \nY=G+jB\\tag{1}$$\n\nwith the upper sign for the in phase wiring and the\nlower sign for the cross wiring in Fig.1.  In matrix form\n\n$$\\left[ \\matrix{Y-g_{m}&-g_{m1}\\cr \n\\pm g_{m1}&Y-g_{m}\\cr}\\right]\\left[\\matrix{V_{1}\\cr V_{2}\\cr}\n\\right]=0 \\tag{2}$$\n\nso that, for $V_{1,2}\\ne 0$,\n\n$${\\rm Det}=0\\;\\;:\\;\\;(Y-g_{m})^{2}+g_{m1}^{2}=0\\tag{3}$$\n\n$${\\rm i.e.}\\;\\;Y=g_{m}\\pm jg_{m1}\\tag{4}$$\n\nand, with $Y=G+jB$, the Barkhausen\n${\\rm Re\\,}Y=g_{m}$, ${\\rm Im\\,}Y=\\pm g_{m1}$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nG&=g_{m} \\tag{5a}\\cr\nB&=\\omega C_{T}-{1\\over{\\omega L}}=\\pm g_{m1}\\tag{5b}}$$\n\n(5a) is the ordinary start up condition\n\n$$g_{m}R_{p}\\ge 1\\qquad R_{p}=Q\\omega _{0}L={1\\over G}\n\\tag{6}$$\n\nthe core pair has to cancel the tank loss.  (5b) is the\nfrequency condition.  With $\\omega _{0}^{2}=1/LC_{T}$,\n\n$$\\omega ^{2}LC_{T}\\mp g_{m1}L\\omega -1=0 \\tag{7}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{1,2}= \\mp {{g_{m1}}\\over{2C_{T}}}\n+\\sqrt{\\omega _{0}^{2}+\\left({{g_{m1}}\\over{2C_{T}}}\\right)^{2}}\n \\tag{8}$$\n\n$${\\omega _{1,2}\\approx \\omega _{0}\\mp {{g_{m1}}\\over{2C_{T}}}\n\\qquad g_{m1}\\ll \\omega _{0}C_{T}\\tag{9}$$\n\nThe two roots are the two normal modes of the coupled\nsystem.  For the straight wiring $B=0$ is a solution,\n$V_{2}=V_{1}$, the conventional in phase mode\n\n$$\\omega _{ip}= \\omega _{0}={1\\over{\\sqrt{LC_{T}}}}\n\\qquad f_{ip}={1\\over{2\\pi \\sqrt{LC_{T}}}} \\tag{10}$$\n\ndifferential inductance $2L$ with differential capacity\n$C_{T}/2$, in single ended notation (10).  For the cross\nwiring $|V_{2}|=|V_{1}|$,\n\n$$V_{2}= \\pm jV_{1}\\tag{11}$$\n\nthe two tanks oscillate in quadrature.  The susceptance\n$g_{m1}$ injected by the {\\it coupling} pair in quadrature\nwith $V_{1}$ pulls the oscillation off $\\omega _{0}$ by\n\n$$\\Delta \\omega =\\pm {{g_{m1}}\\over{2C_{T}}}\\tag{12}$$\n\ni. e. in compact form, with (8),\n\n$$f_{q}= {1\\over{2\\pi }}\\left[\n\\sqrt{{1\\over{LC_{T}}}+\\left({{g_{m1}}\\over{2C_{T}}}\\right)^{2}}\n\\pm {{g_{m1}}\\over{2C_{T}}}\\right]\n\\approx f_{0}\\pm {{g_{m1}}\\over{4\\pi C_{T}}}\\tag{13}$$\n\nFor equal device geometries $g_{m1}/g_{m}=I_{1}/I_{SS}$ so\nthat with $g_{m}=G=1/R_{p}$,\n\n$${{\\Delta \\omega }\\over{\\omega _{0}}}\\approx \n\\pm {1\\over{2Q}}{{I_{1}}\\over{I_{SS}}}\\qquad \nQ=R_{p}/\\omega _{0}L \\tag{14}$$\n\nand, to ${\\cal O}(g_{m1}^{2})$,\n\n$$\\omega _{q}\\approx \\omega _{0}\\sqrt{1\\pm {{I_{1}}\\over{I_{SS}}}}\n\\approx \\omega _{0}\\left[1\\pm {{I_{1}}\\over{2I_{SS}}}\\right]\n\\tag{15}$$\n\nThe sign depends on which of the two quadrature phases\nis taken as reference.  Normally the mode with the largest\nsmall signal loop gain, the $+$ sign in (8), i. e. $\\omega\n>\\omega _{0}$, is the stable quadrature mode.  For weak\ncoupling, $I_{1}\\ll I_{SS}$, $g_{m1}\\ll \\omega _{0}C_{T}$,\nthe pulling is a few per cent and is normally neglected\nin a hand estimate,\n\n$$f_{osc}\\approx f_{0}={1\\over{2\\pi }}{\\rm Re\\,}\n{1\\over{\\sqrt{LC_{T}}}}\\tag{16}$$\n\nthe ordinary (differential) $LC$ resonance at $X_{i}-Y_{i}$.\nE.{\\eightrm G}. with the usual on chip $L=1-5\\,{\\rm nH}$,\n$C_{T}=0.5-2\\,{\\rm pF}$, $Q\\sim 5-10$, $R_{p}\\sim 0.2-\n1\\,{\\rm k\\Omega }$, $g_{m}\\sim 1-5\\,{\\rm mS}$,\n\n$$f_{0}\\sim 2-7\\,{\\rm GHz}\\qquad \n\\Delta f_{q}\\sim {g_{m1}\\over{4\\pi C_{T}}}\\sim 0.1-0.5\\,{\\rm GHz}\n\\tag{17}$$\n\nfor $I_{1}/I_{SS}\\sim 1/3-1/2$.  In round numbers\n$\\Delta f_{q}/f_{0}\\sim 5-15\\%$.\n\nWith the metal ``X'' drawn in the figure literally as a\nshort $X_{1}=Y_{2}$, $Y_{1}=X_{2}$ the two physical coils\non each side are in parallel to ground, in series\ndifferentially, so that the cold differential inductance is\n$L_{d}=2(L\\parallel L)=L$ and, in single ended notation,\n\n$$f_{00}={1\\over{2\\pi \\sqrt{(L/2)C_{T}}}}=\n{{\\sqrt{2}}\\over{2\\pi \\sqrt{LC_{T}}}}\\tag{18}$$\n\n$\\sqrt{2}$ times (10), and (8)--(15) apply with\n$L\\rightarrow L/2$.  Neglecting the $g_{m1}$ pulling this is\nnormally quoted simply as $f_{osc}\\approx (2\\pi\\sqrt{LC})^{-1}$\n($\\sqrt{2}(2\\pi\\sqrt{LC})^{-1}$ with the literal $X$ short)\nwith $C$ the total tank capacity.  Any of the forms\n(8), (13), (15) is accepted as the ``pulled'' quadrature\nfrequency.  In particular for the conventional $L_{d}=2L$\nnotation $f_{q}\\approx f_{0}\\sqrt{1+I_{1}/I_{SS}}$.  For\n$I_{1}\\ll I_{SS}$ this is indistinguishable from $f_{0}$.\n\n> {\\it Remark:}  In differential $2L$, $C/2$ notation\n> $f_{0}=1/2\\pi\\sqrt{2L\\cdot C/2}=1/2\\pi\\sqrt{LC}$.  The\n> in phase normal mode is at $f_{0}$, the (stable)\n> quadrature normal mode at $f_{0}+\\Delta f$ given above.\n> The circuit will normally lock on the quadrature mode and\n> deliver $V_{X1}=V_{0}\\cos\\omega_{q}t$,\n> $V_{Y1}=-V_{0}\\cos\\omega_{q}t$,\n> $V_{X2}=V_{0}\\sin\\omega_{q}t$,\n> $V_{Y2}=-V_{0}\\sin\\omega_{q}t$, i. e. four phases $0,\\pi\n> /2,\\pi ,3\\pi /2$ at $\\omega_{q}$.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "4bb84da9a2ce04611f88f2c6a733e336fa6d87b6bcbd12a722e8171f8d8f00eb"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 3,
          "is_full_credit": false,
          "rationale": "It gives the tank resonance and the correct coupling shift, Δω/ω₀ ≈ (I₁/Iₛₛ)/(2Q). However, it later gives a pulled-frequency expression without the required 1/Q factor, contradicting that result and overstating the shift.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9fb09917ae8858f8003213ac52eae9cc4403612167903aff6685adcc43ddd686",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1997,
        "output_tokens": 17027,
        "total_tokens": 19024,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14893,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1997,
        "output_tokens": 17027,
        "total_tokens": 19024,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14893,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 3,
        "score_percent": 75,
        "is_full_credit": false
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Estimate the oscillation frequency of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 2,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "With an ideal $G_{p}=0$ tank it is the\nRofougaran-Razavi injection locked loop.\nPut for one node\n\n$${\\cal Y}_{p}(p)=G_{p}+pC_{p}+{1\\over {pL}}\\qquad \np=s=j\\omega \\tag{*}$$\n\n$C_{p}$ is the total capacity to the\nincremental ground on the $X$, $Y$ node : the intentional\ncapacity plus $C_{gs}+C_{gb}+C_{gd}$ of the two $n$ MOS\nin parallel on the node plus the capacity of the coil.\nFor a conventional differential capacity $C_{d}$ between\n$X$ and $Y$ $C_{p}=C_{d}/2$.\n$G_{p}=R_{p}^{-1}$ is the loss of the coil\n$Q_{0}=R_{p}/\\omega _{0}L=R_{p}\\omega _{0}C_{p}$,\n$\\omega _{0}^{2}=1/LC_{p}$ is the unperturbed parallel\nresonance.\nIn the small signal incremental circuit let\n\n$$\\eqalign{\ng_{m}&=g_{m,ss} \\cr \ng_{m,c}&=g_{m1}\\cr}\n\\qquad {g_{m,c}\\over {g_{m}}}\\approx {{I_{1}}\\over {I_{ss}}}\n      \\tag{**}$$\n\nbe the small signal $g_{m}$ of the $I_{ss}$,\ndifferential pair and of the $I_{1}$, injection, pair.\nPut\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{I}&=X_{1}-Y_{1}\\cr \nV_{Q}&=X_{2}-Y_{2}\\cr}$$\n\nand, with the conventional sign,\n\n$$V_{G,I}=G_{1l}-G_{1r}\\qquad V_{G,Q}=G_{2l}-G_{2r}$$\n\nso that for one side, e. {\\it g.} the $I$ side, in the\nincremental circuit, Fig.1, with ${{1}\\over {pL}}+pC_{p}=\n{\\cal Y}_{p}-G_{p}$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n0&={\\cal Y}_{p}X_{1}+g_{m}\\left(Y_{1}-S_{0}\\right)\n        +g_{m,c}\\left(G_{1l}-S_{c}\\right)\\cr\n0&={\\cal Y}_{p}Y_{1}+g_{m}\\left(X_{1}-S_{0}\\right)\n        +g_{m,c}\\left(G_{1r}-S_{c}\\right)\\cr}\\tag{1}$$\n\nWith an ideal tail ${\\cal Y}_{t}^{-1}=0$\n\n$$S_{0}={{X_{1}+Y_{1}}\\over 2}\\qquad \n  S_{c}={{G_{1l}+G_{1r}}\\over 2} \\tag{2}$$\n\nso that, subtracting,\n\n$${\\cal Y}_{p}V_{I}-g_{m}V_{I}+g_{m,c}V_{G,I}=0\\tag{3a}$$\nand the same for the $Q$ side\n\n$${\\cal Y}_{p}V_{Q}-g_{m}V_{Q}+g_{m,c}V_{G,Q}=0\\tag{3b}$$\n\nwith\n\n$$V_{G,I}=aV_{Q}\\qquad V_{G,Q}=bV_{I}\\qquad a,b=\\pm 1\\tag{4}$$\n\naccording to the way the two wires $X_{1},Y_{1}\\to\nG_{2l},G_{2r}$ and $X_{2},Y_{2}\\to G_{1l},G_{1r}$ are\nstrapped. $a=+1$ is ''straight'', $a=-1$ ''reversed''.\nIn the figure as normally drawn the two straps are of\nopposite sign and the loop is non reciprocal.  In the\nliteral drawing of Fig.1 they are of the same sign.\n\n*  {\\it Symmetric strapping} $ab=+1$.\n\nEqs.(3) give\n\n$$\\left({\\cal Y}_{p}-g_{m}\\right)V_{I}+ag_{m,c}V_{Q}=0\\tag{5a}$$\n$$\\left({\\cal Y}_{p}-g_{m}\\right)V_{Q}+bg_{m,c}V_{I}=0\\tag{5b}$$\n\n$$\\left({\\cal Y}_{p}-g_{m}\\right)^{2}-ab\\,g_{m,c}^{2}=0\n\\tag{6}$$\n\ni. e. $ab=+1$,\n\n$${\\cal Y}_{p}-g_{m}=\\pm g_{m,c}\\tag{7}$$\n\nWith ${\\cal Y}_{p}=G_{p}+jB_{p}$,\n$B_{p}=\\omega C_{p}-1/\\omega L$,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nG_{p}-g_{m}&=\\pm g_{m,c}\\cr\nB_{p}&=0\\cr}\\tag{8}$$\n\nThe two eigen modes $V_{Q}=\\mp V_{I}$ are the conventional\nin phase and anti phase modes.  Apart from the\n$\\pm g_{m,c}$ change of the start up condition the\ncircuit oscillates, to ${\\cal O}(1/Q_{0})$,\nat the unperturbed tank frequency,\n\n$$B_{p}=0\\;\\;,\\qquad \n\\omega _{osc}=\\omega _{0}={{1}\\over {\\sqrt{LC_{p}}}}\n\\tag{9}$$\n\n$$f_{0}={{1}\\over {2\\pi \\sqrt{LC_{p}}}}=\n{{1}\\over {2\\pi \\sqrt{LC_{d}/2}}}\\tag{9a}$$\n\nWith the normal $0.5-2{\\rm nH}$ integrated coil and\n$C_{p}\\sim 0.3-1.0{\\rm pF}$,\n$f_{0}\\sim 3-10{\\rm GHz}$,\n\n$$f_{0}\\approx {{5{\\rm GHz}}\\over \n\\sqrt{L/{\\rm nH}\\;C_{p}/{\\rm pF}}}\\tag{9b}$$\n\ne. {\\it g.} $L=1{\\rm nH}$, $C_{p}=0.5{\\rm pF}$,\n$f_{0}\\approx 7{\\rm GHz}$.\n$C_{p}$ is to be taken large signal, $C_{p}\\to\nC_{p}+ \\langle C_{gs}\\rangle $ etc.  The $g_{m}\\to\n\\langle g_{m}\\rangle =2I_{ss}/V_{osc}$ in the\nlarge signal steady state locks to $G_{p}\\mp g_{m,c}$.\nIf $\\langle g_{m}\\rangle >G_{p}+|g_{m,c}|$ both modes\ncan start, the ``in phase'' mode $V_{Q}= -{\\rm sgn}(a)\nV_{I}$ with $\\langle g_{m}\\rangle +|g_{m,c}|=G_{p}$ is\nnormally the stable one.  For $|g_{m,c}|\\ll g_{m}$\nthe distinction disappears.\n\n*  {\\it Anti symmetric - quadrature - strapping} $ab=-1$.\n\nThis is the normally quoted quadrature connection,\none strap straight, one strap reversed.  Then from (6)\n\n$$\\left({\\cal Y}_{p}-g_{m}\\right)^{2}+g_{m,c}^{2}=0\\tag{10}$$\n\n$${\\cal Y}_{p}-g_{m}= \\pm jg_{m,c}\\tag{11}$$\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nG_{p}-g_{m}&=0\\cr\nB_{p}&=\\pm g_{m,c}\\cr}\\tag{12}$$\n\nso that the two eigen vectors are in quadrature,\n\n$$V_{Q}= \\pm jV_{I}\\tag{13}$$\n\ni. e. with the usual sign\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nX_{1}-Y_{1}&=V_{0}\\cos \\omega _{osc}t\\cr\nX_{2}-Y_{2}&=V_{0}\\sin \\omega _{osc}t\\cr}\\tag{14}$$\n\nup to the interchange $I\\rightleftharpoons Q$,\nand\n\n$$\\omega _{osc}C_{p}-{1\\over {\\omega _{osc}L}}=\n\\pm g_{m,c}\\tag{15}$$\n\n$$C_{p}\\omega _{osc}^{2}\\mp g_{m,c}\\omega _{osc}\n-{1\\over L}=0\\tag{16}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{osc}^{\\pm}=\n{{\\pm g_{m,c}+\\sqrt{g_{m,c}^{2}+4C_{p}/L}}\\over {2C_{p}}}\n=\\sqrt{\\omega _{0}^{2}+\\left({{g_{m,c}}\\over {2C_{p}}}\n\\right)^{2}}\\pm {{g_{m,c}}\\over {2C_{p}}}\\tag{17}$$\n\nIn large signal $g_{m,c}\\to \\langle g_{m,c}\\rangle $,\n$g_{m}\\to \\langle g_{m}\\rangle $, $\\langle g_{m}\\rangle\n=G_{p}$ for the steady state.  For weak coupling,\n\n$$|g_{m,c}|\\ll \\omega _{0}C_{p}=Q_{0}G_{p}\\tag{18}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{osc}^{\\pm}\\approx\n\\omega _{0}\\pm {{g_{m,c}}\\over {2C_{p}}}\n=\\omega _{0}\\left[1\\pm {{g_{m,c}}\\over {2\\omega _{0}C_{p}}}\n\\right]=\\omega _{0}\\left[1\\pm {{1}\\over {2Q_{0}}}\n{{g_{m,c}}\\over {G_{p}}}\\right]\\tag{19}$$\n\nWith (**), $g_{m,c}/G_{p}\\approx\n(g_{m}/G_{p})(I_{1}/I_{ss})\\approx I_{1}/I_{ss}$ in the\nsteady state, $\\langle g_{m}\\rangle =G_{p}$,\n\n$$\\omega _{osc}\\approx \\omega _{0}\n\\left[1\\pm {{1}\\over {2Q_{0}}}{{I_{1}}\\over {I_{ss}}}\n\\right]\\approx \\omega _{0}\\pm {{\\langle g_{m,c}\\rangle}\n\\over {2C_{p}}}\\tag{20}$$\n\n$$\\Delta f\\approx \\pm f_{0}{{I_{1}}\\over {2Q_{0}I_{ss}}}\n\\approx \\pm {{\\langle g_{m,c}\\rangle}\\over {4\\pi C_{p}}}\n\\tag{20a}$$\n\nSo to ${\\cal O}(Q_{0}^{-1}I_{1}/I_{ss})$ the quadrature\noscillator still oscillates at the single tank frequency\n(9).  The coupling only locks the two tanks in quadrature\nand pulls the frequency by $\\sim g_{m,c}/2C_{p}$.\nFor e. {\\it g.} $g_{m,c}\\sim 2-5{\\rm mA/V}$,\n$C_{p}\\sim 0.5{\\rm pF}$, $|\\Delta f|\\sim 0.3-0.8{\\rm GHz}$,\nnormally $|\\Delta f|/f_{0}\\sim 5-10\\%$ for $Q_{0}\\sim 5-10$\nand $I_{1}/I_{ss}\\sim 0.3-1$.  In the strong coupling\nlimit (17) must be used.  The two signs in (17) correspond\nto the two senses of rotation $V_{Q}=+jV_{I}$,\n$V_{Q}=-jV_{I}$; only one is stable for a given sign of\n$a=-b$, the other is the image obtained by interchanging\nthe two tanks.  Putting $g_{m,c}\\to \\langle g_{m,c}\\rangle\n\\approx (2/\\pi )g_{m,c}$ for the usual current limited\nsaturated switching gives the usual $\\sim 20\\%$ correction.\n\nIn compact form, with $m=g_{m,c}/g_{m}$,\n\n$$\\left|{\\cal Y}_{p}(j\\omega _{osc})\\right|\n =\\sqrt{g_{m}^{2}+g_{m,c}^{2}}\\tag{21}$$\n\nand $\\arg {\\cal Y}_{p}= \\mp \\tan ^{-1}m$.\nFor $ab=+1$ this reduces to $|\\,{\\cal Y}_{p}|=|g_{m}\\pm\ng_{m,c}|$, $\\arg {\\cal Y}_{p}=0$, {\\it i.e.} (9).\n\nAny of (9), (17), (19) is normally quoted as ``the\noscillation frequency'', the ${\\cal O}(g_{m,c}/C_{p})$\npulling being often neglected, $\\omega _{osc}\\approx\n\\omega _{0}=1/\\sqrt{LC_{p}}$.  The common source nodes\n$S_{0},S_{c}$ move at $2\\omega _{osc}$ and can be used as\na frequency doubler.  The amplitude condition is\n$\\langle g_{m}\\rangle >G_{p}$, $\\langle g_{m}\\rangle \\pm\n\\langle g_{m,c}\\rangle >G_{p}$ in the symmetric case.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "5eaa8967d154e8db0b711546b67e38aecbd951e2b7efce4242101dc4fc6e8615"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "Correctly gives the tank resonance and derives the quadrature coupling-induced shift, including the weak-coupling form Δω ≈ ±(gmc/Gp)ω0/(2Q) and its steady-state current-ratio equivalent. The extra exact solution and topology discussion do not undermine the estimate.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9fb09917ae8858f8003213ac52eae9cc4403612167903aff6685adcc43ddd686",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1891,
        "input_tokens": 1997,
        "output_tokens": 17370,
        "total_tokens": 19367,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14340,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 1891,
        "input_tokens": 1997,
        "output_tokens": 17370,
        "total_tokens": 19367,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 14340,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    },
    {
      "question_id": "part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency",
      "part": "part2",
      "question_number": 20,
      "question": "Estimate the oscillation frequency of the circuit in the figure.",
      "figures": [
        "tasks/part2-020-estimate-oscillation-frequency/figure-17.png"
      ],
      "rollout": 3,
      "configuration": {
        "model_id": null,
        "thinking_effort": "xhigh",
        "api_model": "meta/muse-spark-1.2",
        "route": "openrouter_chat_completions"
      },
      "answer": {
        "text": "In the loose coupling limit the four tanks are\nidentical and uncoupled.  Put for one side, Fig.1,\n\n$${\\cal Y}_{t}=G_{t}+sC_{t}+{1\\over {sL}}\\qquad \nC_{t}=C+2C_{gd}+C_{gs}+C_{db}\\tag{1}$$\n\n$$G_{t}={1\\over {R_{p}}}={R_{s}\\over {\\omega _{0}^{2}L^{2}}}\n\\qquad \\omega _{0}^{2}={1\\over {LC_{t}}}\\tag{2}$$\n\nand, in the conventional small signal notation,\n\n$$g_{0}=g_{m}{\\cal I}_{SS}\\qquad \n  g_{c}=g_{m}{\\cal I}_{1}\\tag{3}$$\n\n$$g_{0}\\approx \\sqrt{2k_{n}{W\\over L}{\\cal I}_{SS}}\\;\\;,\n\\qquad g_{c}\\approx \\sqrt{2k_{n}{W\\over L}{\\cal I}_{1}}\n\\approx g_{0}\\sqrt{{\\cal I}_{1}\\over {\\cal I}_{SS}}}\\tag{4}$$\n\nfor the square law, $g_{c}/g_{0}={\\cal I}_{1}/{\\cal I}_{SS}$\nfor the bipolar.  With the sign convention of Fig.1 let\n\n$$V_{1}=V_{X1}-V_{Y1}\\qquad V_{2}=V_{X2}-V_{Y2}\\tag{5}$$\n\n$${\\cal Y}_{t}V_{X1}+g_{0}V_{Y1}+g_{c}V_{G3}=0\\tag{6}$$\n$${\\cal Y}_{t}V_{Y1}+g_{0}V_{X1}+g_{c}V_{G4}=0\\tag{7}$$\n\netc.  E. {\\rm g.} for the conventional Rofougaran\nconnection\n\n$$\\eqalign{\nV_{G3}&=V_{X2}\\;\\;V_{G4}=V_{Y2}\\cr\nV_{G5}&=V_{Y1}\\;\\;V_{G6}=V_{X1}\\cr}\\tag{8}$$\n\nso that, differentially,\n\n$$\\eqalign{\n\\left({\\cal Y}_{t}-g_{0}\\right)V_{1}+g_{c}V_{2}&=0\\cr\n-g_{c}V_{1}+\\left({\\cal Y}_{t}-g_{0}\\right)V_{2}&=0\\cr}\\tag{9}$$\n\nThe conventional parallel connection is obtained with the\n$+$ sign in both lines.  (8) is the anti parallel or\nquadrature connection.  In compact form\n\n$${\\rm det}\\left[{\\cal Y}_{t}-g_{0}\\pm jg_{c}\\right]=0\\tag{10}$$\n\n$${\\cal Y}(s)=g_{0}\\pm jg_{c}\\tag{11}$$\n\ni.{\\rm e.} in the linear small signal sense the circuit\nhas two complex conjugate pairs of poles.  With (1)\n\n$$G_{t}+sC_{t}+{1\\over {sL}}=g_{0}\\pm jg_{c}\\tag{12}$$\n\nAt threshold $G_{t}=g_{0}$ in the large signal sense,\n$G_{t}=g_{0{\\rm eff}}(A)<g_{0}$, and (12) gives for\n$s=j\\omega $ the steady state, Barkhausen, condition\n\n$$j\\left(\\omega C_{t}-{1\\over {\\omega L}}\\right)=\\pm jg_{c}\\tag{13}$$\n\n$${\\rm Re}:G_{t}=g_{0{\\rm eff}}\\tag{14}$$\n$${\\rm Im}:\\;\\omega C_{t}-{1\\over {\\omega L}}=\\pm g_{c}\\tag{15}$$\n\ni. {\\rm e.} apart from the ordinary $g_{0}R_{p}>1$ start\nup condition the tank is pulled off its natural resonance\n$\\omega _{0}=1/\\sqrt{LC_{t}}$ by the quadrature injection.\n(15) is\n\n$$\\omega ^{2}\\mp {g_{c}\\over C_{t}}\\omega -\\omega _{0}^{2}=0\\tag{16}$$\n\n$$\\omega _{1,2}={1\\over 2}\\left[\\pm {g_{c}\\over C_{t}}+\n\\sqrt{\\left({g_{c}\\over C_{t}}\\right)^{2}+4\\omega _{0}^{2}}\\;\n\\right]>0\\tag{17}$$\n\nFor $g_{c}\\ll \\omega _{0}C_{t}$, $g_{c}\\sqrt{L/C_{t}}\\ll 1$,\ni. {\\rm e.} for loose coupling ${\\cal I}_{1}\\ll {\\cal I}_{SS}$,\n\n$$\\omega _{1,2}\\approx \\omega _{0}\\pm {g_{c}\\over {2C_{t}}}\n-{1\\over 8}{g_{c}^{2}\\over {C_{t}^{2}\\omega _{0}}}+\\cdots \\tag{18}$$\n\n$$\\Delta \\omega \\approx {g_{c}\\over {2C_{t}}}\n={1\\over 2}\\omega _{0}g_{c}\\sqrt{L\\over C_{t}}\n={1\\over 2}{g_{c}\\over g_{0}}{1\\over Q}\\omega _{0}\\tag{19}$$\n\n$Q=R_{p}\\sqrt{C_{t}/L}=\\omega _{0}C_{t}R_{p}$ is the tank\n$Q$,\n$$f_{0}={1\\over {2\\pi \\sqrt{LC_{t}}}}\\tag{20}$$\nis the ordinary differential $LC$ frequency, a few\n${\\rm GHz}$ for a normal monolithic spiral, $L\\sim 2-10\\,{\\rm nH}$,\n$C_{t}\\sim 0.2-2\\,{\\rm pF}$,\n\n$$f_{0}\\approx {5\\over {\\sqrt{L_{{\\rm nH}}C_{{\\rm pF}}}}}\\,{\\rm GHz}\\tag{21}$$\n\nand the two eigen modes are split by\n\n$$\\Delta f\\approx {g_{c}\\over {4\\pi C_{t}}}\\tag{22}$$\n\non either side of $f_{0}$.  In the $\\pm $ in (17)--(18)\nthe upper sign is the in phase, $V_{1}=V_{2}$, the lower\nsign the quadrature, $V_{1}=\\pm jV_{2}$, mode.  With the\nsign convention (8) the stable large signal mode is the\nlow side\n\n$$f_{Q}\\approx f_{0}-{g_{c}\\over {4\\pi C_{t}}}\n\\approx f_{0}\\left[1-{1\\over {2Q}}{g_{c}\\over g_{0}}\\right]\n\\tag{23}$$\n\nthe other sign with the opposite twist.  The $+$ sign in\n(9), conventional parallel coupling, gives\n${\\cal Y}_{t}-g_{0}=\\pm g_{c}$, {\\rm i.e.} no frequency\npulling to first order, the two modes are separated in\nthreshold, $G_{t}=g_{0}\\pm g_{c}$.\n\nFor all practical purposes, $g_{c}\\ll g_{0}$,\n\n> {\\it the circuit oscillates in quadrature,\n> $V_{X1}=-V_{Y1}$, $V_{X2}=-V_{Y2}$, $V_{X1}=\\pm jV_{X2}$,\n> at the tank resonance (20) to ${\\cal O}(g_{c}/\\omega _{0}\n> C_{t})$.}\n\nE. {\\rm g.} $L=5\\,{\\rm nH}$, $C_{t}=0.5\\,{\\rm pF}$,\n$f_{0}\\approx 3.2\\,{\\rm GHz}$, $g_{c}=2\\,{\\rm mA/V}$,\n$\\Delta f\\approx g_{c}/4\\pi C_{t}\\approx 300\\,{\\rm MHz}$,\n$g_{c}/\\omega _{0}C_{t}\\approx 0.2$.  With\n${\\cal I}_{1}/{\\cal I}_{SS}\\approx 1/4$, square law,\n$g_{c}/g_{0}\\approx 1/2$, $Q\\sim 10$, $\\Delta f/f_{0}\\sim\n2-5\\%$.  In the very loose coupling limit normally used\nfor low phase noise quadrature generation,\n${\\cal I}_{1}\\le 0.1{\\cal I}_{SS}$,\n\n$$f_{osc}\\approx f_{0}= {1\\over {2\\pi }}{1\\over {\\sqrt{LC_{t}}}}\n\\tag{24}$$\n\nquoted as $1/2\\pi \\sqrt{2LC}$ if $C$ is the single ended\ncapacitance to ground and $2L$ the differential inductance.\nAny explicit tank capacitor $C$ simply adds to $C_{t}$.\nIf no explicit capacitor is used $C_{t}$ is the\nparasitic capacitance at the $X,Y$ nodes,\n\n$$C_{t}\\approx C_{L}+{4\\over 3}WLC_{ox}+2WC_{ov}+C_{db}+C_{sb}\n\\tag{25}$$\n\nso that e. {\\rm g.} with $C_{db}$ neglected\n\n$$\\omega _{0}\\approx {1\\over {\\sqrt{LWLC_{ox}}}}\\tag{26}$$\n\nto within a factor $\\sim 2$.  Including the usual\n$1/2$ for the differential tank the often quoted form is\n$f_{osc}\\approx 1/2\\pi \\sqrt{LC_{gs}}$.  The more exact\nlarge signal quadrature frequency is (17), {\\rm i.e.}\nto ${\\cal O}(g_{c}^{2})$\n\n$$f_{Q}\\approx {1\\over {2\\pi }}\\sqrt{{1\\over {LC_{t}}}\n+\\left({g_{c}\\over {2C_{t}}}\\right)^{2}}\\mp {g_{c}\\over {4\\pi C_{t}}}\n\\tag{27}$$\n\nthe $-$ sign being the normally observed stable\nquadrature mode for the twist shown.  Changing the twist\ninterchanges the two signs.  With (4) this can be written\nas\n\n$${f_{Q}\\over f_{0}}\\approx 1\\mp {1\\over 2}g_{c}\\sqrt{L\\over C_{t}}\n\\approx 1\\mp {1\\over 2Q}\\sqrt{{\\cal I}_{1}\\over {\\cal I}_{SS}}\n\\tag{28}$$\n\nsquare law, $1\\mp ({\\cal I}_{1}/2Q{\\cal I}_{SS})$ bipolar,\nso that for $Q\\sim 5-15$ the pulling is normally $<10\\%$.\nNeglecting the pulling altogether $f_{osc}\\approx\n1/2\\pi\\sqrt{LC_{t}}$ is the usual textbook estimate.",
        "format": "markdown",
        "sha256": "505661498dccb05fd029c94af78a36f649ab0eb9e7156b4e2017daef9d7f3af1"
      },
      "model_call_count": 1,
      "internet_or_tool_evidence": false,
      "source_experiment": "2026-11-09-question-only-rerun",
      "scores": {
        "gpt_6_luna_max": {
          "score_0_to_4": 4,
          "is_full_credit": true,
          "rationale": "It gives the tank resonance and a coupling-induced shift in the required form, Δω ≈ (gc/g0)ω0/(2Q), with the two modes on either side. Its additional gc/(2Ct) expression is part of the derivation and does not undermine the correct estimate.",
          "golden_solution_sha256": "9fb09917ae8858f8003213ac52eae9cc4403612167903aff6685adcc43ddd686",
          "rubric_sha256": "7c95b8e3a1a51fcebb49a1ad05e777ad488f398109bed3af7814ed1709b67a54",
          "judge_model": "openai/gpt-6-luna"
        }
      },
      "tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1997,
        "output_tokens": 15514,
        "total_tokens": 17511,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12953,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "selected_response_tokens": {
        "cached_input_tokens": 0,
        "input_tokens": 1997,
        "output_tokens": 15514,
        "total_tokens": 17511,
        "cache_creation_input_tokens": null,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 12953,
        "complete": true,
        "availability": "complete",
        "missing_fields": []
      },
      "attempt_count": 1,
      "active_score": {
        "policy": "gpt_6_luna_max",
        "score_0_to_4": 4,
        "score_percent": 100,
        "is_full_credit": true
      }
    }
  ]
}
